BlockBefore

San Luis Obispo County, California - Chapter 7, 1917

From History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917. 5,098 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

The text

5,098 words

Machine-read from scans of History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

The discovery of gold had apparent!)' no influence upon the history of this county. The gold frenzy was confined to the northern part of the state. From San Jose to Los Angeles the cattle business was the principal industry. Only two settlements large enough to be called villages even, existed in 1850, San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara. Travel from one place to the other had to be by schooner or sailing vessel, and few stopped at our ports ; for there were no wharves, only "landings," and rarely a passenger; so on horseback down the Salinas valley, over the Santa Lucia mountains, through Cuesta pass to the first little town, and on by the coast trail to Santa Barbara and Los Angeles. Travel by land was very dangerous, for the whole region, especially south of Soledad, was infested by bands of desperadoes. Robberies and murders were of great frequency. The native Californians, with their hatred for the "Gringos" and fear of meeting a like fate at the same hands, would give no evidence against the villains, but harbored them, either through fear or for a share of the plunder.

In 1852-53, the state was terrorized by a band of desperadoes that ranged the country under the leadership of Joaquin Murrieta. Another leader. Jack Powers, with his gang infested this and Santa Barbara counties, making excursions into other territory as well. In 1853, the legislature ordered the enlisting of a company of rangers to hunt Murrieta and the others.

The company was known as Harry Love's Rangers, Love being the captain. Murrieta on more than one occasion was in San Luis Obispo living with his pals. At the end of Chorro street over near the mountains are two little adobe houses ; Murrieta is said to have lived in one, and another scoundrel, Vasquez, in the other. In the spring of 1853 Murrieta and his gang came to town, first sending word that they were coming for a rest, before going on to Mexico; and if any one attempted to meddle with them, the town would be sacked. They arrived, a desperate, swarthy set, "armed to the teeth," and camped in the garden of the Mission. There. were only five or six Americans in town ; and knowing his hatred of them, they kept out of sight day times, and at night camped with their arms in Pollard's store. The building was an old adobe on the corner of Chorro and Monterey streets, where Fletcher's store now stands. Murrieta left town without making any "killings," only robbing a gambler of his ill-gotten gains.

Jack Powers was a criminal and gambler in San Francisco in 1849. Fleeing from justice there, he organized a band of cutthroats and transferred his operations to this section. He would send out spies to find out when men would lie coming south to buy up cattle. Often these fellows represented themselves as owning large herds seeking buyers. The buyers would set a time to come ; and few, if any, got south of the Nacimiento river, which became known as the "dark and bloody ground." Their disappearances remained mysteries so far as the courts were concerned, for reasons already given. Their bodies with bullet holes or gaping knife thrusts were often found beside the road ; or later in some ravine not far distant a bleached skeleton, with jierhaps enough clothing left for identification, would be found.

In November, 1857, two Frenchmen, Pedro Obiesa and Graciano, collected a band of cattle and started north, hiring a Mexican, Prolian, as vaquero. This man and Jack Powers saw the Frenchmen receive money before leaving San Luis Obispo. The following Monday, November 30, a horse race took place at Santa Margarita; Powers, Lenares and a band of "greasers" were present, and that night disappeared. At Paso Robles the Frenchmen received cattle and paid for them. Here Frolian left the cattle buyers, but a man named Nieves Robles appeared and asked to join the Frenchmen and travel with them to San Jose. That night their horses were stampeded. In the morning the two Frenchmen left camp, going in opposite directions to look for their horses. Neither ever returned. Robles made excuses twice during the day to the others at camp and went off, each time returning with his horse in a lather. The next inorning he left, saying he was going back to San Luis. A few days later Lenares, flush with money, was back in tow^n. At last, on December 20, Robles was taken from a gambling den on suspicion of the murder and jailed; Lenares at once went north and warned Powers, who came down on the next steamer and furnished Robles with cofifee, liquor and other comforts, at the same time urging Robles' attorney to get him released in some way. The night before the murder, Juan Pedro Olivera, a man of evil deeds, told another rascal what was to take place, mentioning every one in the plot. An Indian told of seeing one of the men murdered, the one found, by two men on horseback with reatas and pistols. One was never found. Robles was tried. He was a Californian, the murdered men only Frenchmen, and the Californians swore to kill every Frenchman in the county if Robles were convicted. W. J. Graves, the best lawyer in the county, was district attorney, but what could he do with a "packed" jury? One juryman was a fugitive from a murder committed; another, it was later learned, participated in the murder of the cattle buyers.

The cattle buyers were murdered in the early part of December. In May two more Frenchmen, Bartolo Baratie and M. J. Borel, came down from Oakland to settle on the San Juan ranch, which was forty-five miles from San Luis Obispo, fifteen miles from the Mallah ranch, and six miles from the Comatti. They had two Californians for servants, Ysidero Silvas and Luis Murillo. On May 10, eight men appeared saying they were horse runners and wanted to buy food. The food was freely given to them. That night they slept in a hut apart from the rest, leaving on the morning of the eleventh. On the twelfth, Miguel Blanco, one of the party, returned saying he was not going to run his horse, and asked if he might unsaddle it there and rest. His request was granted. The Frenchmen were some distance from the house cleaning out a spring. The Californians were a short distance away cutting hay, but out of sight of the Frenchmen. Miguel Blanco stood on a little knoll that commanded a view of both parties. Suddenly he started towards the two Frenchmen. Baratie left his partner and started to go to the servants. Just as he reached them shots were heard from where Blanco and Borel were. The rest of the desperadoes rode up on horseback; and as Baratie appeared, Blanco shot him, wounding him in the shoulder. A bullet passed so close to the servant .Murillo that it singed his hair. Murillo, .Silvas and Baratie were then bound and driven to the house, where ]\Iadani Baratie was threatened, with death. The bandits then forced Baratie to show them the trunk the money was in. The captain of the band, Huer Rafael, poured the money, $2,700, onto a blanket, dividing it into eight piles, which were passed out to the eight murderers, for so they all were. Baratie and his wife begged for mercy and it was promised. Two of the villains, Luciano and Frolian, one of the gang that committed the double murder the December before, but still at large, were told to take Murillo and Silvas off and shoot them. They took them, still bound, some distance, but finally promised not to kill them if they stayed where they were told until dark. The thieves then returned to the rest of the gang. Meantime Baratie and his wife had been taken to a patch of willows. Here Baratie was shot before his wife's eyes. The poor woman covered her husband's body with his cloak and hat, and so he was found.

Luciano returned after taking the servants away and was told off to take Airs. Baratie to his resort, the "Ctievas." He compelled her to mount a horse and started oft', promising her safet}'. For a week he took her by trails known only to the thieves, and at last arrived at a ranch, the "Pulvaderas," kept by a harborer of thieves. They stayed there one night, but the terrified woman dared not speak. At last he took her to San Juan, the old settlement near Hollister. She knew he was among accomplices and she held her peace. The house where Luciano left her was about a half mile out from the town and was kept by a fellow named Chavez. From there she took the stage and went to Oakland, let us hope to safety and friends.

About five o'clock Murillo and Silvas went back to the house ; Borel lay dead with three shots in his body. They did not find Baratie in the willows. Everything had been rifled and the best clothing was gone. The horses were unmolested save a black horse, and a mare the woman rode. Murillo and Silvas went that night to the Estrella. On the morning of May 13 they went to Captain J\Iallah's ranch, now known as the Huer-Huero, and told their story, ^klallah at once saddled up and came with them to San Luis, where warrants were issued for the murderers as John Doe and Richard Roe. Mallah, Alurillo, Silvas and the sheriff walked about the town to see if they could locate any of the murderers. They stumbled on one, Santos Peralta, who was recognized as one of Chico Martinez's band of horse runners. Of course he denied his guilt, but part of the stolen clothing was found on him. He was arrested and jailed, and that night a party of citizens saved the county expense by taking him out and hanging him.

In the morning word was brought to the town that four of the gang were hid in a ravine back of town, where Pio Lenares had a "ranchito" for stolen horses. The sheriff with fifteen men set out to capture them. It was later proven that Lenares went with the gang to murder the two Frenchmen, as far as the San Juan ranch, but left there because the rest would not consent to the murder of the woman. Lenares' motto was "Dead men tell no talcs." This was also the saying of Jack Powers. For a week the sheriff" and his men hunted the bandits, who on fine horses easily eluded them in the hills. At a ranch, however, they took Joaquin Valenzuela, identified by several as one of the five Love's Rangers were to capture. He was one of Jack Powers' pals, whom he called his "patron." He was hanged in dajdight in full sight of the po]nilace, who turjied out to a hanging as to a new kind of "fiesta."

Before dying he confessed his guilt. Aimthcr party followed on the tracks of Mrs. Baratie and captured Luciano on liis return from San Juan. He was brought to town, confessed and was hanged in broad daylight - "fiesta" number two. Mrs. Baratie was brought down from Oakland by Americans and corroborated the testimony of the others in the case.

One June 6, 1858, Jose Antonio Garcia was arrested and confessed to being one of the gang who murdered the two Frenchmen the previous December. In his confession he told of the part Pio Lenares, Jack Powers and Huer Rafael Ilerrado took, and told of receiving two hundred dollars Powers sent him as his share of the booty. Garcia was hanged at 3 P. M., June 8, another "fiesta"; but now things were getting serious, for justice was being dealt out by the Vigilantes - but that story must be told more fully. On the same night ten men, with twenty horses furnished by the ranchers, set out after the remaining members of the gang. On June 9 another party went to Lenares' "ranchito," and driving in his horses as a preventive measure, started off for Santa Ynez and La Purisima, where the rest were said to be. Pio and his friends were right at hand, however, and saw the party starting, but thought it was two parties. This spelled business; so in the night Lenares and his men left for the immense willow thickets that grew on the Los Osos, then owned by Captain John Wilson. On Thursday morning, June 10, Captain Wilson sent word that one of the gang, Pluero Rafael, had given one of his shepherds twenty-two dollars and asked him to get them food. The shepherd gave Wilson the money and information. In about two hours thirty men were in the saddle and off. The men pushed their horses into the willows, but so dense was the growth little could be done. At 3 P. M. fifteen men on foot entered the thicket beating the brush for their men. At length three horses, two saddles and a little bag of provisions were found. Night was near and it was thought best to get out of the woods. Guards were placed, but wide apart, as there were not enough men to circle the place at nearer distances. One guard was shot through the instep. About 10 A. M. the guard was called oft', and it was decided to let the bandits get out of the woods and then set the "trackers" on their trail. However, twenty men insisted on taking up the trail in the willows. Soon they found Lenares' saddle bags, and robber and murderer though he was, he carried with him a picture of his wife, which was in one of the bags. In a moment bullets flew, one wounding Lenares through the leg. The pursuers then left the woods and the brush was set on fire; but it was so green it would not burn. Couriers were sent all ovc-r the county, and soon one hundred fifty men were on the ground. ,\ close line of guards were set about the willows, through which, all night long, the bandits could be heard breaking their way. In the morning a party of twenty-four men under Captain Mallah crawled on their bellies into the thicket, for shots from the hunted men showed their location. In about fifteen minutes Pio Lenares was shot through the head and Miguel Blanco and Desidero Grijalva taken prisoners. John Matlock, a well-borer from San Jose, was killed and two men wounded, of the pursuing party. The prisoners stated that they had been without food for four days, but Lenares refused to let them surrender. The dead and i)oth sides were brought to town and buried. Alonday, June 14, Blanco and Grijalva were hanged at 1 P. M., all hands looking on ; but now the "fiestas" were not very gay aft'airs. Human life is not a tiling to sec pass without a tremor, and the Californians of the desperado class knew they were all in close quarters. Some of the better class of Californians assisted the Americans in raiding the bands from the county, notal:)ly Romualdo Pacheco.

In 18-17, a man named Read, w'de and daughter, son-in-law, and an old negro ser\-ant came to San Miguel, and as the ^Mission was then regarded as public property, they set up housekeeping in some of the rooms of the old building. When gold was discovered, Mr. Read went to the mines, and in the fall of 1848 returned with several thousand dollars in gold. Read was hospitable and talkative, and showed his "dust" to several people. In October, 1848, a party of sailors, deserters from a ship at Monterey, came to Read's home. He showed his gold and talked freely. The sailors asked to stay all night and permission was given, also food. Mrs. Read had recently been confined, and with her w-as another woman acting as nurse, besides her grown daughter, son-in-law, their three children, the old negro and Mr. Read. The sailors planned and executed the murder of the entire family, even brained the infant on one of the pillars of the corridor. Of course the gold dust was the incentive for the deed.

The following day John M. Price and F. Z. Branch, on their way home from the mines, stopped to visit tlje Reads, who were friends of Mr. Price. Calling, and receiving no answer, they dismounted, entered and soon knew of the terrible murder. After making sure that no breath of life remained in any of the Ijodies, they hastened to the Paso Robles rancho and gave the alarm. One party went north to bury the victims and another south in pursuit of the murderers, whose trail was easily followed. At Carpinteria, or where it now is, close to the beach, the sailors were overtaken. A desperate battle ensued. One of the pursuers was killed and others w'ounded. All the murderers were shot. One plunged into the surf and tried to swim out to sea. A bullet was sent after him and down he went, food for sea monsters. The others were left where they fell, food for vultures and coyotes. Thus closed one of the greatest criminal tragedies of the state and of this count}-. \Miat became of the gold dust? Did the pursuers get it? Other Crimes

In November, 1855, Isaac B. Wall, collector of the port of Monterey and T. B. Williamson, an officer of Monterey county, were on their way to San Luis Obispo. On the "dark and bloody ground" of the Nacimicnto they were waylaid and murdered. No direct trace of the murderers was ever found.

In October, 1853, eight or ten men passed through San Luis Obispo going south and openly boasted of having killed a peddler near San Juan. After being "bad men" here for a few days they stole a lot of horses and left. A party from San Luis Obispo followed them and overtook them in Los Angeles. They had the horses and the stolen goods of the peddler. Three of them were put aboard a boat and started back. At Avila a party with ropes received the gentlemen and there was a triple hanging. One w^as brought back with the pursuers, some say taken in town. At any rate he also was hanged.

Fearless came down from San Francisco with $2,000, and went into business with Jesus Luna, a Mexican. They established a "ranchito" on the Nacimiento. Soon Fearless disappeared ; Luna said he "had gone to the states." Luna sold out cattle, horses, and even the Newfoundland dog and his partner's gold watch, then left for the south. About three months later Fearless' body, or what was left of it, was found near the ranchito. Luna was a pal of Pio Lenares, so the truth is easy to guess. John Gilkey, living on the Comatti ranch, had been killed by the gang who murdered Borel and Baratie, after they left the San Juan ranch. Grijalva confessed that he shot him in the back and Valenzuela dragged him fifty yards with his reata.

Nieves Robles had been acquitted, though every one knew he was a murderer. The majority of the native Californians either resented or resisted punishing the criminals. Settlers would not come into a county where they were almost sure to meet death on the way. Other portions of the state were filling up with a good class of settlers. Here business was prostrate, life very unsafe and the county known far and wide as a camping ground for countless thieves and murderers. From Monterey to Los Angeles stretched a country full of mountain hiding-places, pleasant pastures for horses, and abundant game. No wonder the bandits gathered here from all over the state. Jack Powers and ex-Jtidge "Ned McGowan," infamous Americans, who had fled from the San Francisco Vigilantes, came here and organized bands. They plotted and planned most of the crimes, while the natives executed them, alone if the leaders failed to take a hand at the critical moment. The Vigilance Committee of 1858 was the result, and they deserve great praise for the work they did that the courts could not do for lack of evidence, that is, sworn evidence in a court room.

"The undersigned hereby pledge themselves, each to the other, that in the case of the murder of two Frenchmen, Bartolo Baratie and M. Jose Borel, we will stand together and by all means whatsoever, discover the truth and punish the guilty. The first step shall be the personal restraint and intimidation to the prisoner now in jail, even if necessary to the danger of life. Signed : Walter Murray, Francisco Letora, Francisco Brizzolara, Charles Pellerier, B. Block, P. A. Forrester, Jacob J. Scheifferley, A. Albarelli, Luis de la Cella, Domingo Garcia, Nicolo Ravello, T. P. Commay, J. J. Simmler, Rudol[)h Blum, B. F. Hamilton."

"The undersigned citizens of San Luis Obispo sign our names as members of a body to be called the San Luis Vigilance Committee, the object of which is and shall be the repression and punishment of crimes by all means whatsoever: \\alter Murra}', Fred'k Hillard. S. A. Pollard, Thos. Graves, Labat Pere, G. Leemo, P. A. Forrester, Jules Baume, Chas. Johnson, Wm. Coates, Bernardo Lazcano, Jose Cantua, Carl Dictz, Ferdinand Quievreux, Manuel Otero, Thomas Herrara. N. Amos, J. J. Simmler, Thos. R. Thorp, Leonardo Lopez, Ramon Baldez, J. A. dc la Guerra, Pedro Ruperez, Trinidad Beccrro, John

Many more murders were committed besides those mentioned, but the quick work of the Vigilance Committee put a damper on crime and it was less openly boasted of and of much less frequency. The accounts of those crimes from 1850 to 1858, are taken from a scries of letters written by ^Valter ^Murray in 1858, to the San Francisco Bulletin. He came to San Luis Obispo in 1853, and was from the first a leading citizen, foremost in wiping ofif the slate of criminality, that for so long had made of the county a safe nest for all sorts of vagabonds. ^Murders and roliberics still occurred, but at longer intervals.

One crime frcciucntly referred to as we gathered data for this history was the disappearance of O. K. Smith. Strange to say, he was always spoken of as assessor and tax collector. The stories varied so in date that the writer determined to .sjet at the facts, at least of his calling and the date of his disappearance, and so went to the one reliable and accurate source, the files of the Tribune. There we find that in August, 1869, O. K. Smith ran for assessor on the Republican ticket, receiving 393 votes, but James Buffum, Democrat, received 467 ; as the majority rules, this lets Smith out as assessor. Smith came to the county in 1866 and settled near Cambria. In 1861 he represented Tulare county in the legislature, and had also served as a deputy sheriff in that county. He began farming near Cambria, but being a man of considerable education and ability, he naturally took an active part in county affairs.

The Tribune of June 11, 1870, announced that Governor Worris had appointed O. K. Smith of San Simeon (this name then included all that upper coast country) census marshal of this county. A. M. Hardie worked with Smith taking the 1870 census. February 25, 1871, The Tribune published a letter sent from Cambria and signed by C. Mathers, in which Mathers states that "our friend" O. K. Smith had left Cambria on Friday, February 17, 1871, bound for San Luis Obispo; that a wagon thought to be his had been found on the beach near ^Morro Rock; and that it was feared that Smith had been drowned. On February 25, 1871, a letter was sent to the Tribune from Morro signed by Smith's ^Masonic brothers, G. S. Davis, G. Rothschild and G. AI. Cole, telling about the same news and asking for help in the search for his body or any trace of him, his team or papers.

JMarch 25, 1871, the following description \\as printed in the paper: "Two fair-sized strawberry roan mares, bearing the brand of K in a circle or circle K, one a little darker than the other. Gentle to work or ride. Any persons seeing such horses are requested to write to this office or to Z. B. Smith, Cambria. Papers throughout the state please copy." Now we have two facts at least: O. K. Smith was census marshal, not assessor; and he was undoubtedly murdered, February 17, 1871.

One other fact was established. Smith was last seen alive Friday, February 17, 1871, at a saloon and road-house kept by George Stone on the road to San Luis Obispo. It stood on the rocky point just where the Old creek road enters the coast road, where the old unpainted shack now stands up on the rocky hillside to the right going to San Luis Obispo. A. M. Hardie says it was a bad, stormy day ; that Smith had a premonition that evil was to befall him and wanted his wife to go with him ; also that at Stone's place he asked a man named Rudisill to go on with him, but Rudisill also refused. Mr. Hardie says that Stone and Rudisill helped Smith to harness up when, about two o'clock P. M., he .started out on what proved to be his last ride, and that they used rope and wire to fasten the tugs to the whiffletrees. "The horses never got out of those tugs without help," said Mr. Hardie. Of course from the moment the wagon was found, and no trace of the body, the team or harness, foul play was suspected and suspicion placed upon several men now dead. Here are a few of the many stories told the writer.

In those days the farmers often sent their tax money to the oflSce in San Luis Obispo by neighbors going down. This custom yet prevails. One man (we are .going to eliminate names) says that after Smith's death men presented receipts given by him to them showing that he had nearly or Cjuite $600 of tax moncv him when he was killed. Certain it is that he had papers of some census reports, for a boy sixteen years old named Taylor, brother of Charlie Taylor, the present sheriff, found the wagon and a roll of wet papers belonging to Smith. The papers were taken home and dried out. Later some men rode up to the Taylor house and asked for the papers, which the boy gave to them. They were census reports, and ]\Ir. Hardie received them from the boy, and w^as entitled to them as he was Smith's helper in taking the census. Now for stories weird and otherwise. If they are all just fabrications built upon the facts stated, they show brilliant imaginations and some good novelists have missed their calling. Story number one follows :

Story number two is more elaborate in detail : On the night of Smith's disappearance, a man living on Morro creek went down to dig clams. He saw a fire burning on the beach and, turning back, went up on the blufif where he could see l^ut not be seen. Looking over, he saw two men digging a great hole. They gathered beach wood and built a fire in it, meantime digging another hole. Soon Smith's team, driven by a third man, came around Toro point ; Smith was very drunk and was being held in the light wagon. He was knocked on the head, stripped, rolled into hole number two and sand was scooped in on him. All his clothing, his gold watch, the harness from the horses, their halter ropes and the tongue and one wdieel from the wagon were thrown upon the fire and burned. When burned down to coals sand was scooped into that hole and all traces of the doings destroyed by scraping and scratching about over the sand. Then the three men tied their own ropes about Smith's horses and led them up the creek to a rocky side canon and shot them. The narrator said this yarn w-as told to him by a dying man under a promise of secrecy until after his death, and that it was told to that man by another man. Upon asking why this story was kept secret so long, the man said it would have meant death to the teller had he told it then or while certain other men now dead were living.

This is written not as a fact but because it has thrills in it. It may or may not be true; no one will now ever know. The strange thing was that no trace of the harness or team was ever found. Two skeletons of horses, each with a bullet hole in the skull, were certainly found in a canon not too far from the be^ch to have been led there by Smith's murderers. The wagon when found had lost one wheel and the tongue.

At about the place where the wagon was found others had lost their lives in the quicksand in attempting to drive across when the tide was out, but their bodies or some trace of them was always found. There were many suspicious circumstances, or so it seemed, about Smith's disappearance; but one more story, and then we will leave the subject.

Near the entrance to Green valley in an old house lived a man named Kilpatrick. He was the wreck of what had once been a well-educated, wellbred man, and was well acquainted with Smith. One night Kilpatrick on his way to San Luis Obispo camped in the "monte" or patch of willows all are familiar with, just north of Morro on the road to Cayucos. It was a beautiful moonlight night, made more so by a luminous sort of haze. Kilpatrick had just lain down and composed himself when O. K. Smith, or so it seemed to him, walked out of the willows and up to the foot of his shake-down. So sure was he that it was Smith that he exclaimed, "Where the devil have you been all this time!" Smith stood looking at him in silence for some moments; then turned and disappeared into the willows. This might be called "a psychological moment."

Provenance

Text from History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.