BlockBefore

Siskiyou County, California - Chapter 12: The Courts and Judiciary, 1881

From History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. 10,602 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

18 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

10,602 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 12: The Courts and Judiciary

Law, in its simplest form, was introduced into Alta California by the Caucasian race in 1769, when the mission of San Diego was founded by the Franm

Hudson. B. Gillis

The subject of this sketch, the second son of Ridgway B. and Margaret Gillis, was born at Ridgway, Elk county, Pennsylvania, on the eighth of November, 1842. He is of Scotch descent, his mother being a native of Scotland, and his father, though born in New York, of Scotch antecedents. His parents moved with him to Iowa in 1849. His boyhood and early manhood were spent in the Hawkeye State and in Illinois and Nebraska. In June, 1869, he graduated at the Iowa Wesk^an University of Mount Pleasant, having maintained himself by his own personal exertions during his course of study at that institution. The last two years of his collegiate life were principally devoted to the study of law, he having chosen the legal profession as his future vocation. In the fall of 1869 be came to California with the intention of making his permanent home on the coast. He continued his law studies for some time in the office of George Cadwallader, an attorney at Sacramento, and then moved to Yreka. Here he entered the office of Judge E. Steele, and still labored earnestly to perfect his knowledge of law, teaching school a portion of the time for his support. Mr. Gillis was admitted to the Siskiyou bar in 1871, when he commenced a very successful and lucrative practice. Having a strong ambition to reach the higher rounds in the ladder of his profession, and being determined to master and hold every step, he steadily rose in public esteem and confidence, until in the fall of 1875 the people elected him to the office of district attorney, which he now holds, having been twice re-elected. He was married in the fall of 1871 to Miss Anna M. Reynolds, daughter of Isaac and Maria E. Reynolds, a lady of great mental attainments and intellectual vigor. The union has been one of singular and continued felicity. Mr. Giliis was' one of the Siskiyou county commissioners to wind up the affairs of Klamath county in 1876. He is an honored and efficient member of Howard Lodge, No. 96, of Free and Accepted Masons, and held the chair of worthy master for three years. He has taken an active part in every political campaign since he first came to the State. Being an able speaker he has stumped the county on several occasions in the interests of Democracy, and is considered one of the best workers in the party. The Scotch character largely predominates in Mr. Gillis' personal appearance and in the bent of his mind. He is tall, bony and slender, possessing singularly penetrating powers of mind and brings untiring zeal and activity into whatever he undertakes. As a lawyer he is logical, searching and persistent, and seldom fails to win his point. His long residence on the frontier has given him an admirable insight into the western character, to which hardy, vigorous class he may be said to belong himself. As a public officer he is faithful to the best interests of the people, and as a private citizen he has a circle of friends and well-wishers which only sterling worth and manhood can create.

ciscan Friars under the leadership of Fal her Junipero Serro. At this and other missions soon after established, the padres had full control, administering justice in the manner best calculated to further the interests of their religion and cement and perpetuate the feeble government they had set up among the simple natives they soon gathered about them. The military sent into the wilderness to uphold and protect the missions was entirely subservient to the authority of the padres. As the Caucasians increased and pueblos (towns) were established, justice was administered therein by an alcalde (judge), the padres still reigning supreme at the missions. The pueblos increased in size and the authority of the alcalde and other civil officers gradually encroached upon that of the padres, until when the missions were secularized by the Mexican government, the padres lost all temporal authority, and the civil p >wer obtained supreme control. This authority was exercised along the whole coast and as far inland as the military arm had strength and energy enough to sustain it.

At the time of the American conquest, the courts existed under the Mexican laws of 1837, and were composed as follows in the Territory of California: The highest court, having an appellate jurisdiction and corresponding in character to our present Supreme Court, was the Superior Court of California, consisting of four judges and an attorney-general. It was divided into the first and second benches, the three senior judges composing the first and the junior the second. The first bench was called the Court of the Third Instance, and its decisions were final. Appeals lay to this court from the second bench, or Court of the Second Instance. The latter court had first jurisdiction of appeals from the Court of the First Instance, the highest local tribunal then existing, and corresponding very closely to our Superior Court. The lesser magistrates were the first alcalde and second alcalde, having authority similar to that exercised by our justices of the peace. In some districts the duties of judge of the Court of the First Instance were discharged by the first alcalde. The Mexican laws remained in force, and justice was administered through the tribunals established by them, until the courts were organized under the State constitution in 1850.

After the American conquest, and especially after the discovery of gold had led to the wild rush of men from all over the world and peopled a country before almost unknown save to the naked and barbarous natives, the courts became seriously disorganized, or rather failed to become organized at all. In the many commercial towns and mining camps that sprang up like Aladdin's castle, there was no law save that administered by the restless and excitable gold hunter and no court but the bar of public opinion. To remedy this defect, Gen. Bennett Riley, then military governor, issued a proclamation, June 3, 1849, in which among other things he caked upon the people to elect alcaldes and judges, under the Mexican laws then in force, who should administer justice until the courts to be established by the Constitution .should become clothed with the powers to be given them by that instrument.

Supreme Court

By the constitution of 1849 the highest judicial power in the State was vested in a Supreme Court, with an appellate jurisdiction of causes involving over two hundred dollars, and in all cases of tax and municipal fines, and in criminal cases amounting to a felony, in questions of law only. The court consisted of a chief justice and two associate justices, any two of whom constituted a quorum. The agreement of two of them was necessary to a decision. The term of office was fixed at six years, one justice to be elected in 1831, and one each second year thereafter. The one whose term was first to expire .became the chief justice. The first justices wore selected by the Legislature in 1850, and they chose lots among themselves for the terms expiring January 1, 1852, 1854 and 1856, these terms falling respectively to S. C. Hastings, H. A. Lyons and Noah Bennett, thus making Justice Hastings the first chief justice. In February, 1852, Justice Heydenfeldt by a joint resolution of the Legislature, was granted leave of absence for six months. It became evident, soon after his departure, that the remainder of the court could not transact business with any facility, because a disagreement between them rendered a decision impossible. The constitution empowered the governor to fill any vacancy in the court by appointment until the next general election, but this was not a vacancy, it was simply an authorized absence. Based upon this provision, however: The Legislature passeel an Act, March 25, 1852, authorizing the governor to fill any temporary vacancy by appointment; the next clay Hon. Peter H. Burnett was appointed, but declined to serve, deeming the Act unconstitutional. Hon. Alexander Wells was appointed on the second of April. The constitutionality of the Act was tested on an agreed case, and the members of the court, were divided in their opinions, Chief Justice Murray deciding against and Justice Anderson in favor of the Act. There being no adverse decision, Justice Wells took his seat. When Justice Heydenfeldt returned he gave an opinion concurring with Chief Justice Murray against the validity of the Act, and thus it was declared unconstitutional; not, however, until Justice Wells had retired from the bench.

The amendments to the constitution in 18G3 altered the composition of the court, establishing it as it remained until the new constitution took effect, January 1, 1880. The number of justices was increased to five, with terms of ten years, one to be elected every second year. Five were elected in 18G3, the length of their respective terms being decided by lot. The causes that could be carried to the Supreme Court were placed at those involving three hundred dollars or more. The new constitution made a* radical change in the composition of the Supreme Court. That body now consists of a chief justice and six associate justices, elected by the people, their terms of office being fixed at twelve years.

District Court

risdiction, embracing chancery, civil and criminal causes. As at first created it had original cognizance of all cases in equity, and its civil jurisdiction embraced all causes where the amount in question exceeded two hundred dollars, causes involving the title to real property or the validity of any tax, and issues of fact joined in the Probate Court. It had power to inquire into criminal offenses by means of a grand jury, and to try indictments found by that body. In 1851, the legislature took from this court its criminal jurisdiction and conferred it upon the Court of Sessions, leaving it the power of hearingappeals from that court in criminal matters, and the power to try all indictments for murder, manslaughter, arson, and any cases in which the members of the Court of Sessions were personally interested.

The Act creating Siskiyou county did not assign it to any judicial district, but as it was segregated from Shasta county, it was assumed that it still constituted a part of the Ninth district, composed of Shasta, Butte and Colusa counties. Of this district Honorable W. S. Sherwood was judge, but he declined to hold a term of court in Yreka, although he made a few orders, as will hereafter appear. When the November election approached the question of holding court here entered largely into the selection of candidates for district judge, and Hon. William A Robertson, county judge, became a candidate, with "Court in Yreka" for his battle cry. Tne opposing candidates were Hon. George A. Smith and Hon. William P. Daingerfitdd. Judge Smith Mas the nominee of the Democrats, and upon the promise made by him to hold court here, received nearly the full party vote, and was elected. He never redeemed his promise, and no term of court was held until the next year, when Siskiyou county had become a part of the Eighth district.

Now comes W. A. It ibertson, Att'y for Pl'tiff, and files the Plaintiff's complaint in this case, i.i which Pl'tiff claims that Def 'ts are indebted to him in the sum of nine hundred and ten and GJ-100 dollars, and Pl'tiff also filed his undertaking, with securities, and an affidavit for a writ of attachment. Summ ms and attachment issued and were placed in the hands of the Sheriff for service.

May 20th. Summons returned by She'ff, having been served May 5th, 1852, on two of Def 'ts, Samuel Lockhart and VV. D. Aylett; and attachment returned same day - property havingbeen levied upon. See endorsement on writ for description of property attached.

The regular election for district judges occurred on the second of November, 1852, and Hon. William A. Robertson, county judge of this county, became a candidate in the Ninth district. His proclamation appears below, in the history of the County Court.

By the Act of May 19, 1853, and before any term of court had been he'd in this county, Siskiyou was made a part of the Eighth district, with Humboldt and Klamath counties, of which district Hon. J. Montgomery Peters had been chosen judge at the previous November election.

And now, on the first Monday of August, A. D., 1S53, beingthe time appointed fur a term of the District Court to be holdeu iu said county, by " An Act to fix the times for holding the terms of the District Court throughout this State - approved May 18, 1853," C'imes Honorable Joseph Montgomery Peters and presents a certified copy of his commission from Ins Excellency, John Bigler, Governor of the State of California, commissioning him ;.s Jud^'e of Eighth Judicial District of said State, which is in the letters and figures following, to wit : -

The People Of The State Of California

Know ye that, whereas Joseph Montgomery Peters, on the second day of November, in the year of our Lord, eighteen hundred and fifty-two, was duly elected Judge of the Eighth Judicial District ; Now therefore, I, John Bigler, Governor of the State of California, do by these presents commission the said Joseph Montgomery Peters a Judge of said district, to have and to hold said office, with all the powers, privileges, and emoluments to the same of ri_,ht appertaining unto him the said Joseph Montgomery Peters.

I, Laurance S. Williams, Clerk of the District Court of the Eighth Judicial District in and for the county of Trinity, do hereby certify that the abiveis a true copy of the original record of said c nirt now in my office.

[Seal.] In witness where if I have hereunto set my band and piivate seal (there being no seal of office provided) the 27th July, a. ]>., 1853. Laurance S. Williams, Di-trict Clerk.

And the said Honorable Joseph Montgomery Peters thereupon directed the Sheriff to proclaim the court open for business; whereupon it was so done by D D. Colton, acting Under Sheriff.

And now comes William A. Robertson, Elijah Steele, John D. Cosby and K. B. Suelling, and each hiving filed his affidavit in manner and form, and s-tting forth the requisite facts, as rereipiired by the statutes in regard to the admission of Attorneys and Counsellors at Law, and having taken the constitutional oath of office; it is ordered by the court that they and each of them be, and they are hereby, admitted to practice in this court as Attorneys and Counsellors at Law.

When the constitutional changes were made in 18G3, Siskiyou, with Shasta and Trinity counties, was constituted the Ninth Judicial district, by Act of April 25th, and so remained until the District Court was abolished by the adoption of the new constitution. At that time the civil jurisdiction was raised from amounts of more than two hundred dollars to three hundred dollars, and it was given the exclusive power to try all indictments for treason, misprision of treason, murder, and manslaughter, as well as those which the county judge was incapacitated from trying by reason of personal interest. But little change was made in the powers of the District Court after 1863. A district judge had the authority to hold court in any district in the State, when so reqested by the judge of that district, or upon designation of the governor. Tins privilege was but once exercised in this county, the September term, 1801, being held by Hon. E. W. McKinstry, of the Seventh district, by request of Hon. William P. Daingerfield.

On account of the difficulty found in the conduct of legal business so far from the county seat, the Legislature, in 1872, authorized the district iud 'e to bold a term of court in July of each year at Lake City, in Surprise valley. The citizens of that region were seeking to have a new county organized, and this action was taken as a measure of relief to them, until the foundation of a new county could be agreed upon and effected. Court was opened there awaiting the appearance of Hon. A. M. Rosborough, the judge. Th.it gentleman arrived on the eleventh, and court was opened for business, adjourning on the sixteenth. The next year the term in Lake City began July 14, and ended July 18, 1873. This is one of the few instances in the State of court being held away from the county seat. Modoc county was formed in 1874.

By the new constitution, which went into effect on the first of January, 1880, the District Court was abolished, and all its powers were conferred upon the Superior Court, a new tribunal created by that instrument. The final record of t'.ie District Court of the Ninth judicial district, in and for Siskiyou county, made on the last day of its existence as a judicial tribunal, is as follows : -

At a regular term of the Hun. District Court of the Ninth Judicial Districi of the State of California, conti 'ued, and held within and for said county, at Yreka City, the county seat thereof, on Wednesday, Dec. 31st, A. D. lo79, Court met pursuant to adjournment, and was duly called hy the 'Sheriff. The following order having been received from H n. A. M. Rosborough, District Judge, the Court is adjourned iu accordance therewith, to wit: -

It is hereby ordered, in accordance with third secti m of the twenty-second article c f the New Constitution of the State of California, that all record-:, books, papers and pr ceedings now remaining in the District Court, held in and for .Siskiyou count*', undisposed of, be transferred on the first day of January, eighteen hundred and eighty to the Superior Court of Siskiyou county, and in the language of said section of said Constitution, "the said Superior Court, to which ihe same are thus tran-f rred, shall have the same power and jurisdiction over them as if they h d been in the first instance c unmenced, filed and lodged therein."

It is further ordered that ihe District Court of the Ninth Judicial District be, and the same is hereby adjourned sine die. A. M. Rosbokough, District Judge.

County Court

The County Court was held by the county judge, whose term of office was fixed by the constitution at four years. An appeal lay to this court in civil cases from a justice of the peace. The business transacted prior to 1863 was very small, but at that time it was given jurisdiction of cases in forcible entry and detainer, and the criminal jurisdiction theretofore exercised by the Court of Sessions was conferred upon it. Thereafter it had the power to inquire into criminal offenses by means of a grand jury, and try all indictments except those for treason, misprision of treason, murder and manslaughter, which indictments were certified to the District Con it for trial.

At the first election, held on the third of May, 1852, Hon. William A.Robertson was chosen county judge. He took the oath of office before Charles M. Tutt, president of the board of commissioners to organize Siskiyou county, on the twelfth of May, and two days laier male the first entry on his record as follows: -

It is hereby ordered that an election for two Justices of the Peace and one Constable for Shasta Butte City Township, and two Justices of the Peace and two Constables to fill the vacancies in said unices be held at the respective election precincts of said townships on Saturday, the 2i)tn of May, 1852, between the hour of 8 o'clock, A. M.., and suiisjt of the same day; and that a c>.py of tliij order be posted at the several precinct;, aforesaid, at least tea days previous to said election.

It is hereby ordered that an election for two Justices of the Peace and tvvo Constables for the Townsh p of Humbug be held at the usual election precincts of said township, on Saturday, the 26th of June, 1S52, between the hour of 8 o'clock, A. M., and sun-down of the same day, and that a copy of this order be posted at tire precincts aforesaid at least ten days previous to said election.

The regular election for district judges occurring in November, 1852, Judge Robertson became a candidate, and issued the following somewhat peculiar election proclamation, which appears on the record of the County Court, dated October 13, 1852: -

Public Notice

The qualified voters of Siskiyou county are hereby notified that a geuer.d elect on, in pursuance of the above proclamation, will be held at the different precincts in this county on Tuesday the - day of November, A. D , 1852, to fill the offices specified in said proclamation together with the following township and county officers, viz.: Public Administrator, one Justice of the Peace and one Constable for Scott's Bar Township, two Justices of the Peace and two Constables for Humbug Township, one Justice of the Peace and one Constable for Scott Valley Township, two Justices of the Peace and Wo Constables lor Yreka (City) Township.

In consixjiunce of ihe undersigned being a candidate for the office of District Judge, he declines appuuti ig Inspectors and Judges of Election. The qualified voters, therefore, at each precinct, will meet; at eight o'clock in the morning and choose from amontr their number one person to act as Inspector and two persons to act as Judges of Election. The Judges and Inspectors in ill then appoint two suitable persons to act as Clerks.

Election Proclamation

At a general election to be holden throughout the State of California on Tuesday, the second day of November, 1852, the following officers are to be elected : -

One District Judge for each of the Judicial Districts m the State, and one Member of the Assembly for Siskiyou county. * * * * * * * , * * * * *

From the tenth of June, 1852, to the seventh of March, 1853, are entered upon the record fifteen declarations of intention to become citizens of the United States; also on January 26, 1853, an order for the election of a justice of the peace in Yreka township, to be held on the fifth of the following February; also a habeas corp us case on petition of S. N. Holmes, held for grand larceny, January 27, 1853. Judge Robertson, failing to be elected district judge, opened the first regular term of the County Court on the seventh of March, 1S53, the following being the record: -

March 7th, A. d. 1S53, being the first Monday of March, the time appointed by law or a regular term of the County Court, the Court convened at the office of the County Clerk. Pr >c!ara> tioii was made and Court opened iu due form. Present, William A. Robertson, County Judge ; H. G. Ferris, County Clerk ; and D. D. Colton, Under Sheriff.

The first case on the docket is that of " Theodore F. Rowe vs. Grove K. and Helen Go If rev," an appeal from the docket of Justice J. D. Mason, of Scott River township, which was dismissed at the request of appellant.

Immediately after the March term Judge Robertson resigned and Hon. Royal L. Westbrook received an appointment from the governor to fill the vacancy, assuming the position in May. The appointment only extended until the next general election, and in the fall of the same year he "was elected to the office. The full term of a county judge was four years, and it was assumed that Jud^e Westbrook would hold the office until his successor was chosen in 1857, notwithstanding the fact that the regular election for county judges occurred in 1855. Acting upon this supposition the supervisors failed to call an election for county judge in 1855, but when election day arrived the friends of Hon. A. M. Rosborough went quietly to work writing his name on ballots in a few precincts, of which two hundred and eighty-seven were cast, in a total vote of over three thousand. The result was a contest, ending in the office being given to Judge Rosborough, who held it continuously until he was elected district judge in 1869. In 1857 votes were cast for Judge Westbrook for this office, but the effort was of no effect. Hon. William McConaughy was appointed to the office January 0, 1870, when Judge Rosborough resigned to become district judge, and in 1871 Hon. Edwin Shearer was elected, iToldinothe position until the court was abolished by the new constitution, January 1, 1880.

At a regular term of the Hon. County Court, continued and held within a id for said county, at Yreka City, the comity seat thereof, on Wednesday, Dec. 31st, 187t>, Court met pursuant to adjournment aud was duly called by the Sheriff. Present, Hon.

Ordered by the Court that all cases now pending therein be transferred to the Superior Court of the State of California, held in and for the county of Siskiyou, and that the County Court of said State in and f jr said county, be, and the same is hereby, adjourned nine die.

Probate Court

The jurisdiction of this court embraced all probate matters, the court bjing held by the county judge. At first issues of fact joinel in this court were a ljourned into the District Court for trial, but afterwards the Legislature conferred upon it the power to summon juries and try all issues of fact. There was but little alteration made in the powers of this court, which ceased to exist when the new constitution took effect.

It is ordered tint E. D. Pearce, of Siskiyou County, be appointed special Administrator up m the est .te of Mahlon Lewis, of Humbug creek, deceased; and that said E. D. Pearce be authorized and entrusted t > collect and preserve for the Administrator, who' may hereafter be app dated, all the go ids, chattels, debts an 1 effects of the deceased, aid take the sane into his possession, c ire and control, subject to such order as the Probate Court m .y from time to time make in regard thereto; that Said E. D. Pea-ce be notified of his appointment, and that he be required to enter into bonds iu the sum of li e thousand dollars.

June '/8th, 1652 ibjiug the fourth Monday of June), there being no business for the Probate Court it did not meet at tnis term. State of California )

Ordered by the Court that all cases now pending therein be transferred to the Superior Court of the State of California, held in and for the county of Siskiyou; and the Probate Court of said couuty is hereby adjourned sine die.

Court Of Sessions

The county judge, as chief justice, and two justices of the peace, as associate justices, composed the Court of Sessions. Annually the county judge convened the justices of the peace of the county, who selected from their own number two who should act as associate j ustices of the Court of Sessions for the ensuing year. In case of a vacancy or a failure to attend, the county judge appointed another justice, and as this frequently occurred, some years half

J. S. Beard

J. S. Beard is a native of Northumberland count}', Pennsylvania, and the eldest son of a family of five sons and three daughters. His father, James Beard, was born in Clark county, Ohio, and his mother, - Susan M. Gehrig, - in Berks county, Pennsylvania. His boyhood days were passed amid the scenes and busy life of the beautiful valley of the Susquehanna. He received the education afforded by the common schools and private academies of that locality. In 1853 he became a member of a corps of civil engineers, and for about two years was employed, under Hon. Kimber Clever, on the survey and construction of the Shamokin Valley railroad. He quit this employment to accept a deputyship under his father, who then held the office of prothonotary of Northumberland county. During the time he was employed in this office he studied law, and was admitted to the bar in April, 1857. For a short time he practiced law in his native countj^ and adjoiningdistricts, then bade adieu to kindred, friends, and home, and started westward. Once on the wino\ he did not find a permanent resting place until°the shores of the Pacific were reached. He arrived in California in 1859, and, being then young, hopeful and ambitious at once sought the fortune which he supposed awaited him. Failing to secure a satisfactory business in the practice of law, he shelved his books and went to work as " an honest miner." After much tramping, toil, and disappointment, he abandoned mining for other pursuits. In 1864 Mr. Beard re-engaged in the practice of his profession, at Yreka, and for a year was associated in business with L. M. Ketcham, now deceased. The business of this place was not sufficient to support the army of attorneys then engaged in practice, hence the subject of our sketch again quit the law, and became connected with our common schools as teacher, and thereafter taught school in the Humbug, Hawkinsville, Union, and Etna districts. In 1872 he opened a law office in Etna, where he is now permanently located, and well established in business. July 12, 1874, he married Miss Annie Webster Ackley, eldest daughter of Hosea and Nancy Ackley, who came to Scott valley in 1864, from East Rumford, Maine. The issue of this marriage has been four children, two boys and two girls, three of whom, Annie Ackley, John Augustus, and James Gehrig, are now living. In early manhood he espoused the principles of the Democratic party, but in 1864, becoming dissatisfied with the course and policy of that party, went over to the ranks of the Republicans, and took the stump in advocacy of the election of their nominee for the presidency. And since then he has with his voice and pen supported and advocated Republican principles. For many years he has been identified with, and labored for the advancement of the public schools of the county, and is now president of the County Board of Education. In 1857 he was initiated into the mysteries and beauties of Odd Fellowship, and is one of the charter members of Etna Lodge, No. 184, Independent Order of Odd Fellows. He is also a charter member of Etna Lodge No. 177, Ancient Order of United Workmen. He is most public spirited, and every movement made in the interest of the people, or to benefit the masses, receives his hearty support. He has been identified with every enterprise of a public, or quasi public character undertaken or accomplished in Etna and vicinity since he has made that place his home. He loves the quiet of home life, and finds delight in the society and companionship of his family and friends, and as a lawyer, a man, and a citizen, commands the confidence and respect of all classes.

a dozen gentlemen occupied the- position. The duties of this court at first were chiefly to administer the affairs of the county, a function now discharged by a board of supervisors. In 18.31 a radical change was made in the powers of this court by conferring upon it the criminal jurisdiction previously exercised by the District Court. It ha 1 the power to inquire into all criminal offenses by means of a grand jury, and to try all indictments found by that body, save those for murder, manslaughter, and arson, which were certified to the District Court. In 1855 the Legislature created boards of supervisors in the various counties, leaving to the Court of Sessions only its criminal jurisdiction. In 18G3 the court was abolished and its powers were conferred upon the County Court.

On this seventh day of June, A. D. 1S52, at 10 o'clock A. M., the Hon. Court of Sessions in and for Siskiyou county, California, met at the c >urt house in Yre'.c.i City, 1 1 hold its first term. Present, Hon. W. A. Robertson, County Judge; James Strawbridge and William A. Patterson, Justices of the Peace, called to the bench to act as Associ de Justices.

J. D. Cosby and Thomas H. Coats, Esi-i., cams forward, and each filed his affidavit, took the oath of office, and was admitted to practice as an attorney at law in th s Court.

0.1 app ication of Edward De Witt for a license to keep a ferry at the crossing of the road from this place to Oregon, on the Klamath river, Justice StrawbriJge declined acting as one of the Judges, in consequence of having on a former occasion been employed as an attorney in the case of the petitioner, Ed. De Wibc.

After consideration of the petition of Geo. W. Tyler to be appointed auctioneer, the Court ordered that it be granted; whereupon he presented his bond for the approval of the Court, and ic was approved.

Ordered by the Court that the County Assessor of this county be authorized and required t > assess tax for county purposes, at the rate of fifty cents for each one hundred dollars of all taxable property in this county.

After oonsidernti in of A. Vallard to be appointed auctioneer, the Court ordered that s dd petition be gr in ted; whereupon he presented his bond, and it was approved l>y tlie Court.

At a regul ir term of the Hon. Court of Sessions, continued and held within and for said county, at Yreka City, the county seat thereof, on Tuesday, Nov. 17th, A. D. 1863, Court met pursuant to adj nirnine.it, and was duly called by the Sheriff. Present, Hon. A M. Koshorough, County Judge and Presidi ig Judge of the Court of Sessions, and E. W. Potter and D. 0. Stevens, Esq's , Associate Justices, and the officers of the Court.

This being the time set by the Court for pronouncing its judgment in the case, F. E. Ensign, Dist. Atty., being present, the defendant, Win. C. Kirby, not appearing ; whereupon it is ordered by the Court that the defendant, Win. C. Kirby, pay a fine of one hundred dollars, and that execution may issue therefor.

Associate Justices

The first grand jury in the county was summoned by the Court of Sessions on the fifth of October, 1852, and was composed of the following gentlemen : Dr. W. G. Proctor, foreman, 0. D. Hoxie, John Lintell, N. Garland, Dr. William Dain, Dr. D. M. Davidson, R. B. Hendv, B. W. Arnold, George Waterman, R. L. Westbrook, C. N. Thornbury, E. C. Kelley, William Johnson, H. Vanderpool, IsaaT M. Lusk, Theodore F. Rowe, D. E. Shiel, B. F. Varney, R. M.

Martin, Henry Bowman, Hugh Slicer, George E. Briggs and W. S. Mendenhall. There were twentyfour gentlemen summoned, but John F. Farmer was excused, there being one too many. Two indictments for grand larceny were presented by this body.

Superior Court

By the new constitution the powers of the District, County and Probate Courts were combined and vested in one tribunal, called the Superior Court. There are twelve judges of the Superior Court in the city and county of San Francisco, two in each of the counties ot Sacramento, San Joaquin, Los Angeles, Sonoma, S mta Clara and Alameda, one in the counties of Yuba and Sutter combined, and one in each of the other counties in the State. The term of office is six years. There are no set times for holding terms of court, but the judge is compelled to attend from day to day, the court being always open for legal business during the day. A number of other piovisions intended to facilitate the transaction of business are in the constitution, one of which is that a judge cannot receive his salary if there remains a case undecided that has been submitted to him for ninety days.

At the election in September, 1879, Hon. Elijah Steele was chosen judge of the Superior Court, and opened his court on the fifth of January, 18.50, the following being the record; -

State Of Californ A, Executive Department

Monday, January 5th, 1880. At a regular term of the Hon. Superior Court, begun and held within and for said county, at Yreka City, the county seat thereof, on Monday, January 5th, 1SS0, Court met pursuant to statute and was duly announced bv the Sherilf. Present, Hon. E. Steele, Superior Judge, and the officers of the Court. STATE OF CALIFORN A, EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT.

To all to whom these presents shall come, greeting: Know ye, That whereas it appears from the statement of the vote made by the Secretary of State and filed in his office, a copy of which has been transmitted to this office, th .t at the general election held on Wednesday, the third day of September, A. D., 187d, in the county of Siskiyou, Elijah Steel received the highest number of votes cast for the office of Judge of the Superior Court of the County of Siskiyou, State of California!

Now, therefore, I, William Irwin, Governor of the State of California, in the name and by the authority of the people of the State of Calif. irnia. do commission him, the said E.ijah Steele, Judge of the Superior Court of the county of Siskiyou aforesaid, for the term of five years, from the fifth day of January, 1880.

In testimony whereof, 1 have hereunto set my hand, and caused the great seal of the State to be affixed hereunto, at the City of Sacramento, California, this first day of November, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and seventy-ni.ie.

I, Elijah Steele, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constituti >n of the State of California, and that I will faithfuty discharge the duties of Judge of the Superior Court in and for the county of Siskiyou, State of California, to the best of my ability.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this fifth day of January, A. D. 1880. Attest my hand and official seal at Yreka, Siskiyou county, California.

Said seal to be lettered around the vignette, "Superior Court Siskiyou Co. Cal." Thevi0nette con.-istiug of Mount Shasta and the Black Butte, with a foreground ot trees and shrubs with a lake towards the center thereof, and perched upon the pinnacle of the highest peak of Mt. Shasta, is the Goddess of

Justice Court

A Justice Court is an inferior local tribunal for the adjudication of minor causes and the preservation of the p^ace. By the law of 18-30 the term of office of a justice of the peace was rixed at one year. Two justices were allowed to each township, also two constables, the offijers who serve the processes of the court. The juiisdiction of a justice extended to the limits of the township f.ir which he was elected. He had cognizance of actions on contract, for damages, and to recover specific property, when the amount or value did not exceed $200. In 18.51 his powers were considerably increased. He had jurisdiction of actions to recover money, for damages to personal property, for fines, penalties and forfeitures, actions on bonds, enforcement of lien on personal property, actions to recover personal property and judgment by confession, where the amount in all these cases did not exceed $500, and on a bond taken by him if the amount did exceed that sum, cases of forcible entry and detainer, and the trial of the right of mining claims. The criminal jurisdiction embraced vagrancy, disorder, petty larceny, assault and battery, breaches of the peace, and all misdemeanors punishable by a fine of not more than $500 and not more than one year's imprisonment. In 18G3 forcible entry and detainer cases were transferred to the County Court, and the civil jurisdiction was reduced to amounts not exceeding $300. In 1870 the jurisdiction of cases of misdemeanor was extended to fines of $1,000 and imprisonment for one year, but in 1874 it was reduced to fines of $500 and six months' imprisonment. In 18b'3 the term of office of justices and constables was increased to two years.

The justices of the peace and constables who have held office in the various townships of the county are given below, together with the date of qualifying. The location and extent of the townships can be ascertained in the chapter entitled "Siskiyou County as a Political Body."

Charles Michael Nentzel

This gentleman was born in Okersheirn on the Rhine, in Bavaria, December 6, 1832, and is the third child of Christopher and Christiana Regina (Helmuth) Nentzel. They emigrated to America in 1833, and arrived in New York during the prevalence of the cholera. His father established a blacksmith business in that city. Charles, as he grew up, received the rudiments of an English education in the public school, and studied German and French under a private tutor. He assisted his father from the age of fourteen till sixteen, when he became apprenticed to a jeweler. His father left New York for California in 1850, and sent for Charles to join him two years later. He started in the spring of 1853, crossed through Nicaragua, and landed in San Francisco early in June. He at once went to Scott Bar, where" his father had established a merchandising business, whom he assisted till 1855. He then became a partner with his father and S. Simon. In 1865, his health being impaired by too close application to business, he left Scott river, and went by stage to Sacramento, steamer to San Francisco, and again to Panama, railroad to Aspinwall, and steamer Star of the West, to New York. He entered Dr. Laidlaw's hydropathic cure at Hudson City, where he gradually regained health and vigor. In December, 1865, he took up bis residence with his brother-in-law, Mr. Hintze, on Hudson Heights, where he lived nearly a year, attending a commercial college. In January, 1867, he engaged to work at his old occupation of jeweler, at Chattellier & Spence, in New York, where, for a time, prosperity followed him. His younger brother, David, who had taken charge of a ranch in Scott valley, belonging to Nentzel & Simon, died in the spring of 1872, and Charles abandoned his situation in New York, and returned here, to take charge of the ranch and manage the property. He made the trip this time on the railroad, in thirteen days, arriving in San Francisco July 21, 1873, and at Scott valley five days later. Although the work and management of the farm was to him a novelty, he entered upon the task with courage and energy, and succeeded so well in the ensuing seven years, that he may be regarded as one of the prosperous farmers of Scott valley. He is well known for his sterling integrity, and is generally esteemed as a good citizen and neighbor. In politics, he is a Republican, and in religion, a liberal Protestant. He owns 480 acres of land, all under a good state of cultivation.

At the first discovery of mines in what is now recognized as Siskiyou county, its exact geographical position was unknown. The influx of miners was from both north and south, those coming from Oregon claiming it as within the Oregon lines, and those from the south that the mining district south | of Klamath river was on California territory.

The consequence of this uncertainty was that in 1850 and 1851, and until the organization of the present county, the denizens of that territory lying i north of Shasta Butte and south of the Siskiyou j mountains declined to submit to the judicial author- | ity of either Oregon or California ; but in order to j the maintenance of right over might each mining I district organized as a judicial district and elected I one or more alcaldes, according to the population of the district.

In the mining district known as Scott's Bar the first important question arose between the Davis Brothers and others, the first discoverers of the socalled Goodwin claim, and R. B Snelling and others, who had jumped it during the absenceof the original locators to Sacramento valley, whither they had

It was finally agreed between the parties that Judge Hughes, county judge of Colusa county, should be cilied to preside at the trial. Hughes was sent for, but upon his arrival the Snelling party, who were Oregonians, went back on their agreement, claiming that as their opponents were from California, and Hughes from that State, they feared partiality; and then both parties armed to settle the dispute by the right of might.

of the United States Land Office), and a miners' jury of twenty-four, when the first formal proceedings of a legal nature were held on Scott's Bar for the district of country now included in Siskiyou county.

At the trial the Davis brothers were represented by E. Steele as their attorney, who held a license then to practice in New York, Wisconsin, and California, and is now the superior judge of said county.

The Snelling party were represented by R. B. Snelling (one of the parties who claimed to have been an attorney from Kentucky), a gentleman by the name of Spindle, hailing from Virginia, and claiming a license from that State, and William Clarkson, from Missouri.

The miners, also, in organizing the court, selected General R. M. Martin from their number to act as sheriff, and, all tilings in readiness, the case proceeded, and after a long and tedious trial the jury found that the Davis party ha 1 abandoned the claim, when they went out, wh ch was acquiesced in, and a serious encounter avoided. This trial took place in the early spring of 1851,

Soon after it was conceived on Scott's Bar that it would be better to have a local organization, and R. B. Snelling and a miner, known only as Buffalo John, presented their names as candidates for the office, designating it as " county judge."

In the contest Snelling was victorious by a small majority, and assumed the duties without taking the oath of office, but by the acquiescence of the Scott's Bar people.

In the meantime Yreka had become quite an important point, and they proceeded to elect an alcalde, to determine the right and repress the wrong.

The first alcalde of importance, though two had preceded him, was George C. S. Vail, formerly of Wisconsin. Vail entered upon and discharged for a short time the duties of alcalde with a considerable one-sided ability, openly declaring that if the plaintiff in an action was poor, and the defendant had means, it was an absolute necessity to give iudgment for the plaintiff, as the collection of fees was an important question. Jim Thomas, our present deputy sheriff, residing at Fort Jones, was his lav/ officer.

Vail had not long been inducted into office before a boy made a complaint to his court, claiming five or six hundred dollars agiinst an Oreg m driver for services in aiding in driving ca'-tle an 1 working for him in a claim. Vail issued his summons, which upon being served, the drover sold his cattle and appeared in court to defend the claim. The testimony of plaintiff and defendant was all. of the evidence in the case, and that was in every important matter conflicting. Vail, with the wisdom of a Solomon, held that the defendant, having hurriedly sold his cattle when called to answer the complaint, showed a guilty conscience, and it was prima, facie evid -nee that he lied, and entered judgment for the full claim and ab >ut as much more of costs.

How to enforce the judgment then became an important question, as the defendant defied the court, claiming that he had converted everything to cash, and that he had it on his person, which under the constitution was exempt from search.

Here was for the moment a knotty question for Vail. He had always been loud in his own behalf in claiming the rights of an American citizen, anl was willing to accord the defendant exemption from search; but Vail's wit and his itching palm for the costs soon sug^estel a way out of the difficulty. After a few moments of deep thought, Vail so amended his decree as to order his law officer to enforce the judgment by standing the defendant upon his heal and shaking him well and to levy up >n whatever of valuables should be produced in satisfaction of the execution. Whereupon Thomas, with the aid of the alcalde and plaintiff, proceeded to put the decree in force, when the defendant, finding himself alone in the matter, pulled out his sack of dust and paid the judgment.

The other recognized attorneys up to that time were Ben. M. Penn, of Brownsville, Ohio, a young man of a very fine mind, but who in his youth fell a victim to the ba 1 liquors with which the country was fljoded, and died in Scott valley in 1852; Cardozi, who hailed from New York City and to which pkee he returned at an early day, and has since held quite responsible political positions in that city; Columbus Sims, hailing from Alabama, a sensitive, high-toned young mm of considerable ability; he is believed to be dead at this writing; James Strawbridge, who hailed from New Orleans, and was a member of the first Court of Sessions of this county, at which Judge W. A. Robertson presided as judge. Strawbridge returned to New Orleans; was afterwards quite prominent as a rebel, which was quite a surprise to his many California friends. In character, he was a man of broad views, of liberal disposition, and seemed to be whilst here devoid of all local prejudices.

List, though not least, of the early attorneys of 1851 was John D. Cosby, whose widow yet resides in Yreka. Cosby was a native of Kentucky where he gr.idu ited as an attornev, coming to this country when quite a boy. As an office lawyer Cosby was not eminent, but as an advocate he was rarely if ever surpassed. He was a natural speaker, ready at all times, and was one of those gifted persons that could speak on either side of any important question with great firmness and logic. Cosby upon the organization of the county in May, 1852, associate I himself with John D. Cook in the practice of the law at Yreka, where he h id a very lucrative practice. He was afterwards elected State senator for this county, which office he filled with distinction. After his as-ojiation with Cook, Cosby remained alone for a time, and then in 1857 formed a copartnership with Mr. Steele which lasted nearly three years, when they separated and Cosby continued in the practice alone until the time of his death, which happened from a horse running away with him in the spring of 1861. Cosby was an active politician and was one of the foremost advocates of Native Americanism. In his whole life he was notable for his generosity and prodigality, and although his earnings in his profession amounted to large sums, and in his family expenses he and his wife were not in the least extravagant, yet when called from this stage of action he died poor in purse, but rich in the esteem of those who best knew him.

As we have now come to the organization of the first County Court in May, 1852, it may be well to take notice of the bench and bar from this time on in the order in which they stand on record.

Our first county judge was William A. Robertson, a native of Georgia, a man of firm talent, a genial whole-souled gentleman, and of pure and unblemished character. He presided as county judge until about May, 1853, when finding; the salary was too insufficient to warrant his retaining the position he resigned and R. L. Westbrook was appointed in his place. Judge Robertson then entered upon the practice of his profession, in which he was quite successful. About 1856 he returned to his native State, and afterwards, about 1857, removed to Washington, D. C, and entered upon the practice of his profession, at which place he died in about 1858 or 1859. During the time he was in practice he was for a short time associated with Columbus Sims, and afterwards with Eli H. Stone.

John D. Cook settled in Yreka in the spring of 1852. He was a native of Kentucky, a man of superior natural and acquired attainments. The first year was devoted pretty much to roving and Indian hunting, but finally he formed a copartnership with John D. Cosby, with whom he continued until his health failed, and in 1855 he gave up the practice of the profession and died of consumption at Sacramento City in 1857 or '58.

George W. Pierson was another of the early members of the bar that have "passed over the river." His true name was George Wilmot, and he was a brother to Wilmot of the Wilmot Proviso notoriety. Some irregularity of early life induced him to assume the maiden name of his mother, Pierson. He was known as Pierson generally till his death, which occured in Yreka in about 1857.

Jehu Berry is another that may be considered as of the past. He was born in Ohio; came to California at an early day, and to Yreka as a packer in 1852. He was admitted to the bar and entered upon the practice in 1854, at first as member of the firm of Steele, Rosborough & B^rry, afterwards as Rosborough & Berry and finally alone. He was originally an active Whig, but being elected to the State Senate over D. D. Oolton he, during his term under John C. Burch became a convert to democracy and continued in that faith until he lost his senses. He is now an inmate of Napa lunatic asylum. Berry in early life was a man of much thought and good legal attainments, but no advocate. His forte was office woik.

An attorney of early times was one Hulbard, but of his history none of the old settlers now renminbi oknow anything. He was for a short time associated with Pierson.

E. M. Anthony, commonly known as Mose Anthony, was a lawyer of finished education, and modest unassuming disposition ; was born in Virginia; died in Yreka about 1869. He devoted the most of his time to mining.

A. M. Rosborough came to Siskiyou in 1853; was a member of the firm of Steele, Rosborough & Berry until he succeeded Westbrook as county judge in 1856, and continue! in that office until elected district judge, which office he held until the adoption of the new State constitution, when he removed to Shasta county and then to Oakland, where he now resides. Upon his retiring from the practice, his brother. J. B. R)sborough, formed a copartnership with Berry, Steele retiring. Both Risborou^hs were born in Tennessee. J. B. now resides at Salt Lake City.

James D. Turner held for a time a prominent position as an attorney. He was at one time candidate for district judge, again for the Assembly, and editor of Yreka Union; was a man of marked ability. Returned to Illinois, whence he had emigrated to this State. Soon after his return home he died of consumption.

George W. S. Cummins was born in Virginia, a graduate of a law school, of high attainments as a scholar and thinker. He was a member of the firm of Fair & Cummins. He died at Yreka about 1859, in early manhood. His partner, Col. W. D. Fair, was a native of Virginia, and was for a time a professor in a military college. Removed to New Orleans, where he made the acquaintance of his wife, Laura D. F.iir. He ended his career by suicide in San Francisco.

George W. Tyler, now of Alameda, was an early resident of Siskiyou county. Studied the profession for a time, and soon went back to Massachusetts, his boyhood home; graduated, and returned to Yreka to practice. He afterwards removed to Stockton. Has since held, with marked ability, the office of county judge of San Joaquin county, and more lately was member of the Assembly from Alameda county. He is now practicing his profession with success in San Francisco.

W. S. R. Taylor, an attorney, resided on Greenhorn a short time as a miner; took part in some of the water trials, originating there, but no one now left knows further of his history.

Eli H. Stone was a native of Kentucky. He was for a time partner with Judge Robertson After their dissolution he served a term as district attorney, when to hold tliat office wa3 to get rich. He soon returned to his native State, where he yet resides.

The district judges that presided in this county were, first in order, Judge J. Montgomery Peters, a native of Virginia, a man of fine attainments and finished training, but from lack of energy he was a failure as a ju Ige. He returned East, and finally died in Baltimore.

Mbs. Elijah Steele

This gentleman is the son of Orlo Steele, and was bom near Albany, New York. November 13, 1817. When he was three years of age the family moved to Oswego, in the same State, where Elijah was educated. He read law in the office of Grant & Allen, the latter gentleman being Judge of the Court of Appeals. At the July term, 1840, he was admitted to the bar of the Supreme Court of New York, and then went to Wisconsin, landing in Kenosha (then Southport) on the fifth of October. That fall he was admitted to the Circuit Court of Wisconsin and Illinois, and in 1841 to the Supreme Court of Wisconsin. He practiced law there until April, 1850, during which time he was a member of the first constitutional convention of Wisconsin. In 1849 he was elected to the State Senate, but before his term expired he left for California for his health, intending to stay one year. He landed in Sacramento from across the plains October 5, 1850, just ten years after his entry into Wisconsin. He went at once to Shasta and commenced mining at Middletown. He soon went below again for medical aid. He fell in with some of the Scott river prospectors, and went to Shasta to winter. In January, he started with others for Scott river. The trip was tedious and the estimated distance from Shasta to Shasta Butte was one hundred and ninety miles. He worked for a few days at Scott Bar, and then came to Yreka when news was received of the discovery here, and took up a claim north of Rich guich. It was a poor one, and he met with Robert Atherton, Stephen Watson and others to the number of twelve, and took up a claim on Greenhorn. With James Mc- Cummins and Barny Simmons, he went prospecting about Shasta Butte and lay camped back of Sheep Rock two nights in a terrific snow-storm, which date he places at the twenty-first and twenty-second of March, 1851. In the fall of 1851 Steele joined with Sloan, Briggs and Tiernan, and started an express from Scott Bar via Yreka to Sacramento. They took up a land claim two miles this side of

Fort Jones, and established a trading-post with Tiernan in charge, and another at Scott Bar with Sloan in charge. Steele road the express. On one of his trips he was taken sick in Sacramento, and it was reported that he was dead. Early in the winter his partners closed up the business and departed. Steele met Briggs at Trinity Center with part of the mules. He took from them his own mules and took possession of the ranch near Fort Jones. He was joined by Lucius Fairchild, from Wisconsin. He practiced a little in his profession, and for defending a man charged with murder he received four head of beef cattle, worth $500. With these Steele & Fairchild started a butchering business. Fairchild took charge of the market at Scott Bar and Steele stayed at the ranch. They continued together till 1855, when Fairchild returned home, became Secretary of State, Governor of Wisconsin three terms, General in the army, Consul to Liverpool, and Minister to Spain. Steele formed a law partnership with A. M. Rosborough and J. Berry. In 1856 he sold the ranch and invested in mortgages on Scott River ditch and lost it all. He then went to Yreka to practice his profession. He associated himself with John D. Cosby from 1857 to 1859, and afterwards partner of F. E. Ensign, and then practiced alone. In 1867 he was elected to the Assembly. In 1879 be was chosen Superior Judge of Siskiyou county. He has always taken an interest in the promotion of agriculture, and has imported considerable blooded horses, cattle and fowls, and in 1S66 was one of the founders and for sever-al years President of the Siskiyou County Ai-gicultural Society. In 1843 Mr. Steele married Miss Lucia A. Hart, of Oswego, New York, by whom he had four children, two of whom lived to manhood. Edwin, the eldest, died in 1878, at Lakeview, Oregon. William is now mining at Silver Reef, Utah. Their mother died in 1853, at Oswego. In 1857 he married Louisa P. Hamblin, at Yreka, who died in January, 1866. He afterwards married Louisa E. Lanze, at Yreka, by whom he has three boys, Hubert Elijah, Alden John, and Orlo.

Residence Of Judge Elijah Steele South Suburbs Of Yreka, Siskiyou Co. Cal

Next, William P. Daingei field, a native of Virginia. His resilience was Shasta. He afterwards removed to San Francisco, where he was elected district judge, ami finally one of the supreme judges, and died on the bench in 1880. He was a man generally respected, and the records of the courts, entered by his associates upon hearing of his death, speak his standing and worth.

The third was E. Garter, of Shasta, a native of New York, a man of much greater legal attainments than his predecessors. His history is written in the minutes of his court. He died at Shasta in 1880. His son, Charles Garter, is now practicing his profession in Red Bluff.

He was succeeded by A. M. Rosborough, who held the office until relieved by the constitution in establishing the Superior Court of the county, to take the place of county and district courts.

In this history of district judges we have omitted the name of Judge Smith, of Oroville, who was elected district judge by the suffrages of the voters of this county, this being then claimed as a part of that district. After his election he refused to acknowledge it as p' rtaining to his district, for the reason that in the Act organizing Siskiyou county from a portion of Shasta county, which was in his district, the county was not assigned especially to any district. He died soon after entering upon the duties of his office.

The attorneys practicing in his court are W. I. Nichols, Calvin Elgerton, Hudson B. Gillis, E. Shearer, and Thomas A. Bantz, of Yreka; I. S. Reynolds, of Fort Jones; and J. S. Beard, of Etna.

Provenance

Text from History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.