Orange County, California - Chapter 24: A Chapter of Tragedies, 1921
From History of Orange County, California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Earliest Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. 2,948 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
2,948 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Orange County, California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Earliest Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
In ihe year 1855 a team of horses was stolen from the i lardy brothers in Los Angeles, and the thief, Juan Flores, was captured, tried and sentenced to ten }ears in the penitentiary.
The Hardy brothers, who were living on a i)art of the William Wolf skill place, were owners of several good draft as well as riding horses. They were doing considerable freighting, the business requiring good stock, and this class of animals was of great value. Their riding horses were of the native stock, but were selected for their speed and endurance, as they were often used to run races.
In the above-named year, one Juan Flores and a companion stole one nf these freighting teams and probably intended to make for the Me.xican border and sell the horses. Both Flores and his companion were captured and. after a trial, each was sentenced to ten years in prison.
Two years after the event of the stealing took jilace one of the Hanhs had a load of freight to haul from Los Angeles to San Juan Capistrano. He made the trip without mishap and, arriving at his destination during the forenoon, delivered his goods, and put his horses in a corral and fed them ; this done, he started out to see the town. A few hours later, as he returned to look after his animals in the corral, he noticed several men looking at them ; the nearer he approached he thought he recognized Juan Flores among the number ; this did not seem possible, for he remembered it had been but two years since the episode of his having his horses stolen by him and he had received a ten-year sentence. Observing the approach of Plardy the men went away and the matter was forgotten by ITardy for the time.
It so happened that there was a Mexican woman in an adobe building adjoining the corral who had overheard the conversation of the men who were looking at the horses, and recognized Flores among them by his remarks, which were to the effect that the horses in question were the same that he had stolen and received his ten-year sentence for, and it was now a chance for him to get even by waylaying Hardy the next day \vhen he was on his way home, kill him, and take the team to ^Mexico. His companions, looking upon him as the leader, consented to the plan. This talk frightened the woman and she did not know what to do, for if it were known that she had overheard the conversation her own life would be in danger, and at the same time she did not want to have Hardy murdered. Finally she went to Don Juan Forster, who was a medium through which many of the natives settled their differences, and related the conversation as she had overheard it. It did not take Don Forster long to decide upon a plan of action. He found Flardy, told him the circumstances, but told him to keep (|uiet about it and that he would send a runner out that night to notify the sheriff in Los Angeles to come out and capture the bandit. The runner was sent to inform Sheriff Barton, who immediately made arrangements to frustrate the plans of Flores and capture all of the bandits if possible.
The sheriff' notified Hardy's two brothers, one of whom selected his best saddle horse and, after arming himself, joined the sheriff' and his three deputies, all starting for Capistrano. Sheriff Barton was a typical frontiersman and had seen many desperadoes, and knew how to handle them. However, he took the precaution to make his will before he started out. Each man was armed with a double barreled shot gun and revolvers. They reached Carpenter's ranch and stopped there for dinner. That night they camped by the Santa .\iia River, but the next morning were on the road very early and the ranch of Don Jose Seiiul- veda was reached for breakfast. On the road the party came up with a Frenchman riding a mule ; he stated he was on his way to San Diego and no objection was made to his joining their party. When the men went into the house for their breakfast they stacked their guns on the porch, and these were viewed with some curiosity by the hangers-on about the ranch. Breakfast over, the sheriff and his men came out, took up their guns without examining them, mounted their horses and resumed their journey towards San Juan Capistrano. At a point about midway from the Sepulveda ranch and San Juan some men, twelve or fifteen in number, were seen by the sheriff, who was riding in advance of his deputies, they being strung out along the road, with Hardy and the Frenchman on his mule, quite a distance in the rear. As soon as the men saw the sheriff they called to him not to fire upon them as they were friends. They came up rapidly and as they were near enough, fired, and with deadly effect, for the sheriff and his three deputies, after emptying their guns with no apparent effect, fell dead in their tracks. As soon as Hardy heard the firing he rode rapidly to the scene ; as he approached he saw the sheriff and his men lying in a heap together, dead. He thought he could do nothing alone, and, wheeling his horse, rode swiftly back towards Los Angeles. His fleet horse soon took him away from the bandits, who overtook the Frenchman, but did not molest him in any way, as they were after Hardy. It was fortunate that he had chosen their fastest horse, for the bandits soon gave up the chase.
Reaching Los Angeles, he told the news of the killing of the sheriff" and his men, and soon a party was being organized to go in search of the murderers. In Los Angeles excitement ran high, and it was some time before a party could be organized. In the American settlement at El Monte, not far from Los Angeles, were several settlers who were used to the hard life of the frontier and were none too law-abiding ; they wanted blood and were ever ready for a fight. These joined the posse from Los Angeles and soon, under the wise guidance of General Pico, a brother of Governor Pico, who was very cool in the face of danger, had an understanding that Pico's orders would be obeyed by all. The general decided to catch the men who had committed this wanton murder and he counseled caution among the men.
After killing the sheriff and his men the bandits headed for San Juan Capistrano, raided the store for supplies, as they were headed for the Mexican border, and possibly looking for Hardy and his team, who had in the meantime gone into the mountains and taken a roundabout way back to Los Angeles, which he reached a week later. When the pursuing party reached the town they found the bandits had fled, and then began one of the notable man-hunts in Southern California.
The bandits made for the mountains by way of Santiago Canyon, were followed by Pico and his men, who tracked them to the top of a ridge where they could not get away, as it was found to be too steep. They had let down one of their horses with ropes, but it was killed in falling, and they then gave up all hope of escape. Flores abandoned his horse and, with two others, took to the brush on foot and made good their escape. One young man who was known by Pico, was called upon to give himself up and for the information he would give, was told he would not be prosecute(J. He followed this advice, and after some parley the rest of the band were taken prisoners, bound hand and foot and turned over to the Americans in the party, who took them to a settlement on the present site of Olive. They were placed in an adobe house and kept securely bound and placed under guard. Pico went after Flores and the two others, and by his knowledge of the country, and being an expert trailer, soon captured the former, who was sent back to be kept under guard with the others. He, too, was securely bound and placed on the floor with the rest, and, as usual, the guard was posted over them. During the night Flores rolled over to one of the other prisoners, and with his teeth loosed the thongs that bound him and, this done, his own were taken off, and soon all of the men were free and made
A runner was sent to inform Pico of the escape and he was met coming in with the other two men. whom he had captured alone. Upon hearing the news he was angry, for he had thought the Americans would surely be watchful and not let the prisoners get away. He was determined that these last two prisoners should not escape and, taking them to a large sycamore tree in the canyon, hung them. To show that he had done his duty and partly avenged the death of the sheriff, he cut off the ears of the bandits and sent them to Los Angeles, and then took up the trail of the chief conspirator. These bodies w^ere left hanging, and it was some time the next year that the bones were buried. The writer buried some of them himself. The tree from which these men were hung is still standing on what is known as the Alodjeska ranch.
Pico followed the trail of Flores for some days, seeming to know about where he would eventually be found. The news had spread to Los Angeles of the bandit's escape, and the citizens were thoroughly aroused, for Barton had teen very popular. Flores thought to steal a horse at Los Nietos, knowing that Mr. Carpenter kept many good animals. He approached the place at night, and the dogs alarmed the owner, who was asleep on a stack of hay ; as he aro.se with a gun in his hands Flores could see by the bright moonlight that it would be useless to try to secure a horse there and so passed on. Arriving in Los Angeles he tried to obtain food and shelter, but such was the feeling that had it become known such aid had been given him the persons so doing would have been lynched. He then skirted the town and made for the Cahuenga Mountains. Pico followed him, and at a point about the present site of Hollywood, came upon his man almost exhausted, made him prisoner and brought him to Los Angeles and turned him over to the people, who erected two poles with a bar across, at the present site of the county court house, and hung him. The other bandits were taken to Los Angeles and shared the same fate. The last one of the band was captured in San Jose two years later and was returned for trial. After a year in the courts with the lawyers wrangling over the case, his attorneys had the case transferred to Santa P.arbara County.
The good citizens of Los Angeles had patiently stootl the delay and thought that justice would be done by the court, but when the case was ordered transferred, took the law in their own hands and, taking him from the officers, made another "example" of him. There was no doubt of his identity, for when he was captured he was wearing the silver mounted belt that had belonged to the sherifif he had helped to kill. There are comparatively few men now living who recall the incidents noted here. The writer, who is one of the oldest living .American settlers of Orange County, was an eyewitness of the hanging of F'lores.
The only case of mob violence in Santa Ana history occurred August 20, 18')2. when Francisco Torres was hanged to a telephone pole at the northeast of Fourth and Sycamore streets. William McKelvey, foreman of ^ladame Modjeska's famous ranch home in Santiago Canyon, was brutally murdered July 31. 1892, by this Mexican, who was employed as a laborer under him. Torres fled, was captured at Mesa Grande a couple of weeks after the crime and brought to this city, where he was held for the murder, without bail, and was confined in the old jail on Sycamore Street, between Second and Third. McKelvey had many friends in this city and the officers, fearing trouble, placed Robert Cogburn on guard at the jail. About one o'clock on the morning of August 20 there Avas an alarm at the jail door and a muffled demand to open it. which order Mr. Coghurn refused to obey. Immediately the door was battered in with a sledge .and about thirty men, armed and masked, filed inside. Upon being refused the keys to the cell they forcibly took them from the guard, secured Torres and departed. Mr. Cogburn attempted to follow them, but, upon being invited to return to the jail at the point of what appeared to him a "horizontal telegraph pole," returned to his duties without any further desire to associate with his determined and systematic visitors. There was evidently no time wasted with the captive, and he was strung up to the pole, where the body remained as a gruesome surprise to early risers the next morning. An attempt was made to locate the perpetrators of the lynching through the grand jury, but no indictments were issued and the affair was quietly dropped in official circles.
Perhaps the most notable political event in Santa Ana's history was the physical undoing of Dennis Kearney, in the fall of 1879. This man was campaigning the state in the interest of the workingman's party and the anti-Chinese movement, which at that time was a formidable issue in California politics. He was popularly known as the "sand lot agitator," and, starting from his home in San Francisco, he deluged the state with a ceaseless flow of vituperation and platform blackguardism. Up to the time of his arrival in Santa Ana he had been allowed to pursue his bullying style of oratory without molestation, as his own personality and the many followers who flocked to his support all over the state presented an aspect of brute force which no one seemed disposed to investigate.
In his speech here, in addition to the usual program of abuse, he also included a number of false accusations against the McFadden brothers, who had operated a steamer from Newport to San Francisco, but had been compelled to sell it at a considerable loss to their stronger competitors, the Old Line Steamship Company, and it was this transaction to which Ivearney devoted his slanderous tongue.
' Among the employes of the McFaddens was "Tom" Rule, a man of large stature, supreme courage and prodigious strength. The morning following the speech, as Kearney was about to take the stage for San Diego at the old Layman Hotel, he was confronted by ]\Ir. Rule who demanded the name of the man who tiad given him the lying information concerning his employers. Kearney recognized the nature of the trouble in store for him at once, and immediately lost the nerve which had been so proudly exploited by his followers. He timidly explained that he "would not give away his friends," and upon a second and more imperious demand for the name, commenced backing away from his unwelcome opponent, at the same time endeavoring to draw his revolver. Rule, who was unarmed, hesitated no longer, but struck the ])ride of the sand lots a heav\ blow which landed him against the side of the hotel, from whence the once feared Kearney ran with great vigor and utter lack of dignity to the barroom, out through the dining room and across the street into a drug store, where he was overtaken by the now thoroughly aroused Rule, who pinned him to the floor and pummeled him (|uite severely. By a strange coincidence Kearney was rescued from his very mortifying position by one of the INIcFadden brothers, neither of whom had known of Mr. Rule's contemplated raid on their slanderer. None of his adherents had oft'ered him the slightest assistance, and his departure was in marked contrast to his triumphant entry into the town the day before. In his speeches he had advocated hemp and mob law for the hated plutocrats and capitalists, but certainly did not relish an application of his own medicine. He had announced on his home sand lot platform, before departing on this campaign : "I hope I will be assassinated, for the success of this movement depends on - that" ; but the sacrifice palled upon his appetite when the opportunity for which he had .so eagerly petitioned presented itself in apparent good working order. This incident, which was at once luraMed over the state, had the effect of imme diately diminishing Kearney'- powrr and influence to an alarming extent, and he soon passed into history as a incrc blatherskite.
Mr. Rule, who was the regular pilot at Newport Bay, was drowned a few/ years later while attempting to cross the bar at the entrance of the bay in a row* boat, which capsized in the breakers. The hero of the Kearney episode was struck upon the head by the boat as it overturned and his body immediately sank, being recovered several days afterward just inside the bar.
Provenance
Text from History of Orange County, California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Earliest Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.