BlockBefore

Siskiyou County, California - Chapter 15: The Death Penalty, 1881

From History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. 6,140 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

10 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

6,140 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 15: The Death Penalty

The extreme sentence of the law has been passed upon five individuals in this county, and upon three of them was it carried into effect. In the other two cases the penitentiary was substituted for the gallows. Many murders have been committed and a number of men convicted and sent to prison for varied terms, but it is unnecessary to fill these pages with such unpleasant occurrences, save where a sentence of death was passed. To the chapter entitled " The Court of Judge Lynch " the reader is referred for the particulars of all executions other than by due process of law.

James Brown

After a trial in the District Court for the murder of a man named Antonio, James Brown was sentenced by Judge J. Montgomery Peters, December 30, 1854, to be hanged Friday, March 2, 1855. Before the day of execution arrived, his sentence was commuted to imprisonment for life, and after a few years in San Quentin he was pardoned by the governor and liberated.

Sampson Crowder

Early on Sunday morning, August 3, 1S56, the news went flying swiftly along Scott river that a cruel murder had been committed at French Bar. The body of S. R. Lewis was found with a knifewound in it, while near by lay Sampson Crowder drunk, grasping in his hand a large pocket knife. On the floor, also, lay a large knife, the property of another man.

They had all been on a drunken carouse the night before, and these and a few other circumstances were all the evidence of the crime that could be produced. Crowder was at once taken into custody by Constable Barney, and Justice Daniel F. Finle'y held an inquest, which occupied but a short time and resulted in a verdict that S. R. Lewis came to his death by a knife-wound inflicted by the hand of Sampson Crowder. Lewis was a native of New York and a man of average standing in the community, and great indignation was felt by his friends. They began to gather and talk of violence, encouraged and assisted by a great many who, though not particularly friends of Lewis, were ready to assist at any time in meting out pioneer justice to a murderer. About noon they made a rush for the building where the prisoner was confined, and were met at the door by" the justice, constable, and a number of citizens, who were desirous of upholding the law and sought to dissuade the mob from their purpose. The crowd demanded the immediate surrender of Crowder, and were met with a refusal. They then called for the evidence taken at the inquest to be read, and when this had been done they became doubly excited, and demanded ao-ain to have Crowder given up to them. When they were again refused the}' made a determined attack upon the house, the officers refraining from filing upon them and thus avoiding a futile and bloody conflict. The doors were battered in and the boards torn off the side of the building, layingbare the room in which the prisoner was confined. Crowder was seized by rough hands and hustled along the center of a crowd of five hundred men, to a gulch a short distance down the stream, where preparations were made to hang him at once. This proceeding was a little too summary to suit the idea of justice entertained by many in the crowd, and a murmur of disapproval went up, ending in shouts of " Give him a trial," " Try him first." John G. Berry made a speech advising them to let the law take its course, or at least to give him a trial. A vote was then taken, and the result was almost unanimous for giving the man a trial. They proposed to hang him anyway, but thought it would look better if they went through the form of a trial first. The next step was to select a jury, and this was the rock on which they stranded. As men were solicited to form one of the body they would decline the responsibility. They were willing to hang the man, but did not care to have their names so prominently associated with the act. There were some, also, when asked to form part of the jury, who said they were opposed to the whole proceeding, and as one after another made this remark, they gathered courage, and boldly declared that it was a shame to so contravene the law, and recommended that he be returned to the custody of the authorities. Only six of that whole crowd expressed a willingness to become jurymen. A vote was then taken on the question of delivering him again to the officers, and the whole crowd stepped across the line in a body. This settled the matter, and Crowder was taken back to town, surrendered to the constable, and by him taken at once to Yreka and safely lodged in the county jail.

The law's delay, so annoying and subversive of justice, was not experienced in this case. The grand jury found an indictment for murder, and Crowder was brought up for trial in the District Court before Judge J. Montgomery Peters, on the twenty-fifth of August, but three weeks after the deed was committed. The case was prosecuted by District Attorney R. B. Snelling, assisted by Eli H. Stone and J. D. Turner, while John D. Cook and John D. Cosby conducted the defense. The evidence was entirely circumstantial, and the defense had no witnesses whatever. The trial lasted four days, and on the twenty-ninth the jury returned into court and were discharged. They had been out all night, and were unable to agree, one man holding out for acquittal. Another jury was impaneled the next day, and a new trial proceeded with, ending in a verdict of murder in the first degree, after a trial of four days. On the fifth he was brought before Judge Peters, and by him sentenced to be hanged on Saturday, the first of November.

On the day before the execution Crowder wrote a history of his life, by which it appears that his name was Sampson White Crowder. He was born in Attala county, Mississippi, February 16, 1832, his father being a pious Methodist, and his mother a half-blood Choctaw. In 1845 the family moved to Red river, in the Choctaw Nation, where he lived till he came to California in 1854. He mined at various points in Siskiyou county until the day Lewis was killed. He had been a victim of intemperance, but for four months had not tasted a drop of liquor until this fatal night he yielded to temptation, became drunk, and all that happened afterwards was as unknown to him as to the rest. The gallows was erected on the east side of the creek, near the cemetery, and when the day of execution arrived, Sheriff Samuel P. Fair summoned a bodyguard of fif ty men to escort the condemned man to the scaffold, and preserve order during the execution. At twenty minutes past two Crowder stepped upon the fatal platform, attended by Rev. Mr. Baker, and gazed upon the faces of three thousand people assembled from miles around to see him die. He made a short speech, in which he warned his hearers to beware of drink, that whisky had brought him where he now stood, and said that if he killed Lewis he knew nothing of it. After standing there forty minutes the drop fell at three o'clock, and Sampson Crowder was ushered into eternity.

Scarcely a man can to-day be found in Siskiyou county who beheves that the bloody deed was committed by him whose life paid the penalty upon the scaffold. The man who owned the knife found by the body of the murdered man disappeared the day after the murder.

Danforth Hartson, Or Sailor Jim

Sailor Jim was one of the characters of Siskiyou county, one of the bad characters. He had shot several Indians, and was looked upon with suspicion by many, some of whom thought him connected with the murder of old man Cosby, though in his confession he denied having had anything to do with it. In the spring of 1857 he shot John W. Burke, a most estimable citizen, at Canal gulch, near Hawkinsville, for which he was arrested and tried. Burke made a dying statement, charging Hartson with his death, which was admitted in evidence. The jury, also, went to view the scene of the crime. The trial commenced May 6, 1857, and closed on the thirteenth, with a verdict of murder in the first

Festus Payne

Is the eldest child of a family of five sons and daughters of Daniel R. and Mahala (Sweet) Payne, who were natives of Saratoga county, New York, where Festus was born, January 22, 1824. He remained at home with his parents on the farm until nineteen years of age, when he started out for himself, learning the carpenter's trade, which pursuit he has followed until the present time. In 1854 he removed to Garden Prairie, Boone county, Illinois. In 1859, late in the fall, he started from New York to San Francisco, and from there came direct to Scott valley, where he arrived on the fourth or fifth of April, 1860, and entered at once into milling and carpentering. He is now sole owner of the establishment on French creek known as Payne's mills, the most extensive of its kind in Siskiyou county, with a capacity of 5,000 feet per day; propelled by what is called a hurdy-gurdy wheel, fifty inches in diameter, and estimated at twenty-five horse-power, supplied by a thirteen-inch pipe, 1,200 feet pressure, equal to 120 feet perpendicular pressure. The machinery consists of a double circular saw, an edging machine, for making first-class lumber, two planing machines, a shingle mill, ripping saw, and feed mill for crushing oats, corn and barley, all under the personal supervision of Mr. Payne himself, and in first-class condition. The supply of water is inexhaustible, and the mill is run to its full capacity eight months in the year. In connection with the mills there are abundant lands for gardening and grazing. The location is a very picturesque one in the mountains. On March 17, 1868, he was united in marriage to Martha M. Goodspeecl, daughter of Nathaniel Goodspeed, of Oswego, New York. They have no children. Mr. Payne belongs to a long-lived family. His father died at the age of eighty-four, and his mother is yet living, at the ripe old age of eighty-three. He is a member of the I. O. O. F. at Fort Jones. In religion, he is a Protestant, and in politics, a Republican. As will be seen in the illustration on another page, there are numerous buildings, for the care and preservation of all products on the place; barns for ha}', stable for stock, blacksmith shop, and dry houses for lumber and fruit.

Was a native of the town of Vestal, Broome county, New York, and son of Luther Goodnoe. On the sixth clay of May, 1857, he was united in marriage to Miss L. J. Jones, a daughter of Joseph W. and Atlanta Jones; she was a native of Topsham, Orange county, Vermont. They were married in the town of Bonus, Boone county, Illinois, and resided and did business in Chicago until 1860, when they removed to California. After spending a short time in Quartz valley, he started for the Salmon river country. On reaching The Dalles, in Oregon, however, he repented, and returned to Siskiyou county ; remained a short time at Oro Fino. While mining on Indian creek he met with a severe accident, which disabled him for hard labor, and after operating in the Coyote gulch claim, now the Baker claim, until 1868, he removed to Fort Jones, and there remained in the employ of H. J. Diggles for a short time, and then engaged in merchandising on his own capital. His education was limited, as his mother died while he was an infant, and he was left to the charities of strangers ; was very observing, and one of the self-made men, who are generally successful. In this respect he was not an exception. Being possessed of commercial honor, industrious and careful, he won his reward. He died September 1, 1872, leaving to his wife a good property, unincumbered. He was a member of the Odd Fellows, and is interred in their beautiful cemetery near Fort Jones. Six years after his death, and on the twenty-eighth day of June, 1878, Mrs. Goodnoe was united in marriage to R. D. Stone, of the town of Perry, New York, now engaged in merchandising at Fort Jones. A view of Mrs. Stone's residence will be found on another page of this volume.

Thomas Patton

Is the thirteenth child and ninth son of John H. and Eliza Jane Patton, who were natives of Pennsylvania, where they were married, afterwards removing to near the town of Warren, Trumbull county, Ohio, where Thomas was born, on the twenty-sixth day of March, 1836. At thirteen years of age he went with his parents to Lake county, Indiana, and after about two years spent there, he started for the Pacific coast. Upon reaching Council Bluffs he decided to tarry there for a time, and on the ninth day of May, 1853, he renewed his journey across the plains. He arrived in Sacramento valley, near the site of the town of Anderson, September 6, 1853, and at once went to Scott valley and began work on a farm. He has continued a resident in the valley most of the time since. At one time he went to Nevada to mine, which proved a disastrous undertaking for himself and partner, financially, but was a valuable experience. Three of their party were killed by Indians and their property stolen. In 1856 he volunteered with the " Ninety and Nine " others from Siskiyou, to go and fight the Indians in the Rogue River valley. He was in several skirmishes, the most disastrous of which was the fight in Majr on a small stream between Crescent and Sayler diggings; when out of twenty-one horses twenty were killed, and of the twenty-one men who rode them, only seven escaped. Mr. Patton thinks he was the only survivor who rode a horse out of the engagement, and his recollection is that they did not kill an Indian. In 1864 he purchased the farm he now owns. He has 315 acres of good land, well adapted to general husbandry. He deals mostly in stock. Mr. Patton was married November 23, 1873, to Josephine E. Carraco, who was born in Sutter county, California, daughter of Protus and Emily Carraco. By this marriage there are two children : Minnie Eudora, born September 5, 1874, and Leila Estella, born June 2, 1880. He belongs to a longlived race, as out of a family of sixteen children, brothers and sisters of his, all lived to be grown men and women. He is a member of the Fort Jones Lodge, No. 115, Independent Order of Odd Fellows, of which he has been vice-grand ; also a member of the encampment. A view of his residence can be seen on another page.

Lucius Stafford Avilson

John Wilson, grandfather of the above, came from Londonderry', Ireland, and was known as "Big John." He was a triplet, and at his birth was easily put in a quart measure. His son, John Wilson, was father of the subject of this sketch; the mother was Laura Hay ward. Lucius Stafford W ilson was born in Genesee county, New York, September 25, 1838. He attended the common schools of his day, and received the usual education of boys of his time. When bu'. nineteen years of ace, he sailed fur California, rounding the cold and stormy Horn, and landing in San Francisco in April, 1853. That fall he came to Siskiyou county, and went to the south fork of Scott river, where his brother, John P. Wilson, was working with Samuel Cole, Abram White, Thomas White and Jeremiah Day. He kept a trading-post that fall and winter for M. B. Callahan, located about three miles above Callahan's ranch, and in the spring of 1854 bought it and kept it on his own account for a year. The ranch he now lives on was located in 1852 by his brother and partners, and in 1855 he purchased Mr. Cole's interest and moved upon the ranch to live, and has ever since made it his home. He has owned it all for a number of years. The old log house, hewn by John Fell, and the first hewn house in the valley, shows in the view of Mr. Wilson's place, with a flag over it. It was his first home here, but is now the headquarters of a flock of chickens. In the upper story of that old house was, organized in 1855 the first division of Sons of Temperance in the valley, of which John P. Wilson was the first Worthy Patriarch. Mr. Wilson 'was" married December 3, 1862, to Miss Martha M. Smith, born at Middletown, Des Moines county, Iowa, May 8, 1844. They have been blessed with six children : - Oulton, born September 14, 1863 ; Laura May, Septemher 7, 1866 ; John Milton, October 12, 1870; Lucius Stafford, Jr., March 25, 1875 ; Albert Garfield (deceased) and Arthur Earle, August 7, 1880. The first two were born in the old log house. Mr. Wilson is a man of marked character and stern integrity. He has held the office of justice of the peace for several years, and was for one term an associate justice of the old court of sessions. His love of square dealing and known integrity of character eminently fit him for the position of justice, in which he enjoys the confidence and respect of his neighbors. He is one of the successful men of Scott valley.

Charles Hovenden

. Is a son of George and Hepzebah Hovenden. and was born in England, October 15, 1828. His parents were farmers, and Charles remained at home working with them until fifteen years old, when he and his brother Alfred, now at Hubbard, Marion county, Oregon, emigrated to the United States in 1844. They first settled in Peoria county, Illinois, but later moved into Fulton county in the same State. There he learned the carpenter's trade, and in 1849 he and his brother emigrated to Oregon, crossing the plains with the usual ox-team. Later in the same year thev journeyed on to California, spending the winter of 1849-50 at Sacramento. In the spring, in company with Doctor Williams and E. M. Root, he started up the Sacramento river in a scow boat, and after landing at Marysville and going on to the Yuba river, they began mining about four miles from Foster's Bar. During the next summer he worked in Indian valley for the purpose of changing the course of the stream, and returned to Marysville in the fall and engaged at his trade for a short time. In 1852 he began packing into Indian valley, where he opened a store, which he sold in a short time. He continued to pack, however, until 1856. In 1857 he sold out and went into Oregon to purchase cattle, then came to Scott valley and purchased the farm on which he now lives. In 1860 he returned to Illinois to visit his father, but on reaching home learned that he had been deceased three months. April 22, 1861, he was married to Sytheria E. Harkness, a native of Peoria county, Illinois, and at once set out for a journey across the plains to their home in Siskiyou. By this union there have been five children, Lillian A., born March 1, 1862; Rowena E., June 15, 1863; Cora Antoinette, November 14, 1865; Nellie M., August 6, 1867; Charles W., December 30, 1875. He has one of the finest farms in Scott valley, containing 645 acres; all under good fence and cultivation. The residence was erected in 1874-75, and is full two stories high with thirteen gnod-sized rooms, and thoroughly furnished throughout. He has ample barns and granaries for the care of all stock and grain, and is one of the successful men of Siskiyou county.

degree. On the eighteenth, Judge -J. Montgomery Peters sentenced him to be hanged on Wednesday, July 15, 1857. The prosecution was conducted by the District Attorney, E. H. Stone, and the prisoner was ably defended by S. Hurlbut and Riley Hayden, who tried in vain to secure for him a new trial. Sheriff Fair prepared for him the same gallows on I which Crowder had been executed, and when the day arrived conducted the doomed man to the scene of his death, escorted by the members of Siskiyou Hook and Ladder Company. When everything was ready the fatal drop was made to fall, and every one was horrified to see the criminal's head slip out of the noose, after sustaining a severe jerk. Sailor Jim fell clear through the platform to the ground, from which he was raised in a half-conscious condition and again assisted upon the scaffold. While they were making preparations to hang him the second time, he said, " For God's sake, don't do that again." This time more care was observed, and soon his lifeless body hung at the end of the rope. All the agony of mind, if there is such, that is suffered by a criminal during the preliminaries to an execution, Sailor Jim parsed through twice. The awakening from what he no doubt imagined was death to a realization that he must go through the torture again, must have been terrible to him. No wonder he entreated them not to make another blunder. He made a confession, in which he admitted the killing of Burke, but claimed it to have been in self-defense.

Thomas King

After lying in jail two years, and receiving two trials, hoping for a release from the extreme penalty of the law until a few weeks before his death, Thomas King was executed on the twenty-third day of June, 1865, for a heartless and causeless murder, for dealing a death-blow, unprovoked and unexpected. He was born in Ireland, and when about twelve years of age, left his home because his parents had punished him for some offense. For several years he roamed about the United Kingdom, the associate of bad characters, until for the commission of some felony he was transported to Australia. When the Crimean war was raging, a regiment was raised among the convicts, by order of Lord Raglan, the men being given their libertj' at the close of the war. In this regiment King enlisted, and after the fall of Sebastopol received his discharge. He made his way to Halifax, and from there to California, an 1 to this county. After ruining at Humbug, Scott Bar and various other places, he went to the south fork of Scott river, where he committed the terrible crime, for which the law exacted the penalty of his life.

On the second of July, 1863, having already become considerably under the influence of liquor, he entered French's saloon, and began flourishing a knife in a threatening manner, and was deprived of it by the barkeeper. Among others in the saloon was James Duffy, who had been drinking, and whom King accused of having his knife. The accusation was denied, and upon being informed where the knife was, King demanded it from the barkeeper and it was restored to him. Throwing the weapon upon the floor and striking a tragic attitude, he exclaimed: "There lays me dagger. Whoever picks it up, dies by me hand." Not dreaming of danger, Duffy stooped, picked up the weapon and laid it upon the counter, saying, 'You wouldn't kill me, your best friend, would you?" "Yes, I would," he said, as he took up the knife and made several false motions, touching Duffy's breast with the handle, while the victim stood there smiling, unconscious of danger. Suddenly King reversed the knife, and with a quick, hard blow, buried it deep in Duffy's heart, the murdered man sinking to the floor with the exclamation," You have cut me." King made a pass with the bloody weapon at the barkeeper, and then sprang to the door and fled. The horrified witnesses of the tragedy stood for an instant in blank amazement, and then hastened in pursuit of the murderer, whom they soon overtook and secured after a slight resistance.

He remained in jail until the following February, when, after a trial lasting three days, he was found guilty of murder in the first degree, and was sentenced by Judge E. Garter to be executed Friday, March 18, 1SG4. An appeal to the Supreme Court gained for the condemned man a new trial, based upon the construction of a statute, and not upon the merits of the case. He was again tried in September, and was sentenced to be hanged on Friday, November 4, 1864, but an application to the Supreme Court produced a stay of proceedings until the case could be reviewed by that body. While awaiting the decision of the court, on Saturday, the eighth of February, 1865, he made a bold, and for a time, successful attempt to regain his freedom. Confined in the jail, which was the old wooden building first erected by the county, were also George Foster and Robert Ferry, both under a sentence to the penitentiary for grand larceny, and McGuire, a deserter from the army. The last named was allowed in the corridor, and was in the habit of calling- for water. About eight o'clock on the night in question Foster succeeded in getting out of his cell, and after releasing the prisoners from their cells, had McGuire call for water, as usual, and when Jailor McCullough opened the door he was seized, gagged, and bound, and the prisoners escaped, having their irons still upon them. They had been gone but twenty minutes when their flight was discovered. The town was aroused, and people started in all directions in search of the fugitives. About daylight Ferry was caught at Cherry creek by John Hendricks and others, having been unable to get rid of his irons. About two o'clock Sunday afternoon William Short and Charles Brown found King in a clump of manzanita bushes, near Deming's old brickyard, but a short distance south-west of Yreka. His long confinement of nineteen months had so weakened him that he had been unable to proceed further or to remove the irons from his limbs, although one of them he had succeeded in sawing partially through. A party composed of Livy Swan, A. V. Burns, J. Babb, A. D. Crooks, Sherman, Stone, and Groots, in pursuit of Foster and McGuire, stopped Monday night at Cherokee Mary's, a resort for thieves, nine miles from Yreka. About four o'clock Tuesday morning the two fugitives approached the house and were ordered to surrender, and upon attempting to escape were fh-ed upon by Jesse Sherman, with a shot gun, and Foster was wounded in the head and captured, while McGuire escaped by flight. Foster had succeeded in removing his irons, and now, severely wounded, was conveyed again to jail, while McGuire went to Fort Jones, and, finding escape impossible, gave himself up. Foster and Ferry had the terms of their sentences increased, while McGuire, who would have been released in a few days, was sent to San Quentin for two years for his little exploit in jail-breaking.

George Foster, alias Charles Mortimer, alias Charles J. Flinn, was the leader in the jail delivery, a hardened and reckless felon, and ended his career upon the scaffold. He was first sent to San Quentin from San Francisco for three years, and when his term expired, went back, chloroformed a man and robbed him of $1,800, was arrested, and escaped from officer Rose, by knocking him senseless and nearly cutting his throat. He then came to Siskiyou county, and was soon sentenced to three years for grand larceny, which term was increased to seven years for his participation in the jail delivery. After his release he continued his career of crime, finally murdering a woman in Sacramento, September 19, 1872, for which act he paid the penalty upon the gallows, not, however, until his brother lost his life in a desperate attempt to release him from the jail in which he was confined while awaiting the day of his execution.

The Supreme Court having reviewed the case and sustained the decision of the lower court, King was brought before Judge Garter in May, and was sentenced to be hanged on Friday, June 23, 1865. Preparations were accordingly made by Sheriff A. D. Crooks by erecting a gallows in the jail-yard. King's conduct during the trials had been one of bravado and defiance, and this he maintained to the last, being quite abusive while on the scaffold. He remarked as they were leading him from his cell to the place of his death, "I'm the handsomest man here, if I am going to be hung." But few spectators were admitted within the jail walls to witness the last act of this terrible drama, which culminated at nine minutes to two o'clock. The murderer who thus received the just punishment lor the crime, nearly two years after he had plunged the fatal knife into an innocent and unsuspecting bosom, was buried a little east of town, near the remains of Crowder and Sailor Jim, executed several years before.

William Williams

Influenced by passion and whisky, William Williams committed a murder for which he was once under sentence of death, and now occupies a cell in the penitentiary, where he is doomed to remain till death comes to his relief. He was an old sailor, short and heavy, with a dark complexion, and a hasty temper. For years he herded stock on the Siskiyou mountains, and was familiar with every hill and ravine in the range. Ill-feeling existed between him and John Todhunter about the killing of a colt, which culminated in murder. On Sunday, May 8, 1870, Williams went to Cottonwood, where he spent his time in getting drunk and making threats. About six o'clock in the afternoon he invited several to come and see him kill Todhunter, and then went to Brown's saloon, where his victim was playing cards, whom he immediately caught by the collar. Todhunter raised a chair to strike him, but bystanders interfered, and a scuffle ensued, in which Williams drew a knife, and was thrown to the floor under a billiard table. Todhunter then rushed into the street followed by the frenzied man with the knife, who chased him across the street. The fugitive picked up a stone to defend himself with, but Williams dodged, under his raised arm, and plunged the knife into his side, penetrating the heart. Tne wounded man fell to the ground, and commenced striking out with his feet to keep his assailant away. The others then rushed up and secured Williams, while his victim raised slowly to his feet, and then fell back dead. The murderer was conveyed to the Yreka jail, where he spent several days in weeping and lamenting the crime his passions, inflamed by liquor, had led him to commit.

On the thirtieth of January, 1871, his trial was commenced in the District Court, before Judge Rosborough, and lasted five days. He was defended by E. Steele and J. Berry, while the prosecution was conducted by District Attorney Edwin Shearer, assisted by Calvin Edgerton. After a deliberation of two hours the jury brought in a verdict of murder in the first degree. The day for pronouncing judgment was postponed from time to time to allow the defense to prepare a motion for anew trial, which was presented and denied on the twenty-fourth of February, and sentence of death pronounced, the day of execution not being fixed. Later a warrant was issued by Judge Rosborough, appointing Friday, April 21, 1871, for the execution of the sentence. A supersedeas was obtained from the Supreme Court, and the case reviewed before that body on appeal, the points relied upon being the absence of a material witness, refusal of the judge to give certain instructions, and the denial of a motion for a new trial. It took a whole year to reach a decision; and April 23, 1872, Chief Justice Wallace filed an opinion, in which the others concurred, affirming the judgment of the lower court, in which he said: "We discover no error in the action of the court below in any of the proceedings of the trial. The various legal propositions involved were correctly placed before the jury by the learned judge in an elaborate charge, remarkable for its clearness and force." May 29th, T. A. Bantz, district attorney, moved for judgment, and Judge Rosborough set Friday, July 26, 1872, as the clay for the execution.

Efforts were then made to have his sentence commuted to imprisonment for life. Williams frequently declared he never would be hanged, and attempted to make good his assertion by escaping from jail on the evening of the second of July. Several months before he had succeeded in cutting his irons, but the fact was discovered before he effected his escape. By the aid of outside friends he secured a file, saw, hatchet, and auger. On the night referred to Sheriff Morgan was in Etna, and Jailer Ed. O'Neil was down town, leaving him a clear field to work in. The rivet that secured the chain to the rings about his ankles was quickly filed off, and then he commenced upon the hinges of his cell door. After partially sawing these off he abandoned the task and made an opening in the door by boring holes through it and taking out a piece.

Through this he crawled into the corridor, pried the door of the jailer's room from its hinges and thus made his way into the yard, After filling the keyhole of the gate-lock with gravel, he climbed over the fence by the aid of a table, box, and barrel, and made direct for the Siskiyou mountain. At halfpast nine the jailer returned and was unable to get his key into the lock, A light was procured, and after considerable delay the gravel was picked from the lock and the gate opened, when the cause of all the trouble became at once apparent. Sheriff Morgan soon arrived, and messengers were sent out in all directions to get trace of the fugitive. At noon the next day word came from Cottonwood that he had crossed the Klamath at Groat's ferry, and the sheriff hastened thither with a party. A guard was placed at his cabin, as they expected him to go there for his shot-gun, and then secrete himself in the chaparral, with which he had been familiar for years. At dark he approached the cabin, but hastened away when he discovered the ambuscade, followed by half a dozen ineffectual shots. Some Indians were procured to trail the fugitive through the brush, and for a week all efforts to capture him were futile. Williams left a very indistinct trail by jumping from stone to stone, so faint that the Indians had great difficulty in seeing it, and the whites could not see it at all, and denied that the Indians could, thus delaying and hindering them so much that they refused to continue the search. A number of ruses were adopted to entice him to his cabin or elsewhere, to procure food, but all failed. At last a stratagem was successful. His friends were told that the govo ernor had commuted his sentence, and that if he would come in he would not be handed. Trusting to this promise he delivered himself up on the eighth, only to find, when again safely lodged in jail, that he had been deceived. His account of the life he led on the mountain that week was an interesting one. He had a pistol and hatchet, and had killed a young bear, on which he lived, using the skin for a coat, and had built a little bark hut in the chaparral. The pursuers passed so near him several times that he could almost touch them.

His friends now interested themselves in securing a commutation of his sentence, urging as a reason for such action the deception and promise that had induced him to surrender. Governor Booth was of the opinion that the reasons were good, and his sentence of death was changed to life imprisonment in the penitentiary at San Quentin. to which he was conveyed, and where he now performs daily labor for the State.

Provenance

Text from History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.