Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,27-MONT,44-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Abandoned and condemned. Prooosed site of public aquarium. Sianificance: The Hovden Cannery was one cf the oldest and largest canneries of the Pacific Sardine Fishery. Its heyday in the first half of the 2 0th Century marked one of the inost lucrative national fisheries and an era of literary sionificance in the works of John Steinbeck. Its founder, Knute Hovden, was a leading innovator in canning tech- nology.
Written history
9031 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,27-MONT,44-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Donald Fitzgerald, November, Carroll V?. Pursell, Principal investigator . Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 2) INTRODUCTION TO THE
Story of Hovden Cannery
Studying the crumbling remains of one building on Cannery- Row leads to the realization that there is significance not only in the building, but in the technology and process which it housed, as well. Initial examination of the Hovden Cannery reveals a confusion of structures which have been enlarged, modified and revised, until it is difficult to find the lines of the original buildings. The structures have been added to in all dimensions: walls have been lengthened and heightened, floors and roofs have been added and extended, foundations abandoned to newer, or patched up and repaired, delaying the inevitable corrosion of the elements.
However, this process of midification, if not completely fathomable, is extremely important because it reflects significant modifications to sardine canning process which occured over the years. A description of the present structure of the Hovden Cannery, stripped as it is of the machinery, processing tables, conveyor belts, scales and other paraphenalia of the fish canning process, describes only an empty shell. It is when accompanied by a description of what took place within these cavernous rooms and dark recess, that the true significance of the cannery is realized. Therefore, in describing the Hovden Cannery, this report will include the process and technology of the sardine canning industry.
This is also appropiate in view of the major contribution which Knute Hovden made to this process. He was a major force in changing the canning procedure from what had been a short step away from a "hand crafted" operation to what became a highly mechanized, quantity production oriented industry. It is also important to mention what has happened in recent years to the canneries of Cannery Row. At the height of the sardine canning industry (the period during and subsequent to World War II,) there were twelve canneries and two waste products plants operating on Cannery Row, with a total of thirty nine in the Monterey area .
As of the date of this report, most of these canneries have been vacated (and vandalized,) converted to other commercial uses, burned down or partially gutted, or demolished in order to prevent collapse, fire or injury to trespassers. The Hovden Cannery building is one of the few structures still standing on Cannery Row. However, it is typical of those canneries which the Monterey Cannery Row Plan of called "virtually in a state of ruin." This situation is compounded by a daily stream of trespassers, seeking to satisfy curiosity, gain a memento, or steal whatever is valuable for resale. With the real possibility of collapse, fire, or demolition for safety, the Hovden Cannery as it stands today--empty, unprotected and vulnerable leads a precarious after-life. Hovden Cannery HAER No .
CA-11 (Page 3)
The California Sardine Fishery-Its Rise and Fall
The Pacific sardine fishery once inhabited the coastal waters of western North America from British Columbia to Baja California. Because the sardine is a pelagic, or free roaming fish, the actual number contained in the coastal waters can only be estimated from the numbers caught. During the season, tons of sardines were landed at California ports. By the mid 1 930 ' s , the catch had grown to more than tons, and that level was sustained for a decade. This abundant fishery supported a canning and by-products industry in California that reached an annual value of $50 million.
It became the largest and most valuable single-species fishing industry in the United States, During the approximately twenty five years of growth and sustained abundance following World War I, sardine canneries thrived on the central and southern California coasts. They canned sardines foe domestic and foreign markets, and also reduced them to fish oil and meal for industrial and agricultural uses. With sustained high catches considered a sign of a healthy fishery, canners continued to call for tremendous quantities of fish for their processing plants, and fishermen quite willingly delivered them.
During this time of plenty, fish researchers began warning that adult sardines were disappearing from the fishery and that loss of these reproducers of the stock was the first sign of impending depletion. Canners and fishermen however continued their efforts to fill the demands of the market place. The Legislature and the California Fish and Game Commission, with their dual and conflicting roles of encouraging the growth of the fishing and canning industry, while charged with the protection of the fishery, accomplished no limiting legislation. When the adult sardines had been eliminated and the catch started to diminish, fishermen and canners turned to researchers and cooperative methods, to find ways not to save the fishery, but to increase its productivity.
A high output prevailed until after World War II, but then a sharp decrease in the annual catch occurred. In a few years, it became evident that the sardine fishery was disappearing. By the annual catch had dropped to just over tons, and except for a few temporary upturns, it continued to decline. In when fewer than 100 tons of sardines were caught in California waters, a commercial use moratorium was enacted by the legislature. As the story of the sardine fishery unfolds, it becomes evident that its dissappearance is the result of many factors besides the demands of the canning industry. The reduction of whole fish to oil and meal soon came to play a primary role, as Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 4) did the twice imposed heavy demands for sardines during the two World Wars.
However, the primary reason that the sardine fishery was allowed to be exploited nearly to extinction is that those charged with its conservation were also intent on its expansion and development. Thus, the fishery became a pawn in the struggle between conservtion and exploitation. CANNERY ROW - A
Brief History
The primary purpose of this report is the documentation of a single building. However, much of the significance of the Hovden Cannery lies in the fact that its history spans the era during which the Cannery Row sardine industry was born, expanded to the dizzying heights of a annual buisness, and in a period of approximately twenty years, collapsed and completely disappeared. The earliest inhabitants of the stretch of rocky shore line along which Cannery Row eventually grew, were probably the Tamotk and Rumsen Indians, of the Costanoans. They settled on nearby Presidio Hill, an archaeologist's findings of fish hooks and abalone shells indicate they probably fished the waters adjacent to Point Alones (abalones), the present location of the Hovden Cannery.
The Chinese established a fishing village among these same rocks in choosing for their settlement the protected beach between Point Cabrillo (site of the Hopkins Marine Station,) and Point Alones. Harvesting fish, squid and abalone, the Chinese fishing community by prospered, reportedly second only to San Francisco in volume and value of catch. This prosperity, combined with the social, cultural (and in the minds of some, moral) characteristics of the Chinese settlement, soon led to friction with local fishermen and townspeople, especially many members of nearby Pacific Grove Methodist Community.
The Chinese village was mysteriously burned to the ground on May 16, resulting in the movement of its inhabitants a few miles west to Pescadero Point, on the present "Seventeen Mile Drive" near the Del Monte Properties1 "Pebble Beach". In Frank E. Booth built the first Cannery on the Monterey Peninsula. In addition to being the first cannery in the area, Booth also provided the first local market for fish caught in Monterey Bay, Up to that time, Monterey fish were purchased by brokers for resale in San Francisco, a system quite favorable to the brokers. Booth's cannery provided the fishermen a market to which they could sell directly, permitting them to enjoy more of the profits of their labor. Hovden Cannery HAER No.
CA-11 (page 5) Salmon was the fish most often caught in the bay, and thus the product the Cannery primarily packaged, as Booth had done formerly in Pittsburg, California. Booth also experimented with canning sardines, which at that time were caught primarily for salmon bait or by local citizens for sport. By Booth was canning cans of sardines a year. As a result, he cut back on the amount of salmon he purchased from local fishermen. His cannery burned down the following year, a result, according to some, of the resentment of the salmon fishermen. Booth rebuilt the cannery at the same location in at the foot of the Monterey commercial pier, not far from the old Customs House. By Booth had hired Knute Hovden and Pietro "Pete" Ferrante, who came to Monterey from the Pittsburg plant.
Their cumulative entrepeneurship, ingenuity, and knowledge of fishing led to changes in the technology of fishing which "completely revolutionized commercial fishing in California and represented the first stage in the evolution of sardine fishing operations in Monterey Bay." Their success was also a first step toward Ocean View Avenue officially being renamed "Cannery Row" by the City of Monterey in Booth, Hovden and Ferrante decided to introduce lampara nets from Sicily to the Monterey fishermen. Until this time, fish were caught in small gill nets stretched between two anchored points. Fish swam into the net and were trapped by their gills until extricated by hand when the fishermen periodically checked their nets.
The lampara is a long, wing shaped net, used in the Mediterranean since before Christ. It has floats on one edge and weights on the other, allowing it to float like a fence just below the surface of the water. The lampara was set in a circle around a school of sardines and the drawn together. The trapped sardines were scopped into a barge for delivery to the pier, and thence to the cannery. The impact of the lampara net on Booth's Cannery was staggering. Boats were now able to deliver twenty five to thirty tons of sardines, more than he alone was able to handle. More canneries were built to handle the surplus.
In an Indian named Trott built the "Monterey Fishing and Packing Company," the first to compete with Booth.' It was the first cannery actually built on Cannery Row, but it soon failed. Later in the year, three former employees of Booth's bought the Trott Cannery, and organized the "Pacific Fish Company" . In Knute Hovden left Booth and built his own cannery. He selected a site in New Monterey, at the farthest end of Cannery Row, and anchored his cannery on Point Alones, a rocky finger jutting out into Monterey Bay. The area which Hovden chose contained several nearby residences. It was not long Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 6) before residents made the first of many futile objections to the noisy , smelly canneries which were beginning to befoul their lovely stretch of beach.
World War I had a tremendous effect on Cannery Row. A severe decrease of European canning activity combined with an increasing call for high protein foods by the U.S. government to create a hugh demand for canned fish. Production on the Row rose from cases in to cases in During this prosperous period, the building, buying and selling of canneries became so frequent, that the growth of Cannery Row is difficult to trace.
As an example, the Bayside Fish Company, owned by wealthy Chinese from Oakland, was bought by the Great Western Packing Company in Great Western, which also owned the Santa Cruz Packing Company in Santa Cruz, California, was in turn purchased by Hovden in The Pacific Fish Company (formerly the Monterey Fishing and Packing Company) was purchased by the California Packing Company in and so on. Hovden faced a setback in when his cannery burned to the ground. An investigation determined that the cause was arson, which Hovden claimed was the work of a competitor. The conviction of an ex-convict for the crime did little to aid the plight of Hovden, who had already suffered a loss of capital assets amounting to Insurance covered only part of the loss.
Nevertheless, Hovden rebuilt in at the same site. From on, the cannery industry grew almost without interruption for twenty five years, owing to a successful merger of the production of sardines with the practice of reducing them to meal and oil. This process of reduction had begun in Monterey in when Booth had established the first such plant; ** but it was not until that legislation allowed quotas of fish for reduction sufficient to make the process profitable. Eventually, profits from reduction surpassed those from canning. During World War II, Cannery Row continued to prosper as it had since the season. Indeed, the twelve years from to turned out to be peak years of the sardine catch landed at Monterey (with the exception of the lucrative period).
The wartime period saw several setbacks to the industry, but these were balanced by corrective measures taken by the federal and local governments, and the prosperity continued. The U.S. Coast Guard requisitioned many fishing boats for wartime service, reducing the size of the commercial fleet. In addition, the wartime internment of Japanese robbed the Monterey fleet of several boat owners and operators. Cannery Row was even more directly affected. Many workers, seeking more stable and lucrative employment, left the canneries for industries more directly related to the war effort. At the same time, the sardine canning industry benefited from the high ceiling price on sardines set by the Office of Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 7) Price Administration.
The War Production Board even set aside the entire catch for government use. Furthermore, although providing sufficient numbers of workers for the canneries continued to be a problem, community efforts to recruit local citizens, and the use of military volunteers, helped keep the canneries operating. After World War II, Cannery Row began a steady decline which was relieved only briefly by an increase in activity during the 19U9 50 season. In only cases were canned, one sixth the number canned in By the annual output had fallen to cases. During this catastrophic collapse, some of the canneries kept operating by trucking sardines up from Port Hueneme and Santa Barbara. However, this practice ceased due to spoilage and increased costs.
The canners also packed other fish, including tuna, mackerel, anchovy, and salmon. For a while, hope for continued cannery activity also lay with squid, which had been fished in Monterey Bay waters since the days of the Chinese fishing village. This transition, underway in saw eight canneries employing workers in the summer "off season", before the winter run of sardines. However, without the great quantities of sardines which, for twenty five years had kept them bustling, the canneries rapidly began shutting doors Most canneries did not declare bankruptcy; they merely closed their doors, unable to meet operating expenses.
From a high of thirteen canneries and seventeen reduction plants operating in there were only five operating on the Row in By the Hovden Plant was the only operating cannery on Cannery Row. Knute Hovden retired from active participation in operation of the cannery in At that time, management was assumed by the vice-president of the company, William Lunde, who had been an officer in the company for twenty-seven years. In Stanford University acquired the Hovden property through a sale-purchase negotiation, which contained a lease-back provision. This lease was assumed in by the Wilbur-Ellis Company of San Francisco, which had also purchased the canning equiptment from the Hovden estate, and continued operating the cannery as the "Portola Packing Company".
Finally in the Wilbur Ellis Company transferred its canning equiptment to another plant in Moss Landing, and the old Hovden cannery building has stood empty since. Smoke, odors, noise and hubbub of industry left with the sardines. Little has been written about Cannery Row itself, except for the two novels, Cannery Row and Sweet Thursday. Even these do not help much to establish the historical context of Hovden Cannery. As Richard Persen points out, Steinbeck did not write about the canneries or their workers, but rather about the Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 8) socially outcast inhabitants of the Row.
Steinbeck is now firmly linked to the street he made famous, and the public is equally firm in its romanticized version of what Cannery Row was like * Perhaps the popular saying is applicable here: Cannery Row isn't like it used to be, and probably never was. Today Cannery Row is a thriving, bustling street crowded with tourists arriving by car or discharged from tour buses. They stroll past a variety of restaurant/bars, art galleries, amusement areas (complete with a carrousel and cotton candy) and gift shops of endless variety. Many of these tourist attractions are located in the structures which once housed the canning industry, although the decor of most makes no attempt to reflect former industrial days of the Row.
Monterey has never been a one-industry town, and it does not appear to be suffering today from the loss of the sardine, nor probably has it ever suffered to any great extent. This unusual situation is the result of several events which collectively are responsible for the apparent healthy economic status of Monterey. The primary factor in Cannery Row's survival was that the phase-out of the canning industry was gradual over a period of years, some say up to twenty. As the sardine catch fell after the canneries supplemented their production, as they had done in the past, by canning other species of fish, especially squid. In that year, eight canneries were packing squid, and when the Hovden Cannery was last operated by Wilbur-Ellis, it too was canning only squid.
Another element which had been a major factor in a healthy economy in Monterey, has been the continuance of the military establishments in the area. The Army ?s huge installation at nearby Fort Ord has continued to contribute to the economy since after World War II. Even more directly associated with the local economy are the Navy's postgraduate school and the Department of Defense language school at the Army Presidio, both of which are within the city limits. Probably the most important reason for Monterey's economic health is the growing number of tourists who flock to the Peninsula area. They come to enjoy the beautiful weather and coastal scenery, the recently completed downtown and waterfront developments, and of course Cannery Row.
The refurbished Cannery Row gives a feeling of affluence which stands in marked contrast to Steinbeck's description of "a stink, grating noise" and "an odor offtrottim fish and the indescribable smell of fish meal."1" The .small seems to have turned to that of sweet success. Hovden Cannery H-AER No. CA-1 1 (Page 9)
The Sardine Canning Process
The Hovden cannery building is now an empty shell, stripped of its equiptment and machinery. A description of the building is best presented in the context of a description of the canning process itself. To overcome the difficulty connected with bringing boats loaded with sardines close to the cannery, Hovden erected a stub wharf as far out into the water as possible, terminating the structure with a high tower. From this tower, he strung heavy wire cables to moorings that were placed several hundred feet seaward. The small lampara boats would port directly beneath these cables. Buckets that could hold 615 pounds of sardines were let down on the cables, and when full, were hauled up to the top of the fish tower by power winches operated from the tower.
The fish were then sluiced by gravity flow, through wooden flumes to large rorating wire screen cylinders. Tumbling through these rotating cylinders removed the sardines scales, after which they were sluiced into a series of square redwood holding tanks of five tons capacity each. Fresh water was constantly pumped through the tanks, keeping the fish cold and fresh until they were transported to the next stage in the process. In Hovden added another method of unloading fish from the boats, by using a centrifugal pump. ' This pump, driven by a 30 electric motor, connected eight-inch metal and flexible rubber piping to the bottom of two v-shaped eight-foot by eighteen-foot floating wooden hoppers, which were anchored about 500 feet from shore in forty feet of water.
Boats would unload their catch into these hoppers by various mechanical means including purse-bottomed brailing nets. The fish were sucked from the hoppers at a rate of seventy tons per hour by the centrifugal pumps. This was discovered to accomplish the additional step of removing scales in the process. Therefore, the fish unloaded by this system were delivered directly into the same bins that held the bucket-hoisted fish. The fish were weighed as they were being transported to the storage bins. These bins not only provived elasticity to the operation, by keeping catches fresh until they could be processed, but they also provided additional flexibility by allowing fish of different size and quality to be sluiced to selected bins, maintaining a control on the quality and size of the fish.
This allowed smaller fish to be selected for a select pack.1 From the holding tanks, fish were sluiced to the cutting area. In the early days, the fish were cut and cleaned by hand. By the late cutting machines were in use in most of the canneries. After being placed belly down into compartments of a metal conveyor belt, the sardine's head, tail, and entrails (excluding roe and interior fat) were removed. Hovden at various Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 10) times had from twenty-four to thirty-two cutting machines, each with its own operator, and each machine capable of processing one and a quarter tons of fish per hour. After being cut and cleaned (gutted), the fish were again transported by fresh sea water through sluices to a second set of holding tanks.
These cut-fish tanks were filled with brine, a mixture of fresh water and sea water, the latter drawn by centrifugal pumps through an intake pipe laid 500 feet out from the edge of the cannery. The brine tanks not only kept the fish chilled and fresh, but also washed the blood out of the fish, leaving the meat clean. The cut fish were then flushed through gate- controlled flumes onto metal drapers (belts). These drapers raised the fish thirty-six inches from the floor, then passed them down the center of double sided packing tables. While enroute to the cutting tables, the water drained off of the fish into cement troughs in the cannery floor, and into the bay.
In addition to discarded fish scales and bloody water from the brine tanks, this was one of the many steps in sardine processing that dumped its waste product into the waters of Monterey Bay. In later years, mo*st of the waste products were utilized in the manufacturing of by-products for agricultural and industrial uses . Having arrived at the packing tables, the fish were removed from the moving belt and packed into cans by hand. The filled cans were placed on another moving conveyor belt, which transported them to the exhausters, or precookers. The open cans of sardines were next exposed to live steam for approximately thirty minutes. They were then removed, inverted, and drained by a mechanical draining machine.
The cans were then placed upright on a conveyor belt that passed beneath the spout of a machine which poured a pre-measured amount of whatever variety of sauce that particular batch of fish was receiving. Mustard, seasoned oil, and tomatoe were among those most commonly used. Since both draining and saucing took only a few minutes, the cans were still steaming hot when they were delivered to the sea ling machine area. Each pre-cooker had its own sealing machine. With each machine capable of sealing tops on forty five cans per minute, total output was approximately cans per hour per machine.
The power for the sealing machines was provided by a ^0 electric motor mounted on a high cement pedestal of reinforced concrete which turned a line shaft to which were belted the closing machines (see Photo No. CA-11-51). The sealed cans were then propelled through a washer designed by Harold E, Bergen, the plants engineer. This machine consisted of a cylindrical housing partially filled with a caustic solution. The cans were propelled by an Archimedes screw with holes punched in its flight, allowing liquid to remain behind as the cans were driven Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 1 1) through. A spray of boiling fresh water rinsed the cans as they emerged from the washing machine.
The cans were then delivered into cars of perforated metal, approximately four-foot square, which were wheeled into large retorts capable of holding six or seven cars each. The final cooking operation took place in rectangular steel retorts, or pressure cookers, which were approximately six feet tall and 25 feet long. Their girth was bound with steel I- beams, and they were sealed shut with vault-like doors. When the retorts were filled with canned fish, live steam was admimtted through mains from boilers located in the adjacent boiler house. The remnants of the three boilers and furnaces still remain, although their parts, especially fire brick and piping, are continually disappearing.
Only one of the furnaces still has a tag attached, that of the "Dorward Engineering Company, Pressure of ten pounds per square inch and a temperature of 240 degrees F. were maintained for one hour and a half. The sterilized cans of cooked sardines were given a final washing in a lye solution, after which they were coated with a film of lacquer by a lacquering machine. They were then stacked in a warehouse for eventual packing into boxes which would be labeled by the machine. The box labeling machine presently in the cannery, manufactured by Sprague Sells Corporation, is the only operable piece of machinery which remains. THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF KNUTE
Hovden to the Sardine Canning Process
When the sardine canneries were in their infancy, shortly after the turn of the century, all processes were performed by hand. Fish were caught by gill nets from which they were extracted one by one. They were carried by hand baskets from the docking, or beaching area, to the processing building, where they were cleaned by hand. They were then spread on flakes (trays) in the sun to dry out excess moisture. After drying, the fish were placed in wire baskets and fried in hot peanut oil. As the fish cooked, their blood and oil mixed with the peanut oil, which became progressively darker and more contaminated. The result was cooked sardines of variable quality. The cans into which the fried fish were sealed were hand soldered, square cornered, retangular tin boxes.
Once the cooked fish were packed in these cans, the lids were soldered on by hand and the product was ready for marketing. Knute Hovden arrived in Monterey in and began working as a supervisor of Frank E. Booth's cannery. Hovden was well qualified for suoh a job, being a graduate of Norway's National Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 12) Fisheries College as a fisheries engineer and technician. He had worked for a time in Europe in a position comparable to that of the Area Coordinator of the U.S, Federal Fisheries Bureau inspecting methods and conditions of fish canning. From the time he first began working in Monterey throughout his eleven years with Booth, be introduced many significant changes in the canning industry.
' One of the first problems Hovden sought to solve was the irregularity with which sardines were delivered to the cannery. As a result of the gill nets then used the supply of sardines was not only limited but also was delivered irregularly due to the unreliability of the gilling process. Hovden constructed a series of five twenty foot square floating net pounds (pens), anchored in the bay, into which fish were dumped as they were caught. The canneries were thus assured of drawing upon fairly regular stocks of fresh sardines, quite healthy from feeding upon the rich nutrients of the bay while in the pounds. After being scooped out of these pounds, the sardines were passed laboriously by wicker basket up to the wharf that led to Booth!s cannery.
This process was improved in by Hovden's introduction of the purse-bottom brailer. This crane-operated net-basket could be lowered into the floating the floating pounds (later into the full lampara and purse seines) where it scooped up great quanti- ties of fish. When hoisted up to the receiving containers the gathered bottom of the net was released, unloading the fish quickly. Hovden also replaced the tedious method of hand flaking the fish for drying in the sun, by developing a mechanical dryer. This innovation increased production from 100 cases to cases a day. Another step of the earlier canning process which Hovden modified was the non-uniform method of frying baskets of fish by pushing them through troughs of hot oil.
In Hovden was experimenting with a method of propelling the fish through the oil by uniformly powered chain drives. By he had developed a mechanical cooker which permanently ended the practice of frying by hand. The final refinement to the cooking process occurred when live steam replaced hot peanut oil as the cooking agent. First used under atmospheric pressure and eventually under high pressure, steam cooked sardines in a standardized manner and resulted in a high quality, uniformly flavored product. Hovden is also credited with introducing into Booth * s operation the automatic can capping machines which replaced the earlier hand soldering method.
Two men operating these machines could turn out seventy cans a minute, as compared to twelve men operating the old machines turning out a combined total of sixty cans a minute. y The final and most significant modification during this Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-1 1 (Page 13) early phase of the sardine industry on Cannery Row, came in the manner of catching fish. As with other modifications to the process, the change in the type of nets and boats involved over i period of time and from the efforts of many people. The evolution in Monterey from gill net to the lampara net has been mentioned above. The lampara net allowed sardine catches of up to twenty five tons per boat, a quantity unheard of up to that time.
The significance of the lampara was not only that it caught great quantities of fish, but that such quantities could not be handled by the SIB all boats then in use, or by the limited number of canneries. This change from gill to lampara net was part of a larger transition: a chain of events that led progressively to larger nets, larger catches, and ultimately to the need for larger nets and boats. And so, the industry expanded from a "hand craft" process, to an assembly line production method. A CHRONOLOGY OF THE
Construction of the Hovden Cannery
The construction history of the Hovden Cannery is told primarily by four sets of sources: 1. Documents held by the Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation, which consist of blueprints and drawings on mylar found in the abandoned cannery buildings. These plans are of limited help in describing construction of the building, since they are incomplete, limited in number, and in many cases hardly legible. In addition, it is often difficult to determine whether the construction indicated on the blueprint was ever completed. In many cases, it is likely that changes were considered and drawn up, but for some reason not undertaken. 2. Sanborn maps for the years and found in the Monterey Public Library. 3.
Building Permit Applications submitted by Hovden Food Products Corporation and held by the Monterey Building inspection Department. The city has on file only the permit applications for the years *J. Blueprints of construction changes to the Hovden Cannery which were approved by the city. The city has on file only six such blueprints. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 14) On August 11, the original plant burned down. Hovden switched operations immediately to a temporary location and immediately started plans for his new cannery. There are no blueprints or building permit applications on file in Monterey for the initial construetion of the existing building.
A discussion of the evolution of structural characteristics of the Hovden Cannery is best conducted by reference to the and 19 30 Sanborn reaps. Since no documents are available reflecting changes which may have occurred between and alterations subsequent to can only be observed in the photographs which are included in this report. Some of these 3re discussed below: (1) Originally an open driveway from Ocean Avenue, heading north to the boiler house, allowed access to the latter1 on all but the north side, which had a common wall with the main cannery. The boiler house that exists now was added about expanding into the open space on the north side of the boiler. The new boiler room was constructed of reinforced concrete with a steel truss roof.
This addition also added a pipe shop which is reflected on the Sanborn Map. The pipe shop and a machine room were eventually moved to the first floor of the southernmost section of the "building, directly below the east end of the truss across Ocean View Avenue. (2) The portion of the Hovden property on the north side of Ocean Avenue contained a small fuel oil tank and office, and two small structures. By Hovden was making plans to increase his fish meal and fish oil production capacity. The passage of the Murphy-Youngman Bill by the California Legislature in the spring of accounts for the numerous additions made to the cannery at this time. The legislation increased the percentage of the sardine catch which could be reduced to meal and oil by- products.
Since profits from reduction were growing in proportion to those of canning, Hovden, along with others, increased their by-product production in anticipation of these increased profits. From the reduction plant the meal and oil were transported over Ocean Avenue through pipes supported by the truss shown in the blueprint dated May 29, The meal was sacked and stored in the building which is shown on the Sanborn Map, the blueprints for which are dated May ii, This truss was repaired as indicated on Building Permit Application U5-99 dated May 3, (3) The Sanborn map shows the company office building on the south side of Ocean Avenue, between the drying room and the nailing and machine shop. Sometime between and a small third story addition was made to the south corner of the building.
It was approximately 9 by 12 feet, with a tile roof topped with a flag pole. A major modification to this section of Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 15) the cannery was indie ated by plans dated October 30 , This modification replaces the tile roof on the third fl oor tower and on the second floor r oof. The entire wooden side o f the building (north to the drivewa y next to the boiler room) was faced with stucco. A new wall a nd gate closed off the area pr eviously open between the drying ro ora and the office. The gate a nd fence which were connected to the boiler house were repaired an d heightened.
This por tion of the building, as shown on the above noted plan, generally represents the facade of the building as it stands today, with th e following exceptions: first , the lower row of seven windows in the drawing have been repla ced by two large sections of gla ss block, and second, three wi ndows exist on the building where a large square acess door (8 ft. by 8 originally was locate d. The warehou se on David Avenue, adjacent t o the railroad tracks, was originall y a one-story building with a basement. However, the basement (below grade level at the wes t end of the building) was at grad e level with Cannery Row.
Tnu s trucks had access to the buildin g from Cannery Row, while the main level had a loading dock 'level with freight cars using the ra ilroad siding at the south end of t he building. Photograph No. H 5 shows this building under constr uction. A second floor was ad ded to the warehouse in Cwh ich actually added a third lev el, counting the basement). The p lans for this addition are see n in Drawings 6 and 7 , and referred to on Building Permit dated September 19, (5) A second st ory was added in to the one story room, whose west end had a common wall with the boiler room in This addition, locate d above the retort area, was used as storage area for empty cans. This modification was approved by Building Permit Application H2 A STRUCTURAL
Description of the Hovden Cannery
There are at least seven different sections to the cannery and more than thirty-five adjoining buildings, constructed over a period of approximately fifteen years. Each is constructed adjacent to the next, many with common walls. Much of the superstructure is in bad repair; some of it is either collapsed, or in a state of near collapse. The substructure shows signs of advanced infirmity as well. The substructure is generally the same throughout the This description is drawn from the "Structural Description" section of the Determination of Eligibility of the Hovden Cannery for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places, prepared by the San Francisco District of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, dated September, Hovden Cannery HAER No- CA-11 (Page 16) complex.
About half the building area is built directly on land behind a seawall, while the other half is constructed on a substructure of wood posts on concrete piers in Monterey Bay. This structure is an irregular one, without a standard bay size. Most of the columns are 8" by 8" posts, while there is a section of concrete posts supporting a concrete structure above. Generally, however, the wood posts support beams (6" X 10" or double 3" X which support 5" X 10" joists at 16 inch spacing. Plank flooring tops the joists (2" X 10" planks) and the finished floor is a layer of concrete (generally five inches thick) throughout the building. On top of this is constructed the superstructure, the myriad building types that will be described below.
Along Cannery Row three of the differing construction methods are evidenced. Two of these are wood structures with exterior wood siding. The third, which housed the company offices, is a wood structure with stucco extrerior and red clay tile roof. Traveling northwest on Cannery Row, the first building in the Hovden Cannery complex is a wood structure. It is a narrow clear-span structure supported by bearing walls. The roof is supported with trusses and consists of planks covered with tarpaper. The second building is the office building. It is a two- story structure built on 2" X *l" wood studs. The floor and roof structure are also timber. The interior is wainscoated with wood panelling and has frosted glass partitions. Upper walls are stucco over gypsum board.
Most of the front wall of the first floor is glass block. There is one office on the first floor which has a skylight through the second floor to the roof. The third building along Cannery Row is actually a small portion of the structure that takes up the bulk of the floor space in the cannery. The roof is a series of shed roofs with clerestory windows and gable roofs. Whether shed or gable, the roofs are supported by trusses composed of 2" X 6" and 1" X 6" planks which are in turn covered with tarpaper. The trusses are supported on H" X 10" beams which are supported by 6" X 6" wood columns, generally on a 20-foot square bay system.
The exteerior walls of this section are made of 2" X 6" studs (with horizontal and diagonal cross-bracing) at 16 inches on center, covered 1" X 6" tongue-and-groove horizontal wood siding. A part of this section, which appears to be older, had an exterior of studs covered by 3" boards which are in turn covered with stucco on metal lath. This wall is now an interior wall, but retains the original window openings. Four bays of this portion of the building have collapsed. Built in the far southeast corner of the complex, on the bay side, is a concrete addition whose structure is 1*1 square columns on an 18-foot square bay suporting concrete beams, 12 X Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 17) These beams support 10" X 12" concrete girders at 9-foot interals.
The floor above these is a 6" thick concrete slab. Exterior walls are clay block infill or a combination of clay block infill and 2" X 6" wood studs with stucco exterior covering. The second floor of this section is a wood structure supported much as that structure described in the previous sec tion. The addition of the western end of the complex stands next to the largest structure in the complex. The roof of this section, much higher than that of other sections, is supported on large wooden trusses, which are supported on one end by a load bearing poured concrete wall, and on the other by a row of 8" X 8" wood columns. The columns, without the wall, form 10 bays, 20 X 56' each. The exterior walls are made of 4" X 6" studs, eight feet on center.
There is horizontal bracing of the same dimension lumber. The exterior covering on the walls and on the roof is of corrugated abestos sheets, thick. In this section is a poured concrete cold storage area, approximately 20' X This structure is poured all the way from the rocks below the building. 'The walls are 18" thick. One wall of this section of the complex fronts on the railroad siding. Also along the railroad siding is a very small section of timber construction. The interior walls, however, are poured concrete with 17" X 17" piers at intervals. This wall and the piers extend below the building to the foundation rocks at the bay's edge. The wood structure is similar to others mentioned, except that it is two-story.
A large concrete structure is located with a long wall on David Street and a shorter wall on the railroad siding. The bays in this building are 1 5 ' 6" square and are formed by concrete columns 24" X The concrete portion of this building is two stories, and what is found on the first floor is repeated on the second. The columns support concrete beams 16" X 24" which support concrete girders of 12" X 16" at five foot intervals. The concrete slab supported by the girders is 12" thick. Some of the exterior wall sections are poured concrete while others are clay block infill.
There is a third floor on this building which is a wood structure like those described previously, except that the roof is held up by flat trusses running the length of the gable roof which is built of planks on a regular joist system. The planks are covered with tarpaper. The exterior of the third building is a combination of poured concrete or clay block infill and a stud wall with a stucco applied to the exterior. On David Street, at the end of Cannery Row, is a garage-type door that leads into an open courtyard. Most of the courtyard is covered with a flat wood roof of 2" X 12" members at 24" centers, supported by triple 2" X on one side and the wall of the previously described concrete building on the other. The roof Hovden Cannery HAER No.
CA-11 (Page 18) is covered with ood and tarpa per. Most of the ground is covered with a concr ete slab. A seperate stru cture is loca ted ao ross Can nery Row from the main group of buildi All tha t rema ins of t his building is the reinforced concr ete frame, co nsisti ng o f 10 ,r square columns supporting 10" X 12" beams. The struct ure is b ased on a simple grid system, with 16 bays about 1 2 feet squ are. The floor is a concrete slab. Ther e are no wall s and no r oof. Other features of this compl ex inc lude thr ee sheet metal smokestacks which ri se out of the cente r or the complex to differing heights. These are sup ported aga inst wind damage with guy wires.
Also of interest is t he ext ensi ve d rainage system in those buildings wher e large amoun ts of wa te r we re used in processing. The dra inage system consis ts o f tr oughs formed in the concrete floor, and a system of woo den slui ces underneath the floor structure. Th e loading doo k alon g th e ra ilroad siding is a wood structure with a shed roof c overin g. Hovden Cannery RAER No. CA-11 (Page 19) CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS
Pertaining to the Hovden Cannery
Frank E. Booth opens the first cannery in Monterey (near the site of the present Fisherman's Wharf.) Knute Hovden comes to Monterey to become Booth's cannery supervisor. Lampara net is introduced to Monterey fishing community. First cannery built on Ocean View Ave. (Cannery Row). F. E. Booth constructs Monterey's first reduction plant for converting offal to meal (used for agricultural feed and fertilizer). Knute Hovden leaves Booth and builds his own cannery, The Hovden Food Company. tons of sardines landed at Monterey; cases are canned. Hovden's first cannery burns down. Rebuilding on the same site, Hovden begins canning operations in his new cannery in the summer of Hovden introduces purse seines: effort abandoned after boycott by lampara fishermen.
Murphy-Younger Bill allows increased reduction processing After being re-introduced by Hovden, purse seines, and the larger boats with which they are used, replace lam- para boats and nets. A second story added to the main warehouse on David Ave. Hovden enlarges the boiler house, constructs meal pack- ing and storage building across Ocean View Avenue. Constructs truss to transport by-products across Ocean View Avenue to new building. Largest catch of sardines ever landed at Monterey: tons; cases. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 20) The amount of sardines canned drops from 1.2 million cases in season, to cases. Except for a brief revival in the industry never re- covers. Knute Hovden retires to Mexico. Plant operation continues under William Lunde.
Hovden Cannery becomes the last operating cannery on Cannery Row, Hovden dies in Mexico. Stanford University purchases Hovden Cannery building from the Hovden estate. The Wilbur Ellis Company, San Francisco, purchases the canning machinery from the Hovden estate* Wilbur-Ellis Company leases the cannery building from Stanford, and continues operations under the label name "Portola". Wilbur-Ellis Company ceases operations, moves its can- ning equipment to Moss Landing plant. There are no fish processing plants left operating on Cannery Row. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 21) FOOTNOTES John M. Dennis, "Monterey's Cannery Row, A Brief Survey" (Stanford: 7 July Randall A. Reinstedt, Where Have All the Sardines Gone? (Monterey: Color-Ad Printers, p. 15. 2 Monterey, Cannery Row Plan p. 35.
3 While this report was in preparation, removal of interior doors, fire brick and other valuable items was clearly in progress. ^Richard Persen, History of Cannery Row (Monterey: d'ANGELo Publishing Co., p. 18. ^Subsequent references to "Ocean View Avenue" will identify it as "Cannery Row," except as reference to original documents, which have the original name. (This is soirtetimes shortened- to Ocean Ave .) Persen, History of Cannery Row, p. Reinstedt, Where Have All the Sardines Gone?, p. "The History of Portola," West Coast Fisheries, p. 7. 7 This net was well suited to catching sardines, which are surface feeders. p Eventually, hand rowed lampara boats and separate barges were replaced with larger, engine driven boats.
Fish were then stored in the hold, and piled on deck of the boats returning to the canneries. The amount of fish which were delivered is reported from fifteen to twenty five tons, after a nights work (Earl H. Rosenberg, "A History of the Fishing and Canning Industries in Monterey, California" (M.A. Thesis, University of Nevada, p. 75. Rather than a discrepancy, the amount of fish carried depends on the size of the boat, and when in the development of the technology of fishing the reference is made. Q Dennis, "Monterey's Cannery Row," p. 8. Rosenberg, "A History of Fishing and Canning,", p. 90. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 22) 11 Ibid., p. 12 Dennis, "Monterey's Cannery Row," p. 9. Rosenberg, "A History of Fishing and Canning," p. 84. Ray A.
March, A Guide to Cannery Row (Monterey: Herald Printers, p. 21. 15 Monterey Peninsula Herald, March 29, Hovden moved to Guadalajara, Mexico, where he died on 26 March, Gregory Broughton, "A Study of the Hovden Cannery Property," 7 July, Stanford University. "ibid. I o John Steinbeck, Cannery Row (New York: Viking Press, p. 1.; Persen, History of Cannery Row, p. 39. 1 "The History of Portola", West Coast Fisheries (undated), p. 13, 16. The pumps are no longer in the cannery, but this type pump was manufactured at the time by the Americana Well Works of San Francisco. ^Because of its resistance to deterioration, red- wood was generally used in the construction of these hoppers, as well as the sluices and holding tanks previously mentioned. 21 Hovden's select quality, i.e.
small sardines familiar to the European market, were packed under the "Prefet" label. This label was acquired when he purchased the Great Western Packing Company in ^'West Coast Fisheries", p. 11. 22 Neither precookers or draining machines are left in the cannery today. The former were manufactured by, among others Anderson-Barngrovner, of San Francisco, while the latter, by Emmons and Gallagher Company of San Francisco, and the Universal Canning Machinery Company. The mixture of fish oil and water, drained from the cooked fish was initially dumped into the bay. In later years, it was utilized in the process of reducing waste products into marketable commodities. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 23) 23 Canning machines were manufactured by, among others.
The American Can Company and Emmons and Gallagher, of San Francisco. 24 Some of these cookers were manufactured by the Stan- dard Boiler and Steel Works of Los Angeles. 25 Rosenberg, "A History of Fishing and Canning", p. 76. 2 fi Dennis, "Monterey's Cannery Row", p. 7. 27 Persen, History of Cannery Row, p. 13. 28 West Coast Fisheries, p. Rosenberg, "A History of Fishing and Canning", p. 75. 29 Rosenberg, p. 81. West Coast Fisheries, p. 12. By the lampara net was replaced by the purse seine, a net whose bottom could be closed (as by a purse string) trapping great quantities of fish (some could swim under and out of the lampara).
This larger and more efficient purse seine required boats with power driven equipment to bring in and unload the nets, as well as greater storage capacity in their holds. The purse seine boats purchased by Hovden in were 60 to 78 feet long, with capacities from 40 to 115 tons of sardines. 31 In anticipation of more profitable seasons, the canneries on the Row spent on improvements. This investment proved worthwhile as the amount of fish meal produced rose from tons in the season to tons in the season. Fish oil production for that same period rose from gallons to gallons. Rosenberg, "A History of Fishing", pp. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 24) SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY" Books: Elstob, Winston. Chinatown, A Legend of Old Cannery Row. Orinda,CA.
Condor's Sky Press, Hicks John and Hicks, Regina. Cannery Row, A Pictoral History. Salinas: I and M Enterprises, March, Ray A, A Guide to Cannery Row. Monterey: Herald Printers, Persen, Richard. History of Cannery Row. Monterey: d"ANGELo Publishing Co., Reinstedt, Randall A. Where Have All The Sardines Gone? Monterey: Color-Ad Printers, Theses: Rosenberg, Earl H. "A History of the Fishing and Canning Ind-ustries in Monterey, California." M.A. Thesis, University of Nevada, July, Unpublished Papers: Broughton, Gregory. " A Study of the Hovden Cannery Property. prepared for Stanford University, 7 July Dennis, John M. "Monterey's Cannery Row, A Brief Survey." unpublished seminar paper dated 4 June On file in the California Room, Monterey Public Library.
Government Documents: City of Monterey, California. Cannery Row Plan, an Element of The General Plan . Newspapers: Monterey Peninsula Herald clippings as collected in the files of the California Room, Monterey Public Library. Publications: West Coast Fisheries. "The History of Portola". (circa Interviews: Tony Souza, Plant manager, Hovden Cannery from October until it closed in Interview 3 November Monterey, California. Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 25) Anchor Anchor Diagram or Uio Sordino Canning Process Floa ting Hopper Lifcin^ CsbU Lifting Cable Weighing Scale Weiring Scale Scaling Machines Cookers i o Farking Table !
O I i - Poor ; 1 1 !o Storage Tanks Packing iab3e Khol* fish 1 1 By-Products Plant 4 \o Can Washer Packing Table Cutting Eviccrating Ka thine Brining Tanks for Cut SJrtfinss Mid! nd kjste i ! n ! n [ i Dryers Rwc E>;p!5 Water R E T 0 R T S u Truck Loading Lye Tank Warehouse Lacquer C.isc Labeling, Nil I line. Strapping. Shipping Cooling Rpom Machine Packing I ..t-4-i-4. -|.l:i;)v.t--> 1 |,| [ | t 1"l I 1 = SOUTHERN PACIFIC RAILKQAU TKA!;K5 Enclosure Hovden Cannery BAER No. CA-11 (Page 26) Labels of the various products canned by the Hovden Cannery are seen on this and the following page Hovden Cannery HAER No. CA-11 (Page 27) Hovden Cannery HAER No.
CA-11 (Page 28) The Portola Brand Label The Portola Brand was named after Captain Gasparde Portola, who served in Monterey as Mexico's first Governor of Alta California. The quality of fish packed under this namewon for Knute Hovden the Grand Prize at the Paris International Exposition in
The federal surveyors worked through Monterey building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,27-MONT,44-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.