Dedicated July 28, Burton Park and its attendant buildings are significant as the first public recreation facility established by the City of San Carlos, and as the first Works Progress Administration (WPA) project in San Carlos. The use of adobe for the parks buildings represents a local manifestation of the use of rustic materials and designs established during this period by the National Park Service. Burton Park gave the city a facility wholly in keeping with national, regional, and local recreational and architectural trends, and whose building design and scale were consistent with the surrounding residential areas which featured a number of buildings in variations of other Spanish revival styles.
Description: The Burton Park Club House and Amphitheater are built of bitu-adobe bricks manufactured on-site by local men. Bitu-adobe was a modification of traditional adobe manufacture, and used emulsified bitumen as a binder in place of more traditional straw. This resulted in a more dense and harder adobe brick, suitable for use with Portland cement mortar. Club House Exterior: The one-story building, adjacent to the cul-de-sac that forms the southerly end of Chestnut Avenue within Burton Park, is axially aligned southwest-northeast, with its principal fa~ade facing generally east. The building is constructed of bitu-adobe brick, set in Portland cement mortar with tooled joints.
It has cast-in-place concrete lintels above its doors and windows, with the wood grain of the form boards giving the lintels an appearance of more traditional timber. On the east fa~ade are projecting seating benches in front of windows; the benches are not structurally part of the building as they are pulling away from building. The Club House has a central block, symmetrically arranged with central doors and flanking windows, with set back wings on each end containing service rooms. The central block of the building uses a concrete bond beam to cap the walls; as with the window lintels previously described, this used rough-sawn forms so that the concrete beam mimics a timber beam.
The walls of the two end wings are capped in two courses of common brick, laid up with the lower course of stretchers and the upper course of headers. The eaves are broad and open, supported on 4x6 rafters, above which is tongue-and-groove sub- roof sheathing. The hip roof is clad in split shakes. On the west side of the building exterior the fireplace block projects from the west wall and the chimney is broad and projects just above roof peak height. On the south end of the building there is an addition laid up in concrete blocks roughly the same size as the adobe blocks of the original BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No. CA-2676-A (page 2) building, and the line of addition is marked by a cold joint; the addition is also hip-roofed.
At each end of the building an adobe wall approximately five feet in height angles away from the building at about a 45 angle. The building faces east onto the amphitheater, which is sunken below the grade of the building. The center door of the Club House aligns with the center aisle of the Amphitheater. Interior: The interior of the central block of the Club House is a single large room with exposed adobe block walls. The concrete bond beam along the top of the walls acts as a frieze, above which is a crown moulding, and the cathedral ceiling is finished in Homasote or beaverboard, with molded battens. The main windows are metal casement types, each with two 3-light sash. In the west wall are tripled 4-light hopper windows in metal sash.
There is a large fireplace in the west wall of the building, placed centrally in the main room; it has a tapered hood which joins the wall plane at the ceiling line. The ceiling has a central beam and a series of three kingpost trusses. There are plank doors with broad wrought-iron hinges at both ends of the main room. The interior surfaces of these doors are diagonally-planked, while the exterior faces are vertically planked. Flooring in the main room is sheet vinyl, and is not original. Front doors--now boarded--were glazed originally, with three large lights in metal sash in each door. There are eight ceiling-mounted lighting fixtures in the main room, with power supplied by surface-mounted conduit.
These may be original, and are comprised of three concentric metal circles with a center light bulb. All surfaces in main room are painted in buff-colored paint, except the trusses which are clear-finished, and the brick at the edges of the fireplace firebox which are painted dark brown, as are the doors. The main room of the Club House is now used to store stage sets and other recreational materials. The south wing is likewise used for storage, while the north wing holds a small kitchen and a restroom. The north, or kitchen, wing is flat-roofed, while the south wing is hip-roofed; the south wing was originally flat- roofed, but was given a hip roof at the time the concrete block addition was made at that end of the building. The kitchen sink and cabinets do not appear to be original.
The kitchen has a 4-light hopper window in steel sash above the sink in the north end wall, and there is a similar window in the north wall of the adjacent restroom. The restroom comer sink may be an original fixture, but the commode is a replacement. Historical Context: The land upon which San Carlos came to be platted was originally part of Rancho de las Pulgas, owned by Don Luis Arguello, one of the Mexican governors of California. Arguello maintained a small adobe in the general area of the future town for the overseer of his rancho. Following Arguello's death, his widow sold the rancho in to San Francisco businessmen, Timothy Guy Phelps and John Brittan, with each purchasing approximately half the property. BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No.
CA- 2676-A (page 3) Phelps had arrived in California during the Gold Rush, later moving to San Francisco where he established a mercantile business and held several offices in state government.. Brittan owned a San Francisco hardware store. After buying the rancho, both men continued its historical use as a cattle ranch. Both men built houses on their land holdings, and traveled by rail to their businesses in San Francisco. First conceived in to link San Francisco with San Jose, the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad finally began construction in and was completed by May In the Central Pacific, predecessor of the Southern Pacific, bought the railroad and added it to what was to become one of the largest railroads in the West.
The railroad stimulated development of town sites along the peninsula. In investors formed the San Carlos Land Company to finance the development of their speculative town site on Phelps' property west of the Southern Pacific Railroad, supposedly naming the new town after the first ship into San Francisco Bay. The company erected a depot as their first permanent building, as an inducement to prospective buyers. The proximity to the railroad was no accident. Two of the investors were Southern Pacific officers: the president of the San Carlos Land Company was Captain Smith, Treasurer of the Southern Pacific Railroad (of which Leland Stanford was one of the original builders), and a long-time personal friend of Stanford.
The two had run a mercantile business together in the Mother Lode during the Gold Rush~ Another of the officers of the San Carlos Land Company was Arthur Brown, Chief of Buildings and Bridges for the Southern Pacific Railroad. The depot was intended to serve as a catalyst for the development of San Carlos as a commuter-oriented suburban community. Interestingly, San Carlos was the only town on the Peninsula at that time whose economic base relied on a commuting population rather than upon local industry or commerce. In June the railroad laid a foot long spur track at the depot site for the unloading of building stone, to be shipped by rail from San Jose.
By July, the first material had begun to arrive, and construction commenced in August undertaken by masons and laborers who had been working on the construction of nearby Stanford University. That same month, the San Mateo County Times and Gazette published an account of the project. The promises made by the investors, the paper reported, were being rapidly fulfilled, and in a few months more the nucleus of the proposed model suburban town would be complete. The laying out and grading of the streets had been going on for several months, and had been completed, with streets running north and south being sixty feet wide, and those running east and west being fifty feet in width. Workers were laying sewer pipes along the streets running to the nearby bay marshes.
The next move would be to lay water-mains from the Spring Valley Water Company's pumping works throughout the town. Water was to be BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No. CA-2676-A (page 4) taken from the stand pipe then being erected on the hillside near the works, which had sufficient elevation to give a fall of over fifty feet to the highest point in town. All of this work and more too, was to be completed before the lots were offered for sale. "It is assured," the paper stated, "that before another year has passed, many of the residences will be erected, and the new town of San Carlos which promises to be a credit to the county, will be firmly established." By January the depot was nearing completion.
Completion of the depot, however, failed to stimulate the expected rush of buyers. The town grew slowly, and as late as population hovered at approximately The depot remained the only public building in town and the center of its social activity. There is little mystery as to the failure of the initial development. California was in the depths of a building depression in the last years of the century, and the timing could not have been worse to attempt promotion of a suburban town. By the early years of the century, an exodus from San Francisco to suburban climes following the earthquake and fire, and other economic factors changed the fortunes of San Carlos.
The town remained essentially stillborn until when the San Carlos Improvement Company assumed the reins, expanded development both east and west, published promotional brochures, and finally stimulated development. Even these efforts were not wholly successful, due to water shortages and new demands by prospective buyers for gas and electric service. Still, population quickly increased to San Carlos businessman, Fred Drake drove the installation of electric, gas, and water lines, and the paving of streets. With infrastructure in place, substantial expansion followed. By the population had reached and the town incorporated that same year. By the citizens of San Carlos, California, although pleased with the rapid growth of their city, realized the need to plan community amenities.
At a meeting of the city council on October 22, Fred Drake, a local real estate man and member of the planning commission, strongly urged the council to consider the purchase of a tract of land for the establishment of a community park. Drake's initial recommendation was that the park be approximately one and one-half acres, and which would include tennis courts and an outdoor building for the presentation of dramatic art by the San Carlos players. The city council took this into consideration, and by January had narrowed choices for the park site to four. At a city council meeting on January 20, descriptions of the four sites were presented and reviewed.
The sites included the Woolsey property, lots 1 and 2 in block 38; all of block 6 in Howard Park; the Bertini property, a total of acres; and the Brittan park property, measuring acres. Drake again spoke out suggesting the "Ohio Building" on the bay could be added to the county's playground by adding a yacht harbor, swimming and beach BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No. CA- 2676-A (page 5) resort. (The building in reference had been built as the Ohio Building at the Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco. Following closure of the fair, the building was sold, placed on a barge, and floated to a shoreline site near San Carlos for reuse.) The council apparently dismissed Drake's idea, as there was no further mention of it.
The city council determined to present each of the four park sites to the citizens of San Carlos as a series of bond issues in February Things moved a little less quickly than the city council wished, however, and the special election was pushed back to March 16, at which time citizens could approve or deny any one, or all, of the bond issues. In the meantime, in a gesture of support the San Carlos Community Club publicly announced its endorsement of the four bond issues. There was a great deal of public interest throughout San Carlos for the new community park and playground. San Carlos' Mayor, Asa Hull made it clear that he felt the town could not afford to miss the opportunity to build the proposed amenities.
Hull presented the facts as he saw them to his community: property prices would not continue to remain low; the rate of interest would not be more than three and one-half cents on each and the street bonds currently owed would be paid off the assessment roll in time for the park bonds to be added to the roll. On Wednesday, March 16, the people of San Carlos voted and approved three of the four proposed park sites. Proposition 2 covered 5.2 acres bounded by Brittan Avenue on the south, Chestnut Avenue on the east, Cedar Avenue on the west, and Arroyo A venue on north. This property was available for and proposed for a city park and playground.
Proposition 3 involved acres bounded by Chestnut A venue on the west, Brittan Avenue on the south, Woodland Avenue on the east, and the Bertini residence on the north. Proposition No. 3 was proposed for a hard ball park and athletic field and was available for Led by club president, Edward R. Burton, the San Carlos Men's Athletic Club argued for the inclusion of facilities for baseball. In the end, the city combined the properties covered by Propositions 2 and 3 to create what was to become Burton Park. Following the special election, Mayor Hull spoke to the citizens concerning the tax rate increase on 20, 15, and 10 year bonds, and Councilman A. H. Sagehorn discussed the difficulties in acquiring suitable property at a reasonable price.
During the following week at a League of Municipalities dinner meeting, the city council authorized the issuance of bonds totaling The council also ordered to be published the notice of sale and opening date for bids on March 31, at By December through the bond issue, the city had acquired the land for the park. The city council accepted plans presented by Roland Campbell, county planning commissioner, for the development of the playgrounds and athletic field. Campbell's plans provided for an.athletic field on the former Bertini property between Cedar and Chestnut streets, and a children's playground placed in the adjacent area. Campbell's BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No.
CA- 2676-A (page 6) plans also called for three tennis courts, volleyball courts, playground equipment, and a sandbox that might be converted into a wading pool. He also recommended planting approximately 40 European sycamore trees to line the pathways and parking area. By this time, however, President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal was manifesting itself locally: San Carlos was waiting for federal approval on a plan to share the cost of park development. This plan, which would be the first WPA project in San Carlos, divided the cost between the city and funds allocated from the WPA, with the city's cost being just Six months later, in June WPA administrators assured San Carlos that the city should be able to start work on the park on July 10 or 24.
Mayor Hull appointed Councilmen Roy Gover and Donald Lilly to begin ordering building supplies. The grading work had already been finished, and Gover and Lilly ordered feet of lumber is ordered for the construction of an adobe field house, a club house for Girl Scouts and Boy Scouts, an outdoor theater, and many walks, paths, and other playground features. By this date, the cost of the job had risen to though the cost to the city remained at In September suggestions were made to the city council to make the San Carlos Playground a WPA recreation project, with WPA-paid advisors directing the athletic and playground activities. To do this, however, WPA authorities would have to approve an application bearing the signatures of not less than five members of a city recreation commission.
Much to the embarrassment of the city council, however, they had never appointed such a commission. They hastily took up the matter in an effort to make such appointments in time for completion of the play field. The possibility of appointment to a position of civic interest representative in the direction and planning of the play program reportedly aroused much anticipation in certain members of the community who were leaders in recreational work. At the same time, workers began molding the adobe bricks used in the construction of the recreation hall and shower building at the playground site. The bricks would also be used to construct the 20' by 40' field house and the 20' by 40' scouts' building, which could also be used by other groups.
Adjacent to this building, workers were making ready to build a small outdoor semi-circular theater to seat 300 on some type, as yet undecided, of rustic benches or redwood logs. Forty-five WPA workers were assigned to work on the erection of the new steel baseball backstop, preparation of the baseball diamond, and leveling of the athletic fields. The twelve-month job was still on schedule, with the opening date for the park set for Spring With plans calling for a baseball diamond, a football field, and three full- size regulation tennis courts, the local paper boasted that when completed, this would be one of the greatest municipal recreation centers in the state of California.
Indeed, when Councilmen D R Lilly and AH Sagehorn had finally completed their months-long investigation into the possibilities for the park, their report to the city council was enthusiastic. BURTON PARK, CLUB HOUSE AND AMPHITHEATER HABS No. CA-2676-A (page 7) Their official statement was this: "We believe that completion of this program will give San Carlos the nucleus of one of the best laid out parks and playgrounds on the peninsula, on the nine acre tract recently purchased by the city." Nearly forty more WP A laborers joined the work force on Monday, October 2, More than trees and other plants were scheduled for planting in the Spring.
Now, however, the twelve-month job had been pushed back several months, but the directors were still hoping for completion in late April or early May In November the total cost of the park stood at Eighty percent of this would be paid by the federal government, the rest-- $7 the City. The San Carlos Committee on Recreational Activities, the school board and the city council met in December with Ryan, WPA director for the San Carlos playground project, to discuss further expansion of recreational activities in San Carlos.
In April a temporarily-appointed citizens' committee, headed by George Forbes and appointed to organize a recreation commission in San Carlos, met with WPA Recreational Director Art Ryan from San Mateo to further discuss possible programs that might be conducted at the new playground and park. The city wanted the programs ready to begin as soon as the park opened. At the first meeting of the temporary committee's earlier that month, they had passed a motion to apply for federal aid from the WPA recreation program, hence the meeting with Art Ryan. Forbes later became chairman.of the recreational supervision project and was pleased to report in June that the WPA had approved it.
The city finally held dedication exercises for the new park on July 28, now expanded from an initial recommendation of one and one- half acres to nine beautifully planned acres It was hoped that the proximity to the San Carlos school site would attract school children to play in the park after school; the park would also be useful in supplementing the athletic equipment and facilities of the school for physical education programs. The citizens of San Carlos could take pride in this latest example of the foresight employed in planning a community in which the citizens felt they could easily raise normal, healthy children. In June the city rededicated the park in honor of Edward Burton's many years of community service.