Yuba County, California - Chapter 15: Field Vs. Turner, 1879
From History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. 1,530 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
1,530 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Appointment of Judge Win. O. Turner - Mr. Field's Intended Departure for tlie East - Cause of lviuy Doaorlpticinot a Scene In Court-room - Arrest and Imprisonment of Mr. Field - Writ of Habeas thrum boloro Judge Baun - Messrs. Field, Goodwin and Mulford Expelled from tho Bar Judge Turner Flues and Orders the Imprisonment of the County Judge- Au Appeal to the Supreme Court - The Result Satisfactory to the Lawyers - Another Expulsion Ordered - Impeachment Proceedings Against Judge Turner - Compromise Under a Misunderstanding.
An event, or rather series of events, which for several years placed Yuba county prominently before the eyes of the public, and kept the legal fraternity throughout the whole State in an agitated condition, was the celebrated ' Turner controversy. The young city, of Marys ville was kept ina fever of excitement; bitter discussions t.-,k place between the several friends and champions of tin- opposing parties, and newspapers throughout 'la- State teemed with accounts of the condition of affairs at ra stages proceedings. Both parties have published and distributed pamphlets, setting forth their relative claims and striving by every argument t,, justify their actions in Hie matter. Judge Wm. a. Turner had been appointed to 'be Eighth Judi
Mr. Stephen J. Field bad made all bis preparations for a Nisii to the Eastern States, but was prevailed uponb] Captain Sutter to delay his departure and defend a suit brought against bim in the District Court.
"On Friday, the 7th instant, a suit between one Cameron, plaintiff, --and Captain Sutter, defendant, was called on for trial before Judge of the District Court. Judge Field was retained as counsel "for Captain Sutter. A preliminary motion in the case was decided "against Captain Sutter, whereupon Judge Field rose to read the pro- " visions of the Statute applicable to the point in question, when Judge "Turner said, in a hurried and petulant maimer, that the Conrt under- " stood the law, and would not listen further - that the mind of the " Court was made up - and wound up by ordering Judge Field to take bis seat. Judge Field then stated, in a very quiet maimer, and in '< very respectful language, that he excepted to the decision of the " Court and appealed from the order. Judge Turner, apparently irri- "tated, immediately replied, addressing himself to Judge Field, '1 fine "tUt gentleman two hundred dollars.' To this, in a quiet manner, « Mr. Field answered, ' Very well.' Turner immediately added in apetu- " lant and angry tone, ' I fine him three hundred dollars, ami commit him " to the custody of ike Sheriff eight hours.' To this Judge Field again " replied, in a quiet and respectful manner, 'Very well,' or, 'Well, " sir,' Turner immediately responded, with great violence and manner "of language, ' I fine him four hundred dollars ami commit him « twelve" hours.' Judge Field then told the Conrt that he had a right " by statute to appeal from any order of his honor, and that it was no "contempt of Com-t to give notice of an exception or an appeal, and appealed to all the members of the bar present if it could be so regarded. At this Judge Turner flew into a rage, and cried out, in a explained his errand Mr. Field protested that the sentence was illegal, hut theofficer being obliged to carry out bis instructions, turned the kej and the lawyer was left fore brief period dose prisoner. Che following is the order imprisoning and fining Me Field;
At a ten,, of said District Court held at Marysville, County of Yuba, on the 7th of June, 1850, present, lb,... Wm. R. Turner, Judge, the following proceeding was bad:
"ancethe authority of this Court and having vilified the Court and " denounced its proceedings, the said Field, Goodwin, and Mulford are I " hereby, by order of the Court, expelled from the Bar of the same.'
Judge Haun, having gone from the court-room, proceeded to open | the Court of Sessions in his own house, that being the day fixed by law for its organization. Mr. Field having sued out another writ of habeas corpus, the com-t, presided over by Hon. Henry P. Haun, County Judge, with F. W. Barnard and O. P. Stidger, Assocmte Justices, proceeded with the healing of the petition. The entry of proceedings is the first in the minute-book, and is as follows:-
Koonnnement, and while making his remarks and previous to the close and while the curt was in iiession, R. B. Buchonnan, Sheriff "of Subn county, at the head of fifty men, entered the said court
its regular term, and that order must be preserved while it was " in wssiou. The said Sheriff, Buohannan, then left the court, where- "upon the business before the oourt was again resumed.
" .u the expiration of some five minutes the said R. B. Buohannan, " as aforesaid, re entered the court, and stated Unit the saidH. P. Haun, -- County Judge, as aforesaid, must leave the court and gowithhim; as .. |u. was peremptorily ordered by William R. Turner, the Judge, as -- aforesaid, to arrest the said II. P. Haun, and keep him in close con- -- finament for the space of forty-eight hum's.
-- R, II. Buohannan was here notified that he was violating the laws " of the land, and that he would lie lined if he persisted in disturbing -' the session of the court. The reply of said Buehannan was ' that he " could not lie frilled with,' and immediately seized the said H. B. Haun, -- County Judge, as aforesaid, by the arm, and attempted to drag him " from the room where the court was in session, whereupon a tine of -- two hundred dollars was then and there imposed upon the said B. B. Buehannan for a contempt of court.
" The said K. B. Buehannan then and there called upon the fifty per- -- sons ordered out by him as his posse to take hold of the said H. P. -' Haun, and take him from the court. But the pei-sons in attendance, the order to arrest the Hon. H. P. Haun to be illegal and - unjustifiable, refused to assist the Sheriff" in the execution of his illegal
Julv. the Supreme Cant deeid.d both applications, granting the writs; but after Judge Turner had obeyed these orders, lie again expelled the parties named on the twenty-eighth of October, while the Court was sitting at Nicolaus, the county seat of Sutter county. At the fall election of 1850, J. 1 1. Goodwin was elected to the office of District Attorney, an event which placed both himself and Judge Turner in a delicate position. This difficulty; however, was overcome by the following order, made November 4, 1850: "Although J. O. Goodwin is not recognized by this Court as a member of the Bar of the District Court of the -' Eighth Judicial District, yet the Court feels authorized to permit " him, the said J. O. Goodwin, to attend to all causes or other business " which may require his attention as District Attorney; but the said " J. O. Goodwin is precluded from appearing before the Court in any " other cause or causes than such as require his attention as District " Attorney." November 17, 1850, an order was entered restoring Mr. Goodwin to full privileges as a member of the Bar; hut the other gentlemen still remained under the ban of the act.
But the end was not yet. Mr. Field having been elected to the Legislature, presented a petition to the Assembly from citizens of Yuba county, on Monday, March 17, 1851, requesting the removal of Judge Turner by impeachment. A committee was appointed to hear the testimony on the charges, and reported on Tuesday, April 18, 1851. On the nineteenth, in the House, in Committee of the "Whole, a motion " to indefinitely postpone the charges and testimony in the case," was carried by a vote of fifteen to twelve. This vote seems to have been taken while the members were under an erroneous impression regarding the state of affairs. Mr. Field had introduced a bill which became a law March 11, 1851, by which the Eighth Judicial District was changed to include the comities of Trinity and Klamath, and which necessitated the removal of the Judge, "Wm. R. Turner, to that locality. The members of the Legislature were anxious to speedily close the session, an impossibility if the impeachment trial was proceeded with. In this emergency, one of the Senators, misunderstanding Mr. Field's words, circulated the report that he would be satisfied to have the matter indefinitely postponed, if it did not silently acknowledge the justness of Turner's' cause. Under the law, Judge Turner removed to the new Eighth Judicial District, and in 1851, Hon. Gordon N. Mott was appointed by the Governor to preside in the now Tenth Judicial Hi, triet. Since the controversy, the proceedings of the Courts of and Sutter counties, have been marked by harmony and courtesy.
Provenance
Text from History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.