St. Tnomae Hail v^ the second1 atonWcantbuMo^ Dominic at their San Rafael Convent / Campus. It was buitt in as a Secondary School and Boarding facJRty. At least two later buildings buitt on the Campus were patterned after It, and reflect a similarity of design. Many generations of young women were educated here, and resided in the quarters upstairs. In spite of what now appears to be fairly rudimentary sleeping and battling fadfises, the building is recalled with fondness by former students who have returned to visit as adults. It was designed by prominent Beaux Art-trained San Francisco architect Albert Rests, and is typical of his designs for InsMueonal uses, although he is better known for an eerier aeries of office and banking bufldlngsbuitin San Francisco at the turn of the century.
The site is currently a small portion of a larger acreage that includes the campus of the Dominican Cottege of San Rafael, which was once owned and operated by the Sisters of St. Dominic. The college has been controlled by an independent Board since The area has been associated with religious and educational uses since the founding of the Dominican Convent of San Rafael in 1 WO. Following the Are in the Motherhouse, St Thomas Ha* has served as home and administrative facJBry for the Sisters; new facfteas are now nearing completion, on the site of the Mothemouse. These events have combined to render St Thomas Hall, an unreinforced masonry buHding, obsolete. Following the move to the new center, St. Thomas Hall w i be demolished.
Its significance derives largely from its historical role as an parochial educational faculty, but It is also acknowledged to have architectural value, for its association with Albert Pfeete. It is not a parscufariy well-known structure in the general community, because of the semi-cloistered context created by the original site plan, it has remained relatively unaltered throughout Ks eighty-plus years, but the costs associated with State-mandated structural upgrades, when combined with the buJkSng's obsolescence, have brought about the conditions leading to its proposed demolition later this year. PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History; 1. Date of erection: 1 Thsflrat structure was tha>toth*rhouMavi^^ Prior to it dtmol on It waa recorded HW 1cAnw^ St. Catherine's Academy, St.
Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 2) In a construction contract was signed with a local San Rafael buttder Matthew Brady to build St Thomas HaH. The bufkKng was completed in In Brady was still buttdtng for the Sisters; that was the year he completed the nearby AngeHco Hall. 2. Architect: Albert Pissis was bom in Guymas, Mexico.2 He was the son of a Pans-educated physician who became a leading member of San Francisco's large and influential French colony. The PiaaJs family came to San Frandaco in and son Albert was admitted to the Ecole das Beaux Arts in at age twenty. Four years later ha completed his architectural education with the most distinguished record of any American of his time. Following his studies at the Ecole, he traveled extensively in Europe.
He returned to San Francisco in with an academic knowledge of the fundamentals of construction and design, perhaps more thorough than any other contemporary American except for Me Ecole compatriots Richard Morris Hunt, H. H. Richardson and Charles McKim, all of whom are among the most important names in American architecture of the period. In Pissis designed his Beaux Arts masterpiece, the l-Hbemia Bank, which was the first bufldtng in the style, on the West Coast, to receive international recognition and acclaim. The result of an international competition, the architectural commission was awarded to Pissis, the first Caftornian to demonstrate a mastery of the Beaux Arts method.
Important San Francisco architect VWfis Potic pfodaimed the Hiberrfo Bank the most beautiful building in San Francisco." This building was followed by a career studded with a noteworthy succession of commercial and public structures that popularized the academic movement throughout the west. Pissis remains best known for his fine commercial butidings including the - Hibernia, Crocker and Borel Banks, the Flood and Parrott (Emporium) In Pissis was retained by the Dominican Sisters, for whom he completed St Rose Academy in San Francisco. In near the end of his car ear, he prepared some modest fire-escape drawings for the Dominican Sisters on the San Rafael Motherhouae.3 This ted to a commission for Pisses to design St Thomas Hall. 3.
Original and subsequent owners: Throughout its entire history, St. Thomas Hall has had only one owner, the Sisters of St. Dominic, who continue to own it today. However, at the time of the building's construction, were an unincorporated entity, and therefore, unable to own property under their own name. Consequently, as was the case with the Motherhouae, the building was built on property that was purchased by Archbishop William Patrick Riordan whose name may be found on the original title. 2 Biographical information on Pwis from Kiiker and Obmtead Dominican Archive St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 3) 4. Bulkier, contractor, suppliers: Few records have survived regarding the construction of St Thomas Hall.
Unlike its Mothemouse predecessor, for whom extensive files and documentation have survived, little of the construction correspondence has been saved. K is known that the burtdtng's contractor, Matthew Brady continued to buid for the Sisters for many years, and butt other buttcKngs on the Campus. 5. Original Plans snd Construction BlueHne prints of the original floor plans and exterior elevation from the Piseis office have survived in the Convent archives, and the building appears to be essentially unchanged since that lime. St. Thomas Had was designed as a Secondary School and was physically stratified horizontally in its layout.
The first level contained classrooms, a large study hall / assembly space and laboratories, including a chemistry lab which was housed in a small one-story The second level contained offices, the library, lounge, cess (dormitory space) with 6 foot high wooden partitions and bathing feoHse*. The third floor is the most innovative floor; It resembles a rectangular doughnut in plan with a wed substituted for the doughnut hole. This allows a double loaded corridor on each of the long sides of the Disking wan the interior rooms caning and venttatton from the light well. Light and ventilation were also provided for the second floor through this light well. This innovative layout is not revealed, or even hinted at by the exterior. Bathing facilities are at each of the narrow ends of the floor. 6.
Alterations and additions: AH of the toflet rooms were upgraded in the and much of the electrical system, including the lighting has been upgraded over the years. The most sjgnMcant alteration was the addition of the second floor bathing room that was built above the original chemistry lab at the back of the building. Temporary arrangements to house the convent's administrative offices have occurred since the fire in the Mothemouse, but these are relatively insignificant. B. Historical Context The beauty and temperate cNmats of California had first been recognized by Fr. Junfparo Sena as early as when he began his famous walking tour of the Weet to evaluate sites and locations for the missions. San Rafael was visited by Fr.
Serra, snd the site of the Rsncho San Pedro Santa Marguerite y Las GalHnas selected and developed by the mission fathers as a sanatorium for the Native-American wards of the church. The site of the Dominican Convent was a small part of Rancho San Pedro. By the San Rafael Mission was founded and a Catholic presence was firmly established. Following almost literally in the footsteps of the Padres, the Dominican Sisters established a series of schools and convents in California, beginning in Monterey in St. Catherine's Academy, St Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 4) Their second school was established in Benfcla In and after severs! years in that location, X was relocated to ffta San Rafael site that It continues tooccupytoday.
OriginallytenacraaInsize,it was adjacent to theMagnolia Tract a wealthy residential subdivision that was developed by pioneer shipping merchant end vigilante WRaam Cotaman. Today the Dominican area la sHH known as MagnoRa Vaflay. The achool waa successful In Rs San Rafael location, and over the years ft grew to become an independent four-year cottage, wRh a sizable campus. The set acre portion of the tract that is now held by the convent, with its circular drive is all that remains to identify thoee early years. Part Architectural Information A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: Conceived in a classical Mediterranean style, St. Thomas Hall is a three- story, 19 by rectangular block designed to recall a simplified Renaissance* paJazzo.
The front and rear elevations are the narrowest, and the long side elevations feature articulated end bays. The block form is surmounted by a red tHe hip roof with projecting eaves featuring regularly- spaced modMons. The two lower levels feature banded, round-arched window openings with sat-over-aix double hung windows. The top level features ftree-oveMhree rectangular double hung windows. A small pavilion structure extends beyond the rear of the bulding to house a chemistry lab. The front elevation features and elaborately decorated entrance and overdoor. An arched opening above granite stops announces the presence of a recessed porch. This opening is framed by a pair of engaged, fluted, Doric columns Hanked by simple engaged pilasters.
This base supports an elaborate, articulated entablature, that Is In turn topped by a small sphere above each column, and accented by symmetrically placed scrolls. The overdoor features a rectangular, double hung window, capped with a curved pedfcrtent An oval window at each aide completes the composition. Within the porch area is found marble wainscoting and french doors topped by a The buiktng is constructed of unreinforced masonry and surfaced in cement plaster. Its Kalian roots ware something of a departure for Piasic, who had bumscareef on his forrrf ariryw ^tt>eFrefK* idiom, but similar buttdkigs were becoming the norm on California campuses, examples of which appeared at this time on the campus of the University of California at Berkeley.
Ttwchctoe of thte Mediterranean atyte.cd^ Second Empire Motherhouse, signaled a cr rige in direction for the school. Later campus buildings, including Morris Bruce's AngeHco Hall, and Arnold Constable's Guzman Had were bulk in this style, and strongly resemble St Thomas. 2. Condition of fabric: St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 5) For a buMIng that has passed Its eighty-second year, St. Thomas Hall appears to be In xcettentoondMon. Mnor surface cracks following the Lome Prieta earthquake ware deemed superficial, and the building continues to be occupied. It has undergone few changes, and although its has had some deferred maintenance, It is a aoNd building with simple sturdy detaKs that has withstood the aging process well. B. Description of Exterior 1.
Overall dimensions The front (south) and rear (north) elevations are narrow wide) while the side elevations (east and west) are long long). The side elevations are relatively unreieved, with articulated end bays (see elevations). It is with the front elevation that one begins to discern Pissw' master hand at work. The entrance, with its elaborately decorated moldings, columns and oval windows, is a standout against the plainer rear and side elevations. It features an arched opening accessed by granite stops. Inside, marble paneling frames a porch finished in mosaic tile that leads to mahogany entrance doors. Few are aware of this formal entrance to St Thomas Hall because It faced onto an enclosed quadrangle that formed a cloistered environment that was rarely visited by the public.
The entrance is further obscured by mature landscaping which makes even photography of this front elevation difficult. A handsome building, St. Thomas Hall is, nonetheless, a background bu&ting, exhibiting few of the masterful and visionary qualities that made Pissis' early works important. 2. Foundations The foundations are umeinforced, low-fire masonry, and are not visible from the exterior. 3. Walts The exterior walls are butit of unreinforced masonry faced with cement plaster. Characteristic features include articulated end bays and a clearly defined base, middle and top layer. The middle section has two levels of arched windows, reflecting a vertical hierarchy, with the shorter window the top level. 4.
Structural system Walls: The walls are built of unreinforced masonry with thickness ranging from 22 inches at the first floor and 17 inches above. All exterior brick received a coating of 3M Inch thick cement plaster. The "annex" building received a second floor addition, with stucco-faced stud wads built above the existing masonry parapet. Roof: Theroofissheathedwith1x6T&G Douglas Fir laid straight with 2 x 6 inch rafters spaced at 32 inches on center. Roof purlins are supported on timber trusses spaced on center. Timber trusses bear on top of 17 inch thick exterior brick walls. St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas HaH HABS No. CA-2354-A (Pag* No. 6) Ceiling: Catting joteta are 2 x 6 inches, spaced at 32 Inches on center. CeftJng joists span between the bottom chord of the roof trusses. 5.
Porches The .building has a smaH recessed porch on the front elevation, which is described above. 6. Chimneys St. Thomas Had has no chimneys; the building was heated with radiators which were supplied from a remote boiler, so no visible vent stacks were required. 7. Openings a. Doorways and doors The entrance doors are made of solid mahogany construction. Other inconspicuous doors appear at the west side where a (demotished) connection was made to the original Motherhouse. A connector between the main part of the building and the Chemistry Room acts as a rear foyer, and access is gained through p rs of trench doors win transoms. The front entranceway is an elaborate design and may be seen in large detail in the drawings. Other doorways are contained in simple wooden frames. b.
Windows and shutters At the first and second levels, the windows have round-arch tops framed by simple moldings. They are set-over-six double hung. The third floor has verecaHy-oriented rectangularly shaped windows that are three-over-three double hung. 8. Roof a. Roof shape: The bustling is topped by a shallow (35 degree) hip roof shape covered with red clay We. The top floor has a central Hghtcourt. The roof of the interior of the court is tar and gravel. b. Cornice, eaves: The wooden cornice and eaves are characteristic of the Mediterranean style, and are vlsuetty supported by a deep modittion banding and regularly-spaced wooden modJHions. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: St. Thomas Hall's roof form was simple and straight forward with no dormers, cupolas or towers. C.
Description of Interior 1. Floor plans St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 7) a. First Floor: This floor contains classrooms, a large study hall / assembly space and laboratories, including a chemistry lab which was housed in a small one-story annex at the rear of the main structure. Hallways are very wide, and feature oak wainscoting. Ffeed transom windows along tfw corridors bring light Into the interior of the building at this level. b. Second Floor: This floor contains the library, lounge, cells (dormitory space with 6 foot high wooden partitions) and bathing facilities. Hallwsys are similar to those found on the first floor, but are lined with wooden lockers. c.
Third Floor: By far the most sophisticated floor, this level resembles a rectangular doughnut in plan with a light well substituted for the doughnut hole. This allows a double loaded corridor on each of the long sides of the building allowing the interior rooms to gain and ventilation from the light well, light and ventilation were also provided for the second floor through this light well. This innovative layout is not seen from the exterior. Bathing facilities are located at each end of this floor. 2. Stairways The main stairway is located off the entrance foyer at the front (south) end of the building. It is unenclosed, and serves each level of the building. It is buBt of golden oak with sturdy, carved newel posts, narrow spaced balusters, and wainscoting.
Minor stairways exist at the opposite end of the building. See plan. 3. Flooring Flooring throughout St Thomas Hall is solid oak, over a redwood subfloor, except at the Irsttevet, which is finished in porcelain tile. This tile is laid in a tradfttonal pattern consisting of large white hexagonal porcelain tile studded with a smaller black diamond-shaped square tiles. 4. Wall and ceiling finish All interior partitions are built of piaster over wooden lath. The building makes extensive use of oak trim in many locations, including oak miltwork baseboards, chair rails and picture rails which trim and protect the piaster walls and ceilings. 5. Openings a. Doorways and doors: All doors and doorways are built of oak.
The door frames themselves have simple mtered comers throughout, and are finished with a clear varnish. Some doors have been replaced with fire rated flush doors. b. Windows: The window framing details matched the door frames. The windows themselves are as described above, in the exterior description. St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas Half HAB8 No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 8) 6. Decorative features and Wm Educational and residential butidkige commissioned by religious orders usually reflect a modaat budget, and 8t Thomas Haft is no exception. Tha yau8 sfeo^a*fy.
LitHe money was devoted to unusual or expensive hand crafting, although a high quality has been achieved the frugal budget The orrty decorative features of note are those found on Ins front elevation, wrM have been prevkHisly described. 7. Hardware Hardware includes simple bronze door handles, hinges, etc. Since the bathrooms were altered in the nothing remains of the original bathroom accessories. 8. Mechanical equipment a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation, lighting and plumbing. The building is heated in winter by radiators that are supplied from a remote boiler room. No air conditioning (cooling) has ever installed, but the building offers the opportunity of extensive cross-venlHation, through the numerous window openings.
"Original incandescent lighting has mostly been replaced by incongruous fluorescent fixtures that date from the The original plumbing system remains, and while It may be considered somewhat primitive by today's standards, is serviceable for a community that has taken a vow of poverty. D. Site 1. General setting and orientation St. Thomas hall set the style but not the orientation for the growth of the Dominican collsge.
It was tiie first of trireesirnttar building site, which formed the core of tiie original school, but the others were buRt later, and are oriented on a diagonal road that does not allow the formation of a traditional campus quadrangle, in the College was separated legally from the convent, and St Thomas is the only "academic* building that remains in under convent ownership, and located on tha Convent grounds. 2. Historic landscape design While the garden front of the original Motherhouse was conceived as a foreground to the building, the garden behind the Motherhouse, that was dominated by the south facade of St. Thomas Hall has the character of privacy and repose.
It has changed over the years, but continues to reflect Its original character of intimacy, informality and a setting for contemplation as it has in each of its varying forms. 3. Outbuildings Seven remaining buHdtngs on the Convent property are proposed for St. Catherine's Academy, St. Thomas Halt HABS No. CA-2354-A (Page No. 9) demoHon. Thesa include a utility building, boiler home, carpentry shop, art studio, two oarages, a smati buftding used for offices and a gymnasium.
They vary considerably in size, style and detail, although they share some characteristics, Including simple wood-frame structure and siding, gabled roc4^unomaroenfexltracak>nalm All seven ere secondary in the architectural hierarchy of the SimHar to the background and service buildings of the Dominican College campus, they play a limited role in the character and order of the site, serving mostly a utittarian function and reinforce the promir)ence of the primary buildings such as St Thomas HaN. Part el Sources of Information A. Early architectural drawings The earftest aidant architectural drawings are prints of Pissis* connection from his St Thomas Hall to the original Motherhouse.
Prints from the archive of Pissis' floor plans and exterior elevations were used as the basis for developing the new HABS drawings included in this transmittal. B. Early Views Although an elaborate and continuous archive exists, which was saved from the fire, few early photographs of St. Thomas Hail exist, partly because of the building's position on the cloister. C. Interviews On May this writer conducted an interview with Dominican archivist Sr. Martin, who was bom in and has served the convent for nearly 75m years, to confirm materials prepared in an earlier document entitled: Historic Resource Report Dominican Convent, Volume I, St. Catherine's Academy. D. Bibliography 1.
Primary and unpublished sources Letter of transmittal from Coleman to his attorney regarding transfer of abstract to Rtordan, August Dominican Archives. A tribute from many hands, The Dominicans of San Rafael, The Dominican Convent, San Rafael, Kostura, VvKliam, Albert Pissis BuHdhgs in San Francisco, unpublished manuscript. McGrew, Patrick, -, Historic Resource Report: Dominican Convent. Privatery published, Snyder, John WHIiam, index of CaHfomia BuHofngs, unpublished MA thesis, UC/Davis, 2. Secondary and published sources St. Catharine's Academy, St. Thomas Hall A HABSNo.CAr2354-A(PageNo.10) Krfcer, Harold, Caflbmfe's AnHtectural Frontier: Style and Tradition In fw f n Centary, Gfebs M. Smith, Inc.
Salt Late, , Ofcf on a New Lanc Ca femfti ArcMtecftjre In Perspective, Robert* Rfeiehart, Publishers, Niwat, Colorado, McGrew, Patrick. The Landmark* of San Francisco, Abrarns, Now York: Olmstead. R. and Watkins, T. H., Han Today, San Francisco: Chronicle Books, Bums, John, Ed., Recordhg Historic Structures, The American Institute of Architects Press, Washington, DC, WHIard, WHson and Flam, Sacred Places, Presidio Press, San Francisco PETOWICALS American BuHders Review, The Works of Albert Pissis, by J. S. CahHI, Jan, Architect and Engineer, The Work of Albert Pissis, Architect, Jury E. Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated None F. Supplemental Material HABS Transmittal and Drawings: St Catherine's Academy / San Rafael, California {Survey No. Part R/.
Project Information Sisters of St Dominic as part of a Master Plan for the 6.63-acre site on the east side of Grand Avenue between Locust Street and Acacia Way in San Rafael. The awoMOf's parcel number is The new complex replaces the demolished Motherhouse and renders St Thomas Hall and seven ancillary buildings obsolete. Following completion of the new complex, St. Thomas HaH and alt existing structures on the site except for the Summer House Arbor and the swimming pool will be demolished. St. Catherine's Academy, St, Thomas Hall HABS No. CA-3254-A (Page No. 1%)