Source document
Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,30-LABE.V,1-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Unincorporated Orange County North of the City of Laguna 5. Rating: Fair Beach, California 6. General Description. The residence is located on a 10.4-acre parcel in unincorporated Orange County, north of the City of Laguna Beach. The property is bordered to the north by the single family residential community of Emerald Bay, to the east by the Pacific Coast Highway, to the south by single family and multi-family residential units, and to the west by the Pacific Ocean. The street address of the property is North Pacific Coast Highway. Entrance to the property is provided from the Pacific Coast Highway through an ornate and concrete wrought iron gate. The site is currently developed with a main house, three caretaker structures, an aviary, two outside patios, and a gazebo.
Historically, the main house was primarily used as a second family residence. The three other residential structures on the estate were built shortly after the main residence was built for the purpose of housing the chauffer, gardener, and maid. In ornamental gardens were planted on the majority of the estate and two outside patios and a gazebo were constructed at various viewpoints. A survey of the style of the main residential structure defies categorization, but could mostly be described as a modified bungalow. It appears in review of the structural features that the purpose of the design of the structure was to emphasize the surroundings. The house is large, without detailing and embellishment. The rooms are focused with large plate glass windows overlooking the ocean.
Moldings, light fixtures, cabinets, and other detailed features within the structure are modest. The main room is the living room. It consists of a large living room with a central fire place. The room opens out onto a covered patio which faces the ocean. Two bedrooms and three bathrooms are located on the first floor. A large plain stairwell extends to the upstairs portion of the stmcture with a hallway which opens into the master bedroom and five smaller bedrooms. 7. Historical Background. The earliest records available indicate that Caroline W.
Dobbins purchased, from an unknown party, a large portion of land located north of Laguna Beach in unincorporated Orange County in approximately This property included: Emerald Terrace; Crown Point; and the property which was to become the Smithcliffs estate. Dobbins had the main residence on the property constructed in approximately as a secondary residence. The estate in its earliest years was named Dos Rocas. SMITHCLIFFS (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) HABS No. CA-2298 (Page 2) At a later date, Dobbins constructed another home located adjacent to her residence on the part of the cliff which faces Emerald Bay.
Her granddaughter, Florence Barnes, also known as Pancho Barnes, a legendary aviatrix and owner of Pancho's Fly Inn in Lancaster, California lived in the adjacent home for several years. Pancho Barnes was known for throwing loud parties. Her grandmother eventually had Pancho Barnes move her house to the point on the cliff south of the property. Pancho Barnes' house eventually burned down. In Dobbins sold approximately 10 acres of the property, including her home, to Oscar Howard a wealthy Oklahoma oilman. Mr. Oscar Howard and his wife Inez, owned the home from until his death in The house was used as a secondary home, with their main residence in Pasadena. In Howard sold the home to Mr. Lon Smith and his wife Jane. Mr. Smith was an executive with the Houston based Superior Oil Company.
The Smith family owned the property up until when Mr. Smith's second wife, Marguerite Smith, sold the estate to Mr. Gary Brinderson and his wife Marie. As part of the purchase agreement, Smith continued to live in the home until her death. Ms. Marguerite Smith passed away in 8. Condition. The house is in a semi run down condition. Although the house is large (approximately square feet), the house is not very functional in design . FIELD FORM CHECKLIST SMITHCLIFFS (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) HABS No. CA-2298 (Page 3) General Data Name of surveyor - STA Planning, Inc.
Address of firm - Newport Center Drive, Newport Beach, California Historical Data Names of building or structw-e (current and historic) - Smithcliffs (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) Location (street, city, county, state) - Pacific Coast Highway/Orange County/California Present function - Single family residential structure which has been vacated Original and interim functions - Second home/residential Date of completion - Circa Architect, designer, or manufacturer - Not known Major modifications with dates - Upstairs bedroom and bonus room addition to the rear deck Sources of infonnation -County of Los Angeles Public Records, County of Orange Building Permits and Appraisal Records; local newspapers, local historical books; and the Pirst American Insurance Company Historical Collection photographs.
Unexplored sources - Distant family members
Visual Survey Data
Building or Structure Description Foundation material(s) - Concrete raised Wall material(s) - Exterior shingle siding Structural and mechanical systems - 1 fireplace, 2 murphy beds, gravity flow heater, mechanical chair on stair case Bays - None Stories - 2 Measurements - square feet Shape and orientation - Large and oriented toward ocean Roof (shape. material, otha features such as chimneys, dormers, cupolas, etc.) - llip/cut-up Openings (doors, windows) Main entrance is from living room, the side entrance is through kitchen Porches, verandas, balconies - large covered patio off of the living room with wrought iron railing Exterior - shingle siding FIELD FORM CHECKLIST (CONT'D.) SMITHCLIFFS (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) HABS No.
CA-2298 (Page 4) Notable Interior Features (if interior Is examined). Art deco bathroom fixtures. murphy beds built in 2 bedrooms Mechanics in place - Gravity air heater with ventilation piping, mechanical chair on stair case Setting Integrity of site - House does not qualify as unique. The site may be considered unique because of the large parul, landscaping, location in relation to the ocean and panoramic views. Associate.d buildings - carport, guest house, aviary, caretakers residence, and two temporary residential structures..
Interrelationships (including water and transportation features if relevant) - To the west of the site is the Pacific Ocean, lO the east of the site is Pacific Coast Highway Notable landscaping - Ornamental grounds Has structure been relocated - No Other - This fieJd form check.Jist is for the entire acre estate. The main residential structure is .surrounded by various structures and gardens. This che<:klist includes the entire SntlthcJirfs estate. Condition Present condition - Fair Is this building being adversely affected? By what? - Demolition Other (specify) - Proposed custom lot development SMITHCLIFFS (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) HABS No. CA-2298 (Page 5)
Historic Structure Survey
Smithcliffs (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas), Orange County, California Building Name: Smithcliffs (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) Address: N. Coast Highway Approx. Date(s) of conslrllction: Laguna Beach, California Original Use: Residential, Secondary Current use: Vacant Surveyor: Dawn Neeley, STA Planning, Inc.
Date of Survey: January 3, Condition: Excellent Facade: Symmetrical Good {fsymmetricaD Row Bays_ Deteriorated Stories.-"2'---- Orientation: N s E NE NW SE SW Foundation: Brick Stone @Oncrete Bloc}) Reinforced Concrete Other SlrUctural System: ( ood Fra~ Brick bearing Stone bearing Metal Other_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Exterior Wall Covering: Wood Brick Stone .Stuceo Other: Shingle Sidin Roof: Shape: Gable - Mansard Cambre I (inp/Cut-Uji) Flat Materials: Composition/wood/other Cedar metal built-up Other: ~ SMITHCLIFFS (Howardscliffs) (Dos Rocas) HABS No.
CA-2298 (Page 7) KNOWN HISTORICAL DATA: Include sources: County of Los Angeles Public Records; County of Orange Building Permits and Appraisal Records; local newspapers; local historical books; and the First American Title Insurance Company Historical Collection photographs. SIGNIFICANCE: non-architecturally significant/historically significant based on location and ownership SMITHCLIFFS (HOWARDCLIFFS) (DOS ROGAS) HASS NO CA-2298 0 \ 3 ST-EtR- ._ VilOOD FRAME \ ~ - .-- BUILDING \, ' I /'. \ 1 / / \ __, -. I / .' ' / / ' -- .. ~ . .' / / . I ) 1 --: .i' r-- ~ , . ./, r1 __ ~; ~ ; - - WOOD & BRICK GARAGE~------------/ L...____;I ' ! ,~ ~ n WOOD SHED i / 0 GAZEBO -------r::i 1 S~ O,RY WOOD FRAME-::-- - I : I >- <{ ~' BUJLDING 3 / I ~\ . -~ 0 / I \_ - / r _ : /'- '-) i- "'- '" '~ .
I' (j) ~ ~ :::.:i <{ \ 0 0 0 "- (,) PACIFIC OCEAN --~ '' <{ ,-- -- '\ CL ~ WOOD FRAME BUILDING \ -i HOME I. MOBILE / r: ~\ \, ;1 S-TORY '~ ', ,, ___ . . . . . -., - :c ', ! i -- , ~- --- \ n ) -- , -- -- -- ./ I .- '. ___ -- ~ - :__ - _ - V> WOOD SHED 1 STORY WOOD 'FRAME BUILDING ::c ::c J> 0 a:> <: :z "'- 0 "~ ~- J> I (/I N~ N "'co t:> 0 HISTORIC AMERICAN ~"' .,, SM!ffi'.:UFFS RESIDENTIAL SMITH CUFFS ESTATE EXISTING
Structures on Site Buildings Survey Development Project
Hill NORTH COAST HIGHWAY LAGUNA BEACH VICINITY ORANGE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA NO. CA n"" co "' V> ~~ SMITHCUFFS (HOWARDCLIFFS) (DOS ROGAS) HASS NO. CA-2298 i!i ~ . - - :Ii; I;' IIt BACK PORCH \;' : '\ --< t'. L Cl "i --- 1 1 ;1 LIVING - KITCHEN' KITCHEN DINING ' - - --~ --- - --; 1 ~-: . .,I u'--'' ! ' PANTRYJ / ~ HALL -- HALL - '----=1fiA ~==_==c~1.:i1ll~sET - . .., -1 . ' ~ : ~1 ' . - BAS~MENT~--~ ~ V> ''- I " ;. . j ., ~ ;no BA TH . ;1 CLQ~ET i CL_.,9.SET ' ENTRY -; ~- :c l : ) :~( :1 n ~ 1 :I ,.. - ~ 'i BED :__ j BED J' -~ BED BAR ~ V> 'I MURPHr J ..Fi.\ AYs:1 ~q I ' BED~---/ fee ; \ FRONT PORCH i ~ :! ? . I -1 b :c :c I '.l:>O "' """ zo.. 0 " ~ _,, FIRST FLOOR ):> _,, I U> "'~ 00 Cl HISTORIC AMERICAN 0 ~U> SMITHCLIFFS RESIDENTIAL SMITHCUFFS ESTATE (HOWARDSCUFFS) (DOS ROCAS)
Buildings Survey Development
PflOJECT NORTH COAST HIGHWAY LAGUNA BEACH VICINITY ORANGE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA NO. CA-2298 u::i 0 n "' "'U> ~~ "' SMITHCLIFFS (HOWARDCLIFFS) (DOS ROGAS) HASS NO. CA-2298 BALCONY - , BALCONY - - ' MASTER BED --cLos-Er --""-=""i,=~=~~===' - ~, ~~"I .. : ! ) BELOW CLOSET ~ LOW I < hBA TH L.1 CL)SET ROOF ,2, MURPHY / ' BED BED - ,L ' x1 BED ~1i ~ ' ' . =- '-" j I .: - - - : d ' - L:_~ATH) - =======~=~)~LOS~T! CLOS ;1~ BATH) :BAT!!.:: ' / i: / i HALL ' >=====oj ~., .i-\; N 1 BED 1 -'; 'I -- ___ _ - - ' BONUS '' Vl BA <'" _ :, ~II. <( i: :( ii >- w . I .. ~ al .- BED U) 5 0 - :r: i ' r.- ;1 g l CLOSET j ~ /' l( :1. fLV 1_' ' I r- " -- ' U :!
The federal surveyors worked through Laguna Beach building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,30-LABE.V,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.