San Joaquin County, California - Chapter 7: Mexican Laws and Usages, 1890 (part 1 of 2)
From An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. 15,994 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
13 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
- Part 1
- Part 2
The text
15,994 wordsMachine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 7: Mexican Laws and Usages
[OVEilNOR NEVE, while established at Monterey, dratted the lirst regulation for disposing of the lands by grants, which reiiiained in force forty years. This was approved by the King of Spain. The iirst general decree was made in June, 1779. To each settler (poblador) was granted a bounty of $166.44 a year for the first two years, and $60 a year for the next three, with the loan of horses, cattle and farming utensils, and settlers in pueblos could pasture their stock on lands adjoining towns. No poblador could sell an animal until he had a certain number, and then he could sell only to the government, at whatever price was seen fit to award him.
The Mexican govtrnment superseded this decree in 1824, and again made certain modifications in 1828, and this was still in force when California was ceded to the United States.
The governor of the territory was empowered to make grants of lands to contractors (for towns and colonies) and individuals or heads of families. Grants of the first-named class required the approval of the supreme government to make them valid. For the latter the ratification of the territorial assembly was necessary; but in no case could the governor make grants of any land lying within ten leagues of the seacoast, or within twenty leagues of the boundary of any foreign power, without the previous approval of the supreme government. The authorities of towns, however, were allowed to dispose of lands lying within the town limits, the proceeds to be paid into the Tnnnicipal fund. The maximum extent of a single grant was fixed at one square league of irrigable land, four of temporal, or land where produce depends on the seasons, and six of land for pasturing and rearing cattle - eleven square leagues (about 50,000 acres) in all. The minimum extent was about 200 varas square (a vara is a thirty-three and one third inches) of irrigable land, 800 of temporal and 1,200 of pasturage. The size of a house lot in any of the pueblos was fixed at 100 varas. The irregular spaces and patches lying between the boundaries cf the grants throughout the country were to be distributed among the colonists who occupy the adjoining land, or their children, preference being given to those who have distinguished themselves by;; their industry and moral deportment. All grants not made in accordance with these regulations from the time of their adoption up to July 7, 1846, when the American flag was raised at Monterey and the departmental junta broken up, are not strictly valid according to Mexican law. The restrictions against lands within ten leagues of the sea-coast were never removed. The only legal grant of such lands was made to Captain
Stephen Smith of tlieport of Bodega, which received the approval of the supreme government. In the Ma'cNamara colonization grant made by Pio Pico only four days before the occupation of Monterey by our forces, it was expressly stated that the consent of the Mexican government was necessary to make it valid; yet, in spite of this distinct provsion, large tracts of this coast, from San Francisco to San Diego, were granted to citizens and colonists by Figuera, Alvarado and other governors. All these acts that have never received the sanction of the supreme government would by a liberal construction of the law be null and void.
The land where Stockton stands, as most know, was secured by grant from the Mexican government issued to Don Carlos Maria Weber. We account for this name in the grantee from the fact that at the time the grant was obtained nonebnt a Mexican citizen could obtain a grant, and the department by that name was deceived into believing this was the case. However, reports are conflicting, as it seems the grant was first obtained by Gnlnac, a Mexican citizen, and he and his family assigned to Weber before completion, and hence issued to Weber in the above name.
Much of the land given in Mexican grants was never surveyed. The locality and character of the tract were rudely sketched on paper by the petitioner, sometimes without specifying the dimensions, and sometimes with a mere guess at the quantity. JMo particular blame however, is to be imputed to the Mexicans for this laxity, as the situation during that period was not such as to excite any suspicion that an accurate *urvev would ever be necessary.
Mexican Grants
The Mexican or Spanish grants of land either partly or wholly in San Joaquin County have been as follows, this list giving in each instance, first the name of the grant, followed hj the name of the confirmee, the area and date of United States patent.
Tue Moquelemos Grant Claim
Probably the most important litigation in all the history of San Joaquin County, was that concerning the Moquelemos grant claim, in which Hon. Joseph H. Budd was the victorious attorney for the settlers. The outline of that long series of lawsuits concerning the matter is as follows:
One Andreas (or Andres) Pico claimed as a Mexican grant, alleged to have been made in 1846, a tract of land situated in the counties of San Joaquin and Calaveras, of eleven square leagues, called by him " Moquelemos." The exterior boundaries of the grant were: on the north, the river Moquelemos (now called Mokelumne); on the east, the "adjacent ridge of monntains;" on the south, the Gulnac, or Weber grant, de los Franceses," and on the west, the "estuaries of the shore" (or tule lands) The amount of land included in such exterior boundaries greatly exceeded eleven square leagues. This claim was rejected by the Board of Land Commissioners, but it was affirmed and approved by the District Court of the United States, Northern District of California. On the appeal from that court to the Supreme Court of the United States, the decision of said District Court was reversed, in 1859, and the case was remanded to the District
Court for further evidence. On a re-bearing of the case ill tlie District Court, tliisclairaed grant was rejected and declared invalid and this decision was affirmed by said Superior Court, February 13, 1865.
By the acts of Congress of July 1, 1862, grants of odd-numbered sections of land were made to certain railroad companies, of which the "Western Pacific Eailroad Company by subsequent legislation became one. Such grants were of lands within ten miles of their respective roads designated by odd numbers, not sold, reserved, or otherwise disposed of by the United States, and to which a pre-emption or homestead claim had not attached when the line of the road was definitely fixed. By subsequent legislation there was granted an additional five-mile limit on each side of the line of such roads from which the railroad company could select from odd-numbered sections other lands in lieu of udd-nurabered sections of land within snch ten-mile limit, which such railroad company did not receive from the United States under said act of July 1, 1862, because disposed of by the United States, or because pre-emption or homestead claims had attached thereto previous to the fixing of the definite line of location of such railroad.
Said Western Pacific Company caused the odd-numbered sections of land to which it claimed to be entitled under said grants to be withdrawn from pre-emption, private entry and sale on the 31st day of January, 1865. But the settlers on odd-numbered sections of public lands claimed that the line of said roads was definitely fixed before the time of such withdrawal, and that the odd-numbered sections within the exterior boundaries of said claimed grant "Moquelemos" were not granted to the railroad company because such lands were reserved from such grant to the railroad company, since the question of the validity of said claimed Mexican grant " Moquelemos " was a matter sub judice and undetermined by the Supreme Court at the time the grant to the railroad company took effect.
This view, except as to the definite location of the line of the road, was sustained by the decision of the Supreme Court of the United States, rendered in the celebrated case of Sanger vs. Newhall, in the year 1875. The railroad company had, however, in the meantime been diligent in procuring patents from the United States for all the odd-numbered sections of land within the limits of this rejected grant, " Moquelmos," to which said company claimed it was entitled under said acts of Congress, and said company with equal diligence sold and made conveyances to different purchasers of all the lands for which it had so procured patents. The land department of the United States refused to allow the settlers to tile pre-emption claims for, or make homestead entries of, lands for which such patents were issued until such patents were declared null aild void and were vacated under and by virtue of a decree of an United States court of competent jurisdiction. This state of things caused long and expensive contests and litigation between the settlers and purchasers, claiming under such patents issued to the railroad company for these lands, and much bitterness of feeling was engendered by these contests; and on one occasion in a personal contest between an agent for one of these purchasers and some of the settlers for the possession of one of these disputed tracts of land, the agent, named Patrick Breen, lost his life. The matter of the cause of his death was judicially investigated, but the evidence in the case did not show who the person was who caused the death of Breen, and that is a matter which will probably never be ascertained.
At one time some of the settlers seemed inclined to resist by force the processof the courts until the question as to the title to these lands was finally determined by the Supreme Court of the United States, and the military were called upon to aid the civil authorities in the execution of the writs issued by the courts.
firmness of cliaraoter, incapable of fear, and who knew neither friend nor foe in the discharge of his official duties; who oppressed no one, but who never failed to execntc all legal processes duly placed in his hands as sheriff. These settlers knew "Tom Cunningiiaui," as he was familiarly called, and knew, no matter how disagreeable it miglit be to him personally, that he would execute all processes of the courts which it was his duty to execute, and they therefore resorted to no force to impede the execution of the writs of the courts after they were placed in the hands of Sheriff Cunningham.
After the lapse of a number of years, and on application from tlie>e settlers, the United States commenced a suit in equity in the circuit court of the United States for California, against the railroad company, and those holding title to these lands from and under patents for these lands to that company, to vacate such patents and to have them declared null and void. The circuit court decided in favor of the holders of the lands under these patents, and this decision was affirmed by the Supreme Court of the United States in 1888. The decision of this court of last resort has ended for all time the controversy in favor of persons holding what was called the railroad title to these lands, and the settlers lost the lands and the improvements placed by them thereon. The settlers succeeded in the first litigations in having it judicially determined by the highest court of the nation that the lands were never granted to the railroad company, but the claimants of the lands under the company finally succeeded in having it judicially determined that the lands belonged to them.
The above is the substance of the litigation ; but it will be interesting to add here a quotation from a San Francisco paper, giving the fersomiel of that long protracted war, published in 1879:
"A. patent for the land in dispute was obtained by the Western Pacific Railroad Company, since consolidated with the Central. Subsequently a Mr. Dayton obtained a patent for the same tract of land, from the Land Department, stating that the first patent had been issued inadvertently. Dayton afterward sold to a Mr. Graves, and he in turn to Mr. Newhall, a nephew of McLaughlin, and at the time his chief clerk. McLaughlin's brother-in-law, Sanger, sued Newhall for the possession of a quarter section obtained through pre-emption, while Newhall's claim was a patent from the Central Pacific Eailroad Company. In 1864, under the twenty-mile grant given by Congress to the trans continental railroad, the Western Pacific Railroad Company claimed within certain limits a portion of this grant. The land of this grant was not reserved by the railroad company to the decision of its title; and when it was rejected in 1865 the land was thrown open to preemption and homestead entry.
"Should any one desire to further investigate this matter, we refer them to the decision of the Supreme Court of the United States, published in 1875, in pamphlet form. This decision gives the full histoi-y of the case."
The first case came to trial in the fifth judicial district court. Judge Booker presiding. The settlers, ignorant of the thunderbolt that was about to be hurled against them by the avaricious monopoly, were awakened to thought and action by Messrs. R. C. Sargent, John Grattan, L. U. Shippee, J. H. Dodge and other settlers, and counsel were employed, both in Stockton and in Washington, to defend^not Sanger, but - "Justice against the most infamous scheme ever concocted by luen, who claim in their private lives at least to be honest, upright and fair." Judge J. H. Biidd, of Stockton, espoused the cause of the settlers, and earnestly and successfully did he plead it. Judge Bndd is not entitled, in this case, to any praise for doing his duty as a lawyer; but for doing his duty as a man he is; for the railroad corporation is rich, and there was a great prize in view.
When the case came to trial before the United States Supremo Court, Mr. Newhall, the agent of the railroad company, received more justice than he had anticipated or wished for, as he was anxious to be beaten by his collusive defendant.
Mr. Sanger. By this decision tlie rights of preemption were sustained, and the railroad company were obliged to relinquish their claim to any portion of the Moqnelemos grant, which had been pre-empted before the passage of the act.
The United States Supreme Com t (only Justices Field and Strong dissenting) decided. May 8, 1876, iu favor of the settlers, and the news telegraphed to the citizeiis here occasioned universal rejoicing. Indeed, the settlers were wild with joy, and well they might be, as their homes, around which clustered all that was near and dear to them, were secured to them by this decision. Accordingly, on the 19th they had a grand jubilee at Lodi, which was attended by an immense and enthusiastic throng from all parts of the county, especially from Stockton, where all places of business, even the saloons, and the schools and all public institutions, were closed for the occasion. The Stockton Guard, Firemen, Knights of Pythias and other organizations attended in parade, escorted by the San Joaquin band. Hon. H. S. Sargent, president of the day, announced to the multitude the object of the occasion. A secretary and ten vicepresidents were chosen, and when all were ready Judge J. H. Budd was introduced upon the stand, and delivered a brief but stirring speech, reciting the history of the litigation and eulogizing certain officers of the law who had unflinchingly done their duty.
After the conclusion of the public exercises at the stand, a grand barbecue picnic, music, dancing, plays, etc., were the order until evening; and even at night, in Stockton, there were jo^^ful gatherings and public demonstrations.
Fellow Citizens: - The booming of cannon, the waving of flags, the glad sound of music and the immense concourse of people express more forcibly than I can doit the feeling of the justice of the cause which we are here to celebrate. The history of the long struggle of the people against the avaricious grasp of land monopolists has been a most interesting one. The land monopolist endeavored to wrongfully appropriate the land which the settlers had, by long and patient toil, reclaimed from the barren waste, making the " wilderness to bloom as the rose." After settling in their peaceful homes for years, feeling the perfect security which should have been theirs, they were astonished to see a corps of engineers, headed by Colonel Von Schmidt, marking out the lines of a pretended grant, called the Chabolla grant, covering the homes of hundreds of settlers in this county. After a struggle involving years of costly litigation, the unjust and fraudulent Chabolla claim was removed, and the people rejoiced as they are rejoicing to-day, and they congratulated themselves that they would never be troubled again, - that their rights were secure and their homes insured to them free of future molestation.
"But, alas ! there cairie another. I refer to the grant Los Moquelemos to Andres Pico, covering this very territory. It received the indorsement of the District Court of San Francisco, but the United States Supreme Court being then as now free from corruption, repudiated the false claim, ^w^'again the people thought they were free from the land monopolists. But they were again mistaken. In 1862 a road received a grant of land to aid its construction from Sacramento eastwardly to Dutch Flat and over the Sierras. They had no shadow of right to build a road in this county, and Congress in granting the land had no thought of giving a grant to build a road here. A contract was drawn up between Charles McLaughlin, who claimed to be a contractor, with the institution known as the Contract and Finance Company. A company was formed, to which the Central PHcific Company said: 'Give us the bonds which you expect to steal from the Government and vi'e will give you the land.' When the devil took our Saviour up into an exceedingly high mountain he promised him a large quantity of land if he would fall down and worship him. The devil didn't own a foot of land, and had no right to give any away. The Central
Pacific Railroad Company had no more right to ^ive away these lands to McLauj/hliii than the devil had, but they obtained a ratification of the contract, and on that McLaughlin obtained a certificate from the General Land Office.
" It was believed by the settlers that "the railroad company had no right to the lands, and they determined again to buckle on their armor for the vindication of their rights. Hon. R C. Sargent first started the fight, followed by other citizens. They appealed to the Secretary of the Interior, who declared that the railroad company liad no right to a foot of land in this county. The settlers supposed that finally ended it. They were again mistaken. The power of money is almost omni])otent and it was liberally used in this case. After the ease had been fought, after the decision had been rendered, after patents to the land had been issued, Secretary Delano reversed his decision and said the land belonged to the railroad company. Their men were seen among the farmers, actively at work urging the settlers to settle. They proposed to give them only a quit-claim deed, and they succeeded in inducing many jieople to take their quit-claim deed for lands they never owned.
"McLaughlin then prepared an agreed case. Mr. Newhall, a nephew of McLaughlin, sued Sanger, a brother in-law, and a default was taken. It was appealed to the United States Supreme Court in tlie hope to get a final decision in the same quiet and secret manner. Judge C. L. Robinson (since deceased, - all honor to his name!) made the discovery of the manner of the proceedings, and notified the settlers, who agreed to defend the Newhall case and prevent the wished-for judgment by default. Newhall sud denly found he had more friends than he desired, more advocates for his cause than he wished, - as he was too anxious to be defeated, - and when the decision came sustaining his title to the land, and with it the title ot the hundreds of settlers now living upon the grant, it was to him like a clap of thunder from a clear sky, filling him with astonishment.
The speaker referred to Hon. S. A. Booker in high terms as a man, the purity of whose ermine is without stain, who in the consideration of justice regards neither friend nor foe but decides for the right. Three hearty cheers were given for Judge Booker. The speaker also eulogized the Representatives of California in Congress as having sympathized with the settlers with unfeigned earnestness from the first. He closed, congratulating the settlers and recommending to all that they rejoice with a great and happ}"^ rejoicing and make the welkin ring with their gladness.
This is the title given to an anticipated collision - which did not came to pass - between Sheriff Cunningham and the ranchers of the disputed Mokelnmne grant referred to on a preceding page. The sherifl:'s writ was to attach some grain that had beeu harvested and threshed on several ranches. Expecting that there might be trouble, the sheriff wisely pre-engaged a military force, namely the Stockton and Emmett Guards. These companies, under Brigadier- General James A. Shepherd, upon whom the requisition was made, left Stockton as early as 4 o'clock on the .morning of July 9, 1884, for the ranch of C. K. Bailey. Mr. Cunningham arrived on the ground ahead of the military and found about sixty men on the Bailey and Carpenter ranch, where 250 sacks of wheat were piled up, and was the first to announce that the militia were coming; and this had the immediate effect of causing the settlers to withdraw. The settlers had made arrangements to have 100 of their number on the ground to resist the sheriflfs execution; but, finding that thatofiicer had made arrangements for the State militia to assist him and that they were actually approaching, they concluded that they had best allow the law to take its course. They had occupied these farms two seasons.
Lynch and Secretary Harlbert, of the Settlers' League, came to Stockton for the purpose of consulting the attorneys of the plaintiif, Goodwin, in regard to compromise. The settlers proposed to give up one-fourth of the crop on the Murray place and also one-fourth on the four qi;arter-sections under attachment in the Goodwin suit against Bailey; but this proposition was not agreed to. Other propositions were also made, bnt all refused.
The militia remained in camp on the ground about ten days, with no prospect of being called into action, and were the subject of many newspaper jokes and even of humorous poetry. The very next day after their lii'st arrival on tiie " battle ground," a rich burlesque in rhyme appeared in the Independent. Indeed, many amusing incidents occurred, all the more enjoyable because there was so little prospect of bloodshed, the peaceful termination of the matter being due to Cunningham's style of doing business.
Court-House Squaee
The early history of the county relating to boundary lines and first election of officers is given in Chapter Y . The first order of the Court of Sessions found in Minute Book "A," Court of Sessions, Civil, page 1, and dated June 3, 1850, is as follows:
" It is ordered that notification be given to Charles M. Weber, Esq., that this court is now in session and prepared and ready to receive any communication from him relating to or concerning any donation from him to the county of San Joaquin, of lands for the erection of public buildings for the use of the county, and thereupon notification was placed in the hands of the sheriff."
" Ordered that the sheriff of the county of San Joaquin be, and is, hereby authorized to receive for and on behalf of the county aforesaid, livery of seisin and formal possession of any and all lands and tenements that may be donated to this county."
"It is ordered that one-quarter of one per cent, be assessed on each §100 worth of taxable property, for the purpose of erecting a courthouse,"' etc. - Court of Sessions, Book " A," pape 6.
The city of Stockton, in the county of San Joaquin, was incorporated under general statute by decree of court, about July 23, 1850. The order recites that the town is incorporated by the name of the City of Stockton, and fixes the boundaries. It was further ordered that that council consist of seven members, and that notice be given of an election to be held August 1, 1850. On the 5th of August, 1850, the officers elected assembled at the Masonic lodofe rooms and organized the city government, as noted in Chapter IV of this volume.
The county and city governments having been organized, a question was raised whether the Court of Sessions, having about the same control over county affairs as the Board of Supervisors now have, could take in trust for the county a donation of land. Whether right or wrong, it wa;s decided to deed to the mayor, recorder and common council of the city of Stockton, as trut.tees; aud on Decenjber 26, 1851, Charles M. Weber duly acknowledged a deed, the date of which was August 28, 1850, to the mayor, recorder and common council, reciting, " For and in consideration of the public convenience and other good considerations, * * * doth give, grant, alien, enfeoff and confirm block Ko. 3, east of Centre street, in said city, said block being intended by the grantor as the location of the county courthouse, and for the erection of such other public buildings as may be deemed advisable by the proper authorities."
After this the county and city authorities jointly erected a court-house and city hall, and ]iaid equally for the same, in all about §80,000. This court-house was finished early in 1854.
Hi8T0Bt Of San Joaquin County
to tlie square, the city, after adopting a proper ordinance authorizing the same, did, on October 5, 1855, deed to the county an undivided onehalf interest in the square, reciting tliat it was '' for public purposes and for the public good, as was originally designed by C. M. Weber in his conveyance to said city; said square being intended by the grantor, C. M. Weber, as the location of the county court-house."
The county and city continued to occupy and use the court-house and square, and to pay equally for grading, boring artesian wells, and making other improvements to 1885. The county, tinding it necessary to erect a new and much larger court-house in place of the old one, desired to erect the new building in the center of the square. Some of the city authorities not only denied the right of the county to erect a new court-house in the center of the square, but denied that the county had any right to the square whatever. The Board of Supervisors, on tiie advice of Ansel Smith, then district attorney of the county, decided to bring an action to quiet title to the square.
This action was commenced in 1885 and prosecuted to decree by Ansel Smith, district attorney, and the Hon. Joseph 11. Budd, of counsel on the part of tlie county. The city tiled an answer in the case denying generally that the county had any rights in or to the square whatever. During the trial, before the Hon. A. V. R. Paterson and Hon. J. G. Swinnerton. Judges of the Superior Court, an agreement was reached between the county and city which gave the county about all that the county claimed, and was at the same time wholly fair to the city. Judgment was rendered April 3, 1886.
I'indings were tiled and decree entered in accordance with findings and agreement, the substance of which is given in items 17 to 19 of the findings of the court, as follows: of said city were given the power (subject to a reasonable discretion in relation thereto) to say and determine whether the whole of said square is or will be at any future time necessary for a county court-house.
" 18. That !:aid city of Stockton has no title to said block No. 3, nor any part thereof, except so far as it may have the same under the dedication in said finding IIP mentioned, and such title is subordinate to the right and title of the county of San Joaquin thereto for the erection and maintenance thereon of a court-house building suitable, when required, for the purpose in tinding XVI* mentioned, and whereon and from the time the proper authorities of said city may determine that it is not advisable to erect or maintain public Iniildings thereon, said city will have no right to thu possession of said block No. 3, nor to any part thereof, until said county may abandon the same for the ei'ectiori and maintenance thereon of the court-house and the county and other buildings of the county thereon.
'- 19. That since the commencement of this suit the proper authorities of said city aud of said county have stipulated in substance and effect, and agreed in open court and i-equested the court to find, and the court does find: That the proper authorities of said city of Stockton, to-wit: the mayor and city council of said city, have determined that the whole of said block No. 3 east of Center street in said city of Stockton is necessary for the erection thereon of a county court-house and such other public buildings of the county of San Joaquin as may be deemed necessary by the proper authorities of said county, subject to the use by said city, and reserving to said city the right to the use, of the following space within said county courthouse building, free of charge, for the term of fifteen years from and after the completion of said building, with the privilege of the use of such space or a portion thereof for the additional term of five years, if deemed advisable by tlie proper authorities of said county, to-wit: four suitable rooms for the offices of the officers of said city, three of such rooms not less than twenty by twenty feet, and one not less than twenty bj thirty feet, and the use of one of the court-rooms in said new county court-house for the meetings of the city council of said city, and the use of a portion of the office of the county treasurer for the city treasurer of said city, and the use of a portion of the office of the county surveyor for the city surveyor of said city, and the use of a portion of the office of the county assessor for the city assessor of said city.
"And it appearing in like manner to the court that the county of San Joaquin, plaintiff, and the city of Stockton, one of the defendants herein, have, for the purpose of compromising and settling the claim of said city to the improvements now on the said block, No. 3, east of Center street in said city of Stockton, agreed the one with the other, that the said city relinquish to the said county all its right, title and interest in, and possession of, said improvements, including the building now standing on said block No. 3, and that the county as full compensation thereibr furnish to said city, free of charge, during the building of a new courthouse building on said block, rooms and offices for the city council of said city, and offices for the officers of said city, in the rooms now occupied by said county on Center street in said city, so far as the same will not interfere with the holding of the courts of record in said county therein, and so far as the same will not necessarily interfere with the proper discharge of the duties of the officers of said county now occupying said rooms, and further, that the said county shall and will, so soon as a new county court-house and new county jail is completed by said county, relinquish and convey to said city all the interest of said county*in the present county jail in said county and tlie land on which the same is situate; and it being stipulated in open court that the decree herein so far as it relates to the said improvements may be in accordance with such agreement, the court finds that the said agreement is just and equitable and reasonable and that the decree herein should be in accordance therewith."
Mokelumne Hill Eoad
The recent suit to settle the title of the public to a certain section of this road was successfully prosecuted by District Attorney Ansel Smith, whose draft of instructions to the jury were so clear, pointed and accurate that they were adopted by the court with scarcely any modification. The action was taken in the Superior Court of San Joaquin County, and was entitled, "John Pollock, Road Overseer of Road District, No. 34 East, of the County of San Joa quin, in the State of California, Plaintiff, vs. C. D. Watkins, Defendant."
Notice was given on September 7, 1888, to Watkins that he had built and was maintaining a fence in a public road near Bellota, and that the same was a nuisance, and directing him to remove the same. On September 26, 1888, Ansel Smith, District Attorney and attorney for plaintiif, John Pollock, and Wesley Minta, assistant District Attorney, commenced suit by filing a complaint charging the defendant with maintaining a nuisance, and praying for the abatement of the nuisance (removal of the fence) and for damages. November 7, 1888, the answer of the defendant was filed denying that the land was or is a public highway, and alleging that the portion alleged to have been obstiucted by defendant was a great number of years ago abandoned as a public highway, and thereupon ceased to be, has not since been, and is not now a public highway, and denies that the fence was any obstruction or nuisance.
The case came on for trial before the Hon. Joseph H. Budd and a jury. Ansel Smith, having gone out of office, had been specially employed to conduct the case. The trial was finished P^ebruary 27, 1889, and verdict rendered for plaintiff in the sum of $300. Judgment was entered February 28, 1889, for $300, and costs, $297.45.
ness Mr. Andrew Showers, the owner of the land, about and before 1862, to the effect that he fenced out the land as early as 1862 for the purpose of a public highway, and intended to dedicate it as such. Other evidence was introduced showing that the described land was used as a public highway as early as 1850. It was clear that after a time the travel of the road was north of this portion, and that the waters of the Mormon slough ran in the ditch caused by digging out the portion formerly used as a road; but the contention of the plaintiff was that a road having been dedicated and established, was not and could not be abandoned by non-user, and not even by an order of supervisors; but no order of abandonment was shown. The instructions of the court were very clear, and presented the law of the case fully and upheld the contention of the plaintiff. These instructions were:
"There is no evidence that the Mokelninne Hill road, nor the land on which the barbedwire fence is alleged to have been built, has been vacated or abandoned as a highway by the Board of Supervisors; and the presumption is that it never was vacated. * * * There is evidence that there was in the county of San Joaquin, as early as 1854, and ever since has been, a public highway known as and called the Mokelumne Hill Road, and there is no evidence to the contrary.
" A public highway is not to be considered abandoned merely because it is not traveled over. The sides of a public highway whence earth may be taken for the repair of the road, and ditches within the limits of the road and along the road used for carrying oft' wa'er, are just as much a part of a road as the part actually traveled over. If the road described in the complaint was used and traveled, and had been laid out and dedicated, as a public highway of this county as early as April 22, 1858, then it was made a public highway by the statute of this State.
" If Andrew Showers, while the owner, fenced out the land referred to for a public highway, intending it as a part of and for a public highway, and the same was used as such either by being traveled over, or as the side of the road, or for the purpose of taking earth therefrom to build or repair the road, it became a part of the public highway of this county, and no person had a right from that time to place any obstruction thereon or therein; and if you find that the defendant Watkins did build a barbed-wire fence on that land, and in the roadj then you must find a verdict for the plaintiff. If j'ou find that the land on which his alleged and barbed-wire fence was built was a part of the public highway of this county, then it makes no difference if parties on the north side of the road gave an additional forty feet; that would not cause an abandonment of what was then public highway or a part of one. If you find that the road referred to as the Mokelumne Hill road was laid out prior to 1860 and used as a public highway with the consent of the owners of the land, and that it was the intention of such owners to dedicate the same for a public highway, then the order of the Board of Supervisors of 1860 is evidence that the county accepted the same as a public highway.
" If you find that on or about 1861 or 1862 Andrew Showers, while the owner of the westhalf of the southwest quarter of section 5, township 2 north and range 9 east, ran a line of fence on the south side of the Mokelumne Hill road, intending the fence to mark the southern boundary of said road, and intending to give and dedicate a strip of land, eighty feet or more in width nor th of sai fence, and including the land on which it is alleged this barbed- wire fence was built, as a public highway or a part of said road, and the same tvas accepted and used as a highway by the public generally, then the said strip of land became a part of the said Mokelumne road and a public highway of this county; and no one from that time on had a right to obstruct the same; and if you find that the defendant did build a barbed-wire fence on said road as alleged, you must find a verdict for the plaintiff, John Pollock, and for $10 for every day said obstructien remained after notice to remove the same was served on the defendant, by the overseer of the road district, obstructing the part of the road on which said barbed- _wire fence was constructed.
"The court instructs the jury that it appears from the evidence that one Andrew Showers was from the 21st day- of May, 1861, until the 21st day of November, 1867, the owner of a tract of land in this county, known and described as the west-half of the southwest quarter of section 5, in township 2 north and range 9 east of Mount Diablo base and meridian, and near the town of Bellota, in this county; and if the jury believe on the evidence that there was a road called the Mokelumne Hill Eoad used by the public as a public highway running across this land, and that said Showers, on or about the year 1862, and while he was the owner and in tlie possession of said land, and while said road ran across said land and was used by the public as a public highway, fenced out a btrip of said land, including such traveled road, to be a public highway and as a part of said Mokelumne Hill Koad, and said dedication was accepted, then, after such acceptance said part of said land was fenced out and became a public highway; and neither said Showers nor his successors in interest, nor any one else, had a right to maintain a fence on any portion of said land so dedicated as a public highway; and it is no defense for the person erecting or maintaining any such fence that the portion of said land which had been so dedicated as a public highway, on which said fence was erected or maintained, was no longer necessary for a public highway or had not been used as such for many years, or was in fact a water-course.
"Neither this court nor this jury has a right to say that a portion of a public highway once legally established ceases to continue to be such solely because unnecessary or unused as such, or because it had become a part of a watercourse. The Legislature of this State has conferred upon the Board of Supervisors of this county general supervision over the roads within the county, and to abolish or abandon such parts thereof as are not necessary."
From the instructions of the court above given it will be seen that no formality is necessary for the dedication of a strip of land as a public highway; only the intention of the owner, as indicated by his words or acts, is necessary. This settlement of the case superseded the necessity of any further prosecution of several other suits of a similar nature that had been instituted, and the indications are that all litigation in this line is ended.
Chapter Yiii
SAY Providence deliver us from a boom, if the experience of Los An- ^^^ geles, San Diego and many other points is worth anything," is the prayer of the denizens of San Joaquin County, and a sensible desire it is, if by the term '- boom " is meant the rise of real estate to fictitious values. The people of this valley proceed upon the principle of steady and substantial growth, and consequently neither they nor their Eastern friends are disappointed. Disastrous financial depressions do not occur here.
California is often poetically alluded to as the "land of golden promise." Is is not a land oi performance? In what has it failed'? Gold? Grain? Fruits? Vegetables? And these are the four great sinews of the State that ever made any "promises." Although San Joaquin County was never a gold region, it has the other three sinews in perfection.
The development and wealth of San Joaquin County are steadily growing. Of the 873,195 acres in the county, all but 20,000 or 30,000 acres were upon the assessment roll in 1886. This county, both by rail and water, is as convenient to the markets of the world as any other point in the State.
Varieties Of Soil
to ten milesiti width and twenty-five miles north and south, which in favorable seasons has produced extraordinary crops of wheat. The soil is a deep, sandy loam, in many places from thirty to forty feet to the hard pan, and with a supply of water it could be made the most productive and valuable land in the county. Owing to the great depth of the soil and its location at the eastern base of the Coast Range, it suffers from the effects of drouth more than the land located where the topography of the country is more favorable for securing the maximum of rain-fall. It is a noticeable fact that upon the Pacific coast the heaviest rain-fall occurs upon the western slopes of the mountain ranges, the storm clouds floating inland from the ocean, seeming to be bereft of their moisture as they pass over higher elevations. This large body of land is an important portion of San Joaquin County, and must eventually be furnished with means of artificial irrigation from the San Joaquin river, which in seasons when irrigation is necessary to secure the growth of vegetation pours its torrents of water past the land to the sea.
The red lauds in the eastern part of the county have proven good average wheat land, but when properly worked is very profitable in fruits. It varies in depth, but the most of it is strong, en during soil. It is especially good for plums
Ei8T0Bt Of San Joaquin County
Loam lands are found both in the northern and southern parts of the county. The whole Mokelumne river basin is a magnificent body of this kind. It is sandy and deep. A great part of it is the finest sort of garden loam. This is the " live-oak " country, so called from the liveoak tree growth covering it. There is no land in the State better adapted to small diversified farming than this. It is easily worked, and is unfailing in the production of crops. For twenty years the chief product of the "Uve-oak" farmer has been wheat. But the more wideawake husbandman has not lost the opportunity to demonstrate that for table grapes, almonds, apricots, pears, prunes, peaches, tigs, and for all kinds of small fruits such as raspberries, strawberries, blackberries, currants, etc., this soil cannot be improved upon.
A great reservoir of water extends under the loam lands, and is a never failing supply of water to this district. Whether the year is ununnsusally dry or unusually wet, no difference is discovered in the under-ground water level. Its source is in perennial and eternal fountains. A three-inch well, bored to the deptli of twentyfive feet, affords an inexhaustible water supply the year around. The prevalence of pleasant, tempered winds from the coast during the summer months, encourages the erection of windmills for irrigation purposes throughout the district. A number of ten, fifteen and twenty acre fruit and vegetable gardeners in the vicinity of Lodi, are doing a good business, annually netting the industrious proprietors from $150 to $250 per acre. These gardens are irrigated mostly by pumps and windmills. Two six-inch wells are sunk eight or ten feet apart. Pump plungers are inserted into thegalvanizediron casings of these wells, and are worked by a walking-beam, pivoted between the wells. A sixteen-foot windmill or an ordinary horsepower will operate the contrivance, and lift from five to ten thousand gallons per hour, sufficient to irrigate a ten-acre garden thoroughly. These loam lands along the Mokelumne are valuable, yet can be bought for from $45 to $60 per acre. As old methods of farming give way to better ideas, this section will develop and improve with great rapidity.
Along the Mokelumne river are to be found thousands of acres of rich bottom lands, luxuriantly productive without irrigation. Everything planted there has made prodigious growth. Four crops of alfalfa, making six to eight tons of splendid hay per year, are usually taken from it; corn, sixty bushels, and barley fifty bushels to the acre, are averaged. Hops, patatoes and fruits, and all sorts of garden products grow luxuriantly.
The black adobe lands are strong and rich, the heaviest requiring double the horse-power to break them, but notwithstanding they are the most valuable They have generally been adapted to grain but are easily irrigated and pn^duce the stone fruits well. It is abundant in the vicinity of Stockton. (See Chapter I for further particulars).
Early Mining Period
Previous to 1851 the County of San Joaquin was considered good only for grazing and hunting. There were immense herds of cattle and some horses ranging the valley under the restraint only of the vacaro. The old Mexican custom of the rodeo still prevailed, and was practiced * for a few years later. The rodeo ground was the place where the ranchero or stock- raiser gathered all the stock which was found grazing within his boundary lines. There was a stated day for these gatherings once in each year; and all the owners of stock from the surrounding country came to the rodeo, selected' their estrayed cattle, and drove them to their own grazing grounds, leaving what could not be identified by claimants, to become the pi'operty of the owner of the rodeo, who branded them accordingly.
The soil of the valley had never, with but two exceptions, received into its bosom the plow of the civilizer. Ages had passed by; generations of red men had been born and passed away; nature had planted the grasses and flowers, and the soil had brought them forth again. For successive centuries the elk, grand in his untamed strength, the deer, in his primitive beatify, the antelope, in its graceful action, had taken possession of a land to which nature had invited them. The coyote, the grizzly bear and the mountain lion had found a place that nature had seemed to have created for them, and the Indian had been " monarch of all he surveyed."
Such was San Joaquin County previous fo 1851; but the sleepy centuries had been awakened to learn that the time liad come when the harvest was to be gathered which the ages had been preparing lor the coming man. Time in his flight had reached the point where the change was to come; gold had been found where nature in her bounty had deposited it; that had created an influx of immigration which, like a tidal wave, moved toward the Pacific slope, and with it had come the artificer, the student, the mechanic, and the husbandman, all seeking sudden wealth, and looking to a speedy return to homes left in search of the shining metal. With this immense influx came necessities for the support of this suddenly populated region, and no supply being produced from the soil to meet it, prices raised with the necessity; money was often more plenty than bread.
Under this combination of circumstances the far-seeing turned to the valleys and said. We will dig for gold with the plow, and reap it in the harvest of grain; this soil, which does not hold the metal, holds that which will draw it from the hand of the one that is fortui.ate, as well as those who are not; for all must eat to live. Here in the plains lies the financial lever that, properly applied, will move the wealth of the mines into the valleys. Such men located to stay, and are here now to enjoy the fruit of their forethought.
Others, unsuccessful in their search for gold, disappointed and heart-sick, scattered through the lower country, selecting places not so much with a view to farmings as a desire to seclude themselves from the outside world, that they might forget the far-away home, to which pride and a want of means prevented them from returning. A few of these are still in the country, and are now thankful that seeming destiny forced them to acquire some of this valley when it was apparently of little value.
For other and various causes, the little cabins sprang up here and there over the country, first along the streams, and, as the apparent choice localities were taken up, further back, until today, San Joaquin County has become the garden of the State.
In Castoria Township eighty acres of wheat were sown in the fall of 1846, from which there was no yield. There were a few, some sixteen, acres of wheat sown by Joe Bussell, in 1847, near Lindsay's Point, that was not cut. With these excejitions, there was no grain sown in this county up to 1851. In that year W. L. Overhiser raised sixteen acres of barley on the Calaveras, north of Stockton, and harvested the same. Mr. Sargent also raised between forty and fifty acres, on tlie ground where Woodbridge now stands, and harvested it, although the winter was one of the driest ever known in the State since white occupation, there being only 4 71 - 100 inches rainfall. He obtained a yield of about ten bushels to the acre. These were the only fields of grain cut 'in the county in 1851.
The next year, 1852, considerable barley was raised in the county. K. C. Sargent and W. L. Overhiser each harvested sixty acres; a number of other parties also raised grain. The assessor's returns for San Joaquin County, of that year, give 4,001 acres as the amount that was raised; from the same report we learn that there were produced that season: 5,145 bushels of wheat; 111,489 bushels of barley; 1,625 bushels of oats; 1,245 bushels of co'rn; 42 3-10 tons of potatoes. The mode of cutting the grain whs principally with the cradle, one of which could be had by paying $150, the present price being $4. Wm. McKee Cai'son owned the only threshi ng-machine and reaper in the county. R. C. Sargent imported one of each, the succeeding year of 1853.
Lessons from the older eastern States, and even from the Old World, began to be reduced to practice in this conntj- in due time, and the work is still progressing with profitable results; and tlie area for tliis great industry in this county is considerable. A knowledge of the most effective methods of accomplishing the reclamation of these lands, which we have no hesitation in saying are the richest in the world, has been acquired only bj years of patient and costly experiment; and experimentation seems to be still goincr on. The fresh-water tide lands of the State occupy an area of 350,000 acres or more, all of which has a fertility three or four times that of up-land when thoroughly free from the encroachment of floods. The reclamation problem has been made one of the special lines of investigation by the State engineer, and his report has thrown light upon a vexed question in which the world takes a deep interest. These lands present a vast field for enterprise and capital. The returns of yield in the staples of wheat, barley, potatoes, corn, fruit, vegetables and every manner of produce which a fertile soil, ample moisture and stimulating sunshine can bring forth, show such astonishing figures that the cupidity of men is excited at the very mention. The reclaimed lands on the Sacramento river have for years supplied the markets of San Francisco with a large share of the fruits and vegetables there consumed, and no manner of cultivated plant, tree or shrub that flourishes in any part of the United States, has yet been found to fail when tried on these lands, while they usually flourish with an extraordinary growth seldom equaled elsewhere.
The amount which has already been expended in the reclamation of tule lands in this State cannot be estimated, but it has undoubtedly been several millions. In this county alone S1,000,000 would not cover the cost.
The plan adopted for subjecting the land to cultivation, varies witli the varying qualities of the soil. In some parts, where sediment predominates in excess of the vegetable matter, one of the methods successfully used, is to burn off the tnles when dry, turn over the sod with plows that cut the roots off squarely, and after a few weeks' exposure to the sun, burn the sods. It has been found that the roots burn out entirely, leaving the sedimentary soil as finely pulverized as a flower garden. Treated in this manner, the soil is at once ready for a crop, and requires no further plowing or pulverizing. The first plowing costs about §4 to S5 fin acre, and the burning about 81 per acre. This treatment would, however, be ruinous to that class of peaty soil where the vegetable element predominates, and much of this class of land has been spoiled by tires which have burned out all the substance of the soil down to the water level. The necessities of cultivation on this class of land have called forth agricultural implements specially adapted to them. The tule plow must not only have a cutting edge as sharp as a knife, but be shaped so as to turn the tough sods completely over. The subjugation of the peaty land is accomplished by various devices, the most successful of which is a spiral cutting knife, winding about a c^dinder three feet in diameter. The knives are about four inches apart on the cylinder, and cut the sods up into strips. Other implements specially adapted to this class of land are in use.
The tnle islands have a brilliant future. It is not enough to say that they will soon be the gardens of the State. The}' will be the source of supply for all manner of textile fabrics, and it is not an extravagant prediction to foretell the erection in Stockton at no distant day of enormous linen factories, silk factories, jute factories, beet-sugar factories, and other undertakings of a similar and equally possible nature, deriving their raw materials from island grown products, all of which flourish on these lands as though indigenous to the soil.
To the enterprise of such men as M. C. Fisher, Haggin and Tevis, General Williams, and R. C. Sargent, who as pioneers have risked unlimited capital in this work, the State is indebted beyond estimation. The popular cry against the "land-grabber" and "monopolist" is a futile shaft when levelled in a direction where nothing could be done without large aggregation of capital. They merit all the profits which they hope to gain, and deserve more honor and credit than an ungrateful public is likely to give. They are striving to redeem a howling waste to fruitfulness and fertility. May they succeed! for, wishing them success, we but repeat the wish, " Let Stockton flourish," as, fed and nourished by such resources as these, flourish she must and will.
In the northwestern portion of the county is a large tract of land originally considered of little value because of its swampy character. When the country was first occupied by Americans it was wholly covered witli a growth of tules and flags, and subject to overflow at every rise of the water in the San Joaquin and its tributaries. It is only within the last ten years that intelligent and comprehensive efi'orts have been made to i-eclaini this land, but the result of tlie woi-k already accomplished is very encouraging. Thousands of acres of this kind of land are now producing bountiful crops of wheat and barley, which but a few years ago were but impenetrable bogs of tule and flag.
By the construction of substantial levees to protect from overflnw, the land is made dry and susceptible of cultivation, and its capacity for production is greater than any other variety of land in the State. All kinds of small fruits and vegetables have been raised in abundance without irrigation, and the aggregate value of the products of this region of country will be enormously increased, when the extensive schemes of reclamation now in contemplation and partially carried out shall be fully completed.
Goi)d and sufficient levee protection, under proper management and with the use of the many improved appliances for handling dirt, can be built at a cost of about $5,000 per mile. For the purpose of estimating the cost per acre, it may generally be recognized that most of the unreclaimed swamp lands of the valley can be put in a state fit for cultivation with an average of one mile for each 200 acres of land inclosed. This is indeed an extreme allowance, for frequently 300 or 400 acres would be a fair proportion; but taking the top figures, the cost of thorough reclamation, if understandingly set about, will not exceed $25 per acre
The value of well reclaimed swamp lands is now thoroughly appreciated, and beyond question of a doubt there remains a splendid field for enterprise and capital in the reclamation of a good deal of hitherto untouched land in this region. Owners of considerable tracts of swamp lands in this county have realized as high as thirty dollars per acre from their land, by leasing it to parties who would cultivate it for a share of the crop. The renters, at the same time, have also been well paid for their labor.
The total area of the swamp and overflowed lands of the San Joaquin County is about 250,- 000 acres, of which about 100,000 acres have been effectually reclaimed.
Hundreds of miles of extensive levees have been constructed for the reclamation of this charauter of land, and many thousands of dollars e.xpended for that purpose, but the investment is regarded as a profitable one, and the work is being continued. Tiie time is therefore not far distant when the overflowed lands of this valley, which it is possible to reclaim, will be brought under cultivation. It is estimated that during the year 1882 at least 1,000,- 000 bushels of wheat and barley were raised upon land inSan Joaquin County, which, less than ten years previously, was overflowed the larger portion of theyear, and was generally inaccessible except by boats. This kind of land necessarily improves by cultivation, and it requires several years to fully demonstrate its producing capacity. As the tule roots decay and the native weeds and grasses are killed by thorough cultivation, the soil is easily worked, and found to contain all the elements necessary for the growth of almost every agricultural product raised in the most favored districts of the globe.
ougiily reclaimed lands is offered for sale, as the owners are fully satisfied with the returns, and believe that the investment is a profitable one. Tracts of unreclaimed land susceptible of reclamation, owned bj parties who are indisposed to expend the money necessary to make them productive, can, however, be still purchased at reasonable rates, and it is doubtful whether there are better inducements offered in any locality, for the investment of capital, than can be shown to exist in the prospective profits to be derived from the purchase aud thorouojh reclamation of this character of lands adjacent to the San Joaquin river, in this county. Some of the shrewdest capitalists of California have already invested largely, and although it requires time to make the reclamation perfect, and thereby guarantee a sure profit from the productions of the land, the success attending efforts already made is incontrovertible.
" Union Island, lying between the old and middle channels of the San Joaquin, containing in round numbers some 45,000 acres, principally owned by General T. H. Williams, has been the great field of experiment and research in swampland practice, and great interest has necessarily attached to the progress and development of the work carried on there.
" Wherever practicable, that is, wherever the material employed was entirely sedimentary, the levees have been built entirely by means of horse scrapers. General Williams has thoroughly recognized the futility of any halfmeasures, and the sedimentary levees at the head of Union Island are probably the most thorough, or nearly so, of any work done in the State. One line has been given a crown-width of eighth feet, with a slope of three to one on either side and a height varying from seven to ten feet. The extreme crown-width was intended to furnish a roadway for the island-traffic; a perfectly harmless, indeed, probably commendable, practice in dry weather, but one open to grave challenge in winter-time, and now, we believe, entirely vetoed in Holland and the vicinity of the Mississippi.
" Below the sediment line, General Williams' procedure has been entirely original, and whilst variously criticised by outsiders, contains, we believe, the solution to the question, How to levee in peat lands? Double retaining walls, carefully built up of peat sods, have been carried along the line, and the space between them filled with sand pumped from the river bed. The machines used for this purpose were of different construction, the principle of one, the invention of Mr. Denison, being a vacuum puni]!, the vacuum being obtained by the usual steam jet aud condenser, and the other, designed by Colonel "\'on Schmidt, a huge centrifugal pump with an auger attachment, working at the bottom of the suction ])ipe. The only point of objection to either of these machines is that their effective working is limited at present to sand, to the rejection of clay or more retentive material. The experience of the past winter, however, shows that the sand is by no means the ti'eacherous material when thus employed that skeptics had been disposed to think it, and if we might venture to criticise the combination levee on Union Island, we would say that it comes nearer to entire success than anything heretofore attempted, and could only have been improved upon by yjreparing a peat foundation for the sand, and, perhaps, being careful to avoid any joint or overhang in the retaining walls, but rather to carry them up as a uniformly well-bonded, homogeneous mass.
" The lower end of Union Island was overflowed this year; not as we believe from any defect in General Williams' work, but entirely owing to the obstructive action of some adjoining proprietors who refused anything- like cooperative action.
Ei8T0Rt Of San Joaquin County
river and the San Joaquin proper, contains some 64,000 acres of land. The largest individual owner is Mr. Morton C. Fisher, who owns some 15,000 acres of the upper end of the island, and who owns the controlling interest and is the managing director in the Glasgow California Land Company, owning some 40,000 acres in the lower division.
" The reclamation of the npper portion was completed two years ago, and cost $140,000 for the 22,000 acres reclaimed, making an average of $6.50 per acre. The lower end reclamation works that have been in progress for the last year are completed; 36,000 of the 42,000 acres in the lower division have been reclaimed by these works, at a total expense of $350,000, or about $10 per acre. This is considerable more than the cost of the upper half, as there were more and greater obstacles to overcome, the dam on one slough costing $25,000. Here, as on Union Island, the entire sedimentary work was done by horse-sei'apers, the levee being carried to a nine-foot grade with slopes respectively of three and two to one.
" As the material becomes more vegetable in character the slope is gradually reduced, until, in the peat formation at the lower end of the island, the sides of the levee ai-e nearly vertical, but the width of crown is increased to from twenty-live to thirty-feet. The nine-foot fill ruled nearly all round the island, so that a very massive and expensive levee was the result.
" We believe the proprietors have it in contemplation to proceed now to give all the peaty levee a coating of from two to three feet of sediment and clay from the river-beds. Material is to be disintegrated with a species of pug-mill, and sufficient water added to allow of its being forced, as in the Von Schmidt machine, through pipes on to the levee. The expense of subduing tlie soil and extirpating the tule roots is about equal to that of reclamation; so that when the lauds were fitted for cultivation it was found that the upper and lower divisions costs about $12 and $20 the acre respectively. A bird'seye view of the division is given in this work.
" Bouldin Island, above referred to, contains 6,497 acres of land, of which about 4,000 are in cultivation this year. It lies at the junction of the Mokelumne with the San Joaquin river, in San Joaquin County. The land yields two crops per year, one of grain and one of potatoes; of the former (barley) from fifty to sixty bushels, and of potatoes 150 to 200 sacks per acre.
" It is owned by the members of the Pacific Distillery Company of San Francisco, who have this year completed a very excellent and wellplanned reclamation. The scheme of the proprietors is to devote a large portion ot the island to growing potatoes for distillery purposes, potatoes yielding on these lands a certain crop.
" Staten Island, immediately north of Bouldin Island, lies between the north and south forks of the Mokelumne river, about five miles above its junction with the San Joaquin, and forty miles below or northwest of Stockton, and contains 9,194 acres of land. It was first leveed in 1873; the levees were soon afterward enlarged, and all the land put under cultivation. The cost of reclamation was $28 per acre. The land there is peculiarly rich, yielding two crops per year, and in favorable seasons as high as seventy-five to eighty bushels of wheat, a ton and a half of beans, 2,150 sacks of potatoes.
" Fourteen miles north of Stockton, a large tract of tule land, owned by the Sargent brothers, between "White's slough and the Mokelumne river, were reclaimed by them. Their first levees, along the banks of Sargent and Island sloughs, were found inadequate, and they had to buy up a large extent of land from those around them who were too slow to co-operate, and levee on a much larger scale, which they did with the most signal success."
pie of the State which is, perhaps, of quite as much importance to the well-being and prosperity of the country as the settlement of questions relative to the titles and locations of Spanish land grants; and this is the question relative to the use of flowing water for purposes of irrigation. The water of flowing streams is to the earth what the blood in the veins and arteries is to the animal system: one giving life and energy to the body, and the otlier fruitfulness to the earth.
''In England, where tlie earth is watered by frequent summer showers, and the soil moistened by ocean fogs, water for the public use is not a thing of so much importance as it is in those arid regions of the earth where it seldom rains, and where, without irrigation, the earth would be a barren desert without human habitation. Therefore, the framers of the common law of England, not being taught by necessity the importance of providing for the common use of the flowing waters of the country, gave the same to the owners of the land bordering the stream.
"For the reasons above stated, this law has for centuries, perhaps, worked no hardship or injustice to the inhabitants of that country; but, from the nature of things, it is manifest that laws, which in one country might be beneficial or harmless, in another, surrounded bjdifi'erent conditions, would be utterly ruinous. The inhabitants of all arid countries bains' impelled by their needs have, from time immemorial, given much attention to the laws regulating the public or common use of flowing waters.
"Spain and large portions of Spanish America being naturally arid and subject to protracted droughts, it has been found necessary to make very stringent laws and regulations relative to the distribution and common use of flowing waters. Hence, many laws on this subject are found recorded in the Partidas and Recopilacion de Indias, and, besides, learned essays and reports on the same subject. The jealous care with which the Spanish laws have from the earliest times granted such common rights as pertain to the use of waters, is shown by the Partidas, which declare: 'That the ribero del mar (sea beach), the space between high and low tide, cannot be granted to any person, nor can the exclusive right to the use thereof be conceded to any one whomsoever; but, that all shall have a right to use the same,' in other words, that it should be reserved for ])ublic use.
"In view of this ancient law, the territorial deputation (legislative) of California passed a resolution in 1835 authorizing grants of 100 vara lots to be made in Yerba Buena (now San Francisco) 200 varas back from the shores of the bay; thus reserving for public use the ribero, or sea beach, as required by the laws of the Partidas.
"The General Regulations, published in the city of Mexico in 1761, declare that la regalia is a certain derecho de imjyerio (imperial right) which pertains to the sovereign in certain things, among which are waters, lands, and mines; that only to the prince, and to no one else, belongs the power to distribute the waters. That with respect to New Spain, His Majesty has conceded tlie most ample authority to the viceroys and presidents of the Royal Audience, to the end, that in conformity with the laws and regulations relative thereto, they should make grants of lands and water as of things pertaining to the royal crown.
"From the foregoing extracts it is seen that to the king alone, or to his delegates, belongs the power to grant and distribute lands and the use of flowing waters in the countries of New Spain. The customs of the inhabitants of New Spain induced them to live in pueblos, or villages, around and in the neighborhood of which were located their small plantations, on which were produced their cereals, fruits and vegetables.
'-These pueblos were located on lands bordering on flowing streams furnishing sufficient water for irrigating the lands occupied and cultivated by the inhabitants of the pueblo, the stock farms being on lands that were not susceptible of irrigation, and were only fit for grazing. Pueblos were established under the laws of the Indies, and to the ajuntamientos (town council) thereof were delegated certain powers, such as the granting of suertes (planting grounds) and solares (house lots) to settlers, and the establishing of regulations for the distribution of the flowing water required for irrigating the sowing lands of the pueblo. There being no cultivation on the stock farms, no irrigation was required, the only water needed on such establishment being what was required for the use of the stock occupying the same; hence, such lands were called de ahrevadero (a watering place for stock).
"Had the territory of Spanish America been divided into small farms, as is the prevailing custom among English-speaking people who carry on agriculture and stock-raising in the same rural establishment, then the same laws and regulations relative to the use of flowing waters which control the government of pueblos would doubtless have been enforced with reijard to the use of water on farms or ranches.
pueblos, relative to the distribution and use of water, were exceedingly stringent, the doctrine being that the water belonged to the land, and that it should be so used as that the soil should be forced to yield the greatest possible product of what is required for the support of man. Under these laws, an officer was appointed by the town council, whose duty it was to attend to the distribution of water on the irrigable lands, and to see that no portion thereof, which was under cultivation, should lack its needed supply.
" So strictly were these laws enforced, that if the owner of a lot in cultivation should fail, from neglect or inability, to irrigate his land when his growing crop required water, the ofiicer in charge of the distribution of the water was required to employ some one to attend to the matter, in which case the owner of the lot and crop was charged with the expense of irrigation; the principle established being that in any event productive land should receive the amount of water to which it was entitled, so that it mieht yield Jhe fruits in which all the inhabitants of the pueblo had a common interest.
" The eleventh section of the act of Congress of March 3, 1851, ' to ascertain and settle the private land claims in the State of California,' provides ' that the commissioners, therein provided for, and the district and supreme courts, in deciding upon any claim brouglit before them under the provisions of that act, shall be governed by the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo; the laws of nations; the laws, usages, and customs of the government from which the claim is derived; the principles of equity, and the decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States, as far as they are applicable.' (Fremont vs. United States, 17 How. 553).
" In the same case, on page 557, the United States Supreme Court says: ' It is proper to remark that the laws of these territories under which titles were claimed were never treated by the court as foreign laws, to be decided as a question of fact. It was always held that the court was bound judicially to notice them as much as the laws of a State or Union. In doing this, however, it was undoubtedly often necessai-y to inquire into official customs and forms of usages. They constitute what may be called the common or unwritten law of every civilized country.'
" The following is the language of the late learned Caleb Cushing: ' By the laws of Spain and of the Mexican Republic, grants of land on the banks of a river extend to the edge of the stream {Jilurn «§-««) if it be navigable, or to the middle of the river bed (alveo), if it be innavigable.'
" Thus, in the case of two properties, situated on opposite sides of the river, each proprietor is entitled to the ordinary riparian rights of use and improvement on his side, and to the use and take of water for the purpose of irrigation or for mills. If the river be innavigable, the opposite riparian proprietors own to the middle of the river bed, according .to the extent lengthwise of the river, of their respective properties on the river bank; and if it dry up - as happens to many rivers, either temporarily or permanently - they may occupy the river bed as appertinent to their respective riparian properties. " Under the regulations of 1761, there was what was called ' La servidumbre del aqnaducto,' that is, the right of a person to conduct water over the property belonging to some one else to irrigate his own land.
" All laws originate from the necessities of man, and from the conditions and circumstances of the country which they are intended to govern. England being a country with a naturally moist climate, and abundantly supplied with rain, the common law made no provision for watering the earth by irrigation, because it was never required.
" A large portion of Spanish America being arid, in order that the earth might produce the fruits required for the support of its inhabitants, it was found necessary, in framing laws for the government of the country, to make provisions for supplying the soil with the needed water; hence the doctrine of these laws, that the waters of flowing streams belonged to the sovereign of the country, and not exclusively to the owners of the lands bordering the streams, the sovereign authority distributing the usufruct of these waters in such a manner as that all fruitful soil might receive its equitable share, to the end that the earth might be made to produce food sufficient for the inhabitants thereof.
"Since all law springs from the requirements of man, the more universal and urgent the need of the law the greater will be the attention given to, and the labor bestowed in, the framing thereof. For this reason we find that the Spanish laws of the Indies, and the regulations established in Spanish America, with respect to the use of water, are, like the Spanish raining laws, far more perfect than are the common laws of England with regard to the same matters, since they are the result of centuries of such experience as springs from necessity.
" From the foregoing it is seen what were the laws, usages and customs of the Spanish and Mexican Government, with regard to the use of water for purposes of irrigation. It is also shown that the act of Congress of March 3, 1851, declares that the commissioners appointed under said act, in determining the rights of claimants under the Government, shall be governed by the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo; the law of nations; the laws, usages, and customs of the government from which the claim is derived; the principles of equity and decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States^ - and that the Supreme Court says, iu the Fremont case, that ' the laws of these territories under which the titles were claimed were never treated by the court as foreign laws, and, also, that the court was bound judicially to notice them as much as the laws of a State or Union;' and that they constitute what may be called the common or unwritten law of every civilized country'. It is manifest, therefore, that under the foregoing provisions and decisions, all water rights which had accrued to lands granted by the governments of Spain and Mexico are bound to be protected by the laws and. courts of the United States; and since it has been shown that wherever lands were used for agricultural purposes under the former governments, these laws were enforced, it is but fair to presume that if the same agricultural habits and customs had prevailed among the inhabitants of California under the former government, these laws or usages would have been observed in the rural districts of the country the same as in the pueblo establishments, in which it was the custom of the inhabitants of the country to reside, as has been shown.
" If it be determined by the courts of California that the wise and judicious laws of the former governments of the country relative to the use of water are only applicable to rights which accrued under grants given by said governments, and do not affect those portions of the State in which at the date of the treaty of session no grants had been made, and that.
therefore, tliese portions with respect to riparian riglits are now to be controlled by the principles of the common law, it is manifest that for the well being and prosperity of the agricnltnral interests of the country the law be so nmdified as to give snch encouragement and protection to agriculture as was given by the laws of the former governments of the country, or such as may be better fitted to our civilization and modes of life and progressive knowledge in agriculture."
The question of irrigation had for a number of years agitated the minds of the land owners through the southern portion of the county until tinally the question began to take on the semblance of something more than hope deferred, that " maketh the heart sick." Those who had wished for the result, began to adopt means to produce the same, and we iind, as a consequence, that in June, 1871, James Marsh, Andrew Wolf, Austin Sperry and S. Dunham commenced a survey, with a vievv of ascertaining the probable cost and feasibility of bringing water from the Stanislaus river over the country, to the vicinity of S. Dunham's farm, near Faruiington. They found the scheme practicable, but also learned that the cost would be so great that it would not be advisable to attempt the enterprise at that time.
For six years the old question was laid away in memory's storehouse, to be brought forth on slight provocation and aired; and when the dry summer came, the farmers looked away towards the foot-hills in Calaveras, as looked the wandering tribes of Israel towards Canaan, praying for rain, and hoping against hope that some one would furnish capital and bring from those hills the water that would make the parched plains smile like the perennial gardens. Finally, in April, 1877. an organization was perfected with an actual subscribed capital of $33,500. It was a stock company with 2,500 shares, and the organizing trustees were: S. Dunham, President; David Young, Vice-President; N. S. Harrold,
The Mokelumne Ditch & Irrigation Company was incorporated in 1876 for the purpose of taking out water for agricultural, mining and manufacturing purposes at a place called Winters' Bar, about two miles above Lodi on the Mokelumne river. The original incorporators were S. V. Tredway, David Kettelman, R. C. Sargent, C. R. Ralph, James A. Ellison and Jas. Spencer. Tredway was president and Spencer, secretary. At the date of the incorporation the capital stock was fixed at $100,000, and since then it has been increased to $300,000. Soon after organizing they commenced the prosecution of their work and continued it until they had a stone dau) partially completed at Winters' Bar. Then the work remained stationary for about ten years, namely, until the spring of 1887, when parties living in San Diego County purchased a controlling interest, resumed work and completed the dam in the spring of 1888. This dam is 294 feet long on the surface, thirty-four feet high, and seven feet thick at the top. Headgates were putin with acapacity of 30, 000 miners' inches* of water. A new survey was made in the fall of 1887 and the line located. As soon as the works are complete they will irrigate 120,000 acres of land, which is the territory embraced in the system, and this includes 40,000 acres north of the Mokelumne river and 80,000 acres south of it. At present Senator B. F. Langford is the president of the company and Charles W. McMaster the secretary, whose office is in Lodi.
In the West Side Irrigation District is Tulare Township, a large extent of country particularly subject to amelioration by reclamation and irrigation. While the rainfall is very small in quantity in that section of the county, the mountain streams and reservoirs to the west and southwest are peculiarly accessible.
supply by ditch the fariirers of the San Joaquin with water, and the farmers subscribed to the enterprise to the extent of ^1 an acre on condition that the work be completed within three years; but the company failed to comply with their part of the contract, and the residents of course refused their subsidy.
Aetesian Wells
There are at present ten or twelve artesian wells in the county. Water is generally found at a depth of 1,000 feet which will flow to the surface. Of the wells which have been completed up to 1886, the majority were eight inches in diameter. George S. Ladd was the first in the county to bore a well to tap the deep subterranean reservoirs from which a supply of flowing water was obtained delivered sufficiently above the surface to be carried over his land wherever needed for purposes of irrigation. His well was completed in 1880, and a supply of water of about 15,000 gallons per liour secured. Large reservoirs were constructed into which the water is run and from thence conducted over the land in ditches. The water supply thus obtained has been found sufficient to supply the necessary moisture to render the whole tract of 200 acres extremely productive, and also make it possible to grow an almost unlimited variety of products. Upon the farm of Mr. Ladd, which up to the time the well was completed had been principally devoted to grain-growing, there are now flourishing orchards, vineyards and large gardens, and the following is but a partial list of the products raised and marketed during the season: Pears, apricots, peaches, apples, cherries, almonds, raisin, table and wine grapes, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, onions, sweet potatoes, Irish potatoes, beets, watermelons, canteloupes and squashes. A portion of the tract is still cultivated in cereals and a portion in alfalfa, but each year the area of the orchard and vineyard is increased, and as the adaptibility of the locality to produce profitable crops of any particular variety is ascertained more of such crop is cultivated. The profits derived from this tract are very satisfactory to its fortunate owner, who has never regretted the expenditure made to secure a flow of artesian water upon his farm.
Dr. C. Grattan, who owns a tract of 500 acres four miles east of Stockton, also has an artesian well, the water of which is now being used for irrigation, and he is making large additions to his orchard and vineyard.
Zignego & Co. about a mile from the northern boundary of Stockton, also have a fine flowing well and have planted a large orchard and vineyard and use the water for irrigating portions of their land which are cultivated in vegetables and other crops that require artificial irrigation.
J. D. McDougald has a well upon a large tract of land whicli he owns, about three miles south of Stockton, which gives a large flow of water, and it is also used for irrigation of land devoted to vegetable growing and geneial gardening purposes.
W. L. Overhiser was oi\e of the first farmers to sink wells for irrigating purposes. The water is pumped by steam power from four wells about 100 feet deep at once, which yield a continuous flow of about thirty-six miners' inches of water; the pumps used have five-inch valves, and are worked by a twelve-horse- power engine that consumes one-fourth of a cord of wood in ten hours.
This is the first attempt of the kind to use steam for hoisting water for irrigating purposes in the county; and the experiment will be watched with interest by the citizens. Will it pay? is the question to be solved.
James C. Smith, who owns a large tract of land two miles north of Stockton, lias at present about eighty acres rented to persons who cultivate it in fruit and vegetables. The water required for irrigation is raised by windmills, and one mill furnishes sufficient water to supply ten acres of land. The cost of digging the well and erecting a mill of sufficient capacity to do this work does not cost as much as $200. Tiie remarkable productive capacity of San Joaquin County lauds is clearly shown upon this farm, where fruit of different varieties, - peaches, apricots, plums, cherries, quinces, apples, blackberries, raspberries, strawberries, currants, grapes, etc.. - are grown for market, and also all kinds of vegetables, as cabbages, turnips, beets, radishes, rhubarb, egg plant, onions, carrots, sweet and Irish potatoes, etc. On most of this land two crops and sometimes more are grown the same season. This land is leased at an average annual rental of $26 per acre, the leases to run ten years, and the renters are always anxious to renew their leases at the expiration.
Grain Raising
After the first flush of gold excitement had somewhat abated, the raising of the cereals was naturally the first industry that would be taken up; and this has proved so profitable that the farmers, especially tiie "old-timers," are reluctant to change to other crops. Soon after the inception of this branch of agriculture the grain trade became a leading business of the city. During the mining era this section was an importer of breadstufl's, and even after flour mills were here erected the wheat to supply them was imported at tirst from Chili, South America, and afterward from the bay and coast counties of Sonoma, Solano and Napa. During the year 1857 wheat was brought here from Solano and Na]ia counties, and hauled to Bell's flour mill near Sonora, there to be made into flour, for the supply of the mining camps of that locality. Up to that time most of the wheat ground in the mills of Stockton was also brought from the bay counties. During the year 1858, however. a small surplus of wiieac was produced in this county, and the business of dealing in that product by others than those engaged in the mill business was first commenced.
of Stockton, was one of the first to engage in the business. He had previously been conducting a forwarding business, and his first ventures in wheat were in purchasing the limited quantities required to supply the small mills near Sonora, and transporting the same from Stockton to its destination. His first purchases of the surplus product of this region were made to supply the local demand and mills in San Francisco and Sacramento. In 1858 a small steamer was put on the route between Stockton and Sacramento, making three trips a week between the two places, and her principal cargo from Stockton was wheat. The prices of wheat then ranged from ninety cents to $1.25 per cental, only the choicest variety bringing the latter price. The first wheat stored in Stockton to be held for improved prices, was in 1859. An old adobe building, standing on ground now occupied by Simpson & Gray's lumber yard, was used for that purpose, and also a p irtion of the building on Levee street, known as the Starbuck building. The quantity did not exceed 1,500 tons, and fifty cents a ton per month was paid for storage, and two per cent, per month interest was paid upon money borrowed thereon by its owners.
In 1858 Mr. Peters associated himself with J. A. Jackson, and engaged quite extensively in the wheat business, forming a connection with Isaac Friedlander, of San Francisco, who was one of the first to engage in the business of exporting wheat from California to Europe. The production of wheat gradually increased in this county, and large quantities each year were brought to this city for a market. Thei'e being no conveniences for stoi'age, it was hauled to this city as harvested and threshed, and large quantities were piled along the wharves awaiting shipment. Steamers were paid at the rate of $2 per ton to transport it to San Francisco, and schooners and sailing-vessels proportionately. The increase in the production of wheat was so great that it was found impossible to ship it before the commencement of the rainy season, and it was also found to be for the interest of the producers to make arrairgements to hold their products for better prices than conld be obtained during the harvett season, when so nmch wheat was necessarily forced upon the market.
The first warehouses built es-pecially for the storage of grain M-ere erected in 1868. Messrs. Peters & Stewart erected a portion of what is known as the Eureka warehouse, and Messrs. Kallisher & Koseman erected the San Joaquin warehouse. The aggregate capacity for storage of the two for the year was about 10,000 tons, and it was all taken, and, in fact, the space was filled before the buildings were fully completed. Conveniences for storage seemed to be demanded by the wheat-producers, and the Eureka warehouse was enlarged by its owners the next year, and the Stockton warehouse, the largest structure of the kind in the city, covering a space of 200 X 300 feet, with a storage capacity of nearly 30,000 tons, was erected in the year 1873 by a joint-stock ctunpany, of which John Gavvme was president and manager. What is now known as Miller's warehouse, on the south side of Mormon channel, was ei"ected by Potter in 1872, and Baggs' warehouse in 1874.
Provenance
Text from An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.