Lassen County, California - Chapter 7: 1861. Settlement, 1916
From Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. 7,197 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
7,197 wordsMachine-read from scans of Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 7: 1861. Settlement
It has been told that the "Lassen County Pioneers Society" fixed the end of the pioneer days at the first of July, 1860. This may have been the end so far as people were concerned, but there was a great deal of pioneer work of various kinds done in the county for many years after that.
There were very few land claims filed this year with Governor Roop, Recorder for the valley. The most of the land which was then considered to be of any value had been taken up.
In March Alex Gilman, or Gilmore, claimed an irregular tract south of the upper end of the Adams ditch on Susan river. This year the Susan ville sawmill was run by E. V. and L. D. Spencer who bought it from I. N. Roop.
F. and S. have this to say about Lassen Lodge No. 149, F. & A. M.: "March 21, 1861, the grand master of California issued a dispensation to John S. Ward, David Titherington, Absalom M. Vaughan, Richard D. Bass, D. I. Wilmans, Stephen D. Bass, and A. D. McDonald, to organize a lodge of Masons at Richmond, Honey Lake valley. At that time, owing to a mining excitement, the town of Richmond had sprung up suddenly into the most important and populous settlement in the county, completely overshadowing and distancing Susanville. The first meeting under the dispensation was held April 18, 1861."
In April G. Stacy claimed a piece of land bounded on the east by the land of Luther Spencer, on the west by that of M. S. Scott, on the south by "Woodstock & Brannon, and running north to the bluffs. This land was one half or three fourths of a mile east of Susanville. This year L. P. Whiting started a small nursery on the Conkey ranch seven miles south of Susanville on the mountain road. This was the first nursery in the valley.
J. C. Wemple and Judson Dakin built a board cabin at Milford. (The place was named this year by Mr. Wemple.) It was a little north of the creek and a couple of hundred yards above the road. As soon as the cabin was finished they began to get out the timbers for a gristmill which was completed the last of October or the first of November. It was on the creek just opposite to their cabin and was run by a large overshot water wheel. E. V. Spencer had bought the millstones that Lassen brought up from the Deer Creek ranch and they bought them from him. They put them into the new mill and they were used there as long as it was run. This was the first regular gristmill in the valley. In 1865 Dakin sold out to James M. Steinberger who carried on the business with Mr. Wemple until the fall of 1878 and they then sold out to Hiram H. Dakin. He ran the mill until the fall of 1882 and then he moved to Janesville where he, J. D. Byers, and Hiram E. McClelland had built another gristmill. The Milford mill was not used any more and in the course of time it tumbled down.
In June V. J. Borrette and B. B. Gray located a section of land beginning at the mouth of "Willow creek, extending half a mile up the river, and having a length of two miles to the north. They also claimed the waters of Willow creek to be used to irrigate their land. This year and the next Wiley Cornelison had a store and a blacksmith shop at the Thompson ranch three miles southeast of Bankhead's. David Blanchard was his partner the first year. Timothy Darcey was the blacksmith.
This month when the grain was six or eight inches high a big lot of grasshoppers hatched out in Antelope valley northeast of Susanville. From there they went across the valley, passing through Dr. Spalding's ranch, and doing more or less damage to the crops where they went.
In July A. Ramsey located 400 acres east of Coulthurst's lower claim. He also claimed a section lying to the north of his claim and that of Coulthurst for his son, W. J. Ramsey. Besides this he gave notice that he had taken possession of the waters of Willow creek 480 rods above the ford where the emigrant road crosses it. T. J. Harvey sold his part of the Lathrop and Harvey ranch in the northern part of the valley to a man named Bradley. This year C. C. and William G. Goodrich settled in Mt. Meadows about half a mile below the "Narrows," or about two miles and a half below the upper end of the valley. A man named Duffey, or Guffey, built a cabin about a mile and a half southeast of them and another one named Manuel settled a couple of miles south of them. A family, two men, a woman, and two or three children, lived up the canyon above Duffey.
The Yeae 1861
Dr. Robert F. Moody came into Susanville this year and soon went in with Dr. Brown. He afterwards bought out Dr. Brown and sold drugs in Susanville for almost forty years. Fred Hines and L. N. Breed kept the Smoke Creek station this
In September several men went into Willow Creek valley to locate, so Tunison's diary says, but he tells no more and the writer could find no one who knew anything about them.
The tenth of this month Eber G. Bangham and Louise Borrette, daughter of Dr. H. S. Borrette, were married. This was the fourth wedding in the valley.
F. and S. have this to say: "In 1861 he (Dr. Brown) bought a piece of land from Governor Roop, embracing that on which Fort Defiance stands, and transplanted quite an extensive orchard of apple and peach trees, claimed to be the first in the valley, though Mr. L. Vary is credited with having planted a number of peach stones some time before this." In 1863 the trees set out by Dr. Brown bore four peaches - the first ever raised in the valley. Miss Susan Roop and Mrs. Fuller, the Mother of the Fuller Brothers, ate all of them - the county's entire crop of peaches. "The next school (in Susanville) was taught in 1861-62 by Miss Fannie Long, in a building on the north side of Main street, where the Black Rock saloon was kept."
It should have been told before this that Albert Smedley Wright, who crossed the plains in 1860 and lived a short time in this valley, early this spring took up a small piece of land in Long valley near where the county line is now, built a cabin on it, and put in a garden. The grasshoppers ate up his garden and that fall he bought in with C. M. (Doc.) West who had moved a couple of miles to the north of where he first settled. Osmer Marsh and Robert Ingram came into Long valley this year.
During the fall U. L. Shaffer, perhaps in company with his brother, P. J. Shaffer, bought a large quantity of wheat in Indian valley and had it ground at Taylor's mill. He built a warehouse at Richmond and packed the flour over there with his own pack train, though in this he may have been assisted by other trains. There was a great deal of this flour - some say 300,000 pounds. That winter and the next summer it was hauled to Virginia City with teams. It may be that Shaffer brought a lot of flour into the valley during the fall of 1860.
This year was the last of Richmond's palmy days. Several more buildings had been put up there - among them, Shaffer's warehouse and a few dwelling houses. The Masonic lodge met there for more than a year. It is said that a man named Cragin taught school there this summer. But this year and the next the placer mines on Hill and Lassen creeks gave out and the mining excitement in the country around Virginia City and that on the Humboldt river, which broke out in 1861, took the miners away. The travel from the lower country to the Humboldt mines went through Susanville and that place grew and Richmond went down. Some goods were sold at Richmond during the first part of 1862, but the stock was not renewed. The hotel was run for a few years after this and they had a school there, but no other business was done.
July 27th Henry E. Lomas and John Nichols reached Richmond, having just crossed the plains. Soon after this they sold a span of horses to Smith J. Hill and took his note which was to be paid the first of November. Hill wanted them both to come to Bankhead's and he wanted Lomas to open a blacksmith shop there and Nichols to open a harness shop. Instead of doing this they went on to San Francisco, but when Hill's note was due Lomas came back to the valley and hired out to him for a year. He then went to Virginia City and bought the tools and stock for a blacksmith shop. When he got back they built a shop right across the creek from Hill's house. Lomas and Malcom Bankhead went to work in it and that winter they bought Hill out. Late this year Dave Blanchard built a small store across the road from the blacksmith shop and near the creek and began the sale of merchandise. This building, afterwards used a stable, stood until it was pulled down when the new Masonic Hall was built in 1911.
Preston R. James says that he came to Janesville this fall. A man named Cragin was teaching a private school in the Fort. There were about twenty-five children in attendance, and the tuition was $5 a month for each pupil. He turned the school over to James who taught it the remainder of that year and for some time during the next year. Mr. James taught school in the valley more or less until the middle 70 's.
Henry E. Lomas says that late this fall the settlement at Bankhead's was named Janesville in honor of Mrs. Jane Bankhead, the wife of Malcom Bankhead. Mr. Lomas 's memory is very clear in regard to this matter and many other old settlers agree with him, but there is another story about it that will be told later on.
Late in the fall C. T. Emerson and Colburn Brown built a house at the point of the mountain about a mile and a half northwest of the Lathrop and Bradley ranch. This was long known as the "Tule" Emerson place.
In December M. C. Lake traded his place in the little valley on the west branch of Baxter creek to C. W. (Bill) Fuller for a little hotel on the south side of the Truckee river, a toll bridge, and the land where Reno now stands. Fuller took up this land in 1859, put up some small buildings, and built a ferry-boat for the river. He afterwards built the bridge which was a low one and had to be fastened down when high water came.
During the winter of 1861-62 Thomas N. Long kept saloon in a little building on the north side of Main street between Union and Weatherlow streets. The next spring he moved into the Cutler Arnold log hotel.
The winter of 1861-62 was the wettest one in the history of California and Honey Lake valley got its share of the water. The water at Toadtown was higher than it ever was before or since. The country along the Susan river was flooded and it is said that there was water from the point of the Bald mountain across to the foothills on the north side of the valley.
The following named persons who came into the county in 1861 virtually lived here the rest of their lives, or are still living here : William H. Hall, Robert F. Moody, Arthur K. Long, E. H. Fairchilds, John C. Partridge, Philip Wales and Family, Edward T. Slackford, John D. Arnold, William B. Long and Family, Thomas N. Long, John T. Long, George R. Wales, Archibald L. Harper, Libbie Hankins, and Mrs. Frances E. (Barnes) Cornelison.
The following lived in the county from two or three to twelve or fifteen years: Amos H. Barnes and Family, Henry E. Lomas, Abraham G. Moon, John Nichols, Daniel W. Bryant and Family, Mrs. Emma (Bryant) Vance, John Burkett and Wife, John Bradley, Jacob M. Epley and Family, "William Dicken, Dr. J. W. M. Howe, R. York Rundel and Family, George W. Wilson and Family, Sherrill Wilson, Harrison Sain, William Maskelyne, S. P. Tunnel and Family, Jesse Williams, *William Rantz, *Vesper Coburn, William Fox, *L. F. Prebble, Warren Lockman, M. P. Preddy, Richard M. Menifee, William R. Hill, George James, Amzi A. Holmes, and Mrs. John H. Neale (Sallie Hollinghead) and Family.
Although J. J. Musser failed to influence Congress to organize the new territory at once, his visit to Washington was not without results. T. and W. say: "His influence, though, left its impression, and served to give form and direction to a growing sentiment in Congress inimical to leaving other citizens of the United States under the unfriendly jurisdiction that had already, by the Mountain Meadow Massacre, been demonstrated to exist in Utah under Mormon control. The subsequent development of the Comstock mines causing a large increase of population (R. L. Fulton says there were 17000 people in the mines of Nevada in 1861) but served to increase that feeling at Washington, and the breaking out of the southern rebellion culminated it in the congressional act of March 2, 1861, creating the territory of Nevada. ' ' Its boundaries were established as follows : "Beginning at the point of intersection of the 42nd degree of north latitude with the 39th degree of longitude west from Washington (116 degrees from Greenwich) ; thence running south on the line of said 39th degree of west longitude until it intersects the northern boundary line of the territory of New Mexico (now Arizona) ; thence due west to the dividing ridge separating the waters of Carson valley from those that flow into the Pacific; thence on said dividing ridge northwardly to the 41st degree of north latitude; thence due north to the southern boundary line of the state of Oregon ; thence due east to the place of beginning." This law, however, provided that if any of the territory covered by this description belonged to California, it should still be held by that state unless it consented to give it up to Nevada. Honey Lake valley lay to the east of the "dividing ridge" and so it was taken in as a part of the new territory while it really was a part of California.
In February, 1861, the county court of Carson county "declared that Honey Lake valley was within the limits of Carson county, and appropriated $250 to assist any one in legal resistance to the collection of taxes within that valley by the officers of Plumas county, California."
On the 22nd of March, 1861, James W. Nye of Madison county, New York, was commissioned governor of Nevada territory, and on July 8th he reached Carson City. July 11th he issued a proclamation declaring the government of the territory established. July 24, 1861, another proclamation announced the districts for voting purposes. T. and W. say: "One of the errors fallen into when the territory of Nevada was organized was that Honey Lake valley, owing to the uncertainty of the location of the eastern boundary of California, was within the limits of the territory. It had always taken a prominent part in the affairs of western Utah, was the home of Hon. Isaac Roop, governor under the preliminary territorial organization of 1859-60, and when Governor Nye called an election for members of the first legislature, it was made the ninth council district, and apportioned one councilman and one representative." It was called the Pyramid district and included "all the territory north of Truckee valley, from a point where the Truckee river enters the mountains below Gates and Gage's crossing (Glendale) and west of Pyramid lake." It had a population of 1073.
The governor called an election to be held August 31, 1861. At this election the Union vote was 4300 and the Democratic vote 985. John Cradlebaugh was elected delegate to congress, receiving 1806 votes. Four others ran against him for this office. In the ninth district Isaac N. Eoop was elected to the territorial council and John C. Wright was elected territorial representative. In this district a man named Olney received a majority of the votes for delegate to congress. F. and S. say that Roop received 62 votes out of 68, Wright received 52 votes out of 58, and that Wright was a resident of Long valley, an unnaturalized Englishman, and left this section a few years later. The legislature was summoned to meet at Carson City October 1, 1861. As the western boundary line of Nevada was still in doubt, October 25th Governor Nye advised the appointment by the legislature of Nevada of a commission to confer with California and obtain, if possible, a running of the Sierra Nevada mountain line of division between the two sections. By a joint resolution of the two bodies, passed November 9, 1861, such a commission was to be named in a joint convention of both houses, but they failed to make the appointment. T. and W. say : "In the meantime, Deputy U. S. Surveyor, John P. Kidder, surveyed the lines as designated by congress, from Lake Tahoe northerly to Honey Lake, for which he was paid $550." F. and S. say: "They (the Nevada authorities) had even gone so far as to have John F. Kidder and Butler Ives survey the line both north and south from Lake Tahoe, an action which was not recognized by the California authorities. There was a dispute in regard to the situation of the town of Aurora, also, it being at one and the same time the county seat of Esmeralda county, Nevada, and Mono county, California. The Kidder survey placed Aurora in Nevada Territory."
By an act approved November 25, 1861, the territory was divided into nine counties. Honey Lake valley was in Lake county and its boundaries were as follows: "Beginning at the northwest corner of "Washoe county and running easterly along the northern boundary of said county to the mouth of Truckee river; thence due east to the summit of the first range of mountains east of said river; thence in a northerly direction along said range and the main granite range of mountains to the Oregon line; thence west along said line to the summit of the Sierra; thence south along said summit to the place of beginning." By the act of November 29, 1861, the location of the county seat was to be decided by the voters of the county at the next election. By the same act, Hon. Gordon N. Mott of the Supreme court was assigned to the First Judicial district which was composed of Lake, Washoe, and Storey counties.
At a joint session of the legislature held November 27, 1861, for the purpose of selecting commissioners to organize the various counties, and supervise the election to be held for county officers January 14, 1862, William Weatherlow, William H. Naileigh, and Daniel Murray were chosen for Lake county. These gentlemen did not provide for the election as intended, and the county was not organized until a year later.
Honey Lake Politics. 1861 It has been told that Honey Lake valley was taken into Nevada territory in a provisional way and that an election for members of the legislature of that territory was held in the valley. Plumas county also held elections here this year, and George E. Hale, Cutler Arnold, and Dr. Z. N. Spalding were elected justices of the peace. Dr. Spalding did not qualify, but the other two men qualified as officers of Plumas county. Officers of the law had their troubles in those days, too. A. L. Tunison 's diary has the following brief entry: "February 16, 1861. Helped Court take some potatoes of Jones. Women was armed with pistols, knives, shovels, and clubs which we had to take away from them. Three women." Plumas county collected taxes from those who would pay and occasionally sent officers into the valley after criminals.
Indian Troubles. 1861 There was no Indian war this year. During the first part of the year the Pahutes came into the valley as usual and both the Winnemuccas visited their old friends. Probably they tried to keep their followers from molesting the property of the settlers, for they wanted to live in peace with them. But the Indians were like white men - some of them could not stand temptation, and the cattle running on the ranges certainly were a temptation to the hungry Indians. There were a few of the Pit River Indians left and they never missed a chance to gather in a white man's property; and many of Smoke Creek's band were not averse to increasing their wealth at the expense of their white neighbors, even in time of peace. Henry E. Lomas says that in the fall of 1861 he was camped out in the Granite creek country. One day he was out a ways from camp when he saw a big Indian coming toward him. He was a little frightened, but stood his ground while the Indian slowly came up to him, and from somewhere in his clothes brought forth a piece of greasy paper nearly worn out where it was folded. This paper he handed to Lomas, who read it. It stated that this was Smoke Creek Sam, one of the meanest and most treacherous and dangerous Indians in that part of the country, and that it was better to give him a little of something than to have trouble with him. The paper was returned to the Indian who folded it carefully and returned it to his clothes. Lomas then took him to camp and gave him something to eat and perhaps gave him a little present. The noble chief went away smiling, and this goes to prove "That one may smile, and smile, and be a villain."
In the spring the Pahutes ran off quite a lot of cattle at different times, or at least it was laid at their door. V. J. Borrette says that in the early part of the year he and Luther Spencer bought Antelope valley northeast of Susanville from B. B. Painter and Ladue Vary. One day while they were building their house they came into Susanville leaving their provisions, two yoke of oxen, and a lot of traps of different kinds at the camp. While they were gone some Indians came down from the hills and took the largest and gentlest yoke of cattle, packed all the food and whatever else they could find that they wanted on their backs, and then went their way rejoicing. To do the packing they used all the ropes and straps they could find, and took the lines and straps off some harness that had been left there. They just cleaned out the camp. When they found out what the Indians had done they tried to raise a crowd to follow them, but no one seemed to take any interest in it and nothing was done.
Some of the early settlers say that this summer the citizens of the valley held a meeting and after talking matters over concluded to establish a sort of "dead line" between themselves and the Pahutes. They made the summit of the mountains east and northeast of the valley their "dead line" and notified the Indians that they would kill any of them who came nearer than that. Other early settlers say that nothing of the kind was done. There is no way of deciding Which is the truth, and probably all of them told the truth the way they knew it.
The following was related by W. M. Cain and H. E. Lomas. Not far from the middle of December Dewitt Chandler and his hired man were killing a beef at the Chandler and Fry ranch a couple of miles southeast of Janesville. There were some Pahute Indians camped on the rock pile in the field below Janesville, and one called Jim, his father, and two or three other bucks and some squaws went over and stood around while the work was going on. When it was nearly done the young man who was helping went into the house for something, and while he was gone Jim began to help himself to the liver and some of the other offal. Chandler wanted this for his hogs and he told Jim to let it alone. The Indian at once faced him and patted himself on the chest as if to defy him and at the same time made some insulting remarks. Chandler caught up a stick of hard wood and struck the Indian on the back of the head and knocked him down. He afterwards said that he had no idea of killing him, but he struck harder than he intended to. The other Indians began to string their bows, but when Chandler called to the man in the house and told him to bring out his pistol they left as fast as they could. The squaws soon dragged Jim away, and if he was not dead then he died in a short time, for his skull was broken. The Indians took his body to the rock pile where they were camped and buried it. They killed his dog and burned it on his grave along with some of his other property, and then they burned the whole camp and moved away.
This affair caused considerable excitement in the valley for many of the settlers thought the Indians would take revenge on them. There was some talk of holding an inquest - some say that Squire Stark did hold one at Janesville. They also talked of arresting Chandler and giving him a trial, hoping this would appease the wrath of the Indians. But nothing was done and the excitement gradually died away. There were several reasons for this. Chandler did not intend to kill the Indian and it was thought that he was justified in protecting his own property. Jim had always been impudent and offensive and he had a horse which he said he got by shooting a white man at the Ormsby Massacre. During the Indian troubles of the previous year many horses and saddles and other property had been taken from the whites by the Indians and when peace was made they were not given up. It was very aggravating to the settlers to see an Indian riding a horse or a saddle that he might have killed a white man to get, and besides that the most of the Never Sweats thought that the only good Indian was a dead one.
Notwithstanding these troubles there was no Indian outbreak this year although what occurred in 1861 may have had its effect upon the troubles of the following year. This summer and fall there was a large travel on the road between Honey Lake and the Humboldt mines, but no one was molested by the Indians. When Tunison came in from the Humboldt in November he camped near Breed's station on Smoke creek and Smoke Creek Sam took supper with him. There were a good many Pahutes loafing around the station, but they were peaceful and this state of affairs continued until the next spring.
Mr. Lawson and his family crossed the plains from Missouri in 1859 and settled in Honey Lake valley. In the spring of 1861 he went to stay for a short time at the Jerry Tyler place about three fourths of a mile west of Milford. On the 17th of March he got up at two o 'clock in the morning, this being the first time he had arisen so early. (Some say that he got up because the dogs were making a great deal of disturbance and that he went to the door at once.) After building a fire he opened the door and stepped out, but before his foot touched the ground he fell dead with seventeen buckshot and one rifle bullet in his body. As Mr. Tyler was in the habit of getting up very early in the | morning, the suspicion at once arose that he was the one whom the assassins intended to kill.
The news of the murder was sent all over the valley as soon as possible and early that day a large crowd gathered at the Tyler ranch. The tracks of three men were found going toward the lake and these were followed. One of the tracks was made by a boot of peculiar shape and another was made by a gum boot. Near the lake they found a place where a horse had been tied - some say there were three of them. The pursuing party followed the tracks down along the shore of the lake and after going a few miles they turned and went straight toward the mountain. The tracks ended at a cabin that stood just above the road about six miles below Milford on what was afterwards known as the Shannon and Bell place. In the cabin three men were found asleep - W. F. Warren, called "Curley", Peter Cahill, and Markus E. Gilbert. The men who had followed the tracks woke them up and then began to hunt around the cabin. They found the men 's boots under the cabin, among them a boot of peculiar make and a pair of gum boots, and these fitted the tracks that had come from the Tyler place. It is said that some of the men had at once recognized the track of the boot worn by "Curley" and that the shoes on one of the horses owned by these three men fitted the track of the horse they had with them. Gilbert and Cahill had crossed the plains in the employ of Tyler and during the journey he had considerable trouble with them. They had lived the previous year at the place where they were found.
The three men were taken up to the Tyler ranch and when they were told who had been killed Warren threw up his hands and said "My God. Have we killed that old man!" When Tyler approached Cahill he grabbed a big Bowie knife that the former was carrying and tried to stab him. The men were separated and a guard was put over each one of them. Warren was guarded by Frank Strong and is said to have made a confession to him. Rough Elliott, who at that time was looked upon by many as a sort of leader, wanted to hang the men at once, but the majority of the settlers present were not willing to do this and they were sent to Carson City. According to the best information now at hand they were given two trials at that place. At the first one they were found guilty and sentenced to be hanged. They got another trial and their lawyer, E. V. Spencer, entered the plea that the Nevada court had no jurisdiction in the case - that Honey Lake valley was in California. This plea was allowed and the prisoners were taken to Quincy, Plumas county, California. The records of that county show that Warren made some kind of a confession while at Carson City.
Through the kindness of Judge J. 0. Moncur of the superior court of Plumas county the writer is able to give the following account of the proceedings against them in that county.
The defendants were indicted by a grand jury of which Lewis Stark was foreman on October 10, 1861, for the murder of James Lawson on March 17, 1861, at the house of Jerry Tyler in Honey Lake valley. The witnesses examined before the grand jury were W. T. C. Elliott, Jerry Tyler, and William H. Clark.
The defendants demanded separate trials and W. F. Warren was tried first. His trial commenced October 21, 1861, was completed about two days later, and was held before Robert H. Taylor, District Judge. Patrick O. Hundley, district attorney of Plumas county, and Judge Peter Van Clief conducted the prosecution, and Tom. Cox and John R. Buckbee conducted the defense. The witnesses examined for the prosecution were W. T. C. (Rough) Elliott, Jerry Tyler, F. A. Washburn, Samuel Wood, William Clark, Judson Dakin, and John Dakin; and for the defendant E. V. Spencer, W. T. C. Elliott, J. C. Wright, Thomas Fairchilds, William Clark, and William Hill Naileigh. The jury failed to agree.
Warren was tried again October 25, 1861, before the same judge. The same counsel appeared as in the first trial. The witnesses for the prosecution were W. T. C. Elliott, Jerry Tyler, F. A. Washburn, John Rolfe, John Dakin, Thomas Fairchilds, Samuel Woods, Stephen White, James Docum, Wiley Cornelison, John Neale, John Byrd, and John Bass. The defendant's witnesses were E. V. Spencer, J. C. Wright, Jesse Williams, William H. Clark, R. C. Chambers, Thomas Fairchilds, Smith J. Hill, and Coleman Brown. The trial was completed October 29, 1861, and the jury failed to agree.
Warren's third trial commenced about July 22, 1862, was held before L. E. Pratt, District Judge, and the same attorneys appeared to prosecute and defend. There is nothing to show who the jury or the witnesses were. The trial was concluded on the 25th and the jury returned a verdict of not guilty. On the same day the other two defendants were discharged on motion of P. 0. Hundley, the district attorney.
William H. Clark says that during the trial at Quincy Warren said he made his confession the day after the murder when he was frightened because he thought he was going to be hanged. He said that he told what he did because he thought it would save his life and claimed that it was not the truth. Mr. Clark also said that the testimony of the witnesses for the prosecution was contradictory and that public sentiment seemed to be in favor of the defendants. The friends of the accused men always insisted that they were innocent and some of them said the ones who committed the murder intended to kill Mr. Lawson. After the trial Gilbert, Warren, and Cahill came back to this valley. The first two did not stay very long, but Cahill lived here several years. Gilbert was a resident of Sonoma county, California, for many years and died at Santa Rosa in 1910.
The following was told by Fred Hines. About the middle of April, 1861, Charles M. White, who lived where Haviland built the first house in Toadtown in January, 1857, had a span of fine horses stolen from his stable by Clark Rugg and John Morrow. It has been told that Rugg and Harper opened a blacksmith shop in Susanville in 1859 and Rugg had been there ever since. He seems to have been a natural thief. Morrow had crossed the plains to Indian valley in 1856, but came to this valley to live the next year. He was an industrious man, but was rather slack in his morals. He was paying some attention to a grass widow who lived in Susanville and that took him there quite frequently. During these visits he became acquainted with Rugg and before long they were great friends. Rugg was not satisfied in Susanville and wanted to go to Salt Lake City and also wanted to take White's horses along with him. Morrow was a man who would do anything for a friend so he went along to help him.
The night of the 16th of April they took the horses out of White's stable and started on the emigrant road for the Humboldt river. They went together as far at least as the Lassen Meadows on the Humboldt, and there Morrow turned off and went to Humboldt City ten or twelve miles to the southeast. Rugg went on with the horses up the Humboldt nearly to Gravelly Ford, but becoming frightened about the Indians he turned back. A few days after the horses were stolen L. N. Breed started from the valley to go to Humboldt City. When out near Smoke creek he noticed that the tracks of two horses came into the road and he saw them in the road all the way to the Humboldt river. He also Morrow in Humboldt City. In a day or two Breed set out for Honey Lake and not long after reaching here he heard that White's horses had been stolen. He hunted up White and told him about the tracks he had seen in the road and about seeing Morrow. It was late at night, but White at once rode down to see Hines because Morrow used to make his headquarters there. Hines told him that Morrow had been there that afternoon and said he was going over to Neale's store and then up to Tom. Watson's about half a mile east of Richmond. Hines had partly undressed to go to bed, but he put on his clothes, went out and saddled his horse, and the two men went down to the next place and got William Dow.
The three men went first to the Neale store and there they were told that Morrow had been there that afternoon and bought some tobacco and had then gone on up the road. They went on up to Watson's, but he had not been there. The before-mentioned grass widow had moved down to the Thompson ranch three miles southeast of Janesville, and for that and one or two other reasons they concluded that the man they were looking for had gone down there and they followed him. William Ellison, called "Blue Bill," lived near the Chandler and Fry place and from him they learned that Morrow had left his horse with him and gone away. They reached Thompson's just about daylight and woke him up and asked him if Morrow had been there. He said he had not. Just then some of them saw a man on foot out in the field to the north of them and he was making a circle as if trying to reach "Blue Bill's" cabin. They headed him off and found he was the man they wanted. He was very much excited and drew his pistol, but Hines told him to put it up and not to try anything of that kind. They disarmed him and took him up to "Blue Bill's" and put him on his horse. Then they took him to the Hines and Sylvester ranch and put him in a room up-stairs. On the 11th of May, or about that time, he was given a preliminary examination at Richmond before Squire V. J. Borrette and bound over to the higher court. His bail was fixed at $5000, but he could not raise this and was sent to jail, probably at Quincy.
A man was sent out to Lassen's Meadows, and Rugg was arrested as soon as he got back there and brought to Honey Lake with one of the stolen horses. The other horse had broken down somewhere on the road. Both men were tried at Quincy and found guilty. Hines was subpoenaed as a witness, but he did not recognize the authority of Plumas county and would not go. Rugg was sent to San Quentin for five years and Morrow for four years. About a year before Morrow's term had expired some of the prisoners made a break for liberty while the lieutenant governor was inspecting the state prison. They put the lieutenant governor in the lead and at first the guards did not dare to fire on them. When they did shoot Morrow got a bad wound across the abdomen from a rifle bullet, but he managed to get up to Indian valley and there was captured by John Young and sent back to prison. Probably he would never have been
After being released from prison he came back to Honey Lake and stayed about a year and worked for Hines part of the time. One day when he was hauling lumber he met Breed on horseback and the latter said "How do you do, John." Morrow never said a word, but wound the lines around the brake, climbed off the wagon, and started for Breed. He didn't wait for Morrow to reach him, but put spurs to his horse and rode away in considerable haste. He was afraid of Morrow and told Hines that he should not have employed him and kept him here in the valley.
One day Morrow had a fight in Susanville with Old Man Varney who wore a wig, although his antagonist did not know it. "When he hit Varney the man went one way and his wig the other. Morrow looked first at him and then at the wig and said "God. Didn't I scalp him quick!" Mr. Hines afterwards heard that Morrow and some others stole some horses near Carson City and were captured while making their way east with them. For this they were sent to the Nevada state prison at Carson City. It was reported that Rugg went to Mexico after getting out of San Quentin.
"While some of the conditions remained the same as during the previous year, the gradual improvement for the better went on and each year life became more comfortable for the settlers.
The mining towns on the Comstock lode were rapidly filling up and they made a better market for the Never Sweats. Prices were high, but as yet they were in no condition to profit much by it. There were no mowers in the valley and there were not men enough to cut much hay by hand. There was not land enough cleared up to raise a great deal of grain, but now that a better market had come this work went on rapidly. This year flour had to be brought into the valley again for the gristmill was not finished until late in the fall. It was usually very high in price, but once this fall Shaffer sold it at Richmond for $7 a hundred and that was extremely cheap for flour in those days. V. J. Borrette bought some seed wheat from Sylvenus Conkey this spring and paid ten cents a pound for it. Freight to Virginia City was five cents a pound and a little more than that to Marysville. Langdon and Whiting brought the mail and express into the valley from Oroville and Quincy during the winter of 1861-62.
Provenance
Text from Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.