Yolo County, California - Chapter 30: Temperance Movement in Yolo County, 1913
From History of Yolo County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1913. 2,570 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
2,570 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Yolo County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1913. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Yolo county in the beginning of its history licensed the liquor traffic for the sake of revenue. Had it outlawed the saloons how different would have been the career of many of the descendants of the pioneers who first located in Yolo county and helped make its history! It is pitifully true that hundreds of young men who otherwise would have made good citizens fell victims to King Alcohol during the rein of this great destroyer of life and character.
The first organized effort in the temperance cause was made along moral suasion lines in the fall of 1854, when a division of the Sons of Temperance was instituted at a school-house close to and north of where Woodland now stands. As late as January 20, I860, a division was organized at Knight's Landing, Davis, Plainfield and Washington. This order was succeeded by the Independent Order of Good Templars, organized at Knight's Landing December 9, 1861, by D. S. Cutter, deputy for California. Men and women were admitted to membership with equal privileges in the order. Many of the prohibition workers of later years were in their childhood members of the Band of Hope, the juvenile organization of the Independent Order of Good Templars.
For some years previous to 1873 the temperance forces had been agitating the saloon question, and in the fall of that year the members of the I. 0. G. T. determined with much enthusiasm to make a strenuous effort at the next session of the legislature to secure the adoption of a local option law. The local option bill was framed by the state executive committee of the I. 0. G. T. and introduced by the Hon. Wirt W. Pendegast, state senator from this district, the oldest son of Rev. J. N. Pendegast, a pioneer preacher of the Christian church and founder of Hesperian College. It was supported by the petitions of about thirteen thousand persons, nearly all voters. The Act was passed with little opposition in the senate March 11, 1874, by a vote of twenty-eight to eleven; and on the 14th, in the assembly, by a vote of fifty-two to nineteen, and signed by Governor Booth.
The temperance workers were jubilant and went to work hoping that success would crown their efforts. Elections were held in all directions throughout the state. About seven-ninths of nearly one hundred districts, towns and townships voted no-license, some by sweeping majorities.
county was initiated in Woodland township, the election taking place on May 8, 1874. There were three hundred and eighty votes cast, a majority of two against license. On the 15th of the same month Cache Creek and Grafton townships voted upon the question, followed by other townships. The vote on saloons in 1874 was as follows:
Everything looked favorable for the suppression of the liquor traffic and no one at that time could have been made to believe that liquor sellers and saloon advocates would control politics and defeat every movement made by the temperance people and that the Woodland saloons would be allowed to run until August 1, 1911, sending hundreds of men to premature graves.
In Contra Costa county a liquor seller was fined $50 for continuing his business contrary to law. Refusing to pay, he was admitted to bail during an appeal to the supreme court. Not a saloon in the state, including those in Woodland, closed, all remained open in defiance of the will of the majority, waiting the decision of the court on the test case.
The liquor dealers of San Francisco made no secret of having raised and deposited to the credit of John B. Felton, their attorney, the sum of $40,000 payable, provided he should secure a decision of the supreme court declaring the local option law unconstitutional. No success, no pay. Judge Sanderson defended the law in a masterly style before the supreme court. After two months' delay the majority of the judges, Wallace, McKinstry and Niles, affirmed the unconstitutionality of the law, while Crockett and Rhodes dissented.
Thus the people of California by the casting vote of one man were unjustly deprived of the benefits of a beneficent law. Dollars won out. This unlooked-for decision discouraged the workers and very little aggressive work was done until May, 1883, when Frances E. Willard organized a local union of the Women's Temperance Union in the Congregational Church in Woodland and one at Winters. In the following December Mrs. Mary B. Leavitt organized the Cacheville W. C. T. U. These three unions were, in April, 1887, organized by Mrs. Euth Armstrong into a county union. At later dates Davis, Knight's Landing, Madison, Guinda, Brooks and Rumsey were added to the Yolo county W. C. T. U. Mrs. Emily Hoppin was the first county president, her successors being Mrs. Euth Armstrong, Mrs. A. M. Hilliker, Mrs. M. M. Morrin, Mrs. S. A. Huston, Mrs. G. W. Pierce and Mrs. J. E. Scarlett.
Soon after the organization of the county Mrs. S. A. Huston was appointed superintendent of the press department. Her first work was editing a W. C. T. U. column in the Mail and Democrat until she, with the help of the W. C. T. U. established the Home Alliance July 1, 1891. It was first printed by William Kehoe, then by E. E. Lee until October, 1894, when the W. C. T. U., through the liberality of Mrs. Emma C. Laugenour ,who had been president of the Woodland W. C. T. U. for many years, purchased a printing plant and opened headquarters in a building opposite the city hall. The paper has never missed an issue and has been a great force in educating public sentiment against the liquor traffic. The publication of the names of saloon petitioners proved to be such an effective weapon in the warfare against the saloons that to save them, saloon sympathizing supervisors and trustees changed the ordinances so that no petitioners would be required to get a saloon license. The continuance of the paper through all these years was made possible by the loyal support given it by the members of the W. C. T. U., the churches and the good citizenship of the county, and the patronage of the business and professional men and women of Woodland.
After the W. C. T. U. was organized there was no cessation in the work against legalized liquor traffic and for equal suffrage. The members kept "everlastingly at it." Through their efforts scientific temperance instruction in the public schools of Yolo county was adopted by the county board of education, prior to its adoption by the state legislature. A matron for the first time was appointed at the county hospital and a drinking fountain provided for the public in Woodland and Winters.
A committee from the Winters W. C. T. U. went before the trustees and asked for an election on the saloon question. Their request was granted and the election was held on April 11, 1904. The result was thirty-three majority against the saloons and the election of an anti-saloon board of trustees. This was the first notable victory in the county. Two years later Winters voted by an increased
The second victory was obtaining the consent of the supervisors to submit the saloon question to the voters. Petitions presented at different times during the period of eighteen years were always refused until 1908.
To Frank B. Edson, of Knight's Landing, belongs the honor of being the first supervisor in Yolo county to move that the saloon question be submitted to the voters. The motion was seconded by Supervisor Snyder and passed by the votes of Edson, Snyder, Vaughn and Hoppin. The election was held November 21, 1908. Nine out of thirteen precincts voted out the saloon. Taking the county as a whole, the majority against the saloons was 218. Total vote for saloons 773, against saloons 991. In November, 1910, Blacks and Dunnigan precincts, after a two years' trial of prohibition, voted to remain "dry." The license fee paid by each saloon in the county had been $15 per quarter.
The legislature of 1911-12 passed a law prohibiting saloons within three miles of the state farm at Davis. The law went into effect September 1, 1911, closing seven saloons, leaving only one saloon in the second supervisorial district, on the Plainfield road. A petition was presented to the board at the April meeting, 1912, asking that the application for a renewal of the license for this saloon be denied. The board denied the petition and renewed the license. A petition for an election in the second supervisorial district was presented at the next meeting of the board. It had the required number of names under the new local option law, and the board ordered the election to be held on July 2, 1912, and the Plainfield saloon was voted out by sixty-nine majority, every precinct in the district, including Davis, giving a majority against the saloon. The supervisors on the day of the election renewed the license for another three months. The saloon was closed October 1, 1912.
In the '70s Woodland had forty saloons that paid a license fee of $15 per quarter, under an ordinance without any restrictions, and a red-light district, in which liquors were sold, that occupied a large part of the southeast part of the city. Murders, suicides and cutting scrapes occurred at different times, for which the liquor traffic was directly responsible. Two night watchmen were employed by the city during the existence of these conditions. Through the efforts of the W. C. T. U. the prohibitionists and the churches this red-light district was abolished several years ago, and the whole county, except the small river towns, Broderick and Clarksburg, are now without saloons. A movement has been started to secure an election in those places.
the adoption of a midnight closing ordinance as an economic measure to save $900 per year by dispensing with the services of the night watchman. The ordinance was adopted by the votes of three trustees, W. P. Craig, Edward P. Huston and T. B. Gibson. The saloon fought the ordinance and Mayor Britt, who was engaged in the wholesale liquor business, refused to sign it. Mandamus proceedings followed and the judge of the superior court decided that the mayor must sign it. The decision was rendered just before the next city election, when midnight closing was made an issue in the candidacy of Edward P. Huston, one of the trustees who had voted for it. He was re-elected and midnight closing became the fixed policy of the city.
The next board raised the license fee to $40 per quarter and adopted a precinct option ordinance and later submitted the saloon question to the voters of the city for the first time on April 13, 1903. This board (Gibson, Craig, Troop, Huston and Brown) was the first in Northern California to give the voters of a city the opportunity to vote on the saloon question. The vote on April 13, 1903, was as follows: Total vote cast 830; for saloons 424; no saloons 316; majority for the saloons 108.
On April 11, 1905, another board was elected, as follows : R. H. Beamer, W. H. Alexander, W. H. Troop, Douglas Balfour and Joe Craig. This board in December, 1905, raised the license fee to $80 per quarter. The saloon men opposed it and made an unsuccessful effort to have it reduced to $60.
The saloon question was for the second time submitted to the voters of Woodland by order of the board on February 19, 1907, Craig, Beamer and Alexander voting aye, and Balfour no, Troop absent. The election was held on April 8, 1907, resulting as follows : Total vote cast 826; for saloons 382; no saloons 353; majority for saloons 29. In both of the elections the majority of the resident voters voted against the saloons, but their vote was overcome by colonized voters imported by the liquor interests.
The next board of trustees (Mitchell, Curson, Boots, White and Muegge) were elected on a platform that pledged them not to reopen the saloon question during their term of office, four years. They fixed the license fee at $100 per quarter. Near the close of the four years, at the February meeting, 1911, G. P. Hurst, in behalf of the anti-saloon forces, asked the board that the saloon question be again submitted at the city election, to be held April 11, 1911. Trustee White moved that the question be submitted; Trustee Boots and Trustee Curson seconded the motion simultaneously. On the roll call the vote stood: ayes, White, Mitchell, Boots and Curson; no, Muegge. On election day, April 10, 1911, the anti-saloon forces won by the following vote : Total vote cast 900 ; for saloons 395 ; no saloons 431; majority against saloons 36. The Woodland saloons were closed by ordinance August 1, 1911. In the meantime the new local option law passed by the legislature in March of the same year went into effect and under its provisions the saloon men petitioned for another election, hoping that the voters might reverse their decision. The trustees ordered the election and fixed the date for the same on Tuesday, December 12, 1911. Full suffrage was given to the women of California on October 10, 1911, and Thursday, October 19, 1911, will long be remembered as the first registration day for the women of Woodland. Many women were lined up at the courthouse before the clerk's office was opened for business. At six o'clock p. m., there were still fifty women in line waiting to reach the desk of the clerk, who worked overtime to get them all registered. About four hundred women registered during the day. Some of them were over eighty years of age, and all of them were determined to get their names on the register in time to avail themselves of the first opportunity given them to express their wishes at the ballot box in regard to the re-opening of the saloons in Woodland. When the polls were opened on election day the women were at the polls ready to vote, and their ballot helped settle the saloon question in Woodland and it was settled right. The vote was as follows: Total vote cast, 1,222; for saloons 452; no saloons 770; majority against saloons 318.
The closing of the saloons has not "killed the town," as was predicted by the liquor men, but business has been better, the city is building up rapidly, all buildings on Main street, including those formerly occupied by saloons, are occupied, and the delinquent tax list the smallest in the history of the county. There has been a marked decrease in drunkenness and disorder, the city jail being empty most of the time, the number of prisoners in the county jail has been less and the most of them are vagrants, products of the Sacramento saloons, who have been ordered out of that city by the officials, and they congregate in or near Broderick, in Yolo county, just across the river. But the work is not finished. It will be a constant fight to retain what we have won and add to it Broderick and Clarksburg. We must also do our part toward securing state and national prohibition of the manufacture and sale of alcoholic liquors for beverage purposes, and better law enforcement.
Provenance
Text from History of Yolo County, California, with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1913, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.