Casa Grande was built in as the residence of the general manager of the New Almaden Mining Com- pany, the richest and most productive mining enter- prise in North America. Designed by San Francisco architect Gordon Parker Cummings and Henry W. Hal- leck, then manager of the company, the large two- story brick building was originally covered with stucco, scored to simulate ashlar masonry. Now only the first-floor stucco veneer remains. A low veranda with slender wooden balusters and support- ing posts extends across the front and around the side elevations. The grounds were landscaped in and ca. a lake between the house and Alamitos Creek was constructed.
To formalize the area surrounding the lake, extensive improvements were completed in under the direction of the company's manager, James Butterworth Randol. Until the early century Casa Grande served as the manager's residence and the entertainment hall of the company. It has subsequently been used as a club, restaurant, bar and prostitution hall, and most recently, for commercial businesses on the lower levels and an apartment on the second floor. PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Date of erection: CASA GRANDE (Almaden Club House) HABSNo7-CA-lll6 (Page 2) 2. Architects: Gordon Parker Cummings San Francisco architect, and Henry W. Halleck, manager of the New Almaden Min- ing Company, are believed to have had the supervising positions in the design of the structure.
Cummings, one of San Francisco's most prominent architects in the and was known as the designer of "most of the large edifices in the city." The second City Hall, built is attributed to him, and he supervised the last phase of construction of the State Capitol building in Sacramento in His most recent commission prior to the con- struction of Casa Grande was Montgomery Block in San Francisco. This work was also commissioned by Halleck, who completed some of the drawings for the Block in addition to suggesting various de- tail patterns on the design.
Because of its grandiose appearance, Montgomery Block became known as "Halleck1s Folly." The two build- ings have similar characteristics: thick stone foundations, two- foot deep plain brick walls, and a low veranda supported by slen- der wooden columns. 3. Original and subsequent owners: The property includes acres of land and was originally part of San Vincente Rancho. It is located on Assessor's plot at New Almaden Road, New Almaden. The following chain of title to the property is found in the Office of the Recorder, Santa Clara County Court- house, Santa Clara, and in supplemental sources. The site was owned by Barron, Forbes Company, New Almaden Mining Company. Barron, Forbes Company sold the property to the Quicksilver Mining Company.
The Quicksilver Mining Company sold the property to George Sexton, and the name was changed to the New Idria Company. The property was transferred through mortgage foreclosure to Lake Almaden Properties Company. Thomas Coch acted as agent for the California Title Company. Lake Almaden Properties Company sold the property to David Black. David Black sold the property to Christian! Wineries. Christian! Brothers sold the property to Robert Gray. (The site was leased to the New Almaden Corporation during CAS A GRANDE (Almaden' Club House) HABSNo. CA-1116 (Page 3) Deed, February 24, recorded in Book page Robert G. and Florence L. Gray sold the property to Norman J. Pope and Arthur Cooper. Assignments of Rent, November 21, Norman J.
and Love Brown Pope granted lease to Citizens Federal Savings and Loan Association. 4. Original plan and construction; The custodian of the mine prop- erties during the Schneider, states that Casa Grande was originally conceived as a modest one-story hotel. [The construction] was supervised by Francis Meyer, a carpenter of unusual skill who spent all his life at the mine. [Casa Grande] was constructed of bricks and adobe and heavy timbers. As it developed [the mine managers] Young and Halleck began to eye it with other thoughts and before the ground floor was up, they had permission to add a second floor and to convert it into a residence. Early photographs show that the entire house was originally cov- ered with stucco, scored to simulate ashlar.
The dozen fire- places in the interior were adorned with inlaid mother of pearl, imported from Spain. 5. Alterations and additions: The property's high annual mainte- nance fee of by led the company's manager, Samuel Butterworth, to lease the house to a F.A. Pioche. (Butter- worth Letters, Stanford University).
At the time Pioche occupied Casa Grande an inventory of his possessions included: Silver and glassware - Parlor - 1 e'tagere, 3 mahogany sofas, 15 mahogany chairs., 7 Chinese chairs, 2 Chinese lounges Small parlor 2nd bedroom 5 piece rosewood bedroom furniture 7 piece set of Damask parlor furniture chandeliers, arm chairs some of dining room furniture with marble tops 16 bedrooms, large laundry and garden cottage; some bed- room sets painted, others mahogany, others black walnut; many of rooms with sofas Pioche died early in and the house stood vacant for more than fifteen months. (Randol Letters, 5 August Stanford University) During this time the house and surrounding gardens began to deteriorate. CASA GRANDE (Almaden Club House) 'HAbb Wo.
CA-lllF'IFage k) In James Randol became manager of the New Almaden Quick- silver Mine Company, and Casa Grande was restored as the man- ager's residence once again. A new roof was laid at this time, in addition to extensive repairs to the structure's interior. (Annual Report, February 26, page 23; Miscellaneous Letters, Correspondence, January 23, Stanford University). In Randol built a gymnasium for his two sons and enlarged his daugh- ter's nursery, (Butler, Randol resigned in and the new general manager and his wife occupied the house until the turn of the century. A letter dated October 8, stated that Casa Grande was vacant and in such poor condition that it was uninhabitable.
A second letter dated October 26, noted that repairs valued at were needed to bring the building up to living standards. The proposed improvements included new roofing and plumbing, new shin- gles and paint on the exterior, a more modern stove and bathtub and replastering all interior surfaces. By the renovation had been completed and totaled more than (Innis Papers, "Harry's Administration," page The house was used periodically between and as the resi- dence of George Sexton, president of the new Idria Quicksilver Company. Sexton lost all his property holdings in and Casa Grande was acquired by the California Title Company and developed as a subdivision of the "Lake Almaden" Properties.
After two years of general improvements, the property was sold for profit and converted to the "Club Almaden." The north side of the dance platform was extended at this time for use as a small stage or auditorium. Casa Grande was sold again in the and converted to a restau- rant. The restaurant was unprosperous and the owners subsequently turned the two-story building into a bar, featuring erotic Mexican dancers, and a prostitution hall on the second floor. When Norman Pope bought the property in both house and grounds were in poor condition, suffering from the disrepair wrought by time and neglect. In repairing the house, Pope retained the basic lay-out on the first floor, but extensively remodelled the second floor's north section for use as a single-family residence.
He also in- stalled a new kitchen, two furnaces, and completely rewired the house. Since that time, Casa Grande has housed club and commercial activities on the lower levels and an apartment on the second floor, 6. Landscape design: During the management of Samuel Butterworth, ca. the lake between the main house and Alamitos Creek was con- structed. Fresh plantings were added to the original gardens at this time. CASA GRANDE (Almaden _Club_ House)_ HABS No. CA-lll6JPage 5) Little new work was done to the grounds until when James B. Randol, then general manager, completed extensive improvements, laying pathways, constructed green houses and trellises around the gardens, and greatly formalized the general appearance of the area surrounding the lake.
A chronological list of the landscap- ing completed in was recorded in the "Surface Foreman*s work order book." October 9 Waterbox in front of house put in order and grading done by Dwyer and Stiles. Water tank in garden to be raised by Reade and Kenneth; window sash on roof of hothouse in garden to be painted by Dwyer. October 14 Lattice work to be put up on walk from front of gate to front door and in continuation back of kitchen by McDoughall. October 23 Front gate removed and walks run diagonally as in diagram by Kenneth; steps to basement on left of front steps as one faces them to be boarded in and filled with earth. November 8 Lattice work continued around by Kenneth. November 10 Lattice work continued around laundry yard by Hutton.
In Randol hired an Austrian landscape gardener, paying his passage to this country, to maintain the grounds around Casa Grande. The new gardener, Gustav Magnison, was assisted by a young Scotsman, John McLaren, later to become San Francisco's most prominent landscape architect. The total cost of these im- provements, together with the two caretakers' salaries came to more than (Schneider, The lake was converted to a swimming pool ca. about the time the property was acquired by the California Title Company. In when Casa Grande became the Club Almaden, a parking lot was laid at the front to accommodate patrons. B.
Historic Persons and Events Connected with the Structure: The new Almaden mine is the site of the first mercury deposit dis- covered in North America, and has yielded metal of greater total value than that of any other mine in California, producing nearly one-third of the country's supply of mercury. It was originally a part of Jose Reyes Berryeyasa's Rancho San Vicente, one of the val- leys' large ranches settled after 177 7. Until the innovation of the cyanide process in quicksilver was the chief reduction agent CASA GRANDE (Almaden Club House.) .- "HABS Ho. CA-1116 (Page. 6). used in processing gold and silver.
Metal extracted from the New Almaden mine thus made possible the rapid development of gold and silver quartz mining in California and the Comstock Lode in Nevada during the and The site was discovered as an ore deposit in but not confirmed as a mercury deposit until by Andres Castillero, a Mexican officer visiting the Mission Santa Clara. Under Mexican and Spanish laws Castillero filed discoverer*s rights to the mine, establishing a stock company shortly thereafter. The controlling interest in the mine was acquired in by the Barron-Forbes Company, an English- held firm, who began immediately to build upon the property and in- stall more efficient reduction facilities at the base of the mine hills.
As increased production significantly raised the value of the property, a dispute over clear title and ownership of the New Almaden Mining Company developed between Castillero and Barron-Forbes, coming to a head in A government injunction was placed on the mine as a result, and by a decision of the Supreme Court in Barron-Forbes sold its holding in the 8600-acre site for to the Pennsylvania-based Quicksilver Mining Company. Henry Wager Halleck, general manager of the New Almaden Mining Com- pany, was born January 16, in Westernville, New York.
He re- ceived his early education at New York's Hudson Academy, went on to Union College in Schenectady, from which he was graduated Phi Beta Kappa, and acquired his military training at West Point, graduating in While still an undergraduate at West Point, Halleck was appointed an assistant professor. During this time he worked on the design of the fortifications at New York Harbor, and traveled to France to inspect its harbor fortresses. Upon returning to the States, Halleck wrote a report of his findings, "The Means of National Defense," which was published by Congress and for which he received an invita- tion from the Lowell Institute in Boston to give a series of lectures.
The lectures were later published under the title of "Elements of Military Art and Science," and were widely circulated among military personnel. Halleck was transferred to California in serving as a captain in the Army Corps of Engineers, in addition to being employed by Barron-Forbes as general manager of the New Almaden Mining Company. During the early and years of the Mexican War, he held high positions within California's military government - secretary of state, chief of staff of lower California, and lieutenant governor of the Mexican city of Mazatlan. He resigned from the army in and returned to New York where, in he married Elizabeth Hamilton, granddaughter of Alexander Hamilton.
The couple returned to San Francisco where Halleck established himself in a three-man law firm, Halleck, Peachy & Billings, one of the city's most prominent in the CASA GRANDE (Almaden Club House)_ HABS No. CA-lll6 (Page. 7) mid-19th century. In his capacity as an attorney specializing in land title litigations, Halleck played a key role in the Superior Court claims case for the New Almaden Mining Company. Halleck left California in to serve as a major general in the Civil War. After serving in the field for a year, President Lincoln brought him to Washington, early in to serve as General-in- Chief.
He was apparently not a good commander in the field, inspir- ing one Grant biographer to remark of Halleck*s promotion to General- in-Chief, "Unable to command successfully one army, he was ordered to Washington to command all the armies." In March he was de- moted to Chief-of-Staff when Grant became General-in-Chief. At the end of the war, Halleck served briefly as commander of the Military Division of the James, then transferred to San Francisco in the fall of to command the Pacific division. He was subsequently ap- pointed to head the Southern division at Louisville, where he died January 9, (Warner, Butler, Samuel F. Butterworth was born in Newburgh, New York. He was a graduate of Union College in Schenectady, New York, afterwards mov- ing to Mississippi to practice law.
He was appointed U.S. district attorney in Mississippi during the Van Buren Administration and later declined a commission as Justice of the State Supreme Court. (Lanyon, He subsequently returned to New York and became involved in the New Almaden Mining Company case concerning title to the property. Butterworth was president of the Mining Company since it was organized in and became general agent, manager and sec- retary of the New Almaden Quicksilver Mining Company when it was in- corporated in He established a company store, improved living conditions at the mine camps, and increased the company's production. After retiring in April Butterworth was appointed to the Board of Regents of the newly-organized University of California. He died in leaving an estate valued at (Lanyon, 24) C.
Sources of Information: 1. Old views: Photograph view of rear (south) elevation showing the Chinese pavilion, published in an article by J. Ross Browne, "Down in the Cinnebar Mines," Harpers' New Monthly Magazine, No. 185 (October Photograph ca. showing south elevation and gardens, in New Almaden Museum , Almaden Rd. , New Almaden, CA. Photograph ca. showing Chinese Pagoda to north of Casa Grande (now removed) in New Almaden Museum. (Almaden Club Housel 'HABS No."CA-iiI6 (Page 5) Photograph showing stucco on north elevation before addition^ in Wew Almaden Museum. Photograph showing gardens between Casa Grande and Alamitos Creek to east (now altered), in New Almaden Museum. 2.