Kern County, California - Chapter 9, 1914
From History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914. 5,261 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
5,261 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Referring back to the news items reproduced in the previous chapter it will be noted that on August 23, 1873, appeared a legal notice to the effect that the afifairs of the California Cotton Growers' Association, and Livermore & Chester had been transferred to J. H. Redington ; that in November of the same year J. C. Crocker and Miller & Lux were fencing in a great tract of land between Buena Vista and Goose lakes and preparing to sow alfalfa ; that in January, 1874, "the world-renowned Billy Carr, political Napoleon for the Southern Pacific Railroad Company," was in Kern county looking over his possessions here and planning how to increase them.
About 1874 Dr. George F. Thornton was getting the Bellvue and McClung ranches established for J. B. Haggin. In the same year W. G. Souther was having the big plow built at HoUister for use in completing the reclamation of swamp land district No. Ill, a task which had been taken over by the Kern Island Irrigation Canal Company, which was a Livermore & Chester enterprise, now assigned to J. H. Redington. In March, 1876, Livermore mortgaged to William Houston 5736 acres of land for $60,000. On October 1, 1877, Livermore mortgaged 9792.72 acres of Kern county land to Redington for $97,000. On the same date another mortgage was executed between the same parties involving 12,800 acres of land and $128,000. In the same year, which was one of exceptional drought, Livermore & Chester (as the concern continued to be known despite the transfers noted) are credited by newspaper report with having spent $20,000 in the construction of a dam of brush and gravel thrown across Kern river for the purpose of turning the water into the Kern Island canal. On July 2, 1877, the Kern Valley Water Company, of which J. H. Redington was president and H. P. Livermore was secretary, made an agreement with the trustees of swamp land district No. 116 or 121 (lying north of Buena Vista lake) to complete the work of reclamation which the trustees of the district had begun. In March, 1877, Congress passed the desert land act, and work was begun on the Calloway canal. In January, 1878, Livermore made another mortgage to Redington covering 4480 acres for a consideration of $44,800. In 1878 the Kern Valley Colony issued a prospectus offering seventeen sections of land under the Kern Island canal for sale at $25 per acre in tracts of forty to eighty acres at terms of one-fifth cash, with the balance in four annual payments; interest at nine per cent. For information apply to H. P. Livermore, San Francisco, or Celsus Brower, Bakersfield.
In June, 1879, Livermore and Redington sold to J. B. Haggin the Cotton ranch, comprising 729.03 acres in what is now the northwestern part of the city of Bakersfield. The consideration was nothing. A previous deed had conveyed all the other Livermore and Redington holdings in Kern county to Haggin, and after the deal had been completed Redington threw in this remaining body of land - now selling in town lots at $20 to $200 per front foot - for good measure, and also, as there is good reason to suppose, because he did not care to keep any souvenir of his Kern county investments.
Add to the foregoing the record of suit after suit filed against Livermore & Chester, Livermore & Redington and the diiiferent parties individually by Haggin & Carr, all dismissed or compromised, and you will have a fairly complete syllabus of the complicated chapter in the history of Kern county which bridges over the period during which Haggin & Carr and Miller & Lux came to be the overshadowing factors in Kern county's development ; during which Bakersfield's first hope of colonization came to naught, and most of the remaining sections of valuable farming land in the valley portion of the ciiunty were thoughtfully gathered up. The chapter includes, also, the first bitter contests over the control of the waters of Kern river, and the placing of the troops and batteries for the great battle that was to come later on between the appropriators represented by Haggin and the riparianists represented by Miller & Lux.
Livermore & Redington were wholesale druggists of San Francisco, men of large wealth outside of their drug business, and are referred to by their Kern county acquaintances as of most estimable character. From the start their Kern county land investments were a side venture, and commanded little of their personal attention. Livermore came to Bakersfield but seldom, and Redington almost never. Taking them on their face, nothing could have been more promising than the Kern county swamp land projects. The early reclamation contracts, as we have seen, were taken on the basis of an acre of land in return for moving two cubic yards of earth in the construction of canals and levees. Ten or a dozen years later E. M. Roberts and H. W. Broad took a contract to finish the Calloway canal at seven cents for moving ordinary earth and nine cents for hardpan, and they made big money. The haul is longer and heavier in building a big canal like the Calloway than in a smaller canal like the Kern Island, and the earth moved in the former averaged much heavier and harder to handle than was that in the latter. It would seem that under normal circumstances and management the men \^ho participated with Colonel Baker in the original contract for the reclamation of district No. Ill should have secured their land at an outlay of ten or fifteen cents per acre.
plans. Before the arrival of the railroad, materials of all kinds that had to be shipped in were exceedingly high in price, and after the railroad came the expected reductions in transportation charges were only partially realized. Labor was scarce and inefficient. Drinking water from shallovv wells or irrigation ditches resulted in a liberal infection of workmen with the microbe of weariness, and eiTorts to drown the microbes in the bad liquors that unlimited saloons dispensed were not wholly successful from all points of view.
Then it was an era of large ideas. The big plow that Souther had built at Hollister was not his first nor largest invention of the kind. He built in the Livermore & Chester shops at Bakersfield a plow designed to cut a furrow five feet in width and three feet deep, whereas the Hollister plow cut a furrow three feet wide and two feet deep. The top of the mould board of the first plow was even with the head of a man on horseback. The depth of the cut was controlled by a screw operated from a platform high over the shear, and a long lever extending to the rear was used in keeping the furrow straight. With forty yoke of oxen hitched to it the plow would cut through 4 Cottonwood root as thick as a fat man's arm and the shear and coulter shaved a clean path through the thickets of button willows that grew along the sloughs. The plow was perfectly designed and constructed, according to men who saw its try-out, but the oxen walked so slowly that the earth which the shear picked up was not carried out on the mould board but fell back in the furrow as in the case of a plow that does not "scour." When the bull whackers beat the cattle into a faster gait the plow made a clean furrow, but the faster gait could not be maintained, and at the end of a twelve-mile furrow it was evident that the big plow was almost as unsuited for ditchbuilding as it would be for a watch charm.
Then Souther had the "little" plow built at Hollister. This could be handled with forty head of mules, and the faster animals made the new plow a success. Many of the smaller ditches about the delta were made with the Hollister plow, but its use benefited chiefly the assigns of Livermore & Redington.
In the early days of irrigation in Kern county it was the custom to build wing dams of sand or of sand and brush in times when the river was low to force the water into the canals. These wing dams would start just below the head of the canal and extend at an angle upward and across the river nearly to the farther bank. A freshet sufficient to raise the water above the top of these dams would speedily melt them away, scattering the brush to form impeding islands in the river bed, and the work would have to be repeated so soon as the river fell again. Before the Kern valley canal was finished the cost of these wing dams had reached so great an aggregate that the managers of the enterprise decided to move the intake higher up on the river. This was done, the new intake being finished in 1874. The old south fork channel, however, was still used in lieu of a canal, the water being turned into the old channel from the new intake. Still later the head of the Kern Island canal was moved still farther up the river, and an artificial canal substituted for the old natural channel south as far as the present mill. All these changes were made the excuse for a number of law suits over water rights, the questions involved turning on use, priority and the right of riparian owners to have a natural water course maintained. The suits and the questions involved were technical and of little interest to the average reader except to suggest the numberless good opportunities for litigation that arose while the waters of Kern river were being apportioned. Few such opportunities, it may be added, were allowed to pass unseized.
The agreement between the Kern Island Canal Company and the trustees of the irrigation district was that the company should construct the canal and necessary levees for $16,240, the company to own the canal and retain the right to the use of the water, provided that the owner of swamp land should be given one share of stock in the canal company for every fifty dollars which his land paid into the reclamation fund, and provided that the owners of swamp land in the district should have the preference right - or the exclusive right in case they demanded it - to purchase the water in the canal at rates which would net the canal comiiany a return not to exceed ten per cent of its capital stock annually.
When the very dry year of 1877 came the former expedients to which the Kern Island Canal Company had resorted to draw the water into its ditch did not suffice, and the dam, which is alleged to have cost $20,000 was built across the river. Not only were brush and sand used, but wooden chutes were built against the shoulder of Panorama heights and gravel and boulders were chuted down to the river edge to serve as more enduring ballast. Heavy timbers also were used to stay the waters, and the dam took on so much the character of a permanent work that settlers and water users over the entire delta from Bakersfield to Buena Vista lake were up in vigorous protest against this alleged effort to monopolize the entire flow of the river.
It is profitless now, as well as difficult, to decide just where the right and justice lay. Those who were close to Livermore say that the dam was never intended to take all the water of the river and never did so. It was to act merely as the present weirs do, and it was only for the purpose of diverting into the Kern Island canal the ajnount of water which was due it by right of prior appropriation. This right, they point out, was later established and affirmed by the Miller-Haggin agreement and the Shaw decree, and to this day the canal is entitled to its quota of water whenever there is that much in the river and whether there is anything left for other canals or not.
Partisans of Livermore go on to say that much of the outcry against the Kern Island was raised by Carr, who had begun a systematic campaign to oust Livermore and Redington from their commanding position on the river and (like the astute and experienced politician that he was) sought to enlist popular sentiment as one of the chief means for carrying out his ends.
any rate, it appears that about this time Carr was a prince of good fellows. He was suffering as much as any of the smaller water users, but he was willing to divide with everyone the little trickles that the monopolistic Kern Island people permitted to come down past their works. In fact Carr was the leader and ally of the anti-monopolists, and he was efficient and resourceful.
The men who relate the story from the other side say that no objection ever was made to the Kern Island company's dams so long as they built them of brush and sand as others did, and no complaint was made against the Kern Island taking all the water to which it was entitled and which the irrigators under it could use. The objectors, however, go on to affirm that so much water was forced into the Kern Island canal that it broke and the precious fluid ran to waste over untilled lands while settlers farther down the river had to stand by and see their crops perish for want of moisture. Out of this difference of opinion regarding right and equity and of understanding as to matters of fact, arose the first great contest over the waters of Kern river.
The contests between Haggin & Carr and Livermore & Chester were not so fierce nor on so large a scale as those that came later between Haggin & Carr and Miller & Lux, but they were fairly strenuous. On one occasion when Carr had secured from the court a restraining order to prevent Livermore & Chester from placing a dam across the river to force the water into the Kern Island canal, instructions were issued to the Livermore superintendents to proceed with the work on the assurance that the injunction would be lifted the following morning. From every camp the- men and teams were started out at noon, each taking an independent course as though going about some ordinary work, but all of them arriving during the afternoon at the foot of Panorama heights where the Kern Island intake was. The hours until nightfall were spent in quietly filling bags with sand and piling them on the river's edge. When darkness fell, two hundred men under the direction of C. L. Connor and C. C. Stockton began building a wall of sand bags out into the stream.
Carr's scouts discovered what was going on about midnight, but nothing was done until morning, when Connor and Stockton were placed under arrest for contempt of court. There had been a hitch and the injunction was not lifted. The judge was furious, and Carr was insistent on the officers placing Connor and Stockton in jail, but J. C. Crocker interceded, and Crocker's influence in those days was potent, even with a judge whose dignity had been badly ruffled. The men did not go to jail, and both of them afterward were given good positions by Carr, who could recognize an efficient fighter no matter which side he happened to be on.
As to just what happened to Livermore & Chester's dams the testimony differs, but a notice published in a paper of a little later date offers a substantial reward for the arrest and conviction of the person or persons that dynamited them.
Of course, with Haggin's millions and Carr's far-famed genius and generalship arrayed against them. Livermore and Redington did not fight as stubbornly as they might under more equal terms. No suit of importance seems to have been decided against them, and their contention respecting the paramount rights of the Kern Island canal was never overwhelmed. In 1878 they demonstrated their faith in their position by putting a magnificent body of land under the Kern Island canal on the market and printing a book and maps descriptive of the advantages of Kern county that would do high honor to any colonization agency of present days. At the rate of $1000 for a forty-acre farm and the best water right in the county, $200 down and $200 each year for four years, the seventeen sections which the Kern Valley Colony offered should have sold readily and Bakersfield's early colonization hopes should have been redeemed. But the sale to Haggin checked the colony plans before they got under way, and a long halt was called in the matter of inducing settlement, for Carr had drawn his plans on a much greater scale
It would be a matter of much interest were it possible to ascertain with absolute certainty what were the ultimate plans that Carr had in mind for the vast estate which he helped to upbuild. Some of his old friends state with assurance that he intended (when he had gotten together all the land available in the county and had secured full control of the water) to launch a great colonization scheme and build a little empire of small land owners. Carr is quoted as having called attention to the fact that he was a younger man than either J. B. Haggin or Lloyd Tevis, the other and larger partners in the enterprise, and remarking that in the end he expected his plans to prevail. But the oldest of the three men survives alone, and years before his death Carr's policy was over-ridden and his interest in the Kern county lands purchased.
In a statement published in May, 1880, J. B. Haggin over his signature declared that his purpose was not to monopolize the lands he was acquiring in Kern county but that he intended to ofifer them for sale on liberal terms. In the early days, however, Haggin's trips to Kern county were very few and very brief. He came in his private car, was driven direct to Belle View, where he looked at the blooded racers that were bred for him there, returned to his car and was sped away. Lloyd Tevis was a banker of San Francisco, and while his financial interest in the Kern county venture dates from the beginning of operations here, his name was not connected with the firm, which for years was known locally as Haggin & Carr or Carr & Haggin. and which appeared in the chief legal documents as J. B. Haggin.
Carr's money contribution to the Kern county venture is variously estimated as high as $500,000 to $800,000. Others declare it was very much less. The Gates tract of approximately 52,000 acres, being the odd sections in townships 30-26, 30-27, 31-26, and 31-27, and comprising the heart of the Kern river delta, was the foundation of the Carr & Haggin holdings. This was a tract of railroad land which fell into the hands of Isaac Gates of New York shortly after the grant of the odd sections along the line of the proposed Atlantic & Pacific railway had been made by Congress. Carr's position as political manipulator for the Southern Pacific enabled him, without doubt, to secure other railroad lands on agreeable terms, and he took steps at once to share in the wealth of swamp land which was being so rapidly and cheaply acquired when he arrived in Kern county. All through the records of swamp land districts from 1875 to 1893 the names of Haggin, Carr and Hearst figure prominently.
Aleantime, Carr, on his first arrival here, began taking steps to gain a controlling interest in the canal companies that had locations on Kern river. Few if any of these companies were incorporated and Carr early set himself to induce the owners to organize under the laws of the state. Dififerent methods were pursued in different cases, but one by one the companies filed incorporation papers, and just as surely Haggin and Carr eventually got a controlling interest in the stock. To tell how this was done would require a separate chapter for every canal company, and in most cases they would be interesting chapters. In every case, however, Carr presented the advantages of co-operation, showed how nnich faster and more effectually the work of building canals and ditches could be prosecuted with the financial aid of his powerful firm, offered wages to the stockholders, management and authority to the directors and water to the patrons of the ditch, who usually were the stockholders themselves.
Testimony respecting the treatment of the minority stockholders after Carr & Haggin had acquired control of the canal companies dififers according to the alliance and experience of the witness. Pioneers of unimpeachable character and unquestioned sincerity who were directors and officers of canal companies when Carr began his overtures and for a long time thereafter declare that the alliance was always to the benefit of the farmers. "We did not have money to build weirs and headgates, but Haggin did," says one of these pioneers. "Carr paid us wages for working on canals, his engineers ran out the lines so that we got the water in the right place, and it was my experience that when it came to dividing the water we always got our share. Carr said he did not care to manage the canals - that he would rather we did it. Carr used to come to the directors' meetings, but he let us run things as we pleased."
"Did you ever notice a big cow standing over a water trough when there was only a little stream running in from the pump? Did you ever notice how she gets all the water and the little cows have to stand back? And did you ever notice that when she gets all she wants to drink the big cow is in no hurry to move away and let the little cows have a chance? VVell, that gives you an idea of the way Haggin and Carr and the little farmers handled the water in the early days." This is the statement in brief, of another pioneer of equal standing and reputation and with equal opportunity for information and observation. Between the two opinions the reader may make his guess, or he may let the puzzle go with the knowledge that Carr's control of the canals and the water in them finally became an accomplished fact.
But another factor entered into the method of Carr's acquisition of water rights and into all his dealings with the settlers. He clearly foresaw, as testimony abundantly verifies, the fierce contest that was coming over the use of the waters of Kern river, and he made it a matter of distinct and settled policy to ally his interests with the interests of the people wherever it was possible to do so. The wisdom of his course showed in the great suit of Lux against Haggin, and in the celebrated Miller-Haggin agreement Carr's policy was carried to its logical, ultimate application by making all present and future land owners within the reach of the river parties to the terms under which its waters should be disposed.
While they were gathering up the large and luscious remnants of swamp land which the earlier comers had overlooked and were buying railroad lands, homesteads and school lands and were getting a firm grasp on water rights, Haggin & Carr were by no means overlooking the desert lands. In March, 1877, just as Carr was getting well established in Kern county, Congress most opportunely passed the desert land act that is known by that date. Already, on May 4, 1875, water to the amount of 850 cubic feet per second had been appropriated under Carr's direction for the express purpose of irrigating desert land, and work on the great Calloway canal which was to carry the water to this desert land had been commenced. The first work on the canal was begun by Carr & Haggin's men and teams, but a little later a contract for excavation was given to Vining Barker. In 1877, the year the desert land act
The Calloway canal takes water from the north side of Kern river almost opposite the center of Bakersfield, bears west through the northeastern part of Rosedale and then swings to the northwest over a great territory that needed only water to transform it into the finest of fruit and farming land. Broad & Roberts took the contract to complete the canal at seven cents per cubic yard for dirt and nine cents per cubic yard for hardpa" Mr. Roberts says they found nothing that they could not plow with eight mules in all the length of the ditch. It took about a year to finish the job, and meantime Carr & Haggin were busy securing entrymen to take up the land.
In his statement published in 1880 Haggin describes his operations in Kern county with special reference to the desert lands, which at that time were the object of much discussion. He runs briefly over the subject of his first activities in the county, stating that the Belle View and McClung ranches were established under the direction of George F. Thornton. On account of the malaria bred by Buena Vista and Kern lakes Haggin bought them, and a large amount of swamp land around them with a view to reclaiming them. He proceeded to divert the water of the river from the lakes to land formerly considered worthless for agriculture. He then built Goose lake slough canal to carry oflf the excess water, but this was not sufficient to handle it all. In March, 1877, the statement continues, Congress passed the desert land act. Haggin bought large numbers of odd-numbered sections north of the river, and induced his friends to enter the even-numbered sections adjoining. He bought more water rights and built canals to irrigate a much larger area of land and to utilize all the surplus waters of the river. Haggin states that he desired the co-operation of the owners of even-numbered sections and desired to have them pay their share of the expense of constructing the irrigation system. In order to avoid conflict with strangers he got nearly all the even-nUmbered . sections entered by friendly parties. Since the lands were entered, the statement continues, "invidious and designing persons have grossly misrepresented the facts touching the character of these lands," and efforts had been made to induce unusual rulings by the department of the interior to have the entries cancelled. Haggin had a government commission previously appointed visit the lands in question and make a report to the authorities. In conclusion he made the statement of policy already referred to, to the efTect that he did not desire to monopolize lands, but intended to offer them for sale on liberal terms.
In some cases, it appears, agreements were made with parties to enter the desert lands giving the entrymen the alternative of paying a certain amount for having the water placed on the lands, or selling their equities to Haggin & Carr at a stipulated price. In other cases the entrymen's names seem to have been loaned gratis or for a small fee without the expectation that they would figure in the ownership of the land after it was reclaimed. In either event there were not lacking arguments to show that the bargain was fair and advantageous to all concerned. The lands could be irrigated by no other means known and practicable at the time than by canal from Kern river, and such a canal could be built only by the expenditure of large sums of money. The state or federal government might have taken up the task but aside from these methods there was no alternative that would not
But the invidious and designing persons got the ear of the general land office authorities, and orders were issued suspending all action with regard to the entries. In February, 1891, the order of suspension was revoked, after something like 50,000 acres of land had been withheld from settlement and development for a little over thirteen years. Meantime the original entrymen, homesteaders and pre-emptors generally had become discouraged and abandoned their claims; some of the friends of Haggin who had allowed him to use their names were dead, others had moved away, and generally the plans for gathering in the desert lands were badly disarranged. Enter Miller & Lux at Rear of Stage
During all of the busy and important scenes just described, Miller & Lux lingered at the back of the stage. Their lands lay mostly to the north of Buena Vista Lake, twenty miles or more west of Bakersfield, and about the same distance from the center of the contests between Carr and Livermore over the water rights. It must be borne in mind, however, that Miller's interest in the disposal of the waters of Kern river was quite as great as was that of Haggin, and it must be remembered, also, that his position on the river bore the same relation to that of Haggin as the position of Haggin bore to that of Livermore & Chester. When Livermore & Chester put a dam across the river to force the water into the Kern Island canal it left dry the canals in which Carr & Haggin had acquired the controlling interest. Later, when Carr & Haggin built the Calloway weir to force the water into the Calloway canal the result was to dry up Miller's newly-planted alfalfa fields, and the tule swamps where his herds gathered rough forage. The sloughs and natural water courses through which the remnants of Kern river had meandered leisurely through the broad, flat trough of the valley to Tulare lake changed from clear, though limpid and leisurely streams, to green and slimy sinks of stagnant water. Then they became nothing but streaks of mud in which the feet of the weakened cattle were held fast until the vaqueros came to drag the poor beasts out by riatas about their horns. A little later all the sloughs and swamps were parched as dry as the naked, gray expanses of alkali desert that bordered them, and where the waters had been, great cracks opened in the earth down which a walking stick could be thrust its entire length. Only in deep holes, puddled by the feet of many starving cattle and fouled by the carcasses of dead brutes, was any water left in all the fifty miles of swamp land between Buena Vista and Tulare lakes.
Of course such a state of affairs could lead but to vigorous defensive action on the part of Aliller & Lux, and so the suit of Lux versus Haggin was filed, and after the usual delay was brought to trial on April IS, 1881, before B. Brundage, judge of the superior court of Kern county.
However, before I take up the story of this great contest of rival corporations, let me tell how lesser factors in the development of the county were faring, relate the stories of some disconnected incidents of importance, and show by transient items of interest something of the daily doings of the citizens of those days.
Provenance
Text from History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.