BlockBefore

Stockton, California - History (part 4 of 9)

From A History of Stockton from Its Organization Up to the Present Time, Including a Sketch of San Joaquin County : Comprising a History of the Government, Politics, State of Religion, Fire Department, Commerce, Secret Societies, Art, Science, Manufactures, Agriculture and Miscellaneous Events Within the Past Thirty Years, published 1880. 15,989 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

4 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,989 words

Machine-read from scans of A History of Stockton from Its Organization Up to the Present Time, Including a Sketch of San Joaquin County : Comprising a History of the Government, Politics, State of Religion, Fire Department, Commerce, Secret Societies, Art, Science, Manufactures, Agriculture and Miscellaneous Events Within the Past Thirty Years, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Many of the negroes now living on the San Joaquin were brought here by their masters . Emanuel Quivers, an aged man of family and projjerty, died here in 1879 . He was brought to the State by Colonel Fremont. Governor Bradley brought a deaf and dumb girl known as Eliza, and by him she is said to have had children. In 1850 Mr. Fairbanks brought five negroes from the East, He took them to the mines, and the four men worked for their freedom, paying him $1,000 each. The negro woman afterwards married a white man. Many others in this city and county were brought to the State as slaves, and bought their freedom .

The State of California rapidly increased in population, wealth, commercial importance and agricultural products under the well framed constitution for thirty years. Then it was that the Republican party, by a long continued lease of twenty years of political power, became wedded to the offices of the State, and a change was needed. Long continued power, in official life, gives a feeling of security, and security produces selfishness of thought and purpose . A change of party had no lasting effect, and the political wheels only cut the deeper. Taxes were too high and were assessed unequally. Officers with high salaries were unnecessarily created; the appointed offices of the State were given to a chosen few, and these were taxed for the purposes of defraying the expenses of political campaigns. Gigantic schemes of fraud by corporations were passed as laws by the legislatures. Bribes were given and votes were bought by the thousands to control elections, and the people demanded a change.

Then arose a party under the leadership of Denis Kearney, called the Workingmen's Party, and they demanded a reform^ The burden of their song has been a reduction of salaries and equal and uniform taxation. The Legislature of 1878 provided for the calling of a Constitutional Convention . Delegates to that Convention met in Sacramento early in 1879. The Workingmen had no party in San Joaquin county, and the delegates were elected from the Republican and Democratic parties. Messrs. W. L. Dudley and J. R. W. Hitchcock were from the Republican, and John B. Hall and David S. Terry from the Democratic ranks. In the Convention D. S. Terry deserted the party that elected him, and had acknowledged him as a leader for over thirty years, and joined the hybrid party of Workingmen . The new Constitution was adopted by the Convention March 3, 1879. It was ratified at the polls by the people in May, and at 12 o'clock m., January 1, 1880, the old organic law of the state passed into history, freighted with the joys, sorrows, hopes, disappointments, successes and reverses of a people that are still sailing on the sea of time under the new Constitution, expecting to reap still greater blessings than before, and to leave them unimpaired to their children.

Chapter Xi

All governments of civilized nations must have three separate departments of law, viz: a law-giving or legislative; a law interpreting, or judicial, and a law enforcing, or executive . These three, acting together under one su- perior head, constitute their political system. In the laws of California we have had three changes: first, the Mexican law; second, the mob law; third, the equitable law. Each has had its jDcriod and sway, and we shall briefly notice the laws of the different periods, giving a few examples of each as we

The government of the State under the two first-named systems has been a disgrace to its early history . Mexico, when she won her freedom from Spain, adopted a constitution similar to our Federal Constitution. Legislative bodies and superior and inferior courts were formed . The supreme government had its seat in the city of Mexico. Each state appointed its own governor. " In default of such appointment the office was temporarily vested in the commanding military officer of the department." California, being so far away from Mexico, the home government appointed a separate government, denominated the territorial government, or departraental assembly. This department had its cajoital at Monterey and consisted of a Governor and a council of seven, who had limited power to pass laws of a local nature. The powers and duties of the Grovernor were limited and defined by the laws . He was allowed a secretary, whose duties were also properly defined. The superioi- court was also part of this system, and consisted of four judges and a fiscal. The Territory was divided into districts, and each district contained a court of the first instance, Alcaldes, local justices of the peace and town councils. The Alcaldes had concurrent jurisdiction among themselves in the same districts, but were subordinate to the higher courts. Prefects and Sub- Prefects were officers appointed in each district, who were to maintain public order and execute the laws, their duties being similar to those of the marshals and sheriffs of the present day. Each court was entitled to a clerk, and the salary of the judge, $1,500 per annum, was paid by the Governor. The town council had the same duties to perform that our municipal councils now have, only their duties were more extended. They were to watch the quali- ties of groceries, liquors, drugs, etc., offered for sale; care for the hospital; guard against contagious diseases; submit to the prefect an account of all the births, marriages and deaths; see that there was an abundance of water for the use of the inhabitants, and establish common schools. There were forty articles, all relating to the town council. The Legislature had the power to pass laws for the levying of taxes for these objects, the fund being known as the municipal fund. Commodore Sloat recognized this system, and in a proclamation said (referring to this court): " "With full confidence in the honor and integrity of the inhabitants of the county, I invite the Alcaldes, judges and other civil officers to execute their functions as heretofore, that the public tranquillity be not disturbed, at least, until the Government of the Territory be more definitely arranged . "

The laws then in force were crude, imperfect and little understood by the legal fraternity. They were liable to be misconstrued, and many very curious decisions have been given. The various branches of Mexican jurisprudence in this county were Alcaldes, Prefects, and courts of the first instance, and we shall notice each in order.

The word Alcalde is of Spanish origin, and is the same as Justice of the Peace. The Alcalde's court seems to have been more of a farce than the higher courts. The Alcalde courts were influenced by friendship, bribery and fraud; and when the mob took possession (a common occurrence) woe be to him on trial if he was without friends or money, for his case was hopeless.

The town of Stockton being inhabited but a short time previous to the admission of the State, the Territorial Government is brief . The first Alcalde was George G. Belt, and he signs himself as such September 20, 1849. The next was Judge Reynolds, followed by Benj. Williams. These two men were corrupt and dishonest. When the constable brought a prisoner for trial the question was asked whether the culprit had any money. If the constable said that he did not know, he was ordered to search the prisoner, and if he had no money to let him go. Judge Townsend was in office in the time of Judge Reynolds, but was honest, upright and merciful.

The courts of these officials were not held in any particular locality, but were changed about from place to place to suit the convenience of the judge, the financial interests of that official being the moving force , In the Spring of 1849, the place of holding Alcalde court was on board a brig lying in the harbor. In later times it was no unusual occurrence for the corner of a store, tent or hotel to be turned into a temporary courtroom. The judge would often be seen sitting on a barrel of pork, hard tack or whisky, administering justice. The whisky shop was often made to do duty as a court of justice.

We give an instance of the mode of administering justice for a number of years. This incident took place while Judge Reynolds was in office. The Central Exchange, a building 30x60, was built in 1849 on the southeast corner of Main and Center streets by J. B. Nye and Samuel Geddes, at a cost of $14,000. It was built of wood, the floor of Oregon pine and hewn smooth after its arrival in Stockton. The roof was covered with shingles posting $30 per 1,000. This place was occupied as a saloon, and the first piano ever heard in Stockton thrilled with pleasure the gambling crowd that assembled here . A noted gambler named Bob Collins had rented the tables for $1,000 per month, for the purpose of opening a gambling house . These tables he sub-let to other parties at $10 per hour. Business not being as lively as he anticipated, he hit upon a novel plan to increase his profits and the receipts of the bar. Walking down on the levee, he learned that Judge Reynolds was holding court on board a store-ship. Being acquainted with the Judge, he planned it with tlie proprietor of the saloon to ask Eeynolds to hold his court there, for, says Bob, " if we can get him up here it will draw a crowd to court, and we can do a way up business." It was agreed that the Judge could occupy the attic as a bedroom free of cost. That day Bob saw the Judge, and they walked down to the Exchange and took a drink - a thing which the Judge was never known to refuse to do. Bob broached the subject, showed the many advantages of location, room, etc., lodgings for the Judge thrown in, and they took a drink . The Judge acquiesced in the arrangement, and moved his office goods, consisting of a table, bed, pen, ink and an old book of Spanish law, to his new quarters. Everything was harmonious in this court, saloon and monte bank, until one day an action came before the court in which Bob Collins was an interested party. It happened that a young man who was a sharper, and shrewd at monte and faro, "broke a bank" just below the saloon and came and deposited the money in Collins' bank until the next day. He came the next morning and said to Bob, "I will take my money." " Why, you are joking." "No, I am not," said the depositor, " I want my money." Says Bob: " You have left money here before, and never have called for it, and what failed to hand it over, and a suit was begun. Witnesses were called to prove that he had never called for his money before. While this investigation was going on, the voice of Bob was heard: " Come right up, gentlemen; this is the place to get your money back . " The Judge, stern and dignified, sat in his arm-chair, elevated on a dry goods box. No decision could be made, and finally some one suggested a division of the money. "I want my fee out of this," said counselor Terry. "And I shall have my fee," said lawyer Perley, putting his hand behind him as if to draw a weapon. In an instant fifty hands went down for pistols and knives. The Judge, seeing the state of affairs, stepped down to where the money was lying and pulled it into his hat, filling it nearly, and at the same time re- everybody rushes over into that corner and leaves me all alone." In order to get the Judge out, he got him into a game of poker, won all of his money by putting up aces on him, and then called on the Prefect, George D.Dickenson, to put him out. The poor old Judge, whose love for whisky had brought him to this condition, never resumed practice, but went to Mexico and was never heard of more.

In pioneer work in a State but little attention is given to science, Man's physical wants first demand his attention. In the rush for gold, Kent and Blackstone were laid aside as of no value. But in arriving here the lawyers found their profession more lucrative than the pick and shovel; and, abandoning the search for gold in the mines, they engaged in the pleading of law in the town . As their law books of reference were left in their distant homes, they were obliged to rely on memory. The only law book in town was an old Spanish law book, the property of Judge Beynolds, he having brought it from Mexico. As there were few Americans who could read Spanish, Reynolds read the law and interpreted it to suit himself.

The Mexican court system also comprised district courts, known as " courts of the first and of the second instance." In San Joaquin only the " court of the first instance " was in existence.

San Joaquin district being sj)arsely inhabited previous to the rush for gold, there was no necessity for law or courts, and no records are to be found previous to those of October, 1849. The first records show that on the 8th of October, 1849, the case of Belesario Martinez vs. Dr. Jelly was brought from the court of the second Alcalde on appeal. Hon. Judge Belt was Judge of the Court of First Instance, J. G. Marshall was Sheriff, S. Haley was Clerk and Thos. B. Van Buren was District Attorney. The earliest criminal case on record is the case of The Peoj^le of Upper California vs. John Tracy, for the murder of Dennis

Mahon. The first murder was committed by James McKee, he killing B. K. Thompson in January, 1848. These two men were among the first settlers upon the grant. Thompson was a gambler, and is said to have killed three men previous to coming here. He was arrested and taken to Sutter's fort for trial and was acquitted. Returning to the town, he was shunned by all, and soon afterward started overland for the States. On the way he became involved in a difficulty with one of the party, and was shot dead and left unburied for the coyotes to pick.

The history of these gamblers who infested the State in early times, killing men for their own pastime, has been traced through to the present time, and in nearly every instance they have " died with their boots on" - a common expression for saying that they have died at the hands of violence.

The minutes of the case of The People vs. Tracy show the uncertainty then prevailing relative to the jurisdiction and practice of the courts and the validity of the laws. It appears from the records that the District Attorney indicted the man for murder and arraigned him for immediate trial, when counsel for the accused appeared and objected to the proceeding. The prisoner, however, was placed on trial, and Messrs. Lyons, Fair, Brooks and Creanor, counsel for the accused, apj^eared and objected to the jurisdiction of the court, on the ground that the court is not so constituted as to give the criminal the rights guaranteed by the constitution of the United States, alleging also that there had been no action of a grand jury.

The court sustained the objection, and the Sheriff summoned a grand jury of sixteen men. This grand jury, after taking a peculiar oath, returned into court the following day and presented an indictment against Tracy. The prisoner was thereupon arraigned and required to plead; but his counsel refused to have him jDlead, and moved for a change of venue, which motion was denied by the court. They then movtd for a continuance on affidavits showing the absence of important and material witnesses, who could not be had on a summary trial; but the court refused to grant a continuance, and a jury was duly imjpaneled to hear and determine the case. The counsel then raised the question, " What law is in existence and should prevail in this case ?" After hearing argument on both sides, the court decided that the Mexican laws were in force, except such as were in conflict with the . laws and constitution of the United States. The jury, after hearing the evidence, speedily acquitted the defendant.

Reynolds was succeeded by Benjamin "Williams, who served until the organization of the United States Courts. The judicial acts of Belt had their influence in debasing the early jurisprudence of San Joaquin county. In 1850 Judge Belt and Cajotain D. S. Terry were about to fight a duel about a man named Dr. Roberts, alias Captain Yeomans.

This man had obtained the confidence of young Terry and was a particular friend. Belt Vv'as the first to learn - that Roberts was neither a physician nor a lawyer, but a bandit from Mexico. His aspersion on the companionship of Terry was resented by Terry, and a duel was arranged. On the field of honor an explanation was held, and Terry and Belt each lived to fight other duels.

Judge Belt was said to be the leader of mobs and a violator of law and order, degrading his office in the interests of friends, often giving unjust decisions. He removed to Mariposa, and coming to Stockton in 1869, was shot and killed by Wm. Dennis. The evidence on the trial showed the existence of an old feud between them. They had agreed to settle it by an affair of honor, but the testimony in the case showed that it was a deliberate murder, and that Belt was unaware of Dennis' presence when killed. Dennis was sent to State's Prison for eight years, and died in twenty months from old age, sickness and grief.

their State government, it was to be presumed that mob law, the bribery of judges, the menacing of juries and cruelty to culprits would jDass away; but all great evils must be eradicated slowly and surely.

The judiciary is justly regarded as the highest branch of a political system, and from its decisions there is no appeal. Hence their decisions should be founded on law, equity and justice. In measuring justice to the oppressor or the oppressed, the court should stand aloof from the influence of individual or party, and above passion or prejudice . It is therefore a difficult matter to write a history of the judiciary, when men were bitterly opposed to each other, and sectional feelings controlled elections. Judges are but human, and the power of money and influence was brought to bear strongly in many cases where the punishment of the accused would better have subserved the public interests. The high-handed outrages perpetrated on society by ruffians, which lead to the formation of vigilance committees, show a lax system of administering justice.

That the judiciary were cognizant of these j)roceedings is evident to those best acquainted with the court transactions. The press on one occasion hinted darkly of intrigue between court and criminal, and on another occasion pandered to the sympathy of mob law by justifjdng its acts. Lawyers pleading in the Supreme Court were known to violate the law in the inferior courts by intimidating juries at the mouth of the pistol, and then resume their standing in the higher courts and plead for their friends. So corrupt were some of these courts in thieving and rascality, thac Prefect Dickenson was obliged in one instance to impeach the judge and close the court.

The Legislature on February 19, 1850, divided the state into nine judicial districts. The fifth district comprised Calaveras, Tuolumne, San Joaquin and Stanislaus counties. The courts of the first instance were continued in force until the organization of the district courts, which took joossession of all their records, and jurisdiction of all their actions, and all writs which had been issued out of the courts of the first instance were required to be returned to the district courts of the respective counties, just the same as if they had been issued out of these courts.

The act of February 29, 1850, not only abolished the courts of the second instance and of the third instance, but also transferred all of the business of the courts of first instance to the District Courts, and suspended the power of theAlcaldes in counties having no courts of the first instance, and transferred the same to District Judges.

All the jurisdiction and authority of the Alcaldes was removed upon the election of the Justices of the Peace. By the same act it was provided that the offices of all Prefects and sub-prefects should be suspended and abolished as soon as the judges and sheriifs of the different counties were elected and qualified. All appeals from the Alcaldes' courts were to go to the county courts as soon as the County Judges were elected and qualified, instead of giving to the Prefects the final determination; and all the records of deeds and mortgages which had been kept by the Alcaldes were turned over to the County Clerk and Kecorder.

The District Court originally embracing the counties of San Joaquin, Calaveras, Tuolumne, Stanislaus and Mariposa commenced business on the 13th of May, 1850. Charles M . Creanor was appointed Judge by the Legislature, he leaving that body April 2d to accept the office . It was the duty of an officer known as District Attorney to make the circuit with the District Judge and attend the prosecutions in the various counties. The officers of this Court were Charles M. Creanor, Judge; R. P. Ashe, Sheriff; A. C. Bradford, Clerk, and S. A. Booker, District Attorney. There is nothing of interest in the jurisdiction of this court until the year 1854, at which time the trial of John Taber for the killing of Mansfield took place in the Fall term of the court. This sad, deplorable homicide caused a feeling of sorrow throughout the community, and pioneers look back and regret that two promising, intelligent young men should allow passion to blast the life of one and send the other to an untimely grave. John Ta- ber was proprietor of the Stockton Journal and Mansfield was a partial owner in the San Joaquin Republican. Mansfield was the father of Josie Mansfield, celebrated for her beauty and amours with Fisk and Stokes of New "York.

Articles derogatory of each other, regarding the citj^ printing having been published in each paper, the spirit of anger was aroused . Taber, who was a man of small stature and nervous, excitable temperament and unequal in physical ability to Mansfield, was informed that the latter was armed for him. Arming himself, he avoided Mansfield for a few days, but unexpectedlj^ meeting him on the corner of the present Grand Hotel, on the morning of the 22d of June, 1854, shot Mansfield, from the effects of which he^ died the following day. Taber was immediately arrested by Deputy Sheriff "VYebster, who was on the opposite side of the street, and taken to jail. Taber was confined in jail until the sitting of the District Court, when his trial took place, the officers of the court at this time being Charles M. Creanor, Judge; G. B. Claiborne, Clerk, and Nelson Taylor, Sheriff, his deputy being John H. Webster. On the day of trial Hall & Huggins, assisted by CoL E. D. Baker, appeared for the People, and S. H. Bookerand David S. Terry appeared for the defendant. The triaL occupied two days, the case being given to the jury at halfpast six o'clock on a Saturday evening. In about threehours they came into court with a verdict of guilty, and. recommended the prisoner to the mercy of the Court. Th& Court being compelled to adjourn on Saturday night at twelve o'clock, the term being limited by law to one week,, the Judge could not sentence the prisoner, and he was remanded back to jail to await the sentence of the court in the. January term of 1855. In January fiourt, for various reasons, motion was made by the prisoner's counsel, Messrs^ Terry, Booker and Biggs, to set aside the verdict. The Judge overruled the motion and sentenced the prisoner to be hanged on the 16th day of March. In the meantime^ the honest integrity of the young man doomed to die through a rash act of youthful folly enlisted the sympathies.

Histoey Of Stockton

-of the best class of citizens, and they used strenuous efforts in bis behalf. This we learn from the Republican, which, in a fit of spleen in 1857, smarting under the condemnation of the public for justifying the killing of James King -of Wm. by James Casey, says that "when the editor -IVIansfield was killed no sympathy was expressed for the victim, but now that James King of Wm. is the victim, because we are silent, we are accused of being in league "with the murderers." (See San Joaquin Republican.)

In the meantime great exertions were being put forth to obtain a pardon from the Governor. Citizens, and even ,inany ladies, joined in the j)rayer for executive mercy. Petitions were sent from all j)arts of the State. Everybody - members of the Senate and of the Assembly, ministers of the gospel and ladies pleaded for the life of the condemned man. Nearly 100,000 names were sent to Governor Bigler, and it is said that prayers were offered in the churches that the Executive might temper justice with mercy. Under this great pressure the Governor relented, and a pardon was granted on the 9th of March, 1855. The granting of this pardon was in harmony with the dictates of mercy, but the Executive was influenced more b^ politic than by chajritable motives. It was at the beginning of the long struggle that has since put an end to slavery. Taber was a Whig and Mansfield was a Democrat, and the murder having been caused by political articles, political sympathy .not the first time in history saved the murderer.

Charles M. Creanor, in 1850, took his seat as District -Judge with everything in his favor, indicating a life of usefulness and a brilliant career. Although he had a poor education, and but little knowledge of law, he was, in one vsense, a remarkable man, possessing in a large degree the faculty known as common sense. He was also gifted with intuition, and by these two talents wisely used he gave his decisions from the bench for many years, and they gave general satisfaction. As a judge he might have won a name, honored by the rising generation as an example of judicial excellence, but the love of driuk lias blighted the honest record of his judgeship and left him a wreck on the shadow of his former fame. He was succeeded in 1864 by^ Joseph M. Cavis, a gentleman of purer motives of right, a keener sense of justice and deeper sensibilities of feelingthan are generally accorded to members of the legal fraternity.

Judge Cavis was born in New Hampshire, in 1825, and graduated at Dartmouth College, in 1846. He was admitted to the practice of law before the Supreme Court of New York, in 1848. He emigrated to California in 1853. In June, 1855, he was admitted to practice before all the courts of this State, and entered upon the practice of his. profession in Columbia. He was elected State Senator from Tuolumne and Mono counties. In 1863 he became. Judge of the Fifth Judicial District, serving for the terra of six years.

He removed to Stockton in June, 1870, and practiced law until 1876, when he was appointed Postmaster. During all of his career as judge not a single dishonest act stained his ermine. If he erred it was from judgment and in favor of mercy. Perhaps the kindly feeling and tenderness of the judge cannot better be described than b}'' relating that on one occasion, when passing sentence of death upon a murderer, the trembling voice and tearful eye told of a more convulsive grief in the breast of the j udge than in the heart of the stoical criminal, who laughed in derision at the scene. Judge Samuel A. Booker succeeded Judge Cavis in. 1870.

It was during the administration of Judge Cavis that one of the most important murder trials took place. The case was the one of The People vs. A. M. Swaney and Adelia. Seale. A. M. Swaney, proj)rietor of the Mariposa Gazette and a widower with three children, and Adelia Seale were tried in Mariposa before Judge Deering for the alleged murder of J. W. Seale, her husband, in the fall of 1867. The jury failed to agree, after a trial of two weeks.

Joaquin. On the day of trial, May 6,'1868, the defendants represented by W. L. Dudley, S. A. Booker, Judge JBudd and Judge Jones. For the State were E. S. Pillsbury, D. W. Perley and Judge Burkhalter. The atrocity of the offense and the well known high standing of the criminals created an excitement in the public mind, and the courtroom was crowded every day. For three weeks the <jourt was occupied with the trial, and the evidence was 23honetically reported each day for the Independent. The jury failed to agree, after being out for seventeen hours, and Swaney was admitted to bail. The parties were afterwards cleared, although it was proved that Swaney had purchased prussic acid, which was found in the stomach of the deceased by chemical examination; also, by his own evidence, that he had been reading "Wood's Digest" on the effects of poison. Swaney and his enamored one were married and are still living in this State.

A case of remarkable importance in criminal jurisprudence regarding the soundness of law in convicting on circumstantial evidence was also tried by Judge Cavis .

On about the 12th of May, 1866, Philip Dick, a sheeplierder in the employ of S. M. Simpson, murdered his -employer at the camp in the Coast Range. No person witnessed the deed, but the story of Dick was not corroborated by the facts, and he was arrested and tried by circumstantial evidence alone and previous bad character. He was convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to be hanged. A stay of proceedings was granted, and the Supreme Court reversed the decision of the lower court. A new trial took place, and he was again convicted of murder in the first degree, and again was the decision reversed by the Supreme Court. On his third trial he was again found guilty and sentenced to imprisonment for life. The Supreme Court in this case sustained the judgment, and Dick was taken to San Quentin . Before the expiration of a year he committed suicide by hanging himself in his «ell . This man was in jail for nearly eight years pending his trial, and during that time was defended by Judge

Judge Booker is a pioneer of '49, having arrived in California from his native State, Virginia, in that year. He came to Stockton at the age of twenty-six years, and at once became active in the organization of the citj^ government. In 1850 he was elected the first District Attorney of San Joaquin county, and in 1879 was the last District Judge. His decisions have always been marked by excellence and fairness, and have been sustained by the Supreme Court in nearly every instance. The people, recognizing his ability, failed to nominate any candidate against him for his second term, and had not the new constitution changed the laws, he would probably have served a life term. Regarding neither friend nor foe, he construed the law as he understood it, and his decisions all through the long contested suits of the railroad combination against the peoiDle will be cited in the future as the opinions of an eminent judge and jurist.

One of the most fiendish assassinations ever committed occurred during the term of Judge Booker. Perpetrated without any motive, except, perhaps, that a highly honored citizen and a devoted husband and father might be sent from the earth that a paramour might enjoy the marital bed. At the time of his death, J. P. D. Wilkins was the city collector of Stockton. Returning to his home at a late hour on the 26th of March, 1873, he was struck across the head with a sand-bag, and died the following day, having been insensible from the time of his being found until his death, Mr. Wilkins was a pioneer and had held various official positions in the city, and was high in rank as an Odd Fellow . In his official position and as a citizen he was never known to have an enemy. Various parties were arrested and acquitted, and finally the evidence pointed to the wife and a man in the employ of Wilkins named George Bennett. This woman had many admirers, and her charms had called to her service this man Bennett, who had been lodging in the house for two years previous to the murder.

Bennett was arraigned first, and being a brother-in-law of a judge in Sacramento, Greene Curtis, the best criminal lawyer in the State, was employed to defend him. Two> daughters of the murdered man testified in Bennett's favor but on cross-examination contradicted themselves in several particulars. The other child, much younger in years,, testified to a scuffle at the house on the fatal night, and with all their skill the lawyers were unable to impair her testimony - a remarkable circumstance for a girl only fifteen years of age. The jury failed to agree, and the counsel for the defendant asked for a change of venue to Sacramento. Judge Booker granted the request, and the District Attorney, E. S. Pillsbury, publicly acknowledged that no conviction could be had in the county, and virtually surrendered the case. Bennett was thus acquitted and the charge against Mrs. Wilkins was dismissed .

By the provisions of the new Constitution the District, and County Courts were both abolished and two Superior Courts were formed, neither having any jurisdiction outside of their respective counties. Van E. Peterson, a young man of fine scholarly attainments, legal ability and Christian training, was elected Superior Judge in September, 1879 . He was born in Ogdensburg, New York, and thirty years of age. His early life was s^oent with his parents and in teaching country schools in his native county, St. Lawrence. He is a graduate of the State Normal School at Albany, New York, and for one term was a member of the faculty of that institution. He also graduated from the law school of Union College, and was for several years a student under the direction of Isaac Edwards, Esq., author of "Edwards on Bills and Notes," and during" a portion of his time was Principal of New Providence Academy, New Jersey. In 1875 Jadge Paterson came to California, and after spending one month in Modesto, came to Stockton, where he has since remained in the practice of law. He was a candidate for District Attorney in 1877 and was defeated by the Democratic nominee, "W. L. Hopkins, He was elected City Attorney in 1878 and in.

1879. On January 5, 1880, be took his seat as Suj^erior Judge. He holds the degree of LL.B from Union College, and under his direction during the next five years may justice reach that standard of excellence that all may truthfully say: "Eight has become might.'-'

The Legislature provided for the organization of what was called the "Court of Sessions," as early as April 11, ,1850 . This court was to transact the business heretofore done by the Alcaldes. The court consisted of a County Judge and two associate justices chosen by the justices of the county from among their number. He had jurisdiction throughout all the county in all cases of assault and battery, breach of the peace, petty larceny, and in all cases of misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $500, or imprisonment not exceeding three months, or both fine and imprisonment. It also had in charge such matters as are now managed by the Board of Supervisors. Benj. Williams being at the time Judge of the Court of the First Instance became by election Judge of the Court of Sessions, organizing the Court June 3, 1850, and was the first County Judge under the Constitution, the associate justices being H. Amyx and O. C. Emory.

The law authorized the Court of Sessions to assess taxes, and on the 29th of June an order was issued for all persons engaged in mercantile pursuits to take out a license. This order of the court aroused a spirit of opposition among the merchants, and they were determined to resist any attempt to enforce the demand.

The county having been organized and the officers having been elected, it was necessary to create a fund to sustain them. "All merchants, brokers, owners of hotels, etc., are hereby notified that the Court of Sessions has as- sessed a tax upon tliem, and they are hereby notified to make application to the County Treasurer for a license to carry on such trade or occupation." Licenses ranged from $26 to $250 per annum, and in the same proportion for a shorter period of time, according to the amount of business done, to be judged by the court.

Many thought the act to be an unwarranted usurpation of authority, and a meeting was called for the afternoon of July 18, 1850, to protest against such an unlawful outrage. This meeting was largely attended, and other meetings followed, until a committee of nine was appointed to wait on the County Judge and present the following resolutions : " That the order of the court levying said taxes be immediately erased from the records of the court; that if the above request is not granted, we, the citizens of Stockton, do solemnly pledge our sacred word and honor to resist the enforcement of said order even to the shedding of blood." Other resolutions of the same character were passed by this imjjulsive, misguided body.

Calm and deliberate thought, counseled by mature minds, taught these young pioneers that a tax on business and property was simply a broad, statesmanlike method of supporting the government, approved by the experience of centuries .

The first execution by the court was that of Geo. Baker, who was tried for killing Geo. Turner. Baker was a man twenty-two years of age, and both parties were intoxicated at the time of the stabbing. Baker was tried and convicted, and on the 29th of March, 1851, was hanged, the gallows being erected near the present location of the Franklin school building . This was the first execution in Stockton under the law. James Woods, then pastor of the Presbyterian church, who delivered a sermon on Sunday, June 3, 1851, on the waywardness of this young man, says in his work : ' ' He commenced his downward career by running away from home because his father compelled him to study Latin. After leaving home his career was short. He became a gambler, quarreled with a companion, stabbed him and perished upon the scaffold . Such were the circumstances of the quarrel that he would probably have escaped the gallows, had it not been for the pressure of public opinion."

At the session of the court at which he was tried two atrocious criminals had been acquitted. One of these was Joe Moliere, a boy of fifteen, who it is supposed had killed a man for pay. h. powerful plea was put in for his youth. Extraordinary efforts were made by his lawyers, and finally he was acquitted. This created a storm of indignation. It was amid the raging of the storm that " Mickey " had his trial. Public feeling demanded a victim, and the lot fell upon " Mickey." He was taken to the scaffold on a onehorse dray, and seated beside him on his own coffin was his spiritual adviser. Arriving at the scaffold, in a short speech Baker warned the young " to avoid the path of vice, which had led him to the gallows," and in a few minutes his spirit sped away to the unknown shore.

Four months after this trial Benjamin Williams resigned the office of Judge, and O. C. Emory was appointed to fill the unexpired term. Williams resigned to escape impeachment because his course all through his official term had been " devious, wayward and uncertain." He was put on trial in the District Court for two charges, " bribery and corruption," also for altering the records. In the first charge the District Attorney, C. C. Graugh, entered a nolle prosequi, and he was acquitted of the second through the intriguing of the District Attorney.

Mr. Gaugh was a young man of no ability as a lawyer and weak in character. The Stockton Journal criticised his acts severely, and Mr. Gaugh, feeling himself injured by the article, proceeded to the editor's office to chastise him. They met in the office, and three shots were fired without any serious results. The attorney was arrested and placed under $1,000 bail to keep the peace. The affair was smoothed over, and he escaped punishment. After Williams' resignation, in October, 1H51, Mr. H. TolerBooraem, who was then County Treasurer, was commissioned as

Judge, but not wishing the office, he failed to qualify. In the meantime the friends of Oliver Cromwell Emory were working to get the place for him, although he knew nothing of the principles or practice of law. He was a wagon master in the army and had come to the coast in 1846 with Hichard W. Heath, who was a quartermaster. These men became firm friends. At the close of the Mexican war they came to Stockton and engaged in the livery stable business, and afterwards in running a ferry across the Stanislaus river. They lost money on this last operation, and Mr. Emory came to Stockton to fill, if possible, his depleted jDurse, and intelligent citizens and disgusted lawyers were surprised to see him take his seat as Judge of the Court of Sessions .

Judge Emory, who had been a Justice of the Peace and an associate of Judge Williams, was an honest man, but five months on the bench as the laughing stock of all men taught him that honesty was not the only qualification needed to make a good Judge. Such was the indifference regarding fitness for office, that men were elected to offices which they were not competent to fill, and unfortunately this custom still prevails. Judge Emory resigned and engaged in farming, and Governor Bigler aj^pointed W. A. Root as his successor. J. K . Shafer and B . G. Wier were continued as associates. Judge Root presided at the bench for only a short time. On Thursday evening, October 20, 1852, he presided at a Democratic meeting, and on the following Tuesday the Independent Order of Odd Fellows met to bear him to his last resting place.

Judge Root is the only Judge of San Joaquin county that has died in office. The San Joaquin Republican paid a beautiful tribute to his memory when it said: "A friend to the whole human family is on his way to the better land."

Judge Emory again filled the office of Judge, until the election of his successor, and then again turned his attention to farming. A. Gr. Stokes, a gentleman whose financial abilities were far superior to his legal attainments, was his successor. The office at that time was not a very lucrative one, and the Legislature was petitioned to increase the salary from $3,000 to $5,000 per annum. As soon as the increase of salary was made Shafer became a candidate for the office and was elected.

In 1853, during the term of office of Judge Stokes, the murder of W. A. Brown, the San Andreas express agent, took place. Probably no crime has ever caused more excitement and sympathy for the victim than the murder of this man, on the afternoon of April 1st. Brown was a messenger in the employ of Adams' Express Co . , carrying letters between Stockton and San Andreas. W. L . Bowlin, the assassin, was an employee of the same company in the office at San Andreas, and was on trial for embezzling money, the deceased being a witness against him.. For this Bowlin determined to take the life of his accuser and laid his plans with consummate adroitness. Placing a relay of horses between Stockton and Mariposa, he came to Stockton and fastened his horse near the corner of Eldorado and Levee streets. Meeting Brown near the Independent office on Weber avenue, he fired from a shotgun a load of slugs at him, and, jumping on his horse, fled toward Mariposa. Brown died the following morning. The town was immediately in a great state of excitement. A number of mounted citizens started in pursuit of the villain, but time and sj)eed were both in his favor. On Sunday, April 3d, Brown was buried by the Masons and Odd Fellows. More than two thousand persons followed the remains to the grave. Large rewards were offered for the body of Bowlin, either dead or alive, and large bodies of mounted men were hunting the country about Marij)osa for the fugitive. The following rewards were offered:

Bowlin was discovered a few days after this occurrence in the mountains near Mariposa, on foot and alone, by S. J. Gregory, Irvin H. McBride, Isaac Lyons and Joseph Brown. When the party were within 30 yards of Bowlin, he said: "I suppose I am the person whom you are after." Mr. Lyons replied that he was. Laying down his pistol and knives, he remarked: " Come and take me," and immediately swallowed the contents of a vial of poison. Lyons remarked " He has taken poison." " I have; I am desperate," he said; and seizing his pistol he warned them off, and in a few minutes died. Such was the end of this desperate man; a man who in the path of rectitude would have made his mark, for in this last act he displayed firmness of purpose which few care to meet.

J. K. Shafer, who had been an Associate Judge with 0. C. Emory, a District Attorney under Benj. Williams and Judge Creanor, and Mayor of the city in 1853, became Judge in 1854, and held the office until 1862, when George W. Tyler succeeded him.

Judge Shafer is described as a man of fine personal appearance, and one of the brightest minds on the bench. Commanding the confidence of the community for the first two terms of his judgeship, the pleasures of nature took full possession of intellect and character at the age of 40, and the siren charmer led him only to disgrace his fame and character.

In 1862 he went to Idaho and was sent as Territorial Delegate from that Territory to Washington, and a few years afterward died. During his lengthy term of office the following served as Associate Judges : A. C. Baine, J. J, Drummond, R. W. Noble, G. B. Douglass, J. G. Jenkins and A. G. Brown.

In the twelfth session of the State Legislature amendments to the Constitution were proposed and these amendments were adoj^ted by the succeeding Legislature in 1862. One of these amendments abolished the Court of Sessions^ and its jurisdiction was transferred to the District and County Courts. In 1862 the Judge elect who took

Geo. "W. Tj'ler was born in the East, but coming to San Francisco took up his residence in that city and in 1860 came to San Joaquin county, and made himself famous as the "war horse" of San Joaquin. He was a strong Union man and very bitter against the Copperheads. He was plain spoken on the stump and called things by their names, handling the Southern men without gloves. He WftS constantly speaking for the Union party and thus gained his popularity. So earnest was he in the cause that on one occasion before an audience of 2,000 ladies and gentlemen, the night being warm, he pulled off his cravat, then his collar, and finally his coat, amidst tremendous applause from the excited audience. His strong Union, proclivities elected him to the office of County Judge .

Henry B. Underhill succeeded Tyler in 1864. He was born in Troy, N. Y., September 14, 1821. He graduated with high honor from Amherst College, Mass., in 1845. AccejDting a situation as associate principal of the Duaborg Seminary at Warren, Mass., he taught two years, and then removed to Jackson, Miss., where he taught one year as principal of the public school. Removing to Natchez he taught for three years as principal of the Natchez Institute, and then two years as principal of the Oakland College, Oakland, Miss. He removed to St. Louis in 1853, and in February, 1854, he started for California, and arrived in Stockton April 4, 1854, and engaged in the dry goods business as the best thing that offered at the time . "While teaching he had been reading law with the ultimate purpose of practicing. In June, 1860, he sold his half of the dry goods business to Thomas R. Moseley and gave his entire attention to the study of law, and was admitted to jjractice in the District Court, before Judge Creanor, in December, 1860.

He was elected District Attorney by the Republican party in 1861. In 1863 he was elected County Judge and served four years. In 1868 he was admitted to practice before the

Supreme Court, and also before the District and Circuit Courts of the United States, In the same year the Central Pacific Railroad Company were purchasing land for the road, and Judge Undeihill was employed to attend to matters of right of way and other business connected with real estate, which he pursued in connection with his general practice, until January, 1873, when he gave up general practice and, removing to San Francisco, became the right of way and town site agent of the Central Pacific Railroad Company .

During Judge XJnderhill's term of ofiice there were no eases of a!ny special importance. His decisions were concisely given, and always in favor of law and justice. His successor was "W. E. Greene, a young man well versed in the classics, keen in logic and strict in discipline. He was born in Farmington, Maine, on the 14th of November, 1837. He entered Bowdoin College in 1859, and graduated after the usual four year course with the degree of A. B. In 1863 he came to Stockton and at once accepted the j)osition as teacher in the Dr. Collins Seminary, the principal being Mr. Wm. Yan Doren. Choosing the law as his future profession, he was admitted to the bar in 1864. The following year he was elected Assemblyman on the Rej)ublican ticket, and served in the legislative sessions of 1865 and 1866. Returning to private life again, he was elected County Judge and took his seat January 1, 1868. Having served his second term he resigned in May, 1874, to give his attention to private practice. In 1875 Judge Greene removed to Oakland, and in the fall of 1879 was elected one of the superior judges of Alameda county.

Judge Buckley was born in Yirginia in December, 1829. He came to Oregon in 1852. In 1855 an Indian w^ar broke out and he enlisted in the Benton County Volunteers. Taking an active part, he was engaged in several battles, including a four days' fight at "Walla Walla. Soon after this Governor Curry commissioned him with the rank of

Captain and ordered liim to report to Major Lyton at the Dalles. In 1857 he was elected Assessor of Multnomah -county. He was admitted to practice law before the Supreme Court of Oregon in September, 1860. In December of that year he came to San Joaquin county and practiced law here until his appointment as Judge in 1874. In 1875 he was elected to fill the office, and being in office when the new Constitution was ratified, was again elected, and took his seat January, 1880, as one of the superior judges of San Joaquin county.

The evidence of these courts is not yet complete; there are witnesses unknown who will testify, and judgment can- . not be rendered until the verdict is given. The evidence on the trial of Justice vs. Courts thus far tends to show that justice has been given its due, according to the standard of public morality. The law has dealt kindly with some, justly with others and harshly with only a few.

The standard of morals is higher now than ever before . To maintain this standard history will look to the young scions of the law, and in a local work they have a place, for Stockton has now become a city of homes, around which linger associations of children who are now prominent in the active duties of life .

Stanton L. Carter, the present City Attorney, was born in New York in 1853. When nine years of age, his parents removed to California and engaged in farming in San Joaquin county. Young Stanton graduated from the Stockton High School in December, 1871. After this he graduated from Heald's Business College, San Francisco, and returning to Stockton studied law in the office of Byers & Elliott, and was admitted to practice before the Supreme Court of this State in March, 1878.

His schoolmate Louis B. Noble came to Stockton with his parents in 1857, when four years of age. He finished his studies in the public schools, and soon after this he commenced the study of law in the office of Judge Cavis, and was admitted to practice before the Suj^reme Court in 1878. He removed to Walla Walla, Washington Terri- tory, in 1878, and was appointed Deputy District Attorney. He still resides in Walla Walla, where lie is engaged in the practice of his profession.

Wm. M. Gibson, another young Stocktonian practicing law, was born in Covington, Kentucky, July 29, 1851. He has lived in Stockton since 1854, and received his early education in the public schools of the city. In 1863 he attended school in Oakland and afterward he became a law student in Union University, at Albany, New York, and received his diploma in 1874. He returned to Stockton, passed a satisfactory examination before the Supreme Court in August of that year and was admitted to practice. In 1878 and 1879 he served as Deputy District Attorney under W. L. Hopkins.

James H, Budd was born in Wisconsin, May, 1851, and his brother John E. Budd, October 19, 1853. They came to San Joaquin county in 1858, and received their early education in the public schools. James entered the State University in 1869, and, pursuing the scientific course of study, graduated in 1873 with the degree of Bachelor of Science. His brother, possessing a more literary turn of mind, pursued the classical course and graduated one year later with the degree of Bachelor of Arts . Both studied law under their father's guidance, and were admitted by the Supreme Court in 1874 and 1875.

Samuel Langdon Terry was born in Stockton and is twenty-six years of age. Mr. Terry has passed nearly twenty years of his life in his native city and received his education in the public schools. In June, 1872, he began to read law in his father's office and in April, 1875, was admitted to the practice of law by the Supreme Court. He practiced in Stockton until 1878, when he removed to San Jose. After a twenty months' sojourn in that city he returned to Stockton, and is still engaged in the practice of law.

Chapter Xiii

The Justice Courts were scenes of mockery, farce and injustice, and even in later days but little improvement is seen. There is a case on record in the Justices' Court in 1850, H. Amyx presiding, in which a negro was convicted of stealing a piece of pie, and sentenced to six months in. the County Jail.

The punishments inflicted were whipping, ducking, imprisonment and hanging. The punishment of whipping" was inflicted at the public whipping post. When the Court was held on the brig, a whipping post was erected -on the bank of the slough, and the criminal, bare to the waist, was lashed to the j)ost and the number of lashes imposed by the Court were laid on with a whip. After a wooden jail was occupied the culprit was whipped in private, thongs being fastened around his wrists, thrown over the cell door and fastened on the other side. The punishment of ducking was put into execution hy fastening the prisoner to the yard arm of a vessel, and then sousing him and hauling him out of the water, until justice was satisfied.

The darkest part of Stockton's history is from 1850 to> 1856, when vice was king and virtue a slave. This may be called the mob law period, for mobs and their laws ruled the hour, and men dared not oppose them. Every border State draws to its domain the criminal class who go there to rule or to ruin. Kansas had its border ruffians, and California had its Texas rangers, a class of men whose very presence was a stigma upon any community. Add to these an immigration of A,ustr.alian convicts, called " Sydney ducks," and we have the ruling power in the mob law law period. Stockton was notably cursed, for here was a. wide field for action, and gold was the result of crime. Courts were a mockery. Judges and juries were bribed,, or threatened with vengeance if they dare oj)pose the mandates of the ruling power. Knives and pistols were often drawn in ojoen court, and the leader, pistol in hand, and jumping upon a desk would defy the law to take its course. The two leaders of this element were William Owens and James Taylor, and the death of the latter we shall notice, for they were the terror of the town. After one of their sprees, the following day would find them mounted on their horses and charging through the streets, yelling and whooping, with Bill Owens on his little white pony in the lead . They would ride along, firing their pistols in the air or into some building, as the fancy might prompt, indifferent as to the result. Then honest men had to keep from sight or suffer the consequences. To vary the sport they would ride into a building or tent and destroy property. In their nightly rounds they would visit some restaurant, and arousing the proprietor, would make him set for them a splendid meal, and then leave without paying a cent, and if his dishes were not broken he considered himself fortunate. The following death, in 1851, was the result of this recklessness: " Died, February 22d, Mr. Edwin Hoss, twenty-six j^ears of age. His death was caused by the accidental discharge of a pistol. He was asleep in an upper room and the pistol was discharged in a room beneath, the ball passing through the floor and several blankets, then through the body, causing instant death."

These men have deserved and met violent deaths and none will more strikingly illustrate this than two which occurred in this city. A fandango i)arty was in full blast, and in attendance were two men, Wm. Miner, a noted gambling desperado, and a "fancy" teamster. The teamster noticed Miner dancing with the "girl" of John Quinn; he resented it, and drawing his pistol fired over the teamster's head. The teamster, who was a quiet man and calm in his disposition, remarked: " That is your game, is it? Tw o can play at that," and shot Quinn dead on the spot. On his trial he easily proved self defense, and was acquitted.

time. Stepping into a saloon, then near the El Dorado, kept by a little "French girl," the paramour of Turner, Taylor, with revolver in hand, swept from the bar all the handsome cut glass tumblers and decanters. She sent word to Taylor that she wished him to pa}'^ for them, and he meeting Turner, told him that if he did not pay "his girl," he (Taylor) would kill him. Taylor generally did as he threatened; and Turner, one day, seeing Taylor having his boots blacked, fired tAvo shots at him and killed him. instantly at the second shot.

Taylor's two brothers came from Texas on purpose to kill Turner, in revenge, but learning that he was in the penitentiary, they were satisfied and returned to their homes.

One of the most exciting scenes ever witnessed in Stockton occurred on the second day of June, 1851. Nothinghas ever so roused the feelings of the people as this bold attempt to overturn justice and institute lynch law. On the 21th of May a pony belonging to Billy Owens was stolen, together with other horses. A short time after, Mr. Owens received a message, from some secret source, that some men who were suspected of belonging to a gang of horse thieves were in town. Mr. Owens commenced searching for the persons described in the communication, and found one of them on the peninsula in a low grog shop kept by a man named Russell. This man Russell was a low, disreputable character, he and his wife keeping a low boarding house, harboring and abetting thieves in their nefarious work. Mr. Owens and others took this man Wilson to the gallows for the purpose of forcing from him a confession of his own guilt and of the whereabouts of his confederates; but the sight of the gallows had no effect upon him. He was then stripped and whipped severely, and this punishment having no effect, a rope was fastened around his neck and he was jerked up once or twice. The choking not being as agreeable as the whipping, he begged to be released, and agreed to conduct the mob to th^ place where his confederates were encamped. He led the party out of the city to the cemetery grove where their camp was located. After waiting a short time four more of the men were found and one of the party was seized and whipped, and he confessed that all of the party were thieves - a very natural confession under the circumstances. They were all taken to jail, and on Monday James Wilson, Frederick Salkman, James Nell, Jasper Cochrane and Jerry Boland were brought before W. F. Nye for trial. The evidence being heard, Mr.W. Owens addressed the throng of ruffians who had assembled for the purpose of convicting the prisoners, guilty or innocent, and moved that they proceed to hang them. This motion was seconded by Dr. McLean, whose idea of lynch law was stronger than his sense of justice. In an instant fifty or more revolvers and bowie knives were drawn ready for action; the Recorder, City Marshal, and his deputies were seized and held. All the pent up animosity of the crowd was turned loose, and rushing over tables and chairs they started for their victims.

Boland, a large powerful man, succeeded in reaching the door, through which he sprang and started for the Levee followed by his assailants. Owens being a swifter runner than Boland, fired five shots at the fugitive, when he stopped and surrendered. As the prisoner appeared in sight of the jail, the infuriated rabble, still thirsting for their blood, cried "hang them! hang them!" As the doors closed on the culprits they felt a sense of relief, as they were more anxious just now to get into jail than they would be to get out of it. It was only with the utmost difficulty that they succeeded in climbing the stairs of the jail, their clothing being torn from their backs, exposing the skin which had been lacei-ated by their severe whipping. The Sheriff, Dr. Ashe, then addressed the thwarted crowd, begging of them to let the law take its course; pledging himself that the prisoners should not escape, convincing them that they were well guarded. The people listened to his remarks, and in a short time dispersed.

ernment. This is mob law and these are the most disgraceful scenes upon the escutcheon of our state. During the first ten years of our history as a state men were mobbed and hung by the scores. In the year 1855 fortj^-seven men were hanged by mob law, more than half the number for stealing in the mountain towns. In the opinion of many the officers of justice were in league either with the mob or with the criminal, as the case might be. These mobs, when courts of law would not accede to their demands, established courts of their own and administered punishment as they saw fit. We cite one case occurring a few days after the arrest of the horse thieves, showing the way in which Judge Lynch disposes of those persons that he believes injurious to society. It will be remembered that the man Wilson was found at the house of one Russell, on the Peninsula, and the mob, judging this man Russell to be a character obnoxious to society, proceeded to organize a court and try this man on general principles. When the court was called to order, they selected Ca^Dtain Chapman as sheriff, and Captain A. Bell as prosecuting attorney in the case. The sheriff brought Russell into court. Russell was a " Sydney Duck." His Honor Judge Owens informed the accused that he was before a Mustang Court, and that what he had to say should be said quickly and to the point . He stated that he had been in Stockton but a few weeks; that he and his wife had kept a house of ill repute; that he did not know the men who had been arrested , nor did he know them to be professional horse thieves; that he did not know why they should prefer his house to any other; that he came to this country to make money honestly . At this stage of the proceedings the Judge asked if the jury had been polled, when a bystander remarked that "he thought there was timber enough in him and the crowd without any polls," and he moved that Russell be ducked in the slough. The prisoner was then seized and taken to the water on the levee and thrown in. After swimming out he was again thrown in. Sheriff Ashe apjDeared upon the scene and rescued the pris- oner from the hands of the infuriated mob, and carried him to the jail, but considering that Russell's safety depended in locking him up in jail he was brought over, when the jury of the Mustang Court rendered a verdict that he be well whipped, which sentence was carried out. He was then given sixteen hours in which to leave town.

These mobs were the terror of the town, and citizens, many of them were in constant terror of offending these lawless men in some way, and thereby bringing vengeance upon their own heads.

Another act of the advocates of Lynch law took place on June 25, and is known as the Daly's ranch fight. A dispute having arisen in regard to cutting a crop of hay, several shots were fired between the two parties claiming the land, but without any serious effect. Constable Langdon hearing of the affair went out to try and effect a compromise, but failed so to do. A large and stronger party having collected they succeeded in driving the Daly party off the land . Daly came to the city for protection, and a demand was made for him the next day, by a large company of mounted men, armed and equipped and ready to enforce their demands. The cowardly mob considered Daly as a good subject for Lynch law. This insolent demand was refused by the officials, and the San Joaquin guards were ordered under arms to protect Daly from the lynchers. Finding further bluster useless, they dispersed. The punishments inflicted on these self constituted tribunals of justice were very effective. There were a number of methods employed to reform the guilty, the mildest of which was whipping. The blanket tossing punishment was ludicrous and novel. The method of procedure was to toss the person up and down in a blanket, and the severity of the punishment was regulated hj having the blanket drawn tight, or kept loose, A very amusing incident happened to an actor. Assuming himself to be a star, he apjoeared before the footlights in the character of Hamlet. The audience concluded to dispense with the usual course of rotten eggs, and to treat the actor to a novel experience. At the close of the performance he was invited in to take a drink, and very easily was led into the snare prepared for him. Standing" at the bar, he was suddenly and very unceremoniously pushed backward into a large blanket. After a vigorous shaking up he was allowed to depart - an opportunity he immediately took advantage of.

Another punishment, laughable to all except the criminal, was the punishment of ''riding on a rail." Although this punishment was very ludicrous to the observer, it was terrible to the culprit, and very seldom was any repetition necessary to rid the town of the criminal's presence.

One of the most cruel punishments ever inflicted is branding. Two methods were in vogue; one, to brand the thief or murderer upon the person ; the other, to cut off an ear. These disgraceful tortures were perpetrated by the decrees of mobs, and the leaders ought to have been hanged and society would have been the better. We have already mentioned ducking as one of the modes of punishment recommended and inflicted by the courts [f), and will not again refer to it.

In the first session of the legislature a law was enacted punishing horse stealing as well as murder . with death. The law, though severe, was necessary to protect the property of citizens. Hardly a day passed that horses were not stolen. Organized bands of robbers infested every section of the country, having their rendezvous in the Coast Range and Sierra Nevadas, from which they would sally forth to plunder and murder those who crossed their track. Men would enter the town and steal horses from the doors of the owners, and the names of Joaquin Murieta and others became the terror of the state, as leaders of murderous, thieving bands. The penalty of death for horse stealing was only in force for a year, and only two men were hanged under its provisions. We will describe an execution for murder, to a part of which we were an eye witness. A

Mexican named Jose Barillo had been convicted and sentenced to death. On the day appointed for the execution he was placed upon a wagon and was drawn up Main street. Beside him stood the ever faithful priest administering the consolations of religion, while behind him, to prevent his escape, rode forty or fifty horsemen, armed with revolvers, rifles and bowie knives. It was a sickening scene for display, when the object of their presence was soon to be ushered into eternity. Arriving at the large oak tree near the corner of Main and Grand streets, a rope was tied around the Mexican's neck and fastened around a projecting limb of the tree. The wagon was drawn out from under the man and he was left dangling and suspended in the air until dead. The party then rode back to town, leaving the body to be cut down by the Coroner.

In the private office of the Sheriff is the Eogues' Gallery, containing the pictures of most of the criminals of this section and of the state; also, a cabinet in which are preserved all manner of weapons, that tell the story of many a tragedy. The names of all who have been executed in the county have been neatly written upon a card, and the card has been framed and hung upon the wall. They are as follows: C. Baker, alias Mickey, hanged May 9, 1851; James Wilson, alias Mountain Jim, November 28, 1851; Fred. Salkman, alias Dutch Fred, November 28, 1851; Jose Barillo, June 3, 1853; Thomas Crawford and William Corson, February 14, 1860; Jacob T. Elyea, March 9, 1860; Charles Gedding (colored), May 24,1861; John K. Best, September 6, 1870; J. J. Murphy, April 25, 1873.

Of these men, two were hanged for stealing horses, and eight for murder. Of the murders four were committed while under the influence of liquor, and two while in the heat of passion.

com^oanions led them astray. The crime of Jacob Elvea was a murder the most foul on record. His character must have been one of the worst. A stranger, John Mc- Wade, came to his lodging house to rest for the night. Supposing from his neat, refined appearance that he had money, Elyea in the midnight hour stupefied him with liquor, and then strangled him with a Mexican scarf, and hung the body by the neck, to give the appearance of suicide. Bat a bloody hand on the wall told of a fearful struggle for life, and Elyea was arrested, convicted and hanged as one of the blackest of yillains.

In all new countries the titles to land are subjects of controversy, strife and bloodshed, and San Joaquin county has not been exempt, as the records of the courts will show. A great many lawsuits and two or three murders have been caused by imperfect land titles. Persons have pre-empted a lot of land, and then, carrying theii- titles over a larger amount than belonged to them, have endeavored to hold it by force. Others have attempted to "jump" the land of another and hold it as their own. This business was carried on largely in earlier times, and the '^ squatters" were often victorious. The first jumping of land in the county took place in the Spring of 1850, on a lot of land on the levee, owned by Captain C, M. Weber. A party of men pitched their tent on the lot and claimed possession. The next day they were arrested, and their trial took jjlace in the Court of Sessions . A number of counsel appeared on each side. For the plaintiff. Captain Weber, appeared W. D. Fair, S. A. Booker, Dr. R. Roberts and Thomas B. Yan Buren; for the defense, D. W. Perley, D. S. Terry, E. L. B. Brooks, H. Amy x and Slocum & Spafford. Judgment was given to the plaintiff.

It would weary the patience to begin to enumerate the lawsuits in regard to the ownership) of land. Two of the most celebrated cases are " The Battle of Waterloo," and "The Comstock Affair."

He allowed John Balkwill to occupy and cultivate twenty-five acres as a homestead and garden. Hearing that Drullard had more land than was allowed by the pre-emption act (160 acres), Balkwill determined to file his claim for 160 acres. He filed his petition in the land office in October, 1861.

Balkwill, hearing that the owner and his party, comprising farmers, each of whom had more land than he was to, had agreed to drive him off the j)lace, by force of arms if necessary, as an example to "squatters" in the future, determined to defend his rights and land, even at the risk of his life. He fortified his shanty by placing thick plank on the outside and on the inside, and filling the space with earth. He sent his family to a neighbor's, and awaited his foe. Providing himself with provisions and ammunition, he and a few staunch friends were enabled to stand quite a siege.

In the meantime the opposing party had not been idle. Coming into the city late one Saturday night, they took possession of the old cannon lying on the slough, and loading it upon a wagon, they conveyed it to the scene of action.

Loading it with bolts, nut heads, and scraps of iron, they stood at a safe distance and fired at the fort. Four times did they fire the contents of the blacksmith shop, but their efforts were futile and they cast their cannon aside in disgust. Two causes are given by an eye witness for their failure; being better farmers than cannoneers they failed to hit the fort, and on account of the scattering charge and the distance - 350 yards - the effect of the discharge was lost. Even at this distance the bullets from the Balkwill party convinced the invaders that the defensive party were resolved to "hold the fort."

In this famous and disgraceful action against law and justice no damage was done, except the loss of a finger by the aggressive party from a stray bullet. When the news of the skirmish reached the city, Deputy Sheriff Choate hastened to the scene of action, followed soon after by Sheriff Hook, who arrested the rioters and brought them to the city. John Balkwill is still in possession of the land, and the inference is that his claim was just.

Some time after this event parties jumped a tract of land two miles east of Waterloo, known as the Comstock ranch, and sowing the seed expected to reap the harvest. A suit in ejectment was begun in the courts and judgment was given in favor of the plaintiff; but the squatters refused to leave and prepared to defend their claim by fortifying themselves in an old brick barn that is still standing. Hearing of this armed resistance to law. Sheriff Hook called on the Union Guard, June 2, 1862, to take possession of the ranch. Captain Pearsall assembled his command on that morning in Agricultural Hall, and the full company "fell into line." Exaggerated reports were current that the squatters were determined to fight, and for the only time Stockton had a small taste of the scenes of woe and anguish that were then taking place all over the land from North to South. Wives and children were trembling lest their protectors might be slain.

To see the company was a study of human nature. Some were pale, yet firm, others were laughing and joking to hide their fear. Having received three rounds of ammunition to each man, they were driven to Waterloo, the scene of the late battle. Halting here, a detachment of men, including Wallace Tinkham and Dick Fletcher, was sent forward to parley with the enemy - but they had fled. The owners were put in possession of the place, the guards came back to the city, and in two hours the squatters were again in possession. The matter was soon after this amicablysettled.

The State Of Society

The cry of " Gold, gold," was heard in the harbors of every nation, and suddenly this state, with "its cliffs and rivers of gold," became the objective point of every grade and condition of life, from the youth of sixteen to the manhood of forty-five; from the homes of elegance and wealth and the homes of want and poverty came representatives to the Pacific coast. Crime also sent its delegates from the workshop of the thief, robber and murderer. All were actuated by the same love of money - the love of gold. Some hoped to obtain it by honest labor, others by crime and deceit.

A number of capitalists organized a company in New York for the purpose of running a line of steamships from New York to California, via Panama. The first vessel dispatched after the discovery of gold was the California. Sailing around Cape Horn, it arrived in the harbor of San Francisco February 28, 1849. One month later the Oregon reached the coast, and soon after, the Panama, which was the third of a line of steamers that was to connect with a line of steamers on the Atlantic side . These vessels, or vessels of this line, were the only regular line of communication between California and the East for twenty years. Then the railroad became the connecting link .

Most of the population of California during the gold excitement came to the coast in steamships, and these vessels have carried millions of treasure and brought thousands of tons of freight.

The population of Stockton in 1849 is said to have been about 1000; but this, perhaps, is an over-estimate, as thousands were passing through to the mines and back again. No census was taken until 1853, when J. E. Nuttman reported the population of the county to be as follows:

No state was ever before cursed with so much iniquity, and no state has ever become so pure in so short a time as California. The great change has been brought about by society. Like the new wine in the cask, it has worked itself clear of all impurities, and it is clearer and more valuable now than ever before. Few of the pioneers now living were twenty-five years of age when they came to California, and, naturally impulsive, many of them at once plunged into all of the dissipations of the country, led on by vile companions; wine, cards and women have been the ruin of many a young man. Yet the scenes through which they passed have not been altogether unmixed with good3 for in tlie fire " the gold is purified;" on the battle field the hero is made. The Judge who to-day sits on the bench, guarding the oppressed; the Senator who frames the laws of the state; the merchant who dispenses^his fortune to the poor; the doctor who attends their suffering from bodily disease, are the same ones who look back over the follies of youth and realize that the highest honors belong to those men who have struggled through temptations, and risen to positions of honor and esteem .

Hundreds of sailing vessels left Atlantic ports for the Pacific, having on board bands of men bound for the gold mines. Many of these vessels contained provisions, blankets and clothing, brought by the party chartering the vessel, and sufiicient to last for two years after their arrival. Others, in their wild excitement, would have only enough means to pay their passage, expecting to pick the gold from the streets and to become millionaires at once. On their arrival, however, the delusion was quickly exploded, for the gold was in the mountains, and the sum of fifty to one hundred dollars was required to pay passage. Borrow- ing or begging passage money to Sacramento or Stockton, they would foot it to the mines. A party of fifty chartered the bark Lenark and left Boston, arriving in San Francisco in December, 1849. The event illustrates the ups and downs of the times, as they were both fortunate and unfortunate. They were provided with provisions, blankets and clothing sufficient to last them a year. They sailed up the bay and river to New York Landing, a common place of anchorage then. From this point they came in small boats to Stockton and started for the mines, leaving the vessel and cargo in charge of the captain. As the price of freight was 25 cents a pound, they took very little with them. "When they returned they found the vessel gone. The captain having stolen his " pile," was cruising other seas.

Large numbers of immigrants arrived overland. From the Sierras to the Mississipj)i the constant tramp of feet was heard, and as the tired horse or jaded ox was driven over the hot desert, the song of the immigrant was heard, ''On to California."

Many in the long and weary sis months' journey lay down in their last sleep, and often Indians lurking around the well worn pathway would send the bullet or poisoned arrow to the breast of some one of the party . Yet still they came . Disease, thirst, starvation and exposure would claim their own, yet they must push on to the San Joaquin valley or perish .

In these marches of the brave over the desert and across trackless seas, death has claimed his victims by the hundreds. Unknown to their fellow travelers, they have been buried in some forgotten sjDot without name or date, and the loved ones in the East whom they left thirty years ago have nat yet ceased to look for the return of father, brother or son.

For the first five years there were very few women that dared brave the perils of the desert or ocean, and with a view of returning within that time many men left their wives and daughters at home. Mrs. Benjamin Kelsey of the Weber party, in 1814, was the first white woman in tha valley, and Tier daughter, Mrs. America "Wyman, was the first white child. In 1847 it is said that the first white child was born in Stockton, on the ground where Weber's house now stands, to the wife of Mr. Nicholas Gunn.

The first marriage on record in the papers was that of Mr. Charles Peck and Miss Lucy Jane Dickerson, solemnized by Kev. James Corwin, in March, 1850. She was a bride and a widow within the year, her husband having been killed by Indians. " The nuptials," says the Times, "were celebrated in wine and feasting."

In Stockton, and especially in the mines, women were quite a curiosity, and when the cry of "a woman in camp" was heard, the men would rush out in numbers to catch a glimpse of her, not always from idle curiosity, but because the sight of woman lifted them thoroughly from the low condition of life that surrounded them, to the loving companions and mothers who were waiting for their return on the other side of the mountains .

There was a class of women here, native to the soil, with whom the men associated in sportive mood, but whenever a woman of refinement appeared, no knight of the chivalric age ever paid greater homage to his lady love than was paid to her. Woman in her true nature subdues and refines the coarse and uncouth in man, and had she been in Stockton in those early days, much of this chapter would not have been written .

When, in 1853, good, noblewomen appeared in numbers, a gradual change for the better took place in the manners morals and customs of society.

It is supposed by those who are ignorant of facts, that the pioneers were, as a class, uneducated. California drew many such to her borders, but those who ploughed the soil, built her cities, framed her government and developed her resources were men of strong, vigorous intellects. They were graduates of universities, ministers of the gospel, lawyers at the bar, teachers in the school, merchants at the counter, and the standard of learning was higher than in any other state of the same population. This statement is true in 1880, "for," says a reverend gentleman writing to his friends in the East, "I find more graduates here in Stockton than I ever saw in one place." "With all this intelligence literature was high, and standard books were not to be had. Books and magazines were brought to the coast by immigrants, in small quantities, but were mostly left on the vessel, as the expense was great in carrying them about .

The Eastern mails were received once a month, and even then were often left on the Isthmus to make way for the tons of freight necessary to support the inhabitants. The newsjDapers were read with great eagerness, although the news was a month or two old, and their contents formed the topic of conversation until the arrival of the next steamer. In the Spring of 1851, I. H. Knowles was an express rider, carrying the mails between Jacksonville and Stockton. He received |1 50 each for letters and sold papei's by the way. The papers included the New York Herald, New York Tribune, Boston Journal, New Orleans Picayune, besides many of the illustrated variety.

The pictorials sold readily for $1 50 each, and the taverns and settlers taking from two to five papers, handed out the money as readily as we now hand out a dime for the same. The money was generally paid in gold dust. All persons wore belts in which to carry the dust. These belts were fastened by straps over the shoulders to support the weight.'

Society had no organization, and men were rough and uncouth in their manners and not very stylish in their appearance. The dress of the times consisted of a blue or red flannel shirt and broad brimmed hat, with pants fastened around the waist with a red Mexican sash. The pants were worn inside of a pair of brogan boots. Add to this the pistol and the bowie knife and you have the complete costume of the early times. Every one carried arms of some kind, either pistols or knives.

White shirts and coats were never worn because of the ridicule of companions. When the young lawyer or doctor arrived, the white shirt and broadcloth coat were thrown aside for the coarse garments of the pioneer. Professional men, merchants and laborers wore the same dress, and in public assemblies and on the street no change was required . After the first five years the presence of women caused a gradual change, and one after another adopted the dress of the East and the deadly weapon was concealed from view.

But with all their rough appearance and uncouth manners there was a heart beneath that throbbed with noble response to the appeals of sufi'ering humanity, and these appeals were felt alike by the upright and the degraded. This characteristic of early society is one of its pleasing features, and history gladly tui"ns from the dark picture of crime and vice to the brighter scene of charity and benevolence.

The pioneers sought the new El Dorado, "to make their pile" and then return home. To do this they expected to enter the mines and procure all they wanted in a few months. On arriving here, however, they found the professions, merchandising, mechanic trades and clerkships open to them, and that in those employments they could make a fortune quickly and honestly. "W^ith these, however, there came another class, whose object was to make money, but by an entirely different plan.

In this class were gamblers, convicts from this country and from Australia, Texas rangers, who by robbery and gambling expected to obtain the coveted gold. California became the asylum for all such; for here the thief could escape detection, the gambler could ply his trade, and the murderer flee from justice, or by some means escape punishment. With these men came vice in all its forms. Society was overrun by this class, and saint and sinner associated in one common crowd. Doctors, lawyers, merchants, judges, gamblers, murderers - all in fact gathered in gaming houses almost nightly, to stake their money on a winning card .

It seemed so much easier to make money by gaming that a man's position in society did not keep him from the magic influence, for he saw frequently $50,000 won in a single

The El Dorado, on the corner of Levee and Centre streets, was the principal gambling house. It was kept by- John W . O'Neal, who was afterward elected Sheriff of the county . This place was in full operation until the spring of 1854, when churches, the schools and societies of different kinds began to exert their influence on the morals of men, and for want of patronage it was converted into a store, and was destroyed by fire the next year. An incident of "Xwenty-One," (a name given to a party, 21 being his favorite game), which took place in this house is related. One evening he was dealing the cards with considerable vigor and spirit, when Bill Owens came up to the table and called for the cards. "I handle the cards myself," said Twenty-One. " Grive me those cards," repeated Bill. "I won't do it," was the answer. Bill instantly jumped upon the table out of reach of the crowd, and drawing his pistol give me those Chrds." The next moment Twenty-One was seen going out of the window at a lively gait, and in the morning he commenced business anew, having left all of his capital on the table the night before.

The state legislature, realizing early the great evil, took measures to suppress it, and passed laws punishing and prohibiting gambling. Since that "stock gambling" has become the mania with all classes the same as faro and monte in early times. Every one could not buy stocks, so betting on elections became a common method of gambling. The game of chance had become so woven into the thoughts of society that one of the characteristic phrases of California is "You bet."

and music and pretty waiter girls added to tlie attractions. There being no family circles, the saloons became the genera Irendezvous. Many of the men, drawn to the saloon because they had no other place to go to, were led into bad habits, which in many cases have clung to them through their entire lives.

It is not surprising that in those days of carousing the Sabbath was disregarded by the majority of the people. Stores were kept open and business was transacted the same as on any other day, and amusements of all kinds were indulged in . Horse racing was a favorite sport, and was indulged in by all classes, and dog fights and cock fights were not uncommon; but these last amusements were only patronized by the lower classes.

Man is a social being, and none loved the enjoyment of attending the dance and concert more than the pioneers of 1849. The first entertainment that was respectable in character was held in the Stockton House, on the night of February 22, 1851. The guests, as fast as they arrived, were received by Mr. E. M. Howison and H. Taber Booraem. At two o'clock in the morning they all sat down to a superb supper, and then finished the night in dancing. The following ladies were present: Mrs. Charles M. Weber, Mrs. John Murphy, Mrs. Daniel Murphy, Miss Wilson of San Jose, Mrs. Cook, Mrs. John White, the Misses Scott, Mrs. Waldo, Mrs. Ward, Mrs. Harris, Mrs. Kirby, the actress, and Mrs. Townsend.

In January, 1854, a series of social assemblies were inaugurated at the Weber House by Austin Sperry, C. F. Whale, B. W. Bours and others, which were followed by other parties at th« City Hall.

The first circus performance took place in the latter joart of June, 1850, on the north side of Stockton slough. W. H. Foley came here at that time with a number of well trained horses.

The citizens celebrated the Fourth of July, 1850, with a salute, procession, and an oration in the Presbyterian church, by Thomas B. Van Buren; Foley's band, under

Provenance

Text from A History of Stockton from Its Organization Up to the Present Time, Including a Sketch of San Joaquin County : Comprising a History of the Government, Politics, State of Religion, Fire Department, Commerce, Secret Societies, Art, Science, Manufactures, Agriculture and Miscellaneous Events Within the Past Thirty Years, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.