Santa Barbara County, California - Uiil, 1883 (part 1 of 2)
From HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. 15,926 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
21 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- The Murder Of T. Wallace More
- Administrator'S Sale
- Libel Suit Murder Of T. Wallace More
- Ill-Feeling
- The Crime
- Traces Of The Murderers
- Development Of Facts
- New Evidence
- Sentence
- Great Excitement
- Murder Of T. Wallace More
- Case Reviewed By The Governor
- The Hon. Joaquin Carrillo
- The Bar Hon. Pablo De La Guerra
- Augustus F. Hinchman Albert Packard
- Charles E. Huse
- Hon. Charles Fernald
- Judge Eugene Fawcett
- Francis John Maguire
- Milton Wason
- Walter Murray
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
- Part 1
- Part 2
The text
15,926 wordsMachine-read from scans of HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
The Murder Of T. Wallace More
THE MURDER OF T. WALLACE MORE. Libel Suit - Ill-Feeling - The Crime - Traces of the Murderers - Development of Facts - New Evidence - Trial of F. A. Sprague - Sentence - J ones' Defection - Great Excitement - Jones' Second Affidavit - Case Reviewed by the Governor - Resolutions of the Bar.
Tue high position which the family of which he was a member held, and the preceding as well as the subsequent circumstances, take the case out of the category of common criminal affairs, and elevate it into public importance as involving a large portion of the community in it, as moral accessories before or after the fact. The More family, as the reader of this volume has already observed, have been extensive purchasers of the old landed estates of the Spanish families. The Santa Rosa Island, the Patera or portion of the Hill estate, the Santa Paula y Saticoy, the Lompoc and Viejo Purissima and the Sespe came into their hands. At onetime the More brothers owned a tract on the Santa Clara River, thirty-two miles long. The land difficulty which terminated in one of the most horrible cold-blooded murders, commenced on the Sespe, and about the Sespe lands. Some account of the grant, and the purchase of the land is necessary, to form any clear idea of the murder, or the causes which led to it.
On the 23d of May, 1829, Don Carlos Carrillo petitioned the Mexican Government for the grant of the Sespe tract, on the usual conditions as to settlement, etc.; on the 29th of November following the request was acceded to to the extent of two leagues (8,880 acres), and possibly to six leagues, as will be hereafter shown. The local government put him in possession of about six leagues. Whether two, or six, caused all the subsequent difficulty. This right was afterwards in 1854 purchased by T. Wallace More, who supposed that he was buying six leagues, the prive that he paid, $18,000, being a full value for the larger named quantity. The title to the land was prosecuted by More, using the name of Carrillo as one of the parties in interest. The records of the courts show the following proceedings: -
Administrator'S Sale
By order of the Probate Court of Santa Barbara County, I will sell at public auction, at the Court House door in Santa Barbara, on Wednesday, November 8, 1854, between the hours of ten a. mM. and two p. M., the undivided +? of the Rancho San Cayetano, being the whole of the right to said rancho of the late Josefa Castro de Carrillo, deccased.
This rancho is one of the most desirable places in California, It comprises six leagues of land (con. firmed by the U.S. Land Commissioners) lying on both sides of the Santa Clara River, and covering the entire breadth of the valley. The mountains bounding it are well wooded, and the supply of water from the river and its tributaries is ample, not only for irrigation, but for driving mills. Terms of sale fixed by the Court are: One-third cash on day of sale, and the remainder in one month.
On the 18th of April, 1853, the Commissioners confirmed the grant title to "six leagues and no more." The United States, as the adverse party, appealed the case to the United States District Court for the Southern District of California. When the dissenho or grant was brought into court, it was observed for the first time that the numbers of the grant had been tampered with, and that, probably, instead of six leagues, as was confirmed by the Commissioners, two had been erased and six substituted, though when this was done, if at all, it was impossible to tell, as the impression or belief of the old settlers was that the grant was made for six leagues. Judge
Ogier, before whom the case was to have been tried, died before the case was submitted, but Fletcher M. Haight was so much inclined to throw out the whole matter for fraud, that More's attorney was induced to waive all claim to more than two leagues, which quantity was then confirmed by the Court. The following stipulation was filed by More's attorney, February 5, 1856: --
It is admitted by the claimants in the above entitled cause, that the grant of the land claimed in this case as originally delivered to Carlos Antonio Carrillo, was for two square leagues of land, the quantity as shown in the copy of the expediente on file in the case, and not for six square leagues. And it is further admitted by said claimants, that the said original grant was altered by erasure from two to six square leagues, after the time of its execution and delivery to said Carlos Antonio Carrillo, without the knowledge or consent of the Governors or other officers of the late Mexican Government in California-
March 14, 1872, a patent for two leagues was issued to More. In 1875, he made the effort to purchase the other four leagues. The law under which he made application was as follows, sec. 7-8, Codes of 1866: -
"Where persons in good faith and for a valuable consideration, have purchased lands of a Mexican grantee or their assigns, which grants have subsequently been rejected, or when the lands so confirmed have been exciuded from the final survey of any Mexican grant, and have been used, improved and continued in the actual possession of the same as according to the lines of the original purchase, and where no valid adverse title except that of the United States exists; such purchasers may purchase the same, ete.; provided that nothing in this act shall be construed so as in any way to interfere with the rights of any bona fide pre-emption claimants."
The-settlers claimed that the claim had been confirmed in full; that they had for years been settled on the land, and had pre-emption claims antedating this law, and appealed to the law of March 3, 1861, sec. 13, which declares that all lands, the claims to which have been finally rejected by the Commissioners in manner herein provided, or which shall finally be declared invalid by the District or Supreme. Court, and of all lands, the claims to which have not been presented by said Commissioners within two years after the date of this act, shall be deemed held and considered as part of the domain of the United States. Mr. More's attorney had made application to the Register of the Land Office for permission to purchase. On that officer refusing the permission, the petition was lodged with the Commissioners at Washington, where it was pending at the time of the murder.
Libel Suit Murder Of T. Wallace More
who, to the-number of sixty, "had settled--on the ground which More claimed. Among the rest was Joseph Bartlett. While the matter was in dispute More had Bartlett dispossessed by the Sheriff, tore his cabin down, and burned the materials of which it was made. Not long after, some one who reoccupied the place was poisoned, whether accidentally or not is unknown. An account thereof was copied into the Bulletin at San Francisco, and commented on in such terms that More sued the Budletin Company for $100,000 damage for libel. The case was tried in Santa Barbara, and is interesting as showing the animus of the people towards More at that time, and as explaining, somewhat, the results of the trials afterwards. The offensive article was as follows: -
"Some facts concerning an attempt to poison a settler on the Sespe Rancho, in Santa Barbara County, were copied into this paper yesterday from the Santa Barbara Press. 'The facts serve to illustrate some of the incidental evils of these unsettled Mexican grants. The Sespe Rancho was originally a Spanish grant for two leagues of land on the Santa Clara River, about twenty-five miles from the coast, in Santa Barbara County. After the grant was made, but at what time does not appear, the first rascality was discoyered, in the erasure of dos (two) leagues, and the interlineation of seis (six) leagues. Long after this fraudulent change in quantity had been made, one T. Wallace More bought the grant, affirming, or pretending that he thought it was for six leagues instead of two; although an inspection clearly shows that a fraudulent alteration had been made. All the preliminary papers clearly set forth two leagues.
" These facts were so apparent that it was difficult to find any respectable lawyer to take up More's claim and push it for the larger quantity. The decree of confirmation we believe is for two leagues, and the survey was made to conform tothedecree. The case is now pending on confirmation of the survey before the Land Commissioners at Washington. Sometime since the Commissioner wrote to the Surveyor-General here, asking his opinion about these alterations. The latter did not hesitate to express his conviction that they were fraudulent, and that the grant was intended to cover but two leagues. The settlers knew all these facts, and have known them for years. They know that the man who is claiming six leagues is only entitled to two; and that more than 16,000 acres of land claimed under a fraudulent alteration of the grant, arereally public land. They have settled upon this-surplusage and of course wish to save their homesteads. More wishes to drive them off, and, perhaps justifies resort to means which, naturally enough, are the sequel of a fraud committed with respect to the title papers. One of the settlers a few years ago had his house burned down in the interest of the grant-holder. And recently it was attempted to take the same settler off by poison, which, failing to reach him, took effect on his tenant. Of course the settlers bother the grant-holder, and they think probably under a fraudulent alteration of his grant he is trying to hold land to which he has no title. Ifthe settlers could be poisoned like so many ground squirrels it might, in the estimation of the grant-holder be a cheap means of taking them off.
Probably within the next six*months the grantee will be forced by the Government to curtail his limits to two leagues, and then the settlers may have peace, if it is not thought advisable to proceed any further with the poisoning business in the meantime. There transactions may not be worse than those which have grown out of some other grants, but they illustrate the degree of rascality which these grant abuses have engendered."
Jury in the case of More vs. S. F. Bulletin: M. H. Lane, R. F. Stevens, A. W. Hicock, A. M. Neal, W. S. Marris, C. W. Leach, H. McCaffrey, Joseph Cline, George Smith, M. Fletcher, J. C. Higby and M. Stridl.
Joe Bartlett swore to being annoyed by the Sheriff seeking to put More in possession, that on returning to bis home he found his house burned; that his cattle were afterwards run off. José Ortega testified to More threatening to burn the house; that he removed the grain, and that More set fire to it.
A. M. Cameron testified to hearing More threatening to burn his house as he had Bartlett's, Cameron retorting that if he did he would shoot More.
The testimony generally showed a great amount of ill-feeling between More and the settlers, but the charge of poisoning in the Bulletin was entirely without foundation. It may be remarked, here, that the use of poison for squirrels, coyotes and other vermin, is almost universal; that the wonder is that the number of accidents is not greater. The jury found a verdict for the Plaintiff with nominal damages at $150. The sum was so disproportionate to the amount claimed ($100,000), that the result was considered a defeat of More and a triumph of the Bulletin. The people manifested their delight with shouts even in the court room.
Ill-Feeling
The matter of the libel suit will show the feeling towards More on the part of the people and settlers some years previous to the murder. The public feeling was not much better in the years that followed. The settlers were still maintaining possession while More was endeavoring to perfect his title to the land. The settlers had formed themselves into a league for mutual defense and assistance. Whether unlawful measures had been considered or resolved upon 1s not known to outsiders. Common report says thata resolution in the significant words, MoRE MUST DIE, had been adopted. Members of the league whose veracity is beyond question, if that can be said of any one, state that no such resolution was ever proposed or discussed, much less adopted. It is likely that in this league as in most of such societies there were members whose zeal outran their discretion, whose minds were inflamed by the violent demonstrations and More's efforts to get possession of their land, as they considered it.
T. W. Morez, Esa. - Sir; Sespe Settlers' League met on the 16th inst. While in session a complaint was brought against you for trespassing on settlers' rights who are living quietly and peaceably upon Government land.
Resolved, therefore, that a committee of three be appointed to wait on T. W. More and notify him that he is not to injure, molest, or insult any settler that is settled upon land in Santa Clara Valley, between Santa Paula Creek and the Piru Creek. And if said T. W. More does he is doing it at his peril.
The winter of 1876-77 was unusually dry, and More commenced cutting a ditch to take out the water and carry it on his land. Mr. Storke, son-in-law to Mr. More, subsequently to the murder of More related an affair which probably led to the crime. He testified as follows: -
"We were constructing an irrigating ditch to carry water from the Sespe. There were some eight or ten men employed, and I was engaged directing the course of the ditch, which had been run too low by the surveyor. Mr. More asked me where I was running the ditch, and at my request he went with meto see. As we walked along we were hidden from the view of the men at work. Suddenly Mr. More said, 'There is that man,' and looking up I saw Sprague with a double-barrelled shot-gun on his shoulder. He said, 'Don't you come here; this is my land; don't come here or I will shoot you.' Mr. More answered him, ' Oh no, you would not shoot anybody.' Sprague brought his gun down toa position so that if it had gone off it would have shot Mr. More. The latter went near him, and,jumping caught the gun and turning it from him, grasped the triggers and fired one barrel in the air. Sprague talked very loud and threateningly. Mr. More tried to fire the other barrel but could not. I then caught Sprague by the neck, and Mr. More took the gun away and fired it in the air. I believed Sprague had no other weapons and I released him. He grasped the gun and in the struggle the gun was broken. We then walked away. Inafew moments we heard Sprague shouting to come on, and threatening to shoot. Looking back we saw him behind a brush with a pistol in his hand pointing at Mr. More. Mr. Roberts, foreman of the men, had been attracted by the shooting, and coming up ran between Mr. More and Sprague, saying, 'Don't shoot.' Sprague endeavored to get out of line of him, and shouted to Mr. More that he had had a pistol loaded with six bullets, waiting for him for the past three months. This was not on land claimed by Mr. Sprague. Mr. More had been in possession of Mr. Sprague's land fourteen years before Mr. Sprague settled on and claimed it. On cross examination the witness said that Mr. More was a daring and determined but not a desperate man. He was larger than Sprague. Sprague was arrested for the assault, and was discharged by the magistrate. The ditch was not on Sprague's land, and took water from the Sespe below Sprague's land."
The Crime
Sespe occupied by More, a hired hand by the name of Ferguson, and a Chinaman. The barn, containing horses, wagons, and harness, was set on fire. When the inmates of the house discovered the flames, all ran out to save the horses and harness, etc. The murder of Mr. More seemed to be the sole object as he was fired upon by five men as soon as he came prominently into view. When he fell, three or four men ran up to him, and repeatedly shot him, putting three bullets in his brain at such short range that his features were nearly obliterated with powder smoke, and deliberately left with the expression, "Come on boys."
The murder excited the most profound horror throughout the State. While the sympathies of the people were with the settlers in the contest for homes, the cowardly and brutal character of the murder excited only abhorrence.
Shortly after the murder a meeting of the citizens of the Sespe was held at the house of F. A. Sprague, on the evening of March 28th, to give expression to public sentiment in regard to the horrible murder and arson which had lately been committed. After electing N. H. Hickerson, Chairman, and F. A. Sprague, Secretary, and some discussion, the following resolutions were passed: -
" Resolved, That we deplore with deepest regret the awful tragedy that has lately taken place in our midst, and that we most emphatically disapprove of and denounce the act, whether employed asa means of settling difficulties. or of obtaining revenge either for real or fancied injuries.
" Resolved, That we hereby tender our earnest and hearty sympathy and co-operation to those engaged in ferreting out and bringing the assassins to justice, to the end that if they be among us, that we may be purged of their presence, and if they be not among us, we may be relieved of the stigma that suspicion throws upon us, and that full and exact justice may be meted out to all parties concerned.
F. Delmont, Coroner for Ventura County, held an inquest over the body, and the following witnesses were examined: Juan Olivas, George Ferguson, Jim Tot (Chinese cook), A. J. Cole, B. J. Robertson, Alfredo Ramirez, Ponciano Martinez, and Santiago Rival, from whom the following facts were elicited:*
"That the deceased, Ferguson, Olivas, and the Chinese cook were the only persons lodging in the ranch-house the night of the murder. That they all retired to rest from the fatigues of the day early. That about 12:30 o'clock at night, Ferguson and Olivas, lodging in the same room with the cook, were aroused by him from a sound sleep, stating that the barn (about 200 feet distant from the house) was on fire, the light of the conflagration shining through the window into their room, and they got up and called Mr. More. All rushed out in their underclothes and bare feet to save what they could of the property in the barn, consisting of twelve workee eee ee *We have copied freely from a pamphlet issued by L. C. @ i District Attorney in tlie cdee! sie : pig egies horses.and-their.barness, about 2,000 sacks of wheat, and some barley, with several tons of hay in the western, shed part of the barn - their first thought being that the fire was caused by some accident. The fire originated in the western shed part of the barn where the hay was. That the deceased, Ferguson, Olivas, the China cook, and Ramirez (who slept outside that night), were occupied in cutting the horses loose and turning them out, and in carrying out the harness. The deceased was fired upon while outside of the barn bearing out harness, by two of the masked men, who came forward and guarded the corral gate, and was wounded in the thigh, front part, near the groin, the ball ranging upwards. That he clapped bis hand to the wound, erying out, ' What's the matter ?' That Ferguson called out, 'Run for life!' That Olivas and deceased ran from the north side of the barn westerly into the plain, after getting over the corral fence inclosing the barn-yard, and the two separated - deceased taking a southwesterly course - and concealed thereafter by the smoke of the barn from Olivas. That Ferguson and the others fled southerly into the plain. That three masked men ran and overtook deceased, who had fallen to the ground abont seventy-five yards from the southwest corner of the corral, in the open plain, and riddled the body and head of deceased with bullets. That the leader said, ' Boys, let's go.' That one of the employees of deceased saw three armed, masked men, another saw five, and another from five to seven, who were engaged in the work of arson and murder. That they came to the house on foot from northerly direction, and returned the same way. That one very peculiar track led towards and near the house of Churchill. That of the three men who fired into deceased, two were full ordinary sized men, and the third was taller than his comrades. That one of the masked men told the cook, who was sent to the house for a knife to cut the horses loose, to go back or he would shoot him. That the only words that were heard from the masked men were spoken in plain, good English. That a shell discharged from a Henry rifle was picked up early in the morning near the corral gate. That Ferguson in the night received a spent bird-shot lodging in his forehead. That deceased hid three bullets in the head, one entering the forehead, and several in his bodv, and that he died of these wounds.
"Under this evidence the Coroner's jury found 'that deceased came to his death on the morning of the 24th of March, 1877, by gun-shot wounds inflicted by divers persons upon the head and body of said deceased, by parties unknown to the jury; and that the jury further find and declare the said crime to be a case of willful murder."
Traces Of The Murderers
«The several persons composing that jury, six in number, left the ranch-house of deceased to return to their respective homes about an hour previous to night; but on their way they inspected the footprints of the masked men making their way from the scene of the slaughter. The tracks all led in the direction of the house of F. A. Sprague, or nearly so. One of these parties inspecting the tracks saw distinctly the tracks of seven men going from between the house and corral of the deceased across the plain outside of any road directly to an alder trec, near by a patch of cactus, where he discovered that horses, had been tied (this fuct being developed on the last trial), the tree being about a half mile from the More house, and less. than that from the line of the Santa Clara River; and from the alder tree there were the foot-prints of only two men, which he did not follow to their termination, as it was near night. 'his citizen also picked up one of the masks that had been secreted under a cactus bush near the alder tree.
"The reader is requested to bear the fact of the alder tree in mind, with the fresh tracks of the horse hitched there the night before, as it has a great bearing upon the story of the murder given to the Court by the State's witness, Jesse M. Jones.
"Others of the Coroner's jury followed the peculiar foot-prints of one of the masked men to within a hundred yards of Churchill's house, and there lost sight of it, as it had been effaced by travel in that vicinity. This foot-print showed rows of tacks in the half sole of the right boot diagonally across it, and nails as usual on the heel; the left boot showed no prints of nails on the half sole, but nails in the heel. They measured the size of the track, and when they came to Oburchill's house, and while conversing with him and McCart outside and near the house, one of the persons who had been following that peculiar track to the vicinity of the house, noticed the size and shape of McCart's boots, caused him to lift up his foot, and took the measure, and found it to correspond exactly with the peculiar track which he had measured. They said to him that they arrested him. Then Churchill spoke up in a defiant tone, demanding of them by what authority they, as private citizens, presumed to arrest him. He was answered, by the authority which every citizen without a warrant has to arrest a man supposed to have been connected with a murder. It was then agreed to send the Sheriff next day to effect his arrest.
"On the next day, Sunday, Charles McCart was arrested by the Sheriff, charged with participation in the murder. But he had pulled off and thrown away the fraction of the half sole from his left boot. He was brought to the town of San Buenaventura for examination. On Monday morning, bright and early, came Sprague and Churchill to town, espousing the cause of McCart out of the pure disinterestedness of their nature, of course, everywhere vouching for his innocence, and soliciting counsel for his defense. A long and tedious examination succeeded, founded upon the evidence of the tracks, and he was held by the County Judge, acting asexamining magistrate, without bail, to answer for the crime of murder. I have ever thought, since studying that evidence under all the other circumstances of the case, that it was sufficient to insure his conviction before an impartial jury; and so thought a majority of the next grand jury; but they lacked one of a legal majority, and so the bill was ignored. We shall make further reference to this grand jury hereafter.
" The further prosecution of the perpetrators of this murder was suspended for a whole year. During this interval the good people of this county were making a searching private investigation of the tacts of the case, not to solve the mystery as to the principal parties to the crime, for there has never been the shadow of a reasonable doubt in their minds upon that point, but rather to obtain adequate legal evidence of their guilt. It was discovered that the shell of a needle gun was picked up the next morning after the murder between the ranch-house and the site of the burnt barn. There was no other needle gun in the Sespe settlement but the one belonging to Lord. It was also discovered that the shell of a Spencer rifle had been picked up near where the body of "Mr. 'More fell, in the morning light after the murder; and there was no arm of that kind owned in that settlement except the Spencer rifle of Lord, which had been lent to Sprague two weeks prior to the murder, and was not returned until a few days after the murder. It was further ascertained that the impression of the hammer upon the rim of this shell corresponded precisely with the impression made upon six other shells which had been fired from the Spencer rifie of Lord by a young man in his employ about two weeks preceding the murder. It was also ascertained that Curlee and young Jones, who lived with him, were away frem home al] that night of the murder, on pretense of going to 'stay all night at a stock ranch of theirs in Poll Cafion, not more than five miles from their home. And that about nine o'clock that night they were seen on horseback between Poll Cafion and going in the direction of Sprague's, while Curlee said they were there all night, going to bed early. Also that Sprague and Churchill had both been to Curlee's on horseback, each at a separate time, two or three days before the murder, holding private interviews with Curlee and Jonesaway from the house and hearing of others. It was discovered just before the trial of Sprague that both Lord and Hunt were out of their houses that same night, and about the hours of the murder, upon the pretense of running depredating stock off their land, their two places adjoining. It was also found that Churchill rode to Lord's and had a private interview with him the afternoon before the murder, and Lord told his sheep-herder to stay out with the sheep that night and not come to the:house to sleep as was usual; and that Lord went down to More's sheep camp and stayed till near night, and until he saw More leave there to go to his ranch-house to sleep. All the others in that settlement could give the most satisfactory proofs of their whereabouts on that night, except the seven men finally accused and indicted for this murder. There could not be found any hypothesis from facts ever discovered that could by any moral possibility implicate any others than the-e seven men as being connected with the commission of that crime. No one has ever had the audacity to promulgate any other theory for this offense, or of implicating any other individuals, and no other particular individuals have ever been suspected of a connection therewith.
Development Of Facts
" However, none or all of the foregoing facts were esteemed by the authorities sufficient to put these men on their trial for the murder of Mr. More.
* ey Early in 1878, about the Ist of January, the brother-in-law of Austin Brown had jumped a possessory claim of his in the Sespe settlement, and was encouraged by Curlee to hold it. The next time Brown and Curlee met at the town of Santa Paula, Curlee being on the rampage and drinking freely, hard words ensued between them about the matter, stinging Brown to the quick, and, on going home, Lord happened to ride with him in his wagon, endeavoring to assuage his wounded feelings. Brown said to him, 'Curlee must go slow; I know of his connection with the More murder.' Lord replied, "Tf you know anything about that matter, for God's sake keep still, as you may bring suffering upon innocent persons also. I will see Curlee and have matters amicably settled.' The next day Curlee came to Brown and apologized for his unjust behavior. But Brown was cut to the heart; the wound would not heal, and about the middle of February be sought an interview with Mr. Henry More, the brother and administrator of the estate of the deceased, who was spending a few days at the Sespe Ranch. In that interview Brown made a statement of the conspiracy organized by Sprague and Churchill to murder the deceased, of the parties expected to be engaged in the result, of the time set and the rendezvous, as well as the whole plan of its execution, precisely the same, in word and substance, as given by him in a private statement previous to the arrest of the seven assassins, and as afterwards given at the several times he was placed upon the stand as a witness. This statement was given to Mr. More at the time in confidence, not to be divulged to the public until Brown could move from that settlement to a safe place, as he feared for his life, which had been threatened by the men who had murdered More, if he (Brown) should ever disclose the rare, be ER te
These circumstances and others induced the arrest of F. A. Sprague, J. S. Churchill. J. T. Curlee, Jesse M. Jones, I. D. Lord, H. Cook, and J. A. Swanson, the warrant of arrest being dated the 28th day of March, 1878. The parties were brought before R. C. Carlton, examining magistrate, on the first day of April.
New Evidence
About this time it was learned that new evidence had been obtained. Mr. N. H. Hickerson, who was sick and in daily expectation of dying, had a secret which was weighing upon his soul, being no more nor less than the fact that he had been the recipient of Sprague's confession of his planning and execution of the murder, the testimony being taken by N. Blackstock, Notary Public, given under the condition that it was not to be divulged until after his death. Upon being informed, however, that the assassins were under arrest, and that Brown had made a similar statement, he was induced to come forward and reveal the facts.
Third - My place of residence is on the Sespe River, next place above F. A. Sprague, and seven or Hee miles north of Santa Paula, in said county and State.
Fourth. - I believe that I wm soon to die; that my time is short; and that my present illnes3 is absolutely sure to terminate in death. And thus believing, L cannot die satisfied, without first making a statement of what I may know in reference to the murder of T. Wallace More, which occurred in this neighborhood, in the early part of the year 1877.
Fitth - aAll that I know of said murder follows, to wit: Some time between the date of the row between More and F. A. Sprague on the ditch and the mur- der, I think~just-after the row; F. A. Sprague said to me north of his house, that he was going to kill Tom More, and if he could not get any one to assist him, be would do it alone; and asked me if I would join him, when proper arrangements could be made. But I refused, and told him that I did not go into such operations as that. 1 saw from my house the light caused by the burning barn of Mr. More, on the night of the murder. That was about twelve o'clock at night. Soon after the murder, Sprague (F. A. Sprague) sent for me to attend a meeting of citizens, 10 pass resolutions denouncing the murder of Mr. More. I attended at his house as requested, und found there F. A. Sprague, Jule Swanson, and J. S. Churchill. The meeting was called to order. I was elected Chairman, and F. A. Sprague Secretary. After the organization as above, Sprague offered and read some resolutions which had been before prepared, which were adopted. And Sprague, after saying that it did not matter whether many were present or not, requested me to, and I signed the resolutions as Chairman, and he as Secretary. I then returned home. A few nights after this, a report came that a mob was coming up to kill the settlers on the lower Sespe; and F. A. Sprague sent word to me of the rumor, and requested me to meet him and others at his house and we would defend ourselves. Thinking that I might be in some danger, or that under any circumstances it was my duty to resist mob violenee, I went. and met, in front of Sprague's old store, F. A. Sprague, his son and nephew, J. S. Churchill, and a man who represented himself to be a newspaper reporter. After talking a short time I remarked that I thought the place an unfit one for protection, and that I would hunt a more sheltered one down among the willows. Sprague agreed with me, and myself and Sprague then left the party, and went a few rods among the willows where we were hid, but could see up and down the road. Sprague then, without a question from me, commenced a conversation about the More place, and very soon told me the following particulars of the murder of T. Wallace More: -
He said that himself, J. T. Curlee, Jule Swanson, J.S. Churchill, Charles McCart, Jesse Jones, and I. D. Lord, had decided to meet at a place near a little creek between Sprague's and Lorton's, on the lefthand side of the road. That after completing all necessary arrangements, and arranging their disguises, and securing their horses (some of them, he said, had rode horseback to the place of meeting, or rendezvous), they went across the river-bed on foot to More's ranch-house. On reaching there, they found that the lights were all out and everybody asleep in the house, except Juan Calderon, a Spaniard, who was asleep near the barn. Sprague said that he and one of the crowd went behind the barn and set it on fire, which aroused More, the Chinaman, and all the rest. They came out to the barn, and were trying tosave the harness. That George Ferguson was the first to see the danger or real situation, and that he hallooed to More to run for his life, that he would be murdered. That Ferguson ran to the back of the barn, and called to More to run this way. Ferguson cleared the barn ahead of More. Sprague said no one was to molest Ferguson, and no one fired at him; but More seemed to be shot, as he clasped his hand to his hip, and ran limping; that he ran some 150 yards, and fell, and supported himself on one arm, until he (Sprague), Curlee, and Churchill went to him. That when they got to him, More begged for his life, and said, " For God's sake don't kill me!" and turned over on his back on the ground. Sprague said that he then said to him, with some other epithet, "God damn you, dic." And that he suited the action to the word, and put a rifle-ball through his head into his forehead, which put an end to him. And that standing over him long enough to know that life was extinct, they turned around to go back. Sprague said he had become exhausted, and Churchill and Curlee had to hold him up and assist him back. That he had broke down on account of his lame back.
He said that as they passed More's barn in returning, the rest of the crowd joined them; and that they returned to their rendezvous, separated, and each went home. He said that the murder occurred about twelve o'clock; that Charles McCart returned with 'hem tothe rendezvous. That their disguise consisted of a common flour-sack, with holes cut in it for the eyes, nose, and mouth, which was put over the head and shoulders, one of which he showed me, and said that it was such a one as worn by the party who did the killing. That a common gunny or burlap sack, bottom upward, was put over the shoulders, arm-holes being cut in the corners, and was drawn down over the body.
He said that they were bound to secrecy by an oath, and that the penalty for divulging who done the killing was instant death. He remarked that he expected me to observe the oith; but I neither took any oath, nor promised him that I would keep bis secret.
My reason for not making this known to the Grand Jury, during the session of the Grand Jury last June, when I myself was a member, was bec use one of the party implicated by Sprague, to wit, Jule Swanson, was a member of the same Grand Jury. And I did not then feel that the time had come for me to tell what I knew. I thought then that the whole matter would ultimately come out; and I would not then be without corroborating evidence. As to McCart, the theory then attempted to be established was false, except as to his participation in the killing; und while I was satisfied of it, yet there was no evidence, in my judgment, introduced before us sufficient to warrant us in binding him over.
The stories of Brown and Hickerson had not at this point been made public. The prosecutors and detectives, however, had the matter well in hand and had in view the furnishing of such evidence as would, without any doubt, establish the guilt of the murderers inthe minds of a jury. One of the parvies implicated in the affair, Jesse M. Jones, was but twentythree years of age, and was considered as being led into the conspiracy, rather than fomenting it. From some indications and words let fall, it was believed that under assurance of protection and ultimate pardon, he might be induced to turn State's evidence. An interview was brought about between L. C. Granger, and Mr. Ganahl, the assistant council on the part of the prosecution, and Jones. It may be observed here that Jones had no: knowledge of the matters revealed by Brown and Hickerson, and consequently could not have been in collusion with them, but the story he told of the murder substantially corres-
The parties implicated according to the stutement of Brown, were F. A. Sprague, J. T. Curlee, Jesse M. Jones, Jule Swanson, Henry Cook, and J. 8. Churchill.
These statements, while agreeing about the facts of the murder, are contradictory as to the persons engaged in it, a material divergency, truly, as there was no doubt of the murder or the methods by which it was accomplishe!. The object of the trial was to identify the parties committing the murder.
On the preliminary examin -tion, H. Cook und J. A. Swanson were discharged, Charles McCart and W. H. Hunt being arrested during the hearing as accumplices in the murder. The Grand Jury was organized the following June, and returned a true bill against F. A. Sprague, John Curlee, Jesse M. Jones, J.S. Churchill, Charles MeCart, W. H. Hunt, and I. D. Lord.
The lawyers for the prosecution were J. G. Howard, Frank Ganaht of Los Angeles, L. C. Granger (acting District Attorney), W T. Williams, N. Blackstock, and B. T. Williams of Ventura.
The counsel for the defense were J. D. Fay, Creed Haymond, and W. Allen, from abroad, and J. D. Hines, J M. Brooks, and N. C Bledsoe, Jocal talent.
Kugene Fawcett presided over the court. The prisoners demanded aseparate trial. Regarding this demand the acting District Attorney, L. C. Granger, said: -
As acting District Attorney I regretted this severance, knowing well that it would exhaust the finances of the county, and accumulate a large burden upon the people, who had been impoverished greatly by the total drought of the previous year, and extensive failure of their crops the present season. But above every other consideration, I thought, as the event fully demonstrated, that the jury-material of the county, being very limited, would be exbausted before the conclusion of the several trials; and that as the State could not obtain a change of venue, and none of the defendants would under any cirenmstances move for such a change, a trial jury of unbiased men, otherwise qualified, could not be procured in the county to try at least one-half the defendants; that, in fact, they could not be tried for years, without some action of the Legislature providing for this exceptional case.
for cause, and 120 peremptorily by the six de'endants - one of the seven being discharged from the indictment to become a witness for the State - and the people had sixty peremptory challenges. In the formation of each trial jury a panel of 100 jurors wax In fact exhausted. And the truth is that after the first two trials, to wit: of Sprague and Curlee, in the July term, 1878, we had really in this county not a sufficient number of competent jurors to form another unbiased trial jury. The evidence had all been published and commented upon in our local papers. Parties had been formed, the lines drawn and sides taken; and there was quite a large element, constituting about onethird of the population of the county - not more - actively participating with the defense and working for their acquittal. Of this third, some few openly justified and applauded the foul murder of Mr. More, on the ground that, as they alleged, he had unjustly claimed more land than belonged to him. and had harassed defendants with vexatious litigation, impoverishing them and their families; others, that they would not believe the evidence of men who had broken their word, as was insisted, to the defendants, by disclosing statements made to them under the strictest confidence; and still others, who were interested with defendants by former friendship, business, and social relations; and, as the defendants and their partisans had votes, nearly every officeseeker and office-holder in the county, with a few striking and honorable exceptions, espoused the cause of the defense, after the conclusion of the July term of the Court. Without even insinuating a suspicion of the bonesty and moral integrity of many of those who huve taken sides with the defense, I do most solemnly declare that the major part of the sympathizers do not comprise the better and higher elements of society in this county, - those elemen's that ever form around the nucleus of justice. law, and order, as the foundation of all social peace and prosperity. And I do further declare, as my deliberate judgment, that a large majority of the good people of this county stand with the prosecution in the belief of the guilt of F. A. Sprague and the fellow conspirators led by him to the commission of the murder, and jointly indicted with him. The Spanish- American portion of our population, comprising onesixth of our whole number, the most disinterested judges in our midst of the evidence and the facts of the case, have been and are now to a man in favor of the prosecution.
When the criminal calendar of the July term was called by his Honor, the Judge, the acting District Attorney announced that the prosecution was ready to proceed to
The defense moved for a continuance, upon the affidavit of defendant, setting forth the absence of one Frank Davis, a material witness, by whom he expected to prove that on the night of the murder Davis was stopping at the defendant's house, and would swear that defendant was not out of the house that night. The State interposed counter-affidavits tending to show tbat said Frank Davis, who was well known, had left the country a long time previously, and that defendant had formerly stated that none that committed the atrocious crime, quite powerful in so small and isolated a community as this one is; the abilities and fame of distinguished counsel arrayed in the - none the less momentous because a civil - conflict; the great consequences to society and the individuals accused which were involved in the pending strife; and the consummate skill displayed by the veteran leaders on both sides, in marshaling the moral forces of the facts and issues in the absorbing and protracted struggle - gave a tone and character to this remarkable contest rarely equaled - at least within the State of California. The gentlemen vomposing the jury that tried the case of F. A. Sprague were all, with a single exception, I believe, farmers, and of excellent reputation and high moral and social standing, and the other was a printer and editor by profession, prudent, intelligent and greatly respected.
First. The introduction of evidence to the minutest details as to the scene of the murder and the circumstances accompanying it, as seen by the parties present in the employ of More, and by those who visited the scene in the early morning succeeding the homicide.
Hickerson died previous to the trial, so his affidavit was produced, also the testimony given in the preliminary examination before Judge Carlton. The testimony was complete, not a link being wanting. The discrepancy as to the different parties engaged seemed to have arisen from the fact of the disguises having been assumed before they came together, only two or three being cognizant of all the persons.
The defense formed no theory of the murder, the strongest attempt being made to break the testimony of Hickerson and others of the State's witnesses. It was alleged that Hickerson was drugged, weakminded and an imbecile at the time be made his affidavit, and also at the committing examination. If so, it was a curious imbecility that could weave a fictitious narrative into events that were as complicated as they could well be. The testimony of Jone: was impeached, also some of the members of the family awearing that his reputation for veracity was bad. The jury, however, brought in a verdict of murder in the first degree.
Lord was next-tried, with some additional testimony, regarding a visit to. More's sheep camp the evening before the murder. The jury in his case disagreed.
At the time the last jury was empaneled, the three trials had exhausted about all the available material for a jury. Nearly every man had taken sides, so that it was known on which side he was - on the side of the law, or as an apoloyist for the murderers.
The- acting District Attorney 'even asserted that many of the men had been trained so that they could be admitted to a jury, even with a positive opinion. Some even openly justified the murder, after leaving the jury room,
Sentence
"F. A. Sprague: You have been convicted of the highest offense known to the law. You were skillfully defended: at the trial; every device was exhausted.to save you, but a jury of your fellow-citizens has pronounced you guilty of the great crime witb which you were charged.
"Tn the dead hour of the night, you, the leader of a masked band of assassins, applied the torch to the premises; and, as he started, half-naked, into the light of the flames, you closed upon him and shot him near to death. He attempted flight; you pursued; he fell before you with a pleading voice that should have found pity for him out of a heart of iron, but you remorselessly riddled him with bullets, as you would the carcass of a dog.
"There is no lunguage strong enough to depict the atrocity of such a deed. Your guilt is as clear as evidence can make it. You probably thought you would be upheld by the community in which you lived! Thank God, you are mistaken! There are but few monsters to applaud the act.
"The result of the trial proves that we are yet governed by law; that we are a community of enlightened human beings, and not a society of suvages.
" Let your fate be a warning that justice is sure to follow crime - sometimes traveling slowly, with leaden heel, but striking with an iron hand.
"T will not affect for you a sympathy I do not feel. There is no point in your case for sympathy to gras) at, so far as you are concerned. I feel deeply for your faithful wife and children. They are the ones who need, who receive, the sympathy of all kind hearts: It only remains for me to formally conclude this painful duty. The judgment of this Court is, that on Friday, the 27th day of December next, between the hours of 10 a. M., and 1 P.M, you be hanged by the neck until you are dead; and may God Almighty have mercy on you!"
The court adjourned for the term. During the interval following the term, a new phase was put on the trials that were to follow. Mr. Granger gives the following account of the
The court now stood adjourned fortheterm. The three trials had protracted the July session into near the middle of August. The States witness had been discharged fiom the indictment for more than :«. month, and was maintained as an indigent witness in criminal cases at the expense of the county, his per diem allowed by the Court being $1.50. He had no means of livelihood; his young wife was staying in the family of her father, in the Sespe settlement. He himselt' was debarred access to that family by his wife's father, on account of betrayal of his confederates in the crime. The future looked gluomy to him. In his trouble he resorted to me for counsel. He proposed to leave and go with his wife to San José, where his father lived, but would require $100 in money to effect that purpose. I inquired of him if he understood blacksmithing, to which he replied in the uffirmative. that trade, and that I would try to get him a situation in that business in Santa Barbara or Los Angeles, knowing that he had a brother living at the former eae and a relative, a Deputy Sheriff, residing at the atter pluce. Imade arrangements, shortly, tor him to take his wife and go to Santa Barbara and work at his trade there, enlisting some gentlemen here from that place in his behalf, as a poor, penitent creature, desiring, by a life of good conduct in the future, to atone for the crime into which he was induced by older men, some ot' whom were old enough to be his father. He was freely forgiven by the relatives of the deceased and all good citizens, upon his promise of reformation, and had he accepted my advice he would have received all necessary charitable aid at Santa Barbara. When I made known to him this arrangement he gave his assent to it, but as I then thought a little reluctantly. Still 1 believed he would follow this advice.
At this time be was in that state of uncertainty and doubt as to the best course to pursue for the future that he could be readily controlled by men of stronger will and superior intellectual powers. It was on the evening of the 13th of August. Nathan Stone, whom he personally liked, and who had been requested, with the witness' free approval, to keep him company during the month occupied by the trials, and see that no harm befell him, of which he seemed apprehensive, from any one of the numerous friends and relatives of the defendants in the town; and to see also that no one should talk with him out of his hearing, so as to prevent all misrepresentation - this young friend of his had left the town and gone home. And on the evening afterwards, Jesse tell into the hands of the men of stronger will--men the most seductive in manners and jersuasive in address. He was led, soon after dark, by W. W. Alien, into the august presence of Fay, Haymond, and Brooks, of counsel for the defendants, and others, at their little parlor, No. " 22," in Brown's Hotel, in this town.
When it was reported that Jesse was there, the prosecution, thinking it might be a simple courtesy on the part of Allen inviting him there, sent a respectable young man, whose brother is married to Jesse's sister, to Brown's with a message to Jesse, that some parties desired him at once at Ayers' Hotel upon important business. The young man proceeded there at once, meeting the proprietor, Brown, at the foot of the stairs, to whom he stuted his mission, and that he heard Jesse was in room "22." The proprietor warned him not to go there, saying, " Weare all armed and will shoot; you had better not go, we will make you sick.' He went, knocked at the door, which was opened by Allen; behind him stood Fay. They demanded his business; he replied that a person wanted Jesse at Ayers' Hotel. They said, " Jones is not here; cursed him and threatened violence if he returned. But Jones was thereat thattime. When the real situation became known in town there was
Great Excitement
Sentinels were pliced near the room to take note of what was passing. A serious riot and bloodshed were imminent. It was now generally supposed that the
State's witness was restrained of his liberty against his will. I was proceeding to sue out a writ of habeas corpus. The counsel for the defense got word of it, und Fay and Allen came out with him on the street. They had him in that room for three hours that night, and - Jesse was debauched. He avoided the friends of the prosecution; was surrounded and caressed by those who had gnashed their teeth upon him; was borne in triumph to the Sespe; received with open arms to the houses of his father-in-law and of the defendants; made an affidavit that all he had sworn to was false; and promised to work for the defense. He was from that time provided with means and:a comfortable living; has now his own preemption.claim among them, with houses upon it, and is worth several hundred dollars, with a good maintenance for himself and little wife for the past year - all acquired within the brief period since the 13th of August, 1878, when he broke faith with the State and turned his back upon the righteous course of crime. The unfortunate state of our Penal Code, which makes the discharge of an accomplice, that he may become 4 witness for the people, unconditional and absolute, enabled this young criminal, under the able advice of the counsel for the defense, to do this thing with perfect impunity, scoffing at and defying the serene majesty of the State.
"Jesse M. Jones first being duly sworn says that on the 28th day of March, 1877, I was arrested and accused of the murder of T. W. More, and put in jail the same day. I was taken to a private room by R. B. Hall. He told me that 1 would be hanged for the murder of More if 1 did nottell it. He said that Sprague had told all about it, and he' said that Sprague said I was one of the party, and the only chance for me to get free was to tell all about it. I told him I knew nothing about it. In two or three days after, my wife came to see me, and they took me to the Palace Hotel to a private room, and then brought my wife and my brother to the room. They told me if I knew anything about the murder to tell it, and then I would be let go. I told them I knew nothing about it, and if I did I would tell it to clear myself. In two or three days, Jonathan Jones came to my cell in jail, and he took me upstairs to the courtroom, and told me he came to get me out of trouble. He said the Mores were putting up a job on me, and they could get Spaniards to swear anything for two or three hundred dollars, and they would convict me whether I was guilty or not. And Austin Brown would swear that he saw me that night and knew me; that Brown came to the cottonwood tree to Join the party, and they had started from the tree, and he wa: afraid to call out to them for fear they would shoot him. Jonathan Jones said there was a Spaniard by the name of Leon Neas that would swear he saw me and knew me, and that if I would do as he said, he could get me out in two or three days, and that I could go home to my wife; and that he would give me $300, and in two weeks he would get me $1,000 more, so that I could leave the country if 1 wanted to, and that there was talk of a mob, and that I was liable to be taken out and hanged at any time.
Murder Of T. Wallace More
to tell the story asa favor - it was: only for my own sake. He said he regarded me as a relative - that they had plenty of evidence to convict every man in the jail, and that [confession] was my only chance of escape. And from fear of my life, | told this great story, made from other evidence, thinking I could go home to my wife; then I could tell why I suid it. But as soon as I told the story, they sent me away to Santa Barbara, away from all my folks and friends, and told me if I told any other story, they would use my Own testimony against me. And for that reason I have told the same story. Burit is Nor rruz. I did not help to kill T. W. More. I was in Pole Cafion all that night with John Curlee, and knew nothing of the murder until we came to Mrs. Cook's the next day, about noon. "Jesse M. Jonzs.
This materially changed the face of things. It was deemed best to dismiss all of the cases pending as no others could be convicted without Jones' testimony. A great effort was made to have the sentence against Sprague, quashed.
Case Reviewed By The Governor
"The history of the case under consideration has been familiar to me since the commission of the atrocious crime, and I, with all other good citizens, desired that law and order should prevail, and the crime receive its just punishment. At the time of the trial of Sprague, Curlee, Lord, and Churchill, I watched it with much interest, and felt that if one was guilty, they all were, and that all who took part in the fiendish murder should receive the punishment they deserve. That all the parties who have been accused have been acquitted, except Sprague, should not, I think, have influence with the Governor in determining if this is a proper case for executive clemency. The charge of counsel that the defendant has been deprived of legal rights through the prejudice or bias of the Judge who presided at the trial, if true, I think there must be a way to correct by proper petition or affidavit presented to a higher legal tribunal, as I cannot believe that justice in any court of the commonwealth can be so far shorn of the robes of honor and right, that a legal technicality can be permitted to deprive a citizen of his life. The great question then presented to my mind, to aid me in arriving at a just termination of the case is, has there been any impeachment of witnesses or new evidence developed since the trial, that would, in my judgment, have induced the jury to render a different judgment had the facts been presented them at the time? The most important witnesses on the part of the State were Brown, Jones, and Hickerson, and their testimony, as received at the time, appears somewhat inconsistent, but it has not been impeached, and is the same as it went tothe jury. We cannot doubt they gave it all the consideration their oath demanded. The testimony, however, of Jones has since been declared by him to have been suborned, and false in particulars. The counsel, on behalf of State, have endeavored to show that Jones' first statement about the Sprague case was true, and that he recanted only when his own personal safety was assured, and then it was done for saving his associates in crime. Be this as it may, I believe it my duty to consider what effect his conflicting testimony would hive had upon the jury had it been presented to them. Five members of the jury, who tried the case, signed a petition for executive clemency. Afterward nine of the jury signed another memoriul, saying that those of them who signed the petition did so because of an appeal made by friends of the prisoner, to their sympathies, and they now wish to retract the recommendation, and re-affirm their verdict. The other three members who were upon the jury, have remained silent, or have stated that.' without the testimony of Jones, the jury could not have arrived at the conclusion it did, and that had Jones' true character been known to the jury, his statements would not have had the weight of' a feather in their deliberations. and the probabilities are that Sprague would have been to-day a free man.' The detective who worked up this case, and materially aided in procuring the testimony of Hickerson, states that since it has come to his knowledge that, while Hickerson was a member of the grand jury, he was in the alleged confession of Sprague to him. He now questions the truth of Hickerson's statement, and has grave doubts as to the guilt of Sprague. Prominent citizens of the State and personal friends have called upon me, and many letters have been received, urging that I do not interfere in the case, but to let the law take its course. Otherwise they fear it will encourage others to commit crimes with the hope they may escape just punishment. Petitions have been received from many thousands, including nine-tenths of the names upon the Great Register of the county where the crime was committed, asking for the pardon of the defendant, or at least a commutation of the sentence that has been pronounced against him. While I have given all the petitions a respectful hearing and a carefal consideration, I have endeavored to be guided in my econclusions by the evidence on the transcript before me.
"Although it has been admitted by some who urged that the sentence of the court, as pronounced, should be executed, that at this time they much doubt, ifa new trial were granted, that it would be possible to convict defendant. I have not considered the assertion, but have endeavored to confine myself to the evidence, as. presented at the trial. And not here considering the question, if the defendant, through any. cause, has been deprived of a review of his trial by the Supreme Court, that, had all the conflicting statements made by Jones at subsequent: -trials, and his own confessions that he had been a suborned witness and had sworn falsely, been presented to the jury in this case, there would have been such a shadow cast upon all the testimony that, had the jury found him guilty of murder, they would, as in the case of Curlee, given Sprague the benefit of a doubt, and affixed the penalty at imprisonment for life, instead of death. Deeply impressed, as I am, by the great power that has been delegated to me by the people, and fully realizing the responsibility of the case, I am convinced it is my duty to commute the sentence of F. A. Sprague from death to imprisonment during his life, in the State prison."
The accused were permitted to go out free. No other persons were ever arrested, none looked for. No person, lawyer or simple citizen, ever for a moment thought of looking further for the murderers. The public verdict may be summed in the words, "guilty, but not proved so." There is but one conclusion possible in the matter: The act was approved by so large a portion of the people, that conviction was impossible.
The whole matter is a blot upon the fair fame of Ventura County. But before we proceed to pronounce judgment. let the reader put himself in the place of either party. More undoubted!y bought the Sespe under the belief that he was getting six leagues, and like almost every man, wanted what he had paid for, and with his accustomed energy and decision, set about keeping it. The settlers thought they were on Government land, and determined to maintain their rights. The strongest element in man's character is the love of home. It overrides justice and law; is older than law; it is contemporary with life. When it is assailed, all his furious nature is course of events. The wisest and best being who ever lived on earth, said: "Lead us not into temptation." The source of the temptation is in our deficient land system, which makes large land-holdings and landless people possible.
Tue publishers of this work, in their historical publications, have generally given an especial account of the members of the legal profession. The unsettled state of portions of California, and the absence of' all law but that of might, in the earliest days, rendered the establishing of law and order peculiarly difficult. The lawless element, or those whose business it was to live on the industry of others, as well as those who loved the license that the absence of law gave them, desired the postponement of courts as long as possible; while those who were willing to render unto every man his own, had little confidence in the integrity of the officers who had to be chosen, in a somewhat irregular manner, which sometimes resulted in putting into office men who were utterly unworthy of power. The writer of this work, during a residence of a third of a century in the State, has more than once seen a man elected to the position of magistrate law-abiding man - he who expects to derive peace and security to his rights of person and property in the just observance of wholesome laws - will rather sacrifice something to the form of law than appeal to an irresponsible power, such as the public assembly usually is, knowing that the first has a tendency to the ultimate establishing of law and order, while the latter certainly tends to abrogate all law; for when once an appeal is made to lynch law, however just the verdict given may be, the worst element of society is sure to find excuse and justification to wreak vengeance and wrong on estimable citizens, on insignificant provocation. The lawyer who, under such circumstances, comes boldly forward and asserts his difficulties, and becomes, to some extent, a martyr to justice by sacrificing present popularity for the public good, deserves an honorable mention in history. In most counties the historian has found bright examples of such men, who risked popularity, and even life, in defense of law and order. Santa Barbara County has been found no exception. The names of Hinchman, Huse, Lies, Fernald, Hoar, Packard and others shine brightly in the attempts to bring about peace and security. In this they were ably seconded by the principal Spanish families, who had little sympathy with the class who are ever ready to violate the law when personal advantages are to be gained, or when personal affronts are to be avenged, and who appeal to law only to make it a shield against punishment. Blackstone defines law to be the perfection of common sense. While the almost hereditary magistrates, the Hon. Joaquin Carrillo and Judge Pablo de la Guerra, who so long presided over the courts, had little knowledge of law forms, they had an abundance of good common sense, which enabled them to administer substantial justice; and with the assistance of the legal gentlemen above mentioned, pay due observance to law forms, and thus lay the foundation for that peace and security for life and property which has been so distinguished a feature in the history of the county.
The Hon. Joaquin Carrillo
Who resigned his place as County Judge, to become District Judge, was the son of Domingo Carrillo, who was the third son of Raymundo Carrillo, the founder of the family in Santa Barbara, and the first commandante of the Post- To him, perhaps not less than to Pablo de la Guerra, was due the deference which the Spanish race paid to the American law which was imposed on them. He was the District Judge for fourteen years, being appointed in 1852, to fill the unexpired term of Judge Teft, who was drowned at Port Harford.
The Bar Hon. Pablo De La Guerra
Occupied the position of District Judge after 1866, until near the time of his death, when Walter Murray was elected. An extended notice of Judge de la Guerra is found on page 144, which gives a full account of his career.
Augustus F. Hinchman Albert Packard
Was from the Eastern States, and had the benefit of a classical education; and in addition to his law practice, devoted some of his time to the advancement of schools in Santa Barbara. He was employed in some very important land cases. notably that of T. Wallace More, in pressing his suit before the United States Commissioners and courts for the Sespe Rancho. He did not remain in Santa Barbara long. He is now a distinguished land lawyer in Washington. ALBERT PACKARD
Is a native of Rhode Island, born about 1820. He was raised to the shoe-making business, which is said, for some unknown reason, to be conducive to mental development - a shoemaker, according to tradition, being always ready to pick up the cudgels of argument or sarcasm. At any rate, the trade has furnished very able men to the world, among whom we find Roger Sherman, Henry Willson and others whom the reader will readily call to mind. Mr. Packard had an extensive travel before coming to California, having engaged at one time in business in South America. Upon arriving at Santa Barbara, he became engaged in real estate speculations which left him possessed of much vuluable property in the vicinity. He is at present residing in San Francisco, attending to his extensive land matters.
Charles E. Huse
him again, to make the record of the Bar cumplete. Fhe following brief memorandum of his life has been received since the first notice went to press: -
He was born in the town of Newburyport, Massachusetts, March 1, 1825, his parents being Enoch and Hannah Woodman Huse. His father died at the age of sixty, and his mother at the age of eighty-eight. The Huse family generally attain a great age. The progenitor of the family in New England was Abel Huse, who emigrated from London in 1632. Several of the Huse family held high rank in the Revolutionary War.
ward Everett being the President at that time. Mr Huse commenced the study of law in the office of the Hon. Peleg Sprague, United States District Judge, but did not finish the usual course, coming to California in the year 1849, and locating three years later in Santa Barbara, where he has since resided. He was appointed County Clerk, April 14, 1852, and performed the duties of that office - also those of Recorder and Auditor at the same time, without any deputy - and was also Deputy Postmaster. In the general election of 1852, he was chosen to the. Assembly. He was admitted to practice in the District Court of the Second Judicial District, October 17, 1853, and to the Supreme Court in 1855; and in October, 1864, to the United States District Court, and 'May 4, 1866, to the Circuit Court of the United States, as attorney, solicitor, counselor and proctor.
He often officiated as City Attorney, Member of the Common Council, etc. December, 1854, he was appointed District Attorney by the Court of Sessions, and elected and appointed to the same office for six years. The reasons for these appointments have been mentioned in the previous part of this volume. He also acted as Treasurer when the county bonds were to be issued for the building of the county road mentioned on previcus pages. The Treasurer, who was opposed to the construction of the road, resigning, to make a confusion or delay, Mr. Huse, with the assistance of the Board of Supervisors, made good the vacancy, being appointed Treasurer, and the bonds were issued on time, although the whole matter of appointment, procuring bonds for the faithful performance of duty, and the issuance of county bonds with coupons attached, had to be done in twentyfour hours.
Hon. Charles Fernald
Who acted so large a share in the history of Santa Barbara through a period of over a quarter of a century, is fully noticed in connection with his portrait, facing page 36 of this volume. It may be said of him, in addition to the biographical notes accompanying his portrait, that he is at this writing the efficient Mayor of Santa Barbara, advocating all the
Name was common in the early history of the county, being one of the few who had a knowledge of law forms and the practices of courts. He officiated as Treasurer, Assessor, County Clerk and District Attorney at different times, and was once a member of the Legislature. He wasa man of considerable talent but had some social habits that did not add to his usefulness. He died in San Francisco many years since.
Judge Eugene Fawcett
Whose name occurs in the early history of the county, is a native of Boston, and a member of the family that has furnished so many distinguished statesmen of that name. When Fernald came to Santa Barbara, he found Hinchman, Hoar, Huse and Lies pleading law and trying to model the courts of justice somewhat after the New York practice. Hoar had some social habits at the time that rather militated against his advancement, but he was considered by all as a man of undoubted talent. He remained but a few years in Santa Barbara, when he returned to Boston, in the vicinity of which he was still residing at the last accounts, engaged in agriculture. JUDGE EUGENE FAWCETT
Was bornin Belmont County, Ohio, March 22, 1845, residing there with his parents until 1864, wken, being then nineteen years of age, he went to New York as a member of the editorial staff of the Herald. Onthe breaking out of the war between Chili and Spain in 1865, he visited South America, as the special correspondent of the Herald, remaining there until the latter part of 1866 when he returned to New York, retaining his position as writer until 1867, when he removed to Chariton, Iowa, and commenced the study of the law. In 1870 he was admitted to practice in the Supreme Court of that State, and soon established a reputation for bringing his cases well prepared before the Court. His fuiling health indicating the malady which afterwards proved fatal in 1873, he came to Santa Barbara, where a year later he married Miss Minnie Pray, whose acquaintance he had made while she was a student at the Santa Barbara College. In November, 1875, he was appointed District Judge to fillthe place made vacant by the death of Judge Marray, which place he held until the Court was abolished by the New Constitution. In 1878 he was elected by a large majority as a delegate to the Constitutional Convention while stil] District Judge, on which account his eligibility to the Convention was contested on the ground that no man could constitutionally hold two offices at the same time. The matter being referred to the Committee on Privileges and Elections, was finally decided favorably to Judge Fawcett, the ground taken being that the delegates were not officers within the meaning ofthelaw. The Judge took occasion to explain that the position came unsought to him; was in some degree unwelcome, but that being chosen by a handsome majority, he felt impelled to accept the responsibilities thereof. The Convention indorsed the action of the committee by a vote of 74 to 49, being nearly a party vote.
Judge Fawcett was a type of that strong homely virtue which the people of the United States have delighted to honor, and which has found its best illustrations in the lives of Garfield and Lincoln. Rough even to brusqueness in his manner, it was because he was intensely loyal to his convictions and cared less to conciliate an opponent than to maintain the truth. While he bad an utter contempt for the vices of political and social life, he had a leaning towards the merciful in his judgment of the follies and weaknesses of humanity. As a Judge he swept away, as with a besom, the technical cobwebs with which modern practice has surrounded the profession of the law, and, with an instinct and power born of bis love of'truth, grasped the principal points in a case and came into Court strongly intrenched in legal precedents. Personally, he was rough hewn, of which, however, he was rather proud, and having a boundless disdain for a pretty man, as sume found to their cost when they assumed any patronizing airs. He was of that rare class of men who are loved and trusted by women, feared and respected by men. If he had inherited a constitution that permitted long and persistent study and action, he would have left a name to be remembered in the annals of the nation.
Asa Judge should be, Mr. Fawcett was decisive and stern in his rulings, never allowing latitude to witness or lawyer under any circumstances. This incident will serve to illustrate the characteristic: While sitting as Judge of the 17th District Court, engaged in the trial of one of the suspected murderers of T. W. More, he was met by a protest from Creed Haymond, J. M. Brooks and W. W. Allen, attorneys for defendant, that Fawcett was no longer Judge, having vacated the position by becoming a member of the Constitutional Convention, whereupon the Judge fined them $250 each for contempt of Court, alleging that it was not their province to determine whether the de facto Judge was so by law or not. The attorneys entered affidavit that they had no intention of casting contempt upon the Court, but were acting solely in the interests of their client.
It seemed that Allen, one of the attorneys mentioned, had not been admitted to practice in the Court in which the trials were being held, whereupon he was fined an additional $250.
Judge Fawcett was held in the utmost regard by all the attorneys of his acquaintance. After his death, when some of the parties accused of the murder of T. Wallace More were on their second trial, the principal attorney for the defense saw fit to severely attack Judge Fawcett, not only regarding his decisions, but also ay to his personal character. The attack was so outrageous that a meeting of the Bar of Santa Barbara was held to consider the matter. Resolutions were passed that the attack was indecent, violent, abusive, and false; that, considering that the dictive, and inexcusable, not only maligning the memory of a pure and just man, but as wantonly injuring the feelings of his wife and family.
Francis John Maguire
What a train of thought the name of this man starts. The loug array of Irish patriots and statesmen that have given their lives and fortunes to the welfare of the beautiful but ever-unfortunate isle - Emmett, O'Conner, O'Connel, and others - a long list who vainly exerted themselves to free Ireland, and whose efforts, except as they furnish incidents to _inspire the future youth, seem lost.
He was born in the city of Cork, Ireland, in 1823, of excellent family, numbering warriors and statesmen in its ranks. He had a brother in Parliament, and other relatives, as well as friends, in high places, and had only to give allegiance to the ruling power to have had wealth, honor, and position bestowed upon him. But, with a heart deeply sympathizing with the oppressed and downtrodden everywhere, he could ill become an agent in crushing still lower his unfortunate countrymen.
He joined the liberal or patriotic party, and advocated its principles so well that the Government determined upon his arrest and trial for the high crime of treason. He made his way to the United States, arriving in New York in 1848, and a few years later to California, making his home in Santa Barbara.
of the Spanish race on the coast. He did much to reconcile them to the different styles of land-holding and land laws introduced by the Americans. He was also instrumental in teaching them the duties as well as privileges of American citizens, and otherwise benefiting them.
A meeting of the Bar was called to pay proper respect to his memory. Resolutions recognizing his virtues as a man, his talent and honor as a Counsel and Judge, and his high principles as a citizen of his adopted country, were adopted, also a resulution of sympathy and condolence to the bereaved family.
A deputation of the Bar, consisting of B. T. Williams, W. C. Stratton, R. B. Canfield, C. E. Huse, E. B. Hall, Paul R. Wright, C. A. Gray, and C. A. Thompson was appointed by request of the family to act as pall-bearers. He was a resident of the county twenty-six years, seventeen of which he spent in the public service.
He was broad and liberal in his views, warm in sympathy, and extensive in charity; a public benefactor always ready to promote any public improvement, and was among the foremost in planning the erection of a permanent wharf, building the public roads, and urging the construction of a railroad. He was prudent in his discourse, courteous, yet firm, in manner, and as an officer, tempered all his judicial sentences with mercy and pity.
Was born in Eastport, Maine, in 1821. Going West at an early age he became a student at Lafayette College, in Pennsylvania, subsequently pursuing his law studies with Joseph S. Updegraff, of Sidney, Ohio. When the Mexican War broke out, Mr. Sturgeon enlisted as a non-commissioned officer and participated in the hardships and glories of that contest. In 1849 he came to this coast, with the United States Mounted Rifles, from which he was transferred, on the beginning of the Indian wars in Oregon, to the First Dragoons, and served therewith until his discharg, in 1852. Again enlisting, he participated in the hostilities against the Rogue River Indians, in Oregon, and the Kahmiaka tribe, in Washington Territory. In 1857 he came to Los Angeles, moving thence in 1861 to Santa Barbara, where he has since resided. Engaging in the practice of law, he was, after a time, elected to the office of District Attorney, which he filled to the acceptation of the people. Mr. Sturgeon married Miss Ramona Valenzuela in 1862, the couple now having a numerous family. Mr. Sturgeon has of late turned his attention in part to agriculture, and possesses a fine ranch of several hundred acres of good land in the vicinity of Santa Maria.
ters that delight in measuring swords with one who is worthy of his steel. He is like General Taylor, does not know when he is whipped, but keeps firing away.
Mr.Sturgeon is a forcible writer, and, underthe nom de plume of '' El Cabo," worried the politicians and hungry land sharks very much a few years since.
Milton Wason
Formerly Judge of the County Court of Ventura, and a well-known and widely-honored citizen, was born in Hillsborough County, New Hampshire, in January, 1817. His ancestry were of Revolutionary stock, one grandfather having been Captain in Washington's army at White Plains; the other was also engaged in that war, fighting at Bunker Hill. Judge Wason achieved a college education, belonging to the class of 1842, at Dartmouth. Teaching school for two years, he then proceeded to Boston, and entered the law office of Phillips & Robbins, and completing the ordinary legal course, was admitted to the Bar in 1846. Mr. Wason came to California in 1849, and sinking the lawyer in the gold-digger, labored for over three years in the mines. From 1853 to 1868 he was a farmer in Solano County, representing the county in the State Senate in 1863 and 1864. He moved to San Buenaventura in 1868. In the latter location he has held the office of County Judge for five years, and was State Senator from Ventura for 1880-81. At present he is Deputy Collector of Internal Revenue. In consequence of his agricultural operations and public positions, Mr. Wason has never practiced law to any extent. He was married in 1852 to Miss Maria Angelica Borgniss, and the couple have four children.
ance, and blunt in speech, more given to the equities: of law than its technicalities. He is deservedly popular among the rural population, probably for the same reason that was urged as the source of Millard Fillmore's popularity with the people, 7. ¢, "he never deceived them." He has a miscellaneous library of several hundred volumes, modern works. on the sciences predominating.
Walter Murray
Was one of that class of men from whom heroes are made, whose tremendous motive power is always urging them to action. His career furnishes incident enough to fill a good-sized volume. With a physical development that would stand up to the work his mind conceived, he would have taken the first rank in the nation,
He was anative of England, coming to the United States at an early day, however, so that the character of American society moulded his in all things. When during the Mexican War it was deemed best to send to this coast a thousand young and vigorous men to re-mould society, and introduce American habits of business and thought, the novelty of the project enlisted his support at once, and he secured a position in Stevenson's Regiment, which reached California in time to take part in the closing up of the war. He was with Fremont in his famous passage of the San Marcos Pass, Christmas Day, 1847. He was also in time to witness and take a part in the rush for the newly-discovered gold diggings. He mined a year or two in Sonora, and was associated with Dr. Gunn in the publication of the Sonora Herald, the first paper published in the mines. To his pen principally was due the marked vigor of the paper, which sold, as our information says, like hot cakes, at a dollar a copy. In 1853 he came to San Luis Obispo, studied law, and in due season commenced practice. He became inevitably a power in politics, making his talent felt in every convention, and was twice elected to the State Senate, though belonging tothe Whig Party that was then in its decadence. When on February 5, 1874, Judge de la Guerra was compelled to resign on account of his health, he was appointed to fill the unexpired term. His death occurred October 5, 1875, while in office.
To say that Judge Murray had no enemies would be to a great extent wrong. No man of his positive and aggressive character can pass through life without evoking opposition, but it may be said truthfully that he died universally respected. He had none of the time-serving, truculent spirit so common among successful politicians, but was Walter Murray always, making warm friends as well as enemies. He had an intellect of the first order, and was never confused or misled by sophistries, which he would brush aside like cobwebs. He was an honor to the Bar and to the State which he helped to build up.
Was born in Kentucky, of respectable parentage, one of his relations having been a Congressman. Mr. Dillard was partially educated at the University of Virginia, leaving college before the completion of his course, to join the Confederate Army. He was a member of Forrest's and Wheeler's divisions of cavalry, and participated in the battle of Chickamauga. On the conclusion of the war, Mr. Dillard studied law with Chief Justice Stykes, of Kentucky, and 'was admitted to the Bar in 1867. Two years later, he found himself a clerk in the law office of Judge Myrick, in San Francisco, and stayedthere a year. At the end of that time be located permanently in Santa Barbara. Since his arrival, he has entered into politics to some extent, running as the Democratic nominee for the County Judgesbip, and missing the election by sixteen votes. On the death of Judge Maguire, he was appointed to fill the unexpired term, which he did to the satisfaction of all concerned. Judge Dillard is honest, warm-hearted, and impetuous, above anything like intrigue, or bargain and sale, and would commit suicide rather than betray a friend, or do a mean thing, and consequently has hosts of friends and no enemies. He is given rather to udvise a peaceful settlement than costly litigation - a habit hardly productive of big fees. He is an ardent lover of nature, taking long walks over the hills. He is also well read up in general literature.
This well-known member of the Bar was born in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, in 1842. His family is of Welsh descent, but became connected with many of the old families of Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania by marriage, so that the name is now connected with many other stocks. His father's name was John Custis Richards, the miidle name being derived from the Custis family that Washington married into Dr. John (ustis Richards was highly esteemed, not only for his medical knowledge, but. for his scientific attainments, which, in view of his duties and labors as a physician, were something remarkable. He accumulated a large library of scientific works, which was entirely destroyed by fire when the rebels destroyed Chambersburg. Young Richards, at the age of seventeen, was traveling in Europe with a tutor and finishing his classical education. After spending three years in Switzerland and Germany, he returned, and entered the Jaw school of Columbia College, in New York City, where he graduated in 1866, receiving a special prize of $150 for a thesis on municipal law. The Committee on Diplomas was Hamilton Fish, Samuel D. Ruggles, Theodore Dwight, and other eminent men. He prosecuted his Jaw studies tor awhile in the office of Brown, Hall & Vanderpool, of New York, but his health failing, he went to Erie, Pennsylvania, where he alternated the practice of law with editing the political department of -the-Daily Erie Republican until
1868, when he came to Santa Barbara and associated himself with the Hon. Charles Fernald, with whom he remained about seven years. J ring his residence here he has served the comm ity in various ways, as Mayor of the city, City Atiorney, ete. As Mayor he was very efficient in bringing the expenses within the income, and in promoting reforms generally, so much so that there was a general desire for his re-election. He was the editor of the Times (daily and weekly) for many years, and wielded a vigorous and trenchant pen, not always on the popular side, however, which probably caused his defeat, when he was nominated in 1879, asthe Associate Justice of the Supreme Court. During his editorial career he opposed the subsidizing of the Atlantic and Pacific California Railroad, then a very popular project. The defeat of the measure was owing to a great extent, to his vigorous editorials. He has an extensive and valuable practice. His name has been frequently mentioned in this volume in connection with the most important events of the county. Mr. Richards is a strong and elegant writer, forming his style after classic models. His mind is eminently judiciary, being by his mental peculiarities better fitted to act asa judge than as a special pleader, and is not what is termed a brilliant orator, though sensible and pleasant in his speech. His logical powers are too strong to permit his becoming a special pleader, or making brilliant flights in oratory on every insignificant subject. He hasan elegant home, and is well fixed in the world.
Was a lawyer of much prominence in Santa Barbara ten years since. He was a popular speaker and a much respeeted man for his talents and character. He was prominent in every movement for the improvement of the city or the development of the country. He was the promoter of the project for colonizing the Santa Ana Rancho, which, however, did not succeed. It is not known where he is at
Provenance
Text from HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.