BlockBefore

Pomona, California - History (part 6 of 21)

From History of Pomona Valley, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the Valley Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present .., published 1920. 15,936 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

15 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,936 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Pomona Valley, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the Valley Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present .., published 1920. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Perhaps the most important fact in the early history of Pilgrim Clunxh is that it was the alma mater of two other institutions - the Claremont Church and Pomona College. This was due very largely to the influence of Dr. C. B. Sumner, the "father of the college." who was also the first pastor of Pilgrim Church. As a home missionary for the church in Southern California, Doctor Sumner had only consented to the organization of the church at Pomona after he had become convinced of its imperative need, and also, almost at the same time, of the ideal character of the location for a college of high standard, both intellectually and spiritually. Under his leadership the church became self-supporting within four months, and the people were making heroic efforts to start the college. Before the end of the first year they surrendered Doctor Sumner to the more important and more strenuous labor of launching the college. Though now serving a constituency which includes the whole Southwest and is unlimited by denomination, yet Pomona College was born of Pilgrim Church. From the day when Doctor Sumner first presented the subject in one of his first sermons to the church (meeting then in the Opera House before its own building was finished), this body was most helpful, in great loyalty and sacrifice. After the organization of the board of trustees of Pomona College, and before its formal opening at the beginning of the academic year 1888-1889, it became important to carry on classes for a group of students completing their preparation for college, and Prof. F. P. Brackett was asked to take charge of this work. These classes met during the first half of the year, 1888, in the chapel of Pilgrim Church, and some of these students formed the nucleus of the first graduating class. The beginnings of the college are sketched more fully in the story of Claremont, told in the last chapter.

The old Opera House at the corner of Third and Thomas streets was used for meetings by the Unitarians after the Congregationalists moved into their chapel, diagonally across the road. Rev. O. Clute was their minister from the organization in 1888 until he became president of the State Agricultural College of Michigan, in the summer of 1889. Then for a time funds and membership fell off and the services were discontinued. They were resumed, however, in 1890, with the Rev. E. C. L. Brown as preacher, and still in the Opera Hou=e. In 1893 a new building was erected and dedicated in May, under the pastorate of Ulysses G. B. Pierce, later chaplain in the United States Senate.

In the years since the period covered by this sketch, the church life of the community has developed with the growth of the city. Xew churches have been formed, notably the Christian Science Church, whose earnest following has been drawn largely from the older churches of the city. But this development of church life appears not so much in a larger number of churches as in greatly increased membership, in a larger range of usefulness, and in beautiful church buildings, more worthy of the forms of worship and more adequate to the increased activity of the modern church. These more stately edifices, like the higher type of homes in which the people live, reflect the larger life and the better circumstances which prosperity has brought.

Throughout the history of the town the relations between the various churches have been unusually harmonious. By union services, by joint campaigns, by mutual understandings, tacit and expressed, a cordial fellowship has been mamtained between leaders and people as well.

A writer having affiliation with one or more of the great fraternities might very properly devote much attention to the history of these orders, which fill so large a place in the life of their members and of the city. It must suffice, however, in the present circumstances to refer very briefly to the beginnings of the older fraternities as recorded in other histories. Thus it is stated : that the Independent Order of Odd Fellows was organized ^lay 30, 1876, with H. Eno, J- E. McComas, George C. Egan and Louis Phillips as officers, meeting in the new Central School House ; this following an earlier organization in Spadra, in which Cyrus Burdick was also an officer : that a lodge of the Free and Accepted JNIasons was formed January 25. 1878, W. T. Martin, L. D. Conner, J. H. Egan, T. I^Iercer, J. B. Parker, Charles Weile, J. Schlesinger, J. J. Jester and John White being installed as officers, the ceremony of installation conducted by R. C. Fryer, past master of the Lexington Lodge at El Monte ; and that the Aetna Lodge of the Knights of Pythias was organized August 30, 1884, with twenty-five charter members, including the officers, E. A. de Camp, R. N. Loucks and F. C. Schumacher.

In the summer of 1886 a military company was organized, with about sixty men. P. S. Dorney first, and then A. T. Palmer was elected Captain, and H. E. Stoddard and C. I. Lorbeer, Lieutenants. In October, 1887, they were mustered in as members of the State Militia. The old Opera House, where the Investment Building now stands, was the company's headquarters until it burned, in December, 1895, when they began to plan for an armory, which was later erected with the aid of the ^lutual Building and Loan Association. Much of the money for equipment, and then for building the armory, was raised by dramatic performances, which were always notable events. In promoting these, as in other affairs related to the company, Frank W. Balfour was especially active. A large number of the ablebodied young men of Pomona have served in its Company D, Seventh Regiment,

History And Biography 167

During the captaincy of Terrel B. Thomas many of the company volunteered for service in the Spanish-American \\'ar. Again, at the time of the earthquake at San Francisco, the company did valiant service under Capt. W. E. Stevens.

Of the six or seven newspapers now published in the A'alley, the Pomona Progress has the longest unbroken record, dating from January, 1885, but the Bulletin is the true successor of the Pomona Times, which was first published in October, 1882.

It is said* that a paper called The Nezc Era was published before this, but its description as a paper gotten out by the Pomona Land Company and edited by its secretary, L. M. Holt, also applies to the A''c"zc' Italy, which has been described at some length in the chapter on the "Beginnings of Pomona." Failure to find any copies of The Neii' Bra has raised the question whether they were not one and the same paper. At any rate, such a paper, issued for a brief time by a real estate corporation and published in Los Angeles, can hardly be regarded as a real newspaper of the A^alley.

Hence it is probably true that "the newspaper history of Pomona begins in 1882, when \\'. D. IMorton and H. N. Short moved a small and very crude printing plant from Santa Ana into this settlement and began publication of the Pomona Times. October 7, 1882."

The paper has had a checkered career from the first. A year and a half later, April 5, 1884, it combined with the Pomona Courier, which had been established by John H. Lee in December, 1883. It was then called the Times-Courier, and was edited jointly by ]\Iorton and Lee, Mr. Short having withdrawn. The first editorial of the joint publication says : "The Pomona Times and the Pomona Courier have clasped hands across the bloody chasm, and this week appear as one journal." In November, 1885, W. D. Morton retired and Charles E. Sumner bought out his interest, the paper continuing with Lee and Sumner, publishers, and C. E. Sumner, editor. This arrangement continued until 1888, when }ilr. Sumner sold his half in»the paper to William E. Ward. In the meantime both the Times- Courier and the Progress had undertaken the publication of a daily edition. The former intended to surprise its rival in the publication of the first daily paper, but the Progress heard of it in time to get out one also the very same day. The Times-Courier claimed to have won the contest, however, by appearing two hours earlier than the Progress! The next important change in its career is described in the article referred to above, as follows: "Pomona was at this time in the throes of a revolution over the banishment of the saloon. The temperance people wanted a newspaper advocate of their cause. Neither the Times-Courier nor the Progress up to this date had come out in opposition to the liquor traffic, notwithstanding the city had voted "dry.' .-\fter consultation with Mr. Lee, the senior member of the Times-Courier firm, and gaining his consent to their plans, the anti-saloon people finally induced Gen. John Wasson, at that time editor of the Chino Champion, to buy Mr. Ward's interest in the Times-Courier. At this time the saloon and the anti-saloon elements were about evenly divided. It was a hazardous undertaking to endeavor to change public opinion in favor of the complete banishment of the saloon ; and while success finally crowned the efforts of the temperance people, the result was a death blow to the Times. A boycott was started and the Times lost half of its subscribers and fully a third of its advertising patronage in three months. It was never afterward able to recover its oldtiriie financial prestige." General Wasson continued as editor for some years, but Mr. Lee sold out, and his interest was held in turn by \\'illard Goodwin, C. B. Messenger, C. B. Roberts and H. H. Kinney. Then, after the death of General Wasson, the paper returned to the weekly form. Since its recent purchase by the brothers, E. E. and W. M. King, the name has been changed to the Bulletin; it has again become a daily paper and is infused with new life.

The record of the Pomona Progress is not so varied. Its essential character, like its name - conservative-progressive - has been unchanged from the first, and its publication has been uninterrupted, while its proprietors and editors have been at times succeeded by others. ]\Ir. Edward E. Stowell was its first editor and publisher, and then, after his death, from March, 1888, Messrs. H. G. Tinsley and C. I. Lorbeer. About the first of August, 1891, when General Wasson entered upon his campaign as editor of the Times-Courier, Mr. S. jSI. Haskell came on the staff of the Progress, being for two or three years associated with Mr. Tinsley, and then buying out his interest.

Mr. Haskell's direction of the Progress was the longest of any until the present management, and his character and ideals were firmly impressed upon the paper. During his administration in 1898, the Daily Progress was permanently established, the former daily, like that of the Times, having been discontinued with the depression following the boom. In February, 1905, Captain Stevens and Almon T. Richardson, the present owners, bought the paper and plant of Mr. Haskell, and have edited it together ever since. Already their control of almost fifteen years has outrun that of any others. Of the steady growth of the Progress during their control, and of its present character and influence, it would be superfluous to write.

Mr. H. G. Tinsley may well be called "the veteran newspaper man" in the Valley, for of those who are still in "the harness" here, Mr. Tinsley's work in the Valley began first. Stowell and Lorbeer and Wasson have passed on, but Lee and Sumner and Haskell are engaged in other work, the last two. in Los Angeles. Mr. Tinsley, after retiring from the Progress, was engaged in other work till 1904, when he purchased the Pomona Reviezv, which he has edited since that time. The Rci'iciv was the successor, under A. M. Dunn, in 1900, of the Saturday Beacon, which Ben Havner started in 1895.

Other papers there have been in Pomona, but usually short-lived or merged in older publications. The Pomona Rustler, published in 1884 by Charles Buck, and the Pomona Register, begun in 1888 by John Symes, also the Pomona Telegram, in 1886, were all bought and absorbed by the Progress.

One can hardly rate too highly the value of Pomona's papers to the people of the Valley. In their primary function as purveyors of news they have been diligent and faithful ; as vehicles of expression for the people they have usually been open to all reasonable requests ; as leaders in radical movements for the advancement of the community their policies have differed, ranging from indifference or studied non-committal at times, to a strong and persuasive campaign for shaping and guiding public opinion, or even to the most vigorous and fearless espousal of an unpopular cause.

Rut whatever their confessed policy, and whether designedly or not, the newspapers also serve another and most desirable end. They furnish a detailed history of the region, or at least a mass of data, with much of color and prejudice, to be sure, invaluable to any writer of history. The almost unbroken file of the Progress, which that paper has had the wisdom to preserve, is of priceless worth to the town. Annual numbers, like the Pictorial Annual for 1886 of the Pomona Times-Courier, for instance, with their carefully prepared reviews, should be preserved with especial care.

The "Pomona \"alley Historical Collection," in the Pomona Library, which has been formed for the preservation of all such material, deserves the interest and support of all people and institutions in the Valley.

Pomona Public Library

The Pomona Public Library, as a municipal institution, dates from June, 1890, when a board of trustees appointed by the city council officially organized and took possession of a collection of books and other property which had been acquired with great pains by a group of interested individuals. The real beginning of the library was the organization of the Pomona Public Library and Floral Association, in May, 1887. Its first officers were Mrs. E. P. Bartlett, president; Mrs. U. E. Strong and Mrs. M. Kirkland, vice-presidents ; Mrs. R. N. Loucks, secretary, and Mrs. H. J. St. John, treasurer. They opened rooms in the Ruth Block, and Mrs Bartlett, who was the untiring leader and inspiration of the whole movement, was appointed librarian. Money was raised by contributions and membership fees, but especially by flower festivals, which usually provided $400 or $500 annually for the purchase of books.

In June. 1889, the association offered to give the library to the city, but Pomona was not ready yet to undertake its support. The city agreed, however, to pay for rent and gas in the new quarters to which the library was moved in the First National Bank Building, then just completed. By the terms of the agreement the offer of the library to the city was open for a year. At the expiration of this time the library was formally accepted by the city. The first board of trustees, appointed by the city council, was composed -of the following men: Rev. C. F. Loop, Dr. C. \\'. Brown, J. H. Dole, C. I. Lorbeer and F. J. Smith.

Two events of special consequence have marked new periods of advance in the history of the library. The first event was the gift to the city of the "Goddess Pomona," a marble statue presented by Mr. Loop. While traveling with his family abroad j\lr. Loop saw the original of this statue in the Uffizi Gallery at Florence, and was at once impressed with its beauty and with its symbolic worth to his own city in California. Upon inquiry he found that it was a classic work of art which had only recently been unearthed, though probably centuries old, and he arranged for the sculpture of a replica by the Italian artist,' Antonio Fri!li. It was the presentation of this beautiful statue and the evident necessity of housing it properly that led to the first arrangement with the city and the removal to the

The second event of special importance in the library development was the building of the new Carnegie Library. The first building was begun in 1902 and completed in 1903, and when this became inadequate an addition was built, in 1912 to 1913. The story of the efforts to secure these buildings, the meeting of the conditions, the drawing up of the plans, cannot be told here ; but too much credit cannot be given to those, especially to Arthur ]\I. Dole, by whom it was accomplished.

Pomona has been peculiarly fortunate in its librarians, I\Iiss IMabel Prentiss and Aliss S. M. Jacobus. The latter, since her coming in 190.^, has been not only a most efficient librarian, but a generous servant of the people in many ways.

Social Life In Pomona

The social activities of a city center for the most part in its churches and its fraternities and clubs. Apart from these, or to some extent overlapping these, are other associations which more or less regularly bring people together in a social way. Even to enumerate all these in a work like this would be impossible. Sometimes it has been a school district, or the people of a neighborhood like the Kingsley Tract ; sometimes the people from an Eastern city or state have formed a somewhat homogeneous colony, like the lowans, or the people from Missouri, or the Burlington, \'ermonters. The Grand Army Post and the National Guard in the days of Balfour, and Driffil and Thomas were especially conspicuous with notable dramatic performances. In the days of the boom the Hotel Palomares was a favorite center.

The Choral L^nion. organized in 1888 and directed for some years by Professor Brackett of the College, brought together the singers from all the churches of the \'alley and gave opera and concert performances at certain times.

To a remarkable extent the social life of the town has found expression in manifold kinds of practical service rather than in pure social enjoyment. This has been true in all sorts of occasions for the raising of money for a thousand and one useful ends, like the flower festivals already mentioned, or in all the beautiful work of the Fruit and Flower Mission of earlier days, and, of course, more recently in the magnificent service of the Red Cross. It has been true also in the clubs for intellectual development and culture, especially in the women's clubs. After the churches, the schools and the papers, perhaps no influence has been more potent in Pomona than that of its women's clubs. Not only in the social life, but in literary, dramatic, economic and political matters, the women in these organized groups have distinctly raised the standards of living, besides accomplishing numerous specific and desirable objects. The first of these clubs was called the Pomona Woman's Club, and was organized in 1892. But the organization and activities of the other strong clubs which have been formed in later years lie outside the scope of this history.

Of untold blessing to the whole A'alley, as well as to Pomona itself, is the new Pomona \'alley Hospital, built in 1914 through the diligent efforts of Dr. Swindt and Dr. Kelly, ably seconded by other Pomona physicians, as well as by Dr. Thomas of Claremont, Dr. Brown of San Dimas and Dr. Hubbell of La \'^erne.

Chapter Nine Pomona'S Municipal Life

Incorporation and Liquor Fight - Before Incorporatiox - The Great Issue - Druxkexxess - The Conflict - Chinese Problem - Other Problems AND Contests - The ]\Iurchison Letter - -JMunicipal Solidarity.

Under the county government before the city was incorporated, the laws were not severe nor rigorously enforced. The district was "a law unto itself," or one might say that a kind of low license prevailed. Constables of the township were responsible for its good order, and cases were tried before justices of the peace. Rarely did a case come before the county courts or a county sheriff arrest a notorious offender.

In its first issue of October 7, 1882, the Pomona Times includes in its list of county officers, J. B. Parker as justice of the peace for Pomona, and Joe Wright for Spadra ; also \\'. H. H. Scott as constable for Pomona and D. R. Lilly for Spadra. W. T. ^lartin, often mentioned in this history, is also well remembered as justice of the peace for years in the early days, and many interesting stories are told of the "good old days" when Toots Martin held court.

Incorporation And Liquor Fight

There was repeated agitation for incorporation, beginning long before it was accomplished. In January, 1884, Len Claiborne and others urged the matter, and the Courier published the charter for a municipal corporation of the sixth class according to the laws of the State. In December, 1886, another agitation resulted in a mass meeting at which J. E. McComas presided and J. R. Garthside was clerk. Len Claiborne brought in a petition for incorporation, to which he had secured forty-two signatures. Mr. Aston and Mr. \\'eile, among others, spoke in its favor, saying that sanitary conditions demanded it, and proposing to include a considerable part of the Pomona Tract surrounding the Townsite proper. P. C. Tonner was rather noncommittal: if a majority of the citizens in the 640 acres of the Townsite wanted it, all right ; but the neighboring tract should not be compelled to come in, nor should the saloons have to bear the burden ! Already the problem of the saloons is involved in the question of incorporation. H. A. Palmer spoke at length in favor of the fifth-class municipality instead of the sixth, but pointed out that a population of over 3,000 was required, and that it would therefore be better to wait. The outcome of the meeting was that a motion that it was "for the best interests of Pomona to incorporate" was lost.

In ?\Iarch, 1887, another movement led by Attorney Claiborne culminated in an election. The limits proposed were White Avenue, Alvarado Street, Towne and Crow (later Grand) avenues. The proposition was opposed by such men as Judge Firey, Armour and French, who believed the area proposed was too small. They favored incorporation, but "wanted it right." In the election there were 72 votes for incorporation and 110 against it.

Toward the end of the year 1887 everyone wanted incorporation, but there was still a sharp conflict between opposing forces. Xow, however, the battle front was changed as tlie new issue became clearer. On one side were the saloon element and those who were in favor of an open town ; on the other side were the anti-saloon forces and those who were determined to establish a better order. A few citizens of highest character were conscientiously opposed to the restrictions proposed by the anti-saloon party, and failed to apprehend the magnitude of the issue. High license had not been a success, and the real question was whether the incorporation should permit drunkenness and license of every sort to continue, or whether it should be in such form as to forbid these evils and to encourage the coming of a better class of citizens who would build up a clean, progressive city.

It is doubtless well now to forget the names of the leaders of the saloon forces ; and just because they so highly deserve recognition no attempt will be made to list the leaders on the other side, since any such enumeration must necessarily omit some tmknown to the writer who were just as worthy of mention. The churches and most of the women, of course, were arrayed against the saloon ; and we have already referred to the way in which General Wasson, editor of the Times, championed their cause, and at what cost. But there were two attorneys whose relations to the struggle were such that they cannot escape the historian's notice. One of these was P. C. Tonner, whose character and habits have been portrayed at some length. In this portrayal and in the anecdotes concerning Constable Slanker, some idea has also been conveyed of the conditions existing in the town. Before the boom in 1882, when the population numbered about 500, there were fourteen or fifteen saloons, or one to every thirty-five people. That would be a saloon for every seven families ( !) according to the usual reckoning; and if it be contended that there was then a large population of men without families, it is also true that there was a large share of the population with families of a dozen or more. Women avoided the streets downtown, because of the offensive sights - kegs of liquor on the sidewalks, men standing on the corners and spitting tobacco juice on the walks, others staggering along half drunk and perhaps accosting familiarly any passing lady; others sometimes lying dead drunk in the gutter. When the men working for Fleming and Becket in digging the tunnel north of town were discharged on Saturday night, they would make directly for the saloons in Pomona ; and it was necessary Monday morning for someone to "round them up" like cattle and haul them back to their jobs before the work could go on. Sometimes in a wave of indignation a group of citizens would take matters into their own hands, as when the editor of one of the papers and a few others turned the fire hose on a house of low reputation and drove the notorious offenders out of town ! This condition was greatly improved as the town grew, from 1882 to 1887, and especially in 1887. We have seen that Constable Slanker was elected to that office at the beginning of this year, as Senator ]\IcComas urged, "to clean up the town." And though he had made great progress, by the honest enforcement of such laws as were in force, yet the conditions were deplorable, though not so public.

The other attorney, so conspicuous in the struggle, was Charles E. Sumner, who had been living a hermit's life in Live Oak Canyon on account of his health, and who now came down from his retreat like another David against the Goliath of the Philistines. In the end Tonner and Sumner were both elected on a committee to draw up the articles of incorporation for the city. Both were keen attorneys and the result might easily have been a compromise, but the extreme terms of Attorney Sumner were at last adopted by popular vote, and the first and most important victory was won for good order. But a long contest followed in the enforcement of the new liquor laws. Sumner was elected city attorney for this purpose and gave his wliole time to the struggle. The laws which he had framed himself were well calculated to accomplish the desired end. One clause prohibited visiting a saloon. Some startling arrests were made and there was furious indignation, but the cases were tried and convictions followed. One man was tried for visiting a saloon, before a judge who was himself in the saloon at the time ! Altogether eighteen cases were tried under this ordinance while Attorney Sumner was in office, and convictions were secured in every case. IMoreover, the Supreme Court sustained all the cases carried to it.

Other able men succeeded Attorney Sumner in the city office, who also won important battles for the city. Among those who have served in this capacity were Robert Loucks, Edward J. Fleming, J. Joos and C. W. Guerin, whose ten years now in the office are sufficient evidence of his ability.

The Chinese Problem

In 1885 and 1886 the town of Pomona was much excited over the presence in its midst of the "heathen Chinee." For there was a "Chinese \"illage" then between First and Second streets and extending east from Garey Avenue - a series of cheap one-story shacks - and there was much complaint because of the filth around the village. There were items in the papers about it, and occasionally an editorial. Toots Martin one day advertised an "Anti-Chinese Garden," with the injunction "Patronize our own people and have done, once and for all with the heathen." Whether the agitation would have been created if there had not been a general movement against the Chinese throughout the state is doubtful. But in the month of March, 1886, there was organized "The Pomona Branch of the Nonpartisan Anti-Chinese League." The Progress came out with a boycott editorial, advising against a wholesale simultaneous boycott as likely to precipitate war and impossible of success, "but a carefully considered and systematized attempt applied to one business after another * * * may win." "John Must Go" is the heading of the article in the next issue reporting the proceedings of the second meeting of the Non-partisan League. At this meeting Toots IMartin was in the chair and C. L Lorbeer presented the report of the executive committee. This contained four recommendations, requesting the people : first, to withdraw patronage from Chinese laborers and merchants ; second, to patronize the two American laundries : third, to replace Chinese labor by white ; and fourth, to discriminate in favor of American goods when purchasing. Ln the course of the discussion which followed, Mr. Eno spoke for the Chinese. He thought it wasn't good and Christian-like to boycott them. What would become of the 200,000 Chinese in the state if this plan were carried out? What of the merchants? Should they be allowed to starve? And Air. Aston, the undertaker, replied: "I have been here for thirty years [not quite] and I have always boycotted the Chinese [doubtless] because I knew them to be a damage to the morals of the country as well as a blight upon its material well doing [ !] The Chinese are a growing plague-spot upon the future of our children, and a constant and growing menace to the laboring masses. * * * I would refuse a Chinaman employment, [yes] but were he hungry I'd feed him[?] ; were he sick Fd nurse him [fancy!] ; were he dead I'd bury him!" [verily he would]. Followed then Mr. Hicklin, the liveryman, who declared that those who oppose the boycott only whimper, and whine, and dodge, and squirm, but they have no case. "Let the people stand together and hj-pocrisy must stand aside." So the boycott was put in operation and "John" was so hard hit that he did have to go. In course of time the httle chister of old houses with the picturesque (though quite untidy) fronts with the red and gold paper name plates, inscribed in big Chinese hieroglyphics, were deserted, and then they were all removed.

The unreasoning prejudice against Orientals as a class had its own way in F'omona. as it would in many quarters toda}-. Few seemed to have learned to discriminate between the Chinese merchant or laundryman or vegetable man who is always honest and reliable, on the one hand, and the Japanese speculator who corners the vegetables of a State and destroys enough of the crop to maintain his high prices, or who illegally acquires great tracts of land, who can not be trusted either in private or in public affairs. Shall we ever learn that corrective legislation should be directed against the evil itself, directly, and not in sweeping eviction of a race. How easily the uncleanliness of the lower Chinese classes is regulated and their faithful service to the people retained! The more flagrant and national crimes of the Japanese must also be met by direct legislation, by far more strict and universal immigration laws, by immediate and severe punishment of offenders and by many individual deportations, rather than by unwarranted discrimination against a proud nation as a whole.

One important result of the Chinese agitation was the incorporation of the Pomona Steam Laundry, with J. B. Camp as president and C. I. Lorbeer, secretary. The latter raised a large part of the capital stock by solicitation.

Other Problems And Contests

Not all of Pomona's "scraps" have been intra-mural. She has shared more or less in contests of county and State, as in the movement in 1885 for a division of the State (though by no means unanimously), and in the later struggle to form a new county, to be called San Antonio County and to include the portion of Los .\ngeles County from Azusa eastward, and the portion of San Bernardino County from Cucamonga westward. This movement also, though possessing more of merit and winning a larger following, was by no means unanimous. There have been battles also, almost literally, between the city and great corporations demanding entrance with unwarranted rights. There was the fight against the Sunset Telephone Company which undertook to erect its poles without a franchise and was only prevented by the actual fighting off of its laborers. City Attorney Loucks himself chopping down one of the poles. Combining with Los Angeles and Pasadena, the case was carried to the Superior Court and won.

Within the memory of many was the plucky fight in defense of the Salt Lake Railway's right of way, when the Southern Pacific attempted to defeat them by interfering with their laying of track and running a train over the road in specified time. The mayor. W. H. Poston. himself drove about the town sending men to the scene with shovels and hoes ; and the foreman of the Southern Pacific gang was spirited away in a wagon till the work was done and the franchise secured.

Probably no event has given Pomona and a Pomona citizen the notoriety that came with the publication of the "Alurchison Letter" and the disclosure that its author was a Pomona man. The letter, it will be recalled, was a decoy letter written to Lord Sackville-West, British Ambassador in the United States, from a son of British parentage, asking for advice in his exercise of the newly acquired right of franchise. When the Murchison letter and tlie Sackville-W'est reply were published they created a profound sensation, not only in California but throughout this country and England. The author of the letter was known at first to only 3 select few, including Attorneys P. C. Tonner and W. A* Bell, Judge W. F. Fitzgerald, of the Republican State Executive Committee for Southern California, and Colonel Otis of the Los Angeles Times. It was to have been a secret until the day of President Harrison's inauguration, but some one "let the cat out of the bag," and George Osgoodby of Pomona was revealed as the real and only writer of the "JMurchison Letter."

In November, 1910, after much careful study and discussion, a Board of Freeholders was elected to prepare a new charter for the city, and in March, 1911, this charter was approved by the State Legislature.

Pomona has had a series of devoted and efficient mayors. The last during its existence as a mirnicipality of the sixth class was Colonel F. P. Firey, under whose administration the fine new city hall was erected. Air. Lee R. May, the first mayor under the new charter, served till 1913, when he was succeeded by Alayor \\'. A. A'andegrift, recently re-elected after six years of faithful service.

It is significant that the election of city officers in Pomona has rarely followed party lines. Mayors Firey, Poston and \'andegrift, and Attorney Guerin. have all been Democrats.' when the number of registered Democrats was only about 600. All were nominated and chosen for merit, regardless of party affiliation.

During the early nineties Pomona was represented in the Senate of the state. In 1889 Mr. J. E. McComas, who had been identified with the best life and growth of the city from its beginning, was elected on the Republican ticket, and served for four years as senator for this district.

In the thirty-two years since its incorporation, the municipality of Pomona has developed a strong corporate entitv and consciousness. It has had its nps and downs, its periods of inactivity, as in the days of depression following the boom, and its periods of advance, as in the prosperous years ; but on the whole it has a record of which the city may be proud.

Chapter Ten

Coming op the Santa Fe - Railroad Activities - Boom of New Tovvnsites - - Effect of Santa Fe on Southern Pacific and Pomona - North Pomona - La Verne, Lordsuurg and La Verne College - San Dimas - Mud Springs - Canyon Settlers - The Teagues - Mound City Land and Water Association - San Jose Ranch Company - \\'ater Companies and Litigation - Citrus Industry - Grovx'Th cf San Dimas - Charter Oak - Claremont and Pomona College - The Boom and Its Collapse - Indians and Wilds of the Desert - Toots Martin - Peter Fleming - Beginnings of Pomona College - Claremont Business and Citrus Fruits - School and Church.

The upper part of the San Jose Valley, from the north lines of the Rancho San Jose to the foothills, has been later in its development than the country farther south. Except for the settlement at Mud Springs, and a few scattered ranchers and bee men at the canyon mouths, this development began with the coming of the Santa Fe Railway. This event may be said to mark the division between the prehistoric and historic age of the foothill towns. Eastward from the moist lands of iNIud Springs to Cucamonga, the whole upper country, including the sites of Claremont, Upland and La Verne, was formerly known as the desert. Over it herds of wild antelope roamed, in the sage brush and cactus.

The Coming Of The Santa Fe

Rumors of the coming of another transcontinental railway line were heard as early as 1875, but it was not until 1885 that these rumors had any basis in fact. On the first of January, 1885, it was reported that an official of the Atlantic and Pacific Railway was visiting Los Angeles in the interests of terminal connections for that road, and the prediction was made that trains would be running from Pasadena to San Bernardino by January 1, 1886. Would the road come by way of Pomona, or what route would it follow? At this time there were three railway systems which were evidently working to establish overland connections, the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe, the Atlantic and Pacific, and the California Southern. But the public was informed repeatedly that they were not the same road at all, though some of the same stockholders were in each. It was necessary then for people coming to Pomona by the Santa Fe and Union Pacific to come first to Los Angeles and pay local fare from there to Pomona via the Southern Pacific.

The California Southern had built its line from Colton to San Diego and was running trains (by a contract with the Southern Pacific) from San Diego via Oceanside, Murrietta, Perris and Colton to Pomona and Los Angeles, and also over the Cajon Pass to connect with the Atlantic and Pacific at Barstow.

Arrangements were made by which Santa Fe trains from the East came from Colton to Los Angeles over the tracks of the Southern Pacific Railway. This arrangement continued for a year and a half and nothing was heard of the direct line for some time. The first of January, 1886, came and the first of January, 1887, but no railway. However, in November and December, 1886, surveying parties were noted running lines west from the San Gabriel and past !\Iud Springs. By the first week in January, construction forces of the "Los Angeles and San Gabriel Valley Railroad" had crossed the San Gabriel wash and were pushing toward ]Mud Springs. At the same time a gang of men were working westward from San Bernardino for the California Southern. During January and February, the coming railway was the most absorbing topic of conversation. It was definitely announced that the A. T. and S. F. Company had purchased the San Gabriel Valley Railway. A gap of only thirty-five miles remained. \\'hat would be its path across the Valley? Then came the representatives of the railroad to arrange terms for the right of way.

In February, 1887, about a dozen officials of the Los .Angeles and San Gabriel \''alley Railroad, in Judge Firey's oflice, met about twenty interested landowners, and separate agreements were drawn up granting right of way, with certain provisos as to the location of stations and stopping of trains. Ten acres at North Pomona were deeded by E. D. Rice, George Parsons and A. R. ]\Ieserve. It had not been decided whether the station should be called North Pomona or Palomares or Palermo. C. F. Loop and others deeded a one-hundred-foot right of way through the proposed town of Claremont. and passenger and freight stations were located on the east and west of Alexander Avenue. Others deeded the right of way east through Mud Springs.

A boom of new townsites along the right of way followed at once as a matter of course. In Alarch there was a special excursion to Azusa, which was for the moment the terminus of the San Gabriel Valley road. The Slausons, J. S. and J., officers of the new Azusa Land and Water Company, were in the party. Here, at the time of the auction sale, people stood in line all night to get a good choice of lots, and some paid fifty dollars for place in the line.

The new town of San Dimas was launched with much success by the San Jose Land Company, organized by ]\I. L. ^^'icks, and including thirty or forty others, among them a railway official whose inside knowledge was valuable. The lands offered for sale by the company included not only the town of San Dimas, but all of the San Jose Addition, which was subdivided into twenty-acre lots.

The boom sale was typical. The only building in sight was the boom hotel built by the company. Brass bands accompanied the excursionists and there was much excitement. One eager buyer who had selected a lot from the map went to the spot to see what it looked like before making his purchase, only to find, when he returned to the auctioneer, that the lot had been sold. Alore eager than ever then, he bought another on faith, and went afterward to look at it. This he found in a deep gully. "Well," he said, "I shall not have to do any excavating."

On the old homestead of W. N. Davis, south of Glendora, a new town, called Alosta, was laid out by George E. Gard and D. W. Field, and lots amounting' to $30,000 were sold at auction.

Claremont, which seems to have been also "on the inside," canle first among the towns farther east in its incorporation, advertising and auction sale. This is easily understood when one notes, in the list of the members of th.e company organized to promote the town, the names of F. S. Reigart of Topeka, and William Dunn, general agent of the California Southern Railroad. This company was incorporated January 20. 1887, under the name of the Pacific Land Improvement Company. It included also E. F. Kingman and George H. Fullerton of Riverside, the latter president of the company. The auction sale of Claremont lots was held April 14, after a month of judicious advertising. In May, on the 25th, was the opening sale of lots at Lordsburg, and a week later that of Palomares, as North Pomona was then called. Wholesale advertising preceded each public sale. The local and city papers published long articles and columns of announcements about the new towns and their auction sales. "Claremont the Pjeautiful" became a by-word; one article said, "There is no doubt but that every lot will be readily sold. Before the railroad connects with Los Angeles. Claremont will be a good-size town, with post, express, telephone, telegraph, hotel and newspaper offices, stores and residences." The clear mountain view, the artesian water already flowing in the town, and the attractions of the canyon and mountains all were lauded to the skies.

Attractions of the Palomares townsite were that two street railways would soon connect it with Pomona. Messrs. Firey, French and Company had a franchise for a line up Garey Avenue, and Packard and White had one up San Antonio Avenue. Meserve and Rice advertised "No chenanekin ("sic), no pool, no fixed price list."

The Claremont sale was really a remarkable success, due chiefly to the genial manner and good tactics of Frank ]\filler, whose preliminary campaign as general agent of the company had prepared the way, and of Col. W. H. Holabirc', who conducted the sale. Workmen were actually engaged in laying railway track 'hrough the town while the sale was in progress.

At the great pageant in 1913, celebrating the twenty-fifth anniversary of Pomona College, the scenes of this sale were re-enacted, Colonel Holabird himself taking his old part.

The sale at Lordsburg was also "an immense success." Three brass bands conducted as many excursion parties to the place. Twenty-five hundred people were present and lots amounting to $200,000 were sold. One purchaser, Herman Silver, gave $14,000 for Block 71, but the sales averaged from $250 to $500 each. At the Palomares auction a week later, the sale realized somewhat less than $30,000.

Before considering these new towns more in detail the influence of the new railroad upon Pomona and upon the Southern Pacific may be noted. The contrast between the policies of the two roads was striking. Before the advent of the Santa Fe there was only one local train a day to Los Angeles, and that a passenger car on a local freight. One would leave Pomona at about eight o'clock in the morning and arrive about noon. Returning, one might take an overland freight at sundown and reach Pomona about two o'colck in the night. As one old-timer said, "The policy of the old road was 'the public be damned' : the policy of the new road was to cater to the public in every way." This resulted in a marked improvement in the service of the Southern Pacific also. When it was evident that the Santa Fe would pass north of the city a movement was started at once to make connections with it. Colonel Firey, Charles French and others formed a company and built the line to Palomares (North Pomona) by way of

North Pomona

Of the four Santa Fe towns within the region covered in this history, the one nearest to Pomona was perhaps least likely, on account of its location, to become a large place, although just as highly favored by Nature as the others. The most attractive feature given the town by its promoters, the name of Palomares. has been changed to the uninteresting designation of North Pomona. Essentially a citrus growing district its chief buildings are the packing houses of the Indian Hill Citrus Association. A number of comfortable residences have been built among the orange groves. Its chief distinction is in the great Richards Orange Orchard, for a long time the largest orange grove in the world.

La Verne, Lordsburg And La Verne College

Since the town of Lordsburg has combined with the town of La A'erne and taken the name of La Verne City, it may be forgotten that they were formerly two distinct towns. Lying to the north of the City of Lordsburg, and the townsites of Palomares and North Palomares, La Verne extended from Claremont on the east to San Dimas on the west, the line of division being the old Dalton partition line, which is now the eastern line of B. A. Woodford's Valencia grove. Northward the district reaches over the mountains and is co-terminal with the county. The town itself was located on the highlands below the foothills which divide the San Dimas and San Gabriel basin on the west from the San Antonio and Santa Ana basin on the east. In their choice of soil and climate and view, the settlers of La Verne made no mistake ; in all these it is unexcelled. Only the location of the railway caused other towns, no more favored otherwise, to outstrip this one in population. And one of the preliminary surveys for the Santa Fe did pass through its center. A fine class of people composed its founders, among whom were L. H. Bixby, Solomon Gates, Dr. H. A. Reid and M. L. Douglas. A newspaper called the La Verne Nezvs was started in 1888, published by John Symes and edited by Dr. H.A. Reid. JMr. Frank AMieeler was one of La Verne's most earnest backers, and though his residence is now in Claremont, he is still lo_val to the many superlative merits of La A'erne.

More than once the place seemed likely to die for want of water. At times orange growers had to haul water in wagons for their trees, and the sources of supply were as remote as San Dimas and San Antonio canyons. La A'erne men were interested in boring for water on Indian Hill. Of the eighteen-year contest with San Dimas over its canyon supply, one writer said, "The case has finally been settled amicably to all parties. San Dimas and La A^erne both get the canyon water in winter, when neither of them want it, and both districts go without it in the summer time, when there is no water in the canyon, and when it is most needed." The same writer gives this account of the origin of the La A'erne Land and Water Company: "Many ranchers in La Verne * * * would be hauling water to their trees in tank-wagons today but for the magnanimity of R. A. AA'allace, who in 1899 owned a choice orange and lemon grove of twenty acres. AA'allace bought fifteen acres of unimproved land, put down a well to a depth of 310 feet, by way of an experiment, and was surprised to find, when tested, that he pumped over forty inches of water. This was more than he needed. He could have sold it at a fancy price. Instead of this, however, he called his friends and neighbors together and gave them the fifteen acres and the well at exact cost to him. Thus La Verne Land and Water Company was formed, all the stockholders being ranchers of the community. Only recently this company has been reorganized as the La Verne Water Company, combining with it the Live Oak Water Company, Mesa Land and Water Company, and La Verne Heights Water Company, with F. R. Curtis as president, and R. L. Davis, secretary."

It is only within a few years, that Lordsburg, like St. Petersburg, dropped its "burg" and, uniting with its neighbor and rival to the north, adopted its more euphonious and attractive name of La Verne City. It was first named Lordsburg because it was Lord's burg. A Mr. I. W. Lord bought the property of Col. George Heath and others north of the Mud Springs Road, and organized a company to promote the new town. It was at this time that J. W. Sallee sold his ranch for some $50,000, a fabulous sum to one who had never seen so much money in all his life. After this he was often seen about town, very much "stuck up," in an ill-fitting suit of clothes and a stove-pipe hat. The town was laid out with broad streets bordered with eucalyptus trees, and a number of buildings were put up, especially a large hotel building, the biggest of all the string of "boom" hotels that marked the young towns on the new road.

Soon, however, came the bursting of the boom and all development ceased. There remained, of course, the Mexican ranchers on their large estates south and west of the townsite, the Vejars and Yorbas, the Sotos and Carrions. To the north of the town proper and in La Verne a considerable acreage had been planted to citrus fruits, and ranchers had established their homes. Notable among these ranches was the Evergreen Ranch of 160 acres, purchased of the Sotos in 1884 by J. A. Packard of Chicago, who acquired a fortune in the manufacture of "Frazer's Axle Grease," bought the ranch, built a fine residence and developed a place often visited because of its beauty. Mr. Packard's example has been followed by others, especially in recent years, so that the place is known for its fine groves and its foothill homes.

the citrus groves to the north and cattle and grain ranches to the south, there was yet another element which helped to keep the town alive, during the slump in real estate and other activities which followed the boom. The huge caravansary built by Lord's company, after standing empty for some years, attracted a group of the Church of the Brethren, or Dunkers, sometimes called Dunkards, who saw in it an ideal center for a colony. In 1891 the building and grounds were purchased by a company of these men, consisting of David and Henry Kuns, Samuel Overholtzer and Daniel Houser, who became the trustees of the Lordsburg College. This name was changed to La Verne College later, when Lordsburg became La A'erne City. The importance of this institution lies in the fact that it is the only college of the Church of the Brethren west of McPherson, Kans. Organized at first by its trustees as a stock company, the property was formally taken over by the Church of the Brethren in 1908. From the first the Kunses were the mainstay of the College, giving lavishly of their means and time and counsel. The first president was Dr. S. F. Garst, who served from 1891 to 1893. Others who have followed were E. A. :Miner, 1893-1899; W. I. T. Hoover, 1899-1901; ^^^ C. Hanawalt, 1902-1908; W. F. England, 1908-1912; J. P. Dickey, 1912-1913; Edward Frantz, 1913-1915; and Dr. S. J. Miller, the present incumbent. From its founding until 1912 the work was chiefly of academic grade, but in 1912 Dr. W. I. T. Hoover reorganized the work and established the collegiate course leading to the Bachelor of Arts degree.

Another institution financed by H. L. Kuns is the David and Margaret Home for Children. The La Verne Hotel building, erected as a boom hotel, has thus been transformed into a valuable and useful institution.

The La Verne Leader, formerly the Lordsburg-La Verne Leader, first' appeared May 12, 1910. W. A. Adams was its first publisher and editor. Other papers had had only a very brief or spasmodic existence before this time, among then the La Verne Nezcs, mentioned above, and the Lordsburg Siinbcani, which appeared in 1899 : but the Leader has grown steadily from its first appearance into an established place. John M. Reed and H. H. Webb followed Adams in the conduct of the paper. Then came the "leadership" of William H. Greene from 1912 until recently (1918) Ulrich Knoch, a well-known publisher of Los Angeles, has taken it over.

The change of name from Lordsburg to La A^erne City was accomplished in August, 1917, there being practically no opposition to the change. The occasion was celebrated with a public wedding in which "]\Iiss Lordsburg" was wedded to "Mr. La Verne," with appropriate ceremonies, a banquet and much festivity.

San Diivias

In the "prehistoric" days of San Dimas, there was no town of this name, but from the very first of this story much has been said of "Mud Springs," as one of the stations on the Overland Stage route, where horses were watered atid fed between El Monte and Cucamonga. There was not even a settlement here in those days, only a house or two and some barns where ^Ir. Clancy lived in charge of the station. The place was called Mud Springs because of a number of springs or cienegas, two large ones especially, which made the whole region marshy. Teams could not drive across it, and if one got stuck in the mud or turf a whole acre -would shake with his struggles. When the Santa Fe Railway was built across the cienega, north of the old road, it was necessary to drive piling deep down and plentifully to secure a solid road bed. The name "Mud Springs" is retained as a station of the Pacific Electric Railway.

The canyon north of i\Iud Springs was early called San Dimas. Its name, according to Ramon Vejar, originated in this curiously trivial circumstance. When Ygnacio Palomares first pastured his herds in this part of the country, he built a rude corral up in the canyon in which to keep some of his cattle at times. But it was far from their hacienda and the Indians would run them off again and again, until he gave it up in disgust and called the canyon "San Dimas," after the one who was crucified with Christ and repented before his death on the cross, because, forsooth, he also repented of having chosen this as a place of refuge for his stock! Sometime in the later si.xties, as has been noticed, the Cunninghams "took up" a quarter section of government land, including a part of San Dimas Canyon, and the family lived here for a number of years. Between the Cunninghams and the north line of Dalton's, or San Jose Addition, was the ranch of Cyrus Burdick, also referred to earlier, where is now the C. C. Warren place.

Here in San Dimas Canyon lived also Henry Dalton himself, where in his later years he found himself bereft of friends and fortune, worsted at last through interminable litigation. As some one has said, "He was always lawing," And so in 1884 he lived in a little shack, with his Mexican wife, cultivating a little patch of potatoes, and almost or quite forgotten by the world which was formerly so ready to give him respect. Thus he was found one day by Mr. Fred J. Smith, who had a letter of introduction to him, at the time of his coming to Southern California, from one who had been a partner of Dalton in his better days and still supposed him to be a man of large means and influence. They had been together in mining and other ventures in South America, and had 'each cleared up $200,000, so it is said. "He is a fine fellow," the partner said, "who owns great tracts of land ; but he has one failing - his fondness for lawsuits." So this was the end of one who had owned a third of the San Jose Rancho, all of the Azusa, and the San Francisquito ranches, many thousands of acres, including some of what is now the highest priced farming land in the world.

Well known among the first settlers in this vicinity were the Martins, W. C. and W. T., who were also pioneers in El Alonte. In 1869, Toots Martin (\V. T.) came with his family to the mouth of San Dimas Canyon, east of the Cunninghams, to engage in farming and keeping of bees, which he did for two years, when he moved to the east of Indian Hill, as we shall see later. In the following year, 1872, his father, Wm. C. Martin, or Uncle Billy, sold out his hotel at El Monte and purchased a homesteader's claim to 160 acres on the highlands and foothills at the mouth of the canyon. For fifteen years he lived here on his foothill ranch, farming and raising bees, until in 1887 he sold the property to the San Jose Land and Water Company and moved to Pomona. Though at some distance from other people, he was a well-known and influential man, "straight and generous to a fault" as a neighbor said.

Of those who came to the San Dimas region in the early days and have made it their home, some of them to the present time, the Teague families are the oldest. ]\Ir. C. P. Teague came with others of the INIound City Land and Water Association, which bought the Dalton interests in Azusa and in the San Jose Rancho and its additions. In October, 1878, Jasper N. Teague, his son, came as a surveyor for this company, and having the power of attorney in all aflfairs pertaining to the company for his father, who did not settle here till later. At this time there was not a house within miles of Mud Springs ; nothing except the chimney of an old house, probably the Clancy house, which had been the station for the stages when they ran by way of Mud Springs. Against this old chimney, not far from one of the larger springs, the Teagues built their house, when J. N. Teague had been joined by his brother, David C. Teague. Above the barn which they also built was another spring. The affairs of the Mound Citv company did not prosper and the Teagues turned their attention to raising grain. Begmning the first of January, 1879, they plowed a thousand acres and planted it to grain. But the crop was a failure, returning only four sacks of grain to the acre. The supply of water was very meager, only a miner's inch of water from the canyon for 7,000 acres of land. This was supplemented with a little from the San Gabriel, but the head was too small and Duarte, farther west, had it two days in the week first. On the east bank of the cienega they had sunk a well which yielded a ten-inch flow at first, but in the dry years this gave out. The abandoned shaft of this first well may still be seen. They raised some sheep and cattle also, but under great odds. All the stock had to be driven to the stream on the Carrion place when the water in the cienegas was low. L^ndaunted they planted again the next season and were rejoicing in a luxuriant crop of grain, tall and heavy - as fine a stand of grain as could be grown - when again they were disappointed. The spring was unusually wet. and week followed week with practically no sun- shine at all. In four days they lost it all. So for nearly three years there seemed nothing but hard luck and misfortune. And the end was not yet. Before the third crop was harvested the Mound City company failed and the property passed into the hands of J. S. Slauson of Los Angeles, who held mortgages against the company and finally foreclosed, bidding in all its holdings at the face of the mortgage. The Teagues lost what they had put into the company and most of the land which they were purchasing. They were obliged to move, but were allowed to move their buildings, and got something for the crop. Still the Teagues were not defeated. The father, C. P. Teague, had joined his sons in 1881, and Harvey and Robert, two other brothers, had also come. Buying and leasing more land, they pitched in harder than ever and began to get ahead. At one time they had leased 7,000 acres, including all of the San Jose Addition. The elder Teague was peculiarly fortunate in locating wells, seeming to sense in some way the underground streams of water. After a time the interests of the family in the Addition were given over largely to the two brothers, J. N. and D. C. Teague. In 1887 the two divided their interests here, the latter remaining in San Dimas, while the former moved to Pomona. J. N. Teague had married Anna, the second daughter of Cyras Burdick, and for a dozen years or more the family lived in their attractive home on Park Avenue. During this time he was busy with many interests - raising grain, threshing, growing citrus fruits and contracting, always directing large gangs of men and buying and selling property. He was a "live wire" and an influential man in the city, until his removal to Los Angeles. Since then, by his tremendous energy, his intelligent management and good judgment he has become one of the largest growers of vegetables in the Southwest, handling large contracts for the government, and an expert in agriculture and soils.

After the father, C. P. Teague, had been here for a time, he returned to their home in the North, to sell their old ranch. While there the mother died and the father came back to ]\Iud Springs. There were also four daughters. On his return C. P. Teague with his son, Robert, leased several thousand acres of what became La ^'erne for farming and grazing, building about a quarter of a mile up the road from Mud Springs, near the present Santa Fe crossing. David C. and Robert M. Teague, the oldest and youngest sons, are still living in San Dimas, the former a little east of the old place, and the latter by his nursery in the heart of the town.

Turning our attention now to another early settler in San Dimas, one who came to the region shortly after J- N. and D. C. Teague and has remained until the present time is Eli W. Schuler. He is thus also one of San Dimas' oldest living residents. Still vigorous in body and keen of mind, he recalls with much satisfaction the times of forty years ago. His family had come to California in 1864. After a visit to the \"aliey in 1879 he decided to come here to live. His mother had come from Iowa on account of asthma, and had bought a land claim of John Paine. From a recital of his own recollections one gathers an interesting impression of the surroundings of that time. For, as he says, he knew all the old-timers intimately^he Cunninghams, the Martins, the Burdicks and the Teagues, who came about the same time. He was a "partner of Colonel Heath in the haypress." He worked during harvest for "Chino Phillips." For some time he assisted Hancock, the surveyor, and has since been valuable to other surveyors in locating old corners and tracing out old lines. He had a high respect for Hancock who surveyed the county "when it was sectionized by the Government, after the Treaty of God-a-loop (Guadalupe)" and of whom he says: "He knowed how to run a straight hue, and he knowed how to measure one, if he hadn't as much education as some." From his contact with surveyors he has a most commendable and somewhat rare respect for corner stakes and landmarks of every sort. "Me and Tonner had many a scrap with folks who would tamper with the corners and move stakes over to suit their own convenience." And he had a good word for Tonner. "He always got the lion's share, but he had awfully good traits and he had an awfully nice woman in Mrs. Tonner. Tonner thought the JNIexicans as good as any. Once there was a raffle and voting for the prettiest girl in the Valley. "Mother King's' daughter was getting a large share of the votes, when Tonner came in, asked how many she had and how many votes there were. Then he said, 'Put up your money, Schuler ; no use to throw it away. I don't like to see this business so one-sided,' and cast a majority vote for a pretty Alexican girl."

Schuler was deputy sheriff under Hamner, Cline and others, and knew Billy Rowland well, though he did not serve under him. "I was always a Republican." he says. "They tried to raise me a Democrat, but I was spoiled in the makin'." But he claims a good friend in the stanch Democrat, F. M. Slaughter, of whom he tells many stories. "Slaughter was a good story teller - told them well and liked to. After the emigrants came from the East he would tell a lot of harrowing stories about the Indians, as people were sitting on the porch in front of his home at Rincon, and then, as some harmless Indian came up, he would shout, 'Indians, by G - , Schuler, Indians,' and pretend to be terribly scared, while the visitors ran to hide, really frightened." Schuler's own stories of crossing the plains were blood-curdling enough. A hundred men, he says, were necessary as guards for the train, and these men must be able to hit a mark, three bullets out of five, at sixty yards. Of Mrs. John Brown, who was in the party, he says, "Braver woman never lived ; I saw her kill three Indians." There wa's great danger of stampeding the cattle, and this was done not only by the Indians but by Mormons who often incited them to mischief. "The Mormons in them days," he says, "were regular Bull-she-vys." When Mr. Schuler came to Mud Springs he "farmed.'' One season he had 1,000 sacks of barley, 6,000 sacks of wheat, which he sold at fifty and sixty cents a hundred, and 300 tons of hay, which he was to sell at $9.50 a ton, but he says, "The fellow busted on me, and I only got two dollars a ton." Mr. Schuler has acquired considerable property during his long residence here and is still a hard-working citizen, whose place could not easily be filled.

^\'hile this story does not include the history of Glendora, Charter Oak and Covina, a brief reference may here be made to some things of interest in the country south and west of San Dimas. In 1880 a considerable amount of land called the Covina Tract, was purchased by two brothers from Costa Rica, by the name of Badillo, who made payments on the purchase in part with money borrowed through Hollenbeck of the First National Bank of Los Angeles. Though industrious and making various improvements, they were unable to complete their payments. The times were inauspicious and it became necessary for the bank to foreclose. This would have left the Badillos penniless, and one of them left precipitately, but the other won the admiration of Mr. Hollenbeck, who, it is said, liad been a poor boy and left Missouri with only three dollars in his pocket. Moreover, Mr. Hollenbeck had lived in Costa Rica, and had acquired some money raising coft'ee there, so was especially interested in Badillo and deeded to him a

To trace the title to the lands of San Dimas in the "prehistoric" days, one must go back again to the Mexican grants of 1837 and the following years. It will be recalled that Don Luis Arenas received a grant from the Mexican government of an undivided third interest in the Rancho San Jose and in the San Jose Addition, also full title to the Azusa Rancho, north of Puente and adjoining the San Jose Addition on the west. All this property Arenas sold to Henry Dalton, and the sale was confirmed December 24, 1844, by Manuel Requena, first constitutional alcalde, and endorsed by Jose Antonio Carillo, Pio Pico and Andres Pico, "Commandantes of Squadron," and commissioners appointed for this service. In June, 1866, Dalton deeded to one Francois L. A. Pioche for $5,000 an undivided half of his interest in the San Jose Rancho, and three years later, for $10,000 he gave the same Francois L. A. Pioche a mortgage for these four ranches: "the Azusa Rancho, containing one square league, the Rancho San Jose Addition, containing one square league, the Rancho San Francisquito, containing two square leagues, and the Rancho San Jose." For several years the mortgage was renewed for decreasing amounts, his wife, Guadalupe Zamorano de Dalton then signing the mortgage with him. Then Pioche died and in May, 1874, his executors served notice of action to foreclose. On October 1, 1874, Dalton borrowed $20,000 of the Los Angeles County Bank, which had recently organized with J. S. Slauson and J. M. Griffith among its incorporators. The mortgage given on this date to the bank, covering all his interest in the four ranchos, and the previous mortgages to Pioche, were the sources of endless litigation between the bank and the Pioche heirs on the one hand and the Daltons, or Lewis Wolf skill, their attorney, on the other. Mr. Wolfskill did his best to save his client, and for a time 500 acres in the Azusa Rancho were reserved for a homestead.

On January 27, 1877, l^ie Probate Court record shows that Wolfskill took over from the Pioche heirs all of Dalton's indebtedness to them, his mortgages and titles involved, giving them $40,000 therefor, $5,000 in cash and the balance in notes secured by mortgage to all the Azusa and San Jose ranchos (except the 500-acre homestead), Dalton having deeded his attorney everything. In the midst of this little tangle the Mound City Land and Water Association came on the stage. This company was incorporated July 25, 1878, with a capital stock of $200,000. James B. and David H. Seawell, Thomas H. Hudson, W. A. Spurlock, George W. jMorgan and Lewis Wolfskill were the larger stockholders. These were joined two months later by J. N. Teague and his father, and by James H. and Wm. T. Clark. On this date an agreement was secured by Seawell and others as individuals, with Wolfskill and the Daltons to convey to them all the Rancho Azusa, all right and title in the Rancho San Jose and its Addition and all water, water rights and franchises pertaining to these properties (which included some rights in the San Gabriel River). The consideration was $140,000. of which $10,000 was paid down, $25,000 was due in sixty days and the balance in two annual payments. All these interests were made over by these individuals to the Mound City Land and Water Association, October 2, 1878. At the same time they gave Wolfskill a mortgage on the whole property for the sum of $105,000, given in the form of two equal notes, on each of which he paid down $31,000, the mortgage being at once assigned to the Farmers and Merchants Bank. Now appears the ghost. Six months later the Los Angeles County Bank brought suit against the Daltons, Wolfskill and fifty(!) other defendants enumerated indi- vidually and as corporations, asking judgment for over $22,000. After many summons and demurrers the specter of the mortgage becomes very real in the person of the sheriff, who is ordered to sell the property at auction.

By this time claims were allowed of over $60,000, and the sheriff's sale in June, 1880, realized $55,000, of which the Los Angeles County Bank took $25,000 and the executors of Pioche, by S. L. Theller, Gustave Tonchard and Gustave Dussol, took $30,000. Numerous other sheriff sales followed as other claims were presented and allowed. In the next five years the four great ranches of thousands of acres were tossed back and forth like a basketball, or as in a game of battledore and shuttlecock, deed after deed was made out for the whole property, and mortgages were assigned and reassigned, with amounts at issue running from $1,000 to $100,000. Wolfskin to Cardwcll, Daltons and Wolf skill to the Los Angeles County Bank, Wolfskill to Sabichi, Dalton to Sabichi, the Pioche executors to J. ^Nlora Moss, and then to ]\Iartz and Martz, everybody by the sheriff to the Los Angeles County Bank, et cetera ad infinitum ! But as early as April, 1880, the JNIound City Land and Water Association deeded its entire interest in the four ranchos to J. S. Slauson, and in the end everybody else had done the same thing, the last transfer being that of Widney and Smith and the Los Angeles County Bank, on April 15, 1887. By this time Henry Dalton, his creditor Francois L. A. Pioche, his attorney, Lewis Wolfskill, (his Mexican wife, Guadalupe, too, doubtless) and the other principals, were all dead, the first boom and its consequent depression were past, and another company was coming upon the stage with a new and bigger boom.

\\'hen it became evident that the new railway was to run through the A'alley ;iorth of the San Jose hills, M. L. Wicks, who had been associated with C. T. Mills in organizing the Pomona Land and Water Company, now formed a new company, including in it one or two officials of the Santa Fe Railroad and several who had been interested in the Mound City Association. The largest stockholders were "SI. L. Wicks, George W. Hughes, R. F. Lotspeich and F. Sabichi, but more than thirty others were included, exclusive of some whom Wicks represented as trustee ; and the holdings ran from three shares to seven hundred. The capital stock of 3,000 one-hundred-dollar shares was all subscribed. This company was incorporated February 28, 1887, as the San Jose Ranch Company, and in the next two months received from J. S. Slauson (and nominally from others) title to all the Dalton interests and the Mound City Association interests in the two ranches known as the Rancho San Jose and the Rancho San Jose Addition. The consideration in the Slauson deal was $150,000, for half of which he took a promissory note for $75,000, receiving a mortgage on the whole property, but agreeing to release from its lien blocks of land as sold, under certain conditions. It was stipulated that the Teague brothers were not to be disturbed in their lease of the land during the current season. The company also bought of Louis Phillips 665^'^ acres at the northwest corner of his half of the San Jose Rancho. Thus the new company acquired possession of a large part of the land north of the San Jose hills from La Verne to Glendora and the Azusa ditch, and including a pai t of wdiat is now Covina, being the whole of the San Jose Addition and all of the Dalton section in the San Jose Rancho - nearly 8000 acres.

The San Jose Ranch Company assumed for itself the name of the rancho, though operating on the Addition and edge of the rancho itself, as did also the water company soon to be mentioned, but it gave to the town the name of the canyon, San Dimas, which has been explained.

In San Dimas, as elsewhere, the development of water has been a vital problem. The purchase of the San Jose Addition and a part of the rancho itself by the San Jose Ranch Company carried with it the rights in all the water on the land (and under it) besides certain claims to water in the San Dimas and San Gabriel canyons. The supply from the "mud springs" was quite inadequate, as the Teagues had learned, so the company drilled wells around the cienega and secured a good flow at first. But in time this died down, and they tunneled underneath, so as to tap the wells some forty feet underground and thus obtained a permanent supply.

While the San Jose Ranch Company was developing water in the A'alley another company, called the San Jose Land and Water Company, was formed to handle the water at the mouth of the San Dimas Canyon. Securing a quantity of land they incorporated in May, 1887, with Col. T. W^ Brooks and M. G. Rogers of Pomona, and C. M. Wells of Los Angeles, as officers. The Colonel was an interesting character because of his rugged figure and ways and his varied career as miner and soldier, serving under General Crook in the war against the Sioux. The land purchased by this company included the 160 acres of Uncle Billy Martin, the 160 acres of J. B. Chappel to the west, and another 160 acres on the east. Some of this was good bottom land, some waste, and some mesa. Altogether it gave them command of a large supply of water, which they began to develop at once, running a tunnel and making some improvements.

But the San Jose Land and Water Company immediately came into conflict with the San Jose Ranch Company, which disputed their claims to the canyon water. Then began a series of lawsuits which stopped the work in the canyon, and which became one of the most complex and hotly disputed water contests in the history of water development. The firm of Wells and Dunnigan led the battle for the Land and Water Company. C. M. Wells was a courteous little gentleman, who was for a time president of the Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce, but Dunnigan was a vigorous, combative attorney. Over a score of suits were fought over the water rights in San Dimas Canyon, and some of these were carried to the Supreme Court. During a large part of this time Dunnigan was in actual possession of the canyon, but unable to do much work. Like the Kilkenny cats, tied together by their tails, they fought till only the tails remained. In the meantime M. L. Wicks, who was the capitalist of the Ranch Company - a visionary too, but not a "scrapper" - grew weary of the contest, and gave up his interest in the canyon to develop the water in the cienega. Thirty-three inches were secured here. But a number of the people who wanted more water and less litigation combined to employ E. J. Fleming as attorney, to look after their interests. Largely as a result of their pressure, the San Jose Ranch Company offered them all their holdings - land, water rights and pipes, representing perhaps $?0.000 - but no deal was effected, and a group consisting of the Johnstones, C. B. Sumner and others, purchased their water rights and pipe lines, but not their land. This group organized the San Dimas Irrigation Company. Later there was a settlement of the various claims in a decision handed down by Judge Lucien Shaw. Those adjudicated to have prior rights in the cienega water formed the Cienega ^^'ater Company. There was also the Artesian Belt Water Company, formed by W. A. Johnstone, William Bowring and A. B. Smith to take over and develop the water first struck in a well drilled by J. O. Enell on the edge of the San Dim.as wash.

History And Biography 189

W. A. Johnstone have been actively interested parties in the water developments of the San Dimas region, and are recognized by every one as authorities in regard to water in this region, each having served in every capacity from zanjero to president, and that over a period of years covering the whole history of the town.

The first citrus orchard in San Dimas or La Verne was the fifteen-acre grove set (Hit by D. C. and C. P. Teague in 1886, who now began to turn their attention from grain farming on a large scale to fruit growing. The youngest son of the family, R. M. Teague, in 1889 bought 10,000 young trees and began his nursery business, which now reaches out all over the country, and even abroad. But it has had its ups and downs. Twice it has been almost "down and out." In the early nineties the output had reached 250,000 trees, when overproduction and the panic caused a drop in the market and half the stock was sold out at figures that left the proprietor $50,000 in debt. Then prices rose again to seventy-five cents and one dollar a tree and remained for six years, when the sale of trees reached 350,000, in 1913, more than half of them going to the San Joaquin \^alley. Other ventures have cost him dearly, but the Teagues were always indomitable, and "R. M." has pluckily risen to the top again in a conservative nursery of large variet}' and proportions.

The citrus industry is almost the only one in San Dimas. Why should there be any other? It is in the very heart of the citrus belt. In fact it is doubtful if there is anywhere in the world a spot more favored by nature for raising lemons and oranges - so free from frost and other damaging conditions. And so generally has this become recognized that the available land has practically all been set out by growers ; prices of bearing groves mount higher and higher ; and the canyons and coigns of vantage in the foothills above are becoming more and more seized by retired men of means for beautiful residence places. The great packing houses do an enormous business. In the San Dimas district are about 2,500 acres of citrus fruits, nearly 1,500 being in lemons. The San Dimas Lemon Association in one season ships 850 carloads of lemons, including its branch house at Glendora, 450 carloads being from the San Dimas district alone ; and this output is steadily increasing, nearly a third having been added in five years.

In the development of this industry, in its organization and in the marketing of the fruit, one of the most valuable men in the region has been Mr. Frank Harwood, for twenty years manager of the association and then president from that time to the present.

For over seventeen years San Dimas has had its own local paper. The San Dimas Eagle was launched by H. H. Kinney, for a time the proprietor of the Pomona Times and now an attorney in Los Angeles. When the paper was bought by Mr. C. L. Compton, the present proprietor, its name was changed to the San Dimas Press.

San Dimas united with the La Verne and Lordsburg fnow La Verne City ) districts in the building and maintenance of the Bonita Union High School. Organized in 1903, it has grown to a school of ten teachers and over a hundred pupils. For a dozen years it has been under the able direction of Professor Arthur Durward.

Few towns in Southern California have made such rapid and substantial growth as San Dimas. In the period from 1894 to 1915 its assessment listing increased from $13^,434 to $1.463,218 - more than tenfold. Xo one probably has had a more vital part in this progress than Hon. \\'. A. Johnstone. Coming here with his father's family in the early days of the town he has been identified with nearly all its more important enterprises, especially in the water development and in the bank, of which he has been president since its organization. His election to the State Assembly was a just recognition of his worth not only to the city of San Dimas but to the district.

Charter Oak

.\t the corner of the three ranches, the Puente, the San Jose and the San Jose .\ddition. is the village of Charter Oak. The corner is that known as S. J. No. 10, and was formerly marked by the Tinaja Oak. One would like to find that this was the same as Charter Oak, but the fact is that the Tinaja Oak is gone long since, and that the tree called Charter Oak is at some distance from this corner, though both were in the r>. F. Allen forty acres constituting the N.W. yi of the S.E. 14 of Sec. 8, T. 1 S., R. 0 W. The origin of this name is happilv described by ^^"illiam Hoogendyk. a resident of the place, in the following e-xcerpt :

"It was not until after ^Icxico had declared independence from Spair, that the peaceful I\Iission, then grown to a large and prosperous community, began to lose its peace and happiness. With the first breaking out of hostilities between California and the United States, a prominent Mexican official, San Antonio, took command of the Los Angeles volunteers to give battle to the Americans. The battle of the San Gabriel River was disa.strous to the Americans. They fled from the battlefield, losing their flag and some valuable papers. In the fall of the year San Antonio, wishing to return to his home in Mexico, left Los Angeles in great splendor, accompanied by a few soldiers. The captured flag and the papers were entrusted to him to deliver safely to the Alexican .eovernme'it. It was a rainy day when he left Los Angeles. They stopped at the San Gabriel ^Mission for refreshments, and were here joined by two traders, and on the saddles of these men were bags of gold received in exchange for various trinkets at the various Missions. The rain increased, and the party which had intended to stop at Cienega, which was only a watering place between Los Angeles and San Bernardino, camped instead near some friendly Indians, under some oak trees about twenty miles from Los Angeles. At the Mission a Spaniard who had been unmercifully treated by the ]\Iexicans, seeing the cavalcade start, with revenge in his heart carried the news to the Americans, who were camped a few miles away. Eager to recapture the flag and the papers, the Americans started in pursuit, and came upon San Antonio's party among the live oaks of the upper San Gabriel Valley. Fearing an attack from unfriendly Indians, San Antonio and his party pitched their camp some distance from the main traveled road. They buried their gold, with the flag and the papers, near a large oak tree, for, should they be surprised, the tree, by reason of its size, would serve as a mark to enable any survivor to recover the treasure. Fires were built, and the clothing dried. The evening meal was taken. With the coming of twilight was heard the clatter of hoofs. Americans in pursuit, San Antonio climbed the big oak, while the soldiers made ready for flight. Volley after volley was fired at the small party of Americans. History has never told the story of the slaughter of the battle. San Antonio remained in the tree all night, and two days after his departure he returned to Los Angeles, alone and in rags, with his feet bleeding, and almost exhausted. No one has ever found the flag, the valuable papers, or the gold that was cached by this great tree. An American officer and a troop of soldiers returned to the spot several days later, still in pursuit of their flag and papers, but the rain had made it impossible to find the cache. Holes were dug all around the large tree without success. When the search was given up and they were about to depart, the officer, giving a last look at the place, said : 'This indeed is a replica of the old Charter Oak.' ]\Iany years have gone by since the historic oak which held the beneficial charter has been blown down on the shores of Connecticut. But the historic tree of the upper San Gabriel Valley still stands. In its bark is cut the Sign of the Cross to commemorate the deed. In 1886 settlers bought the land in the vicinity and planted it to orange trees. The place of this historic tree first belonged to Walter Allen, brother-in-law of William Bowring, and neighbor of H. C. Mace, the only two remaining pioneers of this section. It was the task of W. H. Collins, a later purchaser of the land, to level the land of the many holes dug by the treasure-hunters around the tree.

"The Charter Oak of the Pacific Coast stands in the orange grove now owned by R. H. Rowland, in a beautiful, prosperous community named Charter Oak. This historic spot is midway between three prominent cities of the upper San Gabriel \'alley. Three miles to the east we find the prosperous city of San Dimas; three miles to the north the beautiful city of Glendora, while three miles to the west the ever growing city of Covina. Thousands of acres around this tree have been planted to trees bearing the golden fruit, and many who have visited the upper San Gabriel Valley can truthfully say that the golden orange gardens of Hesperides are reproduced on the shores of the Pacific."

Claremont And Pomona College

Claremont was placed on the map by the Pacific Land Improvement Company, as already noted. The land which this company secured was chiefly a part of the eighty acres of Andres Duarte, purchased of H. A. Palmer, 160 acres in the west half of Section 10 owned by Charles French, and the land owned by the Pomona Land and Water Company south of the upper line of the rancho (which crosses the town as explained before) as far as Cucamonga Avenue. The plot of the town was recorded in April, 1887, and included only that portion which lay, north and south, between Tenth Street and Cucamonga Avenue and between Alexander and Forest avenues, west and east, the last designation being one of the original names, when Yale, Harvard, College, Dartmouth and Princeton avenues were known by the more prosaic names of Tremont, Palmer, Pearl, W^arren, Goddard and Forest. Most of these were for Eastern stockholders. Palmer Avenue was named for H. A. Palmer, who bought the Duarte place, then held by Toots Martin, in 1883, and later moved his house from Pomona to Claremont.

One of the company's advertising circulars says : "The name Claremont is indicative of clear mountain air ; clear mountain water ; clear from malaria, frost, fogs and most of 'the ills that flesh is heir to.' The site was chosen before any of the adjoining places were dreamed of. We had the entire line to select from," for the building of the railroad was then a secret known only to a few. This exquisite place was chosen; first, because of the perfect altitude; second, because of the unlimited supply of artesian water; third, because of the unsurpassed scenery of mountain and valley: fourth, because of the giant live oaks and sycamores that adorn its grounds, oaks that an English lord would give $10,000 an acre to possess." Except for slight frost and fog, all this is true indeed, but the explanation of the name Claremont may be enlarged. A number of Spanish names were suggested by Mr. Palmer at the company's request and the one English name, the latter being chosen because also one of the company had lived at Claremont, New Hampshire.

Thus again the derivation of a town name is quite at variance with what is generally supposed to have been, or what might have been expected. Claremont was not named simply for its clearness or altitude, nor as it might properly have been for some Spanish name suggestive of its origin; Pomona College is not an agricultural school, though the name of the town Pomona was suggested by the grangers. North Pomona or Pomona should have been Palomares ; El Monte does not mean mountain, but thicket; nor is there any considerable bridge at Puente as there is at El Monte; Spadra was not named for a spade, but for a Spadra Bluffs in Arkansas; Chino has nothing to do with Chinamen, but with curly leafed willows, chino meaning curly ; San Dimas was a name given in the strange fashion recounted, not to the town first but to the canyon, its first designation being ]\Iud Springs, and then Mound City, there being doubtless no true mound city anywhere about; and finally the most appropriate names of all are not in use save as San Antonio is given to thg little hamlet at the canyon mouth, and San Jose, the original name of the rancho, is retained simply for the "township," because another city in the State was already known as San Jose.

Provenance

Text from History of Pomona Valley, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the Valley Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present .., published 1920, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.