Lassen County, California - Chapter 3: 1857. Settlement, 1916 (part 1 of 2)
From Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. 15,990 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
- Part 1
- Part 2
The text
15,990 wordsMachine-read from scans of Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 3: 1857. Settlement
Lodgings were extremely scarce in the land of the Never j Sweats during the winter of 1856-7, and not many of those who came here in 1856 stayed all winter. The following persons spent all, or nearly all, the winter here. R. J. Scott and Wm. Morehead stayed on their claims, and A. U. Sylvester spent part of the winter with the latter. E. Smith and his Wife and Capt. Weatherlow stayed at Smith 's place on the west side of the lake. Francis Lanigar and his Wife, Eppstein, Antone Storff, and Lynch stayed with Lassen. Hasey, McMurtry, and Elliott stayed on their claim. Dr. W. W. L. Lennox, Lathrop, Cap. Hill, and probably Gilpin and O'Laughlin stayed somewhere in the valley. E. Roop and McNaull stayed at Roop's, and I. N. Roop was there the latter part of the winter.
Early in the spring men began to come into the valley from the other side of the mountains. Wiley Cornelison came here in March. He says there were thirteen men and two women in the valley at that time. Probably some of those who wintered here had gone to the lower country for a short time. The permanent settlement of the valley began this spring. Men came in then to take up land and stay here, and some of them brought their families with them. A good many of those who settled in the valley this year stayed here all the rest of their lives.
The list of those who took up land in 1857 is a long one, but it is given because it will be of interest to those who know the country. It will be noticed that some men took up a good many claims of what was shortly afterwards valuable land, and soon abandoned them, or sold out for a song.
In January A. D. Morton and M. W. Haviland came back, and some time during the month put up a cabin on the latter 's claim. It was on the north side of the river about a mile and a half east of Roop's east line, just about where the Jensen house now stands. This was the first cabin put up in the Toadtown (Johnstonville) country. The latter part of this month, or the first of February, Morton built a cabin on his claim. Probably he was helped by Haviland, Sylvester, Johnson Tutt, and C. C. Walden. This cabin was on the north side of the river, a little northeast of Curlew Butte. January 2nd Stephen O'Laughlin sold his claim to Dr. Lennox, ' ' hecause I owe him money. ' ' January 26th S. C. Perrin, John Teskey, and Asa Adams relocated all the land between the claims of Lathrop and Smith, previously claimed by Reed and Cushings. Probably this was along the lake east of Eppstein. The last of the month Nicholas Clark bought E. Smith's claim on the lake for $400, and sold the east half of it to the "Know-nothing Boys" (Thos. Eaton and Ben. Ward). Mr. Clark's Wife walked over here from Elizabeth Town some time during the summer. They and their son, William H., spent the rest of their lives on this ranch, and it is still owned by their descendants.
In February Gabriel Murphy located north of Manley Thompson on land that was afterwards partly covered by the Baxter and Bartlett ranch on Baxter creek; David P. Dexter relocated the land northeast of Scott that Whitaker had taken the year before; James Belcher relocated the claim southeast of Roop, "formily held by Florancy Smith"; Wm. Hill (Cap. Hill) gave notice that he constituted himself "substitute for Mrs. L. M. Ellis in place of James Belcher," and he also relinquished his claim east of Lassen ; D. M. Munchie claimed a section west of Haviland; - Butts claimed Haviland's land, but relinquished it in about a week; N. Greenwood took a claim south of Morton; James Belcher relinquished his appointment as agent for Mrs. Ellis ; J. W. Tremer took a claim, the northwest corner of which was "a certain tree about two mile below the mound on Susan river"; J. H. Ferry, W. T. Eadwards, and Daniel Terry took three claims along the lake, location uncertain ; James F. Ray and John Meyer relocated the claim just relinquished by Hill ; R. F. Mastin, Wm. Powell, and Mrs. L. Cooper took three claims in Elysian valley, Mastin 's on the west, probably joining the land claimed by Denney and Keelty the year before, Powell east of him, and Mrs. Cooper east of Powell (Charles Cooper was with his Mother) ; John Griffin took a section just north of Belcher's last claim ; Joseph Libler claimed the ' ' water of the creek known as Camanchas Creek for farming and mining purposes" (east branch of Baxter creek) ; A. Fredonyer took a claim north of "Geo. Lathrops formerly Isadore Mayerowtz claim, situated in Honey Lake valley and state of California or Utah Territory as the case may be," but relinquished it in a few days "because he had since learned the same to be claimed and occupied by an actual settler. " In a few days he took another claim along Susan river east of I. N. Roop.
Some time during this month A. T., Leroy, and Cutler Arnold, and the latter 's son Henry, and Malconi and Albert Scott came into the valley, but did not stay very long. The fall before, while on a prospecting trip, L. Arnold and M. Scott came into the valley for a few days.
In March Richard Thompson located a section south of Morton, the center of his south line being about twenty-five rods south of the mouth of Lassen creek; Antone Storff claimed the water from Rosees creek, probably the creek three fourths of a mile northwest of Janesville ; Wiley Cornelison claimed a half section northwest of Haviland; Daniel Reed made a location, place uncertain, and relinquished it in nine days; Cornelison located west of Haviland, but relinquished it in less than a month; Robert Hamilton, N. Clark's stepson, claimed a tract south of the land sold by Smith to Clark. "William Dow, who had come from Michigan to California in 1852, and Henry Hatch came into the valley the last of March. Dow says that the Roop and Weatherlow cabins were then the only buildings where Susanville now stands. They stayed here a few days and claimed some land, and then went back to La Porte; but in the course of a month they returned here to stay.
In April Dow and Hatch claimed two sections on the north side of Susan river seven miles below Roop; Malcom S. Scott took half a section north of the land last claimed by Belcher and transferred by him to Cutler Arnold, but in eleven days Scott relinquished his claim ; Leroy N. Arnold located west of McMurtry & Co. and south of the Belcher- Arnold tract; Belcher took another claim a little northeast of Hasey & Co., but relinquished it the following July ; James Hood and Isaac Coulthurst took a tract on Susan river eight miles east of Roop 's ; J. T. Saum claimed Antelope valley northeast of Roop ; Daniel Reed located what was "formily knone as the Morhed claim" afterwards claimed by R. J. Lennox. This land, so Reed said, had been forfeited according to the laws of the valley, but after an arbitration he relinquished his claim; William C. Kingsbury and Richard F. Cahill claimed a tract east of Lanigar and Nixon and south of Hasey & Co. ; Albert A. Smith took a half section join- ing Lassen on the north and west of Lassen creek ; W. H. Watson located down the river east of Sylvester, and in May he gave up half of his claim to Hugh S. Porter; Thomas J. Harvey took a claim in the ' ' forks of Susan river and Willow creek, ' ' but relinquished it in July; E. P. Townsend made a location west of this; Geo. W. Williams relocated the land northwest of R. J. Scott which had been claimed by Dexter the previous November ; James R. Damrye claimed 320 acres joining R. J. Scott on the southwest; W. W. L. Lennox and Mary C, his Wife, sold the claim he bought of O 'Laughlin to Lassen for $50 ; Morehead took a half section southeast of his place northwest of where Malford now stands ; John Tusky, or Tesky, claimed 160 acres northwest of Antones, probably Anthony Barla east of Murphy (see May) ; John Baxter located all the unclaimed tillable land on the creek west of Gabriel Murphy. The western part of this, which he sold to Matchelor, was afterwards the James D. Byers place; Samuel Brown took up 120 acres north of Scott, a part of the land that had been claimed by Damrye a few days before that ; F. M. Jackson made a location in the neighborhood of Scott, but didn't record it until June; T. J. Harvey also made a claim this month that he didn't put on record until July; Henry Lish claimed a section "at the foot of the lake. ' ' Some time this spring, or perhaps the fall before, Wm. Hill Naileigh (Cap. Hill), located a section joining R. J. Scott, and a little to the northeast of him. This was afterwards the L. P. Whiting ranch, now the property of the Wemple Brothers.
F. & S. say that April 28th, 1857, the legislature of California passed an Act "To provide for the construction of a wagon road from Oroville, Butte county, to and intersecting at the most practicable point the line of the proposed National Wagon Road that has its terminus at or near Honey lake, Plumas county," and three commissioners were named to construct the road. The Act also provided for the issuing of $20,000 bonds each by the counties of Butte and Plumas, provided such measure received the indorsement of the people at the fall election. The surveys made by the government led people to believe that when a transcontinental railroad was built, it would go to Fort Reading ; and it was thought that if a good wagon road was built from Oroville to Honey Lake, it would be the means of turning the railroad in that direction, and making a shorter line to San Fran- cisco. But the measure was defeated in both counties, and the project was abandoned. If this road had been built, perhaps the Central Pacific railroad would have been put through Honey- Lake valley.
In May Pelio Trutters claimed a tract joining Coulthurst on the southwest; Johnson P. Ford took a section east of Hasey & Co., and afterwards sold it to Asa B. Judkins and Dan. R. Cate ; Albert Scott located west and southwest of Dow and Hatch; Harry Jarder, probably Gordier, located east of Hood and Coulthurst ; Daniel Reed made a claim on Susan river about four miles east of the mouth of "Willow creek, and Eli B. Prater took the section east of him; Chas. E. Alvord claimed a half section northwest of A. A. Smith ; Anthony Barla located east of Gabriel Murphy, and James W. Duesler southwest of Cornelison ; Dan. R. Cate took a section which had for its northwest corner a certain tree about two miles below the mound on Susan river; "Wm. Alford, John and Eadcene and James Beart claimed four sections northeast of Murphy and Barla; Rusel Alford located a tract east of Reed, and J. H. Ferry, W. T. Eadwards, and A. B. Norris three sections along the south side of the lake, place uncertain; "W. D. Fitts took 180 acres joining Morehead on the east ; Kingsbury and Cahill claimed a half section east, or northeast, of A. A. Smith; L. M. Robertson and Wm. N. Crawford took the little valley southeast of Lassen, the tract first claimed by Hill ; Hugh S. Porter recorded the east half of the land claimed by "VV. M. Watson, and sold by him to Porter; (This was the first notice recorded by Roop since Hasey was elected Deputy Recorder.) A. Fredonyer located east of Roop, taking in both sides of the river and a water privilege ; Edward Rice took a quarter section west of the Lennox Brothers, and the same day they sold out to him, but it was not recorded until the third of July; H. Sehlke claimed a strip of land along Lassen creek between Thompson and Lassen ; C. Arnold claimed the privilege of taking water out of Susan river for the purpose of irrigating his ranch; Charles C. Walden claimed an irregular tract between Hasey, Lennox, and Thompson; E. Smith & Co. located east of Reed, "some five miles east of Willow creek and near the point where the emigrant road comes in the valley"; J. B. Hixson took a section on th^ south side of the river about three fourths of a mile west of where the emigrant road enters the valley ; C. Arnold claimed 160 acres
George Lathrop and L. N. Breed sold to Reuben F. Mastin, for $150, the place in the upper end of Elysian valley that had been taken by Denney and Keeltey the previous year. In one way and another Breed had managed to get possession of this claim ; and Lathrop, who had bought or relocated Isadore 's ranch, sold it to Breed, or traded it to him for part of the Elysian valley claim.
Malcom Bankhead came into the valley and bought the land where Janesville now stands and that to the north of it from Thomas Mitchell. This summer he put up a building of hewn logs 20 by 30 feet, or something like that, and two stories high. This building was used by him, and others, as a hotel until 1872. Then Dennis Tanner tore it down, and put up a new building on the site of the old one. In the fall Bankhead went over to the mining town of St. Louis, and brought back his wife and four children. His Father, his brother William, two of his nephews, and Ralph Niesham also came with him.
About this time Robert J. Scott, who had built a shanty and raised a few vegetables, sold out to Lassen ; and he built a cabin near what is now the upper part of the town of Milford.
Some time this spring Peter Lassen, the Nataqua Surveyor, ran a base line from near the site of the Johnstonville gristmill to the bluffs near Susanville. It ran just north of Curlew Butte.
Mention has been made of the fact that Roop began to record land claims again this month. After this he acted as Recorder the most of the time as long as any squatter filings were made in the valley.
In June F. M. Jackson recorded his claim, which lay southeast of Goodwin and not far from Cap. Hill; Charles E. Tompkins, James Hunter, and Thomas Llewelen took the land along Baxter creek between the claims of Libler and Storff; Squire Lewis Stark and James P. Sharp bought Commanche George's claim on the east branch of Baxter creek, and relocated it ; Thos. Calloway took the northeast quarter of a section of land claimed by Dr. Fredonyer; - Johnson claimed half a section north of Haviland; Emory Scott located west of Daniel Reed; C. Arnold bought from Roop the privilege of taking water through his ranch; Dow and Hatch sold, probably to W. J. Tutt, the claim they took in April, for a cow and a calf; Edwin R. Scott took a section joining the claim of Dow and Hatch, located in April ; William Powell sold an undivided one half of a tract of 1200 acres in the eastern part of Elysian valley to H. A. and D. I. Willmans and A. D. McDonald.
This spring John H. and A. Clark Neale came into the valley with cattle; and they and Dow and Hatch bought out Richard Thompson, the Neales taking the south half of the claim.
Early in the month Cutler Arnold, with the help of his neighbors, put up a log building, perhaps 25 by 30 feet and a story and a half high, on the northeast corner of Main and Union streets. This was the first hotel in "Rooptown," and for two or three years it was the only one. It is said that Arnold also kept a stock of general merchandise for sale in it. It was used as a hotel for some time, and after that was used for various purposes. For several years before it was destroyed, it was occupied by the Chinese, and was known as the "old China house." It was burned in the fire of September 23, 1882. This fire burned all the buildings on the south side of Main street between Lassen and Union streets. The log house was the only building burned on the north side of the street. F. & S. have the following, which will bear repeating : "For two years this was the only place where meals were served to the public, for which the moderate price of seventy-five cents each was charged. The proprietor also provided a few beds in the loft, to reach which required a little climbing. This portion of the establishment was not patronized as extensively as the table, for few men traveled in those days and in such localities without their blankets, and all they required in bad weather was the floor of some saloon or store to spread them on ; while on fair nights, the ground for a couch, and the stars for a roof, were all they felt the necessity of. Thus prepared, the weary traveler composed himself to sleep, soothed by the soft voice of the coyote, and the sweet lullaby of the nightowl, while various insects indulged in explorations about his person, and creaked forth their comments to their companions. With such surroundings no one could 'court the balmy' without success." Lodgers in Susanville hotels can still have the coyote serenade.
notice to the effect that he had "jumped" the Crothers claim which joined Coulthurst on the west ; U. J. Tutt relocated the second section claimed by Dow and Hatch in April, but he relinquished it in January, 1859 ; Cap. Hill took the land northeast of Hasey & Co. that Belcher claimed in April and relinquished when Hill claimed it ; the little valley between Lassen and the west branch of Baxter creek was again claimed - this time by James Greshly; Thos. J. Calloway and Robert Farish located two sections in Long valley, probably at the lower end of it, but held them only nine days ; in a few days Calloway took a half section in the same valley and a man named Smith located near him, but perhaps no one ever lived on these Long valley claims at that time; Antelope valley was taken by Samuel V. Conner and Jarvis Taylor ; J. P. Ray recorded notice of a claim made by him in June - it was on 200 acres of land between C. Arnold and Hasey & Co. ; Tutt and Walden again located the east section claimed by Dow and Hatch in April ; Wm. Wickhan took a half section northeast of "W. H. Watson ; Thomas Johnson claimed 300 acres between Arnold and Hasey & Co., perhaps the land taken by Ray in June ; Arnold relinquished the land he took in May, and claimed the land taken by Florence Smith in April, 1856, and afterwards by Belcher ; M. S. Scott relinquished the claim he took in April, and located another one which included the land just abandoned by Arnold; Edwin R. Scott relocated the west section claimed by Dow and Hatch in April, but relinquished it in September ; William Bankhead & Co. claimed the vacant land along the Baxter creek between Storff and Baxter & Co. ; Thomas J. Harvey recorded the claim he took in April, this being between Libler and the land taken first by Commanche George. A part of his notice was as follows : "I put up my notice in April and planted my garding and would of had it recorded but had heard it often said that Mr Hasey was not a valied recorder"; Calloway took a quarter section which had the Upper Hot spring in the center of it ; Emory Scott relinquished the land he claimed in June ; W. H. Watson relocated the land east of Sylvester that he had taken the previous April ; William Eaton, F. W. Butler and W. M. Brown claimed the east half of Morton 's section and the west half of Sylvester 's, stating in their notice that the land had been purchased from Morton and Sylvester by H. G. O. Drake, A. G. Baker, H. Burlingham, and Z. N. Spalding, but they relinquished it in three days ; Thomas Johnson and Robert Ferriss relocated the east half of the section claimed by Sylvester in December, 1856, claiming that according to the laws of the valley, it had been forfeited for several months previous to this ; Milton Craig claimed 40 acres in the corner between Haviland and Cornelison; Burlingham, Drake, Spalding, and Baker recorded notice of claim on the section they had bought of Morton and Sylvester ; Craig claimed 40 acres close to the bluffs, and about a mile south of Roop; Dow & Hatch and the Neale Brothers recorded a claim of 900 acres of land, the most of it being what they bought from Richard Thompson; Daniel Reed filed in Quincy on 160 acres of land in this valley, location uncertain ; Thomas Watson bought from Hasey, McMurtry and Elliott the southeast section of land claimed by them, and lived on it the rest of his life. On the eleventh of this month Roop, McNaull & Co. raised the frame of the first sawmill in the valley. It was built just below where the Susan river canyon first becomes narrow and deep, going up the stream. It was a water power mill, and at first had an up-and-down saw,
In August Sylvester located a half section east of Dow & Hatch and the Neales; the little valley between Lassen and the west branch of Baxter creek was claimed by Amos Conkey and James "Williams, his brother-in-law, this being the fourth time it had been taken up since Cap. Hill located it in May, 1856. Shortly after this Sylvanus and Betsey Conkey, the Father and Mother of Amos, came from Sierra county onto the place wTith their family. Williams lived there more than twenty years, Amos almost thirty years, and his Mother still longer. L. M. Ellis claimed a mill privilege "at the foot of the mountain on the stream running through Scott's and Hill's ranches"; Gabriel Murphy filed at Quincy on 160 acres of land in this valley, location uncertain. Dr. Zetus N. Spalding and Wife came into the valley about the first of the month. They lived here the rest of their lives, and the most of the time he was one of the prominent men of the county. William C. Kingsbury brought in his Wife and two boys, Frank and Fred. They came on horseback, each one carrying a child. He soon went into partnership with Lassen.
In September Emory Scott relocated the section originally taken by Dow and Hatch, and which had been relinquished by Edwin R. Scott in July; Reuben F. Mastin recorded a claim of 300 acres in the west end of Elysian valley, and also a water priv- ilege. This was the land he bought of Breed and Lathrop in May; Thomas Bear relocated that part of Fredonyer's claim which lay between the bluffs and the river. He put up a cabin on the south side of the road and a little east of Pah Ute creek. Mary Jane Duvall crossed the plains, and reached this valley August 13th. September 23d she was married to Isaac Coulthurst. This was the first couple married in the valley. They have lived here ever since. September 28th Emma Lanigar, daughter of Francis Lanigar, was born on Gold Run southwest of Richmond. This was the first white child born in the valley. She married a man named Andy Frazieur and now lives in Oregon.
In October W. H. Watson relinquished 40 acres of his claim, and took 40 acres northeast of Morton ; Dr. John A. Slater relinquished 40 acres of his claim about three fourths of a mile northwest of Bankhead's house, and took another 40 acres in place of it; Dow, Hatch & Co. claimed all the waters of a stream four miles below Lassen's; R. L. Bryant relocated the section southwest of Dow and Hatch's old claim that Albert Scott had taken in May ; Robert Steen claimed half of the Antelope valley ranch because it had been forfeited, he said; Edward Rice and John Neiswender relocated the northeast section of the four square miles once claimed by Hasey, McMurtry, and Elliott.
In November Anton Storff located north of Conkey's ranch; McNaull claimed a strip of land a mile wide and two miles long, having the river for its center, and extending up the river from Roop, McNaull & Co's. "Mill Damn." He also claimed the waters of the river and its tributaries ; James Shores, or Shares, took a half section east of Wickhan, who was east of W. H. Watson; William Powell sold D. I. Wilmans the other undivided one half of the tract he sold to the Wilmans Bros, and McDonald in June ; R. F. Mastin sold Richard D. and Stephen Bass his claim in the upper end of Elysian valley. R. D. Bass lived here the rest of his life.
In December F. M. Rinard bought a half section north of Roop and Fredonyer from Weikel, and recorded his claim; Dr. Slater located 620 acres west of Bankhead and Asa Adams, and extending from the timber north across the valley to the Bald hills north of Baxter creek. Dr. Slater crossed the plains this year, and came into the valley with his Wife and a child or two. He was a prominent man until his death. Robert Rushing claimed 80 acres joining Slater on the southwest, and 80 acres along the creek above Slater ; A. B. Riffle took a claim east of James Shores ; Neale Bros, claimed 800 acres on the south side of the river east of the location made by them and Dow and Hatch in July; Parchiel (Zack) Taylor took a claim lying on both sides of the river between Willow creek and the ranch of W. H. Watson. It is probable that some time during this year William F. Raker and William Goose settled about three miles northwest of where Milford now stands. It is claimed that they did, and Ross Lewers says that in 1858 the place looked as though they had been there some time. This year "Whitehead" Ross bought E. Smith's claim in Long valley. A man named Kearns and his partner, friends of Ross, also came in there, took some land, and built a cabin about a mile and three quarters east of him. Ross was a somewhat noted character. He came from Tennessee, and during the Civil War he went back there and enlisted in the Southern army and was wounded. After the war he came to Austin, Nevada, and died there. Orlando Streshly, for many years a prominent man in this county, came into the valley and bought out A. G. Hasey at Richmond. His land lay west of that bought by Thomas Watson. The latter part of June Cutler Arnold went over into the mountains, and brought his family, which consisted of his Wife, two sons, Henry and Rolla, and four smaller children, to Honey Lake valley. They all came on horseback, and the trail was so bad that A. T. Arnold had to come along to help them over it. James P. Sharp bought a part of the Commanche George ranch, and became a partner of Squire Stark. With Stark's boy, John, he came to the valley to live on the place, and Richard and Stephen Bass spent the winter with them. December 23d, 1857, there was recorded in Plumas county a deed from Lewis Stark and Wife to Elizabeth A. Sharp, and the following is the description of the land given in it: "A certain Ranch, piece or parcel of land, situated in Honey Lake valley, county of Plumas and state of California, known as the Comanche George Ranch, and bounded as follows, to wit : On the South by the Ranch of D. I. Wilmans & Co., on the Northwest by a Ranch owned by Dutch Joe, on the east by the Ranch owned by Dr. Slater. On the Northeast by a line commencing at a stake near a creek known as the Irishmans creek and running in a Southeast direction one mile to a lone pine tree on the South bank of Irishmans creek supposed to contain 640 acres of land." Isn 't that a plain description ? This fall Fullbright & Crawford, who had just crossed the plains, came into the valley with 600 head of long-horned Texas cattle, and located a tract of land about a mile and a quarter southeast of the present site of Milford. Charles and Abijah Adams brought in another large band of cattle from the States, and claimed a large tract of land about seventeen miles down the river from Roop 's, in what is now called "The Tules. " This place is now known as the "Byers Ranch." John Baxter located a piece of land about three quarters of a mile southeast of Bankhead 's house, and built a cabin near a spring at the foot of the hill. Harry Gordier took a claim on Baxter creek south of the east end of the Bald mountain - the ranch afterwards owned by Thomas Mulroney. Joseph Todd took up the place east of Sylvester. The winter of 1857-8 Ladue Vary planted some peach stones, or set out some small trees, in the northeastern part of Rooptown. This was the first time anything of this kind had been done in the valley.
Peter Lassen had a blacksmith forge in front of his cabin, but he worked only for himself. Roop put up a blacksmith shop at the sawmill, and did custom work. J. H. Ferry was his blacksmith. In December, 1857, Hines and Tutt went out to Rabbit Hole springs, thirty miles west of the Humboldt river, with two ox teams, four yoke of cattle to the team. They each got a full load of iron from the wagons that the emigrants had burned there because their stock had given out. They hauled it to the valley and sold it to Roop - $1500 worth, and paid $30 a thousand for the lumber they took for it.
This summer Dow and Hatch put up the first board house ever built in the valley. It was built of lumber which they whipsawed, and was sixteen by twenty-four feet, and ten feet high at the corners. That fall they put on twelve feet more in length. It stood just east of the Curlew Butte. That winter Dow and Hatch, Dr. Spalding and Wife, her brother, Thomas Brown, her sister, Fanny Brown, afterwards Mrs. A. C. Neale, and "Whiskey" Smith lived in it. This building was used for a dwelling house until 1898, and burned down in the fall of 1911. In June Dow and Hatch brought the first stove into the valley. They brought it from La Porte on the back of a mule.
This fall Jonathan Scott brought in a pack train load of general merchandise and put it into the Roop cabin. This was the first regular store in the valley.
This year James Jones crossed the plains with his family and settled in Honey Lake valley. He had three children, one of whom afterwards married Stephen White. These children are all dead. For some time after his arrival Mr. Jones lived at the Manley Thompson place, and another daughter was born here on November 10th, 1857. She was named Sarah Margaret, and was the second child born in the county. In 1875 she married George H. St. Clair, who died in 1902. Mrs. St. Clair now lives in Alameda, California. In 1860 a son, James H., was born in the valley, and he is still living.
Names of people not previously mentioned who settled in the valley in 1857. N. B. An asterisk before a person's name indicates that he may have settled here the previous year.
Of those who settled here in 1857 Cornelison, Hatch, Sharp, R. Thompson, Zack Taylor, R. D. Bass, Craig, Raker, Jones, Sylvenus and James Conkey, and Mrs. W. C. Kingsbury lived here the rest of their lives and died here.
Leroy Arnold, W. C. Kingsbury, Streshly, A. A. Smith, Baxter, Lowry, Amos Conkey and his Mother, and Dow lived nearly all the rest of their lives in the county.
The Wilmans Bros., Neale Bros., Cutler Arnold, Edward Rice, Squire Stark, S. Bass, Robert Hamilton, J. P. Ford, the Jones Family, and Thomas Brown lived in the county from ten to twenty years. Gray lived here six or seven years.
Dow lived in the county over fifty years, and was a well known and prominent man. He is now a resident of Pacific Grove, California. Cornelison had a store at first, then a blacksmith shop, and for more than thirty years he ran a sawmill. Kingsbury was county Assessor. Streshly was Assessor and Sheriff. Smith was Surveyor, District Attorney, and County Judge.
To Roop You may perchance when time and age Have furrowed deep your wrinkled brow Turned back and thought upon this page Of some harsh thoughts or big bow bow It may be too these dim lines (Unworthy for a thought they be) Will quicken still as life declines Some friendly pulse to tell of me Then let this simple record pass For Oh I would not be forgot By good old ' ' chums ' ' who glass to glass Hath with me pledged this lovely spot
May 28, 1867. (Name looked like "Sebrach" May 29. 57 Honey Lake is now the center of attraction Men are pouring in daily and the prospects are nattering that in a few years it will be some
May 30 Hill and Hasey came to the Roop House Hill got slitly nebriated and Hasey is him self again Ho. Is. he say Roop House June 5 1857 June 3d Orevill Deligation In with the first Coach ever in the Valley W. A. Gamble Alex Brown S McDermutt H B Hunt Thos Calloway Charles J Brown Report the Road from Orevill to Honey Lake Valley Excellent
7 Orovill Coach leaves at 10 o clock P. M. all O. K. A. Salute fired. Legets Train for the states 20 Men 240 Horses Roop House June 5 1857 Camped opposite the house 18 men Two Women Three Children bound for the States with 38 Horses one Wagon Two of
June 10th 1857 Messrs Gilpen & Wethc-rlow returned after a long and tedious Jouny of Five day by leaving their goods & Wares on the road to be devoured by the Gigantic Coyota after their arrival they make arrangements to start over the Mountains, Mr Wm Eaton to go & help fetch goods & Wares in June the 12th 1857
Taylor went hunting returned and reported to have shot an antelope but could not get it. Roop started with a fishing pole to assist in getting the crippled game it is believed that the fish and antelope will suffer
Taylor Hill and H. B. Ray went to Smok Creek after Iron and when there they got they found they wer to lat the Iron was all gon But they made a rais some where of a tire and Chains For the States 16th
Roops, House Three men from Humbug Valy they intend to come back Shortly to settle there names dont know there names I think the men are Humbug if they come back a Gain to Honey Lake vally
There was one more entry that had nothing pasted over it. It was dated July 20th, but it was so indistinct that it could not be read. The remainder of the book was a record of the trains that passed the Roop House in 1857. The record of the second train was "Second Train Crawford & fullBrite 600 head of cattle & 4 Wagons 15 Men 4 Women 4 Children"
According to the Roop House Register there came through the valley from August 2, 1857 to October 4, 1857 ninety-nine trains, or parties, with 306 wagons and carriages, 665 horses and mules, and 16937 head of cattle. There were 835 men, 254 women, and 390 children. Two or three large bands of cattle and a few of the emigrants stopped in the valley. The rest of them went on over the mountains. They were looking for gold.
In 1856 an armed mob of Mormons had driven the United States District Judge from the bench in eastern Utah, and he left the territory. The relations between the Mormons and the United States government became hostile. Where the Mormons had the power (which was not the case in Carson county) murders were frequent, and a reign of terror was begun. What was virtually a rebellion caused President Buchanan to send General A. Sidney Johnston with a small army to Salt Lake in 1857 to re-establish the authority of the government. Brigham Young ordered all the Mormons living outside of eastern Utah to return at once, and help defend the "City of Saints" against what he called an armed mob.
On the 14th day of January, 1857, the legislature of Utah enacted the following law: "Said county (Carson) is allowed to retain its present organization so far as county recorder, surveyor, precincts and precinct officers are concerned, and may continue to elect these officers in accordance with existing arrangements and laws until further directed by Great Salt Lake County court, or legislative enactment. Section 5 - The record books, papers and blanks, and seals, both of probate and county courts, shall be delivered over to the order of the probate court of Great Salt Lake county. ' '
April 13th the county court, with Chester Loveland for judge, adjourned until the first Monday in the following June ; but it was September 3, 1860 before there was another session of this branch of the Judiciary.
On the 16th of July the California Mormon train, consisting of seventeen wTagons and sixty-five people, left Eagle valley for Salt Lake City. On September 26th 123 wragons and 450 people left Carson valley for the same place. A few of them were from California and Oregon. This left Truckee and Carson valleys almost without inhabitants for a while. The land and buildings left by the Mormons were sold for a trifle. People from California bought up this real estate, and the valleys soon filled up with Gentiles and apostate Mormons.
On August 3d, 1857, at a meeting in Genoa of the citizens of Carson and adjoining valleys, a call was issued for a grand mass meeting of the people living along the eastern base of the Sierras. It was to be held at Genoa August 8, 1857. The object of this meeting wras to petition congress to organize a new territory out of portions of Utah, California, and New Mexico, and to provide ways and means to lay this subject before the President and congress of the United States. Judge Loveland, the Morman elder, and Judge Crane wrere invited to be present and address the meeting.
On the appointed day the meeting was called to order by Major Wm. M. Ormsby, and Col. John Reese was elected president. By this time the Never Swyeats had joined hands with the rest of the people living east of the Sierras, and their representatives were here. Isaac Poop was one of the four vice-presidents of the meeting.
After organization a committee wras appointed to present business before the meeting. They retired to do their work, and in their absence Judge James M. Crane addressed the meeting. Judge Loveland was not there.
The Resolutions were to the effect that the people inhabiting the territory commonly known as the Great American Basin, lying east of the Sierra Nevadas, west of the Goose creek range, south of the Oregon line, and north of the Colorado river and its tributaries were convinced that the increasing population of this region were in danger from hostile tribes of Indians, and from the absence of any law for the protection of life and property, and that some kind of a government should be established in the shortest time possible.
That a memorial should be drawn up setting forth the reasons for this movement, and the same submitted to the consideration of the President and both houses of congress, and that the meeting select a delegate to represent to the President and congress the views and wants of the people of this section.
That James M. Crane, on account of his long residence in and knowledge of this country, as well as his "candor, fidelity, and ability," be appointed to represent the people of this section in Washington.
It was also resolved to appoint twenty-eight men to carry out the work laid out at this meeting, and five of those appointed were from Honey Lake valley. They were Major Isaac Roop, Peter Lassen, Mr. Arnold, Wm. Hill, and Mr. McMurtry. (Probably it was Cutler Arnold, Wm. Hill Naileigh, and L. C. McMurtry.)
In conclusion the members of congress from California and the territorial delegates from Oregon, Washington, Utah and New Mexico were asked to use their personal and official influence to obtain the passage of a bill organizing the territory asked for; and the newspapers of the Pacific coast, and several in the eastern and the southern parts of the United States were "invited and requested to publish these proceedings and memorial, and otherwise extend to us the benefit of their powerful influence and support."
The Memorial was a very long document, and contained a good many misrepresentations ; but it showed the condition of affairs in western Utah at that time, and also showed the ideas of the people living there in regard to their country. The following synopsis gives a good idea of. what it contained.
It began as follows : ' ' The citizens inhabiting the valleys within the Great Basin of the American continent, to be hereafter described, beg leave respectfully to present for the earnest consid- eration of the President of the United States, and the members of both houses of congress this their petition ; praying for the organization of a new territory of the United States. "We do not propose to come with any flourish of trumpets or mere words in this memorial, but we propose simply to submit a few plain statements as the inducements and reasons which actuate us in making this appeal to those who have the power to remedy the existing difficulties and embarrassments under which we now labor and suffer."
It then stated that the majority of the people of this section had been there six or seven years, and during that time had been without protection of any kind from Indians and outlaws ; and there was no reason to suppose it would be any better until some government was organized that could make laws and enforce them. They were law abiding citizens and did not wish to see ''anarchy, violence, bloodshed and crime of every hue and grade waving their horrid scepter over this portion of our common country. ' '
"In the winter time the snows that fall upon the summit and spurs of the Sierra Nevadas frequently interrupt all intercourse and communications between the Great Basin and the state of California and the territories of Oregon and Washington for nearly four months every year. During the same time all intercourse and communication between us and the civil authorities of Utah are likewise closed. "Within this space of time, and indeed from our anomalous condition during all seasons of the year, no debts can be collected by law; no offenders can be arrested, and no crime can be punished except by the code of Judge Lynch, and no obedience to government can be enforced, and for this reason there is and can be no protection to either life or property except that which may be derived from the peaceably disposed, the good sense and patriotism of the people, or from the fearful, unsatisfactory and terrible defence and protection which the revolver, the Bowie knife, and other deadly weapons may afford us. ' '
Even during the favorable season of the year, on account of their location, they could get no benefit from the governments of the neighboring states and territories. The most of them belonged to the government of Utah, but no intercourse could be held with the authorities of that territory, because it was nearly 800 miles to Salt Lake City ; and to get there it was necessary to cross two deserts. Besides that in Western Utah no one paid any attention to the territorial laws. The Mormons, in their social affairs, conformed to the habits of life among the Gentiles; but their dealings with each other were regulated by the rules of the Mormon church.
These were only a part of their grievances. Nearly one half of the county in which the most of the petitioners resided had only two justices of the peace and one constable. No one respected their authority, and very few knew or cared where they lived. The territorial legislature of Utah once made a county called ' ' Carson ' ' out of nearly the whole of this region, but for some reason unknown to the petitioners they abolished the county and established in place of it an election precinct in which nobody voted, or cared to vote.
There were 7000 or 8000 people living within the limits of the proposed new territory and their numbers were rapidly increasing. There were no less than two hundred valleys, running into one another, of the most fertile grazing and agricultural land. In the mountains were found "gold, silver, copper, lead, iron, coal and other minerals, metals and precious stones," and they believed that proper exploration would show that they had one of the richest and most productive regions on the globe. For these reasons they expected to have a rush of population such as settled up California and Texas so rapidly, and unless congress at its next session organized the territory asked for, when the rush did come, there would be no laws to govern the settlers and the land would be full of "unrestrained violence and bloodshed."
' ' There are some portions of the Great Basin of this continent claimed by the state of California in which reside a considerable number of people who, in the winter time, can have no connection with it. This is the case with those who reside in Honey Lake valley. That valley lies east of the Sierra Nevadas, and within the Great Basin, and from this cause the people living in it have no intercourse with other parts of the state during the rainy season for nearly four months every year. They, therefore, naturally belong to the eastern side of the Sierra Nevadas, and on this account they desire to join us in this movement. If they are forced to remain with California they can not know anything about the affairs of their state during the whole time its legislature may be in session. It is, therefore, folly, and worse than folly, to attach the people of this valley to a state about which they know nothing, and care nothing, for one third of the year, and that third the most important part of it to them. They therefore cordially unite with us in this prayer and memorial to congress, asking not only that they may be attached to the proposed new territory, but that they may add their united voices in support of the great necessities for the organization of the aforesaid territory." Those living in southern California east of the Sierra Nevadas and those of New Mexico (New Mexico then included Arizona) living near the Colorado river and its tributaries were also shut off from their respective capitals during the winter months.
It was then submitted that in addition to the facts here presented, all the routes across the continent between the Atlantic and Pacific states would be well guarded when this new territory was organized. The Indian population of the proposed new territory was not far from 75000 or 100000, and the most of them could be very easily controlled, if there was anything like an organized government in their country. For these and many other powerful reasons that would readily suggest themselves, they prayed for the organization of a new territory.
The petitioners suggested that the boundaries of the new territory, which, by the way, was to be called "Sierra Nevada/' be as follows : Beginning at the northeastern corner of California, the line was to run east about two thirds of the way across the present state of Nevada, and then southeast to a point about forty miles north of where Phoenix, Arizona, now stands. From there it was to run south to Old Mexico, and west along the northern boundary of that country to the southeastern corner of California. Then it was to follow the eastern boundary of that state to the place of beginning.
This boundary would take in a range of valleys connected together, and in the winter time the people who inhabited them were almost entirely shut off from communication with California, New Mexico, Utah, Oregon, and Washington ; but in all seasons they could enjoy free intercourse with one another. All the proposed wagon, military, stage, and railroad routes crossing the continent between the Atlantic and Pacific states and territories enter and pass through these valleys ; and the most troublesome Indian tribes roam through or live in them. For these and
The meeting adjourned "with the full determination of all to work in good earnest to accomplish the success of the undertaking. Great harmony and enthusiasm prevailed on the occasion."
No ' ' nourish of trumpets ' ' about that. They certainly claimed everything in sight and "then some." The semi-arid country between the Sierra Nevada and the Rocky mountains can hardly be called "the most fertile grazing and agricultural land;" and although the minerals and metals they told about were there, probably they knew nothing about any of them excepting the gold. They were not one fourth as many whites and Indians as they claimed living in the proposed new territory, and eight hundred miles to Salt Lake City was rather stretching the road.
T. & W. (Thompson and West's History of Nevada) have the following: "Western Utah at the close of 1857 had perhaps two hundred or three hundred people. There was not much to attract settlers. The placer mines were poor, and as the emigration grew less trading with the emigrants was not very profitable. The principal occupation was stock raising from the Truckee to the head of Carson river. There was only one Mormon in the country, and there was no organized government of any kind. The only law was that dealt out to ' Lucky Bill. ' ' '
When the Honey Lakers found they had taken in a lot of settlers to the south of them who paid no attention to their government, they dropped Nataqua and, as previously told, joined the people of western Utah in their endeavor to have the United States organize a new territory. Besides this they had some politics to attend to at home.
The Yeae 1857
enough in the valley to make the property worth noticing, and August 4, 1857, the board of supervisors of Plumas county organized it into a separate township, calling it Honey Lake township. This, and other official acts, and the taxing of the people of the valley brought on trouble that lasted for the next six years. Everybody thought the valley was close to the line, but no one took the trouble to do a little surveying and be sure about it. A part of the Honey Lake settlers said they were in California, and the Plumas county officials said so, too. That was all. The people of the valley, however, were not all of the same mind during the years of trouble with Plumas. Some of them believed they were in California, and were willing to acknowledge its jurisdiction. Others paid their taxes rather than have any trouble. Another class owned property both here and in Plumas. They had to pay their taxes, for if they didn't, their property there would be taken to pay them. But forty or fifty men, most of them men who came into the valley first, endured hardships, fought Indians, and in other ways bore the brunt of the battle, would have nothing to do with Plumas county. They said it did nothing for this valley, made no roads, built no schoolhouses - just came in and collected taxes. They didn't want to be in California, and didn 't believe they were ; and as long as the matter was in doubt they were going to pay no taxes, and were willing to fight it out - and they did. It seems as though a majority of the settlers here wanted to be in the new territory to be organized east of the mountains, but they were not willing to fight about it. The most of the settlers here filed their land claims with Koop, but some of them went to Quincy and filed their claims, deeds, etc., there, too.
F. & S. say: "The action of the board of supervisors, in the creation of Honey Lake township and the appointment of justices and constables (none of whom qualified), called out the following proceedings from the citizens of this valley: (Quoted by them from Poop's record.)
"In pursuance of a notice, the citizens of Honey Lake valley met at M. Thompson's ranch on the twenty-ninth of August, A. D. 1857, and were called to order by appointing M. Thompson chairman, and L. N. Breed secretary.
"Whereas, we, the citizens of Honey Lake Valley, entertaining very reasonable doubts of our being within the limits of the state of California, and believing that until the eastern boundary of the state of California is determined by the proper authorities that no county or counties have a right to extend their jurisdiction over us, therefore be it Resolved by the citizens of Honey Lake Valley in Mass Meeting assembled that we consider the action of the Board of Supervisors of Plumas county an unwarrantable assumption of power.
"Thirdly, in ordering an assessment of the property of the Valley. Therefore be it further resolved that we will resist any action of the authorities of Plumas, and individually and collectively pledge ourselves by all we hold sacred to assist and aid each other in resisting any infringement of our rights.
"Resolved, That the officers appointed by the board of Supervisors to conduct the election in this place be requested to keep the Polls closed upon the day of election.
"Resolved, That a committee of five be appointed as a committee of safety, whose business it shall be to correspond with the authorities of Plumas county, to end meetings when necessary, and to take such action as they may think necessary, subject always to the approval of the citizens of this Valley.
' ' Resolved, That we cordially unite with the citizens of Carson Valley in their endeavors to have a new Territory struck off, whose limits shall be the Oregon line on the North, the Goose Creek range of Mountains on the East, the Colorado River on the South, and the dividing ridge of the Sierra Nevadas on the west.
"We, the undersigned individuals of Honey Lake Valley, feeling a just indignation at the course pursued by certain individuals, calling themselves citizens of this Valley, relative to a certain petition signed by them, and forwarded to Plumas county, praying them to consider this Valley under the juris-
"Now, be it known - First, that the petition above mentioned was drawn up and signed by persons most of whom were, and are now, non-residents of this Valley, and had no interest identified with the welfare of this community. That very few of the resident citizens of the Valley knew anything about the petition until it was announced that Plumas county had appointed officers for us, nolens vol ens.
"Secondly, We are, and do consider this Valley, not in the state of California, and shall continue to do so until our boundaries are defined and established by the legally constituted authorities of the United States, and we will not recognize the authority of Plumas county or California to make ourselves or appoint our officers.
"Thirdly, Were we under the jurisdiction of Plumas county, we would not suffer the office-making power to force upon us men odious to the citizens generally, and destitute of the requisite qualifications to fill any office.
' ' Fourthly, We disclaim the whole proceedings from beginning to end and shall not regard any mandate issuing from under the officers appointed by Plumas county to preside over us.
"On motion, the following persons were appointed on the committee to correspond with the authorities of Plumas county : "Wm. Hill, Mr. Williams, M. L. Robertson, Z. N. Spalding.
"Moved, that the committee authorized to correspond with the Plumas county authorities be vested with the power to draw up a petition to Congress for the purpose of having a new territory organized. Carried.
"Mr. Jackson moved that the corresponding committee be invested with power to draft such laws out of the code of laws now governing the two districts, as may suit the people of said districts in common, but so to form them as not to permit an encroachment upon claims taken under former laws, and said laws submitted to the people for adoption or rejection on such day as the committee may designate. Carried.
"Moved, that a committee of three be appointed to wait on Dr. Fredonyer (one of the justices appointed by the supervisors of Plumas county), and politely inform him that the citizens of this valley can dispense with his services. Carried. Committee, Mark Haviland, R. J. Scott, Z. N. Spalding.
Evidently these people and some of the other citizens of the valley took the foregoing proceedings in earnest, as the following, taken from the "Marysville Express" of about a month later, will show; though, in all probability, the story grew on the road to Marysville. ' The citizens of Honey Lake valley are, for the most part, as violently opposed as ever to the exercise of any jurisdiction over them by the authorities of Plumas county. There is, however, some little inconsistency in their conduct, for when the tax collector of Plumas county came among them, they told him they were not in California but in Utah, and when Orson Hyde from Salt Lake visited them, they said they lived in California. A portion of the people tried to hold an election there on the day of the last general election, but the rest got double-barreled shotguns, revolvers, and butcher knives and stampeded the whole ballot box establishment, 'horse, foot, and dragoons.' "
The following account was taken from the "Shasta Courier" of October 17, 1857: "A mass meeting of the people of Honey Lake valley was held in the town of Mataga (probably they got that name from Nataqua, and got it badly mixed) on Saturday, 3d of October, 1857. The meeting was called to order by Isaac Roop. Peter Lassen was chosen president, C. Arnold, Geo. Purcell, and John A. Slater vice-presidents, and L. C. McMurtry and E. Wick, Secretarys.
"The object of the meeting having been stated, Messrs. I. Roop, W. Cornelison, J. Taylor, Wm. Weatherlow, and Mark Haviland were appointed a committee to report business. In the absence of the committee J. M. Crane addressed the meeting for an hour, and reviewed the policy of the government from 1798 to the present time."
The committee submitted a preamble and some resolutions which were adopted by the meeting. The preamble stated that it was well known that the people inhabiting the Great Basin between the Goose creek mountains and the Sierra Nevada, the Utah line on the north, and the Colorado river on the south had no protection from the Indians, or any protection for life and property. That the people of Carson valley, at a meeting held in Genoa, had petitioned Congress to establish a territory within the limits of those boundaries.
"Resolved, That we endorse what the people have done at Genoa, and we pledge the faith of the people of Honey Lake valley to co-operate with them in this undertaking. That we endorse and approve of the election of James M. Crane as the delegate to Washington for the proposed new territory. That if any attempt is made by the authorities of California to bring the people of Honey Lake valley into subjugation before the line can and shall be made, that we resist all such attempts with all the power we can command. That the California authorities do not try to protect us and defend our lives and property, but try to extend their jurisdiction over us for the purpose of extort- ing revenue from our people. That Isaac Roop be and is hereby appointed to co-operate with "Wm. M. Ormsby of Carson valley and Martin Smith of Lake valley, and bring before the legislature of California a proposition to transfer all of her real or supposed claims to lands lying east of the Sierras to the new territory. That the thanks of the people of this territory are due and are hereby tendered to Judge Crane for the many personal sacrifices he has made for us, and for his untiring efforts to secure for us a territorial government."
It has been told that in 1856 a treaty was made between the whites of Honey Lake valley and the Pahute Indians, and that for several years it was strictly observed on both sides. Mrs. A. T. Arnold has a long statement made by Capt. Weatherlow in regard to the Indians and the Indian wars of early days, and in it he says : ' ' The Pahute tribe of Indians occupied the valley at that time in common with the whites. They were on the most friendly relations, visiting the houses of the whites and trading furs and game for such articles of clothing, etc., as they desired. They were unlike any other tribe I had met in the country inasmuch as they were never known to beg for food or clothing, nor did they at every opportunity pilfer and carry off articles from the whites.
' ' From the first settlement of the valley the Pit river Indians which inhabited the country north of Honey lake made frequent incursions upon the settlement, driving off stock and committing other outrages. Finding that we could have no safety or security for life or property without the Pit river tribe was driven off, I raised a company of sixty men in the year 1857, and went out against the Pit river Indians on several occasions when they had made descents upon the valley and driven off stock. Winnemucca volunteered to go out with his warriors and aid us in fighting the Pit river tribe. The offer was accepted, and he and his warriors placed themselves under my command and rendered most efficient service. He obeyed orders strictly, and fought as well as any white man. He was also of great service in giving me information in regard to the Pit river tribe, their places of resort, etc."
head of cattle from John Weikel, who lived a little to the northeast of Rooptown. Five men immediately started in pursuit, overtook them, and found that the cattle had been killed; but some twenty Indians appeared and showed fight, and the pursuers were compelled to return. Capt. Weatherlow with thirtytwo men, accompanied by Winnemucca and some of his warriors, started after the Indians again. They found them, and destroyed two rancherias and captured two squaws. Sixty or seventy Indians were put to flight and scattered in every direction. They were closely followed as far as the head of Pit river; but they succeeded in eluding their pursuers, and none of them were killed. The provisions of the pursuing party gave out, and they had to return to the valley. "When they reached home they found that the Honey Lakers had got into trouble with the Washos, who may have been aided by some of the other tribes.
The following account was compiled from what was told Mr. Dodge by Wm. H. Clark and A. G. (Joe) Eppstein, from the "Alta Calif ornian, " "The Sacramento Union," "The Marysville Inquirer," and other newspapers published at the time, and from what has been told the writer by Mr. Clark and others.
William Morehead, who owned a ranch about two and onehalf miles northwest of where Milford is now, had a patch of potatoes at the foot of the mountain about half a mile back of his house. The Washoes had been stealing vegetables and small articles from the whites; and one day early in October when Morehead had gone up to Roop 's place, they dug his potatoes and carried them away. When he returned and saw what had been done, he told his neighbors about it; and Joe Eppstein, Cap. Hill, Henry Denny, F. M. Jackson, and the two Robertson brothers went to the Indian camp about four miles down the mountain, Mbrehead, who was lame, remaining behind. They got into a fight with the Indians, killed three of them and wounded another one; but were chased back to Hill's cabin by the Indians. They fortified themselves there, and the Indians went back to their camp. Goodwin's fort was not far away, and about twenty settlers gathered there. Shortly after this they made a dash on the Indian camp and captured some potatoes, but killed no Indians. Eppstein, who had gone to Indian valley, returned with ten men, and some provisions which they greatly needed ; and they decided to attack the Indians on the morning of the 17th of October.
There were thirty-five or forty men, and they made T. J. (Old Tom) Harvey their captain. Among them were Cap. Hill, Eppstein, Joseph A. Knettles, Denny, the two Robertsons, Jackson, Billy Clark, Lathrop, Tom. Watson, Storff, Charley Cooper, L. N. Breed, J. P. Sharp, A. C. Neale, Ben. Foreman, Van Hickey, Frank Johnson, and probably Fullbright and Crawford. The names of the others could not be ascertained.
The Fullbright and Crawford cabin stood about half a mile below where the road runs now, and near the creek that is a little over a mile southeast of Milford; and they started from there early in the morning so as to reach the Indian camps and attack them just about daylight. These camps, two or three in number, were along the foot of the mountain several miles to the southeast. Lathrop, Eppstein, and Clark concluded to go to the farthest camp, because they thought they would find considerable plunder and not many Indians to fight. They hurried along ahead of the others, and got on the steep sidehill about three hundred yards above the camp while it was still dark. There they waited, and just at daylight they heard two or three guns fired by the men who were attacking the other camps. Then from the camp below them, where they expected to find plenty of buckskins but no bucks, seventeen of the latter came forth, all armed with rifles, and started for the upper camps. Their course was toward the three white men, who just then had a sudden longing to see their friends. They started up the hill on the run, and the Indians soon saw them and gave chase. Clark and Eppstein outran Lathrop, and he said "Hold on, boys, we must keep together," and the others waited for him to come up. A couple of the Indians had got pretty close to them, and Lathrop said "Let's fix these two." They dropped behind a granite boulder, and resting their guns on it, fired and brought the Indians down. Just then a bullet fired by one of the other Indians struck the rock in front of them, and filled their faces full of rotten granite. Clark says it stung, and he wiped his face with both hands ; and when he saw they were covered with blood, he was badly scared. They then ran on up the hill followed by the Indians. When they reached the top of it, they could see the other men pursuing a band of Indians. They had driven them from the upper camps, and were coming down along the foot of the mountain. The Indians were now getting very close to the three white men, and Clark, who was ahead, was waving his hat and yelling to the other party to hurry. The latter thought they were Indians and were going to fire on them, but just then they saw their pursuers come over the hill. The whites fired and killed two or three of them, and the rest turned off and joined the other Indians. Right there was where the battle commenced. It was in the sagebrush near the foot of a steep bluff, something like five and one half miles below Milford. The Indians were driven up the bluff for a short distance, and there they got into a pile of rocks and made a stand. When they opened fire from the rocks, every white man jumped behind the nearest tree. The timber was scattering at that place, and there was neither time nor opportunity to pick out a tree to fit the size of the man. Newt. Breed, then a slim young fellow, happened to get behind a big tree; but Harvey, who was large and fat, was so unfortunate as to get a small one. After trying in vain to shrink himself up to fit the size of his tree, Harvey asked Breed to trade with him; but neither at that time nor any other was Breed known to trade a big tree for a little one, and Harvey had to dodge around his tree the best he could. After the fight had gone on for a while, "Weatherlow, who had just returned from the Pit river expedition, joined them with a few men and some of Winnemucca's braves. As they were coming up one of the Indians was shot by mistake. The fight went on for some time. There were a good many Indians, their number was estimated at one hundred and fifty, and they made it very unpleasant for the whites. Finding that they could not dislodge the Indians, they started back along the edge of the timber. Eppstein, who had been shot in the thigh, they carried with them in a blanket. The Indians followed along in the timber above them, and kept up the fight. Both parties sheltered themselves behind the trees the best they could, firing at each other whenever they thought it would do any good.
After a four hours ' fight the whites got back to their starting place, the Indians having stopped their pursuit a while before they got there. The loss of the Indians was estimated at from seven to eleven killed and fourteen wounded. Eppstein was the only white man hurt, and his was a flesh wound and not dangerous. One thing that accounts for the small loss of the whites is the fact that during all of the fight the Indians were above them, and probably shot too high.
Winnemucca demanded blood money for the killing of his man, and it took both presents and bluffing to quiet him down. It would not do to have the Pahutes hostile at this time.
Fifteen or twenty of the settlers intrenched themselves at the Fullbright and Crawford place. The Indians remained in the neighborhood, and the whites prepared still more for defense. It was reported that they attacked the whites on the 18th. That day Morehead and McMurtry came in from Carson valley, and it took watchfulness and fast traveling to get through without being caught by the Indians. "While the fight was said to be going on, Messrs. J. Williams of Honey Lake valley and M. Milleson of Indian valley started for the lower country with the following petition to the governor of California:
' ' To his Excellency, J. Neely Johnson and the citizens of the state of California : We, the citizens of Honey Lake valley, would call your attention to the state of affairs now existing in our midst. We are now enduring all the horrors of an Indian war. The Washoe tribe of Indians whose rendezvous is at the lower end of Honey Lake valley have commenced hostilities upon us. Upon Saturday the 17th of October, inst. after an obstinate fight of four hours we were compelled to retreat owing to a disproportion of numbers. Since that time we have been engaged in recruiting our forces, removing our families, stock, etc. On the evening of the 18th inst. our forces were attacked at their fort and the battle is now raging. We have eveiy reason to believe that the Pi-Utah tribe of Indians here-to-fore friendly, have joined the Washos and intend exterminating the entire white population east of the Sierra Nevada range. The Washos around us number four or five hundred warriors. The Pi-Utahs a still greater number. We are too small in numbers to contend against such great odds. There is in the valley now three to five thousand head of cattle, besides houses, grain, hay, etc. to a large amount in value. We therefore call upon the citizens of the state of
California in the name of common humanity to aid us in repelling the foe now in our midst, and enabling us to maintain our position as a frontier settlement. We desire one hundred stand of arms from the state of California for our protection. J. Williams of Honey Lake valley, and M. Milleson of Indian valley, are hereby appointed to present our appeal to the Governor and the citizens of the state of California, and any attention shown to them will be gratefully remembered by us.
The two messengers reached Sacramento on the 23d or 24th inst. and found the Governor absent, and they could not deliver the petition. However they saw General Kibbe, the Quartermaster General, and he let them have "some 50 stand of arms." General Clark of the U. S. Army, who was also appealed to for assistance, said his forces were too far north to give the aid asked for.
"The Sacramento Union" of October 27th, in commenting on the petition of the Honey Lakers for arms to fight the Indians with, said they did not see how the governor of California could help them as he had the right only to grant aid to the citizens of the state. They told about the meeting of the citizens of Honey Lake valley August 29, 1857, and said they prevented the election as they agreed to at this meeting. They told that the justices and constables appointed for the valley by the board of supervisors of Plumas county had been told that their services were not required, and that the Plumas county assessor had to leave the valley without making an assessment. They referred to the meeting held October 19, 1857, where the Honey Lakers said they would withstand any efforts made by Plumas county to control them before a line had been run to show where they were located. The "Union" thought the governor should not help them unless they were willing to abide by the laws of the state and the jurisdiction of the officers of Plumas county.
On the 27th Mr. Williams had an interview with the Governor about the matter embraced in the petition from the citizens of Honey Lake valley and Indian valley. He admitted the course taken by the citizens of Honey Lake valley, but said they were willing to come under the jurisdiction of California, if it were found they were within its boundaries. Mr. Williams had been in San Francisco and laid the case before Col. Henly, who sent out a quantity of blankets and other Indian goods, with the view of enabling Mr. Lassen, as agent, to settle all difficulties without further bloodshed. Some months before this, application had been made for arms for the volunteer company organized in Plumas county. These arms - sixty stand - were forwarded at once by General Kibbe. It was understood that Mr. Williams was satisfied with this arrangement. The goods were to go up in charge of Mr. Milleson.
We will now see what took place in the land of the Never Sweats during the absence of their messengers. They had a genuine Indian scare on hand, and, as is usual at such a time, the stories grew as they traveled. It was reported that the last, of September thirty well armed men had left Quincy to protect emigrants along the road east of Honey Lake. They were to go to Gravelly Ford on the Humboldt and punish the Shoshones. They killed and scalped a Pah Ute east of Honey Lake, and another one at the Humboldt; and the Pah Utes were going to take revenge upon the settlers of Honey Lake valley. Besides the Washos there were fifteen or twenty thousand Pah Utes; and these two tribes had induced the Indian valley Indians to join them in making a descent upon Honey Lake valley, and had threatened Indian valley. A few families left the valley. Mrs. A. C. Neale says that she went away with Dr. Slater and his family, but they soon came back. The attack on the settlers at the Fullbright and Crawford place was a false report. The Washos withdrew from the valley, and when the Plumas Rangers arrived to help the settlers, they found no Indians to fight. Probably Mr. Lassen made some sort of a treaty with the Washos, for they never made any more trouble in this part of the country.
It was a narrow escape for the settlers east of the mountains. If the Pah Utes had commenced hostilities, too, the Indians could easily have wiped out all the settlements in western Utah.
The settlers in Carson valley also had some trouble with the Washos at this time, for Col. Wm. Rodgers was sent to San Francisco for arms and ammunition to defend the settlers against them. Along the last of October Capt. Jim, the chief of the Washos, came into Carson valley to negotiate for peace with the settlers. He stipulated that justice should be enforced against the white men who violated the rights of the Indians, and agreed to give up to the whites any man of his tribe who committed depredations upon their property. There was no person authorized by the inhabitants to enter into a treaty with the Indians; but Mr. Mott, an old gentleman who was held in great esteem by the neighbors, accepted the terms of the chief, and agreed to furnish his tribe with flour, etc., and in consequence good order prevailed.
The following story was told by Fred Hines. In early days the country between this valley and the Humboldt, and later on up to southern Idaho, was much frequented by the Never Sweats ; and what they did in that section will be told in the following pages.
It will be remembered that when Hines came in from the Humboldt in the fall of 1856, he left some cattle here on the range to winter. When he came back the next spring they were very fat; and he drove them to Quincy and traded them for goods, and hired L. F. Hough to pack them to this valley. He then fitted up some teams and hauled his goods out on the Humboldt about a hundred miles above Lassen's Meadows, and again traded with the emigrants. Morton and Sylvester went with him, but Vary stayed at Deep Hole springs and kept a trading post there. Tutt and Walden had a trading post on the Humboldt in 1856, and in 1857 they went out there again.
About the last of October Sylvester, Tutt, Hines, Chas. Lewis, Walden, J. B. Gilpin, and several men who were helping drive their cattle, were coming back to Honey Lake valley. When they reached Deep Hole Vary told them that if they would stay there a day and give him time to gather up his cattle, he would go along with them. He had nineteen head of large emigrant oxen that he had traded for ; and they were running near a spring on the west side of the Granite creek range, about five miles from Deep Hole. The next day in the afternoon, Vary went after his cattle, but he could not find them and came right back to camp. The matter was talked over, and Hines and Sylvester told him they would go back with him that afternoon and see if they could not find them before dark. Fearing they would be out all night,
Soon after reaching the spring they found the tracks of the cattle and followed them until dark. Then they stopped on a sagebrush flat and hid themselves in the tallest brush they could find, ate some crackers, wrapped their saddle blankets around them, and wore away the long, cold night the best they could. The next morning they followed the trail, which was going in a northerly direction. Some time before noon some Indian tracks came into the trail of the cattle, and this was the first Indian sign they had seen. The cunning savages had, in the first place, scared the cattle into going the direction they wanted them to take without going near them, and then followed, keeping at quite a distance on each side of them until they thought they were safe from pursuit. That day Hines shot a sagehen and a couple of rabbits, and they ate part of them. They followed the trail until dark, and then camped as they did the night before. The next day they followed the trail all day toward the north, and ate what was left of the game killed on the previous day. On the third day Hines, who was in the lead doing the trailing, thought he saw an Indian coming down a ridge from the east, his course being such that it would cross theirs at right angles. He was not sure, though, that it was an Indian so he stopped and waited for the others to come up. He pointed out to them the object he had seen, and after watching it a while they came to the conclusion that it surely was one. Hines told the others that from the way the Indian was acting either he had not seen them, or if he had, was paying no attention to them. He thought the best plan was for the other two men to ride along on the trail of the cattle, and he would ride up the mountain on the side of the ridge back of the Indian until he judged he was opposite to him, and then ride over to him. This was done, and Hines made a good guess and came in sight of the Indian when within a hundred yards of him. He had a load of beef on his back - seventy-five or a hundred pounds - and this he threw down as quickly as he could and tried to get his bow and arrows ready to shoot. But Hines was too quick for him. He put spurs to his horse, drew his pistol, and got there before the Indian was ready ; and making him throw down his weapons, held him there until Vary and Sylvester came up. It was an Indian who had been around the station at Deep Hole during the summer, and he had on a pair of old overalls that Vary had given him. They talked with him the best they could, and he made them understand that he would lead them to the cattle. Hines wanted to make him carry all the beef, but Vary thought it was too big a load and he carried only a part of it. The Indian left the trail of the cattle and they soon struck a smooth Indian trail. As they were traveling along this the Indian, who was a little ahead, broke into a run. Hines yelled to him to stop, but he only looked back over his shoulder and ran faster. Hines soon caught up with him and thought at first that he would shoot him, but because he might help Vary recover his cattle Hines spared his life. A little before sunset they came to a small creek. They had been without water since morning, and both they and their horses were very thirsty. They fixed the horses' bridles so they could drink, and then lay down by the stream to quench their own thirst, the Indian among them. The latter got through drinking before the others did, and jumping across the creek, he started up the hill on the other side. Hines called to him to stop and he did so. Vary said "Never mind him. I want to go up the hill myself," and Hines paid no more attention to them. Vary left his horse at the creek with his pistol hanging on the horn of the saddle, and walked with the Indian to the top of the little hill. When they got there the Indian pointed to a hole in the knee of his overalls and asked Vary for a needle and thread to mend it. The white man took out his pocket-book and sat down on a rock, and while he was doing this the other started off on the run. While this was going on, Hines had crossed the creek and was some little distance from his horse. His attention was called by hearing Vary say "There he goes." This startled Hines and he never thought of going back after his horse, but thought he would run up the hill and take a shot at the Indian. Vary had immediately started in pursuit, but before he had run very far the rowel of his spur caught on a rock and threw him down. Just as Hines got to the top of the hill Vary arose with a big rock in his hand and threw it at the fleeing red man. If it had struck him fair, it would have broken his back ; but it fell a little short and just missed his heel. At first Hines could not shoot because Vary was in the way, and when he did get a chance his nerves were so shaky on account of the running he had done and the Indian was so far off that he missed him. After shooting three or four times without doing any execution he stopped, and the Indian disappeared from view in the brush and ravines. He had left his load of beef at the creek. The men went back to the creek and got their horses and rode to the top of the ridge. It was now almost dark, and they at once noticed a fire in the direction the Indian had gone. Beyond this fire and a little to the left was another fire, beyond that there was one, and to the right there were two or three more. Off to their right and a little beyond them was a large flat on which grew some very tall sagebrush. It was light enough to see that it was an open country away from the hills, and they concluded to camp for the night on that flat. Hines told the other two that if they would take his horse, he would go afoot to the first fire and see what was there. He walked as far as he dared and then went on his hands and knees until he was close enough to see that no one was there. He then went back to the others, and after going quite a ways out into the flat they found a place where the sagebrush grew very tall and not very close together. They spread a blanket over some of these brush and under it they built a little fire out of some dry brush which they broke into small pieces. Then one of them went off a little distance to find out if their fire could be seen. They spent the night there, dozing a little once in a while. The next morning the question arose as to whether or not they should go any further. The Indians knew where they were, and forty or fifty of them might make an attack at any time. At last they left it to Vary because it was his cattle that the Indians had stolen, and they were nearly all the property he had. After some talk he said they would follow the cattle part of the day, anyway, before giving it up. They took the direction the Indian had gone, and soon found the trail of the cattle which was still going north. They followed the trail until two hours before sunset without seeing any cattle or Indians, and then Vary said they had gone far enough and would turn back. They turned around and rode until after dark, and again secreted themselves in the sagebrush for the night. It took three days for them to get back to Deep Hole, using for food the beef they took from the Indian.
had made up their minds that the three men had been killed by the Indians. Lewis took possession of Hines and Sylvester's property, and sent a man to Honey Lake to get men to come out there and hunt for them. The next day after their return they sent another man to stop the help from coming. During that day they discussed the utility of a plan to have the men come on and have an Indian hunt as they had plenty of provisions. The next day they sent another man out to tell them to come on, but he met the other two coming back and they all returned to camp. The man sent out by Lewis reported that the Potato War was going on, and that he could get no men to come with him. The whole party then came on to Honey Lake valley.
This story shows the desperate chances that men took with the Indians in those days. Their safe return was due to good luck more than anything else. Half a dozen Indians could have ambushed them in the brush or rocks, and filled them full of arrows at short range without much danger to themselves.
In the early part of the winter of 1857-8 while J. H. Ferry, always called Blackhawk here, was working in the blacksmith shop at Roop, McNaull & Go's, sawmill, Rough Elliott was hauling lumber from there. One day the two men had a dispute about something, and a few days afterwards Elliott went into the shop and being younger and stronger than Ferry, who was a grayhaired man, backed him over the anvil and beat him up considerably. Not long after this a dog that Ferry knew belonged to Elliott came into the shop. As soon as he saw the dog Ferry said "I know whose dog that is", and went into a little room where he slept, got his pistol, and stepped outside. Elliott was close by, and as soon as he saw Ferry come out with his pistol he jumped behind a big stump near by. They went to shooting at each other, Ferry being in the open and the other man dodging around the stump. Ferry kept going toward Elliott, shooting at him whenever he saw enough of him to shoot at, and finally emptied his pistol. He then said "I'll get him now", and started back to the shop to get his rifle, Elliott shooting at him as he walked away. Before he came out with his gun the boys came down from the mill and stopped the fight, probably saving Elliott's life.
Barber Springs In the fall of 1857 a man named Barber who lived in Carson valley and who had been mining on Gold Run started for home. One night he camped at the springs just over the divide between Honey Lake and Long valley. At that time the trail ran over the hill through a low pass to the west of where the road runs now. The next morning a gun was fired from a pile of rocks close by, and Barber was shot through the arm. The Indian caught up a gun and fired at some one he saw in the rocks, but with what effect was never known. Barber came back to the ranch of N. Clark and stayed there until he was able to resume his journey. For a long time after that the springs where he was shot were called Barber Springs.
Fight Over the Noble Road During the year 1857 the Noble Road was the favorite route with emigrants going into northern California, especially with those who knew something about the different routes. John Kirk was superintendent of the western end of the Wagon road, and the Never Sweats, not having trouble enough with the Indians and the Plumas county authorities, entered into a wordy war with him about this road. At that time Honey Lake valley was the western terminus of the road because the railroad survey made by Lieut. Beckwith passed that point, and because it was thought by Col. Noble the best for entering California. The Honey Lakers were afraid that Kirk's report would cause congress to change the terminus to Carson valley ; and they claimed that he said and did all sorts of unfair things to make it appear that the Honey Lake road was not a good one, and that he was a great friend of the Carson route. "The Butte Record" says that a great number of emigrants raise their voices in indignation about the way that John Kirk tried to force them to take the Carson route. "The Sacramento Union" quotes the foregoing and then expresses the opinion that the complaints did not come from the emigrants, but from the friends of the Honey Lake route and from the traders on that route. The trouble appears to have begun and ended in words.
Provenance
Text from Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.