BlockBefore

Sacramento County, California - Chapter 19: Local Judiciary and Attorneys, 1923

From History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. 5,960 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

The text

5,960 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

THERE could be nothing more instructive and interesting than the origin and development of the judicial system and the aids thereto by the bar of Sacramento City. In fact the history of the bench and bar of this great state had its inception in Sacramento, where the great legal minds were located in the early history of the state.

The southern part of the state was governed chiefly by the old system of Mexico ; but in Sacramento the common law was at once established, and common sense was at all times interwoven into the decrees and judgments, in the start somewhat crude in their construction, but very soon developed into a splendid system with the aid of the bright genius of the early members of the bar. In this sketch it will be our endeavor to make brief reference to many of those brilliant men who have long since crossed the Dark River, and who in their time labored in the local field for the betterment of the law and the administration of justice.

Under Mexican rule the government of California was conducted under the laws of March 20 and May 23, 1837, and those laws were observed on the acquisition of the country by the United States, until the organization of the state government. They provided for the selection of alcaldes, whose duties were to care for good order and public tranquillity, to see that police regulations, laws and decrees were enforced, to provide for the apprehension of criminals, and in some cases to impose fines and imprisonment upon malefactors. There were also justices of the peace, who served as municipal and judicial officers. There was in the territory a superior tribunal, consisting of four judges and an attorney-general, which had the general review of cases tried before inferior courts. There were also courts of instance," in which cases both criminal and civil were originally brought.

The first legislature, by an act passed March 16, 1850, divided the state into nine judicial districts and constituted the counties of Sacramento and Eldorado the sixth judicial district. Afterwards the counties of Sacramento and Yolo composed that district, and it so

The same legislature, by an act passed April 13, 1850, created a county court in each county, and by an act approved on the 11th day of that month, the court of sessions was created, to be composed of the county judge and two justices of the peace, who were to serve as associate justices. The latter were chosen by the justices of the peace of the county. That court had jurisdiction in cases of misdemeanor, and also exercised functions now performed by the board of supervisors, such as the supervision of claims against the county, and management of roads, etc. Subsequently the court of sessions was abolished and its jurisdiction vested in the county court. Its legislative and supervisorial powers were transferred to the board of supervisors. The present state constitution abolished all of these courts and provided for the organization of a superior court in the count)^ with two departments and two judges, with civil and criminal jurisdiction.

In the latter part of August, 1849, General B. Riley, acting military governor of California, appointed James S. Thomas judge of the court of first instance, with criminal jurisdiction. On the 2nd of September, 1849, Thomas entered upon the duties of his office. A suit was instituted for the recovery of money. A summons was made returnable the same day at four o'clock, at which time judgment was entered and execution ordered. This gives some idea of the rapidity with which business, even of a judicial character, was transacted at that early period of Sacramento's history. On the 3rd of September, Judge Thomas appointed J. P. Rogers clerk of his court. The latter gentleman served in that capacity until the 19th of November following, and resigned, whereupon James R. Lawrence was appointed. He continued until the 27th of December, at which time Presley Dunlap was appointed to the position.

ings, afterwards chief justice of the supreme court of the state and subsequently attorneygeneral, also the founder of Hastings Law College, acted as prosecuting attorney. D. B. Hanner, who had been elected sheriff by the people in their primary capacity, attended both civil and criminal courts. The first case before Judge Shannon was a prosecution against a party for stealing a cow from Samuel Norris. During the trial defendant's counsel objected to the proceedings because they were not in conformity with the constitutional provision guaranteeing to every party accused of high crime, that before he could be put upon trial he must have been indicted by a grand jury. The court held that inasmuch as the defendant had not raised the question in the beginning of the case, he was deemed as waiving his right, and that the trial must proceed. The defendant was found guilty and fined $200 and costs, which amounted to $515 ; rather costly beef !

About December 1, 1849, R. A. Wilson succeeded to the bench, vice Shannon, deceased. On January 11, 1850, he appointed A. J. Mc- Call clerk of his court for Sacramento, and on January 26 he appointed Stephen J. Field clerk of his court, to reside at Marysville. Mr. Field was afterwards supreme justice of the State of California, and associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. During the time Sacramento was flooded that winter, Wilson held his court at Marysville. The two courts alluded to did the judicial business of the district, both civil and criminal, until the organization of the judiciary under the state constitution. May 30, 1850.

The first district judges were elected by the legislature March 30, 1850, and James S. Thomas, was elected judge of the sixth judicial district. He resigned November 9 following. Tod Robinson was appointed by the governor to succeed Judge Thomas, January 2, 1851, and assumed office upon the eighth day of the same month. Ferris Forman succeeded Robinson by appointment on August 13, 1851 ; and in September of the same year, Lewis Aldrich assumed the office. He resigned November 19, 1852, and A. C. Monson was appointed by Governor Bigler on November 26, 1852. Judge Monson took office on the 1st of December of that year. Monson had been elected at the general election on November 2, 1852. He resigned August 17, 1857, and Governor Johnson, on the 3rd of September. 1857, appointed Charles T. Botts to succeed him. At the general election held September 1, 1858, John H. McKune was elected, and was reelected October 21, 1863. On October 20, 1869, Lewis Ramage was elected, and on October 20, 1875, Samuel C. Denson was elected. . Judge Denson served

Judge Thomas, after his resignation, returned to the East, and died at St. Louis, in 1857 or 1858. Robinson, who was a prominent member of the bar and belonged to a family of distinguished lawyers, died in San Mateo County, October 27', 1870. Forman was afterwards secretary of state. Judge Aldrich died at San Francisco, May 18, 1885. Judge Monson moved East, and died there. Judge Botts was a brother of John Minor Botts. He had been a member of the first constitutional convention of the state and was afterwards state printer. He died in San Francisco, October 4, 1884. Judge Ramage removed to Kansas City, and died there, February 14, 1879. Judge Denson was afterwards elected superior judge of Sacramento County, resigned that office, and then engaged in the active practice of the law in San Francisco.

As has been stated, the court of sessions was composed of the county judge and two associates. The latter were elected by a convention of the justices of the peace, held on the first Monday of October of each year except the first convention, which was held May 20, 1850. C. C. Sackett and Charles H. Swift were then elected associates. The associates held office for two years. On November 27, 1850, the county treasurer resigned, and Swift was appointed to fill the vacancy. James Brown was elected associate in his stead, and assumed the duties of his office February 7, 1851. On August 14 following, D. D. Bullock succeeded Brown. The last meeting of the court of sessions was held July 6, 1862. The following is a list of the subsequent judges of the court from October, 1851, to October, 1862: cupied -it until the abolishment of the count}' court by the operation of the new constitution. The county court also exercised functions of a probate court.

Judge AVillis left Sacramento and returned to the East in early days. Wilson died in one of the northern counties of this state a number of years ago. Judges Day and Heard are dead. Judge Jenks removed to Oakland and held public office there. Judge Coggins died a number of years ago. Judge Cone was afterwards a member of the state legislature from this county, and is now dead. Judge Clark had been a senator and an assemblyman, and after the abolishment of the county court he was elected, with Judge Denson, a judge of the superior court and held office until the time of his death.

At the first election held under the new constitution, September 3, 1879, Samuel C. Denson and Robert W. Clark were elected judges of the superior court of the county of Sacramento, judge Denson resigned December 16, 1882, and on the 18th day of the same month. Governor Perkins appointed Thomas B. McFarland to fill the vacancy. The latter was elected by the people to succeed himself at the general election held November 4, 1884; and at the general election held November 2, 1886, Judge McFarland was elected one of the justices of the state supreme court. He resigned the office of superior judge, and Governor Stoneman, on December 31, 1886, appointed John AV. Armstrong to the office. At the general election held November 6, 1888, Armstrong was elected to succeed himself. He has been dead for some years.

Judge Clark died January 27, 1883, and Governor Stoneman appointed John W. Armstrong to succeed him. At the general election held November 4, 1884, W. C. Van Fleet was elected for the full term. In 1890 A. P. Catlin and W. C. Van Fleet became judges of the superior court. Then came Catlin and Matt F. Johnson, Judge Van Fleet having become a member of the supreme court. In 1895 a third court was created by the legislature, and Governor James H. Budd appointed Add C. Hinkson as the judge thereof. Judge Hinkson died in this city in July, 1911. At the next election, J. W. Hughes and E. C. Hart, with Judge Matt F. Johnson, were elected. Judge Johnson died during his term, and Governor Budd appointed Peter J. Shields in his place. The bench then consisted of Hughes, Hart and Shields. Judge Hart became a member of the appellate court, third district, and Governor Pardee appointed C. N. Post to the vacancy thus created. At the succeeding election, in 1908, Judges Post, Shields and Hughes were elected, to serve for six years. Judge Hughes died, and Malcolm

C. Glenn was appointed on April 13, 1914, to serve the unexpired term. Herbert E. White and Martin I. Welch were elected to serve a short term, of a few months, in 1914; and in the fall of that year Charles O. Busick, Malcolm Glenn, and Peter Shields were elected, and took office on January 6, 1915. They are still serving.

Courts in the early days were very crude affairs in their manner of adjudicating the rights of litigants. Justices' courts are proverbial at times for the quaint way of administering justice. It was before one of these august tribunals, we recall, that a case was tried at Mormon Island in this county in 1851, in which A. P. Catlin perpetrated a great trick upon S. W. Sanderson, a young attorney of Coloma, Eldorado County. It seemed that Sanderson's clients were working on an old river bed, and constructing a dam for that purpose. Catlin desired to stop this work, and conceived the idea of hoodwinking the old justice of the peace to grant an injunction to stop the work. Acting upon the thought, he gravely proceeded to secure an injunction and had it served and enforced. Sanderson was sent for, and came before the justice armed with books and authorities and tried to convince him that he had no jurisdiction of such cases, and appealed to Catlin not to impose on the court. Catlin looked wise and spoke approvingly of the court's procedure, which made the old justice obdurate, and he stuck to his injunction. Sanderson left for the county seat in a towering rage to secure proper relief, but before he could secure the same the object Catlin had in view had been accomplished by the justice's injunction.

It may not be generally known that in the early history of California other crimes than murder were, by statute, made punishable by death, but such is the fact. On the 14th day of April, 1852, George Tanner was tried in the court of sessions of Yuba County for the crime of grand larceny, in having stolen flour, potatoes, etc., of the value of $400. The verdict of the jury was "guilty of grand larceny, punishable with death." The defendant appealed to the supreme court, which affirmed the judgment, and the prisoner was executed July 13, 1852. Chief Justice Murray delivered the opinion of the court and evidently did not concur with the principles of law, for after setting forth the statute, he used the following language: "It is not our purpose to discuss the policy of this law, although we regret that our legislature has considered it necessary to thus retrograde, and in the face of the wisdom and experience of the present day, resort to a punishment for a less crime than murder, which is alike disgusting

The following novel civil case is quoted from the "New York Graphic": "A remarkable case of mistaken identity was recently related by Attorney Paschal H. Coggins before the Medical Jurisprudence Society in Philadelphia, as having come under his personal observation. Two men - John A. Mason, of Boston, and John A. Mason, of Illinois - left their respective homes and went to California in search of health and wealth. They were both wagon-makers. One left a wife and two sons in Boston, and the other a wife and two daughters in Illinois. The Boston wife heard nothing of her husband after three years' absence, and twenty years later heard of the death of John A. Mason, a wagon-maker. She brought suit for his property, his photograph was identified by twenty witnesses, but at the last moment the Illinois wife turned up and proved that the man was her husband, and the later developments showed that the Boston pioneer died alone and friendless."

Upon this the "Themis" comments as follows : "The Coggins referred to was a resident of this city, and at one time a law partner of Creed Haymond. He was also a justice of the peace here, married a daughter of one of our pioneer citizens, and afterward removed to Philadelphia, where he has since resided. He is a son of Paschal Coggins, at one time one of the editors of the Sacramento 'Union,' and who represented this county two terms in the assembly. Coggins, Sr., ran for congress against H. F. Page in 1872, on the Independent ticket. The case referred to was that of Supervisor John A. Mason, of this city. It was certainly one of the most remarkable cases that ever came up in court, but the statement in the 'Graphic' is not strictly correct. The case was tried before the late Judge Clark. In the contest Haymond and Coggins appeared for the lady contestant, and the late George Cadwalader and W. A. Anderson for the will. It was developed that there were two John A. Masons ; that they followed the same trade - carriage-making; and that they came to California about the same time ; one, however, by steamer, and the other overland. By a strange coincidence the Mr. Coggins referred to was a passenger on the same steamer with the Mason who came by sea, and he was referred to in the printed passenger list as an 'infant.' It further developed that the two Masons worked at their trades in the same block in Sacramento City - Third Street between I and J. After the death of Supervisor Mason, his sons, grown men, applied for letters on his estate ; their issuance was contested by a lady and two grown daughters, who claimed to be the wife and offspring of Mason. There is no doubt that the contest was in good faith and that the lady believed that the deceased was her husband. The testimony, however, developed that there must have been two John A. Masons, and that the husband of the lady contestant had, like many other of the California Argonauts, disappeared long years ago. It was strange that the photographs of Supervisor Mason were identified by his mother and other relatives in Massachusetts, and that the same pictures were identified by prominent citizens of Illinois as being the other Mason. Judge Clark held against the contestants, but said that there was no doubt of the good faith of their contest."

If we should eliminate from our histor}^ the lawyer and what he has done, we would rob it of the greater part of its glory. Remove from our society of today the lawyer, with the work he accomplishes, and you will leave that society disorganized politically, morally and economically. The lawyer is needed in the legislature, in congress ; every business man needs him ; in fact, he is a necessary adjunct to every department of human life. In the following paragraphs are mentioned some of the men who have worthily represented the' bar in Sacramento County.

While Newton Booth never engaged in the active practice of the law, he was a member of the bar. He became governor of the state, and United States senator.

E. B. Crocker was supreme court justice, and the founder of the Crocker Art Gallery, which was donated by his widow to the city and is now one of the chief public attractions.

Hiram W. Johnson removed his practice to San Francisco, and became governor of this state for two terms, resigning when elected to the United States senate.

Creed Haymond was code commissioner and framed our present codes ; also was state senator and afterward chief counsel for the Southern Pacific Company, and died in San Francisco many years ago. He was one of the brilliant minds of the state.

Col. George W. Bowie, the law partner of A. P. Catlin, was, during the Civil War, a brigadier-general of volunteers and served on the border of Texas, Mexico and Arizona.

E. J. C. Kewen was one of the pioneer attorneys and an orator of distinction. He was a Southern man by birth, and had all the fire and vim of that clime. Colonel Kewen was an intimate friend of William Walker, who attempted to form a republic at Nicaragua, and was Walker's financial agent. He finally located at Los Angeles, and died there, No- . , vember 25, 1879.

J. C. Zabriskie was the first city attorney of this city. He arrived in Sacramento in 1849 and later on was alcalde. In 1861 he removed to San Francisco, where he died, July 10, 1883.

John T. Carey was a district attorney of Sacj ramento County, and was appointed United States district attorney by President Cleveland. Later he continued the practice of law in San Francisco.

S. W. Sanderson was judge of the supreme court and resigned to accept the position of chief counsel for the Central Pacific Railway Company.

Thomas J. Clunie was state senator and member of congress. He removed to San Francisco and continued the practice of law until the time of his death.

Frank D. Ryan, a native son and twice district attorney, also one of the board of commissioners of public works, and assemblyman, was one of Sacramento's finest products. No man held a higher place in the estimation of the public. It seemed like the cruelty of Fate to take him from earth at such an early time in his life, as he had but reached his prime when he died, in 1908.

Grove L. Johnson, assemblyman, senator and member of congress, and for years among the active practitioners at the bar of the state, has lost nothing of his vigor and persistence, and is as ready for a forensic encounter as he was wont to be in his younger days. No man has a higher standing at the bar than Hon. Grove L. Johnson. Mr. Johnson can be considered the Nestor of the bar. He recently was appointed to the Federal Land Office here.

Clinton L. White can also be recorded as one of the old leaders at the bar. Once our mayor, and a good one at that, he prides himself upon his devotion to the practice of the honorable profession. His firm, White, Miller, Needham & Harber, stands foremost among the practitioners in this state.

Gen. A. L. l^art, at one time attorneygeneral of the state, was considered one of the best nisi prius lawyers on the Coast. His untimely death was a shock to the profession. No man held a higher place in the hearts of the members of the bar and the public.

Tod Robinson, H. O. Beatty and J. B. Haggin were law partners in 1853, in this city. This partnership lasted about three years. Judge Beatty went to Nevada and was elected chief justice of the state. J. B. Haggin, one of the owners of the Haggin Grant, resided in New York. Tod Robinson located at San Francisco.

George Cadwalader, a pioneer and in early days a merchant, in 1855 entered the law office of Col. Philip L. Edwards as a student of law. Mr. Cadwalader had a splendid practice and never sought any political office, although he took active part in party politics on some occasions. He also wrote some elegant verses. He removed to San Francisco in 1884, and lived but about one year thereafter. The supreme court reports contain the name of George Cadwalader in a multitude of actions. Robert T. Devlin and Clinton L. White were students under Mr. Cadwalader. During his student career, Clinton L. White wrote one of the ablest briefs in the matter of the estate of Thurston, involving some of the most intricate questions of law. The line of argument in the brief was adopted by the supreme court. Judge W. A. Anderson, since deceased, was an associate of George Cadwalader in the practice of the law for over thirteen years.

A. C. Freeman long enjoyed a national reputation as an author of law books. His advent into the practice of law was as deputy district attorney under James C. Goods. His first book was "A Treatise on Judgments" ; later he published a work on "Executions." He was the editor of the Bancroft-Whitney publications and editor of "American Decisions." The career of A. C. Freeman was a great success. He located in San Francisco, and a few years ago crossed the "Great Divide."

Paschal H. Coggins commenced his career as an attorney-at-law in this city, served one term as township justice, and then located in Philadelphia, where he is now engaged in the practice of his profession.

D. A. Hamburger practiced in Sacramento for a few years after his admission to the bar and then located in Los Angeles, where he abandoned the practice of the law and engaged in mercantile business.

Frank Powers was admitted to the bar from the city of Sacramento, but established his law practice later at San Francisco. He was a member of the assembly from that city.

Charles T. Jones, twice district attorney of Sacramento County, and once an assemblyman from this district, died recently, honored by the bar and community in general. During recent years he held the position of chief deputy district attorney. During his career, he was on one side or other of most of the important criminal cases tried in the local courts, and was looked upon as one of the ablest criminal lawyers of the state.

Elwood Bruner, ex-assemblyman and exdistrict attorney, located at Nome, Alaska, as did also his brother, J. Allison Bruner. Elwood Bruner is now deceased, but his brother is still living in Alaska.

W. B. Harlow practiced only a short time after his admission to the bar, then went to Arizona and later to New York, where he died a few years ago.

Judson C. Brusie was assemblyman and secretary to the California Railroad Commission. He died, a few years ago at Los Angeles. He devoted his time chiefly to politics and dramatic writing.

Peter H. Burnett was a lawyer, but never practiced in this city : only acted as land agent for John A. Sutter. He was the first governor of California. In 1857 he was appointed by Governor J. .Neely Johnson a judge of the supreme court. He died in San Francisco, May 17, 1895, at the age of eighty-seven years.

Judge S. C. Denson, now dead, was a resident of San Francisco and Sacramento. For many years, in addition to his judicial career, he enjoyed a splendid practice in this city. At various times a inember of the firm of Beatty & Denson, then Beatty, Denson & Beatty, and Beatty, Denson & (Datman, he always enjoyed a very lucrative business. It was during his term as judge that the famous cases of Troy Dye and Edward Anderson for the murder of Aaron Tullis were tried and the two men convicted and hanged. Hon. Creed Haymond defended these men. When Judge Denson removed to San Francisco, he formed a copartnership with Judge J. J. De Haven, which continued until Judge De Haven was appointed United States district judge.

In Albert M. Johnson, both genius and talent were united in one person. His was an impressive genius, brighter than the sword of the conqueror. His thoughts and ideas bore the rays of immortality, which cast a living, lasting halo around his very being. With him, genius was not a shadow - it was a substance, it was light ; it was matter that never dies. In all his legal existence he seemed like a Theseus led by the golden thread of Ariadne. His logic was like the touch of Ithuriel's spear, his reason like the swell of the ocean. A master of language, which flowed from his lips like a splendid stream, again in torrents as moved by inspiration, at the bar and on the rostrum his flow of language was the most fluent and logical. Its effect was magical, and carried inspiration with every word and thought expressed. Albert M.- Johnson was never obsequious to wealth or power. The later years of his life were devoted, in addition to his profession, to the solution of social problems and to the betterment of the condition of the masses. A truly great attorney, in his comparatively brief career he tasted fortune more than did any other lawyer. He died in Oakland, in 1907, at the age of forty-six years.

Judge A. P. Catlin was a pioneer lawyer, and had many parts in the formation of the government for this state. In 1850 he and John Currey (afterwards superior judge), formed a copartnership in the practice of the law. At that time the leaders of the bar were

Murray Johnson, E. J. C Kewen, Col. J- C. Zabriskie, Joseph W. Winans, J. Neely Johnson, John B. Weller, M. S. Latham, John H. McKune, and Col. Philip L. Edwards. This partnership lasted only a short time, and Mr. Catlin then returned to his former home at Mormon Island in this county, and engaged in mining. It was he who was the author of the name "Natoma" for Natoma Township in this county. In 1853-1854 he was a member of the senate which met at Benicia, and it was due to his efforts that Sacramento secured the location of the State Capitol and was made the permanent seat of state government. Judge Catlin was an eye-witness to the great tragedy of the Squatter riots on August 14, 1850, at which City Assessor Woodland was killed. Mayor Biglow fatally wounded and many others killed. Judge Catlin took part in every great political battle of this state. In 1857 he was a member of the assembly and a participant in the great Broderick-Gwin senatorial contest. In March, 1872, he was appointed one of the state board of equalization. During all the years he was engaged in active practice. In 1890 he was elected judge of the superior court of the cotmty of Sacramento, and served a full six-year term. He was a man of sound judgment and untiring industry, one of the safest counsellors and faithful to his clients ; very slow to anger, but a lion when aroused. While he seemed morose in his disposition, still there was a vein of genuine humor in his composition. No man had a greater knowledge of the incidents of history of this state, and his "scrap books," if they are still in existence, would be a revelation to the future historian.

John C. Catlin and Harry Catlin, the sons of Judge Catlin, were admitted to the bar and engaged in the practice of the law in San Francisco.

J. W. Winans (firm Winans & Hyer) was for many years a prominent attorney in this city. He was a member of the constitutional convention. Mr. Winans devoted much time to literature, and was an elegant writer. For many years he was a regent of the state university. In 1861 he took up his practice in San Francisco and continued until his death, March 3, 1887.

W. B. C. Brown, after having served as county clerk and state controller, became a member of the bar and continued in the practice of the law until his death, April 12, 1882.

W. S. Church was city attorne}^ for one term, then went to San Francisco. He is the author of "Church on Habeas Corpus," and some other law works.

Judge J. W. Armstrong came to Sacramento from Amador Count}' in 1868. He was formerly the law partner of the late United States Senator James T. Farley, of Amador County. He established the law firm of Armstrong & Hinkson. Judge Armstrong was appointed judge of the superior court of Sacramento County by Governor Stoneman. At the succeeding election he was chosen for a full term on the bench. Judge Armstrong was a man of great force of character, and somewhat aggressive in his disposition, yet broad-minded, tender-hearted and generous. He died March 21, 1896.

Judge Lewis Ramage was district judge of the old sixth judicial district. It was during his term that the noted "Tip" McLaughlin case was tried, McLaughlin being charged with the murder of Charles Lundholm. At the first trial the jury disagreed, and "Tip" was tried a second time, at which trial he was convicted of murder. By some unaccountable oversight no order was made by the court to take the defendant into custody, he being at liberty under bonds. "Tip" walked out of the court and never was captured. Judge Ramage was a very kind-hearted man, and had a great reverence for the decisions of the court of his native state, Missouri. It was often remarked by attorneys, that if counsel could produce a decision from Missouri, or something from "Smith's Leading Cases," his case would be safe. Judge Ramage, after his term as district judge was completed, returned to St. Louis, where he died a number of years ago.

John B. Weller, a pioneer lawyer, was governor and United States senator. Governor Weller was a very eloquent orator and a man of pleasing and polished manner.

Judge Robert C. Clark was state senator and afterwards county and superior judge for twenty-four years, up to the time of his death, January 27, 1883. Judge Clark was a model judge, and everybody was his friend. No man held a higher place in the hearts of the people than Judge Clark. The pleasing incidents and anecdotes during his career on the bench would fill a large volume.

D. Lee Donelly was corporation counsel under Mayor Hassett, and at one time law partner of A. M. Seymour. He died about 1911 after a lingering sickness.

John Currey was one of the earliest pioneer law3'ers of this city. At one time the law partner of A. P. Catlin, Judge Currey performed a prominent part in the history of this state. He was for many years judge of the supreme court, and chief justice of that court. Judge Currey was born in 1814, and died in 1912, at ninety-eight years of age. He always was a man of great intellectual powers, and even in his last years retained his remarkable

Judge E. W. McKinstry was in the law practice in this city in 1850. He was one of the first representatives in the legislature from Sacramento Count}*. In 1858 he went to Napa and \vas elected district judge for Napa and adjoining counties. He then removed to San Francisco and was elected county judge. Later he was chosen district judge for the twelfth judicial district of San Francisco. Afterwards he was elected justice of the supreme court of California. He resigned from the supreme bench to become professor of municipal law in the Hastings Law College. Judge McKinstry died at San Jose, November 1, 1901.

Cornelius Cole was district attorney for Sacramento County, afterAvards congressman, and in 1865-1866 was elected by the legislature to the United States senate. At the close of his senatorial term he located at Los Angeles, where he now resides, hale and hearty, though over a hundred years old.

Morris M. Estee Avas a member of the legislature from Sacramento in the session of 1863- 1864, and in 1864 was elected district attorney of Sacramento County. At the expiration of his term of office he located in San Francisco in the pursuit of his profession and was retained in many very important cases. Mr. Estee was a leading member of the last constitutional convention which framed the present state constitution. Mr. Estee was at all times a dignified and sincere man. On the annexation of the Hawaiian Islands, creating a United States district judgeship for that jurisdiction, in 1900 he was appointed to the office, which he held until his death, October 27, 1903.

Judge T. B. McFarland. prior to locating at Sacramento, was district judge of the fourteenth judicial district, comprising Nevada and Placer Counties. At the expiration of his term as judge he came to Sacramento and formed a copartnership with Judge A. P. Catlin, under the firm name of Catlin and McFarland. He was registrar of the United States land office, and in 1882 was appointed by Governor Perkins superior judge of this county. Prior to that he was also a member of the last constitutional convention. In 1884 Judge McFarland was elected superior judge for Sacramento County ; in 1886 was elected justice of the supreme court, re-elected in 1898, and remained on the supreme bench until the time of his death, some years ago. Judge McFarland was a man of fine literary attainments and of most fascinating social qualities. To know him was ever after to be his friend.

Provenance

Text from History of Sacramento County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1923, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.