BlockBefore

Pine Hills Station, Barracks, West Side of Boulder Creek Road at Engineers Road, Julian

Pine Hills Station, Barracks, West Side of Boulder Creek Road at Engineers Road, Julian, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A-, with a 2,721-word written history.

From the record

“The Pine Hills Barracks was one of the earliest guard stations constructed by the Civilian Conservation Corps as part of the Depression Era economic revitalization plan by United States Government.”

Written record, HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A- · the record runs 2721 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

70 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

On the west side of Boulder Creek Road at the intersection of Engineers Road and Boulder Creek Road in the vicinity of Pine Hills, San Diego County, California. On a two acre lot within Cleveland National Forest, approximately 7.3 miles southwest of the town of Julian. USGS Santa Ysabel Quadrangle, Universal Transverse Mercator Coordinates: Present Owner/Occupant: USDA - U.S. Forest Service; Cleveland National Forest Rancho Bernardo Rd. San Diego, CA

Significance

2560 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Pine Hills Barracks was one of the earliest guard stations constructed by the Civilian Conservation Corps as part of the Depression Era economic revitalization plan by United States Government. Of the more than 50 other CCC/Depression Era structures within Cleveland National Forest, the Pine Hills Barracks maintains the best overall integrity. PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page 2 I. HISTORICAL

Information a

Physical History 1. Date of erection: The Pine Hills Station was one of the earliest guard stations constructed within the Cleveland National Forest. It was first identified as a potential administrative site in and a one-acre parcel was surveyed in February The Grossmont Park Company donated one acre of land to help establish a fire station in the area. Enrollees from Camp Pamo Valley, one of nine CCC camps in San Diego County, established a spike camp and constructed Pine Hills Station in 2. Architect: N. Blanchard and E.J. Maher. The U.S. Forest Service's Regional Office hired architects Blanchard and Maher to design standard plans for administrative buildings for the region.

The plans were designed to use "ready-cut" construction methods, and took into account the unskilled labor available. In Federal officials established a limitation on Forest Service buildings. Standardization of the hardware, truss and roof materials, and lumber allowed for a much lower cost for the buildings than would otherwise have been possible. 3. Original and subsequent owner: USDA - U. S. Forest Service, Cleveland National Forest. 4. Original and subsequent use: Seasonal fire station. 5. Builder: CCC labor from Camp Pamo Valley was used for the construction of the buildings. 6. Original plans and construction: Except for a few minor alterations, the building retains its original appearance. 7.

Alterations and additions: Minor renovations to the barracks occurred in A second bathroom was added to the center of the building, and a partially enclosed porch was further enclosed. The original main-entry door was boarded-up, and a new single-entry door and aluminum window were added to the east facade. PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page 3 ' B. Historical Context: The State of California experienced a severe unemployment problem after the decline of the economic situation of the late and the influx of unemployed migrant farmers. When the number of migrants increased in the fall of California Governor James Rolph established a Labor Camp Committee to create work camps for unemployed men.

During the winter of over men served in a total of thirty work camps, including nine on the National Forests of California (Clar The Federal government's establishment of the Civilian Conservation Corps in ended the State Relief program, and state camps were closed or converted to the CCC (Clar The CCC was one of Franklin Roosevelt's "New Deal" programs for alleviating the economic and social consequences of the Depression (Palmer 1).

On March 31, Roosevelt's Senate Bill "for the relief of unemployment through the performance of useful public work, and for other purposes" was passed by Congress (Salmond The Departments of Agriculture and the Interior, as well as State park agencies, were responsible for the specific works projects of the Over 35% of the CCC projects were administered by the U.S. Department of Forestry (Otis et al. By the beginning of July, over CCC camps had been constructed, and about young men between the ages of 18 and 25 were enrolled in the program.

The CCC employed over 3 million unemployed young men in over camps across the nation during the nine years of its existence (Palmer Much of this labor force was supplied by California and although the enrollees did not receive wages, they were provided with food, shelter, medical care, and recreation opportunities (San Diego Union On May the Forest Service began CCC operations in California. In late June 147 Californian CCC camps were operational, including eight on the Cleveland National Forest, with one more planned.

In April the Forest Service chose Pine Valley and Temescal as its first two CCC camp sites for the Cleveland National Forest (San Diego Union Camp Pine Valley was the first camp officially organized in California with the establishment of CCC Company 901 Annual On May 13, Army District commander Major Shepler W. Fitzgerald officially opened the camp and took command over the first on-site detachment of 25 enrollees (San Diego Union 5-14-1933:Ill; Five days later, Major Fitzgerald announced camps for Pamo Valley ), Temecula, Puerta La Cruz, San Diego River (Santee), and Lyons Valley. The Cleveland National Forest took full advantage of the CCC programs, which provided funding and labor to a degree not previously available.

Because the CCC camps had a high percentage of PlNE STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page4 , unskilled labor, the men worked mostly on fire prevention projects, clearing firebreaks and trails. However, the Forestry Service used the CCC to develop many of its facilities. These facilities included guard and ranger stations, such as the station at Pine Hills. The Pine Hills Station was one of the earliest guard stations constructed. The Pine Hills Barracks is one of three extant structures on the station, a USDA- Forest Service Administrative site in the Cleveland National Forest, San Diego County, California.

Located on the west side of Boulder Creek Road in an unincorporated area of the county, it has served as a seasonal fire station since It was first identified as a potential administrative site in and a one-acre parcel was surveyed in February The Grossmont Park Company donated one acre of land to help establish a fire station in the area. Shortly thereafter, CCC enrollees from Camp Pamo Valley established a spike camp and constructed a two-bedroom Plan-B Residence, two-car Double J Plan Garage, Pumphouse, and 35-foot high Water Tower at the site (Palmer The Forest Service increased the site with the purchase of acres of land from the Starr-Rutherford Cattle Company in File-Pine Hills CNF Land Status Atlas). Forest crews removed the water tower in after it had become rotted and unsafe.

The garage was substantially altered in with the replacement of two swing- opening doors by a metal roll-up door, and the addition of exterior plyboard siding. There is some confusion as to when the paint storage structure was built. Forest Service records date the building to but this is unlikely, as photos and maps of the period do not show a building it that location. The paint storage building is covered with the same plyboard as the remodeling of the garage, and it may date from this period, although it is unsubstantiated as to its original date of construction. The U.S. Forest Service's Regional Office hired architects Blanchard and Maher to design standard plans for administrative buildings for the region.

The architects described the new image of the Forest Service in California as "Mother Lode" architecture. This style was a combination of several early twentieth-century styles and was mainly influenced by the designs of William Wurster. Wurster' s designs took some of the popular motivations of "back to nature" and outdoor living that had made the Arts & Crafts style of the early twentieth century so popular, into a more "American" frontier vernacular construction style (Supernowicz and Lux The original landscape design for the site was created by landscape architect L. Glenn Hall, who with George Gibbs, created a standard landscape image and style for Forest Service buildings and designed landscapes in California.

The three main objectives of the Forest Service's landscape designs were rugged simplicity and naturalness, adaptation of the surrounding landscape, and cost of maintenance and construction (Hall PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page 5 An August 19, San Diego Union article detailed the Clevelaru:l's facilities improvements. The article's headline "Depression Gives Forest Rangers Roof Over Heads" editorialized on the posiuve situation for the Forest staff. Supervisor Anderson noted the modem, convenient, and practical design of the new structures with their pine interiors, built-in cupboards, coolers, and sinks (San Diego Union II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION 1. General statement: 1.

Architectural character: The building is a small, two-bedroom barracks residence built by the Civilian Conservation Corp in 2. Condition of fabric: Good. 2. Description of Exterior: 1. Overall dimensions: Approximately 28' x The building is a one-story rectangular structure. 2. Foundations: Poured concrete. 3. Walls: Wood-framed exterior walls are clad in the original wooden 12" horizontal lapped siding with vertical comer boards. The siding for the addition to the enclosed porch is in design with the original siding. 4. Structural systems, framing: The roof is wood-framed construction, as are the walls. The floor is wood-framed over a poured concrete foundation, with a small crawl- space. 5.

Porches, stoops: There is a partially enclosed porch on the east facade of the building that was further closed in during This porch and the secondary door on the south facade are accessed by three poured concrete steps. There is a small enclosure for a water heater added to the north of the secondary entry. PINE _HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page6 6. Openings: 1. Doorways and doors: The original main entry, a single door on the west face of the enclosed porch, was boarded-up in During this renovation, a new single entrance door was added to the south face of the porch. There was also a door on the north face of the porch that has been boarded-up. There is a secondary door at the rear of the building, offset on the west facade.

Both the main and secondary entry are single flush-panel doors with a single light. 2. Windows and shutters: The building still has the original wooden windows with working wooden shutters and rod iron details. A wihdow with two 4/4 casements surrounding a 1/1 casement window is centered on the north facade, with a smaller 2/4 casement window to the west. There is a small unshuttered sliding aluminum window near a double 4/4 casement window on the south facade. There is also a shuttered window on this side. Centered on the east facade, on the addition to the enclosed porch, is a three part aluminum window. To the south is an original 4/4 casement window.

On the west facade, there is a small 2/2 casement window under the eave and a larger four part six pane hinged window opening out from the bedroom area. 7. Roof: The moderately pitched, wood frame, side gable roof is finished with asphalt shingles. The eaves feature a small overhang. Wooden rectangular vents are centered in the gable ends. 3. Description of Interior: 1. Floor plans: The two-bedroom barracks has an irregular rectangular floor plan, with a small second bathroom added to the center of the building during the renovations. 2. Flooring: The wooden floor is covered with vinyl flooring. 3. Wall and ceiling finish: The wooden panel interior walls and ceiling are painted and in good condition. 4. Openings: The wooden interior doors are solid with five horizontal panels.

PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page7 5. Decorative features and trim: There is simple wood trim throughout the building at windows, doors, cornice, and baseboards. There are built-in drawers, cabinets, and cupboards in the kitchen, as well as a space for the former cool box (ventilator refrigerator). D. Site: 1. Design: The site comprises approximately 2 acres. A concrete pad remains where the original water tower had been and a pumphouse formerly sat approximately one half mile south of the complex. A one foot high dry rock wall encompasses the area around the front and sides of the building where the lawn is located. 2. Outbuildings: There is an engine garage and paint storage shed on the site. III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION 1.

Architectural Drawings: see photographs CA-10, CA-11, CA-12, and CA-13 of this report 2. Historic Views: see Newland in bibliography 3. Interviews: None 4. Bibliography 1. Primary and unpublished sources CNF Files (Real Property Records), Pine Hills Station, 2. Secondary and published sources CCC Annual (Civilian Conservation Corps). Official Annual, Los Angeles District Ninth Corps Area, Los Angeles: Civilian Conservation Corps, Clar, C. Raymond. California Government and Forestry II during the Young and Rolph Administrations, Sacramento: Division of Forestry, Department of Natural Resources, State of California, CNF Land Status Atlas (Cleveland National Forest), PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page 8 L.

Glenn Hall, Landscape Manual for Administrative Sites in California Region, San Francisco: USDA-Forest Service, Region 5, Newland, James D. Historic Resources Survey and Evaluation Report: Administration Structures, Report prepared for the Cleveland National Forest, USDA-Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Region, April Otis, Alison, and William D. Honey, Thomas c., and Kimberly Lakin. The Forest Service and the Civilian Conservation Corps: USDA-Forest Service, Washington, D. C. Palmer, Christine S. Civilian Conservation Corps Structures on the Cleveland National Forest, California, Report prepared for the Heritage Program, Cleveland National Forest, San Diego Union, Salamond, John A.

The Civilian Conservation Corps, A New Deal Case Study, Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press, Supernowicz, Dana and Linda Lux. A Thematic Study of Administrative Buildings in the Pacific Southwest Region, San Francisco: USDA-Forest Service, Region 5, 5. Likely sources not yet investigated: none 6. Supplemental material: none IV. PROJECT INFORMATION In a study was made of the CCC/Depression Era buildings throughout Cleveland National Forest to determine which buildings were potentially eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (Newland The Pine Hills Barracks was one of the structures considered potentially eligible by this study as part of a discontiguous district of other CCC/Depression Era structures on the Cleveland National Forest.

This document was created as part of a mitigation plan for potential affects to this building during planned rehabilitation efforts. This report was prepared by the staff of EDAW, Inc. for the Cleveland National Forest in the winter of Christy Dolan, M.A. (Historical Archaeologist/Historian) conducted the fieldwork PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (Building HABS No. CA-2714-A Page9 ' and served at technical reviewer for the document. Architectural Historian Angie Gustafson and Archaeologist Tanya W ahoff compiled reference material and provided text for the document. EDAW graphic designer Dan Brady created the graphics for the document. Photographer Chris Wray, subconsultant to EDAW, provided the photographs for this document.

, " ';, C Figure 1 0 Feet o % OUADRANGLELOCATION Location of Pine Hills Barracks Pine Hills Barracks 00/JI Pine Hilts Barracks\FigureJ\Fig 1 IJ/29/00 PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (BUILDING HABS No. CA- 2714-A PAGE 11 KITCHEN ICE BOX - - -- Source: Pine Hills drawings and onwsite mapping Figure 2 0 NO SCALE Pine Hills Station, Barracks Configuration as of November Pine Hills Barracks Pinr Hil/.1 Barrac/.:s\Fif!,ures\Fig 1 PINE HILLS STATION, BARRACKS (BUILDING HABS No. CA- 2714-A PAGE 12 ;- I\ \ \ I ' \\ --- - \ \ /'- -' - / _.J \ EXISTING GARAGE '' \ BARRACKS ~\ \ \ ,I 'I \ \ ! I ' '\ r I, II ~ \ '- !I I/ I', \ \ I' '\ \ \ ,I ~5~ \ ' l \ ' -- - - - - - - - - !, !\ \ '' -- '-. 1 I 1 -. I I , '' ' ' \ ' '' I' I ', ', ' ' _ I' ' ' ' + '" ~ + --- FENCE r '- _.'

Contour Line

Figure 3 Current Layout of Pine Hills Station 0 0 40 Feet Pine Hills Barracks Pine Hills Barmcks\Figures\Fig J Current

In context

Julian, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Julian

1 record

The federal surveyors worked through Julian building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Witch Creek SchoolhouseHABS CAL,37-JUL,1-1,408 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,37-JUL.V,1A-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.