Sacramento County, California - Chapter 11: Politics in the Early Days, 1923
From History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. 2,652 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
2,652 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
IN 1854 the old Whig party was passing away and the anti-slavery party was pushing its way to the front. The exciting struggle in "bleeding" Kansas was attracting widespread attention and becoming a lively political issue and a fruitful subject for discussion. On Tuesday, Jniy 18. a Democratic convention met in the Fourth Street Baptist Church in this city at 3 p. m. Disturbance was in the air and long before the hour for opening the convention, the doors of the church were surrounded by people, a great many of whom were not delegates. The church would hold about 400, and as soon as the doors were opened the people crowded in and filled it to its utmost capacity.
D. C. Broderick was chairman of the state central committee, and when he ascended the platform he was received with continued cheers. As soon as he called the convention to order a number of delegates sprang to their feet, in order to make nominations for temporary chairman. He recognized T. L. Vermule as having the floor, but before he could make the announcement, John O'Meara nominated ex-Governor John McDougal for temporary chairman. Vermule nominated Edward McGowan for chairman pro tem., and Broderick announced that he could not recognize O'Meara's nomination, and put the question on McGowan's election and declared him elected. McGowan mounted the platform immediately, followed closely by McDougal, whose friends insisted that he had been elected, although his name had not been submitted to the convention in regular form.
The convention thus had two chairmen, who took seats side by side and pandemonium reigned for a time. Finally a semblance of order was restored, and McDougal announced the names of Maj. G. W. Hook and John Bidwell as vice-presidents and McGowan announced J. T. Hall and A. L. Laird as appointed by him to those offices. A scene of noise and confusion again followed, but the gentlemen named took their seats with their respective leaders. The appointment of two sets of secretaries and committees followed and reports were made to each side, recommending that the temporary officers be made the permanent ones. Motions were made to
The convention transacted no other business, but sat as a doubleheader until nine o'clock that night, each side endeavoring to outstay the other. One sickly tallow candle in front of each president illuminated the scene, or rather made darkness visible. The situation lasted until the trustees of the church notified the convention that they would no longer tolerate the riotous assemblage in the church, and the delegates departed without attending- to the formality of an adjournment.
Pandemonium had reigned throughout the session and soon after the organization was completed a crowd made a mad rush for the platform. One of the officers was seized and just then a pistol exploded in the crowded room. The direction of the rush was immediately changed toward the doors and windows, a number of the delegates jumping through the latter to the ground, a distance of about fifteen feet. This ended the exciting events of the day.
The next morning the "chivalry," or Southern element of the party, the wing presided over by McDougal, met at Musical Hall, while the McGowan, or Tammany faction, representing the Northern element, met in Carpenter's Building. The officers of the chivalry wing tendered their resignations and Major Hook was elected president and H. P. Barber, AVilliam A. Mannerly, A. W. Taliafero, and J. G. Downey were elected vice-presidents. The other convention sent a message asking that a committee on conference be appointed in order to endeavor to settle the differences.. As the language of the communication wasconsidered offensive, it was withdrawn for the purpose of modifying the phraseolog}^ A second note was afterward sent in, but as it was quite similar to the first, it met with a flat rejection. The convention then nominated candidates for congress and for clerk of the supreme court : passed resouitions favoring the construction of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad under the auspices of congress, and endorsing the Nebraska Bill, etc. It also elected a state central committee and levied an assessment of five dollars on each delegate, to pay for the damage done to the church building.
ing- to act as chairman. They appointed a committee of seven to invite the McDougal convention to attend their session and also empowered the committee to heal the difficulties. When the convention reassembled the committee reported that they had sent a communication to the McDougal convention, but that the proposition embraced in it had been rejected. The communication sent ^vas as follows :
"John McDougal, Esq., Chairman of Democratic delegates convened at Musical Hall : Sir - The undersigned have been this morningconstituted a committee, with full powers, by and on behalf of the Democratic state convention at Carpenter's Hall, for a conference with our fellow Democrats at Musical Hall, for the purpose of harmonizing and uniting the Democrats of California. You will be pleased to announce this to your body ; and any communication may be addressed to the chairman of this committee at Jones' Hotel."
The report was accepted and the committee was discharged. The convention then proceeded to nominate a ticket entirely dififerent from that nominated by the McDougal convention. It also adopted a series of resolutions alluding to the heterogeneous condition of the party in the state, and to the differences of the convention in this city. The}' urged the people of the state to accept their ticket as most likeh' to effect conciliation. They also appointed a state central committee and took up a collection of $400 to reimburse the Baptist Church for the damage done to it, a committee having reported that the injury to the building would amoun,t to that sum. Several of 'the nominees withdrew from the ticket after the convention adjourned, and the Tammany wing, after the election, ascribed its defeat to the withdrawal of Milton S. Latham, who afterwards became governor, from the congressional ticket.
The time had arrived when a new party was to spring up and enter the field of politics and later to attain a dominating influence in the state. The first mass meeting of Republicans in California was held in Sacramento, April 19, 1856. E. B. Crocker was the leader of the new party in Sacramento County, and opened the meeting with an address that was listened to attentively. George C. Bates was introduced and attempted to make a speech, but so much noise and confusion ensued in a disturbance raised by Democrats and Americans that his voice could not be heard. Henry S. Foote, who had been governor of Mississippi, begged the turbulent crowd to desist from disturbing the meeting and allow it to proceed, but no attention was paid to his protest. When
April 30, 1856, the first state convention of the Republicans was held in the Congregational Church in this city. E. B. Crocker presided as temporar}^ chairman. Only thirteen counties were represented in the convention and of the 125 delegates composing it, sixtyfive were from Sacramento and San Francisco. Resolutions were adopted opposing the further extension of slave territory and of slave power ; welcoming honest and industrious immigrants ; deprecating- all attempts to prejudice immigrants against our free institutions ; favoring the speedy construction of a transcontinental railroad by aid from congress; favoring the speedy settlement of land titles in this state; and the election of only bona fide permanent settlers to ofiice.
A public discussion was announced to take place early in May in Sacramento, between George C. Bates, Republican, and J. C. Zabriskie, Democrat, but when the time appointed arrived, no location could be procured, on account of the anticipated disturbance. The meeting- was therefore postponed until the evening of the 10th of that month, and when the time arrived the disturbance commenced. Rotten eggs were thrown and firecrackers were exploded to create a turmoil, but the police made several arrests and restored order. Outsiders took possessoin of the stand after the meeting closed and a resolution was adopted, declaring "that the people of this city have been outraged by the discussion of treasonable doctrines by a public felon ; and that we will not submit to such an outrage in the future."
Looking back at this day one naturally wonders that such intolerance should be shown in a free state, but "history repeats itself," and there are many similar instances of narrow-mindedness and intolerance in the world's history, not only in political, but in religious, scientific and other matters. But for the evolution of new ideas and doctrines there would be no progress in the world, and today it would be hard to find one to contradict Galileo's murmured protest, "but it does move." The doctrines advocated in 1856 have long ago worked out their own solution, through much bloodshed and devastation, and the whole fair domain of our great republic acknowledges that the destruction of slavery was a blessing to our country.
A few days after the meeting the Sacramento "Tribune" (American), referring to the meeting, said : "The fact that a public discussion was permitted to take place in a public street in the heart of our city, in the presence of a large concourse of our citizens, almost all of whom disapprove the doctrine advocated b}' the speaker, and this, too, when it is the firm conviction of a large majority of the persons assembled that the agitation of the slavery question as the basis of political organization is against the true interest of the state and nation, speaks volumes in favor of the public morals of Sacramento." The extract indicates the bitterness of feeling that had already begun to grow up against the agitation for the abolition of slavery, or its restriction to limits where it already existed. Ex-Governor H. S. Foote, referred to in relation to the first Republican meeting, was well-known on this coast. Born in Virginia in 1800, he graduated at Washington College in 1819, commenced the practice of law in 1822, edited a Democratic paper in Alabama, 1824-1832, and resided in Mississippi for a number of years, being elected by the legislature of that state to the United States senate. He resigned his senatorship and was elected governor of the state in 1852. In 1854 he came to California and joined the Native American party and was its candidate for United States senator in 1856, being defeated by David C. Broderick. He returned to Mississippi in 1858 and took an active part in politics. He represented Tennessee in the Confederate congress. During his life he was engaged in three duels and was wounded in two of them. One of his daughters became the wife of Senator W. M. Stewart, and the other two married and reside in California, while his two sons became practicing lawyers on the Pacific Coast. Mr. Foote possessed considerable ability as a writer. In 1866 he published "The AVar of the Rebellion," and "Scylla and Charybdis." In 1871 he published a volume of reminiscences, and he was also author of "Texas and the Texans," published in 1847. He died near Nashville, at his residence, May 20, 1880.
A remarkable political clash took place July 25, 1865, at a county convention held in Sacramento. Through dissension in the Union party two factions had arisen. Gov. Frederick F. Low was a candidate for the United States senatorship, and was the choice of one wing of the party, but there was strong opposition to his nomination. The Uow and anti-Low delegates in the convention were about equal in numbers and the convention met in the Assembly Chamber of what was then the State Capitol, afterwards the Sacramento County Courthouse until demolished, some years ago. The desks which ordinarily occupied the chamber had been removed, and replaced by chairs to accommodate the convention of 106 delegates who were expected to be present.
It was a noticeable fact, that almost without exception the Low delegates, dubbed the short-hairs, occupied the seats on the speaker's right hand, while the anti-Lows, known as the long-hairs, occupied the seats on his left.
As soon as the convention had been called to order, two persons were nominated for temporary secretary, and voted for. The chairman of the county central committee announced that A\^ H. Barton, the long-hair candidate, had been elected to the position by a vivavoce vote. At once the convention was a scene of confusion, and the Low delegates insisted on a count of the vote. As Barton advanced from the left toward the secretary's table, the delegates from the right made a rush to the left side of the chamber.
So sudden was the outbreak that it is hard to describe the terrible scene that followed and that has never before or since been witnessed in any political convention in this state. Barton was intercepted by his opponents before he could reach the secretary's table and was told that he should not serve in that position. The delegates on the long-hair side of the house hastened to his support, while the Low men presented a solid front to bar his way to the desk, and instantly the battle was on. the opposing wings joining in a hand-tohand conflict. AVeapons for the combatants appeared as if b}' magic, and solid hickory canes, which appeared to be abundant on both sides, were vigorously used. It was a reproduction of Donnybrook fair and the battle waged hot and furious. Spittoons were numerous and flew through the air like bombshells. Inkstands supplied the place of cannon balls and the artillery was in full action. Pistols were drawn and used freely as clubs, but no firearms were discharged or knives used. The principal weapons of warfare in use on both sides were the chairs, which had not been furnished with the idea of their being applied to the heads of the delegates, and uhich were not very well adapted for that purpose, but were swung in the air by vigorous arms and used with telhng effect, being broken over the heads of the contending parties. In many instances they were broken up in order that the legs might be used as clubs. No Homer has as yet sung the doughty deeds performed on that occasion and the names of the heroes have passed into oblivion. The battle, while furious, did not last over about five minutes, and when the artillery fire had ceased, the long-hairs, who had rallied to Barton's support, had abandoned the field. Some had jumped through the windows, and others, who had been badly hurt, were assisted from the scene. The greater number had passed out into the ante-room and the main hall, leaving the scene of conflict. Thus ended this episode of what has passed into history as the "Spittoon Convention."
The long-hairs retired in a body after the battle was over, and organized in another hall, while the short-hairs, as victors, occupied the battlefield and proceeded with business. Each convention nominated a full local ticket and elected a set of delegates to the state convention. The long-hairs nominated Newton Booth for state senator, while E. H. Heaton was the nominee of the short-hairs. The shorts claimed that the trouble in the convention was caused by a partial ruling by the chairman of the committee in favor of Barton, and by the determination of the long-hairs to run the convention, regardless of the rights or wishes of their opponents. The short-hair convention instructed its nominees for the legislature to vote for Low for United States senator, but he afterwards declined. The breach in the party was not healed by his withdrawal, however, and the opposition lasted until August, when the short-hairs gradually transferred their support to John R. Felton for United States senator. When the state convention met, however, Cornelius Cole was elected, December 16, as the agreed candidate of both wings.
Provenance
Text from History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.