BlockBefore

Sonoma County, California - Chapter 13: Immii.katiii.n I'olks I.ntn Siinnma Colntv Kvkkv \(h)i< Am) Coknkk Ok Tmk Cointy Uci Itied, 1889

From An Illustrated History of Sonoma County, California. Containing a History of the County of Sonoma from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, published 1889. 11,667 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

The text

11,667 words

Machine-read from scans of An Illustrated History of Sonoma County, California. Containing a History of the County of Sonoma from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, published 1889. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

rf>TP to 1855 SoiioHiii roiiiity was in a coiuli- :*l}'jl tion of confused transition from almost ^5P^ iiiitivo wilds to permanent civilized occn- ]);unjy. AVliili' the county was largely covered hy y|)aiiisli yrants. yet the holders of such, as a class, had not yet accjuired flocks and herds to occupv their broad acres, and the adventurous Americans very often located within the lines of such grants with as little reverence as though settling upon government land. The grant holders, as a class, had little idea of land value, and many of them were willing to accept from settlers on their domain very moderate prices for the laud. Many, if not most of the settlers, got their land at prices not much above what they Would have had to pay had it been go^erninent land. There were c.vccptions, however, to tills rule, and in a few instances there was consideral)lc friction and trouble between settlers and grant owners, but this will be referred to later on.

.Vbout 1855 a tidal-wave of immigration seemed to sweep over yonoma County, and it was really a marvel how soon every nook and corner of the county available for farming or grazino; was ferretted out and occupied. It was now families seeking homes who came, and following their coming school-houses and churches began to multiply. In truth, within the space of a few years, Sonoma County became one of the most I prosperous agricultural counties of the State. At first, famous for her Bodega potatoes, she I soon took first rank among the graiii-growini,'' and dairying counties in the State.

In tlie space of a few years towns and villages came foi-ward with marvelous growth. J'etaluma as a shipping point made rapid strides. Santa Rosa as the county seat was making siib- \ stantial progress. Ilealdsburg, where in 185-1 ! had been but a residence and blacksmith shop, I became a thriving village, and Cloverdale began to show evidence of its future destiny. Sonoma, ; ever famous as a center around wiiich clustered historic memories, became far-famed for her productive veneyards. l^odega, old in her development there in connection with Russian occupation, took a new lease of life, and Hoilega Bay was whitened by a fleet of sails that carried her products to the San Francisco market. lUoomtield surrtuinded by as fei'tile a country as the sun ever sone upon became the center of a populous and pros|)erous farming district.

In tlmse days the fatness was exuding from tlic !-t-iil of Sunoina County, and tlie crops gathered tlierefroin were abundant to the full measure. While the growing of potatoes coastwise, e(_immencing with Two Rock Valley and extending to iJodega was yet a large industry, the irrowing of wheat, barley and oats soon took precedence and became a source of great profit to farmers. Farming of whatever kind, whether the growing of potatoes or cereals was usually conducted on a large scale. Fifty or a hundred acres of jiotatoes was not considered a large plant, and of grain it was no uncommon thing for a farmer to plant any where from one to three hundred acres, and a large farmer often went far beyond this. Our favorable seasons for seeding and planting of such vast crops was made easy by the improvements in farming imj)lemeuts, but the gathering of such vast crops often taxed to its utmost capacity the labor attainable. For potato digging, the remnant of the almost extinct Intlian tribes of this region were brought into re(juisitioti, and became quite effective aids in farming. The writer once had in employ twenty-two Russian River Indians, and found them excellent potato diggers. During the season tif gathering potatoes these dusky childi-en of nature used to perform a large portion of that kind of labor. But the vices of civilization was fast thinning their ranks, and in the course of years Chinese labor stepped in and did the main portion of the drudgeries ot farm work.

The main valleys through the center of the county, Petaluma. Santa Rosa and Russian River were always devoted maiiily to the growing of grain. The wealth- of grain produced by the virgin soil of these rich valleys is almost incalculable. Russian River Valley in a very early day jiroved its worth as a corn producing region, and in later years became famous for the ])roduction of hops. A writer some years ago drew the following pen picture of the Russian River Valley:

" For more than sixty miles in length Russian River before taking its tinal westerly course toward the ocean, perambulates from Mendocino County southerly through one of the widest and truly alluvial valleys in the State. As a corn growing country it is probably without a rival on the J'acitic coast, and a good corn country can always be relied upon as suitable for a large share of the staple products of temperate climes.

-'We see, therefore, along this great alhnial belt, the whole family of cereals cultivated with singular success, and in the main cjuite free from smut, or injury from climatic influence. As far as any attemj)ts have been made to grow fruit, it succeeds admirably. Along the borders of the \ alley, at the foot of the range of hills that bound it on either side, the vine flourishes luxuriantly, i)roducing grapes of fair size and a flavor of peculiar richness; and we cannot but believe that the time is near at hand when the acres of vineyards aloug this great valley may be counted by hundreds, if not thousands. What the effect of climate may be upon the health of vines and fruit trees along the more central [iortions of the valley, remains to be seen. Of the indigenous forest trees, the deciduous oak predominates largely; and throughout nearly the entire extent of the valley may be seen this monarch of our lowland forests, in its wide-spreading, but varied and beautiful forms, standing apart and alone, or clustered in beautiful groups of a score or more upon a single -acre; and though at this season of the year without a single leat, all are draped in their beautiful pale green, mossy livery, that, pendulous from every twig and limli, imparts a mellowed softness to the breeze, that alike in summer and winter gently sweeps along the valley."

Taking the decade-aiid-a-half between 1855 and 1870, farming in Sonoma County achieved its greatest results. Of course, there were variableness of seasons and prices, but taken as a whole the results were more tlian highly satisfactory. In the single season of 18B4 the farmers literally gathered a harvest of gold. That yea)' the whole southern portion of Cali- tbrnia was made barren by a drought. Here tlie crops were good, and wheat was sold at all the way from three to four iiiul-a-half cents pur liouiid. Even renters, who had [)ut in large crops on shares, found themselves coniparatively rich at the end ot" the season.

The productiveness of our farms and the accumulatinir wealth from dairy products and Ntock-raising were promotive of other industries and created in the people a desire for advance from the primitive surroundings that had marked their early-life struggles. Ornate counti'y homes began to multiply, and the county from end to end began to show the evidences of ])ermanency and solidity. This was not confined to the large valleys along the line of leading tlioroughfares; in every little gem of a valley, sandwiched in among the hills and mountains, there was manifested a growing taste in the direction of more comfort and convenience in home surroundings.

This advancement was made in the lace and teeth of ditticulties and discouragements seldom encountered by the pioneer settlers of any other country. As lias already been stated, many of the settlers went upon lands claimed as Spanish grants, hut of which the titles had not yet been adjudicated by the United States Government. In the early fifties a commission, consisting of three members, had been appointed to investigate these titles, and otdy such as passed muster under their examination got standing in court, and were started on the tortuous way to the court of final resort at Washington City. The ijcnnineness of title to niany of these yrants \\eri; nf very fishy odor. Cnder the treaty of (Tuadalupe Hidalgo the United States Government had plighted its faith to give due credence to all genuine grants made by duly accredited authority of the Mexican go\ernment. This the government certainly did to the full measure. Elsewhere is published a list of the Spanish grants that in whole, or in ]iar% fell within the lines of Sonoma County. We have also j)ointed out the evidences of pwmaneiit habitation witiiin the boundai'ies(jf the county at the time Sonoma was captui'etl. It was for the courts, and nut the histoi'ian, to j)ass upon the validity of these giants. Jf there was wholesale perjury indulged in to secure many confirmations, that is now a matter between the consciences of witnesses and their (4od. It is now all happily passed, and all land titles are in perfect I'ejiose. All now buw to the rule. Stare (lecisi-<.

I!ut it is the province of history to recite events the outgrowth of these confiicting lanil titles. There were numerous "Settlers' Leagues" organized to resist the confirmation of many of these grants. Lawyers were always to be found who would, for a liberal fee, give "squatters" on grants positive assurance that the grant was fraudulent and that he could " knock the bottom out of it." These leagues, in many instances, became secret conclaves, with all the pass-words aifd paraphenalia of secret oi-ganizations. That they should ultimate in resistance to legally constituted authorities was but natural. And even the claimants of grants sometimes were guilty of the assumption that they were higher than the law. While there had been a great deal of friction between settlers and grant hohlers the first serious collision occurred at Bodega. There was no end of land troubles in Sonoma County, growing out of occupation by settlers on what was believed to be fraudulent Sj)anisli grants. This led to a great deal of trouble, and ultimately to resistance to the mandates of law. To give the reader a clear conception of the real temper and feeling of the public at that time on this momentous (question we give the language of an editorial which appeared in the I'etaliima Journal of ]''ebruary 18, IHSH:

"It is boldly asserted tliat there are eighty land grants in this State, which can be proved to have been forged and sworn thus far through the courts by perjury. They lie it is stated, in twenty-seven counties, and cover the homes of nearly 5,000 settlers. AVhether there are any located in this county, we are not informed. It would be a strange transaction if there are not. Our location, and the wull-known i-ichno^s of soil, would certainly be a >trong bait t" tempt the palate of the greedy land cormorants wlio have perpetrated these wholesale frauds. It therefore becomes all well-ineaiiiiig and rightthinking citizens to join wit!) their brethren of San Francisco, in the work of ferreting ont and exposing these fraudulent grants. To this end let every person remonstrate against the j)assage. by the Assembly, of tlie iniquitous and unjust resolution which was spawned by Senator Williams, petitioning Congress for the passage of a law to prevent reviews in cases wliere patents have issued; or in other words asking of Congress to screen the actual robber, and protect the receiver of stolen property under the name of ' bona tide purcliasers and encumbrancers.' Where, we ask, can a parallel be found to this act? Rob and defraud Uncle Sam of the public domain and then ask him to desist from investigation, the object of which is to prove the theft; and all because the receiver of stolen goods may lie a sufferer I As infamous as are the intentions of Mr. Williams' move, we nevertheless see the Senate passing favorably upon it. If we mistake not, our own representative in that body was among its supporter. A knowledge of the unscrupulous intentions of these landgrabbers' has clearly disclosed to settlers the precipice over which they are being rutldessly hurried. A just and proper spirit of resistance to the attempt is beginning to manifest itself in various sections. Meetings are being lield, resolutions of disproval of Mr. Williams' ' substitute ' passed, and Anti-Grant Leagues formed. If moderation and temperance of action predominate, as we trust will be the case, immense good will result to the people at large. The recent developments in the Santillan claim, is conclusive evidence of this fact. Let a union of action be made and time and investigation will rend the screen that now obscures and darkens the homes of scores of the people of California. We shall look with confidence to our representati\es in the Assembl)', to aid in arresting the passage of the resolution by that body."

"Bv reference to another column, it will be seen that the people in this locality are beginning to move in the work of exposing the alleged land frauds, and of heading General Williams and Judge lialdwin in their infamous attempt to rob and despoil the people of California. In the eagerness of these pliant tools of Liinantour, I'reinont, etc., to do the bidding of their heartless and unscrupulous masters, they have moved in so bold and hasty a manner as to neglect that precaution so necessary to successful villainy - the covering up and secreting of all evidence of evil intent. The object sought is too obvious to pass unnoticed by the most obtuse. As a natural conse(|uence, this course on the part of the land claimants, has aroused a just and proper spirit of opposition on the part of the people. The final result of this struggle, will, we believe, be the securing to the public domain of leagues upon leagues of land now claimed by land sharpers under forged titles. That many of these fraudulent claims are located on this side of the bay, we are told there no longer e.xists a doubt. Justice then demands that our people move with a united effort in exposing these frauds.

"A brief reference to the land-claim history of California, presents some startling facts. In the year 1849 William Cary Jones was sent to California by the authorities at Washington, with instructions to ascertain the number and extent of Spanish land grants. In his report he states the result of his investigation to be the discovery of five hundred and seventy-six grants, large and small, several of which was unfinished. Of this number, several were afterward proved fraudulent and rejected. Upon the establishment of the land commission, no less than eight hundred and thirteen claims were filed in before it for action ! A writer in the Alta., asserts that Mr. Jones informed him that after he had returned to Washington, he was offered *20,000 to insert in his rejiort one grant - fraudulent of course, and for which they wished a record in order to give it some show of validity I Comment is unnecessary. The facts alone tell the

The tii'st of these coiitliets over land titles tiiat assuuietl a very tlirealeiiiiig aspect was in June of 1859, and the scene of the disturl>ance was Hodega ranch. The foiiovving in a statement of the case and what occurred as touiid in tiie Sonoma County Jonriinl of June 3d, 185'J:

"The original grantee of tliis ranch was Caj)- tain Stephen Smith, who claimed by grant eight leagues of land, which amount was confirmed to him In' the Hoard of Land Commissioners. He tlien leased to Uethuel Phelps & Co. the right to cut and manufacture into lumber tlie red-wood belonging to the said eight leagues of land, for a term of ninety-nine years, for the sum of $65,000. Phelps & Co., immediately took possession of the lands so leased, and still continue in possession of the same. After setting apart to I'helps & Co. their leased portion of the claim, there was left a large tract of agricultural lands outside of said eight leagues, claimed l)y no one. which was then settled upon and divided up into (piarter sections. Thus matters stood at the death of Captain Smith. We would here state, that various surveys have lieen made from time to time by differerit parties and among them one by Clement Co.\, United States Deputy Surveyor, in accordance with which the grant was finally patente<l. Some time after the death of Captain Smith. Mr. Curtis married the widow of Captain Smith, and became administrator of the estate and guardian of the minor heirs, thus becoming a party interested in the dispute.

'- Some three months since, Mr. Tyler Curtis, on beiialf of himself and the heirs of Captain S. Smith, obtained judgment on a writ of ejectment (by default) against forty-eiglit of the settlers on the Bodega ranch. Tlie writ of ejectment and restitution recpiired the sheritt' to dispossess the settlers, and keep possession for ei.xty days. ( )n Tuesday evening the sheriff, nnaccomj)'inie<l by any one, went to Bodega

"On Tuesday evening Mr. Curtis, accompanied by Mr. Nuttman, of San Francisco, and forty-eight men, arrived here and immediately took passage in coaches ft)r Bodega, where they arrived at live o'clock on Wednesday morning. The citizens of Petaluma, being ignorant of all the })roceedings in the case were at a loss to know the why and the wherefore of this great influx of armed men; and, failing to get satisfactory replies to their interrogatories, furtiier than that the j)arty were bound for Jiodega, were at once led to suppose that the crowd had been brought here for the purpose of taking forcible possession of Bodega ranch. By nine o'clock in the evening the e.xcitement ran high, and about twenty men, armed and accoutred, started for the scene of action, arousing all the settlers as they passed along, who at once joined them, to render aid to their brethren, if found necessary. A messenger had been promptly dispatched to Bodega to inform the settlers on that ranch of what was going on. lie reached there at midnight, and found them entirely ignorant of the movements of Mr. Curtis and his satelites. So rapid and prompt were their movements that by the time Curtis' ' fighting men' had arrived some eighty or ninety settlers had collected, which number, by nine o'clock, A. M., was augmented to 250 or 300.

"Early in the morning, it being ascertained that the sheriff had arrived tlie evening previous, a conimittee waited upon him to ascertain the object of his visit. lie stated that he came there to discharge his duty as an officer, which was, to put Mr. Curtis in possession of his property; lie denied having anything to do with the forty-eight men brought there by Curtis, or even having any knowledge of their coming; and promised as soon as l)reakfast was over to go where the settlers were assembled and see them. This he did. A committee of ten was appointed ti) confer with him. which resulted in a stay of all proceedings for two hours, giving Sheriff ( ireen time to confer with

Mr. Curtis, and convey to liini the wishes and will of the assemblage. Before the expiration of the two hours the sheriti' returned without any (Satisfactory answer, so far as Mr. Curtis was concerned; but for himself, declining to do anything in the matter, believing that the injudicious course pursued by Mr. Curtis, absolved him from the necessity of attempting to carry out liis instructions at that time.

" ,\ committee of the citizens was then appointed to wait on Mr. Curtis, whose instructions were to inform him that tiiey considered he had committed a gross outrage upon the citizens of this county, and the settlers in particular, in having brought there, from a neighboring town, an armed body of citizens, in violation of law and good order, and for purposes which could not be recognized or tolerated; and to demand their immediate return to the place from whence they came. To this peremptory demand Mr. Curtis demurred, believii^g, as he said, that tlie citizens were misinformed, and were unnecessarily excited, and acting from a mistaken sense of duty; and that if they, the committee, would guarantee him protection from insult, he and I\[r. Nuttman would accompany them to the place of meeting, and explain the cause and motive of their procedure. Tiiey accordingly accompanied the committee and made an explanation, Mr. Curtis alleging that in employing these men, he did so with no intention of ottering an indignity or insult to the citizens of this county, but merely for the purpose of aiding himself in retaining possession of property which he thought to be justly his by the decisions of the legal tribunals of his country, when Sheriff Green, in the discharge of his duty, siiould give him such possession; and not for the purpose of taking forcible possession, or doing any overt act; and that he was willing to meet the settlers at any time and compromise all matters at variance, and lease them the lands on which they reside, at one-half the price for which lands on other ranches are leased. Mr. Muttinan then repudiated all connectiim with the 'lighting-men," and stated tiiat his visit to

"The demand for the removal of the armed forces was again made to Mr. Curtis, with a refusal to treat on any subject, until after their return. xVfter a few minutes conference with the sheriff, and one or two others, Mr. Curtis consented to their return, he paying the expenses of their transjiortation from there to »San Francisco. This ended the matter, so far as he was concerned. Wagons were then procured, and the 'deceived braves" and their two boxes of i/ovemment rifles (previously shipped from San Francisco, and directed to Tyler Curtis, Bodega), together with their ammunition and thirty days' outfit, started for Petaluma, accompanied by one hundred or more of the settlers, where they arrived a little after dark, and were received by the firing of cannon and the liveliest demonstrations of joy at the happy and peaceful result of the injudicious and uncalled for movement. On Thursday morning they took their departure from this city for San Francisco, where it is to be hoped they will safely arrive, wiser, if not better men. In justice to the party we would state that those of them with whom we conversed, said that they were deceived in regard to the object of their mission - they believing it to be one of peace not war. During their sojourn liere their deportment was gentlemanly throughout."

In 1862 the difficulties growing out tif sijuatter settlement on the Sotoyome Rancho, near Healdsburg, culminated in a resistance of the county authorities l)y the settlers. J. M. Bowles, yet a respected citizen of Petaluma, was their sheriff. Resistance was made to writs of ejectment placed in his hands. The Petaluma An/us of July 19, 18(52, said editorially:

Stanford having declined tu interpose the gubernatorial authority until it had been made apparent that our county authorities are uueipial to the task of enforcing the laws, Slieritf Uowles has summoned fi posse eiDuitctux of about 300, wlio are notified to report tliemselves, 'armed and equipped as the law directs,' at Healdslmrcr (yesterday I Tuesday, tlie IJtli inst. As ominous as this nntbrtnnate dithcnlty may seem to persons abroad, we do not appreliend tliat any very serious consequences will, at present, result therefrom; but it is one of those peculiar cases, so common in California, which may, unless remedied l)y wholesome and just legislation, eventuate in scenes of anarchy, destructive alike to the moral and industrial wellbeing of the inhabitants of our fair State."

The result of this actiou of Sherift' Bowles is thus graphically described by the Healdsburg correspondent of the Ari/i/s under date of July 15th:

'-At 9 o'clock this morning. Deputy Sheriff Latapie mounted a stump in front of the Sotoyome Hotel and called the names of several hundred men; when about two hundred and fifty answered to their names -pei'haps one-half of the whole number summoned. Sheriff Bowles then explained the nature of liusiness, informing them that seven writs of restitution and ejectment were to be served on the settlei's - Scaggs. Rice, Miller, and others. The jwsse was notified to be readj' to march to the scene of action in fifteen minutes - and much to the disgust of the crowd, they were ordered to proceed on foot; which was not very agreeable as the sun was pouring down in tropical style - the thermometer standing at ninety-two in the shade.

"x\t about half-past ten o'clock the sheriff took his jiofixr ti> the place occupied by Mr. Rice's family, about one mile northwest of Healdsburg. We arrived at Rice's at 11 o'clock, where we found about fifty resolute settlers insi<le of tlie yard fence, well armed and apparently determined not to allow us to proceed further in that direction. We advanced holdly up to said fence - it being understood that the settlers were not to shoot until we crossed the line, which no one seemed inclined to do - when Mr. L. D. Latimer read some kind of a document - probably the 'riot act' - we were not able to hear a word from our position. Sheriff Bowles then read some papers, which we were also unable to hear - supposed to be the order of the court. The sheriff then commanded \\\s 2)osse to assist him in the execution of his writs - 2X)s-se mum - backward movement perceptible - settlers cocked their guns - leaders addressed them - another backward movement on the part of posse, explained on the ground that the atmosphere was purer under the oak trees. Sheriff again demanded possession of the premises - most of hisj^w*«6' seated themselves on logs and the grass under the oaks. Considerable parleying between sheriff and settlers - when it beinff apparent to everybody that nothing could be done without the effusion of blood, the sheriff wisely dismissed his posse. Cheer upon cheer went up from the crowd - both j[«>ss<? and settlers joining in it heartily. The immense crowd then started back to town, ap]>arently satisfied with the day's woi'k.

"It was generally believed that from two to four hundred armed settlers were in the immediate vicinity of the house during the time - though not more than fifty were to be seen. A friend informed me that he saw a large number of armed men in a ravine back of the house about one hundred and fifty yards off.

"The greatest order prevailed - not a drunken or disorderly man to be seen. Mr. (leo. Hranstradder received a severe cut under the arm by falling from a stumj) and coming in contact with a jiicket fence. No other accident."! happened."

The sheriff with his ^w^wc having failed to vindicate the law. the strong arm of the State was invoked as a denier resort. AVhat steps were taken is thus stated editorially in the Ar(/ns of the 24th of September:

"The public mind is again being agitated bv the settlers' ditficulties in the nfigliburluio<i of Healdsburg. In compliance witii the re(iuisition of Sheriff Bowles, (iovernor Stanford ordered out the two military eouipanies of this city, the Petahiina Guards and JMninet (iuards, to enforce the writ of ejectment against IMilier, liice, Scatfgs and others. The two companies aliove nameil. under tlie respective command of Captain 1". B. Hewlett and Captain T. F. Baylis, took up their line of march from this city for the scene of ditiiculty on Monday last. By a gentleman who came down on the Ilealdsburg stage yesterday, we learn that the military were at A[ark West Creek. The same gentleman also informed us that he conversed, just hefore leavino- Ilealdsburg, with several of the settlers, and they avowed their determination to resist the force sent against them. We sincerely trust they will think better of it, and listen to the dictates of cool judgment. The late decision of the courts, in favor of Bailhache, has done away with the pretext on which they predicted their right to resist the sherif!"'s^w.w<^. We ask our fellow citizens to retiect what serious conse- (piences the resisting of military might lead to. If in this instance law is set at defiance, there is a combustible element in ('aliforiiia which would accept it as a license for guerrilla warfare. We cannot, however, believe that our neighbors of Ilealdsburg will be guilty of lighting the torch of civil war in our midst."

"On Monday morning last the military companies which were ordered by the Governor to assist Sheritf Bowles in enforcing writs of ejectment against settlers near Healdsburg, returned to this city having faithfully discharged the duty for which they were ordered out. The majesty of the law has been asserted and maintained, and the serious consequences which it was feared might result therefrom have been averted. Our citizen soldiers, with their etticient otJicers, deserve much credit for the decided and yet humane manner in which they discharged the unpleasant task assigned them. Those families that have had to relinquish homes that cost them years of toil, are now the subject of sympathy, and should be encouraged and assisted in their endeavors to find new and more ]>ermanent homes. Let the difficulties just past be remembered only to guai'd against the recurrence of like scenes in the future."

In 1801 there were about eighteen settlers who located on the (German grant, on the coast bordei-ing on the (iualala Kiver and extending southward toward Fort Ross. The claimant was William Beihler, and being a foreigner, he commenced suit of ejectment in the United States District Court. The writer, then a United States Deputy Marshal, had occasion to serve papers on those squatters in 1861 and knows how " sultry " they threatened to make it for Beihler if he over dared to " materialize in that neck of woods." Beihler got his ranch, notwithstanding, but he has seldom visited it. The grant has now largely passed into other hands.

By reference to the last chapter on Russian occupation at Fort Ross it will be seen that reference is made to a bill of sale given to Captain John A. Sutter, ])urporting to convey to him Bussian title to laud. Tiiis title was a source of considerable trouble to Sonoma County settlers along about 1S60-'1. One Colonel Muldrew turned up then with that title and created quite a panic. The Joiirtnil of Alay 11, 1860 said:

"The Sutter, or Aluldrew claim, lying between Cape Mendocino and Cape Drake, or Punta Reyes, and about which considerable interest is at present manifest by the people of this section, covers about two hundred and eighty leagues of land, and embraces within its bounds, in addition to a large area of public domain, several confirmed Spanish grants. As most of our readers are aware, this is tlie socalled Russian American Fur Company's claim; but we suggest that the territory should hereafter be known as the "Muldrew Principality.

Onr reason for this is. that the Colonel claims that the Russian Fur Company held and exercised exclusive control of the territory during a certain number of years (about thirty-three, we think), and then transferred their rights, privileges and immunities to Captain J. A. Sutter, who in turn sold to the present claimant, he, Muldrew, should of right now be entitled to exercise all the rights and privileges, l)oth civil and political, which belonged to the said original claimants. Let the claim then be known as the 'Muldrew Principality, and let its rightful ]triiice assert and exercise his authority! True, Uncle Sam may not relish the thing much, but how is he to help himself? It was Mexican territory alone that he conquered, and not that of the Russian Fur Company ! What right then has he to complain, though this principality does lay 'adjacent to,' and is surrounded by his potato patch? ' Hy the law of nations" [ior the interpretation of which, and in further proof of the soundness of our arguments, we refer the reader to the articles in the Argus, over the signature of' Veritas,' which we think cannot fail to convince all as their author is known to be no less a person than the valiant Colonel Zabriskie, Colonel Muldrew's legal adviser and expounder), the Russians acquired sovereignty over it, and by the right of purchase, Colonel Muldrew is now the legitimate prince and ruler; but, like the ' Nephew of his Uncle,' we ojiine he will tind Jordan a hard road to travel, ere he is permitted to grasp the golden scepter of this

' Kiiiiiilom liy the sea.'" Colonel Muldrew began to force his claim to this vast estate with much vigor. He had as his attorney Colonel .1. C. Zaliriskie, who as author of the " Laiul Laws of California" was recognized as a lawyer of much ability. Several settlers' meetings were held in Big \'alley, at which Colonel Zabriskie was present and explained the nature of the title upon which his client set up a claim to lands, much ot which had already been purchased by the settlers from grantees holding under Mexican title. Most of the settlers failed to see the potency of the arguments used and Hatly refused to give any countenance to the Muldrew claims. Some, however, seem to have been fearful that his claim was something more than a mere shadow, and we have been informed that Mr. Rennitz of the Fort Ross grant was $6,000 poorer on account of his credulity. Be this as it may, the Muldrew title reached a final disposition in a decision rendered by Judge ISIcKiiistry in October of 1860, which was as follows:

-'Curtis vs. Svtfer, et al. - This is a motion to dismiss the bill npon the pleadings. I grant the motion, assuming that all the facts stated in the complaint are true. The complainant does not content himself with stating that the defendants set up some claim or demands to his lands, but specitically decribes their alleged title from the Russian Fur Company to the defendant, Sutter. Admitting that the averment that the other defendants 'claim under Sntter,' as sufficient allegation that they have receiveil deeds from Sutter, still the - Russian Fur C'oinpany ' is not a legitimate source of title. If an action of ejectment were Ijrought by defeiulants against a party in possession upon the deeds named., as referred to in the bill, those deeds could not constitute a color of title; the defendant in possession would not be required to introduce any testimony to impeach or rebut the deeds. Hence, upon the authority of Ctiiiin cs. Sntter, et al., and Pi.vleij rs. irii(/f//ns, 1 am of opinion that no preliminary injunction should have been issued in the present case, and that the injunction already issued ought not now to be made final or jierpetuaj. And since the only other remedy sought by the bill oi- whicli I'Luild be obtained after a feigned issue, had been decided in favor of j)laintit} is, that the deeds of defendants be canceled, which is not iMily a more effective remedy tlian an injunction, it a])](ears to me that if the Supivme Couit lia\e decided that no injunction should issue, they have also decideil that no decree ol cancelfitioii should be rendered.

description of what portion of the rancho the plaintitf is in the actual possession. It admits tliat large portions of it are held adversely by persons not yiarties to this suit. This is not a case wliere any <locti'ine of constructive possession can apply, nor does it follow that because in order to remove a cloud from a portion of which the plaintiff is in possession, it is necessary to examine the validity of the title to the whole Bodega Rancho - therefore, the court will interfere to remove a cloud from that of which third parties are in possession. Such examination into the validity of the liodega title is in no degree binding upon those third parties holding adversely. l!eing in possession they must be considered (until a judgment in a direct proceeding against them) as tlie actual owners of the land they occupy. The pnr])ose of such a bill of peace is to remove a cloud from the title which threatens to disturb the quiet and peaceable possession of a plaintiff in the actual occupancy of land, and since i*^ is inijiossible to ascertain from this bill that the ]iresent plaintiff is in the actual occupancy of any particular foot of land, the cause must be dismissed.

" District Judge." This decision seems to have effectually and forever, laid the ISIuldrew title to land acquired through Finssian occupancy at Foil Ross.

This grant was a source of much disijiiict and unrest to settlers. Originally there were two claimants before the board of land commissioners, Ortega and Miranda. Ortega had l>een a Mexican sicklier, and married the daughter of Miranda. He claimed to have received a grant of the Arroyo de San Antonio, and placed his father-in-law, Miranda, in occupancy thereof On account of domestic infelicity Ortega went to Oregon and was there when gold was discovered in California. In the meantime Miranda seems to have received a grant for the same land on the ground of abandonment by Ortega. The two titles passed into the hands respectively of

James F. Stnart and Thomas I>. Valentine. They were both laid before the land commissioners, but ultimately Valentine witlxlrew his claim, alleging as a reason that he was satisHed that the Miranda claim was without good foundation. Stuart litigated the Ortega claim to the highest tribunal in the land, and it was rejected. The land was then declared subject to entry as go\ernmeut land. The outside lands were so entei'cd, and the lands embraced within the city of Petaluma were entered in lots under what is known as the "town site bill." Now it was that Valentine went to Congress and sought the passage of a special bill to restore the Miranda grant to a hearing in court, claiming that he had discovered new evidence which showed the genuiness of that grant. For several years the settlers on the land and residents of Petaluma combatted and defeated every attempt to have the case reopened. Finally a compromise was made whei'eby Valentine agreed that if he made his title to the Arroyo de San Antonio grant he would accept " lien scrip " from the government for the same, and not attempt to disturb the title of settlers organized through government to lands embraced in that grant. The years had run their course and in 1873 this compromise was reached. In the Petaluma Argvs of December 19, 1878. we find the following in relation thereto:

-' The cloud that has hovered over the lands on which the city of Petaluma is situated is foi tiinately fast dispelling. The history of the various struggles for title that have involved the settlers here would form a voluminous book, and the inconvenience, dread, uncertainty and possible insecurity of our title have in no small degree retarded our growth and prosperity as a city. The time seems to have arrived at last when perfect security of title can be claimed, without possibility of being overwhelmed or being alarmed at some further period by a 'trumped up claim." The 'Ortega' has been killed by the Supreme Court, and the ' Miranda' will soon be tfoatel off on the public domain, no more to annoy or irritate people. Then, with

ITncIe Sam's title in our pockets, Me can say, ' These are onr lands; this is onr heritage; here we will hnild onr homes and fonnd a city that will rank first among the mnnicipalities of the State.'

"Below will lie found jnililislied entire the the decree issned in the C!irciiit Court for San Francisco, confirming the Miranda claim hut snhjecting the claimant to the proviso of the act of Congress, which says he ' may select, and shall be allowed patents for an equal quantity of unoccupied and unappropriated public lands fif the United States ' elsewhere.

" ' In this case, on hearing the proofs and allegations, it is ordered, adjudged and decreed that the said claim of the petitioners is valid, and that the same be and hereby is confirmed; but this decree and confirmation are hereby made subject to the restrictions and limitations prescribed in the act of (!ongress entitled, ' An act for the Ilelief of Thomas 15. A^alentine, approved June 5, 1872.

"'The land of which confirmation is made is the same which was granted by Manuel Micheltorena, in the name of the Mexican Government to Juan Miranda, on the 8th day of ( )ctol)er, 1844, and on which he resided in his life-time, and is known by the name of the Kanclio Arroyo de San Antonio, and bounded by the Lagnna and Arroyo of the same name, and the pass and Estredo of retaluma, and is in extent three square leagues, if that quantity is to be found within the exterior boundaries, and no more; and, if a less quantity is included in said boundaries, then said lesser (piantity is confirmeJ.

" JjOEE.N/.o Sawyer, " Circuit .Intlge.' " in January of 1S74 the following editorial relating to the Miranda grant appeared in the I'etaluina Argvs, and was conclusive of nil further trouble alwut Valentine's claim : oiir homes there is always an uneasiness tliat periodically breaks into downright fear, and oftentimes panic. There seems to be no security. \Vc build elegant residences and beautify our grounds, but so long as there is a question to the title of our lands, there is a lurking fear always that some day in our lifetime or of our children, the lands may be wrested from us, and we would have our ' trouble for onr pains." Again, in event of a desire to sell our realty, the shadow comes up, and our property is depreciated thereby. And this has been the case with Petaluma from the very day of its settlement. First we had the Ortega and Miranda grants to fight. As if to double teams against the settlers the Miranda claimant withdrew from the United States Commission upon a compromise and helped to fight the battle for the Ortega claim, which, after passing the Ctnnmission, was adjudged a fraud by the Supreme Court. The Government then issued its patents to the land claimed by the grant, and our people with Uncle Sam's title in their pockets, felt comparatively secure. But the trouble had not yet ceased. T. B. Valentine, the claimant under the Miranda saw that he had made a mistake in his alliance with the Ortega, rushed to Washington and endeavored, by an act of C'ongress, to get his claim reopened and before the courts. Here was trouble and vexation again. The Miranda claim was believed by many to be valid, while others took the countrary view. Whoever was right recent events go to show that it would have been a dangerous experiment had the bill l)een passed as it was first inti'odnced. Through the influence of onr representatives, however, the bill was beaten. This ditl not seem to satisfy the claimant. At nearly every successive ('ongress he was on hainl with a bill for his relief. Finally to put tlie matter forever at rest, a bill passed Congress allowing him to jiresent his claim to the courts, and in the event that he should ])rove the validity of his title he was to execute a deed to the lands claimed under the grant, and in lieu thereof take a corresponding amount of public lands wlierever lie might find tliein ami elect. The suit was accordingly coniinenced in the Circuit (^oiirt in San Francisco, and npon trial a decree was issued to tiie piaintitl', when it was taken on appeal to tiie Supreme Court of tlie I'liited States for tiiuU adjudication. Many rumors have been rife that Mr. Valentine, haviiiii- ijot into court and proven liis claim, was not necessarily compelled by tlie terms of the act to take lien lands, hut might, upon the atHrmance of liis case at Washington, come ujion and dispossess the settlers here. A good deal of talk has been made, and a great deal of fear endured by our people over these complications.

'- Finally, however, like all our worldly troubles this vexed and complicated question has been finally settled by Mr. Valentine giving a deed to government through our energetic and faithful Senator, Mr. Sargent, as the following dispatches will explain:

" -WASuiNtiToN, Jan. 5. - Senator Sargent has received from T. B. Valentine, of San Francisco, to be held in trust, a deed in favoi- of the United States, executed by \'alentine and wife, conveying the Miranda grant, in Sonoma ( bounty; the deed to be delivered to the t'ommissioners of the (leneral Land Office on affirmance by the Supreme Court of the judgment recently rendered in Valentine's favor by the Circuit Court of California in an action autliorized by Congress. The deed conveys to the United States all of A^alentine's interest in said grant, and Valentine by the law of last session, is to receive land scrip to the same extent on unoccupied puldic land. This quiets title in favor of purchasers from the Government on thegrant.'

"'W.\suiNuT()N,Jan.7. - The United Slates Supreme (Jourthavingconfirmed the decision of the Circuit Court upholding the validity of the Miranda grant, its mandate to that effect was sent to California to-day, and the deed executed by Valentine conveying all his i-ight and title to the United States in trust for the settlers, was delivered to the Commissioner of the (leneral Land Office this afternoon. This action perfects tlie settlers' title to all lands covered by

" AV^e may state also in this connection that i>ur fellow-townsman, lion, (ieorge Pearce, met Mr. A'alentine on the streets of San Francisco on Wednesday, when Valentine tul<l him personally that he had executed and delivered the deed, thereby confirming the above dispatches. All hail to our homes, which are now withuut a cloud of uncertainty."

This land, as will be seen by reference to the chapter on grants, was conceded to I'artolenius Bojorques, and embraced over 24,000 acres of land. Nearly half of this lay in Sonoma County, embracing the fertile Two Rock Valley. There never was any conflict over the confirmation of that grant. It passed to final confirma tion without let or hindrance. IJojorques %vas quite old when the Americans began to come in and settle on his grant, lie had eight sons and daughters, all grown up and married. To each of these he executed a deetl of one-ninth of his grant, reserving to himself a ninth. There was no partition, bnt father and children alike had an undivided ninth of the vast estate. Each sold land to the settlers as opportunity offered, and at prices nierely nominal. Bnt few of the settlers took the precaution to get other than the signature of the party from whom they purchased to their deed. When the grant was all absorbed by such loose-jointed titles, the outcome was inevitable. Some had barely title enongh to cover their holdings - some had moie than enough, and others had not a shadow of title. In the early sixties a suit was commenced for partition, and over two hundreil, persons were parties to the suit. Most of the settlers banded themselves together in what was called the " Bojorques League" and maile common cAuse for an adjustment of title. The suit jilayed shuttle-cock back and forth thiough the courts for a sjiace of over twenty years. It was one of the most tangled skeins of land title tver adjudicated by the California courts. It finally lendered a conclusion very recently, and may he ranked among the things of the past - although the " Bojorques League" still has an organized existence.

In dismissing the subject of Spanish grants it is in ])lace to say that of all those vast estates, there is now only one in the county, the "Cotato grant,"' that remains unbroken, the balance liaving all been subdivided and sold to settlers. Of the original owners of these grants there are but few who are now even moderately well otl'; and very many are in really straitened circumstances. The manner in which these vast properties were dissipated shows how evanescent anti Heeting is what the world calls wealth.

fi 1 1'^i late Dr. AV. W. Oarpenter, wlio was a student of science, speaking of tliis soc- -^- tion of California said: -'The county of Sononialias never Iteen honored with a jjeological survey. It is jn-etty evenly divided lietween xalley and niountiiin. The valleys having formerlv heen suhinertfcd with the waters of the ocean, were left upon their sulisidenee with a soil of adohe, hut have since received a coat of sedimentary deposit of alluvium. The soil of the eastern part of Sonoma Valley rests upon a hard-pan of secondary formation. The sandy loaua comprisinu; the country lying hetween Petaluma and the coast is modern alluvium. The redwood forests adjacent to tlie coast, helong to the second epodi of the tertiary period - the miocene of ]V[r. Lyell. The soil of the Russian River A' alley largely foi-med through glacial inHnence, helongs to the seconilary period. The mountains are volcanic. Trap, or basalt is tlie leading rock, although ]iorphyry, sienite, granite, slate, ami especially carbonate, or magnesian limestone are found. The mountain range of basalt dividing the i'etaluma and Sonoma valleys was poured out ot the crater of St. Helena and rolling onward, u mighty river of molten lava, couletl and hanlened where we now find it. The streets of San Francisco are largely paved with this i-ock. In quarrying it small caverns are levealed most beautifully lined, ami crystalized with carbonate of lime. Notwithstanding that Sonoma is classed as an agricultural county, its mineral resources are varied, and in the near future will be a source of great profit.

-'('<)(//, of not by any means a superior (jiiality, has been found near the surface on Sonoma l\[ountain not more than five miles from IVtaluma. Practical exjierieuce has upset many scientific theories. Science taught that the native deposit of gold was exclusively in quart/.. The miner reveals some of the richest leads in slate rock. Science formerly taught that the coal deposit was exclusively in the carboniferous formation. The same autliority now teaches that it may be found in any geological strata. It is true that all the coal thus far found belongs to the tertiary, or secondary formation - lignite or brown coal - yet competent observers ai'e sanguine in the belief that when sutiicient depth shall have heen reached coal of good quality and in i-easonal)le abundance will be tbund.

-> J^'trnleum, a sister product, is also known to exist in this county. It is a question whether oil wells will ever prove as productive in Cali- I'ornia as they are in Pennsylvania, for the reason that the horizontal wheels of the palaeozoic age confines the oil beneath the surface in the latter State, while the tertiary rocks of California, turned up ^m edge, allow it to lie forced to the surface by liydrostatic pressure, and capillary attraction, and thus wasted. Hence larj^c quantities of oil on the surface is an unfavorable indication for well-boring.

-' It is for tills reason, and not because oil in quantities does not exLst, that the oil business has not a promising out-look on the Pacific coast.

'' ^«ic'^'.<.;7/'c/'. - Quicksilver, j)rincipally in the form of cinnaliar, e.xists in this county in large quantities. During the (juicksilver excitement of four or five years ago many rich deposits were developed, and worked until the in)mense (quantities of the article found in every section of the State reduced its price below the cost of extraction, which necessarily compelled a discontinuance of operations.

"The composition of ciimabar being 81| grains of (piicksilver and 19.^ grains of sul|ihur to the hundred, implies the existence of an abundance of the latter article also in the county. When (quicksilver exists where there is no sulphur it must needs be in its native form. In the Rattlesnake mine, above Cloverdale, is the only place that it is found in this county, otherwise than in the form of cinnabar. In that mine the pure glolniles ai-e interspersed thi-ough soft tulcose rock.

"'Kaolin. -This article is found in this county, but kaolin being decomposed feldspar, and the pure atmosphere of California not possessing the power of decomposing and disintegrating that article from its native rocks like the murky air of England, the (juantity is correspondingly small. So rapidly does the atmosphere of England decompose feldspar, that granite, or sienite, exposed to the air. bec(;mes honey-coinbed in a few years. The reader is aware that fine porcelain ware is made of finely ))ulverized (juartz crystals, kaolin, and the ashes of ferns - the fern ashes containing enough alkali, in the form of bicarbonate of potassa to produce the requisite effervescent action, in union with the silisic acid of the (piartz. to dcvelope the beautiful finish of that elegant ware. The kaolin for the immense quantity of porcelain ware manufactured in England is gathered in Cornwall, where it is decomposed and disintegrated from the granite quarries.

" Hod ami YMoio Cinher (terrd ih xleitJia), as well as other ochreous coloring earths of a sn|)crior quality, and in great abundance, are found in this county. No better material for paints exist upon the earth.

^^ Petrifactlonx are found in this county and, in fact, everywhere on the coast - under circumstances which upset the accepted theory that petrifaction can (inh/ occur by saturating the wood in thcriiiHl waters. Petrifaction takes place on the surface of the earth - necessarily beyond the reach or intiuence of thermal waters. The large amount nf silex in the soil mav account for this in some instances, as there arc many cases in which an excess of that element causes wood to petrify instead of carbonize, even in the carboniferous formation. Still the proposition holds that petrifactions are found under circumstances which would seem to imply that atmospheric conditions mu^L have something to do with their transfornialion.

^-Copper. - Some rich deposits of c(qiper-- jirincipally in the form of red oxide - have also been discovei-ed in the northern section of the county.

" I nni - Iron is found nearly everywhere, but the UKist valuable yet unearthed are the chromic iron oi'es in the mountains near ('lo\erdale. where the rock formation is mainly st^rpentine. Some of these ores have been in the process of extraction for several years with profit to the owners. .\ small amount of hematite ii'on \\a» found near Santa Ilosa. Magnetic and Titanic iron is found in more or less abundance as is usual in all volcanic rocks.

" Boiling i<pruiiis exist in several localities, the most noted, and reniarkableof whicli are the geysers. These springs are among the most wonderful and magnificent displays of nature in the world. Notwithstanding that the springs are located within close pro.ximity of each other, the chemical properties differ much. We have not at hand a chemical analysis of these waters, init chloritle of sodium (table salt), borate of sodium (borax), carbonate of sodium, sulpluu'i iron, and sulphate of sodium predominate. There is a trace of silica in all of them we believe. LittoTi springs and Mark West are well known places of resort for pleasure-seekers and invalids.

"Imperfect skeletons of several mastotlonshave been found protruding from the l)ank8 of I'etaluma (Jreek, a short distance above the town of I'etaluma, where the floods had exposed them to view; and one tusk found - and now in a cabinet in the latter city - is ten inches in length. They were perhaps mired down while seeking water. Their discovery was merely accidental, paleontological research never having leceived any more attention in the county than its kindred sciences.

As the ijuarries of basalt ])aving blocks in the neighborhood of i'etaluma, 8anta llosa and Sonoma have become one of Sonoma County's profital)le industries, the following from the Sonoma County Jonriud of September 25, 1857, is of interest:

>' On the summit of a hill some threc-tjuarters of a mile to the south of I'etaluma, a very singular ledge of rocks has recently been discovered by some persons engaged in (juarrying stone for building purposes. The singular structure and wonderful uniformity that prevails throughout the ledge, is the feature that renders it peculiarly interesting to the curious. It is well calculated to impress the mind with the idea of its being the work of art.

"The ledge is composed of regular prismatic columns, inclined but a few degrees from the perpendicular toward the center of the hill. The columns generally have five sides, but we observed some that had but four. They are usually about twenty inches in thickness, and are divided into blocks varying from one to four feet in length, which are so closely joined and so firmly cemented together that it is (juiteditHcult to separate them. The columns are bound to each other by a layer of grayish colored cement, about an inch in thickness. The rock is very hard, and of a dark color, and belongs to that class of rocks denominated basalt by geologists. The whole ledge presents the appearance of a solid structure of masonry, reared, like the Jigyptian pyramids, to perpetuate the works and memory of man, in defiance of the flight of ages. So abundant, indeed, are the appearances of design, that we are not surprised that many persons have unhesitatingly pronounced it the work of art. There is abundant evidence, however, tharf; precludes the possibility of such being the case. This columnar structure of rocks is not unfrequent. It is seen along the margin of Snake River, and in the passage of the Columbia River through the Cascade Mountains, perpendicular walls of this columnar structure are often seen rising to the height of forty or fifty feet. The basaltic columns of Lake Superior, Fingal's Cave, in the island of Staft'a, and the Giant's Causeway in the north of Ireland, are all examples of similar columnar structure. Geologists also speak of its occurring quite frequently west of the Ilocky Mountains. We are too incredulous to look upon this singular structure as other than the work of the Divine Arclii tect, and as such it presents a wide range for human thought and study.

'' The discovery of this ledge of rocks so near town, is particularly fortunate for Petaluma. The rocks arc easily quarried aiul brought to town, but the greatest advantage of all is their thorough adaptability to the construction of fire- proof Iniildings neither tire nor water affecting them in the least. We saw a cliip from one of the rocks subjected to fire until it became heated to a bright red color, after which it wa.s immediately thrown into cold water. No chantje whatever from its original appearance could be perceived."

In March of 18H8 there was considerable excitement ill I'etaluma conseijuent upon the unearthing at the head of I'etaluma Creek of the fosi^il remains of some animal of large proportioii^i. In reference to these bones h corres])ondent of the Ar<jni< under date of March 12th says:

"It is assumed that the bone in question is unmistakably a lower jawbone, and from thennmber and conformation of the teeth, it is not the jaw of a hippopotamus, for that animal has six grinders on each side of both jaws, also fonr incisors above and below, and a canine tooth on each side, above and below. Again, it cannot be the jaw of a rhinoceros, for that has seven grinders on each side of both jaws, and from two to four incisors in each jaw. The number of grinders in this jaw, the pairs of conical projections on the same, the entire absence of incisors and canine teeth, together with the length (22 inches) of the shinbone exhibited, induces the writer to believe that it belongs to a narrowtoothed mastodon (mastodon angustidens). The dimensions of these grinders, seven inches in breadth by three inches in thickness, answer to the name. The word mastodon is derived from two (Treek words, meaning conical-shape and tooth. There were two species of mastodons, namely: the great mastodon ( M. giganteus) and the narrow-toothed mastodon. The last s])ecies \\a> one-third less in size than the great mastodon, and much lower on the legs. It was not unlike the elephant, being furnished with a trunk and two huge tusks, and fed upon the rank vegetation of the early world. Thi> was, probably, a juvenile of about seven years, its age lioing determined from the number of pairs of conical jioints found on the molar teeth, while his height is estimated to have been only about eight feet, the estimation being based upon the supposition that the large bone e.xhibited last week was a shinbone. The imperfections of that bone render its identity somewhat difhcult, still its superior articulations and triangular shaft, lead to the belief that it is a tibia.

"On Thursday last Messrs. Dickey and (-Jil more discovered the skeleti.m of a mastodon on Petaluma Creek about two miles north of tlii^ city. Portions of a tusk projected from the bank where the late storm had washed the dirt away. They (jomnienced excavating and have removed the dirt from the head which i.- nf enormous size. The tusk measures twenty-two inches in circumference, and the width of the skull is nearly three feet. It is well worth the investigation of scientific men. It will be remembered that about a year ago |)ortions of undoubtedly the same skeleton were washed out at the same locality, and that we published an account of the same. Discoveries of fossil remains have become so common in CaliforniH, that they liave almost ceased to excite comment, save in scientific circles."'

"Last week we mentioned the fact of the discovery of portions of a gigantic skeleton in the bank of Petaluma Creek. From Mr. S. li. Dickey, one of the discoverers, w'e receive further particulars. We have also received letters from several scientific gentlemen requesting information on the subject, which we cheerfully give. These bones cannot be a part of those found last s])ring, being found fifty yards further up the stream, imbedded eight feet deep in coarse gravel. They are undoubtedly horns, the ii|)per part of the head being found with them. The ilimensioiis are: From the lower part of the clieek Ikhic to the tip ot' the liurii, 8 feet; eaxity nl the liraiii. iJ I'eet, making I'.t I'oet from ti|i to tip of the horns, which measuri'd ~2 ineiies at tlie base. One only was t'ounii. hut a eavitv in tlie earth corresponding in size plainly showed the former existence of another. Two feet ot the point was solid, also 8 inches of the base; the balance crumbled to pieces on exposure. There were two teeth on each jaw measuring 11 inches in lentjth, and 3^ inches in width. They are solid in the jaw, of a darkish color, but resembling ivory in substance. The cheek bones are solid, 18 inches in length. The lnu-iis shot outward from the head, curving to the >ide until within about 18 inches of the point, where they turned forward, the point being a little in front of the head as if for a means of defense. An outside shell similar to that upon the horn of the common cow covered the horn. If the rest of the skeleton bore a proportio'iiate size to the head and horns, the animal was indeed a monster.

The fossil remains found near Tetaluma was the subject of discussion by the California Academy of Natural Sciences. What those scientists thought on the subject, as well as the opinion of the I'etaluma editor, appeared in the Petahnna Aiyns of Api-il 1, ISi;',), aud is as follows :

"At a lecent meeting of the Califoi'uia Academy of Natural Sciences, at ISan Francisco, the subject of the recent discovery of the remains of the gigantic animal at Petaluma was brought up. Mr. Yale said he had been corresponding with the -discoverer of the skeleton of the mastodon lately found near I'etaluma; the bones he understood were being i-enioved, and the Academy ought to take some step toward preserving the remains. The head had been entirely carried away, and other )iorti<uis disturbed. Mr. Carlton remarked that the aninial was said to have been horned, but that which was taken for horns was more probably tusks. Dr. Cooper said the creature w'as either an elephant or a mastodon, aud probably the tusk had been taken for horns. Mr. Yale said that a similar discovery had been made last year in the vicinity of SaJi Jose. Dr. Cooper stated that Mr. llotimau. a membei' of the society, had examined the remains of one of these animals which had been discovered in the valley of Saii Jose, and that upon its being exposed it cruujbled to pieces."

The Ar(jui< said: -' As to the question whether the bones found \\:ei'e tusks or horns, we are decidedly of the oj)iniou that they are horns, as they grew from the top of the head, curving horizontally, for some distance, when they turned to the front as if for a means of defense. Mr. Dickey drew for us a diagram of the head, showing the position of the root of the horns, which was the same as in ordinary cattle. Had they been tusks they would have grown from another portion of the head."

The Ar(ju8 of a still later date said : " Sonoma and adjacent counties ajjpear to be a j)erfect mine of interesting curiosities in the shape of petrifaction belonging to both the animal and vegetable kingdom. What is the most remarkable in relation thereto is the fact that these relics of liygone ages are often found in the alluvial deposits so near the surface of the earth as to frequently be revealed by the plow. We have before us a petrifaction recently plowed up on the ranch of Patrick J.,awlor on the Sonoma Mountains, four or five miles from this city, and at an altitude of several huiulred feet ai)ove the valley or tide level. The specimen is the head and neck {vs fei/iorls) of the fumur or thigh Iione of a mastadon or some other mammoth animal belonging to the pre-historic period. It is a complete petrifaction nearly six inches in diameter across the crown and alioiit seven inches from apex of crown to base. It is virtually the head (os feinor'n<\ with not more than two or three inches of the neck remaining. Looking at its crown it has very much the resemblance of the somewhat round skull of a nearly grown person. It weighs eight pounds. We have seen several specimens of large bones found in tliis vicinity but this is the most perfect petrifaction of the kind that has come under our notice. As this was found so near the surface we doubt not that witli but little labor other bones belonging to tiie same monster animal of which this is a part, can be found.''

One of the wondrous freaks of Nature in this country and one which is well worth a visit by every one who cares for such sights, is the ])etritied forest of Sonoma. Away back in some pre-historic age, Mount St. Helena was an active volcano and threw out vast bodies of scoria from its heart of living tire. Some of this scoria fell upon a forest of large trees and in this mass as if cast in a mold we have great bodies of vegetable matter while retaining their shape and fibre turned in lapse of ages into stone. These trees of stone lie in two tiers in a parallelogram a mile in extent from east to west and about a quarter of a mile from north to south, the roots of these prostrate trees being toward the north. They lie at an angle of from live to thirty-live degrees, the butts being on the lower ground. When discovered they were almost covered with volcanic ashes or tnta, and the ground sparkled with atoms of silica. IMucli of llic brush has been cleared awav and the loose superincumbent deposit removed principally liy Charles Evans, "Petrified Charley," a Swede, who seeing its value for exhibition purposes, enclosed the ground in 1871, and charged a small fee to visitors to requite him for his labor in excavating around the trees. The largest tree thus excavated is eleven feet in diameter at the butt and sixty-eight feet in length, but is broken into several pieces. Much laljor has been spent on the place in improvements until the thou.sands, who have visited the place pronounced it not only one of the great wonders of the world, but "one of the prettiest places" in the hills of California. The forest can be reached and examined in a day by taking the Santa Rosa and Calistoga stage, it being only sixteen miles from the former place. Visitors to the Geysers liy the Cloverdale route, after they have exhausted the curiosities of that wonderful region, with its curious productions of one of Nature's underground laboratories, can reach the petrilied forest by taking the stage which runs between the Geysers and Calistoga. No Eastern or European tourist can truly say that he " has done California" unless he has seen the petrified forest.

Provenance

Text from An Illustrated History of Sonoma County, California. Containing a History of the County of Sonoma from the Earliest Period of Its Occupancy to the Present Time, published 1889, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.