BlockBefore

San Joaquin County, California - Chapter 6, 1890

From An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. 3,681 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

6 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

3,681 words

Machine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 6

THOROUGH political history of any % eoterprisiiig county that has had the population, experience and age that San Joaquin has had would be altogether too voluminous for a work of this kind, and therefore there are given here only a few of the most prominent points. Tiie list of officers and legislators is given in the preceding chapter. The character of these public men, we are glad to say, has been considerably above the average. Less complaint is heard in San Joaquin County concerning her representatives and public servants than in any other municipality of the same extent and terra of organic existence, probably, in the United States.

The reader, of course, will remember that prior to 1856 the two leading parties were the Democrats and the Whigs, with the tariff issue and personnel as the principal points of difference between them, and that the third parties, of a national character, were the an ti- slavery, under its various names of Free-Soil, Abolition, etc., and the American or Know-Nothing. The two latter were so weak in numbers that they scarcely ever had a local ticket in the lield, or committees to serve at all the polls even for the presidential nominees. The Know-Nothings, however, had several extraordinary local victories.

The First Contest

David S. Terry, a Southern Democrat. Under the head of "New York," voted not only son}e of theDenjocrats,but also Whigs and Abolitionists, while under the banner of "Texas" the Southern Democrats voted for him who was afterward the leader of the Democracy in San Joaquin - the noted Judge Terry. The two wings of the Democracy united and on the 26th of April, 1851, organized the first political party in the county, by electing S.imuel Purdy president, Nelson Taylor and Benj. Weir, vice-presidents, and Major R. P. Hammond, secretary. The object of the meeting was to elect delegates to the Democratic State convention to be held in Eenicia. The following delegates were chosen: R. P. Hammond, S. A. Booker, J. E. Nuttman, Nelson Taylor, George Kerr, A. C. Bradford, R. P. Ashe, W. P. Root, and Dr. Reins. Then the Whigs organized and elected delegates to their convention in San Francisco. Both conventions met and nominated State officers. In the county conventions the Democrats subsequently nominated R. P. Hammond and W. W. Stevenson for the Assembly, and the Whigs, Dr. George A. Shurtleff, Henry A. Crabbe and John McMullen: the latter declined. Both platforms and men continued nervously to shift about, and at the State election of September 3, 1851, the county candidates were elected as Independents; but at the election in November following Stockton gave a Democratic majority of 129 votes.

Htstort Of San Joaquin Oountt

By the year 1855 the American, or Know- JSotbing party, bad risen into prominence and carried the State. At the September election of that year this county gave 100 to 250 majority against the Democracy.

The dilatoriness and corruption of the courts led to the I'ormation of a vigorous vigilance committee in San Francisco, whose policy and deeds revolutionized the politics ot the State. May 14, 1856, James F. Casey, a delegate to the Democratic convention, shot James King of William, who died a few days afterward from the effect of the wound. The vigilance committee hung Casey from the second story of a window of their headquaiters, along side of a murderer named Cora. The Repiihlicar , of Stockton, a Democratic paper, did not join in the popular clamor against the vigilance committee, and its course with reference to these matters precipitated a mass meeting in Stockton, which was enthusiastically attended by a majority of the citizens, who marched in procession through the principal streets. A month afterward political excitement again rose to fever heat, and David S. Terry, who had been elected judge on the Know-Nothing ticket, severely stabbed S. A. Hopkins, a vigilance officer in San Francisco, in the neck, on June 21. He was arrested and confined for two weeks, awaiting the death or recovery of Hopkins. The latter recovered, and Terry was set at liberty. It is thought by many that if Hopkins had died Terry would have been convicted of murder and executed. On the otiier hand, Terry was afterward feted and received ovations both at San Francisco and at Stockton, by his few but very warm friends.

Republicanism

In the spring of 1854, Stephen A. Douglas, as United States Senator, led a wing of the Democracy who were in favor of admitting Kansas and Nebraska as Territories witii no restriction as to whether or not they should have slavery. The bill was passed by Congress and signed by President Pierce, May 30, that year, thus repealing the old restriction called the Missouri Compromise, which prohibited slavery west of Missouri and north of latitute 36° 30'. Breaking the stipulation of a compromise naturally excited the people and precipitated them into more vigorous measures for a permanent settlement of the old vexed question, the source of a very tender sore. Those who were thus opposed to the re-opening of the old and dangerous agitation were called "anti-Nebraska" men, since they were opposed to Douglas' "Kansas-Nebraska" bill. This element in 1854 -'55 crystallized into a party called the " Republican," with which the "Abolitionists " generally joined, and also nearly all the Northern Whigs, on account of their natural enmity to the Democratic party.

The next year the people were to elect a President of the United States, and the friends of John C. Fremont, believing that he had been wronged in the early history of this State by being superseded as Governor of California by Gen. Kearny, determined to ran him for President of the United States. The leader of the Democracy that year was James Buchanan, while Millard Fillmore led the Know-Nothing party. In California, as well as in most places in the East, to be known then as a " black Republican," or "Abolitionist" - two epithets designed for the same party - was then equal to bearing the name of mad-dog, thief, " miscegenator," etc., and exposed one to personal injury. He was certain to be ostracised and pert-ecnted. At such a time, in July, 1856, there met together in Stockton: J. M. Butfington, C. C. Firley, Dr. G. R. Warren, John Tucker, M. Walthall, Jr., B. P. Baird, Dr. W. R. Kerr, and a few others, to consult upon the feasibility of organizing. They concluded to issue a call for a mass meeting in order to organize a Republican club, Wednesday evening, August 2. A few met and elected Mr. Buffington chairman, and C. C. Firley, secretary, and the following enrolled as members of the Fremont and Day-

A committee of three were appointed to prepare a constitution and by-laws, and report at a meeting; to be called bv the chairman. On the 9th of August the club met, adopted the constitution aud permanently organized by electing Dr. W. R. Kerr, president, J. M. Buffington, secretary, and Dr. G. R. Warren, corresponding secretary. Meetings of the club were afterward held in the old Baptist Church on Center street, till the election, at which time the club numbered about 100 members.

The first Republican county convention met at the city hall October 10, 1856, and organized by the selection of J. S. Staples as chairman, and. C. O. Burton and JVI. Walthall, Jr., as secretaries. Dr. W. R. Kerr and Samuel Myers were nominated for the Assembly, and I. S. Locke for superintendent of the public schools. On the same day was issued the first number of the Stockton Daily Gazette, a Fremont and Dayton paper, with John F. Damon as editor. At the election there was given in the city of Stockton, 218 votes for the Republican nominees, and in the county, outside of the city, 329 votes.

During the progress of the campaign no remarkable event happened or parades conducted. The principal interest manifested was in the talent of the respective speakers, among whom the chief were the noted Colonel E. D. Baker and a man named Tracy.

In 1857 a full county ticket was nominated, but before the day of the election some of the names were displaced by nominees from the moribund American party. The combined vote was only 300 in the whole county. In 1859 the party polled only 200 votes in the county; but the next year they gave the great Lincoln 1,311 votes.

the Republican strength, as it had a political significance, and the result was what might have been expected, - adverse to the party to which the surviving duelist belonged. To all appearances the death of Broderick, such as it was, ultimately saved California to the Union.

The most important election ever held in the United States occurred November 6, 1860, when this county gave Lincoln 1,311 votes; Douglas, 713; Breckenridge (Southern Democrat), 1,314, and Bell (" Constitutional Union"), 199. Since then the county has generally given a Republican majority, as follows: 1876 - Hayes, Republican, 2,272; Tilden, Democrat, 1,850; 1880 - Garfield, Republican, 2,524; Hancock, Democrat, 2,370; 1882 - M. M. Estee. Republican candidate for Governor of the State, 2,186; George Stoneman, Democratic candidate for the same office, 2,712 (the Democrats this year favoring greater liberty with reference to the use of Sunday); 1884 - Blaine, Republican, 3,079; Cleveland, Democrat, 2,828; Butler, Greenback, 1; St. John, Prohibition, 141; 1888 - Harrison, Republican, 2,829; Cleveland, 2,823; American, 43; Prohibition, 286.

The Second Congressional District comprises the counties of Butte, Yuba, Sutter, Nevada, Placer, El Dorado, Amador, San Joaquin, Calaveras, Tuolumne, Stanislaus, Merced and Mariposa. The vote of this district in 1888 gave Marion Briggs, Democrat, 19,064; John A. Eagon, Republican, 17,541; S. M. McLean, American, 913. Of these totals San Joaquin County gave for Briggs 2,807, for Eagon 2,831, and McLean 277.

Probably here, at the close of this chapter, is the most appropriate place for the biographical sketches of two of the most prominent men in political circles in this county, now deceased. By the index may be found the sketches of many others, both living and dead.

Hon. David S. Teeet

and Jackson Smith, of considerable notoriety in the early days. At the age of thirteen years he was left an orphan, and in his youth went to Mississippi, of which State his uncle was Governor, and afterward married the daughter of that uncle. Subsequently he went to Texas, locating on the Brazos river, about forty miles from Houston, and entered into the profession of law, which he practiced in Houston. He participated in the revolution for Texan independence, and afterward he was in command of a regiment of Texan rangers in the Mexican war. Then a mere stripling, he crawled upon his hands and knees to shoot the Mexicans, at the battle where Santa Ana was taken prisoner. In 1849 he started for California as captain of a company of emigrants, and on his arrival here he located at Stockton. In 1850 he returned to Texas, and early in the spring of 1852 he married Miss Cornelia lieynolds, the daughter of Harmon G. Reynolds, on the Brazos. Returning to California he resumed the practice of his profession; and during his professional life here he had as partners at different times, D. W. Perley, Mr. Carr, his son Samuel, Major Barney McKinney, and the last firm name was Terry, Campbell & Bennett.

September 5, 1855, he was elected by the people to the Supreme Bench of the State, and he assumed the office November 15, where he served successively as associate and chief. This office he resigned September 12, 1859, to participate in a duel with Senator David C. Broderick. The particulars of this noted case, as compiled by the historian Tuthill from the various standard histories, are as follows:

'-The election (of September, 1859), being over. Judge Terry descended from the Supreme Bench to demand of Broderick an apology for the UDcomplimentary remark which Perley heard at the breakfast table of the International [a hotel in San Francisco], more than two months previous and excepted to. By note he asked a retraction of the language used. Broderick asked what he understood the language to be. Terry replied. ' You said, ' I have heretofore considered and spoken of him (Terry) as the only honorable man on the Supreme Beuch; but I now take it all back;' but if that was not the exact language it made no difference: he asked a retraction of any words which were calculated to reflect upon his character as an officer or a gentleman. Broderick responded, repeating his exact language, which was about as the other had heard it, with this difference: ' During Judge Terry's incarceration by the vigilance committee I paid §200 a week to support a newspaper in his defense.' ' You are the best judge,' added the writer of this note, evidently surprised that at a time when such violence of speech was tolerated, language so very temperate and mild should be selected to shoot him for, ' as to whether the language affords good grounds of offense.'

"As mortal combat was predetermined they wasted little time on preliminaries. Broderick's friends held that if his remarks at the International table were withdrawn, Terry's at Benton's Church, which provoked them, should also be withdrawn. But Terry had nothing to letract, nor had Broderick. So on the morning of the 11th they luet for a duel, just over tlie San Francisco County line, in San Mateo County; but Chief Burke, armed with a warrant from each county, came suddenly up, arrested them, and put a stop to proceedings. The police court dismissed the charge because no violation of the law had been committed. At seven o'clock on the morning of the 13th, the combatants met again at another point in San Mateo County, some twelve miles from the city, and no police interfered.

" About flfty spectators were present. Terry's seconds were Thomas Hayes and Calhoun Benham ; and Broderick's were McKibben and D. D. Coiton. Broderick won the choice of positions and word of fire, auJ Terry won the choice of weapons, which were duelling pistols; distance, ten paces. At the word the principals raised their pistols, but Broderick's discharged itself before being brought to a level, the ball strikintr the ground some distance in Iront of his opponent. Terry's lire followed but a second later, he exclaiming, ' The shot is not mortal; I have struck two inches to the right;' then, as he saw Broderick slowly falling, he and his friends retired. The ball entered Broderick's breast near the right nipple, and lodged in the left side. He died four days afterward from the wound. Terry hastened back to Sacramento, and then to his farm near Stockton. He had left with a friend his resignation of the judgeship before the duel came off, to be sent in to the Governor only on condition of such a result as did follow. JSTow he signiiied his readiness for trial. The case was postponed from time to time, moved from court to court, and at last, on a change of venue taken to Marin Count}', where the Seventh District Court was in session, temporarily presided over by Judge Hardy, who came all the way from Mokelumne Hill for the purpose. On the day set for trial the witnesses from San Francisco were becalmed on the bay. The court waited a little while and then the prosecuting attorney moved a nolle j)rosequi, and the farce was ended."

The "farm near Stockton" above alluded to was a ranch about twenty-live miles northeast of Stockton, on the Mokelumne river, near Clements, to which he had secured a title soon after his tirst arrival in California. The land is now very valuable. He sold it in 1861 or 1862, when he went to Texas to participate in the war.

After the commencement of the war of the Rebellion, probably in 1862, Judge Terry went to Texas, leaving his family here, and served on the staff of one of the principal journals in that State, and afterward became Colonel of a Confederate regiment which he commanded until the close of the war, when he was acting as Brigadier General. After the close of the Rebellion he crossed into Mexico about July 4, 1865, in company with about 150 men, among whom were a large number of ex-Confederate officers, as ex-Governors Trusten Polk and Reynolds, of Missouri; Isham G. Harris, of Tennessee; Allen Louis and Reynolds of Texas ; Generals Joseph Shelby, Sterling Price, E. Kirby

Smith, Lyon of Kentucky and J. B. Magruder; Colonels P. S. Wilkes and Gordon, of Missouri, A. W. Slayback and Mr. Blackwell of Missouri, a id Dorsey, etc. Crossing into Mexico at Piedros I^egras and proceeding on to Parras, they were turned back by the Frencli and were forced to pass around the Bay to Matanioras; thence they came by way of San Luis Potosi, Aguas Calientes tiirough Guadalajara to Tepic, San Bias, and thence by schooner to Mazatlan, and thence on to Stockton. Afterward he went again to Mexico and began raising cotton, and while there his wife took him a number of horses from this place.

Mrs. Terry died here in Stockton, in 1885, a noble woman; in 1888 the Judge married Mrs. Sarah Althea Hill (of Sharon notoriety); but she was ostracised here in Stockton to so great an extent that the Judge moved with her to Fresno, in which vicinity he had considerable interest in land, and also an extensive practice.

The Judge was a thorough lawyer, a faithful and shrewd attorney and a good pleader, being clear, emphatic and convincing in his statements and eloquent' in description, but not ornate. He was engaged in a large proportion of the noted lawsuits in this county, among them the case of the County vs. the Railroad Company, concerning the payment of stock, in wiiich he was instrumental in saving to the county $100,- 000 or more. The suit was finally settled by a compromise. As a jurist he was iufluential in the State, and he was a prominent member of the State constitutional convention of 1878-'79.

Religiously, Judge Terry was brought up a Baptist, and as to the fraternal organizations he was in early life a member of the Masonic brotherhood. He was ever faithful to his friends, but intimate with only a few, being very cautious in contracting familiarity with strangers.

shot and killed by United States Deputy-Marshal David JSf eagle, who was at the time accompanied by Hon. Stephen J. Field of the Supreme Bench of the United States. It is a coincidence that the most prominent characters in this sketch were all named David.

Mr. Terr}' in his lifetime had six sons: Samuel. David, Clinton, two Franks and Jeff Davis. They are all dead except Clinton (now abouttwentj-eightor thirty years of age), who is employed in the United States Mint in San Francisco. Samuel was a very brilliant lawyer, being one of the most promising young attorneys in the State ot California. The Stockton residence is still in the possession of the family.

Hon. Denis Joseph Oullahan

deceased, was a native of Dublin, Ireland, aged sixty-five years, at the time of his death, November 5, 1889. He was the son of Robert Oullahan, who was eminent in the profession of civil engineering, being attached to the Eoyal Engineer Corps of the British army. After receiving a thorough course in the schools and colleges of the great Irish city, young Oullahan began a course in the study of medicine and surgery during the term of which his unusually refined and sensative nature received such a shock from the repulsive scenes in the dissecting room that his ambition in this direction was rudely cheeked. Therefore turning his attention to other fields in 1849, he embarked with his brother Edward, now a merchant of Stockton, on a ship bound for San Francisco by way of Cape Horn. The gold excitement was then at its zenith in the distant California, and the brothers started fully equipped with merchandise, portable iron frame houses and other stores necessary to a successful expedition. Arriving in San Francisco, Denis Joseph entered the merchandising and commission business, a year later going to Sonora, Tuolumne County, where he prospered for some time in the commission and forwarding business between Stockton and the mines of Tuolumne. He also established a flouring mill at Columbia, Tuolumne County. In 1868 he returned to San Francisco and there formed a copartnership with John Hill in the real-estate business. In 1873 he went to Stockton to engage at that place with his brother in the wholesale liquor business. Finally in 1886 he I'eturned again to San Francisco, where he was at the time of his death engaged in the real-estate business. In 1859, in Stockton, Mr. Oullahan married Miss Julia Baine, a daughter of Judge A. C. Baine, a prominent lawyer and journalist of Jackson, Mississippi. Mrs. Oullahan died in 1881, leaving five children, two daughters and three sons, who survive their father also.

The subject of this sketch was a man of natural ability and learning. In politics he was prominent in the history of the Democratic party of California for thirty or forty years. His ability on the rostrum was on all occasions acknowledged in the party councils, apt in debate; he was also a linguist, the study of the modern languages having been well finished and polished by years of travel in foreign continents. In 1884, Governor Stoneman, from among a host of eligible citizens, chose Mr. Oullahan for appointment to the oifice of State Treasurer, to fill the vacancy caused by the resignation of the Hon. William. A. January. In his political life, Mr. Oullahan exhibited those marked traits of character which distinguished his personal career, traits which rendered impracticable the realization of any possible political ambition; disdaining the tactics of the machine politician, he ever ignored the advantages to be gained by combination or intrigue, and hence he was frequently denied the honors of exalted office, opportunities which were ofi'ered at dift'erent periods throughout his long career.

Provenance

Text from An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.