BlockBefore

San Luis Obispo County, California - Chapter 16 (2 of 2 so headed), 1917

From History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917. 1,402 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

The text

1,402 words

Machine-read from scans of History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

W'lieii in 1831 a land commission was estal)lishcd to settle the titles to the Spanish land tyrants, many of the Spanish and Mexican grantees scorned tiie "Gringo law,"' believing they could not be ousted from their lands. Those who complied fully with the law obtained patents, but those who refused became involved later in expensive litigation. Sometimes they lost the land entirely. Often they spent the price of it in lawsuits. As a sample case in thi.s count}^ we give the story of the Cuesta rancho.

In 1841, Mariano Bonilla petitioned Governor Alvarado to grant him a tract of land which should be known as la Cuesta. He described it ciuite minutely. It is the land lying in Cuesta canon extending back along a little stream, the stream flowing into San Luis creek. The new city reservoir is near this stream, and the land is perhaps better known now as the Goldtree ranch. Bonilla's petition was referred to the priest in charge of the Alission, as la Cuesta was a part of the old Mis,sion lands. The priest reported favorably, and Governor Alvarado granted the land. April 16, 1842, Manuel Jimeno, member of the departmental junta, made an informal grant of the land, specifying that within one year a house be built and occupied, and that not over six or seven cows and horses, sufficient for family use, be pastured on the grazing lands which belonged to the Mission. The land granted Bonilla was to be for agricultural use and an orchard. Also, he was not to "divert or diminish" the water supply of San Luis creek, which furnished water for the [Mission. He might fence it, but the road must not be enclosed.

March 14, 1846, judicial possession was given Bonilla by the alcalde of San Luis Obispo, Jose de Jesus Pico, who directed two plainsmen, Don Manuel Garcia and Don Vicente Bonilla, in default of a regular surveyor, to make a cord one hundred Castilian varas long and, "in company with witnesses and spectators," measure off the land. They promised to do it "fair and justly." The party proceeded to La Canada Honda, on the range of mountains, and, beginning there, measured off the land, setting suitable marks to indicate the bounds. After the land was legally surveyed by the plainsmen with their "cordel," Bonilla, to show that he was now sole "lord and owner," pulled up herbs and scattered them about ; also he "hurled stones" over his domain. The official witnesses were Vicente Garcia and Jose Ortega. Bonilla planted an orchard, built a house, which he lived in, and also put up a "molino," or grist-mill, and ground wheat for all who would bring it. This old mill, the first one at San Luis Obispo, is mentioned elsewhere.

March 22, 1869, Bonilla sold to P. W. Murphy all his land, save the portion already sold to Sumner. Meantime a United States Government survey had been made; and Bonilla having refused to comply with "Gringo law," his land was surveyed with the rest and the sixteenth and thirty-sixth sections declared school lands. February 3, 1871, the United States Land Office issued to Leonardo Lopez a patent covering Bonilla's land, which Lope? got as school land or government land, and transferred to Isaac and Nathan Goldtree, who proceeded to take possession. Beyond question, this was an underhanded trick. Probably Goldtree instigated Lopez to take the land and furnished the funds, though this is only a supposition. Had Bonilla complied with the Mexican law. and later the -'Gringo" law, he would have been protected, and so would Murphy; but now there was trouble. March 7, 1872, Murphy filed complaint for the recovery of his land and asked that defendant, Goldtree Bros., pay him $640 rent per year since the time they "forcibly, and without complainant's consent," took possession of la Cuesta. ]\Iay 6, 1873, the answer was filed ; and the suit was tried at the May term of court, 1874, without a jury. Walter Murray represented the defendants; C. W. Dana was clerk. The Goldtrees were given judgment, and Murphy had to pay costs of suit.

^Vhen the suit was instituted, all the old records had to be hunted up. As they were recorded in Spanish, they were translated into English. Bonilla's petition, the priest's opinion and Alvarado's consent to it were found in the old custom-house at Monterey. As often as this land changes hands, the Bonilla heirs put in a claim for recognition and compensation, but so far to no avail. These old documents are so interesting that we give them in full, with peculiarities of style and punctuation retained.

This cause came on to be tried at the jMay Term of this Court, 1874, and by consent of parties was tried to the Court without a Jury. The Court having heard the testimony and argument of Counsel now finds the facts to be :

On the 4th day of January, 1841, Jose Mariano Bonilla, a Mexican Citizen, and a resident of California, addressed to Juan B. Alvarado then Governor of California, the following petition:

I, Alariano Bonilla, a native of the Department of Mexico and a resident of the Ex Mission of San Miguel before your Excellency respectfully and in the form of law, represent : That in the Canada known by the name of San Luis Obispo, there is a small plain, on which, with industry and labor, an orchard might be planted and mill built without disturbing the course of the water, and since the Mission of San Luis makes no use of said ]ilace, and does not need the same, and since the temperature of that ])lace is very beneficial to my health, I ask your Excellency to be pleased to grant me in said place, a solar of three hundred varas square, and to permit me to use the water of the Arroyo which runs to San Luis Obispo, without disturbing the course of the same or diminishing its quantity. I will place thereon a mill, plant an orchard and build a house, all of which will be for the pulilic benefit. The said place is well known, however, I furnish a map for your better information.

On the receipt of this petition, wliicli w:is acci miiianied by a diseno showing the location of the land asked for. the Governor referred the same

Let the person in "charge of San Luis Obispo report on the foregoing petition after consulting with the Revd Father Minister as to whether or not the land petitioned for may be granted without prejudice to the Community.

"In relation to the foregoing petition dated on the 16th day of January 1841, I say That I am of the opinion, that the said place may be granted for tlie uses set forth, but on condition, that the grantee, shall not put thereon more than six or eight cows for supplying the family with milk and some horses for his use, otherwise the establishment of San Luis Obispo cannot be maintained, since this place being surrounded by hills, it is a convenient place for the milch cows of the Establishment and the horses which are necessary for the use of the same, the greater part of which are kept there.

In view of the petition with which these proceedings commence, the report of the Father Minister, and of the Majordomo of San Luis Obispo, with all other matters necessary to be considered in conformity with the laws and regulations on the subject, I declare Don Mariano Bonilla owner in property of one half a square league, from the Arroyo of tiie Encino towards the Cuesta of Santa Margarita as far as the mouth of the Cafiada on the principal road from San Luis Obispo. Let the corresponding title issue ; Let registry be made thereof in the respective book, and let the same be delivered to the interested party for his security and let this expidiento be directed to the Most Excellent Departmental Junta for its approval. Ilis Excellency, Senor Don Juan P.. .Mvarado, thus ordered decreed and signed."

As another sample of old-time transactions, we give the following: Don Jose de Jesus Pico goes to Santa Barbara shopping. Perhaps the Doiia goes along. I'"roin the items one is almost sure she did. This old account was found in the office of the county clerk recently. The account is with Thomp-

Provenance

Text from History of San Luis Obispo County and Environs, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County and Environs Who Have Been Identified with the Growth and Development of the Section from the Early Days to the Present, published 1917, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.