BlockBefore

Santa Barbara County, California - Chapter 23: Santa Barbara Railroads, 1883

From HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. 11,359 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

23 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

11,359 words

Machine-read from scans of HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 23: Santa Barbara Railroads

Southern Pacific - Railroad Meeting January 5, 1870 - Numbers of Railroad Projects - Ambitious Towns - Railroad Meetings - Failure Indicated - W ar Between the Press and Times - Oppositioa - Dr. Shaw Vindicated - What No Railroad Means - Before the Supervisors, September, 1872 - End of the Railroad Project - Hollister to the Front - Huse to the Front - Sarcastic on Santa Barbara - Whoop 'em up Lively - Defeat of the Subsidy - New Efforts for a Road - Change of Base - Index, June 9, 1874 - Railroad Meeting in the City Hall - Meeting of February 5, 1876 - Railroad Bill - Board of Supervisors - Fourth Effort.

ALTHOUGH no great lines traverse the county, there has been, to use a Western phrase, "a heap" of talk and fight over the building of railroads, involving a great deal of effort. Even as a failure it was a credit to Santa Barbara, and can no more be left out of its history than other things which have resulted in success.

With the coming of the Americans in numbers came the project for a railroad. As early as 1868 the subject was agitated among the business men, and the benefits of a railroad communication to other parts of the world fully understood. In January, 1868, the matter began to assume shape, and an application to Congress was made for a charter to build a coast road and also asking for a donation of

~ land along the line of the route. The grant was made to the "Santa Barbara Branch of the Southern Pacific Railroad," and named James B. Shaw, Thomas B. Dibblee, Pablo de la Guerra, Francisco. de la Guerra, Thomas W. Moore, James L. Ord, John Scollan, Walter Murray, Jesse D. Carr, KE. B. Boust, O. L.

Maria Gutierrez, M. M: Kimberly, Marcus Harloe, F. A. Thompson, Robert Ord, Miguel Smith, Bascom Williams, Gaspar Orefia, N. B. Jacobs, Livingston McGowan, Robert Cushing, William B. Hyde, J. G. Foster, David R. Patten, William P. Bagley, and Richard C. Kirby as incorporators. It granted the right of way for 200 feet wide, also the right to take timber, earth, stone, or other material from the public lands for the construction of the road, necessary ground for turn-tables, switches, work-shops, and stations; also every alternate odd section of public land for ten miles on each side of the road (not mineral) between Santa Barbara and the junction of the branch to the main line in Tulare County. The word " mineral" not to include iron, coal, or asphaltum; and provided that the lands granted should be sold to actual settlers in quantitics not exceeding 160 acres, at prices to be fixed by the company, not exceeding $2.50 per acre; that patents for said lands should issue as fast as the road in ten-mile sections should be completed.

Southern Pacific

About the time the Central Pacific was completed the same company proposed to build a road from their own line to the Colorado River, to intersect some of the roads which were projected to cross the Colorado River into California. This road was the one which eventually swallowed all the others, and defeated the hopes of Santa Barbara of being either a railroad terminus or of being on the line of a transcontinental road. In the strife which ensued the reader will have no difficulty in perceiving the agency of the Central Pacific shaping things to their own ends. It was to this company, when it first projected the Southern Pacific, that Santa Barbara addressed itself. When the route up the San Joaquin Valley was determined on by them, a junction with them east of Santa Barbara was sought for, and several meetings held to consider the project.

Ratlroad Meetings

January 5, 1870, a letter was read from Dr. J. B Shaw offering the right of way through his land. Charles Fernald, Thomas B. Dibblee, and S. B. Brinkerhoff were appointed to draft resolutions expressive of the sense of the meeting.

The committee appointed at a meeting of the citizens of Santa Barbara, held at the Court House on the 5th day of January, 1870, pursuant to public notice, for the purpose of considering the subject of the construction of a railroad through this county, having deliberated upon the matter, recommend the following resolutions as expressive of their views,

Resolved, 1st. That the rapidly-increasing population of this county, and the development of its great agricultural resources, require the speedy construction of a coast railroad through this county.

2d. That in aid of the construction of such road to connect us with San Francisco and the Southern Pacific Railroad, the county of Santa Barbara be authorized, by an act of the Legislature at its present session, to subseribe to the capital stock of such railroad at least $500,000; gold coin of the United States; and that it pay such subscription with bonds bearing seven per cent. per annum interest, payable in gold twenty years after their issue.

And, whereas, some of the largest land-holders in this county have, at this meeting, expressed their willingness to donate to said railroad the right of way through their lands, and so much as is necessary for depots, stations, etc., and also to donate tracts of land along the line of said road, in aid of its construction, and to subscribe to its capital stock;

Resolved, 3d. That all of the land-holders in this county be, and they are hereby requested to grant the right of way for said road through their lands-

Thomas R. Bard, Charles Fernald, and S. B. Brinkerhoff were also appointed a committee to confer with the Southern Pacific Railroad and inform them of the sense of the meeting.

A Railroad From Santa Barbara To Bakersfield

The Santa Barbara Index has been publishing a series of articles, now reaching the eighteenth number, in regard to the "future railroad system of Southern California." Among the roads pointed out as necessary to be built, and that in course of time is certain tu be constructed, is one connecting with the Southern Pacific Railroad at this point (Bakersfield) from Santa Barbara. The length of a practicable and easy route is estimated at 100 miles, and the advantage to both places is clearly pointed out. Santa Barbara having built herself up to the utmost extent possible on health, and even gone beyond the basis of tangible speculation, now feels the imperative need of a back country, if a damaging collapse is to be avoided. The only way of obtaining it is by establishing a connection with this important valley, the richest and most extensive in the State, by means of the proposed road. It is argued that all our import, trade and stock, etc., would seek this as the shortest and cheapest route. There is no doubt that while such a road would benefit us greatly, it would benefit Santa Barbara relatively still more. In fact, that place can hardly do without it, while we can. As soon as the Southern Pacific crosses Tehachapi, the most of our export trade, with the exception of wool, for a considerable time at least, will be to the immense mining region that borders us on the east, and our immediate need of a convenient seaport will not be pressing. But, in course of time, as our boundless resources develop, a road to Santa Barbara will afford a convenient outlet, and, as an opposition, serve to keep freights and fares at reasonable figures. To Santa Barbara, however, the need of this road is great and immediate. It is the only means by which, during the life of the present generation, it can connect with the railroad system of the State, attract a trade suffic.ent to sustain real estate valuations and its present prominence as a health resort.

Numbers Of Railroad Projects

This was about the time of the completion of the first line of railroad across the continent by Sanford & Company, and when the world began to awake to the grand success of what was considered a visionary and impracticable scheme, San Diego, Los Angeles, and Santa Barbara, as well as other towns, immediately became ambitious to become the termini of transcontinental roads, and thereby become great cities. The plans for Southern California generally contemplated a route as far south as the 32d or 35th parallel. The San Francisco people proposed building a road also, which should make that city the terminus, and the cities along the coast way-stations. The San Francisco project was called the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company. Alvinza Hayward, a successful miner, was the President of this company. The company contemplated a road from St. Louis to San Francisco, intersecting the 35th parallel, near the Rocky Mountains.

The report of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad reports distances and grades as follows: through Missouri, 330 miles; Indian Territory, 389; Texas, 200; New Mexico, 415; Arizona, 397; California, 656. Heaviest grades: In Missouri, near Dixon, 105 feet to the mile; Indian Territory, North Fork Canadian River, 96 feet; Texas, near the western boundary, 63 feet; New Mexico, 106 feet; Arizona, 105 feet. The altitudes in California are Colorado River, 664 feet; Cedar Pass, 5,187; Mohave River, 2,400; Summit of Soledad Pass, 3,215; at the head of Santa Clara River, 1,120; San Buenaventura, 20; Santa Barbara, 25; San Marcos, 868; Santa Ynez River, 532; Summit at Foxens, 1.444; Santa Maria River, 20U; San Luis Obispo, 134; Moro Pass, 1,375; Watsonville, 28; between Watsonville and Santa Cruz, 400; Santa Cruz, 20; Tunnel near Pescadero Creek, 252; San Francisco tide water. Total length, 2,017 miles.

The Texas Pacific Company proposed to intersect the 32d parallel, hence the two roads were sometimes known as the 32d and 35th parallel. The famous Thomas A. Scott, of Pennsylvania, was made President of the former road, it was supposed on account of his oil interests, and became one of the great factors in the railroad problem.

Ambitious Towns

The towns along the coast, Santa Barbara, Los Angeles, San Buenaventura, and San Diego, were full of advocates for each one as a terminus for a continental railroad. Each, like a young girl putting on a gay dress and fascinating smile, coquetting with the capitalist for the road. Each one, when they had a chance, would privately make faces at the other, and say "you are no better than you ought to be." Santa Barbara did not think much of the harbor of San Diego; the channel was crooked and narrow, the anchorage shallow; could not get in or out except at high tide. The country was nothing but sand any way; no soil, no rain. Los Angeles had to lighter the goods and passengers; in a storm they could not.land at all; the town was a long way from the water. Santa Barbara claimed to have the best harbor on the coast; would point to the fact that vessels were frequently unable to pass the bar at San Francisco on account of the swell; that when in, a norther would often bump them against the wharves, while the Santa Barbara harbor was always safe for entrance or anchorage; had the best climate, the most fertile soil, and all the accessories for a great city.

Railroad Meeting

A meeting to consider the necessity of giving assistance to the railroad project, was held May 18, 1870. Resolutions proffering assistance were passed. W. W. Hollister, President; Geo. P. Tebbetts, Secretary. Committee on Resolutions, Charles Fernald, Dr. J. B. Shaw, Capt. W. HE. Greenwell, John Edwards, W. Delancy, E. N. Woods.

Resolution 3. That the property-holders and people of Santa Barbara County will, if necessary, grant material aid to promote the speedy completion of such a railway, if constructed on the line of the present survey through the county connecting San Francisco with St. Louis and the Hast.

The speakers referred to the facts, generally misunderstood by the people, that Santa Barbara was not in a direct line with the proposed road; that Tulare Valley was the arc, and Santa Barbara the chord; that Tulare Valley was mostly level, while this route was rough and mountainous; that there was plenty of Government land on the other route; none here; that to get the road on the longer and rougher route we must make a large donation. Mr. Huse expressed himself as willing to give half his property to have a road through here.

Proceedings Of The Supervisors At The August Term, 1872

The citizens presented three petitions in favor of granting assistance to a railroad company, also one to postpone aid. The District Attorney filed opinious on same. The Board discussed the railroad project during the afternoon and drafted a letter to A. Hayward, Esq., President of the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company, and the Clerk was instructed to spread the letter at length upon the minutes of the Board.

ALVINZA HAYWARD, PRESIDENT OF THE CALFORNIA ATLANTIC AND Pactric Rar~tRoap Company, San Francisco - Sir: A petition has been filed before the Board, signed by some of the members of the Railroad Committee, and other residents of the county of Santa Barbara, asking that there may be submitted to the qualified electors of the county at the next annual election, the question whether this county shall aid in the construction of the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad, by the issue of its bonds equal to five per cent. of the value of its taxable property in this county, according to its valuation on the assessment roll of the fiscal year last past, subject to the conditions which may be proposed by this Board. We deem it proper to suggest that your company, if it desires to obtain aid of this county in the construction of your road, shall prepare a petition and submit it, with your propositions as to the conditions on which said aid shall be received by your company to this road, in time for action thereon on the 4th day of October next. Inclosed herewith we transmit drafts of the petitions referred to, from which you will be enabled to ascertain the wishes of our people in the premises, and the conditions upon which they think it advisable to grant any aid to your road. It becomes our duty, officially, to see that proper safeguards are provided for the protection of the interests of the county, and inasmuch as very little time will be allowed for the interchange of ideas as to the proper mode of submitting the question of subsidy to our people, we desire to say that it will be necessary that your proposition and agreements shall be in writing and duly executed, so that it shall be of.binding effect upon your company in the event that it shall be satisfactory to us, and in the event that the vote of our people shall be favorable thereto. We are of the opinion that it is necessary that a perfect understanding between your company and the Board be arrived at before the 5th day of October next, the time limited for calling the election. Yours very respectfully, Tuos. R. Barn, Tuos. W. Moorg, Jno. EDWARDS. Supervisors Santa Barbara Co. Attest, F. A. Tompson, Clerk. By Joun C. Piatt, Deputy.

The Supervisors adjourned from day to day to receive an answer to their communication. The President of the road accredited Mr. Coffin to the Supervisors to make all necessary arrangements and explanations. The discussions were very lengthy, and resulted in divided opinions.

Failure Indicated

In the Santa Barbara Press of September 7, 1872, was the first intimation of the failure of the project for building a coast line. The article intimated that the Central Pacific Company had probably entered into a compromise with T. Scott, in which the latter was to connect with the former on the line, by way of Bakersfield, the branch road to run from Los Angeles via San Diego.

At a meeting of the Committee of Twenty-six, Charles Fernald resigned his position as President. It was evident that the committee were not a unit on the building of the road, as a proposition to bring about a county subsidy was met with much opposition. A proposition to make Mr. Richards Chairman was opposed on the ground that he was attorney for Scott.

Three rival roads seem to have claimed the support of Santa Barbara; the Colorado and Pacific by the Central Pacific Company, the Atlantic and Pacific, and the Texas Pacific. The first was proposing to run through Bakersfield with the main line, and reach the coast at San Diego and Los Angeles by a branch. The second proposed to run a coast line from San Francisco to San Diego, and thence to St. Louis. Alvinza Hayward was at the head of this company. The Texas and Pacific was supposed to be Tom Scott's road.

The Times announces September 4, 1872, that the Press has commenced a daily in the interest of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad, advocating an unconditional subsidy. From this time it seemed that divided counsels governed the people regarding a railroad, one party being dominated by Hayward, and the other by Tom Scott.

September 11, 1872. Ata meeting of the Twentysix, it was resolved that in case of aid being voted +o assist in bringing a railroad into the county, and that in case the Atlantic and Pacific should fail to build the road in consequence of the neglect or refusal of San Francisco to denote or subscribe $10,- 000,000 stock, then Santa Barbara should donate the subsidy to any road that should connect the county with San Francisco or St. Louis.

"The Santa Barbara Press has commenced a railroad company's daily. Its professed politics is Republican; its religion, unconditional aid to the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad."

The Press says, this "glaring falsehood," etc.; Mr. Richards ought to be ashamed of himself for such unblushing effrontery. But it is in keeping with his whole course before the committee in which he seems to act as if the public were as stupid as he is brazen. Evidently he has no more regard for his own word than the people of Santa Barbara now have, after his attempt to mislead and frustrate them in their efforts to secure a railroad. Professing to be a friend to the movement, he yet places every conceivable obstacle in the way to prevent the necessary action being taken by our citizens in order to secure the county against any possible loss, and at the same time secure the construction of the road.

« . . The people have little use for him or his opinions on railrond matters, and if he is the paid agent and retainer of Scott, he would do well to move his organ down to Hueneme, where Scott's legitimate interests lie, and there work for him in a manly and open-handed manner."

Opposition

In the meeting of the Twenty-six to inaugurate measures to vote a subsidy, it was evident that Richards, Greenwell, and Dr. Shaw were opposed to the Atlantic and Pacific. Richards made a. motion to adjourn sine die, which was seconded by Greenwell. The motion was lost by an overwhelming vote.

The petition asked the Supervisors to call an election to determine whether the county would grant aid to the amount of five per cent. of its property to the construction of a railroad connecting San Francisco and St. Louis via Santa Barbara, subject to the following conditions: -

That San Prancisco should vote $10,000,000; that the proceeds of the bonds should be expended on the road within three years; that bonds should issue only as the work progressed in the county, and then for one-third in stock, not subject to assessment, and the balance in preferred stock; that the railroad extend to Santa Barbara all the advantages that it does to San Francisco, as far as the circumstances permit.

Dr. Shaw Vindjcated

Some reflections having been cast on Dr. Shaw for the course he took in regard to the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad by the Press and Index, the citi-

'We, the old residents of Santa Barbara, having known for many years Dr. James B. Shaw, our kind physician and good friend, and hearing that he has been spoken disrespectfully of by the newspapers, the Press and the Jndex, of Santa Barbara, take the occasion to express to him our appreciation of not only his many acts of charity to the poor in our midst, but his continuous devotion to the interests of Santa Barbara. We look upon him as one of our people, and hope that his life may be long among us. (Signed) P. Joseph, M. Gonzales, O.S. F., Rev. James Villa, M. H. Biggs, U. Yndart, F. A. Thompson, Fran. de la Guerra, B. Gutierrez, W. E. Greenwell, Charles Fernald, J. F. Maguire, J. M. Andonaegui, Gaspar Orefia, John C. Kays, 8. Loomis, RK. Forbush, J. E, Goux, L. T. Burton, R. M. Wallace, Henry Carnes, Chas. Pierce, John S. Bell, José Lobero, N. A. Covarrubias, Arza Porter, John Scollan, D. W. ap Jones, R. Cohen, A. M. de la Guerra, J. J. Alizalde.

At an adjourned meeting of the Twenty-six, Greenwell, Shaw, and Richards took strong ground against the issuing of bonds, and a sharp discussion took piace about the condition that the issuing of bonds should depend upon San Francisco issuing $8,000,000 or more. The measure was opposed by Huse, Johnson, and others, but was carried by a vote of 8 to 7. A motion to adjourn sine die was lost by 4 to 12.

Richards held several proxies, and a move was made that the places of several of the Board who were absent be declared vacant; carried, upon which the matter of Richards' amendment was taken up again, and an uproar succeeded, which ended by Greenwell, Shaw, Richards, and Biggs withdrawing. A counter petiton was circulated.

The Times, September 21, 1872, took decided ground against the subsidy to the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad, and published a dispatch that the Supervisors of San Francisco had postponed the subject indefinitely.

The action of the Board of Supervisors of San Francisco effectually quieted the projects of California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad. The Jndez, in its fourth number, September 21st, significantly asked what it meant for Santa Barbara, and answered as follows: -

"Tt means that we are to live in the half-asleep state in which we have lived so far. It means that the steady and rapid increase of prices and values of real estate, since the prospect of a railroad has been taken into account, must now cease with the removal of the principal cause and be followed by a decline. It means that some of our business men, who are working more in hopes of future than for the present amount of trade, must suffer loss and anxiety. It means that prices of goods and clothing and household wares must be higher, while yet profits on them are less, owing to decreased demand and lack of competition in the carrying trade. It means that, with the finest fruit country God--ever made; wecannot become fruit growers for want of a market, easily and speedily accessible. It means that as a country we are to remain importers rather than exporters - not a prosperous condition. It means that we are to continue to sell potatoes during six months of plenty, at a cent a pound, and buy them back aguin the next half year at two cents. It means that money is to be, as it was before, hard to get and harder to keep. It means a loss of $2,000,000, an amount equal to one-third of all our assessed property, which would have been paid out in our county, and mostly to our own people during the next three years, but will now go into the pockets of farmers and laborers beyond the Coast Range. It means that the bustle and business and flush times that invariably attend the building of a railroad are not for us to enjoy. It means that our chances are forever gone of being on a trunk railway between the East and the West, and that henceforth our ambition can look no higher than to be known as a station on some branch road, leading nowhere. It means that our prospects for becoming a popular place of resort and a great watering place are thrown far into the indefinite future. It means that the unexampled advertising and prominence our vicinity has lately enjoyed throughout the United States, in the columns of great newspapers and magazines, will result in small profit to us, when otherwise it would have been worth thousands of dollars to the county. Is the picture a pleasant one to: contemplate? What shall we say of the men and newspapers who cannot conceal their elation at the prospect?"

The Press, September 28, 1872, contends that the opposion to the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad was occasioned by the visit of Tom Scott to Santa Barbara.

Before The Board Of Supervisors, September, 1872

Colonel Hollister advocated immediate action by allowing the people to vote on the question of assistance. 'No other road will ever be built here. This is our only chance." He proposed to adjourn from day to day to get an answer from the Jirectors of the company.

Mr. Fernald: '' Does not this look like haste? Why adjourn from day to day? Do we propose to tie this county to the company? I say, for one, No! Gentlemen say the people will vote forit. Which company, may I ask, does Mr. Coffin represent? Why don't he come out and say where he stands? Who are his principals? And what is this company, pray? It is a company of speculators and gentleman paupers! Alvinza Hayward is a prudent man; has $15,000,000 invested in mining stocks. Is he going to build this road ?"

At a meeting of the Board of Supervisors, September 22,1872, Russel Heath, Colonel Hollister, and others urged action favoring a subsidy to the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad. Judge Fernald plead for delay.

He thought they were men of means. He thought they owned some 8,000,000 acres of land, which would become valuable when the road was built. The Directors were among the wealthiest people of San Francisco; were by no means paupers.

" Now consider what Fernald has said about a vote of the people on this question. It is with poor grace that he sneers at the people and scorns their petition for a chance to aid the railroad. Who is he sent here to represent? Not the people, but a large bank interest. I would like to see the gentleman go before the people and say to them what he has said here. I say this is an uprising of the people, and they have a right to be heard.

"The gentleman says he wants a railroad. If he has a proposition for one, if he represents any company, let him say so. We are prepared to hear him. I am committed to no company, and only ask aid to this company because it is the only one that proposes to do anything for us. 1 am ready to work with any company that will give us a railroad on fair terms, but I believe that Mr. Scott is opposed to the only road that offers us any chance at all, and so I say give us the California Atlantic and Pacific Road. Does the gentleman say we cannot enter into a building contract with this company? He will not take that position for he knows we can, and that we are safe in doing so."

Mr. Fernald: 'One word, if you please. I am in want of a road so much that I am determined not to be committed to any company that can keep us out of a road. I now solemnly declare that I do not represent any company, Scott, Stanford, or any one else. Oome the charge from where it will, on the authority of a citizen or newspaper, | say what I say as a Citizen. Talk about stock! What an absurdity! The county can't own stock, as the Bar of this State will attest. That won't wash! It won't hold water! If the bonds of the company are worth anything, why not sell them? They won't sell for two bits a cord! I am in favor of a railroad as much as any one, but let us not be in haste; there is time enough."

Hollister: "'I am free to say that I do not understand the love of these gentlemen for a railroad. They seem to want it very much, but do all they can to oppose our getting one. They must love a railroad much as the Fiji Islanders love the missionaries - so well that they kill them and eat them up."

The coast papers generally were very indignant over the proceedings of the Board of Supervisors of San Francisco, which virtually killed the coast road. One paper, commenting on the opposition to a coast line of road, remarked that the engine might disturb the slumbers of grizzly bears, which were common along the coast.

The divided opinion regarding the policy of aiding the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad seemed to have affected the Supervisors. Some of them said they had no right to inaugurate means of assistance until the company should ask for it. Others thought the bonds might be used to pay expenses already accrued without building the road.

Colonel Hollister agreed to~enter into~sufficient | morse! Gentlemen, we don't want this order. It is bonds to indemnify the county against all loss in | death to us. It strangles all our hopes. It denies theamattar: us all our rights. And at whose bidding is it done?

End Of The Railroad Projeot

The terms proposed by the Supervisors in their call for a vote on the question of aiding the road was such that the friends of the road repudiated it in the following address: -

"To the Voters of the County of Santa Barbara: The Citizens' Railroad Committee of Santa Barbara County, in view of the changed circumstances for the present, in matters pertaining to the California Atlantie and Pacific trunk line of railroad through our county, recommend at the forthcoming election that you vcte No on the question of subsidy, for the following reasons: -

"The order made by the Board of Supervisors ignores the will of the people, as manifested by the numerously-signed petitions laid before them, and the committee are not prepared to submit to the will of three men in opposition to the almost unanimously expressed views and opinions of the voters of this county.

"Your committee believe that the people should be judges in such matters; but the Board of Supervisors, disregarding the expressed wishes of the voters, have arrogantly and unwarrantably usurped the power of constituting themselves the judges of what is best for you, and of making and forcing upon you an order for which you did not petition.

"We still firmly believe that the thirty-fifth parallel can and will be built. Although our plan for aiding this road has been delayed, it has not been defeated. On this unsolicitated order of the Board of Supervisors, submitted to your suffrages at the ensuing election, we most emphatically say, vorE No!

Hollister To The Front

"Gentlemen of the Board of Supervisors: I have heard in astonishment the words of this order as now read. A plain proposition was presented to you in the humble petitions of the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company, and of your tellow-citizens. To these petitions you give no heed, and, instead, you grant an order which we do not want and for which we do not ask; for which no one has asked that I have heard of. You put us off when we came before you a furtnight ago, because the railroad company had not presented a petition and contract. They now present both. But what do you say? You offer us an order which no company, not a single citizen, has ever asked, and you refuse to grant us what we have been urging and entreating you to do. Gentlemen, we have asked for bread, and you have given us a stone; we have asked for a fish, and you have given us a serpent, a huge anaconda, a monster of the monopolies of Scott and Stanford stretching from the north to the south along this coast, in the coils of which we are to be crushed to death, and then swallowed without re-

Huse: " Before the Board adjourns I would like to make one or two inquiries in order to understand the matter: 1st. Does the Board absolutely refuse to insert any words so as to apply this aid to the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company? 2d. If you refuse to do that will you not insert, 'and from the line of this county to the Colorado River, by route of the 35th parallel?' Now will the Board refuse? For what reason? Your order recites that the road commences at San Francisco and runs down the coast. Why not define its course after it leaves this county? Why should the Board be arbitrary about the matter? For whose benefit? It seems to me that I am not asking too much of this: Board. You are our fellow-citizens. You reside among us and have your own property here. The people have elected you to promote their prosperity, not to defeat it. If you sell it (this county) you will be held responsible for it by the people."

Huse: " My language is proper and I cannot withdraw it. I said, '¢f you sell out this county.' You may do it unadvisedly. [ no not charge either of you with improper motives. In this sense, I say we shall hold you responsible for your action in this matter."

Hollister: "But, Captain Moore, that lets in any company through our county on the line of the Atlantic and Pavific Road. That will be fatal to us. No other company can benefit us as much, as anybody can see. Our highest hopes will be more than realized by the construction of the road we are trying to aid. Now, it will not do to let in any other us all to let this fail entirely. Pass this order, and you take our weapons away from us. We are then entirely at the mercy of Scott and Stanford; but if you insert the words, 'the California Atlantic and Pacific Company,' we are safe."

Packard: "I have a proposition which I would like to submit. I think we need not hurry. We can't build the road this year, anyway. Let us offer the subsidy to any company and make it a gift outright."

Abbott: "Is it not necessary to insert, 'a first-class trunk of the usual grade?' We ought to guard ourselves against any swindling schemes."

Hollister: "This don't protect us. We want a trunk line connecting us directly with the Kast, on the line of the 35th parallel. Aid to any other road is a hindrance to this road, which is the only one we can offer to aid. We cannot afford to lose this trunk road. Better scalp us at once."

Coffin: "I suppose it is useless to say much more, but [ admire the easy grace and coolness with which the Board has appropriated our route, which has cost us thousands of dollars and two years of hard toil to survey and locate."

The Times of October 23, 1872, contained a fanciful description of the last meeting of the friends of the California Atlantic and Pacific Railroad.

Sarcastic On Santa Barbara

Santa Barbara is to become a great city, notwithstanding the opposition of Mr. Scott and Leland Stanford, who are supposed to be in terror lest the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad should take away their occupation. Santa Barbara has no doubt some reason for aspiring to a metropolitan position. It has room for many houses; clay for bricks can be found in abundance at no great distance; water can be stored in cisterns; fire-wood can be obtained in large quantities from Santa Cruz; an artificial harbor might be constructed; railroads could be built across the mountains which intersect the county in every direction; and there is no law to prevent an increase of the population by immigration or otherwise. In consideration of these advantages, in addition to the unsurpassed salubrity of the climate, we agree with the Press that Santa Barbara should become a great city."

The Press replied in a column of indignation. As an evidence of the crowded state of the hotels, the Press, November 9, 1872, appeals to the young business men who have rooms at the hotels to vacate them, and take rooms in the outskirts of the town, that the numbers of strangers visiting the place might not be turned away, especially, as many of these strangers were invalids, who had come a long distance.

A public meeting was held, and committees appointed to secure rooms for strangers, so that it was thought 100 more visitors could be accommodated. It was proposed to erect a hotel villa, which should have a central dining-room and offices, with a number of small houses connected by planked walks. This could be erected at once so as to accommodate the traveling public, until larger hotels could be erected. The committee to provide rooms was composed of O. L. Abbott, N. W. Winton, R. Bently, J. Phelps, D.D.; J. W. Hough, D. D.; Capt. W. H. Johnson, G. P. Tebbetts.

The papers up and down the coast generally commenced the enterprising talk of the Santa Barbarenos, and wished them success. The Lompoc Record thought a railroad along the coast would treble the population in a year, and proportionally enhance values. los Angeles was rather disposed to make fun of the matter, and headed an article

"Santa Barbara has gone into the railroad business in a frenzy, and her journals are full of the subject. So fervid are their disquisitions that one can almost see the inflamed eye of a locomotive between the lines in their newspapers, and hear the snort of the iron horse as one unfolds the wrappers. In the graceful language which the dilettante editor of the Press sometimes permits himself to use, 'Whoop "em up."

During the railroad excitement, Tom Scott and his party frequently visited Santa Rarbara. His presence always created a flutter in the prices of real estate.

New Efforts For A Road

It was generally understood that the defeat of the subsidy was a refusal to aid Scott in a San Diego road, and the efforts of newspaper and other advocates did not end here. Santa Barbara was spunky, and would not give the matter up. The /ndex wrote a series of articles numbering twenty or more, setting forth the advantages of Santa Barbara as a terminal point for a transcontinental road. These efforts of the Santa Barbara papers were not always received in a friendly manner by the coast papers.

A writer in the Stgnal, March 14, 1874, commenting on the articles in the Jndex concerning Santa Barbara as a terminus for a railroad, says: -

" He evidently thinks that the Atlantic and Pacific Company is composed of fools. He (Jndex man) says they (the Atlantic and Pacific Company) will build a road from St. Louis, and make Santa Barbara the terminus; that they will do, notwithstanding the first place they touch there is just as good a harbor as at Santa Barbara; a flourishing town, and better than all an extensive agricultural country to back it; that they will ignore the existence of these advantages, and construct a road thirty miles further up the coast, at a cost of not less than $600,000, in order to reach the town of Santa Barbara, where there is a good climate, no fogs, no winds, perpetual sunshine, and where no one has died within the memory of the oldest inhabitant. and they even have the presumption to ask San Francisco to aid them in this matter.

"This last evidently refers to a proposition made in the Zniex to have the railroad terminate at Santa Barbara, and connect with San Francisco by a line of swift steamers. The Signal thinks that a road will be built up the Santa Clara River a distance of forty miles, within a few years, with or without assistance.

Change Of Base

From opposing Tom Scott and his railroad schemes, the Press became an advocate of his measures. The reason was found in the following telegram : -

"New York, August 9th. At the reorganization of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company to-day, Thomas A. Scott was elected President, Andrew Pierce, Jr., Vice President and General Manager, and Gen. Clinton B. Fisk, Treasurer. John Edgar Thompson, Thomas A. Scott, Alfred L. Lennis, and David Solomon, of the Pennsylvania Railroad, were chosen Directors. The election of Scott to the Presidency is said to indicate an alliance between the 32d and 35th parallel transcontinental projects for one line of railroad to San Francisco."

The Press announced that henceforth they should look upon Tom Scott as a friend to Santa Barbara, though rather apprehensive that he would build up Hueneme rather than Santa Barbara, and pitied San Diego. It will be remembered that San Diego was to be the terminus of the 32d parallel, or Texas and Pacific Road.

'Poor San Diego! The shadows gather darkness, if we read aright the omens. Our predictions concerning Scott's relations to the Atlantic and Pacific Road appear about to come true."

" We have claimed. and now reiterate it, that Santa Barbara a few fens hence will be the most important commercial city in Southern California. As sure as a transcontinental railroad is ever built below the snow line, this prediction will be verified. 'But,' we hear many say, 'you have no harbor.' We answer whether you call our bay a harbor or not, we do not care. We have the safest place for transacting commercial business with sailing and steam vessels there is on the Pacific Coast. We make no exception to the land-locked bay of San Diego, or even the magnificent bay of San Francisco. The port of Santa Barbara can carry on a large commercial business safer and cheaper than can be carried on at San Diego, Wilmington, or San Francisco. We assert this without fear of successful refutation. Here any amount of ocean commerce can be transacted with greater safety to vessels and cargoes than at any other port on the Pacific Coast. In time, experience, and the low insurance on bottoms doing business at this port, and on their cargoes, will satisfactorily demonstrate the verity of our position beyond cavil. . . Here we have no use for tug-boats, or for channel pilots, or lighters. The expenses of these tug-boats, pilots, and lighters are not added to the commercial transactions carried on at the port of Santa Barbara. Technically, according to a strict definition of the word ' harbor' as a nautical, the bay of Santa Barbara is not a harbor, or place of refuge in a storm, because the bay is not closely land-locked. But as regards the safety of the vessels at all seasons of the year, transacting commercial business, the bay of Santa Barbara is a harbor, and is far superior in the means of saving vessel and cargo, and in commercial conveniences, to the best land-locked harbor on the Pacific Coast.

The whole of Santa Barbara channel may be designated as a harbor. The port of Santa Barbara is almost land-locked by the islands that inclose what is called the Santa Barbara Channel. The space between the island of San Miguel and Point Concepcion on the main-land is the entrance to this channel on the west, while the space between Point Conversion and the Anacapa Islands is the entrance on the east. Owing to the mountainous character of these islands, and also of the main shore, and the position of the islands lying, as they now do, in a row, and forming a protection against the storm of the open ocean, that portion of the sea known as the of a harbor, and is a harbor in reality. Every one who comes down the coast and through the channel, aboard ship, experiences sensations as the vessel rounds Point Concepcion, that he is entering a place of safety, a haven of peace, a harbor. He finds himself entering another sea, basking under another sun, soothed by another climate, and the prow of the vessel clearing its way through smoother waters. The cold northeast wind ceases, and a gentle, invigorating sea-breeze mingles with a warm southern air, and every voyager is stirred with new life and happier feelings. During a period of thirty years previous to the erection of our first wharf, there were not twelve consecutive hours that surf-boats could

" Never has a vessel been lost in Santa Barbara Channel by stress of weather. A southwestern storm is the only one that can effect a vessel in this port. These seldom occur. When they are coming the barometer gives the hint, and every vessel can run for the open channel, or lie under the mountain islands on the south of the channel. In all the past year there was not one day in which vessels could not come into or go out of this port, or lie alongside of our wharves, while, during the same time, there were a score of days when no vessel could go into or out of the bay of San Francisco through the Golden Gate."

In the concluding number of the articles on the transcontinental railroad, the author sums up the reasons for constructing the Atlantic and Pacific as follows : -

2d. It avoids the blockade of the moving sandhills of the Colorado Desert that would obstruct the Texas Pacific Road, a blockade worse than a snowbank,

5th. It will carry transcontinental freight at lower rates, and yield larger dividends from net profits, than would be possible on any other route.

6th. It is so favorably located that when constructed it will control a much larger through business than the Texas Pacific route could secure.

8th. It passes through a superior agricultural country, while nearly the whole route of the Texas Pacific is through a howling desert of sand and gravel.

12th. It would secure the trade of Utah as far north as Salt Lake Valley, and also the trade of the State of Nevada as far north as the mines of Eureka and White Pine.

13th. It would save the general Government more money in the transportation of Indian and military supplies than could be saved on the Texas Pacific reute.

15th. It reaches a port on the Pacific Ocean through the Soledad Pass, nature's transcontinental railroad gateway, the only practicable route for a broad-gauge railroad from the interior of the continent to Pacific tide-water.

16th. Its western end would reach an inexhaustible supply of petroleum, which will soon take the place of coal as fuel for locomotives and steam ships.

17th. Its Pacific terminus will be where the principal furnaces for the reduction and separation of the metaliferous ores of the Great Basin will be established.

18th. Its Pacific terminus would practically be at the city of Santa Barbara, the safest place on the coast for carrying on an extensive ocean commerce.

19th. There is no port on the Pacific Coast where transshipment from cars to ocean vessels, and from ocean vessels to cars, could be carried on so conveniently, and so cheaply, as at Santa Barbara.

Railroad Meeting In The City Hall

November 7, 1875, a resolution was passed indorsing the appointment of *J. P. Stearns as delegate to the Railroad Convention to St. Louis; also of the appointment of J. T. Richards by City Council to same position; also approving a transcontinental road, which should combine the Atlantic and Pacific Road from St. Louis and the Texas Pacific at Albuquerque, in New Mexico, thence westward in a grand trunk line to some point near California, where the road could then branch to San Diego, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, and Santa Barbara, as insuring the interests of the whole Union, and as of vital importance to the interests of Southern California.

"Tt might seem strange that they embraced so broad a ground; but the railroad that is to be built is not for the benefit of one town, but it is to be a great national work. It would do us no good to have a road to the Mojave Desert. We must connect with a transcontinental road or else we are at the mercy of the great monopoly which cuntrols the northern part of the State and would control the southern also. If we watch the course of the Central Pacific Railroad, which is already at Tehachapi Pass, and will shortly reach Los Angeles, and will cut into Arizona in the near future - unless gentlemen have watched this giant monopoly, they cannot be aware of this serpent which would crush it in its folds. [Here he read an extract from the Call, containing an account of a surveying party the Central Pacific bad sent into Arizona towards the Needles, to be absent some months.] We may ask what does this mean? It means that the railroad which was subsidized about the time of the war has pushed its road down from the northern portion of the State, and is stretching out to the east. It has monopolized all California to keep out all other roads. No individual 'can build the road we propose. But this company (Central Pacific) is rich, and if it is suffered to keep out other roads there will be no competition; they will charge what fares and freights they like. Some companies, by their charters, are compelled to submit to prices fixed by the Government; but it is not so with the Central Pacific and Southern Pacific Railroads. Immigration is rapidly coming this way, and the country will soon be settled. Shall those who come this way be saddled with this overwhelming monopoly? No. We want competition. We want those who come here to raise, crops of wool, nuts, honey, oil, etc., not to be compelled to cross mountains for a market. By the route we propose we are 300 miles nearer Salt Lake. But the Central Pacific Railroad wants to take all the trade to San Francisco, which, like a sponge, is sucking up everything. They are not going to Tulare Valley and Los Angeles to benefit those places, but to reach Arizona, and thus leave us out in the cold. It is not enough that Government has given woods and lands to assist it; woods and lands will not build railroads, money is necessary. Money is dear, so we must have European capital; but we cannot get that unless we get good security. If we cannot get American capital we must have European; but that cannot be obtained if Government will not guarautee interest on the bonds. The railroad company asks Government nothing but a guarantee, for which they will give their lands in return. The Government can secure itself against any possible loss by taking a mortgage on the track and rolling stock. When it gives this guarantee we can take the bonds to the Rothchilds, or any other capitalists, and get the necessary money. The people of the South want this road to open up the country, and will aid us. The grand thing for us is to get a connection with the main line. If the road were going through a thickly-populated country the people along the line would take a hand in it; but three-quarters of the way is through uncultivated land, and, therefore, we must have Government aid. If this road goes to Los Angeles and San Diego we shall have our share. San Diego is a good harbor, but a pilot is necessary; Los Angeles is fifteen miles from the coast; Santa Monica is building a road to meet the Independence and the Topeka and Atchinson Roads. If we get this road, then all the trade will come this way. We have a good harbor, well protected; can build wharves where vessels can discharge every day; no pilots are required; there are no shoals; ships with cargoes of tea and silks from China and Japan can come alongside of our wharves and discharge any day in the year. The goods can be passed across the continent over a line that will never be snow-bound, where there are easy grades, and thus supply not only the Eastern States but Europe itself."

He compared our peaceful harbor with Santa Monica and Los Angeles, showing the permanent advantages of Santa Barbara as a transcontinental railroad terminus.

Russel Heath spoke in favor of the projeet. Had always recognized the importance of a road by the southern route. When the Government first lent its aid to a transcontinental road, from a variety of cireumstances it chose the northern route. The southern one was not understood or known by many people. Few people came that way. came that way; saw no serious obstacles in its con- struction. The 'time has come for us to act. "Lt is now a necessity. Freights across the continent have doubled within a year. There is no necessity for it. Labor and materials have not advanced. It is the work of the great monopoly; that is why the capitalists of Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore, New Orleans, and Texas have taken hold of it - have determined to build a competing line. Colonel Hollister, Mr. Ivison, and Mr. Rynerson also spoke in favor of extending encouragement to the consolidated trunk line. Mr. Richards thought his business would not permit him to go to the convention. Mr. Stearns accepted the position and generously refused to aceépt anything towards defraying his expenses.

The convention referred to was held in St. Louis to bring about a system of railroading which should avoid the losses of competing lines, avoid the extortionate rates of monopolies, and organize a system of through lines which should carry freights at a living rate for both producer and consumer, and thus develop the country.

For many reasons, too numerous to mention here, the new railroad combination failed to work, and a second time Santa Barbara saw her hopes of a road dashed; but nil desperandum seemed to be their motto, and a third effort was made. This was to build a railroad along the coast from Ventura to San Luis Obispo, with the expectation of making, at some time, a through line from San Francisco into Mexico, also tapping the Southern Pacific at Newhall. The third effort was more modest in aims than the others, but was, nevertheless, creditable to Santa Barbara, and deserves to receive "honorable mention."

January 2, 1876, a committee, consisting of C. B. Huse, S. B. Brinkerhoff, W. W. Hollister, and O. L. Abbott, drew up a set of resolutions in favor of building arailroad from Ventura to San Luis Obispo by county bonds, and asking the delegates in the Legislature to obtain the passage of a law authorizing Santa Barbara to issue bonds to the amount of $500,- 000 in aid of such an enterprise. A committee consisting of Hollister, Brinkerhoff, Heath, Huse, and Judge Hall was appointed to draw up a bill in accordance with the sentiments of the meeting. Mr. Grinnell, a capitalist of New York, thought the bonds of Santa Barbara might be floated three per cent. interest, at ninety cents.

January 3, 1876, a meeting to consider the necessity and method of building a railroad took place at Tebbetts' Hall. Hollister, Brinkerhoff, Huse, and Abbott were appointed a committee to draft resolutions expressive of the meeting, which was done in a set of resolutions advocating an appropriation by the county of $500,000 towards the work, to be voted on at a special election, and that the chair appoint a committee to draw up a bill to be presented to the Legislature for action. Hollister, Heath, Brinker- hott, Huse, Ivison, and Judge Hall were appointed. Mr. Stearns declined acting on account of private business. Mr. Grinnell, a banker from New York, gave his views as to the probable value of the county bonds in the money markets. Mr. Huse gave some facts about the taxable property of the county, and the unanimity of tax-payers in favor of the project; thought the opposition would come from those who paid no taxes, as the opposition to all works of improvement had, and instanced the stage road in 1858, and other cases. A bill was introduced into the Legislature, in accordance with the wishes of the people as expressed at these meetings. When the printed copy of the bill appeared, it did not meet the views of many of the people, and a series of meetings were held to consider the subject.

Meeting Of February 5, 1876

J. T. Richards in the chair. The object of the meeting was to protest against the bill now before the Legislature. Mr. Hollister advocated the bill. Mr. Cook opposed it; thought we could not get out of the matter, if the bill was adopted, for millions, "Don't let us put a blot on this fair land, which would last forever. I know there is only one way to build it, and that is by putting our hands in our pockets, but I don't think that a railroad is an absolute necessity just at present, though I am sure there are men enough in this county with sufficient means, and who would be directly benefited, to build the road without county aid, and I would willingly be one in a hundred men to give $5,000 towards securing its construction, and I think by their giving that amount their lands would be far more benefited without these bonds than with them." Mr. Huse replied to Mr. Cook; thought that the few people present should not act for the 6,000 of the county; not a hundredth part were present. Mr. Stratton and Packard also spoke against the bill. Mr. Packard thought best to wait till we could put our hands in our pocket and get the money. Mr. Stratton wanted to know who would pay the interest on the bonds before the road was completed, as the bill provided. Mr. Huse admitted that $500,000 would not build the road; that the balance would have to be provided for. Judge Fernald thought we were not able to afford the luxury of a railroad at present. We might pay the bonds for a year or two, then a financial crash would come; an unfavorable season, which would take away the profit of the road, would precipitate a crash and disaster. Mr. Heth said his name had been put upon the committee without his knowledge; did not think the road would be of much benefit to the county.

Mr. Stratton moved that the chair appoint another committee to draft a bill to meet the views of the meeting. Adjourned till Tuesday, to meet in Lobero's theater.

further consideration. At the adjourned meeting, L. T. Burton, Thomas B. Dibblee, Chas. Fernald, Mortimer Cook, Wm. M. Eddy, R. T. Stevens, W. A. White, W. H. Woodbridge, Henry Tallant, E. H. Price, T. B. Jamison, C. C. Rynerson (the three latter being Supervisors), John P. Stearns, J. F. Maguire (County Judge), E. B. Hall, Francisco de la Guerra, Gaspar Orefia, G. Carrillo, and J. M. Loureyra were made Vice-Presidents, and Clarence Gray, Secretary. As much of the bill as referred to the issuing of bonds, the payment of interest, and provisions for sinking fund, was read. Mr. Murphy objected to the whole project; thought that $3,000,000 might not cover the indebtedness; would prefer to donate $500,000 to any company that would build and operate a road; thought if it could always be in the hands of men like Colonel Hollister, it would always be safe; were not sure of getting such men. He also addressed the people in the Spanish language. A resolution was adopted, protesting against the bill.

Colonel Hollister To The Front

'Mr. Presipent: I have been here for several years and have always done my level best for the good of the county and to help everybody. I believe that no community can be settled without a railroad. I have lent money at a lower rate than any one; have helped to build the churches, schools, and public buildings, and have finally done my best to get a railroad bill that would meet the approval of the citizens. As you have decided not to have a railroad, we must go back to our primitive state of locomotion, viz., ox-teams; and in consideration of what I have done, all that 1 ask is that you yoke up a couple of Spanish bulls and send me back to my farm in the old Spanish style."

" Resolved, That a committee of five citizens be appointed to draft a bill, to submit to the Legislature for adoption, empowering the county of Santa Barbara to issue bonds to the amount of $500,000, to be given to any railroad company that will construct and equip a railroad through the country, connecting with San Francisco or any transcontinental line; said road to be commenced within two years, and twenty miles thereof to be constructed each and every year. until completed, and that on the completion of each twenty-mile section of the railroad $100,000 of the $500,000 be issued and donated to said company."

Mr. Cook spoke in favor of the resolution. The chair appointed as a committee to draft the bill, Messrs. Fernald, Hall, Dibblee, and Stratton. Mr. Fernald declined acting, for reasons known to the chair, but heartily indorsed the bill. Mortimer Cook was appointed to fill the vacancy. Mr. Russell made several efforts to speak, but the meeting declined listening to him. Mr. Taylor caused much merriment by trying to collect enough money to pay the expenses of the meeting, and announced the sum of

Railroad Bill

The text of this bill is too long to quote in full. It provided for a Board of Railroad Commissioners, to be elected by the county at the general elections, the issue of bonds to the amount of $500,000, payable in thirty years, bearing interest at the rate of seven per cent. per annum, payable semi-annually, and also providing for a sinking fund, to be levied after the twelfth year; also the right to mortgage the constructed part to procure money for the completion of the road from Ventura County to San Luis Obispo County; to enter into contracts with the Railroad Commissioners of both of said counties for the proper management of the road - and other necessary things. An election was to be held the first Tuesday in May for the people to determine whether they would accept the conditions of the bill.

Board Of Supervisors

Wuereas, At a mass meeting of the citizens of this county, without distinction of party, held at the city of Santa Barbara on the 9th day of February instant, a bill was framed and will be presented to the Legislature, to authorize an election to be held on the 1st day of June next, whereby the qualified electors of this county may decide whether or not the county shall aid in the construction of a railroad by issuing bonds for $500,000 to a company or companies which shall be the first to bring a railroad through the county, according to certain conditions set forth in the bill, and which bill has already been forwarded to A. W. Hayne, member of Assembly from this county, by the committee at said meeting, and

Wuersas, It appears to this Board that the citizens of this county, without distinction of party or locality, exhibit the deepest interest in the subject, and a strong desire to have the matter submitted to them at a special election, whereby they may express their opinion as to the matters mentioned in said bill, now be it

Resolved, That the Honorable Senator and member of Assembly from this District, be and hereby is, respectfully requested by this Board to use every endeavor to effect the passage of said bill by the Legislature and its approval by the Governor.

This effort to have a railroad was frustrated by the refusal of the Legislature to pass the bill on general principles that it was bad policy to build railroads by public subsidies.

A Fourth Effort

Tuesday evening, April 9, 1876, there was a large meeting in Crane's Hall. Mayor Mortimer Cook, acting as Chairman, set forth the objects of the meeting. The first great need of Santa Barbara was a railroad; there is now but one practicable way to get it. The Southern Pacific Company is the controlling power among railroads. They will need feeders, and if encouraged and assisted will build one to Santa Barbara. He suggested the appointment of a committee to confer with that or any other company that was likely to join with us. Upon motion of A. O. Perkins, the Chair appointed Russel Heath, E. Ivison, P. N. Newell, Wm. M. Eddy, and Milo Sawyer. Judge Hall was called to the stand to entertain the audience while the committee retired for consultation. He said that he had no specific plan to offer; that first of all it was necessary to be united, to compromise, if necessary, upon a course of action, and-then work heartily for it. In his opinion, the reason that all plans had failed heretofore was that the people were divided in sentiment, different parties having pet schemes; that we had frittered away our strength in opposing each other; instead of uniting our means to encourage the building of a road we had prevented any company from building. Now, I am in favor of uniting even with the Central Pacific Company, if need be; better with them than no road. Anything for a railroad.

The committee returned from their conference and recommended the following as names of a committee of business, to devise the most practicable means of obtaining a road: Col. W. W. Hollister, Elwood Cooper, John Edwards, C. E. Huse, E. B. Hall, E. H. Pierce, J. M. Hunter, J. P. Stearns, J. W. Cooper, T. B. Dibblee, 8. P. Stow, Gaspar Orefia, Judge Heacock, Charles Pierce, and Mortimer Cook. Mr. Heath said the committee recommended that other names should be added until the list should comprise twenty-five men. C. C. Rynerson, R. L. Chamberlain, J. J. Perkins, H. K. Winchester, and A. A. Oglesby were added. Mr. Abbott spoke in favor of the project; thought there was a general willingness to take stock in a road. Clarence Gray objected to the composition of the committee as containing no poor workingmen. He professed himself strongly in favor of a road, but objected to the means used to obtain it; thought that poor men will not like to be taxed to build the road unless they have a voice in the matter. Mr. Ivison responded that so far no one had proposed to issue bonds or levy a special tax; that the meeting was only a kind of preliminary consultation to devise the best means for obtaining a road. Mr. Ivison said, further, that if Mr. Gray would name a poor workingman who would add strength to the committee he would cheerfully resign in his favor. Mr. Gray again attempted to divide the meeting in the name of the poor workingman, but was effect- ively squelched by Judge Hall, who exposed his designs of arraying the citizens against each other on the property line. He assured Mr. Gray that the workingmen would have sense enough to vote for aid to a road, if it should come to that, knowing that it would benefit them as well as the property owners. It was evident that Mr. Gray was playing to ingratiate himself into the favor of the workingmen. Mr. Pettygrove caused considerable merriment by remarking that Mr. Gray had loaded his gun by putting in the ball first; that when it went off it made a great noise but did no execution. Mr. Norway, having traveled extensively, reported a good feeling towards a railroad up and down the coast. The meeting adjourned with the expectation of meeting again soon. The fire was kept for some time, but no railroads were built through these means. The matter will be referred to again in a future chapter.

Provenance

Text from HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.