Siskiyou County, California - Chapter 16: The Court of Jtjdgre Lynch, 1881
From History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. 8,255 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
14 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Chapter 16: The Court of Jtjdgre Lynch
- Indian Hanged At Scott Bar
- Indian Whipped At Scott Bar
- Frenchy Whipped On Scott River
- Jeremiah Davidson
- Tar And Feathers In Yreka
- George Brunt Outrage
- Crazy Frenchman Hanged At Yreka
- The Greenhorn War
- The Millhouse Mob
- H. D. Weight Heney D. Weight
- Chaeles H. Fletchee
- Two Indians Shot In 1859
- Two Indians Shot At Fort Jones
The text
8,255 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 16: The Court of Jtjdgre Lynch
At its best and under the most favorable circumstances the exercise of lynch-law is barbarous and cruel. The taking of human life in punishment for crime by the constitute! authorities when it has been so decreed by a legal tribunal is terrible enough, and is only justified because society must protect itself; but when the safeguards of the law are thrown aside and prejudice becomes the judge, passion the jury and inhumanity the executioner, it becomes horrible.
The absence of competent tribunals for the preservation of peace and the adjudication of disputes, led in 1849 and 1850 to the settlement of all difficulties by the people themselves. So speedy was this method, and so beneficial in its effect upon societ}r by restraining the commission of crime, that it became engrafted upon the legal system of the State long after the necessity for it had vanished. Wherever was found a mining camp, there also was material for a miners' jury. Men acted too often upon hastily formed opinions. A man was shot, the murderer was captured; ajury of miners was formed and a judge selected; the investigation was superficial and one-sided; a verdict of death was rendered, and the victim was quickly borne to a tree and hanged; all this, perhaps, in a few hours. Sometimes a murderer escapes from the toils of the law through some technicality, and the people in their righteous indignation mete out to him the punishment he so richly deserves. In such a case, though it were better that the law be respected, there is an excuse for the exercise of violence; but when a prisoner is taken violently from the hands of the law, or is seized before the lav.' has had an opportunity to take charge of him, and is executed by an unreasoning mob inflamed with passion, then there ceases to be a shadow of excuse for the act, and it becomes a murder, cruel and heartless, and none the less so because committed by a hundred than if the act of but one.
Several such have occurred in Siskiyou county, the victims in most cases being Indians. The hanging of the Frenchman was an instance of this kind, when a man, probably crazy, was taken from the custody of the legal officers and hanged under circumstances of great cruelty. The Millhouse affair would have been another c *uld it have been consummated. Many have been whipped for theft and other offenses, several of which occurrences are here related, but by no means all of them, enough, however, to show how such things were done.
A great many Indians have been hung and shot at different times, but as these occurrences happened during or in connection with some general Indian difficulty, they are detailed in the history of Indian difficulties in another chapter. A white man had but little chance for his life when in the hands of a mob; an Indian had none. There is only one instance of the escape of one of this race from the violence of a mob, that of Rising Sun, and he did so by his boldness and dexterity, and not because the mob relented in its purpose.
Indian Hanged At Scott Bar
A small company of prospectors was at work on the south bank of the Klamath, near the mouth of Scott river, early in the spring of 1851, among whom wasD. D. Colton. A horse belonging to them having strayed across the river, two of the party named Converse and Haynes crossed over and captured it. While on their way back Converse laid down his gun and stooped over a spring to get a drink, when an Indian picked up the weapon and shot the unsuspecting drinker dead. His companion jumped on the horse and made for the river, pursued by the savages, but was drowned before getting across the stream. The others hastened to Scott Bar with the news, and a party was made up that captured the Indian who shot Converse, and brought him to the Bar. The Indians along the river knew but little about the use of guns at that time, except that they were very dangerous things to get in front of;' but the one who had done the shooting was an Oregon Indian, a Cayuse, or a Chinook, familiar with white people and fire-arms. The captive was taken before Alcalde R. B. Snelling, and after a regular trial was sentenced to be hanged, notwithstanding an energetic defense by lawyer Clarkson. General R. M. Martin was the sheriff at the Bar, and upon him devolved the duty of executing the sentence of the court. A butcher's gallows stood not far away, to which a short rope with a noose was fastened. A lariat was tied from one post to the other, about half-way up, and a plank was placed with one end upon this and the other on the ground, making an inclined plane, up which the prisoner was led so as to stand under the noose. General Martin did not relish his part of the job, and when a diminutive Kanaka offered to relieve him he accepted gladly. The Indian was large, and the Kanaka small, but by climbing upon his victim he managed to get the noose over his head. By some means the Indian got the rope in his mouth, and clung to it with all his strength. He had exhibited the reverse of the stoical calmness in the face of death so generally ascribed to the Indian character, and had cried and pleaded for life, and now that he had the rope in his teeth he clung to it as a last hope. The executioner placed his knee against the Indian's breast, and pulled the rope from his mouth with a jerk, breaking the teeth. He then placed the noose around the prisoner's neck, drew the knot tight, and descended to the ground. In order to save the lariat without cutting it, the plank was pulled away, but the Indian's feet rested on the rope, and it had to be cut, though the crowd expressed the opinion that it was a shame to spoil a good lariat just to hang a dirty Indian.
Indian Whipped At Scott Bar
In 1851 an Indian stole some dust from Varney & Lytle, on Poorman's Bar, and was caught while endeavoring to sell some specimen pieces in a saloon. A brief trial was given him, and it was decided that he should be whipped, and that B. F. Varney should wield the rope. He was tied up and Varney began to lay on the stripes, but with such gentleness that Lytle became disgusted. "Give me that rope," he said, as he took the whip from his partner's hand. Squaring himself for the effort, he rained blows upon the Indian's back until he writhed under them, great ridges rising at every blow. When he was done the Indian was released, with a warning not to come within shooting distance of the river, and justice was satisfied.
Frenchy Whipped On Scott River
There was working on Scott river in the spring of 1852 a young lawyer from Illinois named Smith. He had been there but a short time, but by dilligent labor had accumulated nearly two thousand dollars in dust, which he always carried in a sack in the pocket of his coat. This he always took with him to his claim and never let it get out of his sight, leaving it on his bunk at night and using it for a pillow when he slept. He had a young wife and baby waiting anxiously his return, and his savings had now amounted to what he considered a " home stake," while he was la3'ing plans for his homeward journey. Occupying the same cabin with him was a little Frenchman, a Dr. Baid, known to all as Frenchy. This man knew the habits of Smith and just where he kept his dust. One night Frenchy was absent at Humbug, and Smith with a few others were sitting in the cabin, when they heard a little noise in the corner by the bunk, but paid no attention to it. When Smith picked up his coat when preparing to retire for the night, he was filled with i onsternation to find it light and empty. The sack of dust was gone. Search in the bunk and through the cabin failed to reveal the missing treasure. That no one inside had taken it Smith knew, for they had been where he could see them continually. A careful examination revealed the fact that at the head of the bunk where the coat lay, the chinking between the logs had been disturbed. All rushed outside, and there were found the footprints of the robber by the side of the cabin, where he had removed the chinking, inserted his hand, taken the gold, restored the chinking and departed. Smith's mind at once reverted to Frenchy. He remembered that but a short time before he had left his coat in the cabin by mistake, and Frenchy had come to his claim to notify him of the fact, and that the next time he weighed the sack it was six ounces short. He asserted that Frenchy was the thief beyond a doubt.
News that a miner had been robbsd soon spread in the morning, and a crowd quickly gathered to discuss the matter and see what could be done. It was determined to capture Frenchy, and if found guilty, to. hang him. Cyrus Hurd was selected to go to Humbug after the suspected man, and when he reachedthere found the objectof his search just bound for Yreka. He was informed by citizens of Humbug that Frenchy was there when the sun went down the night before and the rising sun that morning revealed him still thei'e. The night was a dark one; the trail from Humbug to the bar was ten miles long, so rugged and rocky that it was difficult to travel it in the day-time and seemed impossible at night. No one believed the man could go that ten miles to the bar and ten miles back again over that rough mountain trail in the darkness. Nevertheless Hurd decided to take the man to Scott Bar, and so followed him to Yreka. In that town the year before there had been a vigilance committee of which Alvy Boles was chairman, and to him Hurd repaired for assistance. Yreka was then in Shasta Plains township, in Shasta county. Boles sat down to write a warrant, and soon evolved the following formula, and placed the document in the hands of his constable, Abraham Thompson, to serve : -
To any constable of Shaste Plains Township this day complaint having laid before me the Vigilant Committee that the crime of felony has Ben committed and accusing the above named Dr.
Jeremiah Davidson
Of Scott valley, is from Scotch-Irish ancestry, though directly his father James is a native of Pennsylvania and his mother of West Virginia, in which latter State the parents were married, and lived about thirty miles below Wheeling. Jeremiah, the third child, was born on the twenty-first of January. 1824. Some time after his birth, James Davidson removed his familv, then consisting of Narcissa, David M., Jeremiah, William Fleming, and Hannah Jane, the children, together with their mother, to Vermillion county, Indiana, and settled in the town of Eugene, where four more children were born,
Sarah, Finly H., Ann Eliza, and James A. Jeremiah, the subject of our sketch, worked on a farm during his boyhood and early manhood, attending school in winter. He was married on the twenty sixth of August, 1847, to Miss Margaret Ann Johnson, daughter of Hugh and May Johnson, a native of Indiana and born February 24, 1827. Jeremiah and wife had nine children b}' this union, five of whom are still living. They were born as follows : Alonzo F., September 16, 1848, at Savannah, Illinois; Finly H., March 27, 1854 in Scott valley ; John Henry, June 29, 1856, died March 17, 1864; David M., April 26, 1858, died March 10, 1864; William and Charles, March 5, 1860, the latter dving March 25, 1860, and the former March 22, 1864 ; Charles McDermit, April 23, 1862: May Elizabeth, May 6, 1865 ; Jeremiah, Jr., September 30, 1866, and Margaret A., July 24, 1868. Shortly after his marriage Mr. Davidson moved to Elk River Mills in Clinton county, Iowa. While there he was engaged in the coopering business. In the couise of the next few months he changed to Wapello, Iowa, and to Savannah, Illinois, where learning of the great fortunes which were being made in the gold fields of California, he determined to go there himself.
Leaving his family in Indiana, he started with others by the overland route for the west, and arrived at Hangtown (Placerville) August 15, 1850, where he engaged in mining until October of the same year, when he started for Oregon to see the country. He wintered at Oregon City, working in a warehouse till spring of 1851, when he started to Scott Bar, then the only popular mining locality. On the route he learned of the rich mines on Yreka fiats, and proceeded there, arriving in May. He found everything booming, spent the summer and fall mining on Cherry creek and the winter on Indian and Greenhorn creeks. In the spring of 1852 he returned to Oregon and mined that summer in Josephine county, returning to Deadwood in August, and from there he went to the States. Trading a year in drugs and groceries, he started again with his family for California, reaching Scott valley in the fall of 1854, and in 1855 raised a crop of grain, paying eight dollars a bushel for seed wheat. He next went to old Etna and engaged in the distilling business, making that place his home until July, 1857, when he moved on the place where Charles Hovenden now resides. There he lived until 1867, when he again moved in July to his present residence where his children have grown up. Mr. and Mrs. Davidson have lived to see Scott valley transformed from a wild waste, inhabited by Indians, with rude huts, to a beautifully improved tract, covered with pleasant and luxurious homes. Their farm is finely located on the west side of the valley three miles distant from the village of Etna. It comprises 280 acres, well fenced and wateied and adapted to grazing and farming. Mr. Davidson is a member of Evening Star Lodge, No. 186, Free and Accepted Masons, at Etna ; and also of Evening Star Chapter, Order of Eastern Star. Politically he is a staunch Democrat.
Baitl of the same therefore you are to arest the said Dr. Baid and bring him before the people and to be dealt with according to their Judgment. A. Boles, Chairman Committee.
Boles also endorsed it on the back, directing Abraham Thompson "to serve the within rit;" and for fear it was not then sufficiently authenticated, signed his name again in another place. Armed with this document, Boles, Hurd, Thompson, and a few others went to a restaurant where Frenchy was quietly eating, arrested their man, and started with him at once for Scott river. Here they found an immense crowd gathered, who greeted them with cheers, and proceeded at once to dispose of Frenchy's case by miners' law. A jury was selected and the trial commenced. But little evidence couid be produced against him ; Smith's belief that he was the man was about all, while in his defense was the testimony Hurd brought from Humbug that tended so strongly to prove an alibi. And yet on this slight evidence many wanted to hang him. The jury argued and discussed the matter, aided by the crowd, but could decide upon nothing. But for a few who would not agree to it they would have hanged him, but these few could not see how a man could be in two places at one time, and did not believe it possible to make the trip from Humbug and back in the night. While they were arguing the question, Smith tried his powers of persuasion on the prisoner, but to no avail. With tears in his eyes he spoke of the loved wife and innocent babe awaiting his return, that if he lost this money the world would hold no more charms for him, he was ready to die. Suddenly he changed his manner, drew his pistol, and told the man he would shoot him like a dog if he did not confess, and restore the dust, and then put an end to his own existence, but if he gave up the stolen treasure he would see that he was released.
At this juncture the crowd came up with a rope, with the information that the jury had decided to hang him. They had agreed among themselves to run him up once, and if that did not extort a confession, to let him go. This was too much for Frenchy. On the one hand was the rope or pistol, and on the other Smith's promise to aid him. He looked at the preparations made to stretch his neck, and lost his courage. He had taken the treasure, he said, and would show them where he had hidden it. Down the trail he led them to where it passed some bluffy rocks; here he paused, reached his hand up into a crevice and produced the sack of dust. Those of the jury who had before stood by him were now the most eager for his punishment. They had been deceived, and this was a fault they could not stand. An agreement was soon made to give the culprit twenty-nine lashes. He was quickly stripped, tied to a tiee, and a rawhide lash made. Smith was selected to administer the castigation. To this he objected. He had forgiven the man for the wrong, and could not whip him. He would treat the whole crowd, or do anything, but whip the man he could not. The crowd was angry at this; their natures were not sensitive enough to appreciate such sentiments; but Smith made them a speech which completely won their hearts. It was then decreed that the constable should do the flao-ellating.
Thompson stepped to the front and said he did not fancy the job, but that an officer should not shrink from his duty; and, seizing the whip in his hand, began laying on the stripes in a mild way. The prisoner made his first mistake when he was frightened into a confession, and right here he made his second. When fifteen lashes had been given he gave Thompson a look of hate, and hissed through his teeth, " I'll kill you." " Kill me, will you, you dirty thief ?" shouted Thompson, as he laid the blows on with all the power of his muscular arm. The whipping before had beea gentle, but now the blood followed every cut. Thick and fast he rained the blows upon the bleeding back until thirty had been counted, when he was told to hold on, as he had given him one too many, but hold on he would not. Down came the lash with a vicious whiz through the air upon the lacerated back, until the subdued victim pleaded for his life and promised to do the irate whipper no injury. Thompson then relented, unbound the man and washed his bleeding back with liniment. The jury had still one more duty to perform. They took a bag of dust belonging to the Frenchman, weighed out six ounces to Smith for what he had lost before, six to Hurd for a nugget he had lost by theft, jurors', witnesses' and constable's fees consuming the balance. A purse of three ounces was then made up for him, and he was invited to " make yourself scarce," and never be seen in the diggings again, or he would be made to swing. He accepted the invitation.
Elijah Moore & Co. kept a trading-post at Freetown, on the north fork of Humbug creek, in 1852, which was the scene of considerable excitement one day. It was customary for Indians from about the mouth of Humbug to roam up the creek and beg old victuals and carry away offal from the slaughterhouse. Little articles were occasionally missed from this store, and these Indians were suspected of having spirited them away. One day two Indians were in the store, and one of the partners went out for awhile. After he was gone, the other partner noticed a pair of buckskin pants that seemed to him to lie too near the Indians, and removed them behind the counter. The Indians soon passed out and started down the creek. The first partner then returned, and noticing that the pants and Indians were both gone, seized a gun and went to the door and shot one of the Indians who had gone but a short distance. He soon discovered that he had been too hasty, and as he could not put life into the inanimate form of his victim, he put metal into his own heels and took to the mountains. The miners gathered and proposed to have a trial, but the guilty man had escaped. This was no obstacle to the proceedings whatever, for they tried his partner in his stead, a sort of an impromptu Damon and Pythias affair, with the brotherly love ingredient omitted. There was no evidence that this man was aware that his partner intended to shoot, but the crowd was excited, and many wanted to hang him anyway. The better judgment of the cooler ones prevailed, and the man was acquitted. The excitement soon passed away, and as the man killed was only an Indian, the partner who took to the woods returned and resumed his place in the store without molestation.
Tar And Feathers In Yreka
Some time during the year 1853 a man and woman from Oregon registered as 7nan and wife at the Yreka House, then the only regular hotel in the city, and kept by Horace Knights, who rented it from the owner," N. Garland. It soon transpired that the parties were not married, but that they were engaged in a business highly immoral and improper. It must be borne in mind that the moral sense of the community was not as acute as it might or should have been ; that few ladies then shed their refining influence among the people, although a small number of most excellent and refined ladies were then here; but that squaws and women of a disreputable character were to be found in the majority among the representatives of the gentler sex. Still, blunt as was the moral sense of the people, and heedless as they may have been of the demoralizing tendency of their own acts, they took it upon themselves to become virtuously indignant at the audacity and moral depravity of this man, and determined to make an example of him. Let it be said, however, that with some, perhaps many, this indignation was but a cloak. They wanted some fun, and thought that this man, who had no friends, and who was in a business that was not calculated to create for him much sympathy among the better class of citizens, could furnish it. Whatever were their various reasons, this was what they did : -
Mr. Garland stepped into the hotel one evening and called the man outside. There he imparted to him the startling information that there was an organized body of men bent on hanging him or inflicting some outrage upon him, the character of which he was not certain, on account of his business ; that he was his friend and would lead him away to a place of safety. Trusting in the friendship and assistance thus proffered, the man submitted himself to Garland's guidance. They had gone but a short distance when, near the corner of Miner and Third streets, they met a small crowd of men, who demanded his surrender to them. Garland drew his revolver and made a great pretense of protecting him, even firing several shots, being careful, however, not to hit any one. Despite the efforts of this most valiant and heroic protector, the man was secured and taken to a cattle corral on the south-east corner of Third and North streets, where a kettle of boiling tar and a bed of variegated feathers were awaiting him. A judicious mixture of these was quickly substituted for the clothing the moral outcast had worn when captured, and then he was advised to turn from the depravity of his ways, emulate the noble example of those shining lights who were now ministering unto him, to consider the uprightness of their ways and walk therein, and was then released.
"Whether he profited by the good advice is not known, but if it stuck to him as long and persistently as did the new suit of clothes they gave him it must have done him some good. There were but few directly engaged in this lawless act, but a great many were cognizant of it and gave it their approval, while few felt called upon to give the unfortunate man even so much as their sympathy, and no one to see that an official inquiry was made into the affair.
George Brunt Outrage
working on Hamburg Bar, and among them was a company of five men who were bringing a ditch to their claim. One afternoon their tent caught fire, evidently from sparks blown by the wind from the fire with which they had cooked dinner, and burned down. The proprietors, two of whom were named Barnes and Shaw, accused a young Englishman named George Brunt of having set the tent on fire. A number of men accompanied them to the claim of Joseph Reeves, where Brunt was at work, and there ascertained that when the tent was burned the suspected man had been hard at work in the claim. The ditch men seemed to have some grudge against the man, and were not satisfied of his innocence, and during the night went to his cabin, took him away, and proceeded to extort a confession from him by stringing him up to a tree. After hanging him till he was nearly dead, and becoming convinced that he knew nothing of the burning of the tent, they let him go. They were now troubled about the consequences that might follow their barbarous acts, and charged Brunt, who was a very simple man, never to divulge what they had done under pain of death. He returned to his cabin, afraid to go to any one for relief, and lay there alone, groaning with pain. His groans reached the ears of Sigmund Simon, who took his revolver, and went out to see what was the trouble. Guided by the sounds, he reached the side of the suffering man. and asked what ailed him.
Brunt then said he would tell, and turned his face to the wall while he related the outrage that had beeri committed upon him. Simon examined his neck and found his story confirmed by the black and blue ridge left by the cruel rope. The next day Simon went to Johnson's Bar for assistance to punish the men who had committed the inhuman act, and forty men returned with him to investigate the affair. They found the five men intrenched in a cabin, and threatening to shoot the first man who came near them, but after a great deal of talk and bluster they were convinced that their safest course was to come out and stand trial. A court was organized, and the affair investigated, resulting in a verdict for the men to pay Brunt two hundred dollars for his injuries, and to leave the river within thirty days. When the time for their departure had elapsed they were still there, and were granted a little longer time. They finally departed, having compromised with their victim for one hundred and fifty dollars.
Crazy Frenchman Hanged At Yreka
In the year 1853 there lived in a cabin on the Greenhorn road an old Frenchman who was on the subject of perpetual motion. One Oregon packer who had been to Yreka to g bell-mare shod, was passing back to Gn when the Frenchman ran out of his cabin revolver and shot him dead. The man f< his horse, and the murderer Hed to Yreka, pursued by a crowd of miners, who had rushed from their claims when they had heard the pistol shot. He ran to the sheriff's office, where the Tribune office now is, and gave himself up to the sheriff, who took him down the back stairs and put him in jail. In less than an hour a thousand men were in the streets demanding the prisoner. Tools were procured from a blacksmith's shop, and an assault made upon the jail door, which soon gave way, and the murderer was in the hands of the mob. He was taken to the vacant lot opposite Ad. Winckler's residence, where a regular miners' court was organized to try him. Dr. W. H. Gatliff made a professional examination of the prisoner, and testified that he was insane, but it did no good, for the mob was insane also. His death was decreed by the jury. One of the three pine trees that stood back of the present residence of W. I. Nichols was selected for a gallows, and a nimble English sailor scrambled up it, and fastened a rope to one of the limbs. The noose was so far from the ground that the victim had to stand on a horse in order to reach it, and before everything was ready the horse moved, the man slipped off, and he died a miserable, strangling death. The mob, most of whom were Greenhorn miners, then dispersed, and after dark some of the victim's countrymen took down the body that had been left hanging to the limb, and buried it.
The Greenhorn War
Early in 1852 the miners on Yreka fiats began to look about them for more water to work their claims, and soon formed a company to bring the water of Greenhorn through the gulch on the left to the flats above the town. The ditch company was composed of seventy shares, and the work was done by the owners who expected to use the water in their claims. The water was taken from the creek on the north bank about three-fourths of a mile above its mouth. There was at that time but one claim being worked below the head of the ditch, and that belonged to Quinn & Lee, who were working on the south bank and had a little ditch carrying twenty-five or thirty inches of water to their claim. The company procured the consent of Quinn & Lee to the diversion of the water from the creek upon agreement to always leave enough to fill their little ditch, and then commenced to cut their ditch through to the flats, where it still runs and is known as the Sproll or China Hydraulic ditch. After this had been accomplished, gold was found in quantities below the head of the ditch and many claims were located. In winter and until the water became low in the creek in the summer time, no difficulty was experienced in working these new claims, but as soon as nearly all the scant supply of water was needed to fill the ditch, leaving scarcely a drop running to the claims below, there was trouble. Ignorant of the principle and law of water rights that obtained in the mines, the disappointed miners of Greenhorn claimed that the water should be allowed to run in its natural channel, and that any diversion of it to the injury of claims further down the stream was illegal and wrong, notwithstanding such diversion was made piior to the location of the claims. No serious difficulty occurred till the spring of 1S55, when the miners cut the ditch, and allowed the water to run down the creek. The company repaired their ditch and applied to Judge R. L. Westbrook for an injunction restraining anyone from in anyway diverting the water from the ditch in the future. At this time the property had fallen into the hands of half a dozen men, under the name of the Middle Greenhorn Ditch Company. The injunction issued by Judge Westbrook was disobeyed by Robert Wilson, who cut the ditch on the twenty-third of February, 1855, and was arrested for the act by Sheriff Col ton and lodged in the jail at Yreka.
The miners along the upper Greenhorn resolved to rescue him from the clutches of the law, and began to make arrangements for a demonstration in force that night. About' dark they assembled at Wheeler's trading-post and organized for a raid upon the jail. They then started in a body for Yreka. Some half-dozen, among whom were Bob Hardin and the notorious Bill Fox, went ahead of the others, unknown to them, and reached the jail a considerable distance in advance. The jail was situated on the south-west corner of the plaza, opposite where Winckler's house now stands, and before it was a large space of open ground, no buildings having yet been erected there. But a block to the north a festival was being held in the new Methodist Episcopal church, which still stands there, its look of newness long since laded away. A great crowd was gathered at the church, including the county officers, and when the advance party arrived at the jail, they found it silent and apparently deserted. A little investigation revealed the presence of a deputy known as Dutch Andrew, of whom they demanded and received the keys. Wilson was quickly released and spirited away, and all was again quiet. Now, after the bird had flown, came the large Greenhorn crowd to the cage and ranged themstlves before the door. Geoige Chaplin rushed into the church and eagerly told Colton that a mob was making an attack upon the jail for the purpose of releasing Wilson. In the church were the leading citizens of the town, among others J. Montgomery Peters, the district judge. He called upon all good citizens to go up and aid the sheriff defend the jail, but as he manifested no disposition to go himself, the majority thought themselves no better citizens than the judge and carefully remained away. At the first alarm, the sheriff and several others rushed from the church and advanced to where the mob was assaulting the door with an ax, the marks of which can still be seen by the curious to the present day, as the old door now opens and shuts for the accommodation of the city marshal and the guests he entertains in the calaboose back of the engine-house. They tried to reason with the mob and persuade them to have respect for the law, and not to interfere with its officers in the discharge of their duty, but to no avail. A man inside, whom the mob supposed to be Wilson, cried out, "I want to be taken out!" and they made an immediate assault upon the door. A few shots were fired and Hugh Slicer, a well-known and respected citizen, was wounded, and the mob fell back in confusion. Colton took advantage of the lull in the storm to procure a shotgun from his house near by and entrenched himself within the jail, with a few citi- zenswho had hastily armed themselves with revolvers. The defenders within the building, as remembered by two of them, were D. D. Colton, H. G. Ferris, Livy Swan, Charles Hathaway, William Terry, A. E. Schwatka, Sank Owens, Hugh Tate, and Thomas Conner. Up to this time neither the officers within nor the enraged mob without were aware that Wilson had long since been taken away by his friends. The angry crowd now again approached the jail, and despite the warning of the sheriff not to advance, kept drawing nearer and nearer to the door, and when they had advanced to within a few feet, Colton fired upon them with his gun and ordered the others to shoot. A volley was then fried from the inside that completely scattered the assailants, who returned in confusion to their headquarters at Wheeler's trading-post. The defenders then went out and found Dr. Stone lying on the ground mortally wounded. He was carried down to Dr. Daughty's office, where he expired before morning. Several others were wounded, but got back to Greenhorn, one of them dying from the effects of his injuries.
The miners now expected the war would be brought into their camp, and that a sheriff's posse would come to the creek to make arrests. They fortified themselves to the number of one hundred and twenty or more at the point of rocks, above Wheeler's, and for two days no communication was held between them and the people of Yreka. No mining was done on the creek and everything was in suspense. Colton and Westbrook were afraid to go to the fortress of the Greenhorn army, and so prevailed upon A. E. Schwatka to go up there, read the riot act, and see what was the condition of affairs. Schwatka was acquainted with every man on the creek, living there himself, and knew they were all friendly to him. All was quiet as he went up the canon, the claims deserted, and no one to be seen. At Wheeler's he found a man named Atkins, whom he sent to the Point of Rocks with a request for the men to come, down to Wheeler's and hold a consultation, that he was entirely alone and no danger was to be apprehended. Soon a long line of familiar faces filed before him and halted in front of the post, where he explained his mission, read the riot act, and requested them to send a delegation to Yreka to consult with the authorities, ottering to remain himself as a pledge of good faith to the delegates. A committee of seven was sent to Yreka, where they held a consultation with Judge Westbrook, Sheriff Colton and others, which resulted in the appointment of a committee to settle the difficulties and effect a compromise between the miners and the proprietors of the ditch. As a result of this conference the following agreement was made: -
Greenhorn Creek, March 3, 1855. Whereas, We, the committee appointed on behalf of the miners of Greenhorn creek, its tributaries and banks, and invested with power to settle the dispute between the miners of Greenhorn, on the one side, and the Middle Greenhorn Ditch Company on the other side ; we, the committee on behalf of the miners, make the following proposals to the committee on behalf of the Ditch Company: -
4 - That the suit now pending in the County Court of Siskiyou county shall be withdrawn, and the Ditch Company shall pay the cost of said suit.
5 - That the Ditch Company shall pay to this man, appointed to attend to the regulation of the water, a reasonable compensation for his services.
Wm. E. Green, Ch'n. Chas. Botlon, Sec'y. We, the undersigned, members of the Middle Greenhorn Ditch Company, accept the above proposals on behalf of a majority of said company, the undersigned representing a majority of the company. Hugh Bratton,
Litigation was kept up for a number of years, the lawyers picking the bone pretty clean, and it was finally decided that the ditch company was entitled to as much water as the original capacity of the ditch, and the balance belonged in the stream.
The Millhouse Mob
After the vital spark that animated the city government of Yreka was extinguished by the Supreme Court, the citizens requested Sheriff Fair to deputize a man to act in the capacity of marshal, to be paid for his services by subscription. To perform this duty James H. Millhouse was appointed. The Fourth of July, 1856, was on Friday, and the ancient and honorable order of Eclampus Vitus celebrated the clay with a procession. Large crowds of miners from Greenhorn, Hawkinsville, Deadwood, and Humbug, were in town, and whisky flowed as freely as water. Revelry ran higher and higher, and the jollity increased as the day advanced. In the afternoon a number of Greenhorn miners gave vent to their exuberance of spirit by making a raid through Chinatown, and kicking in the doors of their humble dwellings, as well as otherwise abusing the denizens of that delectable locality. Among these, young John Blunt made himself particularly conspicuous, and the marshal undertook to arrest him. His companions interposed, and said that as it was the glorious Fourth the Marshal should allow considerable freedom of action and relaxation of spirit. The marshal assured them that he had done so, and so long as they had confined themselves to making a noise he had remained silent, but when it came to committing outrages upon persons and property he must put a stop to it. He then made another attempt to arrest Blunt, who was rescued by his friends, and ran down Third street, pursued by Millhouse. The marshal again undertook to arrest him, and a fight occurred, Blunt being advised by his friends to " whale him good." The fight lasted for some time, gradually working up to near the engine-house, where Blunt knocked the marshal down and began kicking him in the head. He was pulled away by some bystanders, and Millhouse, as he rose bleeding and almost blinded from the ground, pulled his revolver and, commenced shooting, the third shot striking Blunt in the neck, from the effects of which he died in a few minutes.
As soon as the shooting commenced the streets which were crowded with men were deserted in a trice, but as soon as the last shot was fired they
H. D. Weight Heney D. Weight
Was born in Hancock county, Illinois, in September, 1834. He is a son of Hickerson and Cynthia Wright. He worked at home with his parents on the farm until 1853. During that year his two elder brothers, who had gone to California in 1850, returned to the States and fitted out two wagons and thirty horses, and the three brothers crossed the plains. Mr. Wright says : - " Game was plenty on the route and we had a pleasant trip." They arrived at Placerville on the seventh day of August, 1853. He followed mining in different localities until the month of March, 1855, when he came to Siskiyou county. After remaining for a short time at what is known as the Forest House, he went on to David D. Colton's ranch, now the property of Samuel Eamage. In the fall of 1856 he removed to Scott Bar and mined until 1857, when he returned to Kidder creek and worked in Oliver & Prevost's saw-mill. From there he went to Oro Fino and engaged in working the Jackman claim. After selling it, he bought the claim now owned and operated as Wright & Fletcher claim, one of the best in Siskiyou county. In this mine he worked by running drain-tunnels and drifting for about ten years, but finally abandoned that method, and began the hydraulic process, which proved a success. He was married to Miss Mary C. Wood, daughter of John P. Wood, of Scott valley, on the thirtieth of December, 1872. By this union there have been two sons, viz.: Charles Henry, born January 11, 1875, and Walter A., born June 18, 1877. A view of the mine and portrait of Messrs. Fletcher and Wright will be found in this volume.
Chaeles H. Fletchee
Is one of the most successful miners of Siskiyou county. His parents were Ezra and Mary A. Fletcher, of Somerset county, Maine; the former born in 1814, and the latter in 1819. Charles is the second child of a family of six, three brothers and three sisters. He was born on the fourth of July, 1845, and lived on a farm till he was nineteen years of age, when he emigrated to Wisconsin, and engaged in lumbering till the year 1870, after which, he went to mining on the east fork of the Scott river, at Kangaroo gulch, in this State. This venture was a success. He then invested in a claim on Patterson creek, in Scott valley. In November, 1876, he returned to Maine, his home, on a visit. While sojourning there, the Black Hills excitement became rife, so he came back to California, sold his claim on Patterson creek, and made a trip to the Black Hills. Not meeting with the success he anticipated, he soon returned to Siskiyou county, and bought into claims on the Klamath, where he worked one summer. He then bought into the quartz mine at Oro Fino, which he afterwards disposed of in the fall of 1880, as he had acquired a half interest in a hydraulic claim, of which there is a view on another page.
swarmed out from every doorway and began to shout, "Hang him," "Kill him," 'Now for a vigilance committee." The sheriff's office was in the building now occupied by the Tribune, but a few yards from the scene of battle, and to this place of rtfuge the marshal was hastily taken by a few who desired to save him from the mob. A desperate struggle occurred before he was safely placed inside and the door closed. Sheriff Fair went to the window and endeavored to pacify the angry crowd, but had no effect upon them. They called for Millhouse to come to the window and speak to them. The marshal went, but as soon as his head appeared in sight of the excited crowd that filled the street below, his ears were saluted by the ominous click of a hundred revolvers, and he quickly vanished again. The back part of the building was occupied by the Union, and all the windows on both sides had iron shutters upon them. These were securely closed and everything that could impede the defenders was removed to the center of the room. The miners sent word to Greenhorn, Deadwood, and Humbug that a miner had been killed and they wanted help to avenge him, and a great many flocked in from those places. The next day Dr. Ridgly held an inquest upon the body of Blunt, the jury being A. M. Quivey, J. Carroll, A. V. Gillette, W. Johnson, B. Porter, and J. H. Harper.
Close siege was maintained by the Greenhorn men for three days, the others having wearied of the affair and gone home. The Greenhorners took possession of the balcony of the Odd Fellows' Hall, now owned by the Masons, directly opposite the sheriff's office. On Monday, Millhouse was examined before Justice George Waterman, in the courtroom, which was then in the old Eclampus Vitus Hall on Fourth street, and was conducted thither by a body guard of citizens under Captain Goodall. The examination resulted in his acquittal on the ground that he had acted justifiably in defending himself fiom attack while in the discharge of his duty as an officer. He was advised by friends to leave town, as some one might assassinate him, and did so, disposing of his property and returning to Indiana. He is now living in Missouri. This step was an unnecessary one, as the passions of the dead man's friends had cooled, and no one would have risked his life by shooting the marshal after he had been fairly acquitted by a legal magistrate.
Two Indians Shot In 1859
On Sunday evening, June 26, 1859, a young son and daughter of Colonel R. S McEwan, of Table Rock, left Yreka to return home, and soon came back with the intelligence that they had bc( n assaulted by two Shasta Indians, who wanted to steal the girl. A posse went out and caught the offenders, and they were lodged in the jail. Great indignation was felt in Yreka at what was considered a dastardly outrage on the part of the savages, and when they were let out of the jail the next Wednesday night, some men quietly walked them to a vacant lot and shot them dead. There has alwajrs been considerable doubt about the guilt of the savages, as many think the boy mistook their intentions when they spoke to him and his sister.
Two Indians Shot At Fort Jones
who had imbibed enough fighting whisky to make them quarrelsome, went to Gee's ranch, on the stao-e road between Fort Jones anil Yreka, and assaulted the hostler of the stage company, one of them knocking him down. They then departed in the direction of Fort Jones, soon meeting the stage, and refusing to give it the road. The driver struck them with his whip, when they both fired into the stage, luckily doing no damage. The hostler j umped on a horse, and rode hastily to Fort Jones by a circuitous route, and related the conduct of the savages, and a number of citizens armed themselves and started up the road in the direction of Yreka. Near the edge of town they met the two drunken Indians, who were sober enough to know that they had no business at the Fort j ust then. They started from the road in the direction of Indian creek, but were overtaken and shot just as they gained the ridge.
Provenance
Text from History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.