Van Duzen Bridge, Spanning Van Duzen River at State Highway 36, Carlotta
Van Duzen Bridge, Spanning Van Duzen River at State Highway 36, Carlotta, Humboldt County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,12-CARL.V,1-, with a 2,494-word written history.
From the record
“This is a highway bridge of open spandrel reinforced concrete deck arch type.”
Written record, HAER CAL,12-CARL.V,1- survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,12-CARL.V,1- · the record runs 2494 words · one of 23 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,12-CARL.V,1-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
This is a highway bridge of open spandrel reinforced concrete deck arch type. It is associated with John B, Leonard - leading proponent and Important early designer of reinforced concrete bridges in California. It is also one of only three open spandrel type bridges known to be designed by Leonard. The structure 1s 464 feet in length, has two foot arch spans, and is 20 feet wide. Transmitted by: Gary R. Arabak, Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 2) The Van Duzen River Bridge No. is a structure which has integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling and association.
In addition, it em- bodies the distinctive characteristics of a type (open spandrel reinforced concrete deck arch bridge), period (early and method of construction (concrete poured in place); it may be construed to be the "work of a master" -- John B. Leonard, who was a leading proponent of and important early Twentieth Century designer of reinforced concrete bridges in California (and, in at least one instance, in Nevada). It is one of only 3 open spandrel arch bridges known to have been designed by Leonard. It also shows design aesthetics -- com- plementary arches which were still being put forth as "cor- rect" more than a decade later.
During the early Route 36 (then known as the Fortuna-Red Bluff Highway) was selected by engineers of the California Highway Commission as the main route between the north coast and the upper Sacramento Valley. It was selected as the most direct route, the easiest to construct and maintain, and the safest to travel. Proceeding inland from Fortuna the road follows the Van Duzen River Canyon to a point about 10 miles above Bridgeville. The Van Duzen, a tributary of the Eel River, because of the mountainous terrain and heavy rainfall of the region, can experience rapid rises and become a major stream at times. Coupled with this, many pf the slopes flanking the river along which the highway was built consist of a bluish, serpentine-like material which is slippery and unstable when ' wet.
One point, known as Blue Slide, was regarded as the most ;|s dangerous on the Route, as virtually every winter the saturated slope would slide and carry the highway into the river; indeed it was impossible for highway forces to maintain continuous travel during the winter, and several lives were lost. Other portions of the route notably Blackburn Grade -- were hazard- ous due to the combination of steep grades, sharp curves, and precipitous slopes. Shortly after the aforementioned selection of this route by the CHC Engineers, the Humboldt County Board of Super- visors began a road improvement program.
As part of this program, five bridges were constructed -- two in to eliminate the Blue Slide, and three in to eliminate the Blackburn Grade and to replace a covered bridge at Bridgeville (See Exhibits C and D). All five bridges were designed by John B. Leonard, a consulting engineer from San Francisco who was an important early Century designer of and proponent of reinforced con- crete bridges of California. Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 3) John B- Leonard was born in Union City, Michigan on July 18, His education was in the public schools of Union City, at Michigan State College, at Illinois Uni- versity, and at the University of Michigan. Leonard earned his own way through college doing various jobs, including teaching.
In he moved to Los Angeles where he worked in that City's engineering department. In he came north to San Francisco and spent the rest of his life in the Bay Area. In and he was employed by the American Bridge and Building Company; from by the firm of Bigelow and Little, proprietors of the Bay City Ironworks. found him in the employ of the Southern Pacific's maintenance- 1 of-way department. In he worked for the Pacific Rolling Mill. He first appears as an independent engineer in specializing in concrete and artificial stone. From to he served as chief engineer for Healy, Tibbits and Company, builders of wharves, bridges, and railroads.
From through he is again independent as a consulting civil and structural engineer, and it is during this period that his most notable work in bridges is accomplished. h Leonard was in the right place, at the right time, W to have been aware of the great potential of reinforced concrete as the material of the future. The year of his arrival in San Francisco also saw the completion of Ernest L. Ransome's Alvord Lake Bridge in Golden Gate Park. This was the first reinforced concrete bridge in the United States (and still in use).
While it may never be known precisely when Leonard became committed to reinforced concrete bridges, one can see that by '% he has an awareness, and his various employments would also have familiarized him with bridge engineering in general, and with steel bridge engineering (and the limitations thereof) In particular. From through January and again in he served as associate editor (on reinforced concrete) o Architect and Engineer of California. During the first period Leonard authored a number of articles touting the qualities of reinforced concrete, and had photos of some of his bridges appear in these as well as in articles by others.
Research also shows that Leonard carried his commitment to reinforced concrete beyond Resigning bridges: from about to he was a sales agent for "corrugated bars for reinforced concrete", and from to was sales manager for Pacific Coast Steel,; a major supplier of reinforcing steel. Exhibit E shows an ex- ample of his advertisements which is (as was typical) illustrated with a photo of one of his bridges. Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page A) Following his departure from Architect and Engineer of California in Leonard and then-partner W. P. Day in published a book entitled The Concrete Bridge: How it Has Proved Itself In California" In this, the qualities of reinforced concrete for bridge building were again extolled.
The various types of these bridges -- flat spans (girder type and girdless), filled spandrel arches, open spandrel barrel vault arches, open spandrel rib-type arches -- are discussed. Also mentioned is the fact that these bridges utilized local California products timber for falsework and forms, cement, aggregate, sand, reinforcing steel -- and thus avoided the delays which often accompanied the building of steel bridges due t" the need to ship components in from out-of-state. The book then goes on to illustrate no fewer than twenty of Leonard!s bridges, about which Leonard c calls the reader's attention to the "pleasing spring of the arch".
His designs reveal a concern for aesthetics, for fitting the design to the site, and for detail/ His arch bridges, without exception, reveal graceful parabolic arches rising to a remarkably thin section at the apex. They were used singly or in multiple arch spans as his landmark Fernbridge over the Eel River in Humboldt County. This book is also singularly unique in that it carries on, in bridge engineering, a tradition of practicing architects to publish pattern books. While Leonard was not an architect, and while this was not literally a pattern book, its relation to this tradition -- which dates back at least to the Century Italian architect Palladio -- is clear. This tradition was not without precedent in California either, as the Century architects Samuel and J.
Cather Newsom published no fewer than eleven pattern and other books promoting their design and services. Leonard, however, appears to have been the only consulting engineer of this period to use this approach, and this book remains unique for providing a capsule glimpse of reinforced concrete bridge design in the first decade-and-a-half of the Century. It is likewise a fine encapsulation of the earlier designs of John B. Leonard. The Leonard & Day partnership apparently was terminated about and Leonard is listed variously as a structural or a civil engineer in San Francisco city directories from to In he participated in work at the test highway in Pitfrsburg, California where he furnished the delicate instru- ments necessary for measurements.
This-test highway was notable in that it was one of only two such'test roads in the U.S. built with private funds (this one financed by Columbia Steel Company); all other research effort fell upon the U. S. Bureau of Public Roads. In the early Leonard took on Harold B. Hammill as a new junior partner. Leonard, in association with Hammill, was instrumental in devising a method of analyzing an arch by the ellipse of elasticity. This development, which occurred about was claimed by both men to be quick and Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 5) accurate. It was during his period of association with Hammill that Leonard designed the five bridges on the Fortuna- Red Bluff Highway with Hammill assisting on at least three of the five.
On May 18, Leonard was appointed Superintendent of Building Inspection in San Francisco, a position he held until In he returned to private practice as a consulting civil and structural engineer, in which capacity he continued until his death on February 16, at the age of 80. Leonard's pioneering efforts in reinforced concrete bridge design have not gone unnoticed. Two of his bridges have been designated Historic Civil Engineering Landmarks by the American Society of Civil Engineers. These are the aforementioned Fernbridge, and the former Mountain Quarries Company railroad bridge over the American River below Auburn, California. The A.S.C.E.
recognized the Fernbridge feet long with unprecedented 180-foot arched main spans as providing prece- dent for the Colorado Street Bridge over Arroyo Seco in Pasadena and the Cabrillo Bridge in San Diego. And the railway bridge was, when built in the longest span concrete arch railroad bridge owned by a private concern. Further, the Keeper of the National Register of Historic Places has determined the only known non-reinforced concrete bridge designed by Leonard to be eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places. This latter is a steel Pratt truss swing bridge spanning the Sacramento River between Glenn and Butte Counties, California. Significantly, Leonard's first proposal for this location was'a reinforced concrete bridge.
Only after this had been turned down by the joint boards of Supervisors of the two counties, who also called for a steel bridge, did the present design evolve. In mentioning Leonard's significance in the field of engineering, it must be noted that there is evidence that he played an important role in the reconstruction of San Francisco following the earthquake and fire, though details of that role are not known at this time. Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 6) DC. Bibliography Gebhard, David; Von Bretion, Harriette; Winter, Robert W., Samuel and Joseph Cather Newsom: Victorian Architectural Imagery in Caiiiomia lB/8-l^Ug, Santa Barbara, Regents of the University of California, Hammill, Harold B.
> "Five Highway Bridges Across the Van Duzen River, California", Western Construction News, March 25, Huber, Walter L. , President, A.S.C.E., "An Engineering Century in California", A.S.C.E. Transactions, Janni, A.C., "The Design of a Multiple-Arch System and Per- missible Simplifications", A.S.C.E. Transactions, Janson, DelMar, Revised Original Report, Van Duzen River (Blue Slide) Bridge (unpublished report), dated July 10, Leonard, John B., and Day, The Concrete Bridge; How it has Proved Itself in California, San Francisco, Leonard and ' t)ay, Snyder, John W., Report on Gianella Bridge on 03-But-37, P.M Sacramento River (unpublished report), dated December 1, __^ , America's Highways A History of the Federal Aid Program, Washington, U.S.
Department of Transportation, , Architectural Design of Concrete Bridges, Chicago, Portland Cement Association, (Fa.1936). , Historic Civil Engineering Landmarks oi San Francisco and Northern California, ed. by William A. Myers, San Francisco, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, October, , Historic Civil Engineering Landmarks of Sacramento and Northeastern California, Sacramento, History and Heritage Committee of the Sacramento Section of the American Society of Civil Engineers, San Francisco City Directories for the years inclusive. , "Obituaries", San Francisco Chronicle, February 17, Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 7) X. Exhibits ^ EXHIBIT A V&n Duzen River Bridge HAER No.
CA~9 (Page;8) ^ c^ MiUWHufK lEMflMi-Etf-- / o SIDOELLij-'j-, BRIDGE I Via c 3 ta ai *fTUtX* NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA ^tUHEMAU * ? * 3 A >. r&\ ;'-i-5r / Riverside Park a r-M it it i. n T U K \) \\ ') (> I) s >. ortuna-Uort Bluff Highway ca. ^M /v : * -w prior to realignment and bridge J> ^^T^^^^JTT^^^^OSJ^. construct ion to eliminate Blue Slide <& ^!J '^! ^Hd Blackburn Grade, __ X. ;o> 3^ . # f U^ V.A*:} I ^ ^- a* i-/-vt.x-,y; f. -V * ~ ' X r. i a. I . i I , * - ^ . - - ; - as o p o o '~i-tJ<* Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Pagel2) r* EXHIBIT E THE CALIFORNIA -lOl'RXAI. OF TECHNOLOGY 5ih and Cypress Sis., Oakland 1 _.: -/A.--\ ^c-^sA-j-sss; pcnmery is JEAK HOWARD Two Reinforced Steel J?rches lOO Feet Spans Each, Crossing ol.
Stanislaus River Near Ripon,Ca.L., Reinforced with Corrugated Bars, Designed By John B. Leonard C, E. Corrugated Bars For
Reinforced Concrete
These bars arc carried in stock in San Francisco and can he furnished in any length up :o AO ft. COMPLETE LINE OF All Official Tests and. Juries have given Machine Shop Tools, CORIU'CJATKD BARS place. :e Mixers, Road Graders, JNO- B. LKOXARiX C. K.t Agt. Transmission Machinery, :s ~ Jiisdc: Lngineers E.L.SouU-. C. O-i, \V. P. C'.i C. 05> y\. "V. i ph. U. C. '96 Cornell 'Ol ?02 e Power Plants. Office: MOXJiDMOCK. JV?A" FRJiJVCJSCO, CJiL. Ill u-||li!i^ : . ;niV-i l !." !* J'i'-iiS.- EXHIBIT F *1 7 Van Duzen R: vef^rBridge J - HAER No. CA-9 (Pa&e 13) TIPT y^- :^N I ^WWffjIIt] lU-H-H-H-l i tji-Ti t ^ 11 1V I n I-1:'. . i SjTftl-miim'KlniHii L 1-i. _.V -rt-i > _Jj Hi 1* - fte"^" " _:~ r "C^ "^c 111 s <* q- ^ K' c_ 4 ^ ^ t & CZ) ^ * !*S ^ > 5 C\ < "-J 1 3C? Urn vT T ^N i * 4^? JL ^A.
- w- 2 EXHIBIT G y Van Duzen River Bridge 2 HAER No. CA-9 (Page 14) Van Duzen River Bridge HAER No. CA-9 (Page 15 ) XL* Individuals Compiling Documentation John W. Snyder - Caltrans Staff Architectural Historian Robert E. Easton - Caltrans, Environmental Planner
The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in Humboldt County. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,12-CARL.V,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.