BlockBefore

Carquinez Bridge, Spanning Carquinez Strait at Interstate 80, Vallejo

Carquinez Bridge, Spanning Carquinez Strait at Interstate 80, Vallejo, Solano County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,48-VALL,1-, with a 22,059-word written history.

From the record

“The Carquinez Bridge is a cantilever truss structure which carries three lanes of westbound Interstate-80 traffic across the Carquinez Strait.”

Written record, HAER CAL,48-VALL,1- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,48-VALL,1- · the record runs 22059 words · one of 191 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

46 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,48-VALL,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Crossing the Carquinez Strait between the City of Vallejo, Solano County, and the unincorporated village of Crockett, Contra Costa County, California USGS 7.5 Minute Series - Benicia, Calif. UTM Coordinates: Date of Construction: Engineers: Charles Derleth, chief engineer William Burr, consulting engineer David Steinman, design engineer

Significance

322 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,48-VALL,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Carquinez Bridge is a cantilever truss structure which carries three lanes of westbound Interstate-80 traffic across the Carquinez Strait. (Eastbound traffic is carried by a parallel structure, erected in The bridge was the first major auto bridge in the San Francisco Bay Area, predating by a decade the Golden Gate and San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridges. Replacing an auto ferry across the Carquinez Strait, the bridge was an important link in north-south traffic from the Bay Area to Northern California and the Pacific Northwest, as well as connecting the Bay Area to Sacramento and points east.

The bridge's importance as a north-south link diminished somewhat with the opening of the Golden Gate Bridge in but it remains a critical highway link between the Bay Area and Sacramento, carrying an average of more than fifty thousand vehicles per day. With two main spans of each, the Carquinez Bridge at the time of its completion was the fourth largest cantilever truss bridge in the world, and the second largest in the United States. (The Queensboro Bridge in New York City, constructed in was the largest cantilever truss bridge in the U.S., with spans of and CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 2 Only five bridges of any type in the U.S. had spans exceeding in (the other four being suspension spans).

The Carquinez Bridge was the largest bridge west of the Mississippi River, and the first major bridge designed to resist seismic forces. One of the biggest challenges for the engineers was the construction of piers in the deep and swift waters of the Carquinez Strait. Two of the bridge's piers extend approximately below mean high water to bedrock, through of water and 45 of earth beneath the channel. These were the deepest water piers ever constructed at that time, a record later surpassed by the Golden Gate and San Francisco- Oakland Bay Bridges. Author: Andrew Hope, Associate Environmental Planner (Architectural History), California Department of Transportation.

Written history

21627 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,48-VALL,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The first Carquinez Bridge does not meet current seismic safety standards and would be difficult to retrofit without extended closures. It also has a substandard width for its three lanes of freeway traffic. Consequently, the California Department of Transportation is constructing a third bridge across the Carquinez Strait, parallel to and just west of the bridge. The new bridge will be a suspension structure, and will carry the westbound traffic currently carried by the bridge. When the new bridge is completed in the bridge will be demolished after seventy-six years of service. This documentation is intended to comply with part of the mitigation requirements for the removal of the historic bridge, in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.

I CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 3 Table of Contents 1. DESCRIPTION 4 1.1 Substructure 4 1.2 Superstructure 6 1.3 South approach viaduct 8 1.4 Alterations 9 1.5 Comparison of the and bridges 10 2. HISTORICAL INFORMATION 11 2.1 Transportation context prior to construction of the bridge 11 2.2 The American Toll Bridge Company and approval to build a bridge 13 2.3 The engineers 17 2.4 Design of the bridge 21 2.5 Construction of the bridge 26 2.6 Operation of the bridge 33 3. NOTES 40 4. BIBLIOGRAPHY 53 f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 4 1.

Description

The Carquinez Bridge is a double cantilever, through-truss structure, in length.1 In addition, the south approach viaduct (converted to a freeway exit ramp in is approximately long, giving the original structure a total length of approximately The bridge spans the western end of the Carquinez Strait, about twenty miles northeast of San Francisco. The strait, which is about nine miles long and varies from about to in width, connects Suisun Bay to the east with San Pablo Bay to the west. California's vast Central Valley is drained by the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers, which meet in the delta area east of Suisun Bay. All of this water flows west through the Carquinez Strait, then south from San Pablo Bay to San Francisco Bay, and west again through the Golden Gate to the Pacific Ocean.

The Carquinez Bridge is one of eight large toll bridges in the San Francisco Bay Area which link the various land areas separated by the extensive bay and river network. The bridge extends from the vicinity of the city of Vallejo on the north shore of the strait to the unincorporated village of Crockett on the south shore. It carries three lanes of traffic in a single direction, as a component of the westbound Interstate-80 freeway. The west Carquinez Bridge, which is the subject of this documentation, was originally the sole crossing at this location, carrying traffic in both directions. In a second, parallel span was opened to the east of the original bridge. The newer bridge carries eastbound traffic.

The cantilever truss is a bridge type which consists of "anchor arms" spanning from the abutments to the main piers, "cantilever arms" forming part of the main span, and a "suspended span" which is hung from the ends of the two cantilever arms and bridges the gap between them. Each of the anchor arms balances the weight of the corresponding cantilever arm and half of the suspended span. The Carquinez Bridge has two main spans, with anchor arms at the north and south ends and four cantilever arms. The large center pier supports cantilever arms extending both north and south. 1.1 Substructure The bridge piers are numbered consecutively from north to south. Pier 1 is the north abutment, located at the top of the steep slope on the north side of the strait.

This abutment is a concrete structure 60* wide, in length (along the longitudinal axis of the bridge), and having a total height of It rests on a rock shelf excavated from the hillside. The bridge superstructure is anchored to this abutment at the ends of the two parallel trusses and at the longitudinal centerline of the bridge. C CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 5 Piers 2 through 4 are located in the strait, with reinforced concrete foundations supporting steel towers, which in turn carry the truss superstructure. The pier 2 foundation consists of a pair of reinforced concrete caissons, each 40' square, placed 83' apart (center to center). The pier 3 foundation consists of two pairs of concrete caissons, of the same dimensions as those of pier 2, placed in the middle of the strait.

The north and south pairs are placed apart (center to center), with the shafts in each pair spaced 83' on center, as with pier 2. The six foundation structures for these two piers are each about in height, extending from bedrock up through about 50' of sand and clay and 85' of water in the strait, with the top 10' exposed above mean high water. The top 35' of each shaft is circular rather than square in plan, with a diameter of The pier 4 foundation consists of concrete shafts which are similar to those of pier 2, except that they are much shorter, extending only 22* below mean high water.

Rather than resting on bedrock as with piers 2 and 3, they are supported by a large concrete footing, 28' thick and covering an area 43' x which is supported in turn by reinforced concrete piles driven to bedrock. Pier 5 is on the south shore of the strait and supports the south anchor arm and the northernmost span of the approach roadways. The original foundation of this pier was a reinforced concrete structure, 23' x 84' in area and varying from 8' to nearly 17' thick, supported by timber piles. The pier 5 foundation was enlarged in when the tower legs were encased in concrete, providing additional support for the freeway connection which was built at that time.

At piers 2 through 4, steel towers extend from the tops of the concrete pier shafts up to the bottom chords of the superstructure. The towers at piers 2 and 4 have legs of riveted, solid steel plate, with horizontal bracing between the legs dividing each tower vertically into four sections. The wide north and south faces of the towers have chevron bracing in each section, while the narrow east and west faces have x-bracing. At their bases, where they are bolted to the concrete pedestals, the tower legs are 24' apart in the north-south direction and 83' apart in the east-west direction (centered on the pedestals). These tower legs converge at the bottom chord of the superstructure in the north-south direction, and narrow to 42' (the width of the superstructure) in the east-west direction.

At pier 3, the tower also narrows from 83' to 42' in width, but the tower legs remain parallel and apart as viewed from the east or west. The north and south faces of tower 3 are similar to those of towers 2 and 4. However, tower 3 has a more complex bracing configuration on its wide east and west faces. Each face is divided vertically into two sections by a single horizontal brace, with a major chevron brace in each section. There are also intermediate verticals and additional diagonal bracing, similar to the superstructure portion of this tower. Most of the bracing members of towers 2 through 4 consist of parallel, solid steel plates held together by small, diagonal lacing bars. f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 6 The tower at pier 5 was originally constructed with two steel legs, spaced 64* apart at the base and narrowing to 42' at the bottom chord of the superstructure. The tower legs are braced horizontally, with v-bracing within the rectangular panels bounded by the horizontal braces and vertical legs. (The v-bracing is similar to the chevron bracing of towers 2 through 4, except that the diagonals of the chevron bracing converge at the top rather than the bottom.) In addition to being bolted to the concrete foundation, the tower legs at pier 5 are anchored by steel eyebars partially embedded in the foundation. This is to prevent uplift of the tower and the superstructure above it, as the end of the anchor arm can have a negative load under some conditions.

(When the total load on the cantilever arm is greater than on the anchor arm, pier 4 acts as a fulcrum and the end of the cantilever arm will tend to lift off its support.) Tower 5 was altered in when the new freeway approach was connected, with the tower legs given a thick concrete encasement. 1.2 Superstructure The Carquinez Bridge superstructure is comprised of riveted steel members, carrying a roadway deck of reinforced concrete. It has two anchor arms, two main spans of each, and a length of roadway over the large center pier. The width of the structure, measured from the center lines of the parallel trusses, is The total height of the superstructure is from the truss bottom chords to the tops of piers 2, 3, and 4.

The truss bottom chords have a minimum clearance of above mean high water, giving the bridge a total height of more than from the water to the tops of the piers. The bridge roadway slopes down from north to south on a grade of about 1 percent. To simplify construction, the truss vertical members were set perpendicular to the slightly sloping bottom chords, rather than being true verticals. Thus, the vertical members lean slightly to the south, so that the top of pier 2, for example, is about 1 farther south than its connection to the truss bottom chord. The two anchor arms have eighteen truss panels, each approximately in length, while the shorter cantilever arms have twelve truss panels of the same length.

Major truss verticals, extending from the bottom chord to the top chord, occur only at every other panel point, with minor verticals (extending only from the bottom chord to the intersecting truss diagonal) at alternate panel points. The major verticals are box members with solid steel plate on their east and west sides and lacing bars on their north and south sides. The minor verticals are lighter in section, comprised of paired steel channels held together by rectangular steel plates riveted to the channels at regular intervals, somewhat resembling ladders. All of the diagonals in the anchor arms and some in the cantilever arms are box members, similar in construction to the major CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 7 verticals.

However, some of the diagonals in the cantilever arms consist of groups of four steel eyebars. The truss bottom chords are box members, deep, with solid steel plate on the sides and lacing bars at the top and bottom. The truss top chords are comprised of eyebars in the cantilever arms and portions of the anchor arms. The top chord segments adjacent to piers 2 through 4 (from the pier to the first major truss diagonal) where the greatest tension stresses occur, consist often parallel eyebars in each segment. The number of eyebars is reduced to four in each segment over the remainder of the top chords of the cantilever arms, and six eyebars are used in each segment of the top chord across the length of the center pier.

Over most of the length of the truss anchor arms, the top chords are solid, boxed members. Steel eyebars are used less extensively in the anchor arms than in the cantilever arms because many of the anchor arm truss members must be able to resist both tension and compression forces as the bridge loading conditions change. Eyebars are used only for truss members that are always in tension. The two suspended spans have trusses of the Pennsylvania-Petit type, a variation of the Pratt truss, with the top chords having a slightly convex curvature.

Each truss has fourteen panels approximately 1" in length, giving the suspended spans a total length of about As with the cantilever and anchor arms, major verticals occur only at every other panel point, with minor verticals extending only from the bottom chord to the intersecting diagonal. The suspended span trusses are 72' in depth at mid-span, sloping down to 60' at the "hip," where they meet the cantilever arms. The truss members are similar in construction to the cantilever and anchor arms. However, the stresses in the top and bottom chords of the suspended spans are the reverse of those in the cantilever arms. Consequently, the suspended span bottom chords are eyebars (with four parallel bars in each segment) while the top chords are solid, boxed members.

Bracing between the two parallel side trusses includes lateral braces between the top chords at each major vertical, with x-bracing in the rectangular area bounded by the side trusses and each adjacent pair of lateral braces. In addition, lateral braces and x-bracing are located in the vertical plane at the major truss verticals, as well as diagonally along some of the major truss diagonals. All of this bracing consists of relatively light steel channels connected by lacing bars. At the bottom chords, the two parallel trusses are connected by floor beams (perpendicular to the trusses) at every panel point. These floor beams are 5' deep, and their bottoms are flush with the bottoms of the truss bottom chords.

Six stringers (parallel to the trusses) span between each pair of floor beams, and support the concrete deck. Also below the deck are braces in the horizontal plane, within the rectangular areas bounded by the truss bottom chords and each adjacent pair of floor beams. In the anchor arms, these are chevron braces which point toward the shore, while the cantilever arms have chevron braces pointing toward mid-span. The suspension spans have CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 8 x-bracing rather than chevrons. The concrete deck has low curbs on both sides of the roadway. The protective railing consists of a single metal tube, rectangular in section, along the inside faces of the two side trusses.

On the truss top chords, wire guardrails strung between steel posts allow access on foot along the top of the superstructure over the entire length of the bridge. In addition, there are ladders at various locations which allow maintenance crews to access the top of the superstructure from the roadway. Below the deck are rolling scaffolds which provide access to the underside of the superstructure for maintenance and painting. 1.3 South Approach Viaduct The south approach viaduct (now a southbound exit ramp) connects the bridge to San Pablo Avenue in Crockett. From the south end of the bridge at pier 5, the viaduct roadway curves about 45 degrees to a southwesterly alignment where it meets San Pablo Avenue.

The viaduct extends from pier 5 over a series of steel towers and bents (6 through 11) to abutment 12. It includes four deck truss spans (from pier 5 to bent 9) and three steel girder spans (from bent 9 to the abutment). The viaduct passes over the Union Pacific railroad tracks between pier 5 and tower 6, Dowrelio Drive between tower 8 and bent 9, and Wanda Street (with a very low clearance) between bent 11 and abutment 12. Towers 6 through 8 are located in a low area, just a few feet above the water level, that was filled in the early twentieth century. These towers have concrete footings supported by timber piles. Each tower has four legs which consist of a box section with solid steel plate on two parallel faces and lacing bars on the other two faces.

Horizontal braces divide the towers vertically into three sections, with v-bracing in most of the resulting rectangular panels. All of the bracing is similarly constructed of parallel, solid plates connected by lacing bars. Bent 9, tower 10, and bent 11 are located on the steep slope up to San Pablo Avenue, and diminish in height as they approach the abutment. They are similar in construction to towers 6 through 8, although their footings rest on rock close to the surface rather than being supported by timber piles. The deck truss spans vary in length from approximately to The parallel trusses, each 30' deep, are spaced 28' apart. The truss verticals, diagonals, and top chords are built-up members of solid steel plate and lacing bars, while the bottom chords consist of paired eyebars.

The parallel trusses are connected by x-bracing in the vertical plane at each panel point, as well as lateral bracing at the bottom chords. The trusses support steel floor beams at each panel point. Steel stringers span between the floor beams and carry the concrete deck. The floor beams cantilever out beyond the trusses to carry the deck, which varies in width from 38* to CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 9 The amount of overhang varies at each trass panel point, since the trusses extend in straight lines between the towers, while the roadway follows a curved alignment. The spans from bent 9 to abutment 12 consist of paired steel girders, spaced 28' apart. As with the deck truss spans, these girders support a system of floor beams and stringers which carry the concrete deck.

The girder spans also have x-bracing in the horizontal plane between the floor beams, at the level of the floor beam bottom flanges. The viaduct roadway has low concrete curbs, and retains its original steel railings. The railings have a round top rail, with closely spaced vertical pickets consisting of small metal bars. The viaduct terminates at abutment 12, a concrete mass high and 11 thick at the base. 1.4 Alterations The Carquinez Bridge served for nearly thirty years with only minor repairs and routine maintenance. The first extensive alterations were undertaken in in conjunction with the construction of the new freeway and a second span across the strait.

The original bridge was converted to one-way traffic, southbound across the strait (designated westbound with the new bridge handling the northbound crossing (eastbound As part of this conversion, the 4* wide sidewalks on both sides of the bridge were replaced by 1 wide concrete curbs, increasing the roadway width from 30' to the present The new freeway connection at the south end of the bridge relegated the original south approach viaduct to the role of freeway exit ramp. This viaduct was also modified at its south end, to accommodate a new exit ramp connection from eastbound Pier 5 was greatly enlarged and strengthened, as noted above, to receive the new freeway approach viaduct.

In addition, the center pier protective fender was enlarged to include both the original and new bridges, and a new toll plaza was constructed on the north side of the strait. The next major modification was a project to strengthen the bridge superstructure, carried out in As originally built, the trass top chord members at the ends of the cantilever arms and some of the major diagonals in the suspended spans consisted of only two eyebars. Corrosion of the steel superstructure, attributed largely to airborne salt and pollution, led to the concern that if one of the eyebars in these members should fail, the entire load would be shifted to the single remaining eyebar.

To improve the margin of safety, the number of eyebars in each of these members was increased from two to four.3 Four years later, a similar project was carried out to strengthen the deck truss spans of the south approach viaduct. Additional eyebars were installed at the bottom chords of all four of these spans. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 10 1.5 Comparison of the and bridges The second Carquinez Bridge was constructed upstream (east) of the original. Its overall form and dimensions are similar to the bridge, with the same span lengths, pier locations, and superstructure height, and a nearly identical truss configuration. The pier foundations for the second bridge were constructed in a manner similar to the original, but much larger caissons were used.

A single caisson was used for pier 2, with two caissons of the same size used for pier 3. Each caisson is 53' x in area, and was constructed with 18 dredging wells. In contrast, the bridge used a total of six caissons for piers 2 and 3, each 40' square and having only four dredging wells.4 The most immediately apparent differences between the two bridge superstructures are that the suspended spans of the bridge have horizontal rather than convex top chords, and the newer bridge is substantially wider. The side trusses of the bridge are 60* apart (center to center), compared to only 42' for the bridge. There are other, more subtle differences in the truss configurations of the two bridges.

For example, the center pier of the bridge has fewer vertical and diagonal members on its long east and west faces, and the newer bridge also omits some of the transverse bracing in the vertical plane at the major truss verticals. The suspended spans of the bridge were constructed by building out from the ends of the cantilever arms, rather than lifting a pre-assembled truss into place as was done with the bridge. There are other significant differences in the construction methods and materials of the two bridges. Rivets were not used on the bridge, with high-strength bolts and extensive use of welding employed instead. The truss members of the newer bridge are all box shapes, with perforated plates used instead of the small lacing bars of the older bridge.

This gives the newer bridge a heavier, more solid appearance. The bridge makes extensive use of steel alloys of much higher strength than were available in the allowing for a substantial reduction of the overall dead load of the structure. The stronger alloys and extensive use of welded connections greatly simplified the construction of the bridge. For example, the truss bottom chords in the cantilever arms of the bridge are 40" deep and weigh 840 pounds per foot. A cross-section of these members would reveal fourteen separate components (eight vertical plates, four corner angles, and top and bottom cover plates) fastened together with rivets.

In contrast, the same members of bridge are 36" deep, use only five steel plates, and weigh only 470 pounds per foot.5 CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 11 2.

Historical Information

Transportation context prior to construction of the bridge Prior to the construction of the eight major highway bridges and two railroad bridges in the San Francisco Bay Area, the waters of the San Francisco, San Pablo, and Suisun Bays, as well as the Carquinez Strait and the Sacramento River delta, were formidable obstacles to land transportation. The major auto route from Oakland to Sacramento and points east avoided these water barriers by heading south from Oakland to Hayward, then east to Livermore and through the Altamont Pass to Stockton in California's Central Valley, and finally turning north to Sacramento. This was the route designated as the Lincoln Highway in the first auto route crossing the United States from New York to California.

The Carquinez Bridge, when opened to traffic in reduced the driving distance between Oakland and Sacramento by thirty miles.6 In response to the barriers to travel presented by the bay and river system, an extensive network of ferries developed in the Bay Area. At the Carquinez Strait, ferries were transporting horses, wagons, and passengers on foot long before the advent of the automobile. The earliest of these date from the mid-nineteenth century, and ran between the cities of Benicia and Martinez, about six miles upstream from the site of the present Carquinez Bridge.

There was also a train ferry from Benicia to Port Costa which operated from until the construction of the Southern Pacific railroad bridge between Benicia and Martinez in The first auto ferry service across the strait was begun in by the Martinez-Benicia Ferry & Transportation Company. Ferry service at the west end of the strait, where the Carquinez Bridges are now located, began with the incorporation of the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company in This ferry carried vehicles between Vallejo and the small town of Pinole, about three miles southwest of Crockett.9 From Pinole, drivers could continue south by road to Richmond, Berkeley, and Oakland.

The ferry company's first boat was the long Issaquah, which was purchased in Seattle and began service crossing the Carquinez Strait on July In the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company built the Avert Hartford, named for the company's president. This new boat was larger than the Issaquah, at in length.11 The Six-Minute Ferry began operations a year after the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry, running between Crockett and a terminal at Morrow Cove on the north shore, just west of the present bridge on land now owned by the California Maritime Academy. This was a much shorter and faster route across the strait than the competing Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry, and the company promoted this advantage in their name.

The Six-Minute Ferry was operated by the Association of Mare Island Employees, which also operated the Vallejo-Mare Island Ferry. The company bought the fire- damaged San Jose from the Key System in Oakland, for use on the Crockett-Vallejo route, giving the ship a major rebuilding to accommodate autos. The San Jose was comparable in c CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 12 size to the Avert Hartford, with a length of Competition from the Six-Minute Ferry almost ruined the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company, until a landslide in destroyed the Six- Minute Ferry's terminal at Morrow Cove.14 Shortly thereafter, the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company purchased its rival and began using the San Jose for the Carquinez Strait crossing, sending the Avert Hanford to work for the Golden Gate Ferry Company, which was also owned by the officers of the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company.15 The need for a bridge spanning the Carquinez Strait became increasingly acute with the explosive growth of automobile travel in the early twentieth century. The population of California was V/% million in the early and motor vehicle registrations in the state were growing at a rapid pace.

There were registered motor vehicles in the state by January up from about only three years earlier.16 The Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry carried more than 1 million passengers per year in and in more than vehicles.17 The ferry had revenues of in up from less than only four years earlier.18 This ferry was a critical link in north-south travel, as well as the major route linking the San Francisco Bay Area to Sacramento and all points farther east. The number of vehicles using a new bridge to cross the Strait was expected to be greater than the number using the ferry, since some motorists took the longer route from Oakland to Sacramento via Stockton to avoid the long lines of cars and trucks waiting to take the ferry.

The earliest published reference to the construction of a bridge across the Carquinez Strait appeared in the San Francisco Call on January This article reported that the Napa Chamber of Commerce had passed a resolution calling upon the state to construct such a crossing. The City of Napa, about twelve miles north of Vallejo, along with other North Bay cities such as Petaluma and Santa Rosa, stood to benefit from easier tourist travel from the much larger cities of San Francisco and Oakland, as well as easier access to these larger markets for the North Bay's agricultural products. An editorial in the Call on January advocated the construction of a bridge that would accommodate both rail and automobile traffic, to be built and operated by the state.

Although the state failed to take any action at that time, the proposal was revived in and supported by Boards of Trade and Chambers of Commerce across the state.21 The proposal was again supported by the Call, which editorialized that a high-level bridge should be constructed, "wholly or in considerable part at the expense of the state and made available for use by the trunk railway systems as well as for general transit."22 As in however, the state failed to follow through with a plan for construction of a bridge. The issue did not reappear in Bay Area newspapers until when plans for a privately built and operated toll bridge were being put forth by entrepreneurs.

An editorial in the San Francisco Examiner in September of that year supported the construction of a bridge, but noted that "it is unfortunate that the initiative for this CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 13 new project is private and not public. It is difficult not to be a little antagonistic to private capital financing a project so plainly a public affair." The editorial went on to suggest that "perhaps, when built, the counties benefited will find a way for taking it over and making it the public enterprise it should be."23 The American Toll Bridge Company and approval to build a bridge The Carquinez Bridge, built by the American Toll Bridge Company, began as the vision of two men, Aven Hanford and Oscar Klatt.

Hanford was the owner of several grocery stores in the Bay Area, who was frustrated by the difficulty in getting from his store in Vallejo in the North Bay to his Oakland and Alameda stores in the East Bay.24 The route by auto in involved travel east to Benicia, where one could take the ferry to Martinez on the south shore of the strait, then continuing south by road to Oakland. This route included passage through a narrow tunnel in the Oakland hills which had been built for horse-drawn vehicles in and slightly enlarged in the precursor to the Caldecott Tunnel of Klatt was a traveling salesman for a grocery wholesaler who often had to travel between East Bay and North Bay communities, and therefore was also a frequent patron of the Benicia-Martinez Ferry.

The two men initially decided that a ferry across the Carquinez Strait from Vallejo could compete successfully with the Benicia-Martinez Ferry, and would allow drivers from the North Bay to take San Pablo Avenue to Berkeley and Oakland via Rodeo, Pinole, and Richmond, thus avoiding the longer and more difficult tunnel route through the Oakland hills. They formed the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company, described above, in In the early with the success and continued growth of the ferry business, the two men decided that a toll bridge would be economically viable and more convenient than the ferry.

Planning for the bridge was begun by the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company in and Charles Derleth was hired by the company that autumn to act as chief engineer for the project.26 After the company had secured approval to build a bridge in early the American Toll Bridge Company was incorporated to carry out the project, with Hanford as President (and major investor) and Klatt as Vice-President.27 The original financing plan called for the issuance of stock in the American Toll Bridge Company. In early with construction well underway, this was changed to include the sale of revenue bonds in addition to stock. The sale of both stocks and bonds was relatively easy in the mid-1920s, a time of investment frenzy.

David Steinman's biographer noted that "it was child's play to sell stocks, bonds, and debentures for almost any kind of speculative enterprise. Investment bankers made fortunes only to lose them in the crash."29 CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 14 In addition to the Carquinez Strait crossing, the American Toll Bridge Company also planned to build a second bridge about twenty-five miles farther east. This bridge would cross the San Joaquin River in the delta area, where the San Joaquin and Sacramento Rivers meet before flowing west into Suisun Bay and the Carquinez Strait. The Antioch Bridge, extending from the city of Antioch in Contra Costa County to Sherman Island in the delta, was constructed simultaneously with the Carquinez Bridge.

It was a multi-span, through truss structure, with a short lift span near the south shore. This bridge, although by no means a small structure, was easier and cheaper to build than the much larger Carquinez Bridge, and did not pose the engineering challenges of crossing the Carquinez Strait. The road north from the Antioch Bridge through the delta provided an alternative route to Sacramento from the San Francisco Bay Area.

Although the Antioch bridge carried only about one-seventh of the traffic carried by the Carquinez Bridge in the late it was believed to have been built to pre-empt the construction of another bridge that would have competed with the Carquinez crossing and diminished the revenues of the American Toll Bridge Company.30 Charles Derleth was not involved in the Antioch Bridge project, which was handled by a completely separate engineering staff from that responsible for the Carquinez Bridge.

Contra Costa County approval State law dating to the nineteenth century stated that authority over the construction and operation of toll bridges over navigable rivers was vested with the county on the "left bank descending."31 In the case of the Carquinez Bridge, this meant that approval was needed from Contra Costa County on the south side of the Carquinez Strait. The Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company therefore applied to the county for a franchise to construct and operate their planned bridge. Securing approval from Contra Costa County was not a simple matter, however, with the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. facing competition from two other applicants to bridge the Carquinez Strait and maritime interests voicing opposition to any bridge as a menace to navigation.

The Dillon Point Development Company proposed to construct a bridge from Dillon Point in Solano County, a little less than two miles east of the present bridge location, to a point about halfway between Crockett and the much smaller community of Port Costa on the Contra Costa County side of the strait. This is the narrowest point on the western portion of the Carquinez Strait, and therefore an advantageous location for a crossing. The Dillon Point Development Co. was headed by Alfred Kelly, a director of San Francisco's Hibernia Bank, and the other directors of the company were bankers as well.

Although the Dillon Point Development Company did not take their proposal beyond a very preliminary stage, more serious competition for the bridge franchise came from a succession of companies headed by Dr. Otto Freyermuth of San Francisco. The first of these was the San CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 15 Francisco Transit Company, which was incorporated in June and quickly received approval from the War Department to build a bridge across the Carquinez Strait, contingent on the approval of Contra Costa County. Also choosing the Dillon Point location, Freyermuth's company proposed a suspension bridge with a main span and side spans.

The proposed bridge was designed by Charles Evan Fowler, designer of the Detroit-Windsor suspension bridge (later named the Ambassador Bridge) which was at that time under construction. David Steinman, who would later serve as design engineer to the American Toll Bridge Company, was a consultant to Fowler on the San Francisco Transit Company's proposal.33 Charles Derleth, writing in stated that Hanford and Klatt did not originate the idea of a bridge at the western end of the Carquinez Strait, but were provoked into action by the proposals of the Dillon Point Development Co. and the San Francisco Transit Co.34 Any bridge at the Dillon Point location would quickly drive the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry out of business.

Hanford and Klatt therefore hastily came up with their own bridge proposal, at a location farther west, in order to protect their business. Derleth stated that the Dillon Point location, rather than a more westerly location, was chosen by the ferry's potential competitors because they were prohibited from applying for a franchise within two miles of the existing ferry route. The two competing companies (the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. and the San Francisco Transit Co.) appeared before the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors on November to present their respective proposals and seek the county's approval.

Subsequent meetings were held on December and January At the January meeting, the county supervisors voted four to one to grant a franchise to the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company.36 The county decided in favor of the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company in part because it appeared to be the stronger company financially. In addition, the more westerly location of this company's proposed bridge was seen as preferable to the Dillon Point location with respect to the construction of the necessary access roads.37 Freyermuth, however, was not easily dissuaded from his quest to build a bridge across the Carquinez Strait.

Following the decision of the county supervisors, Freyermuth's Northern California Development Company (successor to the San Francisco Transit Company) proposed that a franchise for a second bridge (at the Dillon Point location) be granted. The American Toll Bridge Company, not surprisingly, objected to this proposal, citing harm to their stockholders. The County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to reject the proposal for a second bridge on September Following the county's rejection of this proposal, Freyermuth went to court in early to compel the county to place the question on the ballot.39 The California Supreme Court voted unanimously in April of that year to uphold the County's refusal to put a second franchise to a vote.40 f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 16 Contra Costa County Ordinance which granted the franchise to the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company, went into effect on February The terms of the franchise included a stipulation that construction begin within four months, and be completed within three years.

According to Charles Derleth, the relatively short time frame was included as a response to accusations by Freyermuth and his allies that the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company was not serious about constructing a bridge, but was merely trying to prevent the San Francisco Transit Company from doing so.42 The franchise was to be in effect for twenty-five years, with the bridge and attendant facilities reverting to Contra Costa and Solano Counties at the expiration of the franchise in The county was to receive per month plus 2 percent of gross receipts from tolls over the life of the franchise. Toll rates were to be set by the California Railroad Commission, with the maximum toll set at 75 cents per car plus 15 cents per passenger in the absence of action by the Railroad Commission.

(In fact, the Commission did not begin to regulate bridge tolls until the bridge had been in operation for ten years, as described in Section below.) War Department approval In addition to a franchise from Contra Costa County, approval from the War Department was necessary to construct a bridge across the Carquinez Strait. The War Department's authority stemmed from the River and Harbor Act of which gave the Secretary of War jurisdiction over the construction of bridges, dams, causeways, and other structures in or over navigable waters of the United States.43 The arguments and debates before the War Department between the two competing companies were as contentious as those before the county supervisors.

The War Department held the first of two public hearings to consider the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company's bridge proposal on November At this point, the company was proposing a suspension bridge, with a main span of about The south tower of this bridge was located in the strait about north of the Crockett piers.44 Objections to this design were voiced by the California & Hawaiian Sugar Company in Crockett, the Matson Navigation Company, and the Grangers Business Association, which exported wheat and barley from the warehouses in Port Costa. These businesses considered the location of the south tower to be a serious obstruction to navigation in the strait. The C&H Sugar Co.

also expressed a preference for the Dillon Point location if a bridge were to be built, as this was east of their refinery in Crockett.45 One of the responses to the criticism from shipping interests was to contend that the additional ferry traffic across the strait that would be needed to serve the anticipated increase in demand would be a greater navigation hazard than a stationary bridge pier.46 In addition to the objections raised at the hearing, Freyermuth wrote to Col. Herbert Deakyne of the War Department on November 17, arguing for the superiority of the Dillon Point location.47 CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 17 Freyermuth also complained that the San Francisco Transit Co.

had invested "many thousands of dollars" in surveys and plans for its proposed Dillon Point crossing, and suggested that the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. was unlikely to bring their bridge proposal to fruition. Charles Derleth wrote a lengthy rebuttal to Freyermuth's letter, which was sent to Col. Deakyne on December Derleth gave several arguments for the superiority of the bridge location chosen by the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co., among them the fact that the deeper water at the Dillon Point location to at mean low water, compared to about 83' for the more westerly site) would make the foundations more difficult and expensive to construct.

Derleth also asserted that the high bluffs on the south side of the strait at the Dillon point location would require a steep and lengthy connector from the south end of the bridge up approximately to the level of the Crockett-Port Costa road. By contrast, the bridge proposed by the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. would require only a short and nearly level approach structure to connect the bridge to San Pablo Avenue in Crockett. The War Department declined to approve either of the two competing proposals until the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors had concluded its deliberations on the issue.49 A second War Department hearing was conducted on March two weeks after a franchise had been granted to the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. by Contra Costa County.

Two plans were presented at this meeting, a cantilever bridge with two main spans of each, and a suspension bridge with a main span of Both designs had the southerly piers behind the northern edge of the Crockett piers, in response to objections raised at the hearing of November On April 17, the War Department approved the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company's proposal to build a bridge across the Carquinez Strait, conditioned on review and approval of more detailed plans.51 The engineers To design a bridge on the scale of the Carquinez span requires the collaborative effort of many people. In addition to a team of civil engineers, such a task requires the involvement of experts in geology, foundations, fluid dynamics, metallurgy, electrical engineering, and other fields.

Although the design of a bridge is often attributed to a single engineer, in practice no individual, no matter how talented, can do all of the work required for such an enormous task. For a major bridge project the Chief Engineer is the person with overall responsibility for the design and construction of the bridge. Much of this person's work is administrative, including the oversight of the engineering staff and contractors, as well as being responsible for contracts, schedules, and budget matters. Although the Chief Engineer is often not the primary designer, he/she has the ultimate authority over what gets built and thus usually gets the lion's share of the credit. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 18 Charles Derleth Charles Derleth was hired by the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company in September to act as Chief Engineer for the Carquinez Bridge project, for which he was paid per day plus expenses.52 Derleth was born in New York City and received degrees from the City College of New York in and Columbia University in He taught civil engineering at Columbia for several years beginning in and moved to Berkeley in where he taught at the University of California.

Derleth was appointed Dean of the College of Civil Engineering at the University of California in a position he still held when hired by the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Company fifteen years later.53 When the colleges of civil, mechanical, and electrical engineering were combined in Derleth became Dean of the new College of Engineering, and held this position until his retirement in the early Derleth had made a study of the effects of the San Francisco earthquake on buildings and other structures, and published his findings in as "The Destructive Extent of the California Earthquake: its Effect Upon Structures and Structural Materials Within the Earthquake Belt." He served as consulting engineer for the City of San Francisco from to and in that capacity was involved in the design and construction of many of the city's large civic buildings and public works projects.55 Following the completion of the Carquinez Bridge, Derleth was one of three consulting engineers hired by Joseph Strauss in to advise him on the design for the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco.56 Derleth also served on the Board of Consulting Engineers for the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, and acted as consulting engineer on several other Bay Area projects, including the Posey Tube (an underwater auto tunnel connecting the cities of Oakland and Alameda).57 William Burr One of Derleth's first acts as Chief Engineer for the Carquinez Bridge project, in January was to retain William H.

Burr as Consulting Engineer. The role of the consulting engineer is to provide an independent review of the work of the design team as a check against errors and oversights, to offer design recommendations, and to provide expertise on particular issues. Although the role is largely advisory, usually lacking direct authority over design or construction, the consulting engineer is typically a person of eminent stature within the engineering profession by virtue of long experience and recognized accomplishment. William Hubert Burr was more than 70 years old when he began serving as consulting engineer on the Carquinez Bridge project, with a long and distinguished career in civil engineering.

He was born in Watertown, Connecticut, and received a degree in civil engineering from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, New York in He taught engineering for over thirty years, at Rensselaer Harvard and Columbia Both CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 19 Charles Derleth and David Steinman had been Burr's students at Columbia. Engineering texts authored by Burr include: Elasticity and Resistance ofthe Materials ofEngineering The Design and Construction ofMetallic Bridges and Suspension Bridges, Arch Ribs and Cantilevers Burr worked for the Phoenix Bridge Company of Phoenixville, Pennsylvania from to eventually becoming general manager of the company and designing numerous bridges, including two large structures spanning the Ohio River and one spanning the Colorado.

He was appointed by President Roosevelt to the board of consulting engineers for construction of the Panama Canal, and consulted on several large engineering projects in New York State, including the Catskill Aqueduct, the State Barge Canal, and the Holland Tunnel. Burr was also retained, after the collapse of the Quebec Bridge, to advise on design changes for the Queensboro Bridge, another cantilever truss structure then nearing completion.60 Derleth knew that design and construction of pier foundations would be the most challenging part of the Carquinez Bridge project, and appointed Burr as consulting engineer in large measure because of Burr's expertise in the problems associated with construction in deep water.

David Steinman David Steinman was the third major figure in the design and construction of the Carquinez Bridge. Steinman offered his services to Derleth in December noting that he was no longer involved in Charles Fowler's competing proposal for a bridge across the Carquinez Strait, promoted by the San Francisco Transit Company.61 Derleth responded that he would take up the matter of hiring Steinman with the Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co. after they had secured approval to build their bridge from Contra Costa County and the War Department.62 Approval from the War Department came in April and Steinman was hired in May as design engineer.63 Steinman was only in his mid-thirties at this time, but had been involved in several major bridge projects and was a rising star in the engineering profession.

He quickly hired a staff of twenty to carry out the design work, which included drafting, calculating and recalculating stresses in the bridge components, investigating alternatives for each design decision, working out construction details, and preparing cost estimates.64 Steinman was born in New York City, and grew up just a short distance from the Brooklyn Bridge on the city's Lower East Side.65 He claimed that fascination with this bridge was the source of his lifelong interest in bridge design and engineering.66 Steinman entered the City College of New York in the fall of in a six-year program intended to include high school studies, and also took night courses in engineering at Cooper Union.67 He later enrolled in the civil engineering program at Columbia University, his application having been endorsed by William Burr, who was then on the faculty.68 A prodigy in mathematics and engineering, ( CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 20 Steinman's thesis project of was "The Design of the Henry Hudson Memorial Bridge as a Steel Arch." (In the the bridge was built by Steinman's firm, essentially as the young student had designed it more than twenty years earlier.)69 Steinman spent an additional year at Columbia and received his in June with a dissertation titled "Suspension Bridges and Cantilevers; their Economic Proportions and Limiting Spans."70 After leaving Columbia, Steinman taught at the University of Idaho from to and in he founded the School of Engineering at the City College of New York, where among his other duties he taught the country's first courses in aeronautical engineering.71 His textbook, Suspension Bridges: Their Design, Construction, and Erection, was published in and remained the standard text on the subject for many years thereafter.72 Between these two periods of teaching, from to Steinman worked in the New York office of Gustav Lindenthal, one of the country's leading bridge engineers.

As Lindenthal's assistant, Steinman played a major role in the design of New York City's Hell Gate Bridge, and supervised its construction. With a span of it was the longest steel arch bridge in the United States at the time. The other major bridge project that Steinman worked on while in Lindenthal's office was the Sciotoville Bridge over the Ohio River between Ohio and Kentucky, a railroad bridge which had two steel truss spans of each. In the early Steinman formed a partnership with Holton Robinson, who was more than twenty years Steinman's senior. The firm designed the Florianopolis Bridge in Brazil, which opened in as the Carquinez Bridge was nearing completion.

The Florianopolis Bridge was an unusual suspension structure, with chains of steel eyebars rather than cables for the main suspension supports. At the center of the main span, the eyebar chain also formed the top chord of the stiffening truss, an economical use of materials and a significant innovation at the time. This bridge had a main span of over making it the longest bridge in South America.74 After completion of the Carquinez Bridge in Steinman went on to design several large suspension bridges at locations throughout the country. One of these, the Thousand Islands Bridge over the St.

Lawrence River between New York and Ontario, exhibited excessive sway and vertical motion during high winds as it was nearing completion in Steinman faced this same problem in his contemporary Deer Island Bridge in Maine. The wind-induced motion in both bridges was dampened by the addition of cable stays extending from the towers at the level of the roadway, diagonally up to the main cables.

Both of these bridges had relatively shallow girders at the roadway level rather than deep stiffening trusses, consistent with a trend among designers of suspension bridges toward a more sleek and minimalist profile.75 This trend toward progressively shallower stiffening girders reached its apogee in the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, designed by Leon Moissieffand completed in Although slender and elegant, this bridge CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 21 proved to be insufficiently rigid, and collapsed in a windstorm only a few months after its completion. Steinman's experience with the Thousand Islands and Deer Island bridges, as well as the shocking collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, led him to an intensive study of the effects of wind on suspension bridges.

As a result of his investigations, Steinman became a leading authority on the subject, developing methods for predicting the frequency and amplitude of vibration in a structure for a given wind direction and velocity, and publishing a series of articles on the subject in the journal Civil Engineering. The culmination of Steinman's career was the Mackinac Bridge, connecting Michigan's upper and lower peninsulas. Completed in its main span was at that time second only to the span of the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco.

The Mackinac Bridge has a stiffening truss 38' deep, and incorporates the results of Steinman's nearly twenty years of studies on the effects of wind on suspension bridges.77 2.4 Design of the bridge Development of long-span bridges up to As early as engineers had designed and built a structure spanning more than between supports. The suspension bridge over the Ohio River at Wheeling, West Virginia, with a center span of was the world's longest span at that time.78 Two American bridges of longer span, both also of the suspension type, were constructed later in the nineteenth century. The first of these also spanned the Ohio River, between Cincinnati and Covington, Kentucky.

Completed in this bridge had a main span of The Brooklyn Bridge, opened in greatly surpassed these two earlier structures with a center span of Other long span suspension bridges constructed in the United States prior to the Carquinez Bridge include: the Williamsburg Bridge in New York City the Bear Mountain Bridge over the Hudson River at Peekskill, New York and the Benjamin Franklin Bridge crossing the Delaware River between Philadelphia and Camden, New Jersey The spans achieved by suspension bridges up to this time were within the feasible range for cantilever truss structures as well. Scotland's Firth of Forth Bridge, with spans of surpassed the Brooklyn Bridge and established a new world record in This was in turn surpassed in by the Quebec Bridge over the St.

Lawrence River, also a cantilever structure, with a main span of In the United States, the longest cantilever bridges were the Mississippi River Bridge at Memphis and the Queensboro Bridge in New York City. The former was completed in and had a span and two spans. The latter was opened in and had spans of and (The Queensboro Bridge is an unusual example of the type in that it has no suspended spans. Instead, the cantilever arms meet at mid-span.) Prior to the f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 22 no other bridge types could compete with the cantilever and suspension designs in the length of their main spans.

The Hell Gate Bridge of in New York City, with its roadway suspended from a steel arch, was the longest example of its type at Thus, when the Carquinez Bridge was opened in with its two main spans of each, it had the second longest cantilever spans in the country and the fourth longest in the world. Among suspension bridges in the United States, only four had spans exceeding In the late and however, several bridges were constructed which surpassed the Carquinez Bridge in span length, including two cantilever trusses and one steel arch design.

The Longview Bridge in Washington State was a cantilever truss with a span, constructed in In the cities of Oakland and San Francisco were joined by the Bay Bridge, which included a cantilever segment with a center span of The Bayonne Bridge in New Jersey, completed in was the only steel arch bridge with spans exceeding that of the Carquinez Bridge. It was the largest steel arch bridge constructed up to that time, with a span.88 While incremental increases were being made in the size of cantilever bridges, substantial increases in the length of suspension bridges were leaving all other bridge types out of the competition for the longest spans.

The Ambassador Bridge connecting the United States and Canada at Detroit briefly held the record, with its span surpassing the Ben Franklin Bridge by The George Washington Bridge in New York City, completed in dramatically surpassed this record with a span of nearly double that of the Ambassador Bridge.90 San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge of set a new record with a main span of which was not surpassed until the completion of the slightly longer Verrazano Narrows Bridge in At the time that the Carquinez Bridge was being designed, it was recognized as one of the largest highway bridge projects yet undertaken in the United States, and the largest west of the Mississippi.

Also at this time, the cantilever truss type had fallen somewhat out of favor with bridge engineers, primarily because of problems in the construction of two earlier long-span cantilever truss bridges. The collapse of the Quebec Bridge during construction in was caused by the buckling of truss compression members on the south cantilever arm, resulting in the death of eighty-two workers. In the aftermath of this disaster, bridge engineers conducted more experiments on larger bridge components, more attention was paid to the design and construction of truss joints, and more analysis was done on secondary stresses caused by deflection of the structure under its own weight.

The Quebec Bridge was redesigned and construction resumed several years later, this time with the cantilever span lifted into place from barges using hydraulic jacks, rather than being extended out from the cantilever arms as in the original design. A second tragedy occurred in during the lifting operation, when the cantilever span, weighing tons, had been lifted about 12' before slipping off its supports r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 23 and falling into the river. This time eleven men were killed.

A new suspended span was constructed and successfully lifted into place in bringing to a conclusion a long and troubled process.93 The Queensboro Bridge was nearing completion at the time of the first Quebec disaster, and was hastily redesigned to reduce the dead load of the structure prior to being opened for traffic.94 Although the Queensboro Bridge was completed without experiencing the spectacular failures of the Quebec Bridge, the redesign and cost overruns contributed to the sense that the cantilever truss was a bridge type fraught with difficulties. Following the completion of the Queensboro Bridge in no major cantilever truss bridges were constructed in the United States until the Carquinez Bridge went up in the mid-1920s. Selection of a bridge type: cantilever truss vs.

suspension Both cantilever truss and suspension bridge designs were initially considered for the Carquinez Strait crossing. Five different preliminary studies were developed by Derleth between October and the granting of a franchise by Contra Costa County in February Three of these were for suspension bridges and two were cantilever designs.95 At the November hearing before the War Department, the American Toll Bridge Company presented plans for a suspension bridge with a main span of As described above, there was substantial objection to this design from shipping interests, who considered the location of the south tower to be a hazard to Navigation.

By February Derleth had narrowed the alternatives to two: a cantilever truss bridge with two main spans of each, and a suspension bridge with a main span of Both designs had their south piers behind (south of) the northern edge of the Crockett piers, in response to concerns about navigation.97 These two designs were presented to both the county Board of Supervisors and the War Department. The franchise granted by Contra Costa County stated that the bridge was to be a suspension Oft structure, unless a different type of bridge was specified by the War Department. In its application to the War Department, the American Toll Bridge Company requested approval of both designs, so that the final decision could be based on more detailed cost estimates, to be prepared after further design studies.

However, the application stated a preference for the cantilever truss bridge: We most strongly urge the cantilever type, Plan A; and if only one plan can be approved, we earnestly ask for consideration and approval of the cantilever scheme. It is the most economical; in our judgement it fits the location best; structurally it adapts itself most satisfactorily to traffic; it is stiffer than the suspension type, both for moving loads and laterally against wind forces.99 C CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 24 In April, Derleth sent additional information to the War Department, providing more detail on his reasons for preferring the cantilever to the suspension design.

Among the several reasons given by Derleth were that the cantilever design would be simpler and faster to construct, allowing the company to open the bridge and begin earning revenue sooner. The expectation that the bridge would probably carry a trolley line at some time also made the greater stiffness of the cantilever design preferable to the more flexible suspension design. In addition, the wire cables required for a suspension bridge were of a particular grade of steel not widely available. Derleth noted that "the firm of John Roebling's Sons has a virtual monopoly on this wire.

By contrast, there are many potential suppliers of steel for a cantilever bridge, resulting in price competition and lower cost."100 One reason that the cantilever bridge was considered simpler and less costly to construct was that a suspension bridge with a single main span would have only two major piers, compared to three for the cantilever design. Consequently, each of the suspension span piers would have to carry substantially more weight and would therefore need to be larger. Since construction of pier foundations in the strait was one of the most technically difficult and expensive issues facing the bridge's designers, preference was given to the cantilever design.

Another difficulty with the suspension bridge design was the expense and difficulty of constructing the required cable anchorages at the north and south ends of the bridge.101 When David Steinman was hired as Design Engineer in May he wanted to reconsider the question of what type of bridge to build, in spite of Derleth's clear preference for the cantilever design. Steinman's specialty was suspension bridges, and he had only the previous year assisted Charles Fowler in developing the San Francisco Transit Company's proposal for a suspension bridge across the Carquinez Strait.

This proposed bridge was to have a main span of which would have made it the third longest suspension span in the United States.102 After being hired by the American Toll Bridge Company, Steinman expressed his preference for the suspension bridge alternative, with its main span, rather than the cantilever truss structure with its two shorter spans. An ambitious man with a keen interest in breaking records, Steinman was undoubtedly attracted to the suspension design in part because it would have been the longest bridge span in world at that time.

According to Steinman's biographer, discussions between Derleth and Steinman on the issue of whether to build a cantilever or suspension bridge sometimes "turned into full-scale arguments."103 In the end, however, it was Derleth who had the ultimate authority over all design decisions, and he overruled Steinman on this issue. Design refinements and details The cantilever truss design had been presented in preliminary form to both the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors and the War Department, as part of the application for the r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 25 franchise.

An artist's rendering showing the proposed structure is dated May and was published in the San Francisco Examiner on May The rendering shows that the proposed bridge was similar in its overall configuration to the structure as actually built. Since this was before Steinman had been hired as design engineer, it is clear that the overall form of the structure and length of its spans was originally conceived by Derleth, possibly in consultation with Burr. Steinman's task was to complete the working drawings for the structure, refining the original conception and working out all of the details.

The preliminary rendering shows a much heavier structure than the bridge as actually built, with more boldly scaled vertical and diagonal truss members, as well as heavier pier towers topped with decorative finials. It also shows fewer (but therefore longer) truss panels, with a correspondingly greater height for the superstructure. In the rendering, the top chords of the truss anchor arms and cantilever arms incline in strait lines to the tops of the pier towers, and the top chords of the suspended spans are parallel to the bottom chords. The bridge as actually constructed, however, has a gentle concave curvature to the truss top chords in the anchor arms and cantilever arms, and the suspended spans have a convex, "camel back" curvature.

The visual result is a more gently undulating structure, which appears lighter and more graceful than the early rendering. The total height of the superstructure on the completed bridge is only slightly greater than the distance from the water up to the truss bottom chords, whereas in the rendering the superstructure appears to be about twice as tall, dwarfing the supporting piers beneath the roadway. In addition, the truss members of the completed bridge are lighter than those depicted in the preliminary design, with the pier towers in particular being noticeably lighter and without the ornamental finials.

It appears that Derleth was not entirely happy with this result, as he remarked in a letter to Burr on October "had I more money at my command in the beginning and had I been guided solely by my sense of proportion, I should have made these towers 2 and 4 heavier. ... I wanted greater longitudinal stiffness.

I must rely on it chiefly from pier The final design for the bridge and the contract drawings were developed by Steinman and his staff at his New York office, in consultation with Derleth and Burr, from May through December Three different cantilever truss designs were initially developed and studied, differing in their width, height, proportions, and truss configurations.106 The most economical design was determined from these studies, meeting the required engineering criteria for strength and stiffness with the least material. The initial bridge designs had a width of 35' between the centerlines of the trusses. However, increasing the width to 42' provided additional stiffness in the superstructure and allowed for the inclusion of two sidewalks in addition to the 30' roadway.

The additional cost to make the CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 26 bridge T wider was calculated to be which was considered a prudent expense to achieve the additional structural stiffness and provide for sidewalks. By comparison, the cost of adding a single sidewalk on brackets attached to the outside of one of the trusses was calculated tobe$172,000.107 In designing the suspended spans, the most economical length was determined to be taking into consideration only the cost of the structural steel required. However, when construction methods were taken into consideration, the spans were shortened to Since it was anticipated that these spans would be lifted into place from barges in the strait, the shorter spans would be easier and less expensive to lift.

It was also determined that the curved top chords of these trusses, which allow for a lighter structure without loss of strength, would result in a savings of about compared to trusses with straight, horizontal top chords.108 The possibility of future electric rail traffic on the bridge was anticipated from the earliest planning stages. The bridge was designed to accommodate the load on the structure from a single rail line down the center lane.

Longitudinal joints were included in the deck slab to facilitate removal of the slab from the center lane and its replacement with rail tracks.109 Rail facilities were never installed, however, since interurban rail service was never extended to Crockett and the era of trolley transportation was being rapidly eclipsed by private auto ownership during the period that the bridge was under construction. The Carquinez Bridge was the first major bridge in the United States designed with seismic forces taken into consideration.110 The bridge expansion joints were carefully designed to limit excessive movement, and hydraulic buffers were installed to resist earthquake forces. Six of these hydraulic buffers, each long, were located at critical expansion joints in the bridge superstructure.

The bottom chords of each of the two side trusses had buffers at three locations: the shore-side connections of the suspended spans to the cantilever arms, and at tower 5 (where the bridge meets the south approach viaduct). These buffers were designed to allow slow movement due to thermal expansion, but resist the rapid movement induced by an earthquake.111 2.5 Construction of the bridge Construction of the Carquinez Bridge began in April following approval of the plans by the state engineer of California in February of that year.

For the next four years, it was one of the major construction projects in the San Francisco Bay Area, predating by a decade the construction of the Golden Gate and San Francisco-Oakland Bay bridges and other major public works projects of the Erection of the bridge required a substantial amount of preliminary construction, including a dock on the Crockett side of the strait which served as a loading and staging area as well as a construction platform. In addition, a large portion of the flat shoreline CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 27 area at the south end of the bridge, with direct access for deliveries by the adjacent Southern Pacific Railroad, was set aside for the storage of equipment and materials.

Substructure Construction of pier 1, the north abutment, required a large amount of preliminary excavation. The steep face of the north shore, a virtual cliff, was lowered 30' by blasting and hauling away cubic yards of earth, which was used in the construction of connecting roads.113 Blasting was also used to create a horizontal shelf of exposed rock to serve as a base for the concrete abutment. After the ground was shaped as needed, building the abutment was a straightforward exercise in reinforced concrete construction, which began at the end of August It was construction of piers 2 and 3 in the deep and swift waters of the Carquinez Strait which posed the biggest challenge to the engineers and contractors.

The current in the strait is sometimes as high as T per second, but varies throughout the depth of the channel, complicating the task of accurately placing the caissons for these piers.115 In addition, the strait is at times heavily infested with teredos, a type of shipworm which is a voracious consumer of wood. Piers 2 and 3 are founded on concrete caissons which extend down to bedrock, about below the mean high water level in the Carquinez Strait. These were the deepest water piers ever constructed for a bridge up to that time, a record which was later surpassed by the Golden Gate and Bay Bridges.116 In order to keep the caissons upright and properly positioned in the strait, steel guide frames were constructed at the locations of piers 2 and 3.

Each guide frame was constructed by driving steel columns, each long and weighing thirty tons, into the mud at the bottom of the channel. The columns extended up through the 80* to 90' of water in the strait, with the tops of the columns exposed above the water. The columns were then fastened together with a framework of steel, and reinforced with horizontal and vertical wood trusses. The completed frame was secured in place by four anchor barges, connected by cables to the corners of the guide frame and pulling the frame simultaneously in four directions. There were six columns for each guide frame, two on the east and west sides and one on the north and south sides.

The west, north, and east sides of the frame were constructed first, and then the caisson was floated into place through the open south side. The south column was then driven and the guide frame completed. The frame had interior dimensions of 46* x allowing 3" of clearance on all sides around the 40' x 40' caisson. A total of six guide frames were needed for the two caissons at pier 2 and four caissons at pier 3. In order to conserve materials, only two guide frames were built, and each was dismantled and reconstructed three times. The caissons consisted of reinforced timber cribs with four dredging wells, each 8* square, from which mud and clay could be excavated as the caisson sank into the bed of the strait. The timber CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 28 crib was a hollow framework which surrounded and separated the four dredging wells. Extensive precautions were taken to protect the timber caissons against the teredo. During construction, each caisson was coated with a wood preservative (a mixture of asphalt and creosote) followed by a layer of tarred felt and another coat of preservative. The structure was then covered with an outer layer of wood planking, and a coat of preservative on this outer layer. It was anticipated that this treatment would allow the wood caisson to last for at least a year, which would provide plenty of time to finish pouring the concrete. Concrete was poured into the caisson in stages as it sank from the bottom of the strait through 45* to 55* of material at channel bottom, until it reached bedrock.

After the caisson had cut through the channel bottom and reached bedrock, the dredging wells were also filled with concrete. A concrete mixing plant was set up on a barge so that it could be floated out to the pier locations, to avoid the costly process of transporting large quantities of concrete from the shore. The bottom of the caisson tapered to a narrow cutting edge to facilitate its sinking through the mud and clay at the bottom of the channel. The cutting edge of the first two cribs was relatively blunt, with a horizontal face about 10" wide. Subsequent caissons were built with a much narrower cutting edge, just the thickness of two steel plates riveted together.

The narrower cutting edge reduced the time required to sink the caisson to bedrock, but the more blunt-edged caissons proved to be more stable and were easier to keep in a vertical position during sinking. To aid in the sinking of the caissons, a water jet system consisting of a network of 2H" and 4" diameter pipes was installed inside the timber crib structure. These pipes fed nozzles along the outside of the crib. Water pumped through the jets at the bottom of the caisson made the bed material more slippery and easier for the caisson to cut through, while the jets along the side walls reduced the surface friction between the caisson and the bed material.

The water jet system reduced the time required for sinking of the caissons, but proved to have been significantly overdesigned, providing much more water than was necessary to aid in sinking the caissons. The water jet system was designed by H. F. Topping, while the timber caissons were designed by George C. Haun. Sinking the caissons was a slow and methodical process. The work of the water jets, combined with excavation from the dredging wells and the increasing weight of the caisson as more concrete was added, resulted in the caissons sinking at an average rate ofjust 6" per eight-hour work shift. The only problem occurred during me sinking of the first caisson.

On September 22, when it had reached below water level (through 30' to 40* of the channel bottom), the caisson suddenly tilted 13' to the south. The guide frame also deflected from the weight of the caisson leaning against it. The caisson was righted by pulling cables attached to the top of the north wall, while simultaneously using the water jets on the north side only and excavating CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 29 material from the two north dredging wells. Three days of work were required before the caisson began to tilt back to the north, and it was not completely restored to a vertical position until October 4. After this frustrating experience, no further problems were encountered in the construction of piers 2 and 3.

Pier 4, located in relatively shallow water near the south shore of the strait, does not have a caisson foundation. This pier consists of reinforced concrete piles supporting a concrete footing, which in turn supports two pier shafts which are similar in appearance to those of piers 2 and 3. Pier 4 was constructed by installing a cofferdam around the pier location and dewatering inside the cofferdam to provide a dry work area to construct the footing. What was expected to be a simpler process turned out to be much more frustrating, however, due to the lack of a watertight seal at the bottom of the wood cofferdam.

The cofferdam was attacked by teredos and became porous, and there was also leakage at the bottom of the cofferdam caused by erosion of the soft bottom of the strait by the swift current. As a result, construction of the concrete tremie seal at the bottom of the cofferdam was hampered by concrete washing out of the porous structure, and the initial construction was unacceptably weak as a result. Much of the concrete in the pier 4 footing ultimately had to be removed and replaced, an embarrassing and costly problem that led to the replacement of the original foundation contractor, Duncanson and Harrelson of San Francisco.

This firm worked on the bridge project from summer until February They had completed the foundations for piers 1 (the north abutment) and 5, and portions of piers 3 and 6, in addition to the rejected work on pier 4. Duncanson and Harrelson also built the construction wharf on the Crockett side of the strait. In April the foundation work was taken over and completed by the Missouri Valley Bridge and Iron Company of Leavenworth, Kansas.119 Superstructure The contract to erect the bridge's steel superstructure was awarded to the American Bridge Company, a subsidiary of the United States Steel Corporation.120 Bridge components were assembled at a dock on the south side of the Strait in Crockett, and lifted into place from barges.

The north anchor arm, extending from the north abutment to pier 2, posed a construction challenge because the depth of water in the strait precluded the use of falsework (temporary supports) except in the area closest to the abutment, above the steeply sloping hillside. Falsework was erected on the hillside to support the truss superstructure only between the north abutment and panel point 8 (not quite halfway to pier 2). Beyond this point, the superstructure was cantilevered out over the water in stages until it reached pier 2. The completed anchor arm then served as support for the cantilever arm, which was extended south in stages from pier 2.

On the south side of the bridge, the shallow water allowed for the simpler method of using falsework for the construction of both the anchor arm (between piers 4 and 5) and the cantilever r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 30 arm extending north from pier The double cantilever arm in the center of the bridge, extending north and south from pier 3, was constructed in a manner similar to the north cantilever arm. To maintain an even distribution of weight on the pier supports, the two cantilever arms were built simultaneously from the long superstructure atop the pier.

With the completion of the cantilever arms, the bridge consisted of three separate structures, each centered on one of the major piers, awaiting the installation of the two suspended spans to link these separate components into a single bridge. The most dramatic aspect of the Carquinez Bridge construction project was the lifting of the two suspended spans. Each of the suspended spans was long and weighed 620 tons, and had to be lifted more than up to the level of the bridge cantilever arms. A great deal of planning and calculation was required to ensure the success of this critical operation, with the Quebec Bridge disaster of fresh in the minds of the engineers and contractors.122 The suspended spans were constructed on falsework over shallow water on the Crockett side of the strait.

When ready for lifting, the suspended spans were transferred to barges by floating the barges under the structure at low tide. The barges, constructed specifically for this job, were equipped with jacks which lifted the truss off the falsework. The suspended span truss structure, supported at each end by one of the barges, was then pulled by four tugboats into the middle of the strait and into position below the bridge cantilever arms. In order to reduce the weight of the structure to be lifted, the suspended spans were initially constructed with only the two side trusses, transverse bracing connecting the truss top chords, and floor beams connecting the truss bottom chords.

(The floor stringers and decking were added after the suspended spans had been lifted into place.) With the barges anchored in place, the suspended spans were ready for lifting. The suspended spans were hoisted into place using cables in a block-and-tackle system, with sand-filled boxes as counterweights. With cables temporarily connected to the ends of the cantilever arms, the counterweights were lifted from barges using an electric hoist. Four counterweights were used to lift the suspended span, each consisting of a wooden box approximately 14' square and 19' deep and weighing more than 150 tons when filled with sand.

The combined weight of the four boxes was slightly more than the weight of the suspended span, in order to overcome friction and inertia and allow for the smooth lifting of the truss structure. With the counterweights in place, their weight was transferred to cables which were connected to the corners of the suspended span truss. With the cables running through pulleys attached to the ends of the cantilever arms, the counterweights could then be slowly lowered to waiting barges, lifting the suspended span up to the level of the bridge superstructure. Some of the complexities of the lifting operation included taking into account an expected deflection in the cantilever arms under the combined weight of the suspended span and counterweights, a calculated 18" CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 31 elongation of the wire cables, and the fact that the barges would rise 21" in the water as the weight of the suspended span was lifted from them. The north suspended span, between piers 2 and 3, was lifted first, on March No problems were encountered in the lifting, and the process took less than an hour. The south suspended span was lifted two weeks later, on March 19, and took only about thirty minutes. The openings for the suspended spans were two panel lengths longer than the suspended span trusses themselves. After the suspended span was lifted into position, it was connected by steel eyebars extending vertically from the top chord of the cantilever arm to the bottom chord of the suspended span.

The remaining gap at each end of the suspended span was then bridged across the top and bottom chords to form a continuous structure. After completion of the truss superstructure (including the addition of floor beams, stringers, and diagonal bracing) a rail track was laid down the center of the bridge to expedite the delivery of materials to be used in constructing the roadway deck. The concrete deck slab was poured in sections on either side of the track, using a rail-mounted concrete hopper.

After completion of the two outside lanes, the track was removed in sections and the deck slab installed in the middle lane.123 Center pier protective fender During construction of the Carquinez Bridge, shipping interests and the C&H Sugar Company resumed their complaints about bridge piers in the strait posing a hazard to navigation. They appealed to the War Department, requesting that it order the American Toll Bridge Company to install protective fenders around the bridge piers, particularly at pier 3, the large center pier in the middle of the strait.

As described by Charles Derleth, discussions over this issue were acrimonious, and the navigation interests were consistently critical of the American Toll Bridge Company's proposed solutions.124 In November the War Department advised the Toll Bridge Company that it would be necessary to install some kind of pier protection.125 While plans for protective fenders were being drawn up and debated, the Toll Bridge Company anchored eight barges around pier 3, four upstream and four downstream. The barges were connected by cables, forming a sort of net for restraining errant ships.126 The company's opponents thought this inadequate, even as a temporary measure, and sought an injunction in federal court in early to prevent the opening of the bridge to traffic.

Although the request for an injunction was denied, the Toll Bridge Company removed the barges in May replacing them with four old wooden sailing vessels. The four ships were loaded with rock ballast and equipped with lights and fog signals. The War Department held hearings in Washington in summer and fall concerning the construction of permanent fenders. By this time, David Steinman's tenure as design engineer CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 32 had come to an end, and the Toll Bridge Company hired the engineers Frank G. White and Harry E.

Squire of San Francisco, working under Derleth's direction, to come up with a permanent solution.130 The engineers developed several different proposals for the fender at pier 3, "all of which were severely criticized by Navigation interests," according to Derleth. In September, the War Department granted a permit for the design that was eventually built, conditioned on the review and approval of detailed plans. This final review occurred in late January putting an end to the controversy.133 The fender as built was shaped like a pointed ellipse, designed to deflect an oncoming ship and result in a glancing rather than direct impact. The design included radial and circumferential girders of reinforced concrete, as well as a reinforced concrete deck slab.

The deck slab was intended to cut into any colliding ship, helping to bring it to a halt before it can collide with the bridge piers. The concrete fender was constructed around and connected to the concrete portion of the bridge piers, making the whole structure a single unit.

It was long in the east-west direction and from north to south.134 (The fender has since been enlarged to incorporate the center pier of the parallel bridge, constructed in Construction of the fender included placing tons of rock fill around the bridge piers at the channel bottom, and driving 454 reinforced concrete piles to support the lemon-shaped fender.135 Work was begun by the Healy- Tibbits Construction Company in July and was completed in December Cost Various figures have been given for the cost of constructing the Carquinez Bridge.

A report by the California Highway Commission listed the amounts of the various construction contracts, totaling Of this amount, about 45 percent was for foundation work, with about 55 percent going toward the steel superstructure and concrete roadway deck.

Engineering and inspection costs totaled equal to about 7 percent of the construction contracts.138 Additional costs included acquisition of right-of-way in Crockett, business expenses such as bond financing, and the cost of the center pier protective fender (which was not completed until The center pier fender was built at a cost of over (plus the cost of installing and removing the two versions of temporary pier protection) which was a significant portion of the entire bridge construction cost and well in excess of the American Toll Bridge Company's initial expectations.

In addition, the American Toll Bridge Company contributed to Solano County's cost of improving the road at the north end of the bridge, and to the state's cost of improving Highway 14 (San Pablo Avenue) in Contra Costa County to handle the anticipated increase in traffic.140 The San Francisco Examiner stated at the time of the bridge's opening that it cost $8 million to build, a figure which must have included engineering fees and business expenses, but would not CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 33 have included the center pier fender.141 Charles Derleth stated in that the bridge cost to build, a figure which undoubtedly included engineering fees and all construction costs, but may or may not have included the American Toll Bridge Company's business expenses.142 2.6 Operation of the bridge American Toll Bridge Company, The Carquinez Bridge was opened for traffic on May a week before the official opening ceremony which had been scheduled for May Aven Hanford, who along with Oscar Klatt was the person most responsible for bringing the Carquinez Bridge from vision to reality, did not live to see the completion of the structure.

Hanford died at his home in Berkeley on the morning of October Following Hanford's death, Klatt assumed the presidency of the American Toll Bridge Company, while George Calder was made vice- president and general manager. Calder was at that time the company's resident engineer on the Carquinez Bridge job, with primary responsibility for management of the construction process and oversight of the contractors.145 The grand opening festivities included sailboat and motorboat races, rowing competitions, and an aerial show performed by a squad of airplanes.

The dedication, by the widow of Aven Hanford, began at pm, followed by speeches by the governors of California, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington.146 The presence of dignitaries from other states was an indication of the regional importance of the new bridge, particularly as an important link in the automobile and truck route along the coast from California to the Pacific Northwest, as this was a decade before the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge in In fact, the cover of the opening day program shows a bear (the symbol of California) standing in front of the flags of Canada, the United States, and Mexico, with the slogan "uniting three flags."147 Charles Derleth called the new bridge "the most spectacular structure yet built west of the Mississippi River" and noted that there were only three other cantilever bridges in the world of comparable size.148 At pm, after an hour of speeches, President Calvin Coolidge turned a key in Washington that set off fireworks at the center pier and unfurled an American flag.149 An estimated vehicles lined up to drive across the new bridge that day.150 In spite of the significance of the occasion, the grand opening was bumped off the front pages of the newspapers by Charles Lindbergh, who completed his Trans-Atlantic flight on the same day.

The opening of the Carquinez Bridge (replacing the former ferry service) closed a gap in two important West Coast auto routes: the north-south route of the Pacific Coast Highway, extending from Mexico to Canada, and the east-west route from the Bay Area to Sacramento and all points CARQUEMEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 34 east. The designated route of the Lincoln Highway, established in as the first coast-to-coast auto road, was shifted from its original route between Oakland and Sacramento via Stockton, taking advantage of the shorter route across the Carquinez Bridge.151 With the cessation of ferry service between Rodeo and Vallejo, the company's two boats were sold to other ferry lines operating on San Francisco Bay waters.

The San Jose was sold to the Richmond-San Rafael Ferry Company, which carried out an extensive refurbishing and rechristened it the Sonoma Valley. The Issaquah was acquired by the Martinez-Benicia Ferry Company, which continued in operation until The City of Martinez took over the company's property and operated the ferry until when it was taken over in turn by the State of California. With the opening of the Benicia-Martinez Bridge in the state ceased operation of the ferry between these two cities, which marked the end of auto ferry service in the San Francisco Bay Area.153 Auto travel across the Carquinez Bridge immediately exceeded expectations. More than vehicles made the crossing on Memorial Day with no significant delays.

This was about twice the 24-hour capacity of the former Rodeo-Vallejo ferry.154 The first nine days of toll collection brought in more than equal to about one-twelfth of the annual revenue that had been projected for the purpose of financing the revenue bonds.155 The bridge's first full fiscal year of operation, from July through June saw 1.1 million vehicles make the toll crossing.

The American Toll Bridge Company received more than in toll revenue during this period, more than 50 percent above the projected revenue and approximately three times the company's expenses.156 As of July with the bridge in operation for a little more than one year, the Carquinez Bridge was getting an estimated 80 percent of the traffic across the Strait, while the Antioch Bridge was getting 11 percent and the Benicia-Martinez Ferry (the last remaining ferry service across the Strait) was getting just 9 percent.157 Traffic on the Carquinez Bridge continued to increase to then declined by about 25 percent 1 CO from to due to the depression.

Use of the bridge rebounded after however, increasing annually to total of more than 2 million vehicles in The opening of the Golden Gate Bridge in did not result in a drop in traffic on the Carquinez Bridge, but only briefly slowed the trend of significant annual increases. The number of vehicles using the bridge increased by only 2.4 percent from to compared to an increase of about 17 percent between and and more than 13 percent between and Even this brief slowdown from to may be more attributable to economic factors than to competition from the Golden Gate Bridge. The initial toll rate established for the Carquinez Bridge, 60 cents per car plus 10 cents per person, was based on the rate previously charged by the ferry service.15 (The practice of r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 35 charging for both the vehicle and passengers was consistent with the way ferry tolls were traditionally calculated.) At $1 each way for a party of four, the toll was a subject of much complaint among motorists. Criticism of the "excessive" toll and calls for public ownership of the Carquinez Bridge began to appear in Bay Area newspapers in after the bridge had been in operation for ten years. These complaints were probably stimulated by the opening of the Golden Gate and San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridges, both of which were publicly owned and had lower tolls than the smaller Carquinez Bridge.

The San Francisco Chronicle editorialized in March that the state of California should acquire the bridge and pay for its maintenance from the state's gasoline tax, arguing that the bridge toll on a state highway and the gasoline tax amounted to double taxation.160 In September of that year, a Chronicle article referred to "a storm of protest against the prevailing toll rates on the bridge."161 Lt. Governor George Hatfield publicly suggested a month later that the California Toll Bridge Authority build a second, parallel span if the existing bridge could not be purchased by the state at a reasonable price.162 The State of California passed legislation in which declared toll bridges to be public utilities, subject to the authority of the State Railroad Commission.

The Commission scheduled a hearing in October of that year to take testimony related to tolls on all four of the state's private toll bridges - the Dumbarton, San Mateo, Carquinez, and Antioch, all of which were in the San Francisco Bay Area.163 After studying the finances of the Carquinez Bridge, the Commission ordered a reduction in tolls in February from 60 cents per vehicle plus 10 cents per passenger (including the driver) to 45 cents per vehicle and 5 cents per passenger.164 The American Toll Bridge Company challenged the Commission's authority to regulate tolls on its bridges, but the California Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Commission on September 27, This decision was upheld by the U.S.

Supreme Court on June Following the Supreme Court decision, the American Toll Bridge Company was required to refund in excess tolls collected over the fifteen months since the initial decision of the Railroad Commission. Twenty additional clerks were hired temporarily to process and mail refund checks, averaging 65 cents each, to motorists who had paid the higher tolls. The last of the refund checks were mailed after five months of effort, in late October This was not the end of complaints about the Carquinez Bridge tolls, however. Only a week after the American Toll Bridge Company had finished mailing out refund checks, Frank Clark, Director of the State Department of Public Works, declared that his department would begin assembling data to support a substantial reduction in bridge tolls.

However, rather than relying on the regulatory power of the State Railroad Commission to further reduce tolls on the Carquinez Bridge, the state purchased the bridge from the American Toll Bridge Company in C CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 36 Acquisition and operation by the State of California, Although the state did not acquire the Carquinez Bridge until the California Highway Commission investigated the economics of public vs. private ownership of toll bridges in at the request of the state legislature. Privately owned toll bridges in California at that time included the Dumbarton, San Mateo, Carquinez, and Antioch bridges in the San Francisco Bay Area, and the Ehrenburg Bridge over the Colorado River between California and Arizona.

The Highway Commission's report to the legislature described the legal basis for the construction of the private toll bridges: It is found that the laws relating to the right to operate toll bridges and the granting of franchises therefore, date back to the Political Code and Statutes of relating to bridges over navigable streams.

No amendments have since been made which change the principle of application of these laws which are based upon the idea of delegating these rights to the counties, and therefore are found to be more or less incompatible with the existing idea of a state highway system.169 The report went on to state that with respect to the Carquinez Bridge in particular, "public officials failed to recognize the necessity of building a publicly owned structure."170 It was concluded that public financing of bridge construction is less costly primarily because the state can issue revenue bonds at a lower rate of interest than corporations can issue stock or bonds, because of the lower risk to investors.

The cost of bond financing and interest for the privately constructed Carquinez and Antioch bridges was stated as 8.7 percent, considerably higher than the interest on government bonds.

In addition, the report stated that the American Toll Bridge Company spent more than million on promotion and organization (incorporation, legal fees, the cost of issuing and selling stock, etc.) for the two bridges, and estimated that these costs would have totaled only if the bridges had been constructed by the state.171 The Highway Commission concluded that all future bridge construction on state highways, or roads that might become state highways, should be undertaken by the state, that the construction of privately owned toll bridges should be prohibited, and that the Highway Commission should be given the power to acquire existing toll bridges.

It was further suggested that the state could acquire the Carquinez Bridge and lower tolls while still generating sufficient revenue from tolls to pay for continued maintenance and amortize the revenue bonds issued for the acquisition.172 In response to the California Highway Commission's report to the legislature, the California Toll Bridge Authority Act was passed in This act declared it the policy of the State of California to acquire and operate all toll bridges on state highways.173 However, the stock CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 37 market crash in October of that year and the onset of the Great Depression delayed acquisition of the Carquinez Bridge for more than a decade.

Additional legislation was passed in authorizing the California Toll Bridge Authority to purchase the state's existing toll bridges.174 The Authority voted to begin negotiations for the purchase of the Carquinez and Antioch bridges in March of that year.175 However, negotiations were not concluded until May of when the Toll Bridge Authority offered the American Toll Bridge Company for the two bridges. The company's board of directors accepted the state's offer on May 20, and the stockholders voted to approve the sale on June The purchase price was based on the anticipated future revenue from the date of purchase to the expiration of the franchise in The value of the bridges as physical assets was not considered, since they were to revert to Contra Costa County at the end of the franchise.

The state sold revenue bonds, bearing interest of only about VA percent, for the purchase of the American Toll Bridge Company's assets. The bonds were expected to be retired by toll revenues in seven to eight years, after which the bridge was to be operated without tolls.177 Some critics of the state's action noted that the Carquinez and Antioch bridges were to revert to public ownership anyway in early about the same time that the state would retire the bonds issued for their acquisition.

The state, said these critics, was "buying dead horses."178 However, acquisition of the bridges by the state had the advantage of allowing tolls to be reduced, which was estimated at the time to save motorists a total of $3 million over the eight years from the date of acquisition to the original expiration date of the franchise.179 The State of California assumed ownership of the Carquinez Bridge on September and immediately replaced the American Toll Bridge Company's toll collectors with state employees.180 Effective December 16 of that year, tolls were reduced to 30 cents per car.181 Bridge traffic increased dramatically in the first years of the stimulated by increased activity at the Mare Island Naval Shipyard in Vallejo.

Bridge traffic in June was 88 percent 1 1 higher than for June of the previous year. During the first twenty months of state ownership (through April the bridge carried more than 7 million vehicles, compared to slightly less than 19 million vehicles during the entire thirteen years of ownership by the American Toll Bridge Company.

With such a dramatic increase in traffic, bridge tolls were reduced again in June to 25 cents per car.184 On August with the state's revenue bonds retired earlier than anticipated, the collection of tolls on the Carquinez Bridge was discontinued entirely.185 Incorporation into the freeway and construction of a parallel span Traffic on the Carquinez Bridge continued to increase in the post-war years, with the growth of auto ownership and rapid suburban development. By traffic on the bridge exceeded 10 r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 38 million vehicles per year, compared to just over 1 million during the bridge's first full year of operation.186 This was the era of freeway building, and in the California legislature authorized the state's Division of Highways to construct a second, parallel span at the Carquinez Strait, with both bridges to be incorporated into a new freeway.187 More than eight miles of new freeway construction was carried out in Contra Costa County, extending the Eastshore Freeway (originally U.S. 40, now from Richmond to Crockett, bypassing the original route along San Pablo Avenue through the communities of Pinole, Hercules, and Rodeo. This construction included the "big cut," southwest of Crockett, the largest earth moving project undertaken by the Division of Highways to that time.

In order to reduce the freeway grade over the rolling terrain, a cut through the hills involved the excavation of more than 8.5 million cubic yards of earth. The cut was deep, with 2/1 side slopes and 30' wide benches for every 60' of depth. The resulting "V" notch through the hills was more than tt-mile wide at the top.188 Construction contracts for the second bridge were awarded in including million for the substructure and million for the superstructure, as well as separate contracts for the I QQ Crockett interchange and construction of a new toll plaza. The superstructure contract was awarded to the American Bridge division of U.S. Steel, the same company that erected the superstructure of the bridge.

The second Carquinez Bridge was completed and opened to traffic on November Because the new bridge was financed by revenue bonds, toll collection was reinstated on the Carquinez crossing in thirteen years after the elimination of tolls on the original structure. The initial toll was 25 cents per car, with trucks charged according to the number of axles.192 Beginning in the State of California increased tolls from $1 to $2 per car on seven of the Bay Area toll bridges to finance seismic retrofit work, construction of the new Carquinez and Benicia-Martinez Bridges, and replacement of the eastern portion of the San Francisco - Oakland Bay Bridge.

(The Golden Gate Bridge, which is operated by a separate public agency, already had a $3 toll.) The twin spans of the Carquinez Strait crossing presently carry an average of vehicles per day.193 The bridge does not meet current seismic safety standards, has a substandard roadway width for its three lanes of freeway traffic, and would be difficult to retrofit without extended closures. Consequently, the California Department of Transportation (successor organization to the Division of Highways) has begun construction of a new bridge to replace the structure. The new bridge will be a suspension span, parallel to and just west of the bridge. The freeway will be realigned to connect with the new bridge, and the Crockett interchange will be reconstructed.

The new suspension bridge will have its two main piers r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 39 aligned with piers 2 and 4 of the existing bridges, giving it a center span of This new bridge, the third structure to be built across the Carquinez Strait between Crockett and Vallejo, is expected to be completed in The bridge will then be taken down after seventy-six years of service. I CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 40 3.

Notes

Section 1: 1 The dimensions given throughout Section 1 are taken from microfiche copies of the original drawings, on file at Caltrans' District 4 office in Oakland. Much descriptive information can also be found in two articles from Engineering News-Record: Derleth, Charles. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait." September 24, pp. Steinman, David B. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge." May pp. 2 Microfiche copies of construction plans, Caltrans* District 4 office, Oakland. Also Hollister, Leonard C. "Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Tests Ingenuity of Engineers." California Highways and Public Works, Mar.-Apr. pp. 3 Microfiche copies of construction plans, Caltrans' District 4 office, Oakland.

Also "Corrosion Closes Bridge for Repair." Engineering News-Record, October p. 16. 4 Microfiche copies of construction plans, Caltrans' District 4 office, Oakland. Also, the new bridge is described in the following articles by Hollister in California Highways and Public Works: "Carquinez Project: Revenue Bonds Sold and Major Contracts Awarded." Jan.-Feb. pp. "New Parallel Bridge." Jan.-Feb. pp. "Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Test Ingenuity of Engineers." Jan.-Feb. pp. "Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Test Ingenuity of Engineers." Mar.-Apr. pp. 5 Hollister. "New Parallel Bridge." California Highways and Public Works, Jan.-Feb. p. 6. Section 6 Derleth. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait." Engineering News-Record, September p. 7 Harlan, George H.

San Francisco Bay Ferryboats. Berkeley: Howell-North Books, p. 17. 8 Ibid., p. 99. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 41 9 Ibid., p. 10 Ibid., p. 145 & 11 Ibid., p. 145 & 12 Ibid., p. 13 Ibid., p. 14 Ibid., p. 15 Ibid., p. 16 Carquinez Bridge Company. Carquinez Strait Bridge (pamphlet), Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Derleth. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait." Engineering News-Record, September p. Carquinez Bridge Company. Carquinez Strait Bridge (pamphlet), Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley.

"Favor State Bridge Over Carquinez Strait." "Bridging the Carquinez Straits." "Bridge Plan Gets Strong Support." San Francisco Call, February "High Level Bridge Across Carquinez Straits." February "Another Bridge." San Francisco Examiner, September Section 24 Harlan, p. Also "A.J. Hanford, Bay Bridge Leader, Dies." San Francisco Chronicle, October 25 Harlan, p. Also California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, p. 46. 26 Derleth letter to Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co., September Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 27 California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, p. 46.

28 "Contracts Awarded on Carquinez Strait Bridge." Engineering News-Record, June p. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 42 29 Ratigan, William. Highways Over Broad Waters; Life and Times ofDavid B. Steinman, Bridgebuilder. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons, p. 30 California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, p. Ibid., p. 19. "Straits Plan Backers Plan for Franchise." San Francisco Chronicle, December "U.S. Approves Bridge Plan at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, September Also "Suspension Bridge Planned Across Carquinez Straits." Engineering News- Record, September p. 34 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley.

Folder 57. 35 Derleth letter to David Steinman, December Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 36 Summary of Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors meeting, January Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Carton 1. "Straits Bridge Permit Given." San Francisco Examiner, January "Second Span for Carquinez Strait Denied." San Francisco Chronicle, September 39 "New Bridge Planned at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, February 40 "County Upheld in Bridge Case." San Francisco Chronicle, April 41 Contra Costa County Ordinance Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 42 Derleth.

"Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 13. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 43 War Department Permit, Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 44 Transcript of Hearing of November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 59. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 43 45 Ibid. 46 "Second Hearing is Held on Carquinez Straits Bridge." Engineering News-Record, November p. 47 Freyermuth, Dr. Otto - letter to Herbert Deakyne, November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 54.

48 Derleth letter to Herbert Deakyne, December Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 54. 49 Derleth letter to David Steinman, December Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 50 Transcript of Hearing of March Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 59. 51 War Department Permit, Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder Section 52 Derleth letter to Rodeo-Vallejo Ferry Co., September Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 53 "Charles Derleth Jr.

Dies at San Francisco Chronicle, June Also Keim, B. Bressler, and R. Horonjeff. "Charles Derleth, InMemoriam. Berkeley: University of California, pp. 54 Keim, B. Bressler, andR. Horonjeff. "Charles Derleth, InMemoriam. Berkeley: University of California, p. 33. 55 "Charles Derleth Jr. Dies at San Francisco Chronicle, June 56 Petroski, Henry. Engineers ofDreams: Great Bridge Builders and the Spanning ofAmerica. New York: Vintage Books, p. 57 Petroski, p. Also "Charles Derleth Jr. Dies at San Francisco Chronicle, June 14, 58 Derleth, "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 3. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 59 American Society of Civil Engineers. Biographical Dictionary ofAmerican Civil Engineers.

New York: American Society of Civil Engineers, pp. C ARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 44 60 Ibid. Burr's involvement with the Queensboro Bridge is also described in Petroski, pp. 79. 61 Steinman letter to Charles Derleth, December Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 62 Derleth letter to David Steinman, December Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 63 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 3. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 64 Ratigan,p. 65 Ibid., p. 16. 66 Ibid. 67 Ibid., p. 46. 68 Ibid. Also Petroski, p. 69 Petroski, p. 70 Ratigan,p. 75.

71 Ibid., pp. 78 and 72 Ibid., p. 73 Ibid., pp. 74 Petroski, pp. 75 Ibid., p. 76 Ratigan, pp. 77 Ibid., pp. Section 2.4 78 Jackson, Donald. Great American Bridges and Dams. Washington: Preservation Press, p. 79 Ibid., p. 80 Ibid., pp. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 45 Ibid., p. 139 and Also David Steinman and Sara Ruth Watson. Bridges and Their Builders. New York: Putnam's Sons, p. 82 World Almanac and Book of Facts, Mahwah, New Jersey: World Almanac Books, p. 83 Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. 84 Jackson, pp. Also Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. 85 Jackson, p. 86 Ibid., p. 87 Ibid., pp. 88 Ibid., pp. 89 Ibid., p. 90 Ibid., p. 91 Ibid., pp. 138 and 92 California Department of Transportation. Historic Highway Bridges of California.

Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, p. 93 Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, pp. 94 Ibid., pp. Also Petroski, pp. The Steinman and Watson account is more critical of the original bridge design than Petroski's, and describes the resulting problems and design changes as being much more serious. 95 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December pp. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 96 Transcript of hearing, November p. 3. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives. Folder 59. 97 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December pp. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57.

Also David Steinman, "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, May 12, p. 98 Contra Costa County Ordinance Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 46 99 Application to the War Department, February Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 100 "Memoranda in RE the Comparison of the Cantilever with the Stiffened Suspension Bridge Type of Structure for the Bridge Over Carquinez Strait," April Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 101 Derleth. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait." Engineering News-Record, September p.

Also David Steinman, "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, May p. Steinman's article notes the difficulties associated with the cable anchorages as the main reason for rejecting the suspension design. "U.S. Approves Bridge Plan at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, September 103 Ratigan,p. KM bridge Over Carquinez Straits," A photographic copy of the rendering is also in the Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 62. 105 Derleth letter to William Burr, October Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 56. 106 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 6.

Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 1 (Y? Steinman. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge," pp. 1 Ibid., p. Also Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. 109 Ibid., p. 110 California Department of Transportation. Historic Highway Bridges of California, p. 111 Steinman. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge," p. A drawing of a typical hydraulic buffer is shown on page Section 2.5 112 Derleth. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait." Engineering News-Record, September p. 113 "Great Blast Exploded for Strait Bridge." San Francisco Chronicle, July f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 47 114 Concrete Piers of Carquinez Strait" Engineering News-Record, October p. 115 Calder, George J.

"Deep Water Caisson Sinking, Carquinez Strait Bridge." Engineering News-Record, March p. 116 California Department of Transportation. Historic Highway Bridges in California, p. Also Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. 117 Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. Also, a detailed discussion of the guide frames, water jets, and caisson construction is in Calder, "Deep Water Caisson Sinking, Carquinez Strait Bridge." Engineering News-Record, March 118 Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, p. Also Derleth, "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 21. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57.

119 "Contracts Awarded on Carquinez Strait Bridge." Engineering News-Record, June p. Also "Contract and Specifications for Completion of Substructure." Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Carton 1. 120 "Contracts Awarded on Carquinez Strait Bridge." Engineering News-Record, June p. 121 Goodrich, Charles F. "Counterweighted Cables Raise Spans to High-Level Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, April pp. 122 Descriptions of the process of lifting the suspended spans can be found in: "Counterweights Lift Suspended Span of Carquinez Bridge." Engineering News-Record, March p. Goodrich. "Counterweighted Cables Raise Spans to High-Level Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, April pp. Steinman and Watson, Bridges and Their Builders, pp.

123 Photo albums. Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Box 2. 124 Derleth letter to Max Thelen, November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 125 "Chronological Record Related to Pier Fender." Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Carton 1. f CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 48 126 Derleth letter to Max Thelen, November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 127 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," December p. 34. Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57.

128 Derleth letter to Max Thelen, November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 129 "Bridge Piers and Navigation." Engineering News Record, November 17, pp. 130 "Carquinez Bridge, Center Pier Fender: Chronological Record." March Unsigned, but presumably by Derleth. Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Carton 1. 131 Derleth letter to Max Thelen, November Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 132 War Department Permit, September Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 133 Derleth. "Carquinez Bridge: History of Construction Period," Dec. p. 34.

Charles Derleth Papers, Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Folder 57. 134 "Bridge Piers and Navigation." Engineering News-Record, November pp. lie "Protecting Bridge Piers from Damage by Ships." Engineering News-Record, December 25, p. 136 Ibid. California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, pp. "Reasonable Historical Cost, Carquinez Bridge, American Toll Bridge Company." (Cases and San Francisco: California Railroad Commission, Transportation Department, Engineering Division. December In Carquinez Bridge Data, California Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento. 139 "Protecting Bridge Piers from Damage by Ships." Engineering News-Record, December 25, p. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 49 140 California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, p. 56. 141 "Great Carquinez Bridge Opens Today." San Francisco Examiner, May 142 "Hearing Continues on Carquinez Toll." San Francisco Chronicle, December Section 2.6 143 Group photograph on the bridge, dated May and captioned: "the day the bridge was informally opened to traffic." Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Box 6. 144 "AJ. Hanford, Bay Bridge Leader, Dies." San Francisco Examiner, October 145 Steinman. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, May p. 146 "Qreat Carquinez Bridge Opens Today." San Francisco Examiner, May 147 American Toll Bridge Company.

"The Carquinez Bridge Opening May (dedication program). Charles Derleth Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. Carton 2. 148 Ibid. 149 "Great Carquinez Bridge Opens Today." San Francisco Examiner, May 150 "Carquinez Strait Bridge Opened to Traffic May Engineering News-Record, May 26, p. 151 Steinman. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge." Engineering News-Record, May p. 152 Harlan,p. 153 Ibid., p. 99. 154 "9-Day Bridge Tolls San Francisco Examiner, June 3, 155 Ibid. 156 California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, pp. 157 Ibid., p. 31. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 50 158 Annual traffic counts for through are included in Hunter, H. G.

"Analysis of the Operating Results of the Carquinez Bridge, With Estimates of Future Travel and Revenue." San Francisco: California Railroad Commission, Transportation Department, Engineering Division. (Case No. November In Carquinez Bridge Data, Caltrans Transportation Library, Sacramento. Annual traffic counts for through and estimates for through are included in "Official Statement of the California Toll Bridge Authority Relating to Carquinez Strait Bridges, Toll Bridge Revenue Bonds, Series B." July Caltrans Transportation Library, Sacramento.

159 "Carquinez Toll Cut Action by Proposed." San Francisco Chronicle, August 160 "Taking Tolls on Highways Relic of the Middle Ages." San Francisco Chronicle, March 12, 161 "Private Spans Toll Quiz Set." San Francisco Chronicle, September 162 "Hatfield Urges New Carquinez Straits Bridge." San Francisco Chronicle, October 16, 163 "Private Spans Toll Quiz Set." San Francisco Chronicle, September 164 Clark, Frank. "State Negotiating to Buy the Carquinez and Antioch Toll Spans on State Highway Routes." California Highways and Public Works, June p. 3.

165 "Court Orders Cut in Carquinez Toll." San Francisco Chronicle, September 166 "Carquinez Cut Put in Effect." San Francisco Chronicle, June 167 "Carquinez Toll Refund Planned." SanFrancisco Chronicle, July Also "Last Carquinez Refund Made." San Francisco Chronicle, October 168 Tons on Carquinez Bridge Under Fire." San Francisco Chronicle, November 169 California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California, p. 13. 170 Ibid., p. 14. 171 Ibid. 172 Ibid., pp. 173 Clark. "State Negotiating to Buy the Carquinez and Antioch Toll Spans on State Highway Routes." California Highways and Public Works, June p. 1. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 51 174 Ibid.

175 "State Launches Move to Buy Toll Spans." San Francisco Chronicle, March 176 "Carquinez and Antioch Purchase by State Okayed." San Francisco Chronicle, May 21, Also "Sale of Antioch, Carquinez Spans to State Voted." San Francisco Chronicle, June 177 "State Takes Over Carquinez Bridges; Tolls Reduced Fifty Per Cent." California Highways and Public Works, September p. 5. 178 "State to Buy Two Bridges, Slash Tolls." San Francisco Chronicle, August 179 "State Takes Over Carquinez Bridges; Tolls Reduced Fifty Per Cent." California Highways and Public Works, September p. 2. 180 "Carquinez Bridge: State Takes Over Tomorrow." San Francisco Chronicle, September 15, i8i <*Xolls Reduced Approximately 20% on Carquinez and Antioch Spans." California Highways and Public Works, January p. 14.

182 "June Traffic on State Toll Bridges Shows Heavy Increase." California Highways and Public Works, July p. 16. 183 "Carquinez Bridge History." California Highways and Public Works, June p. 15. 184 Ibid. 185 "Carquinez and Antioch Bridges Became Toll Free on August 1." California Highways and Public Works, July-August p. 10. 186 Darby, C. H. "Parallel Bridge Across Carquinez." California Highways and Public Works, July-August p. 2. 187 Ibid., p. 1. 188 Hollister. "Carquinez Project: Revenue Bonds Sold and Major Contracts Awarded." California Highways and Public Works, Jan.-Feb. p. 26. 189 Ibid., pp. 190 Ibid., p. 42. 191 Hollister. "New Parallel Bridge." California Highways and Public Works, Jan.-Feb. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 52 192 Hollister.

"Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Tests Ingenuity of Engineers.' California Highways and Public Works, March-April p. 45. 193 "Major Projects on Route 80" (Caltrans District 4 web page), November 194 ibid. r CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 53 4.

Bibliography

Archival sources: California Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento. Charles Derleth Papers. Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. (Cartons 1 and 2 contain written material related to the construction of the Carquinez Bridge, and boxes 1, 2, 5, and 6 contain photograph albums.) Charles Derleth Papers. Water Resources Center Archives, University of California, Berkeley. (Box 10 contains folders written material and photographs related to the construction of the Carquinez Bridge.) Plan files, California Department of Transportation, District 4 office, Oakland. Books, pamphlets, and government documents: American Society of Civil Engineers, Committee on History and Heritage of American Civil Engineering. A Biographical Dictionary of American Civil Engineers.

New York: American Society of Civil Engineers, American Toll Bridge Company. "The Carquinez Bridge Opening May Invitation to opening ceremonies. At the Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. California Department of Transportation. Historic Highway Bridges of California. Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, California Division of Highways. Report on Investigation of Carquinez TollBridge. California Highway Commission. Investigation and Report on Toll Bridges in the State of California. Carquinez Bridge Company. "Carquinez Strait Bridge." Publicity pamphlet. At the Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. DeLony, Eric. Landmark American Bridges. New York: American Society of Civil Engineers, Harlan, George H. San Francisco Bay Ferryboats.

Berkeley: Howell-North Books, InMemoriam. Berkeley: University of California, Jackson, Donald C. Great American Bridges and Dams. Washington: Preservation Press, CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo. CA-297. Page 54 Petroski, Henry. Engineers of Dreams: Great Bridge Builders and the Spanning of America. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Ratigan, William. Highways Over Broad Waters: Life and Times of David B. Steinman, Bridgebuilder. Grand Rapids: Erdmans Publishing, Steinman, David B., and Sara Ruth Watson. Bridges and Their Builders. New York: Putnam's Sons, World Almanac and Book of Facts, Mahwah, New Jersey: World Almanac Books, Journal articles - California Highways and Public Works: June Clark, Frank. "State Negotiating to Buy the Carquinez and Antioch Toll Spans on State Highway Routes," pp.

September "State Takes Over Carquinez Bridges; Tolls Reduced Fifty Per Cent," pp. December Clark, Frank. "Cities Designated to Take Over the Martinez - Benicia Ferry," pp. January "City of Martinez Takes Over Benicia - Martinez Ferry," p. 15. January "Tolls Reduced Approximately 20% on Carquinez and Antioch Spans," p. 14. July "June Traffic on State Toll Bridges Shows Heavy Increase," p. 16. June "Carquinez Bridge History," p. 15. June 'Tolls on Carquinez and Antioch Bridges Again Reduced by State to 25 Cent Rate for Passenger Cars," pp. July-August "Carquinez and Antioch Bridges Became Toll Free on August 1," p. 10. July-August Darby, "Parallel Bridge Across Carquinez," pp. Sept-Oct "Retirement of Bay Bridge Bonds Benefits Highway Fund," p. 58. Jan.-Feb. Hollister, Leonard C.

"Carquinez Project: Revenue Bonds Sold and Major Contracts Awarded," pp. Jan.-Feb. Hollister. "Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Tests Ingenuity of Engineers," pp. CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 55 March-April Hollister. "Now Read This: Carquinez Bridge Project Tests Ingenuity of Engineers," pp. Jan.-Feb. Hollister. "New Parallel Bridge," pp. Journal articles - Engineering News-Record: September "Suspension Bridge Planned Across Carquinez Straits," p. November "Second Hearing is Held on Carquinez Straits Bridge," p. January "Franchise Awarded for Carquinez Straits Bridge," p. March "Another Hearing on Carquinez Strait Bridge Held," p. October "First Concrete in Piers of Carquinez Strait Bridge," p. June "Contracts Awarded on Carquinez Strait Bridge," p.

September Derleth, Charles. "Cantilever Highway Bridge Across Carquinez Strait,' pp. March "Counterweights Lift Suspended Span of Carquinez Bridge," p. March 24, Calder, George J. "Deep Water Caisson Sinking, Carquinez Strait Bridge," pp. April 28, Goodrich, Charles F. "Counterweighted Cables Raise Spans to High-Level Cantilever Bridge," pp. May Steinman, David B. "Designing the Carquinez Cantilever Bridge," pp. May 26, "Carquinez Strait Bridge Opened to Traffic May p. November 17, "Bridge Piers and Navigation," pp. November "Designing a Fender for Bridge Piers in Midchannel," pp. December "Protecting Bridge Pier From Damage by Ships," p. October "Corrosion closes bridge for repair," p. 16.

Newspaper articles: January "Favor State Bridge Over Carquinez Strait." San Francisco Call, CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297. Page 56 January "Bridging the Carquinez Straits." (editorial) San Francisco Call, January "Bridging Straits is Strongly Urged." San Francisco Call, February 9, "Big Structure Will Be Built Over Straits." San Francisco Call, February "Bridge Plan Gets Strong Support." San Francisco Call, February "High Level Bridge Across Carquinez Straits." (editorial) San Francisco Call,6:\. July "Row on Bridge at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, September "U.S.

Approves Bridge Plan at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, September8,1922 "Another Bridge." (editorial) San Francisco Examiner, October "Bridge Over Straits, Plan." San Francisco Examiner, November "Straits' Span Seen as Boon to Land Value." San Francisco Examiner, November "Straits Bridge is Indorsed at Public Hearing." San Francisco Chronicle, December "Straits Plan Backers Plan for Franchise." San Francisco Chronicle, January "Straits Bridge Permit Given." San Francisco Examiner, March "New Type Bridge for Straits Asked." San Francisco Chronicle, April "Vallejo Celebrates Signing of Permit." San Francisco Examiner, April 18, "Weeks Gives Approval to Vallejo Span." San Francisco Examiner, May "Span Across Carquinez to Open in San Francisco Examiner, July "Great Blast Exploded for Strait Bridge." San Francisco Chronicle, August "New Carquinez Bridge Ft.

Long Planned." San Francisco Chronicle, September 16, "Second Span for Carquinez Strait Denied." San Francisco Chronicle, April 3, "County Upheld in Bridge Case." San Francisco Chronicle, October "A.J. Hanford, Bay Bridge Leader, Dies." San Francisco Examiner, CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 57 May "Contra Costa Board O.K.'s New Span at Carquinez." San Francisco Chronicle, May "Great Carquinez Bridge Opens Today." San Francisco Examiner, May "Noise Bombs, Set Off by Coolidge, to Open Carquinez Bridge to World Today." San Francisco Chronicle, June "9-Day Bridge Tolls San Francisco Examiner, February 24, "New Bridge Planned at Carquinez." San Francisco Examiner, March 12, "Taking Tolls on Highways Relic of the Middle Ages." (editorial) San Francisco Chronicle, March "State Launches Move to Buy Toll Spans." San Francisco Chronicle, April 1, "One More Step to Getting Toll Gates off Highways." (editorial) San Francisco Chronicle, April "Hatfield Sees Carquinez Toll Cut to 15 Cents." San Francisco Chronicle, June "State Toll Purchase Measures Signed." San Francisco Chronicle, August "Carquinez Toll Cut Action by Proposed." San Francisco Chronicle, September "Private Spans Toll Quiz Set." San Francisco Chronicle, October "Hatfield Urges New Carquinez Straits Bridge." San Francisco Chronicle, December "Half Dollar Toll for Carquinez Bridge Urged." San Francisco Chronicle, December "Hearing Continues on Carquinez Toll." San Francisco Chronicle, February "Carquinez Toll Cut to 50 Cents for Car, Driver." San Francisco Chronicle, September "Court Orders Cut in Carquinez Toll." San Francisco Chronicle, June "Carquinez Cut Put in Effect." San Francisco Chronicle, July "Carquinez Toll Refund Planned." San Francisco Chronicle, October "Last Carquinez Refund Made." San Francisco Chronicle, CARQUINEZ BRIDGE HAERNo.CA-297.

Page 58 November "Tolls on Carquinez Bridge Under Fire." San Francisco Chronicle, May "Carquinez and Antioch Purchase by State Okayed." San Francisco Chronicle, June "Sale of Antioch, Carquinez Spans to State Voted." San Francisco Chronicle, August "State to Buy Two Bridges, Slash Tolls." San Francisco Chronicle, September "Carquinez Bridge: State Takes Over Tomorrow." San Francisco Chronicle, May "Toll Reductions: Carquinez and Antioch Bridge Fares Lowered to 25 Cents by State." San Francisco Chronicle, June "Antioch, Carquinez to be Toll Free August 1." San Francisco Chronicle, June 'Charles Derleth Jr. Dies at San Francisco Chronicle,

In context

Vallejo, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Solano County, California 258 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Vallejo

24 of 110 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Vallejo building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1-36,508 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1C-8,099 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CX5,167 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1G-4,916 words
Carquinez Straits Transmission SpanHAER CA-1914,904 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1-I-4,561 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CW4,510 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1J-4,224 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1H-4,011 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1F-3,328 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CV2,856 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CY2,827 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CU2,379 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CR2,126 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CT2,089 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-DA2,026 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CZ1,955 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1B-1,858 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1AP-1,793 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1D-1,664 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1N-1,636 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1AT-1,616 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CA-1543-CS1,568 words
Mare Island Naval ShipyardHABS CAL,48-MARI,1E-1,532 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,48-VALL,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.