BlockBefore

Honey Run Bridge, Spanning Butte Creek, bypassed section of Honey Run Road (originally Carr Hill Road), Paradise

Honey Run Bridge, Spanning Butte Creek, bypassed section of Honey Run Road (originally Carr Hill Road), Paradise, Butte County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-312, with a 4,265-word written history.

From the record

“The Honey Run Bridge is the best preserved of four surviving examples of Pratt-type wood covered bridges in the United States.”

Written record, HAER CA-312 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-312 · the record runs 4265 words · one of 13 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

44 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-312. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Bypassed section of Honey Run Road (originally Carr Hill Road), spanning Butte Creek in Butte Creek Canyon, Paradise vicinity, Butte County, California UTM: 10.611088E.4398498N, Hamlin Canyon, CA Quad. Structural Type: Wood/iron covered bridge, modified Pratt truss Date of Probably Construction: Designer/Builder: American Bridge Company

Significance

71 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-312. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Honey Run Bridge is the best preserved of four surviving examples of Pratt-type wood covered bridges in the United States. The Pratt truss was patented by Thomas and Caleb Pratt in and featured wood compression members and iron tension members. The design, favored for its strength and adaptability, became the standard American truss for moderate spans on both railroads and highways by and remained so well into the twentieth century.

Written history

4056 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-312. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Researched and written by Lola Bennett, September Project The National Covered Bridges Recording Project is part of the Information: Historic American Engineering Record (HAER), a long-range program to document historically significant engineering and industrial works in the United States. HAER is administered by the Historic American Buildings Survey/Historic American Engineering Record, a division of the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior. The Federal Highway Administration funded the project. 1 The name Honey Run is said to derive from the honeybees that nested in the buttes surrounding the bridge. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No.

CA-312 (Page 2) Description The Honey Run Bridge is a three-span timber covered bridge on 36 iron clad column piers and mortared fieldstone abutments. The total length of the bridge is 241 feet. The northern span is a kingpost truss, 30 feet long and 7 -6 high; the center span is a Pratt truss, 128 feet long and 23 feet high; the southern span is a Pratt truss, 80 feet long and 15 -6 high. The trusses are spaced 18 apart. The timber deck has a width of 17 -6 between wood plank side railings. The northern span is framed as a kingpost truss. The sloped compression members are timbers, joined at center span. The lower chords are a pair of 7/8 square bars that pass through the lower ends of the sloped compression members.

The sloped members and the bottom chord are connected at midspan by a pair of kingrods, vertical 7/8 square bars with threaded ends, which pass through a metal plate below the transverse floor beam and another plate above the upper compression members, where they are fixed with nuts. Outriggers have been incorporated with the transverse floor beam to provide lateral stability and a supplemental timber bent has been added to increase the load-bearing capacity of the span. The center span is framed as a six-panel modified Pratt through truss, featuring horizontal upper and lower chords connected by vertical wood compression members, diagonal iron tension members, and sloped wood endposts. The upper chords are timber beams and the lower chords are paired metal eyebars.

The chords are connected by 7x8 vertical timber posts and paired rods or rectangular bars. The rods and bars are crossed in the two center panels and angle up towards the ends in the end panels. The trusses are cross-braced overhead with timbers and rods at each panel point. There are metal rod sway braces between the trusses at the plane of the lower chord in each of the six panels. The floor system is supported by transverse floor beams suspended below the lower chord at each panel point. The five timber transverse floor beams have heavy steel channel type beams bracketed to the sides (apparently a modern addition). There are ten lines of longitudinal stringers on top of the transverse floor beams.

The transverse floor beams extend to the outside of the trusses and support the framework (nailers) for the wall covering. The deck consists of timbers laid transversely on the stringers, and running boards laid longitudinally on top of the deck. The southern span is framed as a five-panel modified Pratt through truss. 2 The upper chord is a timber member and the lower chord is paired x2 or metal eyebars. The chords are connected by 6x8 vertical timber posts and paired diameter rods or bars. The rods and bars are crossed in the center panel and angle up towards the ends in the end panels. The truss is braced overhead with timbers and rods at each panel point. There are metal sway braces between the trusses in each panel both overhead and under the deck.

The panels of each 2 This span was rebuilt with new timber following a truck accident in some of the iron was reused and some of the iron was new. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 3) truss are connected at both the top and bottom chord with a 2 diameter steel pin through the fabricated metal assembly that holds the ends of the timber members and eyebars, or rods, in place. There is a floor beam suspended below the lower chord at each pin. The pin passes through the lower lateral bracing diameter rods with looped ends), the eyes of the lower chord, the diagonal rods, and looped rods suspending the transverse floor beams. The looped rods pass alongside the floor beam and through a metal plate below each beam, where they are secured with nuts.

The roof system is composed of 2x4 rafters that frame from the top nailers on the outside of the trusses. The rafters are spaced 24 apart and support 2x4 wood purlins to which corrugated metal roofing is fastened. There are 1x6 wood collar ties between the rafters. The height of the gable roof over each span corresponds to the height of each truss, giving the center span a noticeably higher roofline than the end spans. A sprinkler system has been installed along the roof the full length of the bridge. The timbers of the two original spans (northerly and center) are covered with sheet metal on the top and both sides, evidence that the bridge was originally uncovered.

The exterior of the bridge is presently covered the full height of the trusses with vertical board siding fastened to 4x4 framing generally supported on the ends of the transverse floor beams which extend beyond the outer face of the trusses. The entire housing, including the roof, appears to be a self-supporting structure, with the lower nailers resting on the transverse floor beams and piers. This was presumably done to transfer the dead load of the walls and roof to a direct loading position on the truss. The center span has two windows on each side (one in each of the two center panels). The portals are straight with squared openings with chamfered corners.

A relatively new sign over the north portal reads Honey Run Covered Bridge Iron gates have been installed at both portals to secure the bridge at night. The abutments are mutated fieldstone and the column piers are riveted iron tubes filled with concrete. The lower chords of the center span rest on bolster beams over the piers. The floor stringers of the end spans rest on large bedding timbers on top of the abutment facewalls. California Covered Bridges Within a year of the discovery of gold at Sutter s Mill at Coloma in the population of California tripled 3 , and there was an urgent demand for roads and bridges, a demand initially met by the establishment of privately financed ferries, turnpikes and toll bridges.

Aside from two 3 According to Philip Varney s Ghost Towns of Northern California, In only 400 people immigrated to California. During the following year, with word of [James] Marshall s discovery trumpeted around the world, an astounding people descended upon the area. Between and California s population exploded from to HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 4) minor structures, there were no bridges in California prior to 4 when John T. Little of Castine, Maine, built the first covered bridge west of the Mississippi River, a 550-foot span across South Fork at Salmon Falls. His crews later erected at least two more wood covered toll bridges.

The editor of the Sacramento Transcript praised Little s efforts, stating, When the rivers are high, communication can be kept open by means of these bridges with some of the richest dry diggings in the country, which otherwise would be inaccessible. 5 By the mid there were at least one hundred toll bridges in the gold mining region of California. 6 The majority of these were timber truss bridges and, presumably, many of them were covered. 7 Over time, however, the covered bridges were replaced with new structures, or lost to floods, fires, vandalism, neglect or decay. By there were still thirty covered bridges in California; 8 today only twelve remain.

9 Site History Following the discovery of the single biggest piece of gold ever found in North America, 10 a fifty-four pound gold nugget, in Dogtown (later Magalia) in 11 people flocked to Butte County. This necessitated the construction of a network of roads and bridges. One of the most needed routes was from Butte Creek Canyon to Paradise Ridge. According to the Butte County Board of Supervisors minutes of the board responded to a petition from the citizens of Magalia and Paradise and ordered that the road be laid out and built. Money was raised by subscription, and in the fall of the contract was awarded to A.H. Chapman. Thirty men were immediately given work, and the grading and filling and blasting continued during the winter when weather permitted.

12 In May of a committee visited the scene of the work and found a very good mountain road, not being too steep, and found it was being constructed with great care, so as to prevent washouts and landslides. 13 During the trip, the committee also chose the site for a bridge across Butte Creek, near the intersection of Centerville Road. 4 Panhorst, A Century of Bridge Progress, California Highway and Public Works Magazine, Centennial Edition, vol. 29, no. 9 and 10, September 9, Panhorst s statement is apparently based on descriptions of travelers to California prior to 5 Century of Bridge Progress, 6 Century of Bridge Progress, 7 Stephen Mikesell, Historic Highway Bridges of California (Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, 8 S.

Griswold Morley, The Covered Bridges of California (Berkeley: University of California Press, 9 Three of the twelve have been built since 10 Joseph F. McGie, History of Butte County, 11 According to George Mansfield s History of Butte County The nugget, known as the Dogtown Nugget, was taken to San Francisco and melted into a bar which weighed forty-nine and a half pounds and netted 12 John S. Waterland, Behind the Building of Honey Run Road, Chico Enterprise-Record, January 3, 13 Behind the Building of Honey Run Road, HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No.

CA-312 (Page 5) Bridge Construction In September the Butte County Board of Supervisors ordered the County Clerk to publish a notice to contractors for plans and proposals for a wood bridge across Butte Creek at the Carr Hill Road crossing. In this notice, the supervisors listed the following specifications: The bridge in the center to be at least 7 feet above high water mark; center piers to be two iron cylinders, about 5 and 9 feet in height respectively, filled with concrete, resting on the large rocks that project in the stream; the western shore pier also to be an iron cylinder filled with concrete. There is to be a clear span over the main channel not less than 125 feet in length; a rock wall or abutment to be built at each end about 5 feet high, rock to be laid in cement mortar.

Total length of bridge needed, 240 feet, width 16 feet. To be constructed in a substantial manner, and all square timbers to be of No. 1 spruce. The Board prefers the Howe Truss pattern for the longest span, and strain beam for short spans, but bidders may make their bids in whatever kind of truss they prefer. 14 Three proposals were received and the contract was awarded to the American Bridge and Building Company for George Miller was appointed superintendent of construction. The bridge was described in the newspaper as follows: On Wednesday a contract was let by the Board for the building of a Pratt truss iron combination bridge at the Butte Creek crossing of the Carr Hill road.

The price to be paid is The bridge is to be 240 feet in length, and 18 feet in width, the piers are to be iron cylinders 44 inches in diameter filled with concrete, the spans are 126 feet, 80 feet and 39 feet. The bridge is to be a strong and durable structure of the best class of bridge architecture. A contract was also let for the building of the same style and general plan of bridge at Rock Creek on the Chico and Shasta road for Both bridges are to be built by the American Bridge Company of San Francisco, and are to be ready for travel by December 15 On January 3, Miller reported that the Butte Creek Bridge had been completed in accordance with the contract and it was accepted by the Board.

According to contemporary sources, in a flood washed the Carr Hill Bridge downstream, and no immediate plans were made to rebuild it. Subsequently, three children drowned while trying to ford the river on their way to school, and there was enough public outrage that a new 14 Notice to Contractors, Chico Enterprise, April 15 Bridge Building in Chico, Chico Enterprise, October 8, HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 6) bridge was constructed in No documentary evidence has been found, however, to confirm the latter construction date.

16 According to newspaper accounts, the story of the three children drowning is true, 17 but the location where they drowned is described as a quarter mile from their house that was four miles from town [Chico], and Chico is eight miles from the bridge. In addition, the Butte County Board of Supervisors Minutes state that, at that date, the Carr Hill bridge was in a state of disrepair, suggesting that more than five years had elapsed since its construction. Together with the close correlation of the specifications to the present bridge, this information strongly suggests that the present bridge is the structure. Physical and documentary evidence indicates that the bridge was not covered at the time of its construction.

The timber trusses of the center and westerly span are covered with metal sheathing, which would have been unnecessary if the bridge had been weatherboarded and roofed. In George Miller sent a letter to the Board of Supervisors stating: The flooring and timbers were very badly decayed and it was necessary to replace the whole floor system with new materials which in my judgment makes the bridge as good as the original. I would also recommend that the bridge be housed-in, the cost which would be about 18 No written records have been found to document when the bridge was covered, but presumably it was done soon after Miller s recommendation. Bridge Design Historian Carl Condit has called Thomas Pratt the most thoroughly educated American bridge builder at the beginning of the railroad age.

19 Born in to Boston architect Caleb Pratt, Thomas Pratt was educated in building construction as a young man. He studied architecture at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, and subsequently went on to work for the Army Corps of Engineers. In he began his career designing bridges for railroads and was employed as a structural engineer by a number of railroad companies. 16 The National Register Nomination for Honey Run Bridge cites original plans for the bridge in the Butte County Public Works Department. These have not been found. As-Built plans generated from a study completed by the Donald R. Warren Company are available in the Butte County Public Works Office.

Lois McDonald s article The Roads and Bridges of Butte Creek Canyon, discovered after the author s research was completed, states: I have read that this bridge was washed out by high water in early and but though careful review of newspapers for and early found reports of high water and threat to several bridges, no word that the Butte Creek Bridge at Carr Hill Road was in danger. 17 Three Children Drown, Chico Enterprise, April 19, 18 The letter, quoted in a Butte County Historical Society bulletin, has not been located, but Miller s recommendation to house the bridge was also reported in, Report on Bridge Work, Chico Enterprise, July 5, 19 Carl W. Condit, American Building Art, the Nineteenth Century (New York: HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No.

CA-312 (Page 7) In Thomas and Caleb Pratt received a patent for a truss featuring vertical wood compression members and diagonal iron tension members, a design that was superior to Howe s mainly in the more functional distribution of tensile and compressive stresses in the various members. 20 Developed at a time when railroads were placing new demands on bridges and the structural action of trusses was just beginning to be understood, the Pratt truss (together with the Howe and Whipple trusses) heralded the transformation from empirical to scientific bridge design. While the type was not immediately popular for wood spans, it became so after the Civil War, when, along with other truss types, it was built with wood and iron or all iron members.

21 The Pratt truss was favored for its straightforward design, strength and adaptability, and by in an all-steel version, it had become the standard American truss for moderate spans on both railroads and highways, and remained so well into the twentieth century. As noted by J.A.L. Waddell in The Pratt truss is the type most commonly used in America for spans under two hundred and fifty feet in length. Its advantages are simplicity, economy of metal, and suitability for connecting to the floor and lateral systems. 22 Subsequent History of the Bridge On April 12, a truck crashed into one corner of the bridge, collapsing the eastern span.

Due to the collapse, and partly due to the very limited load capacity of 3 tons per vehicle, as well as the age and maintenance of the bridge, the Butte County Department of Public Works initiated plans for a new two-lane highway bridge for an adjacent site just upstream of the covered bridge. Construction of a new four-span composite steel girder bridge was approved by the State Reclamation Board, provided that the County of Butte will properly maintain the existing bridge to insure its stability. While the new bridge was under construction in public support was growing in favor of restoring and preserving the covered bridge. A thousand people signed petitions, the Honey Run Covered Bridge Association was formed, and funds were donated for reconstruction.

These efforts were helped significantly with the donation of by the Larwin Corporation (Developer of Paradise Pines). 23 The bridge was rehabilitated and opened to pedestrian-only loading in 20 American Building Art, 21 This is one of only a few surviving examples of the revised combination wood and iron Pratt truss. According to covered bridge historian Joseph Conwill, little is known about the history of this type, but it may have been a back-formation from all- iron trusses. Wood covered bridges of this type include Honey Run, Felton, Trinity Ranch, Cartersville, Springwood and Eagle Rock. 22 J.A.L. Waddell, Bridge Engineering, vol. I (New York, 23 Donald C.

Becker, Honey Run Covered Bridge, undated, typed manuscript in the files of the Butte County Department of Public Works, Oroville, California. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 8) Chronology Gold found near Paradise, California. Carr Hill Road (now Honey Run Road) laid out. Bridge constructed by American Bridge & Building Company of San Francisco. Bridge reportedly washed out in a flood and subsequently rebuilt in George Miller repairs, and recommends covering, the bridge. Skyway replaces Carr Hill Road as the primary route between Chico and Paradise. Honey Run Bridge s eastern span destroyed by truck accident and bridge closed to traffic. Bridge bypassed with concrete and steel bridge. Bridge reconstruction completed. Siding replaced.

HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 9) Appendix A Historic Photographs April 12, Photograph courtesy of Raymond Cooper. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 10) April 12, Photograph courtesy of Raymond Cooper. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 11) April 12, Photograph courtesy of Raymond Cooper. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 12) April 12, Photograph courtesy of Raymond Cooper. HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 13) Sources Adams, Kramer A. Covered Bridges of the West: A History and Illustrated Guide. Berkley, CA: Howell-North, American Society of Civil Engineers, Committee on History and Heritage. A Biographical Dictionary of American Civil Engineers, vol., 1.

ASCE Historical Publication No. 2 American Society of Civil Engineers, Committee on History and Heritage. American Wooden Bridges. ASCE Historical Publication No. 4. New York: American Society of Civil Engineers Baker, Jeanne. An Undercover Story: Covered Bridges of California. Chapel Hill, NC: Chapel Hill Press, Becker, Donald. Honey Run Covered Bridge, undated, typed manuscript in the files of the Butte County Department of Public Works, Oroville, California. Brock, Truss Bridges, An Illustrated Historical Description of All Expired Patents on Truss Bridges, Engineering News and American Contract Journal, October 23, September 8, Butte County Board of Supervisors Minutes, Butte County, California, Illustrations.

Oakland: Smith & Elliott, Butte County Department of Public Works, Bridge Records. Chico Enterprise, Condit, Carl W. American Building. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, Condit, Carl W. American Building Art: the Nineteenth Century. New York: Oxford University Press, Conwill, Joseph D. Research Notes and Annotated Bibliography for HAER Covered Bridge Project typed notes. Honey Run Covered Bridge Association. Honey Run Covered Bridge: An Historical Site Preserved. Paradise, California: Dick Ehrsam Printing, HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 14) Darnell, Victor. A Directory of American Bridge Building Companies. Washington, DC: ASCE Occassional Publication, Hallen, Kent, Dan Ostrander and Charleen Kerley.

Chico Centennial Magazine: A Journey Through Time Chico: Centennail Magazine Committee, Hintz, Hamilton L. Covered Spans Nearly 100 Years Old Serve Farmers, The Sacramento Bee, December 10, Honey Run Covered Bridge Association. Honey Run Covered Bridge and the Butte Creek Canyon Area, Butte County, California. ca.1965. Honey Run Covered Bridge, Butte County Historical Society Diggins, vol. II, no. 2, Summer Honey Run Covered Bridge Steeped in History, Butte County Senior Post, vol. 2, no. 8, April Hutchinson, History of Butte County, California. James, The Evolution of Wooden Bridge Trusses to Institute of Wood Science Journal vol. 9, nos. 3 and 4, June and December issues 51 and 52. Krekeler, Brenda. Covered Bridges Today. Canton, OH: Daring Books, Mansfield, George C.

History of Butte County, California. Los Angeles: Historic Record Company, McCoy, Official Map of the County of Butte, California, McDonald, Lois. The Roads and Bridges of Butte Creek Canyon, Butte County Historical Society Diggin s, vol. 38, no. 1 and 2 (Spring-Summer McGie, Joseph F. History of Butte County, McKee, Brian J. Historic American Covered Bridges. New York: ASCE Press, American Society of Civil Engineers, McGann, James. Official Map of the County of Butte, California, Mikesell, Stephen D. Historic Highway Bridges of California. Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, HONEY RUN BRIDGE (Carr Hill Bridge) HAER No. CA-312 (Page 15) Morley, S. Griswold. The Covered Bridges of California.

Berkeley, CA: Univeristy of California Press, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form: Honey Run Covered Bridge, Nelson, Joseph C. Spanning Time: Vermont s Covered Bridges. Shelburne, Vermont: The New England Press, Plowden, David. Bridges: the Spans of North America. New York and London: Norton Co., Pomeroy, George G. California s Covered Bridges, Covered Bridge Topics, vol. 20, No. 3, October pp. 1, 9. Pratt, Thomas Willis, biographical sketch in Dictionary of American Biography, vol. 8. New York: Charles Scribners Sons, Sloane, Eric. American Barns and Covered Bridges. New York: Wilfred Funk, Inc., Tailings of Butte Creek Canyon Centerville Recreation and Historical Association Inc., p. 77. Talbitzer, Bill. Butte County: An Illustrated History.

Northridge, California: Windsor Publications, Van de Kamp, Mark. Renewed Effort Needed to Keep Honey Run Covered Bridge Afloat, Paradise Post, October 20, p.A7. Warren, Donald R. Co. Engineers. A Report on the County Highway Bridges of Butte County, California. San Francisco, Waterland, John S. Behind the Building of Honey Run Road, Chico Enterprise-Record, January 3, Wells, Harry L. History of Butte County, California. San Francisco: Francis Valentine & Co., Wetherbee, Ira A. Butte County California Illustrations.

Oakland: Smith & Elliot, ADDENDUM TO: HAER CA-312 HONEY RUN BRIDGE HAER CA-312 (Carr Hill Bridge) National Covered Bridges Recording Project Spanning Butte Creek, bypassed section of Honey Run Road (originally Carr Hill Road) Paradise vicinity Butte County California REDUCED COPIES OF MEASURED DRAWINGS HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior C Street NW Washington, DC

In context

Paradise, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Butte County, California 289 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Butte County

12 records

The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in Butte County. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Lost Creek DamHAER CA-3675,080 words
Bidwell MansionHABS CAL,4-CHIC,1-3,192 words
Centerville Hydroelectric SystemHAER CAL,4-CENT,1-A-2,752 words
Bidwell ParkHALS CA-692,677 words
Bidwell MansionHALS CA-631,145 words
Bidwell Bar Suspension Bridge & Stone Toll HouseHAER CAL,4-ORO.V,1-213 words
Bidwell Bar Suspension Bridge & Stone Toll HouseHABS CAL,4-ORO.V,1-47 words
Wells Fargo & Company Vault (Ruins)HABS CAL,4-CHER,1-37 words
Centerville Hydroelectric SystemHAER CAL,4-CENT,1-B-35 words
Brewery (Ruins)HABS CAL,4-CHER,2-32 words
Centerville Hydroelectric SystemHAER CAL,4-CENT,1-32 words
Honcut BridgeHAER CAL,58-LORI.V,1-no text held

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-312. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.