BlockBefore

Alameda County, California - The Events Op 1874, 1876

From The Centennial Year Book of Alameda County, California : Containing a Summary of the Discovery and Settlement of California, a Description of the Contra Costa Under Spanish, Mexican, and American Rule, an Account of the Organization and Settlement of Alameda County ... Also, a Gazetteer of Each Township, Useful Local and General Statistical Information, Appropriate for the Present Time, to Which Are Added Biographical Sketches of Prominent Pioneers and Public Men, published 1876. 9,726 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

3 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

9,726 words

Machine-read from scans of The Centennial Year Book of Alameda County, California : Containing a Summary of the Discovery and Settlement of California, a Description of the Contra Costa Under Spanish, Mexican, and American Rule, an Account of the Organization and Settlement of Alameda County ... Also, a Gazetteer of Each Township, Useful Local and General Statistical Information, Appropriate for the Present Time, to Which Are Added Biographical Sketches of Prominent Pioneers and Public Men, published 1876. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

The Events Op 1874

The Green Point Dairy Company Incorporated - Memm'ials to Congress Praying for the Imjirovement of Oakland Harbor - $100,000 Appropriated - Windstorm in Livermore Valley - Failure of a propositiooi to Incorporate the town of Berkeley - A Proposition to Annex Alameda Territory to Santa Clara Defeated - Tide Land on Lake Merritt Ceded to Oakland - Third and Last Year of the County Seat Controversy - County Clerk Goodrich Refuses to Audit Contractor Bahcock's Bill for Work on Jail - Goes Before the Supreme Court ami Decision Favorable to Babcock - The City Council of Oakland Aiithorized by the Legislat^ire to Deed the Plazas to the County ^Supervisors Reject the Offer - Aid Sought hy the City from the Legislature - Views of the County Delegation - ^^ An Act to Provide for the Erection of County Buildings in Alameda County and for the Issuance of Bonds Therefor " - - Mayor Durant Sends the City Council a Message Suggesting Division - Mass Meeting in Oaklaml - Proceedings at Sacramento - A Compromise - The Bill Passed and the County Buildings to be Located on the Plazas - The Local Option Elections - The Contest in Washington, Oakland, Brooklyn, Alameda, Murray ami Eden Townships - Oaklaml and Brooklyn Favor the Law - The Other TowTixships Opposed - Extraordinary Electioneering Scenes - A Majority o/" 51 in the County for License - The Law Declared Unconstitutional - The College of Letters Investigation - Sundry Matters of Interest - The Granges and Professor Carr - Wharf Finished - Death of Hon. S. P. Wright - Proposed Martinez and Livermore Narrow-Gauge Railroad - Grangers' Reunion - Legislature of 187 4:-5.

Tlie Green Point Dairy and Transportation Company filed its certificate of incorporation in the Secretary of State's Office, on January 6tli. The objects of the Company were stock-raising, daiiying, etc., in Alameda County, and navigating tlie bay of San Francisco and tributaries. Capital stock $250,000, with 500 shares of $50 each. Directors: E. B. Perrin, R. F. Tracy, J. T. Brown, A. L. Gurney, B. B. Minor and G. F. Thornton. Green Point is on the bay, two or three miles from Centreville, in Washington Township, but now known as Dumbarton Point.

The Board of Supervisors, at their meeting January 1 2th, adopted a memorial to the Senate and House of Representatives of the United State Congress, praying for the improvement of the Oakland Harbor, as follows:

Whereas it is now understood by your petitioners that an official survey has been made by officers of the United States for the purpose aforesaid, and that a plan is about to be reported by the Board of Engineers of the Pacific Coast.

Wherefore, Your petitioners, on behalf of the citizens of Alameda County and of the City of Oakland, and in view of the very important geographical location of the harbor of the City of Oakland, relative to the marine and land traffic and travel connecting the shores of Asia and Europe across the continent of America, and joining the Atlantic and Pacific seaboards of the United States, most respectfully ask that your honorable bodies will be pleased to grant such an appropriation for the improvement of the harbor of Oakland, California, as may be recommended by the Board of Engineers of the Pacific Coast and indorsed by the Chief of Engineers of the United States Army. And further, your petitioners will ever pray.

The Board of Trustees of Town of San Leandro also memorialized Congress at the same time on the same subject, as well as the City of Oakland, and the result was an appropriation by Congress of $100,000 for the commencement of the work.

A fearful wind-storm prevailed in the county on Jan. 15th. It continued in Livermore all night, commencing at 7 o'clock. Several buildings were badly injured. The grain warehouse, recently built by Joseph Wilkinson, was completely demolished. The blacksmith shop of Hatch &, Holmes was also totally wrecked. The frame of the new Presbyterian church, in course of erection, was totally destroyed. Barns and poorly constructed dwellings were blown down, but no loss of life occurred. The buildings blown down were looselyconstructed frames, large and open, and such as to easily fall victims to a good blow.

Under The Stars And Stripes

cousitler the question of incorporation. The call Avas signed by Professor Durant. The principal property-owners were present, inchiding John W. Dwinelle, A. B. Dixon, Henry Durant, F. K. Shattuck, Chas. Dwinelle, John Kelsey, J. D. Colby, Peter Mathews, E. D. Hiirmon, John Kearney, James Edgar, H. E. Carlton, Arthur Edgar, Horace W. Carpentier, Capt. Jacobs, Mr. Newell, Peter McGee, Mr. Ashby, Mr. Townsend, James McGee, Mr. Higgins, Mr. Boleta, Mr. Morse, J. T. Fowler, Professor Ri.sing.

Prof. Durant presided and Mr. Kelsey acted as secretary. The object was to consider the question of incorporation. Carpentier suggested incorporation with Oakland ; Mr. Dwinelle wanted to keep out of the jaws of Oakland ; Mr. Shattuck said San Leandro was at an exjjense of only about $500 per year. Judge Dwinelle spoke fui-ther in favor of an incorporated town of Berkeley. It was necessary that some system of sewerage should be adopted.

A motion of Mr. Kearney to make the northern line of the county the northern point of the town, was next adopted against the protestations of Cai-pentier. The motion to incorporate was lost, finally, and the meeting adjourned, the farmers being unfavorably inclined towards the proposition.

A bill was introduced in the Legislature to take a strip of about two miles off the southern extremity of Alameda Coimty, and annex it to Santa Clara ; but it failed in its object.

The Tide Land Commissioners were about to sell a piece of tide land at the head of Lake Merritt, but by a bill passed in the Legislature it was ceded to the City of Oakland.

The county seat conflict opened in January, 1874, in the Supreme Court. It appears that County Auditor Goodrich declined to allow Contractor Babcock's claim for work done on the jail, and the latter applied to the Court for a peremptory writ of mandate to compel the County Auditor to allow his claim. The cause was argued on the 20tli of January, when Messrs. Cope Wilson, Attorneys, appeared for Babcock ; and Chas. A. Tuttle for Goodrich. The various allegations in the matter were fully discussed, and the Court rendered a decision in favor of the plaintifi". Subsequently, a bill was passed through the Legislatui^e to allow $1,000 for his costs.

A bill was introduced in the Legislature and passed, authorizing the Council of the City of Oakland to deed the plazas to the county for county seat purposes, and empowering the Board of Supervisors to accept them, should they see fit. The plazas, by this Act, were to revert to the city if county buildings were not erected upon them in four years.

At the meeting of the Board held on the 11th of February Mr. Shattuck called attention to the bill, which was read ; also a certified copy of a resolution passed by the Oakland City Council, together with a deed of the plazas duly signed, and moved that the deed be accepted. The usual majority were opposed to it. The county members said they were expressing the will of their constituents in refusing to accept the proposition. Mr. Case contended that the lease was not legal. He had no evidence that a majority of the people of the county desired a change ; and finally Case moved that the resolution be postponed indefinitely.

The subject was renewed at the following meeting, held Febi-uary 13th. Capt. Wilcox said the donation of the plazas was equivalent to $100,000. Mr. Neale said in opposing a relocation he was doing what the people of his township wanted him to do. Mr. Hardy was sorry Mr. Neale's people Avanted him to remain in tlie stench. Mr. Case said the issue at the last election, upon which four of the members were elected, Avas the removal question. Between the present location and the plazas there was not much choice in the score of "stink," as the plazas were in the midst of dens of the vilest kind, a gas works, and contiguous to the marsh lands. Capt. Wilcox and Mr. Case indulged in a spicy discussion xipon "stench" and the delicacy of the Captain's olfactories. The latter gentleman would urge removal, and if necessary advocate force to have the buildings removed. The motion to indefinitely postpone the resolution was put and carried by the usual vote of four to three.

This ended the matter so far as the Board of Supervisors were concerned. The city had exhausted all its i-esources in that quarter, and set its mind on legislative relief. What could be done thei-e? The County Delegation at Saci-amento could only be pai-tially relied upon. Senator Gibbons had expressed no opinion on the matter, and had made no pledges on the matter when before the people of the county, seeking election. He had, in fact, refused to commit himself, and had consequently met with opposition where he would otherwise have gained votes. He was an Oakland man, to be sure, but then he had the example of Senator Tompkins, who had incurred the hostility of the country people on account of his alleged special advocacy of Oakland, to warn him. Assemblyman Amerman, until the time of the removal to Brooklyn, had conducted the fight for San Leandro, and it could not be supposed that his support would be forthcoming. Mr. Gurnett alone, of the three delegates, was the only man who could be relied upon to warmly espouse the cause of Oakland in the Legislature, and this, of course, he did.

Then there was the question - "What could the Legislature legally do that had not been already done?" Could it properly interfere in deciding what part of a town a Court-house was to be located inl The matter, at any rate, was to be tested, as Oakland had already exhausted every other resource.

At a meeting of the City Council held Februaiy 16th, Mayor Durant sent in a message in which he urged the Council to take the initiative in a movement for the division of the county with a view to the erection of the city of Oakland and the adjoining townships into a separate county, to be called the County of Oakland. No action, however, was taken on this message, which no doubt was merely meant as a thi'eat to be put in force under certain contingencies, "With the aid of the daily papers, which had very warmly entered into the controversy in favor of the claims of the city, public opinion was aroused to action and the legislative remedy sought.

The best legal opinion was obtained, and a bill drawn up to suit the emergency, at the instance of a committee having the matter in hand, called the Citizens' Union, which consisted of prominent property-ownei-s. By this bill, which was entitled : " An Act to provide for the erection of county buildings in the County of Alameda and for the issuance of bonds thei-efor," the Board of Supervisors was directed to issue 8 per cent, twenty years' bonds, to the amount of $150,000, to be redeemed by an annual tax, which raised $1,000. The Governor was required to appoint five Commissioners, who were to have sole management of the money. They were to take possession of the Oakland plazas, and proceed to erect such county buildings as they might deem proper. They were authorized to complete the Jail, then erecting on Block 22, if they saw fit. The bill contained many restrictions, and it was intended that the Supei'visors should not have any control over it, or in any way defeat the progress of the work, even by resigning.

and it soon went before the Committee on Corporations. Both, sides were advised, and, on the evening of the 3d of March, the matter was discussed. Supervisor Case, E. G. Mathews and Wm. Meek, were heard on behalf of the Supervisors. W. W. Foote followed as counsel for the city, speaking for more than an hour. Then Senator Gibbons declared himself. He was in favor of the bill, but said he had offered a compromise to locate the county seat in the vicinity of Tubbs' Hotel, but the idea was not tolerated. Then followed a speech by Mr. Gurnett, before and after which there was a running cross-fire of assertions and contradictions from both sides.

It will be seen that so far Mr. Amerman had taken no part in this year's internecine warfare. The Sacramento correspondent of the News, Mr. Harwood, who took a very zealous part in the controversy, and may be said to have kept the life in it for the Oakland people, wi'ote very despondingly one day that Amerman would " oppose any legislation intended to break the ring in the Board of Supervisors," and this left the matter in not an altogether encouraging condition. The Chairman of the Committee on Corporations, too, was Senator Farley, who, two years ago, had championed the cause of San Leandro in the Senate, in opposition to Senator Tompkins.

On the 5th of the month, the committee met again and heard further statements in reference to the question. The chairman said, on calling the committee to order, the question before them was whether they should take from the Board of Supervisors certain functions they were vested with by law ; whether it was good policy in this case for them to do so.

Supervisor Shattuck appeared and made a full statement of the existing troubles. He cited the example of San Francisco, where the erection of county buildings had been taken out of the hands of the supervisors' and vested in commissionei's.

The question of title to the plazas was discussed, when Mr. Shattuck stated how the plazas were donated and what they were worth; and Senator Gibbons said the original owners of the town site, Hayes & Caperton, had recognized the plazas as public property, and for twenty yeai-s they had been so considered. Mr. Gurnett read a letter from Judge Glascock, attorney for Hayes & Caperton, stating that he was authorized and would execute any kind of deed that was required. The chairman asked what was the general sentiment of the people on the question. Shattuck replied that they denounced the action of the Supei-visors. Senator Laine asked how the vote of the county woiikl stand on the proposition, when Shattuck answered, "two to one." Case asked if the Jail tlien buikling woukl be sacrificed. Shattuck then went into a statement of the buihling difficulty ; showed how the Supervisors were elected for three yeai-s inider the Code ; how they had endeavored to obtain a classification of the Board as to years of service, and been defeated ; and how, under a late decision of the Supreme Court, the Board could raise |400,000 annually by taxation and put up fine buildings at the expense of the people. F. J. Clark, of Livermore, said those who voted for removal in his township were in favor of the plaza proposition. Mr. Shattuck said, in Washington Township many representative men were in favor of the Oakland plazas. Case said that the Jail would be completed in thirty days. Senator Gibbons stated that he had received a letter from >Samuel Marston, of Centre ville, stating that a majority of the people of Wasliington Township favored the pending bill. Mr. Mathews read an article from the Oakland News, which stated that, if the Brookljm people would annex to Oakland, her plazas shoiild be included in an ofier to the county. Senator Gibljons replied to this that he had offered to compromise in favor of the plaza near Tubb's Hotel, in Brooklyn, a most beautiful location, but Mr. Case paid no attention to the proposition. Case and Mathews said they would be very glad to give up the Court-house and get back their town government, and be once more independent of Oakland. And here follows another pause in the controversy before the final and abrupt close of the protracted farce.

After this Mr. Harwood wrote to his paper that success was quite certain, if the bill was got through the Senate. Gurnett could get it easily through the Assembly, whether Amerman opposed it or not. A day or two after there was suddenly a talk of compromise in favor of the Washington (Brooklyn) plaza, near Tubb's Hotel ; then an open declaration that Case would agree to a compromise by which the Jail would remain on Block 22, and the Court-house be built near Tubbs' Hotel ; and that Senator Gibbons was a party to the compi'omise.

Then came a cry of " treason," and a declaration that Oakland was a particle of public spii'it. There was a sudden awakening, how-ever. Senator Gibbons' course was criticised, and a public meeting called by " Many Tax-Payers " on Saturday evening, March 14th, in Brayton Hall, whose rallpng cry was "no compromise." Hon.

Zach Montgomery, on motion of Judge Ferris, was moved to the Chair ; W. D. Harwood and A. W. Bishop, the editors of the News and the Transcript, were appointed Secretaries. Then followed a long list of Yice-Pi'esidents. Judge Ferris moved, the first resolution instructing " our Senators and Members of Assembly to use their best endeavors to pass, without delay, the original bill in relation to the removal and location of the county buildings, and opposing their location elsewhere than upon the Broadway plazas. Senator Gib1:)ons was called for, but was not forthcoming. Mr. Gaskill said he was at the Grand Central Hotel, and moved the appointment of a committee to wait upon him, and he was accordingly waited upon by Messrs. Gaskill, Wilcox and E. Bigelow. They subsequently reported they had seen the Senator, but he excused his non-attendance on the gi'ound of illness. He admitted being a party to the compromise, and would not pledge himself to the removal to the plazas, as contingencies might arise that would influence him. Mr. Shattuck gave his version of the new development, with which he associated the name of A. A. Cohen. He said Senator Farley would report the bill on Monday, unless he 'received instructions to the contrary, and expressed the opinion that the people were opposed to any compromise. Judge Blake followed in a speech, wondering at the conduct of Senator Gibibons, and opposing a compromise. The compromise was to let the ,,J^il renriain on Block 22, and pay the Larue estate $12,000 for the Jai^^d. Hon. R. C. Gaskill followed in a " ringing " speech, condemnjiag the course of the Senator, and declaring the Senate would pass the bill ill spite of him. Supervisor Wilcox made a speech in v/hich he .described the power of a " stench," and said he would prefer to have the county buildings back to San Leandro, or even Alvarado, than ithat they ^should remain where they were. He favored " no compromise." He accused the members of the Board of Supervisors of telegraphing each other with their thumbs, whenever a vote on this question was taken. Marlin had told him he would vote for the plazas, but wheu thumbs went up he " fell down." Mr. Foote accused some of the members of the Board with perjury, and spoke encour- :agingly of the bill. He believed Dr. Gibbons would withdraw his support from the compromise ; he knew that Amerman, who was a prospective candidate for Congress, would not dai"e to oppose it ; and Gurnett, he was sui-e, was in favor of it. The resolution was unanimously carried, and a committee of five appointed to go to Sacrajinento, to assist in the passage of the Senate bill. The proceedings concluded by taking up a subsci'iption to defray expenses. The Secretaries were instructed to furnish the deU^gation with a copy of the resohition, and then the meeting adjourned, feeling that success would surely follow.

The meeting had its effect, and the result was an immediate surrender. The committee appointed proceeded to Sacramento on Sunday. They met at Amerman's apartments and talked the matter OA'er. It was stated that Case would not oppose the bill if the Commissioners were stricken out and the Supervisors allowed to erect the buildings. All but Judge Ferris agreed to this. Senator Gibbons said the bill should be so altered ; it was the weak part of the bill, and the concession was a trifling one. Amerman said he had taken no part in the contest, but could not, as expected, champion Block 22. He favored the bill with the Commissioners sti'icken out. Gurnett did not care who did the work, so long as the buildings wei*e placed on the plazas ; so that the whole delegation were united, and the bill would go through both Houses without a word of dissent.

About midnight Case was called upon. He was not in favor of the bill in any shape, but as all Alameda County's representatives had united to pass it, as an officer of the law he should obey. He "would not do anything to obstruct the erection of the buildings, and as a Supei-visor he would act in connection with all building operations on the Broadway plazas, just as if they were on the location of his first choice.

The praise of Mr. Case, as a man of honor, who had made a gallant fight for his section and his friends, then followed. He had never broken his promise or violated his word, and all that remained to end this prolonged county seat controversy, to finish this three years' local warfare, was the arrangement of the formalities. On the following Thursday Senator Farley reported a substitute for the original bill. Gibbons moved the suspension of the rules, in order to consider the bill at once. Edgerton opposed it, and said he had been requested to oppose it, and wanted time to consider their reasons. Evans said the committee had heard both sides, and the substitute was the result. Gibbons explained ; and on a call of ayes and noes there were 13 noes to 18 ayes, showing that the Brooklyn party were far from being ^vithout strength, even after this compromise was concluded ; and it is doubtful, considering that this was within twelve days of the end of the session, if the fight had been kept up, the original bill could be carried through.

A few clays after there was a hitch ; some of the Brooklyn men - Larue and Duncan Cameron - having heard what wks going on, proceeded to Sacramento and rather disjointed matters. Some new arrangement was effected, however, and the parties appeased ; and on the 19th the bill passed the Senate unanimously, and went to the Assembly. It provided for the issue of bonds to the amount of $200,000, instead of $150,000 as at first proposed, and allowed the deeding back to James Larue of Block 22, should the County Jail be removed. In case the Jail sliould be completed on Block 22, the Supervisors were to pay Mr. Larue a reasonable compensation for the property. Mr. Larue, however, did not want the Jail on his property, and simply asked for a retui'n of the land, which of course could not be, and was refused. There were several Brooklyn gentletiien present, who did not relish the turn things had taken, as several of them had invested largely in the company to put up the temporary county biiildings ; and it was no wonder if they felt as if they had in some way been deceived.

The bill passed the Assembly on the 20th, and at 4 o'clock on the 25th it was signed by the Governor and became a law. Until the very last there was some opposition to it, and there remained yet a dread that the majority of the Supervisors would carry on a hostility, or that the legality of the bill would be tested in the courts. Indeed, a slight move in this direction was made, but all opposition was soon abandoned. The Jail building on Block 22 was pulled down, and the material removed to Washington Plaza, where it Avas reconstructed. This little matter cost the county about $20,000. A bill was passed through the Legislature allowing Mr. Babcock, the contractor, $1,000 for his law expenses in his contest with the Auditor, who very injudiciously put the county to that and other expenses, in taking a position that the Judges made clear to him he had no right to take, in dispixting an order of the Supervisors.

In looking over the whole of this protracted contest, the writer cannot help thinking that the greater part of the acrimony and p; sion that entered into it might have been avoided, and all that was desired accomplished by the use of conciliation and a clearer forecast. At the start the agitation for removal was consigned to the management of one man, who, however active and zealous, was not the proper person to conduct so delicate a business. Mr. Linden was suffermg from ill health, dyspeptic and crabbed, and was not able to use that argument of the manner which pleases, if it does not con- vince. Had only one of the outside townships been won, the battle was assured for Oakhmd. A respectable deputation from the city at the proper time would have done it. But, instead of persuasion, there was too much wordy warfare - too much assumption, for conciliation. The Supervisors, however improper their conduct might have been, when violently attacked received the sympathy of their constituents, and an opposition was constructed so inflexible as nearly to conqtier and endanger the decision of the county. That Block 22 was not a desii-able location, no one will now pretend to maintain ; but in it was centered the local pride of a spirited community, who believed that they were entitled by an vln^vritten compact to the county seat. Again, the southern section of the county, formerly the ruling portion of it, saw the seat of justice gi-adually slipping away from it - from Alvarado to San Leandro ; from San Leandro to Brooklyn - and it was only natural that they should resLst its establishment on Broadway as an Oakland aggression and a centralization of power and advantages. But it is very doubtful, if the location wei'e open to disturbance to-morrow, that the slightest eflbrt would be made to effect another change.

Since the close of the contest a fine structure has been erected, which, notwithstanding some defects, is an ornament to the city and a proud emblem of the importance of the county. It is hoped that by its cost, completeness and convenience, an end is forever put to all further county seat agitations. The latter is an ordeal which almost every county in the land has some time to pass through. We have seen the trouble crop out here first in 1835, with our Mexican predecessors, -who desired to see the seat of justice for this district removed from San Francisco to San Jose, where laws for the Contra Costa were first administrated. When Contra Costa was organized, in 1 850, there appears to have been no trouble in effecting the location at Martinez, because Alameda was virtually without population, a location or a champion; but when the creation of Alameda came, there was the first bitter warfare between the northern and southern sides of the county. The south was then the strongest, and won. It had the population and the resources. The removal to San Leandro was an assertion of the growing power of the north; and the removal to Brooklyn was a piece of strategy that obtained its advantage from peculiar position and tact. The final transfer to Broadway was simply the evidence of cumulative power and the irresistible force of a rapidly augmenting business center, and a spiiit that would brook no resistance and yield to no compromise. All the localities that have lost the boon of the county seat at various times, made gallant contests for its maintenance, and there is no just reflection to be indulged in now, only that they had to yield to the inevitable.

The Local Option Elections

One of those moral epidemics that sometimes sweep over a community, visited the State this year. Reference is made to the Local Option excitement, which found its way to this State from Ohio. It was a new phase of the crusade against intemperance, and had its embodiment in a law which allowed municipalities to detennine by a vote of the people whether the sale of liquor should be licensed within them or not.

A bill to gi-ant this privilege was mtroduced in the last Legislature by Senator Pendegast, of Napa, and unexpectedly became a law. It was familiarly known as the Local Option Law, on account of its granting to every separate town or townshij) the right to determine the license question for itself. The temperance organizations were not slow to take advantage of it, and [female "Crusaders," as they were called, were soon in the held, exhorting people in favor of the law with as much zeal as Peter the Hei-mit, of old. Here was an opportunity, they thought, to rid the land of the evils of intemperance by closing up the liqvior saloons with the force of a legal statute.

The law, as it passed in the California Legislature, required that on the presentation of a petition containing the names of one-fourth of the legal voters of a township, duly authenticated, the Board of Supervisors of the county in which such to-sviiship was situated should name a day and call an election to determine, by a majority of the votes cast, whether license to sell less than one gallon of intoxicating liquors or beer should be allowed in such township or not.

The first petition for an election in this county came fron "Washington Townsliip, and was presented at a meeting of the Board of Supervisors, held on the 2 2d of April. The petition was signed by 270 persons. An election was ordered for the 23d of May, tlnis allowing one month for prei)aration. There were three or four temperance organizations in the township, wdiile the number of saloons was said to be 25 or 30. Both sides prepared for battle. The temperance people calculated on an easy victory, especially as they had the names of a majority of the votei's attached to their petition.

"Wlien election day came, however, they were disapi)ointed, for tliere were cast in favor of their cause but 167 votes, to 184 votes in favor of license. The vote at the different precincts was as follows : Alvarado - for license, 70 ; against, 52. Centreville - for, 67 ; against, 84. Mission San Jose - for, 47 ; against, 31 - a very light vote.

In the meantime petitions for elections were circulating in other townships, and the friends of the cause were active secui'ing the names of voters in both Oakland and Brooklyn Townshijis. Those most active in the work were women. They soon enlisted most of the churches in the work. Organizations were formed- committees set at work, and public meetings held. The enthusiasm was rapidly kindling, and some of the most addicted tipplers wei'e soon giving their adhesion to the movement. A mass meeting, under the auspices of the Oakland Woman's Temperance Union and the Alameda County Temperance Alliance, was held in Brayton Hall, on the 23d of April. The meeting was called to ox'der by the leading Crusader of the county, Mrs. Hariett E. Bishop, a lady recently from the East, and who had initiated the movement in Oakland. Clergymen, business men and county officials took part in the proceedings, and the agitation was regularly inaugurated. The petitions for an election were rapidly being signed, one of the morning papers (the A^eios) had come out openly and advocated the strange doctrine, and the feeling on the question was soon at a white heat. At a meeting of the Temperance Union, held on the 28th of April, nearly 1,000 signatures were reported to the petition, and, at the session of the Board of Supervisors, on the 4th of May, said petition was presented, with the names of 1051 voters of Oakland Township attached. An election was ordered to be held on the 30th of May, and then the real work commenced.

On the same day a petition was presented from Brooklyn Township, but, not having contained a sufficient number of signatures, was not acted upon ; but having been presented at the next meeting, with a sufficient number of names, an election was ordered for the 6th day of June.

At first the saloon-keepers and liquor dealers were not much alarmed ; but they soon became uneasy, and finally were forced into activity. They, too, commenced to hold meetings, to collect a campaign fund and register votes. The County Clerk's office became the scene of unusual activity, naturalization papers were in demand, and the Great Register was the recipient of several hundred additional

As tlie day of election approached the excitement and interest increased. The ladies left no stone unturned. A large tent, belonging to the Seventh-day Adventists, was placed at their disposal, and there men and women held forth nightly on the evils of intemperance, and the benej&ts of the local option law. The clergy made it the prominent theme in their pulpits, confirmed tipplers made temperance speeches, daily prayer meetings for the success of the cause were held, the papers were full of local option discussions, and crowds came over daily from San Fi-ancisco, especially temperance people, to lend a helping hand. Among those who addressed temperance meetings before the election, besides the clergymen of Oakland, were Hon. William Wirt Pendegast, the framer of the law ; Dr. C. S. Haswell, of Sacramento ; W. E. Turner, an Oakland attorney, who took a very prominent part in the contest; S. H. Garter, of Red Bluff; Mrsn Emily Pitts Stevens, of San Francisco ; Miss Sallie Hart, Wm. Yan Voorhies, Judge Chamberlain, Mr. Redstone, Dr. Myrick,Mr. Battei-s, of San Francisco ; Judge Blake, Dr. Henry Gibbons, and several others.

At last the anxiously-looked-for 30th xlay of May arrived. The ladies had carefully arranged their plan of battle. With bountifullysupplied lunch-tables, situated in convenient localities, with an abundance of boquets, tastefully prepared for the button-hole, and with sweet smiles and bewitching ways, they prepared to meet the cohorts of rum. Early in the day they were all at their well-appointed posts, distributing ballots inscribed with the portentous words, " Against License," and soliciting votes. The " big tent," near the City Hall, was the grand rendezvous, but every polling precinct in the city had its guard-house, and was well watched and provided for. AVith boquet-baskets in hand and pleasant smiles on countenance, the most zealous would promenade in the vicinity of the polling places. Nay, some were so intrepid as to boldly penetrate rough crowds of men, clamorous for the protection of their personal liberties against this new-fangled notion, and ai-gue the point with them like experienced politicians. It was, for the female heart, a joyous taste of freedom. To be sure they did not vote, but they made votes. They were not candidates for office, but they enjoyed the i'ai*e privilege of openly expressing their sentiments in front of the ballot-box.

The 30th day of May was not a pleasant one. It was very chilly ; the wind was high and the dust was driven in clouds, and it was anything but comfortable to be in the streets ; yet the ladies did not give way nor coiuplaiai, but manfully held their phices. "Have you voted, sir T woukl be their sahitation to every male they nu^t ; or " Will you have a boquet ?" to draw on a conversation and ascertain the subject's sentiments. A " hard case " would be coaxed into the tent or refreshment place, plied with cakes and coffee, sandwiches, ibc, and converted. A deputation of the dear creatures woiikl sometimes accompany him, as an escort, to the ballot-box, and thus secure his vote beyond pei-adventure. And thus they worked all day long, at times receiving rebukes, and often saluted with cheers. Insults were seldom openly offered ; but when an instance of the kind occurred, woe to the guilty one, for he was hastily hustled by a clamorous crowd to the City Prison.

The "For License" men, although for the time being unpopular, and, in the feminine mind, little short of monsters, kept well up their side of the fight. They were not without friends. Although the bai'-rooms were all closed, in compliance with the law, they found plenty of sympathizers ; and, for the greater part of the day, it was considered a very doubtful contest. The first precinct, it was supposed, would give a large majority for license ; and the second, a large one against it ; while the Point and Temescal, it was thought, would be about equally divided. Towards evening, however, the conviction gained that the women were victorious, as was shown at the close of the count, when it was found that there was a majority of 253 against license, in the aggregate. The following was the vote by precincts: First Precinct - For license, 510; against license, 469. Second Precinct - For license, 249 ; against license, 524. Third Precinct - For license, 171 ; against license, 183. Fourth Precinct - For license, 108 ; against license, 115. Of course there was great rejoicing when the result was ascertained. There were congratulatory speeches, sei-enading and general exultation.

On the second night after the election there was a grand rally of the victorious femmine forces, in the tented field, on the corner of Fourteenth and Washington Streets, where the leaders of the army were crowned with victors' laurels, and the soldiers received congi-atulations and thanks.

Another battle was before them in a few days. The field of East Oakland was to be contested on the 7th of June. The ladies had fleshed their maiden swords, and the thirst for carnage was now upon them. More whiskey was to be spilt, more kegs of beer placed hors de combat. The army of Oakland determined to reinforce the anny of Bx'ooklyn en masse. The forces there were ah-eady well drilled and organized, and the Oakland victory had immensely improved their morale. Mr. E. Gr. Mathews was chosen Commander, with Messrs'. Sumner, Ford, Steen, Pensam, Lynde and Watson as Lieutenants. All the ladies of the town hastened to enroll themselves ia the Army of the East, while a large number of gentlemen volunteered their services as an active reserve. Whatever element of success that might have been overlooked or forgotten in the Oakland battle was here used to advantage. Duties were assigned to every one willing to lend a helping hand ; the organizers of the Oakland victory lent their aid and encouraged the cohorts.

But the other side was not idle. Defeat had not disheartened them ; it only made them more energetic. Nightly they met to raise the " sinews of war," and plan their battle ; every voter was canvassed, and a victory assured. Aid was invited from San Francisco and Oakland, and it came. There was a mightier marshalling of forces on both sides. Captain Badger was chosen general of the spirituous host ; and he called to his aid Hatch, of Santa Clara. Against the latter was pitted the Rev. Otis Gibson, of San Francisco, who led the singing host. Both armies met for review in sight of each other, the night before the battle. Martial music rent the air, and both sides shouted for victory, and were confident it was within their grasp on the morrow. As in Oakland, the temperance host took the field in a tent. The Union Hotel served the license legion for a camp. Hatch harangued his followers at great length, and proved the superior morality of the license cause, and the great evils of no license. In the tent, license was torn to tatters, and all the bottles and glasses smashed.

The eventful morning arrived. The very atmosphere seemed conscious of the desperate character of the approaching conflict, and held its breath. The sun shone sei'enely in the heavens, equally favoring both sides with the effulgence of his rays. The pollingplace was Judge Howax-d's old oflice, equi-distant between the two hostile camps.

In the " no license " camp the refreshment brigade and the boquet battalion were early in motion. Hot coffee and cakes, ham sandwiches and cold turkey were never so abundant on this side of the bay before, or since. The odor of flowers perfumed the au', and sweet smiles, bright eyes and soft words wooed the unwilling voter to cast his ballot against rum.

But the champions of vum were not idle either. They, too, had learnt a lesson from the Oakland encounter, and took advantage of several neglected aids. The streets swarmed with tlie valiant warriors from near and far. Male and female mingled in the moral melee. Martial music rent the air. The war chant of the crusader cari-ied dismay to the heart of the enemy at every street corner. Sallie Hart, leading the light infantry of the local option army, was distinguished for the rapidity of her movements and her sanguinary encounters. From Tubbs' Hotel to Tum Suden's - from the Railroad Depot to Adams Street, was the battle fiercely waged and every inch of ground disputed. Load after load of reinfoi'cements were carried to the battle-field. Never before, since the world began, was there such a wordy warfare. Tongues cut sharper than swords. There was bullyi'agging and brow-beating, badinage and braggadocio, coarse invective and sharp recontre, pointed jests and biting sarcasms, ridicule and rodomontade.

The " license" band-wagon would drive through a tempei*ance crowd and defiantly display its banners, inscribed with tlie legends of " Equal Rights " and " No Blue Laws for Brooklpi ;" and the band strike up with its stirring strains; when the Temperance Glee Club would gather a multitude around it and respond with a chorus that awakened the echoes in the distant mountains, and the refrain of " Grlory, glory, hallelujah ! " pierced the hills.

At last the polls closed ; the combat ceased ; and victory had once more perched on the temperance tent-top. A majority of 84 had decided against license. The vote was as follows :

Thus closed the most remarkable election that ever took place in this State, and perhaps anywhere else in the ^world. It vv-as computed that 500 women were on the sti*eets of Brooklyn that day, doing battle against the bottle. Not a breach of the peace was committed, nor an arrest made - wluch fact spoke well for the conduct of the men who Avere battling for the protection of their business, or repelling what they believed to be an encroachment upon their natui-al rights.

Immediately after the Brooklyn election was formed the Oakland Township Temperance Alliance, the objects of which were the promotion of temperance principles by all suitable means and the securing of the best laws to that end.

It was recommended by the Supervisors that no prosecution be had against those who kept their saloons open after the election, until the first of July following, and that recommendation was acted upon in Oakland and Brooklyn.

The next election ordex-ed was in Muri-ay Township. It took place on the 27th day of June. The largest vote ever polled in the township was cast, and was largely for license. Livermore Precinct gave 241 votes for and 125 against; Pleasanton Precinct, 120 votes for, and only 33 against; Summit Precinct, 23 for, and 12 against - making a total vote in Murray Township of 554, and giving the license side a majority of 214. It was evident from this that the extreme ends of the county were widely at variance on the^liquor question, and each side had won important victoi'ies. Two townships had now gone for Kcense, and two against, and two - Alameda and Eden - remained to be heard from.

As was the case elsewhere, the preparations for the fray in Alameda were very vigorous. Dr. Henry Gibbons marshalled and animated the option host. He had abundance of assistance ; but the ladies, on account of the difference in the population - Alameda being largely German - did not turn out so numerously as they did in Oakland and Brooklyn. The liquor men dropped the policy they had hitherto pursued, of making few public demonstrations, and employed speakers and held meetings, making a good canvass. The election was held on the 2d day of July. That usually quiet place underwent a siege which will be remembered by all who witnessed it as long as they live. The scenes that took place almost beggared description. Ladies from Oakland, Brooklyn and San Francisco, with many gentlemen, were present. A tent was used as a rallyingplace, as in Oakland and Brooklyn. The usual lunch-tables were laid out and the flower-girls were on hand. The singing host, headed by the Rev. Otis Gibson, was there, too, and the fighting host under Turner. The wildest enthusiasm was excited. Here lager was attacked in one of its strongholds, and lager met ifc in no laggard way. A policy of ofiense was determuaed upon, and the ladies were Avarned to look out. The little town was regularly besieged. Hundreds came over from San Francisco, where the liquor men had organized a league. A detachment of this organization, headed by a band of music, marched through the town, singing Bacchanalian songs. Sally Hart was present with her light infantry (an organization of young men and women), but she was overwhelmed by the physical force pitted against her. It was no longer pretty talk and good-natured discussion. Affairs took a decidedly rude turn, and the ladies were finally forced to yield the streets and retreat to their tent, while the battle at the ballot-box went largely against them. The result at the close was that 201 votes were given for license, and only 108 against. The newspaper controversy that followed was very warm. The San Francisco Post and Chronicle, and the Oakland News were very severe in their comments on the conduct of the license men ; while the Alia and Transa-ipt espoused their cause, and defended them against the onslaughts of their adversaries.

License was now in' the ascendant in the county, having carried three out of the five township elections held, and Eden alone remained to determine whether it should be an equally divided victory or an overwhelming defeat for the temperance army. The election was fixed for the 11th day of July. The rudeness practiced at Alameda it was feared would be renewed in Eden, and matters took a decidedly belligerent turn. A strong police force, headed by Sheriff Morse, was on hand to prevent disorder, and many of the temperance men went armed. Even giins were held in readiness. The most prominent men and women in each toAvn in the township - wliich embraced Haywards, San Leaudro, San Lorenzo and Mount Eden - were ranged with the temperance ticket, regardless of pai-ty or political proclivity. Here Judge Russell, head of the Temperance Alliance, was at home. The usual workers on both sides at the other elections were on hand, women as well as men. No disturbance took place, and tlie only arrest made was of a couple of contraband kegs of lager at San Leandro. These were carried off from their hiding place on the margin of the creek, in triumph, and confiscated by the Slieriff. The contest promised to be very close, but the count of the ballots in the evening unfolded another license victoiy. The majority was small, but it confirmed the unpopularity of the new law.

Following were the returns received from each polHng place : San Leandro - For License, 79; against, 87. Haywards - For License, 101; against, 93. San Lorenzo - For License, 79; again.st, bo. Mount Eden - For License, 49 ; against, 9. Total majority for License in the township, 61.

In Oakland and Brooklyn the saloons did not close at the apj^ointed time, and forty-four warrants were served by the Sherilf in one day, for violations of the law. Convictions were had; but an appeal was in the mean time made to the Supreme Court against the unconstitutionality of the law, and Judge Nye reserved his decision until the Supreme Court had passed upon it. The ground taken was that the law operated unequally, as under it liquor could be sold in one locality and not in another. The Constitution of the State declares that all laws must be equal in their operation, and on this ground the Supreme Court quashed the whole business, and the Pendegast Act was repealed at the last session of the Legislature. And thus fruitlessly closed a series of the most exciting, odd, and probably most remarkable election contests that ever took place in the w-orld.

During the winter of 1874 took place the celebrated legislative investigation into the management by the Board of Regents of the erection of the College of Letters of the State University. The building had been constructed the previous summer, at a cost to the State of $130,000, and it was maintained by some that this amount was in excess of what it should rightly have cost by about $24,043.12. Two investigations were held - one by an Assembly and the other by a Senate Committee. It was shown that the Regents left the management of the erection to Dr. Merritt, who was Chairman of the Building Committee, and that he had let the work to certain favorite conti-actors, in order that he might, himself, make a profit thereon. The attack on Dr. Merritt and the Regents was led by Assemblyman Tyrrell, of San Francisco, who was himself a builder, and anxious at the time to bid on the job; but according to his own statement, was advised by Mr. Miller, the millman, that it would be useless for him to do so, as the firm of Power & Ough were sure to have the work, no matter who bid or what their offers were. Mr. Miller, however, denied on oath that he had made any such remark. A great manywitnesses were examined and much time taken up with the enquiry. Power &. Ough, who had in the meantime left the country, asserted by letter that all that they had made by the contract was 3^ per cent., and that the State had in the College of Letters the cheai)est of all its structures. The fact that Dr. Merritt was the owner of a lumber yard, and supplied material for the building, was much commented upon, although the Doctor declared that he had furnished lumber as cheap as anyone else could have done. At any rate, the reports of the Special Committees were condemnatory of the manner in which the work had been carried out ; but nothing more was done about it, excepting Judge Nye calling attention to the matter in his subsequent charge to the Grand Jury.

This year, too, we had Sheriff Morse's celebrated pursuit of Vasquez, which proved ineffectual, as the celebrated detective never got . near the notorious outlaw, who, however, was captured soon after Morse gave up the chase, near Los Angeles.

Oakland witnessed the famous Grand Central Hotel suit - Merritt vs. Wilcox ; was entei-tained and puzzled with the Clarke ghost mystery ; the introduction of public drinking-fountains ; and the establishment of a Board of Public Works.

Prof. Wm. Swinton, a gentleman who was associated with the University since its establishment, as Professor of English Language and Literature, resigned his position and went East. He carried with him the regrets and well- wishes of his colleagues in the University. The resignation took place early in March.

Captain Hii-am Thorne, a member of the Oakland Board of Fire Commissioners, and an old resident of Brooklyn, died suddenly of heart disease, on the morniag of the 13th of March. He was a native of ISTew York, and about 60 years of age at the time of his death. The flags of the City Hall and engine-houses were placed at half-mast in respect to his memory.

The Oilman claim against Contra Costa County, for the l;)uilding of the first Oakland bridge, was up before the Legislature again this session, with no other than the usual result - defeat.

Tlie Livermore Grange of tlie Patrons of Husbandry passed a series of resolutions, at a meeting held on the 1st of August, protesting against the action of the Board of Regents in removing Dr. CaiT from the position of Professor of Agriculture in the State University, and condemning the management of the College of Agriculture, which were followed by many others of similar character in various portions of the State.

Mr. S. A. Penwell, Secretary of the Berkeley Land Company, gave notice, in August, that the wharf was completed, and that all shippers were entitled to the use of the same, free of charge. It is 1,360 feet in extreme length, and 80 feet wide at its lower portion, and at its upper portion, 30 feet. It is a strong structure.

Hon. S. P. Wright, late Disti-ict Attorney of Alameda County, died at Santa Bai'bara on the 24th of July, after a protracted illness. He was formerly State Senator from the counties of Humboldt, Klamath and Del Norte, and served a term as President ^;ro tern. He was an able and honest man. At the time of his demise his plac^ of residence was East Oakland, where he left a wife and two childx'en to mourn his loss. At the following meeting of the County Court, resolutions of regret and condolence were passed.

A meeting of persons interested in the construction of a narrowgauge railroad from Martinez to Livermore, was held at Danville, Contra Costa County, on the 3d day of October. Nathan Jones, of Walnut Creek, occupied the Chair ; and F. R. Fassett, of Livermore, acted as Secretary. A committee, consisting of Daniel H. Inman, of Livermore ; Mr. Baldwin, of Limerick ; Chas. Wood, of Danville ; W. W. Camron, of Green Valley ; John Larkey, of Walniit Creek ; Lafayette Fish and Dr. Strentzel, of Martinez, were appointed a committee to complete the organization. The distance from Mai-tinez to Livermore is 35 miles, and a railroad would run nearly all the way over a level gi'ade, through the Pacheco, San Ramon, Amador, and Livermore Valleys. Several other meetings were subsequently held, but, after a time, the enterprise was allowed to drop.

A reunion of the Grangers of Alameda County took place at Haywards on the 17th of October, at which wei'e represented Eden Grange, Thos. Hellar, Master ; Centre ville Grange, Jas. Shinn, Master; Sunol Grange, E. M. Carr, Master; Livermore Grange, Daniel H. Inman, Master; Temescal Grange, Dr. Ezra S. Carr, Master.

It is situated on the west, or Washington Phiza, on Broadway, between Fourth and Fifth streets. It is constructed of wood, stone, brick and iron, and is an elegant and imposing structure ; in dimensions, 175x100 feet. The contract price was $148,550; but the extras and alterations have raised it to over $200,000. A Jail was also erected this year, on tlie same block of ground, immediately west of the Court-house. It is built of brick and stone, and its dimensions are 40x75 feet, two stories high, with wings. Cost, $39,000; but, with building at Brooklyn, taking down and rebuilding, the total charge to jail account is $70,000.

An Act to define the boundary line between San Francisco and Alameda Counties. [The old line included a portion of the railroad w-harf within the limits of San Francisco County ; the line determined by this Act is drawn at a distance of 500 feet west of the railroad wharf.]

An Act authorizing the Supervisors of Alameda County to erect buildings on Washington and Franklin Squares, in the City of Oakland, and to issue bonds to the amount of $200,000 therefor.

An Act to authorize the Governor to select five Commissioners, who shall have concurrent power with the Council to purchase, construct or condemn water-works. [Bonds to the amount of $800,000 may be issued and the credit of the city pledged.]

An Act supplementary to the city charter. [Makes office of City Attorney elective ; fixes salaries of officers ; prohibits the incurring of debts, etc.]

An Act confirming the action of the City Council in paying City Marshal Johnson the damages recovered against him by propertyholders on Eighth Street.

An Act to provide for the issue of $100,000 of bonds, to fund the debt of tlie city. [$12,000 is provided for the new school-house in Brooklyn ; and the creation of further debts in excess of the city's revenue is prohibited.]

An Act to authorize the City of Oakland to issue eight per cent, bonds, and use the money to I'edeem the ten per cent, bonds now outstanding.

An Act to authorize the trustees of the First Congregational Religious Society of Oakland to convert certain real estate belonging to said society in the City of Oakland and County of Alameda.

An Act to provide for the collection of district school taxes in Townsend and May School Districts, in Murray Township, in the County of Alameda.

An Act in relation to certain streets in the Town of Alameda. An Act supplementary to an Act, entitled an Act to establish a Police Court in the City of Oakland, and define its jurisdiction, .duties, and fees of Court, and its officers.

Mr. Amerman was also the author of "An Act to define the Senatorial and Assembly Districts of this State, and to apportion the representation thei-eof," whereby^ the representation of Alameda County was increased from one to two Senators, and from tv/o to three Assemblymen.

Provenance

Text from The Centennial Year Book of Alameda County, California : Containing a Summary of the Discovery and Settlement of California, a Description of the Contra Costa Under Spanish, Mexican, and American Rule, an Account of the Organization and Settlement of Alameda County ... Also, a Gazetteer of Each Township, Useful Local and General Statistical Information, Appropriate for the Present Time, to Which Are Added Biographical Sketches of Prominent Pioneers and Public Men, published 1876, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.