Lassen County, California - Chapter 13: 1867. Settlement, 1916
From Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. 14,028 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
14,028 wordsMachine-read from scans of Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 13: 1867. Settlement
Susanville. It is probable that some time this year Dr. Z. N. Spalding bought out A. C. Neale and kept the first real drug store in town - one where prescriptions were filled at any time.
Janesville. In the spring a building that stood on the north side of the street about halfway between the hotel and the creek was moved three fourths of a mile up the road. It was put on the south side of the road a little southeast of the Fort. Miss Eva Slater, afterwards Mrs. John C. Partridge, taught the first school in it. This building was used as a schoolhouse until it was burned down about twenty years afterwards.
Milford. Mrs. Mary Harris died in April or May. She was the first grown person to die there and be buried in the Milford cemetery. Egbert, the two-year-old son of T. H. Fairchilds, had died there previous to this.
northeastern corner of Long valley. Thaxter True and Family came into the valley and settled below the Antelope ranch just inside the Lassen county line. Alphonso A. (Pete) Evans came into the valley.
Willow Creek. Summers bought out Davis and got his place and the Pickard place, too. This year a wagon road was built over the Antelope hill. Previous to this the wagon road went up Kice's canyon.
Secret Valley. John B. McKissick says that "Uncle Jake" McKissick took cattle into the valley this fall, but put up no buildings until 1870. He then put a few improvements on a place in the northwestern part of the valley.
Those whose names are given in the following lists settled in the county in 1867. The length of residence does not apply to the children. The following lived here all the rest of their lives or are still living here: J. C. Blake and Family, Mrs. David Titherington, Henry Houchins, William Dunn and Family, S. S. Williams and Family, J. B. Sanders and Family, Thomas B. San-
The following lived here fifteen or twenty years or more: Morgan Williams and Wife, Isaac Adams and Family, Thaxter True and Family, George Boyd, William Waltz, Albert Otto, and E. R. Cary and Family.
The following lived here from two or three to twelve or fifteen years: J. Baker Titherington, Miss Marietta Smith (Mrs. William Dakin), *J. D. Abel, *Oscar Hood, Lucius Post and Family, W. Carson Wright and Family, Alphonso A. (Pete) Evans, and * Joseph (Big Joe) Smith.
In January the Board of Supervisors advertised in the ' ' Sage Brush" that sealed proposals for the construction of a Court House would be received by them until the fourth of February. The following proposals were received: A. A. Smith offered to build it for $12950, F. S. Johnstone for $12900, and William Williams for $9850. The last named bid was accepted, and the building was completed some time during the following October. It has been in use ever since. Previous to this time the Supervisors hired rooms in different parts of the town for the use of the county officers and for a court room. In the fall of 1864 the Magnolia building was used for a court room, and it was also used a while for the same purpose in 1865. At its February meeting the Board allowed J. N. Pine the privilege of moving the Soldier bridge up the river about a quarter of a mile. This is where the line between Sections 15 and 16, Township 29 North, Range 14 East, crosses Susan river, and is its present location in what is now called Tanner's lane. In February Frank Drake resigned his position as Sheriff, and the Supervisors immediately appointed Cap. Hill (W. H. Naileigh) Sheriff to fill the vacancy. In March $1500 was paid to Plumas county, this being the last payment of Lassen's share of the indebtedness of Plumas. April second Marshal Bronson was elected Supervisor of the Third District.
In June the Board accepted a road which had been laid out from the Thomas H. Epley ranch on the Janesville and Milford road, three and one half miles from the former place, to the Shaffer ranch. It ran northeast and north until it intercepted the road from Janesville to Shaffer's, then ran northeast until within two and one half miles of the Shaffer ranch, and then north the rest of the way. At the same meeting of the Board James Ford was allowed $1000 to aid in building the Honey Lake and Indian valley Wagon Road via Light's Canyon and Gold Run. This road was accepted on the seventh of September.
An election for state and county officers was held on September the fourth - 285 votes cast. The following is the result of the election : Joint Member of the Assembly, John R. Buckbee ; Sheriff, Thomas N. Long; County Clerk, A. A. Smith; County Treasurer, John R. Lockwood; District Attorney, I. N. Roop; County Surveyor, E. R. Nichols; Coroner, Z. N. Spalding; County Assessor, Smith J. Hill. Constables. Susanville, 0. Cogswell and Ladue Vary; Janesville, J. H. Breed and Hiram Winchell ; Long Valley, J. N. Woods. Supervisor, District No. 1, E. D. Bowman.
The following is the result of the Special Judicial election held October 16th : County Judge, A. T. Bruce. Justices of the Peace. Susanville, J. Smith and J. Drake; Janesville, Abner McMurphy and Sylvanus Conkey. September seventh E. R. Nichols resigned his office as County Surveyor.
In a small way the Indians kept up their depredations this year. They stole a few head of stock occasionally from travelers and from the ranchers and off the ranges. They prowled around the stations on the'Humboldt and Idaho roads, once in a while attacking, and sometimes killing a lone traveler or teamster.
About the middle of February Collins Gaddy was coming in from the Black Rock mines with a two-horse team. When near Stovepipe Springs he came to a little stream of water where there Was a high ledge of rocks close to the road. He was walking beside the wagon on the side next to the ledge, and when he reached the creek he sprang over it. Just as he did this an Indian who was hidden in the rocks fired at him. That spring saved his life, for the bullet went behind him and went through the bed of the wagon, killing a puppy that he was taking home. Gaddy said that when he heard the shot he looked in that direc- tion and the Indian was so close he could have shot his eye out with a pistol. But he had no weapon, so he ran around the hind end of the wagon and when he got to the other side threw himself over into it and lay down. He then yelled to the horses, and not having any load, they soon carried him out of danger. It seems queer that a man should be so foolhardy as to start out on a journey through a country infested with hostile Indians without taking some kind of a weapon. The fool-killer was likely to get him if the Indians didn 't.
About this time the Indians drove off cattle from Mud Meadows and Deep Hole springs. A band of them was seen prowling around Mud flat, and one of a scouting party of soldiers was shot while on guard not far from Summit lake.
The following is from the "Sage Brush" of August 17, 1867, and gives an account of Winnemucca 's visit to Honey Lake. "This noted chief of the Piute tribe of Indians, having their headquarters on the Indian reservation at Pyramid lake, made Susanville a visit on Tuesday last. He came with letters purporting to have been written by the Indian Agent at their reservation and others of Washoe and vicinity. He brought with him some fifteen warriors whom he stationed about two miles from the town to await the result of a conference with the citizens of Susanville, wishing to gain permission to proceed into the adjacent hills of the surrounding country for the ostensible purpose of hunting. A letter written by Mr. Alvaro Evans of Long valley to Governor Roop urged the granting of the passport. The citizens of Honey Lake valley have suffered much from the ravages of the Piutes, and having declared eternal war against them, became considerably excited at their presence, and set about making immediate preparations for 'taking them in.' In less than half an hour some eight of the citizens of the valley were in their saddles, armed with Henry carbines, and with swift pace crowding down upon the band. The Indians took the alarm at the first sound of the tocsin, and succeeded in gaining the foothills before the war party could reach them. They passed into the timber on the mountains to the north of town, and were thereby enabled to elude their pursuers. Winnemucca, being personally known to several of our citizens as an 'honorable' Indian, was removed to the jail for safe keeping.
' ' The Agent at Pyramid lake and all others whom it may concern, should be cautious about the sending in of their pet Indians into this locality. Enough has been said to satisfy outsiders what course the people here are liable to pursue. No Piute can under any circumstances be allowed to remain among us. What the object of the Indians was we are left to surmise. They have no love for Honey Lakers, and may be the advance guard of a large marauding party, seeking lodgement upon the Ft. Crook and Red Bluff routes of travel. ' '
The foregoing quotation tells briefly a part of what occurred during this visit. In the past years the Indians had caused them so much trouble that the Honey Lakers had sworn vengeance. Probably the most of these depredations had been committed by the Pit Rivers and the renegade Piutes living north of the reservation, but the Honey Lakers were in no mood to discriminate and it was not safe for any Piute to come into the settled part of the valley. Old Winnemucca wanted to visit his old-time friends and he also wanted to hunt around Eagle lake. He was smart enough to know the danger, so he got all the papers he could, thinking they would serve to protect him. Probably he talked to his acquaintances along the road and told them what he wanted to do, for it is said that Robert Johnston followed him to Susanville to see if he could prevent him from going any further north. William Dow and Tunison were coming from Oregon with cattle and Johnston was afraid that the Indians would attack them. When he got close to Susanville Winnemucca sent his warriors to the edge of the hills a mile or more northeast of town, no doubt telling them to be on the lookout for trouble. Taking one Indian with him he went on into the town, and having found his old friend Governor Roop, he dismounted and entered into a conversation with him. When the people of Susanville heard that Winnemucca was there a good many of them became much excited and a crowd gathered around Roop and the Indians. A few of them got their horses and guns and things began to look rather dangerous for the redskins. Joe Hale and Hank Wright seemed to be the leaders of the crowd and they wanted to take the Indians and hang them. Koop told them that he had smoked 1 the pipe of peace with Winnemucca, that he had many times been at the mercy of the chief and the latter had always taken care of him, and that they would have to kill him before they hanged \ the Indians. Captain Weatherlow, Cap. Hill, John Ward, Cutler Arnold, and some other prominent men who were old timers, j joined Eoop and they kept the crowd back. Just about this time ! the Indian who was with Winnemucca and who was still mounted \ on his horse, got frightened and started off down the road toward j Toadtown with Wright and some others in pursuit. The Indian was mounted on a small, beautiful horse that looked like a thoroughbred, and he knew how to ride him. When they got across Piute creek Wright, who was in the lead, raised his gun to shoot, j As he did this his horse stumbled and gave him a hard fall. De Forest thinks that Wright went no further, but Mcllroy says he went on to the Dobyns place. The white men went on, some one being considerably in the lead. George Funk had stopped his team in front of the Dobyns place, about a mile below where the road crosses Piute creek. The Indian went past before he had time to do more than notice him; and when the white man who was following him came along Funk, thinking that it was another Indian, almost shot him before he discovered his mistake. Mcllroy says that a small party of soldiers followed close in pursuit of the white men, and that Funk stopped them at a bridge near the Dobyns place. He cursed and abused them and said he would shoot the first man who crossed it. They all believed him and stayed where they were. I. N. Jones, who then lived about a mile and a half below Susanville, saw the Indians going toward town and expected they would have trouble. A while after they passed he hunted up his rifle, and when he heard a horse cross the bridge close by on a run he hastily put a cap on his gun and ran outside. The Indian was passing the house, running his horse easily and keeping just out of gunshot of the man who was nearest to him. Jones snapped his gun at him three times, but had been loaded a long time and failed to go off. The two went on down the road and more men soon followed. When the man close to the Indian got down to the Johnston place near the gristmill his horse gave out. A horse with a saddle on stood near the gate and he took it and went on. At the gristmill the Indian took the left hand road and after going a short distance went into the willows. Thomas J. Lomas came along at that time on his way from the Shaffer ranch to town. He saw a man with a gun looking through the willows and soon met another man riding furiously. They hunted the Indian out of the willows and he rode off toward the northeast, keeping just far enough ahead of his pursuers to make them think they were going to overtake him. "When he reached the hills he let his horse go and left them as though they had been on foot.
A party went after the Indians who stopped northeast of town; but they must have taken the alarm when they saw the chase going on down the road, for they struck out into the hills to the north and were soon out of danger.
The officer in command of the soldiers talked about shooting people who molested the Indians, and this was told to Hale and the others as soon as they got back to town. Of course this made them feel very hostile toward him and he soon had a row with Hale. Some say that Hale met him on the street and insulted him shamefully, others that the row took place in the saloon and that Hale raised a chair to strike him, but was prevented from doing it. The officer went away, but the soldiers and the citizens kept on quarreling. The latter asked what was going to be done with Winnemucca and were told that they intended to hold him as a hostage. Hale said ''Well, why don't he come out and say so ? " The officer then came out of the Steward House and lined his men up across the street near the Pioneer saloon, and the citizens, with their rifles in hand, lined up not far away. The officer began talking to Hale as if he was a dog, but Joe told him to stop that and talk like a gentleman or he would shoot him. This brought the officer to his senses and his explanation was made without any more trouble. The Honey Lakers were thoroughly aroused, and had the soldiers taken any hostile steps, probably they would have all been killed. T. J. Lomas heard the conversation between Hale and the officer.
Winnemucca was taken into Roop's house for safe keeping. Later on, Mrs. A. T. Arnold says, all the men went away and left her with a pistol to guard him. While they were gone Hale came to the door. She told the chief to go into the bedroom and then told Hale to come in at his peril.
Knudson ranch in Willow Creek valley. It nowhere appears that Winnemucca ever visited Susanville again. Perhaps he thought he was too popular - his presence attracted the attention of too many people.
In the latter part of October Charles League, a resident of Honey Lake valley, hauled a load of freight to Summit lake in northwestern Nevada for Griffin and Williams. He arrived at his destination in safety, and after unloading his freight, started for home. On the evening of the second of November he reached the Flowing Springs station where Charles P. McClelland and Louis M. Crill were taking care of stage stock for the Chico and Idaho line. Robert Elliott stayed there that night, too. During the night the dogs barked and made a great deal of fuss as though there were Indians around, and the next morning they tried to keep League from starting out. Their talk had no effect on him and he hitched up his team and took the road to Honey Lake.
After he had gone McClelland went to looking around the house and found some arrows that had been shot at the dogs. Shortly before this some signal fires had been seen on the mountain, and all this made them sure that a party of Indians was lurking around. It is said that soon after League started Elliott saw a smoke in the direction he had gone and called the attention of the other men to it. They became alarmed for League's safety and McClelland and Crill took their rifles, mounted their horses, and followed him. After going about a mile and a half they saw five Indians going up the side of the mountain leading League 's four horses with their harness on. They followed them for some distance, and finding they could not be overtaken, shot at them, but were too far away to do any execution. They then turned their attention to League and found him lying in the road near his wagon. Evidently the Indians had shot him from ambush, stripped him of his clothes, and hastily departed. Perhaps the smoke was caused by an unsuccessful attempt to set the wagon on fire. McClelland then went across the desert to Hardin City where Alvaro Evans was building a quartz mill, and told him what had happened. Evans at once sent a messenger to Camp McGary and then sent a spring wagon after League 's body. He made a rough coffin and the remains were taken to Honey Lake.
The commanding officer at Camp McGary came with twentyfive soldiers, half a dozen men from the camp at Hardin City joined them, and they took the trail. They followed it south along the summit of the mountain for a part of two days until they were north of Wall springs. A snow storm then came on and they gave up the pursuit. The newspapers accused the Pyramid lake Piutes of committing this murder, but Evans says that the Pit Rivers were the guilty ones.
A week or two after League was killed Alvaro Evans left Hardin City and went to his home in the north end of Long valley. "While on his way there he crossed the trail of some Indians near Wall springs, and they were going south toward the Pyramid Lake reservation. When he got home he sent word to Old Winnemucca, with whom he was well acquainted, to come and see him right away. When he came Evans told him about the murder of League and about the trail toward Pyramid lake, and told him to let him know as soon as he learned anything about the Indians who made that trail. He also told him that if he didn't do something about it, the Honey Lakers would rise and clean out the Piute reservation. (Old Winnemucca had good cause to hunt up that band of Pit Rivers. Besides the killing of League, the occasional depredations of small bands of Pit Rivers in the Long valley country were laid to the Piutes. - F.)
The morning of the last day of November, shortly after Alvaro Evans had left home, Winnemucca came to the ranch with twelve warriors and said that the Indians who killed League were camped in Dry valley about six miles east of the Evans ranch, and that if the Evans Boys would arm his men, he would go up there and kill them. They gave the Piutes some guns and pistols, and Allen Evans, J. N. (Newt.) Evans, Ans. Marsh, Elijah Miller, and five or six other men living in that part of the valley, went along to see the fun. They all started from the ranch about two o 'clock the next morning and in an hour reached what is called "The Sierra camp." The chief said "Wait till daylight. Then we kill them. ' ' About daylight he and his braves went up to the camp of the Pit Rivers. "When they got close to it an old Indian came out and saw them and ran back and awoke the others. They came running out and fired at the Piutes, killing one of them, and this had the effect of sending them back to the white men for protection. The latter immediately charged the Pit Rivers, of whom there were ten bucks and five or six squaws and children. They took to the junipers, but the whites followed them and killed nine of the bucks and captured the squaws and children. The other Indian got away. During the fight the horse ridden by Allen Evans was shot through the withers a couple of inches below the top, and the whites received no other damage. One of the newspapers of western Nevada in commenting on this affair said "Here is the way to fight Indians; ten killed out of eleven - more severe punishment than the whole military force of the government has been able to display in the state for the last twelve months."
Winnemucca took the captives home with him to the reservation and about six weeks afterwards they all ran away. A Piute named George, who had worked for the Evans Brothers and then gone back to the reservation, followed them. He overtook them on the east side of the Fort Sage mountain (State Line Peak), and killed them all excepting a little boy six years of age and a girl of twelve. Probably they hid in the brush and he did not find them. Charles Cramer, who lived in the northeastern corner of Long valley, says that two men from Virginia City were out hunting and found the little girl and brought her to his house. They took her home with them and raised her. The next day after the Indians were killed Allen Evans was hunting cattle in that locality. While riding around in the brush he heard a noise that attracted his attention. After considerable searching he found a little boy sitting on his feet in the snow with a rabbitskin robe over him. Evans took him on his horse and brought him home. On examination it was found that both his feet were frozen hard clear up to his ankles. He was put into an outhouse and some Indians who were camped close by took care of him. In a short time the frozen flesh began to decay and one morning he was missing. Evans supposed that the Indians killed him and took him away.
On the night of December 7th the Indians stole two horses from Willow Creek valley. One belonging to P. D. Hurlbut was stolen from the stable and one running outside from Thomas Summers. They shot an arrow into a eolt belonging to another man and scattered the cattle a good deal. The horse belonging to Summers got away before they had taken it very far.
On the 8th Hurlbut, Knudson, Summers, and Tunison followed the trail of the Indians north toward Eagle lake and found out that two of them were on horseback and that there were perhaps six of them in all. Four days later William Dow, Robert Johnston, Tunison, Hurlbut, Gowenlock, and two or three other men, went to the upper end of the valley and left their horses at Quilty 's place. From there they went on foot and tracked the Indians to the place where they killed Hurlbut's mare. They tracked them a little further and then went back to Quilty 's. The following day they tracked them on to another camp, and from there to one at the east end of Eagle lake. The 14th they started out on horseback and followed the trail to the north end of the east arm of the lake, and there the trail left it. They camped there, and Dow, Tunison, and Gowenlock went on a scout over into Grasshopper valley. They got up before three o'clock the next morning and all of them tramped until sunrise, but saw no Indians - nothing but tracks going north. That day they returned home, having hunted Indians with the same result as that obtained by many an expedition sent out by the Never Sweats in days gone by.
In May Richard Thompson, a very early settler in the valley, was indicted by the grand jury for the crime of murdering his Wife, Margaret Thompson. It was charged that the crime was committed at their home two miles south of Susanville during the early part of March. He was tried at the June term of the District Court, found guilty of murder in the first degree, and sentenced to be hanged. This sentence was commuted to imprisonment for life, and he was sent to the state prison at San
Quentin. After staying there about three years he was pardoned on account of his poor health. He then returned to Honey Lake and spent the rest of his life here.
While this encounter was going on it looked as though it might prove to be a serious affair, but it ended in such a harmless way that people regarded it as a joke. Below are a few of the stories told about it.
Several people who lived in the valley at that time remember it something like the following: On the 31st of March while Joseph Myers was sitting in Bowman & Lockwood's store in Susanville engaged in reading, La Fayette Marks, with whom he had previously had some trouble, approached him from behind and threw his arms around him. Myers was armed with a pistol and a knife, and he drew the latter and jabbed Marks in the arms with it until he let go and ran out of the store. As he went through the door Myers fired at him, but hit the door casing instead of the man. Marks went after his pistol and returned to the store, and getting behind a pile of flour, took two or three shots at Myers who was on the other side of the pile. His pistol then failed to work, and as his opponent was about to get his battery into action, Marks lay down behind the flour. Myers then put his pistol over the flour until it almost touched the other man's back and pulled the trigger, but the weapon failed to go off. While he was trying to get his pistol to revolve Marks ran out of the store and across the street. As he was doing this sprinting act Myers shot at him and just grazed one of his ears. This was the only blood drawn during the pistol practice.
Tunison doesn't tell how he got his information, but says "April 7. Shooting scrape in Susanville last week. Two men fired four or five shots each and one hit once. No harm done. ' '
A man who was in town when the trouble occurred says that the shooting began out in front of the store. Marks fired a shot or two and then, for some reason, ran into the store and lay down behind a pile of flour. Myers followed and put his pistol close to him, but when he pulled the trigger it failed to go off. While he was working with it Marks ran out of the back door and got away.
The records of the county show that the principals in this bloody affray were arrested and shortly afterwards the grand jury indicted both of them. Myers was tried first and was acquitted. Maries was then tried and found guilty of "assault with a deadly weapon with the intent to do bodily injury," and was fined $500, or 250 days in jail. This fine was reduced twice - the last time to $125, or 60 days in jail - and probably it was then paid.
Of all the stories told on this Coast about lost mines the following is one of the strangest. When these mines were discovered there was a wagon load, perhaps two or three wagon loads, of almost pure silver ore in sight Avhich a few years later could not be found. In the same vicinity, still later on, they found large ledges which some assayers said were very rich, while others, equally good or better, said there was not a trace of precious metals in them. Rock from these ledges worked at one time gave large returns. At another time rock from the same ledges, sometimes from the same load, yielded little or nothing. Finally, when a quartz mill was built in that district and run for weeks on the best rock, not even a color was obtained. Another run was made with the same results. Another mill near by made a run without getting anything, and the district was abandoned.
As is usually the case, more than one story is told about the discovery of silver in this district. "In Miners' Mirage-Land," written by Idah Meacham Strobridge, tells the story in one way, and "Thompson and West's History of Nevada" tells it in a slightly different way. The following story of its discovery is the way it has always been told by the men of this part of the country, men like A. B. Jenison, who was intimately acquainted with James Allen Hardin, the discoverer of the mine, and other prospectors who knew him and also knew the Black Rock country. A part of the story of the discovery was told to the writer by William H. Jenison who had it from his Father, A. B. Jenison.
Hardin crossed the plains in 1849. In the course of time the train with which he was traveling reached the Black Rock range of mountains in what is now northwestern Nevada, about ninety miles in a straight line northeast of Susanville. This is a short range extending north and south and terminating at the southern end in a bold, black peak facing the desert. This mountain gives the range its name. "While on his way from eastern Oregon to the Truckee river and thence over the Sierras to California, Fremont camped at the hot springs west of this mountain (about the first of January, 1844), and it so attracted his attention that he took its latitude and longitude and gave it in his narrative of that journey. To the east of the range is the northern part of the Queen's River desert and west of it is a narrow arm of the same desert. We will now go back to the train. By the time they reached this point they were "scarce for almost everything," especially provisions and ammunition. Hardin, who was a sort of hunter and scout for the train, started out in the morning to see if he could kill some kind of game. Jenison told it as though he went alone, Mrs. Strobridge and T. and W. say there were two men with him, and Andrew Hardin of Petaluma, a nephew of J. A. Hardin, says his uncle told him there was one man with him. (Ross Lewers tells that John Lambert, at one time superintendent of the Sierra Nevada mine in Virginia City, said that he was with Hardin when the ore was discovered and that they melted it in a bake oven.) The road runs on the west side of the range, and the hunters traveled across the foothills parallel to it. Nothing grows on this range but greasewood, and the mountain is volcanic rock and volcanic ashes with sand hills down next to the desert. This was a poor country for game and they found none. When three or four miles north of the Double Hot spring (Hardin told Jenison he could not remember whether he was west of the road among the sand hills or east of it in the foothills, though probably it was the latter) they passed the lower end of a little ravine which had been cut out by the water. Something bright in the bottom of it and along its sides attracted their attention, and upon looking more closely, they found it was some kind of metal which they thought might be lead. Andrew Hardin told the writer that his uncle said there was a wagon load of it. It looked as though it would make bullets, and as they were short of ammunition, they took several pieces, perhaps thirty or forty pounds, along with them. When they got into camp they found it melted easily, so they made bullets of part of it and used them. Hardin took a small piece of it with him to California. Jenison did not say what become of the rest of it. In the other two stories it is claimed that Hardin and all those in his train, and Mrs. Strobridge says those in another large train camped close by, were positive that the metal found was silver and that there was enough of it to make them all rich. But in the light of what afterwards took place it would seem that no one who saw it then had any idea that it was silver, or that it had any particular value. Hardin settled at Petaluma in Sonoma county and went to work at the carpenter's trade. A few years afterwards the piece of metal found in the desert, which in the meantime had been carelessly thrown around, fell into the hands of an assayer who found that it was carbonate of lead and silver, and very rich in the last named metal.
About this time, or perhaps a little later, A. B. Jenison and Frederick Alberding moved into the neighborhood of Petaluma from the Kogue River valley in Oregon. They became acquainted wTith Hardin and heard the story of the silver ore, and after talking the matter over concluded to organize an expedition to go back and find the place where he got it. "The Petaluma Journal" of July 9, 1858, says "A party of some fifteen or eighteen persons left this locality a few days since for the eastern slope of the Sierra Nevadas, where they go in search of what they believe to be an immense deposit of silver ore." The paper said that A. J. Harding was the leader of this expedition and that they expected to be gone about two months. T. and W. say the following were the members of that expedition: "M. S. Thompson, Allen Harding, A. B. Jamison, Fred. Alberding, H. Whiteside, Charles Humphries, Major James Pingley, Holt Fine, not spelled right, "Jamison" should be Jenison, and Oman's given name was George W. The other names may be right. It is possible that a man named Clyman and several others were also in the party. Hardin was sure that he would have no trouble in going to the place where he found the silver ; but when he reached that locality, either the face of the country had changed or he had forgotten how it looked, and he utterly failed to find the little ravine where he had seen a wagon load of the precious metal. They hunted for it until fall and then Hardin and some of the party went back to Petaluma, and the others stayed in Honey Lake valley. The next spring Hardin came back with another crowd. Colonel Lewis and "Dad" Wyatt were in this party, and Thompson, Alberding, Jenison, and some of the first party who had wintered here, went with them to Black Rock. They had no better success this year and in the fall the most of the party went below. T. and W. say that Hardin came again the next year, and a relative of Hardin's told the writer that he came into this country three times in search of the mine. If he came in 1860 it must have been late in the fall, for it will be remembered that in the spring of 1860 there were seventy or eighty men prospecting in the Black Rock country when the Piute war broke out. Thompson was there, but no mention is made of Hardin. Alvaro Evans is positive that Hardin was at Black Rock in the summer of 1866.
Of course the Never Sweats took an active part in what was going on. In 1858 most of the men in Honey Lake had done more or less mining and some of them were still engaged in it, and the report that there were tons of silver at Black Rock started many of them in that direction. Some of them may have gone out with Hardin's party in 1858; but whether they did or not, they headed that way early in 1859. Captain Weatherlow and his party went out there about the middle of April, and Lassen 's party soon followed. In 1859 Hardin and some of his party and some Honey Lakers recorded the location of a ledge at Black Rock. From the time of Hardin's first visit in 1858 until the district was abandoned there was more or less excitement in Honey Lake in regard to these mines. Thompson, Jenison, Ladue Vary, Leroy Arnold, and other Honey Lakers, prospected there more or less for six or eight years, and some of them kept it up until all hope was gone. From 1860 until 1866 very few came from the lower country to prospect at Black Rock. In 1862 the excitement flamed a little higher than usual, but it died away and the next three years matters in that locality went on as before.
Some time during the first part of January, 1866, a man who is said to have been a Honey Laker discovered a ledge that he and the other prospectors there at the time thought was the Hardin ledge, so long sought for in vain. The news of the discovery spread like wildfire in every direction, and men from western Nevada and northern California lost no time in getting there, all anxious to find another rich ledge or to get a part of those already found. The most of the travel from California to the mines passed through Susanville which by the road was about 125 miles from Black Rock. The Noble Road, at that time called the "Emigrant Road" to the Humboldt, was followed to the original Granite Creek station. From there the road turned north for a ways and then went east across the desert to the western side of the Black Rock range, about fourteen miles from its southern end.
Considerable of this story can best be told by quotations from the newspapers of that time. "The Humboldt Register" of January 13, 1866, has the following :
"During the past week we have conversed with parties who have been up in the Black Rock region and who report the discovery of the Hardin ledge for which so diligent a search has been made for the past four or five years. Also the ledge near there which other parties found about the same time, but could not again find on going back. Judge Harvey of Susanville saw this latter ledge and thinks it rich; but does not know. Some assays from it show a value of $130 to $200 a ton in silver. The ledge crops a width of about one hundred feet, but Harvey thinks it is broken over and is about fifty feet wide in the perpendicular. A great deal of talk is indulged in here and parties are going out soon to prospect. Several men in this county have been out repeatedly in search for the lost ledge, and they will not be content without a look, even if they don't get a foot." (The other ledge referred to must have been the one discovered by John Foreman and two others in 1852. It was on the mountain across the desert west of Black Rock and was the same kind of ore as that found by Hardin. Mrs. Strobridge says that when Foreman went back there in 1859 he could not find the ledge.)
Later on ledges were discovered that were two hundred feet wide and could be traced for miles. Fred A. Borrette says the first milling test of the Black Rock ore was made at Dall's mill at Franktown in the Washoe valley. A. B. Jenison hauled five hundred pounds there and had it crushed, and it paid at the rate of $306 per ton. I. N. Jones says there were two Thacker Boys at Black Rock, John and James. The latter told him that he was the first man to haul any ore away from there. He loaded an ox team and at first went out on the Humboldt. They would not crush the ore there and he went on down into the neighborhood of Virginia City. "In Miners' Mirage-Land" says that one of the Thacker Boys took several tons of the ore to Unionville where it was worked at the John C. Fall mill. Nothing was obtained from the rock and the mill was blamed for it. The same book says that they were not satisfied with this and another man named Giddings took about a thousand pounds of the ore to Dall's mill. Hiskey, the foreman, who was a good judge of ore, told him his rock was worthless and laughed at him for bringing it so far to be worked. He refused to work it saying that it would be robbery to do so. Giddings hung on and insisted that they should work it. At last, to satisfy him, Hiskey agreed to do it, but told him that if they got anything out of the rock, he would not charge him a cent for working it. The rock was worked and brought great returns and the mill man kept his word.
"The Red Bluff Independent" prints a letter to T. M. Boarman from Honey Lake valley, dated February 7, 1866. It says that the Black Rock country is alive with people. Some specimens of the rock have been taken to the mills at Humboldt and produced $2700 a ton. An expedition, among whom was B. Neel, went out from Red Bluff several years ago, but didn't find anything. Other parties have hunted since then, but have found nothing until about four weeks ago. "The Sage Brush" describes the ledge as being fabulously rich, equal to the Poorman ledge at Owyhee. February 19th Tunison says "Great excitement about Black Rock nowadays." Judge Harvey, E. D. Bowman, Lawrence Bass, Major Smith, and others, had the rock assayed and milled at different places with varying results, and of course the old prospectors made tests for themselves. They hired a man named Isenbeck by the month to stay at Black Rock and make assays of the ores. He was supposed to be a good assayer and mill man and he got from good to great values out of nearly all the samples brought to him. After a while some of the boys began to say that he could find silver in a piece of grindstone.
Torrey 's mill. He expects it to work up into the hundreds, and, as is his habit, offers to back up his judgment. The working will prove Black Rock as to quality anyhow." On the 24th, probably referring to the same load of ore, it says: "A portion of Harvey 's rock from the Black Rock mines has been worked - enough to show that the ledges contain gold and silver, but not enough to indicate the value of the ores. Isenbeck, who came through with Harvey, and undoubtedly an excellent assayer and experienced mill man, was permitted by Mr. Torrey, by request of Harvey, to superintend the working of this rock, on account of its peculiar character. After running three tons through the pans, it was agreed that a different process was necessary in amalgamating. The chlorides floated too easily to be caught by the quicksilver. Accordingly the tailings and the pulp of the other three tons of ore were run into a large vat, to evaporate some of the superfluous moisture from it. Together with hundreds of others we look with much interest for the result of a satisfactory working of this rock. Judge Harvey showed us before leaving for home, a little bar from the ore worked. It weighed 11.40 ounces, and showed by assay .806 fine in silver - $11.87, and .022 fine in gold - $5.18, total value $17.05. A considerable quantity of gold was panned afterwards from the battery, which if worked would have largely increased the value of the bullion. Torrey and Isenbeck are confident that by experimenting a process can be worked out, by which this character of ores can be made to give up almost entirely what gold and silver they contain.
"Jo Voshay has gone to work on his claim about twenty miles north of Black Rock. Black Rock is all the go now. Thursday forenoon a snowstorm was on, which turned about meridian to rain ; but it did not deter a number of prospectors from setting out for the new Dorado. When you see a man sitting in front of a roll of blankets and a frying pan, and behind a Henry rifle, you need not ask him where he is going - he is 'going to Black Rock or burst.' Great excitement is reported in Petaluma on account of the discovery of large ledges of silver near the boundary line between Lassen county and Nevada. ' ' have spoken with have no faith in the reputed richness of the ore there found. They describe the ledges as monstrous in j width, and cropping from three to ten miles on the surface. If they are good silver ore, the boys say it is heaviest deposit of \ it ever yet found in the world. One thing puzzles people. The assayers here can make out but a bare trace of silver in any of the Black Rock ores yet tried, w~hile Isenbeck and Mosheimer make certificates of fabulous results. Black Rock is as much a mystery as ever."
We again quote from "The Humboldt Register." April 7th it says: "Black Rock will perhaps be heard from in a few j days - unless somebody is interested in keeping back the truth. An arastra has been running for several days; and if there is | silver it ought to show. We saw a dab of amalgam which Steve Bass had carefully worked out by hand from an exact pound of rock. The amalgam looked well - felt well. It was cupelled and made no sign of silver. Black Rock is not understood; the ledges may pay - but the thing doesn't look promising by the light we have." On the 21st it says "A handsome specimen Jo Voshay sent us the other day from his claim in the Black Rock region. He took several hundred pounds of this sort of rock to the East last year, and it worked well up into the hundreds - don't recollect the figures. Black Rock promises well, but has not yet been entirely proved." In May A. T. Arnold hauled a four-horse load of Black Rock ore to Dall's mill. It was worked and paid fairly well.
During the year 1866 the Black Rock excitement was at its greatest height. From the early spring until winter Black Rock was "all the go." Everybody talked about the mines and every one who had any speculation in him, or any blood likely to catch the mining fever, owned more or less "feet." When two men met they soon commenced to talk Black Rock, and generally one, or both of them, exhibited specimens of the ore which he carried in his pocket. There was all kinds of "dickering" going on in claims. Like whiskey, it was all good. Some men made the most of their opportunities and got what they could out of it. If they could not sell for money, they traded "feet" for plug horses or "any old thing." The outcome showed that a person did well if he traded his mining claims in that country for "chips and whetstones."
Hereafter all quotations in this article not credited to anything else, are taken from "The Eastern Slope," a paper published at that time in Washoe City, Nevada.
June 23d, 1866, it says "Harvey, Ward, and Buckbee have been in town for the past week. They brought a considerable amount of Black Rock ore to get a working test at Dall's mill and, flattering results are being obtained." July 28th. "The migratory part of our citizens are leaving Excelsior and rushing to Black Eock where there are a thousand times as many inducements as there ever were at Excelsior. Ledges of unlimited extent pay $50 a ton from the top down and this exceeds any discovery ever made before in the mining world."
Some time during the month of June H. N. Skadan hauled a load of provisions, lumber, and shingles from Milford to Black Eock for T. H. and E. H. Fairchilds. He brought back a load of ore for Manley Thompson, and took it to Dall's mill to be worked. Thompson told him that it didn't pay anything. J. D. Byers took some ore from the same district to the same mill. Five hundred pounds paid at the rate of $400 a ton, but when the rest of it, four and three fourths tons, was worked it paid only $40 a ton.
August 11th. "The Evans Boys of Long valley are about building a mill at Hardin City, a city of fifteen houses and 15000 rats, and expect to have it in running order by October first. The people of Black Eock think they have treasure enough there to build a railroad from Chico to Vallejo with silver rails, pay off the national debt, and buy Ireland for the Fenians." Nothing small about that.
September first it published an article taken from the "Mining and Scientific Press," written by J. Mosheimer, well known in Nevada as a scientific and practical miner. He says that numerous assays of Black Eock ore have been made in different places. Some assayers have been fortunate and others have obtained nothing at all. This has been the case with some San Francisco assayers. He says he has assayed more than a hundred samples from Black Eock, and is sure that seventy-five out of that number have contained gold and silver from a low percentage to $900 per ton. The ledges in Black Eock are from twenty to sixty feet wide. Some strikes in these veins are very rich, and he thinks that half of those discovered will pay for the working. Especial credit is due Mr. Harvey for his perseverance in testing those ores. The writer says he has in his possession a bar which was extracted from 3800 pounds of ore at Dall's mill in Washoe valley. The ore was from the Merrimac ledge and paid $48.85 per ton in gold and silver. Another lot from the Monadnock paid $256. This ore was not selected, and was taken from not more than two feet below the surface. The writer says he has no further interest in the matter than to verify the assertion that the Black Eock mines are real mines, and he thinks that several mills will be put up there before the summer closes. The newspaper then says that since the foregoing was written extensive prospecting has been done in the Black Rock region, new and rich discoveries have been made, and arrangements have been made for the speedy erection of several mills. November 24th it says that the Snow Storm ledge has developed richer ore than that famous ledge has ever shown before. December 8th. A letter from Black Rock dated November 22nd tells that new discoveries are being made that surpass anything heretofore found, and that the Evans Company's mill is almost ready to commence work.
"The Sage Brush" of December 7, 1866, says "The mill at Black Rock started to run this week, with what results we have not yet learned. Black Rock is all right, so the Freyberg men tell us." December 14th it says "The mill at Black Rock is running. Judge Harvey has gone out to bring in a load of bricks. Our scientific fellow citizen, Judge Harrison, assisted by ' Messrs. Ward and Bowman, has been engaged during the week j in experimenting on Black Rock ore. The result of these experiments has demonstrated to the satisfaction of the most incredulous, the richness of these mines. The Merrimac is rich, but the Black Wax is richer. Judge Harrison has just called and shown to us the metal taken from an ounce of Black Wax ore. The result of this test would almost warrant the belief that the ore is worth $7 per pound." A letter written from Black Rock about the middle of December said the miners in that section were every day gaining confidence in the richness and permanence of the mines.
The Yeae 1S67
Mention has several times been made of a quartz mill built at Hardin City by the Evans Company. The following in relation to the building of it was told by Alvaro Evans. The Evans Brothers were men of means, and people kept coming to them for help in developing the Black Rock mines. The men who owned ledges there showed them big silver buttons that Isenbeck claimed he obtained by assaying their ore, and at last the Evans Boys concluded to assist them. In the spring of 1866 they sent a man with a team of four yoke of cattle to Black Rock and told the miners to load it with ore, and he would take it to John Dall 's mill at Ophir on the west side of Washoe valley. Accordingly they loaded the team with the best ore from the Snow Storm, Black "Wax, and other ledges that were considered to be the best in the district. The team then came back to Long valley and Alvaro Evans accompanied it to the quartz mill. At that time Dall's mill was run by Superintendent J. B. Hiskey. He at once took some ore from the Snow Storm ledge and assayed it, and told Evans that it went $1000 to the ton. Two other assayers, Wiegan of Gold Hill and a Virginia City man, assayed some of the same ore and could get nothing out of it, though they said something might be there that they knew nothing about. The Virginia City man offered to bet a thousand dollars that there was nothing in the ore. Hiskey said he would take the bet, and would make the assay in the presence of the other man and get the same results. The other man backed down - said there might be something in it, but he couldn't find it. The Dall mill was engaged in crushing ore from the Ophir mine in Virginia City. The ore was treated by the "Bartola" process. It was crushed and roasted and then put into hollow cylinders with old iron and rolled around. Hiskey worked eight hundred pounds of the Snow Storm ore by this process and got $800 out of it. This excited Evans, and he inquired what it would cost to put up a five stamp mill. Hiskey thought it would cost between six and seven thousand dollars, and Evans immediately ordered the batteries and machinery for such a mill from San Francisco. He then came to Honey Lake and had a sawmill south of Richmond saw out some lumber for him. This was hauled to Black Rock and the quartz mill was put up as soon as possible. If "The Sage Brush" made no mistake, it was ready to run the first week in December, 1866, and a man named Cheatam, who had been recommended by Hiskey, went to Hardin City to superintend the running of it. The rest of the story will be told later on.
During the first part of the year 1867 the Black Rock excitement continued, but in a different way from that of the previous year. By this time the country had been thoroughly prospected and everything that seemed to be of any value was claimed by some one. The rush to the district was done, and the excitement was kept up by reports that the ore worked was paying well. Still, as some of the papers said, there was a sort of mystery and uncertainty about it. There were so many conflicting reports in regard to the assays and the returns from the rock crushed that the prevailing idea was that the value of the mines was yet to be proved.
February 15th, 1867. "Reports from Black Rock continue flattering and if the mines stand the test, Washoe county in two years will be the richest county in the state, and in three years Black Rock will be yielding more bullion than all other discovered mines besides. William Kingsbury alias "Smoke Creek Sam" has just arrived from the mines and reports the boys in good spirits. Prof. Robinson, the assayer, is taking out large chunks of bullion. The mill will be ready to run as soon as Mr. Evans arrives with the salt. February 23rd. "It is reported that they obtained $8000 from twenty tons of rock by mill process, and one pound of pure silver from four pounds of rock." "The Sage Brush" of March 30th, 1867, says "News from Black Rock is like the mail. It doesn't come very often, but is good when it comes." The first part of April Bowman and Jenison went from Susanville to Washoe valley with samples of choice ore which they were going to work in the presence of doubters. Some time this year the Fairchilds Brothers had a couple of tons of Black Rock ore worked at the Dall mill and it yielded $500. "The Eastern Slope" of June 22nd said that the practical working of the Black Rock ore was no longer an open question, and that they now worked it in San Francisco by mill process with as much certainty as they did the ore from the Comstock. June 29th. "Hon. C. C. Goodwin left Honey Lake on the morning of the 18th inst. in company with Isenbeck for the scene of his labors in Black Rock. Isenbeck was the first assayer who succeeded in working Black Rock ores by the fire process, and he is now returning to the mines determined to establish the fact that these same refractory ores can be profitably milled. Success to him." "The Humboldt Register" of July 20th calls Isenbeck the prince of humbugs, and says that he is again on his way to Black Rock with a fresh installment of victims to insanity. "The Eastern Slope" said it would not defend Isenbeck because it didn't know him, but it thought that the mines at Black Rock were much richer than those of the Humboldt country. "The Sage Brush" and "The Humboldt Register" told that in August Judge Goodwin had forty tons of what was supposed to be rich ore hauled from Black Rock to the Ophir mill. It was crushed there and then taken to Dall's mill where it was worked by the united skill of Hiskey and Isenbeck. They worked small quantities of ore from each of the ledges so as to find out which one was the best. They then intended to work the ore from the best ledge. September 7th "The Eastern Slope" says that the results thus far obtained at Dall's mill are a complete vindication of Mr. Isenbeck. It also proves that Black Rock is richer than the Comstock. For the truth of this people are referred to John Dall and James Hiskey, and are invited to visit the mill and see for themselves. The paper could not give the exact figures, but it was authorized to say that Snow Storm crushed from $170 to $200 per ton, Black Prince from $150 to $175 per ton, and Emerald $350 per ton. These tests were made by Isenbeck, Cockran, Hiskey, and Goodwin, superintended by Dall. September 21st it says that Mr. Isenbeck has on exhibition in that place fourteen small bars of bullion, the result of working Black Rock ores, the aggregate weight of which is 488 ounces, the exact value of which has not yet been ascertained. It says that Mr. Isenbeck has labored under many disadvantages owing to the lack of machinery adapted to his peculiar process, but that enough has been done to show the character of Black Rock as a mining country. In i conclusion it says that it looks upon the little five-stamp mill of Judge Goodwin and his associates as the pioneer of the greatest metallurgical work in the United States and perhaps in the i world, and that Black Rock is destined to revolutionize the ! monetary affairs of the nation. (Do you mind that?) On the | strength of these results Atchison & Company, San Francisco and Humboldt men, and Judge Goodwin & Company determined to build some quartz mills in the neighborhood of Black Rock for the purpose of working the ores of that district. The first named company selected the Double Hot spring, six or seven miles south of Hardin City, as its building place. Goodwin & Company concluded to build a ten-stamp mill at Granite Creek meadows about thirty-five miles from the mines. In that location there was said to be plenty of wood and water. At this time Isenbeck was working at the Evans & Company mill reconstructing it upon a plan suited to the working of the ores after his own process. October 26th ' ' The Sage Brush ' ' says ' ' Atchinson & Company 's mill is on the road to Black Rock with a fair prospect of being in a working condition at a very early date. Judge Goodwin's mill is ready for shipment, but probably too late to be placed on the ground this fall. Black Rock is the coming country as sure as the world stands." November 2nd it reports that the Evans and Bass mill at Black Rock has commenced work under the superintendence of Isenbeck, and that results will be given a few days from that time. On the ninth it says that Atchinson & Company's mill is in progress, and it looks as though work would begin that fall on the Goodwin mill.
"The Eastern Slope" of November 23d, 1867, reports the failure by Mr. Isenbeck to work the Black Rock ores at the Bass & Evans mill. They think it is because the country is a water formation and that the water takes up the metal in solution when worked with it. That such is the case is evidenced by the fact of the numerous assays and the returns from Dall's mill made over and over again. They think that no one could satisfy Mr. Hiskey that he was deceived in the thirty or forty tons of ore from Black Rock that he has worked, or make Mr. Dall believe that he has furnished hundreds of dollars of bullion coming from rock that was utterly barren. The "Virginia City Trespass" of November 20th says that yesterday they published intelligence from the Black Rock mines on the authority of Charles Isenbeck, who has just returned from that country, where he has been superintending the working of various ores from the mines thereabouts at the Evans & Company's mill. This morning they received a call from L. Bass, who is a partner of Evans in the Black Eock mill, who makes a statement utterly in contravention of what Isenbeck informs them, thus making it a question of veracity between the two gentlemen. Bass said "lam part proprietor of the Black Rock mill. I engaged Charles Isenbeck to go there and superintend the working of the Black Rock ore at a salary of $1000 a month provided he could procure paying returns from the ore. I paid him $500 in advance and he went to the mill. I furnished him with everything he demanded that would insure success in reducing the ore. He worked between ten and twelve tons. Instead of the quicksilver gaining 122 pounds of amalgam, as stated by Isenbeck yesterday, it lost the usual amount in working; and all the amalgam found was about half a pound, which upon examination and assaying proved to be nothing but copper, with no trace of gold or silver therein. After this test by Isenbeck I called upon him to return the $500 advanced upon contract which he promptly refunded to me, he not having been able to procure any precious metals from the ore by his process. Isenbeck is the third person who has asserted that he could get rich returns from the ore, and each has failed. I have yet to see a quarter of a dollar in silver or gold actually produced from working the Black Rock ores, and never any signs of either except in fire assays, one of a dozen of which have perhaps shown gold and silver in paying quantities. I believe yet in the richness of our vast deposits of ore, and hope for some method whereby the same can be profitably worked ; but as yet none has been discovered. At this time Hiskey of Dall's mill at Franktown is engaged in working four and one half tons of ore from the Snow Storm ledge and the returns thereof I will make public. I desire that only the truth be told relative to the district, as untruth will only militate against the best interests of the country in which I am as deeply interested as any one." The "Trespass" says it takes no hand in the fight, hoping that the wealth of the country may be as great as Isenbeck says it is and Bass hopes it is. The following is from "The Sacramento Union" under the heading of "The Black Rock Failure."
"In regard to the recent failure of a test of this rock in which fifteen tons of Snow Storm ore was worked without any silver, as mentioned in the Union lately, 'The Sage Brush' says 'Frank Johnson informs the 'Brush' that no importance need be attached to the failure as no effort was made to acquire any extensive result. Here is more mystery. Talk about mystery in Heaven; we think Black Rock will eclipse any mystery yet developed or undeveloped. On the heels of this comes a letter from the Freyberg Institute, Germany, pronouncing the ore one one-hundredth part pure silver, equal to $320 per ton.' " Ross Lewers says that a man named John Maurer, who had once worked for him, went to Germany in 1866 or 1867. Lewers sent thirty-two samples of Black Rock ore with him, and he had them assayed at Freyberg. The report of the assay was in German, and Rough Elliott, to whom it was given, neglected to have it translated before it was accidentally burned. Maurer said that only one sample assayed anything of value, and that was only good for paint.
The miners turned out and dug greasewood roots to run the reverberatory furnace and for fuel for the engine, and they worked the ore by the "Bartola" process, the same that had been used at Dall's mill. They made a run of thirty days and when they cleaned up they never got a color. The Evans Brothers then took in Lawrence Bass and Chancellor Derby as partners, and some time after the middle of February, 1867, they made another run of about the same length as the first one and with the same result. When it was said that the ore could not be worked at Black Rock on account of the water there, Mr. Evans took five gallons of it to Virginia City and had it analyzed. They told him there was nothing in the water that would prevent the successful working of the ore at that place. Isenbeek said he could work the ore and make it pay, so they hired him as Mr. Bass told; and he made a failure of it after having had the mill fixed up to work the ore by his own process. Alvaro Evans says they had about half a barrel of whiskey at the camp, and the whole crowd got drunk and abandoned the place for all time to come.
About the first of December the Atchinson & Company mill was ready to run, and undiscouraged by the failure of Evans and Bass they commenced working the ore from their mine.
an editorial in the "Mining and Scientific Press "says that while nearly all assayers of established reputation have" pronounced the so-called ores from the Black Rock district to be utterly worthless and no ores at all, ever since the discovery of the mines a class of men with little or no experience have been persistent in their declarations that the ores were of extraordinary richness. These men have even exhibited to hopeful shareholders bars and buttons which they claim have been taken from the ores by assaying and working processes. Hiskey says the last sentence must be intended for him, for outside of Isenbeck he is the only person who has ever exhibited bars of precious metals and claimed to have taken them from the Black Rock ores. The "Press" further says that after two years of effort they have finally obtained possession of a sack of Black Rock ores which a brief examination justifies them in saying are utterly worthless. The card of Mr. Ross advertising Isenbeck 's failure closes the article in the "Press." Mr. Hiskey says he would like to ask the editors of the "Press" if they have any proof that Black Rock is not a rich mineral region. He thinks that condemnation without investigation should stop. The "Press" is not alone in its error. Almost every tenpenny assayer condemns Black Rock because an ordinary fire assay fails to produce results. He makes no claim to extraordinary ability, but he asserts and stands ready to prove that he has worked many tons of Black Rock ore, and generally with good results. If either of the editors of the "Press" will visit him, he will undertake to show him to his complete satisfaction how bars and buttons of precious metals can be taken from the Black Rock ores. It is true that a little mill has been built at Black Rock and that it has made two or three runs which were failures. It is equally true that old men, little boys, and Chinamen in that region never fail to get their button out of ores in small quantities. He thinks the cause of failure is that the milling has been conducted on too scientific principles, and intimates that every mill in the state run by a purely scientific expert has failed. In conclusion he says he has no ax to grind and no Black Rock "feet" to sell, but that he can not help thinking that bars and buttons will be taken from Black Rock in paying quantities after the "Scientific Press" is forgotten.
January 25, 1868, "The Eastern Slope" quotes the following from The New York ' ' American Journal of Mining. " ' ' Durmg the excitement numerous samples of ore were sent to Messrs. Adelberg & Raymond with the whimsical request that they should assay the rock according to the method practiced in Freyberg. As they practice all methods at Freyberg, this request was mysterious at the time; but the cause of it now appears to have been the pretension of Isenbeck to be a Freyberg metallurgist. The assaying of the wax gave no silver and the material was pronounced to be mere bituminous clay. "We presume that the matter will soon die out and be forgotten, but there seems to be still rumors of great results obtained in Washoe from Black Rock ores. Some of the ore was sent to Prof. A. E. Verrill of Yale College. He said it contained a little silver, but not nearly so much as it was said to carry. He also said it was a sort of clay containing some chloride of silver, salt, bitumen, etc."
"The Eastern Slope" of February 1, 1868, says "Mr. Atchinson of the firm of Atchinson & Company in Black Rock has thus far failed to secure any favorable result. We learn that he proposes to make one more attempt after which in case of failure, he will remove his mill to the Winnemucca district, Humboldt county. Cheatam, who gained his experience in Black Rock ores at Dall's mill, is now at the Atchinson mill waiting for chemicals with which to make his final attempt on the untractable ores of Black Rock. We have not, and never had, any faith in working Black Rock ores at Black Rock; and secondly, our faith in Black Rock is no more affected by past failures than by past abuse engendered by spite and jealousy." The paper then says that Black Rock may prove a failure, but they well remember the time when all the knowing ones scoffed at as wildcat all claims on the Comstock. These claims now occupy a respectable place in the opinions of practical miners, and they anticipate that it will be so with Black Rock.
Without any doubt the Atchinson mill was moved, for there is nothing on record to show that they obtained any good results from that run. At least three quartz mills were erected and run in the Black Rock district, and not one of them ever got anything out of the ore. Alvaro Evans says their company lost
The glory of Hardin City had departed and so had the hopes of those who saw ' ' millions in it. " This ' ' city, ' ' named in honor of J. A. Hardin, stood at the western edge of the Black Rock range thirteen or fourteen miles from its southern extremity. "In Miners' Mirage-Land," published in 1904, has this to say of it: "Its buildings are quite dismantled and destroyed. The winds of the Desert - the rains of the years have nibbled and gnawed at the adobes until only the faintest traces that they once were, remain. Of the mill itself, part of the whitish-gray stone of its walls, and most of the tall chimney, stand out in sharp relief, discernible miles away against the darker background of Hardin Mountain."
Probably the Black Rock mines were abandoned by everybody before the middle of the year 1868. Three men of the old crowd, however, went back. A. B. Jenison prospected in that section until 1884. Leroy Arnold prospected in the Black Rock country and northeast of it from 1876 until 1900, a short time before his death. Neither of these two men discovered anything of value. Ladue Vary went back there in the early 70 's and in 1884, "Walter J. Dakin says, or about that time, discovered a ledge containing gold and silver about thirty-one miles north of west of the Queen's River crossing. For this mine he was offered $30,000. One would naturally suppose that after all these years of toil and privation in the desert he would gladly have sold for that sum and spent the rest of his life in comfort. But no. After all this hard work he was going to have something for what he had found, and would take nothing less than $100,000 for his mine. No one would give that for it, and he lived there in the same old way for more than twenty years longer. His place was called Varyville, and there he raised a little hay and a garden. He leased his mine on such favorable terms that although considerable bullion was taken from it, he got nothing to speak of himself. In 1906 he became so feeble that he was taken to the county hospital at Winnemucca, Nevada.
After he had been there about a year he died of the smallpox. He was ninety-six years old, and had lived and prospected in ^hat section the most of the time for almost fifty years.
Daniel B. Boyd, who was the County Treasurer of Washoe county, Nevada, for a great many years, said that in 1872 he was working in a store at Franktown, Nevada. He had eome there from Downieville, in the neighborhood of which he had mined for something like twenty years. One day an overland teamster (one who hauled freight from the Sacramento valley over into Nevada) brought a ten-mule load of Black Rock ore to Dall's mill to be worked. He thinks that James H. Kinkead was interested in having the ore brought there. In a conversation with Mr. Boyd the teamster said the ore looked as though it might have something in it, and Boyd took some of the fine ore that was left in the wagon bed, panned it out, and got a color or two. He then asked the teamster if he had hauled any other rock or mineral before he loaded with the Black Rock ore and the reply was that he had not. Mr. Boyd swept all the fine rock he could get out of the wagon box and panned it out very carefully. He got some gold and a lot of fine bits of metal. He pulverized these in a mortar and then panned it out and got about $2.50 in fine gold.
The following was told by "William H. Jenison, son of A. B. Jenison. "Billy" Jenison was almost raised in the Black Rock country and knew it well. He also knew what kind of ore Hardin found there. Along the last of April, 1909, when the mining excitement was running high in Nevada and a great deal of prospecting was being done in that state, he concluded to take a look at the Black Rock country once more. When he arrived at the place where Hardin City once stood he found that some other prospectors had already been there that spring. He did not know who they were and never found out, but appearances indicated that they had gone away about a month before his arrival. When they got ready to leave they threw their specimens down on the ground in a pile. There was quite a lot of the rock they had picked up, and in the pile he found a piece of ore that was exactly the same kind as that carried away by Hardin in 1849. It was the first piece of it, excepting the one Hardin had, that any one had seen since that time. Of course he could not tell whether it was a piece of float, or whether they had found the ledge and didn't know what it was. It may have been a piece of the ore that was left where Hardin's train camped.
It is probable that long before this the reader has begun to wonder how so much bullion came out of rock that had nothing in it; and how some assayers got big buttons, and "old men, little boys, and Chinamen, never failed to get their button out of the ores in small quantities." It is easy to answer the first question. At that time Dall's mill and the other mills in that neighborhood were crushing rich ore from the Comstock mines. Their batteries and pans were not very thoroughly cleaned and the Black Rock ore picked up the gold and silver left in them. (Alvaro Evans said that the alkali dust on the Black Rock ore cut the gold and silver loose from the old irons in the "Bartola" process.) That accounts for the fact that sometimes half a ton of Black Rock ore would yield a goodly amount of silver and after that three or four tons of the same load would yield little or nothing. The first batch of ore worked cleaned the batteries and pans of what silver there was from the Comstock ore, or the greater part of it, and not much was left to make the next lot pay. Men who were at Black Rock during the time of the greatest excitement there think that Isenbeck made all the ore that he assayed pay well because he had a good job and wanted to "hold it down." Perhaps the "old men, little boys, and Chinamen" obtained their buttons the way Mr. Boyd got that gold. There is something mysterious in the part Mr. Hiskey took. He seems to have been perfectly honest in what he said and did, and it looks as though he greatly deceived himself in this matter.
The writer has talked with many men who prospected at Black Rock and has read everything he could find on the subject. He is of the opinion that Mr. Hardin found the large quantity of that silver ore just as he said he did. He was not hunting for gold or silver and didn't expect to find any, and was not excited about it. He simply thought he had found something that would make bullets. Cloud-bursts are of frequent occurrence in the Black Rock region during hot weather. Men who knew that section well in the 60 's and who went back there twenty-five years afterwards, say it then looked like a strange country because cloud-bursts had cut out new canyons and filled up the old ones. Probably a year or two before Hardin found that ore a cloud-burst had torn open the side of the hill and exposed it to view. Before he came back in 1858 another cloud-burst covered it up. This view was taken by M. S. Thompson, Leroy Arnold, and other men who prospected in that district. The next cloud-burst that comes along may uncover it again, and, on the other hand, it may lie buried there forever.
Provenance
Text from Fairfield's Pioneer History of Lassen County, California; Containing Everything That Can Be Learned About It from the Beginning of the World to the Year of Our Lord 1870 ... Also Much of the Pioneer History of the State of Nevada ... the Biographies of Governor Isaac N. Roop and Peter Lassen ... and Many Stories of Indian Warfare Never Before Published, published 1916, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.