San Luis Obispo County, California - Chapter 33: Vigilance Committee Continued, 1883
From History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883. 3,463 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
10 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
3,463 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 33: Vigilance Committee Continued
Anti-Vigilance Newspapers - Review of the Evidence - A Veteran Bandit - The Case of Pio Linares - Defense of the Committee - Desperate Acts of Linares - The Necessity of a Vigilance Committee - The Criminal Element - The Vigilance Pledge - Roll of Members - Vigilance Subscriptions - The Evidence - Murder of the Basque Frenchmen.
l,T the period when the events related in the preceding chapter transpired, there was a paper published in Spanish in Los Angeles, called El Clamor Publico, the organ of the native Californians and Mexicans, which animadverted severely upon the acts of the Vigilance Committee of San Luis Obispo, charging it with hasty action and executing men without evidence. The Spanish paper was supported in its attacks by the
San Francisco Herald, which was at all times exceedingly bitter against any acts or organization styled Vigilance Committee. El Clatnor Fublico was read by the native population of San Luis Obispo, stimulating the people to hatred of Americans, and threatening dangerous consequences. This necessitated a reply from Hon. Walter Murray, who prepared and published a review of the evidence upon which the criminals were convicted and executed. From this review we glean the following: -
The editor of El Clamor Publico says that Peralta, or, as he calls him, Robles, was suspected, etc. Peralta was recognized on the instant by one of the Californians whose lives had been spared by the iniscreants, as being one of them. This was on the 13th day of May, the day after the murder. He was asked to give an account of himself. He declared that for four nights previous he had slept in the house of a relative named Dolores Cordova. Cordova was sent for and interrogated. He declared that he had not seen the culprit for four days. All this, although done before a Justice of the Peace, was extra-judicial, for our laws do not permit such interrogating. Finally, a pair of handkerchiefs and other articles were taken from him and recognized as part of the property stolen. This much-wronged innocent died mute - not denying his guilt - but refused to disclose his accomplices. He felt himself supported by the law. His accomplices - when, at the cost of fatigue and money, and American blood, freely poured out by brave men, they were dragged from their retreat in the dark recesses of an almost inaccessible wood - when they stood face to face with men who knew the main facts, and who, strong in the rectitude of untroubled consciences, dared to deal out quick justice in the name of self-preservation - when all the paraphernalia of paid lawyers and perjured jurymen was thrown on one side - when Vigilance had hunted them down like wild beasts to their lair, and had demonstrated to them that neither subterfuge, nor fleet horses, nor the law's delay, nor cocked pistols, nor sympathizing countrymen, could longer avail them - then these accomplices voluntarily declared the truth, and disclosed that this very Santos Peralta was the man who shot down poor, wounded Baratie, in cold blood, before his wife's eyes, having purposely led her down to witness the atrocity. Then one of them, Miguel Blanco, confessed freely, what we knew before, that he (Miguel) was the man who killed Borel, and who gave Baratie his first shot. Then Grijalva disclosed how that he himself had shot poor Gilkey from behind, and stretched him lifeless upon the ground he had been tilling, and that Jesus Valenzuela had aftewards dragged him fifty yards at the end of his riata.
Could law have extracted all this from these men? No. But Vigilance did, and that without torture of any description. No impeUing power was used but the exhibition of an unswerving determination and resistless power. The above facts show the nature of the suspicions against Santos Peralta.
Now we come to the innocent Joaquin Valenzuela. This man has never been charged with either the Nacimiento or the San Juan Capistrano murders. But he was an acquaintance and comrade of the murderers - brother to one, chum to another, and was proven before the committee to be as full of crime as an egg is full of meat. In 1853 he was a partner of Joaquin Murietta - the veritable Joaquin. It is notorious that he was one of the five Joaquins upon whose heads Governor Bigler
Just before that time he kidnapped an American child, Anne, daughter of an American named Smith, and brought her down to the San Joaquin River, where he and his Mexican female partner brought her up to learn Spanish and hate the Gringos. The Americans living there took the child away, and advertised for her relatives. The father made his appearance and claimed his child. He accompanied this Joaquin across the ferry on the San Joaquin, at the mouth of the River Merced. Joaquin returned; Smith never. The inference is that Smith was killed by the black villain. A skeleton supposed to be his was afterwards found a league or two from the ferry. I refer for these facts to D. P. Brown, of Stockton; to the mother of the child who lives there now, and to those who lived at and near the mouth of the River Merced, in the years 1853-54.
When the Harry Love's Ranger Law was passed, this Joaquin Valenzuela, alias Ocomorenia, came down to the Tulares and to Santa Barbara County. Here he made acquaintance with Jack Powers. In his company Powers inured himself to fatigue on horseback " in the pursuit of stolen or strayed cattle," as the great Jack's eulogist has it, but which rightly interpreted means, "in stealing his neighbor's cattle." There is evidence before the committee here, which will one day be printed, showing that Powers and Joaquin Valenzuela stole cattle together from Guadalupe, Santa Maria, and Nipomo, and drove them to the mines by way of the Tulares. He has been engaged in this nefarious pursuit off and on ever since he came to this section of the country. He was captain of a band of robbers near Purissima, in Santa Barbara County, nearly two years ago, and committed several robberies there. He is a miscreant of the deepest dye, a hardened sinner, the very type of a criminal. When he was being brought in, he told Captain Mallagh that he thought he ought not to be molested, as he had condescended to be honest for a year past. Creo que Vindes no deben de molestarme ahora, siendo que be condescendido por una ano.
This man was invited by Jack Powers at Santa Margarita, on the night of the horse-race there, on November 30th last, to take part in the murder at the Nacimiento. He replied, "I have formerly been in such things, as you know, but I have given it up." He declined going. When arrested, and asked if he knew Powers, he said yes, he was his patron. He seemed to think that the magic name of Powers would be a tower of strength to him. When brought afterwards before the committee, and when he found out that Powers was compromised, he denied any acquaintance with him. Afterwards acknowledged that Powers had invited him to accompany him above on a "business speculation."
This is the " innocent" man who has been torn from the bosom of his family by a mob and " done to death." Mr. David W. Alexander, of Los Angeles, says that this man " has never been absent a moment from his home." This gentleman forgot, perhaps, to tell the editor of the Clamor Publico, that in November last he loaned this man $100 to bring his wife, from Los Angeles; that he (Alexander) was informed at the time of the arrest, that at that very time when he was supposed to be in Los Angeles, he was here in San Luis in company with Jack Powers and other worthies, at the races in and near this place; that he stayed here several weeks, and that during that time instead of living with his wife, whoever the lady may be, he kept with an abandoned Mexican prostitute, for whose sake two men have been stabbed, and two shot within the last six months. For aught Mr. Alexander knows, this man was at the Nacimiento murder on December last. However, he is not charged with it. Now, as this gentleman has forgotten the above particulars, he has forgotten, doubtless, that this Joaquin is a notorious thief How is it then that Alexander Godoy, of Cuyama, Mr. Alexander's next neighbor, and one of Mr. Fremont's veterans, is thoroughly acquainted with the man's character? How is it that this man's character is notorious to every one except Mr. Alexander? Is not this gentleman, like hundreds of other rancheros in the southern country (not Americans, however) content to hire a vaquero without asking questions as to his character, or even if he knew him to be bad, content if he thinks the man will not rob or murder him? I think this is the gist of the matter.
The Case Of Pio Linares
Now let us return to the tissue of falsity in regard to the first attempt to take Pio Linares. In the first place, the "committee " did not do this. The committee was not then in existence. Secondly, the Sheriff's posse was composed of fifteen men, not forty men. Thirdly, Linares showed fight from the first to the last. The Sheriff had a warrant for the Huero Rafael, a man who had lived in Linares' house. He asked Linares to come out with a light. The intention was doubtless to arrest him, not to kill him, for no man has yet been killed here without a full trial, even by this bug-bear "committee;" no, not even when our men lay blood-stained around us on the cold sod. Then, in the height of the excitement, two of the head villains were spared, brought into town, and confronted by the priest. Well, Linares' reply made to his wife, his brother, and another man - all of whom were allowed freely to pass and repass by the Sheriff and his posse - made to their urgent solicitations that he should surrender, was simply this : ^^No! yo no
This man, Linares, knew his weight of guilt. He was confident that he deserved instant death. He feared it. When he came out he came armed and running like a hound. He was fired upon as a criminal fleeing from justice, and two lives would have been saved since, had he fallen then. The roof only was burned. That was fired after timely warning, in order to get him out and to avoid such a catastrophe as happened in Monterey in 1856, when poor De la Torre and others were killed in the fruitless attempt to take Anastasio Garcia. His wife and children made no miraculous escape. His wife was repeatedly begged to come out, but stayed in only to cover his flight, and then came out at her leisure. The very posse assisted her to save her clothes and furniture. Furthermore, his wife, who has been his accomplice from the first, and has always shared in his plunder, and is a woman of notorious bad character, would, in any other county in the State, now be adorning the inside of a jail, instead of running at large as she now does here. As for the children, they are a mere myth. They do not exist. Neither Linares nor his wife ever had any. Truly one can quote here the very expressive words of the Clamor, "They lie."
Defense Of The Committee
Now as to the whisky. These men who accompanied the Sheriff had been out for more than a week on the Tulares. They had returned home on an unfrequented road on purpose to avoid observation. They had not even seen liquor for three days. Every man of them is a better citizen than the Clamor editor ever can be until he plucks out that Mexican heart of his and substitutes an American one in its place. One of the men, a New Mexican, named Julian Garcia, a brave fellow, followed Linares in the darkness and fired his pistol at him as he ran. Returning, he was seen by some of the party who had been behind the house and had not seen him before. They took him for Linares. It was a mistake. He was tenderly cared for, got medical attendance, and over $ioo for his loss of time. No one is more ready than he to pursue cut-throats and to shoot them down. Such men as he put to shame all such men as the Clamoi editor. The Clamor thinks that San Luis authorities are sufficiently strong to protect the laws if they desire to do so. Now, we do not want his opinion, nor mine, nor yours, sir, on this subject. We will just state the facts: This Linares, after committing the Nacimiento murders, almost openly bragged about them. In a month's time the whole of the details were openly talked about by his own countrymen, and all acknowledged him to be one of the parties.
Desperate Acts Of Linares
Before this, he ran one of our Justices of the Peace all over the town, on account of some trifling misunderstanding. Shortly afterwards, he drew his knife and attempted to stab a very peaceable Mexican for interfering to stop a quarrel. On the night that Nieves Robles, his spy, was arrested, he stabbed two Sonorians in a dance-house, one of whom narrowly escaped with his life. After this, this man and his loose wife were invited to a ball given by the J. P., above mentioned, at the opening of a new hotel. They attended, and some of the first folks, and most, if not all the Americans of this place attended, too. At this ball, this Linares laid in wait for D. D. Blackburn, late of Santa Cruz. That night, he and a party of young Californians, armed, came down to Mr. Murray's house with the intention of firing through the windows at the unsuspecting Americans assembled there. After the matter was adjusted, Linares said to his fellows, "Well, if you come here to fight, why don't you go in? We are stronger than they!"
Miguel Blanco, before dying, was questioned as to whether Linares ever mentioned this last affair to him. Blanco is Linares' nephew. Blanco detailed a conversation which took place between them during their hiding. Linares said that under certain circumstances he could get a portion of the Californians to sustain him. Blanco said, "How can you expect our countrymen to sustain us, who are so criminal?" "They can be brought to do it," said Linares, "they backed me then," referring to the night of the ball. "To this end I have always taken up for them in any petty quarrel. Don't you know that I have always been at the head of all the revolutions in San Luis Obispo?"
This man, Pio Linares, has never been prosecuted for any of the crimes above detailed. He has sat on juries since all of them. The above dying declaration of his accomplice, Blanco, gives the key to it. He was a reckless man, ready for murder in open daylight - murder from behind a bush - in fact, murder in any shape. Every one knew it.
The Necessity Of A Vigilance Committee
The acquittal of Nieves Robles was before every one's eyes. The Californians were disposed to resist or resent any violent means, and to defeat any legal ones. The mover in any abortive attempt against this criminal was liable to be assassinated at any moment. Good men waited for a bond of unity. The natural bond of selfpreservation at length presented itself, and they caught at it, and have, with God's help, succeeded now in righting matters; in creating a healthy spirit in the community, and in preparing the way for another trial of the law. Here, as in San Francisco, I am confident that the law will hereafter work all the better for the quickening spirit infused into it by vigilance.
The Criminal Element
The law-abiding citizens of San Luis Obispo occupied a very delicate position in the period preceding 1858. From Monterey to Los Angeles was the lonely coast road, with occasional ranchos and the villages of San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara widely separated, with many mountains in which were dark canons, pretty valleys, and park-like potreros offering concealment and seclusion, and to this region gathered the worst bandits of California. If not numerous, they were by their boldness and desperation enabled to overawe the majority and maintain a reign of terror. A few Americans like Jack Powers and the infamous ex-Judge McGowan, commonly known as Ned McGowan, of San Francisco, who had fled from the Vigilance Committee of that city, had exerted a baneful influence over the native population, and had been harbored and protected by some of the most respectable people, through fear and in the hope that such a course would protect them from depredation. They thus, in a measure, dominated in politics, ruled the courts, and rendered trials abortive. This made it necessary to organize an extra-judicial power, and the Vigilance Committee of 1858 was the result. It was a bold and honorable movement, and the names of those who participated in it are worthy of the perpetuity of history. Following is the Vigilance Pledge, with the signatures attached, the Vigilance " Roll" and the amounts contributed for the public safety : -
The Vigilance Pledge
The undersigned hereby pledge ourselves, each to the other, that in the case of the murder of the two Frenchmen, Bartolo Baratie and M. Jos6 Borel, we will stand together and will by all means whatsoever, discover the truth and punish the guilty. The first step shall be the application of personal restraint and intimidation to the prisoner now in jail, even if necessary to the danger of life. Walter Murray, A. Albarelli,
Roll Of Members
The undersigned, citizens of San Luis Obispo, sign our names as members of a body to be called the San Luis Obispo Vigilance Committee, the object of which is and shall be the repression and punishment of crimes by all means whatsoever.
The Evidence
The convictions and executions by the Vigilance Committee were after conclusive evidence had been taken, and supplemented by evidence taken at a later date. The records of the evidence and confessions have been preserved, and are such as show the most depraved and heartless characters, long series of crimes and contempt of law, and leave no doubt of guilt that could be expiated only by death and eternal punishment.
Murder Of The Basque Frenchman
Testimony in this case was taken by Jose Maria Munoz, County Judge; W. J. Graves, Notary Public, and J. J. Simmler and James White, Justices of the Peace.
Francois Abadie testified that he was in the employment of Pedro Obiesa and M. Graciano, two men natives of the Basque Provinces of southern France, and known as the Basque Frenchmen, and was driving catde for them in November, 1857. He related the circumstance of their receiving some cattle in a suspicious manner near Paso de Robles, and afterwards the disappearance of the two Basques. These men he had never seen again alive, but at the time of his deposition, in December, 1857, recognized the remains of Graciano, one of them, having a bullet hole in the head. After this Nieves Robles was arrested, and recognized by Abadie as one of the men who had sold the cattle.
Juan Herrada testified, confirming the previous witness, and told of Jack Powers, Pio, Linares, the Huero Rafael, Nieves Robles, Jose Antonio Garcia, and Eduviquez following the Basques.
Nieves Robles confessed his crimes, and stated the agreement with Powers and the others to murder the Basque Frenchmen, and detailed the manner of the murder as told him by Linares, who, with the Huero Rafael, had committed the deed. This confession was made and sworn to before W. J. Graves, Notary Public, June 28, 1858.
Jose Antonio Garcia confessed to participating in the spoils of the murder, but was horrified upon being shown the dead bodies, and fled to his home in Santa Barbara.
Robles had been tried for this murder and acquitted by a jury in the court of San Luis Obispo. One of the jury was one of the murderers, and another was a fugitive under the charge of murder. Mr. Murray, in his account of the Vigilance Committee, has related the main facts of the murders on the San Juan, in the eastern part of the county, extended particulars of which are given in the depositions and confessions taken at the trials, confirming all his statements, and justifying all the acts of the Vigilance Committee.
Provenance
Text from History of San Luis Obispo County, California; with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.