Yuba County, California - Lands and Titles, 1879
From History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. 7,225 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
16 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
7,225 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Lands and Titles
The Right to the Land - Transfers - Disputes in Regard to Titles - Extract from the " Annals of San Francisco " - Action of Congress - The Land Commission - Extract from Hittcll'B " History of San Francisco " - President Buchanan Called Upon to Account for tlio Appro, priations Made for Settling Land Claims - Edwin M. Stanton Sent to San Francisco as Spocial Council for the Government - Sutter's Grants - Squatter Troubles in Marysvillc-Bail. road Lands - Public Lands - U. S. Land Office of Marysville District - List of Ofliecra-Koport of Business Transacted from January 1, 1878, to December 81, 1878.
The Spaniards claimed the lands in California by virtue of discovery and first occupation, and, as in the discovery of America, the Aborigines were considered as having no absolute title or right which could be conveyed by gift or sale. To the early locators, Spain transferred her interest by grants, being lavish in the extent of her donations. In 1822, when Mexico threw off the yoke of Spanish rule and declared herself an independent empire, the right of giving grants was also claimed. At the conclusion of the Mexican war, and after the treaty of Gaudalupe Hidalgo had been signed and ratified, early in 1848, the right to public lands in California passed to the United States government, with the provision that the then existing titles of private individuals and incorporations should not be disturbed, and all grants heretofore derived through the Mexican or Spanish authorities, should be respected. The grants given to these early loeaters were for a definite number of leagues in some valley
I 0X|,eii»ive litigation. The following extract from the Arnuila of Sim fmrnisco, is an explanation of the troubles which beset the landholders.
"The most important decision ever given by the Supreme Court of i' Mifornia was announced to-day, in the case of Cohas vs. Rosin & ii topis. Previous decisions, both of this and the lower legal tribunals, had established principles which unsettled the city titles to 11 nearly ovary lot of ground within the municipal boundaries, and || mightily encouraged squatterism. By these decisions, one title had "just seemed as good or as bad as another; possession being better '! Hum any. The alarming consequences of these doctrines forced both ''liuiu-h and bar into further inquiries and minute researches into the "laws, usages aud customs of Spanish or Mexican provinces and "towns. The new information thus acquired, was brought to bear " upon the suit above named, where principles were evolved and a " precedent formed of the utmost consequence to the community, and " which have nearly settled, though not quite, the ' squatter ' ques- "tious. The decision was pronounced by Judge Heydenfeldt, and was "oononrred in by Chief Justice Murray, although upon somewhat different grounds, and Judge Wells. Without entering upon the merits " uf the particular case in question, we give the ' conclusions ' come "to. These conclusions sustain all alcaldes' grants in the city, no 11 natter though the alcalde himself had been illegally appointed and "made a dishonest use of his power. By this decision - all opposing "precedents having been expressly set aside by the Court - many noto- "rionsly fraudulent alcalde grants have been legalized; but that seems Ismail price to pay for the full assurance of title now given to the "proprietors of the most valuable part of the ground within the "aunicipal bounds."
Tbe confusion in regard to the ownership of these lands became so 6*teiisive, that in March 1851, Congress enacted a law providing for »» settlement of the iand claims. President Fillmore appointed for ""earners of the Board, Harry L. Thornton, Augustus Thompson and %fceu8 L. Felch, but his Democratic successor deposed them and ^'pointed three others. The Land Commission commenced its sittings
"with authority to examine all claims made to land under grant "under Mexico, and conlirm all valid grants. The Act mad.- no " reference to the promise given by Commodore Sloat in bis proclamation issued on the seventh of July, 18 IG, when in baking 1 1 "of the country on behalf of the American Government, he declared " that henceforth California would be a portion of the United States, "and as an inducement for accepting cordially, or at least peaceably, " the change, he assured, the people that 'all persons holding titles to " real estate, or in quiet possession of lands under color of right, shall "have those titles guaranteed to them.' This language was doubtless "used under express instructions from the Cabinet; we know that (( Commodore Sloat had been ordered in 1845, to seize Californiaat the " hrst outbreak of hostilities, and wo may presume that directions " were given to him in regard to what he should say when lie made " the seizure. ' Color of right,' is a phrase common in American "jurisprudence, and would not have been adopted except under the " suggestion of a lawyer. Even if Sloat exceeded the authority " conferred by his instructions, that fact could not be known to the " native Californians, and they were justified in believing that he had " full power to make the promise, which thus became a solemn contract " under the law of nations with every one who submitted to the " American authority." The Thirty-fourth and Thirty-fifth I krogresses having appropriated one hundred and fourteen thousand dollars for legal assistance and other expenditures in settling private land claims in this State, the next Congress requested of President Buchanan, a detailed account of the disposal of this fund. This action caused the general dissemination of the facts regarding the wonderful complexity of land titles, but it was only brought out after a number of years of investigation and litigation. In February, 1858, Edwin M.Stanton was sent to San Francisco, as special counsel for the Government, in pending law cases. Captain Sutter claimed that he *as entitled to thirty-three leagues of land in the Sacramento valley, under two grants; one for eleven leagues, made by Governor Alvarado, in 1841. was adjudged genuine, but the other, which he had obtained from M.cheltoi-enT, for twenty-two leagues, covering the sites of Sacramento and Marvsville, was not allowed, the Commissioner deciding that the act was done after Micheltorena had been expelled by a revolution, and not being Governor, he could not exercise the powers and f unions cf
I I Ii .11 I Want
Whereas, John Augustus Sutter, a native of the 8wi.sn Republio and naturalized in the Mexican nation, has solicited, according to the law of August 11, 182i, for Iris personal benefit and thai of twelve families, eleven leagues of land on the borders ..i the River Sacra nn ii to, in the vacant lands of the northern frontier, in order to colonize good behavior, and all other qualities required in these cases; havinj already anticipated his increased efforts, his constant firmness, and his true patriotic zeal in favor of our institutions, having rodu I to subrnissii n fl number of savage Indians over in those frontiers, and thifl government being sufficiently informed that the mentioned land does not belong to the property of any private individual, town or corpora tion, and that in consequence thereof it is specified in the aforesaid law, and in conformity with the powers conferred on me in the name of the Mexican nation, I bave granted to the said Senor Don Augustus Sutter, by these present letters for bun and his settlers, the sai-l land called La Nueva Elveeia (New Elbetia), subject to the approval or disapproval of the Superior Government, and of the Excellent, the Department Assembly, under the following conditions:
Second - He shall maintain the native Indians of dillerent tribes on those places in the free enjoyment of their possessions, without troubling them, and he may only reduce them to civilization through prudent measures and a friendly intercourse; he shall not cause them
Therefore I order that this patenl being held us firm and valid, the entered in the proper book, and that these proceedings be transmitted to the Exoellont, the Departmental Assembly, Juan B.
Manuel Mioheltorena, Brigadier Ge al of the Mexican army, Adjutant General of the Staff, Governor General in Chief , and Inspector General of the Department of the California*.
Whereas, Don Juan Augustan Sutter, a Mexican naturalized citi-vii, mill Ins son, John A. Suitor, lia\o solicited for the personal bonofitof themselves and family the surplus of land within Ids ranch, named Now Helvetia, us is laid down in the maps which accompany the giant, and the usual investigation and inquiry in relation thereto required by law and regulations having been satisfied. In virtue of the authority conferred upon me, in the name of the Mexican nation, and tor the good conduct and services which the said Sutter lias rendered aud is rendering at the present time, I have conceded to them the mentioned lands; declaring in them the ownership thereof bj these presents, subject to the approbation of the Assembles Departmental, and under the following conditions: -
First They max enclose it without interfering with the paths, roads and highways. They shall enjoy it exclusively, and freely appropriating it to the uses of cultivation which suits their convenience.
Executed on this ordinary paper, having no stamped paper appropriate, Santa Barbara, this fifth day of February, eighteen hundred and forty-five.
Railroad Lands
The lands of the California and Oregon Division of the Central Pacific Railroad occupy a considerable portion of Yuba and Sutter counties. These were secured under an Act of Congress, approved July 23, I860, which granted to the company all the vacant odd-numbered sections within twenty miles on each side of its road. "Where these sections are previously occupied by settlers the company can select other vacant odd-numbered sections within thirty miles of the road, as indemnity. A large proportion of the railroad lands in Yuba county are withheld as mineral, but the company have a force at work rapidly " proving off the mineral," and the sections are becoming ready for sale.
Public Lands
The lands of the United States are or have been disposed of in the following way: - First, under the Pre-emption laws; second, under the Homestead laws; third, by public sale, private entry, and scrip locations ; fourth, by grants to the State. Of the last class are the following: - Grant of the Swamp and Overflowed Lands by the Act of September 28, 1850. Grant of five hundred thousand acres for internal improvements by Act of September 4, 1841. By the Constitution of California the proceeds of this grant were transferred to the School Fund. May 3, 1852, the Legislature, by an Act, earned out this provision, and a law was passed authorizing the sale at two dollars per acre. The proceeds were invested in State bonds at seven per ceut. April 3, 1858, the price was reduced to one dollar and a quarter per acre. All interest falling due on bonds was placed to the credit of the School Fund. The grant of the sixteenth and thirtysixth sections was given to the State for school purposes by Act of March 3, 1853. The grant of seventy-two sections for a seminary of learning, and ten sections for public buildings, was made by Act of March 3, 1853. The gran! of one hundred and fifty thousand acres for an Agricultural College was made July 2, 1862. Ll. s. LAND OFFICE.
Previous to the year 1855, the only United States Land Office in California, was located at Benioia. During that year, by tho authority granted under the act, approved in March, 1853, the State was divided into two divisions, the Upper District, with its office at MaryBville, and the Lower District, with its office at San Francisco. As settlers began pouring in, the location of the offices was found to he too far from the distant parts of the districts, and the business was becoming too cumbersome. Stockton District was formed, a portion of the land and records being taken from Marysville, or Upper District, and the remainder from San Francisco, or Lower District. The next district formed was Sacramento, which was segregated from Marysville and Stockton Dstricts; then followed the setting apart of Humboldt District from San Francisco and Marysville Districts; Shasta District in Jidy, 1871), an 1 Susanville Districtin February, 1871, were taken from Marysville District.
The district, as at present bounded, contains two hundred and twenty-one townships, or about 5,091,840 acres, extending from township eight to twenty-five north. In the southern part, it includes townships three east and three west, and in its widest portion, eleven east and seven west. The following are some of the confirmed grants lying in this district: - New Helvetia, Honcut, Boga, Farwell, Oapay, Fernandez, Larkin's Children, Arroyo C'hico, Jimeno, Jacinto, Colus, Los Putos, Bio de Los Putos, Bio de Los Jesus Maria and Gnesisosi. By instructions from the Secretary of the Interior, January 22, 1872, a considerable portion of Yuba county was withdrawn for mineral purposes. In order to perfect title to this, the pre-emptor, before " proving up," must publish and post on the land notices for thirty days, citing opposing parties to appear. Abundant testimony of the non-mineral character of the land must be offered, and if this proof is satisfactory the entry is permitted, and the course then pursued is the same as in ordinary pre-emption entry. Much of the land on this tract has been thus located on. The following is a list of the townships reserved: - 14 N., B. 6 £.; 15 N., B. 6 E.; 16 N., K. 5 and 6 E.; 17 N., R. 5, 6 and 7 E.; 18 N., B. 5, 6 and 7 E.; 19 No B. 6 and 7 E.; 20 N., B. 7 E.
officers. The first officers of the district were John A. Paxton, Eeceiver, and Charles" Si Fan-fax, Register. They received their commissions May
. ,g55j but the office was not opened until June. Mr. Fairfax re- 1 November 1, 1856, and on the seventeenth of that month, Mr. p^ton forwarded his resignation. Peter C. Rust was appointed to Mi-. Paxton as Receiver, and was also ex-officio Register. October 8, 1857, he was succeed by Charles Lindloy, who remained in the office till September 1, 1858. From this time the two offices irere divided, ami Joseph Hopkins was appointed Receiver, and E. 0. I Hastings, Register. Both of these gentlemen remained in office imlil May 21, 1861, when A. J. Snyder became Register, and James Oompton, Receiver. Mr. Oonipton was suspended May 19, 1803, and was succeeded by Charles G. Bockius. At the expiration of his term, mm succeeded by Dr. Eli Teegarden, April 15, 1867, who remained in the office for eight years, until April 1, 1875, when Judge L. T. Crone, the present incumbent, was appointed. September 1, 1875, Mr. Ayor wus succeeded by Charles M. Patterson, the present Reginter.
District Judqk
la November, I860, Gordon X. Mott was appointed by the Got ernor to the position made vacant by the removal of Judge Win. R. Turner, to a new Judicial District.
County Judge
In December, 1858, Judge S. M. Miss resigned, having been elected to the District Court, and Charles Lindloy was appointed by the Goi ernor to fill the vacancy.
Public Adhinibtrator
and Surveyor divided the Oountj into Supervisor*.] districts as follows: First District Marysville Township No. 1. Beoond District l,ni,l., No. in"! Bar No. 3. Third District - Long Bar No. 4 and- Parka Bar No. 6. Fourth District- Dobbins No. 6, FoBter Bar No. 7 and Keystone No. 10. Fifth District - Northeast Ho, o and Slate Range No. 8, From 1859 to 1874 the Board- was ooinpoBod of three Supervisora from Hi,' following districts: - First -
Long Bar and Parks Bar. Third New York, Foster Bar, Northeast and Slate Range. Sinn, 1S7I tlii'iv have tivc members in the Board The Fii'Bt Distriot is composed of the First mid Second \\ ardeof the Citj of Marysyille; the Second of the Third ami Fourth witli East Bear River, Wesl Bear River and Linda Townships; the Fourth of Roae Bar, Long Bar, and Parks Bar; the Fifth of New Yoil. Slate Range, Foater Bar and Northeast Townsliips.
The early elections have been described in other portions of this volume. The minutes of the Court of Sessions and Board of Supervisor, during the firs! few years after the organization of the county, contain no records of the canvass of t otes.
Clerk
.i Resigned : G~K. Patterson elected June 18. l«Preai4ent«r Ooemfl. lIEesi^ed ; Geo. Menitt elected July 2. I6«esident of Council, itrreadent el Ceuiwil. »EeFi(p>ed ; C. B. Fowler alooted Vny 20. :i Resigned I George B. HorniSh elected. UReslgned NoV.Tth, liTO: E. Eannister appointed. 23Did not quality ; E.H.Ward appointed.
Financial
On the thirtieth of April, l85S,an An of the Legislature, '* to pro- "vide for Funding the Floating Debl of the Citj of Marysville, and, - - (or the Extinguishment Thereof," was approved. The Mayor, President of the Council, and Treasurer were made "The Funding C
" missioners of the ' (ity of Marysville," unci their duties were defined. Certificates of Btocli were to I"- issued to oover the amount of the oit/s indebtedness up to the Srsl of July, 1856. The Common Coun was allowed to authorize the Board of Funding Commissioners to issue bonds similar to the others, " to an amount not exceeding ten another bill wasapproved Eoi the purpose of Funding the Floating Debt. Under its provisions, the Mayor, Treasurer, and Clerk constituted the Board of Commissi -«. Inaddition to the other matters,
"dollai'B, to be expended on the erection of an engine-house for tho "use of the Fire Department, and for the erection of school houses." If two-thirds of the votes were in favor of this measure, the City Counoil were to authorize the Board of Funding Commissioners to issue bonds to that amount. February 5, 1868, two Acts were approved, one amendatory to the oilier. The limit lixed for the amount of tho bonds was seventy thousand dollars. The act merely extended the powers of the existing Board of Commissioners, and ordered them "to pay into the Citj Treasury I he sum of eighteen "thousand dollars" lying in their hands uninvested, which was lobe placed in a fund called the Levee Fund.
Below is a table containing a list of the bonds issued bythe city of Marysville, of which anj are outstanding. Owing to the incomplete and inaccurate records, no satisfactory results could be obtained in the examination of the books pertaining to the lirst issue of bonds, hence they are omitted.
Yuba county lias several times been compelled to resort to the use of bands tostraightenher financial affairs. The recklessness of expenditures in the tiist few years of the county s existence, the high price of labor and material, the lack of anything valuable to form the basis of taxation, soon plunged the county headlong into debt. The first year the the heavy licenses collected. In view of this fact, the Legislature Ian Act, approved April 10, 1852, authorizing the county to issue seven per cent, bonds for all warrants held against the treasury. rjnder this Act, warrants to the amount of $47,615.76 were funded. The old books are either lost, or so incomplete that it is impossible to give a complete history of these bunds. Notwithstanding this relief the county still continued to sink into debt, and March 26, 1857, another Act was passed by the Legislature, providing for the funding of the county debt. Under this Act bonds to the amount of $96,800 were issued. Of these, $53,600 were redeemed, and $43,200 were funded in bonds of 1868, as provided by an Act of the Legislature, approved February 13, 1868. Since then, there have been no bonds issued for general county expenses. Under au Act, approved April 28, 1857, authorizing the county to issue bonds to the amount of §200,000 to the San Francisco and -Marysville Railroad Company, $100,000 in bonds wen; issued. For the bonds the county was to receive an equal amount of the railroad stock. The Board of Supervisors, having refused to issue the other $100,000 subscribed, long and expensive litigation with the California Pacific Railroad Company ( successor to the S. !-'. & M.- R. R- Co.) was maintained, which finally resulted in an Act of the Legislature, in 1861, allowing the county to compromise with the railroad company, by both parties releasing all claims. In 1868, $32,500 of these bonds were funded, $67,500 having been redeemed, and $73,775 having been paid hi interest.
The condition of other bonds, issued by the county, can readily be seen, by reference to the subjoined table. The table also shows that the county has borrowed $460,815.76, for which there has been paid in interest $356,514.45, exclusive of the interest on the 1853 bonds, winch could not have been less than $15,000; also that $302,915.76, have been redeemed, leaving the amount outstanding, or the total bonded indebtedness, $163,900.
The practice of borrowing money for current expenses is certainly a costly one, and the burden of the issuance of bonds to aid supposed beneficial enterprises is more apt to be fully realized after, than before its execution.
Crimes And Punishments
'I'l,,, natural i - 1 1- li-i \ of ociety, when Left uncurbed by legal regulations is towards lawlessness. So it was in tin- early days of rjiiwi iijii 'I'll'' |' ipulation in Hi-' year 1848 and the greater part of intelligent elomonl of Hi'' oa torn cities and States, Bat the next tide that Mowed in threw upon our Bhores the refuse material from the larger ratios on Hi'' Atlantic side of the Continent, and a horde of discharged oonvicts from the Australian Colonies. 'II"' change in lietj
Mi,. 'I.iil, streets or over the lonely plains anil hills, feeling perfect safetj In his Bolitudej now his gold dust must be hidden or placed in realising that fact ami knowing the oonsequence of leniency toward the I'liiniiiiil class, book the law into their own hands. A crime was .' niU'il, ttin neighboring miners quickly captured the suspected person, ii judge whs appointed, a jury summoned ami sworn; attorneys (unlearned in bhe lew) were prov iileil, ami the trial proceeded w ith nil the gravity ami formality of a legally organized court. The testimony was heard, arguments made, and the ease placed in the hands of ths jury. Their decision was final, and upon it depended in most instancee the life of the prisoner, for hanging in those days was the favorite punishment for murder and oven stealing. Of the many peculiar cases in the criminal record of Ynlia County, we will recount a few of the most prominent, and interesting.
Viqilanob Committee
Soon after the organization of tin' celebrated Vigilance Committee in San Francisco, the people of Marysville concluded to unite and form a similar institution for mutual protection. The tendency of the actions in i he metropolis was to drive the criminal class into the interior cities, and it was for this reason partly that the Vigdanee Committee was formed in Man s\ ills. July 31, 1 85 1 . the address of Dr. J. S. Wright, the newly elected President, was published in the Herald. It was a clear exposition of the condition of affairs and the uecessitv for the existence of the Citizen Judiciary.'' About August of the same year, a Vigilance Committee « as organized at Barton's Bar. on the Yuba river, probably growing oat of the action taken in punishing a man named Reynolds, a gun thi. f. At a meeting of the Marysville Committee, held \'i_.i i 19, 18S1, the following resolutions were passed, which clearly show the spirit of il rganization: -
"Resolved, Thai this committee will never lend its aid to any man "or set of men, for the purpose of disorganizing established goveru- mint .,r nullify ill'.; the laws."
i in "I,,-,' 13, 1851, F. W. Shaeffer, J. H. Jewett and B. A. Eddy were appointed a committee to make assessments, to collect the same, to defray the debt and to dispose of the property of the organization. A committee of ten consisting of F. W. Shaeffer, J. L. McDufEe, B. A. Eddy, \V. W. Smith, Horace Beach, L. Steinhart, Charles Gleason, John < !. Smith. ( 'harles Ball and E. Woodruff, were appointed a standing executive committee. The general committee finding no more work to perforin ceased active operations.
A singular instance of assault occurred in 1854; Blummer W. Thurston, proprietor of the Eldorado Saloon, met Br. Winters as he was disembarking from a steamer at the landing, satchel in hand, and struck at him with a piece of wood or a cane. In warding off the blow, Winters' arm was broken, when being at the mercy of the assailant he was severely beaten. Thurston was indicted by the Grand Jury, and after a trial was sentenced to six months' imprisonment in the penitentiary. An appeal was taken to the District Court, which had no jurisdiction. The case lingered along, until some months after attention was called to it by a communication from Judge O. B. Stidger in the Herald. The day it appeared that gentleman was met by Thurston and assaulted. Judge Barbour also seconded the assault with a knife. Being between two fires, Judge Stidger was very cruelly treated. Blummer Thurston was afterwards killed in Fanama.
A peculiar case was that of George Bowe, County Treasurer. In August, 1S51, an indictment was found against him for neglect of duty. When brought before the Court of Sessions, a nolle prosequi was entered. December 2, 1851, Mr. Bowe having been again indicted wa3 brought into the District Court charged with having " wilfully and cor- -' ruptly collected from divers and sundry persons of said (Yuba) county, " the scrip of the said county in payment of taxes and licenses, having " procured by fraud and collusion with other persons to supply depre- " ciated scrip and furnish the same to the persons offering to pay their " taxes, and that the defendant and his procurer divided the profits in
" money thus made by the illegal supply of said scrip which was- in fact first paid the defendant in gold and silver." A motion to quad, the indictment was entered and sustained. A third indictment was. found in April, 185'-', relative to the condition of the books and papers in his office. The matter was dropped and Bowe was re-elected when his term of office expired.
On the seventh or eighth of August, 1851, a couple of Indians from Tuba City were caught on the Yuba river, near Rose's ranch, stealing watermelons. They received a severe whipping and were thrown into the river. On Sunday, the tenth, a party of forty whites went from Rose's to Yuba City and demanded the surrender of an Indian who had been committing some depredations on the Yuba river. They were perfectly wdling to give up the guilty party provided he was recognized by the whites. Being unable to do this and seeing an old Indian crossing the river, he was declared to be the guilty party. The party commenced a brisk fire on the voyager, and the Indians who knew him to be innocent, returned the fire. Several on both sides were wounded and the whites were compelled to retreat. The citizens of Yuba City met and passed resolutions severely condemning the action of the white men and agreeing to protect the Indians in the future.
The Eurdue Case
In December, 1850, a man named Charles Moore, of Winslow Bar, Yuba County, was murdered near Dobbins' Ranch, by Jim Stewart.. The murderer escaped and could not be apprehended. On the nineteenth of February, 1851, the store of C. J. Jansen & Co., in San Francisco, was entered, and Mr. Jansen was cruelly maltreated and left for dead. The store was robbed, and the perpetrators escaped. The next day two men were arrested, one supposed to be Jim Stewart, and the other named Windf red. The first was accused of the murder of Mr. Moore, and while in custody was also charged with committing this later crime. Owing to the inefficient and non-zealous police and judiciary, the citizens decided to take the matter into their own hands. About three thousand people gathered at the City Hall ; twelve men were chosen as a jury; W. T. Coleman was appointed prosecutor; and two lawyers, Hall McAllister and D. D. Shattuck, were chosen to defend the accused. Although one of the prisoners stoutly protested that he was not Jim Stewart, and that his name was Thomas Burdue, the injured man, Mr. Janson, swore positively to his identity. The jury, however, could not agree upon a verdict, three standing out for acquittal. It was with great difficulty that the prisoners could be kept from the hands of the infuriated mob, who were inclined to make short work of all criminals. They were handed over to the. proper authorities, and upon trial found guilty. The sentence imposed was six (by some stated at fourteen) years' imprisonment. Windfred escaped, was granted, - no& /OTMJui - entered, and the cose dismissed. weut to San Antrim, where similar proceedings were hod on theohorge of robbery and the attempted murder of Jansen. He was Itollj released on the third of September, and a purse was made up night before while on o ipree, and who had thencalled to paj for the same, n held a trial and strung her up at once The matte, waf tin ubjed of -I. nnfavorabiec men! in the ne and returned to the laloon. When I" arrived there, Baron drew a large knife and flourished Lt about Harris attempted to strike him with the ax, when Baron tabbed, him with the knife. Harris died that night, and b" a was arroBted, tried and acquitted. Faron was afterward i with Walker in his Invasion of Nicaragua, and rose to the rank of largo and powerful man, Ul the roughs were afraid of him, as he scrupled not to use his Btrengtb on them when necessary. One night in 1858, wliile Jones was watching a game of cards in a saloon, Red Mike, who was drunk, shot bim dead with his revolver. He escaped and wa; never oaptured, though diligent search was made for him. Iln spent that night and the next day lying on the tup of a brick kiln
T1Ik Taxnku Case
Friday afternoon, March 1!>. [S.VJ, a man named George Tanner, alias Tom Grigg, was detected in the act of secreting in bis house a bag of potatoes, taken from the warehouse of Low i Brothers. The house was searched and four tons of stolen goods were found. The man was taken bafore Recorder Watkins, who allowed him to go on two thousand dollars bail. When the fact of his release became known the church bell was tolled and a number of citizens assembled. The alarm also brought out the Hook aud Ladder Company. After much general discussion, aud the expression of extreme dissatisfaction at the act of the Recorder, the crowd quietly dispersed. The next morning (Saturday), Tanner being discovered on the outskirts of the town, apparently aboul to escape, he was pursued and captured. , While mning through a pool of water be dropped an article, which upon examination proved t , be a buckskin bag. containing three gold watches. At a meeting of the citizens on the Plaza a committee of twenty-live well-known persons was appointed to try the prisoner. The trial was held In the room on D street, formerly occupied by the Vigilance Committee. After mature deliberation the prisoner was adjudged guilty of grand larceny, which, by the laws of the Slate. w as punishable by imprisonment or by death, as the jury might decide. The report was read to the crowd outside amid the wildest excitement. "Hang him, hang him!" echoed from all sides. But there was a better element in the crowd which was opposed to any such extreme measure. While the vote was being taken, the wife of the prisoner with her two children was silently but touchingly appealing for her guilty husband. The Mayor inadea speecli against the exhibition of violence, and had a large number of supporters. The committee were in a quandary, but after due consideration decided that having received Tanner from the people they woidd return him to them. This they proceeded to do, but as he appeared, the City Marshal with his Deputy and several volunteer aids quickly took him in charge. The wildest confusion followed, and a general conflict seemed imminent. The prisoner was conducted to the Recorder's office and while the crowd waited in front, the officers passed out at the back door and soon lodged Tanner securely in the jail. Tanner was brought to trial before the Court of Sessions, and on April 15, he was adjudged "guilty of grand larceny punishable with " death." On the nineteenth, the death sentence was pronounced upon him, appointing as the day of execution Friday, May 28. In the last part of May the Supreme Court granted a stay of execution until July 23, a motion for a new trial was, however, denied. Tanner's wife was very persistent in her endeavors to free her husband, and vainly sought the intervention of the Governor. July 23, the day set, the guilty man was executed by Sheriff Gray, on the common a few hundred yards north of the jail, a guard of citizens being present to preserve order. The prisoner made no confession. Upon petition " nu- " merously signed by the most respectable citizens of the city," the Councd refused his body a resting place in the city burial ground, and it was interred outside. The same night body snatchers made a raid on it, and had dug down to the coffin when they were interrupted. The remains were taken up, and the mourning widow had them placed in her yard, where she could keep vigil over the body of him she had loved, This was the only conviction and execution in the State under the then existing law, and it was repealed at the next session of the Legislature. This is a remarkable case on accout of its beingan instance of hanging for stealing, an unusual thing in the United States in modern times.
Other Robberies
In August, 1851, Frank Reynolds stole a gun at Barton's Bar. Upon bis apprehension a court, was organized by tho citizens with Captain Wilson as .1 udge and a competent jury. He was found guilty and the sentence of twenty lashes was executed. On the steamer of the first of November, 18.r)l, the City Marshal, Albert S. Miller, and his Deputy departed, having absconded with two thousand two hundred dollars of the city funds. Suits were brought against his bondsmen to recover the amount, In 1852, John McCune robbed Nonis & Folsom, in Foster Bar township, of three thousand, five hundred dollars and a gold watch, for which crime ho was arrested and tried by the miners. The jury debated for a long time as to the mode of punishment to be inflicted, some were in favor of hanging, some of cutting off his ears, and others of whipping; they finally agreed upon the latter, and twenty-five lashes were administered and the culprit was given twenty-four hours in which to leave the town. Messrs. Norris & Folsom administered the flogging.
Highway Kobberies
Highway robberies were a frequent occurrence. The brush and rough surface of the country afforded abundant means for ambush and escape, hence it was seldom that the guilty parties were caught. Murder was frequently resorted to, in order to accomplish the deed. Of late years, the increase of travel, and the better protection afforded by the officers of the law, have caused nearly a total discontinuance of this crime.
Joaquin Murietta, who for a long time was the terror of travelers, and lonely settlers, never operated to any extent, in this vicinity. He had a sister living in Marysville, whom he frequently visited. Ha was there for a considerable time, in 1850, and 1851, and was known as a notorious character, After the killing of Joaquin, considerable doubt existed as to the identity of the dead robber. His head was amputated, and with the hand of Three-fingered Jack, was exhibited throughout the State. While in Marysville, Joaquin's sister visited the exhibition, and after gazing upon the head, remarked in Spanish to a gentleman within the hearing of Judge 0. P- Stidger, " that's not my brother." When asked who it was, she smiling replied, " It is Joaquin GonzaleB." This would seem to give some credence to the rumor that the real Joaquin Murietta had escaped.
The most notorious robber that ever roamed over the territory in tins region, was Tom Bell. The description of this person is best given in the words of Judge Edward McGowan, as published in the San Francisco Evening Post.
Whealoon Claim
j;,.,,. ... :, . robbed is October, 1876, near the Toll lions.-, one mile m I of the Oregon House. Tom Brown and hie brother stopped the Itagi the brother going to the head of the horses and Tom leveling his gun on the driver. Bcammon, a banker from Downieville, was on and after 0 little difficulty in securing tin- horses, thai were frightened by the firing, the passengers, mail and express were robbed, and the Stage allowed to |o >- d. The eighteen thousand dollars were not secured, as they were hidden in the gun case, ralise and trunk; Scamin eoovored. A party pursued the Browns, and coming upon their the afiairs novel' became generally known. Some however were subjects of general comment for a long time. Probably the most celebrated duel. or rather incipient iluel, which has occurred in the county, is that between Judges Field and Barbour. The latter was Judge of of the Tenth District Court, and in some manner a feeling of enmity sprang up botw i (lie two gentlemen. This spirit led to innumerable little sipinlililes and nearly culminated seriously. Geo. C. Gorliam wrote a severe stricture on . I edge Barbour and handed it to O. P. Stidger, editor of the Uerald, for publication. The same day, as Judge K'old was proceeding to his office, with his arms full of books, he was assaulted bj Judge Barbour, who claimed that his opponent had caused the publication of the offensive article. The parties being separated, by some diplomatic efforts Judge Harbour was forced to send the challenge. This left Mr. Field with the privilege of selecting the weapons and maimer of meeting. It was at first proposed to tight with knives in a dark room, but Judge Barbour would not accede to this, claiming that it was cruelty. Finally it was decided to have a meeting with tire arms, on the opposite side of Bear river. Charles S. Fairfax acted as second for Judge Barbour, and Gordon N. Mott for .1 edge Field. .Vltliough both parties appeared on the ground, an actual conflict was avoided, surgeon appointed. They went to the grounds south of Camptonville. When the stranger fired his opponent fell and was immediately sprinkled with red berry juice. The stranger seeing him fall, and observing the red, which he supposed to be blood, thought that was a good place to get away fr , and no time so good as the present, n.i i herefore broke for the wilderness. Several months later his bones ami clothes were found at the foot of a precipice, over which he had
The body was discovered accidentally in the following manner: - \ man named Blackburn had murdered a boy, George W. Carothers, and fled in the direction the stranger had taken, and while hunting for Blackbum the citizens discovered the remains of the unfortunate victim of their practical joke. Early Tuesday morning, March 8, | So:;, two men fought a duid near the cemetery, in Marysville, with double-barreled shot-guns, loaded with buckshot. One was wounded in the thigh, and had his left arm broken - cause, a woman. No notice was taken by the authorities. Albert Turner and William Houser agreed to settle a quarrel in the honorable way, and adjourned to Sutter county for that purpose, June 10, 1858, The Shei iff interfered however, and they started for Butte county, but finally returned to Marysville. They met near the Hospital the next morning with seconds and surgesno, and had five shots at each other, with shot-guns loaded with ounce balls, distance fifty paces. At the last fire Houser was badly wounded in the right arm. A duel occurred in 1853, in which Richard Rust, editor of the California Express, challenged O. P. Stidger, editor of the Herald. They met two miles below Yuba City. They used revolvers, at a distance of ten paces. One shot was tired and a bullet went through the coat of Stidger. The cause was some articles appearing in the Herald criticising some in the Express, and the motives of the editor in publishing them.
The last resort to the " code honorable," was made by Thomas Burns and John Davis, of Marysville. They had a quarrel over some domestic difficulty, in which Davis received severe chastisement. He challenged Burns to the fiel 1 of honor, and they fought a duel January S, 1871, a few miles below Yuba City. Revolvers were used at thirty paces, and after the exchange of four harmless shots, the honor of these gentlemen was completely satisfied, and they retired from the field.
The most mysterious incident in the criminal annals of the county is the recent Wheatland tragedy. Sometime during Monday night, June 9, 1879, two young ladies, Miss Cara Heslep and Miss Ida Dunn, while quietly sleeping in the house of Wni. Rodden. near
Wheatland, were struck on the head with an iron bar, by some unknown person. For several days they remained in an unconscious state, hovering between life and death. When they recovered they were both unable to furnish the slightest clue to the identity of the person who had made such a cruel attempt upon their lives. Miss Dunn had been carried out of the house, and was found sometime after the occuraiice lying in the yard. The appearances seemed to indicate that both girls were struck by the same blow, as they lay sleeping side b\ side. There were no circumstances connected with the affair to indicate that any other cause than a personal one was the reason for the crime. A negro mimed Williams was arrested, having been seen
Chinaman was also arrested and discharged. Frank Choquette, a Frenchman, gave himself up, declaring himself to be the perpetrator. He was ascertained to be crazy, and was also discharged. After detectives had worked dilligently on the ease for three months, spurred on to extraordinary efforts by the offer of large rewards, William Rodden and wife, in whose house the deed was committed, and who were occupying another room in the house at the time of the occurrence, were arrested. A long and searching examination revealed no evidence against them of any certainty, and they were entirely exonerated. Thus this affair still remains in impenetrable darkness, waiting for possible developments in the future to shed light upon it.
Provenance
Text from History of Yuba County, California, with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories, published 1879, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.