Sonoma County, California - Chapter 35, 1911
From History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. 2,423 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,423 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Tragedy Of The Vigilance Committee Bell
Matt Doyle is historical because of his connection with that famous historical relic, the Vigilance Committee bell. He was christened Manville in the dawn of a long-ago Illinois day, and on the records in the Doyle family Bible (for eighty-one years) it has been Manville. But in the rough-and-tumble times of the "roaring forties" the name was too long for speedy utterance, and it is Matt. On the epitaph of the bel! should appear two other names - George Pearce and J. B. Southard, who years ago left to attend a court where casecontinuances are unknown, and where the time-penalty is eternity. The noted sound-maker was brought from San Francisco to Petaluma and hung in the steeple of the Baptist church for missionary purposes. Like a sister-bell in Philadelphia it was cracked during Hfe, but these coincident facts spring from causes unlike. It was in the early '60s that the Petaluma followers of John the Baptist awoke to the double fact that from their empty belfry no voice went crying in the wilderness; and from the steeple of the Methodist church in another part of the town clanged insistent calls to repentance. This was a sad reflection on their seeming indifference, and a local "association" was held to settle the bell question. In that meeting there was an intensity of purpose and unanimity that made the atmosphere of the hall vibrant, and the word "bell" was spoken so frequently that the room rang as though a Poe recital had broken loose there. Matt Doyle was chairman self-appointed, and led in the argument, pro and con. He said in the preliminary that he had been raised a Campbellite, but "there was damned little difference between a Baptist and one of old Alexander Campbell's folks - the same water would do for both providing there was plenty ot it.'' Then he further cheerfully swore that a bell was as necessary in a Baptist settlement as is a Jordan, and Parson Jehu Barnes was so filled with the pointed expression of the sentiment that he neglected to rebuke the speaker because of his unchurchly language. Next Lord's day the Rev. Jehu followed up with a powerful sermon on the prevailing spiritual deafness of the Petalumans, also on the crying need of a bell to arouse them tn a sense of their deplorable moral condition.
The great cleavage of Civil strife reached westward across the continent, and "north" or "south" held jubilee when the bulletin of battle jarred along the wires. Petaluma being above Mason and Dixon's fateful parallel, the good churchmen of that city in faith as of old, saw Jehovah, a deity militant, leading the federal squadrons when the bird of victory fluttered over the northern bayonets ; when the dispatches pictured the gray warriors unsuccessfully sabering the troopers in blue, it was a case where the God of Battles in His inscrutable wisdom permitted the hosts of the unrighteous to prevail. But the southrons of Petaluma didn't observe strikingly this theory of providential com- mission or omission. Such celebrations were safer up in the alleged "rebel" town of Santa Rosa, where they sang "Dixie" witli a thunderous "anvil chorus" every time General "Jeb" Stuart raided Union territory. In the sacred precincts of the Petaluma Baptist church the dove of peace cooed for "a scrap." Doyle and his kinsmen, the Barnes, were northern democrats, and were contraband. When the bell-question was ringing through the sanctuary, the other side of the divisional aisle did not respond in hearty choral "amens," but Matt, though he was the proprietor of two big livery stables and a string of running horses, did not lose faith. He went out among the ungodly and passed the hat. The collection amounted to $500. He was chosen to make the purchase, and in San Francisco found the old Vigilance bell, lying dumb in cold storage since Fort Gunnybags was dismantled. He quickly concluded the bell that had rang Casey, Cora and other hard men of a hard period into another world, would be capable of ringing the most flinty-hearted Petaluma abolitionist at least into a lively sense of sin and his soul's peril. Under the potent spell of this inspirational reasoning he sought Conroy, O'Connor & Co., and bought the bell. They dug it out of the junk-pile of a generation, and Matt paid the price - $550. He added the four golden eagle-birds needed on the bill of sale, and another eaglebird for freight and drayage, and brought the fine old instrument home. He was exceedingly regretful as the steamer came plowing up the tule-bordered estero, that he could not ring the bell and make a joyful noise, and fittingly announce its coming and his triumphant return. But it was packed in a crockery-crate and its far-sound melody muffled with straw.
Its Golden Voice Fills The Vali.Evs
The splendid bell in its new office filled the bill, and its golden voice filled all Petaluma and Two Rock valleys with persuasive calls to repentance. After its long silence it spoke as never tongue spake - at least in Petaluma. When the soft Sabbath winds blew up the great central llano the back-sliding Santa Rosans were awakened to a consciousness of spiritual shortcomings, and out on the Bodega beaches when the breeze went westward, its treble-harmonies blended with the deep organ-bass of the bellowing sea. It had been a "loud alarum bell" with its hollow dies irae falling on a startled city when tragedy struck the brazen key, now its steeple trembled in the sweet invitational vinite domine. or rocked in the harmonic reverberations of a grand gloria in excelsis. But the Petaluma mission of the bell was not to be only peace and good will to men. It clanged an exultant monody when Death harvested the federal regiments on Shiloh's shell-plowed field : and when the southern chivalry was halted in the gory trenches of Gettysburg a jubilee rolled impartially from that sounding rim in "molten golden notes." Soon the bell was a storm-center around which the sympathizers of secession and abolition revolved like two factions of belligerent bees. The ringing wrought confusion. Announcement of regular Sunday service was attributed to a gunboat skirmish on some Mississippi bayou, or to a guerrilla raid across Kentucky's dark and bloody ground. Call for the Wednesday night prayer-meeting started a fierce non-sectarian contention that raged from McNear's wharf to the Revere house, that was anything but divine in character. Such militant worldliness was not to the moral uplift of the church, nor to the healthful placidity of the non-religious. The spiritual and political became jumbled together in this clash of creeds, and the godly were cori84 HISTORY OF SONOxMA COL'XTY rupted by evil communication, and overhead the great bell calm in the dark, cobwebby crypt of the steeple boomed its metallic messages to a discordant world. It may be said that this confusion of office - confusion of bell-tongue - was caused largely by a change in the office of the bell. It became lowered in dignity to a "town bell;" placed on a civic and social par with the public pump and the street-sweeper. Its additional duties were to tell Sonoma county - also a portion of Marin - just when the Petaluma common council met to provide a new hydrant ; when some citizen's house in that burg was beginning to burn down ; or when the small boy to dodge the curfew-cop must seek the shelter of the maternal wing. This over-time arrangement doubtless was convenient, but it was the moral ruin of the bell.
Matters went from bad to worse as the war-clouds went from dark to darker. Petaluma was "union" from the creek to the graveyard - just put on the real estate market - back of town, but Santa Rosa was notoriously "disloyal" and there was strong talk of arresting the county-seat and confining it in Alcatraz. Petaluma's ulterior designs on that same county-seat began when Petaluma was a civic baby prattling to the mud-hens on her creek. When the Bear Flaggers that early morning, June 14, 1846, pulled down Xallejo's Mexican red, white and green in the Sonoma plaza and then drank up all his mission brandy, they found two brass i8-pounders lying across the adobe wall, their warlike throats choked with last-year swallow-nests. Lieutenant Joseph W. Revere, U. S. N., tried to get the pieces aboard the "Portsmouth" then at Yerba Buena, with the object of having them mounted at Annapolis for the fighting-inspiration of the naval cadets. He employed Jim McQiristian, the sole-surviving Bear Flag maker, now living at Sebastopol in this county, to get the guns down to Embarcadero. The ancient trucks under the pieces wouldn't revolve and McChristian's oxen balked on the haul, and Revere lost his souvenirs. Mac was eighteen years old when he and Midshipman John E. Montgomery, the 18-year-old son of Captain John Montgomery of the "Portsmouth," dragged that battery out of Sonoma, - but that is another story. The gallant middy soon after was killed by hostile Indians near Sutter's Fort under circumstances similar to the killing of the French Prince Imperial by the Zulus in Africa years later, - and that's another story. McChristian's claim for that haul has slept in its War Department pigeon-hole for sixty-three years. - and that is still another story.
One of these brazen death-dealers turned up on Petaluma creek - how, no man knoweth - the battery of a low, rakish scow-schooner, possibly to be used in the capture of the Santa Rosa court-house. Major James Armstrong who had won his shoulder-straps with Dave Farragut and Zachary Taylor, had the "rookies" of the Hueston Guard all-rationed for the invasion, and Doyle had three Lexington colts with two-minute records, in his stable saddled day and night for a Paul Revere ride to Santa Rosa the moment Petaluma took the warpath. Jehu Barnes had been declared heretical and a parson late from a Boston conservatory of divinity was holding down the pulpit of St. John the Baptist. Tinctured with the literature of Harriet Beecher Stowe. he considered every "secesh" in the church a Legre. and threatened those unorthodoxies with expulsion from close communion, till Bill Barnes, the "Jack Hamlin" of the day.
loaded his old-style Colt's and swore he would maintain his full membership if he had to shoot every "black abolitionist" out of the church. The assassination of Lincoln rushed matters to a climax, and one night the bell disappeared from the steeple. Next day several "abductors" were haled before Justice of the Peace John Edward Cavanagh, and George Pearce with his "alibis" and "habeas corpuses" and "nolle prosequis" and citations from the Code Napoleon kept the court busy till after candle-light. Then the "kidnapers" not in custody, made another visit to the steeple and cleaned it out, carrying away the bell-frame, wheel and rope. If Pearce had not gone the limit of his "motion" privileges, or could have kept Cavanagh longer from his dinner, the Barnes adherents would have abducted the church. Then Matt Uoyle bailed out the accused and the matter went over ad infinitum. The cases were settled out of court and the bell and its appurtenances were found in the Baylis warehouse under a pile of potatoes. The recovered was returned to its place and packages of blood-curdling warnings were freely handed to future kidnapers.
One night not long after this event a single, short, sharp note clanged out from the steeple, and then all was still. Next day somebody rung the bell and instead of the expected round, throbbing tone, a harsh, discordant clangor broke out of the place. The bell had been broken, presumabl}- with a heavy hammer, and a wide crack running upward from the rim of the instrument, which could not be closed, nor in any manner repaired, forever ruined the grand relic. That final note was the death-shriek, the human-like protest of the dying, as the soul of melody tore itself out of the mutilated shell and went sobbing away in the night. The jarring clamor that in after years came from that steeple was condemnatory of the act destroying on one stroke that golden voice which was wont to roll in ever-widening chord-waves over leagates of rancho, - over mesa and vale, to fall afar like a great benediction. Though melody will come to that ruined rim nevermore, - how the funereal plaints of bells and ravens and Annabel Lees blend and whisper into recollection when the mind conjures up that melancholy singer whose life-song was a threnody and whose life-day was tlie shadow of death, - though silence broods in its "sounding cells," neither time nor vandal hand can mar its splendid record. Grand bell, - ancient herald of law and order, annointed prophet of peace and hope, its harmonies fireborn and fire-toned when its constituent-earths were annealed and its "sounding cells" were molded into graceful form, - is' there no crypt of honor for it now?
George Ross who taught the first young Petalumans to dance gracefully and then photographed them in artistic poses, B. B. Munday, and John Augustus McNear, '56, household names in Petaluma, hung up their hats in town. Next year Isaac Bernhard, Conrad Poehlmann, John Cavanaugh and J. B. Hinkle attached themselves to the fortunes of the new settlement. The latter gentleman assumed the proud title of "the most popular man in Petaluma." The incident which authorized this distinction occurred in this wise: While absent in the southern portion of the state he became sick, and finally it was reported that he had died. Before a second report announced the error of the first, the newspapers had published the usual beautifully-worded biography of the deceased - an innocent little weakness of editors. When Mr. Hinkle returned home like "one arisen," he humorously proclaimed his astonishment at his own nobility of character and his great popularity, though unfortunately, he said, he never learned of these facts until he died. During "58, '59- '60, W. B. Haskell, W. H. Pepper, H. H. Atwater, B. F. Tuttle. F D. Starke. Kelly Tigh. John W. ;\IcNear, were first seen around town. It mu.st not be understood that these names comprise a list of Felaluma's "solid" men. even during the ten years of '50-'6o. There are others. The> have passed. - some from recollection, because those who might have recollected them have also passed. Under repainted sign-names are the names of men who were formerly in busines.s here and those -disappearing names have since appeared in the marl^le on the "Hill."
Provenance
Text from History of Sonoma County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.