Villa Montalvo was "built in *n tne style of a sixteenth century Italian villa from the designs of the noted San Francisco architects Curlett and Gottschalk, and was formally landscaped by the Bay area's most renowned landscape architect, John McLaren. Villa Montalvo was originally the home of one of the region's greatest philanthropists, James Duval Phelan, one time Mayor of San Francisco and U.S. Senator. Phelan played host to dozens of notables in the political and art worlds at the estate, which remains one of the most visually impressive residential complexes in Santa Clara County. PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Date of erection: 1912-lU. 2. Architects: William Curlett & Sons.
Montalvo was designed "by the architectural firm of Curlett & Sons, the work of principal architects C.E. Gottschalk and Aleck Curlett (Phelan Papers). William Curlett (18U5-191U) was a native of Belfast, Ireland and educated at the Art Institute of Manchester. He immigrated to San Francisco in and by had established his own practice. Together with Theodore Eisen, Curlett designed the Los Angeles Courthouse in a Romanesque style building, and in an addition to the Fresno courthouse. He is also credited with having designed the Shreve Building and the Stockton Insane Asylum. Curlett served as president of the San Francisco chapter of the American Institute of Architects, and the State Board of Architects. VILLA MONTALVO (James Duval Phelan House) HABS No. CA-20U8 (Page 2) Aleck E.
Curlett (18OO-I9H2), the son of William, was educated in San Francisco, and joined his father's San Francisco firm after completing his formal studies. He practiced a few years with Gottschalk after his father's death in 19lU, and in Aleck formed a new firm with Claude Beelman in Los Angeles. The firm's prominent buildings in the Los Angeles area include Union Oil, the Roose Office, Pacific Southern Trust and Savings, Heinshurger Decorating, the Elks Temple Buildings, and the Firestone Tire and Rubber Plant. After the earthquake of Curlett was appointed head of the Los Angeles County School Reconstruction Board, and later served as director of U.S. Housing Administration projects in the area. Charles E.
Gottschalk (186U-I929) vas horn and educated in San Fran- cisco and began his architectural career in Pasadena, California. He later transferred to Chicago to work in the office of Shepley, Rutan and Coolidge, the successor to Richardson's architectural firm, and the firm who designed Stanford University Quadrangle,.Palo Alto, in Gottschalk returned to San Francisco in and joined the Curlett's firm, practicing with Aleck Curlett until He established an independent office in working until his . death in 3. Original and subsequent owners: The Montalvo estate includes 175 * acres of land.
The tract lies within Section IT, Township 8 South, Range 2 West, Mount Diablo Base and Meridian, recorded in Book of Maps M, page 99- The five acres immediately surrounding the house are maintained by the Montalvo Arts Association; the remainder is managed by the County of Santa Clara, Department of Parks and Recreation. The following deed references are located in the Office of the Recorder. Santa Clara County Courthouse, Santa Clara. Deed, July 10, recorded July IT, in Book page 55- Charles W. Fay, et ux, sold property to James D. Phelan. Deed, August l8, > recorded August 19, in Book page Charles W. Fay, et ux, sold property to James D. Phelan. Deed, August 22, recorded in Book page Mary C. Dunham, et al, sold property to James D. Phelan.
Deed, September recorded November 19, in Book page Cunningham sold property to James D. Phelan. VILLA MONTALVO (James Duval Phelan House) HABS No. CA-20^8 (Page 3) Deed, October 11, recorded November 19, in Book page Thomas N- Perkins, sold property to James D. Phelan. Deed, October 27, recorded in Book page Emma J. Cushman, et vir, sold property to Phelan. Deed August 6, recorded in Book 58O, page Estate of James D. Phelan sold the property to the San Francisco Art Association. Deed, October 27, recorded in Book page 95. Pursuant to order in equity of the Superior Court of the State of California, sold the property to Montalvo Association. k.
Original plan and construction: The 175-acre estate is made up largely of the 137-acre tract of land formerly known as "Bonnie Brae Ranch," which "was held in multiple ownership. Construction of Villa Montalvo began in on a virtually barren hillside site. Phelan supervised the construction before leaving for Europe in in his capacity as the Commissioner of the upcoming Panama-Pacific International Exposition of Construction was completed in the fall of 19lU (Phelan Papers).
Curlett and Gottschalk's design for Montalvo was published in Archi- tect and Engineer of California, September and in Overland Monthly Magazine, April During the villa's construction in May Aleck Curlett and Phelan revised details of the Library's original plan: "The panel work in alcove near window cut out and book case substituted for same for making total changes in library up to time (Curlett) left cost Also noted are "changes in billiard room and den amounting to (Phelan Papers, "Aleck Curlett"). Gottschalk assumed supervision of the construction in the spring of when William Curlett became seriously ill and Aleck went to Los Angeles to be with his father.
By May, nearing completion, the house's thirty-five screens had been fitted into the south dining porch, the hardware and refrigerator door were installed, the switch- board cabinet and the door to the billiard roonr's lavatory were hung, and the vacuum cleaner pipes outlet had been installed in the stair- hall. Villa Montalvo was named after the century Spanish novelist Ordonnez de Montalvo, author of the novel Segas de Esplandran the first known publication in which the name "California" appears. A notif central to the novel's story is the griffin, a mythical animal with the body and hind legs of a lion and the head and wings VILLA MONTALVO (James Duval Phelan House) HABS No. CA-20^8 (Page k) of an eagle.
This century motif is represented at Montalvo in the estate's entrance gateposts, designed "by Gottschalk. On a wall of the west (rear) courtyard is a plaque by California artist Mora that is inscribed with a verse written by Phelan: "MDXXI, know Ordonez de Montalvo's fame; Did he not see in Fantasy our California grow out of old Spain' Conferred her Name; Foretold her God; a PARA- DISE: FOR EAGER EYES: HIS DREAM COME TRUE FOR ME AND YOU: MCMXII." While Phelan was in Europe promoting participation in the Pan- Pacific Exposition, he purchased in Granada a pair of ^00-year-old carved wooden doors for the north entry.
A stained-glass transom overhead depicts the Spanish explorer Cabrillo's ship "San Salvador." Novelist Gertrude Atherton, Phelan's constant companion of later years, had her own room in the second floor of Montalvo. She wrote of the house as it was in the "The terrace was approached by a broad high flight of steps but the main entrance was on the north side where there was another terrace enclosed in glass, vine covered and furnished with lounging chairs and marbles. Out of this terrace opened a library with lounging chairs and marbles. Out of this ter- race opened a library with crowded book shelves rising to the ceiling which in turn opened to an immense living room and * beyond was the lofty dining room hung with crimson brocade.
The billiard room was across the hall from the library and like the living room opened on the court. Upstairs were six large bedrooms each with its bath and balcony, and on the other side of the drive overhanging the creek and almost hidden in the woods, was the Guest House, to which bachelor visitors were generally relegated. The main house was luxu- riously and beautifully furnished with many valuable pictures and works of art that Mr. Phelan had picked up in Europe, was always dim and cool on the hottest days; although if there were a large party down for the day only, they preferred to sit on the terraces and sip iced orange juice and lemonade." (Atherton, 5. Alterations and additions: In a local contractor, T.
Mahoney, completed the following projects: Installed pantry refrigerator $ 113 Two-room house Dog kennel 728 Deer paddock 276 Dog houses 55 Rustic observatory 538 Fire house ^13 VILLA. MONTALVO (James Duval Phelan House) HABS No. CA-20U8 (Page 5) Repairs to Red House 232 Repairs to Cunningham House 30 Repairs to Wilson House l8l Painting Tennis Court 129 Greenhouse extension 783 Vineyard fence 162 Cleaning and scraping pool Lattice fence 32 General repairs and painting 280 The kennels and tennis courts remain, all other "buildings listed have "been removed from the estate. The estate stood vacant after Phelan1s death in until it was acquired "by the San Francisco Art Association in and renovated into an artists' colony.
Phelan stipulated in his will that: Villa Montalvo is to be maintained as a public park open to the public under reasonable restrictions, the build- ings and grounds immediately surrounding same to be used as far as possible for the development of art, paintings, music and architecture by promising students. To that end I give said property to the San Francisco Art Association, together with the sum of the income of which shall be used for the maintenance of same. San Francisco architects Spencer, Elanchard & Maher drew up the working drawings for the renovation, which included gallery and studio space, a small theatre, and remodeling the guesthouse and stables for studio use. The drawings are dated and but were not executed.
In the trustees of Montalvo Association assumed control of the estate and in the mid-50s Montalvo was remodeled as a sculptors' studio according to the specifications. The original kitchen became a ceramics studio. Subsequent restoration projects were undertaken by San Jose archi- tects Higgins & Root in and again in The main house was rewired and repaired so as to meet fire code standards as an art gallery. The library's built-in shelves were removed to make the room's design more harmonious with the exhibition space in the original living room. Administrative offices are housed in the southeast service wing. Second-floor bedroom suites were remodeled as kitchenettes. To the southeast of the house a stage and emer- gency exit have been installed in the carriage house.
VILLA MONTALVO (James Duval Phelan House) HABS No. CA-20^8 (Page 6) C. Sources of Information: 1. Original architectural drawings: Color-wash rendering of entrance gates, CE. Gottshalk, In the possession of the Director of Montalvo. 2. Old views: Interior and exterior views, published in an article "by Cahill, Architect and Engineer, September pp- Interior view and northwest garden, published in an article by Mira MacLay, Sunset Magazine, February pp. 3.