San Rafael, California - History (part 2 of 3)
From History of Marin County, California ... Also an Historical Sketch of the State of California, published 1880. 15,979 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
1 sectionThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,979 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Marin County, California ... Also an Historical Sketch of the State of California, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
We have spoken of the equability of the climate of San Rafael, and the softness and purity of its air, peculiarities resulting from its local situation and surroundings. It is said that the mercury rarely rises above eightyfive degrees, or descends below forty-five, (for the ultra severity of the last winter must not be taken into account). There is, it is believed, no other place along the coast of which these meteorological facts can be predicated, and it is these peculiarities, no doubt, that contribute to make the valley remarkable for its healthfulness. But while the equability and salubrity of such a climate must exercise a healing influence upon persons of impaired health, who seek this locality with a view to the restoration of enfeebled physical energies, the beauty of the valley and its surroundinos may also lay claim to a share of the healing process; ibr it is well known that scenes which charm the eye, and which constantly gratify the innate sense of the beautiful, do much to give tone to the feelings, and reach and influence the physical organism through the pleasurable action of the imagination. It is a combination of such causes acting upon the mind as well as upon the physical framework that makes the lovely valley of San Rafael exercise so happy an agency in restoring diseased humanity.
Evening In San Eafael
Within the circling arms of graceful hills The nestling ville sinks like a child to rest ; In the still air, nights' low weird music thrills, , And clouds like wool round Tamalpais' crest
The west, ere while with roses all aglow - Showered lightly on the sun's low sinking head, Is paling from it's rosiness to snow ; The brooding hills their purple shadows spread ; And to their cosy nests the wild birds wing.
And twilight, like a filmy veil soft thrown, By thoughtful mother o'er a sleeping child, In gossamer shadows gently wafting down, Wraps the white ville so quietsome and mild, And for a space sweet peace doth hold her own.
All bustle quiets as the moon climbs high. Threading the glittering maze of shy, sweet stars ; The golden fadeless flowers of the sky - And stripes the placid earth with silver bars. And on the ville a silver veil doth throw.
The air is heavy witb the breath of flowers, And spicy scent of pinewoods from the hill. No sound disturbs the midnight's sacred hours Save a lone night bird's mournful trill, a trill Trembling through the stillness, sweet and low.
Point San Pedro. - Point San Pedro is reached from San Rafael by a hard, smooth road, which affords an exceedingly agreeable drive of a half hour's duration, presenting several charming views of the bay, and many interesting landscapes. The road skirts along San Francisco bay for some distance, then turning northward, leads to the shore of San Pablo bay. Thence a high blufi' turns it back into the fields, and you soon come in sight of Mr. Bullis' residence. Just up in front of the latter you hitch your team to a fence, and a walk of two or three hundred yards brings you upon the scene of the fishing grounds of Point San Pedro. This industry is entirely in the hands of Chinamen, who conduct a very extensive business, employing upwards of two hundred and twenty-five men. The land occupied by the fishermen is owned by McNear & Bro., and leased to Mr. Richard Bullis for one thousand dollars a year, and by him leased to the Chinamen for nearly three thousand dollars. From ten to fifteen acres are occupied, the shore line serving for houses, boat building, shipping, etc., and the side hill for drying the fish, and preparing them for market. Shrimps constitute the principal catch, and of these from twenty to thirty tons per week are taken. The shrimps are dried on the hillsides, threshed, a la Chinois, to get ofi" the hull, winnowed through a hand mill, and sent to market. The fish sell for eight to fourteen cents per pound in the San Francisco market, at wholesale, and the hulls are shipped to China, and sold for manure, where they bring twenty dollars per ton, affording a profit over all expenses of five dollars. It is said to be an excellent fertilizer. Other kinds of fish are taken in great quantities, as flounders, perch, etc., and some of which are used only for dressing soil. The stakes to which the fishers attach their nets extend out into the bay a mile or more. There are thirty-two houses on the beach, and more all the time building. Two boats are now on the ways, one forty feet long, and the other thirty. Nine hundred cords of wood have been used this season, which they buy in Redwood City, and ship themselves to their fishing grounds. Captain Bullis makes a weekly trip to the city with a cargo, the law requiring a white captain on a fortyfoot craft.
Ross Landing. - This is the point from which is .shipped the greater portion of cord-wood cut in this vicinity. During the busy season a number of vessels ranging from ten to fifty tons carrying capacity may be seen daily unloading at the Embarcadero, or taking in freight for San Francisco. The town contains some thirty or forty houses, the several industries peculiar to interior villages being found. It is situated about three miles from San Rafael, the road to which is one of the most charming drives in the district.
Point San Quentin. - General M. G. Vallejo, whose intimate acquaintance with the earliest California history is so well known, says that the origin of this name is as follows : " The great Indian Chief Marin, after whom the county is named, being, in 1824, very closely pursued by Lieutenant Ignacio Martinez and Sub-Lieutenant Jos^ Sanchez, who had under their command, beside their troops, the celebrated Marcelo, Chief of the tribes of Cholgones and Bolgones (tribes living at Mount Diablo), sought refuge in the little islands lying near the entrance of the creek known under the name of Estero de San Rafael de Aguanni. These islands were forthwith surrounded by rafts managed by friendly Indians; but the Mexican officers, not having a sufficient force to justify their setting foot on the land, and being apprehensive that Marin's friends and allies might cut off their retreat, raised the seige and repaired to the ' Punta de Quintin,' where they met with an equally strong resistance from Captain Quintin, Marin's Sub-Chief, and a brave daring warrior.
" Lieutenant Martinez, although his force was inferior in number to that of the enemy, joined battle with the forces of Quintin, and being favored by fortune captured that Chief. The prisoner was taken to San Francisco and detained two years, at the end of which he was set at liberty, there being no longer any doubt that the whites could rely on his promises.
V Quintin was a good sailor, and during his detention was employed by the missionary Fathers of the Mission Dolores as skipper of one of the lighters trading in the bay. Fifteen years later, at the recommendation of Solano and Marcelo, who had given me their guarantee of his good behavior, I placed him in charge of my best lighter, which was engaged in making trips between Sonoma creek (Estero de Sonoma) and the port of Yerba Buena, now known as San Francisco.
" The spot in which the struggle occurred, with such a happy termination for the whites, between Lieutenant Martinez' troops and Quintin's Indians, was, after the capture of the red chief, known as ' Punta de Quintin ' (Quintin's Point) ; but it was reserved for the North Americans to change the name of that place, and to call it 'Punta de San Quentin.' I believe that the change may be attributed to the fact that a large number of them arrived in California under the belief that the inhabitants of this country were very zealous Catholics, and desiring to gain their good- will added San (Saint) before the towns or villages that they visited. I remember having heard on different occasions ' Santa Sonoma,' ' San Branciforte,' and ' San Monterey,' and, pursuant to this custom, they added San to Qaentin.
Point San Quentin is now notorious throughout the length and breadth of California as being the location of the State Prison. In the country the prisoner is sent to " San Quentin;" in San Francisco civic crime has softened it into " across the bay." When it was first adopted as the locality whereon to plant the penitentiary we have not been able to gather, neither have we been successful in tracing much of its past history - fortunately so, perhaps.
The State Prison. - The prison is situated on the neck of land known as above stated; borders on the Bay of San Francisco, and is distant from that city about twelve miles. The land belonging to the State consists of about one hundred and thirty acres, but with the exception of the part occupied by the buildings and yards, five or six acres cultivated as a garden and the brickyard, it is of little value save for pasturage, and in past years furnishing clay for making bricks, but which is now exhausted for that pur-
The prison grounds proper, enclosed by a wall, contain about six acres The wall is about twenty feet in height, the lower half being built of stone and the upper of brick, which portion being in a state of disintegration. This wall extends about five hundred and fifty feet from east to west, and about four hundred and ninety feet from north to south. The buildings are as follows : one fifty by twenty-five feet (outside the walls), occupied by the clerk and commissary of the prison as offices in the upper story, the basement being used as a butcher's shop and storeroom ; a three-story building, fifty-four by forty feet, occupied by some of the officers of the prison, and the prison physician and family. On the south side, and adjoining this building, is the main entrance to the prison, through an archway in the wall, closed on the inside and outside with an iron gate. Adjoining this is the kitchen, dining-room for officers and guards, in a one-story brick building, sixty by twenty feet, made of brick of very poor quality, and which ^ together with the building first above mentioned, will serve but a few years, and will have to be rebuilt of more substantial material.
The buildings in the yard consist: First, one two stories high, forty by twenty feet, built of brick of a poor quality, the lower story being occupied as offices by the warden and turnkey, the upper story being used as a female prison and a store room for clothing. Adjoining the building on the rear is a yard in which the female prisoners are occasionally allowed to walk; second, the wash-house, two stories high, the upper story being used as a hospital, the lower for hospital, kitchen and lock-up - a room mostly used for convalescent patients. In the basement is the dungeon of the prison, which contains fourteen cells, seven on each side of the passage way, each cell eleven and a half by six feet, and nine feet high; near the entrance to the dungeon stands the whipping post. Third, a workshop, two stories high, one hundred and fifty-nine by eighty feet. Fourth, three buildings containing cells situated parallel to each other, two of which are one hundred and seventy-four by twenty-three feet, and contain four hundred and twenty cells, each eight feet long, four feet wide, and six and a half feet high, each cell being furnished with a bunk, two pair of blankets, a straw tick and such other articles as the prisoner can procure. The third building is one hundred and eighty by twenty-eight feet, two stories, the lower one being divided into seven rooms, each occupying the full width of the building. The upper story contains forty-eight cells, each ten feet long, six feet wide and eight feet high. This is the only stone building on the premises, all the other buildings inside the walls being of brick.
For further particulars about the working of the prison, we would refer the reader to the following exhaustive reports of the Resident Warden, the
Report of the Resident Director.- - Since my last biennial report many much needed improvements have been made, which will be mentioned hereafter under the appropriate heading and in detail. It is one of the favorable signs of the times that recently a great interest seems to have been awakened upon the subject of prison management in general. Public men and newspapers have shown an unusual interest in the matter of prison management and discipline, until, I believe, every known system has found warm and earnest advocates. Hence, a few words from me on the subject may be pardonable, not by way of defence of my own management, for in this regard I have nothing to boast of. I do point with some satisfaction, however, to the fact that we have made a great reduction in the running expenses of the prison in the last two years. And for the quarter since July 1st of the present year, although not properly belonging to this report, we have made this the cheapest congregate prison (except three) in the United States, the daily cost i^er capita being only thirty-two cents and eight mills, as will be seen by reference to the proper table. With the system here in general I of course have had no power to deal, that depending in a great measure upon the style of the buildings and the number of prisoners. Still, we have made very many reforms in the last two years, and, but for a defection in the cell buildings and want of room, would have to-day exactly the present New York system. To enable us to adopt that system entirely we must have cell room sufficient to prevent the doubling up of prisoners. Each prisoner must have his separate cell, and the law must authorize his confinement therein for a time at least, with or without work, when he first enters, or at any other time for that matter, in the discretion of the management. The adoption of the new Constitution, which goes into effect on the 1st day of January, 1880, places the management under a permanent board of officers. This accords with the views I expressed in my last report, and will enable the prisons of this State to be brought up abreast with the best institutions of the kind in the United States. In fact, with a permanent Board of Directors and a permanent Warden, and a cell for each prisoner, there is no reason why this may not become a model institution. As soon as the Folsom Prison is opened, which may be at any time after the 1st of January next, a trifling outlay of money will prepare the necessary room to place each prisoner in a cell by himself; When we have accomplished so much, and inaugurated the new system, which we may do by transferring five hundred prisoners to the new Penitentiary at Folsom, ours may then rank among the highest and best institutions for the suppression of crime and the reformation of criminals. To show that our system will then be in harmony with the best prisons of the world, I deem it not out of place here to give a brief description of the prevailing systems in different countries; not that you, gentlemen, to whom this report is addressed, need or require anything of the kind, for you have made this subject a study, but for the benefit of such members of the next Legislature as desire to take part in shaping the new system, and who, from their occupations in life, have been prevented from acquiring any knowledge upon the subject. Prison systems of the world, taken from the latest accessible reports and papers, are as follows: -
Austria has several prisons, but as they are not all built alike, she necessarily has different systems; however, until quite recently, the associate system alone prevailed. But all the new prisons, built since 1867, have been arranged so as to be both cellular and associate, like ours. It is provided by law, that every two days passed in cellular confinement shall count as three days on the sentence, and that no prisoner sHall serve more than three years in cellular confinement. Retired prison officers are pensioned by the government.
Belgium has eighteen prisons, mostly cellular, that system having the sanction of her ablest men. However, in the Belgium prisons, each prisoner is treated somewhat in accordance with his general character and deportment. Retired prison officers are pensioned by the government.
Denmark has a mixed system of imprisonments, her jails being used largely for criminals guilty of the lighter offenses. All criminals sentenced to labor in the State Prison are not treated by the same rules under the same system. Those sentenced from two years to life are under what is here known as the Auburn system. There, are four penitentiaries in Denmark, three on the congregate system and one on the cellular.
France has a great variety of penal institutions, but three of them corresponding to anything in this country. The central prisons, like our penitentaries; the departmental, like our jails; institutions for correctional education, like our houses of correction and reform schools. The cellular system is not in use, but the congregate. Pensions are paid to retired prison officers.
The German Empire has a mixed system of prisons. Baden, a department of the Empire, has a system partially congregate and partially cellular, but no prisoners can be separately confined for a longer time than three years. Upon retirement prison officers are pensioned.
Bavaria has four cellular prisons, one for the punishment of criminals, the others for the safe-keeping of prisoners awaiting trial. All the other prisons of the Kingdom are on the congregate system. Retired officers are pensioned by the government. In Prussia there are forty-seven prisons properly speaking, but one of which is organized on the cellular plan. The cellular system is new in Prussia, but it is claimed that no appreciable difference exists, so far as the i-eformation of criminals is concerned ; but that other benefits may and do result from the cellular system which could never be attained by the congregate. The government pays pensions to retired prison officers. In Saxony, where the best results have been secured, the system is a mixed one. There each prisoner is treated to just what his case is supposed to require. He is treated under the cellular system, the congregate, made a trusty, or given a ticket of leave to spend a time with his friends and family, as the authorities think just to him and safe to the State. Saxony has eleven prisons where this system prevails, and with the best results. In Wurtemberg the congregate system prevails, with common dormitories, except the prison at Heilbron, where a trial is about to be made of the cellular system. Generally throughout the German Empire the congregate system prevails. Italy, like Germany, has that diversity in prison system which naturally results from the combining of many sections under one rule. The Tuscan Provinces have the cellular system. I believe the Neapolitan, Sicilian, and others, have the Auburn system. The best reports are that the government is making efforts towards a unification of systems, but upon what plan I do not know. At the last report, the prisons of Italy were classed by Mr. Wines thus : Two on the system of isolation and partly association; five on the Auburn plan; two partly on the Auburn plan and partly on the community plan ; and forty-five on the community system. Retired officers are paid pensions.
The Netherlands have a system of cellular and association, but no prisoner shall be conKned in a cell longer than two years. Retired officers are pensioned by the government.
Russia has a mixed system, but cellular imprisonment for long terms is forbidden by law. The system in Russia is supposed to be bad, and the management generally worse. Retired officers are pensioned by the government.
Switzerland has mainly the Crofton or Irish system. The congregate system also prevails, but efforts are being made to adopt the cellular of nights. The report of Mr. Wines states : There is a general agreement that the system of association is favorable to industrial labor, and not unfavorable to discipline, but that when extended to the dormitories as well as the workshops it is obstructive to the moral education of the prisoners. Pensions are paid to retired officers by the government.
Sweden has a mixed system of prisons, cellular and congregate, but it is making efforts to adopt the Crofton plan. Sweden pays pensions to her retired prison officers.
In the American States, it is said our first steps were taken in the matter of prison reform in Philadelphia, in 1784, when the old Walnut Street Prison was built, and that the first organized effort was made in 1787 by j|
Dr. Franklin and others. The oldest penitentiary is at Charlestown, Massachusetts, began in 1800 and completed for the reception of prisoners in 1805. Fifty years and more ago a heated controversy was carried on by some of our most distinguished statesmen of that time, as to the best system for penitentiaries. Two systems had strong and able advocates ; one was called the Pennsylvania system, the other the New York system. The New York system adopted at Sing Sing and at Auburn was the congregate, with separate cells for prisoners at nights. The Pennsylvania system, adopted at Philadelphia and Pittsburg, was the cellular and isolation. Several other States adopted the Pennsylvania system, but all have now abandoned it, and in fact it has long since been abandoned at Pittsburg, so that the system now prevails in but one American prison, and but few in the world. The system has been condemned by every able and enlightened statesman who has studied the subject, for the last twenty years, and has been finally abandoned in this country and in most all the nations of Europe.
The Crofton or Irish system commends itself generally to students and prison managers throughout the ' civilized nations. This is but a liberal trusty system. The next in rank, and in the main like it, is the New York system, now being adopted in all tha new American prisons, where it can be done without too much cost. In my opinion, the New York system is free from, many objections which may be urged against the Crofton. For instance, the free association of prisoners, which must take place at some stage of -the imprisonment under that system, is certain to prove destructive of all the good and repressive effects of isolation. The most learned and laborious association for the prevention and cure of crime in the world - the HoAvard Association of England - has lately assailed that system, and not only denounced Spike Island but Mountjoy - Dublin Penitentiary - as well, for the reason, mainly, that a free association of prisoners is certain to breed plots and plans for mischief after discharge; and also, because such association begets a feeling of home attachment for the prison, to which the prisoner returns in many cases without regret. This sort of association here is doubtless the cause of hundreds of returns to the prison, and of course of the commission of hundreds of crimes. In a recent communication of a committee of the Howards to the Home Secretary I find these remarks: " The due separation of prisoners from each other only is an essential feature of a wise and eificient treatment, but mere solitude is unnatural and pernicious. It is neither wise nor merciful. Prisoners, when separated from evil companionship, should be necessarily brought under the influence of good intercourse, both from within and without." In this short paragraph lays the foundation of the best economy, the most humane treatment of convicts, and the best repressive and reformatory methods possible at any penitentiary. These principles may be carried out here, after the new prison is opened, and the
Were I asked to suggest the very best plan for the prevention of crime, I would advise the closing of drinking-houses, and the absolute solitude of prisoners. But the freedom-loving citizen of this country will not be restricted in his right to buy, sell, and use alcoholic liquors, nor will the- -humanity of the age permit such brutalizing of the convict. Were I asked then to suggest a plan alike just to the public and to the convict, I would say keep the convict in a cell to himself, make him work, use every means to teach him the benefits of honesty and morality by placing him in contact with honest and moral people from within and from without. We should consider no man wholly and entirely bad, even though he be a convict, and that every man has within him a germ of goodness which is capable of illimitable expansion. In this age of advancement, when men of every other calling have reached to almost human perfection, it is strange that the moral -and religious cultivation has made so little out of this see4 of goodness, this ^germ of the godly principal in man ! Whatever may be the cause of the fearful increase of crime now noticeable everywhere, it is anyhow a public duty we all owe to the State to save and cultivate all the good we find in and among prisoners, and to this end we should use such methods as justice humanity may dictate. We should not strain after original systems or violent remedies for the management of criminals or the repression of crime, but we should keep up with the spirit of the age, and thereby show our selves as capable and as kiud in these matters as any other people.- I make these remarks because the agitation in the State over the question of prison reform, although good as indicating a proper interest in the subject, is liable to bring to the surface many radical reformers, who would, in their zeal for .the protection of the public, entirely forget the claims of the unfortunate :and the criminal. It is a curious fact that right in the home of prison reform, and in the center of our civilization where the question of prison reform has been most agitated, the number of convicted criminals in proportion to the population greatly exceeds that of any other part of our country. I allude to New York and Massachu.setts. This proves one of two things, either that the teachings of our best moral codes are conducive of crime, or that too much agitation of the prison question is not good. For more than ^one hundred years this great question has been a constant theme of discourse 'by divines and by statesman, and what has been accomplished ? The religious sentiment has been steadily on the increase, civilization has been taking -hio-her grounds, the moral sentiment of the world seems to have constantl}^ improved, yet crime has in no sense been diminished. Since the days of John Howard, who gave the years of his life between 1770 and 1790 for the relief of suffering criminals, and the improvement of prison life in JEnofland, there has been a constant increase of crime in all the Christian nations. Burke says of this great philanthropist: " He visited all Europe, not to survey the sumptuousness of palaces or the stateliness of temples; not to make accurate measurements of the remains of ancient grandeur, nor to form a scale of the curiosity of modern art; not to collect manuscripts, but to dive into the depths of dungeons ; to plunge into the infection of hospitals ; to survey the mansions of sorrow and pain; to take the dimensions of mis- depression, and contempt; to remember the forgotten; to attend the neglected; to visit the forsaken, and to compare the distress of all men in all countries." What a glorious cause he served! Yet it must be confessed that for the general good of the nations, the setting in motion of the humanitarian and philanthropic views of Howard has brought nothing but bad fruit. The benefits have all been on the side of the criminal. The agitation once having been started, the subject being so full of tenderness and even grandeur, naturally enlisted the most eloquent divines and statesmen. So that fifty years ago the excitement seemed to have culminated. Commissions were almost everywhere raised to investigate the subject of prison reform. Commissioners "were sent here from foreign countries, and our own greatest men of all classes set to work in investigating, writing, and speaking upon the subject. And this was natural, as long as the people were interested, for eloquence always selects man's wrongs, misfortunes, and abuses, as the best themes for riotous declamation. As long as this excitement kept up to fever heat, crime increased in the country. Finally a lull came in the agitation, and with it a lagging of the increasing current of crime. In 1872 the eloquence, and the charity, and the sentimentality of the United States again broke out with intense violence upon the subject. They seemed to be and they were, determined to reform the prisoner, and prevent the commission of crime. All the nations of Christendom were seized with a spasm of intense brotherly love for the poor unfortunate criminal. They met in London in 1872, and their great divines and statesmen made speeches and wrote essays. Then, again, they met last year in Stockholm, and did it all over again, in the most fervent manner. All over the United States we have founded prison associations for the relief of the criminal, and we have held State and Federal Congresses for the same purpose, and what has it amounted to ? It has made prison life easier - it has made it easy. It has made crime, as a career, quite respectable in the eyes of very many. It has more than doubled the criminal element of the Christian nations in the short space of seven years. It has more than trebled the number of convicts in some of American States within that time. It has increased our number of convicts from sixteen thousand to about thirty -five thousand, and gives us over sixty thousand criminals in the United States. The convict should be protected in all his rights as a convict, but it should never be forgotten for moment that he has forfeited every other right, and he should never be permitted to forget those things. If there is ever to be any deterrent effect in the imprisonment of the convict it will be when the outside world looks upon him with loathing and with horror, and when the convict lives a life of humility and obedience, recognizing fully his loss, and that of the State, by his crime and imprisonment.
Second, Would confine him to his cell alone for at least a short time upon his arrival at the prison, and would authorize his separate confinement at any time thereafter, in the discretion of the management, subject only to a reasonable restriction as to length of time.
Fourth, Would give him free intercourse with the good, whether reformed prisoners or outsiders, but would prohibit general visitation as at present practiced.
Fifth, Would encourage the " trusty " system by the constant advancement of good and reliable prisoners, and would carry it to the full extent, in rare and important cases, of allowing prisoners to leave the prison and visit their friends and relations.
Sixth, Would have as near silence as possible in marching, in the diningroom, and in the workshops; but prisoners should at all times be allowed to make known their grievances.
Ninth, Would use the pardoning power ten times to where it is now used once; would not use it absolutely, but conditionally. The Governor may impose any condition he pleases ; he may confine one man to the limits of a particular town ; another to a particular township ; another to a county, or to a farm, or he' may send him out of the State or the United States, or he may pardon him upon condition that he pay a sum of money for the support of the prison, or that he furnish beef for the prison for a given time.
There are at least one hundred prisoners here who ought, in my judgment, to be pardoned, and there are at least two hundred more serving excessive, unheard of, and inhuman sentences. Then, again, there are at least two hundred prisoners here, under short sentences, who should either have been sent for life or long terms.
Ojficial Force. - As will be seen by reference to the Clerk's table, giving list and rank of officers, we have been compelled to make an increase of five in the guard force. This was made necessary by the increased number of pi'isoners, and the extra hazard of working a large gang of men on the hills some distance from the prison. We found it absolutely necessary to employ a competent book-keeper as Assistant Commissary, or Commissary's
Clerk, and also to appoint a Moral Instructor. Of the force in general too much cannot be said in their praise for watchfulness and uniform fidelity to their trusts. The officers, one and all, have been true and devoted, and are entitled to the highest commendation for their fidelity to the service.
The Brick-Yard. - The making of brick has not been carried on this season, and never can be again, unless land is purchased in the neighborhood from which the requisite quality of clay can be obtained. Since my last report we have made about six million five hundred thousand brick, to which should be added two million on hand at the end of the burning season of 1877, making eight million five hundred thousand. The cost of the two burning seasons, 1877 and 1878, have to be taken together from July 1, 1877, making a total, mostly for fuel, of twenty-four thousand four hundred and one dollars and twenty-five cents, as may be seen by reference to Table Fifteen. By reference to Table Thirteen, it will be seen that the income from the sale of brick amounted to eighteen thousand one hundred and one dollars and sixteen cents. There are yet owing to the State several uncollected balances for the sale of brick, all of which I hope to collect before my term of ofiice expires. It will be impossible to give «.ny thing more than an approximate estimate of the brick used here in the various buildings and other improvements. Relying upon the best method of computation, it being impossible, the way the buildings and improvements were made, to keep an exact account, I estimate the number of brick used atiour million. We have on hand about one million five hundred thousand, perhaps more. The balance have been sold, mostly for seven dollars per thousand; some, however, at seven dollars and twenty -five cents per thousand.
Buildings and Other Improveraents. - That a full and complete understanding may be had on the subject, the Clerk has retabulated that part of our last report coming under the head of "Building. Fund Expenditures." To this we place, in tabulated form, our expenditures for other buildings since constructed. The recapitulation, marked " Table One," of buildings, shows that we have expended two hundred and twelve thousand five hundred and nine dollars and twenty-five cents for all buildings, and what they are. " Table Two," of buildings, specifies in detail the expenditures. From these tables it will be seen that we have used twelve thousand five hundred and six dollars and twenty-five cents from the General Fund for these absolutely necessary buildings. Since the last report we have put up a cell-building, containing two hundred and four iron cells, at a cost of forty-one thousand two hundred and nineteen dollars and ninety-three cents. The items of cost will be found specified in " Table Two," above mentioned. We have also erected a building for library, school-room and chapel, two shoprooms, kitchen and dining-room, all in one, at a cost of ten thousand four hundred and twelve dollars and ninety-two cents. The part of the building used as a dining-room is about three hundred feet long, forty feet wide, and one story high. The other part of the building used for kitchen, shoprooms, chapel, library, and school-room, is about eighty feet long, forty feet wide, and three stories high. We have also erected a building for a clerk's office and store-room, at a cost of four thousand five hundred and eighty-two dollars and seventy-four cents, which is two stories high, and about forty feet square. We have also erected a drying-house next to the boiler-building, forty feet long, twenty feet wide, and one story high ; also an addition to the boiler-house for the storage of fuel, about thirty feet square, and one story high; also a small building one story high, thirty by twenty feet, at the lower door of the north shop, for the use of heavy machines. The cost of these last buildings have gone into the " General Improvement Account," as there was but little new material, other than brick, lime, and sand, used in their construction. In addition to these improvements, the hill in front of the commissary department, and looking down towards the front gate from the guns, has been cut down, and a heavy brick wall has been erected at the foot, and a terrace wall on top of the hill. This Summer we have built, or rather excavated, a l^rge reservoir on the top of the hill, north of the Prison. It is about two hundred feet above or higher than the lower floor of the shop buildings, and will hold about three million gallons of water. The excavation and cutting down of the hill required the removal of about one million seven hundred thousand cubic yards of earth and rock - mostly soft rock. Table Four, of Clerk's report, will show the amount expended on this important work up to the 1st of July, 1879, to be but one hundred and thirty dollars. The expenditures since that date will properly go into the report of my successor. But I may state that up to the 1st of October, 1879, the whole sum paid out amounted to five thousand and seventy-five dollars and five cents. The whole cost of the work (it is now completed, but all the bills are not in), will be about nine thousand dollars, besides the brick used. The number of brick used in its construction was about one million one hundred thousand; the quantity of cement, one thousand eight hundred barrels, and over all a heavy coating of asphaltum, so that it is as well and strongly lined as possible. I estimate the number of bricks used in all these improvements at about four million. We have been engaged for the last seven months in sinking an artesian well, and have it down now, at this writing (October 81st), to a depth of seven hundred and fifty-five feet. Our contract Avith the well-borers was to pay them six dollars per foot. We can only express a hope that we may strike water; if so, it would almost repay any outlay. Up to July 1, 1879, this work had cost two thousand and thirty-seven dollars and one cent. With our present storage capacity for water, and with the piping and other appliances we have for fighting fire, we may feel perfectly safe from that destro_ying element in the future. That is, we may if we keep a full .supply of water on hand. The Marin County
Water Company have furnished us, as indicated by their meter, somethingover eighty thousand gallons per day. For the excess over eighty thousand gallons per day they claim compensation, their bill amounting to nearly two thousand dollars for the two years ending July 1st, 1879. A majority of the Board of Directors, they alone having authority to audit bills, have felt disinclined to allow anything for the excess, so the matter still remainsunsettled. The company measure all the water sent here into our reservoir, through their meter, and charge it to us. They, however, have very many small customers for water, to whom they sell, fixing their own price and collecting as they please. These customers take thewater from our reservoir,, through our pipes, and in quantities to suit themselves.
I have been at all times willing to pay the excess whenever I could know its quantity after deducting the amount drawn off by the company's customers. As this is an impossibility, or nearly so, I would suggest someother arrangement be made, satisfactory to both parties if possible. Whilst I have been willing at all times to make an effort to come to some understanding upon the question, my associates on the Board have been unwilling to do anything more for the Water Company than we are now doing. I w^ould advise that the Water Company be required to use the small reservoir on the hill for their other customers, and that in the future they be not allowed to take water from ours, as we will henceforth draw from the newreservoir alone. It was gross official neglect, and a great misfortune, that made it necessary for the State to pay one thousand dollars per month for water for use at a public institution located in the country. The Prison should not be at the mercy of any company; should not be in a position to suffer from the caprice or avarice of anybody, but should have water attached to the place as a part of the State's property.
These sums are doubled in this way, as will hereafter appear : Money or warrants received are charged as receipts; when deposited in bank it is credited as disbursements; when drawn out it is again charged as " cash received," and when paid out is again credited as disbursements; so that, the sum appears twice as great as it actually is.
Table Four - Shows for what purpose money was disbursed, and the sun> to each item in the list of expenditures. Reference is respectfully made ta the note at the foot of this table. It has been a custom to allow the officers
Note. - These tables have been found too voluminous for production in these pages, besides they are not absolutely necessary as aids to the reader.
five dollai-s per week in lieu of their board. Many who have families avail themselves of this privilege. Many guards and employes fail to draw their pay regularly from the pay-roll; in such cases the suras are carried to a separate ledger account.
Table Eight - This table makes as complete an exhibit of the matters therein specified as it would be possible to make by a tabular arrangement- On the 1st July, 1877, we had one thousand three hundred and eighteen convicts in the Prison. We now have one thousand five hunch'ed and sixtyfour, an increase of two hundred and forty-six. The average for the two years is one thousand four hundred and seventy-five. The increase for the last two years, it will be seen, is m. excess of that of the tAvo years preceding by thirteen. The total maintaining cost of the Prison for two years has been three hundred and ninety-one thousand nine hundred and eighty dollars and ninety-four cents. The average number of prisoners being one thousand four hundred and seventy-five, it will be seen that the cost of each convict per day is thirty-six cents and four mills. I add here the maintaining cost of the institution for the quarter ending September 30, 1879. This, of course, will again have to be gone over by my successor, as it will belong to a fiscal period which he will have to cover by hLs report. Bat I will doubtless be pardoned for embracing the opportunity to show, as fully as possible, the transactions here under my management :
So far as mere economy is concerned, this is a very marked improvement, one upon which I congratulate the State, and also my associates, who, by their close attention to business, have enabled me to make this flattering exhibit : The maintaining cost, daily, for each prisoner for the last quarter has been 32.8 cents; for two years ending June 30, 1879, 36.4 cents; for two years ending June 30, 1877, 42.7 cents ; for two years ending June 30, 1875, 44 cents ; for two years ending June 30, 1873, 53^.
Without going into details, or making a lengthly comparative statement, showing the maintaining cost in each of the States, I will abridge this report by saying we are much below the average of American prisons in supportingcost. In fact, I have found but three penitentiaries, run under our system, which are cheaper than ours, namely: West Virginia, 3l6 cents; Sing Sing> 28io cents; Auburn, 31 cents.
The three New York penitentiaries, Auburn, Sing Sing and Clinton averaofe 34 cents 9 mills ; the Clinton beinof at a cost of 45 cents 5 mills. I divide the daily average cost per convict as follows, which I believe to be a correct analysis of Table Eight of the Clerk's report.
Table Nine - Gives the maintaining cost per capita, per month of the different items, fractions of mills left out, except in profit and loss.
Table Eleven - Specifies the earnings from which it will be seen that but ninety-three thousand seven hundred and thirteen and seventy one-hundredths dollars were earned by labor. This miserable showing is not to be attributed in any way to want of zeal and proper exertions on the part of the directors and ofticers of the prison, but to the bad laws governing us in the letting of labor. For six years past the law has prohibited the letting of the labor for less than fifty cents per day. This has prevented us from hiring the men except in limited number.s. I believe we would have been able to make this a self-supporting Institution but for this unwise limitation. With this restriction, and no appropriation, or law authorizing us to work the prisoners on State account, w^e have been compelled to let four-fifths of them remain idle, or employ them in unproductive labor. I recommend that even now, at. this late day, the whole matter of letting prisoners for the next two years, be left to the Directors and Warden to do the best they can. I say for the next two years, for after that time, under the provisions of the new Constitution, no labor can be let out bv contract, but all convicts must be worked on State account.
In view of this constitutional restriction, I would recommend that the Legislature make provisions by appropriations, for the working of the prisoners ill the disci'etion of the Directors and Warden. I would do this for the reason that it may be difficult to find contractors, even if the fifty cents restriction should be removed, who would be willing to take the hazard in any mechanical enterprise with a full knowledge that they mu.st break up their business at the end of two years.
The present contractors are the California Furniture Manufacturing Company, working from one hundred to one hundred and twenty-five men - Stone & Hayden, J. C. Johnson & Company, Armes ki Dallam, and the Door and Sash Company, are each working a number of men, but none of them have taken contracts. I suppose they will all continue to employ a limited number of prisoners until the new Constitution turns them out. They all together work about three hundred men, the number varying according to the pleasure of the employers.
Here it will be seen that the total sum received from the State treasury is three hundred and seventy-four thousand dollars. This shows an actual cost to the State of one hundred and eighty-seven thousand dollars per year, all of which might have been saved to the people, but for the reckless reform legislation which has prevented the hiring of prison labor. The sale of manufactured articles on this coast, other than cloth, will amount to over twenty million dollars yearly, yet this miserable policy has been adopted for fear that one hundred and eighty thousand dollars worth of such articles, manufactured by convicts for their own support, would produce injurious competition with the honest mechanic. If the labor could be generally distributed, or even distributed among eight or ten different kinds of manufactures, no one could possibly feel the result except the taxpayers, particularly, as -we are buying and selling convict-manufactured articles from several other States. Reference is here made to the explanatory note at the foot of this table.
It will be seen that we have sold eighteen thousand one hundred and one and sixteen one-huadredbhs dollars worth of brick; anl, also, seven thousand S3ven hundred and ninety-three and fifty-two one-hundredths dollars worth of live stock. This is for the sale of hogs mostly. But for the very bad luck we have had in fattening hogs we might have sold twice or three times the number. We have tried by purchase to keep a sufficient number on hand to consume the waste material from the kitchens and dining-rooms, but by reason of the prevalence of an epidemic we have lost many hundreds ; so that for several months past we have kept on hand a very few, hoping the disease would eventually expend its force and die out.
Table Fourteen - Gives the expenditures per month, other than for maintaining cost, aggregating fifty-six thousand six hundred and ninety -nine and seventy-eight one-hundredths dollars.
At the conclusion will be found a statement of assets and liabilities. This is the general balance sheet, showing assets and liabilities. The liabilities are, of course, set down correctly, but the assets are in no case supposed to represent the true value of the property on hand, except in the case of goods in store. To illustrate: in the case of live stock the real value is, I suppose, about three thousand five hundred dollars, while it is set down at one hundred and seventy -five dollars. This comes from the complete system of bookkeeping by which purchases and sales are recorded, showing finally that the original cost has been as represented in the schedule. This result has been reached mainly by the purchase of hogs at a less price than sold for, they being bought light and increased in weight by fattening.
Labor of Convicts, other than those employed by Contractors outside the ivalls. - Brick-yard and excavations, 180; blacksmiths, 6; Butchers, 2; Carpenters, 4; cart drivers, 16; cooks for officers, 3; commissary department, 8; clerk's office, 2; gardeners, 10; kitchen help, 7; stable, 7; sweepers, 4; servants, 16; waiters, officers' dining-room, 4; wood-yai'd, 4; Avash-house, 5; Warden's office, 4; Warden's residence and gardens, 10; total 292.
Labor Inside the Walls - other than Contract Labor. - Bath-tenders, 2; brick -layer.s's gang, 10; barber shops, 12; boiler houses (2), 10; coopers, 2; cooks, 18; closet cleaners, 12; Captain of the Yard's office, 5; dining-room, 38; door tenders, 14; donkey engine, 3; engine-room, 3; gate-keepers, 8; gate, upper, 3; gate, lower, 3; hospital cooks, 5; Hood's gang, 7; hospital help, 8; lamp-room, 3; library and school-room, 95; mortar mixers and carriers, G; mattress makers, 3; painters, 5; plumbers, 4; room tenders, 12; shoe shop, 20; tailor shop, 10; tin shop, 5; turnkey's office, 4; wood-yard, 4; white- washers, 5: wash-house, 45; yard sweepers, 14; total inside, 394; total outside, 292. Total employed for State and at school, 686. Of this number about 85 are kept at school, the whole of them being boys; leavinsf the number who labor other than for contractors, 601. Whole number employed inside the shops, on an average, 300; inside in other, capacities, 394; outside in various capacities, 292; total number employed, 986.
This leaves a surplus of over five hundred that must be kept in close confinement. We recognize the great wrong thus done these prisoners, but we are powerless to remedy the evil. It will be understood that all attempts at order and discipline with five hundred convicts at large in the prisonyard would be absolutely futile. We do the best we can for these convicts by letting out a limited number at a time for exercise by walking between the cells and in the rear yard of the prison. It will also be seen that in every case, except in the shop labor, we put on all the force possible to crowd in. This is not done because the work is done better or even so well with large gangs, but to give the prisoners exercise and air. In many cases one-quarter of the force employed would do the work better. Much of the labor done by these men is of a purely penal nature, and for exercise and air, being of little utility, and bringing no return.
Turnkey's Report. - From the Turnkey's report, Table I, it will be seen that the total number of prisoners received at this institution since its foundation, in 1851, has been nine thousand three hundred and twenty, and that the total discharges have been seven thousand seven hundred and fiftysix, leaving now in prison one thousand five hundred and sixty-four: -
Table III - Gives the nativity of prisoners. To this table I call especial attention, particularly the nativity of the foreign criminals, and the percentage from each country. This table, just as here presented, would be a powerful argument with which to met our Eastern friends, who think Chinese immigration a blessing. It will be seen that our population is: -
Table IV - ^Makes a classification of crimes, for which prisoners have been convicted, and the number to each. From this table it will be seen that over five hundred prisoners, one third, nearly, of all, came here for burglary and other crimes connected with burglary and attempts at burglary. It will also be seen that two hundred and nineteen are here for highway robbery and attempts at robbery. I call especial attention to these two classes, and beg to suggest that their punishment is not sufficiently severe to deter the -regular professional from engaging in his calling. There are large numbers of burglars here serving out sentences, ranging in duration from one to two years; and there are large numbers of highwaymen here who stopped stages and travelers, intending to take life if they encountered resistance, . serving sentences of from three years up. This appears wrong, and it is wrong, but it may be partially remedied by proper legislation, and prison life made laborious.
Under this table, the fact will be noticed that ninety-seven prisoners are held for life. This, I believe to be wrong, for to every one should be left grounds for hope that some day they may be free. This applies to those who are in for thirty and forty years, and who in the regular course of nature can only be set free by death. A little conditional clemency by the Executive would light up the gloomy hearts of these wretched men with a hope that would at least drive out despair. This must be done to make anything of them other than brooding, plotting, unreliable, unsafe, treacherous, and unhappy criminals. This is natural, for the prisoner who despairs of ever earning his freedom, only awaits his opportunity for murder, if thereby he has the least chance of escape.
From this table it will be seen that there are four hundred and seventy prisoners twenty-five years old and under ; two hundred and seventythree, twenty-two years old and under ; two hundred and two, twenty-one years and under ; one hundred and forty-four, twenty years and under ; one hundred and one nineteen years old and under ; sixty-nine, eighteen years and under : thirty-six, seventeen years and under ; eighteen, sixteen years and under ; seven, fifteen years and under, and two children of fourteen.
It is safe to estimate that seventy-five per cent, of these unfortunate boys have been exiled from home, to adopt a course of crime, by the drunkenness and cruelty of parents.
They nearly all tell the same tale of misery, want, intemperance, parental neglect, and cruelty. If it is the fault of the laws and of society that these boys have become criminals, then they should be peculiarly the care of the public whose fault is their ruin. Idleness in almost every case has proved the downfall of these boys, nor has this resulted from their own choice, but because employment could not be obtained. The work they would gladly have done has been performed by the Chinaman, and they have been turned from door to door until despair and absolute want have driven them to the commission of crime. In nearly all cases theirs were crimes against property, such as are only committed by the suffering - those in want of shelter, clothing, and food. Less whisky and more work would have saved nearly all of these boys to society, many of them to become its best ornaments and most useful men.
It will here be seen that San Francisco sends to the State Prison five hundred and twenty-five ; Alameda sends sixty-three ; Los Angeles sends sixtyfour ; Sacramento sends eighty-six ; San Joaquin sends eighty-four ; Sacramento and San Joaquin have the largest per centage of criminals; Los Angeles and Alameda next ; Del Norte, Alpine, and Trinity being the lowest, and Sutter next.
It appears from this table that an exceedingly undue proportion of cooks have been so unfortunate as to commit crimes, the number being set down at one hundred and four. It also appears that six hundred and forty-eight give their calling as that of laborer. It would be safe to estimate that not ten per cent, of the number ever earned a living by labor, hence they are convicts.
From this table it appears that two prisoners are serving out their seventh term ; four, their sixth ; fifteen, their fifth ; twenty-four-, their fourth ; eighty -two, their third, and two hundred and fifty, their second. From this it will be .seen that of one thousand five hundred and fifty-four prisoners, three hundred and seventy-seven have been returned and are serving beyond their first terms. It appears from this that not quite one-fourth are now serving other than their first sentences.
At the Auburn Penitentiary, New York^ there are one thousand one hundred and ninety-three, of whom two hundred and eighteen are serving beyond their first sentence. This is nearly the same percentage as ours, but not quite so large. At the Clinton (New York) penitentiary there are three hundred and sixty-five convicts, one hundred and eighteen serving beyond their first sentence. This shows a very much larger percentage of returns than is found in our prison, being a fraction less than one-third of the whole. I am unable to find any record of the returns to the Sing Sing Prison, although [ have the latest annual report of the Warden and Superintendent.
Table XI - Is an exhibit of the workings of the " Goodwin Credit Bill,'' passed by the last Legislature. The change from the law of 1864 is not great, chiefly benefiting three, four and five-year convicts. The law as it now stands is an exact copy, so far as the credits are concerned, of the law governing the same subject in New York. I believe it to be a good law, and that it should be allowed to remain without amendment.
Following the Turnkey's report will be found that of the Moral Instructor, to which I refer with great pleasure. The report is so complete within itself I need do no more than refer to it, and to express my entire satisfaction with the good results obtained by the unremitting care and attention of that faithful ofiicer.
Lastly, I refer to the very able report of Dr. Pelham, the Prison Physician. Like that of the Moral Instructor, it is so full and complete within itself that it needs no explanatory remarks.
Before closing this report, I respectfully call attention to the law passed four years ago, and known as the " GifFen Bill." This Act is, in many of its provisions, in direct conflict with the new Constitution, and, to prevent complication, ought to be repealed at the earliest time possible. Even had the new Constitution never been adopted this law, in my judgment, would have resulted in nothing good, but would have been productive of much evil. Two years ago I recommended its repeal, believing then, as I do now that if allowed to remain on the statute book until the first of January, 1880, the time fixed for it to take eflect, that evil would result from it.
In closing this report I congratulate the faithful officers here upon the provisions of the new Constitution, setting the prison management beyond the uncertainties of political strife, and making it a non-partisan institution . The people's decision, that a man's qualifications for prison management shall not be determined by his politics, will, doubtless, abate the severity of the 7naGhine and cause the selection of the fittest. I hope for good results under the new system about to be inaugurated.
Report of the Moral Instructor. - The school and library department of the prison was reorganized and placed under the present management on the 13th day of May, 1878, at which time there were enrolled fifty-four pupils. The whole number enrolled as members of the prison school to June 30, 1879, is one hundred and forty -six. The ages of the' young men who have been under instruction range from eighteen to twenty-two years; the average age is about eighteen years.
The school is divided into five classes, and for each class a competent teacher has been appointed. Great care has been exercised in the selection of teachers. Several had had some experience in teaching previous to their
The greater number of the boys enrolled had received but little or na education; twenty-six were unable to read or write at the time of their commitment; fifty were only able to read imperfectly in the first reader; fifty-two had some knowledge of the first principles of arithmetic, while but eighteen had made that degree of advancement in their studies which might reasonably be expected of boys twelve years of age during one year's regular attendance at any well conducted school.
The nativity of the pupils is classified as follows: - Native born of native parentage, forty; native born of foreign parentage, seventy-seven; foreign born, twenty-nine. Total, one hundred and forty six.
Nearly all the boys admitted to the school had been convicted of burglary or grand larceny, and sentenced to imprisonment for terms ranging from one to three years. A very large proportion of them appear to have never been subjected to parental control or home training. They had never been given any regular employment, taught to work, nor required to attend school.
Thus, free from restraint, permitted to mingle freely with the criminal class, and left without intellectual or moral training, it is no cause for surprise that so many neglected and unfortunate boys become criminals who, under more favorable circumstances, might have become useful members of society.
The boys in general had never attended school a sufiicient length of time to derive much benefit therefrom, and had neither the knowledge, the habits, nor the inclinations of scholars ; neither had they any j ust appreciation of the value of mental culture. Under these circumstances their deportment has been better and their advancement greater than we had reason to expect. The intellectual advancement of many has been truly gratifying to all who feel an interest in their welfare.
Mental training has had its usual beneficial influence, and doubtless some improvement has also been made morally as well as intellectually. They have been separated as far as practicable from older and more hardened criminals, and required to pass each day, under the supervision of the teachers selected, with direct reference to mental and moral characteristics, as well as to their literary acquirements. And while they have been rendered temperate in their habits by necessity; prohibited the use of profane and obscene language ; and compelled to present the appearance of sobriety and respectability, some at least have been prepared to carry away with them their acquired good habits, and afterwards to practice through choice the habits at first enforced and afterwards rendered easy and familiar by continued practice.
evident that a prison is a very poor place for the moral and intellectual training of children, and it is greatly to be desired that discretionary power be given to magistrates to use other means of punishment than imprisonment in the case of juvenile offenders. The Prison library contains 3,118 volumes, among which are to be found many standard works on history, biography, travels, science, theology, poetry, and general literature. The present collection has been made up principally from donations of books made by the Mercantile, Mechanics' Institute, and Odd Fellows' Libraries, and from private contributions by the friends of prison reform in San Francisco and elsewhere.
A valuable and popular department of the library consists of several hundred bound volumes of magazines. The periodicals contributed and collected from various sources have been assorted, arranged, and bound into volumes in the book-bindery connected with the library, where several prisoners have been constantly employed in binding and repairing books.
The privileges of the library are extended to all the prisoners who comply with its rules and regulations, and its influence has been highly beneficial. From the want of sufficient employment in the workshops a large proportion of the prisoners have been compelled to spend most of their time in their cells, and to these the privilege of drawing books to give them mental employment is invaluable.
Many have thus acquired a taste for reading, and have become familiar with the works of the best authors ; others have made an earnest effort to remedy the defects of their earl}^ education, and, with such assistance as was available, have made good progress in their studies ; while others have made a special study of some foreign language, or of some branch of natural science, theology, or mathematics, and have added greatly to their knowledge of these different subjects.
The prisoners who have thus availed themselves of the facilities proffered to them have not only improved their tastes and acquired an increased store of knowledge, but have also strengthened their mental powers, and have been in some measure prepared to regain the confidence and esteem of their fellow-men, and to become industrious and useful citizens.
If the library did nothing more than to afford an occasional hour of relief and pleasure to the prisoners it would indeed be doing a good work but it effects much more than this; the works of the best authors diligently read in most of the prison cells cheer many a sad life with glimpses of other scenes and better things.
The religious services have invariably been attended by as many prisoners as could obtain seats in the chapel. Respectful attention has always been given to the clergymen of different denominations who have volunteered to visit the Prison alternately, and instruct the prisoners in religious truths. Several of these gentlemen have, for many years, been accustomed to visit the Prison regularly, and conduct the religious services, and are hio-hly esteemed by the prisoners. Many appear to have been deeply impressed with the instructions received, and strengthened in their resolutions to return to a course of sobriety and virtuous industry, and encouraged to undertake and make efforts to persevere in an honest way of living.
To the volunteer clergymen, and especially to the General Agent of the Prison Commission, we are greatly indebted for their faithful and punctual attendance at the hour set apart for religious worship, and also for a large supply of books, magazines, and newspapers, collected from various sources and forwarded to the Prison library.
Prisoners have been furnished with stationery without charge, and encouraged to write letters to their friends as often as they have thought necessary. All letters written by prisoners, and also those addressed to them and received at the Prison, have been carefully examined ; and the number thus received during the year has averaged about 2,300 a month.
During the past year, transportation to their former residence or elsewhere has been provided for two hundred and six discharged prisoners, of which number I have been given tickets, - two to British Columbia, fifteen to Oregon, three to Washington Territory, sixteen to Nevada, and one hundred and seventy to various points in California.
Medical Department Report. - In submitting for your consideration my biennial report pertaining to the medical department of the California State Prison, I will glance at certain matters of complaint and suggestions of improvement to be made in its condition, to which your attention was called in my last biennial report. The condition of embarrassment, inconvenience, and annoyance existing at that time, resulting from the preceding disastrous fire, have all, happily, been dissipated by the wisdom and energy of your Board, the liberality of the Legislature in affording the necessary appropriation of money, and the efficient, prudent, and active zeal of the Warden and other officers of the Prison, whose duty it was to bring order out of chaos. As one of the results, the medical department is now amply supplied with all the room required, and all the improvements and material called for by me in the report referred to, and also sufficient cell capacity for the accommodation of all the convicts. Notwithstanding so much has been accomplished, and the time and energy of those properly in charge has been taxed at all times to their full capacity, there still remains unprovided for the matter of the guards' quarters, which was referred to by me in my last report in the following words: -
"The sleeping apartments assigned to the night guards are not sufficient in space or ventilation for the demands of health, and the main draught of air that reaches them is blown over the surface drainage of the kitchen and a contiguous lot of old decaying shed-rooms about two hundred feet in length, that stand against the outside of the south part of the east prison
^vvall, their contents adding to the impurity of the atmosphere. It is necessary that these sleeping rooms should be less crowded and better ventilated, and that the old buildings referred to, together with the officers' water-closet be removed, and that different arrangements be made for the vegetable depot, which at present is one of the shed-rooms mentioned."
Occupying a position that necessarily brings me in close contact with the convicts, affording me ample opportunity for observation, and influencing only in a slight degree their management, control, and discipline, being to «ome extent an independent observer, it is with pleasure, not divested entirely of pride, I notice that there has been a marked and very great improvement effected during this administration in the discipline and gov- -ernment of the Prison, and the disposition of the prisoners. This happy state of affairs is due to the attention given to the subject by the Directors, the efficiency and the humane disposition of the Warden, and the energy and zeal of the officers in the discharge of their respective duties. An important factor in producing this desirable change, is the introduction of the system of credits for good behavior provided for in a law of the last Legislature commonly known as the " Goodwin Bill." The operation of this law effected a marked change for the better in the deportment of the convicts, and therein greatly aided the officers in enforcing discipline and lessening at once the number of cases necessitating corporal punishment, and resulted also in improving their sanitary condition, for it is a well-known fact that the mental status of the prisoners materially affects the vital organs, and that the death rate and disability list is influenced greatly by a tendency to cheerfulness, contentment, etc. From observations of its practical effects, it is evident to me that it is an excellent law, happy in its influence for good, and lessening positively the arduous labors of the officers whose duty it is to maintain order and enforce discipline, accomplishing all these ends without producing that degree of degradation which educates convicts to become utterly outlaws and desperadoes.
I have to report a great change for the better in the habits of the convicts in reference to the loathsome and degrading crime of self-abuse and its kindred associations, which I referred to in my last report as prevailing at that time, from which the following is an extract: -
"The great evil presenting for remedial action in prison life is self -abuse, a vice that undermines the constitution and debases the moral instincts more than all other causes combined. It kills body and soul; and if the subject of this vice is so fortunate as to serve out his sentence, he returns to the community a fit subject to adopt crime as a profession for life. This disgusting vice exists as a primary cause of the principal diseases with which convicts are afflicted, and to repair the resulting injury is the principal study of the Prison physician; and its eradication is also of primary importance in a moral point of view."
This change is marked, and the number of cases now presenting for medical relief, from the vice itself and inj uries resulting physically and mentally therefrom, have very materially lessened.
From the accompanying tables, to which your attention is called, it is apparent that the health of the Prison has been excellent, and that there is a remarkable degree of exemption from diseases common to cell life, originating from blood poisoning called zymotic, and also of malarial origin, the few cases occurring of this class having received the germs of disease before their arrival here. But there has been an increase in the number of chest diseases, and the death rate from this cause has been augmented. This is mainly caused by the sudden change of temperature, produced by the removal of the convict from the close air of the cells to the cool atmosphere which is common here in the early morning. As a rule in these cases, the subject visits me suffering from a cold, more or less severe, affecting the first air passages. The same cause of disease still operating, the case may present itself with chronic inflammation of the larnyx, phondix, or trachia, some one or more of these organs, which by easy grades passes to chronic bronchitis, and finally terminating in bronchial consumption. But by reference to the column of unclassified diseases, which is mainly made up of cases of this character, it appears that the ratio of cases originating from this cause is exceedingly low. The remedy for this state of affairs would be the confinement of the prisoners in their cells until a late hour in the morning, a thing which is impracticable in a work-prison.
By reference to accompanying tables you will see that the ratio of deaths to all reported cases of sufficient magnitude to. require medical attention, is one per cent., and to those which were diagnosed and classified, two and sixtjT'-four one-hundredths per cent. All cases that were aggravated at their inception or then indicated such condition during their anticipated course, and all persons who were physical " wrecks" at the time of their reception in the prison were treated in the hospital, consequently the ratio of deaths for those treated in the hospital only, gives no practical intlication of the sanitary condition of the prison. The death rate of this class of cases is twenty -five per cent.
The question afiecting the best manner of conducting a prison is one of magnitude, requiring for its solution great experience and thorough practical knowledge of the subject in all its bearings, and will, probably, for many years, like the tax question, be antagonized by diversified views. Persons generally of the least experience will give tone to public opinion and shape legislation in the premises. In the discussion of this subject, two antagonizing ideas are generally advanced: one of which contemplates a course of discipline, having as an objective point the infliction of misery, degradation, and shame in the extreme, thus dissipating the last relic of humanity in the subjects and degrading them to the level of the brute creation ; the other.
from an opposite standpoint, are influenced by a maudlin sympathy, affecting them to such a degree that they would condone all crimes, and, in fact, impress into the minds of the convicts the idea that they were a badly misused class, improperly deprived of their liberty, and that a system which holds to punishment following conviction for crime is morally and radically wrong - thus advancing doctrines which, if prevalent, would be utterly subversive of all government, and equally as detrimental in its effect on communities and the family circle, where it would become the germ for misdemeanor and the progenitor of crime.
I do not intend to attempt the task of reconciling these discordant ideas, or of suggesting a happy medium, if there be one, or of offering a solvent for the subject matter, but will content myself with a short reference to some of the bearings of the question that pertains more particularly to the medical department. It is apparent to me that the aggregation of convicts as practised in this prison, and which is necessarily unavoidable from the construction of the prison buildings, and the system of labor utilized, is clearly injurious to their health and morals, renders the duty of enforcing discipline more arduous, and is disastrous in its effect on every phase of the question of reformation. On the other hand, the silent non-intercourse system affords punishment not accompanied by the degree of degradation which accompanies the present plan. It avoids the general recognition and familiar acquaintance of one with the other, and carnal intercourse, which is detrimental to health and morals, and prevents identification elsewhere, which is so prolific of evil to those who leave here with serious intention of reforming.
I favor, then, the silent, non-intercourse single cell plan generally, and for this prison as near approach to the same as the exigency of the case will admit, as a promoter of health and morals, and a preserver of self-esteem and manhood, and the germs of virtue, which are found in all who are not totally depraved, these principles being essential ingredients in the consideration of the question of reformation.
The First Presbyterian Church of San Rafael. - The following interesting record of this church we glean from a sermon preached by the <ilev. James S. McDonald, July 16, 1876, which has been courteously furnished by that gentleman. For something like a year previous to the organization of the church, the Revs. Charles R. Clarke and W. H. Cain preached occasionally in San Rafael, but it is not known positively who was the first Presbyterian clergyman that ministered to the wants of the residents. The Church Records inform us that on September 26, 1869, religious services were held in the public school-house in San Rafael by the Rev, W. H. Cain, at the close of which the following request was read: - ^'San Rafael, September 11, 1869; We, the undersigned, do hereby request you, the Rev. W. H. Cain, to form us into an organization to be called the
First Presbyterian Church of San Rafael, under the care of the Presbytery of California and Synod of the Pacific. Signed, Ai Barney, Harriet B. Shaver, Euphemia Murray, Louisa B. Stillwell, Sarah J. Anderson, Jamef> Munley, William J. Dickson, David A. Brown, Jean H. Brown, R. Jane Dickenson, John McElnay, James S. McElnay, A. Elder." After the request was read, the above-named persons being present, with one exception, proceeded to the election of Ruling Elders, a proceeding which resulted in the choice of Ai Barney and D. A. Brown. On the day following, Monday, the 27th, a meeting was held in the Court House for the purpose of electing a Board of Trustees, the Rev. W. H. Cain being Chairman, and Judge Barney, Secretary, and resulted in the nomination of William J. Dickson, Alexander Elder, D. A. Brown, Ai Barney and J. C. Dickson, who were elected for one year, or until their successors were appointed. Hereafter the pulpit was occupied by Revs. W. H. Cain, A. Williams and A. W. Loomis until November 21st, when, at the end of the service, the Rev. Albert Williams, acting under commission from the Presbytery, completed the organization of the church by ordaining and installing the Ruling Elder elect and administering" the Sacrament of the Lord's Supper. From this date on till June, 1870, the church was supplied for one or more Sabbathsby various ministers. In addition to those already named, the Revs. P. V. Veeder, now a Professor in the Imperial College of Japan ; O. Hemstreet, Thomas Kirkland, James Woods, T. E. Taylor and E. Park held services for one or more Sabbaths. At a meeting held June 21, 1870, the Rev. Townsend E. Taylor was invited to take charge of the church for a year, a call which he accepted, entering upon his labors July 3, 1870. During his pastorate, which terminated July 20, 1873, sixteen persons united with the church, all but one of them by letter. In April, 1871, steps were taken towards raising a fund to purchase a church building lot, and about May 1st the present plot of ground whereon the church now stands was purchased at a cost of one thousand dollars. August 5, 1873, a meeting was convened, with W. N. Anderson, Chairman, and A. Lee, Secretary, when on motion of Mr. Barstow, a unanimous invitation was extended to the Rev. James S. Hawk, of Watsonville, to become pastor of the church. Mr Hawk accepted the call and entered upon his duties September 1, 1873. He was a man of marked ability and zeal. Owing to failing health he had been compelled to resign the pastoral charge of a large, influential and warmly attached church in Pittsburg, and came to this coast, hoping ta find relief and to continue his labors in the cause of God. With gradually receding strength and health he labored for a year with undiminished zeal, but in the verv meridian of life he was gathered to his Father. During the ministration of Mr. Hawk, five persons were admitted to the church. The congregation was once more left without a pastor. At the urgent request of some influential ministers and friends the Rev. James S.
McDonald visited and preached in San Rafael, November 1, 1874, in Masonic Hall, where regular services were held and for which a rent of twenty-five dollars per month was paid. As to the call of this gentleman the Records inform us: - "At the close of the public service in the Presbyterian Church at San Rafael, California, on Sabbath morning, November 15, 1874, a meeting of the congregation worshipping with said church was held, in accordance with notice given from the pulpit on the preceding Sabbath, for the purpose of considering and taking action as to the call of a pastor for said church. Rev. Dr. Burroughs, of San Francisco, who had preached the morning sermon, acted as Moderator; and, after stating the purpose of the meeting, offered praj^er. J. M. Haven was chosen Secretary of the meeting. Rev. Dr. Burroughs, in an appropriate and feeling address, presented the necessity and usefulness of the pastoral relation; and read from the Presbyterian Book of Church Discipline, the requirements of formal procedure to be observed in making a call. On motion of Mr. Trumbull, seconded by Mr. Dickson, it was unanimously voted that the meeting do now proceed to call a pastor. A call for nomination of pastor was made by the Moderator, and Mr. Dickson nominated the Rev. James S. McDonald of Eureka. A vote was taken, and Rev. Mr. McDonald received the unanimous call of the meeting. The Moderator then rendered thanks to God for the unanimity of the action which had been taken, and prayed for a Divine blessing thereon. On motion, a committee of three was appointed, consisting of Messrs. Trumbull, Haven and Cook, to present the call of the meeting to the Rev. Mr. McDonald. On motion. Judge Barney was appointed by the meeting to prosecute the call of Rev. Mr. McDonald through the Presbytery." The call was accepted and Mr. McDonald commenced the labors which he now continues, on January 5, 1875. Immediately on the assumption of the pastoral care of his parish, Mr. McDonald commenced earnestly to work for the erection of a suitable church on the lot which had been already acquired. He saw his noble efforts crowned with success by the opening of their present beautiful house of worship on the first Sabbath in January, 1876. The structure, including the furniture, is valued at six thousand dollars. Up to the time of writing there have been fifty members admitted to the church, while thirteen of these have united during Mr. McDonald's pastorate. The present membership is about sixtyfive. The Sabbath School numbers one hundred and thirty, and is superintended by Thomas B. Morris, while the Ruling Elders of the church are: - - Ai Barney, R. J. Trumbull, Thomas B. Morris and A. C. Nichols.
Methodist Church. - In the early history of San Rafael, religious services were held only occasionally ; the inhabit mts were few and settlements in the districts north of the Bay of San Francisco very sparse, hence a large territory was assigned to one minister. As early as 1851 or 1852, Rev. S.
D, Simmonds, now of San Francisco, held services in several places in Marin and Sonoma counties, and araono- these San Rafael was included. In 1859 L. K. Walker and A. L. Bateman alternately visited San Rafael and ministered to the people, gathering together the few Methodists and those of other churches who had settled there, and forming the nucleus of a society. As the inhabitants of San Rafael and the country north of the bay increased, the demand for more ministers and smaller fields arose, which was met in 1862 by the appointment of Rev. Noa i Burl m to San Rafael and one or two outposts. As yet the people as well as the pastor, were compelled to labor under many disadvantages, arising from want of a church building with services every Sabbath. These were held however in the old adobe Court House. Under the pastorate of Rev. A. J. Burlingame, in 1866 and 1867, as well as under that of Rev. B. W. Rusk in 1868 and 1869, the same order was continued as formerly, but in 1870, under the auspices of Rev. W. Hulbert, property was purchased and a neat church erected, which gave to the society a permanent home, without which an organization is apt to be unsettled and transitory. With the addition of property and building, a church anywhere is destined to have greater prosperity. The first pastor in the new edifice was Rev. Aaron Williams, who continued but one year when he was succeeded by Rev. Noah Burton, who continued for three years. At the se&sion of the Annual Conference, held at Powell Street Church, San Francisco, in 1875, Rev. E. A. Ludwick was appointed to the work in San Rafael, but after six months he was compelled to leave on account of impaired health, still during his short stay he endeared himself to church and people. During the remaining portion of the year until the session of conference the vacancy was filled by Rev. R. L. Harford, who had then lately arrived from the East. Rev. G. W. Beatty, successor to these, served the church acceptably for three years, when, at the session of Conference held in San Jose in 1879, Rev. W. M. Woodward was appointed pastor and still serves the church. Never was the prospect for continued prosperity more cheering than now, and never did Methodism stand on as firm a footing in San Rafael as at the present time. . With the foundation she now has she is destined to go forward in increasing prosperity,
Marin Lodge, No. 191 F. and A. M. - The first meeting for the organization of a Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons in San Rafael was held in Short's Hall, February 1, 1868, when there were nineteen Master Masons present, Henry McCrea being President and S. Bear, Secretary. Application was made to the Grand Lodge, and Dispensation granted June 11th, and the first meeting under such was had on July 1st of the same year, when the following officers were chosen : William N. Anderson, W. M. Oliver Irwin, S. W.; William L. Barnard, J. W.; Bradley Hall, Secretary S. Bear, Treasurer ; Thomas H. Hanson, S. D. ; Hiram C. Buster, J. D.
John P. Bustin, Tyler. The charter was granted October 15, 1868, to the following members : William N. Anderson. Oliver Irwin, William L. Barnard, Thomas H. Hanson, Stephen Holden, Hiram C. Buster, Kenry Kirk White; John Clarke, William Hunter, Daniel Olds, Sr., John P. Bustin, Bradley Hall, Solomon Bear, Aaron Schroyer, Ira Weid, William Holden. The present membership is forty -three, while the office-holders are: George W. Davis, W. M. ; William H. DeGroot, S. W. ; James P. Christieson, J. W.; C. Grosjean, Treasurer ; R. K. Weston, Secretary ; F. J. Jacobs, S. D.; C. E. Bartlett, J. D.; W. J. McElnay, Marshal; J. H. Bugbee, E. Nelson, stewards, and John Dixheimer, Tyler. Lodge meetings were originally held in Short's Hall, until their removal to their present commodious and wellappointed quarters on B street. Meets on the Wednesday on or preceding the full moon.
Lodge has gradually increased in strength until now its membership is fortyseven. It is in a flourishing condition, and meets in the Methodist Episcopal Church. Present officers: - A. T. Kerr, W. C. T.; Miss C. M. Perry, W. V. T. ; Mrs. Roville Gulclie, Recording Secretary ; Miss Ida Hughes, Asst. Secretary; Mrs. B. O. Burrough, Financial Secretary; W. M. Woodward, Treasurer; Palmer Shaw, Marshal; Miss Ida Taylor, Dep. Marshal; Miss C. Clark, R. H. S.; Miss Olivia Coulter, L. H. S. ; Miss Charlotte Weekes, Inside Guard; Houston Jones, Outside Guard; Miss Shaw^ Organist; Charles Miller, Grand Lodge Deputy; F. J. Jacobs, P. W. C. T.; Mrs. M. Fraitas, Chaplain.
March 11, 1878, the Charter members being the original office-holders, who were: - George W. Beatty, P. M. W.; Edwin Gardner, M. W.; S. M. Augustine, Gen. For.; O. Collister, Guide; Charles S. Barney, Recorder; A. La Rock, Financier; C. E. Bartlett, Receiver; Frank Jacobs, Overseer; John Woods, Inner Watchman; James T. Stocker, Outer Watchman. The membership in good standing is now twenty- five, while the present officers are : - S. F. Barstow, P. M. W. ; William F. Waite, M. W. ; Thomas Hansen, General Foreman ; Jacob Gardner, Guide; S. M. Augustine, Recorder and Medical Examiner ; J. H. Leszinsky, Financier ; H. Iverson, Receiver ; Edward Eden, Overseer ; James Duncan, Inner Watchman ; James F. Stocker, Outer Watchman. The Lodge meets in the Methodist Church on the first and third Tuesday of each month.
San Rafael and Coast Range Mines. - The following report will fully explain the probabilities, or rather, the possibilities of these mines, for we believe that their working has been suspended for a time at least.
To the Directors of the San Rafael and Coast Range Mining Com/panies, No. 64^6 Market Street, San Francisco - Gentlemen : - I have the pleasure to report to you, after having carefully examined the property of your respective companies, and obtained by information from others, much of interest to you in connection with them, that the mines are located in Marin county, about four miles from the town of San Rafael.
They lie contiguous to the line of the North Pacific Coast Railroad and the county road, east, and west from San Rafael runs nearly parallel to the general course of the outcroppings, which can be plainly seen to extend from near Fairfax station, on the above mentioned road, for about four miles, in a south eighty degrees west course.
The foot wall of syenite as well as the hanging wall, can be plainly seen at various points over the four miles, and show a very wide and true fissure, these walls being from two hundred and fifty to two hundred and seventy- five feet apart. The croppings at many places over the entire distance are very heavy, and on the " San Rafael mine," where I measured them carefully, they stand boldly above the surrounding soil to a height of from eight to ten feet, and show a width above the ground of eighty-five feet. I took from these croppings about nine hundred pounds of the ore, obtaining it from various places on them, and as fair an average of the ore, as in my judgment could be selected; this I retained in my possession and sent it to this city, and had about seven hundred pounds of it crushed and properly sampled by Messrs. Mendheim & Hofmann; sample bottles under their seal being delivered to my order. These I have had assayed by a number of assayers, who have made the following returns: -
William Gardner rejDorts by fire assay: - gold, twenty-five and one onehundredths dollars ; silver, ten and ninety -nine one-hundredths dollars ; total thirty-six dollars. J. H. McCrorey reports by fire assay : - gold, eighty -four and thirty-three one-hundredths dollars; silver, twelve and twenty -eight one-hundredths dollars; total ninety-six and sixty-one one-hundredths dollars.
A vapor assay made by an entirely new discovery shows wonderful and startling results, which I need not refer to here, as any of the other assays shows sufficient gold to pay well for working the ore.
Upon the mines no work had been done beyond surveying for roads to the tunnel location, as well as surveying for a tunnel site, building a boarding-house for miners, and blacksmith's shop near the proposed tunnel. A road from the county road to the mouth of the tunnel, can be made at a very small expense, nearly the whole distance requiring but the clearing out of the growth of the underbrush to make it suitable for all the ordinary uses. A side-track from the main line of the North Pacific Coast Railroad can be easily made, requiring little grading or other work than laying the ties and rails upon the ground.
Provenance
Text from History of Marin County, California ... Also an Historical Sketch of the State of California, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.