BlockBefore

Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carillo Tenant House, Southwest of Intersection of San Diego & Santa Ana Freeways, Irvine

Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carillo Tenant House, Southwest of Intersection of San Diego & Santa Ana Freeways, Irvine, Orange County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,30-IRV,1-A-, with a 4,017-word written history.

From the record

“The Carrillo Tenant House was associated with the operation of Irvine Ranch during the early century, when James Irvine Jr. embarked on expanding agricultural production through the use of tenant farmers.”

Written record, HABS CAL,30-IRV,1-A- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,30-IRV,1-A- · the record runs 4017 words · one of 68 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

3851 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,30-IRV,1-A-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Carrillo Tenant House was associated with the operation of Irvine Ranch during the early century, when James Irvine Jr. embarked on expanding agricultural production through the use of tenant farmers. It is one of a handful of extant tenant houses that are outliers to the Irvine Agricultural Headquarters Complex, which was determined eligible for the National Register on February The Headquarters Complex is located at the intersection of Myf ord Road and Irvine Boulevard, and the Carrillo Tenant House is approximately 7.5 miles southeast of there [see Vicinity Map, page 8]. Report Prepared by: Rebecca Conard PHR Associates 725 Garden Street Santa Barbara, CA Date: February Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABSNo. CA-2275-A Page 2

Architectural Information

This single-story, circa farm house shows the lack of stylistic detailing common in rural, Craftsman-inspired folk houses of the early century. It is of rectangular plan with an irregular addition to the rear. The building rests on a foundation of wood post construction and measures x 24* on the longest sides [see page The front gable roof is covered with asbestos shingles and has moderate eave overhangs with exposed rafters. It is of single- wall, board-and-batten construction. Small shed roof extensions protect two stoops, one located center front and the other along the east side toward the rear of the house, off the kitchen. The front entry, a wood-paneled door, is placed off-center and has 1 light/1 light, double-hung wood sash windows arranged on either side of it.

Windows on the east and west sides are of varying dimensions and asymmetrically spaced; some windows are paired. The house has undergone a number of changes, and most of them appear to have been made in the The original board-and-batten walls have been covered with asbestos panels which are light green in color. John Poh, a farm tenant who lived in the house from through has stated that the new cladding was added after he left the place in Also after the length of the house was extended approximately feet to the rear. This extension expanded the square footage of the kitchen as well as the back bedroom and created two new rooms: a rear storage room and a second bathroom. The rear storage room is in the location of the original back porch.

The present-day rear door, which is now situated on the east side of the house, may have been moved at this time. The alterations also involved relocating the southernmost window on the west side. No doubt, the louvered aluminum frame windows in the kitchen were added at this time. On the exterior, these alterations can be seen where the flat roof of the addition abuts the original gable roof line. The west side of the addition is clad in asbestos panels, while the plywood siding of both the south and east elevations has been painted. Fenestration here consists of sliding metal casement windows. The interior reveals several other changes, though, surprisingly, a number of the original architectural features remain.

Those components still intact include the 3" tongue and grove pine flooring in the living and bedroom areas, much of the wall molding, several five-paneled wood doors, and many of the original sash windows. It appears that much of the interior remodeling to the house also occurred after when, according to John Poh, it was wired for electricity. The kitchen has been modernized with new cabinets and counters, and the changes are typical of kitchens of that era; the renovations most likely were made by In the living room, the ceiling has been sprayed with acoustical insulation, another indication of post-1958 renovation. In addition, there is evidence that rooms have been rcpartitioned. The original bathroom has also been modernized with a shower stall and new plumbing.

The grounds around the house are landscaped with several varieties of trees and shrubs: loquat, pepper, olive, palm, apricot, bottle brush, lilac, hibiscus, and orange. A playhouse and a barbecue pit are located at the rear of the yard, which is enclosed with wood fence. Outbuildings associated with the house include a board-and-batten garage located east of the house. A bougainvillea-covered trellis is anchored to both the house and the garage, creating a shaded vehicle parking space. East of the garage is located an octagonal concrete footing, which once supported a water tank. East of the concrete footing is located a well house. North of the garage approximately 62' is situated a machine shed of pole construction with corrugated metal roof and walls.

Approximately east-northeast of the garage is situated a U-shaped concrete structure that functioned (it is no longer in use) as a combination retaining wall and loading platform. The center section measures 55' long with a Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No. CA- 2275-A Page 3 36' wing on one side and a wing on the other side. This structure contains an earthen berm that was used as a vehicle ramp. Although the Carrillo House has been substantially altered, it appears to have been typical of housing the Irvine Company built for its tenants. In LSA Associates, Inc. surveyed extant structures on the Irvine Ranch within the limits of the City of Irvine. This study found that out of a potential 273 ranch structures depicted on six U.S.G.S.

topographic maps dating from to 59 major historic structures were extant at that time. Since LSA's study also found that it was not uncommon for buildings to have been moved and relocated on the ranch, the total building count of 273 may have included several structures that would have appeared at more than one location on old maps. In addition, LSA's survey indicated that most of the older ranch structures were gone by the with many of the 59 then-extant structures representing construction that took place between and the years during which the tenant farming operations of the ranch were fully developed [LSA A review of LSA's photographs and survey data indicates that most of the tenant houses associated with the Irvine Ranch probably were built between and World War I.

All of the houses extant as of were one-story cottages, vernacular in design and construction. Most of them embodied architectural elements influenced by the Craftsman style. Gable roofs predominated, usually with an overhanging eave and exposed rafters or angle braces. Several of these cottages were built with an open front porch, usually covered with a shed or gable roof and supported by plain 4x4 porch posts. Exterior wall cladding varied; some cottages were sheathed with clapboard, some with board-and-batten, and some with asbestos panels. Windows typically were 1 light/1 light wood sash, sometimes paired. Foundation systems invariably consisted of wood posts supporting a wood balloon frame structural system and allowing a minimal crawl space.

While tenant and employee residences displayed a great many similarities utilitarian design, lack of ornamentation, and constructed of ordinary materials -- they also reflected enough individuality to indicate that they were built as needed by more than one builder. It is obvious that they were not built from one or two standard house plans, since the size and configuration varied from one cottage to another, although all of them were small and probably had no more than four to six rooms each. In addition, window treatment varied: on some cottages the windows were all one size; on others, sizes were mixed. Placement also varied: sometimes windows were symmetrically spaced, sometimes asymmetrically. The same was true of front porch placement: sometimes centered, sometimes off-center.

In sum, the variety suggests that these cottages were constructed by carpenters who worked from traditional knowledge rather than from plan. The same was probably true of outbuildings. Generally, the tenant houses at Headquarters showed evidence of regular maintenance, whereas those in outlying areas were in various stages of deterioration. Because tenant buildings were not constructed for long-term permanence and because they lay scattered across the countryside, their potential importance as historical resources has been recognized only recently. Many buildings have already been demolished. Since at least 20 of the 59 structures extant at the time of the survey have been razed for various development projects. Most of the structures lost were tenant houses.

While there is little that is architecturally or technologically distinctive about this type of housing, the structures, as a group and in relation to other ranch buildings, reflect the economic status of ranch tenants and the socio-economic hierarchy associated with corporate farming. Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No. CA- 2275-A Page 4 II. HISTORICAL INFORMATION The Carrillo Tenant House was associated with the century development of the Irvine Ranch, although the ranch itself had its origins during the mid-19th century when many California land-grant ranchos were broken up.

By through a series of purchases and court actions, James Irvine, Llewelyn Bixby, and Thomas and Benjamin Flint were in control of approximately acres that had previously belonged to Ranchos Santiago de Santa Ana, Lomas de Santiago, and San Joaquin. Irvine provided the financial support to stock the land with sheep, which proved to be a profitable operation for several years [LSA During the late the ranch supported at least sheep, which were divided into herds of animals spread out over the property. Shepherds reportedly lived in 8'xlO' board cabins next to the corrals where they penned sheep each night.

As many as lambs were born each spring, and wool production is said to have reached as much as pounds annually [Cleland During the early winters of low rainfall forced the owners to reduce the size of the flocks, and the infamous drought of probably resulted in severe livestock losses. The drought coincided with Irvine's purchase of the shares held by Bixby, Flint and Company. As sole owner, Irvine continued to raise sheep for a time, but the primary emphasis shifted to cattle. By however, the vicissitudes of sheep ranching augmented by constant legal battles with squatters prompted Irvine to sell a portion of his holdings. He had the land divided into 40-acre farms, which he offered for sale on the installment plan.

The development scheme met with limited success, in part because new settlers often could not meet payments and in part because railroad companies also were promoting development along their own lines. During the mid-1880s, Irvine began leasing land to tenant farmers, possibly because he had experienced difficulty in selling 40-acre parcels. He first considered allowing tenant farming in about but this type of operation did not really begin to dominate the ranch until after During the however, limited tenant farming seems to have coincided with efforts to diversify agricultural operations inasmuch as tenants are said to have raised barley and hay on leased land.

At that time, the Ranch reportedly took a one- fifth share of the crop [Cleland When Irvine died in he left the ranch in trust for his wife and son, James Irvine and gave the trustees permission to sell the ranch at their discretion. The trustees did, in fact, put the ranch up for sale at auction, but mistakes in the bidding procedure prompted them to withdraw the offer of sale.

Railroad expansion changed the economic prospects of the ranch dramatically during the late After taking the ranch off the market, the trustees took advantage of competition between the Santa Fe Railroad and Southern Pacific and eventually deeded a right-of-way across the middle of the ranch to Santa Fe in return for permission to cross Santa Fe's tracks with roads, irrigation ditches, and other ranch improvements [Cleland During the the ranch operation took on the attributes for which it has been known throughout much of the century. Under the guidance of James Irvine who incorporated the ranch as The Irvine Company [TIC] in the practice of leasing land and equipment to tenant farmers increased. In acres were leased to farmers on a sharecrop basis.

Crop farming also took on added importance, although both cattle and sheep ranching continued. By approximately acres were planted with barley. Two types were grown here: Chevalier barley, which was exported to Europe for brewing, and feed barley. Production reached more than a million sacks annually, with fields generating about 8- 10 sacks per acre. Beans were the second most important crop produced on the ranch during Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, CarriUo Tenant House HABS No. CA- 2275.-A Page 5 the with much of this crop grown on the acres leased to tenants. Wheat, corn, and potatoes were also grown on the ranch [Cleland Meadows Company records show that in tenant farmers were growing barley. In addition to corn, potatoes, wheat, and beans, some tenants began to grow peanuts.

Early in the century, lima and black-eyed beans were added to the list, and by lima beans had replaced barley as the principal crop. Twenty-three tenants were growing limas in that year. In about rhubarb, flax, alfalfa, and artichokes were added to the increasingly diversified operation. Sugar beets were planted for the first time in about and a year later company records show 12 tenants were growing this crop. During these years, the ranch itself still continued to operate cattle, sheep, and barley stations, each with its own camp and employees [LSA Cleland - In the early James Irvine Jr. also experimented with orchard crops. In one of the largest tenant operations began when C.E. Utt and Sherman Stevens persuaded Irvine to join them in a citrus production venture.

The two men formed the San Joaquin Fruit and Investment Company, in which Irvine took a share. Stevens and Utt planted 600 acres of walnuts and apricots and 400 acres of oranges and lemons. Under the terms of the contract, they developed water resources located on the ranch. While the trees grew to maturity, the partners grew row crops such as beans, peanuts, and peppers. Within a few years, the operation started to turn a profit, which allowed the company to expand its operations. In TIC granted the San Joaquin Company a lease for a period of fifteen years, at the end of which time the latter company was to purchase the land for an acre.

During the 15-year lease period, TIC collected 25 percent of the profits [Cleland The success of the San Joaquin Fruit and Investment Company led Irvine to drain low-lying areas of the ranch in order to expand production, and eventually citrus orchards began to replace grain fields. In addition, other row crops were introduced, including tomatoes, lettuce, cabbage, mustard, peas, celery and rhubarb. Beans continued, though, to be one of the principal crops, and as many as acres were devoted to lima beans in the and Tenant farmers grew most of these crops. They leased their houses, barns, and equipment from The Irvine Company, and the company took one-third of the crop as payment [LSA LSA Appendix A].

Marketing cash crops required extensive warehouse and handling facilities as well as housing to accommodate employees. The first warehouse was constructed in and a second was added in In James Irvine Jr. helped to organize the Santa Ana Cooperative Sugar Company and built a sugar beet processing facility. In about The Irvine Company acquired the Holly Sugar Company in Santa Ana. The growing number of employees and tenants with families also led The Irvine Company to build employee housing (bunkhouses and single-family dwellings) and to establish a school and post office near the ranch headquarters on Myford Road.

The company also built a citrus shipping station at ranch headquarters [LSA Sanchez Cleland Meadows Expanding agricultural production required the development of water resources and extensive irrigation systems. In order to finance these costs, The Irvine Company sold off parts of the ranch from time to time. Between and 350 acres at Laguna and 400 acres at Newport were sold off; these became the present-day cities of Laguna Beach, Newport Beach, and Corona del Mar. The cities of Tustin and Costa Mesa also had their origins in such land sales [Hertel Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No. CA- -A Page 6 The depression of the marked the end of expanding agricultural operations for The Irvine Company.

In TIC adapted the leasehold system to urban development with the creation of Bayshores, a residential community. Rather than selling land, The Irvine Company leased building lots for a period of years and changed an annual lease fee as well as a maintenance fee for the private beach that was part of the community. (Eventually the practice of leasing urban residential lots was phased out in favor of fee-simple sale.) During the early the company sold acres of land to the federal government for the El Toro Marine Corps Base and another acres for a dirigible station [Hertel After James Irvine Jr. died in his son Myford inherited the helm.

Myf ord Irvine continued the operation established by his father, a combination of tenant farming, company farming, and cooperative marketing efforts, but he also further diversified the company by investing in housing and commercial development. The post-World War II housing boom provided the impetus for this direction, which continues to the present. The Irvine Company is now primarily engaged in urban development, and its agricultural facilities and remaining farmland are leased to commercial growers [LSA The Irvine Ranch and its successor, The Irvine Company, was and remains a major influence in the development of Orange County.

In this regard, the company shares a place in California history with other large ranch and land companies, notably the Tejon Ranch, the Kern County Land Company, and Miller and Lux, all of which have helped to determine the nature and timing of growth and development in various areas of central and southern California since the late century. While in general their influences have been similar, each of these land companies has operated in its own fashion, and each has left its own mark on the landscape. The Irvine Ranch is distinctive for its tradition of leasing agricultural land to tenants, yet comparatively little of the history of ranch tenant operations has been documented.

Several pertinent research topics remain unexplored, including how acreage was assigned to tenants as well as who determined what crops would be grown and in what quantities. Likewise, there is no biographical profile of Irvine Ranch tenant farmers. The historical context for evaluating the relative significance of individual structures in outlying areas has never been completely developed. Only two buildings associated with the ranch headquarters have been placed on the National Register: the Irvine Bean and Growers Association Building and Irvine Blacksmith Shop, both located at East Irvine.

The most complete study of Irvine Ranch was conducted in when LSA surveyed the historic ranch structures lying within the corporate boundaries of the City of Irvine [LSA, Little is known about the tenants or land-use associated with the Carrillo tenant farm, and the historic name is taken from the family believed to have lived here the longest, the Jack Carrillo family.

The Carrillos lived here for many years (though an undetermined number) prior to This information comes from John Poh, who worked for Carrillo as a hired hand, then moved into the house in The Poh family lived in the house until Successive tenants included the Steve Changala and then the Si Changala families [Poh, personal interview 17 April During the six years that John Poh lived on the place, about 500 acres were planted with lima beans, black-eyed beans, and barley. In about or he built two-thirds of the existing machine shed as well as the electric plant. The house had no electricity at the time, and the electric plant he built was to furnish power for farm operations; the house was not electrified until after the Pohs left.

Other structures situated on the farmstead at that time included a redwood water tank with a windmill and a large, three-portal barn situated west of the house. Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABSNo.CA-2275-A Page 7 The barn was of single-wall, board-and-batten construction; the center bay was used for hay storage and the wing bays held stalls for horses. In addition, a garage sat northeast of the well house, which would also have been northeast of the garage presently located on the property [Poh, 17 April None of these structures remains. III. Sonrccs Cleland, Robert Glass. The Irvine Ranch. San Marino: The Huntington Library, Hertel, Michael M. Irvine Community Associations. A Research Report of the Claremont Urban Research Center.

Claremont: Claremont Graduate School, LSA Associates, Inc. Cultural Resources Division. An Initial Survey of Historic Resources Within the City of Irvine and Its Sphere of Influence, [cited as LSA Unpublished manuscript prepared for The Irvine Company and on file at TIC. LSA Associates, Inc. Historic Property Survey Report for theI-5/1-405 Confluence, City of Irvine, California. Prepared for The Irvine Company, June [cited as LSA Meadows, Don. Irvine--A City on Rancho San Joaquin. Privately printed by the First National Bank of Orange County, Poh, John. Interviewed in person on the premises by Rebecca Conard on April Sanchez Talarico Associates. Historic Structures Report for the East Irvine Historical Site EIR, [cited as Sanchez IV.

Project Information This report was prepared as partial compliance with mitigation measures set forth in the EIR. for Planning Area 34 of the City of Irvine. At the request of the Historical, Archaeological, and Paleontological Committee of the City of Irvine, mitigation measures stipulated that photographs, measured drawings, and archival research were to be completed prior to demolition of two TIC tenant houses in the planning area: the Boyd House and the Carrillo House. Elizabeth Padon of LSA Associates, Inc. served as the Project Manager. The report was prepared under the direction of Rebecca Conard of PHR Associates, who acted as the Principal Investigator. John Elliott (LSA), Kevin A. Palmer Pamela Post and Ellen Keegan provided research assistance and clerical support.

Everett Weinreb of Santa Barbara was the photographer. The historical information included here is based on available published sources, limited oral history investigations, and a brief foray into company records conducted by LSA Associates in A reconnaissance of currently held company records conducted by The Irvine Company in indicated no holdings that would be useful for establishing constuction dates, names of leaseholders, leasehold acreage, and crop production over time. Local historian Jim Sleeper, who has indexed some Irvine Ranch records, was also contacted; a check of his files likewise failed to locate any information regarding the tenants. Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No.

CA-2275 -A Page 8 Vicinity Map Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters Source: Thomas Bros. California Road Atlas luisrrjNGTorr

Beach' Newport Beach

Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABSNo.CA-2275-A Page 9 Carrillo Tenant House Location Source: U.S.G.S. El Toro Quadrangle photorev. Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No. CA- 2275.-A Page 10 Site Plan, Carrillo Tenant House, SAM Ptada iSii mki ' ' N \ \ \ ^ RJMPHOOSS VMICCTANK. 0 A g \ Irvine Ranch Agricultural Headquarters, Carrillo Tenant House HABS No. CA- 2275~A Page 11 Floor Plan, Carrillo Tenant House, H _ _ 1 ' [ U >( 0AfH > j=i Livw<^ #T i I /o N

In context

Irvine, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Orange County, California 294 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Irvine

18 records

The federal surveyors worked through Irvine building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2-10,050 words
Irvine Ranch Agricultural HeadquartersHABS CAL,30-IRV,1-B-4,086 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2B-736 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2A-664 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2N-42 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2H-40 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2E-39 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2M-38 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2I-37 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2K-37 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,3F-36 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2G-36 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2J-35 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2P-35 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2D-34 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2Q-34 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2C-33 words
Buffalo RanchHABS CAL,30-IRV,2L-32 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,30-IRV,1-A-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.