Kern County, California - Chapter 11, 1914
From History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914. 7,183 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
7,183 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
While the short but interesting preliminary between Carr & Haggin and Livermore & Chester was being fought to a finish, Miller and Lux were getting established in Kern county and gathering about them able leaders and captains, of whom J. C. Crocker, S. W. Wible and Capt. John Barker were types. Long before this time Miller & Lux had acquired great ranches and ranges around Gilroy, along the San Joaquin river and far up along the northern coast. In 1872, in conjunction with W. S. Chapman, owner of the Chowchilla ranch, Miller & Lux as owners of the Columbia ranch had begun a canal, the largest and longest in the state, which took water from the San Joaquin river at the mouth of Fresno slough and extended for seventy-five miles across Fresno and Merced and a part of Stanislaus counties.
Miller's activities in Kern county (Miller was the active member of the firm) were an extension of the operations along the San Joaquin. It is not unlikely that Miller at some time had pleasant visions of a great cattle and sheep ranch extending in an unbroken sweep through the rich, black tule lands from Stockton to Bakersfield. During his fight with Haggin & Carr, Miller is commonly reported as assuring them that he would make them "pack their blankets out of Kern county," and there were not lacking admirers of the doughty and vigorous old German who full)^ expected to see him make his threat good.
Jim Crocker had been in Miller's employ on the San Joaquin and was sent to Kern county to lay the foundations for the Miller occupancy here. Crocker was the sort of a man Miller would be expected to choose for the job. A quiet, self-contained man, but a good mixer in spite of his reserve and a man of native force and personality that made him a natural leader. He was bred to get up in the morning at 4 o'clock and go out on hard jaunts with the vaqueros. Chasing down and breaking up organized bands of horse and cattle thieves appears to have been his favorite pastime. If a friend or fellow stockman was in trouble, financial or otherwise, Crocker was ready to go on his bail to the extent of his possessions. Men rallied to the standard of Crocker because of their friendship and confidence and because they liked to fight with a fighter. The men who fought under Carr's colors did so more usually because they believed their personal interest lay in that direction. It was Carr's strong point of strategi', as we have
S. W. Wible, who figures prominently among the Miller forces in the Miller-Haggin contest, was a pioneer of 1852, beginning his western experience as a miner and constructor of miners' canals and sluices and later undertaking the management of larger water engineering enterprises. He came to Kern county in 1874 and built a number of the early canals from Kern river. When the Kern Valley Water Company was formed by Livermore, Redington and others to undertake the reclamation of swamp land district No. 121, Wible was placed in charge as engineer. Celsus Brower had charge of the business affairs of the company. Wible built the great Kern Valley Water Company's canal which extended north from Buena Vista lake for a distance of some twenty-six miles, when first constructed, but which has since been carried much further down the swamp and ultimately is to be built through to Tulare lake. The canal follows the western edge of the swamp and overflowed district, and was 125 feet wide on the bottom and calculated to carry a stream seven feet in depth. It was designed to carry all the waters of Kern river that might flow so far, and also was to serve as the feeder for irrigation ditches that would cover 100,000 or more acres of land. When ]\Iiller & Lux acquired the Kern Valley W^ater Company's interests Wible went to the new management, as most of the men who were prominent in the operation of Livermore & Redington's Kern Island projects went over to Haggin & Carr when the latter came into possession of those properties. Wible afterward became the general superintendent for Miller & Lux. He was noted as one of the few men who stood in no awe of Miller when the latter flew into his celebrated fits of passion. It is related that on an occasion when Miller had made the discovery that one of his warehouses had leaked and wet a great quantity of wool and was dividing his time between furiously chopping hole after hole in the wall of the structure and as furiously jumping on his hat when he found new evidences of destruction, Wible followed his employer along the warehouse wall and jumped on the hat while Miller chopped the holes until the ludicrousness of the performance finally appealed to the cattle king and appeased his wrath. In his old age Wible lived true to his pioneer instinct. He was one of the first to respond to the Alaskan mining boom, and summer after summer he donned the great fur overcoat that identified him for years to strangers and new comers, and sailed for the north to meet the melting of the snows above his frozen placers.
Capt. John Barker got into the Miller-Haggin fight partly l^ecause he was a riparian owner, although his lands were higher up on the river than the intake of any of the irrigation canals, and partly because, like an old war horse, he could not remain inactive when his nostrils caught the scent of battle. Born in England and bred to the sea, he came to California on the news of the first gold excitement, explored the upper San Joaquin valley on horseback in 1854, fought in the Indian wars of Tulare county in 1856, served in a troop of volunteer cavalry during war times, and came to Kern county in the early 70s. He was a bluff, out-spoken man, a vitriolic writer when his righteous wrath was stirred, and an ofT-hand orator, the sarcasm of whose phrases was dulled only by the sledge-hammer method of their delivery. Captain Barker would roast his victim alive, pour carbolic acid over his withered remains and end by quoting a few pages of Shakespeare, Byron or Bobby Burns to give a classic flavor to his philippic. He entered no less fervently into his friendships, and between his battles and his benefactions Captain Barker left his record deeply drawn across the history of the county. In his old age, crippled by infirmities, he used to ride about Bakersfield and between the town and the mouth of Kern river canon, driving an old white horse and a roomy phaeton, planning over old plans for the improvement of the Pierce and Barker ranches and the utilization of resources and opportunities that still lie fallow, waiting till the time is ripe for the fulfillment of the prophecies of the pioneer.
Incidental references in preceding pages have given some insight into the character of W. B. Carr, the generalissimo of the Haggin forces. Fat, aggressive, determined, absolutely unabashed, with bull-dog courage and endurance, he was a typical political boss of the larger and more perfect type. Frequently and fervently cursed and hated, he could walk into a saloon in a hostile ward and in ten minutes have enough sworn allies to insure the victory of his candidates. If a delegation of angry farmers in the days of the bitter water troubles came after Carr with the intention of puncturing him with bullets or stringing him up to a high-branching cottonwood, he met them with an outstretched hand and slaps on their backs and sent them away wreathed in smiles of hope and assurance. Moreover, Carr had the valuable instinct that showed him to a nicety when it was necessary to dispense good coin and valuable favors and when mere promises would suffice. Carr was a finished performer and a skillful tutor, and later actors on the Kern county stage sat at his feet and learned to do politics in the scientific, metropolitan style.
Walter James figured in the water disputes, in court and out, mainly as an expert witness. His long and intimate association with everything that had to do with the appropriation and use of Kern river's waters from 1870 down, aided by a retentive memory and a logical, consecutive manner of stating the salient facts concerning a subject made him invaluable as an authority, and no investigation of water or water rights was complete until Walter James had been examined and cross-examined and with a little nasal drawl and imperturbable deliberation had told just how and why it all happened and came to pass. It is difficult to say whether Walter James in his long record in Kern county shines more as an engineer or as a diplomat, but he is hard to out-class in either capacity. Heads of the Rival Literary Bureaus
Dozens of portraits of interesting actors in the great drama of the Kern river water contest might be added to this little gallery of character sketches, but I shall attempt but two more - those of the chiefs of the rival literary bureaus that flooded the state with syndicated editorials and syndicated supplements setting forth the rival arguments of appropriators and riparian owners and the history, law, custom and usage touching the utilization of water for any and all purposes since Noah launched the ark on the diluvian seas.
In addition to his numerous other activities Julius Chester, in the days of his ascendency in Kern county, founded the Southern Californian and was its editor for a number of years. Like the other weeklies of the pioneer days, the Southern Californian was stronger as an organ of personal opinion than it vyas as a purveyor of news, and Uncle Julius, as he was called by rival editors, was as handy as the best of them in the use of the king's English. He was almost as diplomatic and persuasive in his writing as he was in his speech, and how effective he was in the latter may be gathered from an incident that is related as the truth by a veracious citizen of the time. Uncle Julius had used some of his best literary art in writing up a certain very undesirable citizen, and the day following the appearance of the paper on the street he was sitting comfortably in his ofifice with his feet on the desk when the undesirable citizen appeared. His eye was wild, his breath was laden with liquor and he waved a big six-shooter before the editor's stomach in a very promiscuous manner while he talked.
Uncle Julius recognized that if the bad citizen had really intended to kill him a little matter of his feet being on the desk need not have interfered, and he asked what the trouble was all about as coolly and pleasantly as though it were only an advertiser wanting to know why his announcement did not appear to the top of the page next to pure reading matter as per contract.
Chester took his feet down deliberately, deliberately found a copy of the paper, sat down, put his feet on the desk again, adjusted his glasses and began to read the offending article aloud.
Tom indicated with his gun that the most offensive portion of the story was to be found still farther down, and Chester read on. When he got to the bottom of the last paragraph Tom had admitted that every assertion in the red hot arraignment - and it was red hot - was true, and the two men went out and had a drink together.
Chester in these days had descended from his former position of principal factor in the county's industry and commerce, his property was slipping out of his hands or had previously escaped, and he was constantly being sued for debt. His fighting instinct never forsook him, and during the latter part of his journalistic career he was engaged, a very large share of his time in putting the county officials on the spit and turning them slowly and scientifically over the coals of incandescent journalism. The county officials winced in patience at first, but after Chester was known to be on the financial toboggan they joined gleefully in pelting him on his way to the bottom. Everything Chester had was attached over and over. Once he was arrested on a charge of stealing corn from a Chinaman, but that probably was only a fair offset to the defamatory charges which Chester heaped upon them. The corn theft case was dismissed. But finally Chester's presses and type were attached and sold to A. C. Maude, and Chester was able to retain possession of them only by showing that they had been leased to George another of the picturesque and notable newspaper men of the county, who figures more prominently at a little later date, ^^'ear held down the outfit, and Chester continued to publish the Southern Californian and to berate the county officials. Maude, who claimed that he had bought not only the outfit but the name of Chester's paper, began publication of the Kern County Californian, with Richard Hudnut as editorial writer and newsgatherer in chief. Finally Wear sold his lease to a printer by name of Warren and a school teacher by name of Vrooman. For a time the latter kept a guard over the shop by night as well as by day, but one evening Maude's forces inveigled the guard away and captured the shop.
With nothing left but the name of his paper, Chester took himself to San Francisco and issued the Southern Californian from there until the close of the political campaign that ended with the defeat of what he was pleased to call the Reed ring, and the election of B. Brundage, the opponent of Judge Reed, to be the first judge of the superior court of Kern county. Judge Reed had been judge of the county court, but that office was abolished by the change in the constitution.
Richard Hudnut was a highly educated and very dignified man. His writing was silkier than Chester's, and he had such an easy, refined and polished way of flaying his victim that after the victim was flayed he knew that he had lost his hide, but had in his mind only a vague, circumstantial suspicion that it was Hudnut who had skinned him. When Chester was charged with stealing the Chinaman's corn Hudnut mourned over him in paragraph after paragraph as one might mourn over the grave of misled innocence.
It will be appreciated readily that in a fight like the one which the great water contest occasioned, where it was necessary to depict everyone on the other side as a red-handed pirate, a dark-alley thug and a horse thief, the peculiar accomplishments of Hudnut and Chester were invaluable. Moreover, both Hudnut and Chester had all the history of Kern county water rights at their fingers' ends, and when they were established at Sacramento with the money of the two rival corporations behind them, respectively, they poured out a class and quantity of militant, journalistic literature that marks a milestone in the newspaper history of the state.
Still another journalistic factor was injected into the great fight. When the issue was fairly joined between the riparianists and the appropriators, in 1886, the Kern County Echo was founded by a company of farmers and business men, who gathered one day at the old Burnap drug store and decided that there was still a third side to the great question and that a new organ should be established to advocate it. Capt. John Barker was sent to San Francisco to buy the plant, and S. C. Smith, then a young lawyer of Bakersfield, afterward state senator and still later congressman from the eighth district, was elected managing editor. Through the controversy the Echo urged that neither appropriators nor riparian owners be given a monopoly of the water of the river, but that the state retain the ownership in trust for the people and that the use of the water be permitted for irrigation and other purposes under state regulation and control. Water is one of the elements and is no more a proper object of monopoly than is the air, was the gist of the Echo's persistent argument during those days. The Great Water Suit
The great water suit, known by the title "Lux versus Haggin," not only marks an epoch in the history of Kern county, but marks an epoch, also, in the history of irrigation in the state of California. It began with little more notice from the public than any of the other hundred or more suits that had been filed by rival claimants to the waters of Kern river, but before it had gone far local people realized that this was the battle royal, and before it was finally dismissed it had focussed the attention of the state, ranged practically every California newspaper of general circulation on one side or the other, resulted in the calling of two state irrigation conventions and a special session of the legislature, and started a movement to amend the state constitution so that the supreme court, which rendered an unpopular decision in connection with the suit, might be reorganized. The latter movement did not succeed.
In brief, the contention of the plaintiffs was tliat the}- were the owners of riparian lands along the lower reaches of Kern river, that Kern river was a natural stream flowing in an established and continuous channel through their lands, and that under the common law of England they were entitled to have the waters of the river flow over, through and upon their lands, undiminished in quantity and unimpaired in quality.
The defendants claimed that they were entitled by right of appropriation to divert the waters from the river for purposes of irrigation, to develop water power, and for domestic and other purposes. It was a contest, in short, between riparian rights and the right of appropriation. In addition to setting forth the rights of the plaintilifs the complaint alleged that the defendants, by diverting the water in their canals had rendered the lands of the plaintiffs dry and barren to such an extent that their cattle had neither grass to eat nor water to drink.
The papers in the suit were drawn in San Francisco and sent here to be filed in the superior court on September 2, 1880. On the morning of April 15, 1881, the trial began with Judge B. Brundage on the bench and a formidable array of counsel for both parties before the bar. Louis Haggin was in charge of the case for the defendant, and was assisted by John Garber and George Flournoy, Sr., father of the present justice of the peace of the sixth township of Kern county. Hall McAllister was nominally the chief counsel for Lux, but R. E. Houghton, then a comparatively young attorney, was the active man and really the one who outlined and carried on the campaign.
The reporters of the day declared that the testimony, the taking of which consumed forty-nine days, was tedious and uninteresting, but it is suspected that they were too close to the scene to realize in full its dramatic interest or even its numerous comedy features. The witnesses included everybody in the county who was supposed to know anything about the history and habits of Kern river, the locations of its various courses and the dates when these courses were changed, or anything concerning the appropriation of water from the river, and in addition to these, sundry expert witnesses who had read in books what happened in Calcutta or what the river Nile did in the days of the Pharaohs and whose testimony was duly objected to because they had not been present at the times and places mentioned nor seen with their own eyes the things they pretended to describe.
Walter James, chief engineer for Haggin. and S. W. Wible, superintendent and engineer for Miller & Lux, were the star performers and spent day after day on the witness stand, mainly under cross-examination. Meantime all the attorneys whittled redwood shingles, and it was a part of the unofficial duties of the sheriff to see that the supply of timber never ran low.
John Garber carried a potato in his pocket for luck, and developed a habit of taking it out and shaking it at the witness when he asked a question of especial moment. R. E. Houghton, on a like occasion would stand up, reach across the table and dip his pen in the ink as though he intended forthwith to write the answer down in plain black and white so that it could never be denied, altered or evaded evermore. The witnesses were even more eccentric and picturesque. An old man by name of Stevens, who came from the head of the South Fork valley, made a speech in response to every question that was put to him, and finally as he was leaving the stand he swept his long arm out over the big assemblage of pioneers who crowded the space behind the attorneys and remarked : "I'm gettin' to be an old man, and I don't know if I'll ever see you all here together again; and I want to say to you now, while I've got you all together, that I'm the oldest settler in Kern county." Of course one of the attorneys took an exception to the statement and asked that it be stricken from the records.
Each evening when court was adjourned for the day the attorneys and many of the witnesses for Haggin were driven to headquarters at Bellevue where the walls beneath the spacious porches were lined with maps and diagrams. Here the net results of the day's testimony were reviewed, and engineers, zanjeros and scouts of all descriptions were sent out to get whatever evidence was needed to fill in the gaps.
In the meantime, if the local papers were not doing much in the way of reporting the trial they were sparing no effort to prove what the judgment of the court should be. Despite all efforts to put him out of business, Julius Chester was still editing the Southern Californian, and was presenting through its columns the contentions of the riparianists as represented by Miller & Lux. The Californian, owned by A. C. Maude and edited by Richard Hudnut, was doing no less valiant service for Haggin. But the choicest language of which these masters were possessed they saved for rhetorically pummelling each other.
The last witness was heard on June 2, 1881, and all the testimony, when it was written up, made a stack of paper four feet high. For the convenience of the lawyers the court consented to hear the arguments in San Francisco. The speech-making began on June 20th, and on November 3d, Judge Brundage rendered his decision in favor of Haggin, which was to the effect that the appropriators were entitled to the water of the river as against the riparianowners, represented by Lux. Of course Miller & Lux appealed to the supreme court, and forthwith in Kern county there began a fierce political campaign to re-elect Judge Brundage on the one hand and to defeat him on the other.
We have seen heretofore in the course of this narrative that Kern river seemed possessed of a certain titanic sense of humor, and none will be surprised to read that while the supreme court took its time in considering a mass of evidence, a gist of which was that neither party to the suit was willing to let the other have any water, the river began to increase its flow, and in the early part of 1884 the two chief parties to the suit were engaged in a fiercer fight than ever to keep the swollen river from flooding their lands, even though it involved turning the excess waters over on the other.
As indicated in his statement referred to in the previous chapter, Haggin had reclaimed the beds of Kern and Buena Vista lakes and had built the Goose lake canal to carry off any excess water that the Calloway and other irrigation canals could not handle. The Goose lake canal led off to the nurth, and on the south side of the river Haggin had built the Cole levee farther to prevent the river from breaking over and flooding his reclaimed lake bottoms.
By far the greater part of Haggin's reclaimed lands lay to the south of the river, and by far the greater part of Miller & Lux's reclaimed lands lay to the north. The latter had built levees along the north bank to protect their lands, and had constructed the great Kern Valley Water Company's canal to carry any excess waters off to the north of their cultivated fields.
As the snows melted in the mountains and the river lapped higher and higher against the levees it became a most absorbing question as to whether the waters would break on Miller's side or on Haggin's. They broke on Haggin's side on ]\Iay 17, 1884, and in a few hours there was a hole in the Cole levee forty feet wide and through it a stream of muddy water, twenty feet deep, was rushing to cover all the lands that Haggin had reclaimed with so great expense.
There were great forces of men on the Haggin ranches in those days, and in very short order Billy Carr, Walter James, C. L. Conner, Dave Coffee and other superintendents and foremen for miles around were dispatching workmen, teams, scrapers, shovels and sand bags to the break. With the bags of sand the broken ends of the levee were rip-rapped to prevent further washing, and a row of piling was driven across the break.
Early in these proceedings Henry Miller arrived with R. E. Houghton. Having a suit in the supreme court in which their contention was that they were entitled to have the full flow of the river run over, through and upon their lands at all times, ]\Iiller and his attorney were hardly in a position to object to Haggin's men repairing a break in their levee that would tend to throw the full force of the stream over on Miller & Lux. But Houghton was fully equal to the emergency. It happened that Miller owned forty acres of land in the bed of Buena \^ista lake (surrounded by the Haggin sections) and Miller set up the claim that he was entitled to have the river flow unhindered over, through and upon this land, also.
Miller strode up to the break in the levee where Walter James was superintending the driving of the piles. "\\'hat are you doing here? \\'hat are you doing here?" he demanded.
"I'm just carrying out my instructions," drawled ^^'alter James in his imperturbable manner. "We thought we'd put a few piles in here, because we may want to build a bridge across, or something."
"Well, I don't want you to stop my water. I don't want you to stop my water. Do you understand? I don't want you to stop my water," shouted Miller. "Have a cigar, Mr. James."
So soon as the train could take him back to San Francisco, Houghton went to Judge Hunt of the superior court, and on a petition setting forth that Miller was the owner of a piece of land, to wit, forty acres, etc., and that whereas when the waters of Kern river were allowed to flow over it unhindered, etc., large quantities of tules and other plants and grasses valuable for feed grew thereon, and whereas one Haggin had a force of men at work with piles, a pile driver, brush, etc., endeavoring to restrain the said water from flowing over Miller's said land, etc., and whereas Miller would be greatly damaged, etc., etc., an injunction was duly secured.
By the time the injunction was served the ends of the levee were pretty well protected with sand bags, and most of the piling had been driven, but the water was flowing through the break almost as rapidly as ever.
Walter James was out at the levee when a telegram arrived ordering him to make all speed to San Francisco. He jumped on the horse that brought the inessenger, galloped to Bellevue, and found there another horse saddled and waiting. A man thrust into his hand a purse of money. "The gates are all wide open," they shouted, and James was off for the Southern Pacific depot. He got there fifteen minutes late, but the train was an hour behind time, and he walked over to the hotel. The first man he saw was S. W. Wible.
In San Francisco the next morning James assured Louis Haggin that if he had a free hand and all the resources of the Haggin ranches at his command he could stop the break in the Cole levee in twenty-four hours. Haggin told him to take the first train back to Bakersfield, and to look for a telegram at Lathrop. Meantime the lawyer would undertake to get Judge Hunt's injunction lifted, and if he succeeded he would send a message to Lathrop reading, "Make the trip."
It was no small task to get the injunction set aside for the reason that after he had issued it Judge Hunt had gone on a fishing trip back into the mountains, leaving orders for nobody to interfere with any matter in his court. during his absence. Louis Haggin, however, prevailed on another judge to set aside Judge Hunt's order, and James got his telegraphic instruction to "Make the trip."
On the journey home James laid out his campaign, and on his arrival at Bellevue orders were dispatched in all directions. Florence Gleason with a gang of men was already at the gap in the levee filling sand bags. Word was sent to C. L. Connor to report at once at the levee with all his men. J. E. Yancey and Frank Collins with the crews under them were to follow a little later, and still later were to come C. W. Jackson and the men from the Poso ranch. There were enough men, altogether, to keep* fresh shifts at work at the gap all day and all night.
The camp previously established en the levee was enlarged to accommodate no less than five hundred men. Lender the direction of Dave Cofifee the hoisting engine used in driving piles was rigged to haul wagons loaded with sand along the levee. Heavy cables were laced back and forth among the piles, and the work of building in a wall of sand bags to stop the rushing flood proceeded with system and dispatch.
"But R. E. Houghton never overlooked anything," said Walter James in telling the story. While Louis Haggin was getting rid of Judge Hunt's injunction in San Francisco, Houghton was getting another, injunction out of the superior court of Napa county. This was issued at the request of George Cornwell, who owned a small piece of land on the south side of the river and many thousands on the north side and who made the same representation as Miller had made before Judge Hunt.
Wible was less than a da}- behind James, but when he had reached Bakersfield, and came dashing down the road along the Cole levee with his Napa county injunction and Sherifif Coons, James and his great crew of men were swarming over the levee like human ants, working in a frenzy of haste to place the last sand bags that would stop the torrent of water.
Every superintendent from the Haggin ranches in Kern county was there, with Billy Carr in personal command. The sheriff waved the injunction and ordered the work stopped, but everyone was too busy to hear. It was an intense moment, for many months of work, tens of thousands of dollars, and (what was almost more than either for the men of fighting blood who were ranged on either side) victory or defeat in the contest depended on a few more minutes of time.
Sheriff Coons handed the injunction to Carr and explained its purport, but Carr had to read the document, and his glasses were over in the tent. He went to the tent, got his glasses, sat down and read the injunction and the complaint which accompanied it. All the while Wible was enjoining haste. When Carr finished studying the order of the court he desired James to read it, and James read it, quite as slowly and carefully as Carr had done. Wible stormed over to where Dave Coffee was rushing in the sand bags with redoubled haste and energy, and commanded him to desist in the name of the law. But Coft'ee knew nothing of law or injunctions and he kept right on shoving the sand bags down to the men who were building them, now, just above the surface of the yellow water. Finally Carr sauntered back from the tent, saw that the gap in the levee was closed and the bags of sand rose clear and dry above the surface, and held up his hand as a signal uf submission to the court's decree.
But one thing had not been done. James had buried logs, or "dead men" on the upper side of the levee and had attached to them loops of cable ready to slip over the tops of the piling to help them carry the great weight of the water pressing on the narrow dam. But these loops of cable had not been adjusted, and the upper ends of the piling were without support. For a little while the piles and the wall of sand bags stood, and then, as the water lowered on the outer side, they leaned and swayed ; the sand-bag wall splashed out of sight, the broken piles bobbed merrily to the surface, and the yellow flood leaped through the breech once more to spread over section after section of Haggin's reclaimed swamp land, and "undiminished in quantity and unimpaired in quality," flowed over, through and upon Miller's forty acres of Buena Vista lake bottom until it was covered a dozen or fifteen feet in depth, and it remained covered until the wild geese came and went and went and came again.
On July 5th, more than a month after the wall of sand bags washed out, the water was still pouring thruugh the Cole levee upon Haggin's land at the rate of 3000 cubic feet per second.
But R. E. Houghton never overlooked anything. On July 26th he had W. B. Carr and Walter James haled before the court of Napa county to show cause why they should not be punished for contempt of court for consuming a quarter of an hour in reading the court's injunction.
"Did you have any thought in your mind, 'Sir. Carr." said the Napa lawyer who appeared for Houghton, "that you might profit by the delay you were causing?"
The Napa judge let Carr and James off with a mild admonition, but Judge Hunt was more obdurate. He declared that no court had any authority to set aside his injunction, and that all the time the five hundred men were
Another victory was coming to the Miller forces. The same issue of the Haggin & Carr paper that contained the short paragraph about the Cole break and the San Francisco injunction carried an equally short paragraph stating that the great water suit had been resubmitted. It took until October 27, 1884, for the supreme court to reach a final decision, and the remittitur was not filed in this county until May 28, 1886, but not to make the story long, the supreme justices, or a majority of them, found that Judge Brundage had committed an error in not allowing certain testimony on the part of the defense that would have made but little diiiference, probably, in the main issue. But accompanying their order was a most important expression of opinion to the effect that the English common law respecting riparian rights governed the use of water in the state of California. In other words, as the Chester and Hudnut literary bureaus soon after made the whole state aware, the owner of land on the banks of a natural water course was entitled to have all the waters of the stream flow over and through his land, undiminished in quantity and unimpaired in quality. That meant that nobody could take water out of a stream in an irrigating ditch and spread it over his land, for if he did so, certainly he could not restore it again to its natural channel, undiminished and unimpaired, or either.
Of course every irrigator in the state sat up and howled, and it was not very long before an active and able politician like Billy Carr had them organized and holding big irrigation conventions, first at Riverside and then at Fresno, and drafting laws for submission to the state legislature that were calculated to send the doctrine of riparian rights back to England on the first tramp steamer that left the Golden Gate.
Carr did more. He went to work quietly among the members of the state legislature and before Miller's men knew what was going on he had the signatures of about two-thirds of them appended to a petition asking the governor to call a special sess'ion of the legislature and virtually pledging themselves to enact into law the measures framed at the two irrigation conventions.
Armed with this petition and reinforced by a stalwart bunch of his friends from Kern county and elsewhere, Carr met Governor Stoneman at a hotel in San Francisco. Everybody had a good time, and the governor, who was a veteran of the Union army, distinguished and endeared himself in the eyes of Carr's southern followers by consuming without a quiver more mint julips than any man in the crowd from below the Mason and Dixon line could carry off. Before the evening was over the call for the special session of the legislature was signed.
This was in July, 1886, but meantime Kern county had gone through another political campaign (the hottest and most vindictive, perhaps, which was ever waged in the valley) in which the issue turned on the election of the superior judge before whom the great water suit should come for re-trial. Brundage, of course, was supported by the Haggin & Carr forces, and all of Miller's strength was thrown behind Judge Arick. The latter was victorious by the scant majority of four votes.
labors of Chester and Hudnut and other writers of the Miller & Lux and Carr & Haggin literary bureaus. Supplements treating the water question from Miller's side were furnished free to every paper of importance in the state that would handle them. The next week an equally copious flood of Haggin supplements descended on the readers. Plain print was seconded by whole page, colored cartoons, and these in addition to being sent to the papers were posted on the dead walls about the towns like circus announcements.
The extra session of the legislature convened in August, 1886, and with the din of a state-wide battle in their ears, the members of the assembly passed the irrigation bills as per schedule. But the senate balked. It would not defeat the bills nor would it pass them, and on September 11, 1886, the legislature adjourned with the question of water legislation immersed a thousand fathoms deep in statu quo.
It was sometime during the events recorded in this chapter that Henry Miller made the important discovery and confided it to a friend that "plenty of money makes a good politician."
How much money it took to make the very high grade politicians that fought each other to a stand still in the legislature of 1886, the author has not been able, even approximately, to ascertain, but battles like the one over the judgeship and battles like that at Cole's levee were evidently so immensely expensive that both Haggin & Carr and Miller & Lux wished for peace. The big suit fell to Judge Arick to try, but he granted a petition for a change of venue to Tulare county, which the supreme court sustained, and there the case lay until all the points involved in the contest were settled to the satisfaction of both parties by the celebrated Miller-Haggin agreement. Miller-Haggin Agreement Ends Litigation
This agreement, which was signed on July 28, 1888, and which bears the signatures of thirty-one corporations and fifty-eight individuals owning water rights at the time on Kern river, practically divided the waters of the stream between Miller & Lux and Haggin and the diiTerent canal companies that were represented by them. The length of the document is fully commensurate with its importance and the number of parties interested, but as it was later incorporated into the findings of the Shaw decree, issued by Judge Lucien Shaw of Los Angeles sitting in the superior court of Kern county in 1895, and has been made a part of every deed executed by either of the two great land owners of the county since then, a scant summary of its provisions here is justifiable.
The agreement begins by recognizing that certain of the parties have riparian rights, and that certain other of the parties have -vested rights by appropriation against all the world except the aforesaid riparian owners. This point settled, the agreement provides that the parties of the first part, represented by Miller, shall have one-third of all the waters of the river during the months of March, April, May, June, July, and August of each year, and that the parties of the second part, represented by Haggin. shall have all the remainder.
It provides for the measurement and delivery of the water, and for the construction of the Buena Vista Lake reservoir, covering approximately thirty-six sections of land. The two parties join in this undertaking, sharing equally the expense of construction, repair and maintenance. The two parties also share equally the expense of building the levees necessary to carry the water of the river from the second point of measurement to the reservoir, and of building an outlet canal from Buena Vista lake to the Kern Valley Water Company's canal. Both parties agree to join in suit against any person or persons who attempt to divert any water from the river above the second point of measurement, and each is to bear half the expense of such litigation. All pending suits between the two parties were to be dismissed. The agreement is made a perpetual covenant, running with all the land owned or claimed by any of the parties within the territory described in the contract.
Provenance
Text from History of Kern County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present;, published 1914, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.