San Joaquin County, California - Chapter 13: The Couet-Hotjse, 1890
From An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. 4,738 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
4,738 wordsMachine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 13: The Couet-Hotjse
was originally called the " County Square," and was for a long time used as grounds for packing mules and as a camping place for mule packers. Up to 1852 there were no American buildings around this area, the American settlement being west of Hunter street and south of Levee. A tew tents were north of the slough. A branch of Mormon slough flowed northwesterly, passing diagonally across the southwestern portion of the County Sqi^are and emptied into Stockton channel; and the grounds were two to three feet lower than the present grade. The iirst public use of the square began about 1853, when the Iirst courthouse was built.
In September, 1850, a tax of 25 cents ptr $100 was levied to create a building fund for the erection of a court-house and city hall, but a plan was not accepted until June 14, 1853. It was devised by Ayres and Higgins and furnished by "William Brown. Two days thereafter the specifications were advertised, and at the expiration of a month proposals were received. The contract was awarded to Theodore Winters, who completed the building in due time, for $83,- 920. The corner-stone was laid August 6, 1853, by the Odd Fellows. E. W. Colt and George Ryer delivered addresses. April 3, 1854, the city council, then called the "common" council,
The whole edifice was built of brick manufactured in Stockton and vicinity. The face brick, made by a man named Day, was furnished at $30 a thousand; the inner brick were supplied at $15. The mortar was made from French- Camp sand, which was hauled to the city by Andrew, Jacob and R. Meyers. They employed ox teams, which had crossed the plains from Ohio the year before. The sand, however, con tained loam, and was therefore inferior. John Reynolds, since then a farmer in this county, was one of the masons. He began work on the building September 15, 1853, and continued until the structure was completed. The masons were paid on an average $10 a day. Among them were a Mr. Tinkham, Mr. Castle and two brothers named McHenry. The brick work was under the direction of a BuflFalo (N. Y.) man named Morey, whose head mason was a Cincinnatian named Rhodes.
In February or March, 1854, Gilbert B. Claiborne, the county clerk, moved his office into the building. Two or three years afterward the ground was enclosed with posts and chains. The south hall of the court-house up stairs was used as a council chamber, and rooms below by city officers, while the county department .^occupied the north end of the building.
Indeed, the building was the joint property of the city and county, and both city and county clerkships were held by one man. Previous to the erection of this building the city and county authorities occupied a frame building on the northwest corner of Hunter and Channel streets, and public meetings were sometimes held at the residence of a squatter on the ground.
In the course of time the county outgrew the above described court-house, and the Board of Supervisors passed a resolution providing for plans and specifications and at the same time calling an election whereat the people should vote on the question of issuing bonds to the extent of $250,000, for the purpose of building a new court-house and jail. The bonds were voted, and were readily sold at a premium, bearing interest at four per cent. The board accepted the plans of E. E. Myers & Son, of Detroit, Michigan, architects of many State capitols and other large buildings in the East, and let the contract ty J. A. Norcross & Son, also of Detroit. Work was commenced April 14, 1887, and the structure will be completed probably during the spring of 1890, before this volume is delivered to its patrons. The cost will be about $229,000. The walls are of brick, trimmed with granite, the brick being furnished by the San Joaquin Improvement Company, of this county, and the granite by G. Griffith, for $100,000. The roof is of slate, from Amador County; the iron work is from Rochester, New York; the tile used in the walls and corridors are from France; and the cement is of the "Portland" brand.
The tower is 172 feet high, and in the dome alone there are 750,000 brick. Good stairways lead to the top of the dome for the use of spectators, who from the exterior tramway there can see every point in the county. The tower is surmounted by a statue of Justice. The building is 56 x 126 feet and three stories high. The first story is secured for the use of city officers for a term of twenty years; the rest of the building is of course devoted to county offices and the courts. The structure is lighted and heated with natural gas from a twelve-inch well borei at the expense of the county on a lot one block distant. Steam heating apparatus is supplied throughout the building.
Jail
The new jail, costing about $60,000, will be erected on the corner of San Joaquin and Chan nel streets, occupying the area of two lots, Foi a time it was the intention to build it neare; the court-house, to be connected with it by a subterranean tunnel.
This fine institution is located just outsid* the eastern limits of the city of Stockton, at the head of Mormon avenue. The hospital had been kept for many years on the plat adjoining on the north. In the present plat of ground are about thirty-six acres. The main building, erected about ten years ago, cost probably between $10,000 and $11,000. Two wings have since been added, the last about two years ago, at a cost of about $6,000. The buildings altogether have a capacity for properly accommodating 175 inmates. Three years ago they were very much crowded. The highest number of inmates at any one time was 157. The average number for 1887 was 120; 1888, 105^, and for 1889 probably about 115. Average cost of keeping each patient for 1888, $156.60^, or 42^ cents per day.
The county physicians have been Drs. Clark, Aiken, Charles A. Ruggles, A. S. Hudson, William A. Washington, three years, J. D. Young, commencing in March, 1887, S. P. Crawford, and since January 9, 1889, W. E. Gibbons. The above list may not be quite complete. C. W. Ward has been superintendent since February 16, 1882; preceding him were first Mr. Kelly, then Charles Garrow and John Qiialtrough.
State Asylum Foe The Insane
"Twelve years ago I undertook the task of collating and tabulating the general statistics ut the asylum from its opening, with regard to the patients. I then found, to my great embarrassment, that the records of the institution did not furnish the data for the completion of the desired work. The deficiencies were supplied only by recourse to tlie appendices to the legislative journals, to contemporaneous newspapers, and personal knowledge. From such sources the tables were completed with tolerable accuracy, and they have since been continued from year to year with mathematical exactness. Much valuable information was thereby rescued from irretrievable loss. The following history of the dates and cost of the numerons improvements and additions to the asylum, and other events connected therewitii, I found, likewise, could only be obtained from various sources. They are here brought together in a form which will secure preservation and accessibility.
" As the whole, in its present vast dimensions - it being the largest State institution of the kind on the American continent - has in a great measure grown out of additions made from time to time from imperative necessity, the dates and records of expenditures, with regard to its several parts, are of value for future reference.
" The State Asylum for the Insane, situated at Stockton, had its initiation in the State General Hospital, established at that place in 1851. This hospital commenced its operations in the heart of the city, in cheap wooden buildings rented temporarily for the purpose, on the corner of El Dorado and Market streets. It was opened for the reception of patients in August, 1851.
Stockton. By this act the buildings and appurtenances were dedicated to the care of the insane exclusively, and the institution became solely an hospital for the insane, July 1, 1853.
" In 1853 the brick building, known now as the 'old wing' or the south wing of the present chief structure for the male patients, was built at an approximate cost of $33,000.
" In 1854 the main or center building of the male department was erected, for which the Legislature of that year appropriated $80,000, and the building was iinished for that sum.
" In 1856-'57 the north wing, completing the. design of the present principal structure of the male department, was erected, the appropriation thereto being $40,000. Some time after, contracts were awarded for the erection of this building, and when the work was commenced the decision of the Supreme Court was made declaring the State debt above a certain sura specified in the Constitution - which amount had been already far exceeded - unconstitntional and illegal. This decision rendered the appropriation unavailable, pending contracts based thereon and in the midst of work for which it was designed to pay. The losses and extra expenditures incurred thereby by the contractors were met by the passage of relief bills in 1857 and 1859, amounting to about $8,600, thus making the nominal cost of the nortli wing $48,600.
" In 1857 the present brick residence of the medical superintendent was erected, the appropriation for which was $4,500. Subsequent additions have been made thereto, making the approximate cost $7,500.
" In 1858 the two strong wards, under the antiquated and harsh appellation of 'mad houses' or ' cells,' were constructed; also, the grounds in the rear of the principal buildings were enclosed by high brick walls, making the airing courts; and other valuable improvements, including the frame tower and water tank, were made, a-ll of which were speciiically authorized by the Legislature of 1858, and for which a special appropriation of $40,000 was made and expended.
" In 1863, the institution having become full and crowded, a special tax was levied for ' the erection of additional buildings, yards, and other improvements,' which continued at the rate of iive* cents on each $100 for two years - 1863-'64. From the funds derived from this tax were erected, in 1863, the large second story of brick over the dining-room and kitclien, known as the ' Sixth Ward,' the brick building designated as the 'Upper Tenth Ward,' additional airing courts in connection with the old asylum building, and wooden outbuildings; out of this fund also were purchased the two blocks of land adjoining the one on which stands the old asylum building - one block east and one block west thereof. About $61,000 were expended in connection with the present male department.
''It was from tiiis fund that the commodious new building for the accommodation of the female patients was commenced, and the first part, or the transverse section of the south wing, including engine house, stack, and temporary kitchen, was finished at a cost of $66,885.34. This part of the present new building was opened and 125 female patients were transferred thereto October 1, 1865, leaving about forty-five still in one of the additions to the old building, and emptying the entire north wing of the old building, to be occupied by male patients.
"In the spring of 1867 the front, or longitudinal, section of the south wing was tinisiied, completing the entire wing. The forty- five patients remaining in the old building were transferred to this new structure June 23, 1867, leaving the old building and its dependent additions to be henceforth occupied exclusively by the males. This section of the new building cost $40,400.
" In 1869, the n:ale department again becoming excessively crowded, the row of wooden buildings called the ' Cottage Ward ' was completed and occupied, accommodating 160 patients. It cost about $15,000.
" In 1871-'72 a spacious brick building, designed for an engine house, laundry, workshop, and also for sleeping accommodations in the upper stories for employes and a harmless class of patients, was constructed at a cost of about $33,000, and has been in use for the above-named purposes since its completion in 1872.
" As provided for by act of the nineteenth session of the Legislature, the north wing of the building occupied by the female patients was completed in 1874, at a cost of $79,500.
" This section of the female asylum was opened July 1, 1874, and its construction completed the entire structure on the plan originally adopted, at an aggregate cost of $249,500. It will comfortably accommodate 325 patients.
"During 1875 the asylum property was enclosed with a substantial and comely fence, with appropriate gateways. The whole length of fence is 9,149 feet, and it cost, including the gates, curved flanks corresponding with width of streets at the three entrances, and two coats of paint over the entire fence, $14,780.
" In January, 1875, a new cemetery was purchased for the use of the asylum. It contains about fourteen acres, is situated west of and adjoining the 'Stockton Rural Cemetery,' and cost $2,751.
"The asylum grounds proper contain 107 acres, or thirty-six blocks with the inter-current streets on the plan of the city survey. The land was nearly all donated to the State by Captain C. M. Weber, when the asylum was permanently located at Stockton in 1853.
" During the year 1850, there were fourteen insane persons sent to the station house in San Francisco. It is estimated that at the close of the year the whole number of the insane was twenty-two. They were accommodated in San Francisco. Some received care and medical treatment in the State Marine Hospital, and others were temporarily secured on the old prison brig ' Euphemia.'
" In 1851, the State hospitals at Sacramento and Stockton afforded accommodations for the insane. During the same year the hospital at Sacramento received thirty-four and the one at Stockton thirteen, making the whole number forty-seven.
" In 1852 the Legislature ordered all the insane to be sent to Stockton and placed in the Stockton Hospital. During this year 124 patients were admitted into the insane department of the State General Hospital, including those transferred from receptacles in San Francisco and Sacramento.
" In 1853, as has already been stated, the Legislature abolished the State Hospital at Stockton and created in its stead the ' Insane Asylum of California.' All the sane patients were removed July 1, 1853; and this date, therefore, properly stands as that of the opening of the Insane Asylum.
" On the 8th day of October, 1853, the patients were removed from rented quarters, on the corner of El Dorado and Market streets, to the then new asylum building, now the south wing of the old building."
After giving a table of statistics concerning the inmates from the commencement in 1851 to 1876, the Doctor adds the following interesting particulars:
During the year ending June 30, 1888, 463 patients were admitted to the asylum, and a total of 1,553 were there for treatment, which is nearly half more than the institution can properly accommodate. During the same year 214 were discharged as recovered, fifteen improved, four unimproved, 130 died and seven escaped.
It is a noticeable fact that the commitme^its to this asylum have been largely in excess of those made to the Napa asylum, the average there being only seventeen annually while over sixty are brought to the Stockton institution. The number of patients receiving care and treatment in this asylum increased sixty-seven during the year ending June 30, 1887, and ninety-three during the year ending June 30, 1888, at which time there were 647 patients in the institution. This number is at least 500 in excess of the number the buildings are designed to accommodate, and in consequence not only are the various wards excessively crowded, but the corridors and attics are necessarily used to furnish sleeping rooms for the large number of patients who have been forced upon the care of the managers of the institution. The Legislative provision to transfer about 200 to the new asylum at Agnew, Santa Clara County would scarcely make a perceptible difference iu the extent of service in this large institution.
The numbers admitted to the two State Asylums during the past four years are as follows: In 1885, 820; in 1886, 850; in 1887, 810; in 1888, 818. Considering the sturdy growth of the State in this period, these figures show a falling off in the ratio of those attacked with insanity.
At the close of the year, the number of inmates in the two asylums was 3,115. Estimating the population at 1,150,000, the proportion of insane to population is one in 370. Comparing this with the ratio of insane in other countries and States, it will be seen that there is no foundation for the supposition that insanity is unduly prevalent here. The ratio in New York is 1 in 365; in Massachusetts, 1 in 350;
It has been found that while one-seventh of the whole population are foreign, of the insane, not one-seventh, as might have been expected, but one-third are of foreign birth. Thus it ap pears, that while bnt one in every 662 of the native population is insane, the ratio among the foreign born was one in every 250.
Turning to our own State, we iind this significant showing repeated and intensified. ]So State in the Union has so large a proportion of foreign born, except the neighboring State of Nevada. Over a third of the population of California, in 1880, were born outside of the United States. The number returned as insane in that year was 2,503, of whom 1,618, or two-thirds, were of foreign nativity. That is to say, one-third of our population (the foreign born) produced twothirds of our insane. Or, stated in another form, while one in every 646 of our native born is insane, the ratio among onr foreign born is one in every 180. Giving these remarkable figures their weight, it will be seen that a low rate of insanity in our State would, under present circumstances, be akin to a miracle.
" There are seventy Chinese under our care, sixty-seven males and three females, in the Napa Asylum about as many more may be found. In proportion to the number of Chinese in the State, I consider mental disease particularly rife amongst them. In China, insanity partakes somewhat of the nature of a penal offense. Hence travelers in that country, seeing little of it, proclaim its non-existence, and base thereon deductions unfavorable to civilization. But in Japan, where enlightened and progressive views are making rapid headway, institutions for the care of the insane are beginning to dot the land.
" The injustice of imposing upon the people the burden of supporting these 140 insane Chinamen year after year, calls for attention. At $130 per annum apiece, they are costing the
State $19,000 yearly. The expatriation of mentally defective immigrants is, in other places, a well established custom. From the ports of New York and Boston, so promptly and so frequently have insane aliens been reshipped to their own countries, that the measure no longer even attracts comment. Less than one-half the amount annually expended for their care and maintenance here would charter a vessel and crew and return the whole uumber to Hong Kong, whence they came.
"To these a third consideration might be added: ' Is there a reasonable prospect that his insanity, even if not of such a nature as to require his seclusion, could be benefited by special treatment at an asylum?' An asylum should be, first and foremost, a hospital for the cure of curable cases; but the State law fails to recognize this, its highest and latest acquired function, as a specific reason for the commitment of a patient thereto. Nor, in our present overcrowded condition, can we lay claim to the full exercise of this higher function.
" Unless both of the first two questions above can be answered in the affirmative, the commitment of the patient is a direct infringement of the law. Nothing could be more succinct and unequivocal than the wording of the statute on this subject. ' No case,' it provides, ' of idiocy, imbecility, simple feebleness of intellect, or old case of harmless dementia, or of any class of incurable and harmless insanity, or of delirium tremens, shall be sent to the asylum.'
" Many patients of the imbecile class are deposited here who would not be received in any other asylum in the world; many who are decrepit, aged, harmless, and broken down; who sometimes, too feeble to walk, are carried in and never leave their beds afterwards. This class should properly be taken care of in county almshouses. A nicer discrimination is needed in the commitment of persons to the asylum. The popular error still prevails in some quarters that simply to establish the fact of insanity is all that is necessary."
Of the patients admitted into the State asylum at Stockton during the year ending June 30, 1885, forty per cent, recovered. Of the 233 discharged during tlie year ending June 30, 1888, 214 were sent away as " recovered," a percentage of over forty-six on the admissions during the same period. Concerning the legal bearing of the word "recovered," Superintendent Mays makes the following remarks, which are of great importance:
" In returning a patient to the world again, shall his certificate of discharge read ' recovered,' or merely 'improved?' The question is one fraught with serious possibilities to the newly liberated person. The endorsement ' recoxered' restores him to citizenship, anything short of that does not. From being civilly dead, it makes him again a living integer in the commonwealth, restoring to him what he loses when committed as insane, his forfeited duties and privileges, public and private, his social and domestic rights, his civil and political rights. Unless discharged ' recovered,' his status is left in doubt, his power to make a contract is disputable, his future acts are of questionable validity. He is still presumably insane."
" It may not be generally known that the State, and not the county, pays the cost of transportation and mileage of patients. This is a curious and unique arrangement. In effect, the State offers a premium to county officials to hunt up patients and bring them here. If the expense of transportation were placed where it belongs, on the county, there would be less inducement for the authorities of county hospitals and almshouses to unload their helpless and bedridden cases upon us."
cents in 1887, and 36.9 cents in 1888. This low rate is not the result of any special effort to reduce the cost of supporting the patients, but is due to the great increase in the number cared for, while at the same time the working force of the establishment has remained the same, or nearly so.
It is interesting to scan the table of causes of the insanity as assigned in the commitments. Of the 463 committed, masturbation leads the list of causes with the number thirty -nine; intemperance, the same number this year but proportionally fewer the preceding year; hereditary, thirty-six; injury to head, eighteen; epilepsy and sunstroke, fourteen each, and so on down; business and money troubles, only eight - contrary to the common impression as to the proportional frequency of this cause. " Salvation army" is assigned as the cause in one instance, and " Spiritualism " in four. Doubtless in a number of instances the cause and the effect are reversed in the estimate of the physician or jury assigning the cause. " Reading trashy novels " was the cause in one case. Minds vary so much in strength, susceptibility, etc., that what wonld set one man crazy would not affect another in the least; but every one instinctively knows that any and all indulgences in intemperance of any kind, or exposures, injuries to the head, diseases or drugs affecting the brain, etc., are risks, for no one knows where the weakest spot of his nervous system is. The Superintendent says:
" Insanity is to a large extent a preventable malady. It comes from an ignoring of the laws of health and sobriety. Without entering upon an enumeration of the many causes of insanity, I shall make a brief reference to one of the most prominent factors in the question - - intemperance. All my observation goes to strengthen the belief that there is no greater mind-destroyer than this. It is in the second generation that the evil works its most harm. One-half the insane - perhaps more - owe their derangement to hereditary influence, inheriting an ancestral taint or predisposition. But this he- reditary. taint - how had it its origin? Where the family history can be searched into, the starting point will often be found in a drunken progenitor. The damaging eifects of the excessive use of alcohol upon the brain are more often manifested in the offspring than in the drinker himself. He may manage to keep out of the asylum, and even maintain a respectable place in society, but his children will often find it hard to do so. They inherit qualities that un fit them for the struggle for existence, and go down under the strain. The familes of intemperate parents furnish the recruiting ground for insane asylums. These unfortunate children, if not idiots or epileptics, are liable to grow up with querulous, explosive tempers, with feeble powers of self-guidance, weak in temptation, unstable, self-indulgent, vicious, hysterical. They form the bulk of what are known as the defective classes."
What is now the principal asylum building w-as erected in 1883-'85, the south wing in the former year, the total cost of the whole structure being $224,000. It is of brick, with sandstone facings; and while it is unpretentious in design and free from superfluous ornamentation, there is nothing prison- like in its appearance; on the otiier hand, it is really beautiful and attractive. As it has a capacity, without crowding, of 530 inmates, this places the per capita cost at $425 - - a tigui'e so remarkably low that very few asylums in the country can approach it. The several divisions are so arranged that, while the unity of design is preserved, an abundance of light and air is secured to every portion.
Most of the time the operations of the institution have been more or less circumscribed by the meagreness of Legislative appropriations, as the wants of the growing establishment increased more rapidly than the people were aware of; and it has been said that, for a time at least, "politics" interfered with the best administration of the asylum. Superintending physicians were appointed for political reasons.
In 1856 Dr. Samuel Langdon became medical superintendent. The next year he fought a duel with Dr. William JRyer, being wounded but the contest proved fatal to neither party Dr. Aylett took charge August 13, 1857; Dr W. P. Tilden, August 20, 1861; Dr. G. A Shurtleff, in August 1865, and resigned Sep tember 1, 1883. Dr. W. T. Brown was elected superintendent October 10 following; and Dr. Hiram N. Rucker November 1, 1888. The assistant physicians are Drs. Wm. A. Washington and Junius D. Young.
The board of directors of the asylum, according to the last report (October, 1S88), consists of the following gentlemen: Robert Watt, of Oakland, president, appointed by Governor Irwin 1876, re appointed by Governor Perkins 1880, re- appointed by Governor Stoneraan 1884, and re-appointed by Governor Waterman 1888; J. K. Doak, of Stockton, vice-president, appointed by Governor Booth 1874, by Governor Perkins 1880, and by Governor Stoneman 1884; C. H. Randall, of Sonora, appointed by Governor Stoneman 1884; J. D. McDougald, of Stockton, appointed by 'Governor Stoneman 1885; and Obed Harvey, M. D., of Gait, appointed by Governor Waterman 1888. N. M. Orr, of Stockton, is secretary and treasurer.
The United States Land Office for this district was established at Stockton July 26, 1858, and is now in the Masonic Temple. The first entry upon the records bears the date August 2, 1858.
Provenance
Text from An Illustrated History of San Joaquin County, California : Containing a History of San Joaquin County from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, Together with Glimpses of Its Future Prospects ; with ... Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also Prominent Citizens of Today, published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.