Santa Clara County, California - The whole text, 1888 (part 4 of 34)
From Pen Pictures from the Garden of the World, or, Santa Clara County, California : Containing a History of the County of Santa Clara from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time ... and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also of Prominent Citizens of To-day, published 1888. 15,951 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
6 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,951 wordsMachine-read from scans of Pen Pictures from the Garden of the World, or, Santa Clara County, California : Containing a History of the County of Santa Clara from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time ... and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also of Prominent Citizens of To-day, published 1888. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
" People began to ask if they couldn't stay with us just for a few days till they found some other home; and then, somehow, they stayed on. Everybody had to be hospitable. The Legislature was in session and the town was more than full. The first thing I knew I had thirteen boarders - senators and representatives, and ministers, and teachers. Nobody who came would go away. I could always manage to make people feel at home, and they would all say that they would put up with anything, and help in all sorts of ways, if I would only let them stay. It was as good as a play to see them help me. Mr. Leek (he was the enrolling clerk in the Legislature) was a wonderful hand to make batter-cakes. We got up a reputation on batter-cakes, and our house was dubbed ' Slapjack Hall,' by my boy Al. It stuck to us. Mr. Bradford, from Indiana, could brown coffee to perfection.
" Mr. Orr and Mr. McMullen always brought all the water. They were senators. I used to think they liked the job because there was a pretty girl in the house where they got the water. And that reminds me, several families got water from the same well. It was just a hole in' the ground, about eight or ten feet deep, and no curb around it. Once a baby was creeping round on the ground and fell into it. The mother saw it and ran and jumped in after it. Then she screamed, and I ran out. There she was in the well, holding the baby upside down to get the water out of its lungs ! ' Throw me a rope ! ' she screamed, and I ran for a rope. Then she tied it around the baby, and I drew it up. Meanwhile, our cries brought men to the rescue, and they drew up the poor woman. We tried to keep the well covered after that.
" It seemed impossible to get a cook. We even had a woman come down from San Francisco,, but she didn't stay when she found we really expected her to cook. She said she was a niece of Amos Kendall's, and wasn't going to cook for anybody. Professor Jack helped me steadily, and, as I said, everybody lent a hand. We had a very gay time over our meals, and everybody was willing to wash dishes and tend baby. I used to go up to the Legislature and enjoy the fun there as much as they enjoyed my housekeeping. The March of that winter was something to remember. People used to get swamped on the
" Oh, did I tell you I built the first church and the first school-house in San Jose ? I did. I built it all alone, with my own hands, and the only tool I had was a good stout needle. It was the famous ' Blue Tent ' you have heard of. Mr. Blakeslee asked me if I could make it, and I told him of course I could. He bought the cloth and cut it out. It was of blue jean, and cost seventy-five cents a yard. The Presbyterian Church was organized in it, and Mr. Blakeslee had a school in it all winter.
" We had a good deal of party going, and gave entertainments, just as if we had elegant houses and all the conveniences. The Spanish people were, some of them, extremely stylish. The ladies had dresses as rich as silk and embroidery could make them, and in their long, low adobe houses there were rich carpets and silk curtains trimmed with gold lace. I went to the first wedding in one of these houses. Miss Pico married a Mr. Campbell. It was very grand, but the odd dresses and the odd dishes upset my dignity more than once. Governor and Mrs. McDougall lived in an adobe house on Market Street, and they had a grand party there. I had a party, too, one day, and asked all the ladies of my acquaintance. Mrs. Branham had given me six eggs, and I made an elegant cake, which I was going to pass around in fine style. I began by passing it to one of the Spanish ladies, and she took the whole cake at one swoop, wrapped it up in the skirt of her gorgeous silk dress, and said, ' Mucha gracias! I was never, so surprised in my life, but there was nothing I could do. The rest of us had to go without cake that time.
" In the spring my piano came. It was sent by way of the Isthmus. It was the first piano in San Jose. It made a great sensation. Everybody came to see it and hear my little girl play. Indians and Spanish used to crowd round the doors and windows to hear the wonderful music, and many a white man, too, lingered and listened because it reminded him of home.
" We moved into a better house in the spring, very near where the Methodist Church South now stands. We paid $125 a month for it. But when I look back it seems to me that I never had such an intellectual feast as in old 'Slapjack Hall.' The gentlemen who figured as cooks in my kitchen were the most intelligent and agreeable men you can imagine. They were all educated and smart, and they appeared just as much , like gentlemen when they were cooking as when they were making speeches in the Legislature. I don't believe we ever again had such a choice set of folks under our roof here in San Jose. Doctor and I felt honored to entertain them, and yet they paid us $20 a week for the privilege.
" Of course you know General Fremont and his wife were here that winter, and I knew them both. Mrs. Fremont's sister, Mrs. Jones, and I were great friends. Yes, indeed, there never were finer people than my boarders and neighbors in '49. Let me see ; there were the Cooks and Hoppes, and Cobbs and Joneses, the Branhams and Beldens, and Hensleys and Williams, the Bralys, the Hesters and Crosbys, Murphys, Dickinsons, Hendersons, Kincaids, Campbells, Reeds, Houghtons, Tafts and Moodys. Then amongst the Spanish were the Picos and Sunols. Very likely I have forgotten a great many, just telling them off in this fashion, but I never forget them really. Many of the best citizens of San Jose now, with wives and children, yes, and grandchildren, were slim young fellows then, who had come to California to seek their fortunes. Fine, enterprising boys they were too. Some of them boarded with me. C. T. Ryland and P. O. Minor were inmates of 'Slapjack Hall,' and Dr. Cory and the Reeds will remember it well.
" In 1852 we moved out on the Stockton ranch, and bought our own farm in Santa Clara, on which we built our permanent home, Somerville Lodge. I remember we paid our head carpenter $16 a day. The house cost us $10,000. It would not cost $1,000 now. We bought seeds to plant a garden, and an ounce of onion seed cost an ounce of gold ! We paid $6.00 each for our fruit trees. A mule cost $300; a horse, $400. But doctors' services were just as highpriced, and so we kept even."
The First Legislature
The first Legislature met December 15, 1849, and on the 20th the first civil Governor was inaugurated. Representatives from other districts who had been disappointed in not securing the capital at the Constitutional Convention, renewed their efforts in the Legislature. About the first bill introduced into the Assembly was by George B. Tingley, providing for the removal of the capital to Monterey. The State House was not well adapted to the use of the Legislature, nor were all the conveniences of life to be had in San Jose at that early day. The people of the city, however, exerted themselves to make the condition of affairs as pleasant as possible. They kept open house and entertained the law-makers to the best of their ability.
This Legislature passed the act which gave San Jose its first legal incorporation under the United States rule. The act was passed in March, 1850, and on the eleventh of April the Ayuntamiento held its last meeting, and the new Common Council held its first meeting under the charter on the 13th.
The anniversary of national independence was gratefully remembered in this first year of American civil administration in California. Mr. Hall says " there was a grand celebration, and much more interest felt than on such occasions in the Eastern States. The isolation from the other States made the feeling of national pride increase. We felt as though we were in a foreign land, and the tendency was to brighten and vivify the love of the whole country in every American. On that occasion the Hon. William Voorhies delivered the oration; James M. Jones also delivered one in Spanish for the benefit of the Mexicans present. Mr. Sanford, a lawyer from Georgia, read the Declaration of Independence. Thirteen young ladies dressed in blue spencer^and white skirts rode on horseback, followed by the 'Eagle Guards,' commanded by Capt. Thomas White; also five hundred citizens, some on horseback, some in carriages, and some afoot, made up the national pageant that wound its way to the south of the town, a mile or more, in the grove near the Almaden road ; and there the ceremony was performed, to the great pleasure and pride of the American settlers in this new country."
Under State Government
On the ninth day of September, 1850, California was admitted to the Union as a State, and on the sixth day of January following the State Legislature assembled at San Jose. On the eighth Governor Burnett tendered his resignation, and John McDougall was sworn in as his successor. The overwhelming question was the removal of the capital from San Jose. The citizens did all in their power to retain it, offering large grants of valuable real property and funds for the construction of public buildings. The State scrip which the members were compelled to receive as pay for their services was worth only forty cents on the dollar, but was taken at par by the citizens of San Jose. In short, every honorable effort was made to retain the capital, but in vain. General Vallejo exerted a greater influence, and an act was
With this Legisfature the boundaries of Santa Clara County, as a pohtical subdivision of the great State of California, were defined. It originally included Washington Township, of Alameda County, but this was afterwards cut off, and the county reduced to its present limits, which are as follows : Beginning at a point opposite the mouth of the San Francisquito Creek, being the common corner of Alameda, San Mateo, and Santa Clara Counties; thence easterly to a point at the head of a slough, which is an arm of the San Francisco Bay at its head, making into the mainland in front of the Gegara rancho ; thence easterly to a lone sycamore tree that stands in a ravine between the dwellings of Flujencia and Valentine Gegara ; thence easterly up said ravine to the top of the mountains, as surveyed by Horace A. Higley ; thence on a direct line easterly to the common corner of San Joaquin, Stanislaus, Alameda, and Santa Clara Counties, on the summit of the Coast Range ; thence southeasterly, following the summit of the Coast Range to the northeast corner of Monterey County; thence westerly, following the northern boundary of Monterey County to the southeast corner of Santa Cruz County;thencenorthwesterly,following the summit of the Santa Cruz Mountains to the head of San Francisquito Creek ; thence down said creek to its mouth ; thence in a direct line to the place of beginning. Containing about one thousand three hundred square miles.
County Government
The county government was at first administered by the Court of Sessions, which held jurisdiction until 1852, when the Board of Supervisors was created. In 1854 the government again went into the hands of the Court of Sessions, where it remained until the next year, when the Board of Supervisors was revived, and has administered the affairs of the county ever since. Thus far we have as nearly as possible followed the history of Santa Clara County in chronological order; but in order to facilitate reference we shall henceforward treat each subject separately. Following is a list of those who have administered the government of the county from the date of its organization to the present time: -
On the first day of June, 1850, the Court of Sessions was organized, with J. W. Redmon, President, and Caswell Davis and H. C. Smith, Associate Justices.
From March, 1868, to March, 1870 - David Campbell, John Cook, William H. Hall, W. H. Patton, Oliver Cottle. (Cottle served vice Ballou, who resigned.)
From March, 1878, to March, 1880 - S. F. Ayer, W. H. Rogers, W. N. Furlong, John Weathers, J. H. M. Townsend, M. D. Kell, H. M. Leonard. (Townsend resigned December, 1879, and was succeeded by James Snow.)
Land Titles
As to the titles by which real property is held in this county, while a detailed statement of all the technicalities through which they have passed would be out of place in a work of this kind, a general review may not be uninteresting or unprofitable.
ceded to the United States, it was provided that private ownership in lands should be respected, in other words, that the agreements which the Government of Mexico had made with its subjects in reference to acquiring title to lands should be carried out by the United States. The Mexican Government had been liberal in granting its territory to private persons, but it prescribed certain formalities to be performed before a complete title vested in the grantee. These conditions were, briefly, as follows: -
The party asking a grant of lands must present a petition to the Governor, stating that the applicant is a citizen, the head of a family, and that he is in need of grazing lands, having flocks and herds to maintain. It must contain a general description of the tract he desires, and be accompanied by a map or sketch called a deseno. The petition when received by the Governor was by him referred to the Alcalde, or some other like inferior officer having jurisdiction nearest the land of which the grant was asked. This reference was generally made by a foot-note, or marginal order, directing the referee to inform himself in regard to the facts set forth in the petition, whether it would interfere with the rights of other parties to whom grants had previously been made, whether the interests of the government would be injured or jeopardized by complying with the petition, and such other information as he might deem important, and to report upon it. Upon receiving the report of the Alcalde, if it contained no objection, the Governor made what is called a "provisional grant." The descriptions in these provisional grants were, usually, very meager, and frequently referred to the petition and desefio to help them out. Frequently the grant was made of a certain number of leagues within generally described exterior boundaries, and out of this originated many of the frauds which resulted in the getting of many more leagues than was intended to be granted by the government. The grant was either of a grazing right or in absolute property. It properly should, and generally did, contain a provision to the effect that it should be presented to the Territorial DepartmentalAssembly,which was the legislative body of the territory of Alta California, sitting at Monterey, for approval.
It also provided that what is called "juridical possession" should be given. To this effect an order was generally made to some inferior officer, an Alcalde or prefect, or, in earlier days, to some inferior military officer, directing him to go, with assisting witnesses, upon the land and put the grantee in actual posses- sion. The grant, however, was considered provisional or incomplete until it was presented to the Departmental Assembly and approved by that body. If all these formalities were strictly complied with, the boundaries defined and marked out, and it was not within the exterior boundaries of prior concessions or reservations, it was called a perfect or complete title as contradistinguished from a provisional or inchoate title.
At the time of the cession of California there was probably not a perfect or complete title in the whole territory of Alta California. Under the terms of the treaty, however, the holders of these incomplete titles were to be permitted to go on and complete them under the laws of the United States.
After the acquisition of California, and after ascertaining the inchoate condition of the land grants and the importance of having them segregated from the public domain, and for the purpose of carrying out the provisions of the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, an act was passed by the Congress of the United States on the third of March, 185 1, providing for commissioners to be appointed by the President for the purpose of ascertaining and settling private land grants in California, with a right of appeal, by either the government or claimant, to the United States District Court for the State of California, or to the United States Supreme Court. To this commission all claimants were required to present their petitions for confirmation of their claims. Failure to so present them within a specified time after the passage of the act worked a forfeiture of the claim, which was thereafter treated as part of the public domain. Upon these claims being confirmed by these various tribunals, surveys were maae by the Surveyor-General and patents issued thereon.
Those lands which had not been granted by the Mexican Government were subject to the laws of the United States governing the disposition of the public domain. Besides these two classes of lands there was a third, that is, the lands granted to pueblos.
Under the plan of Tepic, on the formation of each new pueblo in the New World, it was entitled, for its own use, for building purposes and for cultivation and pasturage, to a square of land extending one league in each direction from the center of the plaza, making in all four square leagues. Where the topography of the country, either by reason of the juxtaposition of the sea or of mountain barriers, prevented the land being taken in the form of a square, the four
On the settlement of the pueblo of San Jose, the Mission of Santa Clara having been established to the west, the Mission of San Jose to the north and east, and the Mission of San Juan to the south, it became necessary to designate the boundaries so that the jurisdiction of the pueblo and the adjoining missions would not conflict. From year to year the old inhabitants of the pueblo, in company with the younger persons in the community, were accustomed to go out and visit the monuments erected to designate these lines, and to cast additional stones upon them to keep them intact. The delimiting line between the pueblo and the Mission of San Jose ran from the mountains to the bay, about midway between Warm Springs and the present town of Milpitas. On the west (resulting from the settlement of a controversy between the Mission Fathers and the authorities of the pueblo) the Guadalupe River was fixed as the boundary, while the line between the pueblo and the Mission of San Juan was fixed across the valley to the south in the vicinity of Las Llagas Creek.
San Jose, before the admission of California to the Union, was one of the few populous settlements in California, and was known at that time, and before, as the " Upper Pueblo." It was selected by the framers of our first constitution as the future capital of the State. Such an important destiny spurred the inhabitants to an extra effort to provide suitable accommodations for the officers of the State and its august Legislature. By various efforts, in the new and rather chaotic condition of things, the faith of the embryo city was pledged to pay the expenses of building a State-house fronting on the plaza. It was rather a pretentious building for those times, but would be considered very insignificant in comparison with the structures surrounding that locality at the present day. At all events, with wages at an ounce a day for carpenters and masons, and lumber at several hundred dollars a thousand feet, its appearance and size were, by no means, commensurate with its cost, which was $34,000.
The city becoming involved and unable to pay, under the direction of James M. Jones, an attorney then lately arrived from Louisiana, a judgment was obtained against her and in favor of the creditors. An execution was issued on this judgment, and all the pueblo lands sold at sheriffs sale, and bought in by a syndicate styling itself the " San Jose Land Com- pany." This syndicate soon became known in the local vernacular as the " Forty Thieves," although the number of its members was less than forty, and they were by no means thieves. But the title they claimed under became popularly known, and has passed into history, as the "Forty Thieves' Title."
The San Jose Land Company, after acquiring its sheriff's deed to lands belonging to the city, as before related, claiming to be the successor in interest to the pueblo, presented its claim to the United States Land Commission sitting in San Francisco, praying for confirmation to it, of the lands contained within these boundaries, asserting that there had been a concession by the Spanish crown to the pueblo of that large tract. A mass of documentary evidence, correspondence, etc., was introduced, also the testimony of witnesses, to the fact that these monuments had been placed there years before, and had been recognized by the citizens. Although no formal concession or grant had ever been found or produced, it was asserted that those acts indicated that one had actually been made. The Board of Commissioners and the United States District Court confirmed the grant to these exterior boundaries.
In the meantime settlers had located on lands included in this tract, under the impression that it belonged to the government, or to private parties of whom they had purchased. They had made improvements and established homes. By this decision extending the limits of the pueblo, their property was absorbed, and they united, some fourteen of them, in securing an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States.
At this time there was in existence a body known as the Commissioners of the funded debt of the city of San Jose. Judge Spencer, who was a member of this board, was anxioils to have the decision of the District Court sustained, knowing that the land company had no valid claim, and that if the title to this large tract was confirmed to the city, it could be maintained. He succeeded in effecting a compromise, by which the Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the lower court, except as to the tracts owned by the fourteen settlers as before stated. A final decree was made to this effect. Afterward this large body of land was sold in tracts, to actual settlers, at the price fixed by the United States Government for its public lands. With the proceeds of these sales the debt of the city of San Jose was extinguished, and up to 1887 the city had no debt of any kind whatever. In due
This claim of the San Jose Land Company was the subject of more or less litigation and trouble from time to time until 1869. It came up in the case of Branham ei al. versus the City of San Jose, where it was held by the Supreme Court that the city's lands were not subject to execution and sale under a judgment against her. A number of years later, upon the adoption of a charter for the city, a clause was inserted which, it was claimed, confirmed the land company's title. Upon that claim an action was brought in the United States Circuit Court for the District of California to recover possession of the large body of land within the corporate limits which had not passed by legalized grants. The case was Leroy versus Chaboya et al. - some six hundred different defendants being named, and involving the title to a very large portion of the land within the city limits. Mr. E. Spencer, who was counsel for the defendants, obtained a ruling from the District Court to the effect that the provisions of the charter referred to did not amount to a confirmation in favor of the land company, or its successor, thus ending a case of great importance to the inhabitants of the city and surrounding territory, and which went far to settle land titles in this vicinity.
Mission Grants
Grants, of rather an indefinite character, were claimed to have been made to the various missions, of which there were a number, both in Northern and Southern California. When the missions were secularized, as elsewhere related, these grants reverted to the State. Notwithstanding this act of secularization, several of the missions retained more or less landed property, such as church edifice.s, orchards, etc., and these, in most instances, were afterwards confirmed to the church; but a large body of grazing lands passed into the general domain, and was re-granted to private individuals. There was quite an extended legal warfare before these lands were confirmed to the church. It was claimed that when the missions were secularized all property reverted to the Mexican Government, and as it had never been re-granted it became the public domain of the United States on the session of California, and therefore subject to preemption. The orchard property of Santa Clara was particularly valuable, and was settled on by several sets of squatters. The first was T. W. Redmon, county judge, who held the orchard for several years.
selling the fruit at enormous prices. It went through several hands, and was the subject of much litigation, but was finally confirmed to Archbishop Allemany, representing the church.
We have related how Lieutenant Moraga, under direction of the Spanish Government, partitioned to the original settlers the lands of the new pueblo. These allotments were made in accordance with a rule adopted by the government, by which rule all pueblos or towns were to be laid out and established under the plan of the city of Tepic. Under this plan the tracts of land were divided into three classes: so/ares, or building lots; suertes, or lots for cultivation, and egidos, or commons for pasturage and wood. By the Tepic method each head of a family was given four suertes and one solar.
There is a sufficient record of this allotment having been made by Moraga at the first location north of the present city, but no record has ever been found of a similar allotment having been made after the site of the pueblo had been removed to its present location. It is a legitimate presumption that such partition was made, although there is no record evidence. Judge Spencer tells us that in 1852, and even later, there remained landmarks that showed something of the general plan of the location. Among these were, in several places, stumps of hedge-rows forming alleys leading to the Guadaloupe River - evidently roads used by the women who went to the creek to wash. He says that at that time, and until the willows and other vegetation was destroyed, the Guadaloupe was a perennial stream, supplied in the summer-time from the springs in the lower ground south of town, while from the Guadaloupe were the remains, tolerably defined, of ditches leading into the Canoas Creek. This word " canoas," besides meaning " canoe," also signifies a "trough;" and it was probably for this latter meaning that the Mexicans applied it to this stream, as they evidently used it for the purpose of conveying water to their suertes, or planting lands.
There were also remains of branch ditches, or acequias. One went out and crossed the plaza near the site of the new City Hall, and continued on, crossing First Street near San Fernando, as if to irrigate the land sloping to the north and east. Another one was a little west of Market Street, crossing 'Santa Clara Street diagonally, going through the grounds now occupied by the Sisters of Notre Dame, and continuing to the present site of Hotel Vendome ; from this was irrigated the lands between it and the Guadaloupe River, which it paralleled. In one of the suits regarding the land claimed as suertes, old Pedro Chaboya and other old Mexican witnesses testified that all the alkali ground in the northeast portion of the city was, in very early days, fine land for crops ; but the Coyote River having overflowed its banks and rushed down across the country, the soil was washed off, and when the water receded or evaporated it was transformed into an alkali sink.
It seems that there must have been suertes in the vicinity of where these acequias ran; but whether they were granted with actual title, or only for temporary use, there is no evidence. It was most probably the latter; or, if actual title was granted, the suertes were abandoned. This conclusion is reached from the fact that years ago the oldest inhabitant could not remembeT the location, and also from the custom of the Mexicans, in those primitive days, of using as little labor as possible in growing their crops. Where the soil was refractory they were unable, with their rude implements, to get it into proper condition for planting. When the land became too hard to work easily they would abandon it and go somewhere else. It was their custom to scout the foot-hills for places where the winter rains had washed down the rich surface soil from the mountains, and here they would repair with their families in early spring. Having built their remadas, or brush houses, they would plant the soft, rich beds with corn, beans. Chilis, melons, etc., and watch them during the summer, herding off" the wild cattle that roamed in droves over the plains.- As the crops matured they would gather them, hanging the Chilis on long strings, like beads; the corn would be husked, and the husks saved as wrappers for cigarettes and tomales. It was feast-time with them when the melons were ripe, and fandangoes followed each other in rapid succession. When the crops were all gathered the family would return to the pueblo, and the following spring renew their preparations for their little crops, or milpitas, as they called them. The margin of the hills northeast of San Jose abounded in these rich, mellow spots, and from this was derived the name given to the Milpitas rancho and town. We have re-cited this custom only for the purpose of strengthening the presumption that the title to the suertes to the east of Market Street was but temporary, and had lapsed or been abandoned long prior to the American occupation. Knowing the easy-going, indolent nature of the people, and that the character of the soil in the immediate vicinity of the pueblo renders it particularly difficult to work after a few years' irrigation, it is not forcing a conclusion to suppose that they should abandon a field on which their rude implements could make no impression, for the more fertile and tractable ground at the foot of the mountains and elsewhere.
But with the Americans came the land speculators, and, as the pueblo grew in importance and its lands in value, suits were inaugurated to obtain possession of some of the most valuable portions of the city under the suerte title. None of them, however, were successful, but they formed a chapter of the most important and sharpest litigation of the county. There being no record of the original allotment of suertes, their existence could only be proved by parol testimony, and for this purpose the " oldest inhabitant" was in constant demand. The few old landmarks which we have mentioned were marshaled with all the dignity due their antiquity, but neither these nor the imperfect family traditions of the oldest poblanos were sufficient to warrant a judgment in favor of the claimants.
The methods used by the Mexicans to measure and mark out the boundaries of their grants were very crude, and resulted in much inaccuracy. Many of them, when surveyed out by the United States, shrank or expanded their dimensions to the extent of many hundreds of acres. Persons who had settled on what was thought to be government land would, after some years of labor, find themselves included within the boundaries of a neighboring grant, and would be compelled to lose their homes or purchase them again of another owner. Some persons were compelled to purchase their farms several times before their title became assured. This caused great dissatisfaction among the settlers, and societies were formed to meet adverse claimants, with force if necessary, to prevent eviction.
These societies, though very determined in the expression of their rights, generally avoided violent measures. In fact, with one exception, they confined their efforts to the raising of funds for the purpose of defending their claims in the courts. The exception referred to occurred in 1861, and is thus recorded by Mr. Hall : " The greatest excitement and demonstration that was ever exhibited in this county upon the question of land titles took place this year. The grant of Antonio ChaboUa for the tract of land known as the Yerba Buena Rancho, lying east or southeast of the town, had been confirmed to the claimants thereof under the Chabolla title by the United States courts. There were many settlers of the land, some of whom had occupied the same for quite a lengthy period under the belief that it was public land. They seemed to be of opinion that the grant was a fraudulent one, notwithstanding the fact that the land had been patented by the United States in accordance with the decree of confirmation. The advice which had been given the settlers was evidently not that kind which had a tendency to better them, or to cause them to view the matter in the proper light. They were induced to expend money in the way of lawyers' fees that was as useless as throwing money in the sea. The government had conveyed, in fee simple, the land to the claimants, and no party but the United States could move to set aside that patent upon the ground of fraud or any other ground. Suits in ejectment had been instituted against some of the settlers on said land, and judgments rendered against them for possession of certain tracts in the third judicial district of this State, in and for the county of Santa Clara. Wm. Matthews, Esq., of counsel for plaintiff in those cases, caused writs of execution for possession to be issued to the sheriff of the county, that the plaintiff might have possession in accordance with his judgments.
" The sheriff summoned a posse of six hundred men to meet him at the court-house, to go with and to aid him in executing the writ. When the posse assembled at the court-house they were asked if they were armed, to which they replied in the negative; and being asked if they would arm themselves, likewise replied in the negative. As the posse would render no assistance, they were dismissed by the sheriff. About one o'clock P. M. about a thousand settlers paraded through the town, some on horses, some in wagons, some on foot, and nearly all armed. They had one small cannon. All of the settlers' leagues of the county and some from adjoining counties were said to have been present. Toward the close of the day they went to their respective homes without doing any damage, save that of disobeying the writ." When the excitement cooled off, better councils prevailed, and the differences were settled peaceably.
town of San Jose. It seemed to have been taken for granted that the laws regulating the establishment of Mexican towns had been complied with, and that those in possession had valid titles. Whether the title was good or not, seemed to be a matter of little consequence under the then existing condition of affairs. There were no regularly laid-out streets. The center of the town was the juzgado, or the plaza, and the houses were scattered north and south on irregular lines, with roadway between. This roadway is now Market Street. After the defeat of Sanchez at the battle of Santa Clara, and the certainty that the arms of the United States would be victorious in Mexico, the foreigners became impressed with the conviction that Alta California would be ceded to the victors and a permanent government established. Viewed in this light, the solares and the suertes of the pueblo becami; of more importance, and an attempt was made to settle the question of their ownership. There was a well-authenticated record of the distribution of lots by Lieutenant Moraga, at the first location of the pueblo north of town; but if any distribution had been made when the pueblo was relocated, there was no record showing it.
Early in 1847 the ayuntamientoand Alcalde directed Mr. William Campbell to survey out a plat of land a mile square, to be laid out in building lots. This, assisted by his brother Thomas, he did, the tract so surveyed lying between the following boundaries : On the north by Julian Street, on the east by Eighth Street, south by Reed Street, and west by Market. This tract was intended to exclude all questions of title arising from suerte claims. Mr. John Burton, who was then Alcalde, and had resided here twenty years, stated that the result of his investigation was that no suerte claims extended farther south than Julian, except the Gongora claim, or further east than Market Street. This is the ori'ginal plat of San Jose, and from this survey may be dated the existence of the city. The streets were located through this tract, making nine blocks from Julian to Reed, and eight blocks from Market to Eighth. The exact course of the streets running north and south was N. 45° west, magnetic variation 15° 22" east. The length of these streets was five thousand six hundred and seven feet. The cross streets were laid out at right angles to these.
issue them a new title. Burton, who was no lawyer, seemed to possess a remarkably level head. Notwithstanding persistent litigation on the part of contesting claimants, all the Alcalde grants under the Campbell survey have been held by the Supreme Court to be valid. In Campbell's survey four blocks were reserved for a public square. This was named Washington Square, and is the present location of the State Normal School.
The town having thus been located, its limits and the boundaries of its blocks and lots defined, the settlers from the States resolved to secure a partition of the outside lands belonging to the pueblo. A meeting was called, the proposition to make the survey into lots of five hundred acres each was adopted, and J. D. Hutton appointed to make the survey. This was done in July of the same year. The lots were numbered consecutively, and corresponding numbers placed in a hat, of which each head of a family was permitted to draw one, entitling him to choose a lot, his- choice being in the order of the numbers drawn, z. e., the person drawing number one was entitled to first choice, and so on. After the drawing the Alcalde gave to each party a certificate of title. These Alcalde titles to the five-hundred-acre lots were afterward declared invalid by the Supreme Court.
In May, 1848, another survey of the town plot was' made, this time by C. S. Lyman. He was a practical surveyor and possessed all the necessary implements for practical work. By this survey the limits were extended eastwardly to Eleventh Street. He enlarged Washington Square to its present dimensions, eleven hundred and sixty feet by one thousand and five feet. He laid out St. James Square, which is six hundred and ten by five hundred and fifty feet. Market Square, the site of the new City Hall, he fixed at eleven hundred and sixty by two hundred and fifty-nine feet. Market, Santa Clara, and Fifth Streets were made one hundred feet wide; all the streets running north and south, except Fifth, were made eighty feet wide. The system adopted in this survey is the one now in use. San Fernando Street is the base line and the ranges are counted easterly from Market Street. Other surveys have been made as additional territory was taken into the city limits, but as these are of comparatively recent date and are fully shown by maps and plots in the city archives, a description is unnecessary in these pages.
The tract of land lying west of Market Street and along the Guadaloupe Riv-er, was used for cultivation, and was not surveyed into town lots for several years after California was admitted into the Union. It was held as suertes, and was watered by an acequia, or ditch, leading from the Arroyo Tulares, or Canoas Creek, south of town. This ditch, which has been previously described, furnished water to the people for some time after California became a State; but gradually the foreigners acquired this land from the Mexican grantees and streets were opened from time to time, as the population increased. This fact will explain the difference in the system of numbering and naming as well as of the peculiarities of location and construction of the streets in this locality.
Bench And Bar
The Mexican laws provided for a judicial system composed of what were called Courts of the First, Second, and Third Instance. The first was an inferior tribunal, and it was provided that there should be one at each chief town in the district. The second heard appeals from the first, and had also original jurisdiction in certain cases. The third was exclusively an appellate court. Courts of Second and Third Instance, which were to sit only at the capital of the department, were never organized in the territory of California, and Courts of First Instance had no existence until after the American occupation, the first judges being appointed in 1849 by the American authorities. Prior to that time justice was administered in San Jose by Alcaldes. The first American Alcalde was James Stokes, who was appointed by Captain Fallon when he deposed Dolores Pacheco, as is elsewhere related in these pages. He was succeeded by John Burton, who came to the pueblo about 1830. All kinds of disputes were brought before him for settlement. The written law was meager, but that made no difference. Anyone who had a grievance took it to the Alcalde, who, after investigation, applied the general principles of justice, irrespective of law.
In December, 1846, Burton concluded that he would divide his labors and responsibilities, and, accordingly, appointed a committee of twelve to assist him in his work. The persons selected were: Antonio Sufiol, Dolores Pacheco, Josd Fernandez, Josd Noriega, Felix Buelna, Salvador Castro, William Fisher, Isaac Branham, Grove C. Cook, Mr. White, Captain Hanks, and Guillermo Weekes. These gentlemen administered justice for some time, and their decisions were as imphcitly obeyed as though they were a legally constituted tribunal. The Court of the First Instance was organized in 1849, and held its last session March 30, 1850, when the County and District Courts were organized. The practice in the Court of the First Instance, and, in fact, for some time afterward, was what might be called conglomerate.
There was no code of laws and no fixed penalties. The lawyers were from different States, as were the few law books that were in existence. On the trial of a case, one lawyer would insist on its being considered in the light of the statutes of Pennsylvania, while his opponent would quote the New York code as the rule which should govern. There were as many different penalties for crime as there were States represented in the law library of the pueblo. All this would have had a tendency to confuse the court if he had not had the good sense to reject all authorities and precedents and use his own self-made law. Primitive as the practice of the law was at that time, the administration of justice seems to have been generally satisfactory This cheerful acquiescence in the decisions of Alcaldes and judges of First Instance might be due to the fact that there was no appeal.
The first judge of the County Court was John W. Redmon, a man whose vagaries will be remembered as long as the " oldest inhabitant " survives. He came from Missouri, had been a physician, and claimed to have been present at the battle of New Orleans, where he lost his foot. He was of a crabbed disposition, rough in his language, and not inclined to soften his remarks when expressing his opinions of members of the Bar. He was once asked by the Bar to resign, but refused in language more expressive than elegant. He held the office until 1853, when he resigned, and E. C. Allen was appointed for the unexpired term. R. B. Buckner was chosen at the ensuing election, and sat on the bench for four years. The administrations of Judges Allen and Buckner were in great contrast to that of Judge Redmon, and the attorneys experienced great relief when they realized that they could address the court without being greeted from the bench with some sarcastic remark bordering on insult. After Judge Buckner the judges of the County Court were as follows : John H. Moore, from 1857 to 1861 ; Isaac N. Senter, from 1861 to 1867 ; Lawrence Archer, from 1867 to July, 1871, when he resigned to accept the Democratic nomination for Congress; R. I. Barnett, appointed for the unexpired term of Judge Archer; D. S. Payne, from 187 1 to 1879. Hewasthe last County Judge, the judiciary system having been remodeled by the new Constitution of the State. The Court of Sessions was an adjunct to the County Court, having jurisdiction in criminal cases, except murder, manslaughter, and arson. It was presided over by the
County Judge, who called to his assistance two justices of the peace, who were selected by lot from among those elected for the different townships. This Court also had jurisdiction of county affairs, performing the duties now devolving upon the Board of Supervisors. The Court of Sessions passed out of existence in 1855. In the organization of the District Court the Third Judicial District was composed of the counties of Contra Costa, Alameda, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, and Monterey, including the present county of San Benito. John H. Watson, for whom the town of Watson ville was afterwards named, was the first judge. The first term of the District Court was opened on the twenty-second day of April, 1850. The first case tried was an action for foreclosure of mortgage given to secure the payment of a promissory note for $5,000, with interest at eight per cent per month! The first indictment found in the county was against Juan Higuera alias Toreto, and charged the defendant with grand larceny in taking a horse belonging to Joseph W. McClelland. This indictment was afterwards quashed on motion of the district attorney.
The following is a list of the names, as far as they can be ascertained, of the members of the early Bar of Santa Clara County; among them are many who have achieved State and national reputation: A. C. Campbell, E. D. Baker, Rufus A. Lockwood, Edmund Randolph, Geo. B. Tingley, James M. Jones, A. J. Yates, C. T. Ryland, Simeon K. Gibson, John H. Moore, R. B. Buckner, Wm. T. Wallace, Lawrence Archer, F. H. Sandford, R. R Clement, Wm. M. Stafford, W. T. Gough, P. O. Minor, Julian Smart, Craven R Hester, J, M. Williams, F. S. McKinney, J. Alex. Yoell, E. O. Crosby, H. M. Van Voorhies, O. H. Allen, Frederic Hall, Wm. B. Almond, A. Redmon, A. L. Rhodes, Wm. H. Ramsey, Wm. Matthews, D. P. Belknap, Thomas White, H. P. Hastings, F. B. Murdock, James White, Jos. R. Gitchell, Azariah Martin, Chas. M. Fox, R. A. Jones, Frs. E. Spencer, S. O. Houghton, J. A. Moultrie, C. B. Yamgh, Alfred Cowles.
beyond First Street. It was not well adapted to the purpose, and in 1850 the court was removed to a twostory adobe building on the west side of First Street, about opposite Fountain Alley. It occupied this building until the latter part of 1851, when it was for a short time held in the Bella Union Building, on Santa Clara Street. From there it went to the State House Building, near the corner of Market and San Antonio Streets, where it remained until that building was burned down. It then went into temporary quarters at the City Hall, then located on Lightston Street, between El Dorado and Santa Clara; in the meantime the county purchased a lot at the southeast corner of Second and Santa Clara Streets, and the buildings were fitted up to accommodate the county offices and courts. Here the department of justice rested until 1868, when it went into temporary quarters in the Murphy Block, at the southeast corner of Market and Santa Clara Streets. Its stay here was only for a few weeks, for in the same year the present courthouse was completed and ready for occupancy.
The District Bench was occupied by Judge Watson until 185 1, when he was succeeded by Craven P. Hester, who presided until 1859. He was succeeded by Sam Bell McKee. The Legislature of 1871-72 created a new judicial district, which was called the Twentieth, and composed of the counties of Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, and Monterey. Hon. David Belden was appointed judge of the new district, to fill the bench until the ensuing election. He was then elected and presided over the court until the reorganization of the judicial system and establishment of our present Superior Courts in 1880. Under the new system, Santa Clara County was allowed two judges, and at the election held in 1879 David Belden and Francis E. Spencer were chosen. The great learning and sound reasoning of these jurists gave the bench of Santa Clara County a reputation second to none in the Union. Many times have these learned judges been called upon to preside at trials of important cases elsewhere, and hardly ever is the calendar called that it does not disclose some suit of magnitude sent to them for adjudication from other counties. On the opening of the Superior Court in 1880 a division of the business was made and the rule then adopted has been adhered to ever since. The court was divided into two departments. Judge Belden taking Department i, and Judge Spencer Department 2. All criminal business was assigned to Department i, and all probate and insolvency business to Department 2. The other cases were distributed alternately in
2 the even numbers. Judge Belden died May 14, 1888, and the vacancy was filled by the appointment of John Reynolds, a lawyer of many years' practice both at this Bar and in San Francisco. It is fitting that a sketch of the life and services of these eminent jurists should be presented in this work.
David Belden was born at Newtown, Fairfield County, Connecticut, August 14, 1832. He came of old Puritan stock and inherited their fairness of character and untiring energy, with none of their intolerance. Mr. Belden's father was a lawyer of considerable prominence in New England. The subject of this sketch attended the public schools of his native State, and laid the foundation of his education. He learned all there was to learn in these institutions, which, though noted for their efficiency, could scarcely lead him to the door of the higher education he was to achieve by his own unaided efforts, the completeness of which excited the admiration of all who had the good fortune of his acquaintance. On reaching his majority in 1853, he came to California, stopping at Marysville for two years, where he read law. He went to Nevada City in 1855, and commenced the practice of his profession. During his residence, at Nevada City, he also directed his attention toward mining, but this was more for the purpose of practically studying the geologic character of the country than for acquisition of the precious metals. For the same reason he visited Virginia City, Nevada, and made critical examination of the different silverbearing lodes of Mt. Davidson. Everything he did seemed to be with the object of acquiring useful information, which, when once stored in his retentive memory, was never lost. The knowledge thus gained he bestowed with a lavish hand on those around him. Many a miner whose heart had become sick with hope deferred, has received hints from Judge Belden which have enabled him to realize his golden anticipations; and many a mechanic has received through him the light by which he has been able to do perfect work. No knowledge was so humble that he would not stoop to pick it up, and none so lofty that he would not climb to reach it. There seemed no limit to the capacity of his mind for the acquisition of wisdom. His powers of both analysis and synthesis were wonderful, and however refractory might be the ore that went into the laboratory of his brain, it came out pure and shining metal. In 1859 he was elected county judge, and occupied the bench four years. In 1865 he was selected by the people to represent Nevada County in the State Senate. Here his broad statesmanship and matchless eloqiience won new laurels and gave him a State-wide reputation. At the expiration of his term as senator, he, together with his wife, visited the Old World and traveled for some months through Europe. In this tour he took occasion to investigate, on the spot, many things of which he had only read, and returned with much information added to his already large store of knowledge. Art, science, horticulture, mechanism, roadmaking, political economy, literature, architecture, domestic economy, - he absorbed everything. Returning from Europe he removed to San Jose, in 1869, and resumed the practice of the law. In 1871, the Twentieth Judicial District was created, and he was appointed its judge. In 1873 he. was elected to the same position by a practically unanimous vote. The district then was composed of the counties of Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, San Benito, and Monterey. He held this position until the judiciary system of the State was reorganized, when he was elected judge of the Superior Court. He was re-elected in 1884, and continued on the bench until his death, which occurred May 14, 1888. While his wonderful learning excited admiration, and his strict integrity induced respect, no less did his warm and sympathetic nature command the aff"ection of all with whom he came in contact. He was simple in his habits and unostentatious in his appearance. Anyone could approach him and draw at will on his great stores of knowledge, while neither his heart nor his purse were closed to the tale of distress. He was eminently a progressive man and ready to lend his valuable assistance to every enterprise for the benefit of the community. Many of our proudest monuments owe their existence to the timely and intelligent efforts of Judge Belden. The amount of work he performed was enormous, and it was this interminable labor without rest that finally accomplished his death. He possessed a robust frame, but it was worn out by his still more vigorous mind. It would be impossible to enumerate the many great works which his assistance has rendered possible. His handwriting is visible on every page of the history of the county since his name was enrolled as one of its citizens. At his death the whole State mourned, and at his obsequies all were present to pay tribute to his memory. Business was suspended, the temple of justice in which he had so long presided was draped in mourning, and the people from all the walks of life came forth with grieving hearts to place their floral offerings on the tomb of their counselor and friend. The remains were borne to their last resting-place by his brothers in the profession, and the eulogy pronounced by the Supreme Court of the State through its chief justice, Searles. The whole people composed the cortege and none were left who did not show visible signs of the sorrow which filled their hearts. Judge Belden was married, April 21, 1861, to Miss Elizabeth C. Farrell, of New Jersey, a lady eminently fitted to be the wife of such a man. Highly educated and accomplished, but with strong domestic instincts, she made for him a most congenial home. Possessed of strong intelligence, she was able to render him valuable assistance in most of his work. She was his support and consolation during his wedded life and his true mourner after his death. She remains on the homestead, and preserves it in the same condition in which it was left by her husband.
Whereas, It has pleased the ever wise and merciful Author of justice to remove from our midst and from the scene of his earthly labors the Honorable David Belden, Judge of the Superior Court of the County of Santa Clara and State of California; and,
Whereas, The whole community of which Judge Belden was for many years a useful and beloved member, unites with the Bar in sincere grief about his bier; and,
Whereas, It is fitting that to the public record of his eminent services as a judicial officer there should be appended the seal of a merited recognition by the court over which he presided with dignity, learning, and honor: be it therefore
Resolved, That, in the untimely death of the Hon. David Belden, the Bench and Bar of Santa Clara County have lost a most able, reliable, just and respected member; the State of California a most useful, illustrious, and conscientious jurist; the community a rare example of true greatness and virtue; that, as a judge of the Twentieth Judicial District of the State of California from 1871 until 1880, and of the Superior Court of Santa Clara County from 1880 to the date of his death, he ever wore the stainless ermine of judicial integrity, displaying in his opinions and rulings a quick perception of the principlesof justice, and a deep and discriminating study of the precedents and precepts of law applicable to every case, bearing himself always with a lofty impartiality toward the parties and the interests involved. In his administration of the penal statutes to offenders brought before his court he was ever moved with earnest and untiring desire to temper the severity of the sentence with that degree of mercy required by each individual case, to foster and encourage every impulse toward virtue concealed in the criminal's heart. In his bearing toward the Bar, he was distinguished for the graceful and uniform courtesy accorded every member, and especially noted for the kindly encouragement which constantly flowed to the young men of the profession, qualities which won for him the esteem and veneration of the former and the confidence and love of the latter, - an esteem, veneration, confidence, and love which cease not at his grave, but which will continue to make fragrant his memory through the years to come. That as a citizen, sprung from the ranks of the masses, and, rising through a life-time of labor, by native force of character, to an eminence of distinguished usefulness, his career compels the admiration of all classes of society, and should especially excite the young men of our coast to an imitation of the virtues of his public and private life. In the shaping of public affairs his advice was always easy of access, and ever found well-considered and wise. No member of society was more sensitive to the jjulsations of public opinion, or more apt in appreciation of public needs. Never forward in the impression of his personality upon the current of affairs, he was never backward in meeting the emergencies of any occasion with a fortitude born of his convictions of right. With broad intellectuality, with brilliant literary ability, with incessant zeal, he investigated every problem of life and scattered his conclusions broadcast with a tongue of silver and a pen of fire. That though his loss to the community is lamented as a judge of transcendent ability and a citizen of distinguished usefulness, it is as a man among men that the death of David Belden is most keenly felt and most sincerely deplored. The friend, the brother, the counselor, the very model of all the social virtues, he lived out with consistent purity his simple and noble existence, and is gone in answer to the morning call of immortality. Beside the unstained robes of his public service may be laid the equally immaculate garments of his private life. To the widow of our departed friend and brother, who, through the well-filled years of a noble life has been the partner of his joys and griefs, the Bar of Santa Clara County extends the comfort of the heart-felt sympathy of its every member; in token whereof be it
Resolved, That as a body the Bar attend the funeral and sepulture of her beloved companion. That, as a mark of respect to their late occupant, the judicial chair and bench of Department No. i, of the Superior Court of this county, be draped in mourning for the space of twenty days. That these resolutions be offered before the Superior Court of Santa Clara County, at the next sitting thereof, with the request that they be spread upon the minutes of said court; that a certified copy of the same, and the further action of the Court, be, by the clerk thereof, transmitted to the widow and family of the deceased; and that one publication of these resolutions be made upon the pages of the public press.
"My Brothers of the Bar of San Jose: In the removal by death of my honored associate, we, in common with his relatives and community at large, have indeed suffered a great and irreparable loss. I can but ill bring myself to the stern realization of the fact that the relentless destroyer has taken from my side one who for these eight years has been my co-laborer in the delicate and arduous duties incident to the office of judge of the Superior Court; one with whom I have oft held instructive and pleasant consultations, and with whom I have maintained most intimate and cordial personal relations. 1 knew him well, and thus knowing I can truly say that his virtues were many and noble; his faults few and insignificant. Indefatigable and conscientious in the attention to, and the performance of, his judicial duties, he was stricken while in the midst of his labors. With Spartan courage and steadfast devotion to duty, inherited from his
Puritan ancestors, for nearly three years did he battle with death and stand by his post with unswerving fortitude, attending to every duty of his office. To the oft-repeated solicitation of friends to give himself relaxation and rest, he has often responded from the fullness of his convictions of duty, 'I would rather wear out than rust out.' And most truly did he wear out in the performance of his judicial duties, for not until the overtaxed body and weakened vital organs had broken out in open rebellion did he yield to the inevitable, and was carried out of the temple of justice, which he had adorned as district and superior judge for sixteen years, to linger by the dark river until the ferryman should come to transport him to a haven of well-earned rest.
"Judge Belden was at the time of his death fifty-five years and nine months of age, and had served with distinction and honor in the several judicial positions of county judge of Nevada County, district judge of the Twentieth Judicial District, and superior judge of this county for the collective period of twenty years.
"Not only was he an able expounder of the law, but the citizens of his former mountain home had delighted in sending him to the halls of legislation, where, as a senator, he distinguished himself as an able law-maker and a leader among his fellows.
" He was a truly remarkable man. Many have gone before him whose legal attainments have been equal to his. Others may have equally possessed the treasure of masterly eloquence. But it has never been my fortune to find combined in any other person so many rare and glowing qualities of heart, brain, and personal accomplishments.
" As an orator it has been truly said of him that 'he spoke with a tongue of silver;' his command of language was wonderful, his selections beautiful and most happy. He was wont at times with his bursts of eloquence to hold his listeners delighted and entranced. Although his delivery was rapid, he never hesitated for an apt word or sentence. ' His words came skipping rank and file almost before he would.'
"As a jurist he had few superiors. Well grounded in the elements of law, and conversant with the mass of judicial precedents, he added that ready perception of principles applicable to any given set of facts, and that peculiarly incisive power of reasoning that make the true lawyer.
"But his attainments by no means stopped with those of his chosen profession. His researches in the general domain of knowledge included almost every branch of science, art, history, and political economy.
"Although not a specialist in any one department, he was at home as well when gazing at the gems of night, figuring their parallax and discussing the laws of planetary motion, as when calculating the angle of aperture of an object glass or studying the phenomena of the border line of life exhibited in the amoebae.
"He was a just judge, a wise interpeter of the law and evidence, and withal simple and unassuming in manner, and sympathetic almost to a fault.
"He has passed from our midst forever. The chair that he was wont to fill with so much dignity, honor, and credit is now vacant. His robes of office have been replaced by the winding sheet. We have laid him away in his final resting-place, and have taken to our hearts the solemn and instructive monition that the sad lesson affords.
"A loving wife is mourning the loss of a loyal and affectionate husband. The Bar of this county, and the profession at large, lament the loss of a cherished brother, and the county and State a valued citizen and faithful public servant.
" But the memory of his virtues and noble qualities we should ever keep green in our hearts, and it is eminently fitting that the resolutions now presented by his brothers of the Bar should be inscribed upon the pages of the records of the court which he has caused to be kept so many years.
Hon. Francis E. Spencer was born at Ticonderoga, Essex County, New York, September 25, 1834. During his infancy his parents removed to Saratoga, and thence, in 1846, to Will County, Illinois. Here Mr. Spencer attended the common schools, finally graduating at the academy at Joliet. In 1852, when the subject of this sketch was eighteen years of age, he removed with his parents to California, settling at San Jose. Here Mr. Spencer went to work on a farm, raising sheep and cattle, and general agricultural work. In a short time, however, he abandoned the hills and grain-fields, and commenced the study of medicine. His father was an eminent physician, and this fact influenced the son in the choice of a profession. He soon, however, became dissatisfied with his choice. His mind was eminently logical, and would be content with nothing but exact results. He would accept no proposition that could not be reduced to a mathematical certainty. The exquisite logic of the law suited him better, and he became a student in the office of Messrs. Archer & Voorhies, then a leading law firm of San Jose. He was a quiet student, and attracted no particular attention until he was examined for admission to the Bar of the Supreme Court, in 1858, where he displayed such thorough knowledge as to excite comment. In 1863 he was appointed city attorney for the city of San Jose, and served as such for seventeen years. Soon after his appointment as city attorney he was made a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Funded Debt. Here he made a record that established his reputation for legal learning, and as a man of great resources. He found that the San Jose Land Company, popularly known as the " Forty Thieves," claiming title to all of the pueblo lands by virtue of a clause in the city charter, which they construed as a confirmation of their claim, had secured a decree of confirmation by the United States District Court to the pueblo of a vast tract of land, as is more particularly described in our chapter on land titles. From this decree an appeal, prosecuted by certain ranch owners, was pending in the United States Supreme Court. If he resisted the claim of the Land Company, or contested the appeal of the ranch owners, his intelligence told him that, instead of many thousand acres of land, the pueblo would get but a very small tract. He resolved to aid the appeal and fight the Land Company afterwards. He brought about a compromise by which the pueblo secured the whole tract, except that claimed by the ranch owners, and then in a subsequent case defeated the claim of the Land Company. Then by selling a portion of the remaining land at the government price, the commissioners were enabled to pay off the entire debt of the city.
These two suits, so successfully conducted by Mr. Spencer, not only relieved the city from indebtedness of every character, but removed the last cloud from the title of every foot of land within the limits of the pueblo. As city attorney he watched with an untiring vigilance over the interests of the city. He successfully prosecuted the case of the city against the bondsmen of the defaulting treasurer, Jasper E. Gunn, and in other cases secured the city against loss. His sound advice to the city officials secured the effective and prompt administration of municipal affairs. While studying law he had made himself familiar with the Spanish language, the Spanish customs, and the Spanish and Mexican laws affecting land grants and titles, and on this subject he soon became an authority. His opinion that there were no valid suerte titles east of Market Street, in the new pueblo, has been confirmed by the highest courts in many cases. In the famous suerte suits of Toro versus Beach, Beach versus Maldonado, and Luco versus Hare, this opinion was fiercely attacked by some of the best lawyers in the State, and fought out to the last ditch, but was never seriously disturbed.
As attorney for defendants in the case of Hart versus Chaboya et al., Mr. Spencer succeeded in establishing an important doctrine. As the law then stood, upon the death of a wife her heirs inherited onehalf of the common property. Upon that statute the heirs of Jesse B. Hart brought suit against a large number of purchasers from the husband involving a large tract of land on the Yerba Buena Rancho, in the Evergreen District. He was successful in having the Supreme Court hold that, although the descent was cast upon her heirs for a moiety of the common property, yet, as the husband had the control and disposition of the common property during coverture, he had a right to wind up the estate after the death of the wife, and that conveyances made by him in furtherance of that object were valid. This decision saved the homes to a large number of farmers, and established a rule that prevented a large amount of litigation in favor of speculators.
In these important cases, coming as he did in contact with many of the ablest lawyers of the nation, Mr. Spencer won a reputation for legal ability that commanded profound respect from the Bar everywhere, and his calendar contained important cases in all the courts of the State. His services were in especial demand in actions affecting the title to land, and much of his time was occupied in responding to calls from other counties. In fact, the permanent settlement of land titles in California is due to the efforts of Judge Spencer as much as to any other one man.
As early as 1861 he was elected district attorney, which office he held for two terms, refusing a nomination for the third. During his incumbency of this office he did much valuable work for the county, among which was the recovery of large sums of money on forfeited bonds. In 1871 he was elected a member of Assembly and was made chairman of the judiciary committee of that body. It was during this session that the legislation was had in regard to the then new codes. Mr. Spencer's legal training and clear mind enabled the committee to make its reports promptly and clearly on the large amount of business referred to it, the largest and most complicated, perhaps, that has ever been met by any committee of the Legislature since the organization of the State. How well this work was performed the statute books show for themselves. During this session, also, a desperate attempt was made to remove the State Normal School from San Jose. He had much to do in frustrating these efforts. When the judicial system of the State was reorganized Mr. Spencer was elected one of the superior judges for Santa Clara, which position he has ever since held. One very noticeable peculiarity of Mr. Spencer's work as an attorney was the care with which he prepared his cases for trial. No point was too insignificant to be thoroughly investigated, and the law and authorities thoroughly collated. His wide practice led him to the study of many specialties, and thus no opposing expert testimony found him unprepared. His critical knowledge of anatomy, engineering, geology, metallurgy, and mechanical appliances, with all the new theories developed by the recent progress in the department of microscopy and spectrum analysis, gave him high standing in scientific circles. All this knowledge and these habits of painstaking labor he carried with him to the Bench. As his services as an attorney were in demand throughout the State, so it has continued since he donned the ermine. At the request of local judges he has presided at the trial of important cases in many different counties. In San Bernardino County he tried the great case of Stockman ei al., versus Riverside Land and Irrigation Company, involving the lands and the canal system of the famous Riverside Colony. He presided at the trial of Huse et ai, versus Den et al., in which vast landed interests in Santa Barbara County were at stake. Also in important contested election cases in Sacramento. Also in the great mining case of White versus Merrill et al., in Department i of the Superior Court of San Francisco. Besides his great learning and sound judgment, two other qualities stand out prominently in Judge Spencer's administration of justice, i. e., the firmness and dignity with which the affairs of his tribunal were conducted, and the uniform courtesy which was extended from the Bench to the Bar, and to all others who appeared in his court. Outside of his profession, also, Judge Spencer has ever been a progressive citizen, liberally subscribing to all enterprises having in view the moral, educational, or material advancement of the community. He was selected as one of the Board of Trustees of the great Leland
Stanford, Jr., University, which, being an institution devoted to practical education, cannot but receive great benefit from Judge Spencer's learning and experience.
Hon. John Reynolds, one of the superior judges of Santa Clara County, has been a member of the Bar of California for the past thirty-five years, and a resident of San Jose since 1871. He was born in Bedford, Westchester County, New York, on February 20, 1825, and received his education at the Union Academy, of that town, conducted by his brother, Alexander G. Reynolds. Hon. W. H. Robertson, afterwards county judge of that county, and, later, member of Congress and collector of the port of New York, received his education with him at the same school, each going from it at about the same time to study his chosen profession. He studied law at Sing Sing, New York, in the office of his brother, S. F. Reynolds, afterwards judge of the Fourth District Court of San Francisco. Admitted to the Bar by the Supreme Court of the State of New York, he commenced the practice of law in his brother's office, and there continued for one year. Coming to California in the fall of 1853, he was admitted to practice by the Supreme Court of California in that year, opening an office in San Francisco, where he continued until the fall of 1871. He then removed to San Jose, engaging in the practice in Santa Clara County, where he has since continued. He was a member of the first Republican State Convention, in 1856, chairman of the Republican County Committee in San Francisco during the presidential election of 1864, in which campaign he devoted his time exclusively, for seven weeks preceding the second election of Mr. Lincoln, to his duties as chairman of the County Committee; has always been interested in political matters, although never an active politician. He was married in 1855 to Miss Emily Marshall, of Sing Sing, New York.
Judge Reynolds was lately elected one of the fifteen freeholders to frame a new charter for the city of San Jose. This position he resigned to accept the judgeship of the Superior Court, to which he has lately been appointed, succeeding in that position the late Hon. David Belden. At the establishment of the Free Public Library, he was appointed one of its trustees, and continued to hold that office until assuming the duties of superior judge. He was elected a member of Assembly in 1880, and was a member of that body during the memorable session of the
Legislature of 1881. On account of certain combinations with whicli he did not sympathize, and which resulted in the defeat of the Apportionment Bill, he was not placed at the head of the Judiciary Committee; but it is well known that no constitutional question arose in the committee, or the House, that he was not consulted, and in but one instance was his opinion disregarded, and in that case his vote is found recorded in accordance with a subsequent decision of the United States Circuit Court. Judge Reynolds' practice as an attorney at the Bar of Santa Clara County has been in some of the most important suits instituted within this jurisdiction. Actions involving titles to lands have been his specialty, and in these his careful practice and thorough research have been often commented on. The most important and complicated partition suit ever had in this county, and, perhaps, on the coast, was begun and managed by him to the end, with no error in the slightest detail. This was the partition of Las Animas Rancho, covering the city of Gilroy and many thousand acres of outside lands, and in which there were several very hotly contested controversies, involving about oneeighth of the whole rancho, and which occupied the court weeks in trying. There were about two thousand parties to the record in this action, which was pending for several years. The careful, methodical, painstaking character of Judge Reynolds, together with his learning and knowledge of the law, acquired by nearly forty years' study and practice, eminently fitted him to receive the appointment to the Bench, which he now holds. Among the lawyers now prominent at the Bar of Santa Clara County, are the following, of whom we present brief personal sketches : -
Hon. Sherman Otis Houghton. - The names of few among the pioneers of California are more favorably known, or have been more closely identified with the best progress of the State, than that of Hon. S. O. Houghton. Born April 10, 1828, in New York city, he enlisted, when but eighteen years of age, and still at school, in Company A, First New York Volunteer Infantry, and on March 26, 1847, arrived in San Francisco, after a voyage " round the Horn," to see service in the Mexican War. A part of the regiment, including his company, was detailed to Santa Barbara, but in a short time were sent to the seat of war, the force numbering one hundred and five, all told, under the command of Lieut. Col. Henry S. Burton. On arriving in Mexico they took up a position commanding the town of La Paz, where they occupied a church and other buildings. They fortified the position, and successfully held their own against the most strenuous exertions of the enemy for several weeks, until relief came, when they took the offensive, meeting with signal success, and capturing the commander of the Mexican forces. Mr. Houghton was regularly promoted for merit from the ranks, to sergeant-major, lieutenant, and adjutant of the command. In September, 1848, he returned to Monterey, and, with six of his brother officers, purchased an outfit and went to the mines, meeting with some success. In the spring the company separated, Mr. Houghton coming to San Jose in March, 1849. He then purchased oxen and wagons, proceeded to Stockton, and established a trading-post at Sullivan's Creek, running a pack-train between that point and the camps about Sonora. After this Mr. Houghton purchased in Stockton a stock of goods, intending to spend the winter in the mountains trading. The rains came on, however, the goods could not be moved, and had to be sacrificed With a Mr. Peasley he then engaged in the cattle business at San Jose, the speculation paying badly on account of the depreciation in value of the scrip issued by the State at that time. In 1852 Mr. Houghton assisted in taking the census in Santa Clara County; in the same year he was appointed deputy county recorder. In 1854 he was elected to the common council of the city, and chosen its president; in 1855 was elected mayor of the city, holding office until 1856. In 1871 he was elected a member of the Forty-second Congress, and re-elected in the following year to the Forty-third Congress, Mr. Houghton being a Republican in politics, and a consistent member of the party. From 1852 till 1856 he read law during his leisure moments, and in the latter year entered the law office of W. T. Wallace and C. T. Ryland. In i860 Mr. Ryland withdrew from the connection, when Mr. Houghton formed a partnership with Judge Wallace, which continued till the latter's removal to San Francisco, in 1864. Mr. Houghton has been a prominent member of the Bar of San Jose, having a very large practice, especially in the settlements of the old Spanish estates and the unraveling of their intricate titles. In 1886 he removed to Los Angeles, which city he has since made his home, though he still retains his large real estate and other interests in this valley.
On August 23, 1859, Mr. Houghton married Miss Mary M. Donner. She died on the 21st of July following, leaving one child, Mary M., who was born June 7, i860. On October 10, i86i,he married Eliza
P. Donner, the third and youngest daughter of George and Tamsen Donner, who was born March 8, 1843- She left Springfield, Sangamon County, Illinois, with her parents early in the year 1846, and is one of the survivors of the ill-fated Donner party, whose terrible fate is one of the most melancholy in the early annals of California. Mr. Houghton is one of the leading citizens of this State, a gentleman honored and esteemed by all, and a sturdy specimen of the fine pioneers of California.
Hon. Joseph A. Moultrie was born in Franklin, Missouri, in 1827. He received his early education there and in Madison County. After reading law for a time in the office of W. V. M. Bay he enlisted in the United States Army, to serve during the Mexican War. His regiment was the First Missouri Cavalry, better known as the famous "Doniphan's Regiment." His company was mustered in at Fort Leavenworth, with John D. Stephenson as captain. The regiment was attached to the "Army of the West," Gen. S. W. Kearney commanding. The command left Fort Leavenworth June 27, 1846, and marched across the plains to Santa Fe. The operations of Doniphan's Regiment make one of the most interesting and thrilling chapters in the history of the Mexican War. After the occupation of what is now known as New Mexico, two companies of the regiment, Mr. Moultrie's company being one of them, were detailed to go out, under the guidance of Col. Joe Walker, the famous Indian fighter, to treat with the Navajo Indians. Mr. Moultrie participated in all the battles and skirmishes in which his regiment was engaged, including the battle of Sacramento, near Chihuahua. He was one of the fourteen men who volunteered for the perilous duty of carrying dispatches to Gen. Wool, at Buena Vista. The distance was about five hundred miles, through a rough country, infested with hostile Mexicans. The perils and hardships which this expedition encountered and overcame would fill a book.
The enterprise, though looked upon as a forlorn hope, was successful. Mr. Moultrie was mustered out of service, with his company, at New Orleans, in the latter part of June, 1847. He returned to Missouri, where he remained two years, and again started for the Pacific Coast. He arrived at Santa Fe in 1849, where he stayed until January, 1850. With two companions, he continued his journey to California. At San Diego they separated, and Mr. Moultrie, securing a mule, rode to San Jose, which he reached in June of the same year, the journey from Santa Fe occupying six months. He went to the mines, but was unsuccessful and returned to San Jose in 1852. He secured five hundred acres of land near Menlo Park, which he farmed for one year, and then accepted an appointment as deputy sheriff of Santa Clara County. While occupying this position he resumed the study of law under the instruction of Judge Archer. Later, he entered the law office of W. T. Wallace, and when the latter was elected attorney-general " in 1855, Mr. Moultrie became his deputy, serving in that capacity for two years. He was elected district attorney for Santa Clara County, which office he held two years. In 1861 Mr. Moultrie took an active part in the organization of Mono County, and was appointed its first county judge. At the election two years later he was elected to the same position for a term of four years. He resigned before the expiration of his term, and again went to the mines, and was again unsuccessful. He then resumed his law practice in San Jose, which he has continued ever since. Judge Moultrie has conducted some of the most important cases, both civil and criminal, which have been tried at this Bar, but has devoted most of his attention to cases involving the title to real estate. He is a popular and respected citizen, as well as a prominent member of the Bar. He is a Democrat in politics, and was chosen a delegate to the National Convention that nominated Samuel J. Tilden as President of the United States.
Judge Lawrence Archer, attorney-at-law, rooms I, 2, and 3 Archer Building, corner of First and Santa Clara Streets, San Jose, has been prominently identified with the legal profession and the material and political interests of San Jose since 1853, and a resident of California since 1852, in which year he crossed the plains from St. Joseph, Missouri, not so much for the golden attractions presented then by California as the promise held out of a restored health, the latter having been undermined by the malaria of Yazoo County, Mississippi, and not much improved by a residence on the banks of the Missouri. A native of South Carolina, where he was born, in the Anderson district (now Anderson County) in 1820, he there received his primary education, after which he attended the University of Virginia, and later studied law in the office of Armisted Burt, a prominent attorney of Abbeville, South Carolina. These educational advantages were largely paid for by his own earnings, his father, who had been a merchant and planter of South Carolina, having met with financial reverses while the subject of this sketch was yet a lad, throwing the latter on his own resources at an early age. His parents were John and Ann (Mosely) Archer, both natives of Virginia. Removing to Yazoo County, Mississippi, in 1841 he was admitted by the Supreme Court of the State of Mississippi to the practice of law, which he followed in Yazoo County two years. The malarial fevers of that region making a change of climate necessary, he removed to St. Joseph, Missouri, making the trip by steamboat the greater part of the way, then by stage, and finally, owing to an accident, the latter part of the way on foot. He practiced law in that city with success, remaining there for eight years, and finally resigned the office of district attorney, to which he had been elected three years previously, to come to California in search of health, which seemed impossible to regain elsewhere.
He settled in Sacramento, where he remained until after the great fire of 1852, then removed to San Francisco, where he remained a short time, finally settling, in January, 1853, in San Jose, where he has remained permanently since that time, and where he has since devoted himself to the practice of his profession.
In 1867 he was elected county judge, holding that position until August, 1871, when he resigned that for the session of 1875-76. He was made chairman of the Committee on Corporations, which, on account of the part taken by the railroads in the politics of the State, was the most important committee in the House. As chairman of that committee he prepared a bill to regulate fares and freights, which became famous as the "Archer Bill." Up to this time the people had been industriously educated to the impression that no one who had not served for years in the transportation business could intelligently act in this matter. Judge Archer demonstrated that there was one man at least who could grasp and solve the problem.
The bill was defeated in the Senate, but the agitation arising from it resulted later in the passage of the "Railroad Commission Bill." In 1864 he removed with his family to New York, remaining there for eighteen months, during which time he did not enter into the practice of his profession or any business engagements. He returned to his California office to enter the campaign as a nominee for Congress from this district, which at that time included San Francisco and the entire southern portion of the State. Judge Archer has twice been elected mayor of San Jose, the first time in 1857 and again in 1877, in neither case elected as a representative of either of the great political parties, but as a candidate of the better elements of both parties, the last time opposing the nominee of the so-called Workingmen's party. He also served one term in the State Legislature in 1866.
He was married in Missouri, in 1848, to Miss Louise Martin of St. Joseph. This lady died in 1869, leaving one child, Louise, now the wife of M. J. Flavin, a merchant of San Francisco. He was married in 1870 to Miss Alice B. Bethel), a native of Indiana, at that time on a visit to relatives in California. There have been born to them two children: Lawrence, born in 1 87 1, and Leo, born in 1874. Lawrence is now attending the Santa Clara College, and Leo attending the public schools of San Jose.
Judge Archer has 160 acres, in the southeast corner of San Jose, where he resides, and on which he has an orchard of thirty acres, planted in cherries, apricots, and prunes. This place he has owned since 1861, and has devoted it to farming and fruit raising.
The Judge took great pride in his cherry orchard, which consisted of four acres, from which the income averaged about $3,000 per year. He was the first fruit-grower in Santa Clara County to utilize the labor of women and children in his orchard, thus giving desirable employment to a large number of deserving people. Judge Archer foresaw the future prosperity of San Jose when he first settled here, and has done much to develop the resources of the county. He purchased largely of real estate, and the fact that he could always procure what money he wanted with no other security than his word, indicates the estimation in which he was held by the community. He was always foremost in improvements; he built the first prominent brick building on First Street, and always kept in advance of the first rank of progress. During all the heated political campaigns in which he has taken a prominent part, not one word has ever been spoken reflecting on his ability or integrity.
Hon. Joseph S. Wallis, of Mayfield, has been associated with the Bar of Santa Clara County for upward of thirty years; and while most of his contemporaries of the '50's have passed away or retired from the active practice of the law, he stands to-day among the most active and able men in the ranks of the profession. Judge Wallis is a native of Massachusetts, born at Salem, on the twenty-fourth of October, 1825. The Wallis family was established in this country generations back, when the brothers, Aaron and Joseph Wallis, came from England, among the early settlers of the old colony of Massachusetts. His father, Joseph Hutchinson, was a merchant, and conducted a large furniture business. His mother's maiden name was Sarah D. Hutchinson. She was also of English ancestry, and sprang from the Governor Hutchinson family, of Massachusetts.
Provenance
Text from Pen Pictures from the Garden of the World, or, Santa Clara County, California : Containing a History of the County of Santa Clara from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time ... and Biographical Mention of Many of Its Pioneers and Also of Prominent Citizens of To-day, published 1888, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.