BlockBefore

Contra Costa County, California - Chapter 16: Early Criminal History, 1917 (part 1 of 2)

From The History of Contra Costa County, California, published 1917. 15,882 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,882 words

Machine-read from scans of The History of Contra Costa County, California, published 1917. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

The People vs. Wempett and Wampett. - On September 28, 1850, two Indians named Wempett and Wampett were found guilty of manslaughter by a jury, and sentenced to pay a fine of one dollar and two weeks' imprisonment, but who their victim was, or what were the circumstances of the case, the records do not divulge.

Murder of Aparicio Morales. - On May 29, 1852, Jose Antonio, an Indian, stabbed Aparicio Morales at or near the residence of Doctor Tennent in Pinole, from the effects of which Morales died. Antonio was duly tried before C. P. Hester, district judge, found guilty July 9, 1852, and sentenced to be hanged. He was executed August 20, 1852. He was hanged from the limb of a sycamore tree in the suburbs of the village of Martinez. A barrel was placed in an old cart, and the condemned man required to stand on that ticklish foundation while the rope was adjusted. The cart was finally driven away, and the poor fellow tumbled off the barrel and into eternity.

Killing of Ignacio Flores, alias Figaro. - The victim in this case was killed at a place known as the "Chicken Ranch," on October 30, 1853. He came to his death by severe wounds from knife and pistol at the hands of Miguel Nabaro, his wife Antonia and Rafael Soto being apprehended as accessories to the act. On trial the accessory Antonia was discharged, but there is no record of what became of the others.

Murder of James M. Gordon. - The particulars of this deed were communicated to a Stockton newspaper by Doctor Marsh at the time of its occurrence. About seven o'clock in the evening of October 2, 1854, three men came to the house of J. M. Gordon, near Doctor Marsh's, and desired him to give them directions about the road, saying that they had lost their way. As soon as Gordon went to his door, he was shot by one of the party ; another of them fired at him also, but missed him. One of the balls struck Gordon, inflicting a mortal wound. Gordon fled in the darkness, and with difficulty reached Doctor Marsh's house, about two miles distant. The object of the ruffians was undoubtedly robbery, as the house was found to be ransacked. The men were traced and ultimately arrested in San Francisco. They were Henry H. Monroe, Andrew Hollenstein, and Thomas Addison. Monroe was duly tried for murder, convicted, and hanged November 24, 1854. While awaiting his execution Addison attempted his rescue, for which he was indicted by the Grand Jury, and imprisoned, but on January 20, 1855, made his escape from jail and has never been captured. The other accomplice, Hollenstein, was handed over to the custody of the sheriff of Solano County in the same month.

Killing of Terrence H. McDonald. - It appears that on June 11, 1856, Rafael, an Indian, and Isabel, an Indian squaw, stabbed Terrence H. McDonald on the right side of the neck, from which he died instantly, the deed being committted in his own dwelling. September 5, 1856, they were convicted of manslaughter, the man sentenced to ten years and the woman to eighteen months imprisonment in the State prison. There was also an accomplice, who was discharged.

Murder of Doctor John Marsh. - Perhaps no more horrible crime than the murder of this pioneer can be found in the pages of any history, and certainly no better example of justice following the guilty than that which tracked one of the murderers to punishment eleven years after the commission of his foul deed. Doctor Marsh had been for many years - long before the American occupation of California - the owner of the Los Meganos Rancho, of which he became possessed, as we have elsewhere stated, by purchase, in the year 1837. Here he dwelt, surrounded by his people, flocks, and herds, for full two decades. On or about the 24th of September, 1856, business called him from his farm to Martinez, some thirty miles distant. In the gray dawn of the following morning his horse and buggy were found in the town of Martinez, but without an occupant. Then followed the search, which led to the discovery of his body in a roadside ditch, immediately upon which the pursuit of the murderers was undertaken. On the day fol- lowing Jose Antonio Olivas was captured; after making confession as to certain money found in his possession, taken from the body of the murdered victim, and impHcating FeHpe Moreno as principal in the deed, he was tried and convicted, but, escaping from jail, he eluded justice for more than ten years. In September, 1866, he was recaptured in Santa Barbara County, and brought to Contra Costa to await his trial. About the same time Felipe Moreno was taken in Sacramento, where he was going under the alias of Don Castro. When arrested he made desperate efforts to escape, but being mastered was quickly handcuffed and incarcerated. The third party implicated in the terrible murder, Juan Garcia, has up to the present time eluded justice. The trial of Felipe Moreno for the murder of Doctor Marsh was commenced on Saturday, September 23, 1867, and on the following Thursday the jury brought a verdict of murder in the second degree against the prisoner. The principal and only positive witness for the prosecution on this trial was Jose Antonio Olivas, one of the three persons indicted for the murder. Separate trials for the prisoners had been procured by District Attorney Mills, with the purpose of using the testimony of Olivas for the State and corroborating it, as to material points, by that of unimpeachable and disinterested witnesses. The defense relied mainly upon being able to prove an alibi ; but notwithstanding the very able efforts of the counsel for the prisoner, M. S. Chase, of Martinez, the testimony failed to convince the jury, as the verdict shows, although it was not as severe as might have been expected, possibly because of the youth of the prisoner, and the doubt remaining as to whether he may have been the principal actor in the perpetration of the murder, or merely an accessory. The story of the Doctor's death, as told by Olivas, is as follows : On the morning of September 24, 1856, the date of the murder, Jose Antonio Olivas and Felipe Moreno, aged twenty-five and nineteen years respectively, in company with some females, came into the village of Martinez, where, having attended church, they proceeded to Pinole, returning from there between four and five o'clock that same evening. They almost immediately continued their journey to Pacheco alone, and when reaching the hill about a mile from Martinez paused a while to await the arrival of one Garcia, who was expected to meet them. Olivas then went on ahead for about two hundred yards, when he was overtaken by his comrades, and the three urged their horses into a gallop. While so pro- ceeding they met a man named Swanson. Not long after this circumstance Doctor Marsh was observed to be coming in his buggy. Hereupon he was accosted by OUvas, who asked him for certain money due him for services as a vaquero, to which the Doctor replied that he would be paid on his return from San Francisco, but that he had no rnoney with him then. The deceased now rode away, while the party remained behind and concocted a scheme to kill him, but finally arranged that he should only be robbed. They then followed in pursuit, and on overtaking their victim, Olivas, by Moreno's orders, seized the Doctor's horse by the head, while Moreno jumped into the buggy and Garcia stood guard alongside. The deceased at once faced his enemy and said, "Do you want to kill me?" to which he received the reply, "No," from Olivas, and "Yes" from Moreno, and, notwithstanding the dissuasions of his companions, this youthful fiend slashed the unfortunate man in the face with a knife. He was then dragged out of the vehicle and fell to the ground, being before, however, wounded in the hand; Olivas having then dismounted, as he says, for the purpose of assisting the Doctor, who came toward and struck at him, a scuffle ensued, Olivas crying to Moreno to free him. Thereupon Moreno observed, "Why should I let go this old cabron?" and forthwith stabbed his prostrate victim in the side. Upon receiving this wound the Doctor cried aloud, when Moreno was prepared to repeat the operation, but was pushed away by Olivas, who parried a cut made at him. The Doctor now attempted to rise, but was only able to stagger a short distance and fell into a ditch dead. His pockets were then rifled by Garcia and Moreno, who afterward cut his throat, the deed being witnessed by Olivas from his saddle. This terrible crime being perpetrated, the triumvirate repaired to the top of a convenient hill and there divided the booty, whence they repaired to some houses for the night and afterward fled, and for ten years and upward escaped the iron hand of the law. Moreno was sentenced to imprisonment for life in the State prison on November 29, 1867.

Murder of Nicholas Brenzel. - A most atrocious murder was committed near the San Domingo Rancho on May 21, 1859. A man named John Mohr was accused of killing Nicholas Brenzel by striking him with a scythe, and was duly arrested in Martinez. From the testimony of the wife of the deceased, it would appear that Brenzel and Mohr, who were both Germans, were engaged during the year in cultivating a ranch together. Mohr owed Brenzel several hundred dollars borrowed money, and Brenzel asked him if he would not pay a portion of it, as he wished to purchase some grain-sacks. On Mohr's refusal to let his partner have any money, Brenzel replied that he would go to San Francisco, borrow the money there, and purchase the sacks on his own account. This conversation took place in the house on the morning of the crime. A few minutes afterward the wife of Brenzel heard a cry of distress, and on going to the door saw Mohr with a scythe-blade in his hand, and near by was the prostrate and bleeding form of her husband. She asked Mohr why he had killed her husband. He replied, '*I did it because I wanted to," and then threw down the scythe, seized a spade, and endeavored to strike the dying man again.

Killing of an Unknown Man. - At an early hour on the morning of October 13, 1859, several citizens living in the vicinity of Lafayette missed their saddles, and it was at once conjectured that horse-thieves had visited the neighborhood, several horses having been stolen from that district a week previously. The alarm was given, and in a very short time a party of six or eight citizens started out and soon got on the trail of the supposed plunderers, those in pursuit being guided by fresh tracks of horses. The trail led across the hills in the direction of San Ramon Valley, crossing it about a mile on the west side of Alamo, and thence toward Mount Diablo. They proved to the Mexicans who had picketed their horses and encamped on the ground close by, having with them saddles belonging to David Carrick and Homer Shuey. They were suddenly surprised by their pursuers and ordered to surrender, a command to which they paid no attention, but endeavored to make their escape. They were fired upon by the citizens, when one of their number fell mortally wounded, having been shot through the head. The other two took to the chaparral, but as soon as they became aware that the pursuing party was endeavoring to capture them at all hazards the rascals came out of the bush and gave themselves up. The wounded man was conveyed to the Walnut Creek House, where he died the same night. He was a Mexican, apparently about twenty-five years of age, and on his body was found a letter from the noted desperado, Tiburcio Vasquez, dated from the State prison at San Quentin,and bearing the super-

Killing of Edward Norris. - This tragedy took place at Conkling's Hotel, on the road between Lafayette and Oakland, on the evening of December ii, 1859. The particulars, as gleaned from the Contra Costa Gazette, are as follows : A. H. Houston, of San Francisco, was the owner of some five hundred acres of the Sobrante claim, on the San Pablo Creek. The property had been squatted on by settlers, with all of whom, save one, Mr. Houston had compromised, so as to obtain full possession. This one, a man named Edward Norris, had fenced in some seventy acres of Houston's land and refused to give up possession. On December loth Houston went over to his ranch for the purpose of making some arrangement toward a peaceable settlement of the dispute. He visited the house of Mr. Norris on Sunday, the nth, but not finding the latter at home, left a request that he would on his return call at his (Houston's) farm-house and have a talk with him before the hour necessary to start to take the last boat that was to leave Oakland. Houston then returned to his house, and, after waiting as long as possible, he left word with his father-in-law, W. C. Pease, who was in charge of the property, to settle the matter peacefully, by paying Norris a reasonable sum to leave quietly. Norris, however, did not come to the house, and in the evening Pease went over to the hotel near by, kept by Conkling, for the purpose of getting supper. While eating, a crowd of men arrived at the hotel, among whom was Norris. They were in the bar-room while Pease was in the dining-room. The conversation of Norris and his friends was upon the matter in dispute between the former and Houston. Pease, hearing his name mentioned in not very complimentary terms, stepped to the door of the apartment in which Norris and the others were conversing, and, drawing a pistol, demanded to know who had anything to say against "Old Pease," at the same time raising his pistol, cocking it, and threatening to shoot the first man who raised a finger. Norris, who was in the act of drinking as Pease entered, put down his glass on the table ; some harsh words then passed between Pease and Norris ; the latter, who was unarmed, reached forward to seize the pistol, when Pease instantly fired, and Norris fell

Killing of Sadello Catiyo. - During a drunken brawl at the house of Jose Silva, in Rodeo Valley, on the night of May 10, i860, a Chileno named Sadello Catiyo, was killed by his countryman, Assesso Gayarado.

Murder of Guadalupe Tapia. - Guadalupe Tapia, a Mexican, was mortally wounded with a knife on July 4, i860, by Ramon Ruiz. They were seen together near Alamo, each having a horse, though dismounted, and just previous to the attack deceased was observed to be reclining on the ground holding his animal by his bridle. Ruiz now suddenly rushed upon him with a knife, inflicting a terrible wound in the abdomen, from the effects of which he died in a few hours. The murderer was arrested, but at his trial, which took place January 16, 1861, he was discharged, the jury disagreeing, there being eleven in favor of conviction of murder in the first degree and one for manslaughter.

Killing of N. Nathan. - The 'Gazette of February 15, 1862, says: "The body of N. Nathan was found near Pinole a few days since, much decayed." The verdict of the inquest was that he had been robbed and murdered. His license as a peddler bore date about the middle of December, 1 861. He was aged about twenty-one years and had no relatives in California.

Killing of Patrick Finnegan. - On the evening of November 30, 1862, Patrick Finnegan was shot at Clayton, under the following circumstances : It would appear that a troupe of minstrels gave a performance at the Clayton House in the evening to a rather noisy audience. At its conclusion one of the company was somewhat roughly handled by certain parties present, and R. L. Bradley handed him a pistol, telling him to protect himself. He did not use it, but returned it soon after. One account of the affair was that in passing the pistol back it was accidentally discharged; while another eye-witness stated positively that on receiving it Bradley willfully shot Finnegan. The ball struck deceased on the left side of his nose, passing into the head and killing him instantly. Bradley mounted a horse and made his escape.

Killing of James Magee. - On December i, 1862, James Magee was shot and killed by James Tice. There had been a difficulty between the parties, and in the afternoon in question Tice, who had been drinking, went to the ranch of the deceased, and some hard words passed between them. Tice at length wished to shake hands, to which Magee objected, telling him he was drunk, and ordering him off the premises. Magee had a shot-gun in his hand at the time, which he had gone into the house for. He turned as if to leave the spot, when Tice presented his pistol and shot him in the left side. He exclaimed, "Oh, I'm a dead man sure!" and almost immediately expired. Tice mounted his horse, rode to Martinez, and put himself in the custody of the sheriff. Deceased owned a valuable ranch in the Moraga Valley, and had accumulated a handsome property. Tice was duly tried before Hon. S. F. Reynolds, district judge. May 30, 1863, when a jury returned a verdict of not guilty.

Murder of Louis d'Alencon. - On the night of Thursday, or the morning of Friday, March 12-13, 1863, Louis d'Alencon, the keeper of the Valley House near Martinez, was murdered by some person or persons unknown. The last that was seen of the deceased alive was on Thursday night by the hired man, an old friend and fellow countryman who lodged with him, when, having shut up the house, they partook of a drink together before retiring for the night, the man then going to bed leaving D'Alencon in the bar-room, where he was in the frequent babbit of sitting up all night engaged in writing, he being a regular correspondent of the French newspapers in San Francisco. The companion soon fell asleep and was not disturbed by any unusual noise, but thought that had there been such he would have noticed it, as he was used to D'Alencon's habit of being up and moving about all night. At a very early hour on Friday morning, Pancho Flores, passing the Valley House on the way to a rodeo, noted the door ajar, and saw the body of D'Alencon lying on the floor between it and the bar. Pancho tried to enter, but was unable to open the door wide enough on account of the position in which the inanimate form lay. He therefore went around to the back of the house, awoke the hired man, and asked him what drunken man was asleep in the bar. The two then went to ascertain, and were horrified to

Murder of an Unknown Man. - A stranger, dressed in working clothes, arrived at San Pablo on the night of August 4, 1863, and, after eating supper at the hotel, took his blanket and proceeded a short distance up the road, when he turned off into a wheat-field, spread his bedding, and lay down. The following morning he was found there quite dead, with a wound in the temple, apparently caused by a blow from a heavy instrument. The body was yet warm when discovered.

Killing of John Pete. - On January 11, 1864, one Frank McCann killed John Pete in a quarrel over a game of cards at San Pablo, but what the particulars of the outrage were we have been unable to gather.

Murder of Martine Berryessa. - On February 8, 1864, at the town of Old Pinole, Martine Berryessa was stabbed with a knife by a man who was known by the solitary name of Francisco. Death was almost instantaneous. The facts of the case are these : Some two or three weeks before hard words had passed between the parties, and a charge of horse-stealing was bandied from one to the other. Thereupon a scuffle ensued, in which a cut was received in the leg by Francisco. They then separated, after threats were made by Francisco, and they did not cross each other again until the day of the fatal meeting, when Francisco and two men with him were for some hours at Pinole. Just as they were about leaving, they saw Berryessa, and, going up to him, Francisco observed that somebody wanted him at a place near by. Berryessa refused to go with them, whereupon he was told he should be made to go, and Francisco drew a pistol upon him. He held up his hands as if to ward off the shot or to seize the weapon, and then, instead of firing the pistol, Francisco unsheathed a knife and stabbed him under the arm. It entered his back immediately below the shoulder, penetrating the lungs, and causing him to fall dead. The murderer and his two companions then fled. Francisco being caught by the bystanders, after a short chase, was lodged in the jail at Martinez.

explained reason, he attacked a man named Humboldt, a resident of Oakland, Alameda County, who, in self-defense, turned on the deceased and slew him.

Murder of a Man Named "Jo-" - ^^ the month of June, 1874, but on what day we cannot ascertain, a man called "Jo" was stabbed by one Alvarez at Pinole. The cause was liquor and jealousy. Alvarez delivered himself up to the authorities, but was discharged.

Murder of Jesus Diana. - The following murder was committed November 12, 1864, under the most vengeful and brutal circumstances. It appears that a Mexican by the name of Luis Romero had been living in a family of the same nationality a few miles from Pinole. In that household was included a young woman about sixteen years old, the sister of the mistress of the house. This young girl's name was Jesus Diana. Romero was courting her and was very anxious to marry her. She, however, refused all his solicitations, whereat he was very much incensed. Immediately after breakfast on the morning of the fatal day he took his gun and started off, as he said, on a hunting trip. Only a few moments passed, however, before he came back to the house and found the married sister outside at a well near by. The murdered girl was within, washing dishes. He then went in and stabbed her in the back with a common butcher knife. Her screams quickly brought the absent sister to the door. Upon the latter crying out to Romero to desist, vhe turned upon her too, with the same knife, when she ran away. He called to her not to be afraid, for he should kill himself also. He then went back, took the gun, put it to his own throat, holding it under the chin so that the charge would pass into his brain, and thus killed himself. Before doing so, however, he stabbed the girl in several places, one of the wounds going entirely through the body.

Murder of Valencia. - On August 25, 1866, a Mexican, or native Californian, named Valencia, died at Martinez from the effects of a wound received at the hands of Jesus Garcia, on the previous Tuesday. It is said there was no provocation for the assault, although some quarrel had occurred between the parties. The attack was made with a stick or club of oak wood, with which the deceased was severely beaten upon the head and other parts of the body. Garcia was arrested, tried, and on December 27th sentenced by District Judge Dwindle to imprisonment for two years in the State prison.

Murder of Mrs. Elizabeth Robinson. - The following most brutal murder was committed on the night of December 26, 1866, on the person of Mrs. Elizabeth Robinson, an aged woman who dwelt in the vicinity of the Roman Catholic church. The facts of the case as alleged are these : The body of the deceased was discovered lying upon the floor by the child of a neighbor some time during the forenoon of Thursday, the 27th, and upon this information a number of persons immediately repaired to the premises and found the body in a night-dress upon the floor of the rear room, with the head, face, arms, and hands fearfully cut and gashed and several stabs in the breasts and throat, one of the latter being entirely through the neck, from front to back. Near the body was a piece of candle and a candlestick. The appearances led to the belief that the deceased, aroused by the noise made in entering the house, had risen from her bed, lighted the candle, and on entering the rear room from which the noise proceeded received a severe blow upon the forehead, followed by assaults with the knife, against which the gashes upon the arms and hands showed that she made a protracted but unavailing struggle. The floor of the house displayed bloody tracks, and upon one of the partitions was the full print of a bloody hand, made by the murderer probably on groping his way through the dark. There were also the marks of bloody fingers on the sUding window, showing that he had carefully closed it on his retreat from the premises. The object of the murder was undoubtedly plunder, as the deceased, who was about seventy-five years of age, by a long life of toil, had accumulated some property, and may have been supposed to have money with her in the house, which had all the appearances of having been searched after the life of the woman had been taken. Two days later a mixed-blood Mexican and Indian, called Manuel Jaurez, was arrested under circumstances that tended strongly to identify him with the murder, several of the articles belonging to Mrs. Robinson having been found in his house in Martinez. He was duly incarcerated, and, after a trial lasting an entire week, was found guilty of murder, the testimony against him being entirely circumstantial, but most conclusive. On May 10, 1867, he was sentenced to be hanged on June 28th, on which day he was executed at the jail at Martinez. Before the carrying out of the sentence, in response to a notice that he was at liberty to say anything he might desire to communicate before execution, in substance he remarked: "In a few minutes I shall be in the presence of my God, and I now declare that I am innocent of the crime for which I am to die ; and what I have previously confessed I did in the hope of escaping punishment."

Killing of Sacramento Leibas. - On the evening of January 7, 1867, Sacramento Leibas was shot and fatally wounded by Antonio Figueroa in the Pastor House, a saloon and boarding-house in Pacheco, and principally patronized by native Calif ornians. A difficulty had existed between the parties for some time, and several weeks before deceased complained of Figueroa for threats against his life, but the evidence submitted to Justice of the Peace Sayles, before whom the case was brought, did not warrant placing him under bonds. On the evening of the killing three men came into the saloon together, Bonifacio Pacheco, Espirito Almosan, and Antonio Figueroa, all somewhat under the influence of liquor. Figueroa commenced to abuse Leibas, who replied, "It's all right ; I don't want any words." He then directed his conversation to Antonio Leibas, brother of the deceased, in the same strain, and finally the remainder of those present came in for a share of his vituperation. After a while he went out, but soon returned, followed by Pacheco, who was apparently endeavoring to hold his arm. Figueroa raised a pistol, pointed it at Sacramento Leibas, who was standing behind the counter, and fired, the ball taking effect near the heart of the unfortunate man, who died in about an hour and a half. Notwithstanding being pursued, Figueroa escaped. Pacheco and Almosan were arrested as accessories, and after examination were discharged for want of evidence. They were subsequently rearrested and lodged in jail at Martinez. Figueroa was traced to a point on the San Joaquin, near Firebaugh's Ferry, where it is supposed he obtained a crossing in a boat kept there by a party of Sonorans. The accessories were found not guilty May i8th and discharged.

tonio Corquillo had been in the employ of Peter Lynch, who resided on San Pablo Creek. On a certain Saturday evening in the month of March, 1867, a bottle of Hquor was taken to the cabin where both men lived, and both becoming intoxicated a quarrel ensued. The Portuguese finally went to his bed, but was soon after assailed by Lynch. A struggle ensued, and in self-defense Corquillo seized a monkey-wrench from a tool-chest near by and dealt Lynch a fatal blow. He made a full confession, surrendered himself to the authorities, and on May 11, 1867, was tried and acquitted.

Killing of Enoch J. Davis. - One of the proprietors of the Cumberland house, at the Black Diamond Coal Mines, named Enoch J. Davis, died March i, 1867, from the effects of a knife wound inflicted by William Bowen some ten days prior to the decease. From the testimony given at the inquest it appears that Bowen and another party got into a quarrel over a game of cards and were ordered by Davis to go out of the house and settle their difficulty ; they accordingly went out, and after a scuffle returned, still disputing, when Davis again ordered them away to fight the matter out, at the same time applying some derogatory epithets to Bowen, upon which he ran to his room and returned with a

Davis replying that he did, plunged the knife into his breast ; then going back to the room, in which there were several other lodgers, threw the bloody weapon on the table and declared he would take the life of any man who called him such a name. Davis's wound was not at first thought to be mortal, and Bowen remained at the place until within a few days of his victim's death, when he left.

Killing of William Nesbit. - The circumstances of this case are from the dying deposition of the victim. The murder was committed near Somersville on the night of December 21, 1866. On that night, a difficulty having originally occurred between Nesbit and George Vernon, he (Nesbit) went to the house of Vernon for the purpose of settling the difficulty without further trouble. Stopping at Vernon's door, he told him that he wished to talk with him peaceably and settle their difficulty without further words. Vernon said, "All right ; wait until I get my boots and I will come and talk with you." Vernon went into the house and returned instantly with a pistol, and while Nesbit was sitting on the porch fired at him, the ball striking him in the breast. As he jumped to run he again shot him in the back. He also fired other shots which did not strike him. On April 24, 1867, Vernon was found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to ten years' imprisonment in the State prison. In 1871 he was pardoned, the grounds given by Governor Haight for so doing being: "There are serious doubts of his guilt, and it is the opinion of many of the citizens of said [Contra Costa] county that he should not have been convicted, and these doubts seem well founded.'*

Killing of S. A. Carpenter. - On September 30, 1868, S. A. Carpenter, an old and well-known resident of Alamo, was found dead in a trail leading over a ridge to his residence, about two hundred yards from where the body was discovered. His horse, all saddled, had been previously found roaming about, the circumstance which led to the search. The deceased was in his shirt-sleeves, as if only a temporary absence was intended. He had been shot through the body, the ball entering the right side just below and behind the arm, and coming out of the right side a short distance below the nipple. There was no apparent deflection in its course, and, passing about an inch below the heart, produced death almost instantaneously. From its evident force, the ball was thought to have been discharged from a rifle or heavy revolver. His pantaloons were also cut in the folds on the left side, apparently by a ball that had passed clear of the body. Carpenter is described as a man of very eccentric disposition. He was unmarried, and lived alone in a little spot that he had surrounded with a wealth of floral beauty. Shrubs of various kinds were artistically trained in the most attractive style, and flowers of countless hues unfolded in beauty and mingled their fragrance around his humble dwelling. His house was a model of neatness and order that would have won encomiums from the most thrifty housewife, and the general aspect of the place gave evidence of the esthetic traits of its possessor. Some little time before. Carpenter gave unmistakable proof of insanity, and was for a time removed to Stockton; after his return he had not been generally regarded as of sound mind. He was very irritable, and disposed to be quarrelsome toward his neighbors and all others with whom he came in contact. He had made threats to poison stock, and in many ways made enemies. Pos- sibly some one unaware of, or unwilling to allow for his infirmity, may have compassed his death in revenge for injuries received at his hands. Be that as it may - the murderer made his escape.

Killing of Mrs. Laura Walker. - A man named Walker, who lived on the farm of Mr. Sellers, near the Kirker Pass, on the Nortonville side, was arrested on September 5, 1869, for causing the death of his wife by beating her. Both the accused and deceased are reported to have been indulging excessively in drink at the house of a neighbor, and the beating occurred on the way home. On November 30, 1870, Walker was convicted of manslaughter, when a motion was made for a new trial, which was denied, and the prisoner sentenced to ten years' imprisonment in the State prison.

Killing of Jose Vaca. - In an affray at the village of Concord on May 2, 1869, a California Indian named Jose Vaca was killed by another called Fernando Feliz. The deceased had been well known in the vicinity for a long time as a drunken, brawling, besotted fellow, the other being also well known as a quiet, inoffensive person, past the meridian of life, and afflicted from early age with an infirmity that made him a cripple. It appears that the deceased, who had been drinking to inebriation, approached the hut of Feliz with a bottle and wanted him to drink, an invitation he declined, saying that **much whiskey is no good," but told the other he would make a fire and give him something to eat. While making the fire Jose seized hold of him, saying, "Now, I've got you where I want you, and mean to kill you," thereupon striking him a heavy blow with the bottle and breaking it. Fernando, struggled to defend himself, Jose meanwhile slashing and punching his face with the fragments of the bottle, still held in his hand by the neck. In the scuffle that ensued, they got outside of the shanty, where Fernando found an opportunity to seize a large knife with which he gave his antagonist two or three lunges, one of which, as was found on the postmortem examination, passed entirely through the heart, severed the fourth rib, and killed him instantly. A judgment of justifiable homicide was returned.

Killing of George Minchell. - George Minchell, who, with his family, had been living in Ygnacio Valley, about two miles from Pal6o HISTORY OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY checo, and farming on the lands of Charles S. Lohse, was shot at his own door on the morning of September 8, 1870, by a man named William Donovan, who had been in his employ and claimed an unpaid balance of wages, while, it was asserted on the other hand, that he had been overpaid eight dollars. It is said that Donovan visited the house of the deceased on the previous evening, demanding payment of the claimed dues in abusive and threatening language. Minchell directed him to leave the house and followed him out. A moment afterward the discharge of a pistol was heard, and Minchell re-entered the door, saying to his wife, ''Mary, I am shot." "You are not going to die, George, are you?" "Yes, Mary," and he immediately dropped dead upon the floor. Donovan was arrested, and when the sheriff approached him with the manacles, he exclaimed, fully realizing his situation, "Oh, God, this is what drink has brought me !" He was duly tried and convicted, and on December 8th, sentenced to be hanged on February 3, 1871. Judgment was stayed, however, and on April 15th Donovan was granted a new trial on the ground that a continuance asked for the defendant on the former trial was improperly denied. The continuance was demanded for the procuring of witnesses to prove that the prisoner had been an inmate of an insane asylum, and it was denied on the admission of the prosecution that the fact alleged would be proved by the required witnesses if they were present. The Supreme Court decided that this admission was not sufficient, and that the defendant was entitled to an opportunity of proving the fact. The case was moved to the San Francisco courts, and on December 12, 1871, Donovan was again convicted of murder in the first degree. Afterward, in February, 1872, a motion for a new trial was sent on appeal to the Supreme Court, which issued a writ to stay execution of sentence until the "pending motion is heard and decided," and on June 27th directed that an order be entered affirming the judgment of the court below, and directing the lower court to fix a day to carry the sentence into execution. He was again sentenced to be hanged on December 13th. In the meantime a petition to pardon the murderer had been sent to the governor, who declined to interfere, but ultimately execution was stayed by Governor Booth, who was moved thereto by an immense petition for a commutation of sentence.

par, indicted for the murder of Herman Heyder, by poison, put into the food served to him by the accused, when the deceased was a visitor at his house some ten or twelve miles southeast of Antioch. The general facts and features of the case may be briefly summarized as follows: On the 6th or 7th of September, 1870, Heyder and Caspar were brought into Antioch, at one o'clock in the morning, Heyder lying in the bottom of the wagon and Caspar sitting upon the seat beside the driver. Both were represented to Doctor Howard to be suffering from the effects of strychnine taken with the food they had eaten for supper at the house of Caspar some five or six hours before. Heyder died soon after reaching Antioch. Caspar recovered, and, from the medical testimony and other facts subsequently developed or considered, it appeared doubtful if he had exhibited any symptoms of having been poisoned at all. A jury was summoned to make investigations in the case. After a patient, thorough, and protracted investigation Caspar was held on their finding to answer before the grand jury on a charge of poisoning Heyder. The finding of this jury, and, presumably, of the grand jury, was based wholly upon strong circumstantial evidence of the guilt of the accused. It was, in the first place, almost inconceivable that so atrocious and diabolical a crime could have been committed without some motive of envy or cupidity; but the most diligent inquiry failed to develop a fact or suggestion which warranted suspicion that anyone had been prompted by such motives to enter Caspar's house in his absence and mingle strychnine with the various condiments and articles of food which would be eaten by him on his return, for the purpose of killing him. Large quantities of strychnine were found in the sugar-bowl, in the pepper-box, in the salt upon the table, in the syrup, in the butter, in the batter-pan, and in the flap- jacks, eaten at least by Heyder for supper - for he was unquestionably poisoned, exhibited all the most painful symptoms, and died within a few hours after the fatal meal. Strychnine was found in his stomach, on chemical analysis of the contents, and in the undigested portions of the cakes he had eaten. The question then arose with the jury of inquest. Had Caspar any motive which would possibly have prompted him to such an attempt to destroy the life of his visitor and guest? It was shown that Caspar and Heyder had been acquainted for some time ; had worked together in herding sheep ; that Heyder had money, and that Caspar had been trying for some time to borrow several hundred dollars from him. His statements in relation to the preparation of the supper when Heyder came with him to the house, after having been with him when he had been working during the afternoon, and many other circumstances developed in the investigation, produced a conviction of Caspar's guilt in the minds of the jury of inquest ; and the testimony before the grand jury doubtless produced such conviction there as to warrant his indictment for the murder. With the strong circumstantial evidence of guilt which had warranted the findings of the two juries, the prosecution at the trial brought in the testimony of the two prisoners confined in the jail, to prove an admission to them in prison on the part of Caspar that he did the poisoning. This was the only testimony purporting to be of a positive character against the prisoner, and it probably had not the weight with the jury that the testimony of persons unaccused of crime would have had, though these prisoners had no apparent motive for testifying falsely against the life of another. It is therefore not surprising that, under their solemn responsibilities, with no alternative but condemnation to death or acquittal, the jury should have failed to find a verdict according with the general conviction of the prisoner's guilt.

Killing of James Fergusson. - A stranger named James Fergusson, on his way from Gilroy, where he had been employed in the redwoods, to his home at Windsor, Sonoma County, arrived at Martinez too late to cross the ferry on the evening of June 4, 1871, and met a violent death between midnight and Monday morning, under circumstances of a peculiarly painful nature. The deceased was accompanied by his three sons, aged respectively eighteen, thirteen, and ten years, and being obliged to remain over night at Martinez put up their horses in the stable of the Alhambra Hotel, where he and the two younger lads at a later hour made camp beds, the eldest boy at a still later hour going to his bed in their wagon, which stood in the stable yard. During the evening Fergusson had been drinking pretty freely, and obtained from George Gordon Moor, Sr., the sum of $175, which deceased had given him to take charge of. This money was not found on his body. At about eight o'clock p. M. he went to the saloon of Francisco Saurez and there remained until one o'clock on Monday morning, leaving at the same time as did Alexander Naghel, William Higgins, and K. W. Taylor. The first of these, whose testimony is the most important relative to material facts, stated at the inquest that while there, Taylor playing on a guitar and Saurez on an accordion, deceased jumped up and began talking about soldiering, saying that he had command of fifteen hundred men. Not much attention was paid to what he said, and after a little they all drank together. The deceased then began showing the sword and fist exercises with his cane and fists, most of them joining in the play. Deceased then asked Taylor to take the stick (for attack) and he would defend himself with his fists. After one or two passes Fergusson said to Taylor, 'T could have hit you, so and so." Taylor replied, "I could have knocked the knuckles off of you," etc. After a general ''skylarking," Taylor handed the stick back to deceased, who, in flourishing it, dropped it on the floor, then giving it a kick that sent it over the screen. Saurez picked the stick up and told the deceased he would keep it until he went away. After this Taylor and Saurez played the guitar and accordion, and deceased wanted them to play "Dixie." They complied, playing and singing, Fergusson joining in the chorus. Negro and Irish songs were then sung. Then Higgins asked for a Union song. The deceased said, was made to this remark by anyone. Taylor sang one or two more songs, and afterward a Union patriotic song. After more singing, Saurez said, "Let's all go to bed." Taylor said, "Let's all take a drink." All drank except the deceased, who got up and said he "had a boy twelve years old in his wagon over there, and that he had made that boy fetch his man." Taylor said there was no use talking about that now ; the war was over. Deceased then began talking about one Southerner being equal to five Yankees. Taylor and Saurez were at this time looking over the accounts of the latter, and while thus employed, and while the deceased was bragging about being able to whip five Yankees, Higgins, who was sitting on the billiard-table, came forward and proposed that all should go home. Taylor said, "We will all go home if Saurez will treat." Saurez treated, and all drank, including deceased. Taylor, Higgins, and Naghel then went out of the saloon and started toward the bridge. The deceased started at the same time, but turned back to enter the saloon, when Saurez ejected him, telling him to go home and go to bed, as he wanted to shut up. Naghel further stated that he left Taylor in order to go down the street; that the deceased walked up against Taylor, who then turned aside and tried to avoid him. Naghel then walked back to where they were. Deceased again walked up against Taylor, who said, "Go away from me. I don't know who you are, and don't want you to follow me. Go about your business." At this Taylor gave him a shove and he fell backward. After he got up Naghel told him he had better go away, but he would not, and persistently thrust his society upon them. Naghel then asked him where his wagon was. He pointed to where it stood, and he was told to go to it. He started in that direction, Taylor, Higgins, and Naghel walking after him toward the residence of the first named, deceased walking on the sidewalk and they in the middle of the street. When deceased reached Wittenmyer's corner he halted ?nd turned back, still walking on the sidewalk, and went around the corner towards Sturges' Hotel. The three then remained talking for a short time in the middle of the street and opposite the thoroughfare leading to Brent's warehouse. While standing there, Fergusson came back from the direction of the Alhambra Hotel, and approached in the middle of the street to within about fifteen steps, when he dropped on one knee, with a gun pointed in the direction in which they stood. Naghel remarked to his companions, "He has a gun ; look out !" They all thereupon concealed themselves in separate places of safety, and the deceased got up to follow. Naghel ran again in the direction of Brent's warehouse, but did not notice where the other two went. He saw, however, deceased drop on one knee as before and saw the flash of a gun. A few seconds later he heard Taylor call for Brown. Naghel then went back to Brown's porch. He (Sheriff Warren Brown) brought out a carbine and gave it to Taylor, cautioning him to be "very careful, for it would go off easy," and, "not to shoot if he could help it" or words to that effect. In the meantime Naghel was dispatched for Gift, to arrest the man. Taylor then took up his position by the railing near the end of the bridge. He now saw deceased approaching, holding his gun as if ready to fire, and searching about him for someone. Seeing Higgins, he pointed the weapon toward him. At this moment Taylor stepped to the end of the bridge and ordered him to hold up his gun. He immediately wheeled around and pointed it at Taylor, when he (Taylor) fired and killed him. Taylor then handed himself over to the sheriff, who had now come up. The jury found a verdict that deceased was killed by K. W. Taylor, the shot being in self-defense.

Killing of Silverio Monjas. - Of this affair the Contra Costa Gazette of July 8, 1871, has the following: ''During the past week the people of the central portion of the county have been intensely excited by occurrences growing out of the disputed ownership and possession of a certain portion of the Moraga grant, about which there has been much litigation and contention for several years. The land in question is claimed on one side by Isaac Yoakum and on the other by members of the Moraga family. Some two months or more ago the sheriff, by writ of the District Court, was directed to put Yoakum in possession of the lands, then occupied by a portion of the Moraga family, but he had, as is claimed, no authority in executing the writ to remove and dispossess such of the Moraga children as were not named in the instrument, and he refused to do so, Yoakum, or his agent, as is said, refusing at the time to accept possession unless all the Moragas and their personal effects were removed. Yoakum subsequently, however, went into occupancy of the portion of the premises to which the writ entitled him, and the Moragas remained in possession, as the sheriff had left them, of a portion of the land claimed by Yoakum, and to which, as we understand, he would have been entitled under the judgment of the court but for an error of omission in the complaint in action, upon which the judgment was rendered in his favor. From this situation of affairs, both parties claiming and believing they had legal and equitable rights which they were justified in asserting and defending, much heat and bitterness has arisen, and several serious collisions have occurred to the imminent peril of life on both sides. Some time early in May several rifle-shots were fired at one of the Moragas, and the horse he was riding was killed by a man in the employ of Yoakum named William Steele, who was at that time, together with one of the Yoakum boys, under onethousand-dollar bonds to answer before the grand jury of the county. Since that time the temper of the hostile parties has not improved, and threatening demonstrations and preparations have been made on both sides, with no very serious results, however, until last Sunday (July 1st), when Silverio Monjas, one of the Moraga party, was shot by William Steele, as he affirms, in self-defense. On the previous day there had been a collision between the parties and a good deal of shooting. In the melee one of the Moraga girls was struck with a gun and severely hurt by Yoakum, and the horse he was riding was fatally shot. Reports of these occurrences spread rapidly about the county, and created a degree of excitement and manifestations of indignation seldom produced in our usually quiet and moderate community ; and the excitement and indignation reached a higher pitch on Saturday, after the shooting of Monjas, threatening to culminate in a vengeful outbreak against the Yoakum party. In the heat of the excitement many intemperate and improper charges and threats were made, which a cooler judgment and fuller knowledge of facts would not justify. Sheriff Brown was on the ground shortly after the shooting of Monjas on Saturday, and, on the information of Yoakum, found and arrested Steele. Yoakum voluntarily offered to surrender himself to the sheriff for examination before any competent magistrate upon any charge that might be preferred against him, and accompanied the sheriff to Walnut Creek, where, on finding Justice Slitz was absent, they proceeded to Pacheco, and on reaching that place found that Justice Ashbrook was also from home. Yoakum here declined to accompany the officer further, though he offered to give his word or bond for appearance whenever and for whatever purpose required. As the sheriff had no warrant or authority whatever for detaining him, he was allowed to go ; and the sheriff has been highly censured therefor, but, so far as we can see, without the slightest reason."

Monjas, who was shot by Steele, died about three o'clock on Saturday morning, and a jury of inquest, summoned and sworn on Sunday by Justice Allen, continued their inquiries until Monday evening, when the inquest was adjourned to ten o'clock Saturday morning at Walnut Creek. Steele was brought before Justice Ashbrook for examination on Thursday; the people in the conduct of the case were represented by District Attorney Mills, and the defendant by Judge Blake, of Oakland. The examination was concluded on Friday afternoon, and Steele was held to answer for murder without admission to bail. The jury of inquest found Isaac Yoakum to be accessory to the killing of said Silverio Monjas. He was brought before Justice Ashbrook, of Pacheco, on July loth, to answer to the charge of assault with a deadly weapon, with intent to commit bodily injury upon the person of Gunecinda Moraga, in Moraga Valley, on June 30, 1871. On motion of Judge Warmcastle, acting for District Attorney Mills, the charge was modified to one of assault and battery. The defendant, contrary to the express desire of the court, and the prosecution, objected to trial of the charge by jury, and in deference to his objection the case was tried without a jury. The trial occupied the greater part of the loth and nth of July. The defendant conducted the case in his own behalf, assisted by a young lady, his daughter, who wrote out the testimony as given in by the witnesses. The evidence produced clearly sustained the charge, and established that the defendant had proved an aggravated assault upon the Moraga girl, striking her twice with his gun and inflicting severe hurts upon her person, while, at the request of his herder, she and her sister were assisting him to drive the defendant's sheep away from the inclosure held by the Moraga family. Yoakum was found guilty and fined five hundred dollars, but gave notice of appeal. On the charge of being accessory with WiUiam Steele in the killing of Silverio Monjas, Isaac Yoakum was brought before Justice Wood, of Danville, on July 24th, examination being continued till the 27th, and at its conclusion he was held upon bail of three thousand dollars to answer to the charge.

The case of George Steele was tried in Alameda County, before the Third District Court, whose term commenced February 19, 1872. The case was transferred for trial on the motion and affidavits of the prisoner's counsel to the effect that existing prejudice would prevent an impartial trial in Contra Costa County. The case was set for March 4, 1872, and on that date he was acquitted. He was then held on the charge of an assault to murder, with bail bonds fixed at two thousand dollars.

Killing of Patrick Sullivan. - On the afternoon of October 28, 1871, Justice Ashbrook, of Pacheco, was notified of the death of Patrick SuUivan at the residence of James Sullivan, his brother, near Bay Point, from a gun discharged at his head by Mrs. Catherine Sullivan, the wife of James. Of the untoward affair we find from the testimony adduced that James Sullivan was absent from home for several days, and had returned only on the 24th of October, but heard nothing frpm his wife that anything unpleasant had transpired, but observed that she did not speak to his brother, nor he to her, and on the 27th his brother told him that he must look out for another man, as he was going to leave. On the day of the killing they had been sowing wheat in the forenoon and all were at the dinner-table as usual, but his wife did not eat, a circumstance that Sullivan attributed to her being unwell. After eating he (the husband)' moved back his chair and was reading a newspal68 HISTORY OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY per, when he was startled by the discharge of a gun in the room, and, on looking up, saw Mrs. Sullivan standing in the pantry door with a gun, and saw his brother fall forward on the table. Shocked and alarmed, he sprang up and rushed out of the door, his wife following with the gun in her hands, and the children clinging to her skirts. In his excitement and agony of mind, he exclaimed, "My God, what have you done? Was it an accident?" To which his wife replied: "No; I shot him. He deserved it. He was a villain. He attempted a vile outrage on me !" She then told him that the deceased, on the night of the 23d had forced open the window, entered her bedroom, and attempted to outrage her, but she had fought him off, and on her declaring that she would take the children and go to Cunningham's (one of the neighbors) for protection, he threatened if she did so, or if she reported a word of the matter to her husband, he would kill her. On the following morning, after she had passed a sleepless night, while she was preparing kindhng wood to light a fire, he came in, threw his arms around her and attempted to force her into his room, but she fought him ofif with the butcher knife she was using to split the kindling, and her little boy, who had been awakened by the noise, coming into the kitchen, he retired; but during the morning, and before the return of her husband, the deceased found an opportunity to renew his threat to kill her if she reported a word of what had occurred. All the testimony and collateral circumstances seemed to sustain Mrs. Sullivan's statement of the matter to her husband, and the statement she made upon the inquest and the examination is the same. She was apprehended and held on five thousand dollars bail to answer to the charge before the grand jury. Mrs. Sullivan was duly arraigned and the case set for November 24, 1 87 1, when she was very properly acquitted.

Killing of Peter Peters. - On March 14, 1872, a Welshman named Peter Peters was shot and mortally wounded by a fellow-countryman named Job Heycock. From the testimony given before the coroner's jury, it appears that Heycock was aroused from his sleep on Thursday morning between the hours of four and five o'clock by a great noise in the room adjoining his bedroom. He got up, went into the next room, taking with him a loaded double-barreled shot-gun. It was quite dark there, but he thought he noticed somebody going upstairs. He called out to him to stop, but receiving no answer he fired. The deceased fell down to the bottom of the stairs. Heycock approached him, found him to be Peter Peters, a very particular friend of his. It also appeared from the testimony that William Rees, a person living with Heycock, was about lighting a fire in the kitchen when the deceased approached the window from the outside, broke a pane of glass, raised the window and came in. Rees did not know who the person was, his light having gone out, and was frightened so that he ran upstairs, causing thereby a great noise, which woke everybody in the house. The jury of inquest returned a verdict of justifiable homicide.

In regard to the principal of this afifair, the following "strange story" appeared above the signature "W" in the Alameda Advocate of May II, 1872: ''In 1837, on the 26th of November, the cosmopolitan community of Crumlin, a small village in Monmouthshire, in the western part of England, were aroused and somewhat bewildered by the commission of a foul crime, the perpetrators of which did not only escape, but so skillfully covered their tracks that discovery seemed impossible. A recent disclosure made under very singular circumstances, as will be seen from this brief narrative, has brought to light this once-thought impenetrable mystery. The circumstances may not be unfamiliar to many of the old residents of Monmouthshire. The victim was a young man by the name of Mason, who was found dead on the old Crumlin bridge with his body mangled in a fearful manner. A few weeks after this foul crime had been committed, three men disappeared from the village very mysteriously to parts unknown. There has been strong suspicion that these were the guilty parties. One of the three was named Peter Peters, better known in this country as 'Welsh Pete.' For fifteen years he had been rambling through the dififerent mining districts of California; the last few years he has been laboring in the Mount Diablo coal mines. His voyage through life had been anything but pleasant. Given very much to dissipation, under the effects of which he was laboring on the morning of the 12th of February last, when he, at about five o'clock leaped from his bed, imagining that he was surrounded by a host of enemies with various kinds of weapons in their hands, with the intention of taking his hfe. He ran into an adjoining house for protection, and jumped through the window of a back kitchen. Heycock, the proprietor, heard the noise and went to the kitchen door with his gun in his hand, and, as he says, called three times. Hearing no reply, he discharged the contents of his gun into Welsh Pete's body, when he fell to the floor. In a few moments he seemed quite conscious, and Heycock promptly dispatched a messenger for medical assistance, acknowledging that he had made a mistake. The utmost attention was paid to the wounded man, yet he gradually became more feeble; but his strength and voice were spared to make a clear confession of being accessory to the murder of Mason on the old Crumlin bridge thirty-five years before. At ten o'clock the same day his symptoms became worse and in a few moments after he breathed his last."

Murder of Valentine Eischler. - On November i6, 1872, one Valentine Eischler, a German, was killed on Marsh Creek, about eight miles southeast of Antioch, near what is called the "Chamisal." He was living with his wife upon a small farm, and had in his employ one Marshal Martin. During the stay of Martin, Mrs. Eischler formed a determination to get rid of her husband, and several plans were formed by her and Martin for carrying into effect her deadly purpose. In pursuance of the plan, Martin went to Antioch one day and purchased a quantity of arsenic, and when he came home she mixed some of it with stewed pumpkin and put it on the table for supper. But it so happened that Eischler did not partake of any of it. The next morning it was thrown down the privy vault. A few days after she repeated the dish, but Martin claimed that he persuaded her to throw it away. She then wanted Martin to tell Eischler that there were some pigs for sale at Point of Timber, and to go along with him in the wagon, get him to drinking, and then buy a bottle of whiskey and put arsenic into it. Martin went along with Eischler, but for some reason the plan did not succeed. Another plan was then formed by which Martin was to knock Eischler off the wagon on the way home from Antioch and run the wagon over his head. A neighbor riding home with them prevented this plan. Then she suggested that Martin should shoot him, Martin had a revolver which he had purchased from a man who got it in Vallejo, and it would be necessary to go there to get cartridges to fit it. She gave him the money to go there, and he got the cartridges and returned. The day upon which the murder was committed, Eischler went to Antioch for a load of flour; Martin accompanied him, according to instructions. Before starting Mrs.

Eischler placed an old blanket in the wagon so that Martin, after killing Eischler, could wrap the body in it, and when he returned she would go with him to an old well near by, throw the body down the well, pour coal oil upon it and burn it up. Martin's heart failed him, and he did not shoot Eischler. When they returned she was very angry with Martin for not carrying out her plan, and told him that he did not love her, or he would do as she wished him to. After unloading the flour and putting the horses in the stable (it being about 4 p. M.), as Martin testified, he went about doing the chores, and Eischler commenced making a doubletree. He had a piece of coupling, an axe, saw, hatchet, and jack-knife, and was using the wagon-tongue as a workbench. Martin says that while he was watering a cow, which had to be led to water by a rope, Mrs. Eischler came out and commenced talking to her husband. They had some very high words. He heard Eischler say on the back of the head, knocking him over the wagon-tongue so that his body doubled over it ; then she straddled the tongue and struck him two more blows on the front part of the head. Then she called Martin to come and help her drag the body into the stable. After placing it in the stable Martin went to saddle his horse for the purpose of going to the Good Templar's lodge at Eden Plains schoolhouse, about two miles away. While fixing his horse, he said that she went into the stable and struck the victim two more blows with the axe, and that when she came out she said that she had found him sitting up, but that she had fixed him now. When Martin returned from the lodge she told him to go and arouse the neighbors and tell them that Eischler was dead in the stable, and that the horses had kicked him to death. He obeyed her instructions. When the neighbors came some of them suspected that he had been murdered. The next day, when they went to examine the body, they found a great many horehound burrs on the woolen shirt of the deceased, and by this means they found where the body had been dragged to the stable. Afterward they noticed the flies gathering upon Martin's shoes and pants, and this fact, together with the burrs upon the woolen shirt, led them to make search for the place where the murder had been committed. During this search Martin was very active in leading them off in different directions, but finally they came to the wagon and examined the sandy soil around it. They soon found a damp place, and putting some of the sand in a basin of water it exhibited a bloody color, and a greasy scum arose to the surface. Martin and the woman were then arrested and taken to Antioch, where they both made confession, each charging the other, however, with having directly done the murder. Martin's testimony under cross-examination on the trial substantially agreed with this summary of the facts of the case. Martin was duly executed January 23, 1874, having previously made a full confession of his share in the dreadful crime. On the scaffold he said, "Gentlemen, I am here on this platform to die an innocent man. That woman deserves ten times as much to die." It is not meet that we should here note the details of his execution ; these will remain in the minds of many of our readers. The wife of the victim of the barbarous drama has been ever since an inmate of the lunatic asylum at Stockton.

Killing of Jamiens. - What is known as "Sidney Flat," about half a mile below Somersville, was the scene of a most wanton murder, committed about one o'clock in the morning of January 2y, 1873. Two wretched and disorderly brothels, to the annoyance and mortification of the respectable residents of Somersville, had been for some time shamelessly maintained on Sidney Flat. At the hour named, as is gathered from the evidence, a drunken inmate of one of the establishments, named Hattie Davis, in company with an American, was on the way from one of these houses to the other, which are separated by a distance of two or three hundred yards, followed by a Mexican named Jamiens and a Mexican boy about seventeen years of age. Jamiens was playing upon a toy musical instrument, and the boy was carrying a bottle of whiskey. The woman's drunken brawling attracted the attention of some of the visitors at the brothel she was approaching, and several of the men, among whom was James Carroll, started from the house toward them. On meeting, one of the number named Green said the woman asked him to take her home but on his attempting to do so the man who was with her tried to detain her, and he knocked him down. At this moment the two Mexicans joined the group, Jamiens playing upon his harmonica, the toy instrument before mentioned. Carroll asked the Mexican boy what he had in his hand, and upon being answered that it was whisky he snatched the bottle from the boy and knocked him down, either with the bottle or his pistol, and turning on Jamiens, fired. Jamiens fell, exclaiming, *'I am shot through the head," which were his last words, though he did not cease to breathe for some three or four hours afterward. The deceased had been employed for some time at the Somersville mines, where he bore a good character and was generally known by the name of 'Trank." On April i8th Carroll was convicted of murder in the second degree, and was sentenced to twenty years' imprisonment in the State prison.

Killing of Michael Duffy. - Thomas Redfern was arrested on the afternoon of June 21, 1873, at his residence, about a mile south of Martinez, for having shot and dangerously wounded Michael Dufify. The wounded man was removed from Redfern's place, where the shooting occurred, to the county hospital, and his right arm from the elbow to the shoulder was found shockingly shattered and mangled by the shot, which had entered the side of the neck, shattering the bones about the head of the spinal column and the base of the skull. He died July 4th. Redfern, it seems, had taken Dufify out to his house some days before and had been spending most of the time there in convivial indulgences, until a quarrel arose between them which culminated in the shooting. May 14, 1874, Redfern was declared by a jury not guilty.

Murder of Martin Gersbach. - The locality known as the Hertsel place, on San Pablo Creek, some three miles below what is called Telegraph Road crossing, was the scene of a murder on the evening of August I, 1873, almost precisely parallel in cause and circumstances with the Eischler murder mentioned above. If there be any difference at all, it is that in the last deed both the implicated parties were apparently persons of competent mental capacity and responsibility, while in the other case neither of them, perhaps, were up to the common measure of mental competency and sense of responsibility. In both cases the wife and the paramour plotted the death of the husband, attempted it repeatedly by means of poison, and finally compassed it by a direct assault with murderous weapons - in the former case with an axe, and in the latter with pistol-shot, hammer, and axe.

three or four thousand dollars, it was said, and had been a lessee of the place where he had lived with his family, and where he was murdered, for something more than a year. His wife was a woman of about the same age, of German parentage and American birth. The paramourmurderer, Nash, alias William Osterhaus, was a man about the same age, also of German parentage and American birth. By the woman's statement, Nash was engaged by her husband about Christmas, 1872, to work on the place, and he soon began to pay her some improper attentions, which she slightly resented at first, but soon began to accept and encourage. When the character of the subsisting intimacy became apparent to her husband, he became enraged, and threatened to procure a divorce; but as he did not move in the matter further, they plotted to kill him, first dosing him with croton oil, given one day when he complained of being sick, then trying to have him take arsenic to counteract the effects of the oil, and then by putting laudanum in his coffee, which he would not drink after the first taste. They then tried to dispose of him by saturating his pillow with chloroform, but without avail. Nash then determined to pick a quarrel with Gersbach for the opportunity it might offer of killing him, but was unable to arouse his resentment. Finally, on the night of the murder, as she stated, after the woman and her husband had retired to bed, Nash, who occupied a room upstairs, called for Gersbach to come up there. Gersbach, instead of complying, rose from the bed on which he was lying, with his clothes on, and hurried out of the house. As he did so, Nash came downstairs with a pistol in each hand. He ran out after Gersbach, and she heard six shots fired in quick succession. She then heard a low groan, and, on going to the door, met Nash, who said Martin was shot. Just then he groaned. Nash at once took a hammer from the kitchen, went out to where Gersbach lay, and she heard several blows of the hammer on his head. Nash then returned and said he had finished him. He told her he would go over and tell Roland, a neighbor, he had killed Martin in self-defense, but just as he was about to go Martin groaned again. Nash went out to where he lay, and she heard heavy dull blows given ; then Nash returned to her and said he had finished him with an axe. Then Nash went off to carry his report of the death of Gersbach, and when he returned, before morning, said he would have to leave. He changed his bloody clothes, took about thirty or forty dollars that belonged to his victim, and went away. Such was the woman's statement. The officers found the bloodstained cast-off clothing of the murderer, his pistol with six empty chambers, and the blood and hair-clotted hammer in the room he had occupied, and spots of blood about the floor. Near the spot where the body of his victim fell they found the other pistol, fully charged.

After the murder Nash went to the house of a neighbor named Muir, a few hundred yards distant from that of the murdered man, and called him up. Muir's dogs made such threatening demonstrations that he remained some little distance off. The barking of the dogs was so furious that Muir could not distinctly hear what he said, further than that Gersbach had been killed, and he therefore went over with Nash, or following him, and found the wounded man still alive. Muir requested Nash to help him carry the wounded man into the house, but he refused to do so, and while Muir was gone for other help, as we understood, Nash changed his clothes, and left the place. The murdered man lingered until August 4th, and was sufficiently conscious during a portion of the time to give intelligent directions for the care of his boy and his property affairs by a friend, and to clearly designate Nash as his murderer.

After more than a week's hunt night and day among the hills, following up the scent of every reported straggler, and in almost every instance finding they had been on the trail of the wrong man, and while Sheriff Ivory and his staff of officers were still scouring the hills and valleys for Nash, a telegram was received from Governor Booth with the information that he had been captured at Battle Mountain, Nevada. Under-Sheriff Hunsaker immediately dispatched a courier to find Sheriff Ivory, and telegraphed to the Battle Mountain justice that he would start for the prisoner immediately, inquiring at the same time if he had a description of Nash and was sure he had him. A reply was received from the justice later in the evening that he had the description and the prisoner acknowledged himself the man. The courier sent for Ivory found him above Danville, shaping his course toward Tassajara. He at once returned homeward, and with all speed made his way to Battle Mountain. Nash was duly tried, found guilty May i, 1874, and sentenced to imprisonment for life.

In the case of Mary Gersbach, the jury, after three days' and nights' deliberation, failed to agree. She was again tried, with a like result in December. 1874. The case dragged its slow length along up until No- vember 9, 1875, when District Attorney Mills applied to the Supreme Court for peremptory writ of mandate and review in the case of Mary Gersbach, which was denied. On Wednesday, November 17th, she was discharged from custody on her own bond of five thousand dollars.

Homicide of George Muth. - The village of SanPablo was the scene of another bloody murder; the date was August 10, 1873. The victim in this case was George Muth, a young German, who had lived some years in the vicinity, and was generally liked and respected. He was killed by Henry Ploeger, also a German, who lived usually in San Francisco, but for some years during part of each season had been engaged in haypressing, and had been so employed in San Pablo at the time of the slaying. He had, some time back, it is said, sold a hay-press to Muth, and was displeased with him because he had engaged in business rivalry with him. On August 10, 1873, both parties were at the village, and both had been drinking, though it was a very unusual thing for Muth to do so. Ploeger had made threats against Muth, and the latter, just as Ploeger was about to mount his horse, crossed from the opposite side of the road and laid his hand on his (Ploeger's) shoulder, asking him what he was threatening him for or what had he against him, or some question of such purport. Ploeger instantly drew his pistol and shot him through the heart, killing him instantly. Ploeger claimed that he anticipated an attack with a pistol when he drew his, and that the shooting was unintentional. The bystanders, however, did not seem to have been impressed with such belief, and were inclined to execute summary justice on the spot, regarding it as an act of unprovoked and wanton murder. The prisoner was held by the officers and safely taken to the jail at Martinez, November 27, 1873. He was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to six years imprisonment in the State prison.

Killing of Ramon Chavis. - A native Californian half-breed named Ramon Chavis was shot by Constable John Wilcox on August 23, 1874, at San Pablo. It appears that the deceased had been at the house of Wilcox, drinking and quarreling during the evening, and Wilcox had several times been obliged to intervene to stop fights in which he had engaged. Before the shooting Wilcox had retired to bed, but was called up by some one who said that deceased and some one else were killing somebody. Wilcox got up and partially dressed himself, took his pistol and went out, to find Chavis and another partially drunken man charging their horses and riding over a man they had thrown down in the road, who was a half -demented person residing in the place. Wilcox commanded them to desist, when Chavis rode off a few yards, wheeled his horse and charged on him. When within a few feet Wilcox fired, and Chavis fell with a shot under the eye-socket. The coroner's jury found that the homicide was justifiable.

Murder of Ah Hung. - The salient facts in this case are as follows : The deceased, Ah Hung, some two months previously opened a new laundry at Pacheco, and subsequently took Ah Sing into partnership relations. There was also a Chinese boy, Ung Gow, employed in the establishment. They all retired as usual on the night of January 16, 1876, Ah Hung sleeping in an inner apartment, Ah Sing in an outer room, on a table, and the boy, Ung Gow, on the floor under the table. About daylight the boy was awakened by a noise, and heard Ah Hung exclaiming that he was killed. He ran into the room and saw Ah Sing attempting to haul him off the bed and chopping him with a hatchet. The boy attempted to pull Ah Sing away, but he turned and struck at him with the hatchet, inflicting one or two cuts, saying that he would kill him too. Ung Gow ran out to escape him, and went directly to the other washhouse, up the street, to give the alarm and find protection, but was refused admittance and driven away. He then went to Tiedeman's place and reported what had occurred. Constable Henry Wells was the first to visit the scene of the homicide, and there found the deceased in the front apartment, still with life enough remaining to make some moans of suffering, and most horribly hacked. He survived but a few moments. From the appearance of the place it was evident that the dead man had made a fearful struggle for life after being mortally wounded, the floor and walls were marked with bloody hand-prints, showing where he had endeavored to regain his feet, while blood-clots, and even pieces of bone from his skull, lay about the floor and on the walls. The murderer was captured and had on his person clothing and money, together with a purse, all identified as the property of the deceased. April 19, 1876, Ah Sing was tried, convicted of murder in the second degree, and was sentenced to forty-five years imprisonment in the State prison.

Killing of Jose Arrayo. - A bloody affray occurred on March 2, 1877, about three-quarters of a mile from Walnut Creek, when Jose Arrayo was stabbed by Ramon Romero, who was at once arrested. Arrayo died on the loth of March, and Romero was committed on the charge of murder, for which he was tried, found guilty November 23,

Killing of James Mills. - On June 18, 1877, a young man named Mills was fatally stabbed in an affray with P. B. Martin. It would appear that ill-feeUng had existed for some time between the parties, which culminated in a fight on the day named. Mills died on June 24th, and Martin was arrested, tried, and on April 20, 1878, found not guilty.

1878, it was rumored about Antioch that George Mitchell, an old resident of that town, was not to be found, and there was a strong suspicion that he had been murdered. About half -past ten o'clock on Thursday night he accompanied William Brunkhorst to his residence on Front Street with a lantern, the night being dark and stormy. Mitchell was duly sober and told Brunkhorst on parting that he was going to Dahnken's saloon on the wharf, where he slept, and retire for the night. Carson Dahnken had closed the saloon. In about fifteen minutes after Mitchell left Brunkhorst a pistol-shot was heard on the wharf by several parties, but it seems no one went out to ascertain the occasion of the shooting. Dahnken, who slept in the rear of the saloon-building, said he also heard the breaking of a lantern, the broken glass of which, together with several spots of clotted blood, was plainly to be seen upon the wharf. It was believed from the circumstances that Mitchell had been murdered and thrown into the river from off the wharf. Poles were brought and a moment's search proved that such was the case. The dead body of Mitchell was brought from the water and a bullethole or knife-wound found on his left side over the heart. Suspicion at once fastened upon William Hank, a German, in charge of the schooner **A. P. Jordan," which had been lying at anchor a few miles down the river. Hank had been in town on Thursday, drinking freely, exhibited a pistol, and was once during the day prevented from shooting at a man in Martin's saloon. Shortly after the shooting Hank went into Gordon's saloon and told the bar-keeper that he had just killed a man on the wharf, his (Hank's) clothes being at the time quite bloody, with his nose, face, and lips scratched and bleeding. Going out of the saloon he fired at some dogs, and finally went to Dahnken's hotel and entered the room of Joseph Parker, a boarder. Parker awoke and finding a strange man in the room inquired what he wanted ; Hank said he was a stranger in the house and wanted a room. He finally slept upon a lounge in the sitting-room, where his pistol was found in the morning by Dahnken. While search was being made for Mitchell on Friday morning, Hank left the wharf in his sailboat for his schooner. As soon as the body of Mitchell was found, Constable Pitts, with two Italian fishermen, started in pursuit with a boat and overtook him. Pitts got into his (Hank's) boat, and on being told that he (Pitts) was an officer come to arrest him Hank leaped overboard. He was handcuffed by the constable while in the water, taken into the boat, tied, and brought, shivering with cold from his voluntary bath, to Antioch. George Mitchell was an Englishman, forty-seven years of age, and had lived in Antioch and its vicinity since 1859. On April 24, 1878, Hank was tried and acquitted. Immediately after trial, and ere he had left the court-room, he was joined in matrimony to Mary Augusta Raymond, who was present during the proceedings and watched the case with eager interest.

Killing of Jose Reyes Berryessa. - On Monday evening. May 20, 1878, near the crossing of West Main and Castro streets, in the town of Martinez, Jose Reyes Berryessa, a native of California, made an assault upon Louis Kamp, in resisting which he shot and killed his assailant. It appears that Kamp was passing along the street toward the bridge carrying a pail of water, when Berryessa approached and addressed him angrily in Spanish, Kamp answering him in the same language. Berryessa then assaulted him with violent blows of his fists, causing him to drop his water-bucket, then grappled and threw him repeatedly and violently, either with his fist or with a stone cutting his face and causing a copious flow of blood. Just then Constable Gift's attention being attracted to the affray, he ran up, pulled Berryessa off, and commanding the peace, told them they were both under arrest and must go with him before the justice. Kamp said he would go, but Berryessa defied the officer insultingly, and immediately renewed the assault upon Kamp, striking and again throwing and falling upon him and hitting him with a stone while down. Gift again pulled him off, but he struggled free, making threatening demonstrations toward Kamp, who was then upon his feet, according to the testimony, backing away while drawing a pistol from his right hip pocket, which he presented and fired just as Berryessa, in breaking from Gift's hold to reach him, was turned partially sidewise, some ten or twelve feet from him, and shot into his right side just below the nipple. Berry essa stooped, placed both hands on the wounded part, walked to the sidewalk from near the middle of the street, sat down, and in a few seconds expired. The verdict of the coroner's jury was that the killing was justifiable.

Death of an Unknown Man. - The Contra Costa Gazette of March 22, 1879, has the following: "We mentioned last week that the body of a man, some time dead, was found on the afternoon of the 13th inst., on Hyde's ranch, about four miles south of Cornwall station, and that Coroner Hiller had gone up to hold an inquest. Following is the verdict of the inquest: *We, the jury summoned to inquire into the cause of the death of a man found on the 13th day of March, 1879, lying on the ranch of F. A. Hyde, caught in the fence dividing the lands of said Hyde and W. E. Whitney, having viewed the body and heard the testimony presented, on our oaths do say, that from the evidence we suppose his name to be Levy Gish, aged about thirty years, nativity unknown, and that he came to his death some time in the first part of March, 1879, the exact date being unknown and that his death was caused by violence, but by whose act is to the jury unknown. Hyde's Ranch, March 14, 1879. Signed: A. A. Hadley, B. K. Walker, Thomas Prichard, Wm. Fahy, Lewis H. Abbott, John Tepe, W. J. Whitney, Joseph McCloskey.' The body was that of a man apparently between thirty and thirty-five years of age, about five feet seven or eight inches in height, with fine brown hair, curling in small curls all over his head, and reddish mustache, no beard, dressed in light-colored cassimere pants, dark-brown striped calico shirt, with undershirt made of floursacks having the brand of the Kern River Mills, hickory outside shirt, old boots with tops cut off, and no coat on body. The body, with a bullet or bludgeon wound on the back of the head, was found lying on the west of the fence dividing the land of Hyde from the land of W. E.

Whitney. Both feet were through between the pickets, apparently caught while he was endeavoring to get over the fence. The body was lying partially on the left side, with the left arm bent up under it and the right arm extending upward and in front of the face, the sleeve of the shirt drawn up over the hand. About twenty-five feet from the body, along near the fence, there were signs of a struggle, the ground being torn up and a great deal of blood on it and some hair from the head of the deceased on the pickets. Some four or fiye feet from the fence lay a pair of new gray blankets with a great deal of blood on them, and near them an old coat very much wrinkled and a great deal of blood on it and curls of hair similar to that on the man's head and on the blanket. Near the head of the body lay a pair of blankets similar to the others, but clean, rolled up and not tied, a black felt hat, and a letter from Abram S. Gish addressed to Levy Gish, Ellis Station, dated October, 1870. Over the fence about twenty feet from the body was an account of sales of wheat and a letter dated March 6, 1871, from Bryant & Cook, Commission Merchants, San Francisco, addressed 'Levy Gish, Ellis Station.' The body had evidently been lying there six or eight days.

"Constable Erwin, of Point of Timber, has since been at Martinez, where Mr. Hiller has the effects found with the body, and has identified the pants, and from the description is satisfied that the man is one whom he arrested February 25th, with two others, for burglarizing Peter Swift's house near Point of Timber, and found in his possession five letters directed to Levy Gish, EUis, and Moore's Landing. The men were taken by Erwin to Antioch and lodged in jail there, and the same night broke out and decamped. Erwin also identifies the coat as one that was worn by one of the companions of the deceased when arrested, but the coat then worn by him was of a better style and quality. The probability is strong, therefore, that the dead man was one of the three fugitive burglars, who received his death wound at the hands of his companions, or some other unknown person or persons, within a short time after their escape from the Antioch lock-up. It could hardly have occurred immediately after, as the ground where the body was found had been marked when wet, in the death struggles of the deceased, and it did not rain until several days after their breaking out on the morning of February 26th. It may therefore be inferred that they remained somewhere concealed in the neighborhood for possibly a week or more, there being no way of determining when the supposed murder was committed further than that, from the condition of the body, it could not have been less than eight or ten days before the remains were discovered, and it must have been after the rains of the first week in the month had softened the hard dry ground.

Provenance

Text from The History of Contra Costa County, California, published 1917, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.