Sacramento County, California - Chapter 9, 1890
From An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. 4,342 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
4,342 wordsMachine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 9
fNDER Mexican rule the Government of California was conducted under the laws of March 20 and May 23, 1887, and those laws were observed, on the acquisition of the country by the United States, until the organization of the State Government. Those laws provided for the selection of alcaldes, whose duties were to care for good order and public tranquillity, to see that police regulations, laws and decrees were enforced, to provide for the apprehension of criminals, and in come cases to impose lines and imprisonment upon malefactors. There were also justices of the peace, who served as municipal and judicial othcers. There was in tlie Territory a Superior Tribunal, consisting of four judges and an Attorney-General, which had the general reviewing of cases tried before inferior courts. There were also Courts of " First Instance," in which cases, both criminal and civil, were originally brought.
The first Legislature of the State, by an act passed March 10, 1850, divided the State into nine judicial districts, and constituted the counties of Sacramento and El Dorado the Si.xth Judicial District. Afterward the counties of Sacramento and Yolo composed that district, and it so existed until the taking effect of the constitution of 1879, whicli abolished that court.
the 13th, 1850, created a County Court in each county, and by an act approved on the 11th of that month, the Court of Sessions was created, to be composed of the county judge and two justices of the peace, who were to serve as associate justices. The latter were chosen by the justices of the peace of the county. That court had jurisdiction in cases of misdemeanor, and also exercised functions now performed by the Board of Supervisors, such as the supervision of claims against the county, the management of roads, etc. Subsequently the Court of Sessions was abolished, and its jurisdiction vested in the County Court. Its legislative and superr vision powers were transferred to the Board of Supervisors. The present State constitution abolished all these courts, and provided for the organization of a Superior Court in the county with two departments, and two judges, with civil and criminal jurisdiction.'
-isdiction. He appointed W. E. Shannon judge of the Court of the First Instance, with criminal jurisdiction. On the 2d of September, 1849, Thomas entered upon the duties of his office. A suit was instituted for the recovery of money. A summons was made returnable the same day at 4 o'cloak, at which time judgineat was entered, and execution ordered. This gives some idea of the rapidity with which business, even of a judicial character, was transacted at that early period of Sacramento's history. On the 3d of September, Judge Thomas appointed J. P. Rogers clerk of his court. The latter gentleman served in that capacity till the 19th of November following, whereupon James R. Lawrence was appointed. He continued to the 27th of December, at which time Presley Dunlap was appointed to the position.
Judge Shannon opened his court for criminal business in September, 1849. R. A. Wilson was appointed clerk, and S. C. Hastings - afterward Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the State and subsequently Attorney-General- - acted as prosecuting attorney. D. B. Hanner, who had been elected sheriff by the people in their primarj^ capacity, attended both the civil and criminal courts. The first case before Judge Shannon was a prosecution against a party for stealing a cow from Samuel Norris. During the trial, defendant's counsel objected to the proceedings because they were not in conformity with the constitutional provision guaranteeing to every party accused of high crime, that before he can be put upon trial he must have been indicted by a grand jury of his countrymen. The court held that inasmuch as the defendant had not raised the question in the beginning of the case he was deemed as waiving his right, and that the trial must proceed. The defendant was found guilty and fined ยง200 and costs, which amounted to $515 - rather costly beef.
About December 1, 1849, R. A. Wilson succeeded to the bench, vice Shannon deceased. On January 11, 1850, he appointed A. J. McCall clerk of his court for Sacramento, and on January 26 he appointed Stephen J. Field - now a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States - clerk of his court, to reside at Marysville. During the time Sacramento was flooded that winter, Wilson held his court at Marysville. The two courts alluded to did the judicial business of the district, both civil und criminal, until the organization of the Judiciary under the State constitution, May 20, 1850.
The first district judges were elected by the Legislature March 30, 1850, and James S. Thomas was elected judge of the Sixth Judicial District. He resigned November 9 following. Tod Robinson was appointed by the Governor to succeed Jiim on January 2, 1851, and assumed ofiice on the 8th. Ferris Forman succeeded Robinson by appointment on August 13, 1851; and on September 15, the same year, Lewis Aldrich assumed the office. He resigned November 19, 1852, and A. C. Monson was appointed by Governor Bigler on November 26,
1852. He took ofl[ice on the 1st of Decem'oer of that year. Monson had been elected at the general election on November 2, 1852. He resigned August 17, 1857, and Governor Johnson, on the 3d of September, appointed Charles T. Botts to succeed him. At. the general election, held September 1, 1858, John H. McKune was elected, and was re-elected October 21,
1853. On October 20, 1869, Lewis Ramage was elected, and October 20, 1875, Samuel C. Denson was elected. He served until the new constitution, abolishing the court, took effect.
Thomas, after his resignation, returned to the East, and died at St. Louis in 1857 or 1858. Robinson, who was a prominent member of the bar, and who belonged to a family of distinguished lawyers, died in San Mateo County, October 27, 1870. Forman was afterward Secretary of State, and is now living in the East. Aldrich died at San Francisco, May 19, 1885. Monson removed East, and is still living. Botts was a brother of John Minor Botts. He had been a member of the first Constitutional Convention of the State, and was afterward State printer. He died in San Francisco, October 4, 1884. McKune is still in the law practice here. Ramage removed to Kansas City and died there February 14, 1879. Denson was afterward elected superior judge of the county, and resigned that office and is now in law practice in this city. A sketch of his life appears on a subsequent page.
As we have stated, the Court of Sessions was composed of the county judge and two associates. The latter were elected by a convention of the justices of the peace, held on the lirst Monday of October of each year - except the lirst convention, which was held May 20, 1850. C. C. Sackett and Charles H. Swift were then elected associates. The associates held office for two years. On November 27, 1850, the county treasurer resigned, and Swift was appointed to fill the vacancy. James Brown was elected associate in his stead, and assumed the duties of his ofiice February 7, 1851. On August 14 following, D. D. Bullock succeeded Brown. The last meeting of the Court of Sessions was held July 6, 1862.
After the abolishment of the Court of Sessions, Judge Clark continued county judge, successively elected to that office and occupied it until the abolishment of the County Court by tlie operation of the new constitution. Tiie
Willis left here and returned to the East in early days. Wilson died in one of the northern counties of this State a number of years ago. Day died recently. Heard still lives here. Jenks removed to Oakland, and has held public offices there. Robinson is still a resident of Sacramento. Coggins died a number of years ago. Cone was afterward a member of the State Legislature from this county. Clark had been a Senator and Assemblyman, and after the abolishment of the County Court was elected, with Denson, a judge of the Superior Court, and held the office until the time of his death.
At the first election under the new constitution, September 3, 1879, Samuel C. Denson and Robert C. Clark were elected judges of the Superior Court. Judge Denson resigned December 16, 1882, and on the 18th Governor Perkins appointed Thomas B. McFarland to fill the vacancy. The latter was elected by the people to succeed himself at the general election held November 4, 1884; and at the general election held November 2, 1886, McFarland was elected one of the justices of the State Supreme Court. He resigned the office of superior judge, and Governor Stoneman, on December 31, 1886, appointed John W. Armstrong to the office. At the general election held in November, 1888, Armstrong was elected to succeed himself, and is now serving on the bench.
Judge Clark died January 27, 1883, and Governor Stoneman appointed John W. Armstrong to succeed him. At the general election held November 4, 1884, W. C. Van Fleet was elected for the full term, and he still occupies the bench.
The Attorneys Of The Past
James C. Zabriskie was the first city attorney. He was a native of New Jersey, of Polish stock, was Colonel of a regiment of New Jersey militia, and with his regiment participated in the inaugural ceremonies of President Jackson, and was warmly entertained by that stern old veteran. He was an intimate friend of Com-
!nodore R. F. Stockton, after whom the city of Stockton was named, and was selected as master of ceremonies on the occasion of the inspection by the great peacemaker, on board the Commodore's frigate, Princeton, on the Potomac River, in 184:4. The inspection was witnessed by President Tyler, members of the cabinet, foreign ministers, members of courts and the representatives of the beauty and fashion of the national capital. The guns had been fired twice, satisfactorily, and the guests were about to retire to the banquet, when one of the cabinet officers begged Stockton to fire just once more. The Commodore complied, and it proved to be "three times and out," for the immense piece exploded with terrific force and scattered death and desolation about the deck! The Secretary of State and of the .Navy and several other distinguished persons were instantly killed, while Thomas H. Benton, Commodore Stockton and many others were more or less injured. The life of the President was saved as by a miracle.
Zabriskie arrived in Sacramento in 1849 and established a law office in a little shanty under an oak tree which stood near the intersection of Second and K streets. His library consisted of a single volume, "The New Jersey Justice." He had, however, a good business, and in a few months was elected second alcalde.
In early days he was a Democrat and a follower of David C. Broderick, and published a paper, called the Sacramento Register, in favor of Broderick. Afterward he became a Republican, being one of the first to espouse the cause of that party in this county. In 1861 he removed to San Francisco and continued in law practice there until his death July 10, 1883.
James H. Hardy was elected district attorney; afterward, January 28, 1859, was appointed judge of the Sixteenth Judicial District by Governor Weller, and later he was elected by the people to that office. During the war he was impeached by the Assembly for treasonable utterances, and his' trial before tlie liar of the Senate resulted in his removal from office, Alay 14, 1862. He afterward removed to Virginia City and thence, in 1866, to San Francisco, where he died, June 11, 1874, at the age of fortj-two years.
Joseph W. Winans left New York City, his native place, with a party of young men who had formed a joint-stock company, and who had purchased and furnished a sailing vessel, and they came around by Cape Horn to this coast. Winans had no idea of making anything but a transient trip, and expected to pick up lumps of gold from the surface, enough to furnish a competence. He left his office practice in the care of a partner. The vessel arrived at San Francisco, August 29, 1849, and was brought up the Sacramento River and anchored opposite Sutterville. At tiiat point the members of the company gathered their mining implements and started for the mountains, and Mr. Winans purchased from them a controlling interest in the afterward a prominent citizen of California, he opened a law office in Sacramento and took charge of an important law case for Jessup. The profits from his law practice extended beyond his anticipations. In the great fire of 1852 his law library, one of the largest in the State, was destroyed, and the few books that were saved were deposited in an iron building for security; but that building also was burned.
Mr. Winans went to San Francisco, purchased an extensive library and rented a primitive but high-priced office here, in whicli he did business during the day and slept at night; but the first great stormy winter demonstrated that the roof was decidedly " unseaworthy," and one night his new library was ruined by the water which came in torrents through the roof. In 1861 he rctnoved to San Francisco and continued his practice until his death, Marcli 3, 1887.
While in Sacramento he was prominently identified with the society of pioneers and the City Library Association, and was an early president of both these institutions. He was dele- gate at large to the last Constitutional Convention, taking an active and important part in its proceedings. He was also a writer of distinction. Several of his poems have been e.xteiisivelj republished; and his prose writings in the riacer Times, the Sacramento Union and other journals have attracted wide attention. His private library was the best selected in the Stale. For several years he was regent of the State University, and for a time was president of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, and also of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children.
John C. Burch practiced law here and was a member of Congress. Was in favor of the establishment of the "Pacific Republic," and wrote the remarkable " Cactus " letter.
Edward J. C. Kewen was born in Mississippi in 1825, and was thrown upon his own resources at the age of thirteen years. He studied law, and at the early age of nineteen years he entered politics and became a prominent orator. He came overland to California with Dr. T. J. White and fainily, and married a daughter of the Doctor's in this city, December 10, 1849; this was probably the first marriage in Sacramento. Colonel Kewen was elected the first Attorney-Gtneral of the State, by the first Legislature, soon after his arrival. In 1851 he was a Whig candidate for Congress, but was defeated by a small majority. Pie left Sacramento in 1852, and established himself in law practice in San Francisco. He was, however, of a restless and daring disposition. One of his brothers was second in command under William Walker in tlie fillibuster e.xpedition to Nicaragua, and was shot and killed there, in June, 1855.
of the embryo republic, and also became a member of the judicial tribunal. He took an active part in the subsequent military movements there, and at the close of Walker's rule returned to San Francisco. In January, 1858, he became a citizen of Los Angeles, where he died November 25, 1879. He was several times a member of the Legislature, and in 1868 ran for Presidential elector on the Democratic ticket.
James L. English, who still resides here but is out of practice, served at one time as mayor of this city, and at another as State Treasurer.
Murray Morrison was a brother of the late Chief Justice Robert F. Morrison, who in early days was district attorney of the county. He afterward served as district judge in the southern part of the State, and died at Los Angeles, December 18, 1871.
Other men who have served as district attorneys of Sacramento County have become members of the United States Senate; as, Milton S. Latham, who was first elected Governor, and a few days afterward United States Senator; Cornelius Cole; and Frank Hereford, who removed to the East and was elected from West Virginia.
J. Neely Johnson was elected Governor by the Know-Nothing party in 1845, afterward removed to Nevada and served on the Supreme Bench there. He died at Salt Lake, August 31, 1872.
Ferris Forman was appointed Secretary of State by Governor Weller, January 9, 1858, and served for a while as judge of the Ninth Judicial District. He now resides in the East.
James W. Coflrotli represented the county of Tuolumne in the Assembly and Senate several terms, and unsuccessfully ran for Congress several times on the Democratic ticket. Pie died in Sacramento, October 9, 1872.
E. B. Crocker was appointed a justice of the State Supreme Court to succeed Stephen J. Field, on May 21, 1863. Field had been appointed by President Lincoln as associate justice of the National Supreme Court. Later Judge Crocker made extended visits to Europe and made one of the finest art collections to be found in America, which is now public property in this city. He died in this city, June 24, 1875, and his widow has distinguished herself in several magnificent gifts to the public. See sections on Crocker Art Gallery and Marguerite Home in this volume.
W. S. Long, a lawyer of note, practiced in this city twelve years; was police judge, and afterward represented Colusa County in the Legislature. Died at Shasta, February 21, 1871.
In partnership with Long for a time were Charles D. Judah and Presley Dunlap. Dunlap was born in Pennsylvania, in 1817; moved to Illinois and then to Iowa, where, in 1842, he was elected clerk of Des Moines County, and was recorder of that county for two years. When a young man he was a warm and intimate friend of John C. Breckenridge. He arrived in California, August 16, 1849, and in October following was appointed deputy sheriff by the first sheriff of the district, there being then no State or county organization. In December, 1849, he was appointed clerk of the court, and at the first county election, in April, 1850, was elected county clerk. For a time he was surveyor, and afterward lawyer. In 1857 he was elected city police judge, and after that term expired he continued in the practice of law until liis death in this city, September 23, 1883. In 1879 he
I. S. Brown figured prominently as a criminal lawyer, being engaged in many important cases. He died in the spring of 1889, while holding the ofiice of justice of the peace in this city,
George Cadwallader arrived in California in 1849, engaged in merchandising, studied law, was admitted to the bar and rose to a position of prominence in his profession, having much to do with mining-debris litigation. He removed to San Francisco, where he died April 28, 1884, never having held any public office.
C. G. W. French practiced law many years in Folsora, then in Sacramento, and while here was appointed by President Hayes Chief Justice of Arizona.
A. C. Freeman, who is a distinguished compiler and writer of standard law books, and editor of "American Decisions," is now residing in San Francisco.
A. H. Lynch, his former partner here, was at one time a justice of the peace, and came to be a journalist of some note. Died a number of years ago.
L. H. Foote was a police judge. Is the author of a number of poems and prose articles which have been published in magazines. He was for a time United States Consul at Corea.
James C. Goods was one of the most prominent criminal lawyers in the State; served several terms as district attorney, and was one of the leaders of the Democratic party. Died in this city November 23, 1877.
Henry Hare Hartley occupied a foremost position in the bar of the State; was county judge of Yolo County, and in 1865 ran on the Democratic ticket for justice of the Supreme Court, but was defeated by Judge Sanderson. He died in this city March 12, 1868.
Daniel J. Thomas, besides being a lawyer, was most conspicuous here for having been connected with some of the railroad enterprises. Died here several years ago.
Henry Edgerton was one of the most brilliant men who have figured in the political and legal history of the State. He was a matchless orator. Served as district attorney of Napa County, and prosecuted the celebrated case of Edward McGowan, which grew out of the acts of the vigilance committee of San Francisco in 1856. He served in the State Senate from that county in the eleventh and twelfth sessions. He died at San Francisco, November 4, 1887.
Thomas J. Clunie represented San Francisco in the State Senate during the twenty-fourth session, and November 6, 1888, was elected to Congress, which office he now holds.
J. T. Carey served one term as district attorney, and ran unsuccessfully for State Senator. He is now United States District Attorney, appointed by President Cleveland.
William Neely Johnson, brother of the former Governor, was at one time State Librarian. He afterward became blind, and finally died in San Francisco in June, 1885.
J. G. Severance was a prominent member of the bar of Amador County, as well as of this county at another time, and is now practicing in San Francisco.
Silas W. Sanderson represented El Dorado County in the Legislature, and in October, 1863, was elected justice of the State Supreme Court; in October, 1865, was re-elected, but resigned January 4, 1870, and became attorney for the Central Pacific Railroad Company, which position he held until his death, in San Francisco, June 24, 1886.
W. B. C. Brown served as county clerk, and I'ebruary 6, 1876, was appointed controller of .State, to fill the term made vacant by the death of James W. Mandeville. He was a prominent candidate for the Democratic nomination for Governor in 1882, but he died April 12 of that year, in this city.
The last City Directory furnishes the following list of attorneys now practicing in Sacramento, extended sketches of some of whom appear in a subsequent portion of this work:
A Queer Case
A remarkable case of mistaken identity was recently related by Attorney Paschal H. Coggins before the Medical Jurisprudence Society in Piiiladelphia, as having come under his personal observation. Two men - John A. Mason, of Boston, and John A. Mason, of Illinois - left their respective homes and went to California in search of Jiealth and wealth. They were both wagon-makers. One left a wife and two sons in Boston, and the other a wife and two daughters in Illinois. The Boston wife heard nothing of her husband after three .years' absence, and twenty years later heard of the. death of John A. Mason, a wagon-maker. She brought suit for his property, his photograph was identified by twenty witnesses, but at the last moment the Illinois wife turned up and proved that the man was her husband, and the later developments showed that the Boston pioneer died alone and friendless. - If. Y. Graphic.
Upon this Themis comments as follows: "The Coggins referred to was a resident of this city, and at one time the law partner of Creed Haymond. He was also a justice of the peace here, married the daughter of one of our pioneer citizens, and afterward removed with his family to Philadelphia, where he has since resided. He is a son of Paschal Coggins, at one time one of the editors ot the Sacramento Union, and who represented this county two terms in the Assembly. Coggins, Sr., ran for Congress against H. F. Page in 1872, on the independent ticket. The case referred to was that of Supervisor John A. Mason, of this city. It was certainly one of the most remarkable cases that ever came up in court, but the statement in the Graphic is not strictly correct. The case was tried before the late Judge Clark. In the contest Hayward & Coggins appeared for the lady contestant, and the late George Cadwalader and W. A. Anderson for the will. It was developed that there were two John A. Masons; that they followed the same trade - carriage-making; and that they came to California about the same time; one, however, by steamer, and the other overland. By a strange coincidence the Mr. Coggins referred to was a passenger on the same steamer with the Mason - who came by sea, and he was referred to in the printed passenger list as an "infant." It further developed that the two Masons worked at their trades in the same block in Sacramento City - Third street between I and J. After the death of Supervisor Mason his sons, grown men, applied for letters on his estate; their issuance was contested by a lady and two grown daughters, who claimed to be the wife and offspring of Mason. There is no doubt that the contest was in good faith and that the lady believed that the deceased was her husband. The testimony, however, developed that there must have been two John A. Masons, and that the husband of the lady contestant had.
like many another of the California argonauts, disappeared long years ago. It was strange that photographs of Supervisor Mason were identified by his mother and other relatives in Massachusetts, and that the same pictures were identified by prominent citizens of Illinois as being the other Mason. Judge Clark held against the contestants, but said that there was no doubt of the good faith of their contest."
Provenance
Text from An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.