Santa Clara County, California - The whole text, 1881 (part 6 of 24)
From History of Santa Clara County, California : Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description .., published 1881. 15,999 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,999 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Santa Clara County, California : Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description .., published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
It is enough, however, for the present, to say that this Court has decided that under the words "more or le.ss" such fractional part of a league over and above the number of leagues mentioned will pass, as may be contained within the boundaries described in the grant. This point was not discussed at the hearing of this case, the District Attornev bainof aware that it had already been pa.ssed upon by the Court.
The questions more particularly debated were: - First, whether the Court had any power by its decree to designate the boundaries of the tract confirmed to the claimant, or whether the language of the grant must be adopted, leaving the location of the boundaries and the identilication of the natural objects called for to the Surveyor General. Secondly, what were the boundaries called for.
As to the first point I entertain no doubt. The Court is not, it is true, authorized by the Act to designate the " extent, locality and boundaries" of the land. This, in the absence of a preliminary survey, would be impracticable; but the determination of the validity of a claim to a particular tract of land necessarily involves an inquiry, to a certain degree, into the boundaries or the extent of the tract, the validity of the title to which is in question.
If the Court decrees tliat the title of the claimant is valid to a piece of land, it should by its decree identify and designate that land, so that it may be known to what the claim is valid. But surely it is not only its right but its duty to construe by the aid of evidence and argument any ambiguity or uncertainty apparent on the face of the grant itself, and where the grant, as in this case, speaks of a "Sierra" as a boundary, to ascertain and declare what Sierra is meant, and to express in its decree that it confirms a claim to a tract bounded by a particular and specified Sierra, anl not by such Sierra as the Surveyor General may consider to have been inten leil.
The Supreme Court, in many of the cases brought up on appeal from this Court, have entered fully and freely into the question of boundaries, and appear to have considered their determination not only as within their jurisdiction, but as an appropriate and important part of their duties.
The remaining question to be considered is, what boundaries were intended by the grantor. The only one of those mentioned, the identity of which was debated, is the southern boundary mentioned in the grant as "thj Sierra." The point to be determined is - -what natural object was meant.
The evidence shows that the tract called Capitancillos is a valley lying along an cirrov/o or brook; on the southerly side extends a range of low hills, running from east to west. At their eastern extremity, where they are intersected by the Alamitos, these hills attain considerable elevation, but they decline in height towards the west, where they reach and are turned by the Arroyo Seca. Behind this ridge or cuchilla the main Sierra or mountain chain raises itself to a great height, and is separated from the ridge of " lomas bajas," already spoken of, by the two streams mentioned. These streams rise at an inconsiderable distance from each other and flowing in opposite directions between the Sierra and the lomas bajas, they turn the eastern and westei-n extremities of the latter and debouch into the plain. Upon the slopes of the ridge of low hills, as well towards the valley on the north as towards the streams behind it on the south, the best or most permanent grazing is to be found, and on this ridge are situated the valuable quicksilver mines, the existence of which gives to this inquiry its chief importance.
The question is - Is the Sierra mentioned in the grant the mountain chain to the south of the lomas bajas, or is it the lomas bajas themselves ?
If there were no other means of determining this question, the word " Sierra " itself, by its necessary import, as well as from the evidence which shows to which of these natural objects it was in fact applied, would leave little room for doubt. The natural and ordinary meaning of the term clearly points us to a great mountain chain, rather than to a ridge of low hills parallel to but separated from it. The evidence is conclusive that such was the meaning and use of the word with reference to these particular natural objects, and that while the mountain range was known as the Sierra, the ridge of low hills was known as the "Cuchilla la mina de Luis Chaboya," or as the lomas bajas.
The expediente furnishes more conclusive evidence on this point. The tract is described, as we have seen, as of one " league, a little more or less, as is explained by the map accompanying the expediente." On this map is found rudely delineated a mountain range, and this mountain range is inscribed "Sierra del Encino," or "of the oak tree." The Sierra mentioned in the grant is therefore evidently the " Sierra del Encino," for that is the only Sierra delineated on the map.
The evidence discloses that there is on the main Sierra or mountain chain an oak tree of extraonhnar}'- proportions and strikin!:f appearance. Situated on a sjKir or ridge of the mountain, it is a conspicuous natural oLject from all parts of the valley and for many miles around. The photograph exhibited in Court shows that its size and isolated situation arc such as to strike the eye and arrest the attention of the most casual oUscrver. Few who reside in that part of the country but are ac([uainted with the existence and situation of this tree, and it appears in the speech of many of the formeiinhabitants to have given a name to the Sierra on which it is .situated. If then, as appears indisputably, the Sierra referred to in the grant be the " Sierra del Encino," the Sierra on which this oak tree is situated must be the one.
The grant we are considering mentions as the eastern boundary of the tract granted " the rancho of citizen Jose R. Berreyessa, tuhich has for a boundary a line running from the junction of the Arroyo Seca and Arroyo de los Alamitos southwai'd to the Sierra," et3. This line thus dividing the two ranchos had previously been a subject of dispute between the colindmites or neighboring proprietors. It was finally settled, however, by the Government before the grants issued, and a dotted line, indicating the boundary agreed upon by the parties and fixed by the Government was made on the diseno of Berreyessa. This line is described in both grants in the same terms.
That under consideration i-efers, as we have seen, to the rancho of Berreyessa as the boundary of the rancho of Justo Larios, and then describes the line as the boundary of Berreye.ssa's tract. The same inverted mode of description is used in the grant to Berreyessa. To determine what the boundary of Justo Larios' land is, we must, in literal compliance with the terms of the grant, ascertain the boundary of Berreyessa's land, and in ascertaining the latter we resort to the map on which the dotted line is marked. In Berreyessa's grant, as in that of Justo Larios, the line is described as extending to the " Sierra," and as the ranchos were conterminous, and the eastern boundary of one is the western boundary of the other, the " Sierra " to which their common line of division extends must be the same. On recurring, then, to Berreyessa's map and the dotted line alluded to, all doubt is dissi[)ated as to the range of mountains referred to.
On this map two ranges of hills or mountains are rudely but unmistakeably delineated. They are separated by a broad valley - far broader than that actually existing, but indicating by its exaggerated delineation the discrimination in the grantor's mind between the ridge of low hills and the Sierra, or mountain range behind it. The lower ridge is inscribed "Lomas Bajas," while the chain behind it and distinctly separated from it is in.scribed "Sierra Azul," from the hue which the mountains assume at a distance.
The dotted line which by the grant is to terminate at the " Sierra " is produced across the " Lomas Bajas," across the valley beyond them, and terminates at the " Sierra Azul."
There can thus be no room for doubt that the Sierra intended was the main Sierra or mountain range, and as the western line of the land of Berreyessa extended to this range, the land of Justo Larios, which has the same line described in the same terms as its eastern* boundary, must have the same extent. The Sierra referred to in Justo Larios' grant must necessarily be the same as that referred to in grant the of Berreyessa, and as to the latter, there can be, as we have seen, no question.
Other considerations in support of this view might be urged. I think it unnecessary. There seems to me no room for doubt that the Sierra referred to in the grant was the main Sierra described by the witnesses, and not the range of low hills whi'ch has been attempted to be assigned as a boundary.
The documentary evidence of title exhibited by the claimant in this case is as follows: A petition to the Governor dated December 20, 1844; a marginal decree or order for information by the Governor, and a favorable report by the Secretary, Manuel Jimeno. On receiving this report, the Governor makes the following deci'ee, "January 6, 1845. Granted as asked for and reported by the most Reverend Father Minister Micheltorena."
The claimant has also produced a record of judicial possession, which seems to have been formally given him by the Constitutional Judge of First Instance of the Pueblo of San Jose Guadalupe, February 18, 1846.
It is objected that these documents are insufficient to vest any title, either legal or equitable, in the claimant. It must be admitted that the concession in this case is not the final documento or title which, by the eighth article of the regulations, the Governor was authorized to issue when the definitive concession was made. In Arguello vs. The United States, (18 How., 543) the Supreme Court, after alluding to the " informes " usually required, says: " by the fourth section, the Governor being thus informed may 'accede or not' to the petition. This was done in two ways; sometimes he expressed his consent by merely writing the word ' conoedo ' at the bottom of the expediente; at other times it was expressed with more formality, as in the present case. * * It is intended merely to show that the Governor has ' acceded ' to the request of the applicant, and as an order for a patent or definitive title in due form to be drawn out for execution. It i.s not itself such a document as is required by the eighth section, which directs that the definitive grant asked for being made, a document signed by the Governor shall be given to serve as a title to the parties' interested." But this concession, although not] the final title which issued under the eighth article, is nevertheless a grant. The words of the grant are positive and plain; and though shorter and more informal than the usual decree of concession, commencing with the words " vista la peticion," it is in all respects as effectual to constitute an inchoate or imperfect title.
It has always been held by this Court, that according to the provisions of the regulations the formal or definitive title contemplated by the eighth article could not issue until aft3r the concession of the Governor had been approved by the Departmental Assembly ; and that though the practice of issuing that document in advance of such approval, and in terms " subject to it," obtained to a considerable extent, yet such [a document, where no approval had been obtained, constituted merely an inceptive or equitable title. Whether this latter view be correct or not, no doubt can be entertained that the first decree of concession, whether made in the more formal manner usually observed or, as in the present case, by the short declaration that the land was "granted as asked for," aflbrded the basis for the Departmental Assembly, whose approbation was necessary to perfect or give " definitive validity " to the title.
When, therefore, it appears that this inceptive title has been delivered to the party shortly after its date, and has been regarded by the j udicial officer as furnishing the requisite authority to enable him to put the gi'autee in possession, it should be treated as vesting in the grantee the inchoate or equitable title, which, when followed by occupation and cultivation, ought to be respected.
There is no reason to suppose that when the Governor, after having obtained the requisite information, had acceded to the petition, made a decree of concession, and ordered the patent to issue, he would have declined to sign the title in form. So far as his action was concerned he was fundus officio, except the merely formal actor signing the final " documento ;" and it may well be doubted whether, if this concession had been approved by the Assembly, he would have been at liberty to withhold from the party the formal evidence of title which the eifjhth article directs him to issue in such cases. It is not explained why the Governor did not in this case pursue the more usual practice of issuing the final title "subject to the approval of the Assembly." He may, perhaps, in strict conformity with the regulations, have withheld it until the approval was obtained, or he may, according to the loose and informal practice of the countiy, have considered that for so small a piece of land the grant indorsed upon the petition was sufficient to secure the rights of the applicant. The concession was at all events delivered to the grantee ; for we find it in his hands very soon after its date, and by virtue of it the possession was formally delivered to him.
" From a careful examination of all the proofs in the case, we think the preponderance of proof is in favor of the claimant, and must be regarded as establishing the fact of the cultivation of the place, by Garcia, from a period anterior to the grant, to the time of sale to Enright" (the present claimant). We see no reason to dissent from this conclusion.
The remaining question relates to the location and extent of the land. The petition described it as " two thousand" varas of farming land; a note in the margin of the petition, by Pacheco, states that the petition for the farming land is for eight thousand varas.
Under this description juridical possession was given of a piece of land two thousand varas square. There might, perhaps, be some room to doubt whether the land described in the petition was two thousand varas square or two thousand squai-e varas; but the note of Pacheco, the construction given to the concession by the Alcalde, as well as the natural interpretation of the words when properly used, satisfy us that the intention was to grant a piece of land two thousand varas square, or bounded by a line eight thousand varas long, taking the four sides together, as stated by Pacheco.
On the whole, we are of opinion that the grantee acquired by the concession, an inceptive or inchoate title, which, when followed by cultivation and juridical possession, constitute an equity the United States are bound to respect. The decree of the Board must be afiirmed.
Where a decree, thi-ough mistake or accident, does not express the judgment of the Court, it may be corrected on motion made after the expiration of the term at which it was enrolled.
When this case was called in its order on the calendar, the District Attorney stated to the Court that he had no objection to make to the aflirmance of the decree of the Board and to the confirmation of the claim. An order confirming the claim was thereupon entered upon the minutes, and the parties were directed to draft the decree and present it to the Judge for signature, first submitting it to the District Attorney for examination. A draft decree was aireonlingly presented to the Jud<,a', with an indorsement thereon, signed by the District Attorney, that the same was correct. It was therefore signed by the Judge witliout examination, and 'in entire reliance upon the consent of the District Attorney that the decision of the Board should be affirmed, and his certificate that the form of the decree was correct.
Notice liaving been received from the Attorney General tliat the United States would not prosecute the a])peal from the decision of the Board, and a decree in this Court having been made, as above stated, before the reception of the notice, the District Attorney entered into a stipulation and consent that, no appeal should be taken from the decree of this Court, and that the claimants might proceed as under a final decree. After this stipulation was entered into, it was discovered by the District Attorne}', that, through error or accident, the description of the land, contained in the decree of this Court, was widely diff'erent from that contained in the decree of the Board; and that the land confirmed by this Court is of larger extent and different situation from that confirmed to the claimants by the Board - the claim to which alone he intended to consent should be affirmed, and the United States hail consented not further to litigate. A motion is now made to amend the decree signed by this Court, as above stated, so as to make it conform to the decision of the Board. It is resisted, on the ground that the term having expired, the Court has no power to alter or amend its final decrees.
If the application were intended to procure a revision and correction of any errors, either in law or in fact, or to change opinions once given, or to obtain a new decision, it would of course be denied. Even if a Court had no jurisdiction over the cause, the judgment is binding until reversed on error. (6 How., 31.) But in this case, so far as the Court can be said to have passed at all upon the questions submitted to it, its judgment and intention wei'e that the decision of the Board should be affirmed. It certainly cannot be said to have intended to depart from that decision by confirming to the claimant another and a different tract.
Such was the obvious effect of the first order of confirmation directed in open Court to be made, and such was supposed to be the effect of the decree signed on the faith of the District Attorney's certificate of correctness. If then, through accident or mistake of the District Attorney, the decree approved by him and signed by the Court^does not describe the land which he was willing should be confirmed, and which the Court supposed it was confirming, it would seem to present a case of mistake which the Court after enrollment has the power to correct. In so doing it makes no new decree, nor does it review or reverse any former judgment, nor make a new decision on points already passed upon. It merely makes the written decree conform to what was in fact the judgment of the Court, and enters a decree now, such as it intended to enter then.
In that case a decree was improperly entered at a previous term by the inattention of counsel who drew it. It was sought to be amended on motion.
Per Curiam. - " The practice of this Court heretofore and of the Federal Courts in this place has been inquired into, and it appears that in all cases where, by nnistake, an entry has been made, it has been rectified on motion. And where any error has been committed by the officers of the Court, or gentlemen of the Ba-r, it has been corrected on motion. Let the decree be set aside and entered now as it should have been."
A similar power appears to have been exercised by Lord Hardwicke, in Kevijp vs. Squire, (1 Vesey, Jr., 205) and in other cases cited in the brief on the part of the United States.
On the whole, we think that the case presented is one where the Court has the authority to amend its decree ; and that a decree should be entered nunc pro tunc, affirming the decision of the Board, and confirming the claim of the appellees to the land as therein described.
It should, perhaps, be observed that it is contended by the counsel for the claimant that the decree entered in this Court does not substantially differ from that of the Board. It is enough to say that the description of the land is entirely different, and designates boundaries not mentioned either in the original petition of the claimant, or in any of the documents presented by her. It is apparent that the land confirmed by the decree of this Court may he different from that confirmed by the Board. The possible existence of such a discrepancy would seem to be enough to warrant the amendment of the decree, so that it may conform to the decision intended to be, as expressed in the decree itself, " in all things affirmed."
Where one of two persons to whom a grant was made has exhibited a deed from his co-grantee, and obtained a confirmation of his claim to the whole tract, the co-grantee who has presented his separate claim for his half, and who denies the execution of the deed, is entitled to a confirmation as against the United States, and the rights of the parties inter sese will be left to be determined by the ordinary tribunals.
In this case the genuineness of the grant, the regularity of the proceedings, and the fulfillment by the grantees of all the conditions are established by abundant proofs, and admitted on the part of the United States. The proceedings up to the issuance of a final title and including an approval of the grant by the Departmental Assembly, were conducted in strict conformity to the Regulations of 1828; and on June 11, 1834, the final documento required by those regulations was issued to the appellants, Maximo Martinez and Domingo Peralta.
The present claim is by the representatives of the latter, and is for onehalf of the rancho. Maximo Martinez has also presented his claim, which, however, embraced the whole rancho. To establish his title to the share of his co-grantee, he gave in evidence an alleged conveyance, dated May 19, 1884, from Peralta to himself. As this conveyance seemed iDvimd facie toshow the whole title to be in Maitinez, the claim to the whole was confirmed to him by the Board and by this Court. Domingo Peralta now presents his^ claim, and would clearly be entitled to a confirmation of one-half of the land,^ had not the United States put in evidence the conveyance alleged to have been made by him to Martinez as above stated. Many objections to this document were urged on the part of the claimant; but its genuineness and supposed legal effect wei'e strenuously denied.
The District Attorney declined to argue the questions discussed by claimants, observing that the controversy was one in which the United States had not the slightest interest; the grant was unquestionably valid, and the land had already been confirmed to Martinez, the appeal in whose case had been dismissed by order of the Attorney General, lie further observed, that no decision of this Court could in any way determine private rights in the parties to land admitted not to belong to the United States, and to which the full legal and equitable title was already vested in private individuals.
The District Attorney was understood to say that he interposed no objection to a confirmation to the present claimant, if the Court was of opinion that such a decree should be entered.
It has heretofore been decided by the Board and this Court that third persons have no right to intervene in these proceedings to ascertain whether land claimed under titles derived fiom the former Government is public or private land. As the decree of this Court and the patent issued under it cannot effect the rights of any parties, except the United States and the claimants, it seemed manifestly improper to allow an inquiry, instituted to ascertain the rights of the United States, and to determine what was private and what public land, to be controverted into a complicated series of ci'oss ejectments between various private claimants, and this, where the decision of the Court could not in any event decide the rights litigated before it. The only course, therefore, to be adopted was to confirm to the claimant whenever he, by a deraignment of \!\i\G privid facie regular, showed himself to be the owner of a valid grant.
firming in some cases the same land to different persons claiming under the same original grant. But as each suit was separate, and as the Court could not enter into questions of adverse private rights, this anomaly was not to be avoided. Had the present claimant been permitted to intervene in the case of Martinez, he perhaps might have shown, as he claims to have done in this case, that the alleged conveyance to Martinez was fabricated or inoperative. As he was not permitted to do so, it seems equally improper to allow that conveyance to be introduced into this case, nominally on the part of the United States, but really on the part of Martinez, to defeat the claim of Peralta to a confirmation, which if it were not for that conveyance he would be clearh^ entitled to. Besides, if the validity of that conveyance is to be passed upon by this Court, Martinez should be heard, and allowed to introduce testimony. The District Attorney has neither any interest nor power to represent him. To the United States it is indifferent whether the land beloncfs to both the oricjinal grantees, or to Martinez alone.
To refuse to confirm this claim, is a recognition of the validity of a conveyance which ma^'^ be liable to grave objections. But to confirm the claim, is merely to give to the claimant a right to a deed from the United States, relinquishing and quit-claiming any supposed title they might have been deemed to possess, and the reception of which merely puts the claimant on an equal footing with his adversary, and enables both to contest with equal evidence of title from the United States their adverse rights before the ordinary tribunals. I think that the only course to be adopted is to confirm this claim, and to leave the question of ownership inter partes to be litigated before the tribunals having jurisdiction over the subject matter of the controversy. A decree must be entered accordingly.
The claimants have produced in evidence a grant purporting to have been made by Pio Pico, on June 30, 18i6, conveying the orchard of Santa Clara to Castaiieda, Arenas and Dias in consideration of twelve hundred dollars paid by them to the Government. Also, a memorandum or account, purporting to have been signed by Pico, of the articles furnished to the Government by the Senores Castafieda, Arenas and Dias, in payment of the purchase money of the gardens of Santa Clara and San Jose. This receipt or account is dated Los Angeles, July 2, 1846. The grant purports to be signed by Pio Pico, as Governor, and by Jose' Matias Moreno, as Secretary. Appended to it is the usual certiticato, signed b^' Moreno, stating that "a note of this superior decree has been taken in the corresponding book." No expediente from the archives has been produced, nor do those records contain any trace whatever of the execution of this grant. No corresponding book lias been exhibited, nor is any such found among the archives. No po.s.session of the hind was taken by the grantees during tlio existence ofjthe former Government. It is stated by Jas. Alexander Forbes that the orchard remained in l)os.so.ssion of the missionary priests up to the year 1849 or 1850. About that time, one Osio obtained the po.ssossion, but by what right or title does not appear. The claim thus rests enti)-ely on the alleged grant produced by the parties, with the usual proof of signatures, and on the parol testimony offered by them.
It w^as proved before the Board that at that date Pio Pico was not at Los Angeles, but at Santa Barbara, with his secretary and suite. The claimants have taken, how^ever, in this Court, the deposition of Cayetano Aienas, who testifies that the grant was made in Santa Barbara, and sent, by the Governor, to the witness at Los Angeles, where it was received by him July 4, 184G; and it is suggested that the grant was dated Los Angeles, the Capital of the Department, though actually signed at Santa Barbara', in accordance with the practice of the Governor. The explanation is plausible, though it has somewhat the air of an afterthought to meet a difficulty that had unexpectedly ari.sen.
It is strange, however, that the receipt above referred to should particularly set forth that " it was given, for the security of those interested, in the City of Los Angeles on the second of July, ISJ/J," when, in fact, if executed at all on that date, it must have been executed in Santa Barbara, or on the Governor's own rancho.
The grant, as has been stated, is to Juan Castafieda, Luis Arenas, and Benito Dias. Castaneda is dead. The other two have been examined as witnesses. It is clearly proven, and indeed, admitted by Cayetano Arenas, that the grant is in the handwriting of Castaneda.
It is also in proof that during the month of June, and during the first days of July, 184G, Castaneda was at the head-quarters of General Castro at Santa Clara. That about the lOth of July, he was on the road to Los' Angeles, at which place he arrived about the end of July. These facts are established by the testimony of General Castro himself, by that of Benito Dias, and Cayetano, and Luis Arenas. Dias states that he left Monterey for Los Angeles on the 10th, or 12th of July. That on his way down he met
Castafieda with General Castro; that they proceeded together to Los Angeles, where they arrived about July 20th; that they saw Pio Pico, on their journey, at his rancho of San Marguerita.
Cayetano Arenas, the claimant's witness, states that at the time he received the grant from Pio Pico, viz., July 4th, Castaheda, Benito Dias, Luis Arenas, the father of the witness, w^ere not in Los Angeles, but were in the upper country; and that the latter arrived a few days aftcrwards- Luis Arenas testifies that he first saw the grant in the hands of Castafieda, in his (Arenas') house, in Los Angeles; that he left San Josd for Los Angeles the day after he heard of the taking of Sonoma by the Americans.^ This event occurred in the middle of June. Supposing, then, the witness' memory to be accurate, he must have lingered on the road, if his son is to be believed, a considerable time, for Cayetano Arenas swears, as we have seen, that he received the" grant in Los Angeles, on July 4th, and his father did not arrive until some days afterwards. Luis Arenas further states that he " met Castafieda in Los Angeles a little while after his arrival." We have already seen, however, that Castafieda did not arrive in Los Angeles until about July 20th. And Luis Arenas admits that when Castafieda showed him the grant, Benito Dias and Governor Pico were in the place, and that he saw them every day.
Bearing these facts in mind we proceed to consider the testimony of Dias with respect to the execution of the grant. This witness swears that the grant was executed in Los Angeles about August 1st; that he saw Castafieda write it, and that on the same day he brought it back to the house of Litis Arenas, with the Governor's signature attached to it; that the receipt for money and articles furnished was written a few days after, but that he (the witness) never paid anything on account of purchase. If this testimony be true, there is an end of the case.
The fact that the grant is in the handwriting of Castafieda would seem of itself such a corroboration of Dias' testimony as to exclude much doubt as to its truth. Arenas himself does not pretend to have heard of the grant, or the agreement for the sale of the orchard, until after Castafieda's arrival in Los Angeles, and this notwithstanding that, if the receipt be genuine, he^ Castafieda, and Dias, had, on July 2d, furnished to the Governor cash and various supplies to the amount of three thousand two hundred dollars. He further states that he gave the Governor two hundred head of cattle;. that he received back three hundred dollars in change, and that he delivered to Pico a writing which showed that he made his part of the payment with the two hundred head of cattle, which were then on Pio Pico's rancho. He adds that Pio Pico has these same cattle to this day. Benito Dias states that he knows of the payment for the orchard of Santa Clara only from what Castafieda told him, viz., that he (Castafieda) had given a note to
The fact that the grant is in the handwriting of Castaiieda might, perhaps, be accounted for, consistently with the good faith of the transaction. on the hypothesis, which, however, would be purely conjectural, that Castaiieda had written it out, and sent it to the Governor. But in such case he must have written it before it was signed, and how can we explain the circumstance that the date (June 30, 18iG) is in the handwriting, and evidently written at the same time with the rest of the document? But, supposing this difficulty surmounted, the receipt is evidently antedated, or a fabrication. Arenas could not have assigned the cattle spoken of by him^ and the receipt for which is acknowledged, on July 2d, at Los Angeles. He did not arrive until a few da3's before Castaheda; and his son, the only important witness for the claimants, states that he arrived some days after July 4th. Castaheda could not have paid the cash, or delivered the other articles mentioned in the receipt, on the 2d of July, for at that time he was at the head-quarters of General Castro, at a distance of several hundx'ed miles; and yet the receipt is in his handwriting. The account given by Dias seems the only mode of reconciling these discrepancies, and though I should hesitate to accept his unsupported statement, whether for or against a claimant in cases of this class, in this instance it is corroborated and confirmed by other testimony, as to justify a belief in its truth. Cayetano Arenas is the only witness on the part of the claimants who pretends to have seen the grant before the end of July. If the claim is to be confirmed, it must be on his unsupported testimony. The account given by him bears strong marks of improbability. He states that the grant was sent to him, "as it related to his father's business," and that he was instructed to retain it until Castaheda came down from the upper country. His father arrived a few days after, but Castaheda did not'arrive, as we have seen, until about the 20th. The father of the witness was one of the original grantees. It is sti-ange that he should not only have withheld, for nearly two weeks, his grant from his father, who was as much entitled to receive it as .Castaheda, but should not at least have shown it to him, or, so far as appears, mentioned its reception. That Luis Arenas saw it for the first time in Castafieda's hands is positively stated by himself. The deposition of Cayetano Arenas was taken after the rejection of the claim by the Board. It is, perhaps, not unfair to say that testimony of so much importance, and introduced for the first time after the claim was rejected, is liable to much suspicion. Luis Arenas was examined and cross-examined at length before the Commissioners,
The fact that Pio Pico was not in Los Anjxeles at the date of the grant had already been established. Had he known that the'grant was in the pos- session of his son from July 4th until he delivered it to Castaneda, he would naturally have stated it. He does not allude to the circumstance. It is difficult to imagine that Cayetano Arenas could have received this grant, made for the benefit of his father, amongst others, and retained it in his possession for nearly two weeks, without ever mentioning the fact, either at the time or even subsequently, up to the moment when his father testified before the Commission. There are the circumstances which tend still further to corroborate the statements of Dias. The alleged motive of making this sale was the exigency of public affairs, which compelled the Government to avail itself of all the resources at its disposal. It was dated within a few days of the capture of Monterey. The payment and support of the army must have been of the first necessity, and the use to which the money and other articles would most probably have been applied ; yet Castro, the commanding General states, that he never received any money ai'ising from the sale of the orchiards for the expense of the war, and that if money from that source had been so appropriated, he would certainly have known it. On his cross-examination he repeats that, though Pio Pico might have applied money or property arising from this sale to public uses without his (witness') knowledge, yet he could not have applied it to the use of the army.
But Luis Arenas negatives the idea that the cattle at least were applied to public uses, for he states (perhaps unguardedly) that the two hundred head given by him to Pico are still on Pico's rancho. This fact alone would be sufficient to raise a suspicion that the Governor did not, in a crisis in public affairs, in good faith, attempt to obtain supplies b}' a sale of public domain ; but rather that he has been induced at a subsequent day, for his individual advantage, to sign an antedated title. But if there were less force in all these circumstances, one consideration seems to me decisive. Neither Pio Pico nor Moreno have been examined in the case.
The Governor, in the absence of all evidence from the archives, was the person who of all others could have explained when and why he made the grant; why it was dated at Los Angeles; from whom he received it for signature; to whom he sent it; to what use he applied the property, and how it happened that he signed a receipt for it at Los Angeles, on the. 2d of July, as received from Castaneda, Arenas, and Dias, when no one of them was at that place.
Moreno might have explained how it happened that the grant was in this case written by Castaneda, when the latter was at its date, and for some weeks subsequently, at a distance of several hundred miles. If the grant was written by Castaneda and transmitted to the Governor for signature, Moreno might perhaps have told us how it happened that Castaneda guessed so prophetically the day on which the Governor would sign it, and was able by anticipation to fill in the date at the time he drew the instrument. For
In a case like this, surrounded by circumstances so suspicious, and depending, on the part of" the claimants, upon the testimony of Cayetano Arenas alone, the depositions of the Governor and his secretary ou^ht not to have been withheld. If the decision of this cause depended upon weighinij the unsupported testimony of Arenas against testimony equally unsupported of Dias, the duty of determining whieli had sworn falsely would be difficult as well as painful. But the testimony of Dias is corroborated by every fact in the case, while that of Arenas, if not inconsistent with them, is wholy unsupported, and explanation from the best if not the only source from which it could be furnished, is withheld. 1 think it clearly my duty to reject the claim.
Having reached this conclusion, it is unnecessary to <lisr.jss tie question whether the Gov'ernor had authority to sell the lands of the Missions, or at least the orchards, vineyards and cultivated portions, which, under the d3cree of the Supreme Government and the proclamation of Michel torena, had been restored to the missionary priests.
After the above opinion was read, it was suggested to the Court by the counsel for the claimants, that the deposition of Jose Matias Moreno, which was on file in the case of T. 0. Larkln vs. The United States, had been by consent, admitted as evidence in this. The claim in the case of L%vkin vs The United Stales is founded on the same grant as that exhibited in this case, and is for a part of the orchard.
" Moreno testifies that the signatures of himself and Pico are genuine, and affixed at the time the documents bear date, and that Pico signed them in his presence. He also swears that the documents are in the handwriting of Castaneda, that he saw him write them, and that they were written under his (witness') directions, as he was much occupied with official duties.
" It is enough to say with respect to this statement, that it is abundxntly proved by the testimony of General Castro, Benito Dias, Luis Arenas, and Cayetano Arenas, that Castaiieda could not have bjen at Santa Barbara on either the 30th June or 2d July, the days on which the documents are dated.
" The statement of Cayetano Arenas, the chief witness for the claimants, is wholly incompatible with the idea that Castaneda could have been at Santa Barbara and written the grant by Moreno's directions.
The testimony of Moreno, therefore, entirely fails to afford that satisfactory explanation of the circumstances which the Court is entitled to expect. It has only served to confirm me in the opinion already expressed as to the merits of the claim.
But if the grant be genuine, the claim must be rejected, on the groand that the Governor had no power to grant in colonization, or sell for a money consideration, the orcliards and like property of the missions.
The claim in this case is founded on the alleged grant to Castaheda, Arenas and Dias, the merits of which were considered in the case cf J. W Redman vs. The United States.
The southern, western, and eastern boundaries of the tract granted to Justo Larios declai-ed, leaving the northern boundary to be determined by quantit}^ The former opinion (reported at page 184) with respect to the southern boundary, maintained.
When this case was first submitted to this Court on appeal from the Board of Land Commissioners, it was considered that the four boundaries of the tract were indicated with reasonable certainty by the grant and accompanying diseiio. It did not escape the observation of the Court that only three of those boundaries were designated in the grant, viz., the southern, the western, and the eastern; but it was thought that the description of the tract in the decree of concession as the " Canada de los Capitancillos," and the delineation on the disefio of the two ranges of hills within which it was contained, sufliciently indicated the location of the noi'thern boundary, the mention of which was omitted in the grant.
The Court was confirmed in this view by the representation of the petition, on the diseTio, that the tract delineated upon it was of the extent of one league a little more or less, indicating, as it seemed, that he solicited not a specified quantity, but a particular tract, the estimated area of which he declared to the Governor. When, therefore, the Governor granted to him the tract solicited, and described it as " of the extent of one league, a little more or less, as explained by the map," it seemed to the Court necessary, to carry into effect the intention of the grantor, to confirm to the claimant the tract delineated on the niaj), even though, as anticipated by the Governor, its extent might be " a little" more than onu league; provided such excess did not exceed a fraction of the usual unit of measurement in colonization grants, viz., one league; ur in other words, provided that tiie quantity over and above one league was such as might reasonably be deemed to have been asked for by the petitioner and granted by the Governor, under the description "a square league, a little more or less."
The clause in the third condition, by which the surplus was reserved to the nation, usually called the sohrante clause, was disregarded by the Court, that clause being a formula generally, and almost invariably inserted in all grants, without reference to their nature, and being not unfrequently found in grants where all the boundaries are distinctly defined, and even in grants where no boundaries are mentioned, but which are for tracts of a specified lenofth and breadth, where obviouslv no sohrante can remain.
On the hearing, the location or existence of a northern boundary was not brought in question, but the discussion chiefly, if not exclusively, turned upon the location of the southern boundary - the right of the Court to locate which by its decree was denied by the attorney for the United States. In that view, however, the Court did not coincide; but by its decree it defined and located the southern boundary, and thereby decided the most important if not the only point discussed on the hearing.
By the judgment of that Court it is decided, not only that in the grant itself there is no call for a northern boundai-y, but that " there is no reference to the diseno for any natural object or other descriptive call to ascertain it; that the grant itself furnished no other criterion for ascertaining it than the limitation of quantity expressed in the third condition, which thus becomes a controlling condition in the grant." The mention of quantity as "a league, a little more or less," the Court regards (after rejecting the words "a little more or less," as having no meaning in a system of location and survey like that of the United States) as so explicit as to render improper any reference to the petition and the diseno, or any inquiry as to " whether the name Capitancillos had any significance as connected with the limits of the grant."
As to the propriety of the location of the southern boundary by this Court, the Supreme Court expresses no opinion, but the grant is confirmed for one league of land, to be taken within the soutliern, eastern and western boundaries mentioned therein, and the cau.se is remitted that this Court may declare those boundaries from the evidence on file and such other evidence as may be produced before it.
As this Court had already declared the southern and only disputed boundary of the tract, the remanding of the cause, with the directions above stated, appeared to this Court to be an instruction to review and reconsider its opinion on that point, and also to allow further evidence to be taken in relation to it. The cause having been originally heard, with the consent of both parties, and without any suggestion that further evidence was desired or obtainable, the application on the part of the United States for leave to take further testimony was resisted on the part of the claimant. It seemed^ however, to the Court, that the directions of the Supreme Court clearly contemplated that such testimony should be taken, if offered, and that the obedience due from this Court to the mandate of its superior required it to permit either side to offer such further testimony as might be desired. Additional testimony has therefore been taken, and it now remains for the Court again to declare the boundaries as originally declared in its former decree, or differently, if on reconsideration that decree should appear to be erroneous, or if the additional testimony is such as to induce it to change its opinion.
In the opinion heretofore delivered, it was observed - " The evidence shows that the tract called Capitancillos is a valley lying along an arroyo or brook. On the southerly side extends a range of hills, running from east to west. At their eastern extremity, where they are intersected by the Alamitos, these hills attain considerable elevation, but they decline in height towards the west, where they reach and are turned by the Arroyo Seca. Behind this ridge or cuchilla the main sierra or mountain chain raises itself to a great height, and is separated from the ridge of Lomas Bajas, already spoken of, by the two streams mentioned. These streams rise at an inconsiderable distance from each other, and flowing in opposite directions, between the Sierra and Lomas Bajas, they turn the eastern and western extremities of the latter and debouch into the plain. Upon the slopes of the ridge of low hills, as Well towards the valley on the north as towards the sti'eams behind it on the south, the best or most permanent grazing is to be found, and in this ridge are situated the valuable quicksilver mines, the existence of which gives to this inquiry its chief importance." To this description it may be added, that the range of low hills are not throughout their whole length eijtirely detached from the sierra, but are connected with it at one point by a spur or ridge running ncarl}^ at right angles to the general direction of the sierra and the lomas. This ridge is at its lowest point one thousand one hundred feet above the level of the valley. The height of the Almaden Peak at the eastern extremity of the lomas is about one thousand five hundred feet above the level of the valley, but the lomas as they extend towards the west diminish in height, and are separated by various depressions, which permit easy access from the valley on the north to the Arroyo Seca at the base of the sierra. The average width of the ridge is one mile and four-tenths, and though at the Almaden Peak the descent to tho valley is abrupt, yet further to the west the diminished height of the hills, and the frequent depressions in the ridge, permit the valley to be reached at many points by easy and gentle declivities.
It is proper to add that after the proofs were submitted, tiie Judge, at the suggestion of the District Attorney, and accompanied by that officer and the representative of the claimant, visited the premises in order by personal inspection to become acquainted with its topography, and to be able more accurately to understand and to appreciate the testimony.
The grant itself describes the land as bounded by the "Sierra;" but the question recurs - What is the natural object so designated? Is it the main chain to the south of the Lomas Bajas, or is it the Lomas Bajas themselves? The natural meaning of the term "Sier^ra" would seem to point to a great mountain chain, rather than to a range of hills parallel to it and separated from it, except at one point where the two ranges are connected by a narrow ridge or divide.
On the diseno presented by Larios, the sierra is described as the " Sierra del Encino." The very remarkable oak tree from which this name was evidently derived is situated on the main chain of mountains, and is a conspicuous object from all parts of the valley. The "Sierra" mentioned in the grant is that on which this tree is situated, as distinguished from the Lomas Bajas or lower ridge to the north*of it. Or did he intend to include within it both ranges.'^
On the part of the claimant, numerous witnesses testify that the part of the Sierra Azul on which the oak tree is situated, is called Sierra del Encino, but that the low range of hills on the south of it, and separated from it by the creeks, was never known as the sierra.. That they were, until the discovery of the mine, called Lomas Bajas, and subsequently " Las Lomas de Mina de Luis Chaboya," or " Cuchilla de la Mina de Chaboya." They describe the rangfe known as the " Sierra" as rising from the streams, and the latter as runniiicf between the sierra and the ridge known as the Cuchilla de la Mina.
No less than nine witnesses, many of whom have lived in the neighborhood from twenty to forty years, testify to these facts, and to their testimony may be added that afforded by the diseno of Berreyessa, who at the time he presented it had been established in the crtriadn ahont nine years. On this map the two ranges of hills a,ve distinctly delineated separated by a broad valley - far broader than the ravine actually existing. The lower range is inscribed "Lomas Bajas" while the upper is marked " Sierra Azul ;" thus indicating that in 1842 and at the time when the petitions of both Larios and Berreyessa were before the Governor, and before the question had any im- portance, a marked discrimination was made even in the rude diseno presented by the applicant between the ridge of Lomas Bajas and the sierra behind it.
Antonio Suiiol testifies that he never heard of the Sierra del Encino, nor of any range of hills called the " Cuchilla de la Mina de Luis Chaboya." That the mouth of the mine is in the " Sierra Azul." On his cross-examination he states that the ridge has been called " Lomas" or " Lomas Muertas de la Sierra Azul," and that after the mine was discovered " we always said the mine of Chaboya which is in the Sierra Azul."
Jose Maria Amador testifies that he does not know the " Sierra del Encino," nor " La Cuchilla de la Mina de Luis Chaboya." That the mine is situated on the " Lomas Bajas de la Sierra Azul." " It is in the Sierra Azul itself. The Sierra descends regularly ; there is no breach nor separation in it. The mine is in a low loma. It is all known as the Sierra Azul. from the foot to the top of it."
Jose Romero testifies that he does not know the Sierra del Encino, nor the Cuchilla de la Mina de Luis Chaboya. That the name of the mountain on which the mine is situated is the '"Sierra Azul."
On his cross-examination, in reply to an inquiry as to the name of the creek " which passes between the Qaadalupe TYiine and the Sierra," he states its name to be the " El Arroyito del Corral del def unto Rafael." That he knows the loma where the Guadalupe mine is situated, and the sierra in which it is. That l<mia and sierra, mean the same thing with us."
It is unnecessary to comment on the testimony of these witnesses, for the preponderance of evidence is clearly against the accuracy of their statements or their recollection.
If then we were to fix the southern boundary of this tract by calls of the grant alone, the evidence would leave no room for doubt that the grantor meant by the term " Sierra," in the grant, the lofty chain of mountains on which the oak tree is situated, and which being for the most part covered with chemisal, presents an azure hue at a distance; rather than the lower and parallel ridge, known as the Lomas Bajas or Cuchilla de la Mina, and which is for the most part covered with wild oats and suitable for grazing.
But the great difficulty in the case is presented by the diseiio which accompanies the expediente of Justo Larios. On this diseno a single range of hills, inscribed " Sierra del Encino," is rudely delineated ; from this range the two creeks are represented as debouching into the plain. If this sierra be the main Sierra, the Lomas Bajas ai-e entirely omitted on the sketch. I have been much impressed with the very able and elaborate argument on this point submitted by the counsel who appeared for the United States, as also by the testimony of many surveyors that, guided by this map alone, and crossing the valley in a southerly direction, they would stop or fix the southern limit of the tract at the foot of the first hills which rise from the valley - that is at the foot of the " Lomas Bajas."
It is urged that the southern botindary, as shown by this diseno, is a line drawn at the foot of the range inscribed " Sierra del Encino," and from one creek to the other, and not along the course of either. That if the range delineated was intended to represent the main sierra, the arroijos, and especially the Seca, would have been represented as running below or to the north of it, and not debouching from it; and that the Lomas Bajas would not have been omitted.
It may perhaps be admitted, that if we were to be guided by the diseno alone, it would not be easy to avoid the conclusion so earnestly and ingeniously pressed upon the Court in the brief submitted by the United States. The indications, however, afforded by the diseno, are not free from all ambiguity. On that sketch the two streams are represented as debouching from the hills, at points .situated on a line nearly horizontal. The map of Lewis, exhibited on the part of the United States, shows that the Arroyo de los Alamitos, called on the Larios diseno Arroyo de los Capitancillos, issues from the foot-hills, or Lomas Bajas, at a point considerably to the north of that where the Arroyo Seca turns the western extremity of those hills and debouches into the plain. If a line then be drawn from the point where the Alamitos debouches, to that where the Seca turns the lovias, it would depart considerably from a horizontal line.
But if the sierrxc on the diseiio be taken to mean the Lomas Bajas, the map of Lewis shows that the tract between the Alamitos and the Seca on the east and west, and the Capitancillos and the foot of the lomas on the north and south, is about four times as loncj as it is broad.
Again: The Arroyo delos Capitancillos is represented on the Larios (:?i.se/?,o as running towards the south-east diagonally across the valley, and then turning towards the south and running in a southerly direction perpendicularly to the valley, and nearly parallel to the Arro3"0 Seca for a considerable distance, until it reaches the sierra. But if the sierra which it reaches was intended to be the Lomas Bajas, it should be drawn as meeting them while running in a south-easterly or diagonal course. No part of its southerly or perpendicular course should be represented. The map of Lewis .shows that the course of the stream from a point above or near the hacienda is delineated on the Larios diseno with tolerably accurac}', and that from that point it flows in a northerly direction perpendicularly to the valley for a considerable distance, and it is only after turning and leaving the Lomas Bajas that it takes a directiou diagonally across the valley. If, then, the red line drawn on Lewis' map as the southern boundary of that tract wei'e drawn on the Larios diseiio to the corresponding point of the Capitancillos, it would strike the latter not far from the letter " A," on that diserio, and that portion of the stream flowing in a north and south direction would be excluded.
Again: By looking on Lewis' map it will be seem that the Arroyo Seca, after running in a westerly direction along the base of the main sierra, and between it and the lomas, on reaching the end of the latter makes a sudden bend to the north and debouches into the valley at a point very near the base of the sierra; in other words, that at this point the flat or valley land extends nearly up to the base of the main sierra. If, then, a line be drawn from this point to the most southerly point of the Arroyo de los Alamitos or Capitancillos on the diseiio of "Larios, it would nearly coincide with the base of the sierra as contended for by the claimant; and would moreover be almost a straight line, and in this respect correspond with the indications of the diseho better than the very sinuous and irregular line which is found by following the base of the foot-hills which project into the valley. For it is to be observed that neither of the lines run by Lewis as the southern boundary of the tract follows what is claimed to be the boundary indicated by the diseiio, viz., the base of the lomas; but run upon the sides of and over those hills at a considerable and apparently arbitrary distance from their base.
The slightest comparison between the disefio of Larios and the map of the country shows the former to be in many other respects incorrect and defective. The angle of the creeks at which the eastern boundary commences is not laid down, and the lomita which is also called for in the description of that line does not appear. It is, therefore, no very extravagant supposition that the Lomas Bajas were also omitted, particularly when the circumstances under which the diseno was drawn, as detailed by Petronillo Rios, are considered.
The foregoing observations, I think, warrant me in saying that the diseno of Larios does not afford those clear, certain, and unmistakable indications of the location of the .southern boundary contended for by the counsel of the United States.
The record shows that Justo Larios and Berreyessa had occupied different portions of the Caiiada de los Capitancillos for many 3'ears before the date of their applications to the Governor for their respective grants. Between them a dispute as to their boundaries had arisen. Before the grant to either was issued, they appeared before Josd Z. Fernandez and agreed upon the line which should form their common boundarv.
The description of this line, as given in the report of Fernandez, was inserted in both grants, and the line was marked by that officer on the ilhseno of Berrcyessa "as being the more exact." In the grant to Larios the eastern boundary is described as the rancho of citizen Berreyessa, "which has for boundary the angle," etc., and in the grant to Berreyessa his western boundary is in like manner described as " the rancho of citizen Justo Larios, which has for its boundaiy^ the angle," etc. The eastern boundary of Justo Larios is thus indirectly described in his own grant, but directly in that of Berreyessa: while the western bjundar}^ of the latter is in like manner indirectly in his own grant, but directly in that of Larios. At the tim-i of making the grant the Governor had probably before him both disenos, but certainly that of Berieyessa, on which the boundary line described by him in lx)th ijrants had been marked bv Fernandez for his information. In determining, therefore, the boundaries of Justo Larios, it seems to me not only proper but necessary to recur to the grant to Berreyessa, where alone the boundary of Justo Larios is described as such, and to the diseiio of Berreyessa, upon which it was marked "as being more exact."
The Governor did not grant to Justo Larios the tract delineated on his diseno, viz., the land between the Arroyo Seca and that of Capitancillos, or a line to the east of the latter. He granted the land between the Arroyo Seca and a line drawn from the angle of the creeks, passing by the eastern " falda " of the " lomita in the center of the Canada to the sierra;" and this line was marked on the Berreyessa diseno, and at a considerable distance to the west of the Capitancillos or Alamitos.
In declarinn; this boundarv, therefore, which was different from that solicited by Larios and indicated on his diseiio, we are compelled to resort to the diseno of Berreyessa, which becomes quoad hoc the diseno to which the grant refers. On the Berreyessa diseno the two ranges of hills are rudely but unmistakably delineated. The first or most northern is inscribed -' Lomas Bajas," while the higher ridge to the south is inscribed "Sierra Azul." The valley represented as lying between them, though its width is grossly exaggerated, j'^et serves to indicate by that very exaggeration the discrimination in the grantor's mind between the Sierra and the Lomas Bajas.
The dotted line commencing at the angle of the creeks is produced across the lomas bajas, across the intermediate valley, and the Alamitos represented as flowinof throufjh it to the base of the main sierra.
If this line be the eastern boundary of Justo Larios, as I think it must be considered, there can be no doubt as to the range of mountains intended by the term " Sierra " in his grant.
It is urged that Berreyessa had applied not only for the Canada do los Capitancillos, but for all the hills which pertain to it; whereas Justo Larios petitioned for a part of the caiiada alone. That therefore in the grant to Berreyessa, and on his diseno, the line was extented so as to include the low hills solicited, but that such an extension ought not to be made in favor of Larios, who solicited the canada alone.
This argument assumes that the term canada as used in these grants does not include the low hills at the foot of the sierra, but that it is bounded and limited by them. But the language of the petition of Berreyessa referred to seems to convey the contrary idea, for it speaks of the low hills "which belong or pertain to the said cailcida." He (.loes not ask for the canada and also a portion of the sierra, but for the canada and the low hills pertaining to it. It is surely not reasonable to say that he considered and asked for the low hills as not belonging to or a part of the canada he solicited.
Again: The Governor, who with respect to Berreyessa, it is admitted, intended to grant th^ low hills, describes the tract granted to him " as a part of the place known as the Canada de los Capitancillos," thus showing that in his apprehension at least, the place known as the Canada de los Capitancillos did include the low hills solicited. In the grant to Larios it is described as the "place known by the name of Capitancillos" - the word canada being omitted in the grant though it is inserted in the decree of concession.
Again: The Governor, confessedly intending to include within the grant to Berreyessa the lomas or low hills, bounds his grant by the sierra. With both petitions and both disenos before him, and with his attention directed to the discrimination between the sierra and the low hills belonging to the Canada, he nevertheless uses the same term sierra in describing the boundary of Larios. Can we infer that in the grant to Berreyessa he meant by this term one natural object, and in that to Larios another? I think not. The sierra referred to in both grants must be the same, and as that intended in the Berreyessa grant is unmistakable, we are enabled to fix with corresponding certainty the sierra referred to in the grant to Justo Larios.
I have cfiven to this case much attention. I have endeavored to decide it uninfluenced by the previous opinion of this Court. Upon the best consideration I have been able to give to the questions involved, I have not been able to discover that that opinion was erroneous.
In the opinion of the Supreme Court, (20 How., 42G) it is said: "The southern, western and eastern boundaries of the land granted to Larios are well defined, and the objects exist by which tho.se limits can be ascertained. There is no call in the grant for a northern boundary, nor is there any reference to the diseno for any natural object, or other descriptive call to ascertain it. The grant itself furnishes no other criterion for determining that boundary than the limitation as expressed in the third condition. * * If the limitation of quantity had not been so explicitly declared, it might have been proper to have referred to the petition and dlseuo, or to have inquired if the name Capitancillos had any significance as connected with the limits of the tract, in order to give effect to the grant. But there is no necessity for additional inquiries. The grant is not atfecteil l»y any ambiguity. * * The grant to Larios is for one league of land, to be taken within the southern, eastern and western boundaries designated therein, and which is to be located at the election of the grantee or his assigns, under the restrictions established for the survey and location of private land claims in California by the Executive Department of this Government."
From the foregoing it is, I think, evident that the Supreme Court considered the southern, western, and eastern boundaries were alone designated in the grant, and that as the limitation of quantity was explicit, and there was no ambiguity in the grant, the northern boundary was to be determined by quantity alone ; and that it was " not authorized to depart from the grant to obtain evidence to contradict, vary, or limit its import."
When, therefore, this Court has, pursuant to the directions of the Supreme Court, declared those three external boundaries, it has declared "the southern, western, and eastern boundaries of the land granted to Larios," and the remaining boundary is to be ascertained by quantity.
It is urged on the part of the United States that the league is to be taken within the three boundaries named, but it is not of necessity bounded by them; that its location wnthin them is to be subject to the restrictions established by the executive; and that the northern boundary of the league is to be determined by the northern boundary of the tract within which it is to be located.
The Supreme Court undoubtedly says that the league is to be located luithin the three boundaries mentioned. But a reference to the preceding part of the opinion dispels any doubt which might be suggested by this expression.
It is said unequivocally, that the southern, western, and eastern boundaries of the land granted to Larios - not of the tract within which the league granted to him is to be taken - are well defined, and the Supreme Court explicitly declares that the northern boundary is to be determined b}' limitation of quantity alone. " The grant itself furnishes no other evidence for determining that houndary than the limitation of quantity as expressed in the third condition. This is a controlling condition in the grant;" and they add that no additional inquiries to ascertain that boundary (the grant being free from ambiguity) are necessary or authorized by law.
boundary to be ascertained by quantity, and to be run at the election of the grantee or his assigns, under the restrictions established for the location and survey of private land claims in California, by the Executive Department of the United States.
The following is a list of land claims connected with Santa Clara county presented to the Commission, pursuant to the provisions of the Act of Congress of March 3, 1851, entitled, "An Act to ascertain and settle the Private Land Claims in the State of California:" -
Bernard Murphy, claimant for Las Uvas, three square leagues, granted June 14, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to Lorenzo Pineda; claim filed January 22, 1852, confirmed by the Commission September 19, 1854, and by the District Court January 14, ISoG; containing 11,079.93 aci'es.
Robert F. Stockton,^claimant for Potrero de Santa Clara, one square league, granted February :29, 1844, by Manuel Micheltorena to James Alexander Forbes; claim filed January 24, 1852, confirmed by the Commission November 15, 1853, and liy the District Court October 29, 1855; containing 1,939.03 acres.
Juan Miguel Anzar and Manuel Larios, claimants for Santa Ana, one square league, and Quien Sabe, six square leagues, granted April 9, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to Manuel Larios and Juan Anzar ; claim filed February 6, 1852, confirmed by the Commission November 7, 1854, by the District Court December 11,1856, and appeal dismissed June 4, 1857; 48,822.60 aci'es. Patented.
Daniel and Bernard Murphy and James and Martin Murphy, claimants for San Francisco de Las Llagas, six square leagues, granted February 3, 1834, by Jose Figueroa to Carlos Castro; claim filed February' 9, 1852, confirmed by the Commission August 22, 1854, by the District Court October 22, 1855, and appeal dismissed November 24, 1856 ; containing 22,979.66 acres.
Maximo Martinez, claimant for El Corte de Madera, two square leagues, granted May 1, 1844, by Manuel Micheltorena to Maximo Martinez; claim filed February 12, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 28, 1853, by the District Court September 10, 1855; and appeal dismissed April 2, 1857; containing 13,316.05 acres. Patented.
Bernard Murphy, claimant for La Polka, one square league, granted January 19, 1833, by Jose Figueroa to Ysabel Ortega; claim filed February 17, 1852, confirmed by the Commission August 15, 1854, by the District Court January 14, 1856, and appeal dismis.sed January 18, 1856; containing 4,166.78 acres.
Antonio and Faustin German, claimants for Juristac, one square league^ granted October 22, 1835, to A. and F. German ; claim filed February 21, lbio'2, conliniu,.! by the Commission December 18, 1852, by the District Court June 7, 1855, and appeal dismissed April 28, 1857; containing 4,482.41 acres.
Julian and Fernando, sons of Santos, a neophyte, claimants for Rincon del Alisal, 600 varas, granted December 28, 1844, by Jos^ Maria del Ray (priest) to Santos and Sons; claim filed February 27, 1852, rejected by the Commission November 21, 1854, and for failure of prosecution appeal dismissed by the District Court April 21, 185G.
Jose de Jesus Vallejo, claimant for Arroyo del Alameda, 1000 varas square, granted December 80, 1840, by Manuel Jimeno to J. de Jesus Vallejo; claim filed March 2, 1852, and rejected by the Commission October 18, 1853.
Martin Murphy, claimant for Pastoria de las Borregas, 3,207 J acres, granted January 15, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to Francisco Estrada; claim filed March 3, 1852, confirmed by the Commission January 24, 1854, by the District Court October 17, 1850, and appeal dismissed November 18, 1856; containing 4,894.35 acres.
Antonio Chaboya, claimant for Yerba Buena or Socayre, granted November 5, 1833, by Jose Figueroa to A. Chaboya; claim filed March 8, 1852, confirmed by the Commission October 17, 1854, by the District Court January 21, 1858, and appeal dismi.s.sed October 8, 1858; containing 24,342.64 acres. Patented.
Bernard Murphy, claiming for Ojode Agua de la Coche, two square leao-ues, granted August 4, 1835, by Jose Figueroa to Juan Maria Hernandez; claim filed March 9, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 21, 1853, by the District Court January 18, 1856, and appeal dismissed November 18, 1856; containing 8,927.10 acres.
Jacob D. Hoppe, claimant for Ulistac, one-half square league, granted May 19, 1845, by Pio Pico to Marcelo Pio and Cristoval; claim'filed" March 19. 1852, confirmed by the Commission May 8, 1855, by the District Court March 2, 1857, and appeal dismissed April IG, 1857; containing 2,401.32 acres.
Quintin Ortega, et al, claimants for San Isidro, one square league, granted June 3, 1833, by Jose Figueroa to Quintin Ortega, et al; claim^'filed'^March
Juana Briones, claimant for La Purisima Concepcion, one square league granted June 30 1840, by Juan B Alvarado to Josd Gorgonio and Jose- Ramon; claim filed March 23, 1852, confirmed by the Conunission April 11 1854, by the District Court April 17, 1856, and appeal dismissed December
Animas, 3 042 acres, granted February 14, 1844, by Juan B. Alvarado and Manuel Micheltorena to Lope Inigo; claim filed March 23, 1852, confirmed by the Commission November 20, 1855, and appeal dismissed February 16, 1857; containing 3, 391.90 acres.
Jos^ Maria Alviso, claimant for Milpitas, one square league, granted September 93 1835, by Jose Castro to J. M. Alviso; claim filed March 30, 1852, confirmed by the Commission March 14, 1853, by the District Court March 3, 185G, and appeal dismissed December 5, 185(5; containing 4,807 acres.
' Antonia Hicruera, et al, heirs of Jose Higuera, claimants for Los Tularcitos, decided by boundaries, in Santa Clara and Alameda counties, granted October 4, 1821, by P. V. de Sola to Jose Higuera; claim filed April 1, 1852, confirmed by the Commission November 28, 1854, and appeal dismissed December 12, 1856: containing 4,394.35 acres.
Antonia Higuera, et al, claimants for Llano del Abrevadero, described by boundaries, granted January 1, 1822, by P. V. de Sola to Jose Higuera; claim filed April 1, 1852, rejected by the Commission December 19, 18o4, and appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution April 21, 1S5G.
Jose Maria Sanchez, claimant for Las Animas or Sitio de la Brea, granted Auoust 17, 1802, by Marquinas to Mariano Castro, and August 7, 1835, by Jose' Fio-ueroa to Josefa Eomero, widow of M. Castro; claim filed April 5, 1852. confirmed by the Commission February 14, 1854, by the District Court May 17, 1856, and appeal dismissed January 26, 1857; containing 24,- 066.24 acres.
Antonio Suiiol, et al, claimants for part of Los Coches, one-half square leaaue -ranted March 12, 1844, by Manuel Micheltorena to Roberto; claim filed April 6, 1852, confirmed by the Commission March 20, ISoo, by the District Court April 1, 1856, and appeal dismissed December 24, 1856; con taining 2,219.34 acres. Patented.
Valentin Cota, et al, claimants for Rio de Santa Clara, granted May 22, 1837 by Juan B Alvarado to Valentui Cota, et al; claim filed May 10, 1852, rejected by the Commission October 31, 1854, and confirmed by the District Court June 4, a857.
Maria Antonia Mesa, widow of Rafael Soto, claimant for Rinconada del Arroyo de San Francisquito, one-half square league, granted February 16, 1841 by Juan B. Alvarado to M. A. Mesa; claim filed May 25, 1852, rejected by the Commission March 21, 1854, confirmed by the District Court November 26, 1855, and appeal dismissed April 16, 3 857; containing 2,229.84
Liberata Ceseiia Bull, et al, heirs of William Fisher, claimants for La Laguna Seca, 4 square leagues, granted July 23, 1834, by Jose Figueroa to Juan Alvirez; claim filed May 27, 1852, confirmed by the Commission Sep-
Mariano Castro, claimant for Rancho del Refugio or Pastoria de las Borregas, 2 square leagues, granted June 15, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to Francisco Estrada ; claim tiled May 31, 1852, comtirmed by the Commission January 23, 1854, by the District Court November 23, 1859, and by the U. S. Supreme Court.
Encarnacion Mesa, et al., claimants for San Antonio, one square league, granted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to Prado Mesa; claim filed June 11, 1852, confirmed by the Commission January 30, 1855, by the District Court March 10, 1856, and appeal dismissed March 13, 1857; containing 898.41 acres.
Francisco Berreyessa, et al., heirs of G. Berreyessa. claimants for part of the Rincon de ios Esteros, described by boundaries, granted February 10, 1838, by Juan B. Alvarado to Ygnacio Alviso ; claim filed June 28, 1852, confirmed by the Commission December 26, 1854, by the District Court December 28, 1857, and appeal dismissed February 18, 1858.
Rafael Alviso, et al., claimants for part of the Rincon de Ios Esteros, described by boundaries, granted February 10, 1838, by Juan B. Alvarado to Ygnacio Alviso; claim filed June 28, 1852, confirmed by the Commission December 26, 1854, by the District Court December 24, 1857, and appeal dismissed February 20, 1858; containing 2,200.19 acres.
John Roland and J. L. Hornsby, claimants for Los Huecos, nine square leagues, granted May 6, 1846, by Pio Pico to Luis Arenas and John Roland; claim filed July 6, 1852, and rejected by the Commission November 7, 1854.
The Mayor and Common Council of San Jose', claimants for land, described by boundaries, granted July 22, 1778, by Felipe de Neve to Pueblo of San Jose; claim filed July 14, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 5, 1856, and by the District Court November 26, 1859.
Charles White and Isaac Branham, Trustees for C. White, et aL, claimants for lands granted by Felipe de Neve to the Mayor and Common Council of the City of San Jo.se; claim filed July 14, 1852, and rejected by the Commission February 5, 1856.
Ellen E. White, claimant for part of the Rincon de Ios Esteros, 2,000 acres, granted February 10, 1838, by Juan B. Alvarado to Ygnacio Alviso; claim filed July 19, 1852, confirmed by the Commission December 19, 1853, by the District Court December 28, 1857, and appeal dismissed February 9, 1858; containing 2,308.17 acres.
Juan C. GaHndo, claimant for Mission of Santa Clara, granted June 10, 1846, by Jose Maria del Ray (priest); claim filed August 30, 1852, rejected by the Commission June 12, 1855, and confirmed by the District Court October 21, 1857.
Charles M. Weber, claimant for Canada de San Felipe y Las Animas, two square leagues, granted August 15, 1839, by Manuel Jiuieno to Tomas Bonn; claim filed September 11, 1852, confirmed by the Commission May 8. 1855, by the District Court January 21, 1857, and appeal dismissed March 4, 1858; containing 8,787.80 acres.
Charles Fossat, claimant for Los Capitancillos, three -fourths square league, granted September 1, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to Justo Larios; claim filed September 13, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 28,
1854, by the District Court August 17, 1857, decree reversed by the TJ. S. Supreme Court and cause remanded, 20 Howard, 413, on decision of U. S. Supreme Court on the survey, 21 Howard, 445 ; containing 3,360.48 acres.
Candelario Miramontes, claimant for Arroyo de los Pilarcitos, one square league, granted January 2, 1841, by Juan B. Alvarado to C. Miramontes; claim filed September 22, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 6,
Andres Castillero, claimant for the quicksilver mine New Almaden, formerly called Santa Clara, discovered by him in 1845, with two leagues of land granted to him by the President of Mexico, May 23, 1846. Possession of the mine was given by the Alcalde, Antonio Maria Pico, December 13, 1845, with three thousand varas of land in all directions from the mouth of the mine. Claim filed September 30, 1852. The Commission, January 8, 1856, confirmed the grant of three thousand varas, and rejected all other claims. On the ground of fraud, the United States, October 29, 1858, obtained an injunction from the United States Circuit Court to stop the working of the mine. On January 8, 1861, the District Court rejected all claims to land, confirmed the mining rights, with seven pertinencias for mining purposes; and all shadow of fraud having been dispelled, the injunction was dis.solved, January 26, 1861. [The pertinencia varies from one hundred and twelve and one-half to two hundred varas square, according to the inclination of the vein.]
Sebastian Peralta and Jos^ Hernandez, claimants for Rinconada de los Gatos, one and one-half square leagues, granted May 21, 1840, by Juan B. Alvarado to S. Peralta and J. Hernandez; claim filed October 9, 1852, confirmed by the Commission August 8, 1854, by the District Court March
Maria L. B. Berreyessa d al., claimants for San Vicente, one square league, granted August 20, 1S42, by Juan B. Alvarado to Josd R. Berreyessa; claim tiled December 30, 18.52, confirmed by the Commission July 3, 1855, by the District Court March 13, 1857, and decree affirmed by the U.
Augustin Bernal, claimant for Santa Teresa, one square league, granted July 11, 1834, by Josc^ Figueroa to Joaquin Bernal; claim filed January 3, 1853, confirmed by the Commission September 5, 1854, by the District Court August 11, 1856, and appeal dismissed November 2, 1858; containing 4,460.03 acres.
6, 1845, by Manuel Micheltorena to Francisco Garcia ; claim filed January 17, 1853, confirmed by the Commission August 8, 1854, by the District Court April 26, 1858, and by the U. S. Supreme Court; containing 710.14 acres.
Barlecia Bernal, claimant for Embai'cadero de Santa Clara, one thousand varas square, granted June 18, 1845, by Pio Pico to B. Bernal; claim filed Januaiy 17, 1853, confirmed by the Commission December 12, 1854, and by the District Court .February 23, 1857.
Jose de Jesus Bernal et al, claimants for Canada de Pala, eight thousand by one thousand two hundred varas, granted August 9, 1839, by Jose' Castro to J. de Jesus Bernal; claim filed P^ebruary 24, 1853, confirmed by the Commission June 26, 1855, and appeal dismissed May 7, 1857; containing 15,714.10 acres.
Ellen White et al., widow and heirs of Charles White, claimants for Pala, one square league, granted November 5, 1835, by Jose Castro to Jos^ Higuora; claim filed February 26, 1853, confirmed by the Commission December 19, 1854, by the District Court February 23, 1857, and appeal dismissed Febx'uary 9, 1858 ; containing 4,454.08 acres.
Antonio Maria Osio, claimant for land near the Mission, granted June 23, 1846, by Jos^ Castro to A. M. Osio; claim filed February 28, 1853, rejected by the Commission February 6, 1855, and appeal dismissed for failure of pro.secution April 21, 1856.
Mai'ia Concepcion Valencia de Rodriguez et al., claimants for San Francisquito, eight suertes of two hundred varas square each, granted May 1, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to Antonio Buelna; claim filed February 28, 1853, confirmed by the Commi'^sion November 28, 1854, by the District Court February 4, 1856, and appeal dismissed April 2, 1857 ; containing 2,250.98 acres.
Joseph Sadoc Alemany, claimant, in behalf of the Christianized Indians, formerly connected with the Missions of Upper California: 1st. In behalf of the Indians of Santa Clara, under a grant by Manuel Micheltorena, June 10, 1844, for all the vacant lands of Santa Clara ungranted before that time. 2d. In behalf of the Indians for lands known as Las Gallinas, El Nacimento and La Estrella, in San Luis Obispo county, under a grant of Manuel Micheltorena, July IG, 1844. 3d. In behalf of sixteen neophj^tes for small tracts of land, from one hundred to three hundred acres each, in the vicinity of the Mission of Santa Ynes, Santa Barbara county. 4th. And in behalf of the Indians generally, one square league in each of the twenty-one missions; claim filed February 28, 1853, rejected by the Commission December 31, 1855, appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution in the Northern District February 23, 1857, and in the Southern District December 22, 1857.
Francisco Arce, claimant for fifty by sixty varas, granted June 3, 1846, by Pio Pico, to F. Arce; claim filed March 1, 1853, confirmed by the Commission, June 12, 1855, and by the District Court, March 9, 1857. - Joaquin Higuera, claimant for Pala, one square league, granted November 5, 1835, by Jose' Castro, to Jose Higuera; claim filed March 1, 1853, rejected by the Commission December 26, 1854, and appeal dismissed, for failure of prosecution, April 21, 1S5G.
Henrv C. Smith, claimant for one-fourth league, granted November 2, 1844, b}^ Miguel Muro (priest), to Buenaventura, et al. (neophytes); claim filed March 1, 1853, rejected by the Commission March 27, 1855, and appeal dismissed for faikire of prosecution, April 21, 1856.
Jose de Arnas, claimant for five square leagues of Santa Clara Mission, granted August 1, 1846, by Jose' Castro, to J. de Arnas ; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission April 24, 1855, and b}^ the District Court February 11, 1856.
Pufina Castro et al., claimant for Soils, granted by Jos^ Figueroa to Mariano Castro; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission December 4, 1855, and confirmed by the District Court May 1, 1856, and appeal dissmissed March 24, 1857; containing 8,875.46 acres. Patented.
Narciso Bennett, claimant for one hundred and forty varas square, one solar, granted November 28, 1845, by Pio Pico, to N. Bennett; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission October 23, 1855, and appeal dismissed, for failure of prosecution, February 23, 1857.
William A. Dana, et al., claimants for part of San Antonio, six thousand one hundred and two acres, granted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Juan Prado Mesa; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission July 10, 1855, confirmed by the District Court March 3, 1856, and appeal dismissed March 20, 1857; containing 3,451.89 aci-es. Patented.
William A. Dana et td., claimants for part of San Antonio, two tliousand five hundred and fifty-one acres, granted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Juan Prado Mesa ; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission July 10, 1855, and by the District Court March 23, 1857.
James W. Weekes, claimant for part of San Antonio, three thousand and fifty-one acres, granted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Juan Prado Mesa; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission July 10, 1855, and appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution February 23, 1857.
Henry C. Curtis, claimant for part of San Antonio, five hundred acres, crranted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Juan Prado Mesa; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission July 10, 1855, and by the District Court March 16, 1857.
William W. White, claimant for part of San Antonio, one hundred acres, crvanted March 24, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Juan Prado Mesa; claim filed March 2,*1853, rejected by the Commission July 10, 1855, and appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution February 23, 1857.
Mary S. Bennett, claimant for two tracts, one, one hundred and forty varas square, and the other, two thousand by one thousand varas, near the Mission, granted December, 1845, by Pio Pico, to Narciso Bennett ; claim filed March 2, 1853, confirmed by the Commission July 10, 1855, by the District Court February 28, 1857, and appeal dismissed April 14, 1857; containino- 358.51 acres.
J. W. Redmaii, et al., claimants for orchard of Santa Clara, ten acres, granted June 30, 1846, to Benito Dias, Juan Castafieda, and Luis Arenas; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission, December 18, 1855, and by the District Court, May 21, 1858.
Guadalupe ^Mining Company, claimant for part of Canada de los Capitancillos, described by boundaries, granted September 1, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado, to Justo Larios; claim filed March 1, 1853, confirmed by the Commission, May 2, 1854, and by the District Court,- August 17, 1857.
Martin Murphy, Sr., claimant for part of Las Animas, one-eighth of twelve square leagues, granted August 17, 1802, by Marquina, and August 7, 1835, by Jose' Figueroa to Mariano Castro; claim filed March 2, 1853, and discontinued April 3, 1855.
Clement Pinaud et al., claimants for garden of San Cayetano, one thousand by two hundred varas, granted August, 1845, by Pio Pico to Juan B. Alvarado; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission February 8, 1855, and by the District Court October 2, 1860.
Thomas O. Larkin, claimant for Mission Santa < 'lara orchard, fifteen acres granted August 30, 184G, by Pio Pico, to Juan Castafieda, Luis Arenas
Nicolas Berreyessa, claimant for Las Milpitas, under a decree signed by Pedro Chaboya, first Alcalde of the Ayuntamiento of San Josd, of May 6, 1834, to N. Berre3''essa ; claim filed March 2, 1853, and rejected by the Commission October 16, 1855.
Martin Murphy, claimant for three hundred acres, granted by Manuel Micheltorena, to Shelton; claim filed March 2, 1853, and rejected by the Commission March 27, 1855. Discontinued.
Widow and heirs of Anastasio ChaboUa, claimants for three suertes in San Jose, granted in 1785, by authority of the King of Spain, to Mazario Laez, claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission January 30, 1855, and claim dismissed by the District Court, for failure of prosecution, on January 8, 1858.
Barcelia Bei-nal, claimant for Embarcadero de Santa Clara, one thousand varas square, granted June 18, 184'8, by Pio Pico, to B. Bernal; claim filed March 2, 1853. Discontinued.
Barcelia Bernal, claimant for one square league, granted in 1845, or 1846, by the Governor of California, to B. Bernal, et at.; claim filed March 2, 1853, and rejected by the Commission March 6, 1855.
Jos^ Maria Castaiiares, claimant for Arrovo de los Calsoncillos, eleven square leagues, granted December 28, 1843, by Manuel Micheltorena, to J. M. Castafiares; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission April 24, 1855, and appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution February 12, 1857.
This chapter has been inserted mainly as a place of reference in respect to the grants made to the early residents of the County of Santa Clara. It is hoped that the whole taken together will form matter of not an uninteresting nature, and that a perusal will have repaid the reader.
A LOVE of crime is a fatality which would appear to follow the Indian into his partial civilization, the Mcxxican-Spaniard from his native clime, the Anoflo-Saxon from his far-off land, and the Mono-olian from his Celestial Empire. All would seem lost to the natural cry which springs alike from instinct and religion, that " whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed," for dread crimes are not committed by the violent and passionate alone ; we might almost say, would that they were, then would the chillinof deed of horrid murder be confined to the crouching assassin, and the hellish deed of suicide be the work of the insane. But human nature is various and confusing in its many failings; temper will outstrip discretion, a blow will be struck, a shot fired and life will be sacrificed, and though escape of present punishment may be effected, happily it is assured that a dread fear of detection in the future, will haunt the criminal, for it is truly said. " conscience makes cowards of us all."
The following notices have been gleaned chiefly from the local papers of the county; unfortunately we have been unable to trace the punishments meted out in every case : -
Provenance
Text from History of Santa Clara County, California : Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description .., published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.