Sacramento County, California - Chapter 10: The Squatter Riot, 1923
From History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. 3,212 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
3,212 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
MANY of the immigrants arriving in 1849 were imbued with the idea that Sutter possessed no valid title to the land where the city stands, as his title was founded on the grant by Governor Alvarado, and the United States had subsequently conquered and taken possession of the state. They considered the ground public land and subject to settlement. Moreover, they claimed the boundaries of Sutter's Grant, as defined, did not cover the site of the city, but ended some distance above it. Also that it could not embrace the site of the city, as by its stipulations it should not be subject to annual inundations, and that by improving Hock Farm he had overstepped the boundaries of his possession under the grant either to the north or the south ; his engineer's lines, when correctly drawn, placed his southern boundary considerably above the city. These claims were not accorded much attention by those who had purchased from Sutter.
But when the immigrants across the plains arrived a few months later, things took on a different appearance. Weary with the long journey, and many of them without money or homes, the idea that they could own the land by simply taking possession of it was an alluring one and the ranks of the "Squatters," as they were called, increased rapidly. Lots were staked off in various parts of the city and those taking possession boldly declared the squatter title was superior to that from Sutter.
An association was formed, and the first meeting was called by John H. Keyser, and held at the house of a man named Kelley, on Front Street, above J. A number of meetings were held there prior to the flood of the ensuing winter. At first the members of the association were mostly ignorant and uneducated men, but later men of tact and talent succeeded them and their addresses began to be viewed with anxiety by those holding Sutter titles. Their speeches were incendiary, and in May a talented engineer, Col. John Plumbe, joined them and became their surveyor and recorder. After the floods of January and March, their organization was made more thorough and a feeling of hostility grew up between them and the holders of Sutter titles. The members of the association began to demonstrate their views by taking possession of lots in various parts of the city. Contests ensued and removals were made from time to time.
May 10, 1850, John P. Rodgers and Dewitt J. Burnett began action in the recorder's court against James J. ]\Iadden, B. F. Washington presiding-. The lot settled upon and claimed by Madden was on the southeast corner of Second and N Streets. The defendant claimed that the land was owned by the United States, and therefore subject to a title by settlement and improvement. The case was argued and the recorder decided against defendant, fining him $300 and costs, and ordering restitution.
The defendant appealed to the county court, but Judge Willis sustained the lower court. The defendant asked to appeal to the supreme court, but there being no law then to sustain the appeal, the motion was denied. Both parties grew excited during the trial, and the Squatters as a body declared against the restitution of the property pursuant to the judgment of the courts. After the decision the Squatters issued a poster, claiming that the laws passed by the legislature were not recognized by congress and not binding, and that the settlers would resist and disregard all decisions of the courts in land cases and also all summonses or execution by the sherifif or other officers, and resolved to appeal to arms on the first show of violence to their persons or property by the sheriff. The card caused great excitement, and many who had hitherto passive!}' approved of the Squatters enlisted against them. On August 11, the Squatters held a meeting on the levee and the proceedings were reported in the "Transcript" the next morning. Dr. Robinson was the chairman and the meeting was much excited, both sides of the controversy being heatedl}'' debated. J. H. McKune, who afterward became prominent in county affairs, James McClatchy, afterward editor and proprietor of the "Bee," and others spoke in defense of the Squatters' action, while Samuel Brannan and Col. E. J. C. Kewen defended the Sutter titles. Captain Sutter claimed the land within the city limits by virtue of his grant from the Mexican government, and through the guarantee of the treaty between the United States and Mexico. His claim was sustained by the settlement at vSutter's Fort, by improvements made, by occasional occupation and use made of the site of the city and by a map of the survey made for him by an engineer whom he supposed to be a competent one, locating him on the land.
As the meeting progressed. Dr. Robinson in a speech defending the Squatters' resolutions, said that, as for him, he meant at all hazards to defend the property he had settled upon.
Madden retained the possession of the property in litigation for some time, by the defense of the members of the association, and the house itself became a sort of garrison, containing a variety of w^eapons. In his endeavors to execute the writ of restitution, the sheriff discovered a number of persons whom he knew among the party who were resisting his authority. He reported the names of James Mc- Clatchy, Charles Robinson and others to the court and warrants for their arrest were issued b}- Justice Sackett. McClatchy delivered himself up and was confined in jail during the subsequent conflicts. Madden was finally ousted from the house, but recovered possession on August 14.
"At two o'clock a body of Squatters numbering about forty proceeded to the foot of I Street, on the levee, and undertook to regain possession of a piece of ground which had lately been in the occupation of one of their party.
They were fully armed and a general understanding prevailed that their object included the liberation of the two men committed the day before to the prison ship, upon the charge of being concerned in a riotous assemblage on the morning of the 12th, for the purpose of forcibly resisting the process of law. After the displacement of some of the lumber on the ground the party of Squatters were deterred from proceeding further in their intent. The mayor had meantime recjuested all good citizens to aid in suppressing the threatened riot, and very large numbers had gathered about the spot; several citizens also, armed, proceeded to the prison ship, but no demonstration was made in that direction.
"The Squatters retreated in martial order, and passed up I Street to Third, thence to J and up to Fourth, followed by a crowd of persons. They were here met by the mayor, who ordered them to deliver up their arms and disperse. This they refused to do, and several shots were fired at him, four of which took effect. He fell from his horse, and was carried to his residence dangerously, if not mortally, wounded. J. W. Woodland, who, unarmed, stood near the maj'or at the time, received a shot in the groin, wdiich he survived but a few minutes. A man named Jesse Morgan, said to be from JMillerville, Ohio, lately arrived, and who was seen to aim at the mayor, next fell dead, from the effects of a ball which passed through his neck. James Harper was very severely, but not dangerously, wounded, in supporting the sheriff. It is difficult to give an exact detail of the terrible incidents which followed in such rapid succession. It appeared from an examination before the coroner, that the party of Squatters drew up in regular order, on arriving- at the corner of Fourth Street, and that the sheriff was several times fired on before he displayed any weapons. Testimony was also given as to the person who was seen to fire upon Mr. Woodland. The mounted leader of the Squatters, an Irishman by the name of Maloney, had his horse shot under him : he endeavored to escape, but was pursued a short distance up the alley and shot through the head, falling dead. Dr. Robinson, one of the armed party under his command, was wounded in the lower part of the body. Mr. Hale, of the firm of Crowell Hale & Company, was slightly wounded in the leg. A young boy, son of Mr. Rogers, was also wounded. AVe have heard of several others, but are not assured of the correctness of the reports. Upon the oath of several gentlemen, that they saw Dr. Robinson deliberately aim at the mayor, he was arrested and placed in confinement. An Irishman named Caulfield, accused of a similar act with regard to both the mayor and Mr. Woodland, was arrested late in the afternoon.
"After these terrible scenes, which occupied less time than we have employed to describe them, had passed, a meeting of the council was held, the proceedings of which appear in another column. The citizens gathered at the corner of Second and J Streets and other places throughout the city, and proceeded to organize parties to prevent further outrage. A body of mounted men under command of the sheriff, hearing the report that the Squatters were reinforcing at the Fort, proceeded thither. The lawless mob were nowhere to be found ; scouts were dispatched in all directions, but no trace of them could be discovered. Meanwhile several other parties had formed in rank and proceeded to different, parts of the city, establishing rendezvous at different points. Brigadier- General Winn issued a proclamation declaring the city under martial law, and ordering all law-abiding citizens to form themselves into volunteer companies and report their organization to headquarters as soon as possible. At evening quiet was fully restored throughout the city. Lieutenant Governor McDougal, who left on the 'Senator,' and expects to meet the 'Gold Hunter,' will bring up this morning a detachment of troops from Benicia. An extraordinar}^ police force of 500 was summoned for duty during the night.".
The minutes of the council show that B. F. AVashington was appointed marshal and Capt. J. Sherwood assistant, to whom all persons desiring to make arrests were requested to apply for aid and authority.
A letter in Dr. Robinson's handwriting was found in his tent after the riot, detailing what he had done and the plans of the Squatters for resisting the law.
The next day brought other developments that saddened the community and were de-^ tailed in the "Times" of the 16th. Sheriff Joseph McKinney was shot down it was said by a man named Allen, who kept a hotel at Brighton. McKinney had gone out with a party of about twenty to arrest some parties said to have been concerned in the riots. Mr. McDowell, of Mormon Island, who was well known at the house, was sent to make observations and report, but the sheriff did not wait for him to return. He rode up to the door and demanded that Allen and others should surrender, but they refused and several shots were fired immediately, mortally wounding McKinney. Several of the sheriff's party entered the house, where about a dozen Squatters were, and killed three of them. Allen, though wounded, escaped, and a number of prisoners were taken to the city.
force and aid the authorities to maintain order. On the 17th two military companies, composing the 2nd Brigade, arrived on the "Senator" and General Winn offered their services to the maj'or and council, but was informed that the citizens' organization under Washington was thought to be able to sustain the law. The reports that the Squatters had enlisted the aid of the miners in the hills, who were coming to Sacramento to aid them, were found to be false, and quiet was soon restored. The funerals of Captain Woodland and Sheriff Mc- Kinney were attended b}- almost the whole city and such was the spirit shown by the citizens that Squatterism never reared its head again, although disputes over land titles continued for many years, making costly and annoying litigation for a long time.
As Mayor Biglow was severely, and possiblv fatally, wounded Demas .Strong became the acting mayor for the remainder of his term. B. F. Washington was appointed marshal. The death of Woodland, who was cit)^ assessor, was due to his kindness of heart. He was walking up the street with a friend and when near the corner of Fourth and J, the Squatters ranged themselves diagonally across Fourth and J Streets, with their guns presented toward the mayor and his party, who were approaching. AVoodland saw their threatening attitude and exclaimed to his friend, "Oh! it is too bad for these men to take such a stand, for they will certainly be shot down. I will go up and advise them." He went forward a few steps to attempt to mediate, when a ball struck him and killed him almost instantly.
Ben McCulloch succeeded McKinney as sheriff and afterwards became quite a noted man in the history of the nation. He was born in Tennessee in 1814 and always evinced an inclination for a roving and adventurous life. He went with Davy Crockett to Texas, to take part in the revolution that freed that state from Mexican rule. In 1836 he joined the Texan army under Gen. Sam Houston and was assigned to the artillery service. He served with credit at the battle of San Jacinto and was employed afterwards on the frontier, in surveying and locating lands in Texas. On the breaking out of the Mexican War he raised a company of Texan Rangers that became famous during that struggle. It was accepted by General Taylor and took a prominent part in the battles of Monterey and Buena Vista and assisted in the capture of the city of Mexico. After the war was over President Pierce appointed Mc- Culloch United States marshal of Texas and the present efficient force of Rangers in that state is the outcome of his organization. The Rangers of today are picked men, noted for their iron nerve, and are the terror of evildoers, penetrating where the other officers of
In 1857 McCulloch was appointed, with ex- Governor Powell, a commissioner to Utah. It was believed that at the time of the inauguration of President Lincoln he was in Washington for the purpose of taking possession of the city at the head of a band of secessionists. If so, the plan was abandoned, on account of the precautions taken by General Scott. Later on, he was commissioned brigadier-general in the Confederate army and assigned to the command of the forces in Arkansas. He issued a proclamation in June, 1861, to the people of that state, calling on them to assemble at Fayetteville to defend the state from invasion. He was in command at the battle of Wilson's Creek, where General Lyon was killed, and it is stated that he surrendered the command to General Sterling Price, on account of some misunderstanding with him. He led a corps of troops from Louisiana and Texas at the battle of Pea Ridge, and fell on the second day of the engagement, March 7, 1862.
Henry A. Caulfield, who was arrested and charged with firing on the mayor and Woodland during the riot, led a stormy career in this city afterward. He was a man of violent temper and often became involved in trouble. Born in Ireland, he came to the United States and in 1844 was a member of the Emmet Guards at Albany, N. Y. During the anti-rent troubles in that state, his company was ordered to Columbia County to assist the authorities in repressing the disorder, the anti-renters having killed an under-sheriff, tarred and feathered other officers and committed other outrages. He came to Sacramento in 1849, worked as a carpenter and joiner and became active in Democratic politics. He was arrested b}^ John Cleal between here and Brighton as he was fleeing after the riot, and brought to this citj^ strapped to a horse's back and confined on board the prison brig. With a number of others he was indicted by the next grand jury on a charge of conspiracy and murder. They were never punished, as Governor McDougal had declared he would pardon them if they were convicted, and a nolle prosequi was subsequently entered in their case. He was afterwards active in the Squatter troubles that followed. He settled on a farm on the moimd north of the American River about 1851 and lived there till the flood of 1852, when he sold the place to Patrick Bannon, and removed to
George Wilson was a justice of the peace and associate justice of the court of sessions and had made some remark that gave offense to one of the attorneys. June 19, 1851, the attorney came to the court room and demanded a retraction. Wilson refused and when the attorney struck at him drew a sword cane and stabbed him. Caulfield was entering the room and fired several shots at Wilson, but did not hit him. Wilson seized Caulfield round the neck and was about to send a bullet through his head when R. P. Jacobs, a policeman, rushed in and saved Caulfield's life. At another time Caulfield was shot several times by Thomas O. Shelby over land matters and several of the bullets he carried to his grave. On that occasion he was unarmed and the assault was unprovoked. As it was thought he would die, a priest called to see him. "I am told you have been a very bad man," said he. "It is a dom lie and you are no doctor. Get out of here," was the reply.
At another time, in 1856, he had a quarrel with a man named Miller about politics and some mules. It was at Miller's house and he attempted to strike him with a flat iron, but Miller broke a cane over his head and was about to throw him out of the window. Miller's wife intervened and Miller let go and Caulfield fell to the ground. Miller sent word to the coroner that he had killed Caulfield, but when the dead wagon arrived the supposed corpse had walked to the county hospital. The same year he was stabbed by a man named Frank Nolan on Front Street, and wounded so severely that for several days he breathed through the knife wounds in his back. August 15, 1878, he had a dispute with WilHam G. English, over a lot on R Street, and shot English, who died a couple of days later. For this murder he was sent to the state's prison for six years. Caulfield was short and heavy set, and had lost an eye in one of his encounters, giving him a trucvilent appearance; he was much feared by many citizens on account of the ugly scrapes in which he engaged, nearly killing some or being almost killed himself. July 2, 1888, while walking on the R Street track near Fourth Street, he was struck by the evening train from Folsom, evidently not having heard the whistle, and was killed instantly.
Provenance
Text from History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.