Sonoma County, California - Chapter 16: Fremont the Man of the Hour, 1911
From History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. 2,457 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,457 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 16: Fremont the Man of the Hour
After the insurgents found themselves with a victory on their hands they were confronted with the question of what to do with it. Fremont was considerable distance away and fleet vaqueros would soon carry the news of the capture around the territory. There was a discussion as to the disposal of the prisoners and it was finally decided to remove them to Sutter's Fort. As very friendly relations existed between captors and captives the General took part in these discussions and was in favor of the removal as he wished to be more in touch with a United States officer. He advised his people in the pueblo to remain quiet, that they would not be molested and he would soon return from Sutter's Fort. In Sonoma and while enroute he was secretly approached by Calif ornians with the suggestion that they organize themselves into a strong force, attack the Americans and rescue the captives. Vallejo strongly disapproved of this. He knew such action would only cause needless bloodshed in the district and he knew what even many American officers in California did not know - that this was the beginning of the end of Mexican dominion in the territory. He was not obsessed with the madness that would send his simple vaqueros against those rifles whose discharge was the prelude of death. But he immediately communicated with Commander John B. Montgomery of the United States Sloop of War Portsmouth, in San Francisco, requesting that officer to use his authority or exert his influence to prevent the commission of acts of violence upon the inhabitants of Sonoma by the insurgents in that community. By order of Commander Montgomery the following reply was written by Lieutenant W. A. Bartlett, U. S. N., to Don Jose de la Rosa, Vallejo's representative:
"Sir: You will say to General Vallejo, on my part, that I at once and entirely disavow this movement as having proceeded under any authority of the United States, or myself as the agent of my Government in this country, or on this coast. It is a movement entirely local, and with which I have nothing to do ; nor can I in any way be induced to take part in the controversy which belongs entirely to the internal policies of California.
"If they are Americans, as they avow themselves, they arc beyond the laws and officers of the United States, and must now take all the responsibilities in which they have placed themselves, being answerable to the laws of Mexico and California.
"I have now for the first time heard of this movement and in making the most positive disavowal, for myself and for my Government, as having in any wise instigated or aided this. I also disavow the same on the jiart of Captain Fremont, United States topographical engineer, now in the country for scientific purposes.
"If my individual efforts can be at any time exercised to allay violence or ])revent injury to innocent ])ersons, it shall be exerted; but as an officer of the
Government of the United States I cannot have anything to do with either party. They must take the responsibiHties of their own acts. From what has already transpired I think it clear that no violence will be committed on any one not found with arms in their hands. You will assure General Guadalupe Vallejo of my sympathy in his <lifficulties; but I positively cannot interfere in the local policies of California."
Commander Montgomery was clearly within the scope of his official dui\ ^as he had not been .sought by Gillespie - but his disavowals gratuitously repeated, showed an interest strongly personal. At that period there was considerable disavowing of Fremont's work, on the part of United States officers. Sloat had to stir himself and follow the Pathfinder's lead and take Monterey, then he disavowed, and resigned his naval command in the Pacific, which did not save him from the departmental reprimand, he received for his delay. Stockton took his place, and in the intervals between some tough fights with the Californians in the southern portion of the state, did his share of the disavowing. General Phil Kearny, the conqueror of New Mexico, marched into California late, but early enough to disavow Fremont's action. Shubrick, another commodore, had his ship on the coast long enough to also do some disavowing. Colonel R. B. Mason came last and disavowed, but as he was inspector of troops possibly this was somewhat along the line of his duty. However, they all did more or less disavowing of each other. At one time during the conflict, California had two military governors, and as they were antagonistic to one another, the territory appeared to be back in its normal condition under Mexican' rule. Colonel Philip Cooke, one of the latest arrivals, amusingly describes that prevailing condition : "Colonel Kearny is supreme somewhere up the coast. Colonel Fremont is supreme at Pueblo de los Angeles, Commodore Stockton is supreme at San Diego. Commodore Shubrick the same at Monterey ; and I at San Luis Rey ; and we are all supremely poor, the government having no money and no credit, and we hold the territory because Mexico is the poorest of all."
Commander Montgomery, who had not been schooled in the "secret work" of the administration, might better have remained aboard the Portsmouth and "attended to his knitting," instead of questioning without knowledge the action of an officer in another branch of the service ; as it was he assumed an untenable position, and so places himself on the general record of official error. As his government and that of Mexico were then busily at war, - and he should have been in the "trouble" - his technically-blameless inactivity, his caution, assumption, and hurried proclamation of his government's California policy, show weakly before Fremont's soldierly activity and unerring judgment. The Patlifinder found a broad path by which California walked into the American Union while his brother officers were disavowing him. Yet to Montgomery's credit he supplied the Bear Flag people with United States powder from the "Portsmouth."'
To more fully acquaint himself regarding the situation in Sonoma, Montgomery sent one of his officers, Lieutenant John S. Missroon. to that town. His observation on conditions appears in the fcillowing jiortinn of his report:
'it only remains, sir. for me to add that, so far as I could judge and observe, the utmost harmony and good order prevail in the camp, and that I have every reason to believe that the pledges of kind treatment toward all who may fall into their hands will be faithfully observed. I also enclose copy of a letter which 1 addressed to the Alcalde while 1 was at Sonoma, which copy is as follows:
'Sir: A^ \-ou were informed yesterday, through my interpreter, my visit to this place is of a strictl} mediatorial character, and was induced by the application of General Vallejo to Captain Montgomery, requesting him to adopt measures for the protection of the females and peaceable inhabitants of Sonoma.
'I have the pleasure to assure you of the intention of the foreigners now in arms and occupying Sonoma, to respect the persons of all individuals and their ]jroperty, who do not take up arms against them, and I leave with you a copy of the pledge which the commander of the party has voluntarily given to me, with a view to the pacification of all alarm.' I also enclose copy of Commander William R. Tde's pledge :
Jo The .Vlcalde Of Sonoma
'I pledge myself that I will use my utmost exertion to restrain and prevent the men in arms under my command, all of whom present acknowledge my authority and approve the measure of forbearance and humanity, from perpetrating any violence, or in any manner molest the peaceable inhabitants, in person or property, of California, while we continue in arms for the liberty of California. (Signed) Wm. B. Ide, Commander.' "
While the naval commander at Yerba Buena in an unofficial way sought to counsel kindness and moderation on the part of the Americans toward the people of the pueblo, there was not at any time the slightest danger that the Sonomans would be ill-treated. W'illiam B. Ide. a man of sterling worth and considerable culture, -seemed to shape and control the conduct of those under his command. .\nd this was no simple task, as his force largely included men unaccustomed to restraint and not sufficiently posted as to the cause and object of the movement and consequent!}- often disposed to oppose measures they did not understand. Ide was a native of Ohio, came across the plains, reaching Sutter's Fort in October, 1845. Military Governor R. B. Mason, June 7, 1847, appointed him land surveyor for the northern district of California and in addition he was Justice of the Peace at Cache Creek. He received the grant of the Rancho Barranca Colorado, in Colusa county. Ide practiced law and was elected County Judge of Colusa county, September 3. 1851. He died at Monroeville. December 18. 1852, aged fifty years.
Country Without A Fi,Ag
Aiier General \'allejo and the other captured officers had been dispatched to Sutter's Fort under the escort of Captain Ide, Merritt, (irigsby, Hargrave. Kit Carson and several others, the "squatters" as General \'allejo might have called them, started out to look over their claim. They were new at Statemaking - that is when the fabric is built up in a night, or in a morning - before breakfast, it was an accumplishmenl somewhat larger than stocking a rancho or furnishing a farm. .\s to her defensive properties Sonoma was mjt a
Gibraltar, and the several hundred slielt-worn muskets and other weapons in the place, seemed anything but dangerous to the Americans whose long rifles, many of them, had been tested in places where a miss meant the finish of the shooter. The chief government building in a Spanish town is called a citadel - Castillo ; a Spaniard ma_\ run shy on many accomplishments but he may be trusted to fill in on names. The investigators found the battery - nine or ten old brass cannon, each piece lying prone across the adobe wall as if the soul of war within the gun was dead. Vallejo almost to the tear-point had pleaded for better armament for Sonoma and the northern frontier, as protection against undesirable immigration, and the Supreme Government of Mexico had ordered him to shoot pronunciamientos at the invading strangers. But out on the plaza this board of inspection found something more alive - the national ensign of Mexico. A soldado viejo of the southern republic had stolen out in the halflight and hoisted the bit of bunting to the top of the staff. For hours, unnoticed by the strangers passing below, the little flag, still faithful to the cause it served but could not saAC, saucily Haunted its eagle and its red, white and green in their faces.
This reminded ihcm that they were yet without a goveriiiiienl standard. They were North American.-; and would have raised their red, white and blue when they lowered the red, white and green, but Fremont had advised them not to do so, fully knowing that as they were not acting umler the formal authorization of the United States government, such action would raise the ever-ticklish question of neutrality. Mexico had fiercely complained of the raising of the American flag at Monterey, four years before, and Commodore Ap Catesby Jones, U. S. N., had been made the convenient scapegoat - faithful government servants frequently are - to appease the Mexican minister at Washington. So the Pathfinder, when he induced the historical Thirt}-three to visit Sonoma that June day-dawn knew, - even though he was obeying a secret order, its official existence not to be revealed, the office and the honor of the scapegoat for him was a strong possibility. But he anticipated the interference of the United States naval forces on this coast and again his judgment averted what would have been to the revolutionists an awkward international situation. This does not infer that their situation apparently was not tending in that direction, or that Captain Fremont in his surveyors' camp on the American river was not anxiously listening for a gun-salute to an American flag waving over Yerba Buena. If the expected war had not taken place it is possible that presently the rough-riders of the Bear, with their cub-republic, born at break o' day, would have been moving out of the pueblo with President Santa Ana's Mexican cavalry in the vicinity. Not only is all's well that ends well, but, at least in this case, all's well that begins well, for an American army was then fighting its way toward the City of Montezuma. The insurgents, revolutionists, filibusters or whatever they may be called, had "guessed" aright, and the California grizzly, strolling (en passant) leisurely along the folds of their flag, was umpired in - safe.
Yet this movement, new and in advance of the wisdom of the period, this forerunner of the change that was to awake the sleeping territory to progress, came in for adverse judgment from the jxiliticians orbing around the national ca])ita]. The inconsistencx of this decision can be seen in the receptions of the two states that came to the northern repubHc during that decade. Texas, not menaced by a foreign power, and barely justified in her action, won complete independence from Mexico and then almost immediately offered herself to the Union. She was admitted, a slave state, by a whig administration whose central creed was anti-slavery. California, a ripe plum falling to a British squadron, her long length of ocean-shore to become a line of foreign fortifications whose guns would train eastward toward the American frontier and her then miserable system of government promising to be a constant thorn in the side of her neighbor over the wall of the Sierras, was encouraged to separate from the southern republic by a democratic administration in the face of a strong protest from these same whigs. The protesting statesmen, after the war, proposed that California be sold back to Mexico for $12,000,000, and if agreeable to the other party, the United States to retain San Francisco, shore and bay, allowing Mexico $3,000,000 on account. As this government by the treaty had assumed a Mexican debt of fifteen millions of money due American citizens, these diplomats of finance considered that they were proposing a highly profitable real estate deal. Shortly after this, Marshall, digging a sawmill ditch in Coloma creek, struck his pick into a nest of nuggets and next day California's market value went up to nearer twelve hundred millions in gold, and to a moral figure that can never be estimated.
Provenance
Text from History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.