Sacramento County, California - Chapter 10, 1890
From An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. 7,330 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
7,330 wordsMachine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
SfTN Sacramento there have been twenty-four M executions of criminals, sixteen of which ^ were according to the forms of law. AVe have space here for a brief account of the principal cases.
In 1850 robbery and murder became so frequent, while the law's delays were so characteristically slow, that the people became exasperated and arose in self-defense. The first victim of their vengeance was Frederick J. Roe, a professional gambler. While quarreling at a monte table in the Mansion House, corner of Front and J streets, he engaged in a fight with an unknown man. The bystanders separated them and stopped the row several times, but it was as often renewed. At length a peaceable and industrious citizen named Charles Humphrey Myers, an immigrant from Columbus, Ohio, and a partner in the blacksmithing establishment of Joseph Prader & Co., again parted them, when Roe shot him for interfering. The ball entered Myers's bead, but did not kill him instantly. He was carried to the blacksmith shop, where the wound was examined by surgeons and pronounced to be necessarily fatal. The excitement of the large crowd which had gathered became intense. L)r. Mackenzie, a member of the City Council, mounted a wagon and made a violent address, stating that crime had run rampant Ions enough; that the courts and ofiicers seemed powerless to prevent it; but that it must be stopped somehow, or all respectable and honest people must leave the city; that the remedy was now in the people's own hands, and that it was a duty each of them owed to society to aid in applying it. He was followed by David B. Milne and Ross and Taplin in the same strain.
The addresses were eflective. A meeting was organized, of which Ross was appointed president. In the meantime Roe had been taken into custody by the ofiicers, and news was bronght that he was in the station-house, corner of Second and J streets. The meeting promptly and unanimously resolved to bring him out, and a large crowd proceeded to the prison, where a still larger body had assembled. One Everard addressed them, stating that if ever they intended to rid the city of the scoundrels that infested it, now was the time. He advised the appointment of a committee who should determine what justice was in the case, and James Queen followed to the same effect, urging the selection of a jury for the immediate trial of the prisoner. These speeches were continually interrupted by loud and long cheers, mingled with cries of "Ilang him," etc.
the name of God and Sacramento let him be tried by the proper tribunal, the courts of the country. He was interrupted by cries of " No, no; they have proved useless to prevent crime he don't get justice in the courts, then I will help you get it; I pledge you my honor I'll resign my office and help you ; but now I am a sworn officer and you cannot, you shall not, have him while I am such." He attempted to continue further in the same strain, but his voice was drowned in cries of, " Let the peo])le have a jury," etc. Queen tried it again. He was in favor of laws and of supporting them, but ours have proved inoperative; let us have a people's jury; let us imitate San Francisco."
C. A. Tweed was then called to the chair, who said lie believed the prisoner was a great scoundrel and ought to be hanged, but he wanted the hanging to be done by law. He was consequently hustled out of the chair and Scranton forced in. Then Justice of the Peace Bullock attempted to speak in behalf of law and order, but his voice was immediately smothered beneath tumultuous cries of "Jury! jury! appoint a jury."
A jury was announced, all of whom accepted, except F. C. Ewer, who stated that he was a newspaper man, and that it was his duty to make an unbiased report of the proceedings, which he could not do if he participated in them. Dr. V. Spalding was appointed in his place. The jury retired to the Orleans, on Second street, and organized by appointing Levi Hermance foreman, and George G. Wright secretary. A committee was appointed to guard the prisoner and see that the officers did not remove him. Some of the officers attempted at various times to address the assemblage, but were invariably shut off. The marshal again addressed the people, stating that the prisoner could not be taken from Ilia custody until his own life had been taken; "If Roe escapes the courts you may have him; but now I call on all good citizens to aid me in liis protection." Some four or iive advanced, but the only notice the crowd took of
The -privilege of letting the prisoner have a lawyer was proposed and voted down. After a few further attempts at speech-making, and endeavors by the marshal to preserve the prisoner, the deafening yells of 2,500 or more people goaded on the leaders to a determined effort to execute Lynch law. The jury was quite deliberate, while the crowd was impatient. Committees were sent to the jury to hurry them up. They reported that the jury were acting fairly, but needed the protection of the people to keep the lawyers out, as they (the jury) could elicit the testimony themselves. Simple facts did not require legal gloss. The lawyers were ordered out, and staid out.
As Myers was not yet quite dead, Tweed undertook to make a point temporarily in the prisoner's favor; but it was useless against the cries of, " But he will "die, and you know it; the doctors say so, and so will the other man!" One stentorian voice, ringing above the rest, shouted, "Yes; the murder was deliberate and coldblooded. The murderer has made a widow and four orphans. Blood for blood! He must die! Let those who are in favor of hanging him say Aye!" The whole street reverberated with the sound of the Ayes.
Dr. Taylor hoped every man present was armed. If so, he wanted a picked body to go with him and take the prisoner; " if we have him in our custody we will know where he is." A large portion of the crowd stepped forward, but were stopped by a cry that the verdict had been rendered, which was read from the Orleans balcony at 8 p. m. amid perfect silence, as follows:
We, the committee of investigation appointed by our fellow-citizens to investigate the circumstances of the unfortunate occurrence that took place this afternoon, report that after a full and impartial examination of the evidence we lind that at about 2 o'clock p. ii. this day, Frederick J. Koe and some other person, whose name is unknown, were engaged in an altercation which originated in the Mansion House; and that after said parties had proceeded to the street, and where they were fighting, Charles H. Myers, who was passing in tKe street, interfered with words requesting them to desist fighting or show fair play ; and that immediately thereupon the said Roe called out, '- What the devil have you to say?" and drew his pistol and without further provocation shot said Myers through the head.
The above signers composed the entire jury, except Dr. Spalding, who, after participating for some time, withdrew in consequence of what he considered the undue influence of the people's committee sent to the jury. As soon as the verdict was read there was a general stampede for tiie station-house; and there Dr. Taylor, who had urged immediate action from the first, stated that he had visited the prisoner and found him penitent; and lie thought the murder was without malice or deliberation and he hoped a committee would be appointed to guard the prisoner until the next day, when a course of action might be determined. The Doctor was hooted and hissed off. A. D. Rightmire said the verdict had been rendered, and he now considered it the duty of all good citizens to see it carried out; he was ready, for his part; and lie was thereupon appointed marshal, by acclamation.
About 9 o'clock awning posts were pulled up and made into battering rams, with which the door of the station-house was assaulted, and under the blows from wliich it soon yielded. Deputy Sheriff Harris stood in the door-M-ay, with a small posse in his rear, and held the place for some time, both by remonstrances and threats to fire; but the impatient multitude crowded those in front up against the door, and through it, against Harris and his aids, pushing them over and taking thein prisoners. Roe was chained in an inner cell, and there was considerable difficulty in getting him unshackled; but as soon as that was accomplished he was informed that he was to be hanged forthwith, on one of the large oak trees that then stood on Sixth street, between K and L. A large portion of the crowd imnie'diately rushed to the point, but a sufficient number remained to guard the escort of the prisoner. Arriving at the tragical spot, where a staging had been erected for the purpose, they placed the prisoner upon it, tied his hands and feet and sent for Rev. M. C. Briggs. Through this man, Roe said to the public that he committed the deed in a fit of passion, and had nothing more to say in selfdefense; that he was an Englishman by birth, was twenty years of age, and had a mother and sister then living in the old country. After the minister had performed his duties, a rope containing a slip noose was placed around the prisoner's neck, the other end thrown over one of the limbs of the tree, and this was seized by a multitude of strong hands, which launched the prisoner into eternity, in the presence of an estimated assemblage of 5,000 people. Myers, however, was not dead at the time the prisoner was executed.
On July 9, 1851, William B. Robinson, James Gibson and John Thompson knocked down and robbed James Wilson on L street, between Fourth and Fiftli, in broad daylight. They were seen and arrested, and before 4 o'clock p. M. more than 1.000 men surrounded tiie jail. Violent speeches were made, and a crowd organized by electing a president and secretary. A jury was impaneled, but it could not agree; and it was decided that the parties siiould be indicted and tried on the following Monday, when a special term of court would meet. The court met at that time; but, to give the counsel for the defense time to prepare, it continued £lie case one week. - The prisoners were tried separately. On Tuesday Robinson was found guilty by the jury, and his punishment, death, was also designated by tiiem. On the 16th Gibson was likewise convicted, and on the 18th Thompson also. Under the first statutes of this State the crimes of robbery and grand larceny, as well as murder, were punishable by death, in the discretion of the jury. July 21st Judge Willis sentenced all three to be hanged August 22d; and accordingly Gibson and Thompson were executed that day, on an old sycamore tree at Sixth and O streets; but Tiobinsou was first reprieved by the Governor and afterward iianged at the same place by the people.
On the night of Sunday, February 20, 1853, John Carroll, alias " Bootjack," was murdered on the levee near Tenth and B streets. He was one of a gang of thieves, and was killed by his associates, who suspected that he was a traitor to them. One of the parties arrested for the murder, William Dunham, turned State's evidence, and Jack Thompson, Barney Ackerman and Charles Stewart were tried, convicted, and sentenced to be hung. A gallows was erected about three or four hundred paces east of Sutter's Fort, on an open plain, where every person was afforded an excellent opportunity to witness the execution; and on the 29th of April, 1853, the men were hanged. Thompson was aged twenty-five, Stewart twenty, and Ackerman nineteen.
Ah Chung, a Chinaman, was executed between J and K streets, just below Sutter's Fort, May 9, 1856, for the murder of one of his country-women, named Ah Lei, February 8, 1856. The execution was public and was witnessed by a large number. The culprit claimed the murdered woman to be his wife and accused her of infidelity.
Samuel L. Garrett was hung near Sutter's Fort, June 27, 1856, for the murder of Amiel Brickell, at the Golden Eagle Hotel, April 26, 1855. Brickell had had some difiiculty with Garrett relative to the daughter of the former, whom the latter was accused of having seduced, and it ended in Garrett fatally shooting Brickell. On the 20th of November following he was tried for the murder before Judge Monson and convicted. He was sentenced to be executed January 9, 1856, but an appeal was taken to the Saj)reme Court, and May 5 the judgment of the court below was sustained and the convict was again sentenced to death, which sentence was executed. Garrett a native of Pennsylvania, born in 1833, was married to Miss Harriet L. Brickell, the daughter of the murdered man, by Justice C. C. Jenks on the prison brig the Sunday befoi'e the execution, in the presence of a large assembly. She attempted suicide by taking poison a day or two before he was hanged.
William S. Kelly was executed at the same moment, for the murder of Daniel C. Howe, at Lake Valley, El Dorado County. On the night of July 10, 1855, Mickey Free, George Wilson and this Kelly went into the cabin of Howe and Ruggles, traders, for the purpose of robbery. Free shot Howe dead, and Wilson shot Kuggles with a long rifie, but did not kill him. liuggles turned his side to them after receiving the wound and asked them to kill him, when Free said he would accommodate him and stabbed him several times with a bowie-knife. After Ruggles was dead Wilson declared that Kelly must have a hand in the murder also, and forced him to cut the throat of the murdered man. This is the version given by the criminal himself.
Free was executed October 26, 1855, at Coloma, and in his confession substantiated Kelly's statement. Wilson was the principal witness against Kelly, and testified that Kelly cut Ruggles's throat before the latter was dead. Kelly got a change of venue in November, 1855, to this county, and was tried and convicted before Judge Monson, December 20, 1855. The usual motions, in arrest of judgment, a new trial, etc., were made and overruled, and an appeal taken to the Supreme Court, but the judgment of the Lower Court was sustained and the original sentence was executed.
Peter Lundberg, who murdered John Peter Ritz, was executed in the water-works building April 13, 1860. He was at work for a man named Palm, and between his employer and Ritz there was an enmity, which grew out of a dispute concerning some money which the latter owed the former, and did not pay on account of failure in business. Lundberg confessed that he was induced to commit the murder, and Mrs. Palm was arrested for the murder, but acquitted. One'dark night Ritz walked out to call on a friend above the old gas-works, and when returning, about 9 o'clock, was shot dead. The officers suspected that Palm committed the deed, and officer Burke went to Palm's house. Mrs. Palm was there alone. Burke turned down the light and waited. In a short time Lnndberg arrived, and the muddy appearance of his clothes, etc., caused the officer to suspect him, and he was arrested.
The case of William Wells, in 1860, was an extraordinary one. It seems that an old man named Matthias Wetzel had been murdered and robbed of a large amount of jewelry and precious stones some time during that year. Wells had been arrested for this murder at Virginia City, Nevada, some of the spoils found in his possession, and was on his way from that place to Sacramento in charge of Deputy Sherifi' Wharton, of Sutter County, and George Armstrong, a mountaineer of Virginia City. July 25 they left Marysville for this city. Tiie stage reached Nicolaus with all safe on board and was about to continue the trip when Wharton went to the driver, Whipple, and told him that that the morning stage from Marysville had been met on Lisle's bridge by a posse of men who had the appearance of a rescuing mob. Whipple drove into town without his passengers, and reported to the police officers the state of affiiirs, and that Wharton expected assistance, and would wait until the officers came. Officer Deal and Whipple returned to Nicolaus, where they learned that Wharton had engaged a wagon, and a man named W. C. Stoddard to attend them; and that they had left Nicolaus at 10 p. M. by the river road, for the.purpose of avoiding the supposed mob. At about 1:30 a. m. they arrived at a point about half a mile from Swift's bridge at tlie mouth of the American Eiver. At this time Stoddard was driving, with Wharton sitting on the seat beside him. Behind them, on the bottom of the wagon box.
sat Wells; and stretched out on the bottom lay Armstrong fast asleep. Stoddard remarked to Wharton, "We are near to Sacramento; you had better wake Armstrong up." As Wharton turned to do so. Wells shot him in his right side, which had the effect of knocking him off the seat among the horses. The next instant Stoddard was shot and instantly killed; and a third discharge rendered Armstrong helpless. By this time Wharton had disengaged himself and tired on Wells, who was retreating and returned the fire, striking Wharton in the thigh.
It appears that Wells felt entirely safe for a time, as he coolly started toward town, then went down to the river, took a row-boat and rowed back to the scene of the tragedy, where he robbed Armstrong of the money and jewelry stolen from Wetzel. Armstrong died that day, and Wharton the next.
Wells evidently had taken the key to his handcufl's from Armstrong's pocket, and, after freeincr his wrists, had snatched Armstrong's revolver from his belt and used it as above described. For several years he was reported as having been seen, sometimes in one State, sometimes in another. March 1, 1866, the officers brought a man whom the\' had arrested in Idaho, to Sacramento, under the impression that he was Wells; but it proved to be Donald McDonald, and he was released, and afterward presented with $600, by vote of the Legislature, to compensate him for loss of time and damage to reputation. The last we hear of AVells is in a letter received by the Union, from a man in Idaho, in which we are informed tiiat Wells was killed in Washington Territory in 1864, by one of the party with whom he was traveling. But the theory generally accepted among theofficers of Sacramento is that Wells did not disengage himself from the irons, and in attempting to swim the Sacramento River was drowned. He had been known as a man of low character, frequently arrested for petty larceny, and as a lounger at Wetzel's saloon.
works building, November 29, 1861, for the | murder uf Catherine Gerken. On the night of January 4 preceding, tiie murdered woman was found at lier residence on L street, near Second, at about midnight, strangled in her room. The deed had been committed evidently for the purpose of robbery. On the afternoon of the following day, Officer Frank Hardy, with the aid of a convict called "Jimmy from Town," arrested Kahl at the Father Rhine house, on J street, opposite the Plaza. The watch of the murdered woman was found on his person, and he gave no very satisfactory account of it. lie was tried, convicted and sentenced to be executed. His case was taken to the Supreme Court, and sent back to the District Court with directions to carry out the original sentence. He was a native of Germany, and twenty- three years of age.
William Williams was hung May 20, 1864, for the murder of A. Blanchard. Williams was born in Wales in 1827, and came to California in 1854, settling in San Joaquin Township, this county, in partnership with Blanchard._ They quarreled, had a lawsuit and dissolved partnership. Afterward they ranched as neighbors, but continually disagreed. They had a difficulty about the ownership of a horse, which was settled in Blanchard's favor. Williams had in his employ a half-witted Englishman, named Joe Blake. On the night of August 3, 1860, Blanchard was returning home from Sacramento, when Williams and Blake lay in wait for him in a ditch. Williams had a pickhandle, and Blake a wagon-spoke. Next day Blanchard was found dead, with his head terribly mutilated. For this Williams was arrested, convicted, and hanged in the extreme outskirts of Washington, about a quarter of a mile from the river.
George Nelsou Symonds was hung in the old water-works building, December 4, 1863, for the murder of B. F. Russell, on the night of July 11, 1860, near Benson's Ferry. Symonds and Monroe Crozier were arrested for a robbery committed in Placer County, immediately after the murder, and before it was known that it had been committed. On the 12th of July they crossed the ferry with four horses, saddled and bridled. Their clothing was wet and their appearance suspicious. When arrested for the robbery they had a valise containing bloody clothing, a stencil plate with the name of B. F. Russell on it, and other articles of the murdered man.
In October, 1860, Symonds turned State's evidence in the robbery case. Crozier soon after escaped, and on the night of October - two bodies were found in the slough near the ferry, which had evidently been murdered several months previous and sunk. They were discovered when the water in the slough dried up, and proved to be those of Russell and Selizer, who had early in the season started for the Coso mines. The trial of Symonds, who was brought down from Placer after the bodies were found, commenced March 9, 1861, before Judge McKune. He was convicted, and sentenced to be hung May 10. The Supreme Court granted him a new trial, and it comnjenced June 2, 1862, and on the 6th he was again convicted, and sentenced to be hung July 25. The case was again taken to the Supreme Court, and on September 18 the judgment of the District Court was affirmed, and he was sentenced for the third time.
Frank Hudson, a Corporal in Company I, Second Cavalry, was executed at Camp Union (Agricultural Park), June 16, 1865, for the murder of Lieutenant Daniel Webster Levergood, at Camp Bidwell, Butte County, on the 14th of April. Levergood had ordered Hudson on a doubfe quick in the afternoon, for drunkenness, and at 9 o'clock in the evening the officer was shot, and died in two days. He was certain that Hudson shot him, and as the latter at once deserted, the evidence was very strong. He was captured, tried by court-martial, brought here and hanged.
Exchange Saloon. The alleged cause wa.s that Lundhohn had written some slanderous articles about a relative of McLaughlin's, which was published in a disreputable sheet called the Mazeppa. McLaughlin was indicted. The regular venire of jurors was soon exhausted, and a second one drawn, which, singularly enough, was almost entirely composed of the prisoner's friends. The prosecution exhausted all of their peremptory challenges and were obliged to go to trial. As expected, the jury failed to agree, and after being out threj days were discharged, though defendant objected. Shortly afterward, defendant's counsel applied for bail, which was refused by Judge Eamage. A writ of habeas corpus was issued by the Supreme Court providing for bail, which was granted in the sum of $10,000, the court holding that the fact of a disagreement of the jur^' indicated grave doubt about the offense being murder in the first degree. The second trial was held in October, and the jury gave a verdict of murder in the first degree. Defendant's counsel gave notice of a motion for a new trial. The judge then adjourned court until 9 o.'clock the next morning. McLaughlin was not given in charge of the sheriff, and walked out of the court-house. During the evening he was seen at several places in town, but did not appear for sentence the next morning, and was next heard of in South America, where lie died a few years ago. Judge Ramage held that the order of the Supreme Court admitting McLaughlin to bail and the bail bond provided for the appearance of the defendant for judgment and the execution thereof, and that by issuing an order to take McLaughlin into custody, he would be placed in contempt. The case became subject of much comment.
Charles Mortimer, whose true name was Charles J. Flinn, was executed in the Sacramento County jail-yard, May 15, 1873, for the murder of Mary Gibson. »
On the morning of September 20, 1872, the citizens were startled by the announcement that Mary Gibson had been brutally murdered at her saloon and residence on "Jib-boom" street - now extinct - or near the Station-lionse on Front street. Her body was found in a rear room with her face badly lacerated by a blow from a broken tumbler, and her throat cut with a knife. A glass of beer was found which by analysis was ascertained to contain strychnine. The house had been ransacked, and it was believed that several hundred dollars in coin had been stolen. The hand of the dead woman grasped a portion of a man's whiskers, evidently torn from the face of her murderer in the death struo-gle. Officers Harris and Dole, having seen Mm-timer drunk the evening before, suspected that he might be the murderer. Carrie Spencer, a companion of Mortimer, was arrested on suspicion, and Mortimer himself was soon afterward arrested. An examination of their room revealed the fact that the suspected parties had possession of several of Mrs. Gibson's dresses. In Mortimer's pocket was found a paper of strychnine. Altogether, the clues of the identity of Mortimer were as definite as could be desired.
During the progress of the trial it was found that he had killed one Caroline Frenel in San Francisco, in May previous. He was convicted of murder in the first degree, and afterward he prepared a confession at length, which he gave to S. C. Denson and Cameron H. King, his attorneys, as the only means within his power to compensate them for their legal services in his defense. In this confession the convicted man admitted having murdered both Mrs. Gibson and Caroline Prenel; but, as is natural, he implicated Carrie more than himself. According to his confession it seems that he was naturally a very selfish man, willing at any time to practice deception in order to get more than his share.
On the night of April 16 a remarkable attempt was made to rescue him from ihe county jail. The sheriff and deputies had been informed that such an attempt might possibly be made. At 1:30 o'clock the yard bell was rung, and Deputy Sheriff Cross, on going cautiously into the yard, encountered a man with his face masked, without iiis boots, with his coat turned wrong side out, and with a revolver in his hand. He had scaled the wall with a ladder. He attempted to enter the jail and Cross fired at him twice and killed him. It became evident from papers, etc., in his pockets that his name was William J. Flinn, and that he was a resident of Lynn, Massachusetts. Mortimer subsequently acknowledged that this was his brother, and that his own name was Charles J. Flinn. He had left home in 1858, since which time his family had known nothing of his career; but after his arrest here he wrote to his brothers, for the first time, soliciting their financial aid.
An elaborate attempt was made to prove that Mortimer was insane during the past few weeks of his confinement, but without avail. He feigned insanity by staring vacantly at the walls, refusing to speak, brushing away imaginary flies, etc. According to the sentence, the wretched convict was hanged at noon, Friday, May 15, 1873, in the presence of about 150 invited spectators. Many more were of course outside the wall desiring admission, among them a number of women. lu the execution the fall was immediately fatal, not a quiver of muscle being noticeable.
About midnight of April 7, 1874, the body of John Cruse, a German sailor, was found on Front, near N street. His death had evidently been caused by stabbing. Although there at first appeared to be literally no clue to the identity of the murderers, yet the measures adopted by Chief Karcher and his force were so energetic and conclusive that before dark of the day following the police had arrested the culprits and obtained the full particulars of their crime. A month afterward the Grand Jury presented indictments against Domingo Estrada and Filomena Cotta for murder in the first degree. May 15 they were arraigned, and pleaded not guilty. I. S. Brown appeared as counsel for Estrada, and James C. Goods, Jo Hamilton and Paschal H. Coggins for Cotta. June G Estrada was convicted with the determination by the jury that the punishment should be death; and July 9 Cotta was similarly convicted. Sentence upon both was pronounced July 28, and September 18 was set for the day of execution. Appeal was taken to the Supreme Court, execution stayed, and on final hearing the men were sentenced to be hanged February 19, 1875. Friends industriously circulated petitions to Governor Booth for a commutation of sentence, but without avail, although they were signed by many prominent men. The sentence was accordingly executed, in the presence of 200 invited citizens. For more than two hours previous to the moment fixed for the hanging, the houses and trees in the vicinity of the jail yard were filled with men and boys hoping to witness the final scenes. Two days previously, Estrada's mother, on hearing that he was to be executed so soon, fainted, and raved all the succeeding night, being quieted only by the use of chloroform ; was in a comatose state all the next day, and subsequently had several fainting spells. Estrada's death seemed to be a painful one, as he had convulsive movements or an active pulse for twelve minutes after the fall; and Cotta's pulse continued fifteen minutes.
On April 1, 1875, a horse-race was run near Koseville. David Turley, a sheep-herder, was present as a spectator. He had been drinking very freely, and was on horseback. W. II. Shaw, a farm laborer, was also present, quite intoxicated. He was on foot, and applied an epithet'to Turley, who pulled a pistol and shot him dead. Turley rode to Roseville, surrendered himself, and was brought to the county jail in Sacramento; was tried for murder, and defended by Creed Ilaymond. The defense was made upon the ground that the accused was so intoxicated as to be irresponsible for his acts; and it was shown at the trial that he had drank an inordinate quantity of whisky. The law, however, provides that intoxication is no excuse. for the commission of crime, but can be regarded only in initigarion of punishment. Turley was convicted and suffered the penalty of death, February 25, 1876.
on Seventeenth street, between 1 and J, a pistol sliot was heard; but no investigation was made, and the result was not known until the next morning, when the body of a policeman, Joseph Scott, was found lying upon the sidewalk. He had been shot through the heart, and from the blood marks it was ascertained that he had passed across the street after having received the wound. For many years the murder remained a mystery. The only clue was that a citizen in the block, on hearing the shot, looked from his window and saw four men running, one of whom wore a long, white coat. Several years afterward a convict named James Ivey, in the San Quentin State Prison, informed the authorities that three men then confined in the prison were the persons who had committed the crime, and that he had overheard them detail the particulars of it. On the expiration of the terms of these three men, they were brought to Sacramento, whf-re two of them made a full confession. They had been in former years inmates of the State Prison, and on the night of the killing of Scott had, in company with another exconvict named Edwards, arrived in the city on a freight train from Marysville. The ride was stolen, and as the train slowed up about Twentieth street they jumped off and started through the city, with the understanding that they would rob the first person whom they met. There had been a fire at the Protestant Orphan Asylum, at Nineteenth and L streets, earlier on that evening, and Officer Scott had been detailed to watch the ruins. He was passing through Seventeenth street when these four men overtook him, and in an attempt to rob him he resisted and Edwards drew a revolver and shot him, as described. The men did not stop to search the body, but ran away from the city and continued on to Stockton, and finally three of them arrived in Sonoma County. There they burglarized the house of Judge W. C. Wallace, who apprehended them, and they were sent to the State Prison. While serving this sentence the authorities received the information of their complicity in the murder of Scott.
They were put upon trial at Sacramento, before Judge A. Van K. Paterson, then a superior judge, but now a justice of the State Supreme Court. Two of the accused, as we have stated, made full confessions, and were permitted to plead guilty of murder in tiie first degree, with the understanding tiiat their punishment should be life imprisonment. The third one stoutly refused to confess, and exhibited feelings of indignation because the other two had. Finally the authorities proposed to him to plead guilty as the others had. He accepted it and received a life sentence.
On the morning of August 2, 1878, A. M. Tullis, a wealthy fruit-raiser on Grand Island, in the lower part of the county, was found dead in his orchard, with a bullet-hole through his body. He was a bachelor, aged about fifty-five years, and had lived alone upon his ranch. There was apparently no motive for the murder, as no property had been taken, and for a time the officers were at sea to unravel the mystery. At length pieces of new redwood lumber were found in the tules on the opposite side of the river, a little lower down; and from the indications they were portions of a duck-boat. Upon one of the pieces were figures used in calculations of lumber measurement. These boards were secured by the officers, and the pieces containing figures were taken to the various lumber-yards in Sacramento, and a salesman at one of the yards identified them as iiaving been made by himself. It was developed subsequently that Anderson had purchased the lumber; that the salesman had figured the number of feet in the purchase upon the smooth side of a board; tiiat Anderson's curiosity was aroused as to how the determination could be made in a manner so simple; that the salesman had repeated the figiiriTig upon one of tlie lioards wliich Anderson liad purchased. The officers then found tlie drayman who had taken the lumber from the yard, and discovered that he had delivered it at the house of Dye.
The information from the neighbors showed that a boat was made in the basement of that house, and the expressman was found who had taken the boat to the river. Parties along the river had ohseri-ed an unpainted boat containing two men passing down, and their descriptions were obtained. Upon this information a clue was based which resulted in the arrest of Dye and Anderson, the third party being then unknown. They were confined in separate jails, and they confessed fully concerning the crime.
Dye had been elected to, and was thea holding, the office of public administrator. It was ascertained from their confessions that soon after his election he had entered into an arrangement with Anderson and Tom Lawton] to kill certain wealthy persons who had tio relatives in the State, to enable Dye to administer upon their estate and receive the commissions. He, of course, was to divide the spoils with those who killed for him. Tullis was the first victim selected. Anderson and Lawton went to Tullis's ranch in the duck-boat, and met Tullis in his orchard. They had never met him before, but he liad been fully described to thera by Dye. AYhile in conversation with him, Anderson struck him with a sand-bag, and Lawton shot him. They then rowed to the opposite side of tiie river, and started up the road. By appointment Dye met them on the way up in a buggy, the signal of his approach being that he should whistle the tune "Sweet Bye and Bye." They returned to the city and took oysters, and Anderson on the same night rode up to Sutter County, where he had been employed on a threshing-machine, and resumed his work there. It was understood I)etween them that in case there should be danger a letter should be written to him, signed by a fictitious name, and that the name should be underscored with one line or more, to indicate the degree of danger.
John A. Paekee, Esq.: - Tour child is very sick. Yon must come home at once. It would be well to come down in tiie night. It would be so much cooler for you. Call at the Doctor's new iionse. I will be there.
The signature was doubly underscored. On the receipt of this note Anderson came down on horseback, and was arrested by officers who were watching his house. Lawton fled, and has never been captured. Dye was tried first, and Anderson next. Both were convicted of murder in the first degree, sentenced to be hanged, and were executed in the county jail-yard on March 28, 1879.
The defense of Dye was made upon the ground that he had years before received an injury which caused a lesion of his brain, and consequent insanity. - There was a division of opinion among medical witnesses on the subject. After his conviction a sheriff's jury was called to determine the question of his insanity, and the verdict was against him. That question attracted considerable attention in the medical world, and was elaborately discussed in quite a number of pamphlets subsequently issued.
A Siberian named Simon liatan had some misunderstanding with a man which resulted in his being beaten. He applied for a warrant of arrest for the party, but was refused. He then procured a revolver, sought out the party and met him at the corner of Fourth and K streets. He shot at him, without effect, and ran away, pursued by a large number of people. While passing through the alley between K and L and Third and Fourth streets, and as he reached the rear of the International Hotel, James Lansing, the proprietor, came out into the alley in front of Ratan and attempted to stop him. Ratan
Lansing hsid been a sheriff of the county and also assessor; his standing in the community was high and his friends many, and the news of his being shot spread over the city like wildfire, and the city prison in which Ratan had been lodged was surrounded by a large number of people, who threatened summary vengeance upon Ratan. Lansing died that evening, in great agony, and several thousand people immediately surrounded the prison. It seemed that a riot was imminent. The mayor of the city addressed the crowd, urging them to return to their homes and allow the law to deal with the offender. His appeal was of no avail. The military were summoned and they drove the mob from the immediate vicinity of the prison, and established a guard line about it. A Gatling gun was placed in the prison door^ fully prepared for service in an emergency. A dispersal was effected. A month later Ratan was placed on trial for his life, the jury convicted him, and he was sentenced to be hung.
About the same time Joseph Hurtado shot and killed a man named Estuardo, at Front and I streets. He was subsequently convicted and sentenced to be hung. The attorneys for Ratan and Hurtado appealed their cases to the Supreme Court of the State, without avail. Then their cases were appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States, upon the point that an information filed by a district attorney under the provisions of the State Constitution was void; and that no man could be put upon trial for a felony e.xcept after having been indicted by the grand jury. It was claimed that the State constitution was repugnant to the United States constitution. The Federal Supreme Court, in an elaborate opinion, held that the point was not well taken, and the parties were re-sentenced to death. Subsequently doubts as to the sanity of Ratan were entertained, and the Governor commuted his sentence to imprisonment for life.
Hurtado was consumptive, and he died of that disease in the County jail before the day arrived for his execution. He had been a hotel runner, but was a man of quarrelsome disposition, although of sacriticingfidelitytohis friends. On one occasion he saved the life of a friend at the risk of his own. Some years ago he had a difficulty with a man named Denny, and the latter was killed. He was put on trial for the murder of Denny, but was acquitted. The night before his trial he had married, and the defense for the killing of Estuardo was because of the infidelity of that wife.
In March, 1888, John Lowell, a well-known rancher, left his home near Brighton to visit another ranch in El Dorado County, about seven miles from Folsom. He was missing for several weeks, and search was made for him, and on June 2 his remains were found buried in a cellar under his house. It was subsequently ascertained that three men, John Henry Myers, John Olsen and William Drager had borrowed a team at Sacramento, driven up to Lowell's ranch, ostensibly to engage in wood-cutting; and that while they were going out to look at the wood one of them shot and killed Lowell with a shotgun, and disposed of his body as indicated. The motive for the crime was to steal a buggy and some horses and harnesses from Lowell. They returned with their plunder to Sacramento, and disposed of it openly. They were arrested, made full confession, taken to Placerville, tried, convicted and sentenced to death. Myers was executed November 30, 1888. The other two appealed their cases to the Supreme Court, and are (April, 1889), still awaiting the decision.
Lowell, the murdered man, a few years before had a difficulty with some parties at Brighton, and he shot and killed Joseph Powers. He was placed upon trial for murder, and the jury acquitted him.
Provenance
Text from An Illustrated History of Sacramento County, California : Containing a History of Sacramento County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Prospective Future ... Portraits of Some of Its Most Eminent Men, and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.