Sonoma County, California - Chapter 9: Mexican State of California, 1911
From History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. 2,556 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,556 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 9: Mexican State of California
After laying out Pueblo Sonoma in accordance with the governor's careful instructions, Vallejo completed the secularization of the Mission Solano. With the distribution of the movable propert)- to them, the Indians generally returned to their rancherias, and the mission community having no legal existence settled down into the status of a parish, though administrators were appointed by the governor to attend to the disposal of the lands claimed by the institutions. Presently the ex-neophytes, in consequence of troubles with the hostile Indians, or "gentiles," as they were distinguished from the christianized natives, placed much of their livestock in the care of General Vallejo. Though the comandante's position as custodian of private property was not recognized by law it seems that he accepted that duty and faithfully cared for the herds of his red proteges for their benefit and protection and for the common good of the community. As this resulted in gain rather than loss to the livestock the wisdom of the choice and management is manifest. The comandante not only cared for the property that had been distributed to the Indians, but he tried to keep them in some kind of order and government around the mission, knowing that only within the influence of that institution backed by the military for emergencies could the natives be kept under that mild discipline that would make them useful to the community and useful in themselves. General Vallejo would have established another - the twent\--econd - mission farther north, as he was wealthy and powerful enough to ha\e endowed it with a good-sized rancho, but the ecclesiastical power.s of the territory were discouraged, and the military man's missionary plan got no further than a plan.
The ex-mission convert reverting toward the original moral type soon became a mission-memory, and this was inevitable. Much unjust denunciation has been lavished upon the disestablishment of the missions, hut this has come from writers whose sentimental flights led them awa\ from the original purpose of the missions, and the causes of their ending. Those institutions, as christianizers and civilizers of the California aborigines, were doomed longbefore the Spanish Cortes in 1813 passed but did not enforce the decree of secularization, and before the Mexican Congress in 1833 brought about the same enactment, for early in their history it was seen b\ intelligent Spanish officers that the missions could not make the Indians self-supporting citizens, and that the mere herding of them on the great mission tracts of land - taking about one thousand acres to support one Indian - was only maintaining them in a dependency, a servitude which doubtless was mild enough for his personal comfort but did not lift him out of the low plane of ages. The Spanish Governor Borica, in 1876, said: "According to the laws the natives are to be free from tutelage at the end of ten years, the missions then becoming doctrinaires, but those of New California, at the rate they are advancing, will not reach the goal in ten centuries ; the reason God knows, and men, too, know somtthing aljoul it." Utticial investigation several times during tiie decades of mission life showed that very few of the neophytes could read or had any literar) knowledge whatever beyond the simplest church service. Also, the general assembling of the Indians in and at the missions, however sanitary the change from the white man"s viewpoint, wrought disastrously in the end. The mission managers coukl not unilerstand the fatality of housing the Indians, and could not overcome the natural apathy of the native to anything remotely resembling hygiene, and the losses from disease were greater than gains from all sources. In a comparatively few \ears the missions would have been depopulated. Moreover, Spain when she established and foisted and protected the missions, also provided for their final secularization, as the following instructions given \'iceroy Bucarili August 17, 1773, to the comandante at San Diego and Monterey.
"Article 15, when it shall happen that a mission is to be formed into a pueblo or village, the comandante shall proceed to reduce it to the civil and economical government, which, according to the laws, is observed by other villages of this kingdom." Other sections of the Cortes decree provided that 'the secular clergy should attend to the spiritual wants of these newly formed curacies," and that "the missionary monks relieved from the converted settlements shall proceed to the conversion of other heathen."
Vallejo A Busy Official
The Mexican congress twenty years after followed closely the decree of the Cortes in a practical and humane distribution of a half of the lands and other property to the Indians who had for years assisted in the accumulation of this w^ealth. To protect him against himself the neophyte by law was prevented from selling, mortgaging or in any way disposing of the land or cattle given him. The other half of the mission holdings were for the pobladores - colonists- -the urgent need of whom at last Mexico became conscious, and whom that government tried to encourage just previous to the time the United States took the whole proposition into her own hands. The padre's vast ranchos were soon covered by the big government grants and the colonist who was to receive a tidy little farm and many other gifts out of the mission treasury, w-as disappointed.
Added to these disagreeable features, Jose Maria Hijar, the chief promoter of the enterprise, landed into tmuliles of his own when he landed here. He was a man of means and some eminence in ^lexico and if permitted might have carried his colonization scheme to some success, but among a people where every person watched some other with fear and distrust, official or private interference was to be expected. When Hijar left Mexico he had in his pocket his appointment to no less ofifice than that of Governor of Upper California, signed by President Farias. Shortly after the new appointee's departure. Vice President Santa Ana, with the promptitude of politicians in Spanish America, chased his superior out of the republic and proceeded to revoke that exofficial's work. A horseman rode from IMexico to Monterey in forty days, heating Hijar and his company by sea, and when the new governor arrived he w-as again just a plain citizen. Governor Figueroa sent the colony to Sonoma, where the families were located by the comandante on the pueblo lots, but among the leaders there were dissensions and disagreements which but for the strong hand of Vallejo would have broken out in open rebelHon. As it 'vas, several of the adherents of Hijar went down to Los Angeles, where they soon had an active revolt under way - revolutions were easy and frequent in Los Angeles during the Spanish and Mexican periods. However, the Hijar insurrection subsided that same afternoon and the governor - on paper - was exiled.
The colony plan of populating the territory with desirable Mexican citizens, as well as the building of the "city" in the Santa Rosa valley having been abandoned, Comandante Vallejo at Sonoma found himself - for about ten years - a very busy official. He had the lately mission-emancipated neophytes - about as helpless as children - with their property to look after, also the Indians of his military district who had never received any mission-taming, and were ready at any hour to rush him and his corporal's guard of soldiers out of the country. With the home-seeking colonists from Mexico, bands of American immigrants were finding their way into the fertile Sonoma valleys, though he repeatedly had been ordered by his superiors to prevent this "lawless invasion." This Spanish characteristic order, utterly absurd as well as impossible of compliance, Vallejo did not even pretend to obey, and he was too strong in territorial politics to be molested. So he kept his pueblo of four leagues square in peace while the cheap "rebellions" of wrangling officials were troubling the country from San Diego to Monterey. In the corps of the Native Sons and Daughters of the Golden West may be found the names of descendants of the following settlers who drifted into Sonoma county during "35 and '45 : Mariano G. and Salvador \'allejo ; Julio, Joaquin and Ramon Carrillo : Rafael Garcia ; Ignacio and Pablo Pacheco ; Nazario and Francisco Berryessa ; Felipe and Lazaro Peiia ; Manuel Vaca : Domingo Suenz ; Gregorio Briones ; Juan Aliranda; Marcos and Cayetano Juarez: Bartolo Bojorques; Francisco Duarte ; Fernando Felix ; Rosalino Olivera ; Victor Prudon ; George Yount ; John Wilson ; James Scott; Mark West; J. B. R. Cooper: Edward Manuel Mcintosh; James Black; Edward Bale; James Dawson and Timothy Murphy. General Vallejo in 1832 married Francesca Benicia Carrillo, one of the daughters of Joaquin Carrillo, and three prominent gringo pioneers of Sonoma, Henry D. Fitch, Jacob P. Leese and Juan B. Cooper, married sisters of Senora Vallejo. With these stalwart Yankee brothers-in-law as neighbors one may readily see where the Comandante got his high opinion of the Americanos del Norte.
The Carrillos were prominent among the old California families, settling first at Santa Barbara. Jose Antonio Carrillo seems to have been the "statesman" of the south and as such took an active part in the "capitol city" and other contests that kept the two ends of the state in constant wrangle. Los Angeles, the hot-bed of political dissension, and San Diego were geographically mated, and the combination could always be counted upon opposing Monterey - - if they were not too busy opposing each other. San Francisco in those days had not reached a chief-city importance, so the "capitol" pendulum swung up and down the state - even after the Americans "came," till it finally stood stationary on the Rio Sacramento. In 1835 Jose Antonio Carrillo as territorial delegate to the Mexican Congress lobbied through that body the decree making
Los Angeles the capital city. Jose appears to have cut a pretty wide swath that session in Mexico, for next year it was learned that he had persuaded Presidente Bustamente to appoint his brother, Carlos Carrillo, governor of California. This pleased the Angelenos, because with a governor within their gates thev could humiliate Monterey. But Monterey was well supplied with governors that year. Governor Figueroa's death left Alta California legally in the hands of the diputacion or territorial legislature, of which Jose Carrillo was the presiding officer, but being a congressional delegate in Mexico, Jose Castro, another member, assumed the governship pro tern. The diputacion then decided to meet at Monterey.
Four pro tem. governors passed through the office tiuring the next nine months, and after the last one had been shipped back to ?^fexico. General Jose Castro and Juan Bautista Alvarado, a customs clerk and a man of considerable ability, started a full grown revolution. The diputacion declared El Estado Libre de Alta California - The Free State of Upper California - forever independent, and arraigned Mexico for crimes that made the acts of George III of Great Britain seem lamb-like in comparison. Then California had two governors, and as Me.xico had revolutions of her own at home, she let the newfree state work out its own salvation, - and back into the Mexican confederation. Afifairs were somewhat mixed. Governor Alvarado of the north was the nephew of Governor Carlos Carrillo of the south and Los Angeles was for anybody who made that city his residence. That civic peculiarity yet may be observed in Los Angeles. General Castro's army of one hundred Californians made an imposing array on parade, but his fighting force consisted of fifty American riflemen under the command of a Tennesseean named Isaac Graham. It is not known that these men did any fighting during that campaign, but as it was known in both gubernatorial departments that they could and would shoot to kill, their mere presence on the field won the battle. Although Governor Carrillo and his brother, the member to Congress, were from Santa Barbara, that pueblo in its turn got up a revolt and he sent troops to punish the rebels, but this force was badly used up by Pio Pico, his brother-in-law. This sent his southern excellency scurrying out of Los Angeles and as far away as San Diego. A number of his friends did not get out in time and were caught by the northern governor, who sent them up to Sonoma, where Vallejo could keep them in seclusion for a few months, which he did although they were the adherents of Seiiora Vallejo's gubernatorial kinsman.
Alvarado's subjugation of the southerners progressed smoothly. Whenever Graham's riflemen showed up before a rebellious city, that rebellion was over and the ayuntamiento, or city council, would issue a voluble pronunciamento in which detestation for Mexico and veneration for a "hijo del pais" (son of the country) in the governor's chair were pretty well mixed. Finally Carrillo fell into the hands of his "arribefio" (upper) rival, and Alvarado, like a kind nephew, turned his captive over to his aunt, who assured him that she would keep el tio - the uncle - out of politics and otherwise be responsible for his behavior. Sefiora Carrillo seems to have been a woman of power and influence, at least in her own home at Santa Barbara, as she kept her word.
which was more than did the city of Los Angeies. That place with San Diego so annoyed Alvarado with their intrigues and plots that he passed the word down the coast that if they did not behave themselves he would shoot ten of their leading men. As he had this number in the Castillo at Sonoma with the key safe in Comandante Vallejo's pocket, the Angelenos and the San Diegos quickly concluded that Alvarado could and would do what he threatened, and he had no further trouble with them. But the free and sovereign days of Alta California were numbered. Some months before this .'Mvarado had reached the conclusion that an independent state containing a contentious population and menaced by a foreign immigration could not exist. He had quietly "explained" to Mexico and had taken the oath of allegiance to the constitution of 1836, and in return for handing California back to the Supreme Government of Mexico, he was appointed governor. As either a salve for his wounded dignity or for a place of exile, the ex-governor was given the Island of Santa Rosa in the Santa Barbara Channel. On this western Elba, or St. Helena, Don Carlos Carrillo, like another Napoleon, settled down on his seagirt rancho and as a typical Californian let his todays slip into the "mananas." Considerable space is here given to the Carrillo name because of the part played by members of that family not only in the lower portion of the state, but later in Sonoma ; in connection with M. G. Vallejo, also with the settlement of the Santa Rosa valley. This digression into general history shows how Sonoma county on the northern frontier of the Mexican dominion played her role in the final act of Spain in the Calif ornias. Sonoma is the last settlement of the Spanish crown in America if not in the world, and is the last colonv from Mexico in California, hence the story of this county must carry much of the general history of the state.
Provenance
Text from History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.