Yuba County, California - Chapter 14: Courts and Bar of Yuba County, 1879
From History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. 3,006 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
8 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
3,006 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 14: Courts and Bar of Yuba County
Introduction <>f Law Into California The Courta under the Mexican Law ,.f 1S37- Proclamation ,.1 (1., vcni.ii- eciniolt Riley Election ol Alcaldes at Marysville and Eliza Courts M
,.f BeBBlons Probate Court -Recorder's, Mayor's, and l'uliee Courta Justice's Court - Courts under the New Constitution -List of Attorneys with Records.
Law may bo said to have been introduced into Alta California in 17G9, when the Franciscan Padres, tinder the leadership of Father Junipero Serra, founded the Mission of San Diego. The Padres had full civil control of the mission settlements and administered justice, not as we have been accustomed to in our courts of law, but hi the manner best calculated to further the interests of their religion and government. Later, when Pueblos were established, justice was administered by an Alcalde (Judge), whose authority and that of the other civil officers gradually encroached upon the jurisdiction of the Padres, until finally, when the Missions were secularized, the civil power obtained supreme control, its authority extending along the whole coast, and as far inland as the military arm had strength to cany it.
Under the Mexican laws of 1837, we find the courts established as follows for the territory of California. The highest court, having an appellate jurisdiction and corresponding in character to our Supreme Court, was the Superior Court of California, consisting of foiu- Judges and an Attorney General. It was divided into the first and second benches, the three senior Judges composing the first and the junior the second. The first bench was called the Court of the Third Instance, and its decisions were final. Appeals lay to this court from the second bench or Court of the Second Instance. The latter court had first jurisdiction of appeals from the Court of the First Instance, the highest local cunt then existing, and having somewhat the powers of our District Court. It became customary for the Fust Alcalde to discharge the duti.s of Judge of the Court of the First Instance. The lesser magistrates consisted of the Alcaldes and Justices of the Peace, whose duties were very similar and corresponded closerj to those of our Justices. During the period intervening between the American conquest, >n 1846, and the establishment of the new courta under the Constitution
It was by virtue of this proclamation that the inhabitants of the town of MaryBville, January 18, I860, eleoted Stephen J. Field, First Alcalde, settled to require a local magistrate. The authority of the Ale, hie; elected in January continued until June, at which time the Judges of the courts, as established by the Constitution, assumed the duties of their office. The election to till these positions occurred on the first Monday in April, and resulted in the election of Henry P. Ilaun, County Judge and Chief Justice of the Court of Sessions; Win. R. Turner was appointed Judge of the District Court by Governor Burnett.
Supreme Court
By the constitution of 1849, the highest judicial power in the State was vested in a Supreme Court, with appellate jurisdiction of causes involving over two hundred dollars, and in all cases of tax, municipal fines, and criminal cases amounting to a felony, in questions of law only. The Court consisted of one Chief Justice and two Associate Justices, any two of whom constituted a quorum. The agreement of
I, |8S2,onoin 1 884, and one in 1856. The Governor was pventhe powortofillanj vacancy by appointmenl until the nexi general election. h, February, L852, Justice Heydonfeldt, bj joinf resolution of the Legislature, was granted leave of absence for six months. Ii became
I sr.ii. WhenJirstico Heydenfeldt returned be gave an opinion concur rim, wiili that of Chief Justice Murray ogoinsl the act, and thus it was deolared unconstitutional; not, however, until Justice Wells had retired from the bench. The constitutional amendments of 1863 altered II"' composition of the Court, establishing il as it is to-day.
the length of then' terms decided among them by lot. The causes which could be appealed were placed at those involving over three hundred instead of two hundred dollars.
District Court
Under the law of 1850, Yubn county was in the Eighth Judicial Distriot, and the first term of the court was commenced June .">. 1850, li\ Hon. Win. K. Turner. The jurisdiction of this Court was very hum', moulding chancer} . ch il and criminal. It had original cognizance in all oases m equity, and its cavil (uiisduticn included all cases whsre tlu' amount exceeded two hundred dollars, causes involving the title to real property or the validity of any tax. ami issues of fact joined in the Probate Court. It had power to iuquire into all criminal offences by moans of a Grand .liny, ami try indictments found by that body.
The first Grand Jury assembled June t. and was composed of the following citizens: - W. Fetter, foreman, F. W. Shaffer, Geo. Hubbard, W. W. Cleveland, A. T. Parish, .1. s. Kelly, W. W. Nelson, X D. Meek. John 11. Washburn, Win. Kin-;, 1. Washburn, Normon
I,, 1851, the Legislature took from the curt its criminal jurisdiction and conferred il upon the Courl of Sessions, leaving it the power of ppeals from that .-nit in criminal matters, and the power to try all indictments for murder, manslaughter, arson, ami other cases that could not !«- tried in the Court -of Sessions. At the some session ,1,, Legislature formed Vul.a, Nevada ami Sutter Counties into the Tenth Judicial Distriot. In 1851, Hon. Gordon N. Mott was ap-
At the opening of the District Court, October Id, 1851, Hon. W. T. Barbour was present, with a commission from the Governor as District Judge of this district. He intimated that he desired on interview with Judge Mott before making the formal demand for the office, and the. court was adjourned till two o'clock in the afternoon. During the recess Judges .Mott ami Barbour, together with the members of the liar, held a consultation in the office of the Recorder. Judge Barbour stated that he had a commission from the Governor as District Judge of the Tenth Judicial District, given iii consequence of his election to that office by the people at the last general election, and that lie had taken the constitutional oath of otlice. Judge Mott stated that he also had a commission from the Governor as District Judge, and claimed that, as his commission was given to fill a vacancy in the office occasioned by the failure of the Legislature to elect, and as it did not mention the tenn for which lie was to hold office, it would hold till the election of District Judges in 1852. The Constitution provided for the filling of such vacancies " at the next election by the people," and the question of right lay on the interpretation of these words, whether they meant the next election, or the next regular election for the office to be tilled. Upon the assembling of the court in the afternoon, Mr. Barbour appeared and demanded the office and records (this course having been previously decided upon), and then the court adjourned to allow the matter to be carried to tin' Supreme Court. There it was decided that Mr. Barbour was the rightful claimant to the position; he accordingly took his seat without further interruption. In 1853, the Tenth Judicial District was changed by the Legislature so as to embrace Yuba, Nevada, Sutter, and .Sierra counties. Again, in 1857, an alteration was made, reducing the district to Yuba and Sutter counties; and in 1863 ,tlie size of the district was increased to four counties, Yuba, Sutter, Colusa and Sierra, since which time there lias been no further alteration. The Legislature also, in 1863, raised the civil jurisdiction from amounts over two hundred dollars to three hundred dollai-s, gave it exclusive power to try indictments for treason, niis-prision of treason, murder, and manslaughter. Since that time there has been but little change hi the powers of the District Court.
A District Judge has authority to hold court in any district, byte quest of the Judge of that district, or upon designation of the Governor. The term of the Judge of the District Court was fixed by the Constitii
County Court
The County Courtis hold by the County Judge, whose term was tkn] by the Constitution at four years, lion. Henry P. Haun was elected by the people of Yuba county on the first Monday in April, 1850, ami opened the County Court, Juno 3, 1850. An appeal lay to this court in civil cases from a Justice of the Peace anil the RchhiIit's court. The business transacted by this Court was at first necessarilj very small. In 1863, the Legislature made the jurisdiction of Hits Court to embrace cases of forcible entry and detainer. The Court of Sessions having been abolished, criminal jurisdiction was given to tills court with power to try all indictments, except those for treason, mis prision of treason, murder, ami manslaughter, which indictments must tie
Court Op Sessions
The Court of Sessions was composed of the County Judge as Chief Justice, and two Justices of the Peace as Associate Justices, whose term of office was one year, and who were elected annually by the .his tices of the county. The first term was commenced June 10, 1860.
of Supervisors, which the court continued to perform until 1*55, when the Board of Supervisors was organized. In 185 1 , the power to inquire into criminal offenses by means of a Grand Jury, was transfened from the District Court to this court. All criminal indictments wen- tried here, except for murder, manslaughter, and aisun. In 1863, this court was abolished by the Legislature.
Probate Court
The County Judge is also Judge of the Probate Court. The jiirisdtetion of tins court embraced all probate matters. Issues of fact joined here were adjourned into the District Court for trial, or by agreement could be tried in this court. Afterwards, by act of Legislature, the Probate Court was given the power to summon juries and try issues 01 fact. There has been no great alterations in the powers of tins court since that time.
The charter by which the City of Marysvdle was incorporated in 1851, provided for a Recorder's Court, to be held by the Recorder oi the city, elected annually by the people. The fint to till this position was Gordon N. Mott, elected in 1855. The jurisdiction of this court extended to the city limits, and embraced the same civil and criminal 1*'" era as those possessed by a Justice of the Peace. It also bad exclusive Jurisdiction of all violations of a city ordinance, nuisances in the city, ragrancy, and disorderly conduct. By the charter of 1856, the civil jurisdiction of this court was taken away. The office i,f Recorder was abolished by the Legislature of 1862, and a Mayor's Court established; all the powers of the Recorder were transferred to the Mayor of the city, who held the new court, By act of the Legislature, the city was ^incorporated in 1876, and the Mayor's Court was changed to the Police Court, as it exists at present, with the same powers as those possessed by the Mayor's Court. The Police Judge in elected annually by the Mayor and « lommon I lounoil.
I!y the law of 1850, the term of a Justice of the Peace was fixed at nun year; bis jurisdiction extended to the limits of the township in which ho was elected. He had cognizance of actions on contract, for
: oxceod two hundred dollars. In 1851, his powers were considerably inoroosod, He had jurisdiction of actions to recover money, for damages to personal property, for fines, penalties and forfeitures, actions mi bonds, enforcement of lien on personal property, actions to recover personal property, and judgment by oonfesBion, where the amount in all those cases did not exceed five hundred dollars, and on a bond taken by him, ovon if the amount did exceed that sum, casus of forcible entry and detainor, and the trial of the right of mining claims. Tho criminal jurisdiction included vagrancy, disorder, petty larceny, assault and battery, breaches of the peace, and all misdemeanors punishable by a fine of not more than five hundred dollars and not more than one year's imprisonment. In 1863, forcible entry anil detainer cases were transferred to the County Court, and the civil jurisdiction reduced to amounts not oxcoeduig three hundred dollars. In 1870, the jurisdiction of this oourt in eases of misdemeanors was extended to lines of one thousand dollars and imprisonment one year. In 1874, this jurisdiction was reduced to lines of five hundred dollars and six months imprisonment. In tin- city of Morysville, the Police Oourt has cognizance of criminal poses lo tho exclusion of tho Justice's Court.
Under The New Constitution
The new Constitution, adopted by the voters at an election held May 7, 1879, changes the whole system of judiciary. Article VI., Section 1, of that instrument reads: "The judicial power of the State shall be " vested in the Senate sitting as a Court of Impeachment, in a Supreme " Court, Superior Courts, Justices of the Peace, and such inferior Courts "as the Legislature may establish in any incorporated city or town, or " city and county." The Supreme Court, is to consist of a Chief Justice and six Associate Justices, elected by the people, and their term of
The Superior Court combines the duties and powers of the District, County, and Probate Courts. The term of a Judge of the Superior < lourl is fixed at six years. The Judges of the Supreme and Superior Courts will be chosen at the next goneral election, and will assume their ilnties on the tii-st day of January In. The [towers and duties of these courts will be defined by the Legislature at its next session. "The legislature shall determine the number of Justices of " the Peace to be elected in townships, incorporated cities and towns,
The disciples of the law have played an important part in the history of this county, and much of its success is due to the efforts of these gentlemen. Most of those in the profession during the pioneer dayB of the county have moved to other localities, some rising to prominence, some sinking into oblivion, and others are numbered with the dead. The Bar of Yuba has always been, and is now, justly celebrated for the learning, culture, and ability of its members, and has given to the country many who have achieved a national reputation in the higher walks of political and judicial life.
In the following list, the date immediately following the name is the year in which practice was commenced at this Bar. Although some of the gentlemen came to the State prior to 1850, yet none are marked earlier than that, as the courts did not assume riieir duties until June of that year. The second date is the year of death, or removal from this Bar. Those marked (*) are still practicing here.
Francis L. Aude, 1850-62. Born in Kentucky. Came from Missouri. Supervisor, 1857. Member of the Assembly, 1858-59. Went to Virginia City in 1862, and from there to San Francisco. Now lives in Virginia City, Nevada.
Stephen J. Field, I860 63. From New fork. First Alcalde of Marysville, 1860. Member of Assembly, 1861. Justice Supreme Court, 1869. United States Circuit Judge, California, 1863. Was elevated to the Supreme Bench of the United States in 1863, which position he now holds, He is q brother of Cyrus W. and David Dudley Field.
1860, mid l.h'' Sacra nl" ''/mm, 1SII1. Clerk in United States District Court, 1865-67, Candidate for Governor, 1867. Secretary United States Senate, 1868-79. Secretary Nati i Republican Executive Committee, 1876. Now resides in Washington.
I1',. < t. F. Hastings, 186] 62. From Ohio. Atone time a Member el' the Assembly. Register United States Land Office, 1859. Moved In Washington, I 862.
Franois L. Hatch, 1854-63. From Texas. District Attorney, 1858-61. Went, to Santa Clara county, 1863. Is at present County Judge of t 'olusa county.
Henry 1'. Haon, 1850-61. From Iowa. Born in Kentucky. County Judge, 1850-53. United States Senator to till Broderick's unexpired term, I860. Died in Marysville, 1861.
David 1.. Maun, 1858-62. From Kentucky. Member of Asseiubly, 1861. Went tn Plumas county in 1862, where he was District Attorney and still resides.
Leonidas Martin, 1 850-5 G. From Alabama. District Attorney, 1854-55. Returned to Alabama in 1856. Was appointed Minister to Valparaiso, where he soon after died.
F. J. McCann, 1850-70. From Kentucky, Bom in Maryland. County Judge, Siena county, 1856. District Attorney, 1864-65. Went to Santa Cruz in 1870, where he now resides.
J. W. McCorkle, 1850-63. From Ohio. Member of the Legislature, 1851. Elected to Congress, 1851. Moved to Virginia City, 1803. Went to San Francisco, 18G8. Now resides in Washington, engaged in prosecuting claims against Mexico.
R. S. Mesick, 1851-63. From New York. State Senator, 1857. Moved to Virginia City, 1863. Was District Judge in Nevada. Resides in San Francisco.
Zaeh Montgomery. 1854-64. From Kentucky. Member of the Assembly, 1860. Went to San Franeiseo in 18G4. Editor OeeUlmt ami Vanguard, 1864. Was a member of the Legislature. Now resides in < lakland.
Cordon N. Mott, 1850-60. From Ohio. Served in the Mexican war. First County Judge of Sutter county. Distiict Judge, 1851, City Recorder, 1855. Appointed Judge of the Supremo Court in Nevada, 1861. Delegate to Congress, 1863-64. Court Commia. sinner, 19th District, San Franeiseo, since 1874.
James McC. Reardon, 1857-75. From Maryland. Wont to Virginia City, 1861. Clerk Supreme Court, Nevada, 1863, Returned to Marysville in 18G7, where he died in 1875.
Marysville.Yuba Co. Cal
Gabriel N. Swezy, 1850 75. Prom New York. District Attorney, 1863. City Attorney, 1856. Member of the Assembly, 1857. Died in Marysville in IK7.r..
Herald, 1850. Leader of the filibustering expedition to Lower Cali- [omiiiin 1853 54. Editor in Sacramento in 1865. Leader of the cele orated invasion of Nicaragua, where he was captured and shot September [2, I860. Ho was known as " the Gray-eyed Man of Destiny."
Provenance
Text from History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.