BlockBefore

San Luis Obispo County, California - Chapter 31: Church, Bench and Bar, 1883

From History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883. 13,031 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

27 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

13,031 words

Machine-read from scans of History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 31: Church, Bench and Bar

Methodist Episcopal Church, Rev. A. B. Spooner - Protestant Episcopal Church - Methodist Episcopal Church, South - Presbyterian Church - The Present Condition - Rev. Rufus Deming - The Bench and Bar - J M. Bonilla - H. A. Teflt - An Exciting Trial - Judge Joaquin Carrillo - Pablo de la Guerra - Walter Murray - Obituary of Hon. Walter Murray - Tribute by James O'Sullivan - ^Judge Murray's Family - Eugene Fawcett - Louis McMurtry - D. S. Gregory - The County Court - W. J. Graves - O. M. Brown - Romualdo Pacheco - ^Jos6 Maria Munoz - ^Joseph M. Havens - William L. Beebee - McD. R. Venable - District Attorneys - Parker H. French - Hubbard C. M Ely - P. A. Forrester - James White - N. D. Witt - A. A. Oglesby - Ernest Graves - F. Adams - Robert C. Bouldin - R. M. Preston - Members of the Bar.

'HE history of the church in San Luis Obispo begins with the founding of the mission in 1772, and continues with the history of California and of the county to the present time. But the history of the missions has been given in the early chapters of this book. During all the period of Spanish possession, and for many years reaching into the American era, the Roman Catholic was the only religion tolerated or professed within the sound of the mission bells, or within the jurisdiction of the authorities. The Americans came and took possession of the country, the Government being indifferent to religion, protecting all, but favoring none, and the new-coming people paid but little attention to church matters. Generally they were orderly and law-abiding, many were professors of religion and observant of church requirements, but in the absence of ladies and families society remained disorganized and the churches were neglected. At what time the first Protestant clerg}'man made his home and held the services of his church in San Luis Obispo County it would be difficult to tell. The necessity of an organization was not so great as in the newly-settled counties of the North, as here the mission church was always open, and those of liberal minds and religiously inclined could assemble and worship there.

Methodist Episcopal Church

The Methodist is the church of the West, accompanying the pioneer on his march, and where the pioneer has rested there is soon found the altar of the church. The first church in San Luis Obispo was erected in December, 1869, and the first service held in the building, then incomplete, was on Sabbath, January 2, 1870, Rev. A. P. Hendon, pastor, who makes the following announcement : -

We gladly embrace this opportunity of informing the public, and friends of religion, through the pages of the Tribune, that the Methodist Episcopal Church of San Luis Obispo is now enclosed. The promptness with which the mechanics, brethren, and friends have responded to the call for help, in the way of work, is truly praiseworthy.

We have ordered the windows and doors, which will not cost to exceed fifty dollars, and at our first service we hope to raise this amount by collection.

We now respectfully invite the attendance of the people of San Luis Obispo and vicinity, whom we hope will respond to this call, irrespective of religious denomination.

The above is an indication of the struggle, even at that late day, to establish a Protestant church in San Luis Obispo. Those who were contributing to the construction of the building were called seceders from Rome, and as late as August, 1870, aid is asked to pay the church debt. The building cost $1,400 in cash for material and labor, other than what was contributed.

In October, 187 1, Rev. B. W. Rusk became the pastor, dividing his time with San Luis and Cambria, the latter at that time becoming a prominent town. Mr. Rusk had previously been pastor of the church at Humboldt Bay, and removed thence with his family to San Luis Obispo.

siding at Old Creek, chaplain of the San Simeon Lodge, F. and A. M., and conducting religious ceremonies when and where he was called upon to do so. For some years he alternated with Rev. Mr. Rusk in holding service at the church in San Luis Obispo.

Under the leadership of Rev. D. H. Haskins, the pastor in 1S74, the church lot on Garden Street, between Marsh and Higuerro, in the mission vineyard tract, was purchased, and preparations made for moving the church edifice upon it. To accomplish this required several months' work and a large expense, but it was finally completed and the new building dedicated on the 21st of June, 1874; Rev. C. V. Anthony, of Oakland, preaching the dedicatory sermon. Great interest was taken in this improvement, and the congregation at the dedication was the largest ever seen in San Luis Obispo. It appears to have been as enthusiastic and liberal as numerous. The minister stated that a debt on the building, created by the removal and enlarging, amounted to $900, and asked for contributions to pay it. Contributions to the amount of $1,020 were immediately made. The ladies of the church, by their own contributions and collections, soon after purchased a bell weighing 1,000 pounds, and it was placed in the belfry.

The building, now bearing the name of Garden Street Church, is forty-eight feet in length, thirty-two feet wide, and twenty feet from floor to ceiling. The vestibule constitutes the base of the spire which rises to the height of seventy feet, and contains the belfry. The w^ork was done under contract with Mr. H. S. Laird, and the painting by Mr. Austin.

The holding of the Annual Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church of southern California in San Luis Obispo, was a matter of great interest during the second week in September, 1882. The conference was presided over by Rev. Bishop Hurst, of Iowa, and many distinguished divines were present. The Committee of Arrangements were Revs. Adam Beard, W. A. Knighten, and C. Shelling. Rev. I. M. Leihy delivered the conference sermon, and during the session addresses were made on various subjects by Revs. E. S. Chase, A. N. Fields, J- B. Calloway, F. D. Bovard, J. H. Peters, J. H. White, H. J. Shaff"ner, M. F. Colburn, T. S. Uren, F. S. Woodcock, A. M. Hough, G. W. Elwood, A. W. Bunker, C. Shelling, Adam Bland, and Bishop Hurst.

Rev. H. J. Shaffner received the appointment as pastor of the church in San Luis Obispo. This gentleman had formerly served in Colorado, and during the preceding year had presided over the church at Hanford in Tulare County.

Rev. W. F. Wenk was reappointed to the circuit, including Morro, Cayucos, and Cambria. Rev. F. S. Woodcock, who had in former years (succeeding Mr. Haskins in 1875) been the pastor of the church in San Luis Obispo, was appointed for Lompoc, and Rev. Mr. Whittemore to Los Alamos.

The retiring pastor of the church in San Luis Obispo, Rev. R. M. Kirkland, who had been a resident during the two preceding years, was unattached.

Rev. A. B. Spooner

The pioneer minister of the Protestant Church in San Luis Obispo County was the Rev. A. B. Spooner. This worthy divine met a sad fate by drowning in Morro Bay, February 5, 1877. Mr. Spooner being an old resident of Morro, and fully acquainted with the harbor, at times acted as pilot when his services were required. On the evening of that day he heard the whistle of the steamer Mary Taylor calling for a pilot to guide her in, and started out in a small boat to answer the summons. The tide was running out, and when his frail craft came in contact with the surf it. capsized, and Mr. Spooner was lost. Through the channel the current was running with great force, carrying the unfortunate man to sea, and his body was not recovered. The event cast a gloom over the whole community, as he was widely known and much loved and respected. Memorial services in his honor were held in the various churches of San Luis Obispo.

Mr. Spooner was about fifty-six years of age, possessed of marked individuality of character, a vigorous intellect, and sound constitution, bidding fair for a long and useful life. He was a member of the Methodist Episcopal Conference, and had, previously to settling at Morro, been actively engaged in the ministry. He was also Past Grand, in good standing, of Chorro Lodge, No. 168, I. O. O. F., and prominent in the Masonic Order.

Protestant Episcopal Church

St. Stephens Episcopal Church is the title of the society in San Luis Obispo, and dates its organization from August 21, 1867. The vestrymen and officers elected May 14, 1868, were Dr. W. W. Hays, Senior Warden; J. B. Townsend, Junior Warden; G. F. Sauer, Treasurer; John Flint, Secretary; J. H. Hollister, O. Kemp, J. Jones, and I. C. Smith, Vestrymen. Rev. H. Chetwood was the first minister to hold service, of which we have record, he preaching in the Odd Fellows Hall July 28, 1872. This gentleman was highly regarded as a talented preacher, and although stationed at San Diego, frequently visited and held services in San Luis Obispo.

In April, 1873, 'steps were taken for a more comjalete organization of the church society, and at a vestry meeting, April 14th, the following officers were elected: W. W. Hays, Senior Warden; McD. R. Venable, Junior Warden; C. H. Phillips, Treasurer; R. Pollard, Secretary; J. W. Flint, M. Henderson, J. Pennington, and W. J. Marcus, Vestrymen. At the same meeting plans and specifications for a church edifice were submitted, and Dr. W. W. Hays and Mr. M. Henderson were appointed a building committee to advertise and receive bids for the construction of the same. At a subsequent meeting the contract for the building was let to Mr. Walter Jerome for the sum of $2,500, and Messrs. Venable, Pollard, and Henderson were appointed a committee to solicit subscriptions to the building fund.

St. Stephen's Church was completed in October, 1873, at a cost of $2,800, and adding a few extras brought the total cost to $3,000. The site is on the northeast corner of Nipomo and Pismo Streets, on elevated ground, ren-

A Sunday-school, under the auspices of the lady members of the church, had previously been organized, which, before the construction of the edifice, had been held, first at the residence of Dr. Hays, then in Odd Fellows Hall, and other places.

The regular pastors of St. Stephens have been Revs. C. M. Hogue, S. S. Ruth, J. E. Hammond, and R. W. Summers, the last being the present incumbent, and also the Superintendent of the Sunday-school. The membership numbers twenty-nine, and about thirty-five children attend the Sunday-school. Regular morning and afternoon services are held. A cabinet organ presided over by Mrs. Summers, assists the choir in the rendition of sacred music. Rev. Mr. Summers, the pastor, is distinguished as a scholar and archseologist, and Mrs. Summers as a botanist and musician, in both of which sciences she teaches.

Methodist Episcopal Church, South

Rev. M. W. Glover was the first preacher of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, in San Luis Obispo, holding service at the Court House November lo, 1872. Rev. Mr. Underwood of the same denomination occasionally held services in the same place.

Early in 1873, Rev. Mr. Glover, the pastor, took preparatory steps toward the erection of a building for his church. For this purpose a lot was obtained north of the Court House on the elevated land of that neighborhood, and a number of enterprising citizens subscribed the funds for the building, Mr. J. P. Andrews heading the list with a subscription of $200. The building was erected during the summer and fall of 1873, and dedicated on the 5th of October of that year, Rev. A. M. Campbell, of Los Angeles, preaching the dedicatory sermon. The building is a substantial frame, painted white, without a spire, and at the time of its completion was called the finest appearing structure in the county. The seating capacity is for two hundred persons. The construction of this building was due to the enterprise and energy of the pastor, and in his honor it now bears the name of "Glover Chapel."

The annual session of the District Conference of this church for San Luis Obispo District convened at Guadalupe on the 9th of June, 1882, Rev. W. B. Kavanaugh, P. E., presiding, DeWitt Hubbell, Secretary.

W. C. Triplett, J. Barker, G. E. Franklin, and L N. McGuire, were elected Lay Delegates to the Annual Conference, to meet in San Luis Obispo, November i, 1882; and J. R. Norris, L. F. Potter, E. C. Cunningham, and S. D. Triplett, Alternates.

A resolution was adopted recognizing the vast amount of good being done in the interest of religion and morality by the temperance cause, and pledging the members of the Conference to use their best efforts to promote its advancement.

The second quarterly Conference was held on the 17th and 1 8th of February, 1883, in Glover Chapel in San Luis Obispo, Rev. W. H. Klyce, P. E., presiding. There was preaching by the Presiding Elder, and by Rev. W. D. King, who is the present pastor. The affairs of the church were reported as progressing favorably. Rev. W. L. Stevens, Elder J. W. Leach, and others have held services in the church.

Presbyterian Church

The first preaching by a minister of the Presbyterian denomination in San Luis Obispo was by Rev. Mr. Frazer, of Oakland, July 18, 1874, who then urged the organization of a society here.

A number of the friends of the Presbyterian Church met at the residence of Judge Venable on the 1 2th of May, 1875, and took preliminary steps for the organization in San Luis Obispo of a society of that denomination, and the organization was consummated on the Sunday following, the 1 6th of May. Rev Alvin Ostrom was engaged as pastor, and services were held in Little & Cochran's Hall during the summer of that year. Shortly thereafter a church edifice was erected on the corner of Marsh and Morro Streets, where it still stands, a plain, but respectable and capacious structure, with seating capacity for about two hundred people.

Rev. Mr. Ostrom had been a missionary to China, and was a highly educated and able gentleman. He also established a school, with aspirations to advance it to a collegiate institute, but it did not long continue.

The Present Condition

The ministers of the various churches often held services in the other towns of the county, and organizations of societies were made and churches built, and the ministers of other localities often preached in San Luis Obispo. The Christians, or Campbellites, have been represented by Rev. Mr. Wright, Rev. Rufus Deming, and others; and the Baptists by Rev. L. Riley, and others, but they have not built churches. At Cambria the Presbyterians have an organization with Rev. H. Vernon Rice as pastor, and at Estrella, Rev. H. . E. Adams does service in performing the marriage ceremony and preaching for the Methodists. At Arroyo Grande the Presbyterians have a church. The mission of San Miguel is presided over by Rev. Father Farrelly, who also holds services in the Catholic Church at Cambria, but this denomination is more particularly noticed in the history of the missions. San Luis Obispo is now well provided with churches, which are provided with able ministers and are as well maintained and attended as is usual in the rural counties of any State.

Rev. Rufus Deming

Mr. Rufus Deming, of San Luis Obispo, died May i, 1880, in the eighty-second year of his age. The deceased was a native of Massachusetts. Many years ago he emigrated to Illinois. He came to California in 1858, and settled in Napa County, where he resided for eighteen years. Soon after coming to California he lost his fourth wife, and in 1856 was married to Miss Jane Love. Father Deming, as he was familiarly called, spent a long, active, and useful life. As a citizen, he was interested in all that pertained to the welfare of his country; as a neighbor, he always merited and received the confidence and esteem of those who knew him, while to his family he was a devoted husband and father. Early in life he became a member of the Christian Church, to which he was devotedly attached. He was a faithful worker in the cause, and exemplified his profession by an upright and consistent life.

The Bench And Bar

With the history of the organization of the county and with the records of elections is given the names of the various Judges of the courts with mention of proceedings, and there remains but little to be told. In connec tion with practice at the Bar in a county Hke San Luis Obispo there naturally occur many incidents worthy of record, of a singular, amusing, or tragic character, but these, if any such transpired, are sacredly locked in the memories of those cognizant of them, or lost in the oblivion of forgetfulness.

Going back to the earliest dates to find a member of the legal profession a resident and practitioner of San Luis Obispo, our researches exhume the name of Don Jose Mariano Bonilla, the first to occupy the judicial bench of the county.

He was born in the city of Mexico, in the year 1807, and received his education at the National College of San Yldefonso, in said city, where he received various diplomas, and was made a Bachelor of Letters. Through application and talent, he became a prominent member of the Bar of the city of Mexico. In 1834 he came to California with one of the colonies sent from Mexico, as Secretary to Governor Figueroa. From that he was promoted to Judge of the First Instance.

He married the daughter of Don Inocente Garcia in 1837, that gentleman then being the Administrator of the mission of San Miguel, and acted as Secretary to his father-in-law. He was afterwards appointed, by Gov. Juan B. Alvarado, Administrator of the mission of San Luis Obispo, at which place he made his subsequent home.

After the annexation of California to the United States, and before the Constitution of this State was adopted, he held the position of Sub-Prefect and Alcalde under the Military Government, and after the adoption of the Constitution, he became the first County Judge of San Luis Obispo County. During the time that Hon. Romualdo Pacheco was County Judge, Senor Bonilla was District Attorney. He was afterward elected Supervisor, holding the ofiSce for several terms, until in 1866, he retired to private life. He was also engaged in numerous private enterprises, one of which was the building of the Cuesta Flouring Mill, in the early days of the county. Don J. Mariano Bonilla died in San Luis Obispo, March [9, 1878, at the advanced age of seventy-one years. In private as well as in public life he was always found honest and worthy of every trust reposed in him, and his death was sincerely mourned by all classes of people.

During his incumbency as County Judge, attorneys were very few in San Luis Obispo, and it is related that on one occasion, in 1849, a case was on trial before him involving the right to a horse between two Mexicans. There were but two lawyers in the county, W. J. Graves and Judge Bonilla. Graves was the attorney for the plaintiff, while the defendant had none. This appeared to the Judge a hardship for the defendant, with no one to present his case against so able an opponent, and he called upon the Sheriff to preside over the Court, and leaving the Bench, took up the cause of the defendant, and tried the case with all the energy and earnestness of which he was capable. But his eloquence and skill availed not, as after careful deliberation he rendered judgment for the plaintiff.

The Constitution adopted in 1849 provided for the division of the State into Judicial Districts, and that at its first session the Legislature should elect one District Judge for each, who should hold office for two years after the I St of January succeeding his election, after which the Judges should be elected at the general election and hold office for six years. The District Court was given original jurisdiction in law and equity; in all civil cases where the amount in dispute exceeded $200, exclusive of interest; in all criminal cases not otherwise provided for, and in all issues of fact joined in Probate Court.

The counties of San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara constituted the Second Judicial District, and Henry Amos Tefft was elected by the Legislature as its District Judge. This gentleman was a lawyer by profession, born in the State of New York in 1824, and came to California early in 1849. He was elected to the Constitutional Convention from San Luis Obispo, and was an active member in forming the first Constitution of the State. At the election adopting the Constitution and for officers under it, he was elected to represent San Luis Obispo County in the Assembly, and chosen by the Legislature as District Judge. He married Dona Maria Josefa Dana, eldest daughter of Capt. Wm. G. Dana. The lady, as a widow, subsequently married S. A. Pollard, and died in 1878. Judge Tefft, in returning from holding court at Santa Barbara, was drowned while attempting to land from the steamer Sefiafor in the harbor of San Luis Obispo, February 6, 1852, and his body was never recovered. He was held in high esteem as a gentleman of education and high promise, and his loss was sincerely mourned by all.

An Exciting Trial

One of the puzzling questions in the early days of the county government was how to observe the forms of law. Courts were established and the Judges desired to proceed with dignity, but with the exception of the Judges, and one or two others, the methods of law were enigmas past their finding out. Mr. Samuel A. Pollard was a young gentleman who seemed to know more than the people generally, and he was called upon to do the services in several offices, being elected Recorder. He relates the following story of the first criminal prosecution in San Luis Obispo : -

In the summer of 1850 a party of Texan "cow-boys," driving a band of cattle to San Francisco, passed through the rancho of Mr. J. M. Price. In those days there were no fences, and live stock roamed wherever it chose. It was a common occurrence for a drover of sheep or cattle to start from San Diego with a small band, which would gradually increase on his way up the coast, until, upon his arrival in San Francisco, he would market a gain of five hundred per cent. This augmentation of his drove was a mystery to the honest owner. It always transpired in the night, when it was too dark to distinguish one animal from another. If a ranchero had the good luck to discover his brand in the herd before it had passed on beyond his reach, he could only accept the ever-ready apology and reclaim his stock, to again be at the mercy of the next invader. There being no direct proof of their guilt, these unprincipled drovers escaped prosecution, and some of them grew wealthy in their nefarious business. Mr. Price was not a man to be trifled with by "cow-boys;" so, when he was informed that some cattle of his brand had been seen in a drove on the road, he posted off to town, and with the Sheriff and a posse, came unexpectedly upon the drovers, and they were arrested. The county of San Luis Obispo had just been organized. There were not more than three or four persons in the town who had ever been in an American court-room. This was the first occasion of the opening of the District Court of the First Judicial District. The CountyRecorder was merchant. Postmaster, Deputy Treasurer, and now was called upon by the District Judge to display his legal ability as District Attorney. For, be it known, there was not a qualified lawyer in the county in those days - and the people were happy. There was only one other man in town, besides the Judge, and the man of many offices, who could read English - an old whaleman who had been stranded on the coast long before gold had been found in California. Consequently, the first pleading before a court of law in this county was done by the aforementioned County-Recorder-merchant- Postmaster- Deputy-Treasurer- District- Attorney. He had never opened a law book in his hfe. He applied to the Judge to instruct him how to proceed with the case. That functionary replied that the duty of the District Attorney was only a matter of form, and with his assistance a list of questions was wTitten down to be propounded to the accused. With this preparation he set out to convict six as desperate looking fellows as can now be found on the border. They asked for time to send to Los Angeles for a lawyer. The continuance was granted, and in ten days he made his appearance. Court was formerly opened in a room in the old mission building. The room was severely unadorned, and chastely furnished with a single table and two benches - chairs being out of the question. The Judge took his seat at the head of the table, with the prosecutor at the side. The counsel for the defense at this juncture stalked calmly into the court-room - a veritable Texan giant, in a red shirt, with no coat, his pants tucked into his boots, and a brace of huge revolvers in his belt. The latter he slowly drew forth and deliberately placed upon the table before him. His six healthy clients, who had been released on bail, by leaving their cattle in the Sheriff's hands, were similarly provided with weapons of defense. Thus, before a single witness had been called, it was clearly apparent to the Judge, jury, and prosecution that the opposite side were prepared to demonstrate their innocence with some very convincing arguments. The case had opened in a manner that was highly dramatic in the first act, with a decided tendency towards tragedy at the close. The District Attorney went bravely through the routine of questions furnished him by the Judge. No evidence could be produced to prove that the cattle had been purposely taken into the drove. The learned counsel for the defense pleaded that the cattle had strayed into his clients' fold at night, and that their presence had not been discovered. The jury returned a verdict of acquittal, upon the condition that the cattle should be returned to their rightful owner. The counsel for the defense arose and tendered his thanks to his Honor in the following "well-chosen" words: "May it please the Court: I, in behalf of my clients, congratulate you and the gentlemen of the jury upon this favorable verdict. I am not accustomed to failure in my practice, and it was my intention to gain this suit if I had to clean out Court, jury, and all." And they would have done it. With this he tenderly took up his shooting-irons and departed. It is unnecessary to add that the prosecutor, who is the writer of this, was perfectly satisfied with the verdict.

Judge Joaquin Carrillo

The unfortunate accident which caused the death of Judge Tefft created a vacancy in the District Judgeship of the Second District and Joaquin Carrillo, then County Judge of Santa Barbara, was, in February, 1852, appointed to the vacancy. This gentleman was the son of Domingo Carrillo, who was the third son of Raymundo Carrillo, the founder of the family in California, and the first commandante of the presidio of Santa Barbara. The family of Carrillo was of high rank and influence, and to the Judge, as well as to Don Pablo de la Guerra, was due, in a great measure, the deference paid by the native California people to the American rule which the change of flag imposed upon them.

Judge Carrillo was not familiar with the English language, and the proceedings in court, when the trials were in that language, required to be interpreted to him. At the general election in 1852, he was elected Judge of the district without opposition, and held the office until 1863.

Mr. D. F. Newsom, who, in 1853, was appointed County Clerk, and from his skill in such matters was of great usefulness about the public offices, relates some incidents illustrating the imperious and convivial character of Judge Carrillo. On one occasion the Judge invited Mr. Newsom to join him in a social glass, which he declined, saying he never drank. The Judge was much incensed at the refusal, saying one who would not drink was not fit to be Clerk of his court, and for his discourtesy he would remove him from his office, and called upon the Sheriff" to furnish him a deputy for Clerk. As there was no one available qualified for the position, Sherifl" Mann immediately appointed Mr. New

Pablo De La Guerra

After the census of i860 the State was again apportioned into judicial districts, and San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara, Los Angeles, San Bernardino, and San Diego, were made the First District, to take effect in 1863. By an amendment to the Constitution the judicial election was segregated from the political election, and ordered held in October, while the latter was held in September. The candidates for Judge of the First District in 1863, were Pablo de la Guerra and Joaquin Carrillo, of Santa Barbara, and Benjamin Hayes, of Los Angeles, the choice falling upon the first. Judge de la Guerra was one of the foremost of the Spanish-American people of California. He was born in Santa Barbara, November 29, 1819. His father was Don Jose Antonio de la Guerra y Noriega, an officer of the Spanish Army and of the Spanish nobility, who was at that time in command of the presidio of Santa Barbara. The name De la Guerra, being the oldest of the family titles in Spain, was retained, and that of Noriega dropped upon the death of the father. Don Pablo bore a conspicuous part in the public affairs of California, both before and after the annexation to the United States. He was educated at Monterey by the fathers of the Catholic Church, aided by Prof W. E. P. Hartnell, and while there, when scarcely of age, was appointed Surveyor of Customs. After the annexation he was Judge of the Court of First Instance, and in 1849 was elected a member of the Constitutional Convention, and then Senator, representing the Senatorial District of San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara. The latter office he held until 1853, when he was succeeded by his brother, Don Antonio Maria de la Guerra. In 1855 he was again elected Senator, re-elected in 1855, 1857 and 1859, and made President pro tern, of the Senate, succeeding to the office of President of the Senate, and therefore Lieutenant- Governor in i860, upon the resignation of Gov. Milton S. Latham and the advancement to that position by Lieut-Gov. John G. Downey. In 1863 De la Guerra was elected Judge of the First Judicial District, as before stated. This position he held from the date of his incumbency in 1854, being re-elected in 1869, until declining health compelled his resignation in December, 1873, he dying on the 5th of February, 1874, aged fifty-four years. A further sketch of his life will be found on page 157 of this book.

Walter Murray

Upon the resignation of Judge de la Guerra, in December, 1873, Hon. Walter Murray was appointed by Governor Booth to the position of District Judge of the First Judicial District, then composed of the counties of San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara. He had been a candidate for the position in the election of 1869, carrying the county of San Luis Obispo, but was defeated by the large vote of Santa Barbara in favor of

Gentlemen: It has long ago been determined by thinking and observant men, that Judges should not be selected upon mere party grounds. To this end our State Constitution provides that the judiciary shall be elected at a time other than that fixed for the election of non-judicial officers. Nevertheless, the politicians throughout the State discard this wise principle, and, in the interest of party, almost universally make party nominations. It is a bad practice, but it exists; and until it be abolished by common consent, it must be borne with as best we may.

I come before you as the Republican candidate for the office of District Judge of this district, composed of the two counties of Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo. As I have indicated, I deprecate the practice of electing judges on party grounds. I therefore declare to you that I feel no man bound to support me merely because I have received a party nonjination; and I solicit the votes of all men of all parties, who upon a calm review of the circumstances which surround us, and of the character and qualifications of the candidates, shall deem it fitter that I should be elected rather than my opponent.

I am a resident of San Luis Obispo, having been engaged in the practice of law in that county for the last fifteen years. I also have the honor of a large acquaintance in Santa Barbara County. For my qualifications for the office in question I refer to my brethren of the legal profession, who are best qualified to judge of them. For my character and conduct, also matters to be considered, I refer you to those who know me, and they are many, throughout the district.

If elected, I will- endeavor to serve you with fidelity, and to concentrate whatever energy and ability I may be conceded to possess, singly to the purpose of fulfilling the duties intrusted to my care.. I will consider it to be my duty to hold all the terms of court by law provided; to dispatch all court business promptly, that jurors, witnesses, and attorneys may as soon as possible disembarrass themselves from an often unpleasant duty; to know no friend, nor party, in the administration of my official duties, but to render decisions to the best of my own judgment, and unbiased by all extraneous considerations, of whatsoever character; in the administration of the criminal law to be strict and inflexible, always ready to show mercy, where the facts justly call for it, but regarding its exercise upon any other occasion as misplaced and perverted.

With this brief enunciation of my ideas of official duty, I submit myself to your suffrages, and cheerfully await the decision (affecting your interests far more than mine), which will be rendered by you on the 20th instant.

The, history of this gentleman is briefly told in the following extracts from many published notices of his death, which took place in San Luis Obispo, October 5, 1875, in the fiftieth year of his age.

The Angel of Death has again visited our people, and robbed them of a wise officer, a good citizen, and a true friend. Just two years ago, Pablo de la Guerra, Judge of the First Judicial District, was called to an untimely grave. Yesterday, the last solemn rites were performed

Walter Murray, whom we now mourn, was born in London, England, in the year 1826, but came to the United States at an early age. Previous to seeking his fortune in a new world, he received a three years' training - from the age of thirteen to sixteen - in the chambers of an eminent London barrister. In the atmosphere of those inns of court his mind was imbued with a spirit of conservatism that had its controlling influence upon all his acts and words in life.

Upon his arrival in the United States, having a taste and talent for newspaper writing, he devoted himself to acquiring a practical knowledge of the printer's trade, with the view of becoming an editor. His first experience was in Boston, where, while acting as compositor in one of the large newspaper offices, he published a small journal, entitled the Mechanic^' Apprentice, a copy of which is in possession of a citizen of this county.

Promoted by a love of the country of his adoption, as well as for the laudable ambition to make for himself a name and fortune, and animated by a restless spirit of adventure, at the outbreak of the Mexican War, he was eager to be found in the ranks, fighting under the stars and stripes. He joined the celebrated Stevenson Regiment, which was organized to occupy and hold possession of California, and accompanied it in 1846 to the scene of its operations.

He made a faithful and a good soldier. Upon the disbandment of the regiment in 1848 he drifted, with many of his companions, to the mines of the Sierra Nevada; but soon abandoned the uncertain search of the glittering metal, for the pursuit he best loved, and for which he was best fitted.

In 185 1, he with J. O'Sullivan, established in the town of Sonora the first paper printed in Tuolumne County. [The paper was established before Murray & O'Sullivan's with it. - M. A.] In 1853 he came to San Luis Obispo, where he was admitted to the Bar, and has since resided, pursuing the practice of the profession of the law. He was also, for many years, connected with the Sari Luis Obispo Tribune, of which journal he was the founder, and by the power of his vigorous pen, he made the best country newspaper in California.

Having held many offices of trust in the county, in December, 1873, he was appointed by Gov. Booth District Judge of the First Judicial District, to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Pablo de la Guerra, which position he occupied at the time of his death.

Walter Murray was a man of strong convictions, fixed principles, and great independence of character. He was nothing of the time server. In politics he was a Republican, and a consistent one, and in the advocacy and defense of his principles, showing neither fear nor favor. Although determined in his opinions, he was never a radical, but had respect for the honest convictions of all.

His journal, the medium of expression of his views upon social and political matters, was noted for its conservatism as well as force. As an aspirant for office he was dignified and gentlemanly, never allowing himself in the most heated campaigns to be led into the use of any of the low weapons of political warfare.

As a friend, he was ardent, unflinching, and untiring; as an enemy, bitter but never mean. As a lawyer he was faithful to his clients, and pre-eminently courteous to the members of the Bar. As a Judge, his unselfishness and independence displayed themselves to great advantage in his total disregard of consequences to self in the rendition of his decisions. In the profession and on the Bench he was industrious, painstaking, and conscientious.

At the close of his life few men in the district were more popular than Walter Murray. His last hours were blessed by the companionship of devoted friends and comrades of his camp life, and no less warm friends of later years, who cheered him with their gentle and hopeful words, and with tender hands ministered to his every want. While these men last, his presence will be with us, his memory remain green until their hearts cease to beat.

Hon. James O'Sullivan, who had been the companion in arms with Murray, and associated with him in mining and journalism, contributed the following to the mem. ory of his friend: -

The death of Hon. Walter Murray, Judge of the Firs Judicial District Court, in San Luis Obispo, on the 5th inst., calls for more than a mere passing notice.

Judge Murray was a pioneer Californian, having come here from New York in 1847, with Stevensons' Regiment. A native of London, England, he emigrated to the United States when quite young. In Boston he served apprenticeship to the printing trade, and at the age of fifteen was editor of an apprentices' paper, which he filled with marked ability. His fine intellect and native talent were improved by a good early education, and he was a man who would have made his mark anywhere. After having worked at mining for two years, he was associated with the writer of this in 185 1 and '52 in the proprietorship of the Sonora Herald, and he edited and conducted the paper brilliandy and successfully. In 1853 he moved to San Luis Obispo, where he has remained ever since. In the legislative session of 1858 he represented San Luis Obispo in the Assembly and made a creditable record there. The Sacramento Union (high authority) said he made the most logical speech uttered in either house during the session. He has been frequently honored by the people of his county, having been District Attorney and Treasurer, and finally on the occurrence of a vacancy, he was appointed District Judge by Governor Booth.

Having been intimately associated with Judge Murray from the time he left New York, in 1846, until 1853, and thoroughly knowing his sterling qualities as a man, his fine abilities and his goodness of heart, I trust I may be allowed to pay this tribute to his memory.

Judge Murray left an interesting family, a wife and several very promising children. Mrs. Mercedes Murray was a lady of Spanish descent. She survived her husband but a few years, dying in San Luis Obispo.

One lovely and accomplished daughter. Miss Anita Murray, has been for some years a teacher in the Mission Public School, and another resides with and makes one of the pleasant family of C. B. Rutherford, Esq., of Oakland, a life-long friend of Judge Murray.

Eugene Fawcett

In the judicial campaign of 1875, Walter Murray had been the prominent candidate for District Judge, but his death occurring on the eve of the election left the field between L. C. Granger, and Judge Eugene Fawcett, of Santa Barbara, the choice falling upon the latter, judge Fawcett was born in Belmont County, Ohio, March 22, 1845, residing there with his parents until 1864, when, being then nineteen years of age, he went to New York as a member of the editorial staff of the Herald. On the breaking out of the war between Chi'e and Spain in 1865 he visited South America as the special correspondent of the Herald, remaining there until the latter part of 1866, when he returned to New York, retaining his position as writer until 1S67, when he removed to Chariton, Iowa> and commenced the study of the law. In 1870 he was admitted to practice in the Supreme Court of that State, and soon established a reputation for bringing his cases well prepared before the court. His failing health indicating the malady which afterwards proved fatal, in 1873 he came to Santa Barbara, where a year later he married Miss Minnie Pray, whose acquaintance he had made while she was a student at the Santa Barbara College. In November, 1875, he was appointed District Judge to fill the place made vacant by the death of Judge Murray, having been elected in October for the succeeding term, which place he held until the court was abolished by the New Constitution. In 1878 he was elected by a large majority as a delegate to the Constitutional Convention while still District Judge, on which account his eligibility to the convention was contested on the ground that no man could constitutionally hold two offices at the same time. The matter being referred to the Committee on Privileges and Elections, was finally decided favorably to Judge Fawcett, the ground taken being that the delegates were not officers within the meaning of the law. The Judge took occasion to explain that the position came unsought to him, was in some degree unwelcome, but that being chosen by a handsome majority, he felt impelled to accept the responsibilities thereof. The convention indorsed the action of the committee by a vote of ssventy-fpur to forty-nine, being nearly a party vote.

In September, 1879, Mr. Fawcett was elected Superior Judge of Santa Barbara County, taking his seat Tuesday, January 6, 1880, and dying three days later.

He was universally lamented, and many marks of respect were paid to his memory by the people and by the press throughout the State. The State Senate adjourned for the day in honor of his memory.

Judge Fawcett was a type of that strong, homely virtue which the people of the United States have delighted to honor, and which has found its best illustrations in the lives of Garfield and Lincoln. Rough even to brusqueness in his manner, it was because he was intensely loyal to his convictions and cared less to conciliate an opponent than to maintain the truth. While he had an utter contempt for the vices of political and social life, he had a leaning towards the merciful in his judgment of the follies and weaknesses of humanity.

As a Judge should be, Mr. Fawcett was decisive and stern in his rulings, never allowing latitude to witness or lawyer under any circumstance. This incident will serve to illustrate the characteristic: While sitting as Judge of the Seventeenth District Court, engaged in the trial of one of the suspected murderers of T. W. More, he was met by a protest from Creed Haymond, J. M. Brooks, and W. W. Allen, Attorneys for defendant, that Fawcett was no longer Judge, having vacated the position by becoming a member of the Constitutional Convention. Whereupon the Judge fined them $250 each for contempt of Court, alleging that it was not theii province to determine whether the de facto Judge was so by law or not. The attorneys entered affidavit that they had no intention of casting contempt upon the Court, but were acting solely in the interests of their client.

It seemed that Allen, one of the Attorneys mentioned, had not been admitted to practice in the court in which the trials were being had; whereupon he was fined an additional $250.

The Constitution adopted in 1879, wrought a radical change in the Judicial system of the State. District and County Courts were abolished and the Superior Court established in their stead; one Superior Court foi each county, and in such counties as required them a number of Superior Judges were elected, each presiding over a department of the Superior Court for such county. Louis McMurtry was elected Superior Judge of San Luis Obispo County on a Union ticket, defeating W. McConaughy, the nominee of the Workingmen and New Constitution Parties. Judge McMurtry was a native of Kentucky, born in 1840, and a resident of San Luis Obispo since 1874. In 1877, he was elected District Attorney on the Democratic ticket, which office he filled until promoted to the Bench. The duties of his high office he conducted with skill and satisfaction until stricken with disease in 1882, and even then he struggled with his maladies and presided over his court when physical suffering rendered it exceedingly difficult and painful so to do. At last he succumbed to disease, dying on the nth of February, 1883, at his residence in' San Luis Obispo, leaving a widow, an accomplished and estimable lady, and several children. He was buried in the cemetery of San Luis Obispo, the funeral being conducted by the fraternity of King David's Lodge, No. 209, F. and A. M., of which he was a member.

The city and county offices were closed on the day of the funeral, and the Court House and rooms of the Judge were heavily draped in mourning for the deceased. At a meeting of the Bar, called to pay respect to his memory, Messrs. F. Adams, D. S. Gregory, McD. R Venable, and J. M. Wilcoxon were appointed a committee to draw resolutions of respect and condolence; and the following were reported and adopted: -

The members of the Bar of San Luis Obispo County, sensible of the great loss they and the people of this county have sustained in the death of the Honorable Louis McMurtry, the late Superior Judge of the count) of San Luis Obispo, have met together and do adopi the following resolutions: -

Resolved, That the members of the Bar are deeply impressed with the great loss which they and the commu nity have sustained in the death of the Hon. Louis Mc- Murtry, our late Superior Judge.

The courteous dignity of his manners, the integrity ol his mind, his love of justice, and the ability with which he has ever discharged the duties of his office, inspired all with respect and admiration. We, with the people oi the county, mourn his loss.

Resolved, That the Secretary of this meeting transmit a copy of these resolutions to the family of the deceased, and express to them the sympathy of this Bar.

D. S. Gregory

The decease of Judge McMurtry left a vacancy in the office of the Superior Court which it was incumbent upon the Governor to fill. The administration being Democratic the appointee was expected to be of that political party. Petitions were forwarded by friends of various gentlemen regarded as qualified for the position, the most numerously signed and most influential being in favor of Hon. D. S. Gregory, who received the appointment from Governor Stoneman, and qualified for the office of Superior Judge of San Luis Obispo County February i6, 1883. The appointment was universally approved.

Judge Durrell S. Gregory was born in Mecklenburgh County, Virginia, in 1825, whence his family removed to Georgia, in 1830. At an early age he entered the office of Judge C. J. McDonald, at Monticello, under whom he read law assiduously for several years. Judge Mc- Donald was a conspicuous member of the Georgia Bar, and sat upon the Bench of the Supreme Court of the State. While yet a minor, young Gregory was admitted to practice in 1845, the Legislature having passed a special Act for that purpose. It was a fine compliment to the youthful lawyer.

Judge Gregory came to California in 1850, and settled in Santa Cruz County, where he practiced his profession with success and distinction until 1854, when he removed to Monterey County. His brilliant reputation followed him, and shortly after his appearance there. Judge Gregory was called to take a prominent part in the celebrated land case of Sanchez-Belcher, which attracted profound interest at the time on account of the bloody tragedies caused by the fierce litigation. He has also been the attorney in a number of the great land cases of the State, the reports of some of which make hrge printed volumes of many hundred pages each. As a counselor in questions of law, particularly where relating to land and the confused titles derived from the Spanish system, he is regarded as without a superior in the State, as in these measures he has been a close student and has had an extensive practice. Being conversant with the Spanish language he has been enabled to extend his researches in the archives and law books of the Mexican period, and to practice successfully with that people.

In 1857 he was elected to the State Senate from Monterey and Santa Cruz Counties, and served during the sessions of 1858-59. In the latter year he was elected District Attorney of Monterey County; and in i860 he was sent as a delegate to the memorable Charleston Convention. He came to San Luis Obispo in 1882, and entered into co-partnership with Hon. Frederick Adams, of which firm he was a member at the date of his appointment.

Hartnell, daughter of Prof William E. P. Hartnell, who was distinguished as a scholar and teacher in Monterey long anterior to the conquest of California, and who subsequently was translator of the laws and Spanish documents for the State. Mrs. Gregory is a highly accomplished and charming lady, to whom the Judge is devotedly attached. They have had three children, two of whom are living.

Judge Gregory is a favorite with the body of the people, who know him as a capable, honest, and mild-mannered gentleman. His great and varied legal experience, his disposition to weigh fairly and to deal justly, render him a fit arbiter of the conflicting interests and rights of his fellow-men. He occupies the Bench at the present time, acceptible to the Bar, and giving satisfaction to all classes of honest people.

The Constitution of the pioneers authorized the elec. tion of a County Judge, who should be Judge of the County Court, Court of Sessions and Probate Court. Under the first statutes passed by the Legislature, these courts were given extraordinary powers, combining legislative, judicial, and executive, rather conforming to the Mexican system, which reposed nearly all power in the Pre fecto, or in his absence the Sub-Prefecto, or Alcalde. In San Luis Obispo this system conformed well with the spirit of the people, and the Court of Sessions became the absolute power of the county. Don J. Mariano Bonilla, who had been Administrator of the mission, Sub-Prefecto and Alcalde, was elected the first County Judge, and was succeeded in office by John M. Price, elected in 1850, who had also been Alcalde. This gentleman presided over the court less than one year, when he was succeeded by

W. J. Graves

The history of Judge Graves in California would tike one back to the early pioneer days, and during all the intervening time he has occupied a prominent position as a member of the Bar. Under such circumstances one would now class him as the patriarch of the legal fraternity, but the still young appearing and stalwart frame crowned with the dark locks of the prime of manhood, appear to render inappropriate the venerable appellation to which he is entitled. In the biographies of members of the Constitutional Convention of 1878-79 is the following sketch: -

Hon. William J. Graves was born in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, in 1830. He was educated in the same county, and at an early age commenced the study of law in St Louis, Missouri. During the war between the United States and Mexico, he served as Lieutenant under General Sterling Price, and so added the title of Mexican Veteran to the others he now bears. From Mexico he came to California in the year 1849, first residing in San Francisco, then setting up his tabernacle in San Luis Obispo from 1852 to 1859, afterwards moving around somewhat and finally settling permanently in San Luis Obispo in 1865. The people of his district look on him with very favoring eyes. During the first period of his residence there he was elected to the Assembly of the State for 1855-57, and during this latter period has been sent to the Senate for the sessions embraced in the dates of 1873-77- He is a married man, his family consisting of his wife and seven children. Democratic in his political leanings, he was elected a member of the Constitutional Convention on the Non-Partisan ticket, as he is prepared to employ his patriotism and ability in the revision of the organic law of California, independent of any particular organization.

Was elected County Judge at the election of 1852, and took possession of the office in March, 1853. He had previously been County Surveyor, and filled other positions in public affairs. He held the position during the term of two years.

Romualdo Pacheco

Succeeded Brown in the office of County Judge, being elected in 1854. The name of Pacheco is one of the best known of the old families of California, conspicuous in the history of the country both before and after the annexation. Romualdo Pacheco was born in Santa Barbara in 1831. His father was Romualdo Pacheco, a Colonel in the Mexican Army, and stationed in California, and his mother, Dona Ramona Carrillo y Pacheco, afterwards Mrs. Wilson. Upon the arrival of Governor Victoria at San Diego, in 1830, coming to take charge of the Government of California, he was met by Colonel Pacheco and an escort, which accompanied him in a triumphal march through the country, occupying several months on the way to the capital, Monterey, California. Pacheco was the adherent of Victoria, and upon the insurrection of Avila and others at San Diego in 1831, marched south to suppress it. On the 5th of December the Governor's party met the insurrectionists at the Cahuenga Pass, near Los Angeles, and although an agreement had been made to settle the affair without bloodshed, Avila had resolved to kill the Governor on sight. Meeting him he rushed forward on horseback with his lance and attempted to thrust it into the Governor but it was parried by Pacheco, when Avila turned upon him and lanced him through the body. Governor Victoria, quickly recovering from his surprise, shot the assassin, and Pacheco and Avila fell dead to the ground together. Colonel Pacheco left a young and beautiful widow, and two sons, Mariano and Romualdo. A few years later the widow became the wife of Capt. John Wilson, formerly a sea captain, but then a merchant of Santa Barbara. Subsequently he obtained the grant of the Los Osos Rancho, in San Luis Obispo, and moved upon it, and there was the home of young Romualdo Pacheco. The many successes in political life of this gentleman are referred to in the chapters on the political history of the county. The venerable mother. Dona Ramona Wilson, also mentioned in connection with the Fremont invasion, still survives, residing with her son-in-law and daughter, Mr. and Mrs. F. Hilliard, in San Francisco.

Succeeded Pacheco as County Judge, being elected in 1857. This gentleman was a native Californian, well educated in his own language, but unable to speak English. The opposing candidate was ex-Judge J. M. Bonilla. Judge Munoz held the office until succeeded by Dr. Havens, who was elected in 1861. He was a candidate for Sheriff on the Republican ticket in 1865, but was defeated by De la Guerrra, the Republican vote being divided between Munoz and George Stone. He was again a candidate in 1867, with a similar result, and { again in 1869. Judge Munoz was drowned, with the wreck of a steamer on which he was traveling to San Francisco, leaving a widow, who still resides in San Luis Obispo, occupying one of the pleasantest homes of that pleasant city.

Joseph M. Havens

Reference is made to Dr. Joseph M. Havens in the sketch of the fraternal societies in this book. Dr. Havens was a pioneer of California of 1849, settling in the mines of Calaveras County. He located in San Luis Obispo late in the decade 1850, and in 1861 was elected County Judge. He was a well-educated and highly-respected gentleman, a physician by profession, and is remembered as the father of Masonry in San Luis Obispo.

William L. Beebee

No name is better known or more highly respected among the pioneers and the present people of San Luis Obispo than that of Judge Beebee. He is a native of New York, born in 1829. In 1847 he arrived in California in a United States storeship, making his home in San Luis Obispo, where he has resided, excepting at short intervals, to this day. In 1848 he followed the rush of gold seekers to the Sierra Nevada, but did not make a long stay in the placers. With the organization of the county in 1850, then scarcely of the legal age of manhood, he entered upon public life, and has ever since been foremost, though never obtrusive or seeking office, in public affairs. Justice of the Peace and Associate Judge from the earliest days, the honored title has grown to him as a Christian name. His residence in those years was on the beautiful rancho of 1,000 acres, about nine miles south of San Luis Obispo, formerly known by the name of its owner, but of late years as the Finney Dairy, Judge Beebee having sold it to the Steele Brothers in 1867. Judge Beebee has filled many official positions, being one of the first Supervisors, and in 1863 was elected County Judge to succeed Dr. Havens, and was again elected in 1867. The last election was contested by Charles Lindley, his competitor in the campaign, and after long, perplexing and expensive litigation, Beebee was confirmed in his seat. In 187 1 he was again the nominee of the Republicans for County Judge, but was defeated by McD. R. Venable. Since retiring from office he has been actively engaged in business, being of the great lumber-dealing firm of Schwartz & Beebee, and very successful in the enterprise. Few men have passed through the exciting scenes of Cahfornia pioneer life, occupying positions of high trust and responsibility, with a more unsullied record than Judge Beebee. Landing upon the coast in his youthful days, when society was disorganized and temptations great, he has maintained the even tenor of a gentleman, and, in the prime of his life, is one of the honored and wealthy citizens of the county he has so long made his home. He has been twice married, Mrs. Alide M. Beebee dying November 4, 1879, leaving a son bearing the name of his father. November 14, 1880, he was married at Calvary Church, San Francisco, by Rev. Dr. Hemphill, to Arietta S. Beswick, of San Francisco, and the family now occupy one of the pleasantest and most elegant homes of San Luis Obispo.

Mcd. R. Venable

The judicial election of 1871 was held on the i8th of October of that year, and the choice of the people for County Judge of San Luis Obispo fell upon McDowell R. Venable. This gentleman was born in Virginia in 1836. He served with distinction during the War of the Rebellion, being in the army of Gen. Kirby Smith in Texas at the close of the war, which there disbanded upon the collapse of the Confederacy. In 1869 he came to San Luis Obispo, soon taking a high position at the Bar, and was elected County Judge as above stated. In 1875 he was the only candidate for County Judge, and received nearly the entire vote of the county.* Judge Venable continued in office until the adoption of the New Constitution, by which the office was abolished. Since then he has enjoyed a lucrative practice in his profession, and with his interesting family resides upon his fine property in the suburbs of San Luis Obispo.

District Attorneys

The records of election make no mention of the office of District Attorney in 1850, but the Court of Sessions appointed O. M. Brown to serve as such officer. He was afterwards elected County Judge.

Parker H. French

Was appointed District Attorney in 1851. This redoubtable person is well remembered by the pioneers of California. He was a man of great energy and an adventurer of the first class. Why he became a resident of the quiet county of San Luis Obispo, in view of his character, it would be difficult to surmise. Coming to California in 1849, with a large party of adventurers from various parts of the East, via the route from Texas through Mexico, he was arrested in Durango for some of his bold and high-handed proceedings, and for this arrest he subsequently presented a claim of $300,000 against the Government of Mexico, which became an international question between the two Governments, but was finally rejected. After serving his term of District Attorney, French was elected in 1853 to represent San Luis Obispo in the Assembly, and bade good-bye to this county. In 1855 he was the editor of a Know Nothing paper in Sacramento, and in the same year joined the fillibustering expedition of William Walker to Nicaragua. There he became Minister of Finance to Walker's Republic of Nicaragua, and was sent as ambassador to the Republic of the United States. Notwithstanding his credentials from such high authority, he was not recognized as ambassador, nor as occupying any official position. He afterwards engaged in business in St. Louis, Missouri.

Hubbard C. M. Ely

Succeeded French as District Attorney, being elected to the office in 1853. Ely was followed in office by W. J. Graves, elected in 1855, and he, being elected to the Assembly the following year, was succeeded in office by James White, appointed by the Board of Supervisors. Walter Murray, was elected in 1859.

The name of P. A. Forrester often recurs throughout this book, showing him one of the active and prominent men in the business and public affairs of San Luis Obispo County. He was born in Pennsylvania some fifty years ago, coming, when a young man, to California and to this county, which has long been his home. Here he has occupied the positions of County Clerk, Superintendent of Schools, and District .\ttorney, being elected to the latter office in 1861, holding it until 1864. During the quicksilver mining period of 1861 and following, Mr. Forrester was one of the prominent mine owners, and realized quite a fortune in his enterprises. He has occupied many positions of trust, filling all with satisfaction to the public. In March, 1883, he was appointed by Governor Stoneman, State Commissioner of Immigration, which office he now holds, making him a temporary resident of San Francisco.

James White

Was elected to the office of District Attorney in 1863, and succeeded Mr. Forrester in the position. In an obituary in the Tribune is the following notice of this gentleman: -

James White, Esq., died of lung fever May 14, 1872, in San Luis Obispo, aged sixty years. The deceased came to this county from Alameda, in 1856. He was originally from the State of Indiana. Since 1856 he has practiced law in this place. In 1856 he was appointed by the Board of Supervisors to be District Attorney of this county. In 1863 he was elected to the same office by the people, and re-elected in 1865 without opposition. The deceased presented very peculiar traits of character. He was a bitter enemy, but would often sacrifice himself for his friends. He was fixed in his opinions, and pursued them regardless of cost. Although the community in general was opposed to him, he left not a few friends who were ready to support hiin at all hazards. At his death may all enmities be forgotten, and the universal verdict be Requiescat in pace.

Walter Murray was again elected to the office of District Attorney in 1867, and was succeeded by Newton Dennis Witt, who was elected in September, 1870. He was born in the State of New York, in November, 1823, where he lived until he was eleven years old, when his parents removed to the State of Ohio. He served in the United States Army during the Mexican ^^"ar, at the close of which he came to this State, from Illinois in 1850. He was engaged in mining until about the year 1856, at which time he became connected with a newspaper called the BtUte Record, in the county of that name. In i860 he removed to Mendocino County, where he held the position of Deputy Sheriff, under Hon. L. M. Warden, who was Sheriff of that county, until 1868. He came to San Luis Obispo County with Mr. Warden, and in 1869 was elected District Attorney, which office he filled with credit to the end of the term, after which he practiced law in the courts of the county and district. He was appointed Police Judge to serve out an unexpired term, at the close of which he was elected to that office by the citizens of San Luis Obispo, at the municipal election. The duties of the offices held by Mr. N. D. Witt, in San Luis Obispo County and Cit}', were performed in an honest and able manner; and though his political opinions were strong and somewhat extreme, they were never allowed to influence his actions in public life.

Mr. Witt died in San Luis Obispo on the 21st of April, 1878, in the fifty-fifth year of his age. He was a member of St. Davids Lodge, No. 209, F. and A. M., under whose auspices he was buried, in the Odd Fellows Cemetry, with appropriate ceremonies. The Tribune records that the procession that followed his remains to the grave was one of the largest that eyer turned out in the city of San Luis Obispo.

Was the next to fill the office of District Attorney of San Luis Obispo County, being elected in September, 187 1, defeating Walter Murray, the Republican candidate for the position. Mr. Oglesby, during at least a portion of the time of his incumbency, was also editor of the Dtinocratic Standard, and Mr. Murray of the Tribune, and a sharp political controversy was maintained between the rival papers. He was re-elected in 1875. Mr. Oglesby was a young man of bright talents, and has left the reputation of being an eloquent speaker. He is no longer a resident of the county.

Ernest Graves

As Superior Judge of the county a sketch has been given of Louis McMurtry, who was elected District Attorney in 1877, as the successor of Mr. Oglesby. By the election of 1879, Ernest Graves was elevated to the office of District Attorney, being nominated by the Workingmen and the New Constitution Parties, and defeating at the election W. B. Dillard, who had been nominated by the Republican and Democratic Parties. Mr. Graves is the son of the distinguished lawyer and pioneer, Hon. W. J. Graves, his mother being the daughter of Don Jose de Jesus Pico, one of the oldest and most prominent families of the native Californians. He was born in San Luis Obispo County, which has always been his home, and which delights to honor her native sons. Mr. Graves was re-elected to the office in 1882, and is the incumbent at the present time.

Since the organization of the county the Bar of San Luis Obispo has numbered among its members several able and eloquent lawyers, and in its present representation stands the equal of any in the State. In the early years there were few lawyers, the veteran Graves standing alone as the representative of the past. In the sketches of the officers of the courts nearly all the pioneer lawyers have been mentioned.

Hon. Frederick Adams has not held office in San Luis Obispo, but stands one of the leading members of the Bar and of the most prominent citizens of the county. He is a native of Pennsylvania, having been born in the old "Keystone State," in 1832. His father was of Scotch descent, and a distinguished surgeon in the United States Army. Having accompanied exploring expeditions in the Northwest and on the great plains during the early years of his life, he resigned from the army and settled in St. Louis, Missouri, where the childhood of Frederick Adams was passed. The father desired that the son should follow him in the profession of physician and surgeon, and the boy received instruction tending to that end, but the father dying while the son was young, was not able to carry out the design. The education received, however, proved of great service to him in many instances in after life.

In 1849, Adams joined the topographical engineers to locate the boundary line between Mexico and California, and crossed the plains to this State in that year, arriving on the Colorado River, at the mouth of the Gila, the last of December of that year. The broad and turbid river rolled between him and the land of promise, and the delay in crossing was fatal to his aspirations of being ranked among the pioneers of '49! But from early in January, 1850, Adams has been a pioneer of California, of Oregon, and of Idaho. Coming to California as a youth just entering manhood, with a constitution of iron and Herculean strength, with a courage that knew no fear and an energy that knew no obstacles, he was just the one to go forth in the development of the new State, and to penetrate all its wildness. The mines of course received his first attention. In the wars in the North, with the Pit River, Trinity, and Rogue River Indians, he took an active part, being Captain of a company of volunteers, and has partaken in many most desperate engagements. For a number of years he resided in Oregon, was there a member of the Legislature, and was appointed by President Lincoln Judge of the Territorial Court of Idaho. From this he is given the title of Judge, by which he is usually addressed. After leaving Idaho, Judge Adams resided at Yreka, practicing law and editing a newspaper, always taking a prominent part in politics, and making it fully understood that he is a Republican with pronounced ideas of American progress, but generous to all. We next learn of his residence at Santa Cruz, where he took a prominent position at the Bar of that county. While a resident of Santa Cruz he formed the project of the Temperance Colony at Lompoc, in Santa Barbara County, and with other capitalists purchased the Lompoc Rancho, and successfully carried the project into execution. While engaged in this his business brought him often to San Luis Obispo, and, in i88o, he made that city his home, where he has since resided with his family, building, early in 1883, one of the prettiest residences in the city, located upon a spacious lot on Chorro Street, between Marsh and Pismo. As previously stated, Judge Adams is a Republican, always taking a prominent part in all political questions, and being an eloquent and powerful speaker, exerts a leading influence in his party and in all public matters.

Robert C. Bouldin

Among the prominent lawyers who have practiced at the Bar of this county was Judge Robert C. Bouldin, who came to San Luis Obispo in 1874, and died here of heart disease December 16, 1879, at the age of fortyseven years. Judge Bouldin was born at Lawyers Rest, Charlotte County, Virginia, in August, 1832. He was from one of the prominent families of that State, his father being an eminent lawyer, and, at the time of his death, a Member of Congress, dying of heart disease upon the floor of the House of Representatives while engaged in an important debate. A brother, Judge Wood Bouldin, of the Supreme Court of Virginia, also died of the same disease. Robert C. Bouldin was educated at the University of Virginia, thereafter married and entered into the practice of the law. At the outbreak of the Rebellion he joined an independent cavalry company and entered the service of his native State, continuing in the army until the surrender of Lee and the close of the war, although, at last, disabled from active duties by the inroads of the fatal disease he inherited. After retiring from the army, he was, in 1865, elected Judge of the County Court of his native county, and continued in the office until he resigned in 1874, to make California his home, seeking the genial climate of San Luis Obispo for his health. He was regarded as having no equal at the Bar in questions of common law and equity, and his early death was regarded as a serious loss.

A meeting of the Bar of San Luis Obispo County was held on the 19th of December, 1879, to adopt resolutions expressive of the feelings of the members upon his demise. Judge McMurtry presided, and P. A. Forrester was chosen Secretary. After eulogistic remarks by several members, R. M. Preston offered the following resolutions which were unanimously adopted : -

Resolved, That the members of the Bar of San Luis Obispo County have received with profound sorrow the announcement of the death of Judge Robert C. Bouldin, late a member of the Bar of this county; also

Resolved, That in his decease his family have lost a kind husband and father, the Bar an honorable and learned Attorney, and the community a good citizen; further

Resolved, That as a mark of respect to the memory of deceased these resolutions be spread upon the journals of the several courts of record in this county; that a copy be transmitted to the family of the deceased, and copies be furnished the Southern California Advocate and San Luis Obispo Tribune, for publication. On motion of F. K. Miller, Esq., the Secretary was directed to forward a copy of the resolutions to Judge Fawcett, with request of the Bar that the same be entered upon the record of the District Court.

Was a practitioner at the Bar of San Luis Obispo after 1876. He had previously, for a number of years, been a resident of Morro, and in that year was elected to the Assembly, serving one term, and making an honorable record. Returning from his duties at the capital, he made his home in the city of San Luis Obispo, and commenced the practice of the law. This he continued until 1881, when declining health compelled him to relinquish business, and he moved to Santa Rosa, Sonoma County, where he died March 22, 1882, in the fortieth year of his age.

Members Of The B.4R

There are many members of the Bar of San Luis Obispo, now and heretofore practicing their learned profession, whom it would be proper to mention in detail, but whose history is unavailable at present. Among them are the names of W. H. Spencer, J. M. Wilcoxon, Jasper N. Turner, C. H. Clement, J. R. Patton, and R. B. Treat, who, with those previously mentioned, present an array of talent equal to any in the State, and invite the litigious to those expensive conflicts so profitable to the few and ruinous to many.

Provenance

Text from History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.