BlockBefore

Santa Barbara County, California - Chapter 18: Operations of the County Government, 1883

From HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. 8,554 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

24 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

8,554 words

Machine-read from scans of HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 18: Operations of the County Government

Operations of the County Government - Qualifications for Office - Conscious Greatuess - Court at La Graciosa - Lawless Element Among the Americans - County Jail - Roads - First Buard of Supervisors - Establishment of the First Newspaper - The Guzette - Military Company - Discovery of Gold Mines - Notice - City Government - Indian A ffairs - Big Storm - School Matters in 1856 - Delinquent Taxes - County Treasurer in Troable - Trouble for the Guzetle - Problem in Ethnology - Funny Jury - Banditti - Light- House - City Improvements Called For.

--spirit but the form of the law." Substantial justice may be done without the forms of law, and great outrages on the rights of persons and property are sometimes perpetrated under legal pretensions. Private quarrels and difficulties among the natives were often settled by a resort to arms or physical strength. The office of Alcalde was, to a great extent, advisory. When an offense of great magnitude had been committed, public opinion, led by the principal familics, who were almost hereditary arbitrators, would mete out wholesome punishment, and thus prevent a repetition of the crime. A jury trial was as far from the policy of the Spanish Government as an ecclesiastical trial for a criminal otfense would be in the United States. When put on either a grand or trial jury, the average Mexican had little idea of the law, consequently his oath to decide according to the law and evidence was an unmeaning ceremony. A few men among them, taught by the constant responsibility of maintaining law and order, were fitted for exercising judicial functions. Of this number we may reckon Pablo de la Guerra and Joaquin Carrillo, both of whom, though unacquainted with the American forms of law, and one not even acquainted with the language in which the laws were written, executed impartial justice, and gradually taught their countrymen the importance of trusting the settlement of the rights of persons and property with a higher tribunal than private vengeance. Sometimes, in the beginning of this system, a jury would acquit even a notorious criminal, thinking that the punishment was properly a right of the friends of the victim. As an instance in kind, the case of Ordaz may be mentioned. He was said to be the son of a priest, and, of course, illegitimate, inheriting the curse of violated moral laws in a double degree. It was said that he was a member of Solomon Pico's gang, and so heartlessly cruel that he was not considered respectable enough for membership in a band of highway robbers and was expelled. On one occasion, when practicing some kind of trick in horsemanship in Santa Barbara, he was so badly beaten as to get the laugh on him. A few minutes afterwards he obtained a weapon, and without further or other cause for offense, he instantly killed his successful rival. It was done in the presence of a multitude of persons, yet he was acquitted by a jury.

When murder was so cheap an offense, and likely to be committed on slight provocation, the necessity of self-defense often compelled persons who were far from being murderers to take life; and instances of this kind occurred where a slight misstatement of facts, or want of knowledge of the circumstances, would make the matter look bad. Of this kind was the affair, which occurred about October 1, 1851, between John Scollan and George Heavey, who acted for some time as Deputy Sheriff. Heavey had threatened Scollan's life, and the parties met in a lonely gorge between Santa Barbara and the Santa Ynez Ranch, the difficulty being about the ownership of land in that vicinity. Scollan came into town, acknowledged the killing of Heavey, but claimed that it was in self-defense, which, on an examination before a magistrate, was decided to be the case. If public opinion did not justify the act, it excused it, and he was not subject to any annoyance about it afterwards.

Qualifications For Office

It was to be expected that the natives should elect to office those whom they had learned to reverence and obey. It mattered little to them that few of their countrymen were qualified to execute the laws. They were not only ignorant of the laws, but their whole life had been spent, not in a lawless manner, but under a code entirely different in its details if not in general results. As Justices of the Peace, they would exert a sort of advisory authority; as Constables and other peace officers, they were out of place, as they were in acting as County Clerks, Treasurers, Deputy Sheriffs, or anything that required clerical functions. Many times native Californians were elected to office, the duties of which were a total mystery, and an American deputy was an unavoidable necessity; and hence an entire change of programme in the magisterial affairs often became necessary.

It must be said, however, that the Americans themselves were not wholly qualified for putting in motion the machinery of county government. Many of them were young lawyers, making their first flights in law and logic, inflated with a sense of the responsibility of the profession, and rather unfamiliar with the practical application of the principles laid down in Blackstone and Kent. The American law system was as mysterious to the natives of California as was the famous wooden horse to the Trojans, and contained in its body as many possible evils when it was once admitted into the civil citadel.

Among those who had only a common-school education upon which to base their administrative ability, the case was not less confusing. The apportionment of taxes, the appraisement of property, the collection and disbursement of the revenue to those who had never handled more money than would pay a month's board, were quite often beyond their comprehension, as they often are of older heads. They found the county out of debt, but they soon had evidence of their want of skill in a debt of $24,000, without a public building, road, or improvement of any kind. They seemed to have adopted the principle of using money freely when it was in the treasury, and when it was not to be had to issue promises to pay.

Conscious Greatness

A sense of importance characterized most of the officers under the new arrangement. To become a magistrate was to be elevated above the common people. It entitled a man to honor and respect: When the "court was in session" the dignity of the magistrate-had_init.something. awful, that. was not. to be trifled with. He stood in place of the great American Government. He spoke with the aathority of 40,000,000 of people. Behind him was the big guns and vessels aud armies.

Court At La Graciosa

A man by the name of Green, occupying the position of magistrate, was holding an inquest over the body of a min who had been killed there. The place of meeting was at the store or saloon, which was, in fact, the only public building in the settlement. While the inquest was being held, one of the Arrellanes, a family of wealth and character, came in, and, stepping to the bar in accordance with the custom of the country, asked fora drink. Unaware of the awful dignity of the magistrate who was presiding over the cadaver, he failed to remove his hat. The watchful Justice of the Peace, however, saw the offense, and with a magisterial frown fined the Don $5.00 for contempt of court. Arrellanes very respectfully apologized to the court, saying that be intended no disrespect; that he had often drank there, and had not considered the unusual circumstances of having a court in session. Now for the vindication of outraged dignity. In view of the eminent respectability of the offender, the court would remit the fine if the Don would stand treat for the crowd; so justice was placated.

Lawless Element Among The Americans

To add to the difficulties of maintaining law and order, a strong and active element among the Americans practically denied the authority of any officer, American or native. Jack Powers and his crowd, together with the Dunns, would have been troublesome customers even in the older States, where law and order were crystalized into custom. The daring and recklessness of such men begat a kind of admiration among the people, which, while it could not be considered esteem, was not wholly the result of fear, but was rather the respect paid to power. It must not be thought of Santa Barbara that that place alone had hero worshipers of that kind. The respect and sympathy for the James Brothers, in Missouri, one of the oldest settled States in the Union, are more deplorable than the actions of the " hounds" in Santa Barbara. In the first case the admiration for the men extended, in some degree, all over the Union; in the latter case the demoralization was but small in comparison, and, to some extent, excusable in a country just emerging from the chaos incident to war. Santa Barbara was no worse than other Californian towns, perhaps not quite so bad as San Francisco, where the hounds had several " runs."

In the election of 1853, the roughs laid a plan to capture the whole Legislative and other officers by setting the watches and clocks around the town back, so as to organize the election boards with their own men as officers. They succeeded so well, that

The elections generally went Democratic. Huse was, however, a Whig, and oftentimes received the entire Democratic vote, the highest compliment that could be paid him.

County Jail

In the year 1853 measures were taken to erect a secure jail. Proposal and plins were called for. Three plans were considered, coming from M. M. Phelan, Henry Barnes and George Black, the plan of the latter being accepted. It contemplated a building 40x184 feet, made of brick, with one large cell 14x14, and several smaller ones, lined with boiler iron. The price was limited to $6,000. W. I. Box's proposal to build it was accepted, with forfeiture of $500.00 for each day beyond December 1st, that it remained uncompleted. Henry Carnes, Isaac J. Sparks, and Antonio Ma. de la Guerra were appointed Commissioners to superintend its erection.

City of Santa Barbara. Polling place, house of Don Luis Burton. Inspector, Antonio Ma. de la Guerra; Judges, Luis Carrillo, S. B. Brinkerhoff.

October 12, 1853, the County Court instituted measures to purchase the house of Doiia Magdalena Cota, to be used as a Court House, to be paid out of the accumulated jail funds. Appraisers were appointed, and notice was given that the Court wished to occupy it immediately.

The facilities for transacting judicial business were very bad. The official papers were kept in an open case with pigeon holes, so that any paper could be abstracted or destroyed with little risk. The jail was a place where a prisoner was held more upon honor than any merits of a jail as a place of forced detention. The walls were adobe and the roof of tile. A stout jack-knife would enable one to dig through the walls in half an hour. A favorite way with the Indians to open an adobe corral, and take stock ont, was to saw down the walls with a rawhide lariat, an Indian on each side of the wall pulling the lariat to and fro. At this time the jail-room adjoined the court-room, and did not differ from it materially in character.

February 16, 1854, a petition was received from Francisco de la Guerra and others, praying for appointment of W. W. Twist as Sheriff, and also a communication in connection therewith, from Padres Ma. Jesus Gonzales, Antonio Jimeno, José J. Jimeno, and José de Jesus Sanchez. J. S. Smith also asked to be appointed Sheriff. The Court appointed Russel Heath as Sheriff; also Charles E. Huse as District Attorney, Heath resigning the latter position to become Sheriff.

April 3, 1854, Charles Fernald became Judge by the election of September, 1853, having held the position up to that date by virtue of an appointment of Governor Bigler. Judge Carrillo, of the District Court, administered the oath.

The question of highways began to be more frequently considered. Hitherto the ordinary means of travel, beyond a Spanish cart, was on horseback. A Spanish cart would run almost anywhere, but the gradual introduction of wheeled vehicles necessitated the construction of better highways. The county was laid off into road districts corresponding with the townships. District No. 1, from the southern boundary of the county to the Rincon; District No. 2, from the Rincon to the Rancho Del Refugio; District No. 3,to the San Luis Obispo County line. Supervisors were appointed as follows: -

First Board Of Supervisors

Up to 1854 the county business was transacted by the Court of Sessions. It was now entrusted to a Board of Supervisors, holding office for three years. The first Board was composed of Fernando Tico, Pablo de la Guerra, and Ramon Malo.

According to the report of the Treasurer, the amount of taxes collected in 1853 amounted to $20,172.29. This showed a considerable increase in the revenue. The receipts, beginning with 1850, were as follows: -

Establishment Of The First Newspaper

Notwithstanding Santa Barbara had set up claims as a metropolis, and even, at one time, laid claim to the capital ot the province, it never had a newspaper, and probably, until the coming of the Americans, never felt the want of one; in fact, none was printed throughout California, though an apology for a press and font of type, which had been used by a priest to print some religious tracts for the use of mission schools, was found at Monterey when the Americans took possession of that place.

Newspapers were not wanted. The information usually disseminated in a newspaper had no market value in California. The mission register kept a record of the births, marriages, and deaths, which made up the sum total of life. The rest, which was of consequence, was taught by the fathers, and so a newspaper was not necessary.

This Santa Barbara enterprise was inaugurated by R. Hubbard, T. Dunlap, and B. W. Keep. It was independent in politics and religion, with very little local news. It contained a highly colored account of a marvelously beautiful people discovered on the island of Terra del Fuego, 3,500 feet above the level of the sea. Both men and women were remarkable for personal beauty and gentleness of manner. They lived on fruits and milk, and were hospitable and brave, with a strong belief in religion. It is quite likely that all travelers, since that time, have been induced to remain and marry among that people, as none have ever come away to tell the tale. The new postage law, making the postage three cents on letters carried 3,000 miles or less, and ten cents on all-over that, was noticed. The Crimean war also received a line or two. The project of dividing California into three States was also discussed, and the measure condemned. The skeletons of two men, apparently murdered, were found between the Purisima Ranch and Santa Rosa. The loss of the Golden Age was also announced. In an article on the public schools, Don Pablo Caracela announced that the incredible number of sixty-five children were attending the public school. Considering the size of' the county, that it was 150 miles on the coast, and extended from the ocean to the Sierra Nevada, and included the large islands off the coast, the number was certainly astonishing. Among the advertisements were hair-dressing and repairing of clothes by D. B. Streeter; Pacific Express Co., and dry goods and general merchandise, by L. T. Burton & Co.; C. V. R. Lee, Attorney at Law; Pedro OC. Carrillo, Surveyor and Inspector of the Port; A. Flying & Brothers, blacksmiths.

The third page was in Spanish, and contained the same general news and a few items of Mexican and South American affairs. The fourth page contained mostly San Francisco advertisements. Price, $5.00 per year.

The second number contained an article on the fearful amount of crimes committed between Monterey and San Diego, on the lines of travel, and the discovery of more victims of the highwaymen. This was a beginning, perhaps, of the wave of public opinion, and vigorous executive measures which broke up Jack Powers' gang, for at this time he was in full career, and often made Santa Barbara his home; but it would probably have cost any man his life to have denounced Powers as a highwayman, for he had numerous friends, and, then, who knew anything about it? So men made it a virtue to mind their own business, and insure comparative safety by keeping a wise tongue. The absurdity of trying to keep prisoners in an adobe jail, was also the subject of a paragraph.

Military Company

During the summer of 1855 a company of mounted riflemen was organized, Henry Carnes being Captain, C. R. V. Lee, First Lieutenant, Charles Pierce, Second Lieutenant, G. Millhouse, Surgeon, and S. D. Johns, Secretary. The object of this was a love of military display, and, perhaps, also a probability that, in the disturbed condition of society, a military company would cause more respect for the laws and give greater security to life and property. The frequency of murders and the presence of numbers of persons in the town without any visible means of support, all tended to cause a general sense of insecurity. Perhaps, too, this year was about the time when, in the change of government, the old system had ceased to awe the lawless, and the new had not become respected.

Democratic Convention, 1855

The names of the delegates are given to show the political standing of the individuals: Township No. 1, Fernando Tico and Pacifico Sanchez. Township No. 2, Carpenteria - Juan Pablo Ayala. Santa Barbara - Joaquin Carrillo, Russel Heath, José Carrillo, José Lorenzano, Antonio Ma. de la Guerra, Pedro C. Carrillo, Juan Carrillo, Guillermo Carrillo, José Maria Covarrubias, R. G. Glenn. Township No. 3 - Antonio Maria de la Guerra cast three votes for the township.

The Whig party was in so hopeless a minority as to scarcely make any organization. At the election the 5th of September, Pablo de la Guerra received 321 votes, all others 60; Charles E. Huse, for District Attorney, received 252 votes, all others 1. The reader will perceive that the nomination for District Attorney on the Democratic ticket was left blank. This was to give the means of voting for Huse, who was a Whig, showing that sometimes a sense of the merit of a man is stronger than party ties. Russel Heath received the entire vote, 377. The opposition vote varied from zero to 60. Prohibitory liquor law - Yes, 39; No, 248. In San Luis Obispo, which formed a part of the Senatorial District, Pablo de la Guerra received 145 votes, to 8 of all others.

Discovery Of Gold Mines

Southern California was for a while the scene of as much excitement as Northern California was in 1848. Mariano Lopez, while watering his horse at a ravine on the College Farm, near the mission of Santa Ynez, picked up several particles of gold, which were forwarded to Santa Barbara and exhibited to the people. On the receipt of the intelligence, quite a number left for the place of the discovery. Gold was found in every gulch and ravine in the vicinity. John Kays, a well-known merchant of that time, visited the spot and reported that the men were making an average of $4.50 a day, which, perhaps, was quite as much as the Sierra Nevada miners averaged in the palmiest days, and thought that, with water and the machinery used in the Sierra Nevadas, the average would be at least $10.00 per day. The face of the country resembled the mining districts of the north, and the gold was much like that taken out on the North Yuba. It will be remembered that gold was discovered on this range in 1842, and worked until the retreat of Flores into Mexico in 1846. The location of the mines was about thirty miles from Santa Barbara, in a northerly direction. The travel across the San Marcos Ranch became so annoying that the Major-domo, Lopez, put up the following notice: -

"To all persons trafficking by the road to, or by, San Marcos, that if they do not present and report themselves at the dwelling-house, and if I shall meet or find them within the limits of said rancho, shall treat them as suspicious persons, and shall have them taken prisoners and hold them responsible for the consequences.

This style was rather more than the people cared about enduring, and was likely to produce a conflict between them and the ranch owners, but Dr. Den, the owner of the rancho, published a notice in the Gazette, over his signature, that the warning was given without his knowledge or advice, while he was in San Francisco; so the speck of a war-cloud blew over. Considerable gold was taken out of the mines, but they did not prove extensive or rich, and were soon practically abandoned.

City Government

The City Government had from time to time exercised the rights of removing nuisances and punishing disorderly conduct, and must needs have an income. Taxes were imposed as follows: -

The city also passed ordinances respecting the alienation of the city lands, providing that not exceeding 500 square yards should be deeded to those who had resided on the Jand forten years. To those who have resided on the lands three years, the land should be deeded on payment of fifty cents per lineal yard, measuring around the tract. Lands would be sold to those who had not resided on them, for a fair consideration, to be fixed by the Council; but in no case should a tract containing more than 500 square yards be sold to one person, and then only on his erecting thereon a house containing two habitable rooms, and inclosing the lot with a substantial fence.

It will be seen that the city fathers set their faces against land speculations. Certain lots were reserved for the following purposes, viz.: Nos. 215 and 197, to be called Washington Syuare; Nos. 299 and 3,000, to be called Junipero Square; Nos. 58, 59, 73, 74, 84, and 89, to be a public promenade or alameda. An ordinance was enacted, prohibiting the carrying of deadly weapons, also closing the places of business on the Sabbath.

Indian Affairs

Reports got into circulation that the Government contemplated the removal or discontinuance of San Sebastian Reservation, situated in the Tejon Pass, which constituted the only protection against the depredations of the Tulare Indians, who had in former times been a terror to the southern counties of California. The exposed situation of the ranches, extending, as they did, over immense extents of' territory, made them particularly liable to Indian depredations. It was estimated that 3,000 horses were stolen in 1851-52-53. Including the adjoining counties, the loss was estimated at 12,000. Life was always endangered, and frequently lost. Santa Ynez was actually stormed once, and the horses taken from the corral, while the owner and his family only saved their lives by barricading themselves in the house.

At San Cayetano a body of Indians surrounded the house, because a citizen, who had made himself obnoxious to them, was visiting there. The Indian depredations for three years for the southern counties was estimated at $200,000. It was the general opinion that the breaking up of the reserve would bring about a general Indian war.

Big Storm

"On Monday afternoon, a little before sunset, dark and portentious clouds arose in the northwest, and before morning the heavens were overspread and some rain fell. Early on Tuesday the wind began to blow from the southeast, and continued to increase in violence during the day, and at night had become terrific, attended with frequent showers of rain. A schooner, named liza Thornton, which had been previously hauled up on the beach, was driven inside of a cornfield and had a hole stove in her bottom. The sloop Mazzini was unable to make an offing and was beached by her captain and considerably damaged. - Two men who were in charge of her succeeded in swimming safely to the shore. The surt rolled in with great fury, and the mad force of the waves dashed into fragments the hulks of two large vessels, the Hallowell and Pilgrim, which, for several years, have been comparatively undisturbed by the tide. Many fences have been prostrated, but no serious damage done, so far as we have yet learned, except what is above stated."

School Matters In 1856

According to the Gazette the Spanish population of Santa Barbara County had hitherto manifested great opposition to having English taught in the common schools. This condition of affairs was changed during this season. The School Commissioners, Hull, de la Palma y Mesa and Huse, assisted by Geo. D. Fisher, County Superintendent, held an exumination of teachers: Present, Mr. Baillis, Owen Connolly, Victor Mondran, and Pablo Caracela. Owen Connolly and Victor Mondran were permitted to teach school for one year, beginning February 1st, unless the certificates were revoked. The monthly salary of teachers was fixed at $75. Thecertificate of Caracela was revoked, to take effect January 30th inst. One appropriation of the State School Fund was lost, through failure of the County Superintendent to report. An attempt was made in the Legislature to remedy the matter and permit Santa Barbara to receive her quota. It was urged in objection, that Santa Barbara had no school house; that the English language was not taught there at all. The failure to report was said to be in consequence of the want of mail facilities. The teaching of English was commenced this season, and the quota due Santa Barbara was, after some difficulty, paid over. The school tax of five cents on each hundred dollars, levied in 1854, began to bear fruit, and the schools were no longer a place for a helpless and useless man to draw a comfortable salary. Santa Barbara was particularly fortunate in having a teacher who could appreciate its beautiful surroundings. If the question should ever arise, Who discovered Santa Barbara? that is the Santa Barbara of the poets and esthetics, the following communications from the teacher of the only English school will forever settle the question beyond a doubt: -

"GENTLEMEN: I, and the pupils of my school, together with the people of Santa Barbara, rejoice at your entering upon the duties of your office as School Commissioners, and regard it as the advent of better times for the cause of education in this community. We therefore most cordially welcome and invite you to visit our school at as early a day as your other important duties will allow you. By your so doing we shall not only feel happy and encouraged, but also highly honored; and when you do come we hope you will not be wholly uninterested if the result should be no more than the finding of a large number of nice young ladies and gentlemen assembled together, cheerfully and eagerly pursuing useful and necessary studies.

"And permit me here to state for your information, that I have been teaching this school for nearly a year past at a salary of only $75 per month. I now respectfully and earnestly appeal to your honorable Board, hoping you will be kindly pleased to increase my salary, and thereby give us new impetus in the discharge of our laborious duties.

This communication not having the desired effect of raising his wages, he tried another, and this time, doubtless, did all that he could do in the way of eloquent writing. He introduced the subject by stating that the school was flourishing; that it numbered seventy-eight pupils between four and fifteen. Half the number were young ladies (whatever their age may be), one-third being Americans, the rest Spanish; that the best of feeling prevailed between the pupils; but that in consequence of the depreciation of the county scrip, in which he was paid, he felt obliged to tender his resignation.

"The studies under recitation, at present, are orthography, reading, penmanship, arithmetic, geography, syntaxical analysis, and grammar, of both English and Spanish languages. To this course I intend soon to add book-keeping, composition, and declamation, and also the higher branches, when the pupils are prepared to begin them. And it is to be hoped the day is not far distant when the visitors of these schools will have their eyes and ears greeted by the classics, the arts and sciences, for the cultivation of which Santa Barbara is peculiarly adapted to inspire a taste; with its climate, unsurpassed for mildness and salubriousness by any in the world; its picturesque and sublime scenery, both by land and sea; its beautiful and fertile valleys, abounding in evergreen and classic oaks, and gorgeously carpeted the greater part of the year with profusions of flowers, common to California but unknown elsewhere; its hot and cold springs of medicinal and lifegiving properties; its ancient churches and missions, whose dilapidated ruins still exhibit specimens of their former magnificence and grandeur; its pineclad hills and lofty mountains, scaling high the heavens, nodding to and picturing forth their God; its capacious harbor, into which noble ships and steamers come, all, all spreading out before the eye and imagination an everlasting feast of what is rich- est and rarest in nature, inviting alike the pen of the poet and the pencil and chisel of the artist and sculptor, and encouragement for agriculture and commerce. : : ; : ; .

" Finally, gentlemen, 1 have only to remind you that my salary is too small, and, even that, not paid to me, and you know as well as I do that munes invitat ad laborum, so that if you do not increase my salary, and pay me for my services, I herewith tender you my resignation. [ have the honor to be, gentlemen, your fellow-laborer in the best and most honorable of causes."

Delinquent Taxes

A list of some of the delinquents are given to show the rates of taxation on the large ranches: - Carrillo, José Antonio, 4 Lompoc and Mission in cantar barbaraae nse emeeeen cereeee 31 05 Valenzuela, Salvador, + Santa Clara .._...- 30 474 Villa, Joaquina, heirs of, Rancho Tequepis.- 6 90

County Treasurer In Trouble

We have several times referred to the fact that the books of the county were badly kept. The Treasurer, Raymundo Carrillo, had not reported according to law, and the Grand Jury, in accordance with their oath, reported the delinquency. As the consequences of the official investigation extend through several years, the affair will be fully described.

Presentment By The Grand Jury

"The Grand Jury of the county of Santa Barbara, upon their oaths, present the Board of Supervisors of Santa Barbara County, consisting of Antonio Maria de la Guerra, Esteban Ortega, and Juan Rodriguez, and declare the said de la Guerra, Ortega and Rodriguez have wholly failed and neglected to publish any report of the Treasurer, as enjoined upon them by law; and the Grand Jury declare that a report of the County Treasurer, made to the Board of Super- soever upon the condition of the public funds of this county, and upon the accounts of the Treasurer, been published by them since they have held the office of Supervisors, namely, since the last general election; and the Grand Jury further charges that the said Supervisors have not required the Treasurer to furnish a report at the regular sessions, as required by law, but have utterly and wilfully failed, omitted, and neglected to do so, and they have thus withheld from the public information which they were entitled to possess, and which it was the plain duty of the Supervisors to convey as is provided by law: " CHas. Pierce, Foreman of Grand Jury."

The names of the jury were Thomas Martin, Miguel Garcia, Vicente Garcia, Horatio Robinson, Martin Kimberly, Juan Garcia, Daniel Flying, W. D. Hobson, Francisco Leyba, Gervacia Ayala, José Carrillo, Pablo Valencia, Manuel Cota, Pascual Bottilleas, Chas. Pierce, José Olivera, and John Haskell.

"Since the publication, last week, of our views upon the propriety of exacting from the officials a full compliance with their public duties, and of our approval of the action of the Grand Jury in presenting the Board of Supervisors on account of their neglect to cause the reports of the County Treasurer to be published, we have heard it announced that we were actuated by improper motives, and were instrumental in bringing the matter to the attention of the Grand Jury. It is a part of our business, as journalists, to expose public abuses and grievunces, whenever they come to our knowledge, and no officer, however lofty his station, need expect that we shall be silent upon official neglect or misconduct that comes to our knowledge, if we suppose an exposure of them will have a tendency to cause their correction or remedy. From this course we shall not be deterred by low, muttered threats, or hostile insinuations from any quarter. We have long been aware of the bitter opposition to this paper, which has been, and still is, entertained on the part of some of the officials, who love darkness rather than the light, and of the obstacles which they have studiously thrown in our path. We can assure them that their unremitting efforts to withdraw us from the proper course of' our duties are utterly unavailing, and that the blows dealt upon us will recoil with double force upon their own heads. The acts of officials are public property, and we shall treat them as such. With the men, as individuals, we have nothing to do, but with their acts as officers we are concerned, and claim the right to comment upon them. So long as we have facts to go upon, and draw legitimate conclusions from them, we are sure that our patrons and the public will sustain us. If there be any, in such case, who carp at it, we shall regard them with the scorn and contempt which their degradation deserves. The threat publicly made by an official, the other day, that he would annihilate this press, we regard as supremely ridiculous, positively ludicrous, and we can scarcely suppress an outburst of cachinnation as we sit upon our three-legged stool and remember it. Let him be careful lest his infernal machine or fowgosse, which he may resort to for effecting his purpose, explode in his hands before he can set it under our office. We take it for granted that he meant a material annihilation, for we doubt if his stupid brain is capable of conceiving any other.

"We should be sorry to-haveit'supposed that we" were instigated by any individual motives in agreeing with the Grand Jury that those reports should be published. The paltry sum which would be paid for publishing them, in depreciated county scrip of uncertain value, is entirely too insignificant and trifling to attract or claim consideration for a single moment; yet we know that an obsequious set of vulgar sycophants, too timidly crouching and sneaking to make an open charge, have secretly and maliciously whispered and hinted, and given utterance to vague and intangible surmises that greed of pelf incited us to make the comments which we did, and to take the part which we have done. It is true that. one of us- gave testimony~ before the Grand Jury; it is also true that such attendance before that body of inquest was under a subpena, duly served by the Sheriff; and it is also true that the questions propounded to us were answered to the best of our knowledge, and we suppose it to be true that the presentment of the Board of Supervisors was, in some measure, based upon information which we had it in our power to give.

"These vipers who emit their venom against us would have wished us, no doubt, to perjure ourselves, and conceal from the grand inquisition anything derogatory to their bantlings. This is the only rational conclusion at which we can arrive, in view of the whole matter. If we have been the means of contributing, in any way, to the correction of a public abuse, and have conduced to the introduction of a more strict and faithful discharge of duty on the part of the officials, we may rejoice at it, however much the galled jades may wince. We hope to hear no more of this matter, for it is really too puerile."

"That the charges contained in the presentment are not sufficient to warrant the Court in instructing the District Attorney to draw an indictment thereon for the purpose of putting the parties mentioned upon their defense in this Court. The offense charged consists of an omission to which no penalty attaches criminally; and, further, the presentment does not charge willful and corrupt misconduct, which it would seem are necessary to form a basis of complaint for removal from office."

The matter came before the District Court, presided over by Joaquin Carrillo, a relative of Raymundo, the County Treasurer, and was sent to Los Angeles for trial.

August 5, 1855, the Supervisors requested the Treasurer, Raymundo Carrillo, to give a statement of the condition of the County Treasury, its debts and revenues, also amount of taxes in 1851-52.

A second communication was made to the Treasurer, requesting a statement of all moneys received from the imposition of fines. One to the District Attorney asked for a statement of all the fines imposed by the Justices of the Peace in Township No. 2.

August 17th the Supervisors again asked for information of the Treasurer as to the number and amount of county warrants that had been approved or authorized by the Court of Sessions.

September 27th the Supervisors settled with Raymundo Carrillo as County Treasurer, and his account for $577 was approved in full. From the appearance of the records it would seem that a portion of the Grand Jury, a majority of the Board of Supervisors, and the Gazette, which, of course, represented a portion of the public, formed a party, determined to bring Raymundo Carrillo and his Deputy, Henry Carnes, into the position of embezzlers of the public money. The amount in dispute was about $4,000. The cases were brought before the Court, but postponed to the next term, when they were dismissed without trial. The Supervisors eventually made a settlement which did not show the Treasurer to be a defaulter.

May 1, 1856, the Gazette contained an editorial, complaining of the want of an active city government which should repress disorders and crime.

"Tt does not sound well to hear it said that, since the incorporation of this city, more than six years ago, not a single public improvement of general utility has been made, if the survey and maps be excepted. Not a single street has been graded at the public expense, nor an artesian well sunk, nor a gulch filled up, nor a tree planted, nor a school-house constructed, nor a public edifice of any sort even projected, nor a wharf at the landing attempted or planned, or its cost estimated."

A report was circulated that Bishop Amat proposed to build a new church, and convert the old one into a nunnery. The Gazette asked whether it indicated an advance in civilization, or retrogression towards the medieval ages? A writer took up the subject as follows: -

«" EDITORS OF THE GAZETTE - Gentlenen: I read with some surprise a paragraph in the last number of your paper, which, after stating that a cathedral would soon be built here, continues thus: -

" Report further says that, on the completion of the cathedral, the building now used as a cathedral, will be converted into anunnery. Quere. Is this an evidence of the progress uf civilizatio, nor does it indicate a retrogression towards the medieval ages?

"Now, Sirs Editors, I previously thought your policy was neutral in politics as well as in religion, but, at the same time, must freely confess that, although the paragraph was ushered in under the imposing 'we' of journalists, I believe it was written by some of the highly educated gentlemen of our little community, who, on all occasions, endeavor to exhibit their profound learning, and indulge their unmitigated bigotry towards the religion of the majority of the inhabitants of the South.

"The gentleman, whoever he 1s, who put the learned ' quere,' no doubt, not alone, expects that all of his color would give a unanimous assent to the latter part of the sentence, but his learning and bigotry would be equally shocked if anyone would have the temerity to doubt a conclusion at once so logical and so well established. So he thinks.

" Now, Sirs, I, for one, will not give in my adhesion to the latter part of the celebrated 'quer¢,' because I am firmly convinced, and it is an admitted fact, that the medisval ages would be dark were not the learning and the arts preserved most sacredly by the monks, who devoted their lives, not alone to the service of God, but were solely instrumental in the preservation of the learning handed down to posterity.

"Tt is not necessary for me, Sirs, to defend the institution of the Sisters of Mercy; their fame, virtues, and holy labors, are not only potent, but appreciated by the world. Yet there are some young gentlemen whose delicate nerves are discomposed at the mere thought of lovely ladies being shut up, and buried in a cloister, instead of being ornaments of society they voluntarily fly from, while the sensitive gentleman is left to mourn in hopeless bachelorhood!

"Enough, Messrs. Editors. I am sick of an exhibition of sneering ignorance, bigotry, and intolerance, and regret that your sheet was made the medium of its dissemination.

Editor'S Reply

"We know of nothing ever published in this paper since we controlled it, trom which Roman Catholic could infer that its ' policy was neutral in politics and religion.' We claim to be independent in both. His communication seems intended to be a thrust at some one, but whom it may be, we know not, and care less. How he comes to believe that the paragraph referred to was written by some one of those ' highly educated gentlemen,' as he styles them, is rather strange, as it is not embodied in any communication, and we suggest that this expression of his belief is not very courteous to ourgelves. We have to inform him that his belief is entirely erroneous. We can discover nothing in the 'quere' which smacks of any 'attempt to exhibit profound learning,' or which discloses any 'unmitigated bigotry:' We do not wish to undertake to follow him in the description of the character of 'monks who were instrumental in the preservation of learning banded down to posterity.' We do not profess to know much about posterity, tor we are not seers, and will therefore content ourselves with affairs of the present. We do not deny that we are young, and if this be a reproach, we candidly confess that we merit it. Being of robust constitution, however, we hope to outgrow it in time. Really, we think, that if 'Roman Catholic' will calmly examine his communication, he will find it open to some of the very charges which he studiously seeks to direct against us, or somebody, by perverting the paragraph in question, and striving to wrest and extort from it a meaning, which the plain import and construction of its terms will not convey.

"We wish to have it distinctly understood that our columns cannot be used by anyone for the purpose of attacking a private individual or class of individuals, or as a vent for malice or private hostility, from whatever cause it may proceed. We have, in this instance, admitted the foregoing communication, with all its objectionable features, because it is signed by one who may, perhaps, represent a class of our subscribers for whom we entertain high respect. They need have no fears that this paper will array itself against their faith or doctrines, but they will also understand that it is not to be drawn into a labored advocacy of them by opposing those of any other class. We like the doctrine of the widest

The object in admitting these things into a permanent history is two-fold; 1st, to show the temper. of the times, and 2d, to show how the paper, by imprudent speech, gradually alienated its supporters, until it was compelled to supend publication.

Problem In Ethnology

May 22, 1856, being Corpus Christi day, was made the occasion of festivities, and according to the custom of the country, as Cesar would say, many of the participators got hilarious, on the aguardiente, and fell by the wayside, so that the city marshal had to provide them with free lodgings. Many of the rioters were Indians, and, as a severe law had been enacted against selling liquors to Indians, the occassion was favorable for a multitude of petty suits. Several merchants were fined for the offense, but in the course of the investigations, the matter of '' white man or Indian," so mixed was the population, was difficult to determine. One of the merchants, a respectable and influential citizen, was accused of violating the law, by selling to a Yaqui native. The trial for misdemeanor was before Antonio de la Palma y Mesa, the question of guilty or not guilty resting on the decision, whether a Yaqui was a white man or an Indian. An immense amount of ethnological lore was brought to bear on the case, in which the origin and locality of the white races, the requisite shades and facial angles requisite to make a man an Indian, were fully set forth. Expedience, or rather the inexpediency, of making a respectable merchaut guilty of a misdemeanor, won. the day, and the learned Justice decided that the prominent cheek bones, yellow skin, straight, black hair, and and dark, black lustre eye of the Yaqui were the effects of climate and not of heredity, so the Yaqui was a white man, and the very eminent and respectable merchant, who sold him liquor, had not violated the law which prohibited the sale of intoxicating liquors to the Indians.

Funny Jury

The ludicrous trials did not all occur before the Spanish Justices of the Peace. During the summer of 1856 some farmers at Carpenteria got into difficulty about the right to mow grass on a certain lot. John O'Connor and James McGlockin were arrested for assault and battery, one McDonahue being the complaining witness. The case was brought before Valentine Hearne, Esq. O'Connor was tried first, and, after listening to the testimony, the jury retired and, after due consideration, brought in a verdict of guilty against McGlockin, who had not been put upon trial! Upon being sent back they returned with a verdict of not guilty, and directed that the complaining witness, McDonahue, should pay the costs. McGlockin was then put upon trial and after a thorough investigation the jury brought in a veraccused of any misdemeanor. A bystander suggested that in view of the unusual ability of the jury, the question as to "who struck Billy Patterson?" might be finally settled by that court.

Banditti

The following was about the last outrage that was perpetrated by a band of criminals for plunder. The unanimity of the people, both Mexicans and Americans, in the pursuit of the criminals, showed a growing sense of the importance of law and order.

"On Saturday last, at about eight o'clock in the evening, a series of crimes was committed at the Rancho of " Las Cruces," in this county. A party of six Mexican desperadoes entered two of the dwellinghouses and stole money to the amount of about $200. In one of the houses two of the gang bound with a strong cord the hands of a widow lady, some sixty years of age, who resides there, and committed violence on her person. One Thomas Romero, a resident of Monteceto, who was tarrying there, was shot in the breast; the ball traversed a thick part of the door behind which he was standing. * * * The reports of three outrages reached this city about ten o'clock, on Sunday. The messenger brought a letter from Las Cruces, and two memorandum books, which were reported to have been dropped at the house by the villains who fired the pistol. The books contained several accounts with vaqueros, bills of sale of cattle, and other items, which pointed toS. C. Foy as the owner of them. This gentleman had passed through this city a week ago with a band of cattle, and suspicions were at once aroused that he had been robbed and perhaps murdered. A posse of nine well armed men was collected by the Sheriff and dispatched on the road leading to Las Cruces, which, by accessions at different points, was soon increased to eighteen. On Sunday evening news arrived that reinforcements were needed, and a requisition being made by the Sheriff upon the Santa Barbara Mounted Riflemen, a detachment of twelve members, armed and equipped, were promptly at hand and dispatched. The force which first started proceeded to the rancho of Las Cruces and ascertained that the occurrence was substantially as stated. Some of the party returned on Saturday and some on yesterday. They brought in two Sonoranians as prisoners, who will be examined before a magistrate to-day. Another Sonoranian named Jesus, against whom there is some evidence, succeeded in making his escape. Being mounted upon a fleet horse he eluded all pursuit. We have learned that Mr. Foy has been heard trom beyond the Rancho of Las Cruces, and it is therefore probable that he lost the memorandum books spoken of somewhere upon the road between this city and Las Cruces, and that they were picked up by the person who let them fall at the house."

The circumstances of this robbery and outrage were so heartless and savage that the community was thoroughly aroused. The necessity of a standing force was apparent. A supply of ammunition and rifles was obtained by subscription. Native Californians, as well as Americans, uniting in the matter. The fact of the robbers being (apparently) Sonoranians, between whom and the native Californians much ill-wilrexisted-on-account of tormer-raids; induced the Mexican population to co-operate heartily in bringiny the offenders to justice. The most of the band were subsequently captured.

Light- House

The light-house near Santa Barbara was built this season and was 38x20 feet with basement and two stories, walls of hard brick, window sills and caps, and stairs of granite; walls of hard stone and brick, eighteen to twenty-four inches thick; circular stairs to tower; doors and windows of eastern lumber, locks and hinges of brass; iron gallery on the summit of tower. G. D. Nagle, of San Francisco, constructor.

City Improvements Called For

The Gazette again called attention to the needed improvements; thought the visitors who came by every steamer would leave in disgust unless more attention was given to the streets and highways; suggested that the city fathers, from whom so much was expected, had fallen into some of the open wells with which the city abounded.

The Santa Clara River was said to be dry at its mouth. There was little feed on the hills, and many cattle were slaughtered to enable the rest to escape starvation, and there was a general reduction of the herds, although the drought bearno proportion in its disasters to the one a few years later.

Provenance

Text from HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.